Meer informatie over de collectie is beschikbaar op: http://repertorium.librarv.uu.nl/node/2732

Wegens onderzoek aan deze collectie is bij deze boeken ook de volledige buitenkant gescand. De hierna volgende scans zijn in volgorde waarop ze getoond worden:

More information on this collection is available at: http://repertorium.librarv.uu.nl/node/2732

Due to research concerning this collection the outside of these books has been scanned in full. The following scans are, in order of appearance:

OyiNTILIANI RHETORIS CLARISÂ« finÂ» orÃ¤torinrimi 'mjlitutionum libri XI l. reÃituti pene in uniuerfum Ãbi, opem (y induftrid lodchimi earner. Ioannis Sichardi aliorwm^ doitiÃmoru/ntt

AdieHa e^ pricipuorum locorum libri primi o- feÂ» cundieiu[dem earnerarij expofitio,nec inreli(iuorum li brorim locis difficilioribus ^uÂ£ adoiiis annotatafunt aut declaraupr^eterijmus.

OGITANTI mh^duditores Ãudio p,rdtionem dliciuAm,qud meum trgd cholM bM Agrippindtes fludium plenioreteflimonio decldrdrem, ni* hil mihi dd bdc rem eÃiedeiut uiÃnt edi, qudm Ã eiufeemodi dutoribM cnuclcandis matmicrem, qui prÃªter expoUtdm zr ex* pre/fdm dicendi^O' r^^io-i-x^formindjefdcuUdtem (qm quid per Deum immortdlcm ddmirdHUui ? ) profumdd etidm, cdÃigdtd^ difcipUndrum omnium exuperdntid iu dicium,rdtionem^ mgenij exdeuere posent. Igitur pro mgenq noÃri modulo endrrdtif Liuio, SdluÃio, C^fare, er dlijs quibufddm ilUi proximÃ¨ ÃmiUbui^quoruim fcilicet biÃoru mdgii dd rerum mÃgnium cognitionem, er di* dionis mivnditiem,qudm iudicium Uterdrium, Ãne quo iunui ed omnii naÃer condtuf, compdrdndum ^fdeiurntt ex copiofd Latmorum dutorum btbliothecd Ã¯dh.Quinti* lidnumRhetoremcum primis Ã¯uculentu,m,permeliores mÃdntis duni hardi, de fentetia iudicij noÃri, (quod qud Ãtperexiguivm fdeik dgnoÃo)me uobis mterpretdturii idmunte denumciome diedr ÃhohenoÃr^ confuetudini^ nmui [dtiffeciUfti^din ewm Ãi k^f^ndis nonius pkrd*

4jlt;tedd'DiAe{Hcorum,multiidd Rhetor um amonem ret uocdrein er expendcrem, ne feilicct def ul', doriÃ¨ ^ mÃdr iKilgi,officium interpretii ohirem ,fa(iMn eÃ¼, ut pluris gt;nKobfcuriord,quiincdpereiÃ¼dru/mdrtiuâgt;Â» ruda poft fent.trdd diffe exifimer Ergo Â«t certdm corum quÂ£ ant notdui hiÃ©ien^M,ty pofthdc(uolente eo, cuiui nutu omnii reg'imur'idnnotdturusf.m,rdtionem ofÃ«ddmyÂ£n uoiK, ÃudiofiÃ. ddoli-fccntet ,iloquentiÃmum credfliÃmunt tndgiflr im Tdl-âi im offÃ¨ro:de quo,qitid(âMo^ quad dinnt^ orejfdM pro merito pnediedrinonpotcll^prdfdtomni notdcere^qu'dmpducddicere.Sed mterm neuosldtedt^ quid m hdceditione pr^fiterit typegrdph'M Gymnieuf, homo ut multo diUgentiÃmut, ftc dd bond ftudid promo u ndd propenfm ddmodum, Primum predbm mets data rem iÃ m typis mediocriom preÃit: quad minuti iÃi o' eedentes dufcuUdtionibiK pdrum conuenidnt, o^eiem oeulorum mirifcÃ¨ obtiinddntigrdndioresuero mdgnitut dine fuidifficilem uftbia circumferentium fdeidat. Prlt;n tered do-^iÃmorMH quorunt^ cdÃigdtionet o dnnotd^ tiones ddijciendtn curduit : quod ego quoq; fdcik pdffus funiyCun pleri(^ docentidmeiufccmodileilcrem alentt. gÂ«Ã³uidedntur,ddm iÃdipÃ ufurpdnt, dpud igndrosdo*

MARC VS 7amp;biui Citimtilianuf Rom^ nutuf e^i quibut ConfulibuSiMt quo imperAte ex fire no legi. veriÃmei comeÃ¤ura adducor,HtÃdem Ubris tempo ru nonha.beA,ubilegUur QumtiliAntuCalAgwAurbeHi (finite oriundiuMAm MArcut VAleriui HArtidiis CaIagt; guritdnidgriAlumnuicu Hiberos memoriA dignos fuis 'EpigrAmAtibus in fer At, nuUS, de Q^mtiliAno mentionent fecit,fed eurnfepArAtim cum uenerAtione nominAtt

Et ipfe dicit cum e(fet AdÃ³lefcentulus,cognoui(fe Do-mitium Af-umcr Senecdm,qui Ambo fub Her one petic' retSeneedmUbro fexto Diuifionum Qumtilidni decide nidtoris memmit, cuius Adhucexteintmultie decUmAlio^ nesAcutÂ£ er breueSyÃylodliquAntuluremiÃiorejsAuus fuit M.VdbijGiuintiliAni,quiRomemultis Annis rhetor ricencufummdldude docuit.Etipferurfus Qjfintilidnus mentionefdcitpAtris.,quicAufidicusfuit Apud principe, Hcq; notitiA,nec^ grdtid cdruit.DomitiAnienim CÂ£furls nepotum cur A ei delegAtdfuit.nifciplina dus euÃigAtiÃi mie pleniÃmum teÃmoniu C.Calius aÃirt. Ã^ui fub tdU praceptore tdntum profecit,ut fui tÃ¨poris orAtoresfAci h fuperduerit.Duxit uxorÃ« ex nobili fAmiliA,ex quA libcÂ» ros fufeepit,quÂ£ AcerbiÃmA fdtoru forte m primA innen ^ tutis forerAptAfuit.Alteraexliberis,cumlibrude CAU

fiscorruptÂ£ elofjuentu cdidifJet,dniif2t.PoÃeticu'ilt;heto riceslihros fcriberetyQuimiiiAnamfilium u^icu parÃ¨tis lijmen de foldtiiwn rogo dÃ©dit.TeÃis etipfe infeUx fenex fudrum Idchrimdru eÃ¼ t Bius filiold ex alia,ut crÃ¨^uxo reTutilij eeptitis KÃ³rndnifilid genitd,nupfit iiouio CeÃ¯o ri uiro diro^Citjo tempore dccelfer it,affirm Arc non du^ dco,quoniAm is ^ui trdditffidecdret,

POST multds,eds^ nec indiligentes ornnmo M. FitÂ« bij Q^mtilidni editiones, cam e^ nobis dus edendi conÃlivm ffibijffiet, uiÃÃumus id reHiÃme er ucluti du^ ffiicdto fdÃuri,Ã non ut c^teri ferÃ¨ noÃrd etdte omnes^ ingenioffied exemplaribut pdulÃ´ uetuÃioribus Ãrcti hoc fa cere ingrederemur.Ã®iec enim obfeurum eil, ejuantam ma ximis eptibuÃ]; dutoribus clddem dttulerit hoc emendatio nis genus,epio illotis quida manibus dd dutores qudÃ per ludumdccedwnt,pro libidine ut quidq^ inmentÃ¨ uenerit dut toUentes, dut ingerentes. Q^je res cum cateris ferÃ¨ oinnibus,tum ipÃ maxime Pdbio obfuit,dde(),ut comemof' rarepigedt quam fubindedlijsdt^idlijs mendis fdoloru quorumdam uitio ueluti tmlneribus affidusÃt, dum pro fe quifq; hoc Ãbi Ãumit, ut in alieno libro ingeniofus uHcd tur.Quo fadum efl,ut [ubdititijs quibufdam in^rtis, no o modo pnteritaÃnt quÂ£ ad rem fadebant, fed quod eH rnulto grdttiÃmum,ccieperint interimmpretioeffiezT

ujÃ¹, 'ui migni fdUcet nominii tunlra, quie dl omut diceH dimtiont lange hteq; alhorreant. ld quad fortd([e dliU fit tolerdliUitijfed ubi quice^uid dixerk feceris 'ue in exÃ© pl jm protm'dd alit,dtlt;p deinde mitutionem, ihi quimlk ' iet pdrum error cti-im cdpitalk cR. i^ec accidit bic quad ferÃ¨ dlidf,ut errdtorum nos aUqiundo pudere poÃit, fed plicemus etidm nolis errore^ duin exempta quica^uid eiiu rei eÃ¢ fdcere nos pcrfunfum hdlemus. Hrc nabis cdufd fuit,hamdniÃimeleÃ¼or,ut dutorem lange eminentiÃmu er dieendigrduitdte,ey dcu/minc iudicij in msnus fume* remiM,no(fuidemhocdntmo,utfpemcuicjUdm fdeeremm nihikpoHnoÃrumliborem farerclitjuiquod luce indiÂ» gedt,quis enimboc ÃbiniÃ impudent iÃ mus poliiceri dU fit:' fed ut probdremus fdltem ÃudiumnoÃrumm reÃk tuendispro uirili noÃrdeiufmodidutoribus,quos fdnÃ¨ perpdocos tempor urn miurid reUquos nabis fedt, SmHl uterhis grdtiÃedremurquimÃddiuthoedgcremusnul lm finemfddcbdnt.Quorum quidcm prsdpuusfuit lO At^.AtiTONlt^VSCdffouienfiSyUircum dbfolutd olm ertium,quÂ£ in fummm uirum cddere poffunt cognitio' Â«epr^ditus.t m rei medicÂ£ edUentiÃmus^qui ex medid ferÃ¨ Poloniddd nas exÃ«pldri uetere fubmiffofiepra dmi eiti^ noÃrlt;e iure dpud me egit, ut tergiuerfdndi nullwnt relinqueret locum,Vt dutem hul edsfimdniÃmeledor, lt;nbsp;tofilif naÃri rdtioncm,quid in toto opere Ã^edduermus,

Ãtit dccÃ®j^eAnitio cnrs noUf fuit mugnopere, ut Ã®p[um dt Ã©lionis flum ufque^udq; fui fmile effet, cainq^ oh edufAm nihil ueriti ^uoriMiddm iudicid mQuimus loco quicquH uifum effet aUcinide drrcpfiffem contextum,id tdtnen ue Ãm exif mes fdiÃ¯um duce excmpÃ®dri,fine quo ufqueddeo nihil putdmut tenidudum ejfe in ueterimt Konimenth, ut nec uUdm peRem fudijsducAnius mdiorem. Scinde cum flerd^i udrie legerentur,ntdrgmilus curduimm adfenbi ed quoq; quÂ£ 4 fententiit,ut uidebAtur,pYopofto longif fime recederent'.non hoc dictes ut uulgdtd editionc ddi mndtdobfeurd quiddm f^ffeeremui quit leÃorem moi rdrentur,fedquodpdulÃ´ Acutioribiu tdnqudmex uefii-l^'j^P'^lf^l^^^fyfâ^f^t'ior leÃ¢io,cytiod i::r duidius fdÃ u* ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ras nonnuÃos putubirnui, quo mmufnoRrum iudiciimi

interpofuiffemui.Ã®^ccuero'ttificidx eo quxddm etidtnnu refdrefn quibus tibi neciudici'dmnofrwm,nectxcmpldr diligenter dlioqui fcriptum,fuffecerit, dd qu^ intelligent Ã d Delio, ne quid dliud dicdm,ndtdtore fit opus, Scd cogi tdbis eiufmodi fuiffe fufeepti negotij rdtionem, cui uix ipfe Â¥dbiut fi idin rendfeatur fdtis fitfuturut,tdntum fAt.

africaniluliiuiresindicendo. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

ager ab agendo diffus Ã quibufdam nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;?

aglaophon clarus piffor nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'

agrippa unde diffus nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;-

bafli Auhdnlaus nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;624

talui judicium nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;*J5

canthusferrum quo rotÂ« uinciuntur nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;jr

taputpracipuumeftinadione nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;yoj

2^ capfisunde componatur nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;47

carbo C.etiam in ubemaculo fokbat uti cxerdtatione di-cendi nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fff

cicero quando Icgendus nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;103. amp;nbsp;104

confilium quid fit nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;_

confuetudo quid pofiit in ratione loquendi nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;4*'K 37

DEcebit aliud alios nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«sy. 8lt; Â«cS

declinationum ratio prse omnibus confiare debet puero 54. deccri obferuatio nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;_ Â«so.amp;esÂ»

debberatiuum genus remOtÃ¼ fit ab omni afftdationc 204 drliberatiui Hue fuaforij generis ratio

demofthenesadmedfl puer pupillares afliones habuit 74Â» demefibenes lex orandi

Demofthenes non uidrtiir faris pet f. Aus ipfi Ciceroni yja Demofthenesinlittoremeditans cor.fuefetbat firreconcio* num fludus

demofthenisurt nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fij

diallage nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;S5Â»2lt;5 6i

dieendi maximum uitiumÃ uulgarirationedifcedere 4$j dicendi ratio quibuscontincatur

emendationisfeueritas atteritingenia puerilia empedocics carmine philofophiam eft complexus

epichirema quibus confier,amp; quomodorefelhtur epicurus difciplinas omnes fugit

eupoliscomicus nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ibidem

exprÃ¦poficioquamincompolÃ®tioneuim habeat exclamatio exempla quid poflunt in orationc.Ã quo modo tradctur ab

gallilaus nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;sta

hyperbaton figura eft potius Ã¿ tropus nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;4!,K 114-^ â '*

mendax memorfit nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;_

meelis liber de literie nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«i fitsa

metus in peroratione habet plus 3 in proocmioloci jy* milonis confilium in uitulo ferendo

morumeuramoportereeffeoratoribusprareipuam 757 miindum Pythagoras compofitum effe dixit harmonica ra-tione

fnufica,8teius laudes nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ibidem

orator quid obferuet in (hfcipiendis caufis TÃ¯i.K7Â«.K 7 57 orator non eft nifiuir bonus

paronomafia nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;_

parrhafiusdaruspiAor lineasfubtiliflimeexaminauit 701 partes orationis quod lint numeratx

periphralis figura nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ji4'Slt;ji9

perfpicuitas fumma orationisuirtus eft Â«4,92.8e 4Â«? petoritumGaHicuni eft nomen

philiftihiftoricilaus nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ibidem

pleonafmus nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;491.8e s.Â«f

pcÃ«carum leftio quid confÃ©rÃ¢t nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ibidem

probationesartificiales nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;_

probarioncs inartiSciales apud rhetores qua dicantur asÂ» probationespathetica

profopopceix nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;_ jÂ»t.8(;;4

protogenespiftor quibus rebus excellueritinpiÃ¢ura 7Â«Â» prouerbiauimnonnunquamhabentiocorum

pyrrhichius pes cuiufmodi nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;_

py(h igoras pri mus philofophum fe dixit nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;7

quinrilianus przeeptor nepotum Domitiani fuit quintifiani confidum in toto libro

quintiliani liber de caufis corrupts eloquentix quintidanidberi mortui fuperdite pÃ¢tre R

rifus captatio quando fieri debeat romanis fummum crimen luxuria fuÃ®t rumor quomodo traAandus fitÃ rhciore rutilq P. exilium fub Sylla

feribendi quis fÃ®t modus feribendi bene ftudium non eft contemnendum feripti a: uofuntatis ftatus

feneez genus dicendi,Si Quintiliani de co iudicium feneez copia in dicendo fententiarum genera fententiarum ornamenta fententiarum quz fint figurz feptimh libri obfetuarionum feriorum tria genera fermo quibus conftet rerun Sulpitn laus feruilhNouianilaiis fidonh in carmine fÃ©licitas

figna quomodo traftenturin probatione artificial] Smilitudines quomodo eludantur

149

Â«s 76S 7Ã¯ 37 Â» 191 172 661

lt;21

8Â» Â«2^ 19 4 lt;10 374 3â3 30 744

4Ã Cl 6Z 636

Â«4 44Â» 7lt;3 6tt 163 49J J2Â« Ã28 21Â» 391 49 627 624 633 2S4

flatus quot,8C undc ducatur nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;isj.ist

flatus ejus quidifturus eft nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;703.704. yoj-Sf 70Â«

flatuanf clari nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;7Â«.8(7Sj

ftylus qualis effe debeat nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;lt;3lt;. amp;nbsp;637

fynalÅphe qux dicatur nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;39.ÃfÃ¯*a

tibulli laus nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;_

tiro libertus CicerÃ³is trÃ¨s libros de locis feriptos reliqt 372 toga ad calccos dimifia ek antiquitus

conuicio, ut libres, Mos dd Mdr^quot;^'^ ceuumnteiimde injiitutione ordto rid feripferdm, idm emittere mcipe rem. t^dm ipfÃ¨ eos nondum opmd^ ^'^^ [Ã¯^!^ ffâ^turuijje, quibus compo nendis,ut feÃ¯s, pduloplus qudm biennium, tot aUoqui ne f^otijs diÃrilius impendi : Ci^d tempus non tdm Ãylo,quot; ^K4WinquifitioniinÃitutioperis propÃ¨infiniti,cy k^Drinde H^ pendis dutoribus,quifuÂ»tÃ¯nnumerdbiks,ddtu eli. V* ratn.quam fus deinde Hordtijconfilio, quim ArtePoÃ«tied findet,^^^^Qjll^^'f ne pracipitetur editio,nonumq; premdtur in annum,dd eii Petrâ Mo bam bis otium,ut refrigerato inuentionis dmore, ddigen p^^J ^P' tius repetitos tdnq lector perpenderem. Sed fi tdntope*

^^ ^ffldgitdntur, quarn tu affirmas, permittdmus uelei uentiSjC^urambene foluentibus precemur. Multum tem in tM quoi^fde de diUgemid poÃtum eÃ¼,ut in nM*^^^ . nus hominum quimemenddtiÃmi uenidut. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^â¢

Et auram.) Pontanus,i cuius autotitate amp;nbsp;iudido diaa^ film fentire nefas ucluti eft pro auram oram, amp;nbsp;Irgit, K in*' terpretaf, ufus ad hoe teftimonio Liuiano li.rS.in eo libcllo quemde AfpirationecÃ¶fcripfit, quemfecutuseriam author diftionarh, quod CopiÃ¢t cornu appellant, inter expenÃ©dutn idem adferit. Sunt amp;nbsp;alii quoep qbus hoc defendcre placuit. Etquanq fortaffis magis applaudat auram, tarnen ob hu* iufeemodiuirorÃ¼ wthuritatetn amp;nbsp;confenfum, rem in dubio

rfÃ®inquainns.prjferrfm cum ex hac re dignitas fcripti 81 au-* thons non imminuatur. Mofdlanus, modo fint ilhus quae in hunc autorem fub illius titulo fcruntur annotata , au' ram magis probat. Camer .ritis utriufque linguÃ§ pernia da rus oram mauult.Quidenim(inquit)aiiram fignificettâncÂ«Â® em bene precemur hie aftruere liceat, maxime cum in quar' , to huius autorislibro fimiliter legatur magno cenfinfu ex* empIorum.-Nauim confpexi quanti ueheret interrogaui,

' de precio conuenit, confeendi iublatÃ¦ funt anchorae, foluimus oram, profedi fumus. Eft au tern

OyiNTlLIANI IN ORATORIAE â¢ mÃitutionii UlrtM primu,dd ^urecUum yiilorium^roamiwÂ».

i 4 mf ^uiddm fdmi^dritn ppÃj*^di- ^^^^jâ**â S-^lj rent, ut ^liquid de rdiiene diemdi munere do* componeretn. diu fam eauidein re^ htldtui,quoi dutores utriufque Iw^u/icuriÃmosncn i profefflee ignorAdm muhdjC^u^ dd hocoptu pÂ«'rti)tfrrÂ»(jdiÃ¯Ã¯gfÂ«'Â»^Ã«'^ââ.Pâr tiÃime fcriptd poÃerK reUc^uilÃe. Sed ^ego ex Citufi dabatur, fdciliorcm mihiuenidm me je depreedtionÃ©s drlitrdhdr

fore ^ hdc dccendeidt^ur iÃimd^if^ iSf(2.iiâ^Ãl,^^^^'''fââ^ opiniones priorum, O' (^udÃdm etidm inter Ãe centrdri dtfdifÃcil^ eÃeteÃeÃ¤u}: Â«t mihi Ã non inueniendi noud^ dt'iertÃ©iuiiicdndi de ueteribuf, iniwngere Idborem non iniuÃeuidej^ntur. QuMnuÃdâdtpmnontdmmeutneed ret pr'dÃdndi eptod exi^ebe^tur Ãduad,^ negdndi uered fwndidddtiM fe tdmendperiente mdterid,pha ^Udm im* ponebdtur oncYK,Ãponte fufcepi:fimul ut pleniori obÃCd quio demercrer ^MiÃimosmei ^Ãmul ne uulgdrem ui dm ingrejÃti^ dUenit demie ueÃigijs 'mÃÃerem. N4W cÂ« terifere, lt;jui dftem or Andi Hierin trddiderunt, itd Ãimt

* ^A**^** nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Xi--t -^t A luX 'rj rt rh Ifjiit, rijgt

^^21fh^fâ f^f^^^ Â°â^gt;^ edidgenere doUrim fiuW* ^â pe^*per ^â^*â etoquentii mdnum imponereMÃ¯fiucfqtUetnnctttes feddunc. tdnqudm pdrui qm priÃ¢t difcimut fludidffiÃ¿cnon dd fit

uit ) utexe- numuiceseffent : ffu^quodproxmum uero^nuUdmin* c' Jm^mati' ^â^â^^ fferdMes grdtidin cmd res, ctidmfinecelfidridtf proeul tdmen di ofientdtione pofitat, ut operum fidfii* gid j^c{ldiUur,Ã¯dtentf^ddmentd. 'Ego cum nihil exiÃi mem drti ordtoriÂ£ dlicnum,fine quo OratorÃ© non poÃe fieri fdtendum cÃ¼,nec dd ullius rei fummdm,nifi price* dcMibiuinitijsperueniri^t^nord^tfid qm fijegU gd(,non fit mdioribui locuf,demittere mefion reeufdbot

nec dUter qudmfi mihi trdddtur edueMdut Ordtor^fiti* did dutformdre dh infdntid incipidm. Qj^od oput M.dv celle vidoritibidiedmus, quemcum dmieiÃtmumno* bit, turn eximio liter drum dmorefldgrdntem, non pro* pter hic modÃ³,qudnqMm fiuntjhfi^d^digniÃ'tmum hoe yâ\ngt; ^^^^^ -^^ ^^^^ chdritdtis pignore iudicdbdmutffed qÃ

ferc ^^^^-P^i^^i^ primd itdt mdnifejlum iter di Ingen, lu.) tilge dj lumen oÃendit, non inutUes fore libri uidebdn* Eloqucntia. tur,quosdbipfisdicendiuelutincutidbuUi,peromnes, to.Vt em ho ^Â«âÂ« t^odo dhquid Ordton future conferdM, dries, dd in*ânia'fâ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^ operis perducere defiindbdmut. At que co jngen'h ipfiâ tndgis,quod duo idmfub nominemeo libriferebdntur dv lumÃªeftdo tis P.hetoricÂ£,nequeeditidme,nequeinhoccompdrd* qucntiÃ¯. nbsp;nbsp;^-^ u^nque dltÃ¨rum fiermoneper^duum hdbito, pueri,

p turn,boni iuwnes,Ãd nimium dmante^ mei:,trmerdri(i tditionK Ã¯wnore^t^^dwrdnt.Qudre in bis quoq- libris trtvnt eddÃ« dU^M^muUd mutdtd,plurmid ddicÃ¤d^omnix f utro compofitiord, er (indm nos poterie eldbordta.

Ordtorem dutem ii^twmus iUum perfeddmyqMeffe fi uirbonw non potejldtdct non dicepdi modo eximidnir^' m eo fdcuUdtem^ledomnes Mimi uirtute^ ext^^tusy ^jA*'Â»*^^ li6T*^ tieijue hoc couccl^crm, rdtionem rcÃ³lx honeftgeji uite â â (ut quiddrnputducrumt^dd philofophos rdegdddmt ewn uir mauere duiUs, er publicdrum priudtdrumq; rcrum ddmmijlrdtioni dccommod^us^ i^SZ^Ã¨'^^'^ confilijs ur*â bes,fwnddre legibus, emenddre iudicijs poÃit, non dUus fit profetio qudmordt^r-Qudre ta^tÃ mejuteor ufuo rum {pdibufddm,^uie philofoph^um libris confmentur, tdmÃ« ed iurÃ¨ ucre^ contenderim cfje operis noftri, pro priori dd drtemordtoridmperjjncre. An fj frequenci^i mede iuÃiiid,fortitudi^e,tcmperdntid,cÂ£terisqi ftmilitâ bus fit dijferendi^iGr i^eÃ´, ut uix uÃ¼dÃoÃi^dufdre^ periri,m ^â^ntna^dUfpu ^Uicfio ex hjs a^di,ed^ ot-mnid inSeniione, dtlt;^ elocutionefint explicdndd,dubjM bitur ubicun^ uis mgenij, ef!opid diccndi^opuldtu^j,^^ ibi pdrtes ordtoris effe pnecipudsi 7uerunilt;^ hÂ£c,ut Ci Â£i3.5 jj q, cero dpe^fme colligit, quemudmodum iumdd ndturd, rat ore. fic officio quoq; co^uldtd,utjjdc [dpi^es lÃ¼^ eloquen*^'.^dfl-e^.\nn. tes hdberemurtScidit deinde feÃudiujdtq; mertid fddu eR,M drtes effie plures uiderentur. Kdmut primum lm âK'iÂ«Â®*rt. fud elfecoepitinqu)ellu,infittitiMc^ eloqucntiiebonis mdÃ¯cutiiCurAnwru^uidifertihdbebdnturjreliqueruntÃ¯

it. inde ijuiddm coMen^to bene dhendi More^ ad for^ mdndos Mimos, mftituendMqi uin leges rcgrcÃi,piir^ tem t^uidem potiorÃ©^jÃ¯ diuidi poJJct^retinuerunt,nomen tdmÃ¨ fibimjoJeiHiÃimum drrognucrut, ut foli fupienti^ fiudiÃ¶/i uoedrentur. C^uod nei^fummi imperdtores, ne que in confilijs rerum miiximlt;irum,lt;ic totius ddminiÃrd tione Keipub. prxcldriÃimeÃei^ti, Ãbi unqudm uendi ure fumt dufitficere enim optiwi qudm promittere md, tuerunt. Ac uetenm quidem Ãpientu profefÃorMn midtos er boneÃd pTrcepilfc, et ut praceperunt etum uixijjc facile concejÃerim, noÃris uero temporibus fub hocnomÃ¯nc miximdin pÃ¯erifque uitidUtuerunt.i^on enim uirtute deÃudiÃut hdberentKf philofophihbord bunt,fed miltun, er triÃitidm, er diffemientem d er te Pliilofiv nbsp;nbsp;^^ habitum ^Ãimitmt^Ã¤mt pretendebdnt.n^edutem

phosinquit qÂ«f uclutproprid phdojophieafferÃ¼tur^dÃm trdHd tÃ©pore per^ ^'^ onmcs.Qjiis enimnon de iuÃo^equo de bono,modo hiberi feuo- non er uir pcÃmusloquitur f Quis non etidm ruÃieo* diU fed ^2-â ^â^ ^^^i*^ ^^ ^^â^^^^ gt;*'^^gt;*tAlAus qiurit^Ã®^dm uerboruM cie laborant propriet AS de diÃerentid, tnmibMquifermonÃ« curt hd pMa^aurem ^â^^ debet^Ãe_communis.Sed Ã¨d er feiet opting,et Ã©lit ftudia turn quetur Ordton quiÃfuijfet dliqudndo perfeÃ¤us, non Ã fintuitfac philofophorufcMis uirtutisprteeptd petereneur.KuC pta^oceft' neceffceil ddeos dU^Mndodutoresrecurrere, quided Â«fficia conti c^^ ^^ dixi,pdrte or^wt drtK,meliorÃ« prtfertm oc nÃ©ant, Ktra

dÃ¢t quidam ^^l^i}^Z^^ ^ **^^'^'' ^^ft^^^ ^^Ã¯'f'i^ff^J^S^iÃ¿f *^Â°^ ^^Â°*â tcrtitudinÃª xumuÃ¼imr inH(tftis,fei tt^ m^f dUeph ufof eÃe docar

yHit^.^itigitur ordtor uir tdlit, cjudHi^tÃ¯rJdpÃ¯ens dppcl ^Jj^quot; g^âJj Æâ idri poÃit,nec moribui modi pej^^ui {n^m id med (lui uiurpat?At demopmione, (^Udnqfint (luidiffcniidnt,fdtis non cA) qui quot;Equot;Â»Â® â' fed etidm fcÃ®^id er omni fdcuUdte dieÃ«di, eptdUi ddhuc fi^Xator De fortdjfe nemo fuerit. Sed nonideommut nobis dd fum'' hacuero qd mdm tendendum eR^quo^ f^^^^Ã¿^^ f^^^^Si^^f^^l^j^^ ne p1âilofÃ³'Â° etfi nondum (^uenq fdpiemem repertum putdbdnt, prÂ£f phoÃ§: Ã ^^tu ceptd tdmenfdpieittig trddiderwnt. Ndw eR eer te dliqd Ãlj^^g^^ria confimniitd elo(iuentid, nelt;^i dd id pertienire.ndtur^u gramirime q mdni ingenij prokibet: (^uod Ã nort cotmgdt, dltius tdmÃ« ^d^^^xhnt^ ibunt, e^ui dd fummdm nitentur, 5 ejui pr^fimpid dejjte hn, rdtione ^Â«o uelmt euddendi, protinm â^ixS^^.i^dJ'u^itc â ^^e^-^J-n^ â'^Xâ^^ ^^^^â^ ^^P^^^^â^'i^'^ lt;^nilt;*^i^id,Ã ne minord ejuiZ^Ã© -'^^^ dem illd, uenvm open quodmftitutiiiuinecejf^ri^r^^,'^^^,^^ ribo, W.m liber primm ed c^ue funt dnte officium rh^p^ nbsp;nbsp;â^

ris commebit.Secundo,prinUd^iU rhetonmiicmeii^djf^ er que de ipjdrhctoricÂ£ fubÃdntid clUÂ£runtur^rd^Abi tniit.Qjiiiilt;j; demceps inueittioni,ndm c^hiu^diffiofitio fubiungitur.Qudtuor clocutwni,in cuim pdrt^iP^P ridde pronuwidtio ueniunt^ddbuntur â Vnui dccedei^ in i^uo nobii oritoripfemfoi^mMdut eib, ut c^ui mores dus,eine in /âu^ipieudlf ,dif^ndist AgendiseduÃs rdtio, ^uod elo(iuÃ¨ntiÂ£ genuii^uis dgendiÃeiedt cjÃÃni5,iluÂ£ poRÃnem Ãudid,(iudtum noÃrd udlebit inÃrmitdsÃliffie

remus.ais omnibus Ã¤dmifce^it^J^utlt;^uiÃ^ locus poÃuU ^âJ^ Ã^i^ bit dicendi rdtio,e^ut non eorÃ¼ modo feiemid, eptibus fo lis ^uiddm nomen drti^ederimtj,Ãudiofos inÃrudt,^quot;

8 M. FAB. C^IN'nj^^JTÂ« fed dkre f^cÃ®Ui^uirestugerÃ¨ elo^iKntiÃ¯^^it. N4/Â« pkriM^ nudiÃ¨illxdries, nimid fibtiUtdiK^Ã¼dtÃ¯one frdngunt dt^ ^â^^^S^i^iS^^J^^ ^^ ^ ord^hne genei-rofw, ear mi^mfuccum mgenijkbiwt, or o^d dete* g'.M-.qtiÂ£ ut nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;er dÃringi neruk fuis debent, fie cari-pore operiendd fÃ¹nt â¦ Ã¯deo^ nos non pdrtieuhm iUdm, ficut pleri^ifed ^uicquid utile dd infiitueditm^ordtorein ^^ putdbdmus,inbos XII libroscouilm'di,hrciiitcromnid-quot;^ '*^ '*'^â^n^f^lt;i^gt;ttogt;^ft^^itdo. t^dmfi quantum de i^udq; re dici pote A '^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;*1profiqudmur,finis operis non reperietur.ltlud tdmen in

primis tefidudume^ nihil praceptd dt^s drtes udlere, SXÃ» Æ 'Lâ^^*^âfi ^^^^â^â ndturd. Qudpropter ei cui dÃ©crit ingeni n^sÃ»ii^ fdi^tgt;Aiam non mdgis heefiripid fivnt,lt;iudtn de dgrorum cultu â¦quidtm fierilibus terris.S^ter^dUdingenitd cuic^ ddiumentd quÂ«^ ddÃMdni^fiox^dtus p^tfens llt;amp;oriSjUdletudo,c5fidn '\^*'tJ^-,âZiT^^gt;^^'^Â°'''âk^^ fi^'Ã´dÃ®cdobtigertvnt,pojfunt rdtione dm '*Â»*vÂ»*Â»Â»V*âd^pUdri. Sed nonnumquim itd defumt, ut boM efidj^jmge* nijfiudij^ corrumpiM * Sicuterh'xc ipfd^fine doSlorc perito^udio pertindei, feribendi,legendi,dicend^muk td er continua exercitdtione ,perfe dliÃ®s nihil profuntt

a Illud autem.) PrÃ§cidit id quod A Horatius quantum effe feribit natura ne an arte condaret eruditio. Cum em omnis eruditio cultura ingÃ©niÃ© Ãt, ubi deerit ingenium nc culture quidem potent effe locus. Ac fiquisideo Ãudia doftrinaijt contemnere uelit,quod uecordes nihil illis adiuuentur,per' inde ac Ã literas,quia in aqua nihil fcribi poffit, fpemat.face re uideatur. Nam eo ufij humane fapientix uis non extent ditur,ac admirabilis fane doÃ¢or is Ãt ac diuinus, qui mente caÃbs inÃruat fapientia,ut ait Euripides.

GITVR niitojilio^pdtcrfj^cmde â^^^^^^^^^j^^^^ illoprimwin qwmoptjmuw cipUt,â^^^^ ^^^ iti^gentior^^m^ijsfict.VAl mvgt;vÂ£gt; r^-^^K Ã cA querdi^ pdueiÃimis ho minibuatm perdpiendi qujitrd* ddittur eÃe coneeÃdm, pleros^ ue ro Uborem ic tempord tdrditdte mgenij perdere. 't^dm coitirdyplures reperÃM ^ fdciles in excogitdndo^zx ^^ 'quot;'' 'â'^ ^y^' diCcenddmprombtos-.ciMppeide^ihominindtufdie, Ac Oâ¢quot;Â«â non p nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;r nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;r quot;10 animÃ¢t! peut dues dd ^Ã³ldd'jm,elt;pti dd curjim,dd jxwtidm ferlt;e âm/ed re^ gignuntur ,itd n^Ã proprid ell mentis dgitdtio dtlt;jue propria quÃ§ folertid^nnie origo dnimi ecdeÃis creditur. Uebetes ue j^^vrh i*â ro er indociles, nonmdvis feÃ§iwdumndturdmhommes gnis. candet eduntur,eiUd,mprodigio!dcorpord,GrmoÃ^MÃgnid. ^^^-j j^^^^,^^ Sed hi pduci ddmodum fuerum^dp^^entu/m., lt;^uod in ferisomnibÂ» puer is ducet j^es piur'moriim,lt;luÂ£ cum emoritur^xtdte, J^^j ^^^ mdnifeÃuMellnonndturdmdefecijJejÃed cmM^PpÂ£^ tionis ufus Ãd^Mcn ingcnio dUus dlium.concedo. Sed ut plus effi ^^^JJ^^ ddt dut mmut^tiemo turnen reperitur^eptifit Ãudio nihil exiftit. conÃecutuSt Hoc ^ui peruiderit, protinus ut er it purent ''lt; ân!Ã^^'^ââ fudus, derem eptummuxime curumÃpei futuri Ordtoris^ * m^endut Ã¯ Ante omniu ne Ãit uitiofus ferma nutricibiu/^fÃÃZfÃÃÃrf^ tptusfljieri poffet,fdpientes Chryftppus optduit, certe quuntum res pdterctur, optimus digi uoluit^ Et moruM^y ^ ^^^ ^ , quidÃ« mbw hM^ubicpriorrutio endrede tumÃ©etiumÂ»^ ^u hcptuntur'.'iids primum dudiet puer,hurum uerbd effirttiiXC^'^Ã^^^ gere tmitudo conubitur. EtnuturutenueiÃmiftanus eai^'^'' â'ââ*â 1 rÂ«w ^Â«lt; ruUbM'i'dnnis perdpimus, ut fupor epio noud tanimis

*^4^,^^^ lo M. FAB. Q^VINT. INSTIT. 0^ iiÃiifZcjf'^'-tmbuAt durdtmec Idndrum colores,quibutftmplex iÃ¼e cd ^Â°'''mutdtuscÃ,cluipoffunt. Et hicipfd mugis pertmd . hitent, qua deteriord funt, Nlt;m bonufdcile mu* '^'^^'â'ftfd^^â^^â^^^^P'^^^lt;^â numcqMndom bonumuerters uiduf

Parentes ^^â ujfuefedt ergo(ne dim infuns quidem eÃ) fermoni ^'^h.fdx'Ã»i^^ ^^f^*^quot;^Ã^' Ã^Pi^^lt;^tftihus uero qiumplurmim effe eruditions optduerm. Ver urn nee de pdtribus tdn*, Hcc a pud Ci tKÂ« loquort Ndm Grdcmor^^eloquentie multum can* ^fÂ°f'^'f''^ tubjfedceepmut Cornelidmmdtrem,cuius do^mM. re Heet^por^ Ã^mo in poÃeros quoq^ eÃ epiÃols trdditis.Lt Li^Ã roTriÃ»uiri Udrcddidiffemloquedo pdterndm eloquenddmelegdn fun^cÃ¦Ã¼r tioremdidtur. Et CiÃiorptnf^ÃUioritio^Ap^Eriuui Oftauianus, ros hdbitd lcgitur,nontdnfim mfexis fjonorern, LiÃ©e td Antonius,

tur ide huie fbei dcÃm.itm, idem duod de nutricibui di* clum)it. De piddgogK hic dmliw^ut di^int eruditie ruditos feiint â^^H emm peiia iji, qui pdulimt dliquid nltrd primdtlUefdi prÃ¶gyeÃi,fdlfdm fibi fdentii per fui teredere fionem induc runt, t^dm O' cedere pneipiendi pefitts.

indigndntur, tÃ¿- uelut iure quodum poteÃdtis, quo ferÃ© hoc homiwtrn genuf intumefdt, imper ioÃ dtque interim Xeomin Aie f^^^^'^^-^ ftâ^^^^^^^m fudmperdocent,t^ecminut error ea xidri fu iffe fi^mt nocet moribw. Siquidem Leonides Alexddri pidd Pf dogogum gogus,ut d Jidhylonio Diogene trdditur,quibufddm cum

ORATOR. LIBER L lÃ® Æ gâm ill illx mi^itMionc fuerili fu/nt^erjautd. Sicui mul ^ââJ'* ^^* Uw-deor exigcre, cogitet omtorem iri^ttui, rein drills itam thure Am,etidm cim ei formduio nihil defucrit, br^tered plu nawm mife rAAcdiffi:iliord[uperejje. Ndm^y fiudio perpÃ©tua,^ lympjadw^ fr^lidntiÃimis pr.eccptorib'M ,amp; plurihiK^ciphnis 2quot;'}âââ* ââ optWfft.QWitpro^tcr^rifciptcrtiUjt^op^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;a â ndago

0u;s wdUAbit^rMc/nrdtioni,d^uerit, fed hommi. Si id* gum flt;d da-wert Â»oti coMinget, ^MAkÃ¯ mdxime uelm bdhere nutri* j^, uoiuifre ces pueras,pifddgogus, dt imui certe fu dÃidims,diccn dui pioge* dl nan imperituti Q^iJiiJdd eru/nt dh his prÂ£Ãnte dlum quot;,oââ'X.c ttodi(lduitiofe,corrigdtprotinus,nec'mÃidereilliÃindt, tio fit Baby* dum tdmen mtelUgdturjJd^^^d^r^ dixi, honiem eÃe fquot;quot;âph,Â°Ã³X* boe remedium. A fermane gr^co piterÃ¼ meipcre mdla, phus, qui in quidldtmus,lt;ptiplunbus in ubuefl,uelnabisnolentibus }J.g,âX*R(Â» fi perhibet,ftmul quid difciplmis^^^i grecis prins in* mÃ¢ uemt cÃ¼ ÃituenduseÃ,unde (T noÃr^'liuxerunt.aon turnen hac ^â^^' ^â ddeoÃuperÃitiofe uelim fieri, ut diu tutum laqudtur gr^

cÃ¨,dut difidt/icut plerifi^ maris efi,}imc enim dccidunt er erris plurimd uitid in peregrinum fanum corrupt^ej-/^yf^-^J^u^ ferma nis,cui cum gr^a figure dÃidudconfiietudme

firÃt,in dinerfd qualt;^ laquÃ«di rdtiane pertindeiÃime du ^^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â^ rdnt.t^n lange itdq- Utind fubfcqui dcbettt,et cita pdri ter Ã¯retltd^et,ut cÃ¼ aqudU curd Imgui utrun^ tueri cÅ permus, neutrd dlteri officidt, emidd litcris mfiituen dos,qui Â»fiÂ»2^^ [fftemun^, effen^^on putduerÃ¼t,qdâ iUd prim-jm dtds er mt^edu^difciplmdrum edpere, ey

Idborem puti non poÃit. In qm fententid Hefiodum ejfe ** nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;' ' f^ui date grt^ntndiietmArifiaphdneni ^

iira^KÂ« pr^ucÃ¯unt, Ndw is primm vtsso(ihhÂ«i*, in ^Â«o Ubro fcripti pud Hero* hoc muenitw^negMit efje huiiu PoctÂ£. Sed dij quoque dot. ssroitt^ dutores, inter duos ErdtoÃhenes^idempr^ceperuMt, wiHicwj.fid McuÂ«lt; dutem (pit uudum tempiÂ» Medrecurd uolunt, ut fefiwftrÂ«^ ^hryfippui'-ttdm is, lt;pidmuis nutricibus triennium dede ac fubiece* rit,tdmeit db iUis c^uoq; idm mformduddm (pidmoptimii ^gt;^- mjlitutis mensem infdntium iudiedt. Cur dutem non per qui' Ãcepu' tin^^tdd literds ttds,lt;iue dd mores idm pertmet ^ Nf$ fcripfit de e' ignora toto lUo, de quo loquor, tempore uix tdntum e^ bero^Â°ficut cyftMtum coferre units pojlcd poÃit dnnusi Sed timen paulopoft mihij^ui hocfenferunt, uidenturnon turn difcentibus in fabiâdtat, jj(j^p(irte,qudm docentibus pepercijJÃ¨.Ciuid melius dbo ^^^t^ *^ ^idinfdcienS,ex quo loqui poteruntf Â¥dcidns enm dliqd neceffe e^:Aut cur hoe, quintulumcunque eA ufque dd feptem dnnos lucrum^fdÃididmus^ Ndm certe qudmlibet pdrunm fit quad contulerit letds prior,mdiord tdmen dÃ¼ qud difcet puer eo ipfo dnno, quo minord didicifiet.Hoc perfingulos dnnos prorogdtum in fuMmdm proficit,cr quintum mfdntid pr^fumptivm eSi temporis, ddolefcen ffiJiy^ tiÂ£ dequintur. Idem et idm de fiqucntibusdnnis prices ptum fit,ne quad cuique difcendwm fft, firo difcere mei pidt.tion ergo perddmus primwn fidtim tempus, dtque eo minus, quad initid literdrum fold memorid confidut, quÂ£ non modo idm e^ mpdruis, fedetidm temeiÃimd eÃ¢,^cc fum ddeÃ´ Â£tdtu imprudens,ut infidnium protic fplcnÃ© â*^ tener is deerbe putem,exigÃ«ddm^ plendm operdm.

i^dm id in primis eduere oportebit, ne fiudid qui dmdre ttondum potefi,oderit:cr MdritudmÃªfemel percept dm

fturn ttkrrf rudcs^mos reformidet. 'Lufw hi(]^^ro' '^ gcturÃ®^ idudetur, er nonnunquimfeeijjefe gMdeiit.

Akqiwwdo ipfo noknte doetdtur alim, cui mwdedt,con tenddt tnttrm^tt fepius umetre fc^utf:t,prÂ£mjs etidtnj'^^^^;/^*^, i qÂ«Â« Mfcit itU tta^yCuocctur.PdrM doccmiK innituedu/itt' â â¦*

ordtomn profeÃi, jed til [M eMm jiudifs Infdntiit: cr^^ei- â¢ 4..^, 6. Mt corporum max tÃ¼dm fortiÃmorum eduedtio d IdÃ©lt^^ .^^/-r,lt; ewnisiji mitiim, dudt, itdfuturta elot^uentiÃimui edidit dU^uindo uigitum, t^ioc^uj^fmu/m 'tneertd uocctcntd uityZ^ biÃt aredformM Uterdrum. Nre Ã c^uid difetre Av^^it^i Ãdtii non e^l^idco nee neeeÃe ell.Quod Ã nemo r^pre certum Rendit pdtrem, qui hicnonnegiigcdd'mpâÃ¶jiliopiitcty'^ Â«AÂ«Â«*-tur improietur/i lt;^uii cd qm domi[uÂ£ reÃ¼e fdceret^ puhUcu promit ? Attj} eo mdgii,quod minord etidmÃdei Â« ^ â^'^^ ^ â¢^ Umminoresperdpiunt, etutcorpoiÃdddquofddmmeni^^^^^ Ijror^Ãexw formuri niÃ ttne^ nonpoÃimt ,Ãc dni^ Â«*~Â«-Â«* mos quoque dd pknique dunnes roturipfum fdcit.Att PhilippusMdeedonu/m rex AlexdndroÃlio fuo primd U^^ terdrum dementd trddi dh AriÃotcle fiimmo eius atdtis Ab Arifto.) philofopho uoluijfet, dut iUe ÃÃecpiÃet hoc officium,fi ^^'â ^Â®*.^ non Ãudiorum witid cr d perfediÃmo quoque optime piacuit indi trd(ldri,etpertmeredd Ãmmdm credidiÃettYin^rmus j^pju^epl igitur Alexidrvm ddri nabis mpofitu grernio, dignum ftolÂ« Phi* ttMdeurd infdntem(qudnqudm fuuscuiq- dignuseÃ)pu 'âPP** de At ne me m ipfis Ãdtim dementis etidm breuid docedi monÃrdre compendidi tieque enim mihi iÃ¼ud fdltem pid cct,qupdÃeri in pjurmis uideo^Uterdrunt, nomind^et (onttxtumprw quAmformddS piruidi diÃdnt.GbÃdt

VÂ»*Â»-*M^H^ A*:*^***^boe d^nitionift^umearwnt, non intÃ¨demibw mox dm â^ tff^f^^Ã¼ti dtm df^cej^cm memoridm fc* ti^ df^xi^ecdf puerU, r^^^o e^uo primu feribi folcni 'quot;** contextuuideMur^retro^gdntrurfiiSjCtMridpermu-^ tdUonc j^rturbent ,doncc literdte^i 'mÃituttntur fd^ i^vL^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^ ft0Yint,non ordine.Qudpro^t^rjiptnne/icut hom^

^â ^f,^ji^^^-^^^JJ^^^'^^â^â^â gt;f^^â^^buntitr. Scdqd' in Uteris ^eli/yUdbis non t^ehit^ NoÂ» exclude aut id quot;^ ^Z^^^iÃªxi^â*Â°'^ ^^4^^^â^^Ã¯iâ^^^^'^^^^ â^^ ^âfâ^^gt;^duminfantegra* ^Jo X/-^gt; 'ââ¢lt;riid,eburne^etiamliterdrÃ¼formatinlufumoffÃ¨rret nel ft quid aliud, quomagisittaittasgaudeat^inueniripoo' 7^ ^,^^s'^â teh,quod trdÃ drc^m^eri^nomindre^iucudivm fit. Cum ^â^^â ^Syi!^f^^^Â° '^'^ ^^^â^ ^âÃ^iS^^y^^i ^Â°^ ^^^â^^ fTit,eds tabel ^.^it^ ^ '^â¢'â â''^Â£ quamoptime inficalpi,ut per iÃ¼os uelut^ulcqs dacatur ^.in^- fiylus NÃ neq- errMt q^ie^jtd^du mceris (continebi ^f^ 'â âfw ntrinq; margmilus ) nelt;^ extra prifiriptuea er.tt nbsp;cara ^^^^- ^^^^^j^^^ ^^^^ lt;â^flt;fpii*iÃ^t^^'i^a uefti

gia^fwm^it driieulos, neq; egebit ddiuim^^manu ftU Bene feriben manui fuperimpofitd rcgencis.tion efi aliÃ©na reT^a fie diliudiuin. rÃ¨abhonejlisnegligifielet,curabeneacuelociter fieribe diMam cum fit in fiudÃ¿s^pr^^uu, quo^, folo uerus iUe proficdlus,cs' altis radicibus nixus parctur,ficibere,tdr^ dior Ãylus cogitationem mordtur, rudis er confiufius itt

tcUeUu caret,wndc fiequitur alte^i^andi ex bis qui et transficrendd fiunt labor.Quare cum fiemper cf ubique, turn preedpue m epiftolis jeerctiser fdmiliaril us de* leÃ³ldbit, ne hoe quidem negledum reUquijfe. SylUddi

AdcoMuiuinddmedmfUeldcceleridM^Jicummo^it fdidtt^ MiAitdtd Uterdrum inter [e connin^io,Juppedi tdrefine uUi cogitdndi fdltem mord poterit ; tune ipÃs fylidiÃ¹ uerld complet, er bw fermonem connedere in nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;' )

cipidt.lncredÃ®bile eH: eiudntum mardi leÃ¼ioni fefimdtioe ddijctdtur. lÃ®mc enim dccidit dubiti^tip, mtermiÃiOyre Stc petitio,plut qudm poÃiwt dudentilm, deinde e^^rrd mtaiiSati runt,etidm bit iiUit idm^iwt difÃÃe^u^j,lt;^ertdlit Â«t * *â¢â go in printif UÃ¢io^deMeconitt^d, amp;^diu Ientior,d9'^^^sz*^^ nec exercitdtione contmgdt emendd^uel^tdt.T^dntiZu'^'.^â^f!!^^^ fproÃ^icere mJeMr^^od omnesprmpiunt, er 1?^â^ ^^^c^'^^/^ uiderejnon rdtionif mod6,Ãed ufm (pioej; eft,lt;ptonidmÃitgt;'^H'itf i,t^^ quemid intuemi priord dicendd funt: o^ ejno^di^iHi^'Ãz^^/jl^^Zr^Ã* Wu eli,diuÃ¯denddintentio dnimjitdUud uoce,diiÃ¼t'ocu'y't nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'l'*7â

MdgAtUTduud non pctnuchitcurd^CyCfm Z^^^^^^^o*^^^^^^^**â mind puer {qurrnddnit^um nwrÃ'c^)cixperÃ,ne hanc j *â * operdm in uocdbulit Ã¼ulodrtbiu, z^ fortc occurrenti* Extat Calo but perddt: frotmuf enimpoteÃ¢ interpreidtionem Un^ peRtio gloP putfecreUorifJd ed ^uds Graeci y^uayagtiocit, dam lt;â?âHippos tfliud dgitur,edtfeere,e^rinter primd elementdconfeepti bro fic fed â rem pofted propriu tempos deÃderdturdm. Et (ptonidm Ptâ? '*^gt;y** wcdm dÃ©tenues mor Amur,bi ipM^ uerÃu^uidi jâ^i{^Â«Â§âââ 'unititionm [eribendi propÃnemir^mnotioÃs udim

7gt;i kZtx gt;x5J fcquitur nxcmemoriii in fenc^utem'^Qr m^reÃn dumo Exhife'uer â'^Ã^Ãh^ mores proficiet.Etiim diÃ 'dcl^^^^u^ui^ bis bene per 'gt;âo^Km,,(^ cleilos ex poÃ«tis mdxitneCndnque eoruw pdf dare^patÃ©r ^^ lt;^Â°g^â^âogrdtioresl)locosedifcere inter lu^umlicet. gd lue Quin Ndw cz maxime neceffdrid cÃ¼ ordtori,ficut fuo loco di intelligent^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;amp;'^d-pr.icipueÃrindtur,dtq;dliturexer dum fit. cUdtione, cz in his de Ã¼iiiius n^ loqumur Ã¦tdtibus, t^ux nihUdum ipfx ^Jegenefdre qaamt,propÃ¨ fold eli quÂ£ iu4idre curdm docentitwn poÃit.l^on dlicnumfuerit cjgt;^^i^^^^^VÃ¿f^^ihi^-^^â*^^^^^^^Â° f^^ dbfolutius os,et expreÃi or femo^t nomind quÂ£ddm uerfus^ dffÃ¨Hdtie diffieul' tdtis ex pluribus O' djferrin^eoewntibus inter fefylld lis edt^endtos^o tteluti con^dgofos qudmeitdtiÃimeuol e uint, 'Xlx7^^7tal, gr^ceuoedniur, resmodieddiilut^ttd tdmen omiffdjnultd linguÂ£ wtid, niÃ print wexiimwtur dnnis,inentenddbili in poÃerum prduitdte durentur,

a nbsp;nbsp;Qua fi quis.) Hoc eft,modisoÃ¯bus precipieda funt opti ma.qbus fi quis uti non uoluerit,non poffit pretendere uerf rationisdemonftrarauidelicetignorationem.fcdipfiusfuc'â rit negligentia. Vt fit,dcfuerjt, culpa fucrit, feu ut itadicam, defeftusQuod autem duriufculc diftum uideri queat, quÃ§ fi quisgrauabit,funt tarnenitalocutiiUofecuIo. Plm.; epirt-lib.Ncmpe quam in fenatuquogj, ubippetinecelTecrat.gra' uari tn uel punfto temporis folebamus.

b Quidam literis J Videntur hac in re diftributionem Ã§ta turn Graeci refpexiffe, qua: fecundum Hippocratem hac eft. Prima atasab anno unoadufq^feptimÃ¼.SeePda a7 uflt;514Â» Tertia Ã 14-ad 21.Quarta Ã ai.adiS.ufqp.QuintaÃ¤ iS adj?Â» Sexta Ã t j .ad 42 .Septima Ã 42.ufq; ad 49. Prima,infans.Se' cunda,puer.Tertia,adoIefcens.Quarta,iuucnis Quinta,uir. Sexta, ftnex. Septima,decrepitus,quod ille dixit TsfuÃiirKS, autlior Pollux- Gum igitur non arburarentur infantes utr

ORATOR. LIBER I. 17 liter literis infritui poffe cenrucrunc hacc ftudia differenda ufi^adpucritiam.

c Ariftophj.)Id eft paulo infra tempora Philodclphi. Au diffe enim hue Ariftotelc(n,qui prÃ¦ceptor fuerit Ariftarchi, Callimachn tradunt,8( Zenodotfi.altcÃ§? cC effet puer adhuc. alterum iam adokfeens, caeteÃ§j magiftro poftea ufum Erato fthene,qui Athenisin Aegyptfluenir,acccrfitus Ã PtolomÃ§o, tertio rege Aegyptiqui Euergetesdiftusfuit. Zenodotusau tem apud PtoloniÃ§um.Lagi fi!iÃ¼,quj Soter diftus cft,fuerat, illius9 filioslitcras docuerat.Ita illa Ã§tate doftiffimos uiros qu) pofteritati conferuarent ftudioÃ§gt; amp;nbsp;artra cultum.numi-nis prouidentia ccllegit. Na eumperpetuu motibus, extin lt;nbsp;fto AIexadro,uexataâGrscia,difcipljna9Ã¯ ftudia negligeret, illeq^ orbis artiii,qu5 uoeÃ¢t QiluaXioii zsaic/Iiiaii diffipatus iam effet,expuifi Alexandria doftiff. homines, omnibusin gene ribus feientiaÃ§: iniurijs amp;nbsp;immanitate PtolomÃ§gt;,ftptimi re--gis Aegyptioi)z,quc xazifysTKy dixere omnes infulas 80 ciuita tes GrÃ¦coÃ§Ã®,cÃ´pleucrunt,tanq rediicentcs,q olim inde artes exceffiffent, amp;nbsp;ft qiiafi in tutelam PfolomÃ¦cÃ§? contuliffent. d Quas GrÃ¦ci.)ln lib.de poÃ«tica,quiextatinftriptusAri ftoteli,lcgitur.Nomen aut proprium effe,aut gt;X3JtÂ«[i. Pro' prium quo utantur ahqui coÃ¯ter.7XÃ¶jTÂ«[i,quo alrj, ita idem nomen effe poffe proprifi K ?x5]â¢y,ut eiyuvoy Athenienfbus gt;XÂ»]Ta|)fujffe,Cyprijs proprifi,unde apparct gt;X2Â«fÂ«idixiffe uocabula minus uii!go,aut nota,aut ulÃ¯tata,cuiufmodi Poe ta^Ã¯Ã¯'mtplurima,autaliundefumpta autrepetitaabantv quitatc, autnouitiamel efficÃ¯ioneuelccpofitiÃ³e,utlogi pro Iiugis, para tragccdiare,maftigia, bolus. Vetera funt, perdu* elhs exanclare.NouoÃ§t ratiolatius pater, nam amp;nbsp;quse quafl abolira, ufurepofita funt noua uiden queant. Sicut uexare poffit nouÃ¼ uiden,cum fit uctus ac proprium,cuiufmodi no bis difcentibus linguam Latina occurrere multa folent. Effi ftum nom fuerit Ã Saluftio,fiqu:dem uerum eft dixiffe eum quod anint. LoquÃ©ciam.Intelleiftus maxime nouitate facit, ut exterebrare amp;nbsp;cxpifcari, pro exquirere, hue pertinen# tranflata. Compofitio eft fimpÃ¼cior.ut collutulare, tripar* cos,leuifidz.

e Greece' uoc3nt.)Vrperterricrcpus. Therapontigonus,^ Platagidorus.utapud Ariftophanem ff!jyÂ«gt;'i/cvuX*f}'Oxo/xÂ« TÂ«s amp;nbsp;KOMWoÃKXeXegÃ§M/xow. Sed hze quifque fibi excerpcre ex poeus pctcntiucrfosautetn integros maxime prodent,qua

lis Ã¶f Catullianushic;CÂ»m Thyafo SatyroÃ§i amp;nbsp;NyÃgenis Ji knis.Item.Funcra Cecropis neefunera portarentur.amp;ille antiquusjraxinus.fixaJcrox infefta infundifur ofTis. Et fi' cutnoskcimusdocendicaulTd Fiammiuomas'q; plagasco' lis altas fulminit arces. Has maximas ut fic ditam confrago fitafÂ£S,L.amp; M.amp;S. KRfaciunt.Vndc ueteresS-amp;Mabnee re folebant,amp; uitiofaÃ¨ didum ab Ennio annotatur,Tum mk lia militum oAo.

^Ed nabis idm pduldtm dccrefcere vucr,O' exire de difcere fcriomcipidt.Uoc igitur potiÃt^ tnum loco trdÃ¼dnddjÃ¿Moj^^, 'Vtiiius ncfit donn,dtlt;p ^,.,^^ intm priudtos pdrietesfiudentem continerc, dnfreejutif tiÂ£ ficholdruAn^etj^lu^^Ucis pneeptoribm^^dere^ Clariff.ei' Q^dÃ¼uf/emcumbiis,dquibuscldrifiimdruciuitdtlidiiH uit.)VtLy'

cargo, quod ^Â°âgt;'lt;^^ fiwt mjiituti ,tuniemwrntiÃmts dutortbustu* ex ils quÃ¦ de deo pUcuiffie^EJon e^t tdinc difi'muldndu effie nonnullos nio^^naitu i^^ ^^ ^Â°^proptâ pubbeo more priMd qudda. perfudfitoe eis feripta dijfientidiit. Hi du^ ^rdeipue rdtiones fiequi uidenturt eisfathron* ^i*^/j^^gt;^^amp;^confuldnt^fitgiedoturbj^b^ ftat. Nee nS Â»Â« eim Â£tdtis,quÂ£ filtdd uitid mdxime prondode edU* ^Adhen^^is f^'^^'^â^ fâ^?^^ flt;^^'^^^Ugt;^ Mindm falfoiiÂ» fieri confue- Ã¤dretur : Alterdm^ ^od c^t^quis futurus cA iÃ¼e prit uwVipÂ«âd ^^P^Â°^âliberdliustempord Jmimpenfurus twiuidetur, eft ca tu quo ^dn^eddem mplwejj^drpidtur. Prior edufd prorfus inaaÃ¯iffe'*^ t*'''^^^' ^dmfifiudijsquidemfcholdsprodejfic^ moribut antiqui mo- â^^SlF^4r^ ^^H^^^ potior mihi rdtio Muendi bont mi^1 Soia ft^^i^'â^â^^^^^P^^S^ifS^fiA^^^j^Z^L^lil^^^^^^u^ rcTraditV fientemid^confÃ¨rtd iÃd dtq^ iadifierctd ftitimeque enitii ^pTtmi ^^^ lt;gt;ydtorem nifi bonum uirwin itidi(o;Qrfieri efidinfi

f off fl Â«ofo. Dr bic re igitur priut .CorruMpi mores in ^â,*5 ^Mde fchoUs^utditf. nam er corrumpuntur interim', fed do* uelhinc ap--mi amauefer furd multi eins rei exempli, torn life her Pâreat.quod , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;{ Â«nfet infan

de epmm co, eruAtÂ£ jMctiÃme utrob^ue optmonis. Nu tes quclt;Ã¯ A tun cuiÃ»jque timen curi^ ^iÃj^i^jnentem id pcio* nutricAâ in riÃcilem, dinegligentiimfcrmindi,culiodiendicj^ in quafiiudum Â£tite primi budoris mon minorem fligitus ocafonem deferendos p fecreti prxluerint. l^im^er^potc^^urph ^HfJi'i'ii^tbus, ficus iUe prteceptor,nec tutior inteYfefuos milos,cpiim ingenuos pirummodefosconuerfitio eÃ¼. At Ãhom ipflus indoles,Ã non caci, ic fopitijgt;iri;ittum focordii fii, erprÂ£ceptcrcmcÃ¯igere ÃndiÃTmum c^uenque^cu* iusrei pneipM prudemibus cuneU ,cr difciplimm, ^UÂ£ mixme feuer i fucrit. Heet, er nihilommus imicuM gnuem uirum, iut fidclcnilt^rtum literi filij fui id^ iiwgcret cuius iÃiduits comititus ,ediin ilio^nte^ai resfi'ict,ciui timehuntur. Ticile enthuit^m^Mre^^ dium.'Vtimm liberorum noÃrorum mores non ipÃ deremus. infintiim fitim deUcijs foluimus. Mollis idi eduatio, eptim mdulgentum uoamus, neruos omnes Indulgcntia. er ment is er corporis frin^t^- Qjiid non idultus con* c^^~^ cupifcet, Mi in purpuris repit f tiondum primiuerbi exprimit,tim^occu^ntd^it, Umc^nch^Uwinpofcit. a Ante piliium eorum e^uimos mÃitÃ¼imus. inledicis crefunt, Ã terram ittigerint, Ã¨ minibus utrin^uc fu* fmentium pendent. Giudemits Ã quid licentius dixe* fmt. Verbi ne Alexindrinis quidem permittendi deli* AkxÃ¯drfn# fijs,rifu et ofculo excipimis^ Hec mirum,nos docuimus, dcjicist.

20 Â«.JAB. pVlNT. INS T IT, ex nobisM^urwl, iioÃ¯irM dmictu, nofiros concubMOS conumm/friob^n^ cdtiitcis Ãrepit^pude e^'^fi^i ^ii^ff^^^tntur.Titcj^wttliKttt^fittdendturiH , difewnt h^cmiferi dnteqium feidnt uitid. effc.lnde foluti de fluctues non decipiunt Ã¨ [eboUs mdld iÃd ,Ãdjn feho* Idsdffirivnt Â« Verum 'm fludijs mdgis udcdbituflus uni^ mco quot;^â^^ Â°^^k ^il ^rohibet effe iflum,ncfcio quÃªm,umim iet ^^Ã¿Ãª?/(amp;J^i!Ã¢^srâ*lt;^^^*^Ã©5!^P^'^^ niÂ».^^i^^â^Ã^tiwt(^ non po^et,lumen tdmen^ÃcMueniut hono ^'^\â '^^^^iÃimiitenebris defloliiud'miprÂ£tuliÃem.1gt;ldm optimus Z^^^Zlt;^ Q^'^^â*^fâ^ P^^^pl^o^fri^^Ã¼^i^^ifde^dcmdiore fc thedtro tof^Â» 'Tjy^i/â cfdignum putdt,dt uero minores ex confleiencidÃÂ£ mfir^ ^jff^^T^^ '^mitdtis birere flngulis, zy officio fungi quodummodo ^ 1H^^- nbsp;nbsp;P^di^^ru non 'mdignuntur. Sed praÃet dUcuiuel grd

pdrdbilem mdgiÃrum domi bdbedt, mem tdmÃ¨ iÃ¼e totu/m in uno diem confumpturus eÃ¼ S Aut poteA effie uÃd turn ^^^yii^ftuf^' perpetuddifcemismicniio,quÂ£ri0nutufM oculorwit '^^'^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;' oltutucommuoffidtj^cturÃcumprÂ£Ãrt'mtpufloplusfe

creti temporis jWidde/tderent, Nc^j enimtdifcÃ«tt,feri benti et cogitditti ^feeptor dÃiÃit,quorÃ¼ dliquid dgen tibus cUi^unaufmteruentus impedimento eÃ. LeÃio quo^non^njs^necfemperprÂ£eunte,uelmterpretdnf' ci^e.-V'^Q ^ teeoet'fduin^enimtotdutorum no^tidcont'mgeretl^ ^ ! â¢^ y^â/â^JA^rgo modicum tempus eA, quointotudiemuelut opus to Z^ âfle^^ ord'metur.ldeo^ per plures ire^offunt, etidm que find ^rr^ ^ .^ ^ g^j^ ^^^^-^^ P^^|.^ plerd^^o bd^nditionÃ« bebent, b^quot;'Ãd quot;ft ** ^^^ ^^^^ ^'^ omnesfimiifperjerdtur, Tdeeo de purti

tionÃ¼fi^ et deddmdtioibu^ rhetoru^^bus certetpiAtufeum^m^^s dmÃ® ^Â«e numeric ddhibcdtur^tumÃ© umtfquif^; totu f^^^^'^Ocidkanfirx' enim uox iÃA pr^^^'^Ptori^t cÅiJd.minM plurihut fuffi^iyyiiiwas. tit,fed u^ol,M^^^ ide lÃ¼cÃ¯tfceiloris^ Idrgitur. G ^â Â»â¢ââ-^-^^âfit^ mdtiau quoi^ 'd^rdtione loquendifi differdt^UdcliiÃ´nÃªs^ txplicetjhiftoridt expondt, pocindtd. cndrret,totÃ®Wt dit' fcent,ciuot dudieM, At enim emÃ©iiSdtioni prdcclioniÃ´-

pidcet^)mox iÃ¼ui compdrdbimus commode.Nec ego t^-'^^iet^d^if men co mutt puerum umo, uit ncgltgdtur. Scd ne^ pre ceptor bonus mdiore fe turid | ut fufimcre edm poÃit, onerduerit:cr m primis ed hdhendd curd eÃ¼, ut is omni modo fidt nabis fdmilidriter dmicus, nee officium indoo cendofficilet, feddffrÃ¤umiitdttunquimerimusmturd-^ zfT^ bd^liecfiinÃ¨quifqudmUterisfdltem leuitcrimiUtus,eum ''t?'^/ây'^f in quofiudium,Ingenium^ perf^exerit^onit^udm quo quegloridmpecuUdriterfouebit.SedutfugiÃªdtfifitmd^tt v^^ii^ gnefchoU (cui ne ipfe quidem rei affemior) fi dd ^UqnÃª^^^Zgt;^^^^ merito concurritur,non tdmen boe d iugt;l(t,ut^ugiendlt;ie ''f^^f^,f^^ffi^'^ fint omninofcholetdUud eR enim uttdree^^ud eUga- âZ^is y,- .^Ãf re.Et fit refjit/umus^i*c^^rd dicuntur, idmexpUce*f^f^ t^tZ^' mus quid ipfi ^u^^f; ' Ante omnid futurus Â°'lt;^'^o^fâf^,^^Ãff^,^' CM 'm mdximd celebritdte,et m medid TAepub.uiuendum^t^j tli, dffiuefedt idm d tenero nonjrefmmddrÃ§ homme^^ne ^Ã¿n^ -^3^^ que did foUtdrid,^ ucJnt uml^tiÃ¯i uitd pdU^erH.^xciZZC^m -Â»^, ^'*2rir!^â^f^ lÃ¼toUenddferner efi,quÂ£ 'm huiufmodife^t,- /.^^Z^ZZ^ cretis dutÃ¯dnguefcit^cr^quenddmuebup'm lt;i^dco^^umâ^^^!ZJZ'^ ***â dutit^dut contre tumefcit md^^erludjione.ifeieffc eSt

.enim nmiumtribuAtfibLttui Ce ncminiTomMraL Drift *:â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;-' aecumprofercndiijuntftudiijCiligAtinfolcyÃ^oniniii

Â«OMA ofinduntjUt lt;lÂ»i /olm didicerit,quod inter rMltos faciendum e^^ Mitto amicitint, ^M Ad fenettem uft^ firmiÃime dur Ant, rdigialA quidam neccÃitudine imbu tie. Nf^ enim eR fAnfUu^ijs^t^m c^udm ftudijs ini* tiAri.SÃ«fum ipfufnej^ommunis dicitur, uhidiÃet^um p Ã congreffu,i[ui non^iommibus folimi,fed mutis quo^ Animdibut nAturAHi eR,fegregM-it^At domi ed fold di* fcere pote^, quie ipft priecipiefuur, mfchold etidm quit dUjs. Audiet multd cpt^diie probdri, muÃ¯td corrigi,pro derit dUcuiut obiurgdtd defidij, proderit Iduddtd Mud prid,excitabitur Idude jcmuldtio, turpe ducet adere pi z^a.,jHd nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ri,pulchrufn fuperdffe mdiores^dce^i^ut omnidhiecdni

Ambitio uir mof.cr licet ipfd MtiÃ¼ fit t^itioiÃecpienter tdmen edit tutucaufa. Ã uirtutum cÃ.NoÂ» iÂ»utilcmfcioferudtumeffe d^ace ptoribm meis morem,(jui cum puerofin^l^es difriba erdfttyOrdmem dicendi fecundam uires ddidni, et itd fu periore loco quif[uÃ§decldmdbdt,ut pacedere profeHu uidebdtur â¢ Uuiut rei Micid prxbebAntur, ednobis in* gis pdlinÂ£ contÃ©r^icijduccfeitcro c^em^rnultojiulcher rimum. HecdehoclmeldecretÃ¼merat, tricefimus dies reddebdt uiHo certdmmis poteftdtem. Ãtd nee fuperior fucceffu curdm rÂ£mittebdt,e:T dolor uiHum dd depeÃ¼en dim ignondwdm concitdbdt.Ã¯d nobis deriores dd jiudiil difcendi ficesf^didijfe, ejudm exhortdtioem docentiu, piedigogorum cuÃodidm,uotd pdrentu,cpidnttvm dnimi weiconiedinrdcolugercpofnm,cQHttlidem.ScdfKHt

ORATOR. LIBER L tj ^miores in literk profeilut tlit gmulitio,itd indpienti lgt;its,dtlt;^ ddhne tenetsjcondifcipulorum qudm pr^cepta rtf iHcimdior,hoc^0*^0^facilior,^itdtio c^l.Vix ef turn fe^rmd dementi dd j^eiolÃ®crc'cffmgÃ«deic^Ud [um Md^putdnt} do^uentix dudebunt, proximd dmpleditn tur mugis,ut uites urboribus dppl'citd, inferiores pritÂ» Upprehendendo rdmos in cdcumnd cMdunt.Qjiod ddep^^ 'quot;â^â**' ^y^â'4 ver urn eft, ut ipftiÂ» etidin mugijiri, ft timen 'd^^tiÃ³flii^^*^^*'^^'*/^'-utiUd pruferet, hoc opus fit, cum ddhuc rudii trdUdbit ingenid^non fidtim onenre mfirmititem difeÃ«tiwm, [ed temperdreuires fudf,zy id mteÃeHum cutdientis defcen ^^^-^fjf ^^ ^fidi orif ingufti f[ffff^J^^ humorit ^^-^ eopldm rcfiiustnt,[enfim dutem 'mfltientibus,uel etii iÂ«o fitUdtis complentur:fic inimi puerorum quintum excipe repofiint,uidÃ«dum eR.^dmmdiord'mtcÃ¼c(lu,uelutpdmhf fi^^ritii rum dptos dd percipiendum inimos non fubibuntt Vtile igitur e^l hdbere quos mitdri primum,mox umcere ucd lis,it d pduldtim er fuperiorum jfies erip. Htsd^iÃ³ pri ceptores ipfos non idem mentis, de jfiirittÂ» in dicendo poffe concipere,fingulistdntim prafemibus, quantum ilidcelebrÃ¼dtedudientiuinjimÃ©ios. MiximdetiimpirS . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

tloquciUhg conjid^dnmojnme dffici, htine cocipere tmd,gt;,n ,â¢-gwcf rÃªntm^t Innsformdri quoddm modo dd mturim'^'t'^'* forum,dequibusloqumur,necef[eeH, Isp^oquog^''^^'â quot;quot;^ tteroÃoredfiorq; cÃ¼,hocmdioributuplutor^i^ c^^^â f^f^[^i,â ^^ mouetur, idcoq; er liudc crefcit, er impetu dtigeTur,

^ â^J^.^^?quot;Â®*â* âÃª^'^ guudet. EÃ quiedim tdeitd^^y v^Ã¨n^ u Mi^ndtio^um dieendi tantÂ» fompAntim ÃdborilnÂ»'quot;'^'^'^'^^'

^â Â»Â«wÂ». Â»^Â»i *^ wtivmduiitorcm dentittn^,^det Jupfa modum fer*' j'^A,lt;^^A,^gt;tnones(ittoÃlcre.Et fanÃ¨ coimpidt ^uKnKnte,ueldecli^ mdntii hdbitum,uel ordntis uocem,iÂ»c^u^,proniwcid^ tionem,i!lam demc^i dnimi ft corporifmottvnt,fifdorem, ut dUd pr^teredm, et fdtigdtionem,dudiente uno,nÃ³nne gf, wj ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^uidddm pdti,furori fimilc uidedturfNouefJet in rebut humdniseloquentid,fi tdiUum cumfingulitloqueremurÂ» a nbsp;nbsp;ConcbyliÃ¼ ex eoÃ§Â« pifciuin gencre eft, quos Graeci Ã¨Ã¯fÂ« Ks/tyMÂ«Â» uoeantpeipue aptos gulf. Plinius ut purpura intâ c5 chas ponit. Hor.epod. NÃ³ me Lucrina iuuerint cochyba. Grae ci uidenf conchilia dixiffe.gnali appeUatiÃ¶c TÃ h^KKÃJli^fjttc, ut apud AthenÃ§Ã» ex Epicharmo ayifii Tra/foÆawi noueux!Â«, b Alexandrin.)Notneft de AlexÃ¤drinaluxuria,quid lite ris DiandatÃ»fÃ®f.cuÃ®portÃ«toftâindulfitCleopatra.Annotatii etiameftÃ Valerio ficfuiffedeliciiscneruatos AlexÃ¢drinos, ut cum cos A rchelaus aduerfus Gabinium urbe edudos, ca' lira uallo ac foffa cingere iulTiffct uniuerÃ fuedamarint, ut tityiv ,t,^^ ^ut-iÃ opus publica pecunia faciendum loearetur.

^e*^^ 02^ rdtionepuerorum ingeiÃ¼d dmolcdntur, O'^uo modotrdddnddfint. CAP. III.

r*772ââ^ ^â*'^T~^^â*â^'^ ^^^^ Pâ*'^^^}'^Â°â^^^lt;^^ ParitÃ¤t ingenium eiut, ^YiÂ»Ji nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tnprmtsq^ndturdmperjj^iciet. IngenijfignuMM

'^â¢^'â^^1''quot;^'' ' ''pitruK prÂ£cipu!im,mcmorii ek. Eins duplex uirtuifi*

I 'tati (il^pfrcipe^e^ofidelitercontinere'.Proximwm'imÃ¯U^ ua de 5 Cice tio.iidm i^^lt;^ e^ docilif tidturlt;e:pc tdmen,ut ed ^uÂ£ Â» aJâ*^^^^' ^^^^^^ '^quot;^^^^l^}^P^ hdbitum forte et i^effingt;,O' fi gt;Ã¿Ã¹i vfrid IRidi ^Pf*â*notÃ¤blfeeH. Noddbit mihi jpebonte indoUs^efti culx imitari ^âââ^ imitidi fludio pctet,ut ridedUir. Ndm probtu^p^ ones.inquit, in priwis erit iUeuere'ngeniofut, dlioquinon^iutdui^ Â«f indobs^n ^â^^hn tdrdi^Jf'^Jm^nij,lt;ptdmmdU-Probt^Mtemdbi^o dices,amp; que fegni,O'idccnfe'pMrimum dberit.Ã®iicmcM (^UgtÅ¸ddelf

^hqulcifiidpblju^t,^^^^^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;id SVnS

f^ fiMfemmd, celeriut fe effu^^, er 'mitdtÂ£ ff ie Ai et ^^, ^ y,^, â¢ 1 hcrbuiÂ£dndnibuidriÃisdntemcffemflduefcuM.'Pldcent' '^

(piondminodotrdÃ¼ji'i^^uiJitdifcentis dnmM,S^t c^ui^ XÂ»Â«ey.M^ Ã¢^m, niji mftUer^^emiÃJ : eptidd imperidmiigndntur:

(piof^dm continet t^uSjf^uofddpt deb^tjit: dlios contint f^^Ã^^'^ÃfÃ^ wddtioconttmdiiÃn dlijsplut mpeiiafdcit^Mdii iÃ¼e dc*âX^lt;t ' AtHt tur ptKr,(ptcmUtK^c^tet,lt;piem^kiridiunct,lt;p(iuiClut^*^^j^i^^^^^ fiedt.Viic erit dfÃ¨ndui dmbituÃiuc mordebit abiurgdtio, htvnebonorexcitdbittinhoedefididftunfpidmuerebor-

Ddndd eSl tdmÃ« omnibut dUaud remiÃio^non folwin auid'^ÃÃ^ f â¢'â^^ nuUdres cÃ¼ poe perfcrrcpoÃit continuum liboreni,dt^^^Ã^' p^ que Cd quotp, lt;ptÂ£ fen fu er dnimd cdrent,ut ferudre uiM^t,^Y-fiam poÃint,uelutquietelt;Ãternd retendutur,fed tpiod retinentÂ»r fiudiwm difcendi,uolutdte,(ptÂ£coginonpotcSl,conÃdt^ tnet^^^otit tt^ Udep er uirium pliw Afferunt dd difcendum renoMi dc evr^^^s^J-it^^ reccntes,erdcrioremdnimiV)n,lt;piiferÃ¨nece^itdtilutre

pugndt.Hcc me offindcrit lufut m pueris,eÃ¼ er boeÃÂ»^^^ '^ gnwm dldcritdtHineip mm triÃem,femper^ demiffmÂ»

1^^ Ati PÂ°ff^ cre^Â£circaftudUmentti foi^fCwn^ fiyou'Ã¯ibcquo^imaximenaturali M^iStTUf mp^'utdeeatr

iÃ oiiit tarnen fit remiÃionibut.ne aut odium fiudioru/nt aciiint negw^aut otij co'uctudtntrnnimiai. Simt ctiant nonnuRi acuendis pu^oru mgenijs non inutiles lufus, cum pofitis muice cuiu/q^generisquxfiiimafik temulM tur. M.ores ^ inter ludendum fimpUcius detegnt^ modonu^a Meatur jetas tam infirma, qu^nÃ¶ protinus quid reÃ¤Ã¼^prauumq^; fit di fiat,turn uel maxime forman ,M^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^j^^^ fiftiulandi nefiia e^i, ez pneipientibus facile ere dit. Vrangas enim citius qudm corrigas, qua in prauton induruerumtt Protmus ergo nequid cupide, nequid mÂ» probe,nequid impotenter faciat,moncdus ell pucr.Ã¼a*

lt;' uihuur^k^^^ii^^^dÃ¯^entes,quanlt;fiumetreceptumfit,cebry Ã^yp dt 'j^^us ânonimprobet,n^ime^uelm^mmwm,quiadefor r^hÃ¨Ã³pewty,^^^^ ^^ff-YHih; cdl,Qr certe quod conuenit,fi atatem mud fi AX^ rgt; ,.âtes,miuriat deinde, quodficuiedi menstamiUiberaUs, ^yu -y^ utobiurgationenoncorrigdtur,isetiamadplagas,ut ^^ppÃ^^ qu^q- mancipia, durabitur: pofiremo, quod ne opus erit quidem hac caftigaquot;tlone,fi afiduus fiudioruin ' ' exailordfiitcrit.'i^umcferÃ¨negligentiapiiedagogorii/m fc emedari uidentur,ut pucri nonfacere qui reda fu/nt eogantur, fed cur nonfccerint,pumiantur. Denique aan parutilu uerheribus cocgeris,quid iuueni facias, cui nee adhiberi poteÃ¼ ku mffifi,^^tmfiord difcenda fumtf Ad . nbsp;nbsp;4Ã§ quod mult a udpulamibus di^u deformiatZ^ mox ut*

frciwdif f^tur^ fÂ£pe dolore uel mctif^cidcrw^, c^ui fuior'rÃ©jr'mgit dnmm, Ã§y Abi-citquot;, /tÃ§jj rpfiut Mcisfuo 8^^ O'tedium diHdt. Idm Æ mmor m ddigendh euÃo

âiiTprteceptorum moribui fuit cura, pudet dicere in quie probrd^dndi hommes ifo c^dcdi iure AbutAn tur, qudm det aujs ^Â«o^ ttonr,uqiu.m oceuÃonem hic mi ferorummetus. t^onmorAbormpdrtehACfnimiumelito-ft'^^ia

^od inteÃ¼igitur,Cl^dre hoedixiffe futis cA,in leftitfw c^,/.^Â«/ infrmdm er miuriÂ£ obnoxidm^nemmi de bet nimium li* cere.NMteduibus 'mÃ¢UucndusfitArtibM^wiÃc formd*^^^â*'^ *d bitur^ut Ãert poÃit Ordtof, nbsp;nbsp;lt;{Â»Â£ m (jUid^uc igtdte m*

chodndd,dicere mgredidr^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Eicere in '

a Rctenduntur.)Ideftremittuntur,namhancuimrcha grediar.^y* bet,uf relt;ludo,refigno Similitudinedufta abarcubâ.qmbâ MÂ«ityo|., turn fagittard non uti cogitct.ne neruos quidem accoiiuno' darefoleant. Herodotus fcribitAmafidem Aegypfnregent, reprsebenfum ab atnicis, quod uoluptatbus indulgent co* meffationibusfedederet,reipondifle,qui arcubus praeliaren fur cum illis uti ueUent, rum intendcre, ubi uero lam eflent ufi remittere confueui(re,nam fi nung retendcrentur fore ut diruptinulli effent ufui. Ira quoquchumanamconditionem fefe habere, nam fi homines rebus feriisfe perpetuo occuper, neque aliquam uitÃ¦ partem iocis ac lufibus imperti int, im* promfum aliquem uel in furorem, uel morbum fonticum delapfuros iduidentem fe utriquereifua tempora impend dere,

PRi^M, m^ui legendi, fcribendi^ ddeptM frit'^Xi^r^^^^ fdcultdtem, grimdticif e^i locut, nee refert dc^Â£^â gt;^^M oi^ co,dn de Idtmo locptir, e^udnspidm grtcum ejfe priorem fildcct.Vtricj^ eddem uid eH.Hecigitur^rofef iocu^f^'^^''^^^^ ^ uÃme in iu^f pirtes dimdMur^ re^ii lo^u Ã©difiÃ© mid, '* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

/ '\^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;in^ontcpromittit.Ndetfcribcn^iriitÃ¯o^^iunildciM loquendo eR,et endrrdtionem praccdit emÃ«ddtd leÃ¼io, er mixtum bis omnibus iudidum efi. QMquidÃ« itd fe* Critid. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ucteres grdindtici, ut non uerfus modocen forid Ã¼iudsm uirguU notdre,amp; libros,qui fulfordere turinfcripti,tdsjuim fubdititios fummouerefctmilid per^ mifcrint fibi ,feddutoresdliosmordincm redegcrini, dlios omnmoexe^eruitnumero.Ã¼ec poctAS legijfe futis 1^â^jy'^tti eR,excÃ¼tiendum omne fcriptorum genus, non propter â âquot; 'â* hiÃorids moio^ed uerbd,quie frequenter ius Abdutori-Â» bm fumuni. Tuw needtrAmuÃecn ^rAmmdtice poted ^ff^ P^^f^'^^iS^J^ ^^ dicÃ¨dum fit, Nee fi rdtionemfidcrum ignorctfpoÃ«tM inteÃ¯ligAt, qui (ut dit A mittAm) toties ortu occdfu^^fignorum m deeÃA* rdndii temporibiu utAturHeC ignArAphilo^opkif^ciM propter plufmos in omnibus ferÃ¨ cArmvnibut locos, ex intmd qudftionu nAjWAliwm fubtilitAte repetitos, tuM uel propter Empcdoclem in ^Â£cis,VdrronÃ« dc Lucres' titm in ldtinis,qui pricepid fdpientig uerfbus trddide runt. Lloquemid quoique non mediocri eH opus ,utde undquAq^ edrum quds demonjirdumus rcrum,dicdt pro â^ * *y^? '^ pria et copiofe. Quo minus fans ferendi,qui bdne drtem ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ut tenuern dc tetundm cduiÃ¯Ã¯dntur: qua nyt ordtori futu

ro fwnddmeittdfideUter iecerit,quicquid fiperÃruxeris corruetjiteceffdridpuerifjiucundd fenibus, duleisfecre torumcornes,or qua udjoldomnifiidiorum genere, plus bdbedt operis, qu'uni oÃef^dtion^.

NE quit igUur t^n^Mm pirMfdjUdiiit^dmmdti ceselÃªmÃ¨nid, nonc^uU^^^ÃtopÃ©rÃ©ecofondn Â»rr^yiM^ tes Ã uocdlibus difcernere,ipfdslt;ji eds in ferniuoedU^ Â«K*. merit, miUdrumq; pdrtiri, fed quid interiord uclut fden buius ddeumtibusAppdreiit muit drum rerumÃubtiU^, que non modo dcuere ingenidpuerilid, fcdÃ¨xÃ«rcÃ¨rc 'dfgt;' tiÃmdmquot^ eruditionem deÃientidpoÃit.An^uiufk^iyiVr,-a,-, ie bet duris e^ exigcre liter drum fonosf non her de mdgi/c'^^J^ei^ii/ qu'uni neruorum. At grumdtici fditem omnes in hune def^'^Ã^f^^ feendent rerum tenuitdtÃ«, dÃ©fini nealiqug nobis neceffd^''^ rite liters,non cuntgr^d'/cribimus, turn enirn db his-dux Â«1- u-et- ikÃ^iva' dsmutudmur, fed proprie inldtinis, utinhii^feruus cr^''^ ^ tL uulgus,AcolicÃ¼m digummon defiderdtur,ey mÃ©dius eu j^^^ ^^ quidiim u cr i liter Â£ fonus. NoÂ» enirn fie optimum dieb id eft â fonus mut,ut opmum,z^ heri,neq^ Ã¨ pldnÃ¨,neq^ i duditur.An ^y^*â â'^ rurfus dUte redundcnt,prÂ£tjr if^/fi^h^i^: quÂ£ fi tur mÂ« Uto neceffdrid efi, etidmeomrdridmfibi pÃ´'fcit'.E.t k,quÂ£ ce â'Ã¦ ^gt; quot;5*Â®

{ius(^ecies^,iiÃ®fi quad pdulum d, nofiris obUqudtÃ»ffedp literÂ« inter pd dpud QrÂ£cos,nunc tdntum in numero munet, er no* ^âquot;Â® Â®'' firdrum ultimd x, qud tdmÃ« cdrere potuimus,fi non qute fiffemus. Atc^ etidm in ipfis uocdlibus grdmmdtici ekui\,^;i^ Ã«, dere,dn iditptdt^^pxonfondntibus ufus dcceperit,quid idm^^ r- V'vÂ»**!^ rtP ^!^ÃS^'Ãthf^i^^/gt;^ â '*Â°^ â^ ^Â°t-Atlt;^ Ut uocdles iugun ^-^ â'^*' tur, dut uridm longdm fdciiM, ut ue^res fcripf^e, qui gemmdtione edr^ ucÃn dpice uiebuniur : âdÃ»t duds^Ã ^t rvvft\ ^pM^ cUm ck irib^^^^^Vii^ bM^m, Ã¼UQi ^Ã§^^ ^quot;^

quit Ãm, Ãnon uliqujc officio ^nj^Aftum fiwgAntur, C^u erctetiAmqâiomododuAbâM demivmuocAlibufinÃ* ip/M coeundi natura Ãt^ euw, cot^nMiu^n wUa^niÃ al t^^^.Jj^'^S^t-Atej^Ãteri i^li^dit. ^onijatenim cÃ, ab iÃ¼o iacit. EtutaiiomoTo num Ãribitur uuivM^iy fer uns, Sciat etiim Ciceroni plaÃ§ai jje aijo aij aijamqi gemt nata iferiber^quod Ã cR,ctiam iimgetur ut conÃonans. ^?Â« yÂ«,Xy.gt;-d ^^^^iiÃ^^f^lt;^^ lt;lâ*^d wÃ® liters proprium, quid coim Zc^Z^^J^ *^ gt;num,quÂ£ eu quihui cognatio: nfe-miretur, cur exfcant Scsbclium. noÃit fcahelium, dut d pinna (quod cR acutum)Ã-ewis 'â^-^,, ^f^^X^- trinque habens adem bipennis,ne iÃ¼Ã³rumicqiuiur er^ ^ a foycffi ^ qui qui|^ 4 pennia duabus hoe effie nomen exiÃiiÂ» ru^t^A-tgt;dgt;: â Ãtattt,pinaafauiumdiciuolunt,'t^cquehafmodonoue* ,dntmutationes,quaf affÃ©rant dcclmatio, aut prapoÃ^ ^Rt 'tio,ut fecatfecuit,cadit exciditjcalcat excalcat, cr Ãc Ã lauando lotua,o- inde rurfus idotus, (y mille alia, fed Pkriq; cÃ¼ 1^^ ^ '^^^^ 4âÂ®^ cafibu^ Â£tate tranÃerwnt. Uam ut Vd non uidfrÃ©t lefifetj- RuÃjin Valerios, 7urios^ uenerund^ta arbos, 'i^jc dl quot;'' Idbos.Mpos, etiarn (y clamos dc paffes'letaiisffucrunt. ftio, ne rc' A tq; hfc ipfa s liter A ab his nommibi^ exclufa, in qui^ ^ikalUn ^â^^^â^ ^P'^â^ â^^^â'^^ ^^^M^jÃ¿^^^quot; dtqnÃªpuÃ¯tare expngÃ« t dicebant, quo modo foedum fadusq; pro affiratide, ad io3chrci I'^'^â^â ^^^^â dl.^.âii^ZtÃªJii*â contraG^pi ita affirare hic lafes reftitu fjkiu,ut pro Fundinio Cicero teffem ,quiprimam enn diacre fuÂ«â'^â^^^â^^dicerenon poffet,irridet,S^^^Ã¶'^uÃªmlocum' ftilicetfik alt ar um dedimus aliquando ,umde ^rwaserbrÃ¹zÃ¨s, fqim.Merpt ^bdena, neenon cadem fecit ex dueUo JbeUum, tmde agennimsf dueliÃ¼S quidam dicere b^Ã^aÃ¹ff fÃ ^d'fflortW,^l^^

K. ZrvÂ«.. 4^0 R AT 0 R. LIBER L $i tf^r QJfâ* lt;^ ^'^â'â^ â^ââ* ^ ^w-etJÂ«*Â« cogndtiofQutire mi mumirumjfiuetuÃis operibiaurbisnoHrÂ£ c^ celebri-)^ bm templis legMtur AlexMter, cr CaJflt;uKrit. Ãjuid o At(iueu prÃ®mÃ»tdtie muiccm Æ ut liÃ¨cobd Ã§^ iMr^Otthâ^â gt;'â^'^ *5 Æâ¢ chides,ZJ-Pul^wf^^b^rentur.AcncmgrfÃ¢sJdtcin p^^ ^^^r,,^ t^Â«gtf^rj(IfdfrÃ´Â»K,'Ã®f probdueront,Ãc oisiihij^tiuÃ« ^ â'nos 5lt;^ wd'wia feccrut Aeoles,dd vU(JÃ:in dÃ©duit as eÃ.Ouid ^ â pifiolÃ r n gt;nbsp;MOÂ» e quoq- i loco fuit, ut Menerui, cr Iclcr, cr magetâ pjg,,jÃ¦^, fer,cr deiout ui(iorc,pro deioui uiitori. Sed mibi locu ââ*''' fn''ptÃ¢ fignire^fitM^eÃ¼. Non enirn docco ,frd ddmoneo doduÂ«' quot;^ââquot;^~ ros.lndcin fyUnbMcurdtnenÃbit,dc c^uibusm orthoj^y ^a of^-^ grdphiii pdued ditnotdbo, turn uidebit, dd (ptem hoc pf j. -sÂ«â-^ tâ tinet, quot cr ^H^ pdrtes ordtionis, epunqudm de numt ropdnumeonuenit.

a Aeolic.dig.) OuoufiAfolenfcsfuntproafpirationc, atlt;Ã® etiam in medio diftionum, ut uocales fepararenC. Etuis ut nomme etiam indicator figura gemini c tradnur,cum po teftas literac fcibcet fuiffe uidcatur. Iraq; illi pro iXiva FiXita dixere.K Ã§o/o^ ^^gt;/oji, amp;nbsp;/Â«li Zaf 05.

les aPpirationis notant tantum pofuere quod ?lt; ipfi in amiÂ» quis codicibus aiiimaducrtimus,Â«uium legentts Â«die. Qued etiam ex hoc Quintil.loro manifefium eft. Nam fi afpiratio nisinquit.fignatio neceffariaeft. ent etiam attenuatienisjd eft quam ^iX^v uocant. Etfi Athenxus diuerfum fenfit.Nam K ueteres ait non fupra, fed ante uocales afpirationem poÂ» fuiffe,arbitran etiam fe.fts uocalibus quibus afpirari ueUent H literÃ¢ ptatferipfiffe quod Romani adhuc obftruent. Loc3 fubfcripfiexlib. 9. Tin/tÂ«ijjÃ³juivoi t^vainyÂ«i')i,v^j'ix rnna^ (tui THv svoÃ¼Ã¯Â«/ TH Tr^^ffiiifia Ã§Ã»init , oun its! Ãa/HtiiTUÂ» TiJÃ®afq wCtsty lÃ¨s aXXÂ«s,7rjgt;Ã yÃ ^ TÃ¶uTUV TCcotHitiv, oÃ®^iÂ«i A x^/iÃ tÂ«3 H soixuÃ¼v TuTtuitftoÃ¢s TiiÃ¹nrKXa'csirHy J'xSimyJ'dTriÅ¸Kilat^xl^t V^a TtxvTw Tur /Â«ituyojutVMÃ¯ }V()/*Â«TBÃ¯ TÂ» H Ttpj'yct'f^ftjÃ¤ ÃZ* /49V(ftÂ»Ã¯ Ãquot;]Â«J/(Â«JÂ«/*5(trjÃ¯Tt|Â»

c Atq; ut uocales) Videre etiam Graininaticum oportet, quomodouocalcsfuain uidelket retinenttsuim feu potefta tem conifigÃ¤tur. Aut enim eadem pro longa geminanf, qua geminatione uetcres longam uolucrnt mrclhgi, ita ut GrÃ§cÂ« cum apicem fupra ducunt,hoc e(t,ut ipfi loquuntur tk^/zÂ«' Kpay.ut Dii.Feelix, Viirtut. Aut coeut in diphthengfi q eft uo cis commiftiOjUt prximus.coelii.Tribus accidere neutrii po' teft.Coitus autem uocalium complexio eft: accipiÃ«da,quÃ¦ Ã¤ GrÃ¦cis noininatur iTu'xXK-l'it. ut in Ã¨Ã§5Â«XMÂ»Ã®- ? Ã.ftint in topic xione,8Â£ confpuo/p. Nunq autem eafJemconfonanres ton pleftimur pronuncia(ione,uteflficio addico,id 91 duabus iftis uotalibus i 8C u.cS pro eonfonantibus funt,ufu uenit.Ã natu ra confonantium alicniim.Porto i litera ut confonans tn etj am iungitur.Sicut tih in afficio amp;nbsp;addico ff.et dd. iunflas nÃ³ compleftimur, id eft diiiidimus pronuntiatiÃ¶c, ita in ano Slt; Pompeftus.n.ut fit ai una,amp;: io altera fyllaba,pei,amp; ius.

d Scam.Scabel.) Habetem AI amp;B. cognarionÃ« quod in GrÃ¦cis eft maniftftum,ut cum in pi jterito paftiuo priini of dinisacuti fono^tuerbo^t, primae fyzygisc mutae in M. trÃ¤n' feunt.Eft autem magna cura hare res animaducrtenda.SC tra denda pucris.quaexpcdita multum dtffjcultatiscxclulum fucrit.

e Quornodoferdum.) HÃ¼clocum ita deferiptnex antigs duobus confentientibuscodicibus confidomcexplanatuÃ§t, utappareataudafter,a quibufdam mutatum fmfTe.quifup' pofuere fordefi foedusip. quomodo SC apud Prifcianum li. igt; mendofÃ¦ legitur. Nam hot loco nulla fit de inutatiÃ¶e a fpi ra tionis mentio,8( contextusoratienisiftam inculcationÃ© nul lo modo patitur. LegÃ«dum igitur ftrdum,focdus!p quorum uttStp quid fignificet nemo ignorat.Docet a fit Qynt.diligÃ© ter obferuandum, q liters fuos locos naturaliter obtineant queue in alioÃ§e quafÃ® fubierint. NÃ¤ SC R.in locÃ¼S.SC in hums T.alicubi fucceffit. SC F.litera utimur pro afpirato, qus eni Grsci per Ã-enuntiarunt, Latini per F maluerunt.ut ftma, fagus,fur,afer. QuÃ¦ igitur Cryci,inquit afpirate pronuncia runt,nos quidem non afpirate diet mus, fed tamÃ« confimilitâ. Docuitenim Sc Prifc. inter F SC?, proferedum differentiani effe. Poftet aÃ¼t gs cupiens fundaniC aliter neg Ã§^uv/Ã¹iof ft ri bereCHoe manifeftum,ut confido expofitione noftra fequen tibus etiam declaratur,ubi aliaÃ§j quoque literarum permu' tationeinoficndit,utBurrhus proPyrrlio. Bruges ,pP]irye

ORATOR. LIBER L 55 gibus,baigna, proPhalÃ§na. Quod non animaduertentesifti torrtftortsetiÃ¢ huncloiÃ´deprauaruntjupponctes belenÃ¢. Ca ttÃ§t quod fequitur fdlocum, ftlitemcj, etiainfi in praefen-tia hoc fcriptionis genus tueri non queain, tarnen fccutus,cÃ¼ uerum judicaflem, aliquote codicum cxpreiTain feripturam, aliquorum cuidentia ueftigia,fic relinquendum putaui.

Â£ SiciAor )Confueucre AeolÃ«fesproo.Ã¯.poncre.ipfuintÃ¿ â¢i.ut plenius fonarent o JWll^ÆS quart explere, ut (oufÂ«Tay, non quidem longa prima, ficut fi diphthongus effet, ou oporteret effe.quoduerfu Calliinachi probauit Prifeianus lib. i. fedi fenptioneToÃ¼ofono Aeolicoexpreffo. ItaoÃ¹^uartÂ« Aeolen^ fes dicere,rcriptum Ã Quintilia.accipip, quos Latini imitati, ut in a!qs plerifij, Vlyffem fecerunt.

Etfw enm ^quoru/m fuerunt Ariflotcles dti^ue^O-vX^XrvTMA ah TheodedeSyUerbd niodo,o- nom/nd, er eoniwit^^i^Tquot;^â* '^^quot;'^ iiionestrddiderunt, uidtlicet quad in uerbis uim ferma vi^-ÃAh^ f-^, nifjn nommibiu mdteridm-.quid dUfrum e^ quad ^Â°lt;iâ*iâ!^^^^'^X^^f^ mur,dltcrwn de quo loqumur: in coumHionibut dutent'^'^yr^ eorumcomplcxwmeffeiudicdueruntiqudsconiundio^'^''^quot;' ^â â'quot;â^ nes d plerip^ dici feÃ¯o^fed hxc'uiletur ex fyndefmomdiÂ» gis propridtrdnÃdtio.Pduldt'm Ã PbilofopbiSfdcmdxid

me Stoicis du^im cR numerus^dc primtvm conumHiom^^ lt;*y-pwn 'gt;vOVMgt; busdrticuii ddieÃi, poAprÃ¦poptiones,nominibusdp^,,^ *Z^cJ^ pelLdtio,deinÃ¼ pronomÃªn^demde mixtum uerbo pdrti'd cipiumjpfis uerbis dduerbid. Ã¼i^er ferma drticulosna defderdt/deo^ in alids p^s ordtionumfpdrgwntur.

Seddcceditfuperiortbuitnterieiiio.AlijtdmÃ«exidone ^'^^^'^ â ' is dutoribus oda duntdxdt pdrtes fecuti fuM,ut Ariftar

chus,cr dtdte noÃrd Pdltma^qui uocdkulum,fiue dppel Utionem nomini fubiecerunt tdnquimfpecies eins. At hi ^i eiliud nomÃ«,dUud uoedbuhmfdei'dnt^wuem-.'Ã¼ihdoff c .

tKmut fucrunt, qui ipfum udhuc uocdiulum di dppeUdÂ» ^f^^^^'^ ^^^^^ ^gt;*^â^''''^gt;*f,^^ effet uocMom corpm uifu tdHÃ^ qur minifeÃum.do.-nM^ IcHua appeUdtio, cui uel alte^ rim ^effet^uei'utru/nque, uentus, ealum, dem, uirtudgt; [ f^iâ^'7â*^Alt;I^figt;4Â»lt; Ã§r dffi^rdtioncm,ut heu,er trdHdtionent, ut nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ni^pproidntur, Vocdlulu dn dp

^-^ â ^'âUâ^'ipcÃ¼dtio dicendd nbsp;nbsp;Ts^ixruya^ ia, er fubijeiendd nomiin

nee ne,quid pdrui refert,liberum opindturis relmquo^ Declmdreinprimisnoinmdetuerbdfcireoportere pueros,er generd noffe, CAP. VII.

NOmind declmdre er uerldin primii pueri fel* dnf, neq; enim dUter peruenire dd inteUeUum fe 0rr^Ah^iA'rquenti'dm poffunt,qaod ddmonere fu^erj^cm.jn erdt,ni fidmbitiofd feftmdtione plerique d^pofieribi^but hiaf^^^^ rentier durit oÃentAre difeipulos ctrcd'^Ã©iQftordind A ^r^m^l1^,^^ lunt, compendia mordreniur^^Atqui/; quis er didice^ ritfdtis,^^ quodnonminm decffe interim foÃ¯et,eruo* luerit docere quÂ£ didicit, non erit contents trddere in nommibm tridgenerd,er ed quÂ£ fient duobiis,omnihuf* uecomunid.i^tc Ãdtim diligente putdbo, qui promifeud qua epicend dicMttur,oÃenderit, in quibm fexmvterqi per dltirum dppdret, dut quÂ£ foeminmd pofittoe mdreSj ^,fi^^'f^2^'^â^ 4ttt titrait fammtu ÃgniÃednt, qudlid funt murent^ er Glicerium.Scrutdbitur mille preceptor deer dtque broMtic nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^Â°^(gt;Â°^â^ '^

locucofulite foslongos^ fecerunt.'Vbierit dliudÃcretius,Sylllt;e,Bur CimcrariÃ¶, fi^G^bd:, Plduti, Punfe, Seduri, dlidq; ex edfu ndfeentk

tn^t, et bis lt;iuÂ£ poft nutos eaenimt, Mide Vopifem, inm Cottd,Scipiones, Lenates, Sennifunt : (y ex lurijs au fis pentes (iuolt;^,dc locd,zy dUd tnultd repcrids inter nommu edufids. in fieruis id intercidit iUud genus ([dâdu* ceidtur Ã domino,tende mdrcipores,publipores^,Qjtit rdt etii,fiit ne dpud Gracos uÃ¼ i^uddA fieteti cdfitn, et dd pud nos eptoq- feptimi. NÃ¤ cum dico bdfid percuÃi,no u^ tor dbldtiui ndturd,nec fi idegritce died datiui quot;^ t^o^Ã¼*^

S5lt;Â». ÃÂ®^Ã ^Mfi.Â°X^Ji'{^^^^ ^Ãª^^^'^^^.^'i^i gÃªner d,Z!r (pidlitdtcs^cr pcrfonM,(y numerps/Li^

terdrij penÃ¨ifia. funt bidi^ttriuUlfiJcieMj^.Jims^^^^ quÃ³d.gt; ddmiÃdturbdbutduiedeclmdtionibÃ¼snohtcÃ¼attur. Nj ^â¢â*' ^ ^'^Â®'^ , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;non dicitur,

?^3l^5fÃ¶ii **â uerbi^t^Odtiones fint dubt iUud autÃ© pÃ¤ idri potefi:, Ã¤uiddliud dUo loco ut IcÃ¼us (y fipi* â*âÃâ'' domus r nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;noadinodu

^^tS^^(Ã©^^^''â'^^J^^^^^^^!lgt;i^i^^^^^ ^^r^^^^^^^^ diffimik eft nutritor. IdtnÃitUfris MiejodiÂ» fyludm^nÃ¨nnepropriic âÂ«'.^ modi cuiufddmrdtionise^^^^dmono^^UiumetutinueniAsi foruffistoe cuifimilefietur,dccipimtis,diiter,tit: lt;^X^T^7lt;Â«;%i*quot;*â'^â'* Pdditur intered domus omnipotetis otympi. Ãfiter,M: jurbaf uero 7otis VfiqueddcÃ³turbdturdgris. 'â'** nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'' perfedifta,

EÃ etidtn quiddm tertius modus,ut urbs bdbitdtur,tende Ã®â^^quot;^ etcdpuscurrifur,mdrcnduigdtur. Prd/us quoq;,dtlt;fi po itidÃ«beHa' tM diner firn u^Ã¨nt q'mdiednt.Quidfquod multducrbd âÆ âÂ®quot;âquot;quot;* i^ontotwmdecltndtton^ord^cferutfou^ddbetummu PRANS.fie tdntur,ut fero wj preterit o. QUieddm ter tig demu per^ omcat em ai Æ- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. terum cum,

ongfigiird dKtmtur,tit licet,piget, t^gddfimtle epnd qu, prandit. (14 pdiiumrinoeMif in din(rbiÃ¼ trdfiMihus.t^d ut iw.Â«*Â»Â«â¢!quot; qui potjuK.

( Ãu Cf diuj itd di^u Cf fidu. Swit enim hac quolt;^; uet bd pAniapiAliii quidem^non timen quiUi didofifio^. , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, HeuirtutibiKCfuitiisontionK. CAP. iX.

(t, yi nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;AmcuMomnKoritiotreshibeituirtutes,utemen*

w, v^'Z'^'^A.diti.ut dilucidi,ut omiti fit,quiidiccrc ipte, quoi err^M-^ -^^ eH pr^cipuum, pÃ¯eriq^ ormtuifulijciumt, totidÃ© uitiif qug fivntfupndidis coiiiririi,emendite loquÃ«di regu^ lim,qult;e gnmmitices prior eA pirs, examnet.Vlicigi i i^^^i^^âvturucrb.K^itÃ¼jjngulis^iut pÃ¯uribus.Verbi numc generli liter iccipi uoto^mm duplex eorum inteUedus eftultert qui oii perquit fermo neditur figniÃcit,ut ipud Hord, Horat.in yerbd^ prouifim tem non inuiti fequentur.

uitdntes imbiguititem quidim dicere milueruntjuoceSt didiones^,loMiqnes,pnguli funt,iMnÃ³fird,dutperegri ni^u^mplicidjdu^con^ofitd^Mt^ iut tnnÃd* r c^f^^lâ âyy| 'td:duiu)itdtd,dutfidd.VniuerioÃ¼iiium fepiusqudtn ffi^i^j^ me A.Licet enim diamus iliquid proprium,Ãped o[um/ubiime,nihil tdmen horwm,nifi 'm compÃ®Ã¨xÃ¹ loque di,[erie^ cotingit. Leutdimus en'nn uerbi bene rebus dC commoddtd Â« Sold eA, quÂ£ notdri poÃit uelut uoaUtdS, iv^mvitt^ tucjxovicc dicttur^cuiu^ mcoddcclu$e$i^Ut inter duo,quÂ£ idem ÃgniÃcint,dc tintundem udlent,quod mi lius fonet,milis, Pr'mtd bi^iriÃmi^icÃolacifmifoeditiS ithfit.Sed quid 'mterim excufintur bte uitii,iut con[ue^ tud'me,dut dutorititc,dut uetuÃdte,iut deniq^ uiemitd^ te uirtutunut^dm fipe i Ãguris a fepinre difficile eÃf ne quem tdm lubricd obferudtio fiHat, dcriter fe m mu^

tenue iifcrimen grummuticus intenddt^de quo nos Idtim ibi loquemur, ubi de figuris ordtionis trftddndim erit, interim uitiwm qdâÃt m fmgulis ueriis,fit bdrbdrifmus. Barbarifm*. Occurrdt mihi forfdn dliquis, quid hic promijjor tdnti operis dignufdut quis hoc nefdt, dUosbdrbdriftnos fcriÂ«' bendoÃeri,dliosloquendofquid quod mule fertbitur, md Ie etidtn did neceffe eÃ¼: quiuitiofe dixeri^qonudq}^^ fcnptope^ccdt.lUui'pr^'^QÃe^ffjrd^^^^ t^ne^dnfmutdtioneihocfecudim, diui/wne, compte feriptionis, lt;^oi^m^Sed ut pdrud fint Iw^jSt k^'â pueri docentur ddhuc,e^ grdmmdticos offidj fui commo bcibo.sde* nemut.Ex quibus ft quis erit ptdnÃ¨ impolitus, e:^ ueftibu ta Ã^go'bi IÂ«wj modo drtis huius mgrcjfuSyintrd h^c quit profitentibosdepof wn commentdriolis mlgdtd funt,cofiÃet: doÃ iores wÂ«IJ?*^jJ^^ ^â td ddijciÃ«t,uel hoc primt^^uqd^ bÃ¿rbdrifmwm pluribus MufÂ» eUo * ntodis dccipmus:Vntim in gÃ«te,qudÃe)jt,fi quis ^Ã'â'^gt;j^jgf^'^r nel UilÃduimldtina ordtioni nomen inferdt, ut fcrrjwÂ»,h,adfum,â S quorotÂ£ umduturjdicifoletcdnthusyqudnqiumeoj^^'^ urri'afâ* qMm li^fJ^PJttitur Perfiut, ficut CdtuUus ploxenu cir^ rum, ItÃ« Bur Cd Pddim muenit^er in ordtione l^ie^fiue iUd Con^ *âÂ« iP Bruto. nelij GdUi c^,in PoÃlionem,cdfndr dfjeddtor Ã¨ GdUid du^^^^^^^f^^ Hum eH,ndm m^rÃ¼gdnt,quod Sdrdum eH, iUudÃ«s Ctccphfiiat, tere ro ex MuÃridJixU^Ajiejum genm bdrbdrifmi dccipi^ bnvât mus, quod fit dnimi ndturd, ut is d quo indolenter quid, ue^ pftat.ee dut mindciter,dut crudeliter didum fit, bdrbdre locwttÂ« Q^^^^jâ exiÃimdur : Tertium en iÃ®lud uitium bdrbdrifmi, cuiuschotuM,^ â¢x^gt;^ptduulgofuntpfurmd,fibfetidm^^^^

teÃ^ ut uerbo cui tibebit ddijciit Uterdm fyUdidmue. uel Ex oratione Â£ J fSeauroj^

ranc non dftrdb^f dwt dli'dOrÃ³ HlU.Mt eundÃ© aUo, aukm reH^ locum citÃ¢t, ftidocopothit. SedquidiimfcremiAciAtionemrruditio Â«de pro um nis fumerdÃ¯UexPo'Ã©tK folcnt, er stores duos prlt;ek* tilsconlula- . . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â¢

ribâmaftru' Ã¿ttcrmmMtUT.Sart MttmdxM^^ ^hinciipud jen catos latrun ptores c(irminum,dut uenia di^ndyMt ctidm Idude ducL culosdicit. * z

potiufi^ tud docendt crunt mmuf uulgdtd. Kim duos m WHO nomine fdeii bdt bdrhdrifmos Tinea Pldceminui ,ft ^!^Si!^^^ i^oftenfto credimus,preculAm pro pergn ld dicens,et mmuidtione cu c pro ^uteretur^ et tranfmu tdtione earn r prxponere^^^j^e/demi.At in cadÃ© uitif gemindtione,er Ã¯gt;\etieo Sufficieo dicens Ennius,poÃ«ti^ co iure defenditur. Sed in profd cjuoa eÃ¼^ugdansidin receptdmmutdtio. N-tw Cicero C^fh^Ã¯tdrivm exerÃ¤tÃ¼ iicit,ipjÃ¯cdnobonuocdnt,er Thrd/imcn'M pro Tharfo meno,multi dutores.etidmJijslineo trdnfmutdtio,uenÂ« Genius ex iicd^iwru/nt,Ãmiliter dlidi ndmÃueeÃ¼fdi^umdjÃentior, Â«âm Sc de * ^^flt;^^gt;^^^^'xit djjcntio,multi^ er b^cquot;^ dnalogidm ft* re citÃ¢t, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cuti,Ãue iÃ¼ud uerum eR, htc Ã^oq; pars con^c^u de fett

ditur. At iÃ¼e pex^^pinguisq; doÃ or, 7ut iÃ¼u detrdHio nem,duibies^monemputabit. Quidf quad quÂ£ddm quÂ£ ÃnguU proeuldubio uitiofd Ãunt^iurÃ¤d Ãne reprea benÃone diaM^ Ndm erdudertr^ er pondo diner forum generum ftmtbdridrifmi. At d'Mpondo,er trea pondo,ufq; ad noÃrdm Â£tdtem db omnibus diilum eÃ,et reÃ¼e dici MejfAldcoÃrmdt. Abfurdum forfanuidedtur dicere bdrbdrifmu, quad eR unius uerbi Mtiu,Ãeri,per numÃ©ros, dut genera Ãeut folaeciÃnumt fcala tarnen (T [copdjcoiftrd^ bordedfCj' muÃdÃcet Uterdr^mMi^iQ^

1KtÂ»,ietriiiionetn,diie{lionem non hdhedfftJlon dUout^'^^.'quot;' ââ* . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. tarutinmul

tiojAjMt,^ quod plurdud jin^thriter,O'jinguldrid plu /'a.offenf.cre rdl'tfr effiruHtur ; Cf vtidu qui dixenmt, ofn^Tm â*Â° â1âÂ®'^ Oui Â° nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;r nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;t diusdixeut:

Ã crut.SeÃ¿ioc q^oj^iWUrccoâ^c^^ juminc drtt,culpd Nouamuiia, ^Mortwidii pcmcrfciÂ«, perplexe uidear e:^ ipfc quitjlio^â amp;nbsp;Martiahs Wfm Addidiffe. Plot cxigut fuitiliMii quf decidut in di Â«ndita mu* cedo uitu^quu exepldedru iradi fcriptonopolTunt^ ni fia cadis, K fl cum uerfia inciderut, Ã¼tdtuijioPicÃ»^Z'^ BuropAtjet, âmft^au* ei contrixiT^j^tiu,Ãd^dtMlt;di^Xip^t q^c(.7\.o?^^p Grxei fiera. uocAt,noscoptexionedJcimut,quAlKejiApudP.VArro.

Cum te flAgruuideiedium fulmine Pb^ton.'^'^'^'^.'^'^'^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;j.'

Kdmf, effet profd ordtmJdfdemliterj^tSnn^i^^^^^ rif fyUdbif bci^l^df^Pjrietejrd^^fus/M fp^fetOj jtuccum fylidl3dcoYrcptdproducitur,ut: u/v..^^ Â«u v.vV^i i^'^

* yniia ob noxdm zs- furidf. P-xtrd cdrmen nqn depre bendusSed nee in edrmine uitid duceddfume.Vid nero na mji dure exigimtur, qÂ«Â« punt per fonos,qudnquAm per dfpirdtionem/lue ddifcitur uitiofe,ftue detrdbit^dpui nos pote^i qu^ri, dn mferiptio fit uitium,fi b Uterd e^b, H ufpiratio* Â«ott notd^cuiuf quidem rdtio mutdtd cum temporibuf eft ftpiiK^frcifime ed ueteres ufi etidm in uocAlibus, cum Â«dos^rcosc^ dicebdnt. Dtw deinde referudtwn,ne con* fonintibus d^irdretur, ut in Grdcc^ C^, triumpis, E* rupftbreui temporenimius ufHi, uteborpn^ ,cbentu^. riones, pneebones ddbuc quibufddm m^cr^^^ nid,.

nednt, Qua de re CdtuUi nobile efpivrdmmd cft .in* Confulelo* ie dwr^t ((({nat m^^i^^^9amp; ^^^^l^}^^J^gt; annotate

Â«requenter ^ mihi:nj.m mehe lÃ¿to^ pro medpud dntiquos,Trdgx ^^M-Wvv^ *^1â^ didrum prÃ©cipite fcript ores mue ter Hut librisinueni* ^ â^^J^/^^t^ â¢ Adhuc difficilior obferudtio cA per tenores, quoi â ^^a^(^ ^uidejtuA dnti^UK di^^onom comperi,ut uidelicet decimito d Gra^^ uefbo, qui rovyÃ§ dicu^l decents, quM Gneci Tt^OT'ad'laquocdntyCum dcutd et gruuts AÃd pro dUd ponitw^ in h'oÃ§.CdmiiÃ¯uift deuitur prund^dut grdUK^^rofixd,ut CÃ©thegtts,et prmd dcutd. N^ ft me^ tma^Kcâi ^â^ifiuidMr,dutflexdprogrdui, dutgrduisprodpice cumdufta fe dreuduAd fefuetur: quA ex diidbut fylldbts in^ifogÃ© quenti, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^fj^^t deinde fleAcntes dupliciter pecednt.Sed idfepitU

in grge^ i^dfui dccidit^ut AtreuttquÃ« nobis iunenibui doAiÃimipnesdcutd pr'mdlfce^qÃ¯eb^u^ecefdrio fecundd. grduis efet. Item Terei,r^er'^.^âc ^ dcc^, a nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tibus trdditd. Cte^rwmidm/cÃ¯o q^Ãdm eruditos, nonÂ»

nullos etidm grimdtico^c doceren de loqui, ut propter â-^â¢^r^rid^'^Ã¼ugdidm uocum de Ã¼erboru difcrimind, uerbum interim xi,d.^t^Â».^,-^Â»McutofonofintdHt,ut m tuis: CiuÂ£ctrcdmkttord,circu 'f^^Z^f ****^ Fifcofos fiopulos. nbsp;nbsp;nef grduempofueriitt fecundum,

oor-c Jti Mt,tCircusdiciuidedtur,tiacircuttut.l^qudtttuquAle^ter ^'Ã¨^fff^r^ rogdntes^dui,copdrdntes,dcuto tenorecocludunt,qd!

'ednt m ceteris ueterÃª leoem fectuuntur.Mibi uidetur co P Tang unÃ¼.) ^^^âÂ°'^^^âii^â^^^ilt;llt;fodhtfloc^ewdcoÃ¿M^M.Ndcu^ Sicut femp- dicocircumUttord, idnqtumtvnÃ¼mentmw deuT^ri^s ^*l^^*^^'f^^ tdnqudm in und uoce,und eA dcutd^qd^ ib.mmpee idemdccidit millo: â â ^ TroU qui primus dboris. acuâ¬Â°Â«uâ^ ^^'^â^ ^ ^^^^ 3âââ$ ^lt;^i^^ifio f^^li dwentwmf ut-.

ORATOR. LIBER I. 41 ^y^'lt;lt;gt;Â»^ fccuinpiUxc^ uolucres. âmmuoliicrj^swcdUncMA^y,-^ r v-igt;i.t ilt;^gâigt;nylt;iuiietljjiiturdIreuit,tamÃ©pojttwn^on^deÃ¼/. ''^^7^~^^ nc fieldt iMum,(iucm non redj^it uerfm hcrou^Srpd^quot;^^ / *4Â«Â«^ v^fdwr^h^cdprdeceptotto^rojtonrecejej^duiÃco'^ ^^^^ fuctudo uicerit,âdetui lexferfnonK^olcbitur^cMUi di^^â^^^^^^^^^^^^!^ cilior dpud Gnecos ohferMtio eÃiCjuid plurd iÃK loc^ucn-^'^ ^.gt;*^1 di gcnerd,ciudf j^i^XÃ¯iÃai^ uoednt, er lt;juod dUÃ¯s uittor fum.mterm dUis redum eÃ¼^dpad nos uero IrcuiÃimd^^ ^^'Sok^ rdtio: Ã¼dnci: m omniuoce, dcutdi'^rdnumerim trium^ f^*â fyÃ¼ibixran continetur, fiue ht fint m uerbo folryfiuc Mr^ i'-it-^-^ ^i tm^t er mots dut proximd extremt, dutdb ed tertid^^^t ft^.rs^^ JriM^b^rr^tdc^ibus loquot^n^aid longd, dut dcutdi stut ^Xd crit. eodem loco breuis^utiauc grduem hdbebit^r^d^s ,n^^^^s onum idcoi^ pofitdm dntc ]e,td efi db ultmd tertid dcU^y^^7d^ _,^^ Â».4 ft.EA dute^'m omni Mee u^ deutd/ed numqudm pbtt^^'^^'dfyi^^ Mtd^nccultimduntiMtnudfosk m dyffyÃ¯ldbts prior.Pre '^^ tered nimqiu.mc'dicm^exd^er dcutd:itdlt;^ neutrd cldu* caâqd plur^ *^ detuocemIdtindm Pdueroquefuutfylldbeimii^,erut aquo.autquot;^^^ dcutd dutflexd ne fit dUeput uox fine dcutd. Et iÃ¼d per fo ^oW^nts/''^' nosdcciiimt,quÂ£demonfirdrifcriptononpolÃunt^iitid amp;nbsp;hiatus oriserlmgue^ioraKia'/doji^zy 7^o!SJ'Â«^^fdoÃ¹lt;âerâi% â^^^â7*Â«^ Â»oÃ³tTÂ«!? er â ssAxT^x'Xp.mi^ fieUcioresfingendis nommi /Jtins dixit. tui Greci uocdt, ficut Koi^o/xia/j cum uox esodfi in re quot;yâ o^i^siuditur. Sumt ctidmjppriia^jt men^rriWi lationÃª illÃ¢ llt;:^foni,quibj^nonn^^m nd^ones re'prebendmus. ^^*âfoiadi J^^^ij^turtAirnt^m^.Ã¿^fi^ddmMttts^ eStÂ« SeÃ¤pa crit igd Meuocdtur c?^oiTrax,ite^mcnddtd cum fud quot;ââ^ fetipto tutdte uo(u cxpldtiAHo.Udm fie dccipi potefi reUd.Ce^ non potcilÂ»

~.t ^fâf.i.gt;tj-^fdutttd omnid ex plunbi^ uodbui junt^^quorum enk^, . p tu^ ffquot;'^^IccciftmUfquiefumciredh^cqÃ¼oqidififutdtMi^MM^ r.^^^L^'^â ^ddmqui tcont-extu,orAtionis decidere eurncofitenturfi' ^Â».â^^^^â¢^/â ^quidtMientvniut emend^ione uerbuord^i^^oÃit ,Ã¯':i ^^ quot;^^^(^erb o ^e uitium,nqn rnJcrrnowj^lfi^fiiinty^u'fnfiu^Ã¿ drndra cortick^eu medio cortice,per genui fdcit fioiact quot;nbsp;^^ _^^^^ nbsp;nbsp;fimum,quorum neutrum quidem reprehend^cumfit ut ^quot;dfu^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;triufique âVirgiUut Mtor, Sed fingdmui utrundiÃ¨etnon

rede didum, mutdtio uocU dlteriut,inqÃ¼i uittum erdt, 'Ktnifcn.areddm loqucndi rdtionem ficreddit,utdmdricorticit ilat in'^^r- fi^^gt;^^^ medidcortice,quoimdnifeftee c^umhÂ£edt 1)0 effe Sote neutrum enn^itiofium fiepdrdtim ed, fied compofiitio^ in 7amon^ ne'^ccdturyquieidmfiermonii ed. lÃ¼ud eruditim quie^

!K5 neeg per ritur, dÂ» m fmguiii ^Â«o^Mc uerhis poÃit fieri foloeci^ ree amaro ('^^â ^^ ^â â*^âââ âi'*^ ^'^ ^^ uocMS diedt, ueniff, dUt fi nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;[ neq: corticis pbtrcf d fie dimittcns,itd loqudtur, dii dut difcede^ nee'Â» nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;l refrdKndi ^^'f^f^nfumdb mterrogdtio^edijfiein^fi^t^i^^ poteft.fedcÃ³ centi,quemuideo,itd occurrdf,ego, 1Â«gefitutidmnÃ³ti^' | firuftio tue' âj^^^ putdnt idem uitium inefje, cum dUud uoce, dUui fit peecatum titbit*, Â«H mdnu demonfirdtur. Huie opmioni nec^ue ogt; ingenere. mninoaccedo,neq;pldnÃ¨ dtlfientio-.ndmidfidteor^f^ Â«.Vvt fi ^y ^ccidere uoce umd,non tdmen dUter, qudmfit jil Ãud Terctia' quod uim dltcrim uocK oltmedt, dd quad uoxj^ r^f* nbsp;nbsp;i

f.^'^' rdtur,ut fiolcxcifimui ex compÃ¯exu fidt eoru/m^qu^ui m / pronuntiatÃ¼ jignificdntur, amp;nbsp;uoluMdt ofienditur. Atque ut omneM^^t in â rior quot;de ^fâ^*^ â^^^ife^XÃ^^^ dliqw.ttdo m uno uerbojtWd* Ã¼cerctur.in qu^mfifo uerbo^Pcr quot dutem, amp;qu^s dcdddtl^s ââ quot;â¢ ^^âââ' (ieh^onfidtisconaenit, qui^^idatfimc^ quddri^iri^^

tatione^i^ua ordo turbatur.^Ã¹o^ igfi^enim ho^oluit^^ quot;^^^ ** | ÃMtem^^o ^^l^t Ex ^o gÃ©nerean fit iguurmuiTfi) ferZ ^ ^^Zt^ ,v.

monis dulitdripotefi.quid maximos Ã uiÃÃTsmâiÃ»ierfil * quot;^'^ Cra'^ | fuijfic op'mioncui^eojcwm apud alios fit etiarnfic^ens^^ ^^

apud alios ntwouam repcriatur. }iÂ£clri'a einer a qua^ dam diducwiÃ¼ a ^olÃ¼ecijmo, er a^iedtonts uittum

Vi-i^v ovxr/xo/j.detra'^ionis'i^t^'!/jjmucrfiqnisavlt;aâseoaiiu,y^aÂ»^^t^. â'

^J'^ ^âââ$ codent modo poffellmmutat^ne coni'^^ ^^ trouerfia e^t cum aliud pro alioponitur. liÃ¯pfr omnes^*'^â^:^'^''^^__ orationis partesdeprehendnnuStjrceiuentifimeinueri'^^^i^C^^ bo, quia plurima huic occidunt, ideoc^ in eo fiimt folaa-â^'^,^-^â^'^ ^i[gt;Â»i^^gfgt;i^ra,tempora, perfona^^o^osfi^f iafia Jf2SS-â' tus cos dacijfeu quaUtates placet,ucl Iex,uel ut Mij woÃ¯^ dem. odotnam totidÃ« uitioru crunt formte,mlt;juotspecies eo ^ {^ef^-t-gt;^ -k^' rum q^d^deouibu^u^radiÃ©lum eA, diuifierts.Pntei^ rea numÃ©ros,m qui^ nos fingularem, ac pluralem habe mus,Griecier d'mit'^','^ai^mfuerut,winobi^q^uo^

^ue adijcerent dualem,(cri^cre,legerc,quod deuitandt â^f^y^tgt;tH^,-^^ quot;nbsp;a^eritatis gratia moUitÃ¼ eii, ut apud ueteres pro ^quot;ââ^^fi ^^^?'^'fr^ 1 ^^'^^i^lt;^^^â^^Sâ'^^^^^^Â°^1d*Â°^ ^^^^ ^'^^ â- ^ i^^'^'^i'-^ nÂ»^^A^'

Ãologene^Ã©'cÃ³littfitt^^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ã© mÃ^W^XÃ^*

fere ratione,et âm nommibus deprehÃ«datur,er pc quot^i '^s ^^^^* vjiu-rariÃ'mus dus fit ufus, apud nofirorum nemineiu^',^^^^^^^^^,^^' hit obfirMio repcridturAum Ã¨ tontrarises nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^ fgt;^'fâgt;f''^'^

44 M^. J A B. Q^ INT. INS TI Ti Aeneid. tÂ» Deuenere locos. t^tConticuere oÃ«s,et: Cofedcrc^duci!) Wetamo. ij, (Inerte nos doccint,nil borum di duos pertmerei^^ TC ^uolt;j^,quAncjM,m id A^onius Rufus c}( dÃ¼^o ponit exemplÃ¼,de^uribÃ¼spAtroTÃKpr^copronuciet., ^idâ non Tit.Liuius cired 'mUid ftdtim prmuUbriiTenuere, induit,drcem,Sdbini,cr moxfm dduerfum Romani fuU â ^ rigt;â^ â^'quot;'''quot;trefSedt^uem potiusego,lt;judm H.TuÃ¼iumfe^Mr^ c^ui inOrdtoreyiionrcprehÃ«dodni^uitjfcriplere/cri^lÃ¨rut

t.lt;.mâ^M yÃ¯^fit plxcilmM^encrc^^numero,propri^Mtcmafibut, patrium no tj^uicquUeortvmdUerideceit, miepâi^âfitiiti/ngdtuf tnen Gram^ licct^pcr con^^dtionesjCr fuperldtioneSiitem^ in qui Â«nt.inquo buspdtrtumpropoJJefiiu^xitur,uelecotttrdt'tJdmui patrif figni' tÃ¯^^od fit per qMntiidtcin^^ ut mugnum peculiolamt ÃcutgÃ¨ntÃ»e cruntt^ui folxcifmwnpÃ¼teni-, quid pro nomme i^eg^Ã¯^ ?n quo gen* pofitu/mpt dimmutum - ^gP^dfii^^i ^idfinprop^iuM nuâ Artemf P*ââ^'dpp^em, figmficdtioue mm deerdi. SolaafiW ^^^'^^'^J^'^âpor^ouitiu!m non eil in fenfu^fed in complexu.Ã¯n pdrti in iit.tt^^^- ciptopergenuf^ZTcdfumjUtinuocdbulotpertem'pord, Æâ7l ^^quot;â**Â»âÂ»'^â*^ '^ ^^*w59â ?.Ã¯^ââ*92!?^*^ inuiroq;,peccdtur. Prono frl^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^_ men quo^ gtn^, nume'rum,cdfus hdhety quÂ£ omnid red

huiufmodi errorem ; piunt foloec^i, er quidem Meh Â» ** [y^' X plurmi per pdrtes ordtionK^fid id trddei^efinis noeH, neitd demu uitium ejfie creddt puer,fi pro quot;dlid ponnuT dlidtut uerhu uii nomÃ« effe deiner it^ uel dduerbium uii â. pronomen,^ fimilid. Hdm funt qugddm cogndtd^ut di funt^id csi,eiuÃem generis, in quibus ,^ui dUdjfieciefi^ Qportet utctur,non minus quÃ¹m ipfio generÃ¨pe^mutit^

deU^ucrit.Nam er dn,cr dutcomunÃ¤iones fiwt, mak ^^-timmmterroges,hicaÃ¹tiÃ¼c 'fjt. Etnc anion 'aducrhia, ^^' qui tarnen dicat pro iUo ne fecerk, non fecerk /midem ^on-'mcidatuititvM,quilt;ialteru/rtineÂ»andieÃ ,i1tÃ¨iimuetan , , ocHocampltut,mtro or mtuf loci aduerbia^ot^en tn intus,y^ tiis,Gr intro [win :,folcecifmifunt^ Ed^'m'dSuerptOe^^ f^Â°^Â°[lâ'^^''''^gt;^t^âgt;'ieiiionu^,^iepojjtionwm decadenti''''â'^ /** ^ Â®^ ^^^^Â°^Â°(â^i[tHtK tn ordtione comprehenftonk tmui [equentium^ac prioru/mjnterÃ ^[onucniet^^i^io, Qutdamtarnen er[i^eÃ¯etn[olaciÃnihaient^er diciui^ C ^â¢â¢^â¢â¢^ nyi'' tiojkiwn poffuntiM trdgadid Thyejles, cr ludi florae â fâ*^'' â'*^â ^â^'^.M^^â^^l[^^^^^[l^*^ ^â^'^ [^qt^^ittif^^^f t^^'^^'^.^/tly'^ '^^^[[^^*'^^'^ ^^â^^ ^ gt;f^t^^i^lt;^ dmÃ . Sc^[ein^^^gi^f^d^ CA rti^*^^ turnommÃ¢lWtur ,frcque^iord quidem dpud Poetdti'^[^l^^J[^'^ ^'^^^^^[^^^^^^^[b^^l^'yi^^''^P^^/^' Hlt;S.m,^.WMÂ«MÃ bebit abduant rdtionem^ut docebtmiu co[duem pdulo dtt[â' , te promijmuf^loco'. Sed boe quoty quod [ebenia uocelur^ fi ah aÃ¯iquo per mprudentidmfadum erit, [olacilmi ui tiononcarelit.tneddem[pecie[wnt,[ed[chcmatecareti^ ^^ Utfuprd dixi^a^nundfarnmna,qifilut tMrÃ¨suiunturt nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;** â

er ncutTdlid,quibta famiia. Uaiienutde[olaci[mo:ne r r'gt;i^^('gt;^gt;^ cf queenimdrtemg^amt^dticdmc^poner^daor^ilÃ¼muti er^^.u^ lt;..-lt;-[ed ewm ttt wd'mem meurrerct^inboUordidm trafire nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'Vâ*^

hC nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;mftitutwin oYd'tncmfequiir^erbd

dutkUmS^dut ^eregrina [wnt.Peregnpdjiorrb ex omni uerba. * but propÃ¨ dixerm getti^ut^Ut^om^es, Ã¯n^ituta etiam muÃ¯ta uenerunt.Taceode Thu[cK,ef Sa^tnity^^ ^^ââ^^^^e^us^' fiinit i^o^indmt^eoruntfertnoWMetitemycÃ¢iuLitt aJwPÃªHai'

4Â« M. FAB, QVINTq INSTIT. tertwsor^o ^^^^^,^Ã^â^'i^Sl'*^^^dmodum PoUiodeÃrehe^itin tes i Cicero Ciuio pdtMmitdhm,licet'Ã´mnid ItuUcd pro KomdUM bi turquot;n quot;Bru ^^^^^â plutmd gdÃicÃ© M^erimtiut rhedd^depetoritut^^^ i to, ^â^{ââât^IffJÃ^â^Â® tdinen, altera Uontiin utitUtjCr a mdppdm plt;ocj;, uÃtatum cino nomen, Par^tti ucndi^ cdnt,cr gurdos,(iuos pro Ãolidis aceipit WMvu^, ex H(*

^Â£cum jermonem firsdpue pertmet : ndm zy mdTiJtn^ ex pirte rommiM mie conuerf^ eSl.Ã¼'co^i^^^u^tl; GrÂ£cd ^^mur ue^it^uhi noÃra^tmt/jeut iÃi Ã nobit nonniM^ mutudnturAndeiÃ¼d qu^Ãio exoritur, dn ediÃ© rdtione per edfm duci cxdrnd,^u^noflrd,conuetiidt.At nbsp;nbsp;, Ã reperiM^rdmmdtiew/n uetertim dnidtorÃ«ynegct qnied Ã¼Mm exidtind rdtione mutddum^ Mid cum Cic dpud nof t^Â«lt; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^djusdbldtiut^y^t^iÃinonhdbent,pdruMcMMnidt '^^i^quot;'^^^â^â*^.Ã^Ã2t^â^fâL^Ã^.?Jiâ*^iâ^,^yjS^^ uti.QjtinÃ¨tidm Utt quot;fZ^^i'^e* ^^^ ^^^^^â¢'^ ^lt;^i'ttM, qut potentioren^dcere Imgudm Uti nbsp;; t, ^ yi gt;lt;'^^ndmfludehdnt,necdliend egeremÃitutisfdtebantur.W

^t^'^e CdÃorem medid fyUdbd prodiidd prommeidrurt, Hoc eft*oÃ¯^^â^?^Â°S-{âââ^ ^Ã^^ nominibui dccidebdt, quorum Latina decli primd poÃtio 'm edÃdem, cfuiu CdÃor literdf exit .Et ut' olongum*quot; ^ââ^â^^^iâ^â^ Theldmo ZT Phto indm^ejum Cicero cpit^^ ' qui quidenj (juc dppeUdt) dicerentur,ret'mucrut,cptid Utmum 'cfuoi [ ^ ^^(tnerÃªino Q^ fj^^j^ Ã^|^^^.J^^^^^^^p^^l^^^^^Ã§^â ^^^J^I^^Jff nbsp;nbsp;!

dtqu^s ^terdf exire temeremdfculmd greed nomindre HocaÃf pdtiebd^ur .ideo^i CZ dpud CÃ¦Ã¯ium Ãegmuff ^^ Pelid Cmc'tnndtu^,^ dpud M^ldm, bene fccit Eutitid' i^ dpud deeronem, Ã¼ermdgorui Nf miremuTf^upd di i

Â«[Â« noÃ¦ literdfid tit fyUdid termMdrentur.Ã¯nde olynt Â»Â»01 t yviV n poZTtyrdnnpdcutdmmedidmfylfiilid^dcder^nt^flMd'^'^quot;^

dwbus logis jec^uenlihtif^i^findml^eu^m^^^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'

rtlid plurimu. Nhw recentiores infiituerimt, grids Â»0Â« ''^^ââ ^ââ*- , winibiM gnciis deeÃ¯mdtiones potins dire, c^uod tdmen *'ââ â Â»Æ ^âgt; r^-Â»

i^fium non fimper fieri potfS, Mibi Mf w pincet LttmÂ«t^.X,/Â«- ^ (^^ , raUo^fw fecpii^ qÂ«oÂ«f^Â«e ^c^itu^ecor. Nf qÂ»c inm Cdf-^t^ ^^^di c^

lyp[oncm dixerim,ut lunonetn, qwnqudw fiecutas diiti*^^f,^'*^^^ \ ([uos.C.Cifiirutitiirfid^dtioticdecliHdndLSeddutori*

titem confiuÃ¨iudo fu^MÃ^neiterK '^di potermt ugt; tro(^imdonon 'mdeceMer e^i,lt;{ui gnenm figumm fiepii mtUtjnon Utine tinidmJedciirArej^rdienfioncmlv''^^^^

loijuftur-SwipIicÂ«uoces^imdpofitione,id ndturd CompoRtiÃ¶ fm conflit jsompofiti dutem Ip^^l^fiÃ¼oii^J^ fudigwn nes nomina. tÂ«r,Mt iM^enUjtMterdu re'^ugnMibus mtÃ©r fe dMlus, ^^^,;^j. * qiwlc eft ^pertcrrftiÂ«, dkoqw poffunt dU^Mndo conti greiangiânÃª nudridui^ut'mcompofiitus^reconditta^et^oCicxro^5o^y;â.â . tur, fMfurdu.AutÃ¨duolH^quificÃ rporÃ gt;^^^^^ rubadutfgt; fcnt,ut WdkjfiewÃ¯.N^w fx trifut nofin utic^i ImgM non {um. r concefferiw,qÂ«4mÂ«Â«Ã¯ cap/ii, Cicero diedt ccpofitiiefic'^^otatoh j ex cÃpe fix uincr muenidntw ([ni Idipercdlid^i^i ^^^^Vd'^C.^â^fi â* '^

Et fdni itdfe hdbet, fdcrUi([Udle dpud Howfjy4Â»o$ efigt; gt;^.' (^^J^^ ^^ ^ Sfd bxc non Ww ex tribw | Â« f ÃÃ^ ^^Ã^MS^vi^

48 M. FAB. QVINT. IN^XlTt. â C^eterum etidm ex pritpofitione^et ^^qiqi^o^diif^ ^i( re uidetur ÃruxilJePdcuuius: tierei repsdroÃru meur uiceruicum peeÃ¼t.iiengtmtur dutem,dut ex duobui Idtid ?^t^â^l ^''-^quot;^^^ ii^^Sr^ ut piperfm/ubter fÃ¼gt,qudqudm exitÃegris compoÃtd fintM^ritur. Autex intÃ©gra z^corriiÂ» /.k.^' ''lt;â^j^quot;^^t'pto. Ut mdleuolui : Aut ex corrupto er Integra, ut nod ^ ^Z^^gy.-^ ,ââ gt; (tiudgutiAut duobui corrupt it, ut pedifiauus ; Aut ex ^^i^rn nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;''quot;quot;^Â°fito ^^qregrmo^tbteuntuidutco^rd^ucepttogtu/quot;

Â»â¢er Antiedto: Autexduo^peregrinis ^ut EpirtrediÃ¼t ^, ^P^dppJ^Ftdm cum fit prapojltio Itti grxcd, rheddgdÃicu/m,nec

CrÂ£cuf tiimcn^nec c^Uw utitur compofito^Roniiinifu^ urn cx utroq; dUenofe^artM. Frequenter dutempr^^o

hxccompo' tdmd^iiCrjiXQsdccct,nabisnanusfuccedit,necidfieri fta Ã prapo ndturdputo.fed idienis fduetnui, ideoÃ³i cum KM^TOvii nbsp;nbsp;'

^^^higitur hoe l^dâlMS^'f^i^fiwÃ¦.^llâ^ri[ti^^^^^ y^Pi^*^ *ââVâ 'Â°' Propridfunt uerbd,cum idfignifiednt, in^d prmum Nslib^^pofi' dewmtndtdfiu^.TrdnÃdtdte^dUump^urdpiUeÃ¼c^ tio.quafi pri Ãum,dlium loco preient^ yfitdtis tutius utimur. Noirt Sabs fit ^ ^Â°^finequoddin periculo^n^uittiiwfi receptd funt, âquot;{y modiedmÃ¯dpdemdfiÃ¨runtordtori',r'epuiidtdPetidminia

quot; nbsp;nbsp;1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cosexeMtt.AudendtimttÃ¼nen,ndn^utCiccrodit,etidnt gt;

mik iÃ¼is meritÃ© Iduddtis Xlyli Ãªgt;io^, Cââ ^^^ âvj^^ fingeredudednwUdmnc i^re, duihinnire fortikt

imprdfnKe iÂ» UM*^ ^ moduldtione pcdÂ«i^ ultcram wd^ luntlt;pu,lidftvnt: Imadeftirperecifum. Oquot;. *~' Ãencid.iu l AÃ«rite ejuo con^eÃerc pdlumbcs, t

tid uirorwm iudiciu/m prordtione,er uelerror honejiut^quot;^ '' ft'^'^ ell,mdgnos duces fe(lt;uentiltu. Confuctudo ucrocertiÃi^i^ c/t m^ r*gt;f md lo(^uendi mdgifird, utendum^ pldnÃ¨ Ãrmone^tÃu* f ilt;yM C^â mo, cui publied formdek. Omnid tdmen tilge exigunt

dcrc iudicium^^ ^P^lt;^amp;^ prgcipHe,(pidm proxime ex Anaiogjj. a- .v grgcotrdnsferentesÃ¯ntdt'inum,proportionemuocdiict-^ gt;^-'- f^it^ runt-.'E-iui hgc uis eSt^utid ^uod dubium eS:, dd dliquii ' â fimile, de quo non qugritur, referdt, ut mcertd certis probet â¦ Quod efficitur duplici uid,compdrdtione fitmili âÂ«*, ifexjfimtsmd^rnefyÃ¼dbis(propterquodede^ut ,^ ^^ funtj finguÃs,ntgdntur dehere rdtionem ) er dimmufV'^^^'^^'ni^^. tione.Con^rdtio m nommibus, dut genus deprebÃ«dit,^^'^^^^ dut decliMdtionem:Genus^utfit qugrMur^funis^ '^^^f'^l^^fâ^/^^^^'^Z^^^^ Z^ fi^^f^mmmu/mÃtmiie Ãlifit pdutsiUeclmdtione^ ii^T^ ,xt4 ^^f^^ ut/i uenidt tn dubium,bic domu dicendum fit,an hdc nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;f,^

VO M. FAB. QVINT. INSTJ,Tr^-jâ exeiÂ»(;loreccdAm,furem mdjcul^u^^e f^iculMO* y^iâquot;-^ flendit, Bddem^u uerhii ejuaq^ rmttdcompdratioms,Kt Æ ^â^^ amquos [ecutM^fcrucrc breui medid fyUdhÃ¤ di* i^^^Jj, ^-^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cdtjdepreh^t^w uitiofe loqui, quo^d ^nid qu^eÃ§r o

Uterii fd^dimodo termindMur, eddem fi mmfinitif e Uterdm medid fyUdbd deceperumt^ utique produiidfH hibeiit,prdndeo,pcndco,f^ondeoj ^rdndcre, ^enderf, fj^onderc. At quÂ£ o foldm hdlcnt ,'ddmmodo per Cdngt; dem Uterdm in mfinito exednt, breuidfiumt, lego, dico^ curro,legere, dicere,currere.EtidmÃeRdpud Lucili* urn: nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;teruit dqMisrferuet, ferait m^c ,feruet dd

annum. Sed pace dicerc, hominis en^itifimi U* filmte nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,^^j ^ Chit, ft ferait putdt iuijtmac currit, ^ legit, feruo diet

f^-r ZZ^-^ftur^ut^uno O' le^^, quod nobis induditurn eR.Sed npd^ 'ZJZ-iiif^i^ i^^eR bite u^^mpdrdtiotndm fcruit illi eRfimile ferait, ^'^f^ffi^jt proportionein ftquenti^^icere necejf eR ^eriu*^^

f^^t, bl. i^,^qaisinuenÃ®tur,utmemoridrepetoconui(losdm^^uirt preben^rant, quod boejaerbo^^M eifern pepegi : tidM id ^uidc^ dixiffe fummos dutores eonftebdu^r, ratio* nemidmen n^dbdni:''^rmiUer(, quid primd pofitio pd cifeor, cumb^cret ndturdm pdtiendi ,fdceret tempore prlt;Â£tento pda as jam. Nox prÃªter dutorttdiem ordto* rum dtque biforicorum, dndlqgid quo^ diRu/dt taebi i ^'^â¢^(âÂ»^ffiUY ^ j^iiff cumin XII td^fUs ieoeremuti nUtd pa* tf's^^ ^^^ Å¸^u'^^t^mucmebdmit^ jimtie huic^j^t Ande printdpo^ f^f^i^^'^.^^Ã^^^^ ^R*gt;^ Ã aetuÃdte exoleuerdt, dppdrebdt pago, ut cdd9;wnde noerdtduiia,fic pepigi nos dicerfjUt eeeiiiÂ». ,

Sfd memincrimutync^j^er omnid duci Amhff^pofftrti tionc^^cumjiti tp^A pfwimk in locis repugnet. Ott^A^ dim fine duiio conintur cruditi defendcre, ut cum de* prehenj^n est le^ (y luput fimih pojidonc, ^Uintunt cdfibi/^ numÃ©rique diÃciuiAnt, itd rej^ondent, non eÃe pAriiic[uidlcputtpicahumfuJapi^mdfculmum:Quâ^gt;^f^fgt; 'quot;^ ^J^i. ejMnrV drro^m co libro qÂ«o mitid Row jnÃ¦ uriis enar^l^ZÃ¯'^^^!^ â'^^j ^âi,^!^!^^ l^'^Jj'â2^

medd dtiquid contendu/n^Pritered quonidm utrunepte'-c^ â^^''^^ 4 Gr^cis dudwm eR,dd edmrdiionem recurrunt,ut 7scÃ¯^K^ y-^j-f .^i^ f?^%â^âââ^?^ ^â^f^if^i'^t â¢ ^^^ tarnen quomodo ef* '^^y^â*^-'^SJ^ifif^Â°â!l^^ ^^^-^^^^ fÂ«mi/nmd, fwguldri nomi* Mtiuo u s Ãni'td^nuM(pu.tn^enitiuo cdfu in ris fyÃ¼dldtn temmdutur, fdcidttdinen Venus Veneris f item cum eslitertsjinitd perudriosexednt genitiuos ,nimqudm timen eddem ris fyUdbd termimtosf Ceres cogdtdici Cereris iÃ§^i nero,ciuttotdpofitieniseiufdrmindb'n'' ^'^

benjes ,uola, uolui er uoldui .j^dm preterita ^idem ^-^ ^^^ v^t^ tempore, iurie formdri uirbd prmiperfondoUte* â^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'quot;^ i'A^tert^Atd,ipfd\ndlogidconÃteturt Sic^uidem fd*â^*quot;^â*^ '^^^^ sit cAdocecidi,jpondeoyfpopondi^^m^o^pinxiylegd

Ifgi, pono pofti, frdn^o Ãe^, Idudo iMddui '^ Kon ^^^'^J^TdS?''*'â^fi^Sf^^J^^'^^ ^otfines', dndlogid demi*'^^ fdcaloJormAm loquendi dedit^fedinuentdesi peft*^^ n^'e^Ã¼^ ^Mm iQ^uebdiHW J er WMum in [ermone, eptid ^Â«Â»

.Â«.....Ãf^s- axas- Â»Â®Â«ivw, ^kÃ¯fÂ« nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;exempla,nee .

' 'XÃ¼^'^t' ^^^^^'^Â°^â*^'^^iyÃlt;^ ohferMtiOjÃ»iipfÃ mantilogiiimnul* f^f,...?7iquot;.s * ld retdlidfecerit,qukm confuetudo. Inherent tttmÃ« i^ui 'Z^Tm quot;nbsp;'^â'^^^,^^^^l^^^/^â^J^}l^Ãª^gt;f^f^ femer/tMe^MÃ^cittr

fotius dicM, qudm duddÃ¤er,licet omnes outores aU* ud fequintur,^ emicduit non emicuit,^^ conire non co '^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;X^ ^^^'^â^^^-^âf^^l^.^!?'. â^^'^i^âff^ ^ feiuijJe,Gr iribuni

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ft^ytiM aw^omodofiatfrugduidsfitdem centum nn

^^Aâr^/moseJJe^qudndoc^ mutdfU er numcru^^'^cjcie ZZ^^XX.^.Mmus enim,dc non eSfuetudini et decori feruicbdmut,fi '\u/Ã¯^â â^'~^cut in plurimis,quÂ£ TuUiut in Ordtore diuine,ut omnid, CMX Lu' execluitur. SedAuaujluscluocii inepijlolis ddcTCitfd^ ex lulia Â« ,^/Â«a^Â«2Ã¯tÃ³^Â»Â»^ ^/Ãª^f^ Agrippina dum mdlit,non ^uid nÃfit Idtinum, fed^uijifit odiofum, bSuSquot; ^Pf^ S^^iZifXX^fl^^ l ^I^m'^' ^^â^^^ifidamÃª^GozTvamp;apjoidmputdnl,ijMn^^omini^ lii^dffunftÂ» *^^ excludotCiuid enim tarn necejjariumiqudm ceria io^ eft, unius epi cutiof im^^^xrendum ei iudico quoad licet, diu etiam fifex^p^' ^^âfijniibut repugndndum,fedaboUta atqueabrogata adC-extÂ« retinerejnfokntiiecuiufidaefi/tjriuole in paruis idÂ£la hba'fxap?7. ^ji^'^l^,^.^l^Â£^^^^^^â^^â^^Ã¯^^l^^^^quot;^Sih'^/{S*i^f^^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'

duÃa feewndafyUabd fdlutduit,ducte(eÃ¼ enim) cr edict x face dixerit^otius^quam quad dicimus,ZT cojeruamJe: afr**^-***^ hisadijciatfacc^Jd^ce, zp- fiimiUa. ReHa eÃ¤^e iad, /^,,4.^ ^i^-j negdt^ fedadioeet or moUior,Qr mdgis trita. 'Ego i,t^ ^-^hlt;. tamÃ«nonaliomdgUditgoryqudmquodobliquiscafibtit

BMCTt etium primai Jwipopttones non muenire,Jea mu* tirt permittimt, Â«t ctim dur CJ- robur ita diHi tic fen , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

pt^ in Jummis antonbut, m o literM pcundÂ£ jyiMbit trMSferwnt,lt;iuUfit roborii^ et ^m^is.Ã¿dfhtr Autem et -^ quot;â¢^â¢yar y^ guttur Â« literM m genitiuo feruent, ideo^ etUm ieeW ' â-â '~^â^ 1^Â» Â»

^ femur controuerftdm feccru/nt^quod non mt/nt^ efi Ih.â^^^,v^ centiofum, q^m fifulphurio- gutturj fuiijcerent m S^f^^Z''d'j',^^s nitwoliurimo medtAmf^uiÃ effet ciorK er roiorK,ftt\â^^. '^^^^J''''quot;^ cut AntoniuiJ^niphoj qui robur quidem er ebur, it que Gnipho etuntirmur fatetur effe, uerufieri mit exhis robun, ckooSÂ» fe ^^'fL^â^^'^J}^'â^'f^Â°^ ft AnimiduertÃ©ret liter iruiffi* culo.quÃ© K'^^ nttitÃª,fcirent'fKab eo,quod c^roburrÃ§boris Ãeri^quo SJp^tu^ modo ib eo qd'eÃ¼ milesditnes,tnilitisdimitK:iudex,umlt;gt; quolt;Ã¯ tradif dex,iudicis^'mdicis,ei qug fupri iim AttigitCluidfnqn^'^jJ'f*^^^Â°' pmiks quolt;^,ut dicebim,pofitrones^ longe diMn^p^ ,,^^ ^ gÂ«r^ pjr obliquos afM exewnt,ut' uirgo,Ã¯imo,fu)Ã¹sjbiCÂ»v^ ^vc'rrvt^ fut,ciÃ¯f^is,puppif^ (^y mille ilid^cum illud etiM ieddit.

nt lt;^Mdimpluriliternondicdntur,quÂ£difn contre Ãn*ff^'^ ff'â^'â^i, guliri numero,quÂ£ddm afbuccireint^ quxdim i pri^ tZfJ d fe^' tnkftitimpofitionibutTotimutentur^uilupiter.Quqdquot;^ *â' ue^bitetiimicciditfUtferotul^cÃ¼iuipriieritumperfe^ dum,erulteriM non muenitur ,jqecplurimumrefert^âquot;,^^Ji^^id^yi^ **fB^i!i^^ Pdi^dâÃ¯^ld^ â¢ '^^Mâ'^ progenies gÃ©nitif V^^f^^ZdZZ uopnguliri, quidfpespluuUfÃ¯ciet iQuomodo Autenf^ quire et ruere,uel m prit eriufdiendi modo^el 'm piri'^'d ddZfS'^df tkipiitnnfib^tiQÃ¿id dedUjs diarn, cum f^it^ttsJe^f.^fZfdd.. y^^ ^^^Idi^fyj^tuiyinfenituffemtifenitoficiit^mcertvM^^^ ptfQ^re miinon 'muenuÃe did uidetur^iliudeffe li^^^ *â-^ JÃ¯.iX

Ã4 M. FAB. QVINT, INSTIT. _ tine,dliud grdmmdtice loqm. aie drdndlagid nimiuM^ Etvmolo- Etymala^iw^uerb^^^^^^^

*ââ inuenitur aV/d-GoT^ofi, quad ed natd : num uerbum eX â^âf^edfLiff^^i^^lx^ dudum^id cÃ âlfJ'JlÂ°^ium,^Â£e Cicero qui finxit, ^J^'^^i^^f^foff^iddt.Sunt qui uim potiuÃ¯intuitifirigmdtionÃ¨uo â f^t.^ Ã§p^jquot; j^h^et f^(^jUttdouCtimneeeffdrium,quotietin terpretdtianeres,de qM^UÂ£ritur,egetiUteum M. CtU m feeffehominemffugtmic probdrÃ¨, non quid dtÃmes

fu(nM il ne mentiri c^uidem potcmt^fcdcjiMa t^ilis mul tif,id e^l^uÃ¼uofui, nndefit.di^u^ugaÃ¯itiix. Ideoq; in definuimibtÃ¼ Ã^i^nntur Ã¨tymologiÂ£Ãocui, Ã¼oimun^l etUm bArbird ub e tienditiiconutur Gifeer,nere, ut ciM tnauctrum diet Sicilidm,M trictuedratnMeridiem.in me

uultq diftio didiem oportctit^lt;luÂ£rieuryaluq- c^ua conâue^t^ijerut nu naturaUs u^i,Contmet in Cc multam eruditionem, Cue iÃ¼d ex GrÂ£ facieslit,lÃ¯

quando lÃ¼Ã¢ ds ortn tuflemiK, quijuM ftlurimd, prÂ£ci(gt;iie Aeoued Ãauit^''**' ^quot; rdtione,cui cd ferma naÃer fimid 'imui,declmitd,fiue ex Aeolica ut hiÃaridrum uctcru/m natitid, nammd hoJ^iÃ¿^^lo^^^ mutatio ou nemium urbiuM reeiiiirdmuf.tvncte Bruti,?ublicalÂ£,9i* mbreueu, ,. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;t

Si interpofi ^'?^â^^i,^â}!/iJ'^fâ!V?*âi^^.â^â^^i^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'llâ* Cd^ltouunif

ttouprocÃ¶ Ã§^caÃ¼cmQuirindlem,er ArvletumdbpeUdndirMo, lonantc.ur la^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â n nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â j

cuÃ¼ Dauus. l'igt;n^dminord,in (luibuimdx^ÃudiaÃemt ril fdtigi Bruti.) Vide t^r (luiuerbd pduluni decUndtd, udrie er multipUciter

Liuiulib rÂ» f nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;*

Dc publico^ lt;^ducritatâ¬mreducunt^dutcorreptis,dutporrcatSydtÂ» lalib.n^^ ddic^is^dufdetr^iSfdut permuUtii ^CerÃ fyÃ¼dbif Utt Zt^i ^^i^-^.'Cnic prduis mgimjidd foe^imd uf^ ludibridÃ¯dfi^f-Confulcrc, ^'^ '^ ^^^^ ^ (Wf^do^n Ã MieUo ; Nd Z^^kve (^

ddhuc renunet iÃ¼ud,rogdt bo i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ni conMMÃ^R bonunt indices,Seinttanomen dedcrit

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^tddineuÂ»ijdebdireslunt^M^ex^redoryet dlidplurimdâ^^' -^y-' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'^^^r^S^^E^^''El^^^!^^^^^i ^TjimUium^Z^E'^^n, Ã^ââbis,r'dtionem. Idmnt zy cluÃts Ã cMMo. er le pus leui'Â»~^, quot;^ ^quot; t,igt;k. pes,QruiilpesuoUpes,etidm.ifitcrÃ§ret?itieemreai3i*gt;^*^,^gt;t-

quid minin',eJiu^y, ctii ne domine ippeHdri, qui^it bn wo mtui^qiuftitero no oibus dnimdUbns aide origo^iut^^^**'^ â¢^ âquot; iÃ¼iprmimqrtalesjintenonw impoÃieYiitttcrrieqÃbi,* - 'i ''â ^ af-lt;^ ^âZ^ ^4 lt;^i^^^ ââ^ nerberuto.Pergdmm, Ãc penteniemm eoufq;,utÃeUdJuntmis ÃiUd credAtiir,cuiai etymologies â*^â^ ^^7 Mtorem cldriiin futiÃ¨ in Uteris nomineiri in ed pdrtc

d me repreh^ittir,mbumdnu eR:qui uero tdlid Ubri7to fkxiÃmt,nomind fi^ ij^fi 'mferipferut, ingeniofee^ Ãbi ui fus eR Cdiui caelebis diccre, ueluti cceUtesjfittod one *^Ã¤binius.

uentipe, ^dm quid CÅlo Sdturnut genitdlidd^a^t,^edddÃl^^uf^ ^?^^U^ lt;^bjl^J}i^^i qi^^i^f^xore edreMtei^tLdUM pTtui Ait Adiâ. ! nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;idm,quidpetit uit^. Se^cuinonpo^Vurronem ftâue^fÃ^'^J/^f^â^~ niddqui dgru quid in eo dgdtur dliqd^t gmetdos qd gre Æ''~,' Ã©^Ã¯iX quot;'^

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;gdtjnnuolent^diiiosCiceroni perfoddere u^jMt (ddcu'inâ^'âquot;''^

enim ferait) can dlterÃ¼ ex graco^t nuwÃ'c^iueiydb teru exuodbuf duiu: Sed boe tdiuifuit uertere,ut meru IdiqwdIoÃ¯dwÃ¯dttquiftmerdHOÃAsnommdretur.CiMdi

'^ *^7* *^ââ Â»Â»Oâ* duUtMerunt etymoloÃ¿e fubijcerc omnem nomlnis cdufunyUt ex hdbitUji^ucmddmodumdixijlon^s ^ t^ fos,tx fold) jlrepere,mtrmurdre,Ãªiidm deriintÃ¤ja d ut lontdte dicitur ucloXtZS'com^fitdplcrdquc hisfimUif ^ut fine dubio diiunde'origmem ducunt,feiÃ¨aie nonet gem^cuim in hoc opere non eHufut nifi m dubijs.

a Mappam.)Mappas lint ca dicebant,qm canantibus in fncnfamdabantur,autquiaffcrebantipfi. Martial.XII. At' tulerat mappam nrmo dum turra tirnEntur.cJo/H(i Grxci uo cantjaci au tem Ã prxtore mappam cÃ¶fueuifft.Iudis Circene libus.uclex Suctonio manifeftum eft. Et Martialisineuqd modo citauimus Epigrammate, Cretatam prator cum ueP Iet mittere mappam. Id autem fmlTe lignum magu quinl pramium crediderim.

ngt;^'X 'TErbductuftdterepetitdnon folivmmdgnosdffer ^\*^. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;âquot;^j\f J:ores1ydbent,fedetiÃ¿ndfferuntordtionimdieHd

^f^^Z.'',!^ J^ â'â^^^^!^^^ deUadtione: ndm^^ dutoritdten âXquot; '-^ 1^7^ dntiquitdtiVhdbent, et quu interim ^ f^, grddidmM ,g uitdtifmilempdrdnt.Scd^ufeÃ¼mpd^^Ã¹ne^crebrd â¢*Â«***Igt; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â¢Â» M^fint hec^nce'gt;Hi:uiifÃª^d,(fud nihil e'^odiojiiudp^^dtiot

'^^'fZfgt;Zff.'quot;ne,nec uticiue db ultmif zy idm obUterdtis rÃ©f e^dtem gt;nbsp;Xr ''^Ã¤ 77 P^*^Â» 1â^^^,^^?Â°Pquot;â,.^S ^^'^^^'^â e^exdntUre, i,-Pi, c^.t.-i ^'profdpid,0'SdiioYumcdrmmduixfdcerdotibus[uis o^rr-^ ^.^ Ãtif mteUedd.Sed iÃ¼d mutdri uetdireTIgio^confecrd S rf wÂ».t ' tt^Ãtien^wm eR. Ordtio uero,cuiui fummd uirtui e/Ã¯ per jpiau^^udtn fituitiofdft egedtinterpretc^Zrgo ut no *i^^ â b ?râ¢ ^^^'^^S,K^ljquot;^^?, ^^l^â^)^^â^ ueter urn mdxi* j ^f-Z^-^if me noiiA. SimUÃªtarÃªd dutoritdiem ratio, Ndw etidwÃ

fote^iuiitri nihil pÃ©cari, t^uiutitur his uerhis ,([UÂ£ funmi Autores trdiiderunt, mwItiMn timen refert .non^i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;i^,(^^

' ~ tuburmMbtmdmn (rSnrchilfudwm iim m noiis auifgt; Tuburdu^ â,tpu,mfcrAt^licetCAto jttit^pr. Nee Â«OÂ£(odic.cj,jjiun|^.Â£urjiy3yy, -

â*yâ'ââiifolÃ0ttt Ã§Ã¯Ãcu^:,necgi^ioÃ¯lt;i^tqu^[Ãcil'idd dixit,nee heUuari.

^'Deepnfuetudin.e^ CAP. XL /a^ti^dÂ« SVpfrfft igitureonfuetudoirnrnfuerit penÃ¨ ridietti'- Â»rgt;''^-^.

lum,mAÃe Ãrmone^ejuo ioeuti ÃM.h^n^es, ^Uim Ã¯^^'^^^/^ ^Â«0 lotpuwur.SÃni^uidem eR iUu^uepÃ¼ifermo,^uimzt^.^^ZZ^'d^f^ ue^ut loij^ndi eonfuetudoSed Inde ipfi neceffirium e^^'x'^â^/''quot;/â¢â¢^*f iudicium, eonÃituendÃ¼mlt;iue m pritnis id ipfti/m, quid Ãt ^Mod eonÃtetudmem uoeemut : qui: pen eo quod plures ficumt, nomen ieeipidt, perieuloÃÃmum^dcihi^rdeee* ptim,no2^orAtionimodo,led(,([uodmdiiiKeSl')uiti.'Vnt^ ''^ ^^ ^Â»â¢'

i^Z^ ^Ã¿^a^Jd ueÃ¯li,zr eomdm m grddut Ãdngere^et m idine^ ^** '- ^ '^â^^ K perpotdre^^udmlibejhie inMferint eiulidtÃ«, non entZ- JS- ^Z^ eon^ettidÃ³^uid nihÃ¼ horum edret reprehenÃone: dt ld '^quot;'' ^â'-^'^ udmur er tondemur,er eonuiuimutex eÃÃuetudme.Sic y^^*' '^ mlocpiedo,nonÃ(iuiduitiofemultKinJedcrit,proregu

ld fermonie deeipiendum erit. N4m Â«^ erdnÃdm (luemdi^^ 'â âââ* 'â'quot;' *ââ¢*â modum utdgoÃnperitUolt;jui^mur,totd fiepe thcdtrd,er Â£^tlt;r^f\i,' fJ7^'tf4 omnemcirci turidmexeldmdffe hdrhdrefcimut.lc.rgo coquot;** 'Â®*â*quot; fuetudmÃ©fermonii uoedio eonfenfum eruditorwm,Ãcut wuendi,confenfwM 1/onorvm.

lie orthogntphid. CAP. XII. j^,.f T\.quot;Ty?^3â*?â^^ d^^wiu^ufi fitloquendi regulif

ci o^^oy^xquixp uocAnt,nosre^e feriiehdifeientiM'no L 0 ^-v.Â«- (yÂ« tninemiM. Cuius dn non m hoc pofitd eH^ ut nouer mut ^â¢.-.A^.'id^a^uibusqugqs fyUdbd Uteris cojiet. N4mid quidem infrt ^j^Ã¿.J^X^Ã^rdnmtdticiofficiumcl^edMum, utmedfertopinio^ ây. ^.-e^ ÃulffUl-^gfff ^ jj, ^u^q^ leihet ut longisfy^dbis omnibus apponcre ^jeem meptiÃimum e^, quid plurim^ ndtu* ^,,,y.gt;^i,/^ rdipfduerii,quod fcribitur,pdtent,fedmtermneceffid lt;ây^'y^ yiwm,cum eddem Uterd alium dtq; dUu inteUeiiu, prout correptd uel produit d esl,fucit^ut mdlus^, drboremfigni ficet,dn hominem non bonum, d^c diÃm^itur. Pdlut dUud prio^efyÃ¼dbd lo^d^dUud ÃequctiÃgniÃcdttH euw Ã¨ddem tite/d n/mmdtiuo cd^re^K^dbldtMo longd eilt A nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;utrum Ãqudmur plerunqi hdc notd monedifumus.Simili

putdu^^t^d qu3qsferudndd diÃrimind, ut exprt pojttÃoncm,Ã'uerbivm fequercturffieHo, ddieHd Ãeudi d literd,cxjjse^oifed ft peilo,rcmotd sÃrilcre'^ d^^'âJÃ¼i'^i^fPâ^-^ ^â^^i fi^^ ^ft ^ 'gt;^ultis diffÃ¨re ntii.ut ud^cum t'*^'^â^i'^/SP^^P^'^PÂ°f^'^^Â°}^^^}Ã¿''ff!!lââ^â^dutemconiunHiOj tdeei ~^ Â»-fc^ y^ff^â^ret.Uemcu/mfttemp^ji^nifedret^perquomtf co^ ââ¢^'-/7^nlt;^'t^^^ff^gt;^t-j^cJuds f^ue^sÃenberetur. Irigidiord ^Ã¨Ã¨Zf^^dffÂ»^^ dlld,ut ^^uiequidyC qudrtd hd^cre^^ne mterrogure bis â ^ C^i'^^n-nidercmur .ltquotidienoncotidie,utfit^uoddiebus. â ^â'Ã¯^'^k']^^^â^i'U/tn hÂ£c idm inter ipfus ineptids lt;^udnuertM. C^Ãi 7^^'X^ * f'^^^^ââ^Ãi^lhedo,priepofttiones,fonumqucmnM^*e^ â¢~rit^^ t.^iiant^un quem fepurdite. obferudreconuenidtutcimii

ORATOR. LIBER I. to obtmuit, Ãecundjm enim b liter dm radio ntigis dudiimt p. Et immune, iUud n ^^ 2it,fequen{is fyUdblt;e [o^^^^^dm, m ^emmd coj^dtur. ',^\^^^^i^i^^ Eft etidmim diuidendii uerbis obf^^^o^ntedidm ^'^^^'quot;^^b^^^^jÃ¿^^ confondntem priori,dn fcquÃ§itti fyÃabx ddmrgd^^Arui^^yiiit^piiX-i^ f^ex ep^qad pdrs eim po^erior d j^edditdo fft/ ram tertid dibit: AbjIemiM, fluid exibfimentid nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;-compound uox ell, primÂ£ rehnquetur. Ndw k eiuidem in omiftrim. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;' fl!i^i^^lt;^tbji utendum puto, niÃ que ÃgniÃeat etidm ut ^^^ Q^'^Ã¦j folÃpondtur. Hoc eo non omiÃ, quod t^uidd e^uotu^r^Ã§as egquot;Æ Ã Ãqiutur neeeÃdriam crÃ©dit,'cm hic literd, que dd ^ quot;nbsp;tepe felff omnes uoales uim ^t^crferdt.yerumqribomphid ijt, g^ut, g^ quaq-con^uetudim ieruit,ideoq; fepemutatdeh^Ailldgt;^nef^Â«. nc^ ffiSrn^ uetujliÃimd trdnjeo tÃ«pord,quibus crpduciore^ utere,^gy^j pri- -*-' quot;^ neeÃmHes hU noÃris^t^Jorm^ei^,'^ 'ii^^^ *^^â ^Â°Squot;'.* gt;Â»âA^ d^iuc^fd,Jicu7dpudGrecos oJue^e^^uemtermlogo, dc^â^jan^y* ^Â»^^ breu1s,ut apud nosimterimp^rb fylldbd, qud nomine luo tauit Smo'^^^ exprimit, poÃtd eH^ utIdtmis uetcribus d plurmis in âiffeâpoâÃ¯roteT^-tttrbw idtima.m ddieHa^quod mdni/^um^ e^ÃM ex fyiubÃ¤ qui

^^Â«0^ ut in pulummSoU^qui coUturiuxtd ede cuit'' cipio ou. NÃ¢^^-^ nmÃuefprug. quod ucÃperid^emdccipmus. De mutdti ^^ ^ quot;|'jfjÂ®âÂ»'*^Â» oiif etii literdrÃ¼,de qudfuprd dixi, nihil repetere bic ne ^ dixcrunt. X- /o *' eeÃ^ csl.f^tÃÃ: cnim Ãeut Ãribebdnt^oquebdntur, Se '^^Ã^ p^j^ng'â miuocalcs^mÃ¯nd^e diunon^ngt;*ÃâdtiÃÃmimorÃ^dtqi fieri pofte ar ÃF^lÃilli'*f^^ â^ Aedu^uUr^orredds [yUalds gemi y^g^y^^jf* nis,lit dixi,uoc'dltbus fcripferunt. Drutius durMitMc i fis rompt langeais ediem rdiioh-, ^Â«lt;i Gmci % i uterentur/d cdÃ ^âg^ âJâ^

^ntc quot;re ftdquot; ^â^^ numeris^ difcretkeiliUtJ^iliui^rÂ£cipitz Ã©oquasâlt;t fo ^^gt;!jP't^^l^^^Jlf/S.^,Â£?Ã¨^^!!â^''^f^^^^^^

jio quernÃ¯Ã©' vt'pwreiÃ¤uresfidntf '^dcdemceps. idenu defideraret. W^fâ*''â*Â»^5â^8Â» lt;âââ^^ ^^ââ¦â* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â¢

tlicruus'rc' ^fwsn^viMhAbet,tmn mcomodtimdUqMndo, Nxm fpondet. AP in^s,quÂ£proxmdmdbuÃ¯timdlitcrdmchdbciiwt07^ At^go dixÂ» ^Â°^^ termtadbuKtur, ilhint mtionem fc^uentes utemur Pk iiulojn- e grmin^cjitÃ³lu fu/nt hue Mrcei,drgcnteei,^fimdidtH XiÃ³Â« cX i'*'^^ ^^ pr^dpue, ^t^d leUionem inÃituentur, etidtit matici uo- impedimento erit,ficut m Grxcis dccidit ddieHiont ili* ^ ^^'^J'^t^^^gt;i'^^ ^Â°Ã^i^ ddtiuKedÃbud mpMe^timddferi ^^ ^fj^^fÂ«^Â»Ãi^^Ãdm ftidm mterponunt,uti)i'\Hi5ii!i [^^.^ A^ â â lt;quidetymologidexdiuifioncmirtfyUdbK fddddefide* ^^^(^^^quot;^^ rct edmliterdmdeÃyÃ¼dbdm^cuitu nwneeUtemmponi* muf,udriÃªpcr der i cff^rcbdnt,(luiddm femper, ut Grf ci,quiddtn finguldriter tdntum^cum in dAtiuum^ud ^d aqui tiuum edfu/m incidifjent 'vnde Pi^di ue^is, er dmu ^vr ^^ ^v..VergiliMdmdntiÃimM UctuÃdtiicdrmmibM inferuitt S^Z ^ Z^^Z^.Z Inijfdem plurdU numerouteÃ¹tuur,hi SylU, GdWie.P'il ZZZZZ â^Z''quot;^:ZZ^ ^'ââ^ ^âlt;â3gt; F^z^^ pucibj pr^ceptum, quod quid pluri* vt Â«^Â« 0Â»^^, butcxplicdturÃ¼e^ibui,ÃquKpdrÃcreddt,dpudipfti/ni y^^ 4- ZZ-^-^â-itinonorequirdt.Quid^quodCiceronistÃ«poribt^,^u* yZquot;^^' ZZZ' luÃ¼^i infrd, fere quoties j literd medid uocdlÃ¯Ã¼m fongi* -^^ .^A Â»â¢ lt;''yii)n, ueÃ¯ fubieÃ¼d longis effet, gemindbdtur f ut eduffr, cdffuStdiuiffionctyquomodo er ipfi^et yer^ftiag^ que fmpffJfemMui ear urn docent. Atq^ipduluÃ¯u/mJit^ f moresfillud qwd nos gemind dicimÃ¼f, luffi nmd dix^^

/_^A2-^ 5XS^*^y,?ER h 61 âriwt^Ltidmopt'mtK^mdxinwTÃ¹tmediAm^ fyff^t* -^^^^ ticterihiK Â« fucnt^dccipcrent^ C.prjmiwn CicJd'^'mJerÃ¯'^'^'^Â»^^^^ ptione trdditurfddwM. HerÃªniMic Ã¨ Utent tcrnimdmui^Tft^ L^-rt^ â Â»Â»â¦^ dijictcmm comicorum adhuc Ubris mumo, fceri ad gt;ne'}/^J^^t!l^ uettit,lt;iuod idem in epifloUs AuguÃi, qÂ«4Ã® fM manu [cri fÃt^iut (mendMitydeprehenditur, QjÃ¤d,non Cato Cen

^it^Ji^^ t^jif^iftÃne^. Et Ã lAejfaÃ¯a 'm lAro/d'â-Ã^:fi:^'^'^t^d^ des liter a poÃtum f^he^, ^ ^Mfe feriptum 'm multorum Q^fe^'f^d^ librii efl.Sed am^ocuoluer'mt dutwes nefcio-.T.duiwm, y;,~/^gt;*quot;^ bw ufum ex P^diano comperi, qui er ipÃ e^feiÃ¿tehft^'',l'JJc^f^-gt;'^a^ tur,hjec ttoj i Ut^d^nmuf^ C^d dicauortices^eA nor fut^ettera^ ad ewndemmodwmlqute primo Scipio AÃi canut m ejiteramfecivndam uertiffe dicituntiofiri prÂ£ ceptores ceruorn feruomq^ ueto literis fcripferunt,quia fubteÃ a fibi uocalit m WUM fonumcoalefcere^ey con'^ fimii aequiret, nume u gemma feributur ea ratione qua Es ratione.) i^r Ã^Ji^^'^3^â^Â° f^^^^ ââ?â^âJ Â«ox^Mlt;iÂ»jfcntmiut efficitur. Ã¼j^rc fibi fu w (.M^f^'^^^^^^ât CÃ^diÃ¹t' AeoUedm iÃÃ m Â¥ ad hosufut Ib pra docuit â^^^!^f^!^ *^â ^^^ ^^^ meliut:,quod cui tribut quat Ã^ig^^â ^ kÂ« 7tâ'Â®PÂ°/â*' Eteris notamut, 'm quo puer is nob^ adjpm^ daud.) Sue 1 * gÂ«cm pne fonum, quoi utebanturi tantum ut al iUo ^Â«i t^tÃ³literatÂ«' 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;diÃmgÂ«crctÂ«r.Qgi(I,qMlt;e [crAumtur aliter quamenum figuras exco

\ ti^ur^^dm er Gdut Cditer^oiatur^quie 'muerfa Â»âÂ»^um''eÂ«qiS \ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;lie rem decUrdt,^ w tamCaiat effe uodtatat^quam CdÂ» bus Aeoiia l nbsp;nbsp;ioj/tiim Â« nuptuhliM fdcr^d^reh Nee Cneitseam ^f^^^^^,'

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;litrrdm in prÂ«Â«owMjw noU dccif it,^wfoMt^ colum pUus altera

gred-ens ma ojlcndit.MuleA fiw.t veneris huius, Sed hoc Moq: itÃ¨res (!r^i~^^o^^ nupta oratie modvm tAm pAru'Â£ quitflionK exccU rint. iudias ^'^^u clâ, ego b^Anihoc uMrc plurimAm debet. Ego,niÃ quod confiiez / Gaia. Anno tudo ob^uerit,Ãc feribendum quicqueÃudico quorne^ tauir Plutar , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

thusratione â^IÂ°â^^^-^â^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â^jâ^literArum,ut cujlodiAnt uo^

addita,qd tÃ¼ ceSjÃ¼râwÃui^cpofTtum reddAnt legentibus. ItAq; id ex'' muni adini' P'^^^^^^ debent,quod diduri furnui. liefere fuut emeti^^. riarationÃª dAte loqueiidifcribendi^ ^rta^du^ rdiejUAs^ famp;^Ã^f Â« wnquam ^â^â^^^ orndte^ dicendi, non eqÃ¯ade grÃmAiicK^croi'^ materfami- fed ctvm mihi oÃieiArbeto^f^f^^Jâd^-^â^â^^Â°Ã¼i,Â°^^'gt;'^^^^ rttfiW***â pfno-'R-cditAutjt^AcogitAtio^quolÃ¯iAmforejquihlt;ec^

lt;lgt;iJ,f^ixJmusj^'^^^mi^^j^^editrfÃªtkAâquÃ³^ fuccurrendo nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^ extremem quoq;

Grammat:- dnxictAte^tjneptAScAtiiÃAtio^defcenden^^ Atqibii lunT*^^^^ '^^Ãª^^^'^^o^^^'^h^(Ã¶mmuicredo.Ã¨cdnihilexgi^AmdticA nocuerit,nifi qd'fitpcrudcuum cd. An ideo minor eÃ Mi

Tullius orAtor, quod ide Artis huiusdiUgetiÃmu^uit, ^, er HI filiOyUt epiftolis AppArct^ rede loquendi ufq;qMlt;^ nÃper quoq; exddor^ Aut um C^ CteÃaris fregerut editi de dmlogid librii Aut ideo minus Me'^aU nitidus, quU quofdd totoslibeUos, nonuerbis modofingulis,fed etii Uteris dedit ? Non obÃdnt hlt;e difciplm^ per iÃ¼ds euntis bus,fcdcircA iÃAS liitrentibus. ^/'^âzr'^ a CffaremDilt;!Ã¯atoremdicit.Hoslibrosaccipiofijiirc,quo nimmÃªtiofitin Bruto Ã Cicerone ad ipfumftrjptorunidÃ¯ lingua Latina.

DeleHionepueri: CAPÂ» XIII. y^-^a^ SVpereH ledio, 'm ^Mpuer ut fcidt ^i ~jt(jÃeniere Ã^iritumdeie^, quo loco u^fum diÃmguerc, tibi eldUddÃ¯ufÃenfÃ¹sjt^e 'mcjj^idt^udnd^tt^^dfucÃ¯fub ^/* quot;/âp'^Z^ mittendd uox,^uid quoq- Ãexu,(ptid ItntiuSyCeleriiKycS-.ZZ^'ZJdifu.

tititim, Icniui iicendum,^c^nÃrdri niÃm opÃ¨re ip far''' f^^Z elt;- f non potfil. Vnwm 'Ãªh igitur ejuod in i^dej^irte pne^- â âââquot; â y^^^ â¢Xl^Ã¯â'^'*âââ^ ^^^i^^lidJ^crepoÃitintiÃi^dt.Sit dutem Poc^f^^.^ ^'-v^quot;â, f^ i-rtdrÃ¼'m prirnif ltSlio wrilK^fcilmfMul'ij^^udddm gf^ZZ'^Ã^Z'r -^â^

f^^Kt^nc^ui^mprof^Jmilif^idcdrineneHyetfepOrro^-t^^^j^^

/ 'ââ ^^.^^^ pfdlmdte, ut nunc d p^^if^ ^I^P^'^^f^^^f:!^^^'*^ S^ tplafmatc r.f^''*'^â'' optime Â£â Cifdrempr^exidtum dShuc lt;^e^iiÂ»ut}z^^Z^^ ^^dixille:fcdnt,^mjfecdntdi'.ple^if^Ã§dn^~^ec^rojo*'^^ 'âZ^-âifZtZ

t^mmeidriue'im.Ppe tdiwnpcxwmauenddm, auoquot;diÃind nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^

5^^^***$ Â«tÂ«Â« ^Â«ic^wd rudibw ^_omfiiÂ«wi igntr^ ^,.^r^~.^ A.^ â¢ a^Ã risinfederit,nonmodo^e^ui'diferidpfeduelmugis([ni^^^iZZZ^Z'iZ'^ ^^^^oneÃd funt difednf.ideo^ Â°piitgt;^^gt;^Ãii^^^'^^gt;^^^fZfZbPZ,'^Â° âquot;â ^ db Homero^^t^^ Vergdiol^io inciperet^ OMMMm Homefbi* â¢â^ â^/^â ^

^d intcÃ¯lig^ndiff eÃ¶r^ w^tesyÃrmiore iuaicioo^ut^â^Ã^*^Zj^ fffZfP^^^^^dhuicreiJupefehtempus^ncepÃ®Ã©ehmfemelIcd'â*â^ ..^Â«iÂ»Â«*Â«. ^' ^^^â^- â¢ i^nitfirn czfuhUmitdte heroiciedrminis dnmuiZifZ^^^^u^it: *fji*fii^i Crquot;ex mignitudine rertim Ã^iritum duedt, c^â.^^^fâX^M^ iâ^ ^^h^â^f*iiâÂ»'Vtiles trdgadie^dlur.t et lyrici, ft td^}Ã¯^P^f,â^ii^;

HoratiuÃ¯. j^AntetGnciÃcentÃ©rmÃ¼it'dyt'HoriitiiiminduibufiUift nolm inter^rctdri.ElcgiducroMiq^c^M ama^ er neu* Vide loachi. 4Ã¯f^^^ââ^t^âi,^$*ââ*ââ*^*â SÃ¶tddeorum ( WÂ« ..Fâ:^!!?^^^ââ^â^^^^ nepr^cipietjdwnijiÃ¼iem^R'^amouediiturt 'â¢Coinad*quot;'^ ^^ ^^^^ PÂ°^^^'âfi *â^Â» ^^^^^ iid'firmitis dit^jÃ³iur re* '^' fcruemur,Comad,iii;,lt;^ie plurmu^t^ cloquemium con / nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ferre poteilicum per omnef perlonas et dffvdusedt^

4^0. to nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ufumjnpwrii putem^pdulo poÃ¼ fuo loc^dicdm. Ã¯^dm

cwm mores m tutdfucrmt, inter pricipud legendd eritÂ» deMendiidro h^uor, nectdmen cxchfcrlm dlios. N4Â« lt;l^Â°^â^^Â°resaf^rentutilitdtKdli(j^,^d pue* H,^r^^// ^ j^^â ^â^^nidximemgeniumahntdtlt;J; ditimimdugedift, i.tt/â^x o-^ ,e^ prdegÃ¨dd: Cf teris (lut dd eruditionrm modo pertinÃ©t, 1^^^7'^'^,7^^doh'gd. ittds j^dctum dibit^lAul^Mtem toteres etidtn ^^^^^.Zid^'Ã- lÃ¤KrconferÃ¼t^r^udne^uimplerie^plusingenioquitmdt , quot;^^^^iX^S ^^ ^â â^^^'^hinprimis copldm un^orum, quorum in tri rrgt;ns ^ r,-,.Tvo2:sgcedâ^s^r^ittts^comoedij^selegdiftid,er quidam udut Oeconomia, MicifmosJ/nueniripote^:y0econqi^d_quolt;^ jÂ»bisdili*

^da argumÃ© rwÂ» fohmuirtutemfe^etuidfMtducrimt.SdnÃ³litds eer Â«roiib*. xqâ^V* â^^^^ Ã icdmjuiriÃ®itM dh Ãjis prtrndd, quindo nos in feribens Atti omnu dcUcidrÃ¼ uitid,diccndi quo^i rdtione deflexintuf' Xi^^ meT ^^â'5; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^^^^^â^ â ^â*^ ueterum poe*

i^^ V. frequentertdmfndpud Afmiiim^etidm^^cftcros^^ F ^ty ^r Â»Â«i.- Jumtproxmi,uidmws ÃnnÃ¼, AceÃ¼fPMÃuij^LÃÃ§if^fi: -ââ ^ZÃ¨- j^o^tZ- rentqZZiZedr dUorum inferi uerfuSjfimnMnÃ³n en^^

:^i^â^Q^Aâ^^'^â LIEER I* â¬^ f^i^lÃ^bjt'^vÃ ^^â¢uii^i'â^^ ^^^â^^ â^â^d^dit^U, c^ poetiquot;^

Ã ilS^ ^Â°âdptdtibui dures d. for Ã¨fi dfferitdie rej^irent, spii ^r-^usdcccdjt^Ã¶mcdio^fsutihtiis ,ciim fententipeonm, *^^^'^^3!i!^^â^hÃ¯^ftj^^'^f^^^'j^ P^Ppofdfre co^ÃrnKt,_y^^^s:'.,,.,t^igt;

j^ le^ionis^nonfcholdrum temporÃgt;us^fcd uitÂ£ffdcio terf^^^. o â ^'âif^^f!SfJ' âquot; pri^egendo, grdmmdticut o- iÃld iftideMy^r^Jff/f.'^ '2â'''^^''^-^i^y/^^f^^^^lt;^kit, ut ^drfes oydÃonfrj^ddi fi^^f^'ââ^,f^^ dff^sfÂ°ifjouerlt;âudejideretâfetpÃ©durn proprietd'tes,clu^d''dcÃA^.K 1^^^^ tr^debent effc notÂ£ m edrmmihuSyUt etidm m ordtrnd conf'^' Â° nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;p,

f'^ P^Ãttoue^deÃderentur, deprebenddnt^i (jUÂ£ bdrbdrd, ^t(- quic impropridj^u^cjfntrd legem Ãolt;^ucndifunt compa ^ ^tdT^Ã^^gt;uonutexhiiutiq- mprobenturpoÃ«tÂ£:lt;iuibud,quid^^^^2iv^fff^^^_ P}^^^fyuiremctrocogwntur,ddec) ignofcitur,ut ui^'-^^'â'^

52 citjwiTÃ¯c dpp^dtionibu^ ^fP^âIlFf^^ â¢ ^^ tdpidjims eh'm,lt;!:x fchemdti^os,et/chemdtd,ut d^xi^uo cdmus,z^ldudÃ^uirtutis necefitdti ddmuiSed ut coma nedt^tifcidUum,^ memoridm dgitet Â« ldlt;ptoc^ Â«ter Æ ^fh^Z^,^^ primd ritiimentd non mutile, demonfrure quoib, lt;luÂ£^'yff''J^^fâ^ â¢'â ^ uerldmodismtcUigcndti fint.Ci^cd gloff^dtd^tÃ¼fn^ e^te-(\^^i cR uocammui uftta^,riohuhitAdcÃ¼Ã¼ frÃ¶fcÃionk'^j f^-ruf.di^oentidrli.tnimutrotndiorecurdidmdoccdttrobos^

omncsyf^uwui prjuctpuenon poernd njodo,jcd etidtn ord^.^ffi^f.^ t q nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;iâiâgt;'d(^,id eR, figurdx ^^^^^^quot;ZLââ ''^Z

t,*gt; tcl,^Â«Â«^d'ioivoici'^UocdnturjCluorumcgoÃcuttropo-d.f^ ^^^^um trdiidtum vit eumloci^diffÃ¨ro^ i^.!^^^i^^Â£^Ãi*Zâ^-'^^'^'^^ â^ '**

^^4lt;*^ â^ Occonomid uirtM^qux 'm decora rent, ^ttii ^â*l*âââ^P^J^â^^ââââââ^âââ'^\S^*^^Â«j?fcÂ«Ã®/dÂ»({Â«tÂ»lt;lt;Â«w, ' âi^dinuerbii,ubicopid'probnbili{,uiimi^M-HiidC^ rÂ«vÂ«'iâ'' Ãfgt; v, i- nbsp;nbsp;^^^^^ endrrdtio hiÃoridrum, dUigen^uident iÃ¼d, non

y^i^J^^^^ 'â ^^ fofnijjefxtiscRâ¦ PerÃquiquidcin quad qu^q; ''â ^^^ yZ^'i^c^ )l^ry,Zucl con^mptiÃimorumhommum dixmt^fUt niinii mi^ ^gt;^^^-^âigt;y^'^'/'^^â^gt;'^^^Ã!^,^J^^^^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^f '^ ^^met^dte^ obruit iÂ» Ã¼^^Tt-Mn' 7,0 ^i^â^\enid,nteliuidHjtiidcdturd. i^dniciiii omnesetidmindb ,,Â«,/wgt;^*.,Â»y. lt;nbsp;o ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. gt;7713 *lt;7X) .

^^irty-i^^^.t-^^ndi lectionefcedM excutit^dnihbia quoq; fdbuln dteo^ ^\'.-^'â^f^Ã¨^^ Â»*?j^f lt;^ÃÃ^â^!^^^dh'AtqutplcnifimteiuÃnoditmp^. ' ^^''m'j^^ d^i^nentK ^mmdticorum commeutdrij^'^ioapÃsquot;,'qui ^^,c^ ^^t^^aZ compofuenmt, Qtis noti, bJdm Didymo quoqtie,quo ne i'^â^,L^^ ^Â°P^^^flt;^ifÃ^*â^^^^^l[^^â^?^^^^ume}l,utcu,mhiÃo j\lt; â¢ Â°^cuiddmtdnquimudnirepÃ¼gndret,ipfiuiproferre* */, quot;^^Z^riÃ^(^tur Ã¼ber, quiedmeontinebdti quad cuenit priecipuein ^'iiX^^/tiquot;^ef;fdbuloÃiufqueddderidiculd,q(tÂ£d'dtn'e'^din pudendit

Y ^^lt;^; ^iÃunde improhiÃimo cui^ ptere^e Jingendi iÃentid e^t Ã¨i^V^Zf^^,^!^^^^^ ^^ â^ââ '^i^^'^f lt;^Â°JÃ f ^ dutoribuf, Ã¹i'/'Ã¹ecmitÃmen^ 'Ã^ti^â^''â '^'f^ilt;^r tuto, quidÃwÃiÃ¼ri^quinunqMm fuere, non pop quot;nbsp;^ Zâ'â v^f' funt-^dm m notioribus frequentiÃime deprehendunt t ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^^^ ^^gJlj^^ ^^^ ^^Ij^- -^j.^^ uirtutes grdindtici bd^

foruwijfjuiyiÂ«Â« iÃ¼imthodiccn, hmc l^iÃarwe^iocinf^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;|

AdiieUmtÂ» tdmÃ¨nÃ¨orucu/^ MgdAdicendibrimÃ³r'dÃ¯ttt nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;\

^uibuixtdtcsnondu^rbetond:dfgt;ientcKmflituM.Ã¯gi I^'^r'^ j ^ ff-j..*''J^^IÂ°f/^^^^â'^ â ^'*Â£f^^^fi^^d^â*^^^'^^*h^ ^roxjmz^^ fucceduMt^ndrrdreÃrmone*piiw,etnihiife fuprimoiu'^ extournte, DemdreAndegrdcihtdte jtyloextgcrccoat.-â'âlt;^f'y'â-'â'^, -vÂ»^ 1 feintuerfui

ââ turn pirÃ^rdJi duddeim uertcre, qujd er breuidre que ''^'âi y^-thi _n^-ddet 'fxorndre QibfonodipoetxfenfuÃ¿^^t^tur.Ãi^iod'':^d^^^â^^ ''d^i^^opu^,etidconfummatisprofcIToribus difficile. MicoflM^y 'fââiP^Â»ââlt;*S'Â»^

chriÂ£,ctethologiÂ£, fuhieiHi^didor^ rdiioniiiu, ^t^i^^^^^^dZ^ Crdmdticos fcribdntur. Mid initium ex ledione ducut,'â-^^quot;^ lt;a:râ4gt;,.,âi

{( tentldKmuerjdl^seituox,etnologldperjclnlscotlneturi/'Ã§;^â^ââ^* ',Z**' ebridru plurd generd trddimtur. VÂ«uÃmilefententii, Chria. ^^^^ quoi dl po^itu in uoce pinpUci, dixit iUe^dUtydiccre idttÃSÃ®Ã¨riim c[uod f ft in rej^ondÃ«do, mterrogdtus nel cum ei didu effet,rejÃondittTertiu buic non diÃmi^^ f ''â¢'^ (^ --^ Ãe,cim (fu^non dixiffet,fed dliquid uelfcciffet,etidm itt'^Z^'âT^^^^ ipforufdilis ebrid effe putdt, ut erdta, cum mdodum'ZZ- puerum uidiffct,pÂ£ddgogu eiut percuÃit.Â£t dUud P^^^Ãl^'â^Ãâf^^Ã^^ pdr ei, Mod turnen eodem nomme dppeUdre, non dudet.''ââ^ f

\ât^ leddicuty^iÃ¼i^ie,^ lAÃo,Me uituludffueuerdt ferre,Xfâ'Â«'âgt; tp //f^.â.tduriimferebdt. 1Â» bn onmibuf er aeclinlt;^i^pef cofde ^, '^dpdi.^ducitdredfM,tytdm fdHoruqdidorurdtioc^^tidr '^ iylt;tâ.^9^/f^gt;u ]^^,.rdtiimeulM d poetis celchrdtds,notitiÂ£ edufd no cloquera-r^f^tâ e^i^A,^

{2^^ *^ ^^'^^ ^â¢^Um /^â ^^^t^'((t^ fift^ ^*^ ii^Cr'*t9âi^^ -v^**^ ^^nv9t^KÂ»^ v/~^

i : nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;**** ^vy****lt;'UÂ»lt;P ^rc^-w^ / if^ ^r:,â^' -9r/r/Q/9^~^/tr-1^ t^-tj-^f^* ,

â y^af~ A^^^ Â»Â»Â»Â» sf â¬8 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT, | r,,âl^/^!^^J^fÂ»Ã âhhctlt;ve$Tdmlt;Ã¿K^ ncccÃ'mxgrMmutidsfc ; TY.Kriii^yiâMi/Htterunt: Grad mdgis operum litorum cz onerd, Z}quot; tno* sÃ¯grxr^Â«Â»Â»-Â». nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;:

HAÂ«degrdmmdtiedqii'imbrc^iÃmepotui,noit ; utomnid diceremi feildtui,^^^ mfimtume^ i rat i fed ut maxime necejfdrid : nimc decÂ£t er ie artibus, ; ^uibuf mÃituendos priuflMm tra^Murrh^^Ã®^ ^e^ ! roscxiÃimo^Ãriciimfuliuwim^utcffiafturorbKiÃ¼c Ã x nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^n!flt;^J^nnistdiilrÃ¼mâ^o^ifcipÃmdrum |

^/ntHi^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;effidendum ordtore^Jdtis mIcm Johe, fin fint huw oÂ»fi^^

L .^^_^^^^perineKÃdriZ^iuritur.t^Jm^^uT^^ â^Ãª^'^^lt;^ ^'lt;^'^^f^,^^^'^ f^l^ Â» dicenddin ue fententidm pertmet fcire^^ ' ^e â ^ZS^^t^'^'^^^^^ in^dtd, lined conflitui tridnguld i^ui^^^i' quot;â ^^^ ct^.^Ãdteribusppfiin^ Aut quo melius,acide fend'd'ream,mlâ ' lffi^' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fo^snommbus )Cr ffdc'iji

kviy-^t^ y^^ ^^^ff^Ãx ^ ^^^^Sif^^'Â®***â**â'â*^^'!' muÃcosjui^, ^ vs **w 'fl^^ fff^'^'^â^'^âÂ°âââ^^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;5 Ã¯nteuigdntt QuibuÃ,)^

'gt;,^ 1#Â»Â»X A^ lt;S ego pritpum hoÃ§ r^o^deo, quod cy M. Cicero fcri*f' ^quot;^^'âk^iv^ PfÂ°^â^fi^^f^â^^^Â°f^^âl^^'*^^â^^^ftâ^^^^gt; uoneuMdUtt

Iits tt^itui ordtorem, qui fit, dut fucrit, fed imminent i^ qiun^oncepiÃefios dnm oj)erfediifdus,cx nuUd pdt^^e^ 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;te eeÃdtttif. Hum cifpichtem formdirtcs^cum quiÃi^f^

gt;w*. ^i'.^^^Ãf^' C â¢gt;*Â»ÆÂ» T^Â»'M-/h/ _4 -w^**Zf nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^**'Â»^^

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fl/Ã¶**iP***

^^fUicot^mmÃtui uni^iquj^^^ut Ã ictwt^mo^lis^i^'^^^^^^^^^J^^^ dimdetii,non modocignitioe cceleÃiwm uel mcf^aUumMr^'^ â¢^â''/ââ¢rf'* PâwÂ»â* â¢?J^Wâfââlt;*â*â*Â»f^^^ HMdam pdrM fine ft ipfâ^^^^y^^y^^ demum f^imcs^dtiÃ§'unt ,pcut cx^wÃ^ds mtc^^d.ip^^,rv,^yrr^^^^ 9uitites,non'(Ã®!Mccrdtt^Â£^AUt^ocodiini'boElntfice''âââ' J

^'^^Idfientem,ied c^utdlÃ®lumne m minimis quidem opor^^;^ nv ** teAt fdUi. Similiter ordtorem, c^ni debet ej^Jtijpiens,noit^Â»^i- j^J^v a\ A^

Geometres fAciet^dM MuficM, ^ux^hK dUd fit^Mg/tan^^J^^'^^l^^'^ fed h!e^Ã´^^dytes,utfitcoSftimindtui,iutidbwtt.^ifi6â v^rÂ» Synoff,^ 'Z,i^f?^^^ ^i^'dotwnâ'^idem,dtc^'drCd^Â£^morbK,^ tlt;^l^Â°'^'j^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^ .t

â^^i^neribiu medetttur,ex muUiSidt^ intermconttdri]! lt;^uost 'i^ uvff^-c^a fU^ t^

^ue inter fe efjÃ¨dibut componi uidemus, ejuorwn exdi*''^^ âf^J^'^-^ '-'^quot;Ãterfofit iUd mixturd Mid,^Â£ nuUi edru pmilis eH, '^uty^ JX-^j yrttt^i^rrr }^C'^Â°^^^â^^^ PââââPâ'ââ** uiffif^x omnS^^mit^ c^utd'nni'Ji^^'^' LZ'â'^'^^'^ / ntilidmeUis Ã¼Ã¼ inimitdbilem bwnAnerdtionifdporejud^^JX 4^*^^

vio Ãoru de fuccoru genere ^rÃcumtinosmirMt^r,flÃi'gt;'^'^ Â»Â«*^-. mtjo,qtM nihil prlt;Â£Ãdtiutbomini dÃ©dit proui'dÃ«tid^M^^â^^''^^^^'^j2 vi^ui drtibut egeti i^iÃ©Ã©tid cu fe no oÃendÃt in dicedo^vy b u nccprofernntyiiim tdmenoccultdin fuggerivnt, zy tdei* ^f^ ^^-v^IâÂ«s tÂ£ ^uoc^uefentiuntur ylnit^U^ui^ fine hud^r^JASb^Ã¼Â» f,,^^.ty â/triÂ»

erit totum, cui uel pdrM deerunt. O' optimum hoc eÃe^y Ãf^^^-j^ conuenieLcuuK etidmfi mdr^âp^eseÃ,nos tdmenprlt;e

eipidmm omnid,utfdltÃ« plurdfidnt.Sed cur dÃ©peint dni^'^gt;'- gt;y/u-/i Â»-^a mwindturd enim perfeÃ um OrdtorÃ© eÃe non^ohibet.^^Ãquot;â'^ÃÃâiÃÃÃ Turpiter^ deÃerAtur,(luicc[uid fieri poteSlâ'^^ rÂ» ,lt;gt;^^â^ i/y fpÃ'tlu -yii^^f^y

^^'^^^'^ ^/\ '^i'â*^^amp;Â°â*^^M^^^iÂ° filter urn potmmcffecoH ^t^^,-fp-^'^^:,jf^Ji,tcn(:it5.alt;im quit ignorÃ¢t KuÃcen(Mdc bicpri

â¢* ^ wodo, umictiÃ¤rn uenerationif htbuiffc,M ^^m mnÃeif ^'^ O^eu^^^^^^f^ f^P^MfiMic^^r^ittur^^^t^m ditos,jOr^ 'â hin w^*8ââ Cice pheuf ct Linus,(Ãorum utrunque dijs^mtum, di^iM iâ' '^deh Æiquot;deÂ° '^^^^^ ^^^^ ''^'*'^'^^ quoclue ntlt;ji dgreÃes dnimos ddmirdtio pe'^tii^iuina. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ne mulcerct,non ferds modo, fed fdxd ctidin,fyludsÃ;dn^.,, g'. t^^!^^^f^^;^xifÃ^Ãentdt^emoriÂ£trdditumeR.ttT''mdgenes ,r^,^'^'tg.ii, dulo^ejl^pnttuimmUterisÃudÃmmdnti^uiÃi^dmnni

Apud Home ^^^^^ ^xtiÃ¼Ãfe.Et teÃimonio Ãwt cl'dri'Ãimipo'et'lt;e,dpui rÃ¼ Achilles ^uos mter regdUd conuiuid Idudes heroum, dtcjiic dfo^. ^uÂ«*'Â«quot;'^quot;â fâvgt;nlt;^^lt;^ithdrdm cdnebÃ¤ntw AofdslferoiUe VergdiÃ nÃ¶nneedniti ,

Aencidj. BrrdtttcinlimdmJolisciildbores, e^Citl^erd, in^ej./ib^- Quibus cem pdldm coÃrmit dutor cmincntiÃitnus,mu*

^/fl^i,^ gt;' ÃcmJiwndrUeu etUmreru cognitioneeÃe epnittndi, â ^Ifiit,^ â¢Â» ^lodÃÃMr,erÃetidmordtorineeeÃdrid;Ãquidem,ut ^*â ' ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dtximus,hic Ãuo^ pdfi^qait dir ordtoribiÂ» rcUddÃd pbi_^

^.j^ .d^i^lolophiscdoccupdtd,noÃrioperisfuit^dcÃncoimUlin-^ fiif;^idnon^oted eÃe pfeÃ©ldeloquentid. Atquicldros [ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nominefdÃÃiÃiguirosnemodubitdueritÃudiofos muÃt

1 Ã©;^XdÂ« ?1^* f^^ÃÃp^â!!Ã¼l ^t^dgordi,dtlt;]i e^ fecuti deeeptdm fine [ ^^ '^^ dubio dnti^uilus oplnionem uul^dMrmt,mudu^ ipfiM j , eiiÃrdÃ¼o^eeÃecoi^ofiit^^qMm^^^

l â âÃÃ^ÃZ~^lt;â^''^'â^- ^^â^J?,?^Â°conientidiÃmilt^mcÃ¶ncordid,qMm

! '^if^t^ âquot; â râ^^dittlb.dimotÃ»Ã¿tt,JonttmquoqÃ»ebKmotibiu2ederut, 1 ^â ^-rrH^-m^^ d/fd Klt;(m ildto am in dlijs tjuibufdMjtMn prgdpue in

/Ã J^..?,^^ ,? .ââ, , . â -^^l,^^^ Ui^t^^^t â Â«- Â»t^t , yrgt;/i,mMlt;! /f^vgt;d

Â«.^CMd m nojirii Icgionibui cornuA, dc tube fdciunt $â quo*/-'^'^ -o^^rr^ gt;Æ 'Xt^ cortcfiHÂ«Â« quduto cA uehementtw^tdmum KomdAZ^quot;^'^^ '^ ^ â¢*quot;7âJ?â*jÃÃ 1^5â iiÂ°'lt;'ilt;^ c^^fi^i- f}'^l^^if^Â°^iamp;^gt;*ââ^ fruÃ¼rd

demonijslegum Mtor.muÃccsiixiflimimprohduit. Atâ que (dm ndturd ipÃd uidetur dd tolcrdndosÃdaUm hlo* j reÃ¯juclwt mMtm noin dediffe.Siquidcm e~t remi^fi edn â

twhortdtw,ntc^olim'mhisopcriTdiK,m([wbuiphri^â' quot;' wncondtuisprxcimtcaUtiudiucwndduocccon^irdt^fei

etiimÃn^lorumfdtigdtio^ cj^ddmUbetfe rudi moduidtio ^â^-Ã^ âr-Â«f foldtur.tdudem ddhuc diene drtii puleherrim^ uide Â»try th^ s.^ or,nondwme'dmtdnKnorAtoYiconiivngcre.Trdnfcdmui ^li^n^o f,j ^Â»gt;-'^'^ â2â^Â»â id qMoqKe,qÂ«oJ gydrnmdtic^e^onc^, de tf'Uliee^^.ÃfÃÃ^^^^^Ã^ r^' \^^*f^^^ivni* Sii^ttidei^'Ãrekitd/ijdt^ueAri^Ã»pnuis'^ -^'j-^ -^Â»^ r^ â M^^quot; '*âw ^bicÃ¤dm^rdmdttcc^t milites putdueÃ¯wnt,^eofÂ» ' quot;-^^ ' ^bA/Â« dem Mriufe^-reÃ¯prdeceptoresfuiffe, emn Sopbron oÃen Sopbron.

ditilAmoram eiui^mjnjptor, fed quem Ptttodito^^^^^f::;^'^^ v LX Â«Â«I^â^**â^Â» ^^ ftif^opios edpiti UbrQf dw, eu nfo^â^^^if^^^'ffjfquot;' ^*^'

de etidm itte mos,ut in conuiuijs po^ candm circu/mfer^â/y' ^Â«^Â«^i^if fctuf lyrd:cui(Kfie tmj^eritti cum Themijloclcs confiffutfifi^ vÃ¿rÃ®mio:' ^Ã^^^^ ucriis Ciceronis utdr,hdbittu ek 'mdoHior. SeÂ£,hââ ^^'^^^- ^^1^^^^ Ã^*â$ Korndnorum epulis fidesde tibids ddhi*{ '^â Cicero Tuf ^^â'^ morisfuit. Verfus quoqi Sdfi^um fidbent cementâ^.

^Av.7^ hdbuifie creddtur,turn Eupolis,dpud auem Por^dmus et Mark*. Hoc njufiKen,cr literds doceT. Et tAdriefis guTeA'^ype^O'^

gttauir Hy^ l^gt;!l^y,ilj^ ^^ mupcn jetre^mfi Sternly confitetur.Arip i Iis^utex^ne/^'â^â^^^^*â^quot; â^Â°^ ^Â° libro,fitc mfiitui pueros dntigui'^ bul.Arilio' ttffjo^f ^^lt;- Jkmmfirat, Et dpud^endndrum m tiy jâ^, pha. ^pp3fi^fioblt;^mÂ£ofien^^lt;^uirppofientifilium pdtri uelut rdtiOftÂ»' cat'aÃ¼t^oP Â«f^ '^t^iSlf^fi!*^ 'â eduedtionem contulerdt, op^â^' km X effÅ- ponens,fi pfdltrijs et Geometris multd dicit dedifie:- VÂ«J^^

'Tt â quot;^ *Â»*^ r ^ nifefium,ne iÃ¼is guidcm,gM^udcs dc beUicofi uidentur, fi^â^ ~.- s^^-^urdm inujices,gudntdm iÃ¼d recipiebdt Â£tM,dcfuifie.Ee ; ^ * quot;nbsp;*^i^uft ^XÂ«- ^^^ ^ pfouerbium uf^' GrÂ£corum celebrdtum efi,indo d y^^ firas^ //XÂ«. Ãos d Mufisydtq^ Grdtijs dbefie. Verum quid ex ed pftf fi'J^^, â7 *i^!^'P'^^^ P^tdt futur ut Ordtor,difierdmus. Elum^os mufiice^ M'â '^^ Â«/ft- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fhdbet duplices,m uocibus tyr in corpore':utriufgueenuÂ»

â Agt;Â»gt; gt;gt;^ '^^^/^jtoxcnus muficui diuiditm ^Sfd.ofjo-jj.i'Xl^cr'jd-i'^ ÆÂ«'Â»)lt;gt;Â» '^^Ã/jf^orumdÃ¯terummoduldtione,cdnoredlterum,dc ^ ^ÃL,quot;, ^^quot;-^ ^-^foniscofidt^^ Kumigitur non hÂ£c omnid ordtori necefid^fi^^^

, f'X^p^^-ynM^ue^lnrimijl^Ã§rfimet^ Hifi forte m curmMus tdjitiiWt'fi'f-1 t pHâ^TX^{Â»^waÂ»j?fK?/htÂ»ÃHrlt;(^Â»Â«Ã^wo^^ nbsp;nbsp;;

^pui^io ujcum^m Ãgcnfo^ipcrMcM cf,Auffotfeom^or .â¢Â«Â»* ^^ 4 r^Ã» â^ poftio, grfot^inorAtione c^uoq- ult;i,riepf^Ãªrumodoff^Â»^^^^J^,^ ^'m, ^dhibetur^ut in mufeeMAnq; (y wee, er mp^uUtio^i f^^^ g^â'^'^ ^^^ ^.^i^'}^^^ iu^iter,moderAtA feniter cA'ff.^-^^^iii^â^

nit, MAc^ Arte c^nfeiuit cum eorivm, qua di^t^AffÃ¨ ^^ ^^^ ^ibuf.AtquimorAndoqtioiinte}mouocK,reinifio,fte ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. n

7 XMy^ertmet Ad mouedos Audiemium Afjeilut. AliA qua^^^^t-^-' ti^,^â*^ ^^ ^lt;^^cdtionis, et uocis{ut codent utdruerbo^modu

I-Â»tionf condtAtionem iadicum, aUa miferJeordiAm petiÂ«â ^,^ mnijCwm etiAm orgAnif, quibtu ferma exprimi non pof

ten , afici Animos in diuerfum hdbitum femiAmt^^or* paris quoq; decens,et Aptus motus,qui 4icftur iifMb/J^icÃ©, *Â« ^ff^l^'''ilt;^gt;^^lt;7'iliumdepeti poteft^in^qua^c^^ A^o â âr^^^Â°^gt;7gt;^tmA conf fit, quA de re fepofttiÃ¯snobis'cn[0 Z^ ^â^' â ^i^j* ^Ab^it in primis curAm uods orAtor^^uid^u cfu^ t'fft^t^ y'o-' tAmiÃuÃcesproprMnifSed ne hxc quidem prlejumc^A ^f^'^^fquot;'^

pArsen,utuno interim contentiftmut exempÃ¯o C^GrAc uex Cicerof-^- .lt;Â« châ,prÂ£cipui fuorum temponm orAtoris,citteoncionAn ne amp;nbsp;GeUioZ''

ticonf flens pon cv/m muficut,ffulA,qMm tonArion ttai'i,^^ ^ f^^ffZ' '^-'^ cAnt,modos,qMbi^ deberet intcndi,minier dbAt. Hgcet^^f^^^^ff^ ^f.fi^citrAintcrfur^difrmAS^Anion^sffÃfe^rerrefo'ptmftes,'^^'^,^^^.^ *^-^^^ *^ Sf Â«lt;t fnit, Libet probier quafdAm imperitioÂ» nbsp;nbsp;^^T^icw'

f-^4,f^ res,etiAm erdfiorefut uocAnt)mufi, dubitAtionem IâÂ«iÂ«lt;tl*^^^^â ^ 71-^itdtisexmrr^.nAm P^tex cerU legendos ordtori fu^- ''^^f^'^gt; *'^^

tufo coneej^fmt. tfum igÃ¼urmfme hÃ¼ufee^ At ft quis^fff^y.,,, b^^ td cÂ£cus Animi e^ut de aÃ¯Ã¼s dubitetdUos ccrte,qui cArdgt;-'*h t^mrf^ mmA Ad lyrAnt Ã§oi^ofuerunt.Uec diutius forent dicen nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'

^^ ^^^^^ ^^^â^ '^^^^ Â°^^^^ Â» ^â^^ '^^^Â° Ifffflndm difciplmdin nolt ^Â»^r^ fint peroÃ^durducritjnon eil committcndum,ut iÃ¼d dufigt; .

â¢ /i,gt;vgt;Â»-*'^ i^^nexipfis^quibutfdmtnodÃ³ufuijcxÃ«plujcreddmejfe ,(t ^^ a^^-f ntdnifefium.qihe mihi, qt quAtmut Kuf^pldcedt, dp(f s- lt;nbsp;â,(, ^ i tim turnen proferendiM puto, non Imnc ^me pnedei, f^j^' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^Jf^l^f^ttK ejfiaemmdtd ^zyquot; impudua^odis Ãd* quot;â ^ ^ r^/Hu. (^ Ãnon ex pArtcmiÃimd,Ã quid in nobis uinfis robo rismdnebdtÃc^ctiitlfedqiMldudcs forti^mÃc^^.^ tur^ quA^ue z^ ipfi fortes ednebant ;Nlt;'c p/dlterid ^tifd'^ ^fambuca â^ddicds'Ã«tÃ¯dm uirgmibus probis rccufdndd,fed nee co '^ Ã§^^^lrt 3^ 3,gt;titiottfiÂ» rdtioniSidd mouendos ,leniendos^ dfiÃ¨dus pad Pollute plurimitm udiett'NdmerPythdgordnt dccipimiis,conlt;^r interorga- â '^^0f^^^^]^j^^^^Jl0f,^^fJ^tnd^Ãl^ftf^wfftâ7 mutdremj^ndeum modos tibicmd^compofiiiÃCtEt f^i^as' C^^^f^Metidmnulric^m,quteddhibenturinfdntibufj '*1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;lt;nbsp;dieildtÃ¹mi^lutiin q^2f^^l^fÃ¿^n^d^nd^Ã¯i otiin nonmeruditedd^cldmdndum'^^ mf^erid^m^uApo ' nitur tibicen, qiufdcrificdnti ^y^i^ ceemejdt^ ado AtheneusE iÃo in mfdhidm^etper pr^teipitid aetatadccufdri,q^cdU ^^' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fd mort^ extiteut:Qjiie ft dici debet db ordtore, ncc di ^i^tt^tÃ¨fic^'Jt^^^^^^^^ fcienildm Mufices poteÃ¢ y quontodonon finnc^jh, ' quoque drtem nceejfdridm effeufuinofrOj ucl miqui tonfentienti nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â*â^' '=^â ^-^1

OTCATOR.* LIBER- IÂ« 7TVi*4**'*^^'^'Â»***^*^ B IN Geometriitpirtcrn TatenturclTeutilemtenemÂ£â !gt;Æ â'^'^ â'v | tdiwu^j agitdn ndhqucdnbnoSy dcut^

td celcritAtcnt percipiendi ^enire^ mde concedwtt tjed.â^gt;quot;'~^ r^^-i- 1 prodeffc cam non ut cÂ£teYM,cum percept Â£ jint, fed cum^X^ZZ^-.-/^

difcituryexiÃimAnt.ld'uulgAris opmio cÃ¢, nee fine can :lt;,^Ã^-*^ ^f-^- 1 fitfummi urn etidm im^elijdm huicJcietMiÂ£ ojper^m ^Â»ZJ^Jfquot;^ '^

d^rwnt, Ndm cum ft geometrid diuifdm numÃ©ros dt^j a 'OÂ» formas, nwiwfrortiw qÂ»ilt;Jcm notitid non ordtori modof'^.fZZiZ^ .gt; fedcuicZi^;prints faltcmUteriserudito neceffdridsA^^'^^ 'f^

incd^is uero uelf-equentifme uerfdri fold fm quitus dhor,nÃ¶ dicojicircd fummus trepiddt,fed ft digitorwn Vide anno' fdltÃªmcerto,dutmdecorogefii^dcS^utdtioediffentit, cWmiC^â iudiedtur mdoHtts.iUd uero imedfisrdtko,^ ipfd qu^de^^^ f^i^âs cddit frequenters cdufaxindin de terminis, menfurisc^'-r â ^^-^ââ ^ ^ fumt lites,fÃ¨dijdlet quAnddmdiidmyumdrte ordtorid co'fe~_^â','Z.tf\s gndtioem.idm primwm ordo c^'geomâetriÂ£ neceffdrius^'fquot;^ norme 4 ctoq^fwÂ«/ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â'âââquot;^ iÂ»*^.* ,,Â«-*Â«.

feauentid^eZeertis inccrtd.nonnefd m diceJo fdcmuil 0^1 a iHm propofttdru quxjUonwM coclujio, non totd fc re confidt fyUogifmisiPropter quod plures vnueniesyqui'^^^Zt'^ â iidk^iet fmdem,qquirbetoricÂ£ fae^ur^dne driÃ«. ^-^ 'Vertm cr ordtorjtidtn^irdrq^nonfdmcn nunq probd*^â ZZZ^'^^ bit di dkHice, NÃ o^yUog^fmis jtres pofcetutetur, tiriÃªenthymerndie,quirhetoricusfAfykogifmw^DeniofZZt^t^ ^' ,,j^ que^o^ofiMquÂ£ iumt potenttfim^fgfdmmicit ^tto fZ^ZZ-Z^ZZZ: *^/^^'^ ^^^Â° diciWÃ¯tHr. Qgid dut mugis ordtio,q f robd Â«^ â^f^' Z' ^actionem petitiÃ¯dlfd quoque uerifmiUdy geometrid rdÃ¼o*râ^irt^^ ijr,

^, p^g. QVIMT. I^STIT,^/ rl.j^ f,âiJ^ Pl^^S^^Phi^^ gt;i^iSf gt;nbsp;(^tiHw puen luierefolebdtmn^ Vte^X^^ ^^^^â Sâ^^Ijj^S'^ lt;li*^lt;gt;i}d^lt;â^.pfopoff^^i lt;^5^ ci,^.Â». ddtiQubrwmlocorumextirmielineaedndemm^rM j^n^ s^ couiguM, eorum Ibdcium etuoo: Moi hu imen contme^ \-,Â»,a Mtinne tur,pdr}itjiec^eÃ¼:^jiijdljivmeÃ¼,Ã¼dmpr'nntvinrt^ ^4^^^* * fert, cuiiu/it formÂ£ itte circuits, reprehenÃ^ d geom( tris fimt hiftorici, qui mdgnituimem infuldrum fdtis Ji* â¢*'^âTâÂ«â^C 2f^^Ãlt;^â^^^^'^â*^amp;â^t^Â°^^ dmUtucreiUerunt, tJdmutqufi ^Â«â ^Z ir^f^CA-it^/ que formdjperfeÂ£tiÃ'tmd,itd edpdeiÃimd eSitHeo^ dr* cumcurrens lined,Ã effidet orhem^qutt formd eÃ 'm pld* nis mdgis perfe{ld,dm^lius j^ddum compledetur,qu'dÃ»t ft qudirdtum pdribus ortse^idt. 'Kurfus qiuirdtd tri* dngulit, tridnguld ipfd plus tquis Idteribta, qu'dm 'mre* qudlibus^ Sei dud forÃtdn obfcuriord,nos fdciUimum eti lugfrum. ^^ imperitis fequdmur expefmentu. lugeri menfurdiit ducentos zj- qudirdgmtd longitudmis pedes ejfe, dimi* dio^ 'm Idtitud'me pdtere,noferÃ¨ quifqudm ek qui igno ^^^â^(^i^ f^^^t-cuitus, c qudntumedmpidduddt,colli gereexpeditimi.At centeni er odogeni 'm qudmq^ pdr* tem pedes i^^m j^dtim extremitdtis,fed multo dn^liut tlaufiquaÂ» diuifÂ£ ^tuorllnetsdreie fdeiuLldÃcompuUreque feuÂ«Â«?'** pigrt,breuioribus numeri^dÃ« d^edti m deni m quddrilÃ' pedes,qu/ifd^td per ordmâ 'mtfd centum cru/nt.At Ã Ijr^R^y-r^-^ M'mic^nipÃ¨r tdtw,qumi Ãnfrote ltnt, ex tUÃ¶ quad lt;un Y, p z^U^v^, pleiluntur qudrtdm dedufent cOt^m ctrcumduduSi ut '^//^âi'J^^^''^Â° ^Â°^^f.^J '*^t'in^ ^deuiceni ftnguUs d^ent^on plu*, res mtui qM^rdtos hdbebu/nt, ^td^erquoriot^ttu/u dueetur.qux cirewwbit AUteigt;Ã¼intd,eiuÃcm/^dt'fcritt

tUiiÂ«ei(^Ã»xcentumio^met *Itiquiequidfbrmit^MtÃ'.fÃ^^'â^^ Anti ictrixeriStimplUudmi quoq^ peribit.'Ergo ctidm^' .J^^L~râ_ id, fieri poteft,, Ut MMore dreuitu minor loei amplitudoquot;^* * , cluditur.fiocm phntift^imincoUibUiMUibuiÃ©iietÃ¹mt.^

âquot;C^^P^^^^^ P^i^i^j p'^ Pâ ^U^ ^'*i'*^ ^^^ â¢ QuidC quod fe^^^^t^-^'^ eidem Geometrii toUit id titionejnufquemundi^^quA

1-1*'- cum fiderumcertos^n^ltutosqicutliutÃ¯Ã¯imÃªrisdocett^ ^^^ ^^ ^Zirdifdmui nihileffe 'mordimtu itci^ fortuitÃ¼ ^ quod ipfu/n^Z-A^^hJ^^ nonnunq^mj^ertinere id or it or cm poteft. An uero eu ^ quot;'' â^â'quot;^ Pericles Atiienienfes Solis obfeuridone territos,Yeddi^ bePerkli

tis ctusrei ciujis, metu ubenutti Aut cum Sulpitius tue pitio exepu G(tllÂ«lt;âiÂ»ÃªjÅrÂ«tti L.^4hK de lu^Jk^ioM dij^eruit^ y^j'Æ ?ââ^ neuelutpro'digio'diuimtus fiHomilitum inmiterresg^^quot;''^^^*

') v /-^^â*^ââ^ uidetur elfe ufas oritor^ offici^Qu^od Ã Ã®^i 0Â« ^'fâ Â« ^\\ciM'inSiciliifciffet,non codent co^fujus metu, pulcher* Kb.^L^ titnuw AtbenieÃum acerdium perdidijjet. SicÃ¼t Hion, Dione PluÂ» euwt id deÃruendim Vionyfij tyrinni^muen^nonjH *^â^â:^â^â â tdiciÃidctcrritus.Sihtexcm^JilÃauÃM be^i^ttifeii^''''^^'â musc^ quad Archimedes tinus obÃdionem SyrieuÃrum ^^^''^^ ^^^ in longius tnxit, illud utiq^ iim propriu id effidendum i â¢* rfâââ*â

' quodintcndimus,plurimisqi(iÂ£Ãiones^quirumdijÃciliÂ« or iUi fitioneexpGeitio elicit ^ ^ââ^Ã^'^^ diuidÃªdi^ de ^ ^/^ quot;^j-^y fedione in inÃnitÃ¼, de eeleritite iugendilinadbus ilUs probitionibus folui folere, ut Ã ed ontoriiquod ptoici* mus demonÃribit liber) de omnibus rebus dicendumjnuÃ¯

^,4^â3^âX' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ali(Ã¿iid Coinadocjuolt;^,dum elt;itcnui,(lM

tiiiÃ´tetuoÃ§is'exitti'atc^ngiuolo, autfciuUtcr tretnerf, ^â'- ? '^ 'â^1'*^âââ^ âA'^ ^briÃ©tatis effingat, neeferuiUucrniiiÃ¼tc imbua ^ v-^ (^J^-^ tur nccamori^auarltii, metti, difcata^Ã¤a, c^utc nec^; â^,^Â»XÂ»^^**^ ortÃ¼ori pvnt necefjarid, er mcMÃ« prxcipue in Â£^e pri â¢ nbsp;nbsp;^*. fr.- ^^ f.' mi tenerdnt ddhnc,Ã§r rudern mÃciutit^lJdmfirques imi

^^.quot;^^ â4*ââ iâ^tio,trdgt;tfit m^mores. Nfc geftuf o^uidem omnK^Ac mo^ tu^ comoedii petendm e^, (^MnqiMn enim utmni^ to ^^ ,Ax,... ), ^.p ^^ ^^ quendAm niodivnt pÃ¯tefidre debet ordtor, pluris ^'Z!^Z^^\1 â^'*^ ^^^^ it^fr/f 'Afcenico,nec Miltu^n^c mdnu, nee exgt; i^eet'iUt^i-^ curfionibMnimiui Â« N4Â»m fiquotn his drs eA dicentium, ^ y^^^f^'^ fâtprimAeÃ¼^nedrseffeuidedtur.QttodeÃigiturhuiuS â â¢ doÃ¼oris o^dumfinprimis uitiA,ftquA fuM,oris emen'' ^::rÂ°^ e ^^^^'detyUtixpi^ffdlÃni uerbd, ut fudquÂ£q; literj Con^ enn /,, ^âi^.^)â^'^timtur.QudruÂ»idmenimuelÃª)Mtdie;TtÃªtpt^fftt^ilt;tâ^ ^Tâ- Z^â '^ â*^^â^^^ IdborAmm.ciuifddm uelutdmorÃ¨s^dr^meffi ^ ^t-^^^^ cimÃ¼s,isrdiijsnod!Ãimilibus,fedqudfihebetioribMp^ .â.?^â{?',â^,^'Â»â 7muidmus. (^iÃÃÃ Æ ^iterÂ£ q^ DcmoÃhcnej^qiioq^ Ãdbo â^^'' âZT^â yMity'xiuccÃ¨clii^^rumuiseU dpudnosquÃ³^iiyâcum t^^e-^,, ^.i /-^ edeÃmiliier g non uAÃuerut,i^ dc^d moUiimtur.^c pue

â¢^^y.' ^^ 'â¢^nccuerbdin fducibus'pdtietjtrdudiri,ncc'Ã¶ramp;indnÃ¯tdte V^T..Azâ^ 'a,.^^f^fi^^âÃ^i^^!^^^^fermonipuroconucn^^nt piieem Hods ndturdm plcniore ouadam fono drcumlini,^

y^miMitw, g^^ W040 e^tu ^'itfilt;^^^ dutÂ» Curi^it etu, ntcxtnm^j^^ctl:gt;Â£intcrcidAt,utpdr'â'';^ â^^â^ fipi^rniojit, ut (^uotiet cxddmdndum crit, Idtrrwm (Ãd' KCe^^t^ây^^ nitut fit iÃ¼c, non edpitK,Oquot; g(fui dd uocetÂ», utdtui^fffff tZlif^^ geflumdcconimodetur.ObfcruddMfieritctiA.tgt;tM relidfx^f^^f ^'' jufdciesdiantiStne fdbjd detor^uc4gt;^ur,np Immodicu^^^i^.,^. hidtw riÃ¤um diÃenddt, nefapmus uultut, ne deif{li in '^'*- 'â^ â terrd^^^ne in cimdtd utroUbet ceruix :tidmfrons plu^. ^ ribusgenereus pecedt^ Vidimultas,(quorum fuperciUd.-^-:^ ^adfnguiosuaciscondtus dUcMrentur,aliorumconfrid.

dd, dUorum eudin difridentid., cum dliero in uerticeni'^'^f, tenderent, dltero peneocului ipfr premcretur. Ã¯nfni*â^^^'^ turn dutem,ut max dicemus,in bis quoejuc rebus momen'd^^rf .Â»v turn e{l. Et nihil pateel pldcm,^cjuod n^n de^cÃ^. Debet dutÃ³rit^e fiudcndum, ep. condtdtionÃ¨ confirait ird, fÃ¿iisÃexusdecentmiferdtionem. Quaditd optime fdd*^'â'^''^ ft, fi certos ex comadijs elegerUflocos^,lt;^4dhoc md* xw idoneos, id e^ ddionmu fimi/es. iidem dutem di pronuncidndum non modo utilifimi, uerum dd dtigeni ddm cpiociue eloquentidm mi^xime dccoi^moddti crunti â^'^^ ^'^ ^tim mfirjmd Â£tM^diorÃ©i nonc^iet * Ãjettrjmi cum legere ordtiofres oportebit ,cum uirtuiesedruidtn f^'*^}â*^Sf}.^Ã¤^^^lt;'ililt;itiis, dc peritusdfriÃdt,n!d' â¢dite foldUc^HZc formet, ueru difcere etidm'Ã©iedd ex hiS flt;^amp;lt;tt,lt;s- Cd dieere fintcmddrc^i^ lt;luemddmodÃ dge^,^ ^^ ^ re opor^eiii^mprotinuspronuncidtioneuocem Z!^ medi,^gt; â^^.

/^^^/âeew^/,f j^uipdulumeti^rpdÃ¯efricKUdcduerumt.Non dehisw â^â¢idor, quibus pars uitÂ£ in olco, pdrj in uino confumitur Ã³^tran^^ff/i^ qui corporis curdmentem obruerumt, Hos enim dbef fedb eo^^uminftituimusqu^longiÃime uelm. Sed no men eH idem bis Ã quibus ge^ motusq; formantur, ut^eUji fint brdcbid,ne indo{lÂ£ ruÃicÂ£ ue mdnus,ne fd . tus indecorus nequd in proferendis pedibus inÃitia, ne caput oculi^ ab alia corporis inclinatioe difideant. Nd ncq^ boc ejfe in parte pronumciationis negduerit quisq,

nec ipfim pronimcidtionem d^ordtore lÃ¨cÃ§rnet. Et eer* te quad fdcere oportcat, non intignanSum rÃ difcere, cum prafertim bÂ£c chironomid,quÂ£ eH (ut nomine ipÃ) decldrdturÃex geÃus,^^ db Hits temporibus beroicis or td ft,O' d fummis GrÂ£ciÂ£ uiris ,cxdiipfo etiarn Soerd tiauMtcfi tra te probdtd,^ pUtotte quoq^ in parte ciuilium pofita uir^ phTi^t^vâ ^â^^'^^ ^ Chryfippo in preeceptis de liberoru educatio z^iuftiiruy ne compoÃtis non omiffa. Uam Ldcedtmonios quidem ei^^rtiiÂ«' ^^â^â^â fâ'â^tâigt;^iÂ°^lt;^^qtundamyUn^ddbeUdquoqiutileM, Jis Ã¨uK NMiXu, hdbuijje inter exercitdtiones dccepmus, NfgÂ«e id uete

iTTMv. De turn nomine,de rehgione duras dd boctepus fdltdtio. Et Gymnaftica m^inx.CiceronisdeOrdtoreU .uerbdCrdfi.abuspÃ¯i^ pub. in de Ie cepit, ut ordtor utdtur idtertvm tncundtione forti,dc ut^

gib. vq. Lace rili,non a fcend cr bijlrionibus ,fed db drmis, dut etiaiH fsUatfon^ pdhÃra, cuius difeipUni ufus in noÃrdm ufq^ Â£tdtemft â esuffxn ace Â«e reprebenfione defeendit. A me tarnen nec ultra pueri quot;'^'^' les annos retincbitur,nec in bis ipfis diu: neq^ enim gea ^ f,^ ic^'^Â» p^^ordtoriscomponiad fmilitudinemldltdtioisuolo,

(xgt;r^ lt;^i^ k1- â Â£/ -rn^rm j-'^Ã¯ ^ntt^e ^rr- f'^'^*^ 'Ã¼^r^ â¢y^/^ j * j^ /frjy ifht^f^n'' m -zM*i*âgt; ^frtlt;^â^f'ff^,Â»fv^y^^f^^ ^-^f^ z^v^^ar-

ORATOR. LIBÃR 1. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;j

l^i fuheff'c AU^Md ex hdc cxcrcitdtiÃ¶e pucrUi^ unde nosâ^ H'tidt^quot; ,^ non id dgentes^furtim decor iÃ¼e difcentibus trudUus.;^/^^ f^o^ec^uitur, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â ri-â-â^gt; i^'.i^^ki-

fi'^diÃ¼d difcendci fint codem tempore. quot;nbsp;2^^gt;^^k'^7Z/ CAP. XIX. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;',3^Â«^'H.t.*,.^^fA

a y teri folet,iin,etidm fi difeendafint hlt;ec, f^odcm^^-y^^^'quot;^Â°^ tempore turnen tndi omnid^ etpercipi poÃmt^ â r^ r^Å¸ ^-i t^^^ 4*^

^ dwerfumjendentibui fad quM necd'r,y â^ltâ^^fnr^jnecdiÃ©'sipfeiufficieit.'EtfitMamepd* tutur tÃ³e ttids robuÃior, timen pueriles innos onenri non oportedt. Sed non fitis perf^iciunt,lt;piAntum natudi'e^'A^fquot; ^^^ Yd bumdni ingenij MlcAt,clUÂ£ itde^l dgilis, cz uelox fic Zr:^. Â« l.,X^.., m omnem pdrtem,ut itd dixerim,fÃe^dt^t ne poÃit epti '^-'' â ^'â â¢^r 'quot;if'^ dem dUeptid dgere tdnlum unum, in plurd nero non co* dem die modo^fedfodem temporis momenta, wmfudtn (Â»â'' Â«f'Â« impepddt.Aitnerocitbdrlt;xdi,npnfimiilet mcmoriÂ£^amp; - Â«z^Â»â HAz.., lt;ârtlt;, fono uocis,et pluribus flexibusferuiumttewm interim dli ^^^inv^tiit^ -1 NavÂ» SJj!i^!}?^ d^xterd'^rcutiiwt, dlios leud trdhuni,câonti*quot;'quot;^''' nent,prob^/nÃ¨pÃªs^iiemotiofusccx^ml^enaemgt; porp^erudt. Et hÂ£c pdriter omnid.. i^idnos dgenli '^^'!^'' *Æ fubit^neeeÃi^dte dejprebefi^nÃ³nne dud dicimus^dUdpro *''quot;' -Â« â^''^ uidemusiewm pdriter muetio rerum, elcHio uerborwm, contpoÃtio,geÃtis,pronumcidtio,uultusmotus^deÃdf* retur.Q^teÃ uelut fub wto condtu tdm diuerfd pdrent Ã c-'^^v^ 5 '^ niÃ¼l,cHr non plurimis curis bons pdrtidmur^ ewm pneti^ fertim reÃeidt dnmos, de repdret udrietds ipfd,contrd^ fit dlilt;pidnto difficiUm in Idbore una perfeuerdre i idea

CZ Ãyius le^Ã©lione requieÃeit ,QripÃus leilionis tigdiien Ã¯^Ã¯^ {eudtur, C^udmlibet muUd cgerimus,i^uoddm td* men modo reeÃ«tes furnus dd id quod inÃplmusl^Qjiis no , o btumdi poÃit,Ã per totum diem cutÃ¹fetmqi drei: unuW mdgiÃrumfent f mutdtione recredbitur, peut, 'm cibifi quot;^quorum diuerfitdte reÃeiturÃomdchus, o- pluribt^mf norefdÃidio dUtur, Aut diednt iÃi mitÃ«, qui fiÃdlid rd'^ x tio difcendi,Ãgrdmmdtico fall deferuidmus,dc'inde geo metrie tdtum. Omittumus interim quod didicimus, mox ,,JrdnÃcdmus dd muÃcum,exciddnt prior d^Oquot; cum Idt'mis â Ãudebimus literis, non refÃieidmus dd greeds, er utfef quot;nbsp;melfinidm,nihilfdcidmusniÃnouiÃimum.Curnonident fuddemus dgricolis,ne drudÃmul cy Wmetd, er oledS,cr etrbuÃum coldtit,ne prdtis,er pecoribus,er hortis,ct dl

vcdribtu duibM^ dccomodent curifCuripfi dUc^iiii fo* ^'â ââ^^'^^â^^ f^f^m negotijf^dliquid deÃderijs dmicortvm,dÃ¯icjuid rd tionibut domeÃicK,dlicjitid curÂ£ corporif,nonnihil uoltt pidtibut t^uotidie dÃ¤mm Æ qudrum nos und res quolibet '^^â^^'^^^^â^^^^fdiigdrcL Adc^dciUus eÃ¼ multi fi n^^^^^ Atifv.^cere qudm diu.llbtd ^uidcjnmmimeucrendum ell,neld ^^^â ^âj^^ ^Â°^^gt;^ fludiorum^wridilÃcilius tolcrentt nelt;j^enim ui v7^1?7j^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ld Â£tM minus fdtlgdturMirumÃtforÃtdn,fcd experigt; \^^^^^^^^^^^gt;^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Nd)Â« er dodUord funtingenidpri

^7^ intrd bienmu g uerbdrc(ieformdrepoti^riwt,^mu^^^^.^ gt;.^r'^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nulloinftdnte^omnidferÃ¨loc^uuittur.AtnouitijsnojtrK/'^ *J ^j ^^^t^VÃi^v^Â»^ per ([uot dnnos fermo Idtinus repugndt f Mdgis fcids, Ã nbsp;nbsp;* ri^-y^^Ah^ â ^ueidmrobuÃuinÃituereliteriscceperistnonÃnecduÃ -

y â^ did ssÃ³j.d'o/j.aSei^ cos,qui m fuA quidq; Arte optime Ã-f ciÃt. EtpAtiÃ«tioreilldborKnAturApucr/SjÃ¼uAmiuueni*^^'^â^^ ^-y,-bus,uideiicet utcorpord mfAntium, ne cAjus,quo in ter-^f,.^^ ^^ ritoticsdeÃcrv^diir,tA gr Miter dJ^igU^ncc ^per mti^^^^^^p nuf,(2' genui reptAtio, nee po^^reuetÃ«puscontmui 1Â« fuseer totius diei difcurfus,qutA pondus lÃ¼fs Abc^,necfe ^s^^^ lt;^~mr7n^1^ ipfgt; g^AUAM^ÃeAnmi quoq-, quiAmiwre eonitumouengg^^^^^^^'' tur,necfuo niju^udijs iÂ»ÃÃuAit,(cdformAnda^fe tAntu^ modo prAÃdnt,nonÃnÃliter fdti^ntur^ Pr^Ted [ec^â â¢gt; âU^ r~*k dumdliAm ditdtis iÃ¼iits fdciiitdtenjJueluifimf^jft Joeg teis fequuntur, nee quiC idm egerini, metiivntur. AbeU iilisddhucÃ¯dlorisiudicifi.PorrÃ¨uPfreftuÃ«terexpertiru '

^i.niffgt;m'iÂ«tusdfjieitfinjusfdtigdtio,qudmcogitdtio.Seine -agsÂ»' . temporis quidem wsq plus erit, quid his f^tibiu 0Wff^J~^^ in AudiÃ«do profeÃ«lus eÃ¼Xum dd Ãylumjeceiet,ctm ge

nerdbit ipfe Aliquid Atq^ componet,tu/ni inchodre htc ÃÃ¼^-- ^ quot;quot;/â¢ âV-did uel)son udc^,uel non libebit.Ergoctvm grdmmdti^ ^J^â^'~fl^^^ ^ eustotmiiemoccupdrenonpoÃit,neÃdebe^^t,nedifcÃªâ^ Â»^-h tis '^^'emimtjedioMertdq^,^qi^b^^ott^ l)Â£c tem porumudut fucei/iM dondbimus^^dnntecegoconfumi ^rr-r^-^ Ãudentem in his drtibM U^lo^^cctnqdÃl^T^utmuÃ'Â» cis ndtis cdmied excipidt,nec dd uti^ minutiÃimd GeaÂ» metrixoperAdefcct^dLnoncqmoedumm^^rontvncidn^^. ^^ ^^^ do,nec fdltdtorcmi^g^fdciotquieÃomnidexigcrem,-ââ^ 'â¢^â-*-Æ

^^J^^'^ i^dmen tempus ilongdeibenmquiiediÃit^âÃ'^^'^Ã i.Ã¯-i,^lt;ctds,cy ego non de tdrdis 'mgenqs loquor. Denique cuv^^j^Ã§''-*^-^^'/

^^ ^â^^i^^^^ (Italie difcendA ordtorifut^ro puto, epunuit ^-1 '^'^^^'Ãªr 1 fUto ? qui non contemns diÃeipl^is'^dx pr^Ãdreâpot^^^^ZÃ^!^

Ãi,..j^^ffgt; Â«4 M. FAB. dVlNT. JNSTl^^^-^ ^/fY^ ^ htf^ ''^ terant AthcnÂ£,non Pytha^re^i^^ ad lt;^0! w UiUUm^ â¢Z â^â^^'j^^itMigduera,, Aegy^ti ^Ã¼o^ l^icerdotes ddijt, dtque eo^h i^inj^^^i,,,^ lt;nbsp;Yi^^ nrcdnd pcrdidicit. GifficuUdtis pdtroemid prides''

Ã ^na xtmuf jcgiHUe ^J'^cque enim nobis opera imor eil, nee 'X â^wf'^,^ âlâ*^â^Ã^ ^of^^Ãd^ dtq^remmpulcherrmd eloquentidjpe^ â¢quot;âV'^. ''ââ¢ '^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;titur ipÃjed dd uilem ti^ ,^ Ãrdidtm lucrum dccl/it^^.

_^ quot;^'ZZfâââiâk- gimur^iedfit fine ha in fora multi, et^y dccjuirdiÃ¯tydtMJr^ â'^ fitlocupledor dlj^uafgrdidfm^rcanegocidtor^etpliHâ'^ '^fffj' Zrfffquot;^ weifuÂ£ debedrprÂ£co,ne uelm c^uidÃ© leilorÃ« d^r^i t^ln jÃ^Â»^ rti^ fluidjludidreferdtcompuMurum^QuiucrÃ¶imd^ment iffdtnefoqUentiiedi^umdeiMddip mente coceper it, quiÃ©^ ^a^rcr^unj^* ^^dm^utditSo'phoeles-noignobilistrdgicut)rcgindm re rum ordtÃnem ponet dMe oculosfiudum^ non ex Ui* pe'dduocdtionum,fedexdnimofuo, ercontempidtione, .^^ â gt;^Â»ilt;' cr^ dcfciÃ«tidpetet,perpetuumillu.m, necfortunÃ¦fulieÃ«lu, â ^JZ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fdcile perfuddeiitfibiut tÃ«pord,lt;iuÂ£l^e{idculis,cdmp0f

â ^ â'ââ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;uiuiorum mord conteriint,GcometrÂ£ potiia, dc Mufeo tmpenddtyCjMntoÃâu^ deleddUonis bdbiturut,lt;iudmex iÃ¼a InÃªrudrtKÃoruptdtibui^ Dc dit enim hoeprouiden* tid hominibui mtmiu,ut honeÃd rndgis iuudrent. Sed noi

-f ,'quot;.^H^: ~r .ie, i}Â£c: ipÃ dulcedo longiiu duxit.HdÃ¼enus ergo deÃudi* is^qtiibMditteqMmmdiordcdpidtpuerinÃituendiae^, proximiu liber uelut noutim fumet exordium, Oquot; dd rhe toris offcidtrdnfibitt

f^ (^ ^ ^^ ^/:^^^^ Ãry\^f*lt; ifta-^'l^ â ^Of^^ ^rrrtrj ^W^pi,^'^,^^ ^^M^F ABir^:^sS OyiNTlLIANI DE INSTIT VTIÂ« ÆÂ«-Â«^4-Â»/^Â«

E N VIT confuetudo, (^Uje ^noti^,^^^^ die mAgis 'mudkfeit^ut price jptorb bus eloquentie, Ldtiaii quidem[ent per,fed etidm Gne^i^ir^rim diÃi'y puli Ãrius,qudni rdtio poÃuldt trd^ _______________â dereMur. E.iM rei duplex cAufd ed, quod O' rbetores utique noÃtijudi pMcs'Ã¶gt;nljeruÂ»t,et grdmmdtici dliftw occup^eru^t^^dme^idecddMAre tnodo, et ÃeieMidm declAtnAndi,dcfdcÃ¹ltdtÃ« trdiere,ofÃ eq fui ittewnttid^ intrddÃihcrdliudÃ'iudiciAcÃj^idte ^i^iÃ^iiiiexA uij^p^Ãwne'^ Ã^ âie^auM.^ ^hi nonjdtis cre^Mttexcepiffi'qui reUÃ¤4 crdM,quo not- ^'âââ quot;-' ^-âgt; tntne grdtid quoq^ bis hdbendd eÃjed dd proÃopopeddi â^T^ 'i^^tZ-' uÃ^,et ddÃudÃoriAt,in quibtuouMdicendiuclmAxmiiMai .^.y^^^-^Ã y^ eSifirrumpuKt. Hmcergo dccidit,utquÂ£ dUcriM Artis'â¢^âr^'y'^'â^-'

primi er AM oj^erA/idA ÃM^enM i:ouiÃmA,z^ A:tM^/â'^,i.'Ãquot;,. ^ .â^*Â£?'^â^ jÃ¿!^ diÃd^linis de}gt;itA, w/ebofit mhiore ÃtbÃ^'''^^-ry'*-^-*râ-dAt,Acr^etoricenApud grAmmAticos exercedtAiA duod^'^^'^'f^^^^^ fAmAxmeridiculu,non Ante Ad declAwÃn'^i mAgijirww^quot;^

Æ Co ^ykv tnittendtituideturpueri^drcldmiirefcÃ¼t.^osfuuincui ^ ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, ^ueprofeÃioniinodimidemut,ZTgrAmdtice((iUAinU''

^y.cZ:^'^^^â'^^â'ââ¢ trAnsferentes UterAtur^muocAjiei^t) finafttos t-^y-' noritfprj^Ãrtim tM^ Ab hAc AppeÃlt;^onK fuÂ£ pAuptrt- . â^^^^^^^^â '^^â^'â^^â^^UA'pr^iiÃ¼icoÃitere,prou^A. NAi^nUk â¢ 4^-ry^M Ã Ã¹fonteA/JumptispoetAruhi^oricorwin^ii^'Ã»Ã®^pÃ¯enÃ´ y^ ^rAgt;Â»lt;iMgt;r- i^mÃii;aiuf.oÃKiiciimprÂ£terrAtioncmreilelo(puedi 'ââlt;^^^r^^ ^^'^ ffoftp^ruAliocpiicopiofAmtpropÃ¨omni'jmmAximArÃAr tiu fcientiA AmpkxA fitiOâ rhctoricc^cui nomen uk clogt; f^Aeadi dedi^oÃetA fuA non detrellet,ncc occupAri gM dedt p^tmemÃª Ad fe lAborÃ«, (jut dum opere cc dit Ja po ^y^nAt nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ff^ pofjeÃione dcpul^A eÃ¼.lifec inÃciAbor,Aliquem ex bk

, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;qui grAmmAticen proÃteAntur,eoufqi Ãdentiie progredi

, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;pojje,ut Ad hÂ£c quoq^ trAdÃ«dAJiMciAt.Sedcuin id Aget,

fiJ^^iÃ¯'lt;^^v^Â°'^^ officio fiMtgetur^nonjuo.TSiospo^n qu^rmut, ^ -^i^j^i^ quAdo hk,quÂ£ rhetorice pÃ¯Â£cipÃ¯t,percipiÃ«dk, puer niA i^;^/^'/i^ turnt effe uideAtur, Ã¯n quo quidemno id eR ^ÃmAndu, 'JÃ©:^!^i^^$li^^^ ^t^^/fi q'-iAnerdnffudffnAm efficerit. w nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'Et nc d^^ differ A,quAdo Ãt rhetori trAdeduific lt;^i

gt; ^^^^^^^^Â»^^^^^â^{â'''-{^^^â^^^^â^ podritSed hoe ipfu^ Ã©xfupÃªriore ' â¢â^'^*7â!^^^^^3?{?/^âNlt;Â«Â»^grlt;wMttw mumuiufqi Ad ÃuÃoA ^ ^7C2^^,riM,quÂ£funtApudrhetorÃ«mAteriÂ£'intcrrud'imeiitAdi

i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;rhetoi^eoput di. At fi rhetor ^y

, .y^^j.t^.o.-^^*^'mAoffictAoperkfuinoreeuÃt^ n^rrAtiMbiesfiAtim,^â ) T^'^â^'eXtt^^ iâ^udxndi uituperundiqi opÃ»jcuÃ®is cu^iCei^^effderA

^quot;^(^^ ^^^''^â^ â?â'iff''JffJ^^^AntiquishocJ^fffiejid_MâgÃ«dAeloqiiÃ© ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cxercadionkMrtheies dicerÃ«t,Ã³' comumes lp .

dixi,^uod non tu dlid (jUÂ£ funt'^c^rÃ ^roprM^tuc^tÃ^^^^^^^^^^J^ 'm illud iudicidk edufg genm inciddi^Ann^mforo ndr nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;âA *^^

rdnduenfqud m Ã^'^^? gt;^^fi},^Ãgt;^ JV uapwrimujno iMii.,^..,^,-,^,.,,^^,: deuituferdtio ccrumnibusillk r^f^t^tUetjttfmtur?;^^^^2Z^' NoÂ» cÃ¶mimes iociffiue qui funt in uitid direÃ¼Ãqudks le gimui d Cicerone compofitos, feu cjtibm qutefiioncs ge^ nerdÃ¯itertrdddjipr^qudles funteditidQuintoquoc^i Hortenfio, ut,fit'ne pdrub drgumentis cre^d^, ^ pro tejlibiM, er in tefles 'm medifs litium^meduUkucr'iâ fMurfArmdfmtthge quodimodo prgpdrddd,Ãemper, ^â^ ut bis cummpolcdtutdrii.Quj: qui pertinere dd ord'' tionÃ« non putdbit, id ne Ãdtudm quidem mebodri credet nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'^

cum eim membrdfundentur^Ã¼ech hdne (ut dliqui putd* ââ ^^^â ^ bimt^ejtatdttonetn medm ftc quisq cdlumtnetur, tnnqud cu/m qui Ãt rbetori trddendui, dbducenduw p^2^^ d iXdmmdtick putem. Ddbtmtur iÃ¼is tam quoq^ tÃ©mpÃ³rd fud^neq; erit ucredum, ne b'mk prgceptoribui oneretur pucr.Ã¯ionen'mcrÃ¨^et,lcd diuidetur, qui fub'iwomifce IdturIdbort^ erit Ãuiquifquit opcr^ nugiÃer utiliov, quod ddbamp; opinent Gr gei,d Ldfmis omijÃum eiltet f^^*^'7 '*^^ Tiuideturexcufdte,quidfu/nt,qui Idbori iÃi fuccejjerint^^^ -ff^ Zgt;2Zc7^, ^moribwo-offi^rgceptorum. CAP. ll.

L ^Zoeumddediin fludijsuiresperueneritpuer~â^p'â^^gt;-^^âif ^^^â^^^^^AÃ¢i^^^ ^^^^^^gt;A^f^^^âquot;^^t^ mew eouÃqui poÃit^trddedw nui drtis mdgiÃris erit^ ^ 7^ ^*\lt;

^:^^ 88 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTrT,C J (Trrv.râ^kÂ« âf^ /t.^rQuorum MJ primU mj^icimores oportebit,^(fpde^lt;^o ^^r^^^â¢'^.\^^â '^^â^â^â^â'â^ potiÃ^fnuinhÃ¤c partetrdd^fumdggre^j i^uid non in ceteris quoique doÂ£loribus,idem hoc exarni^ nMdumgudmjilige^iÃime putem,Ãcut tfÃdtMÃum Uf bro fuperiore,Ced quod mugis eiÃ¼i reiâneceÃdridmmigt;^, tionem fdciÃaids ipfd difcentium. Num ei ddi^uÃ¯tijer^ pÂ« e ri dd hosprxceptores trdnsferur.tur^Oâ dpud eos iuue ncs^ttdmjddiperfeuerdntjdeoqimdioxddhibÃ«ddtu'tit fannos ^rued,ui*etteneriores animos abmiurialan^tas do ^xzJtLV^^ â ce nt is euÃodiat, er ferocioresÃ licentia ^luitas detet bigt;gt;r,A .^rh' r''-}-fjt^t^^uerojat ed fumr^^praÃa^' aÃ^inentiam, K^y.i ui -^â^'*^ljl ^fÃ'i^nte feueritate c'onuenientiumquoq- dd [e mo rcs aÃrinxerit. Sumat igitur dnte omnia parentis ergi difcipulos (uos dnimtwn,ac fuccedere fe in eorundem Ã¯o* ^ ^ ) A^- emnÃaquibiuÃ^iberiiradaittur,exiÃimejApf^chj ,^^^ -^Â»Â»i Pcat Mud^eeJirat. fJot^^mtas eiusir^ts,nonquot;diÃo â*7 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;luid fit comitas,ne mie qdiu^jiwcoÃ¯ttÃ¨piu^oriatur.pilt

^^^i^^i rÃn^jddqhoncÃ^^acbohofermofit.'lAamquofepiut r. ^Ã''^ monuerit^ocrdrÃ¼is caÃigabit. Ulinimc iracundu^^ tarnen eoru que emendanaa^rumt difmulatorJftmpÃ¯eX m docendojpatiens laboris, afiduus potius quam(mmo dicusAnterrogantibus libenter rcÃondeat,non mterÃ¯O gantes pe^ntefur ultra. In laudandis difcipulorum di^ dionibus necmÃignus,nfTtffuJus:^lt;^fdres altera txdigt; urn labor is,after d fÃ¨Ã§uriiateTnpdrit. 1^ ctnetplando qux corrigÃ«da erut no acerbus,m'mim^; contumetiofus. N* id quidem multos d propoÃto Ãudendi fugdt,quqdquÃ dam fie obiurgant,qudÃ oderint. ipfe aliquidÃmo nti^td

^:t^'*'^^^^^i^^^^âi^ I^^^^ duAita rcferdnt.Li^t enim fd j^-jis exemplorum dd imitMdum ex leÃ©lionc ÃippÃ¤Ã¼ct, td |â âIÃ^i^yd'^ ^â¢4.^weÂ« uiiu md^ ut dicitur, uox aUt plenim, prÂ£cipuÃ©lt;juc u Æ amori fi^Zeim prÂ£ccptoris, {[uem difcipuli ( ft modo re{lefunt tm- ââÂ°. ^âPÃ¯*Â«*Â» iZ^ftituti ) er dmdnt, or uerentur. Vix diitcm dici potent, k d/orato* â7^y5â^'^Â° ^fitiut imitemur eos quibui fdueniM. Uimime ^^ 'il- ^Â«le uero permittendd pueris ( ut fit dpud pleroft^ue ) Ã¤ffurt- oÃ¯s appara * S^^^b Sfi^iinAiÃ©b in Iduddudo licentid. Qumetidm tÂ«Ttâ.ornatusÃ©i; uenum modicum eÃe, cum Matent, tcfiimonium dÃ©bet. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^j^Ã¦ j

Ufierouitioftfimd, au^cfdmidm pumMitdf Ã¹oedtur, ci.Eft^ a-inutc^M^tfiÃ¯niq: lÃ»uddndi'cum eSl Mecord.n- tbo Pâ^ Ciceros dtrdUfjZ^ feuere imliitutKmfchoiifduend,tum fiudio^ ad Atticym. rum penucioft^irnd hofifi ^juperMcM. enim uidetur'^'^quot;'quot;â'^'^^ curd,dcÃ¯dbor,pdrdtd~quic(Ã¿iid effuderintlande.vultum ^^â igitur prieceptorie intucri,tdm epti dudiut debent,quant ^ ^ ^\.x^ ipfequidicit.Itdenim,probandadtqiimprobddddifier , Ce^/r.^^.lt;,a.,, nentfic fiylo focultafconimgett duditiojiiiudicÃ¹im. At ni!mcproniatq;'fuccinÂ£ii,ddomnenf^dufuldninoncxur7â'*^J'^/''â/â''^ gunt modÃ¨,uerumetidm e^urrimt^z^ cam indecor a ex, ^,^^^ y^t.^ dff^f^tUioneconcldmdnt.ldmutuumeRje^ibideclamatioa..'. ^equot; ^^ nisfortund: Hinc tumor, (y uana de fi perfuafio, ufqueâ^ ,~r^^

ddeÃ ,ut iUo condifiipulorum tumul^jnfidti, fi parum d praceptore IdudciÃ¼uf, ipfideftto male fint fint t^Sed fi quoq^ priceptores intente,ac mod^e dudirfueÃ¯mt. Ã¼o^â^fquot;'*^' enim iudicio^ifiipulorum dicere debet mdginprf fed di feipuU mdgifiri. Q^m/t fieri pote^l,tntei^ndM dnimui

^ in hoc quoq;,utpcrj^iciiit qux (^uifiji, amp;'quom^oldttgt; â t^^ a^^'Zi^ Ã¢fiintpilicerequgbenedicettnonfuomdgisqeorumno 'i^v iftiw fffine deleHetur, qui rede iudicabunt.Pueros ddolefan tibui federe permixtos^on pÃ¯deet mihf i^dm etidmfi uit tdliS:,qiulern ejfe oportet Ãudqs^moribM^ pr^poÃtum, modern hdbere^oteil etidmiudientutem, tdmen uel 'm Ãrmitdf Ã robuÃioribm fepdrdndd eÃ,et edrendum non fÂ°^^ er'mt'ene turpitudmKy uerumetidm fuf^icione.

tlÂ£cnotdnddbreuiterexiÃimdui:ndmutdbfitdbul t'miis uitijs ipfe prlt;eceptor,dc fcbÃ³ld,ne pr^cipiendu qui liÃ¯^A^j./ y,Â»-y,y.dein credo. At Ãquis eÃ,qui Ãdgitid mdnif^d 'm deligen doÃfij pr^ceptore non cuitet, idm JimcÃidtcÂ£terd quo ^j^rn .p^Ã ^ue^ ^'â^?M^^5Ã!?^^^coponerecondmur,ejle ./Ã7^ fbi hdc pdrte omijfd,fuperudcM :

* â iUorum quidem perjMÃo ÃlenttojrdnÃetMid - nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^' eiui etidm cum idoneos rhetori biuwsbutd^

i^Ã¯j^-^v ys.yyVerunt^ non tume c^muotrudendos emmentifimo ereâ i^'iÂ« â Â» Ã Aâft ''duwt Sed dpud n^ores mÃ¯iqudndiu det'ment,tdnqudm 'uÃ/z fUtuendis drtibus mdgis fit d^'m^d^ixfitM prÂ£cepto* i'f^ y^âh^ ^^itfCumTtimteÃ¼ei^dtqÃ¯mtidtiowtn f^ciU^r/um di 'gt;,iey.gt;i-tlt;.iM' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fuÃeipiendds elemÃ¨nforum molcÃids mmus ^âperid.Ciud

f,dyf.t -^ Hl- Â«if?Â»Â»w mihi nonurbitror diu ldbordndÃ¼,ut oÃenddm qum /^Mf^yrrquot; fg Ãf mcUus ootimis mbuLqudntd 'm elucndis ciuÂ£ femel ^^'f^ydi^ cofequdtur,ciimgemmdtu/m ^ ^'^^ÃÃÃ^â^ ^â^âf^ fuccelentÃ©s prcmdfEttÃ¿Ã¹deM dedocendi grduiitf, t, gt;Jff^ , yrÃÃ dc primM docendi.Vropter quad TUmoiheum cidrum Â«L mryyy.yyy^ ^,^,yâ.f 7^jfygJi, â .ât., .rti rrÂ»' , yy^ fi.yyâyf.â, ^^C.^^yd^rf y^^

^^^^^^^^.^!:^^amp;^n!i!i^^^^,^â iâ*'^'^ Ã ^^^^^ trddereit'f^;^'^â^^'â'^'^ ^'*'''^Ã¨!?J^^'^â' ^^^ duplexiUMM^uod interim fuffi*r ^^,.. ^^

^ tenti fivnt^^^uÂ£q^qudm Ã©ripfdreprehet^we digndâ'^â^^'^^^^^ '^^{^^^'^^^^^ ^dmÃ« ejjet utcumt^ tolerAU^i^tem^nodi prlt;e^^iyffZâZ^_g^ ' ceptores minm docerent^on peins. AUer^iUc etium freii^nu^^^^ ^^-^7^ quentior, lt;[uod cos (pii impliorcm di^di^cuÃ¯tlt;Ã¼eml^^,\fj^ (Ã¼*^. ^fonfecuti^m putiint dd m'niordl^cÃ¨derc.ld^ ^^^^'^^â â^^'^^-â ^ri, epiidfajlididntprtendrehdnem^ioribuscurdm, ^^^ ^^l^' i^tcrme^na omnino non poÃint.'Ego'porro'eu.mqui no'ÃÃ^Ã!^^ÃÃ^_^ lit ni nÃ¼mÃ©ro prxeipientium non hdbeo, polTc Mtem ftt'^ *'gt;ârf~gt;^^quot;âgt;^'^ neht .^ optimum tpKneptecontendo .Prmum tptodeu/nÂ»;s-,fh- ^vf^.^. fpii elotpientidcxteris prÂ£^et, iUd cpioepie, per qÂ«Â« ddJ^/'^^SrXX^'' elot^wntidm peruejutiw, diUgentiÃime percepi^c aÃ§eir^; quot;i^'^*â^

Ã¿i4 plurimiwn m pnei^edo u^et rif^ZZ^-^'' tio,ipiie dodiÃmo cuipte pldniÃimd eSi.PoÃrctno,lt;piid^''^-^'^tr'Ã

^^^^.^^*JfÃ¦^^Â°^â^ âââ:^- Vide quÃ§ tra W forte lauem pitdem PhididX optime fecit^iUd dutem duxerjt ex, quim orndmentum eins opetis dccedunt, alius melim ^uemfa fldbordffet: dut ordtor lopÃ¼ neÃdet, dut leuiares morf^ eoloachu tojcurdrenonpoterit pritÃdntiÃimusmediem. Quid^}l^jâº-,-â ergo i non eH pt^eddm elopuntid mdior, pt^rn ut edntÃ ^^'^ÃÃÃ^ ^ inteUeUu confepti puerild inÃrmitM poÃit Æ Ego nero^- ^ tu^ â¢â '' r* f confiteor ,fed hume difiertumjÃÂ£ceptorem,prudeiitem

^ lt;nbsp;^âo^iCrjwnf^t^d^docendieff'e^oportebit,fiiSmittengt; 4^tÃ«fcAd menfuTA difcentis,ut uelociÃimusqui(p,ÃtÃorte

^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«Â« procediit Ã¼ltriitqudm comes poÃit.Qjudffi'^riM*

^ ^p ^^-^ ^ucdccidit^MfticilioriifmtAdintcÃ¯ligendivmsO'luciiio Ã§Z^r^camp;M.vâgt; ramuUÃ¶tlt;jtiÂ£d(doiliÃmiotiuolt;jidicumttir:'iiiunf:irpTi , ^ \,^;^â-fK^gt;^ fHd,eRelo^tKntiÂ£uÃ¯rÃ¯uipÃªrj^Kui^,G!quot;qiioquifqÃm^.^ gt;nbsp;^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;genig minus miet, hoc P^gi^ dUo^^c^e^z^Mdtare cÂ»âi^

ndtur: ut Ãdturdbreucs 'm, digito^ri^umfur, er phi^^j^gt; trcmuloj 't^rmifnmMitr.'!^dmtumidos,erJc^rru^tos, er'^t^ CicozeUx.'i'nuÃ®Ã´steÃ¿âijUocivncj; dUoedÃ¢o^etÃ®^gÃ©nÃ©rÃ© pf^c^fÃ®, cer uÃ¦ imkatFo ^Wâ* ^â^^^^ ^^ *!}^/^gt;f^^ mfirmitdtisnitio Idhordrefft^i â*'o^ ^t ^â^ ^^^PP^^ 'IPgt;^ roborc'fed udletudmein ^kMut quot;'b^^o horrort Sa' â^â'^â^quot;'^ ^pfi gt;nbsp;pknun^ diuertiM^rit*?rgo ctidm obfcH Ã®uftianÃ¦, in rior guo guifji deterior. Non cxcidit mihi ÃripÃffe me munter afpe ^^^^Â° priore,cum potiorem injcholis eruditionem elle rnatÃ« Catul domi dicercm,Ubentius fe prirnd Ãudid,tenerosq: profe'^ Froptii'inz quot;â*'=ââ Miitdt^nem^conÃ¿ci^ulorum guÂ£fdciUor eÃet, compofitos erigere: ^o^d,quot;qÃ¹ibiÃ¯fddm]icdccipipoteil,tdngiiim tmlLr^Hoc nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^ fementid priori diuerfd fit.ld i

em ex uiriÃ¼ me procuidberitmdq; eu CAU^u ud mdximd eÃ¼, cur opd wÂ«Swfo ^lt;^â'*^f prlt;eceptori fit trddenius puer,quad dpud eudi Ãe t, ficut nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;feibuUquoq; melius 'mÃituti,dut dicÃ©t quod inutile noÃi

iefaeÃ®Utas** ^'^ddriyÃ¤utÃquid errduer'mt,Ãdtimcori'igentur.Atin r,uoc6, ut g/ dodus nie etiain probubit fortune uitiofd.er pldccre dn Ã¯Â»Sklt; ^^^'^^^â(^ tuamp;fuo co8et.^lt;^ojiJlo^ntid,quiiÂ» Witas placet, Â»toribus prÂ£ÃdiuiÃ'tmus,qutquot;dd Pheehicis HomerideX^ eftÃ®nL^i ^'^^^'â ^ dicere,dc fdeere docedt.

miQrandam X X '^^^ ^â^^ primds m docedo pdrtes rhetornin (Xjftlt;^f mr'' * ^.I, r^-rn^ t^Cf^^ier .^â¢t^t^t,tt^'' -^ i^i^-r-^v,- Ci^^rtrlA tyiM'^ ^'^ââ ^â¢^ al';.Â»,^ brK ^^-^.â ^Â»v.lt-^H^'lÂ« ^rân ^,râfftfnlt;,nA ,n^âgt;^ V,rxf^ f*gt;^, ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;âild Â»ff-d-ru^ 'ir^f* .-,âgt; ^tyr, ,,nÃ' r4^fâ ,:rn^'â'^lt;'lt;Ã¿i'gt;^^ârâ^'i^\

^'r-f^^^ ^^rlt; ni.Â£-^^^^- ^ ^^^i/^^^ ili:l^megt;lt;.'gt; y^tfay^t '.^^m^M I /Â«(^Â»Â«Ã 1* ,^*gt; Xtr^^Hn^^ e-fV vr^**v^ ' ^^rr*^r^ ^i~ jft f^l/t^''^f^f^^ ^ ^quot;t^ g^^,'^ I ''.^n/r^:^

ORATOR^ LIB^,^r.,/,*,V^?Ã,^( \ fuUm, trdiere indÃ¼idm', ^dU parompcr iÃ¼d^ejUie P^^'J^^^^t uulgo uocdtur,drte rhetor iedt Ac mihi opportu^nm tnd'tâ fimiHimi. xme uiietur mgreffut do eo, cuiut dUc^uid fimilc dpui ^^â^jjquot; âÆÆ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;|

grdmmdticos puer didicerit.Â£t ^uid ndrrdtionum, rxermoUitudine P^â* ^tSiSi^f^ â|Fi*Z?F*'f^ lt;^^FJ^hniK ^ecics-^dhulAÃ¿\^^P^^^â^^^^ qux uerfaur'mttd^cedijs Ã^cdmimibus, non d ueritd^z uitio Oui te mod^ed etidm dformd ueritdtK remotdin: Argum? '^Ã¦ W*-tum,(^uo^f^^m^quot;^d uj^jfimilc'com(xdiÂ£jingu^ HiÂ« n^d^ontol PorM^m^ude^ 'gejl,e rei Ã«xpo/ttio^ GrdmmdticK dU'^ âÂ«lut gt;lle a-i,Ttjmpo^cds dedipui : dpud rhetorem mitium fit biÃe'!â pShÅnÃ®xq^ rÃ¯d,tdttto r^uirior,lt;iudnto ueriorSed ndrrddi quidem, fc Ã Peleo

cum de luaicidU pdrte dicetn^. Interim dimonere itlud mite ene daÂ» fit eÃ^ut fit ein?^ i.flddprorfM,nclt;^ ieiumd.^dm ^Â»Ã¯^nÃ¼'^uJ* na opw erdt tdntivm Ãudijs Idhoris impendereffirÃªsnuamp; effieeret ora d^H' ''*^Â°f'^^^â*^ biddifi'i^ Ãtit uidereturf Nr^ rurf^fi'-- a^oKm ^'* â^nuofdfz^ dccerfitis defcriptionibui, in quAfplm^Ã¯mi^ que rerum. tdtione poÃ«ticiS licentie ducumturÃdficiuidt.yitiÃ¼ utrim ^^Æ P^jfj^ lt;igt;*f,peiui timen iÃ¼ud ^uod ex itiqpid,^udm ^upd ex cof^ NarrationÂ«* pid uenit.Ud inpueris ordtio perfe(id necex'ioLnec^Ãje nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;lt;!gt;Â«Â«Â«Æ

Â«rt potest, mehor^utem est mdoles Idtdgenerojtq; co forma.) Vr fidtuf^ct uel^iÃ¹f^i^o epneipiens interim jfiritus.tgt;tec tabula Atret Æ unqudm mÃ© tri b'is difieÃ«tisSmif offÃ¨nidtji cjnfdfiipcr^ M^âcÂ«^,AÂ»*â fuerit,lt;ium ipfis dodoribus hoc eÃe cur^e uelim, ut tene dreftidis Â« nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'^

n ueluti iptoddm iucimdiops difciplmÂ£ cibo IddeÃ©y pdÂ« onÂ« AiTdÂ» tidntur.^rit iÃ¼ud genius iniÃ©rm corpus^qnod moxdd^ ^Â°Â£jâ^l*tSgt; ât.* Â«ÃW dtds dÃringdtibme^es rohoris, Ã¯iacUm mn^ ^Ã«^r fâ'' ^^

94 FAB. QVINT, INSTIT* _^'^^ ^*-^'â^ infirmitdtemj^ ^^erum mintin fokt, protinu! ^^^^fM^^o ^.obmmcmbris cx^r^^fiinftinsfÃuiniliÃ cÃ¢Ã¼s'pMrd, ... -r^^rt nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^^fâffidty(^ inuentKgdudent, fint licet iUd non fitii

ftcrilid nullo Ã¯dbore umcuntur. lUd mihi inpueris nutÃh^ Judiao prÃ¦z Ydtrdn^^nff^tdederU, tn nbsp;nbsp;mgemu/m mdiciopr^^ ub/in^enis f'^^i^â*^ ' ^dtmdmeffe pnmÃ¹^f^u^^ dbunddMio^ i'ud jcio con' rcm,dtque ultra oudmoportedt ft(!tun.Multum inde ie^

nid etiain nbsp;nbsp;detcretur.Sit modo unde excilipofit, zt^ quad excedp, uis^Iudici5 ^^â'^^^)Ãi^ofiâibinttio^em^ni^iimldnfindÂ»i^^.â-ftudjo para* xerimut,cr quam aldtÃ¼rd dltior'nmpdt. QjfÃ³dmc aei^ ^^^, hit iStdtibuf fentire minut mirabitur^quid^d Cicero^^ ^^â ^Ã¯^ âf'J^Ãª^^â^-^'Â°^Â° ^t''^â^ Ã e/firdt in ddolcfcenie/acwiditâiK-â Z\,.if,'ci^ l^^Ojidpro^terh priwsjuitdndus, ztj- inpueris prtieci'' y?^ S-d^^ Xâ^ pue,mdgifiÃ©r aridw, non minus quam tener is adhuc f Ã quot;â^4 w*?^^* *^Ãâ^^^^^ÃfiÃâf*âÂ°Z^^^Â°Ã^â^ â¢ ^'^â^^fi^'^ humdef^/ ^ ' Cicero d nbsp;nbsp;Pf*^^^ O'Uelut tÃ©rrMjfcUdntcs, quj^nfhil^rd quo^. /â^ oratorez^ tidietnam fermotumM^lfj^eM^c^^

1 /â'^gt;Â». râ^ifÃ¿p fdnitdte, ^ iudiciilocoinfrmitds eÃ^ : ^â^dum fitis pu^ ' e quot;^ -^^ ^^^ ^â'âÂ° â^^l^i!â^ tdipfumjnMunfuitiu^,quod uirtu â Zt^i' *â¦*.'â¢' tibusedreni. (^drcmihfw^dtjuritds^quidemipj^elli ' '^^ rfi-^''^/h'^â^^^^^*^iilt;^â^lt;^t^^â*fi^lt;^j^^P^O'd^sfi ^^/a,âi, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ycn(,cr uetuftdte proficient, t^eid quidem quod ddmo^

.. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nedmusindignum^R^ngenidpuerorwmnimid interim

w quot;^./fei^n â^'P/^'^ ÃC^Â°/Ã®'i^^^ odcrunt i zy quad niAxlmc nocet, /^r,0ihgt;j- tOi, /dum Old timÃ¨ittjiihilcondtur, wodstidin ruflicK notdi^ .

fff, lt;luijronAlbMtÂ£gt;if^nfmj^utMt AdhibedAm fff'^Ãt^^^Zâ^^ ^ j c(m^(^ui(ireformiddreferr^ui^ntur,crnodHcicdtricÃª pdti paffe. luc^^ n^J^ maxime debet effe prlt;ece7â re^i^/^rif n^^ ptor^t reAicdi^^ aiix'ffio^^ffffurd ffnt a ff erd, modi mdnulenidturffduadrÃ¨^qMffcrrcM^dymutdrc etu, ^â -^.^^^p rcdiiitdcuridÃdtrdtioneyiUuniindrc^terponendodli gt;Ã¿*idjÃ®^.^oi}tw^ hoc lt;^uolt;^ erit utile,totdt ffffm diddff^ff^ quot;^]^^^ re mUeruf^quAi O' imiteturj^uer,et interim tdnffjudi^^v %(lt;^'gt; -gt;.^ dmet.At Ã tdm negligens efÃylut Ãierit, ut emÃªddtioneff^ff^^'ffquot;^^ ^ non recipidt,expcTtMffum^rodeffe^quoties ednde mdtet .tlt;'^^/:â^'^'^ ridm rurfut d meretrdffdtdjerike^ede^ntegro iuberÃ«: poffe enim^eum d^uc tnÃ«Ãiui,ffddte^ifinuÃo mdgis Ãu adtius ^âlt;^y^ff^g^t^ii:nt.Aliterdut^l^d 'lt;etdsel^nddnddeÃ,et_^^ ^^^ ^.^^ pro modo uiriumyCr ex^endu,^ corri^endÃ¼fipus, So Ifhd ego dtcmptKrKdl^uidMÃs UceniiuÃ¯dut Mm, tiuddre me ddhuctuf^ur^dejti^m^^iu^idem non per* nitteremjtd t^r ingenio gdudehdtÃ¤^o- iudicio nonfdUe

* 2?? ^ââÂ»Â»'â¢Sed ut eo reuertdr wnde egreffm Ãim,ndrrdtio* c^ quot;â^^y^^^ofnponi, (iu^tdmdiamd^j^t deffff^tdÃiU* â^...^-ââ ^^ â ^^'^^S^i^y^olo.tidmut primociimffrmoin^ituitur'.,Â£ccif'''^^ A^n^^ffij

^^^â lt;tt$ emÃ«ddtÂ£ ordtionis dccffieni'cxic^ Kv'^lt;''i^â^^'^Ã^tlt;gt;^^necexpe{ldtdcogitdtioâe^^^^^

, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;n- mi*^ - â ^ rnrrf-jy, tr a^ Mtf ^.,^j.,r/:th'â rfr

^z*. ^ ,^^e_,:f '^^P^fitorui^rndne^diumjp^s uero co^'Ã©mptuf opt .^^,yr-^^ tA^i-ris^ZT iWdCÃ¯ccun^'^nSiZ^con/^uctudo peÃimedicen^ quot;^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;-di,^mdlo;umexercitdtK^'auÂ£mddiwsquoqÃ¯iro''

f^/âtlijeciuf Ãc^^ucfitcrpcrdidtt, dr^dnsdefe^ej'pufio'm'' ^Ã¤â^âXZ; iFw ^^dfdturÃ.rÃ¹ juumpdfdndÃ¦fd^liÃ¯dtK temp'u^^itc d 7 t lt;gt;-Â»Â» gt;Ã§ âiâiÂ»^gt;.nobKnegligcntertocuiiÃctrdÃbitur. Interim fdtife^, ft puer ojnntcur^Jt^mo^^^jÃumittd xtAi cdpit)ld^ o dâ-if-h' -'Ã¤}^^^^^ dlicpiiijprpbdb^^crÃ¯pferit, in hoc i^uefcdt,huiui ^^^W..â^ ^^^^^â nSÃ¹rit^etÃ dtAÃ®le detmi/m wi^epiod quxrhuf, â p-lt;^i i^ 4-.t^-gt;'(^aMciproximâMn poter it eudderejCjuidntcdifcetreilc ^/ZZ^j Z^ â^diccre,(pudm cito.iidrrdtionibuf non inutiUter fubt^,, Â«Â«H'Ã¿'ââ* ^â^''^eitur^put deÃruendiconfirrnddiqi ca.quod Iva^x^H, ^^â f ^^vwtf^ re^Ã^/V i ^^ ^ fK^^^t i i^y- ^ri(iHP d*^^ A ' -^f fff*fÂ»^'^^ft^% * J0 VÂ»fV*'^' Pwfigt; p'Uff^ KceTjxr^S^H uocdtur.ld porro non tdntivm in/dbulo - âfââ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fis^ey cdp^^trddit^J^ri pote^, uerwmÃ§tidin mipÃf Ãe Valerio â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;(plierdtur, dnÃt crcSSfile/Â« Corui.Liuiâ peredput V dlcrij pugiuntis fediÃe cor^tp,lt;pii ^ ocu* CeÃ¼i.'i^f'n'* Â°^^ hoÃis GdUiroÃro dtque d'.is duerberdreti^Siiind'' cap. ii .Idem trdnq; pdrtem ingÃ¨s dd dicendum mdterid, ut de ferpen ang^ue mequot;'5 ^â^Ãâ^Z^â^Ãi^^^-^di:ur genitut,cr LupdRomul^et J^ moratii. 7. gend tqume '^Ãdmgreets hiporicis pieru^ipiep^Mt pa^Romuu'' ^^A^i?- '^^Ji^^^^â^ ' 5âÂ®?^ ^^^â^^ queri'Ãlh ^'temporet lib.i.Liuius. deloco,lt;pto geÃdresdieitur.nonnunqudmde perÃ^ Aequot;eria ^ ^^ ^â*Â°Ã'^â^^lÃ^â*^ ^iltiitf fi'^âiaâ^'Ã^Â£^^^j^â^^p^.il^ gt-erf^ ^~p! ^^Ã hiÃoricK diÃentiuntiÃquot;^ pduldtiip,d,'i mdiord ten rah^'^ a-wdv^ikdere mcipietÃdudd^e^fÃ¶suiros^ uituperdreimp^ âââ^Â«H^XTiZ^^j^^MâÂ®^^ ^Â°â^ fintpUcis utilitdtK pjp^^ e^^dn^ey i^â*

'â'^'^n^recdufdrumpotctiÃimd^ idm turn 'mÃruittir^cum rcsÂ»^ idn^ftif-ed pofcet ujurut.iÃ®me i^^uoque exemidtio fubit eompdÃâ2j^(*,f;J(,â^ rdtionis, utermelior, utÃ©rue deierior ; ciUÂ£ Ã¼Mnaiu.m-^quot;quot;quot;ââ' â' ^

Uerjdtur m rdtionc fimiU^tdmen Z7 dupUedt mdtendm;-^ tquot;^-rr^t^^f^^^ et uirtutwm uitiorumq;,non tdntum ndturM,f0^cTTdm'^^^ ^u'i^Â»^'' â modimtrdadt.'VerumdecirdiaeldudiSyContrd^jMot'^yy'^^h,^ ' *â' j fÂ°J.^-^:^Â°^'^^^^loci(,delois lo(juor,lt;Ãiibus eiird pext'^'^^'^''^ Â»â-â^^ fouds m ipjd uitid moris^e^ perordre, ut in dÃdterumÃÃÃ.''^Ã,2[i^.ÃÃ^i.l aledtorem^pecuktorc^ex meSiÃ Ãvnt indices: amp;quot;{^Ã'(u^!,J^,^fi'^â^ Â«ai]ciiK,Ã¢ccu]lt;tttoncs,qMnqudm ni ^oque ab lÃ¼o geriet' raU ff^^^jitu d^ ^M.fdam dedÃ¼ci^ccies folent,ut fi po*^ mtur adulter cÂ£C'M^aleator bdupcr^petulMs fenexMtl firff bentautem nonnu/nÃ¼uametidm defenlwnem.t^dmey pro iuxitrid,i^ pro amorc dicmui, v leno interim plt;t

rafitmÃ©^ defenditur yÃe ut pon hemini patrocu^ur, fed erimmi. Thefes dutem lt;^UÂ£ fumuntur ex rerun com'^ ^^^^^rygt;' gt;â pdrdtione^utruÃicd ne uitd, dn urldnd potior: iurif^c*âyi^â'^ nbsp;nbsp;'

rÃ¯ti,dnmii^rK-Mmldu^ maior^mire^untddexercitd''^^â'-^â-lt;-_ iionerndifendHI^dciofiX dtque uteres quÂ£ uel dd fudt'^^P^^^Â°,^^' y'' lendiofficium, ueletidmdd iudic't^jiilK^Mipnen^-^,f'Ã®^ ^^rZ iuudnt plurimum. l^dm poÃerior ex priediÃ is ÃMus^n quot;â' ^ cdufd Murgnie copiofiÃime d Cicerone trdHdtur, Simt 'â ', -; quot;â^^ '*? tzitUpenÃ¨totÂ£dd deliberdtiuum pertinentesgenpSf^' '' ' ^VAi!}f,l*^^=ff^^'^f ^â^ Ãuitn^igiÃrdtiKt IStan^ '^âââ^''^^y^lTf, ptores mei, net mutili, (^ nobis etidm iucundo genere rÃ¿ * ^' quot;â â¢*â¦' 3

gt;^j^i^lt;^lt;^J conic^dU^cdufts, De Venere *â ^â*^^^re dt^ exr^ui iiibcrcC, cur dmatS^l^. Aufenn exr demonios Vf^^^ (j^Ã¼ itd crederetui^Cti^c^o pucÃ¯, Â«t epigram 4c uolucer, et fdgittis defdee dmdttu.b' Cmilid. in ctiÃ¼ Pifturp aÃ¼t ^utliTdtdbdniini^jiMttdte^uiui m cotrouerÃjsp-ei^ues fasProperti iâ^^dÃª qudles junt de teÃHiM, [einder ne hls credenduWf Â«s lib. 2, nbsp;nbsp;f14f drgumentlSfdn hdie nd d did pdruls Ãdes, ddeonti nifeÃÃ¼ eÃ¢dd^rmfes dSfones pertmere, ut quidd nee ignoides in officijs ciuiUbnsfiriptos eos,memorid^; diU getiÃime mdddtos,in proptu hdbuermt,ut quoties effet eccdffo,extÃ¨pordlcs eoru diÃ¼iones hls uelut emblcj^dtit exo^^re^nijtr, Qyo quide^n^c e^ lll^^J^^ iudiciuM diffvrre fuÃineoÃummd Ã¼idcidntur mihi mffrmitdtÃ©de [e coÃteri. t^dm qffdhi poÃint in cauÃsiqudru lurid de noM femper^effi fpeiesj^ropriu mnenire^quomodo pro poÃtls ex pdrte dinerÃt reffodere^ dÃ®teredtionibus uelo citer occnrrereeteÃerogdrclqui did in his,.quÂ£ffiMj: cp miinid, er MÂ» plurimis edufis trdHdtKUr, wtlgdÃ¼Ãmos fenfui ucrbif,nifi tdto dnte pritpdrdtis, prosequi neque

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;catydUtfdpidiuinouedntyUclnttp-igidie^repojiticM,^!-.

dut pudorem, depreheiffd toties duaientium memoÃd^Ã' quot;infeUx ÃtppeUex, quÂ£ Ãeut dpud pduperes dmiitioÃoSi

j â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;pÃ¯uribuierdiuerfisofficijsconterdtWyCwmeoquidetn, â¢ continenÃ¯

- 'fi^rfZr^ *7tÂ»gt;^â ^^^^^â^J^ ^/^ Ã^âÃ dliquo propria quÂ£^iÃ¶wsuinculo

-^, .W^f^ o R/ T 0 R. J^l EER irÂ» 99 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^, lt;^pIratWM, ud auod diÃmila dl citerKiUeldupd blctâi^â^-' ^gi^^^/

^Jrgt;'}!Ã^d;^}^^;^â¢^df^_ folct,npn^^iddcjidem^^Ã¤,.^ tur,fed t^uid pd^dituc^^ut yuddm^upntUr^ grdtid'^^'^ VirbofjÃmoslocosdrcej^txwm e^odHebedtndfeif^ jententidtitd Ãvnt dutemjpecio^d hÂ£c or utiUd,^ oriwn ~ y^'^*i~^ lt;. twr fx c4Â«p, CjeteruÃMmUbet 'pulchrd l^utio, tuft dd-^'^quot; âquot; 'â ^^â ^â¢^^ uidoridm tenditjuitf^; fupc-^cM,fcd interim etidm co^t--^ mn-m/c trdrid cSl. Verum hddenufeudgdrifdtis fijerit.LegWiif-^'^ '^^^â'^ ^^.âS-ÃF ^'^â^P^^^dtio idm mdiorei^ depra^Ã¨f^mK o^e ^^^^J^^I^^'iTd^}*^'^^'^^ de^Ãderdt, ^Â«.f (^uilemfiiijorÃ¼s, dn eÃ¶tronerÃjs mdgis dccomoddidlitex(Ycttdtio^co^ue tudine ei 'amp;reci'uÃ¼dtu divert.Apa^ Orficos cnim IdtÃ¶r f^/Pj^â ^Â°^' fitriJddiudicÃ¨uocdbdtury^oindni^proÃ¯concipn^J^e mofthenis

nu,ZT Tere cert^ dictmtur.'Hdm cr geÃ«erd funt trid/d amp;nbsp;hÂ«tÂ« np.t fntjpi^lÃ¯at^MtiÃ¯urifÂ» QjieiiuiÃo'dÃ¤ldUdenttKdgis ââf*'^ââ^â Ãpe{liit,fi eptis ed per grddui dugedt^ifuod iÃ¨x,lt;^ticd pu

_^ djwbuf^uxriÃokt^comumd omnibui. Aut enim de iure Cafare flt;rP dubtidrlfotcn eiut ^^ogdt^^ut de PÂ» Clodio qui no ri ^^Q^^f te ereilte Tribunus drguebdtury dut de ipÃut regdtio^ Publium n^dcTl udrJu^gt;Ãuj^Wjn^^^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;gÂ«Xin

WZâ^L^pll^^J^Â°Ã,if?â aÃTi'^tirc^io^^fenitu que* uel duÃpidd^ dlidd ue quid quod legitime objietÃdicitur c^Ã^Ke ldtde(fe,uelfcrri,ÃucdikuimdncntiÃlegurepugnd^^ afit locusexâ

ftioe in Clo* f.eÃq^ codent feri Ufro ÃHoqucceridmine huiuÃnodi JJf^Â® â^Â®'

lt;i0rafrvbH âK^tinv nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^f-h ^â *i^ Hr ^mvi^rrP j^rtw â^rftgt;^t^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,\y f^^f^ddi

Siue non tri trÃ¤Ã¼Aniur^ ^dm uuium,dut muerigt;K,dut m rcit^t^t nÂ» ^acr^i ^^'^^^ ^â^^'^^^^ ^^ fâ^^^^ fignificent,dn fit in bis ah^d /(^r.^âe â5 ait/olitas dm^i^^amil^jclt^diilcxft^^^^ cottfintidt,dn iÂ« fo lâ^'^ii' bus in urki P^^'dâgt;^ referri debedt^dn m fingMos hommes. Mrfx^s â quot;âquot;Ã¶t^enire tner ucro commime ell quisrere^M fit bonefddn utilis-5Â« Ã'^VicIta^^cgcm iÃ¿^Â°^o plurcsfierid ^^lerifquc partes, fed nos iuflun'., 4 ÃTi^*^Â®quot;^â^*â ââ' f^gt; reUgiofum, cÂ£terd^ hisfimiUd, honefio complet proXlga- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;l^*fti^ââf!^â^^fi^^i'ti ^Â°^ fimpUciter excuti folet,

bÃ¤tur.quas Aut enim tcjreiffd^ufritur,ut digndnejigt;oen.i,uelpÃ¯amp; dinun/s tri Ãtquot; â^^^ ^^ '^Â°^Â° premij pansue,i^ui td m'dior 5 mi num nundi' norculpdripot,efhvtifitds quo^ mterÃ¨m ndturddifcet aÂ«Tpiffe^q*P ^â^^'^â^^^^^â^ tempore. QuxddmdnoÃ¼meripoÃint, dam prolo' dmbigi filet. iJeUludcjuidemignordreoportet,leges busmioeis nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;totds,aUqudndo^xpdrtereprebÃ«difolere,cÃ¼

promuigati exemplum rcj utrtufiue nolis claris ordtionibuspri^ krent ^' ^Â° ^âââ*^ââ' â¢ ^^â^ mefdUit, eds quop^uc legef effe, quÂ£ non in quibus Fabi perÃettmmro^en{ur,fetliehonoriiiu,Ã¤utimperijs, usfaccreui- qmH;AÃ¯dnilidfuit,deqMclcerÃ³nisoratioefidSedde his nihil hoc loco pr^cipi potcR. ConfiÃ¢t enimfroprii rerum, de quibus dgitur,non commiwi qÃ¼dlitdie. His fe

y ,Â».Â«,A3 ^ rÃ¨ueteresfdcultdtemdicendiexercuerimt,dffumptdtii ZÃ^ts?^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;men d didleHicis dr^umj^dndi rdtione. t^nmfiUdS di ed.,Ã¹^a .e/h imitdtioncmforfconjiliorumq;^ mdtcrids,dpud Grlt;ecos â'iiiiH^ifei^iv'ff.t dicere,cired DemetriilmfhdfirjdinÃitutumfcrccons ]-x' ''^fe nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;? nbsp;nbsp;^4tgt; AndbipfifdgenuscxÃ©rcitdtionisfitinuentum(ut

â .w y^ÃHf^ IZ A dHoquo^librofum confie fins) pdrum comperi.Sed ne /7^-,i,fidifiapffmi^^ i^i^â¢ fidi'hocfortifiimcdfjirmdntfiitlofitJsidonco HM^.^ /i^- dutore nitimtur, Ldtuw nero dicÃ«dipneceptores^x''

ÃÂ« Â». t A-t'i j^tk^t^l^fytycrc^^n Â»^^fd Â»Â« yned * ' ttt^Â»: rri dP Asi lt;icnH.(*Â»

^ r^c l^M- loYo .\^v ^r-nt^'^v- rt^'^^AYâ^W\ ,J^ Â»ui- .-litut^^^ y^ Xd^/'iÃ«o^-^api ^ ^Xi-i-^^tS fV^ t}9 gt;ni-^i-^' ftC^âgt;^(c^'iyt \ â¢

â¢^^^Hj t^yf^ ^^fVrrtiTo ^Â»^Â£2^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;A-^ri k'V^^tf7f^/^'r^^fÂ«i''

. z.ORATOR. LIBER II. 101 irtmii L â¦ cnÃi temporibut capilJc Cicero dUtor eÃ¼, Ciceronem I quorum mÃgnis mixime ^lotim fuit. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;here Sucto / nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;' r)eleitione0rdtorum,z^iiiÃoricorumdpud, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;musmepi-Rbetorem. CAP.^.y,..4 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'

OE^ewtwBCdcclimdniipoftpdulÃ³,f^term ^iÃ^ nee.dÃ©clama Æ 10 primlrbetorieeÃ¯ rudmcutd trciÃ³lctnÃ¯iWjijoTÃ¶mit* *âÂ®' * ^''âT ^Â» ^â/â''â¢- â tendum uidetur id c(Moqj ut moneciw,qÂ«4(Uiwn ft coUdtâ um Latmus turui dd profedum difcentiurhetor, Ã ejuemidntodwtn ^Â°ff'^^^ â' Ã grdmmdticis exigitur poetdru endrrdtio: itd ipfe quo roCiarle^ ^KC biÃorig ydte^i etidm migh or^ioiiUi'ml^ionc,fufcer'ff^^âfâÃ¿^^yââ^ ptos d fe di^ipulos mÃruxcrit,([uod nos in pawew, quo riimidgilt;isexigebdt,etpdrentesutilee(fecrediderAtÃâ!/^'^quot;quot;i / ferMummsXgterÃfentientibitsidm-itu'^pptimdydug ttc'nen nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'

â'â ^Ã^'ljâK^Â®/â^â^âtâh'^KOj^ cz;bâglt;t confuetudo aU tir docendifee^ amp;gÃ©,ct robupijere iwienesjnec bwe ^^^,-^ ^^^.^ libÃ³rcmdefiderdntes,exemplwmno^ri!mfelt;luebdntur. - ^ / a Nec tarnen etidm f t^uid noui udfero lt;Ai^^]difÃem,prgci^f^'^^^^^,â'*Ã'^^^^^ VJ- jwÃoÃ^zywp Â«de ret. Ntwe uerofcio id fieri apuiâÂ»quot;Â«-quot; â^ââ Â«lt;Â£Â±ââ'*â'-' Gr^cos/cebnagw per i^iutp^es, quia wuidentm^m pord fufiedurdyfi Ãegentiims fingults praire femper ipfi uclmt.Et berek prxlrftio, qn^ wt boe a Jbibetwr, ut fa* eiledtquedifiwdepuerifcrip^doculisfeciudntur,etidm ^t. .^â..^Â»fcv y, iKa qnÂ» Â«fm cuiuf^ue^ei^i/t^uid nmus ufitdtum

dat,docct, njultum vnfi-d rbetoris officium exifiimdndd^ 'gt;.^^^0^ -y A/a * nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;eft Â» A( dcn^onjlrare ^irtntÂ«, ucljiquando itd i^fi^d.t/âf^f^f f'^^quot;^^^^;^

Hitia, id profej?ioniÃ¯ cÃ¼m atque promi/?i, quo femd^*, pruw cloquciujÂ« poUicftur, maxime propriumeft, co ,p ntd/cktr^Y quidem ualidiÂ«?, qÂ«od Â»0Â» utique biwic laborem docen* â â â'i^Â«â$^ â^

Rniocatis.) tiuM poftulo,ut dd gremiÂ» Yeuoedtii cuim ([Hif -^ eortiM bÂ£o,uâquot;magÃ¯ ^^^ ^^â'' ^^iÂ°gt;^i defer UM. N^ mi^ cufAciliM.tim eti Her prate- am mi^pi uidetur migK utile, fxÃ¤o filentio, uwim iH* cos hbfos^^s ^tn(lt;juod ij^l^m mperdri per wees optimu eÃ¼)conjii attulerint, tuere ledorem, ut protinuf pronuncidtioni auock difue reuocatis ad nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^

defermat. tio(ndmfKcldriMquÂ£dice^urfmteUigipoteriwt)ni* Z^/jr nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;otiofum pAti,(pU9d^; minueiitione,lt;Ã¿iod^ in docu^

'^^*^'^^^^ ^^^^â ^â^^ ^ P^(^Â°^fÂ»^lt;gt;^Â°^^'^^^^ quot;â¢ t^wÃ¯^^natÃ®^-i/*Â»-(^ diets rdtjo, duÂ£)wrdndi lux, hreuitas, fdes, quod dU* /t*^gt;t4t^ .1^A-af lt;nbsp;'i^â^lt;^?J^?^j}^^^gt; ^^ ^!â^^ occultd cdlUditdS.fidnque cd ^^^^'*^ ***^!Ã¿^^ ^^Ã nbsp;dm^cf non pof*

: 4'-n^ Æ Â«s- iTw iucimditdte permuicedt, qudntd m mdlediilis dligt;e* â 7 Æ 4. r^imso .^lt;/f^ ntdÂ«^ locis tfrodnitds,ut deniquc dommetur m dijvat f nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;buSydtque in peUord irrtmipdt,dttimumqi iudicumfimi

^^^^ â ^â*^ ^^^ â â^ifi^^'*^ ' '^âââ in ritione eloquenÃ¼, '^Jfc,^ g;^i/â-qUoduerbumproprium,orndt^^hme,ubidmplifi*

,wC(i^^gt;'^ Z^i^ trdgt;^af^,quÂ£figufduerbprwm,quÂ£Ãcnis CT qnd'dri â ^^^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^(t,^dj(irllKt4menc'ompÃ³fitio.fJeidquidÃ«inutile,eti*

tr,Â°^'6f^ J^^t'^adin corruptâdÂ« dliqMndo er uitiofa or dtiones, quditd* ^quot;^ââ^dicioruprduitdte mirentur,legipd^mpuf .

j;.Â»--. ,nr' â^ ris, ojÃ¯Ã«di^mhisq multd improprid, obfcurd, tumidd, '^^^âZ^^ f^frn^hunulid,fordidd,ldfciM effammdtdfint,qua non Iduid

^Ã¹^li^ht^*^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;quod finit prdMj Iduadmur Â» NdjÂ« femio rcHusÂ» tS'Ã^-â

ORATOR. LIBER IR^^JCJ CIÂ«Â«JtpM Mturiun cnuncid^,nihH hdlm ex inzenio inur, ucro^ijtia utcwnq^ dcjlcxa jwnt^ cx^mÃ , tiara niiramur,nQn aUter quam dijlortKfi^uocuna^quot;^'^^^'^'^ fnoio proiigiojis corportbii^^dpudfjuojddm nidit^ est fYeciu^quAmbKyquienihilexcomntunÃ¼lia'biiusbonii^-^/^^^ lt;? '^^ ferdideriMtt.^ft^etiam^uil^eci^capiim^^Ã¯pSjÃ¯e^y^i/â^^f'^f'ct VÃtKP^.QT Ã¯iw^M comas acÃ¼comctuihu^,Z7'non[uo co loi'c nitidis,^hs effe formi^^utaiit, q poÃit tribuere in edrrupt^ttituj^t pulcbritudo corporis uenirc uidea* tur ex maiis moribus^'^eq; Ãolumbic ^Ã^debebit doce^^ o/^Ã/foCv^^ re preceptor,fed frequenter mterr^gare^z^ iudidu di fcipuloruexperiri,Sic audientibus fecuritas aberit^flee Vy^TÂ» '-.ââ¢Â»Â«Â»su^j quÂ£ dicentur perfluent dures,fimulq} ad id perducStur, quad ex hoc qu^ritur^ ut mueniant ipÃ er inteUigant^ ilamquid aliud agimus ^lt;fcendo eo^quefemp^dpeen (i-^-m^ difpui Hoc diligentiif genus auÃm^ic^re^pUts coÃatuaâ rum difectibus, Ã¼ omnes omnium artes,quÂ£ iiwantÃne ^Â»^^Â»hc dubio muÃ¯twm,fed htiore quidam comprehenfone, per, .r-u.* ^T.e^ ^ ?,;

ire quipoffumt^ Sicut de re militari, quanquam funt tra^^^^^^ r ' dita quad A prÂ£cepta comumia, magis tamÃ© proderit fd re^quA ducu quif^ ratione, in quiU loco, tÃ©pore Ãt ufus nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^

fapienter,aut con7ri,^am in omnibus ferÃ¨ tninus miet^^f,!f,,^,^ pracepta qudm experimenfa. A^ uerq ^eeÃmayt ^^fff^'f^ '*^-^ demprÂ£ceptor,u^ite^Ã«plo fuis auditoribus,no plus co ââ¢,â lt; v:ââÂ»-7^X tulmntledidfcero iutÃ¼emoÃhehes ? Corrigetur l?â^'^^ff^^''^l^^ ldm,Ã quid in d^clamand^di^puluserrauerit.t^on po f^Ã«'frrtwntaâ

AUcitd enim uitU quift^ue reprehendi mMuk i^udm fuit 'â^^^ Nfc deer tint plurd^(^uÂ£ dicerem, [td neminem bte uti litaf fugit, dte^ue utindm tam non pigedt fdccre ijiai, qudmnondij^licebit.

^i4^Z.iZr^^^â^ ^1^â^^'^ ^^Â°^ tninoreSy^Md Ãeij^or e^grum inte^^,, â¢ Ã¤usuidebdtur, prebduernnt, dlij Ãoridita gemulut ii alenddprmdrumietdtum ingeindmdgis dccommoddt

-M, -'âât^'f^xttM.'E.goopt:mos^uid,emcrÃdt(m,crfemper,fedtd* compolÃ¯til menefirim c^M^mum (juen^ue, o- mdxme ex* 'Z^ZÃ¯^irL^!'âi- PÂ°Ã/.ââÃ^.!!'^lÃf'âf.âi'^,^^^^d!!!!}A i!^fJ^'^â[amp;^ Ã^^ ^â^'*1^^ â gt;]t^tâ^ um,0-btcbiÃoritemdiwK eitdutor,dd qitemtdmenM

*'~^ nbsp;nbsp;teUigendum idm profeHu opui fit.Cicero,ut mihi ^um :X'ft^*^â^^^^^ Â» ^ ^iS'^-^ff^Xi^^ lt;l^^i^e^^ dperttu eAfdtis, neeprodejje td^um, ^detidmdmd^ipoteli} iPIinius ^f^ quemad^od^um Liuiut prÂ£cipit,ut quif^i erit Ci* lt;nbsp;^ic^-f:f,lt;âv â¢â â ceroni fimilmne. D'M_dutcmgenera mdximceduenid iiâA^- puemputoiVnumne^uii eorudntKjuitdtiinimimiid

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, mirdtor^in Grdccborum^Cdtonii^, zy.Riorum fimili*

â ^Â»^ â /â¢itOiMiÃ¯uni.Ã¯^dntnetjf uim corn ddhuc inteUchu coJÃ¨i^MiiitÃ¹r, ^(-iQiKâflQfj^^ ^ui turn fine dubio erdiÃ¶piimd,fedno* ^fâZ^ ^ Ã^i^ temporibui oliÃ«nd contenti (quad e^ peÃimum)fi* ,. ^.yy/^HrÂ»â tnilcs fibi mognis uirii uidebuntur-. AJterwhiyeluod hÃ¿C diuerfiumeil, nerec^K_buiut IdfciÃ¼rÃ¨ ^ofculitcdpti, wluptdte prdMi delmia^Wi at prtdulce iUad genus,(t

puerslibus 'ragenijs boe grdtias, quo propiutm^ddui^T.a;-^^^^ ment^irmisdutemiu pciis^iMci;oxMperiodpopv^gt;m ^ tis, fiuferm^rdntiquojK^'re, ex quibusÃ difumdtur nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;r folidddcuirÃis^^geii^uis,det7â^orudKjeculi'^UAlo^^^^ turn naÃer bic cultus clirius enitefce't,ii:ynou^,quibu^ b ÆÂ», ââit^ ,^ ^ipÃs multd uirtus ddeÃ¢- Ã¯^c enm noftdrdiMis. nd^â^Ã^ iurdfLmtidMt, dicendi mutd^us ^nus,^tiltxd, no^'i^' 2 c '^^ ^ bis qu'dmoportebdtmduÃunifSt itd^Stdm ingenÃ¯o iÃ¼i ^j^Ã§j^ L-vX^ V^ nos Ãuperduerumt, qudmpropoÃto, I^ultd ergo liccbifcx'-â*â. gt;gt;Â»âgÃ» c Æ;? eligere.Sed enrAdAm erit, ne bis quibus permixtdÃvntf^â,^t.^'^^^^\^f^^^ inquinentur. QuÃ¶Ãidm uero^idmouostotosmitdxi'^ oportedt,0âfuiUenuper,cÃ'^c ejje quidem,libentei^Â£^â'^^^ ^^^^2,

non concclTcrm moioMeru/metidtn contenderimSed m.y^ rgt;V~ ^ Â«Â«Ã'â âlt; ^ qÂ«i pnffion cuiuj^ue eSt promwcidre^ TuUM dred pn ores imitdtio eH nel emtur. Idcoq^ bdne nouorwr^iÂ«^ '^^^ }J^^,ZÃ¼ PuU le{lionem,ne imitdtio iudicium Mecederet. ''/â â¢ ^âf^^â /âÂ» / / â¦quot;quot;lt;â¢â 'â '

, De diuijionc. yn. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;j âJ

FviittidmmiKcdinerjum ^rteeÃ¯^ientiu^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,â^^'

dd dicendum ddidUt, non contenti diuijwne dirigerez o Æ Â« re n ^i r.^y^i, Idti^ dicendo prÃ¶fecluebdntur, neejohm prahdtioni^, ^**2,)/^ t,â*^â ^b â^â ^^?k^!â^,4^i^!^ dfjÃ¨Ã¼ibtu'Alij^cimi prim^tUO ieV*^Ifhw^ d y?fw\ dolineM duxijJent, poRdecidm'dtiÃ³nesâepuodomififjet^-quot;-â '{^^'^^ 5f^j trd^dbAt,^uofdd nero locos non minore curd,lt;l ca ^ /âmÂ» âgt;^-^igt;-fi,fu. ^^ dicendum ipfifur^crent, excoÃ¯ebdnt. Vtile utrum^^'quot;'' ^â^y^' ââ^5â* Cr idea neutrum xb dltera^epdrySed^fdcex^^^

^/SlÃ«^ f^^lt;^lt;^lfcÃt:,pliÃ¼proderii demon^rdlfeprotinÃ³s m-j- -14 /ft n. ^nk-MM, (lUM reuocdre db 'errÃ¶te idm Idpfos Â» Vrmum^^-^'psZquot; *

^^1^ o â ^H'''*âây^,l,n/^âl â^quot;quot;1/, Ægt;Â»â /â .lt;Â»,/â ^ gt;7â,(^'Â»Wgt;Â«/ ^Ctbi-rn-^m^ d/^yf^ {'w-f.flj^nr-^^ f^iKptquot;v-Ã^a,ui-/Ã¿n,lr-blt;^^ItÃ¼^Il,^l)

(if t'C^iC^f^'m^ t ^^rmitui^ f^rrio t^f/t^ 4ny _^.^nrf7f '^*â ^^ ^^'f^^ ^â^^t^^hn^*^*^ lOÃ' M. F AB. QVINT. INSTIT.,^,^ -^ e^i'.idemedatyoncmyuribusmodoiycipiiintjdiuifioHtt^ nero ad cogitationemetiant e^^yldruperferunt. IXW de ctiam quad Ubentius preclpientem auduwÃ,^atnte^ ^â¢*d^^endentem.Si lt;ptiueropaulÃ³ fwn( uiMciares yÃ¯nbii â '.preÃeftmwo.ribuSyetiam iraÃetmtur adinonrtioni/t H '4^Mi,JS^^^ti^^^^ ^^P^ggt;^â^'^^^^ idco timen mÃ¯niK uitii aperte co^ â^''^^^quot;quot;!!â * lt;tr^^n^Ã^t.tiâabend(ienimratiocgterorU'm,cjuiT(^ ~\?.^y^CtÂ£â,Tâ' Ãi effe^qnÂ£ preceptor non cmÃ«dauerit^crydet^.'Vtriy que dut ratio milcenda eH, er ita traÃ¤anda,vt res i^^ r - nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fÂ°^^y^^^* t^ane^ inapiemib^andaerituelutpr^

1Â»Â» nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;t^f^ijji^feddexcmpluuidehuturybreuiaiptedaindetno Xâ^Â«,^'^^â 'â' fi^â^'^^^ ueÃigid,(^ue perfecutijam luisjur^busfweji^ ' f^ff^ iÂ»^ ::,S,^^t.niniculoprop^redi^poÃint .Nowntyredi^byoypor tebit,ncmila confuctudme femper aÃ¼entvm labor em Ie* quendi, nihil per fe conari er ^terere fdant. QHod Ægt; fatis prudenter dicenda uiderint^iampropÃ¨ confu/nani ta fuerit predpientis opera. Si c^uid Ã«rraÃ¯ierint,adbttc erhÃ¤lta^diK^r/ducendi.CuireiÃmlequiddifacicmes j duescernimus, ^ue tenerif mjirmis^foetibus cibosore ' f^Â° ^Â°?1^Â°^p^rAuntur.Atewntuiftfiwt adulti,paKlum , egredinUis^ercircwnuolare,fedemi^ainpreceden* ' **^^^ lAerocoeio, fuetpie ^iZ^'-'^^fMi^ip/brumÃdutix'permittimt^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;i

â ^/r^a-^y^^.iv'i^ Idiid epc confuctudme mutandum prorfus exipmo ; ryiti^y ,^t^ ^i^iis^ Mfbus ntme dijTcrimus ^tat^Jteo^ â¢ .A^./ j^/;i^â,t. wgt;M^uÂ£jcripjermt cdt!cant,?:r-certdjUtinorifest, ,

4blt;ri^.^0R ÃTORj^LIB^ER II.^^/107 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;J

^icii^nt, c^d'quidetn'mAxtm^pdrmcxiguntjAt^-l| qÂ«riudemum(luiereliberosfnosjiciMmÃ-cjiicittiÃi*^'^^^'' ^^-^ tne dccidmiucr'mt, crcdimt^ cum ^ofcdu^pi^i^ue dt^^^ ^â'ffrrj ligcntii cogt;t^et. ^ilt;^M~fcribere pueras,^b'.rimubKjue ngent^ââ'â* fjj^^^ boco^erf pÃdnÃ¨uelnn,ljc ediÃere e^â^Ã¶^ex or^ ftat, - ^Â°â , genere dignAt^lÃ t^*^ ;^ raÃ¼Ã³iummwmlocosjmulto tndgis fMdeiim^i^Am ZT' iic*gt;-ârlt;r^''niyâ^ ^^:^ ereebUur dcrutf mÃ¨morid, Aliend compledendo quAhi^'^ ^ ^ fM-.CT c^ui enmt m difficiliore buiut generis Idbore utr nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;i,rtn

fdti fmemolcfiiA,^uÂ£ ipÃ compofnerutjdmfdmilidriusv ^w^/i i^^^^^n^irgt;^â dnimo fuo d^Ã«t etdÃutÃcet optimis,Ãmper(ii hdbelut 't 'gt;^lt;rKâr,â intrdÃquodimitentur.EtidmnonfentiemesformAnt 1^ y^t^^e^H^ ontioisiÃ¼d,qudmmente'pemtusdÃ¨:cepcr'mt,exprimÃ«t/^^^^^â' Abunddbunt Autem, co^duerborum optimorum, zy co poÃtione.de figures idm aan ([Uffitis, fed fronte ex â¢fÃ¨^

quot;^tÃ³uelutthefduro fc'offÃ¨remibia-Accedit his or iu^'^'' '*â cimddin jermone bene d qÂ»o$ d,japrum reldtio er in l^Mââ ,^^ cAufisutilis.NdmerpbM AUtqritdtisdaunted,quÂ£^'^^i^^3^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.

non prefentis grdttd hits juut compdrdtd, et Uudem nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.,b do-r^fi

pemdior^,cpid^ÃnoÃrdfwt,concilidnt, AJiqiundo'^ r^st-ecc, tdmen permlÃ¼endumquc ipÃ fcripferviitdicere,utld^ loris fuifruhum,etidm ex iÃii,qÃÂ£ mdxme petitw,idit

ieplurm'jm edpidnt, Verum id Ã¼uoque turn fieri opÃ³r '^â ^^'^ Æ Â»Â»lt;/?Â»â¢gt;Â»gt; tebit,cwmdueiuid commodiut Imducrmt^uteouemt ;^ ^ult;,Â»^ prlt;emio fiudij fui donentur, dc fe meruiffie, ut dicerentif^ ' A^ ^A gdudedM, ee^^y^- â^r., . oer.'â'''.- lt;^Â£Â»^r'^''^' ,,,t /^^A ^ a, Anficymdum fui quifque ingenij docendus fit *ââ quot;^ â ttdtWAntt CAP. IX.

_ 'Â«Â»* A^TT/fewk Ã d ^\ /IrttKfrgceptoTKbMtnfOKt/tecn^nurÃ¼o,^ rtw^rhcmrif ' ^^ U^eittcrinhisquoserudiendos^ufeeperit,noti re diferimmd mgeniorivm,0' â^Ã ^Ã¨nqi tutum md^Ã®* ââ^^*' /-^ biefcrdtfcire.'i^tiihellmro^incrt'dibiliiciuxiiiinuiri Z\Z*â^,^â^ ââ?'â ' ei((s,necpdUcioresdnimonvmpenÃ¨qMm corportifoÃ¯* Ca n^^nM:! ; i^m^t^g^Quocl, inteUigi ctidm ex ipÃs ordtoribm poteÃ^d^i tdntum inter fe diftdnt genere dicendi,ut nemo fit due'' ri fimilis,^udmuis plnrimifeddeoru^epeos probdut^Uni* j/ Â»gt; ctr idtionemcompofuerint.Vtiledeindepleri[^ uifumejl, â ig-/^ ^^ââ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^f^ prÃ´ppdndturfbottddoari* '^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;_ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ndfMÃ§rciit,z^ mid podÃtmuYningcnidquo tender et, A'^iZ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ã i'^^^pdlÂ£ÃrÂ£peritiMjCumindliquod plenum^uerK gymndfium uencrit/xpertui eoru omni modo corpuf,dn'imim quo^ difeerndt^Ã¨tÃ¢ gÂ«i/$ certd'' ntmipr^pdrddus fiti ltdprjeccpioretnelotjueinii cdm Jdgdeiter fuerit intuits fCuiuf mgeniupreffo liindt'oi^ i^i- ., -s-jr/iryi^e genere dicendi,cuittt~dcrt,grdui,duld,dl^ero,nitido,at tgt;7,,n^m A Idnoindximegdudedt,itdfemmmoddturufinguli5,ut '1 in eo quo quife^ eminet prouehdiur^uod ettr ddiutd cu^

A mturd mdgii euAk/Ã¨nt: erfim diuerfd dueMur,^^ in his quibus minus dpt^ cÃ,Ã}tis paÃ it cfpcere,ey ed , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;in (tut ndtusuidetur,deterÃ§iofdddt mkrmtord.QÃ¿pi tnihHliberdcnmuelcontrdreceptdsper/udÃonesrdtto yy,/n-vÂ»^Â»,f^'' nifcquentifententideR)iÂ»pdrteuerumuidetur.'!^dgt;it t nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;/ proprietdtejj^eni^orudijpicereprorJusneceffdrui/tn

dr/ura fâ/Ã''^ ell,lnhis'quoiÃcertumÃudiorumÃdcered(lcÂ£iu/iiÂ»,ne i -â¢ ? nÃ-,,Mh-'_^ ^ â,^âtno diÃtudfeni^dn^u^ crit dlius h^orU'migÃÃ¼ipne* quot;'quot;quot;''Ã'h^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.^i^^^dti comp^Uui dd^cirmen, dlius utilis^udioimik

ut nonnu^rm /Ã³ffâ*//^gt;Â»jÃ¯tfÂ»|t .Sif diJcerM^^di*â tendimagiÃer, (juo modo PttheÃricus iÃ¼c curforemfici^ ^f tt^Mt fugilem^aut lu(idtorem,a.liiÃ¯d ue^uidex^s^f r^^f^l [imt [Mrorimi certaminumt Veru/m ei,quifc^o dc^mi ^ 'ââ Utur ytion^ umm pMenicdilt;lMm,fed inomnitt ^Ujeâ-quot;^ ÆÂ«Â»Æ 4Ã*Â»5 ^ j fu/nttitM^operK, ctumfiquAdjfficiUorduideluM^retAS^â2^^ ^igt;^^â^^^ \ lorindum eli. Ndm Ã§y owiHwo[uperMcuderdtdo^ri^ ^^,1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^ nd,fi tuturd fufficcret. An Ã Ã¿iKWgpno c^i^Uk^oc ^nnj^^^ (Â«t pM^i fwnt) maderit wi boe ruw irtpdÂ» ttimidut -^rn^ tiemur^ Ardumdtf^ iciwium non alemw^ er (^uÃuei' ** â 'ââ '^o^'^'^i ^'/^ jliemuii ^dmll c^^d^ dtirt^cre neecff ar mm eil^cur^^.^^, ^^'^^^^ ''. non ffitddijcerÃ©concefffwm^ Ucq;ego conirdndrÃ¹rdm pMgno:nott tnm defcrendum id ionumyfKluodjm^i tj^^^i^fftt^*^^' turn c^^ mffimo,fed dugcndu dddendum^; ffnod ccp'^

fdt.An noncUriÃmusiÃepnccptorlfocrdtes,{[uem (nero Â«o mdgis libri bene dixiffe, ejudtn difdpuU bene docuifiâ fe tefldntur, euw de E^bor^^tffue^ Tbeo^om^po fic itigt; ** diem t, ut dUeri frenK dÃcr^cijcdribui o fut effe di^

prxci^iti, concitdtionem ddiuudnddm docedo exiffimd '^'wdyn â¢Jif^y-nit,cwM dUerum dlteriut ndturd mifcendumdriitrdrei- . Â»^i Ãªff^ Â»i'^^t^^ turijmbedUis tdmenÃmgenijs fdnÃ¨ Ãc obfe^endum Ãt, Mtd^umm id ^Ho wedt ndturd,duc^ltur.ltdenim^d' folum poffunt,meliut e^^ient,Siuero liberdUor ndtw^ matetia rd comigerit,er m'^ud meritÃ© dd jfem ordtoris fimut ^?,amp;'^Ã'^ âÂ«nlt;t dicendi uirtui omittendd cft. N4m licet

P^ri^'^-Jâ*?.W^*quot;eii,ctterit tdi-men non repugndbit, dt^ue c'a enupdrid fdciet bit) iti t hf '

' Unjir/^I^A quot;Â® nbsp;âââ^Â®* QVIKT. INSTIT. ^lt;itiibui emmehit. SicutiÃ¼e (ne cibeodem c^^^lo r^i^ 'â'^'- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tnui) exerendi corpora ^critM^nonfi^occn^^umpiÂ»^ MtuÃen fitfccpcrn,pugndfcrÃ¯re,ucÃ'cÃ³^e tÃ¯iiuum,lt;iK^ actcros nexui mo'do,dtqucinhis certosdl'quos doecpitÃdo* gt;^:t :Â»,. inniiiquffimteiiiscÃ¨ridmmK.'EritquTcx^isiilicludno

^/^ân)^ â^/gt;'âii;),..ipoÃit^ in id mdximc quod poterie incumbet. Hdmfufd Aiihd'^'ut ^^â^^Ã^Â°Ã}tMddprorfM: Vnum, ne tentes ,quodtÃ'^ , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;non poÃit:Altcrum,nc db.eoquadquhoptimeFdcit,ilt;t re^ti-a .,,i^â'^iht^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;_ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.

Ã¼liud,cuiminusestidoneus,trdnsferds.AtJifucÃ¯i[^lt;igt; Nicoftratâ. docebitur,iÃ¼c,quem ddaÃ¯cfccn^Jl^Ã©t^uidimuSt ^ieo^ Ãratus,omr^usin^odoeÃ«dipdrÃbq^ firniÃterutetur, efÃeietq; iUum, qudiis bic fuit, luddhdo, pugndndÃ³que,

^uoru utroqj certdwine iÃdem diebm coromihdtur iÂ«* ufdidm.Et quAtoid indgis ordtorisfutun mdgiÃro pro *^'^^^^â^âcrit^IJonenmfAt^cRd^icamp;Â£pre^eJdMH,_. p Â«M Â» nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dt^t ÃbuUt^erfdutÃ¤Ãm, no mdgis qmm p^ondjco'dcn

'mafi/n' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tisidiÃ¼Mn.dutmcdÃ¼sAtitfiJduibwfonK-duthortmicti

dm pdrticulis exceUere^^TSA Iteut athArd,ttd or^tfo, per fedd non eR, nifi db imo dd/immum omnibus int(tt(lt;i ntruis confentidt.

a PalÃ¯ftricusoWeft, gymnases. Nam palfftramgyffl'' Iiafiiim dixere. Sunt aufem gymmea agonifmata ftadium, â¢isÃ¯vrÂ«iXt^,JâitnXis,J'oXf)(^ifjTTX'nKi. Suniijliarccurfuiinoml na,3u)-MN hoceft^Ceftus. tsÂ«Xk, Iioc efr, Lufta. TrayKjanoft turn tous uiribus decertabÃ¢t, pugnando luftando'^.SX/tÂ«Â» faltus.

b Hoc apud Ciccronem de claris oratoi ibus copiofius. apudSuidamqucqjficlcgirur. ^(pllÆO! M/naits i) hÃ³-m/A'S^t /Â«/iKSi'igaTS X.'ios.ti/AifaiAiiii^dT'H/AaiHTKiaTr' (vavf/um^ rds X'â)âÂ«j ip/Aii/Awi tipdtyÃ¨i^ tÃ®gt;oÆogt; HÃ¯ To HÃo; Ã¯t7rXWJ Â»r^

IjAXVUOV THS ;50fl'Â«S quot;Trfios K, Vw(jgt;Ã s,xyi /XKÃMÃÂ«*^XUV STTITÂ«

Â«V.Ã A SioTrO^TSOSTquot; Â«905 â JSUH-foS It, KÂ«KCH9Â«Ã . TkA Ã^af^j -ÅOXÃj gt;9 OuÃ¯tXt'S, K) Ãojas AI-5505 (piXÂ«Xn9Hs sÂ» 0(5ÃxjâÂ«4-5Å¸.07OWlO01lylX THSi fâi Ail'i iÃ®Â« XÂ«XiÅ¸Ã´ JCiS^ rivA iÃopv ZiVTfOu.

c nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Nicoftratus iÂ« TSfuAtviioou-f 9fu?i'Â«s. Kodori filins,quem feptimuin ponit Paufanias in corum numÃ©ro qui qfdem die busuicerintTrayiiyaTiniiq TscÃ®XKjiJieliaxay pnmo, Hoc loto obfcruabis intcrpretarum effc Fabium ziÂ«gt;ityÃ¢Ti0j), pugnÃ¢. Quod certamen quale fucrit, pauloante dekripfit, omnibus enim uiribusin eo utebantur, amp;nbsp;quomodocunqut poterant aduerfanmniinpctebÃ¢i-.Neigiturdâxerispugilr.'.TiiÃ¹sTsay.- , Â«.Æ itTiÂ«5Â«s, 5qui funt â auHjÃ¢i, Phonafeum auÃ®em uotar m.agp JtrÃ¼ uocaÃ¼fatis, in qua mil um in nioduin flaborafic Crace^^ Ã¯OsintcUigietijimexCiceronisKbropotcftdeOratorei. VÂ«. i/Â». ^.r C^^T.;

l^e officia HrÃ ^ulorum. CAP. X. ' Z^^^^^^t/.i PL^tUe offieffi docentiuM locutus idffiiputos U'^^t^^T-jfj^^^^j. ivnwm mterim moneo, ut brÂ£ceptores fuosnonntiZZ^C'quot; '^'^'^ quot;f' nuf quÃm ipÃjiudid dment, O' pdrciurs e ffi^Â°ncn {uid^' '-^^'^^^''â''^'''â dtm corporumffied mentium crcddM[.IJiuÃ¯tu/ntl}Â£c pie. ii 7t^i\ ^TiVtCo^lho jiÃ© S/^ ' tlÂ« confert jiudio. pdm o Ubenter M/Jent,, o di^^^/T^-iZ'^^f tr^dentyO effi fimiies concupi^centAnip^osdenit^ cee^â' 'quot;'^ tut fMdru liti et edderes canuenient, ftKÃ«ddti.non

}ceiuur,lAudlt;itigdudebivHt^t fint cladriÃimifuffio,mef^lt;t^7^iri it^co/; rebutitur. Ndw ut mar^ officium c^^ docere,fichorury

pubere fe dociles. Aiio^wtj-Â«cHtruw^nc dlterojuffi* faitenim''gt; ^^â ^'â^^ 'Jt^ ffiM bominisw^ut ex utro^ gigÂ»^Â«Â« roW%â t^if^ir'^fy'^^ jfdrferif femmd,nifi iÃ¼dpriemoffiiiu foÂ« y yquot;Ã¯i.A'^â/'^ire tient fulcus^Ã¼A cloqucntid codlefeere necjuityiiififocidtdffi'^'^ trddentis^dccipientis^concordid.

**^ Z nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^ ^^ primis operibiii,quÂ£ non ipfd pdrMÃvnt, Ãi 12,l^Ã^'^''^''f^ â^/Q ^i^Ã/^ S-âf^Ã inembrd dtlt;^ pdrtes, bene inÃitutoÃ¼ iÃ Â»Ã^^f^ c^uc exercitdto,idmferÃ¨ tempus dppetft dggredH'diÃ^ 'â '^Zâ'quot; ââ^ r^M. f^^^^)^^^ââ^^^^ mdteridxt qiurwn dniequdin uidm W A-^ r^f ^^ fUÃ¯ i ^ir^H/'f gredidr, pducd de ipfd, mihi decldmdndi rdtione dieen'' v^.i,i^,^(^ , -^j dd funt, quÂ£ quidemut ex omnÃ¼nis nouiÃimeinuenti), zlt;^Â»X/ ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^''â*' ^â^^^^ ^1^ utiliÃimd.tia lt;:^cim(lddejiuibut dixiwin i'-tuo ,tt ,^.jin(Ã¨fcrccojUinet,p-uerUdtifroximdmmd^in(tgt;ir(i LT*'^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ditAdco^Ã¼iieil:ccleirdtd,utpÃ¯eriâfqittidereturdifof

mindernelot^uÃ§iuidmucl foldfufficcre.t^cq; enimuif^ tm uÃ¼d,perpctuÂ£duntdxdtÃ³rd'tionis, reperiripotcH, l quÂ£ nonÃt cum hdc dicendi mc^iMione commwKAÃ . ^uidem ra iÃd culpd docentiumreeÃ¯dU^tt inter prÂ£cif 'Z pyi^,â^râÃ^^P'^â*^ ^Â£cwrupereittelolt;iuentidmcdufdf,licentid,dt^

â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;infeitid decldmitium fiicrit.Sed eo cjucdndturdhcnutU

jcv^ry^i, esi,oene^tiUcct.^wtergoÃ§ripjiemdteriie,^tiitpngen ^^Ã,\m^AZT^i-*^'lt;^gt;^^^^/wwBwf fff^MÃ«/ Â®^ decldmdtio in quintitrit z.Â»Ã§.wÃA- ; C.Â»^v ^Â»âtximepoteRJmiteturcdsdaioiKs^n^udrm.exerci , j'^i'^''â''V'^*^^ *â*^dP'}^d^,l^PfKi^ÃÃi,^^â^â^^Â°^?^pe^^iktu^iw^ -lt;i.d,^tâ^ quot;'âquot; reÃionÃd,etfÂ£uiorejtrdgicÃnouerci:^^dÃd^iwgiidd 'Z;^^i'^rÃ^â^X. ^fdbÃ¼lofd,fruÃrd inter^^on/iones^epiniepdidtd ^iit ^t'f^- ^rj^^quot;'^ *''W*^9S^ergo^tJivnqudmh^cfuprdÃdem,^ poe^ â¢i.i.f nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^ tied (utacre dixcrim)themdtdiuiicnibui pertrd^dre

Â» A/a^T.â rgt;-/y,J,Â£-' pmittcmui,ut expdtienturyZT gdudednt mdterid, et i^^ ^*^^^ZÂ»^J7- Ãkiforputed^t optimum^ $edcerteÃtttgrdndtd(;r tumiSd,nonÃuUd etidtn cr^ derioribus oculis intuetuiri dieuÃt^deÃjdmeedendum eA, implcdtfe decldindtordli ^Uddo,dwnfiidt,ut ^uddrupedes cum uiridi pMo lt;amp;*

Ã¿wiv fff^â^yrrrm^^*â^ Gt^irt ^ f^'JÂ»'^ .J ^^ â p'Â»^Â»n i^ 2 cir -i^^r^ C^tÂ«*Tn(Ã

PentÃ¦/wtt,fdKgÂ«wtwdftrdÃ iÃ rtcquot;cMrdÂ«fÂ«r,cr/Ã®cddci^^^(^^ I^e^^^ â bos uiribus conferuAnOs idoneos redeuÂ«t,itd Ãbi quoq; - Â«^w^s) Â« ^ iv (j- ; tcttiwndos ddipes, et quiequid humorÃ¼corrupti contritquot;^* ^lt;^y^ xent,emittendum,fieffefinus2Acroij^^iuMlct.Alio*^^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;' -qui tumor iHc minis^ primo cuiuÃetw^ ueri operts co*^^ ^^quot;'i^^^ mtu deprehendetur. TotjiTOdHtÃ© dccidmdndi opM^^^lX^Ji ^7, diuerfum omnmo d|'oKnJÃ¯Ã¯gt;tM cdufis cxi^imdi^,hi pÃ¯Â® jJ,2Ã¯:?7, ^â^' fectone rationem qutdcm 3 qud iÃdfxcrcit.it 10 inuenw--hÂ«^ *1Â»Â»^ ,WTâ'flt;-Vâ fit,peruidcÂ«f,NS fi faro non prfpdrdtjdut fcenic^ oJle^X^f t Â»^^X^lt;. ^'^^^Â°^=i'^fnnoÃeuocifcritioniÃmiliim OM^e^'^â^^Ã^^^Zquot; ** mm dttinet Ã¯u'dicÃ©mpripdrdre,qui nullits eft i ndrrdre quod omnes fcidite ^dlfumiproby ione s^ddhiberÃ©'edu/Â«, de qua, nemo Ãt pronuncidturus ? K hdc qui^^otio^

tMum.AfficiueroirayUvlluilufermouere^ciÃ¢uieRluâ^â^''^ ^ ., dibrijfmppwgNÂ«cwufddniJimttlrfcrwdducrumdiferi*J^/ -yâ â''â7 ,,,, menmÃ§ra^iHjÃ¯mconJucJcttniÂ«, Nihil ergo inter fo'' ~^^^^ i renfe gernÂ« dicendi/tq; hoc dcc];tmitorium intercrit ^ ÆÂ» 'â'**ââ¢ ,â^^ ,7^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;t Si profÃ§ftiM gritii dicimiw,nib4.y tindmquf .^^.Â«^ conf^tudmem po^et;ut nominibus Â«terewr^ t perpKT*^ ,^âÂ«ygt;^-?' 1 xetttigKjO-lortgiorisitliqHAndoditiKcotttroucrfiilejTrt '^ quot;^^^ ^ât^^ 1 gereitturjCr Â»wbdâm Â«fw quotididnoÆoptd wintMtime' dÃ¯?'^j ZLv^ '^ nbsp;nbsp;, remw,^ locos infcrcrc morts cjjet, qMÂ« nos ^uamlibet quot;Æ â;y ^â^'^4!^^/,, ptfetUivn [colis cxcrcititifumus3tgt;roncsin foroinuc^'.âit- 7 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;\

niyt: si ucrom oÃentdfioem compdretur dccUmdtio,^'^^ -fâ,2^7'^'^â'quot;' fdnÃ¨ pdululu/m dliquid mcldmye dd Moluptdtem dudien ^ ' tiwndebtmm.Ndm cyhis dctionibiis,qux tn aliqiwpac ^ * rt(,w^â*i-^1^âÃ¯,' dubio ueritite uerfdniur,fcd funt dd populdrÃ¨m dptdtic V y*Â« /Â»r^ -q (â¢'^â¢' dclcadtionem, ^iwkÃ¯legmwMPdnegyricos Â»totÃm^'ÃnÃ¨gy^'

^^/Off^i^^ Â«4 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT, 1 â¢tr/Â«^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;hoe demonlhdtionumgenuf, permittitur ddhibere ^^. '^â^ âiâ'â,Ã'^^^â cultus,omnem^dÃ¯tÃªm, qmlatereplerun^ue inluUdji I debet, o- non confiteri modo, fed ofentdre etism boni f nibus m hoc aduocatis.. CMye dcclamatioauoinMi

v.tiJ^i'2trii nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;iudiciorimi,confiliorum^imdgo,fimilisejfedebetwn' i4^f 'm(0-.4i, tdti,quonidmdutdliquidinfehdbeti7riJ^^n?MÃp,nonni â' fnbftbi nltorls.dffumere,^dâ^ciHt dilom comici,q ix^' t'^^ 'XJtd prorfus ut nos i^lgo Ãoquimur., ^ron^cidnt, quoi nbsp;nbsp;' ^,\ffet fine arte,nee tdmen prpci^ndturd^reccdi^,lt;lÂ»o I \Ã¼tio perfret imitdtio, fed morem cmnmi^is huius ff^ monis decore quoddm fcenico exorndnt,Sic quoque idigt; aud nos incomodd ex his quds finxerimus cofeauentur, \

5Ã¼fnÃ¯ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^ prlt;ccipuc ^od multd in hii.reÃi^^tHiniurincert^ij

W ^ quÃ¦^ i^^^ furnimutfUt luXuaur tttdtei,âfactiltlt;ites,tibcri,fdrÃ© noftro arbi- tes, urbium ipfariM uires, iurd, mores, dlU hls fimiHiÂ» .;Hlt;i^^ mus Æ Â°quot;^quot; Quin dUi^Mndo etidm drgumentd ex ipÃs pofitioiwâM

^' â^^/^''^ 'ââ^â^ W'^V^ ducimus.Sed hite fuo qu^que loco. Ciuimuis enitn . -ii^X^' ff^-mff^- otnne propoftum operis d nabis defltnati eij^eiiet, Â«^ ''J^^ *2^**' Â°^^^Â°^ inÃitUAtur, turnen ne quid ftudioft requirdÂ»t,eti â*isi^ ^ ^^/^J, .4 dmjt^uiderit^ciuodddfcholdspertinedtproprie.mn^^ TjfÂ»wâf,^ 'm^r^ fitunonomÃ¯tiÃªmus,

^\t^lÂ»i/fn^ â Nammagosamp;.)Excmp[umMagidâ¬damatio.X.Â«a^ i^T rrÂ«z quacQuintilianoadfcribuntur. NeuereÂ»prima.Refpony â nbsp;nbsp;^H^ quarta.PeftilentiÂ» uideturpofletaledari.Pefiilenriagraf' ( ftntemiffifuntquioracuIumconfuleret.Re/ponditDeuÃ I Câ^ Ithtif^- gt;l/fijquot;âââlt;â*Â®*^2fuiffet,quÂ»nondumeflâetmater,ceffaturumniâ ( rivid^^M fuidt, ^*quot;â PriusquamuatesderelponfocognouiffetpriuawÃ¯Â® Â» ' amfuammaAauit.Vates ftatuereiuuencamjd efifit^fquot;'

A*HTiilt;,immolandam. CeffaMitpâ¬ftilenti3,qmfiliamocddlt;* i rat poftulatur ho middij.

j A w Rmc ergo Â«oBk mehoinid eft ed [gt;dri drtis, c)^ r^â^^^J' '^Â«Ai. lt;nbsp;I ^lt;luicdperfmitiumfolent,lt;^uipriordomiferunt,lt;Ã¿M nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1 r^Ã^^mwidco c^uofddm mipfo fidtim Imme Ã³bftdturos, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1

Jed ndturdjud^ imlgdrimodo, er fchoUrumexcra* ^Â»ât^'/^^^^kif ^rZ-^j M^^ idiionecontenti,ridtdntetidmdÃ¼iztMidmnoflrdÃ¯n,fX

tmplo mxgni ^Moq'j nomiww pro[eiJoYwm,^uoru ^u^f^ yt^r^ v l**^?Pipo^)iÂ«terrog4taÃ¯ lt;^uid effet ffhÃ©md et noemii,w ^^ ~^ â 'â¢^ij Â» f^^i'rtfet^uidÃªffedliddrempertmeretj^effem^deeÃ¯d^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;_ , nbsp;nbsp;^.

â j^i ââ!â/'?lÃ¯ffts4f^AliiM per^otdnti/rljeodoreÃ¼idit Apol^^^yy^iâ.^/y.

tuit HrbdniiÂ« ex confej^ione mfeitid ffx tldii.^orro h',^ Ã¼^/'fYyfhav ^^~re^

eÃ¿tidfyheneffio'mgen^pritfiAtesfunthdbiti^etmultit f tu me morÃ¹ digÂ»4 excUmitwerMt, plurwtoj bdi^ t Ãmi ^JX.'^^a^J,

Heere ff, er uirihm uti ^oridntur^l^ei-etÃ¼m opM effe pÃ¯obdtione, dut diÃio/ittone iw rcbiw ÃÃ¤is e^uo^ffed end^r â'â¢'â^ gt;^t^^v imreigntid plenS/Ã®t Auditorium, ffntenti^s grddihwt^ ^,m^/. vk-i^-j ^WÃoptimd lt;{UÂ£^Ãpericulopetd^ur^C^metidmÂ«*â'^*^'^yT.yquot;. cogitdi}do,nuUdrdjiojKddhibitd,dÃ»ftTÃ um mtdentes^^^ ^JZ^Zr^ Wdgniwn dIqÂ»tS.^Â«Ã³^trÃ³ ff offer dt pluribw ffpejiie bui expeddnt^dut murmure mcerto,uelutcldfficoÃ¯nffin -Â»-âââ¢^ fti 3 concitd^ipmtwn corpora twotiwn no^enumtidtidu^^' '^ ^:^^^ ffdquÃ¦rftidis uerbff ii^commoddnt.Ã¯^onntdli certdfibi,, ; ' c/.^ Â«^^^ iwitidpriupquÃ¯ ffnffii^uenermt,deffmdÂ»t,([uibiKdÃ¼âÂ»'^'^^^iia ' â quid diferti fuStuwgendtMn fft^edlt;^ diu fecu ipfi cidre q;

â¢'^ â^'^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Alii dci}tccps,dtc^ mdcAlu non minuicomunid dt^ueno tdduicrtunt. Qjiiplurtmuuidciiturhdber.crdtiottis,nlt;gt; in cdi^M tdntum IdborcmfuUm^fcd in locos mtendwit) dÃ¯q;mhis^non^or/on ^roÃ^iciunt, feddbruptdWif .. ddm^Ã¹rfortcddmdnivmuawrc,idcÃ¹Ã®dntÃ»r^^ndept^^^^^ f^ '''^/'quot;dijfolutd^^ircx diucrjis congeftdordtio cobiererenolt

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;poÃÃ¼^fimiUs^Ãt commetifdrijs puerorum, in quoi d

quÂ£ dlijs decldmdntibui Iduddtd funt, rcgerÃt.MdgnH y. zy Ãi nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^'â^ fiff^tt^tCr res bonuiitd enim gloridri foÃ¯Ã«t)di

/n^^lt;gt; -Ãn',tr^ T dut^ni o- bdrbdri,etÃ boe faÃ©ff^l^ eÃ rdtio dicÃ©Ã¼-, , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;QudrcincruditiingcniofwrcsntÃ¼gohdbediitur.

opmionem,ut fortius diccre uidedhiurindodi' i^ A- ''^fffrÃ â^ quot;^ trimumyUitio mdle iudicdntiii,qui meaoran bdbere tÃ¼tn , i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;credunt,eA,quienonhdbcntdrtcm,uteffringcrcqdpi''

.^^^y^fquot; quot;^^Â» rivmpere qudmfolucre, trdhere^dm duccrepn^ ââ'T^'^Jquot;*â' 'quot;quot;'^^^^^VQhuÃius.t^dmerglddidtorffuidrmÃ¶rummfcui^ X^gt;Â£y.f;i, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^ rixdm ruit,^ lu(idtor,qui totiusjorporis nixu in ii

-Â»quot;Â»lt; jw ^-â txK^ifquod femelmudÃt incumbit,fortiordbVisuocdturyCUin â5*Â»lt;â el- ^iâ/^idiif'interim ethiefequenter fuisuiribusipfeproÃernitur, '^IÃJvâ'^Jj''^quot;'^ erittumtiehemetfsimpetus,excipitjdtKrfdrijnwllisdt ^ quot;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tkului^.SedfuntmhdcpdrfÃ©duximperitostttdmnittt

rdiiurfdlÃ¼nt : nam er diuifocum plurmum Mledtin cdufsfieciemiirÃ¯um minuit, er rudid politis mdiorit erffdrfdcompofitiinÃ¼merofiordcreduntur. Ldpf^. tered qurddm uirtutum uitiorumq^tticinid, qudm^ euf pro libero^ temerdrius pro forti, effufus pro copio*

ORATOR. LIBER IR II7 ioiccÃ¯pitur. ^ledicit dutÃ« incruditm dpertiui,cr fe pint nel cum pÃ¨ncuto^lc^ti Utigdtorit^frci^ucntcr cti ^â¢Maledicus amfuo. A^jÃ¨rte^yijid resopmioncm'^quidlibcntiÃimc^â^:''quot;' hommes dndiut edtlt;pi^diÃ§ere ipÃ npluiÃ'ent.lUud (pio ^ue dUeru/m ^uo^ejim eÃ¯ocutioncipld periculum, mi^ nw nitd^condtuÃ¯^ perdite. inde euenCtnonmwqudm, ut dUcinid grande mninidt, qui femper^uiierit^uodni^i umeh^erum^riiÃ¯oatenit,^:^- cÂ£terduiii'd non pen^^^ â^Z^. ''i^^ f^t.Vroptcr^ocquo^mterdumuidenturmdo^icopii-'^^^^â^ dm hibevemdiorem, quad dicunt omnid, dodis eh de^cZt^v-i^/x -^^r â -^io (y modtu-Uis dccidit,quod d, curd doeed i quad in^ t^ndermi,readut. 114^ iUud quiÃionup- drgumento^^^â^ud^ ^^â ^^.,, ^ riMdpudcorruptdiudicidfrigus eiutdittj nihU^ dUud ^- ^gt;^ââ-^ ^^uim quo uel prduis uqluptdtibus dures dÃijlitium per ' mulcednt,quieriM.sÃ¨MÃªntitt qiioq^ ipfÂ£,quds folds pc* twnt,mdgiseminent ycurnomnidcircdilhin fordidd zy-dbie(ldfint,utlumind no inter umbrAS,quemddmodv.m Cicero dicit, fed pUnÃ¨ in tenebris clirford^fnt. Ã¯tdque ^'^Ãf^f^ â iÂ«gcÂ«io)Ã¯ uoceMur,utlifet, dumumen conÃet, contu*''^Ãâi^JÃ.fi^'' meliofe fc Ãuddri difertum, i^ihUomimus conÃten.duitWffâ,'âÃfâquot;'^â^Â°quot;^ eSletidmdetrdheredoSlfmimdliquidiUtlmdmj^udi* buSjZycotesMeUbuSjZTUinquetuÃdfemjfeduitidi^fjâÃ*^^^ ^^ trMt^tÃ¿ueo folo mmus e^,quod literie perpolierut^^^^^quot;^-^'^ qÂ«o melias, Ver urn bi prqniMcidÃ¼one^uqq^ fAmimdiffv^-Zi-^^ Â«J ceniiforti^'quertvnt.'iidm o* cldmdnt ubiq^,Ã©yâ omnid * -^27^ ^ nbsp;nbsp;lt;nbsp;lfH4t4,Mtipfiuocdnt,mdnuemÃ¼^i^t,muÃ¯todifcÂ»rfu,iatp,y^Jamp;(f72 4 belitujilt;t(ldtione^gefu,motÃ¼cdpitis furentes. Idmconi'quot;^ ? f. deremAnÃ¼sfterfe pedcmincutere^f(xmurâpedius,fron*fquot;'.'fquot;. â

lt;pHHArgt;v .^rrry*rb /ojzrtMu wf^-^J?*â*â z quot;' ^T nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;/ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;/

f nr^ .gt;^gt;^ JIS M. F4B. QVINT. INSTIT. Z^-Ã¯â''''quot;,r'Ã ^gt;^clt;^â^^re, mircddpuÃAtÃ¯inrcircuÃ¯iim f^cit,cuM r^^f, rvjgt;^tv Ãª f^ ^'^dUuijUt'mordtionemult^.fubmittcretiu.riire.dif^O; 7r''j6 ^âilt;^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^ prom/m^dofimtn cuilt;p eoriMÂ», ({ne ^^h^gt;â ^U' ; t-ot^v^^r t dieet color i Ã¤ccomoddre ddu /cidt^ or Ã quid fit per ft* c^, .i-x''!'â-^ â tudobferUdtionedigmiytnodeflicseU'eetutderimilit.Ãi f^lhdwumdpfieÃUMtflÃ¼jeeilpotiufuioleiuid.Cu 'tnte ^^ ^im nonddores modi dUquos muenidt/ed quad eÃ tut â*''â gt;.-lt;.^/^ f'^gt; prxeeptoreietUmqui brcuÃ¨dicendi exercitdtio^ â r,^ ^at * 4tinemcÃ³nfiecuti,Ã¶milJdrdtione,uttulitimpetut,pdfimtii lt;t,, ^,a fi'âilt;^^^-'fifixltucntur^eos^ qui plut honoris literis tribuerwttfit ^.rÂ»/gt;^^[:'H.i.^,4 ^P^Â°^Grieiunos,ettrepidos,etinfirmos,utquodi^u(f }^ff ^^V^^^ bum conttimeliofifiimivin occumt,dppellent. Veruidis^^,, yZ^,^/^'--^â^-^'*^â^^'^grdtulemurfineldbore,finequot;rdtione'finedi^i* ! lt;,., ^Â»ry'44rz. pHnd difertis. No;qudndop^cipiendi mimus o' ilt;i^ â *â^X.^^ tÃ³ f^^'quot; depreedti fuimuf,O' in faro quoq; dicendi,qtdd ' G Â»*^^ ^ffi hqneÃiÃimum finem putdbdmus, defimere dum deÃdeni j remur,inquirendofcribendoq-idiid,confolemurociunt j nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;noÃrum, quÂ£ futurd ufui bonx mentis iunenibus drbi''

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;MfÂ«'â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tramur^nobis certc fu^t uoluptdti.

1 ^/ .â¢ â ^ j ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^Â° â^^^^'â ^ â^ exigdt id pritceptorum genus,

'^ ^ _^ l.yquodeildplerifq;firiptoribusdrtiumtrdditu, ^^Â°^â^''^^^^^i'^fiâlââ^fddmlÃ©gesimmutdbiÃ¯inecefiitdte confcri* f^^^h^'â/f^.^^ftâ*^Â°fi^quot;^^^erMt,Vtiq^ procemiumyO H q^ k r â¢^â re.^rrH ^/w er/.- ^âP^f^^^^^ ffs^ftâOtio quÂ£ lex deinde ndrrdndi,pro L^J^ ^â ^^.t't^^^Â°^'i ^?i^iÃ¤Ã^^^ â^ ^^is^dm pÃ¯dcuit,excurfio,tu/fU ,1 i X^ f^^ ctftusofdoquÂ£Ãionum.,cÂ£terd^uelutÃdUterfdcere â^^ ^ Afv^im d^ fff fut nonfit,quidum tun^ wÃi feqptm^riSrdt enim V,^ ilt-âtsr flYA ffr^- fusn y^iCi^ \ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;*'^ , âÂ»**t iilÂ»*? /-gt;â¦ âJ^n * *i^rrvrgt;^ ' ^^^ -

ORATOR. LIBER II. 119 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;I

ioÃ¯lceYesprorfiKfMilKAcpdruA,ftwno(^lreuipriegt; , w,Â«.Â«fr I fniptocontineretur^S^mutAniurpleraqiCiiufis^tem^iT,Â»'/^^^â â' | poribui^neceÃitdte,occlt;ilione\ Ati^idcoresin.ordtOYe'''^'^'*^^'^^ '^ | pr^cipMconÃUwm(R t^uuMric,2j^\ tdcoiKrtitur.CiMdqienim pmeipidf imperdtori,lt;iuÃ³y,^. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^ ^

*^^^^Jm^'^S^l^^i^^^i^'^tfrontem, comudutrm^pro/^^/r4gt;^ ^'Â»Â»' moucdtyd^uitesprocomiliiitlocet^'ErithdC^qMdctnrc, _ ^^^^'^ ^^^â Ã¼iÃmdfprtdfÃerdti0,(juotiesUcebit,(edmutdi}iturnd t^iâ quot;'' turd lodfi mans occurret/tfiÃ¼men obfidbit,coÃ¼ibut,fyÃ¯''^â^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;j

UK^dÃ¼d. ue diÃeritdte prohibebitur.iiutdbit hoÃiumge ^p^J_ÃÃ2â-^-7â^'^ nMhutdbitprÂ£[entlseoditiodi(crimmif:,nurx'dcicdi

Ydid^nwne cuneK,nw)K duxiujs, nunc legtone pugndbC idr, nonnivnq tergd etidm ded ifje Ãmuhtd fugd prode^ ^^ \.,i.^d^^ gt;nbsp;ritdtdproxmiunecclfdriimtdnfupcrudcuu/m,breucdn'^'^ f ,^gt;,,4^^ longiut dd iudue^mni^e^mpne diredo, dn dUciudndtf^*^^^^^'^ duer[opeidlilt;iMmpgurdnki'iccnduÃt,con]hi{iddnld, \^c,4'^ c.,*^ tins Md ndrrdtio.cot^ud ^ diuifd^redd dit ordine peri^* ^^c^^^ , a^ WHtdto,cdujiedocebut.itemq;decMdÃionuordAie,cum^^f^-;^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^

tdi excogitduit.Kon negdbo dutÃª Ãc utilee(ÃeplerÃ¼q;t^^^Ã^X^^J^''''^ iliocpii necÃriberciuerÃ¼ÃtddeiÃd nobis Ãuddebit utili

tM)}Anc,reliais mdgiÃrorum dittoritdtibtiSjÃeejuemur., ; Ã¿z^ ^V-^-i E^Hidem id nidximcprtcipid, de reitens iter urntje iti ^ ..^. rum^monebo^^ '^sduMinomntMuJÃe'deYÃr^orf ^ /^ Ã^l^^^^^t^M^^xpeiidt-Expedit dut [dpe mut dre ex ! / ^^â^ _Â«Â»Â«âiÂ»Â» iHocoÃhutOilrdditÃ¶^ crime aUijitd^Zp' interim deeeti^Ã^Ã;^^-^^'^^^

'^Â° M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT- ^^ Â»^wri^VjV nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Mt mlidtuis dte^ue piÃurisuidemiii, UAriArihitbitui}^

i^^^i-Ã¨bi^ ^ it^dipedes, ^ dfwhmis'dd imd rigens opuff ^v^^^' '^^quot;^'â ^ fi^xiÃ¼amp;^Gr utÃcdixj:rnn,motuiddtÂ°ddiim'cldenidtn 'Ã¼^i ^.-,r.- ., â ^. eÃÃdK,,idconecdd iwmmoiv.rnÃorm 'Ã¼ ' Ã''^ , â^^â''^ m'mÃurntÃe ^nuT^CitrfiimJjdbeiÃ¼'Ã¼uxddma'i^^

^c7fCQ. funt^i^dmmixtdc'^roeÃ't^dtdmd'iÃÃ¶rtÃ¼^^ eUbbrdtum, ^udm ed iUe Difcobolos lAyronii f Si Huif

tdmÃ« ut pdrum redum improhet oput, nonne di intclie du drtisdbfuerit,m aud Â«rJ pmcipuc Iduddbilis dl Â«Ãlt;lt; Jri/^ ,Â«^gt; ipfâtiiouitlt;UdcdtfficMidfiCiudmlt;iuidemgrdtidmctie âquot;i^^/ ^i^iÃ¯?^ d^runt figure, quÂ£^ m (cnfibus,(iuÂ£^ Â«* 1 v uerbif funtJ^utdi etidm aUquiddredo^dte^ hdne prf Â». ^ ^^ ^^gjff ferunt^quod d confuÃ©tÃ¼^^me uulgdri rtee^ runt.lldbet m pidurdf^ccient totdf^ies. ÃpeUes tdme omifli imagine Antigoni ÃdterÃªtdntu ditero oÃedityUt dmiÃi

â¢H. ^^fr^i^^ni'OculidefornitMIdterct.CiuidCnon inordtioncoperi^â mdd fwnt quÂ£ddm,Ãue oÃendi non debent,Ãue exprimi

^/ P^â^ iathi^itd' Cithniw in ed tdhuU, qM Colotc Teium uidt. Ndm civtn '^âZ'Z~- ^^^^^ /.V ^ Iphigenix immoUtione pinxiffettriÃem Cdlchdntem l'quot;'^'' ''^^ triÃiorem'VlyÃcmdddidijÃt,Meneldolt;iueinfummMn 't3J\4^'2i*icâ ^ P^l^^^^^ ââ^^^ eJ^ceremixporÃ«,confumptK dffidibiu non lt;Ã¯gt;4Â«.Â«j. ^âf nÃ©pÃ©riens quo digne modopdtfÃ¯suÃ¼itumpoffetexpri* ir^ ' ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tnere,uelduit dut cdput^etfuacui^dnimo dÃ©dit dÃmd

CAYtygine ticerc fAtim puto,(iuAnt pArum dicere^Pro \,J^Z^Ji^ ptcr eine mihi Temper mor is fuitcpMinmnimc dUigAre quot;ââ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;y 4^

me Ad preceptAi^Uic Â«a0oAÂ«Â« uocAt, id e^l^ut dicAmta ^t^^Ar-rT ^ quoiÂ»odopolJumuA)uÂ»iuerfAliA,uelperpetiMtiA.RAro enm reperitur hoc genns^ut non lAbefA^iri pArte aU'^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â^^ ^A'/t^ ]

i^uAji^fubruipoÃit.Seddehiipleniui lÃ¹o^Ã»ice^ locoiâ^'-^fl trAÃAbimus. IntcrmnolofeiuuencsÃnis quem ex his qui breues pleruneÃ cirewmferumtur, Ariis hJ'^^ i Ubclium edidicefmt/zyÃ¹Ã¨lut d^ccreiis technicorumiu* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â ^'^/'^

tospMent'-lÃuitolAborejAÃiduoÃudio^riA exercitA^^.4.^ ^, s^f: ^â-^ tione,plurib'M expÃ¨rimentis, AltiÃimA prudcntiA,pre*^â' ^^^â' fentiÃimo conÃlio coÃAt Ars dicendi.Sed Adi^tur hiSp'e gt;^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;-^y

quot^/UAmenrÃ¨llA uiAm,non mAorhitAm monÃrenif' â ^'^'quot;^ AquAdedmAre quicredideritnefAS^pAtiAtur neceffiil.^-;^^'^quot;quot;'''' eÃ¼ iUAm per fÃ»mes ingredientium tArditAt^m. ItÃ³^ cr^^ Â« c^M. ;.^ Â»^~w ÃrAtu/nmUitArilAboreiter fApedeferimw eompendia^^^^^ ^ dudi,crfi redi^ amp;item rupti torrentibus pontes m-gt;â ^^^ Â« ^âlt;,. eiicYmt,circuire cogemur,t:i;-Ã innM tenebitur tmeen* y'quot;^' '^'^â'^ dio,pcr pArietem exibimusiLAte fufum optu e^^et mul ^quot;'â^, ^ ^^Ã^' tiplex,zy props quotidie nouum,cy de quo numqui di^)^ ^^ ÃA erut omniA. QÂ«x funt tAmÃ«irAditA,quid ex his opti pyÂ»lt;^^ mum, ^ ÃquA mutAri,Adiici, detrAhi melius uidebitWt iKereexperiArÂ»

RHftoricen in ÃAtmum trAnferentes, turn OrAtoÂ» .riAm,tum OrAtricem nomimAuerumt, C^os equi dem nonÃAudAuerim debitA hude^quod copium Romd nifermonis Augere ientAueYUtU.3ed non omniA nos dut

b/UAT M^ ^ j rentes cx gr^co fe^uuntury peut ne iÃ¼o$ciuÃ¯dcm,(iuoti^ i r-^yif art^. ^'esfuifutilt;^uerl)iffignArenoflrduoÃ¯ueruÂ»t,0'^i^^^^ â ' ^^ T^ Mtkr^*^^P^ftdtio non mmui dura eÃ,^ ittd Plduti,eÃenM it^ jl' V tÂ«.^ /-Â«in^ Â«r^t-rw ^neeittid, Sed ne proprid quidem: ndm ordtorid ÃcejÃ ' ' bl*''^ ,â^''quot;'^â~^ Vftur,Melocutorid,ordtrix,o-Â£locutriXtiUddutÃ«i( ; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^quot;^âit ^'â'^ Ã¯oqumur rhetoried tdlis eil,qudlis eloquentid. Nff

; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dubie dpud Griecos quoÃ duplicem mteUcHum hdlti-

NrfÂ»$ KÂ«p modoÃt dppofiiult;prsjhetoricd,ut nditis pi* rdticd:dttâ¬rianothÃ¨nrÃªi.^iidlis eÃ philofophidjdmtciti^-ii /'^â^tZXâquot; N0^Ã¿pÂ«Â«WÂ«0lÂ«WÂ«j/i^l^41T/Â«t^lt;(Â«(SM,Â«^F^ i' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;o rn^^riÃ© neeUtc^dtoridquÃ«ddmodÃ¼ordtorid*, 'urm in rhet^driÃ

dj Â«^*^77^:3 -lt;7^^ non fit. i^on pugnemm igitur, cum prefertim plurintif fn * ^^i^-âJSX^^ dlioqui Greets fit utendu. ^dm eer te ^Phyficos,wÃ t vj Â»gt;gt;^n,^,t,- (osO'GeometriifdicA,neuimdffÃ¨rdh^nomittibusigt;i* M Â»^âÂ«(_ â7quot;''âÃdecordmtdtinumfermonetnmutdtione.'Deniq:cumt^â â â ' TuÃtws etu ipps Ubroru^ quos bde de re primÃ¼ feripp ydt,titulis Greco nomiiiie utdtur, profcÃ«lÃ¨ non eH uer^ â¢^^^/quot;^^ quot;-i du,ne temereuidedmurordtorimdxmo de nomine d'T* lt;Â«^Â» rrgt;..i^/i^'â^^^i^ Ã'^ credidi/Jc.Igitur rhetorice ( idm enim fine nietu t' fi.^(^x ^^Â». cduittdtiottisMemutJ}dcdpeUdtione)ficutopinoropti* ^lâ^^'Ã^ â^^ nbsp;nbsp;*^^ diuidetWjttfde drte,drtifice,de opere diedmus.^

* ^r^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;erit que dijciplmd percipi debet, ed eR bene dicendiÃi

â^.-c t/'i,^,^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;drtifieeÃd eÃ bond ordtio. Hec omnia rurfus diducun*

/yi^âj/'/^ ^Â«, ^-1, turfit l^cies.SedilldfcquentidfiioÃ¯oco,niic que dept*

ordtores dici putdnt: Alij (quord^n nas fetttcntiÂ£ dcce-^ dimui) nomen hac, drt em'ij;dc qudioc^imur^bonddo

njitm tribui uolumt.^rum dÃ¼t,lt;iui diccndifdcultdtem mdiore,dcmdgiiexpeteniduitÂ£ldudeficernunt.Qjlt;i* / ddm rhetoricen itim tdntum, amddm fcientidm, fed

Uirtutcm,(piiddmu]wm,ciuiddmdrtemc[uidem,leddjci^ m^r^/n.-gt;gt;d3., b-lt;*.lt; entid^Z7 uirtute feiunddm, quiddm etidm ^Mitdtem

^utfirÃ¨mperfuidenda^dut indicendodppofiteddper^^^ ^ ^s/fi^dâ; fuidendum, pofitum ordndi mitnusfivnt drbitrdti.id e* nmfieripoteÃ dbeolt;Ã¿iolt;iue^([uiuirbonusnonfit.U^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^â^JÃ¯^'f^

igiturfieeptentiÃimui finis rhetoricÂ£ uis perfuidendi^^ '**â^ ^â''â^ QÂ«od ego uwÂ» dppeUo,plerii^ potefidtem^nonnuUi fdf-cultdtemuoednt : ^Â»Â«e res ne quid dffÃ¨rdt dmhiguitdtis,^

â¢turn dico tIw i}^mlt;x./d.ii}.}iiec opmio origjnÃ« db Ifacrd AliÃ¢s. uim te(|Ã¯ tdwen re uerd drs qua circÃ¼fertur,eius eHyduxit. â*âââ^ quot;*ââ*â QÂ«icHÃoÂ»gefitduolÃ¼tdte 'vnfdmdntiÃ¼ordtoris officid,^'^^quot;^'' -^y quot;X fnÃ«irtij temerÃªcowehedit,diceseffÃ§ rhetorieÃ«perfod''^quot; '' *^*7'âV deaiap^epdest,-aeiÃ«'s^lt;rH!j,i'ts^yop.Ã¯iieqientmnim^ ,lJ^^^ pntifirimeddÃ¨utidecldrdtione,qud Ennius M^Cetheg^^^Ã^ ; a^m^s Suddit meduUdm uoedt. Apud Eidtonem quoq^ Gorgids '' ^ * â^^^Zne^ w Uhro, qwnommf dm 'mffriptiae^, idem fiere diciti

124 H. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT, fed hlt;inc Pldto ittiut opinionem unit dccipi,non fiunt-Ct

/, w... .v . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â^^â'0 pluribus locis firipfit, ordtoris officium effe,dice* . -^lt;lt;iyc..- , r^ '^' ,redppofiteddperfuddendum.lttrbetoricisetid^uosf^ Æ ^^â'' ne dubio ipfe non probdt^finem fdcitperfuidcre .âvint

Crpecunidperfuddet,etÃ¿rdtÃ®d,eiduioriidsdicenli5,fi * ^ ^ TTquot; 7^3gt;vV ^^ dignitds,poÃremo df^eÃ¤us etidm ipfe fine uoce,lt;^uo ud y f'gt;^ .( . recorddtio meritorum cuiuf^y uelfdcies dUejudt^iferi^

lilis^Hcfl^ormipukhritudofentÃ©ntidm diiiit.NdinÃ¼' Ck^ro^deÂ° j,^^^^i^^^^Ã^ A^oip^yCum fciffd ueÃe cid Oratore j. ^trices (fuM is pro pdtrid pe^Ã³re dduerfoju^cpiffet,Â°* amp;nbsp;c nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â¦ âw ftf^^^^^^^ ^^P^^ hdbuit Ãducidm/ed ocitlis popuH

y *Â» if^lhc jo *^ i'lt;âA^ Aom'dfii ditulit uim,einemiÃ¼oipfo dÃtedu mdx'memo*

'twin in hoc utfolueret re^ycre^itum elttSeruium epi* , j^^ ^ jj dem Gdlbdmmifcrdtionefold,(judnon fuosmodoUbd Sulp. Cicero ^Â°^ puruulos in concionem produxerdt, fed GdUi eM^ -t4*^ * Â°^â*â? -^.SnlpicijfiUwm fuis ipfe mdnibus cir^tulerdtfÃªldpfwn^

' efjÃ¨yfum dUorum monumefttK^^Cdtonis ^,r^tiogt;^^ J f^f^ retneine' J^.^*R f^*'^ Phrynen non Ãyperidis dÃ¤ione efiunp^ /v i^â4fpienfem ca' dimirMt,fed conÃ^edu corporis, eptod ilUÃeciofÃi* /r^f ^an^ab Eu' â*âââ ^lt;^^i didudd nudduerdt tunicd,putdÂ»t pericu* rjrâ^â¢^~'thyn3,defen lolikerdtdm. Qw ftomnidperfu-dent^non e^i bieÃf des^t^i cÃ¼ ^'âÂ° locuti fumus,idoncus finis, tdlt;^oÃ©p diligetiora ÃP fenfiffet non uifi fibi,lt;iui cum de rhetortec ide feinirent^e^iflimdr^ oradonefua^^ââ'*â^dicendoperfuddendi,Q_uemfnemGÃrgi^i^ â Indices, pro eodem,de ^uo fuprd diximus libro, uelut coddus d So* *^umue^^ '^^â^^^^â^^^^' ^ ^âÂ° âÂ°^â diffentit TheodeÃ¼eSyfiueip^ difcidit amp;nbsp;pe id opus eÃ¼, lt;iuod de rhetorice nomine eiifs^ mfcr3^gt; ^^TumÃ©' ^^â^^â utcreditumc^y AriÃotclis,inquoe'ii,Ãnem'^fâ

dent enim diccndo,ttfl dueunt in id dÂ«od wolÂ«nt dlij duo (Â® Â«?*Â®'^*â* y â lt;(Â»e,Â«t meretnceStMuldtoreSf corruptorcj. At Æ oWM roiutionem.^ â¢Â«

non pcrjiudcttemper orAtor^ut mtermnonÃi propri Vn U^^^^ ^^^^ â tM bic JwiK citw, interim ^itÃ§Ã§munii ewm bw ^Â«i lt;tb 0YA^ ^ ^^ ^ .^ *quot; â tore procwl dbfÃ¯wt, Atoni non multiwn db boc fuie dl* reo dices mi â cÃ A^oUolQruf,dicens,iuiiciAlK orAtionn prtmtwn er j^^j^ ^^y^ ^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

(Â«per omniA e^c,perfM,d,erc Mici, Z}- fententiAm eim usw iudi' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

dweere in id quod Â«clit.'Ndm er ipp orAtorem fortune tÃ®TrAthÂ«Â« â fAijcit, ut fi non per f^firit^nomen fuum retinere non us life. xin. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

fpofiit.Ãi^Ainrcceff'erivntAeuentu,ficutArifiotc\es^â^^â^^^ ^.^f^^ I (lutdicit,RbctoricecftuKW!Menifndiomnwwiordtiogt;;Jj^^^^,7j,.;,, â ne prrfiufibiÃ¼d, Qiii finis z^ iÃ¯Ã¯ud uitiwn, de duo ft* â¦ Â«^Â»Â«'^Â«Pâ /Â«^ â prddixnniw,bdbct,etMÃ¯/upcrcjuodttijiiMUc^tonemc^ J, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

finem effie demonfirAnt, dicere qux oporteat omnid dd ferfiMdendum,fiAtis refi^onfum efi^cum pcrfiwdcre non * tAntumorAtor^elfiecouicmus.AdditAfiuntloisAiiAUA*^ ^ ,^ Ã¯ie.Qttiddtn enim lm Ar es o'mnej, quidam dreu ciuiles '^^^ y^iftâ / â modouerfarirbetoricenputaueruMt,quorumueriiw u^^ â.^m , Â»â Â»^â¢'* Â»gt;â tnwn fit, in eo loco, qui buitÂ« quieÃionifpropritMcft/'â^ , ^ lt;./â,Â»u

' dicdm.omnidfwbiccijje oratoriuidetur Arifioteles,cu^âj dixitjHHneJfe dicendi, quid in qult;iqucrc,po/?ite(fc^^ pcrftwfibde.Ãt p4^roclÂ«,qMi non quidem adijeit in qÂ«*7Z kv c -.^ -Â«^ que re,fed nihil excipiendo idem oÃenditjUim enim noÂ» ^

^it muÃ§ntendi ^pdfa m ordtione perjw,fibilc,ciwp^gt; Z^ ipfi fÃ¶hnt dmplchtmturmucntionem. Q^oi uiti^i^^ * fugiens Theodors Â» uim pMdt mucnicndramp; elÃ³^flt;^

t, f^i.y^v -iÃ©,âh. c^Qrn4tucredibHiAmomniordtione.Sedcumcoi(i^ ' 4f.,n^^ iÂ«.Â»!Â«^ tnoi'ocredibilid,cpiopcrfiu,fthili4nonordtorinticniiih^

'^'^'^^^J' Adijciendo in omni ordtionc, mAgis qudmfupcriorcsi'^ ^^f^- ffff^', ,^ ccditfcclcrd qwq; fu4dentibu4,puÃ¯cherr(mie rcinoma'p Gorgididpud PhtoiKm fMdÃ«difeMificeminiuiidf ' t^^r^s nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^^^^^ ^titifelJÃ©^. De iuÃh ^Jp-Jfgt;igt;ft^^Ji

â ^^,v aÂ»v.Â»h^ fdcultdt^m.Ciuiue'iro-nonomnidfHbijciebdntordioriâ o tnm^i gt;,gt;^s â^^fp^'jgnfÃ¯fij^f ^^ uerlafiaf, M nfeejfe erdt, ddhibucrunt ^* fcrimind,(Quorum fiit AriÃon,Critoldi ^enpdtcticidif' fcipuluf,cuiiK bic fines eÃ¼:fcientid uidendierdgeniifd^y Iki^^^^* qnxfiionibuiciuiÃ¯ibuspcr ordtioneni popuhrispi^^ fnafionis. Uic feientidm, c^uid Peripdteticus eli,nonigt;^ ., nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Stoici,uirtutislocoponit,populdremdutcmcomprcbeii '^'h'â'gt;-â^âgt;^'^âfÂ»lt;' ^gfid^gpifÃi^ÃQfigffj^ (tidmcontumcliofusc^ dduerfd

â ^L, A nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^4rtÃ«ordndiflt;}tidmnihilputdtdodÃªspcrfudfurdmAHtsi â

.id^vjZi ^TÂ»w de omnibus e^ui circd ciuiles demtvm c^udÃioncs oritore â â-^^'f indicdnt uerfdri,diÂ£lum fit,excludi db hÃ©splurifmd ofi^

^w â¢gt;^^^i ^p^quot; torica pars tertid.-OdMiuslheodorit! Gdddramdi^^* Z^-^J r^ gt;nff'^^titfgt;Ã¼cmtt(ttlt;fÃ¼4rtem pudern effee^^dwgt;gt;fgt;^ aj ^ro^ ;â â'^âââ tutem putduenwtAtd enim dicit(ut ipÃs coruw nerbH \ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^Ã¨^â^â^Â°irdnÃulerjmt)^sinmx,amp;

amp;ide:Vii iiccnÃ¢i er floqÂ«tndi dercbuiciuilibutfub. t^â^^^;^ ;,/^^ I ieSiKÃibitcamfiMdAmfcrfÃAfioneyttfinodim corpora

hAbitUfereorivmtlUiedicetpronuncidtioncMiÃ¼ealidj,^^quot;''^ quot;' *quot;quot;â*3'^ l fed dut eddem,Aut ex ijfiem compofitd,^uÃ¯bta item cum

ÃtuiddmcdmneO: ummea- feientum,neck drtÃ«putd^e^ tr^a^-^-j- I rut^fed CÃ»toldiu ufum dicendiJ^a, hoc TÃSnÃgnijicdtlt;. L'*ââ:Ã¦Â«a^j,f;/gt; l AtbfrtfiÂ« fdUendi drtem.Plerilt;^ dut dum pducd ex Gor^g* ^p^j

dnino^eÃ¢Ã«m Mi iuÃieidmi Aduldiionem dutem medi tmÂ£^uocetcolt;^uorum.MipÃ um,er fxemtdtncKmM^ ^^ v^ ^^^'i ' goÂ»ttm,qÂ«i colore)Â» 'fucoyZ^uerumrobur'mdnifAgmd'^â^' ^quot; '^â , ^^midmurjegdlis'cdÃ»iiÃ¯ddicÃ©^u^itiie YhetoricÃ¨. QaÃ omnU finÃ®t lt;^dÃ« Ãriptd 'm^oc Ubw, dift4^ i Socrate tHMÂ« perfoÂ»lt; uidetur PldtoÃgniÃcdre (ptid fej^idtSed Soevatis per ^ [Â«Â«t cim fermonesdd codYguÃ«hdos,lt;[Mconird diÃpu J^^^^Â«rpÃ¼. tdntnmpoÃti,^uoi^Y^^ uoedM^dijdd fY^ed^quot;^'Z^ j^ tÂ«eÂ»dMÂ»4Â«{ Ã¦o-y^S^^oÃ® rffpelUWw. SucrÃ¢tes dRi JfJUÂ» ,^*Â»lt;^

UX M. FAB. oyiNT. INSTIT.-,^,, Pldto,cciin ^uidem^^Uie tumexcrcebdtuY', rljetorictn M lent putiit,ndm z^ dicit bis uerbif : t^to/j ^p T^ÃTtop, Ã¶p i/xe(= TsoTimyi^Ã®^ NoÂ« tier dm dutemer honejidto inteÃ¯ligitt Itdlt;^ dij^utdtio i^d coMrd Gorgidm ia c^^^ ditunoinapwayw T ^mv^tKop J^lucciop iÃ¯vAi,\^^ Ã¦' KKiop ÃÂ»Zilt;Ã5 J'!gt;lt;.xilt;x,i{Q^ 'n^aiff^/}. Ad^wd tÃ³f jâ* dem coiUicefdty ^ed^ermonem ft^c^it PoliÂ« wuenamp; c^ lore mconÃderdtior, coatrd lÃ¿tem iUd de fimuld^o amp;nbsp;dduldtione dicimtur. Turn Cd^dis ddhuccoheiidtior, e^ui tdmen dd hdne perducitur cÃ¯dufuldm, kp fx^o^l'^^ ofSÃ¦Ã§ jnro^iKop ia'ilt;^,d'lKÂ«iÃ³p aja tfe dvcn t^ Ã¯â'''^â* P-ova '?n' d'iKoÃ³wp^ut dppdredt Plxtoni non rbetorictti

uideri mdlum,fed ed^ uwm^niÃ iu^o de bono^ non coÂ» tmgere.Adhuc dutem m PÃddro mdnifejiiui fdcit,bdnc drtÃ«confummdricitrdiufliciefiuoc^fcieMiAnonpojfci i ^ ^^/,t yiâ,ni/,) cui opmioni nos ^uo^ dccedimus. An dUterdefenÃene ni t^rhf Soerdtis, Greorumaut^ro pdtridceciderdtttlduinÂ» jnr,. n,Â» (j Â» 2 ââ''^fcripÃlJet^ qiM certÃ¨ Ãmt ordtoris operd. Sed^ in Hb^^ â

hommivmgenufjtjuodfdcultdtediceniimdÃeÃ¼tebdtitr, Æ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;inuedluseR.tidmo'Ãocrdtcs^mhoneÃdmfibicrediib

xme feribere Utigdtoribus quit iÃ¼i pro fe ipfi dicertut, alicno g^^^ morK^^ itd iuri, quo non licebdt pro dUero iiâ ^^ refidt^xdhibcbdtur.rioÃ«iores quot^ eins dTtis,l^niiÂ» idoneiPldtoniuidebdnturÂ» ^uirhetoricendwÃiMÃ^ pdrdrentiZy nerts meredibilid praferrent-iJdm id qu9 y^qwdicitinPhtdro. ConfenÃjJedutemittis fuperiori^

fwnhQrjltor ÃmUf- tAWÃucri pctit.Dcnidf pdulÃ´ po^tÃ®^ ^Â»i^'* 'â ^' i Noncntm boni conÃientii, feiuidoru Utigdmis eft r ^ ^t mfâ'f/t^] frÂ£mium.QÂ£Â£Ãuerdtffent,^cÃimorim}iommtmfo^^ ^4,^Â»r^^-â^J^', , ret ,b(ec tlt;tm ftrniciofdnocenÃ¼ÃmK moriiwidre wi*^*â^^^.. ^^j-Ã¢^ , Prutnenti,^- Â«equitiÂ«Â» prxerptis ddiuw^re .Sed ini nl^quot;^ â¢^vi:-^'^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

tionem opimonzs fue wderint.Nos MtemmgreÃifor*^ p. Uw. Ã®f^'^ ^, Wire ^erfeSium ordtorew, quem in priww effeionume^^, lt;^^,^,;^â â^'^ ' , MtrtwnMolMmtWjdd'coÃ¯jqtttdcbocopcremcViwfe^iiwt,â' ^quot;^,^ ^.^^^ , rcMertdmMr.Rbetortccn dutem quiddm ednJem cittilitdA^' ^..t^.gt;^ ^' tem c(Jf tudtcdÂ«cruÂ«t.Cicero Ãientie duilis pdrtem Â«o* 'â¢^^^âââ'!^,âZiZ!t^ , cdUciuilw dutew/eÃ¯entid idem quod fdpientid eft-Qui*^*^âââ^ ^ââ¢**Â® nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

dam etidm pbiloppbiXjquoÃ¯tim eft ifocrdteÃ¯: Hutc fub. -; '^â^J^'i^2 ytr , PdntiÂ«mdxi)neconuenit)Ã¯nitio,rbetortceneUcbettÂ£di'''^'Â£,^,i %Â»t^^-*;^ eendi fcientidm.Ndm er ordtionis omnes uirtutei fcmcÃ¯c^h^^'y ^',f,tr^f'-^gt; comp[cftitur,erprQtgt;MiMmoÃ¯CÃ®ettdmordtorK,Ã§i^bc^xflt;-gt;flt;' yh'-^^-^ ne dteere non^oj?it,ni/ibonult;.Idem UdIctCbrjfippip*., J^â^quot;''^** ^^^^ nw fllf duflus d.CledÂ«lt;e,j^ien(idrefteJicendi. Suntplilt;^^^â*/v.^Mv. i^ reseiufdcm,fcddd dlidj qu^jtioncÃ¯mdgispertinÃ«t. IdÃ«*â^ -^ pwirct Ãnif boe modo âcomprebenfui^perjuddere quoi oportedtjnyjquoJdr^dicxit^dUigdt.Atbcncdr ^^ i(^âr-f^ rÂ«^quot; tK,dicrrc fecundu uirtutem ordtionis.Excludunt Xrb ^i^quot;â'*^?,^â^*^ ' torice md!oÃ¯,cr tiliqut 1'cientidm ciuiliuo^cioriwn edM'quot;â-â' 'â pjrtdufrut,/i feÃ¯entidm uirtutem iuiiednt, fed dngufie in j^y^m-,,, trdciwilfjqMaeÃionejcoercent. Albutiiwnon obfcurtÂ«^ Æ*Æquot; pÃ¯off(for dtqj dutor, feientidm bene dteendt effe confen quot;nbsp;'^â \f'^,'^f^^'^ Xlt; ftyfei excepttontbui pecedtyddijeiedo ctrcdciuiles quXtff-^'Vâ'*'â* Ãionej, Q- credibilitcr, quorum Ã¼m utrique reÃionfum ^, ^.i ^...-i p^v fft.ProbdbilwCZilliuoÃMtdtK,quireflefewtiÃ¯eerii'â ^^^

j nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;150 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTiT.

Vnw^^ quot;Ã^!^^^â^^ ^j^SÂ°^^^*^^ Pâ^^â^^^tMrt. Hl fivntferÃ¨ fines twlt;lt;5tÂ»Â»( t.fhf â^,,gt;,^AÃ© ittufircs,^dequibusprigcipuedijfiutAtur.tllt;igt;noninet I AX/^quot; ZZiSf^^mperfiequinec Minet, neepojfium^cumpr^ ' A 'rrmrhroj^-i- ,^â quoddA,M Arbitrer, fiudium cirÃ§d feriptores dr fin exU: fÂ£^\j''-i,n^n-'^^ terit,namp;ilijÃcmuerbis,quiâprior dUquisoccupdfiei^

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;r^nH,-tfj^fjj^(f^^if^^^iii(o^f0culal,ffil'^^P^l)lf-^f^()}iinw^

? ( nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;MiqrqujeMuetiero/edqugpUcebiwdficutfioc^rbeton

. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ceneffcbcnediccndifcientidm,eumre^rToquodesiÂ°* ptimiim,quiquÂ£ritdliud,peins uelit.iiis'dpprobdtisfi

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, mui mdnifefi^ efi: iUud quot^,quein finein,uei quid finit Cicero de ÃjttÃ¤n CT ultimum bdbedt rbetorice, quod ri\@^ did* Ãtero effequot; igt;*n,dd quod omnis drs tendit.T^dm fi eH ipfi bene did ait, quod 0' di fiientid,finis eins cr fimmum eH bene diceret-^â^^^ Ã SÃff*' .^^âÂ«{Â«^(^â/'^R'â^^quot;â''Â«' ^^^' XVII.-/' fententiata ^Equiturqihefiio,dnutilis'Rhetorice:ndniquidini

* Vi^^y ut adM ohâ L^uebementer in edm muebi(oient, zy quod fitindi*^ r.ygt;gt;Â»iA referri opor gniÃimum, in deeufdtionem^ordfionis_utuntur ordnii autinu^ ^ââtibus yioquentidm eje, quÂ£ poÃ©nis Ã©ripidticclejlos, ,Â«cuiutfrdudeddmnenturinterimboni,confilidduedmut ^petws^cc Jcditioci modo^ pofuuresje^^^^ inexpu' ld ctidtn inexpidbilidexcfientur,cuius deniq^ tuin mi

1 x/Ar^^ tifso^rate' ximefitufius,cumprofidi(tscotrdueritdtemuilet.t:iiii â ; 'Â»ic [ââ^ notÃ¼ cft ex 0quot; Soerdti obijciumt comd, docere eum quomodo pim ' quot;^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;5â*Â»^ Æquot; rÃ©medufdm meUorem fdddt^ZT contrd TiCidn,lt;y Got*

â¬ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;f p'nÂ» sjj nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â»Â»ÆÂ»Â»Â» A\vrr*H/Â»vlt; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^I9t^iif^i mtr^j^fquot;quot; r '

507 HtIÃ¶JXoTâOV . . fÂ» p nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;S / t 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;11' n/i

Kfinju wÂ«lt;' metojA non ImfftiKtdntumJfd rebut etumpMcitjv tÃ¯^^J.^ie,Ã¼ (loq^etM,turbMerintduitdtumÃdtut^eleuertcrWgt; '

fÃ³c(Mc er Ldccdifniom'Ã¼rum ciuitate cxpulpw, er A* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

tbenw quoique,ubt dUor mouere usÃ¢tes uetdbdtMr,Â«c* .,Æ//-gt;cm.J ^ *ââ¢'*â¢ iHtrfci/jmordndi pote/ldtem. QuoquidemmodoÂ«cc

nique ipptppifmid.Nam erduxFlaminius,cr Grdw nio contratâ ^V^â , cbi/s/turnmijGlducjiCmagiRrdtuSjCrMtweiÃicwJMue#i Â«end, er MI bw qut pbilo/opborwin nomine male Â«tunÂ« Annibale ge ^j ; tur ,griiMt/?(tHlt;i nonnunqiwm Ãagitia dcprebcÂ«fdfiMit,âÂ£â'^J^JÂ°â^^-i^;V ] Cibosdf^trnenmr, dttuleruntfÃ¦pctwlftudwiisciiufiWjxxn DeC. ' nunqium teÃd jubedwiÂ«, fupcr bdbitdntes dliqiundo ^^Ã§^âf^, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'

pTocumbunt. Non fahricetur militi glddiiw, poteft uti trum feditio ' eodemferroUtro, Quisnefcitjgncs,aquas, fine quiÂ»nibus-itct^

Â» A . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â dtSaturni'â ,

btÂ« nuUdjit uitd,cr(ne terrenw nnworerXolemlundiÂ«Â» nisc Clau* que prlt;ecipud Jiderum, aliquado etidm nocere^ Num igi '^ gâ^â^ ^I tur negabitur de/ormemPyrrbi pdeem C/cus ille Appi ceronis.

, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.VA , nbsp;. r

eloquentid,crcontrdlegci A grands popular is pit; annotait er Cdtilmac /rÃ©git duddcidiH.'âcr fupplicdtioncÃ®jqut

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ruit .^ Nonne perterritoj milittwÂ« dniwoj Jrequenter df'â

l LdccdiCtiionij, dut Atbenien/es magis moucri-nt, quam f populus Romanus, dpud quem /umma femper oratorio j * busdignitos fuit.EquidemnccurbiuwconditoresrcÂ»

iÂ« populos, Â«i/Ã® doÃ³l d Â«oce commotd: nee le gum reper* torÂ« Æ^fle [ummA ui orandi con/ccutoÃ¯, ut [e ipfi bomiÂ»

MfS dJ feruitutÃ« iuris djlrmgerent. QÂ»wj ipfd uitf pâ'* 41 ^^ ccptd,etidmfindturdfivnthonelld,pÃ¯ustiimendifongt;ii â¦wÂ«gt; tem I'^ ddsmentcsudlcnt,ciuotiespulchritudmctnrcrwin,c^'^ rÂ«YÂ»^ -^ttt^â^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tils ordtionis iUumMdt. Qj^dre ctiMji m utrdnlt;l^ f^'gt;^^

^X .Atv^ A pi ^ udlÃ«t drmd fdcunUf, non tdmÃ« eR lequum id hdheri i^^ -^â'^â' â^r^^ lu/m,lt;lnobeneutilicet.VeruhtcdpudeosforÃtdntliH ^((^/^^ lt;7^quot;^rdntur,(jui[ummdmrbetoricesddperfuddendiuimff^ ^â 'ZcKâ¢^â¢^-^'f'^^ilt;âltnlertvnt.Si nero eH bene dicendi feientid, ^uem nosji* O W â¢*vlt;J' fSi -r^rrtrUj^ â Ã nem fequmur, ut fit ordtor m primis uir bonus, Mfilf*â O2f '^2dii ^!^erte effe edm confitendum ell.Â£t her de deus iÃ¼e pr^^ y;s ^ Â«;^'quot;'gt;**''5 ceps,pdrens rerum/dbriedtor^ mundi, nuUo mdgis bÂ» Ã¼tfi,^Z^,T/^âC''nimem fiepdrduit d, citeris, quic quidÃ«mortdlid effent^ ''^*Z^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;smimdlibuSflt;ptim dicendi fideultdte. t^dm eorpord^dt

t -^ f\ta^y ' dem mdgnitud'me,uiribus,firmitdte,pdtientid^uelociti^ J^X-^m VÂ«*X te pnefidntiord in illis mutis Mdemus, eddem mmus egt ^^M^-,' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^ dcquifiiquot;^extrinficus opis.t^dm O' ingredi citius,ct

^y^t/Ãy S^h pdfii^O trdndre dejuds, citrd docentem ndturd ipfifci* nJ^d v^h-â^ââ^ tvnt^Etplerdduecontrdfrivusexfuocorporeueliiu/ii^ r...4 ^fi,nÂ»^^Z'^turt0âd,rtMb^smgenltdqudeddn^^erexobuiofereuif ,A-w nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. {lus,circd(juÂ£omnidmultushominibusldbore{i.^dtio

Mmâ'â^*Ã¿^4iÃ®**'^ â^*â ^2'^â' *^Â°^^ prgeipudm dedit,eius^ nosfocios eUt hv^d nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;t -cumdiisimmortdibusuoluit ^Sedipfirdtionecjuetti^

o /'^âhU. ,^nositwdret^wq}tdmejjetmnobismdnifeftd,nijtc[at y^xc-r^if ^ ^^â '^â¢â^âconcepiffiemusmente^promereetiAloquendopoffemtU, ' Æn k^lt;fiilt;'gt;c^ '^^^^nod mdgis deefie etter is dntmdlibus,qudm mteUeduÂ» 'i^ '?*ât^ /â.n.o ^ eogitdtionem qudnddm uidemusttidm f^dm cuU \it^^ iâd^yv^ Ud,0'nidostexere, oeduedrefatus, oexcludertt ^quot;iZ^dkâ^ ÃÃ i'*^^^ v^lponere in hyemem dlimÃªtA, operd qutinii

tÂ«r.DfÂ»i^ bomwicf, i^uÃ¯bui negdtd uox eH, ([udMulumZ,.^â^ diiMiitdnimuiitltcÂ«le^K^(^irefinihHddijsordti9'^rr,^er^iv,^lt;i\ ne meliui dccepimw^i^uid tdm dignwm ejjecultu dc ldio^

re duedmut, Mt w quo mdlmws pn^drc hommihutt nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â7^]^;

quoipfihommescÂ£terisdnimdUbus priaientiEo^uiÂ«-^ ^â^^ demmdgis, e^uodnuUd mpdrte fleniusldhor grdtidm refertAd'dd(Ã³mdnifejiumeYit,fjcogitduerimMwnde^/ ^C^ quot;nbsp;^â^â^jquot; e:^ c^uouffÃ¿ie idm prouedd Ãt ordndi fdciAtds,zy ddhuc ^. -gt; Â« ^ ^^ /Â»y Â«lt; dugÃ©ripote^.UimutomittdmdefenderedmicoSyregÃ©^quot;^^^iJ quot;*'â Ã¯e conÃ§Ã»tes fendtum,populum,exercitum 'm qÂ«Â« twlt dit^^n^a. cw,qÂ«4mÃt utile,couenidt^^ lono uiro,nÃ³nne pulchrH -jr' lt;â-jâ^â 7 Â«d hoc ipfum eÃ¼, ex commuai mteUedu ueÃ¯'bis(j^,([ui*'^^^^ ,X^-' -^ lus Mdmur omnes, tdgt;Hum djÃa^ui Idudis or gorille, ut

a Vbi after mouere.) AthensusXni.i^Ã®Ã§tJu'Â»Â«XÃ¯y^tÃ¯a J.tl'jÂ«TaÃTa^H?l5/iÂ«,/*n/lVÂ«0ln]l7'3^'â'5|JXÃ¯gt;Ã³vTWpÃ7riy TIVOJ, HÂ« Ã jbXiTji/dWf Tif UKTIiyOftu/XHOf, H TÂ«^ HKTH^OyK/iLnV *f'' Â»1amp;.H0C eft: AbfoIutaPhryna.fcitumfaftum cR, nÂ« tui di* cÃ«dipro altcro miferationc uti liceret, neue teum aut ream in iudicio afpici fas effet.

*sfiK\'Ks 'iv\i^^^lrlQ^â ^15Æa7^]s(ls^Æ Ã³v]Â«,|uÂ»kKjKÂ« thji tXXaJâÂ«,Id Â«ftJbi turn furens Pericles iUe Olympius,fulmine tonitrufj tontutbabat Grxciam.

AnRbetorice fit dn. CAP. XVIII. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,.,

intÃ¯ Â«omit ft expdttdri pdrtc m hdc,et mdiagere^ wil f: ^-.......i^Cttr di edm liwjha nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;J^

t^^4 j^fiÃ³,t,^tquot;^f^^fgt;/f4tÂ»prÂ£eeptadtcenditrddideruÂ»tjKmoÃ¨tt hitauit,utetiam ipfis librorum titulis tefiatum fit,f:ri* ptoi^osdedrterhetorica:Ciceroueroetiameam,(iufi -^Tâ,Â»/w ^^Ai( ^hetoriceuocetur, eÃ'e artificiof^clo^uentiamdicit. jp ^p.n^ma f.,.t.tCl^odnonoritorestaittuuen^icauerÃ¼^t,utftudijsilit'â Ã¨Â»^'tf^gt;^ 1 Aquot; ^'ââ^ ^ prÂ£fiitijje uideantur^fed ctimh'^ philojophit f 1^^''â/^^/^^^ CZ Stoid/t Peripateticiplcrun^ eSfientÃ¼mt. Acme dn 'quot;(â '^^^^nl^^â^fijfÃ^^2i^iinhancpartemq^uaeÃionistraÃ©ladM r^i'quot;^ '^m^^,,^^^â^^^'^â^'^ i^^ ^^ â^^fÂ® âÂ°^ eruditione modo,Ãi TO^^h^fti nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;4 fenfu reinotiu honunis^tfabricandi quiden (^ texen

Tr-f/m M. ^mM di,cr Ã¨luio Mfa diducendt artenrputet:rhetoricen m'' tefH^^ximumdcptdcherrimu,ififupradiximus,opia

^,^^7Ã¯'^Â»^ ^Memillos,qui contra dijÃutarunt,non tam id fienÃlÃ Mthex AanC^^/ifgitoddicerenti^exerceremgeniamateriaedifficiiltit^

'v}v(.tl.oe .i^. tnnlj, ar ClytemneÃram: q^nquam is, quoi his di^imile non j, ^t.y)^ fjJet,compofuiÃÃcordtionem,^ieeÃijab'âiiacÃ¶tttriSo'' crdtem,dicitur. CiJiiddm natur alemejfierhetoricen not lunt, er tdmen ddiuuari exercitatione non diffitentnr, ton^pad^ ^ ^ ^'^^ ^'^â'âââ^ '^^ O^itore dicit Antonius, obfert Cketonem. nationem quandam eÃe, nonartem. c^upd non ideÃ³^ut .if^'fta.agt; .5t... prouerodecipidmits,eÃpoÃtum,ÃdutÃikonqperfot ^/f^^ %quot;^' f^J^fuetursqmiiÃiHMldtordrtisfuit.uanedutemopi 11 ^'^â^ i, nionem hdbuiÃe Lyfias uidetur,cuius fententiae talis ie ^',it^ i^^^ aCfenfioeSl,quodindo{iicr'b'drtgt;dn,erferuiprofecuvn i^^i^f 3v^^ *-nrâ*'^ ioqwuntur,dliquid '^^ Iiinile pmeipio,narrent,p^^ *^ Ã rrAom^l lt;nbsp;;vlt;v;^ vV/ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^i*^ yo'HiebAiw i^ ,y^j^ i^gfr^^tV ^

ORATOK* LIBÃR 11/ IJS ' icni,reffutcitt,ra' (qÂ«od Â«m btamp;edt t^^ogi) dc^rec^^j^ tur.T3e'mdeddijeiwntiilMuerlgt;orumedu^ilÃ³nes,nihA . qÂ«od fx drtefidt,dnte drtemffuiÃe, dt^dixiÃe hommes 'âff/'^^â^ pro ffe,i!a- in dÃ¯ios ffemper,doctores drtis feroidm.O' eir pÃ§ orator crt âThyffiA er Corded primum repertos:ordtionÃ« igitur liba. ^^^^^ttffmÃe^eoe^drtenoneffe-HosporroeluAdoeoe 'â'^ffffâ''â'^^^ ^ pfrtr6w^ r^do(!Ã¯raZfioÂ»Uborlt;t(MtMcxqKircre,qtMnâÂ«?â7^Z â qudm dpud H^eru etidm ^rdceptorÃª Phxmeem, twit fÃ¤nro t^* Â«igfÂ«d^tuw^h^^Ã«dijtÃ ordiorespitres,Ã©romnemÂ»â^^- ^i' tribusdueihusordtionisgenus,raeertdmmdlt;iuo(^pro^^ A m /^ poÃtdeloepiemir inter iuuenesmuenmus. Qummex Decxlatura latHr^ dypei AchiU(s,et lites ffwnt,et ddores.illud enm Aââ^??lfj^

Aimoncre fdtis cR, omnid quie drs confummdrit d quot;ââ^^^^^ I rd mitid duxi^c^dut toUdtur medicittd,lt;iud ex Ã³bferudi- f^ ^^yZ, time[ilubrii die^i hit contrdriorwm refertd cSitzyut 'â â'^' f nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;I quiU/'dJ ^Ã¼cctytotd conjldt exf^mentis,'^dm er iwttX^J}Ã^ ÃâÃ I WiM ieligduit dUi^uis, dniec^ud bite drs effet,et feiirÃª c^ui-^j^b ~^râ^â o^ / -^ I titra-eS^mÃ¨i^iiyWm e^uidutwnÃ¨mÃ¼ideidtffcdciiiU^ff ^^^^^^ 1 id uiietudoipfdcoÃ«gerdtjimtigduit.itiecfdhYicd fit drsffyiâ

cdffs enm primi iUi Ãne drtefecerÃ¼t. Nrc muffled, cÃtd - -^ -^ ^^^.--r^ | tWdcffdÃ¯tdturpereimnesgentes dUquomodo.ltdffirbeffffffffff'I torice uoedri debetffermo quieunei^ffuiffc ei dnte^ effet s^C ttyrti Â£~t~^

ââ¢â Z^,. ââ*'Ã¯,co/Ã¯tflior.SjHfrofionqÂ«ifq(uMloqÂ«i(Â«roMtoÃ¯'cft,'ââ^*â*ââ^ Â«^lt; i Jb.^^o tttdmennontdn^ordtoreslolt;^uehdntur,neeeffffceÃorii'-^, lquot;^â^f'â'^toeemff^udrte,needntÂ£dYtemfuiffefdtedM.ur,(iU9rvi'i(^(^^ .j o^' C^Z^*^â^ ^â0$ exclHdttÂ«r,qÂ«od dÃ¯ct4Â«t,Â»qn effe drtis i^^^'''-^'ff^â^ff' quot;nbsp;y*quot;'.-! , f, ynv â. fdeiint^i tfon didieermt,diceYe dut hom'tnes,et qui no''-^ â^ V^^ T^ k âquot;ââ ' didicQHtiâ Ad f(Â«â(Â« rfÂ» toffrrddtione Afferunt Dewddehh0fi4Ã4 gt;Â»â¢ vlt;p^ J â ^â'^^^'^ â^ r^p'^*^^ â¦*lt; J(.r^^^ ph-br^htfruf- j nbsp;nbsp;^ c J lt;^^^^^ ***^^^^ ^^t

Â«55 M. FAB. O VINT. INSTlT. â rcmigem er Aefchmem hypoertten or dt ores fuijje t r fo-^^t^ tje^ orator effe t^ui non didicit^ poteR,Cf bÂ®^ fera potius,^ ntw^m didiciffe quis dixerit-.cpun^l^^ Aefchines db mitio Ãt iferfdtiu in liter is, (pus'p^ft â^* us etidm docebdiSiemdiemne'^non diJieiÃe certuÃ^gt; er contmud dicendi exereitdtio potucrit tdntu/m,efâ^â** tufeune^ poÃed fuit,fecijje. Hdm U potentiÃtmam ^ ^^h.'^â*i^^et fcendigenusell.Sed ddhucprgÃdntiorc,ÃdidicijÃ^f tc^^n^nhb Jdf^ futuruMÃiiÃedicereheet. fieepseenimordtiones Ãn w ui ^Â»'âl^ !''iereeRdufus,UteummuhuMUiluilTemdicendo fcii^[ % 7J^^!^''i,^'^' fnM.AriÃotdes^utfolet^â^u^endi^rdtidsurdonÃ^^'^ Ã.:^^h.id j^âgt;f^âr.â^i'tdtis Ãtgdrgumentdexcogitdwtin'GryllOjfedidentet, / 'f'-!â,^Ã¯lgt;l^i j^'^dedrte rhetoried tres libros fcripÃt,et m corumpti^^, non^rtem folum eimfdteturSed ei pdrticuÃM ciuiHtd* tis,Ãcut didkaicis, dÃtgndt, MultdCritoidus co^tlt;^ multd ^o4ius Athenodorus Â»Agnonqw^ ^detmxit Ãbi mferiptione ipfd Ãdem, qud rhetorices deeufdtione Epicurusdi profeffus e^.'^dm de Epicuro,qui difcipUndSomnesÃd gk^^'quot;** fâ amp;^:gt;^iM mirorM complurd dicu/nt, f:d ex pducis loeit dudd. Jtd(p potentiÃimis eorumbreuiter occurrdni,lt;ft ,ân nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;mmÃnitumeiueÃioeudddt.PrimdhisdrgumentdtioeX

, jKru/in,rhetorices nuUdm efje proprid,,^uod eÃefdl[ii/m v.y^^^w^gt;i^s -^feeptentibus probdbotdlterded cdÃ¯lmnid,nundmdt^ dSt ideft i^^^tfdlflt djfentire opinionibus,quid conÃituifine conf cognitionÃ© ceptione non poÃit,quÂ£ femper uerdfit, rhetoricen iÃ rcrim. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fentiri fdlfis,non effeigitur drtem.Ego rhetoricen noi

6ge^h( e nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nun^dicerc fdlfidproucriiconfiteborifiedtiQUiieoti

fiVi ^uo^i effe opmione cocedA^t^uid loge diuerfiim Â«Ãââ 7^â*ââââ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;I

ipfi qnfd Â»ii^^ ut dij uidcAtur ^^cfre. Nj cr imj^_^\^'^^â'^ji^Ã¨^ | YAtpr fAilti^titurl^pe/tttiAnnibAl/uminch^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^ j^,^^^ l

per no^ m m Aduerfos montes Agens ^rme^d^ljpecieni ho^i Abcutis exercitus deditjed iUwmfefe^t^ipfeeiMi^

- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;*****â1* ,7. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1 De Minvis

cedtemomut,cum permutAto cwm uxore hAmtUie cÂ»JtoÂ« |,lt;^ fâXit did ut muliereiuÃt, fdlfdm de fe opmionem bdbuit, fed Herodotus^ .^-, cujlodibuspr^buit.ltemordtorcu/mfdlfo utiturpro ue g^jÃ^'j^â^'^'â ro fcitfdfivm effe, eoej^ fe pro uero utitnon ergo fdlfdm pium apud Â»^*Â«Â» bdbetipfeopmionem, fedfdUitdUurn.^^Cjeew eum ^*Â«*â^gt;b.4Â» (e^nebm pffudiffeiudicibusmedufd Clue^ntijgloriA*^â'^ 'rlt;^^ifl-.^^i., /.;. tiM cft^ihi!ipfe uidit.'Ei pidorcwmuiArttifu^ efÃcitt^^fffÃâif ut ([ueddm emmere in opere, ejuxddm rece^iffe creiA* â¢ â ^ tniu,ipfe ed. pldnd effenon nefdt. Aiunt etidm omnes Arfff^Z^i^ s~Â«' a twbdkrf fnemdliijuempropofitwin AdcjuemtendAnt/â^'^ ^ bwKc modo nullum effe iarbetorice^modo non pr^Udri fffffff^j^ nbsp;nbsp;*3 gt;

eimt^M fYomittdtur ^mentiumtur. tios enim cffefinent^â^^Jquot;^ââ''ââ' iÃm o^endimus, e:T ijÂ«w effet dixmus t^^r^fidbit hwne nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^ ,

femper ordtor, femper enimlÃ¯Ã¨ne dieet. 7irmum AuteMfff^'yffff^f^ boe lt;[uod opponitur, diuerfus eos fortdffe fit, ([ui perA fuddere fnem putduerunt.Ãoffer ordtor, drs^ Ãnobis^-^ fmitd non funt poÃtd uAeuentu.Tendit ([uidem Ad uiHa'i^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'â''

fidm qui dicit,fed cwm bene dixit, etidmfi non umcAt,ii quoi drte conimetur effÃ¨dt. Ndm er gwberrwtor uult' quot;'^^fâ^-T y' fdluA ndue m portwm peruenire^fi tdmen tempeftdtefue rit 4brept(Â«,no idco wnw trit gubernAtor,dicetlt;^ noÂ»

nTX'lXS â^ ^m^^ti^^fi tarnen dut udictud'^ uJ^djfl^^ ferdmid legri^liÃ´uetjuocdfufÃ»mtnd noncoMigit,ii^'^ â¢\T^'i^Sâ^t^lt;âj^^^ipfcomnid fecundumrdtionem fccerit,mcdiciMÃgt;^^ ,Ã®frlt; Ti:,jLJii nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;non excidit.ltd ordtori bene dixiffe ÃnK cÃ.NÃ cÃ¼ ^fj ^tj^tfi^h^ ai'kquot; ^âlit ed,ut po^l pdulum cldrim oÃcnicmu^,m ddu poÃtij^o ^ Xnâ.-C^rft^^ w effv^lu. Itd fdlfum erit illud ^Ko$ quad diciMr,drtci Â»â¢'â¢â*â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fare qudndo ÃiH finem confecutÂ£, rbetoricen nefciffâ Ã^'^ZC^â^^^â ââ Nrfw/Ãªquift^ benediceremteUi^it.VUetidmuitijsrb^ toric^i^oidrj nuUd fdcidtlcrm^dniur^ ^'^^'^i^^^ â fnm ^ilt;^â^j^lt;^^^^utjnoMjt, QuoruneutrumÃ«h tut quot;^'di' /^{^ -t ij f^iftumexbondrdtioeproficifcitw,ideoq}necuitiv/iUt - v nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;i^dm O'mÃªddciiim dicere etidtnJdpieMidlieiMndocoU Aji^eeJfumeÃ¼ ; 0 dÃiHiu,fi dÃ¯iter ddic^uUdtemperdud '^

ai ^â*dexnonpoterit,neceffdriomouebttordtor.ttnpeÃ¯iti â'â ^!zr^-i!j^^-^ '''^ ^^^ t^diednt, o ^uiÃ-cquenter 'm hoc ipÃim fdUenÃ ; 4 4^^JÂ»ftâ¢ lt;.^,.Â«,^ Æ Ãmt, ne errent .UdmÃ mihi ÃdpieiUcs indices dentw, â¢^Z;lÂ»^Ã¤^ Ãpiemum condones, dt^ue omne concilium,nihil Ã¯nuif T^f^^^^'^S^''-Ã«^^â^^^^â^^gt; ^^^â^ SX^tid, nihil opmio prieftmiptdjdlftl^^ Æ ^y^w, ^yÂ»f-âl'^â^â'j teÃcs,pcrciudmÃtexiguuseloquentiÂ£locus,op^Â°^^ , â-5 .^Tt^^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;(Â°^''^ deleddtione pondtur^Ãm et dudientium mobÃ¤et

nnimi^o tot mdiis obnoxiduerUds, drte pugndniutÂ» '^'^fâ^yquot;quot;* â^^â^^ 3 amp;nbsp;ddhibendd lt;iuÂ£ proÃmt t neque enm ejuireRi ; v/gt;?XXA, A /i^c **^â^ depulfiu ed, reduci dd edm, niÃ dUo fiexu poteRlt; ^^ S?'*^i tytoricen eduiUdtio ed, lt;{^ â j^: fe-â^-H.. y;^^Â»'^ ex utrlii^ edufe pdrte diedtur. Inde hoc,nuUdnt eÃe it â-^.^ZâZlt;^'^'^'*ââ* temfibiconirdridm, J:iulldmdrtemdeÃrucrequodefi 7quot; Â«-^râc ^;^, â Ã§irit,dcddcrehoc rhdorices operi^tÃ¨^dUtdiddiCit^

ORATOR* LIBER lÃ®* 159 ^^^^* j^m^ (igt;rÂ«?(gt;iw j JocfrfjdHt non iieenit^ ita ud per hoe none^e Artcnt,â 'r^gt;

da prxcepei^_^tidmcÃ¨^U his doeedt. C^Â£ÃmiU^^Sj^'^~^:^^^ Ã¼pp^.ret de ipfi rhetorice did, ^!lt;3e fit Ã borto Ktro,4t^^â

fupoftitdccidere,utexutrii(jj p^vteor^or^ieÂ»mragt;^ sf^^Ã¹^i t^^n, ] loniKfdicdt'ddmen^umiiunhoe tpto^- '^i^^timnettwi^ f^efZe/ ' cad[Ã¯,wtdÂ«oÃ®Æap^f)^te^ aJi'qiufidy iwjÃ¯x caufie m diMcr-Â»!fquot;^'^^'-'Ã'^j-â-^^^-^^ ; /âÂ«m trabditi, (jwndoq; etidin pdgniÃ¼urosmter fe eos,Ãâr^'/^^ât^n^v^t^ ', ntioitiduxeritjcredunt^ re^ondeboprypofitis, â*^$Â®â^âh^^ ~âv^ ' iuqMidfm, ut dppireAthÂ£c differfta cos ciuo(^- frufircht^J^r**quot;^ CÂ»*â â 'w*Â» /t F f^eogitdtdjfiuimdlidmoributnonienordtoriimduigÃ©t^^^^fâJ^^fffff'^^^ \ c^^ TyUmrhetoricen estcontrdridfibi,cdufdenimciicdit^ '-'^,^' â¢âbt^rne^A , ^^ fi/ionÃ¯Ud fecumipfd^Mponitw.^ecfi pugnentwter^^^^-^'X^;^ , f nbsp;nbsp;fe (pli idÃ« didicerÃ¯nt,ideircojirs,lt;{Uie utriq-, trdditd c^*^^^4^X3^â^'l

non eritidUoepiinÃ¨cdrmoru,lt;fuidfnepeglddiiÃ¼oresfub'^-^ '-'quot;^^^ f^âJ^ \ \ eoicmmdgi^rocruditi'mtcrfecomponiwtur,nccgu^-gt;iti^T^f^â^gt;' , berndndi, ([uid ndMlibut prlt;elijs gubermtor ek guber*^^'-'^''/^'^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;\

ndtoridducrfui,necimperÃ¼oridj(iuidlmperdtorcum^^'^'^'''^ imperdtorecontendit. Item noneuertitoput rhetorice Ã®^^^ i ^i\,h^^i

, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;quod effidt Ã® Â»eq; enfin po/Ã¯tuw i fe drgumentum foluit^Zt^ '!^Z^jl^

u^r-p,ordtor,fed nerhetoriceeptidem. Qaw upudeo^quitÂ«^,Câlt;vo j^f i'-^'^ ^^ Â»7 ^rfuiiendofinÃ© putdnt,dut ft quw, ut dixi, lt;^iftf',duos^^-ff^'^ff^ff^^ ^^,^^ I^âi unter fe bonos uiros copofuerit,ueriftmHid quirenturt/^ ^â^ yz^'^Z^ ^ | nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Non dWemp quid eft ikero crcdibHiut,id ei contrdri^'^^f^i^. ^j,:dâ,,,. -^

I,^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^-, fââtMitft.'NecprtecipittMiqudmnondicend(t,necdieent '

\ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;contrdrid,fed quÂ£ in qiui^ cdufd dicendd fu/nt.^oit

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;feinperdutÃª^etidmfifrefiuenti^'mKUeritdXtuendderit, nbsp;U

| y.^nZ'lt;i^4^^'^'rj^^ dliqudndo exigitcomurtisutilitÃ©s,utetidmfdl[dda Ãâ I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fenddntur.Ponunturht c^uo^mfecundoCic.deOrdtlt; nbsp;** fj/^^'â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;lib.contrddiÃ¤ioneSydrtcmcdrumrcYxmcIJc qui^cha 'quot; lt;y ââ'â'â* 'â¢/^Â« tur, ordtom omnem dHionem opmione non fciemid ca 6^^^ 4,^/^gt;i^tinm,(^idcrdpudeosdicdt,^uine/cidnt,cripfcdi* ^â^â^ â^^flt;^^^^gt;^^ ^^ lt;dterum,id ell,dn[ci [ ii^fnhaib^^'i^imfâ^^â*^^^^^iâ*^diedtur,nihilddordtorisdrtem,dlterii hr.^^.^, ^^-' refpondcndum,Arsedrumrerumefi,lt;phefciuntur,rht^^-/âi7..a fo^c-i/^m fonceefi drsbenedicendi, benedut^mdicerefeitord\^,

quot;^ftÂ»! tkuâ^j nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dqud,dttt qudtuorjlemcntd, dut corpord m^ d^âty^'^gt;Â»i^\- ^ fecdbilidelTe,exctuibttsresomnesinititvmduxerÃ¿tt,trd -^

... yÃ¼ jT^ ^i^: terrt coUigunt^difdj^^dm tdmen fMm drtem uoedot' fj ^- Qji^dfirdtlocfficU ,uthÂ£c non opmdri, fed propter f^ it^/Zr fj.,Y^^^,. uim probdtionum fcireuidedntur^cddÃ« rdtioidpmff^ ^c/j e^ ^Â»^â ^/â¢â â^â^ a^YeordtoripotcR.Scddncdufducrdfit,nefcii.ticlt;^â

-Â» A..râ ^, j ;^ t w atem qutdem,dn dolorem cdpitK hdbedt, ciui hoe je f* 7'J^''''â'^ - nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tÃ© dieet, curdbit tdmen tdnqudm id ucrum fit,et erh^t^

r*vw rtt mediemd f Quidfquod rhetorice non utic^ proj^f^ f'^tr^ ni'^ji^-t^j^jiâ^jfxbct femperuerd dicendi,fed femperueriÃmÃW, ' âf'ff.^ Zâf^'^'^ dutem effe ucrifimiUd ejut dicit^Adijciumt hi qui eont^^ t'ri,''fÂ«'Â°^,'''^^râ?h ik fentinnt,quodftpequtindlijsUtibtuimpugndru/x^^* J^K e^M. jrrrivAAdorescdufdnvm,eddemin dlijs defenddnt,lt;juodnoX^^ 'f^tyte â / tifjfedhommiseliuitivm.llacfuntpritcipiiX'ii'^â

txi rhetoricen dicJ.mur,ilid et mmorti,Ã§r tarnen ex bdr-^)?-, - fontihut deriMU.Conjirmituriiutem eAmetTeArten quot;''^'^7â Mjn, ireuiter.'iJlt;imÃue,utCleiÂ»thesuoluit^cirseSl potc^M

fere probate Ãnis oifenudur hartem conÃare ex pnece Prohatus.) ptionibM conÃntitntiiut^zy coexerdtAtis ad Ãnem Mi ^ââ3 ^^* lern uitÂ£, iam oÃendimuf nihil non horum 'm rhetoriceTix^tiisi itÃ»S'i*^ , Melje. QÂ«icJ.'âqMod er 'mjÃe Ãione, zy exercitatione^ut ^'^â.âtlfÂ»^*''*^ quot;^ Ãrtefcoterie, conÃat. Nee poteft ars non effe, fi eftâ^j5âtâ^z.(., ^â^- Ars dialeaice,(ptodferÃ¨ conÃat,cimi ab easpecie mdgK ^^^i^j^^lâ7ti*â^quot; ' quim genere dijjerattSed nee iÃ¼a omitteda fwnt,lt;[Ua'm -ty^KÃ§ovTÃt^.Lâ^,. re alius fe 'martiÃcidliter alius artiÃeiaUter gerat, 'm ea !Â» t^ fx^A *âquot; ^-lt;â'' effe artetet'm eoc[uodcpiididicerit,melius fadatciuAtnââ- -^ /'ââ^''^^ â'7y qui non didicerit effe artem, Ate^ui non folum dodus nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â j!,A',. ^oiSaWjfedfhiim doctor doflutn m rhetorico opere ftt^,Yrr~rgt;i 7-.Â«Â»Â»-â '^ feraiit,neceiJenteiusalitert'AmultaprÂ£ccpta,tamc^^''^,^^-^gt; , ^^' magni epii docerentÃd qÂ»od civtn omn^us conÃtendum .^.^r^ ;'ygt;^ gt;â â¢ '^ turnnoiis pricipue aui rationem dicendi a iono ui â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^â^â'â '^ ro nonfeparamus. '4

a PaterÂ«us.) Atrometes,hocexprotrat AefcÃ¯iiniDemo ^^ '^^,z;p â9âÂ®pfSÂ®'f'Ã¯*9***â-*M*'r97jÂ«J0#pÃ³f quot;^^ fi/anKyhiaTrfOt^^ ^ Â« fwup^y ^(XÂ«p]p('Ãw|i x^ 7Â« litJÃ¶yÂ« ixanyyt^m, Ã , Txxi/KyayÃ¹' â¢V^iifÃ¶ii.oiâatTaTafniauKsXtuS'ijiXTsou/Ã³sixuji. Demades autÃ© MutÃ¯fiiiusfuit.Siipfenauta primÃ¼,mox rhetor, quem neÂ» gant orationem ullam feriptam emittere uoluiffe.

lt;^-Â»fgt;^ rA^Ay I^t M. FAB. Q^VINT. INSTIT. ii%ji^e^ii, ^gt;r0^^; Hcslco^t^itionelt;p-ifitm^tioncrertim^clMÃiscRÃ¤Ãn} ^''^â¢^â ^f^^^^'^C ^amp;^fgt;^i^exigent^{itvm,fcd ipfo rei,cuiutÃudiuin * nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;hxhet,inteÃ¯leaucotuentlt;i,citiÂ£^^^KVUocdtur:Ahie ^' '^^ ?^-^^^^gt;- Wâ â¢-(gendo,ciMrum m hocfinn cR, z^ ipfo^Ã¤u^ pcrÃd^

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;citur,^udlii eÃ Ãltdtio: Alig at cffvÃ¤uj qui Optra (^(f o^ /quot; 'ocu^fubijciiur)conltanmdiioneÃnemdcdpiuÂ»t,qudnt t / .^A^ ^tsou^iiap dppcÃ¯ldgt;ma,qudla c^ piUurdÃ©fÃ©rÃ© iudicdtidu eftjrhdoricen m dUu conÃÃere.noc enim quad eH offi \^i^^?r ^^ (^^p^yficit,dtlt;^ itd db omnibus didum ck^ Mibidut i,gt;'gt;Â«^ -vt-^ ^r^ uidrturetidmcxilliscieterisdrtibuf mttlttandiÃ¯umcre. e;^^ n ^v5âQv..nAJ j^^ifjp^pg^f^ dliqudndo ipfd res per fe inÃtdioneelÃ y/ y-â'y^ iLi.^,,/ contentd. EriteiÃ¼m rhetorice in ordtoreetidintdcente, '

dÃ©pÃ©rit dgerc^udpropo/jtOy uel aliquo edfu iwpe^ L^^7â'^^'^ *** ^^âtStnonnidgisdeÃiKteffeordtoTy^nKdicutt^cttri ^j ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, difeceritfinem.NdmeRdÃ¯iquiSydcnefcio'^dnmdximut

âÃ â^^Ã¼^Z â ^ ''^ ^^^^ ^^ fecretis ÃudijsÃu{lut,dc turn 'purd uoluptds Hts .4^. r^,ur.^ r'^ru, cum dbjau ideR^e rcceUertatt, zr coittÃªpld ,-^ t^'h^^j 0^lt; 21iud tionefuiÃttutur. SedeffrÃ¯tiuequoq^ aliquid ÃmHeÃri e, ^ pti^ordtionibia,uelhiflorijf,quodipÃanopiainpdrte h 0 ^m^^^.^i^i' ordtorid merito ponimia,confequetur. Si tdmen iwd ex t^^y '^^^^ !Z^tudrÃbta hdbenddÃt, quid mdximia eim ufiadlfu rcr^ Alt;â7lt;âÂ»tâÂ»âf^f â ^ontMeiur,dtq;e^iineoÃcqucntiÃime,dicdturdÃ¤!iiigt; â 7z,y/^'tA. uÃ§lddmittiflrdtiud.Udm ZT hoc eiufdem rei nomen til* â^^^'Zâât, '^/^^ytrtim pluf conferdt eloquentie drs,dn nuturd. fhâ ^(^ icAC,^,^M ,*'Â»:tgt;^- â^ CAP. XX.

â^*^T^J^^â^' ^'O^*Â® ^^ eti4m,'naturine{iutdd eloqucntidnicd f^^-iJan^^hn'' i^ferdt,dndodlraid,Ciuoddd propoÃtum quiient

â ^ Z^t*gt;rgt;^ lt;'*WfMj ^ TT7/â^ -y^rr/i^ J^Ã¯^fi gt;r^ gt;*ây^H^ nbsp;^

Mopri opera Â«tWl pert we t;Â»cc enm confurnmit^ ord^y-^ â¢^ '''^^^ 77 tor^if} ex utroe^ifieripotefi, flurimum idmenreferre^^^^, ,iâ^jgt; \ Arlitror, ^wm effe ^Uffiione 'm hoc loco uclimui. N^w gt;nbsp;â ââ s^quot;^

fit ^irti utrilibet omnmo Alterdm detruhM^nAturd etidtn ' â-* t^^â^^^'^ fine doUrmJ, mwÃ¯ttwn Mlebit^ioSirmd nuUit effe fine M^'^

^^^ F?^Ã¯liÃ' ^â^ ^*P**â coÃ«(tttt,WÃ¯ mediocribui guident '^^^^â^^^J/'^'' 1 utriicfi mxiiif Adhuc nitum credim effie momentwn, c^/^ ^^ fwmmxtos AutÃ« filwdodriniiidebere, 5nAturÂ£patata.

^ricoli frofuerit^Ã¨ terri uberiutileAÃicjuidetiAmnuUo nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^

colenfe mfietur. At 'm folofixcumdo plw cultor, 5 'pf^' '^^*â^â}^A^*^ 1 per fe bonfiafioU efficict. ^tfi finxiteles fi^ui^c^uodi^^J, ^ 1. â¢ t; i-^

^a/mmdnÃ¯btufiuilfietj^mtw^TOor^Â»âDewi^nataramate*^ ^^â ^^â â^tÂ»-^ b â^'^''âtit^Ars^dQ^'rmÂ£eSi.'hÂ£cfingitiiUdfingitur^.'l^M ^y^^^-^^

quot;^ fwnma,materiaoptmiameltorl \^'tZ^'^^quot;^'^ i^Kh^Ã©rniC, ijlt;Â«'^rn An uirtuifit rhetorics. nbsp;CAP. XXI. â^ÃJr.^3r^^*lt;

qae liuddri Ã§er fe,nÃªlt;[u^uitnfer^rij^(fiwt,fed ati* ^' 7.4^^ ^StAUtfecusfieavndum moresutemiuMfiivntjhdhendti ...-^ ^â^jk^STÃ©^xÃ¯â* Zâ*^ Â» â^ eomplMn'b!M ctiiin ptiIoppborM'â*^^^^^^,^^:^^*^

'; pllt;icet,MirtaÃ¯?EqaidÃª iUad quod m fiud'ijsdicÃ«di pleric^ fU H*Â«.'^â4Â»Â«*^ LÃ³rV^ fâ^rtcaeriwit 0- exercent, aat nuUa drtÃª,qalt;^TtXvÃ¯Â«'v*t.^xÂ»^*â^'LA ââ^ââââÃ¯â^ ^Lpato (maltof enim uideo fine f(Ã¯tionc,fine li ^^ ât^-Â»Â»^ egt;- /f teris,e[m,uel'tmpudÃ«tid,nel firmes duxit, rnÃ«tes^Autmd jTi^Ar^^'^TT/ hm ^mfi ortc^aa nawitv dicimwÃ¯ .Na t:^ fini TÃ©

t.,J.: ,eei^ 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;z^ejJenonnulloscxiÃimo^quifdcultdtetndicendidii^O

â'^'^ ^quot; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;minumperniciemconucrteruttt.fd.ixT(XdoTiXvÃ¯lt;xlt;itiÂ°*

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;e^ueeÃ©i quÂ£dd;n,idciifupcrM.câMdrtK imitdtio,(lddni

hil fanÃ¨ nee boni ncc mdU hdbedt, /cii ^nuldborein^Ãu^ i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;lis illius fuit, qui grand ciceris ex ^atio di faute mifd,

[ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;indcumcoittinu(),a'ftnefruflrdtioneinferehat.lt;:itiein

Â»HHt etngt;/rx,.' nbsp;nbsp;eu/mjpeilajfctAlexander,donatediciturriufdemlegi*

1 ^gt;â ^â^f^^â^''^-^^tnmismodio. Ciuodquidempremium fuitlÃ¼ooperedi gniÃimumViis ego comparandos exifimo,qui in decU mdtionibus,qudselfeueritatidiÃimilimasuolunt,dtdti multo fludio de labore confqmunt.Verum hlt;ec quant in^ | ^â^Cd/K â .f^r .â, fiituereconamur,ercuiusmtagmemanimococepimus, -^^^âi,v ^ fij i,^ ^if^ ^gffg ffj^g conuenit, quÂ£q; eR uerd rhetorice, uir^ Â«^^^^quot;i^'fff'lf^ tus erit. C^uod philofophi quidem multis er deutis congt; ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^lt;*^^* cÃ¯ufonibusccdligunt,mibiueroetidni'planiorehdcproa

A C nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;VwM/ Pr'^$lt;?âj5?â probationeuidetureffepcrÃiiciium. Ab

.gt;X^ his h^cdicuntur: Si confondre ftbimficiendis, denen ho Â»/ gt;quot;^ fdciendisuirtutiseR,quiepdrseiusprudeMiduocdtur, ^ eadem m dicendis, de non dicendis erit. Et fi uirtutes pr^. A ^.^âÂ«(f funtydd quas nabis etia amequam doceremur^mitiaqud

jl lt;Tgt;rÂ» nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ius ruficis quot^ de barbaris appdret aliqua imago,nes

'^fi nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^'rteficeffeabinitioform^qs, ut poffemus ordre pro

r'f'^lt; tf â ^jÂ£h,^''tonis,etiamfinonperfe{ie,idmenutineffentquicdani, 0 â gt;'gt;!pn(j^Ã¼i,(,^ utdixi,femindeiusfacultdtis,mdnifefumeR.'!lt;ioneddÃ© :!-ft-(^Â»nâ-ho A J^,, (^^i^nthisnaturddrtibuse^,quÂ£duirtute funtrentoa

qwiUqMtdfm ZenondieÃ³conÃ¼vnxit,uthdnecomprejf^^ rÂ» â¢^^ yi^â^i mpugnwmminui,illAmextpiicitÂ£diccretJimikm,cÃ¼lt;trit-^-,rr,^Ky ., di^utitnxuirtui erit, ddeo de bde ^Â«f '^edo^or, dt^ '^â¢^i

dpertior tinto cft,nibil dMbitibitMr.Sed plcniut hoc i^f^^ quot;'lt; ^~ dt^ dpcrttiM intueri ex ipfis operibw uolo. Ndm quid, ^, ^ ^L t^'gt; oritonÂ« liuÃ indo fdeiet, nifi bone/lorujdc tur^^ Æ eb â ritUi^Aut mfuidendo niÃ utilitate pcr^pcHii dut^ w * dicijs/t iii^itiÂ£ Ãt igndriKiQuidfnonfortitudvnem po

utiudicu/MUoniMÃ^mtercircunÃiÃi miâiitum Armi ^^'^,.^'^^ ? 7â^â^â 1 ccniiMfitiutfiuirtu^Ã³nÃ¨ft,nccperfc(lAquidemeffef;^:â^^ poj?it Qrdtio.Quod/Ã¯/d wqwoqjdnimdÃ¼'umcflMtrtK^j'^K^iTvio Ã© qud prlt;e/idt c^terd, nel pIcrdqÂ«r,Ht in leone â¢wprtwÂ»Â»Â»^^^â'*'â^^â'^lt;, 1 equouelocitethomincporrÃ¨rAtioncAtqiorAtionctx^t,,, â^ .^; v.u^quot; 1 ,, cellcreciÂ£tcriscerttMneil.CurnontAmincloÃ¼ucntiA,^â^1

gt; ^w.m orAUoneuirtutem eim ejje crÃ§dAmMj^'^cicq- hoc Agt;' ^â ^â'''^ud'c'tcÃªrortÃ¯dÃfferitCrAfTuaeSeniwVlpduenVivtAAârâ^^

dcjummttsuirtutibu^^EtippCtccroluAperlonA^cu/rn^,^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

dd BrMtwm in epiÃolis,ttvin etidm Alijs loci5^rtM,Ã« edm^ y^'****'' *W^ mrÂ»lt;,^' dppelldt.Atproamitwndliqiidndo, wndi'rdttonetndi^yyyyTy'^ t^^^ cit nidliw botnOjOquot; Argument A, fic ut nihil fit in bis ââ ^â quot;'Ã¯iA ^n wrÂ»Ã¯ J^w^ quirenduw. Ndm e? btro pugndbit Acriter, uirtut tA^^â^'^^'ââ'*/^Ã^ ** â¢nen trit fortitudo, et tomentA fine gemitu fcret wdlw - ^''^^J2^â' '*^5^^

.^^quot;MttUdpÃ¯ltcddemjfed dliter. Su^ciAM i^iturhxc^i^Ã¼fj*y ^ Ã frvgt;r7 (tj )f ft^ de Htilitdte JÂ«prd nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;quot;tTâ

I '^HifÃ¯rV Â»gt; ^w jX If^cr/i -rmfj^/Ãªnf/n ^rArhit-ri ^ ^/Xrvfrr i^ r^A: LSÃi^rh-VÂ« Â«â¢ F^S- OylNT. WSTIT^i^ I Jâlt;^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;-â/'^'^ l\/l Atcrixm R.hetoricesquidamdixerntcjjeoy\,.,.

I *â^Æ- â)'^z, 'â^r*â*JLVJ tionem-, qM mfententidponitwapud Pl^t^^^^.lf âxyi.y^'p^,^- '^^^ttemGorgiiiSi(i^Â£fiitd dccipitur,ut fermo^iM^^^

l ^.â^^^ quot;^, 7 pfm^^^fc compoÃtuf diedtur ordtio, no mdtmd,fcd (fpiu eÃ»t [ wr,%,^4^^7yx ^ MÃdtudriÃÃdtudindm Ã³'''^rdtioc^citur drie, ÃeutÃ^ ' Ã'^. ^dj ''fâ- â*â^'^ud. amp;^hdc dppcÃdtioejterbd ipÃdÃgnifiedriputdinufgt; ' i 'y^ld ^^}e nihil h^eÃnerer^/tibflM^^^^^ C^uiddm arfftÂ», foi A4c^^f. fÂ«dji- n^ntd perÃidÃbi!id,quÂ£ cripfd m pdrtefunt operii,(t^Ã^â ^k/Ã¯'^f Ã^,^ i^^^{o^ eg^nt.QuiddmeÃ¼tt^s quxÃioneÃ'i^-i'^^â¢'^â â'fquoruop'miononciudÃ¯itdtcfcdmo^o errduittEÃ¼cnM^^ ^/l 'i^.rj'^drA^ ^f^cmdtcrurbetorices/ednoÃ¯^old.C^tdM^quu K-w A^ ^f^ftt),6 d ftn fit rhetoric^m^eridineitutotdmuitdmuocdnf.A^ tf ^T^X^wâ ^edijt ^p^ilt;gt;â nottomni'Mi uirtutum mdterid fittotd uitdeed -y^f^ ,^Â»r/f*Â« Cgt;^hf'fiâquot;pkneque edrum uerÃentur mpdrtihiÃ¼,fitcut iuÃitid/or Ã^rf:Ã^^^^ÃCÃ;j^âtÃ¼udo, commentid, proprijs officijs ^ fuo fitte mtelli* certi,^ f,^-^^^^^^ji gwntur: rhetoricen eptoq; dicimtm twd'dl'iqud pdrte po

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ncnddm.eiquelocivmmelhKe'negoa^etfidÃiondntÃi

; ^ii ' , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;e^'Tt^u.y/JMTinop^EgOjttecpieidÃiiicdutoribus^tndteri !

' f^^/'''-^ÃÃr^^ ^^^iÃrh^oncesiuiieoÃ³itinesres^^UdÃ«ctvttqficidddi'' [ r.hÂ»Jn,/t//^'Â»gt;' nbsp;nbsp;cendum fuhÃ¯e^a erutt Ãdm Socrdtes dpud Pldtonem H

cere G^rgia uidetur, non in uerbiseffie nidteridm,fid in rebus.Et in Phidro^bdldm nÃ³nin iudicijsmodÃ³ et co

â fn/^ X* Â»irfAi^tUK 4^t*- â\ â ââJâ â¢*Â»-*;* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;' l'**- \ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, r /t â¢ - 1 i49

! Afri if^' C ^^^r*Mgt;^ cionibtis/ed m rebus etidm pruutis^dc domeÃicis rntto J nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ricene/fiedemonÃrdt.GittotndnifieÃuMeRÃtdneopinio . !

De Orat.i. ^ff^ ipÃm pldtonis fuijje. Et Cicero ^uoddm loco mdte 1 ridm rÃetorices uoedt res,quÂ£ fiubieÃ©lÂ£ fitunt ei,ficd eer* tds iemum putdt eÃ'e fiubieilds: dUo ucro^dc omnibus re â , bus ordtori dicendum drbitrdtur, bis guident uerbii' '

hue dlibi : Vf rum enim omtoriyClUte funt m honimum Â«t^^gt;^7i tTX^ I td(qMAdoqMidctâiMfdÂ«crfdtÂ«rorlt;ttor,lt;ifq[jCdcftetfH54^gt;Â«lt;/

omnimdteriddicereedmfdtentur,propridmhdbercmd ^ s^Â«* â â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;teridm,(iuidmultiplicemhdbcdt,negdttt,^dneqÃtnfinisi}â^f'unÂ»^ Ã¿^^' 1

â tde{l,etidmÃeÃmultiplex,crdliieciuolt;^drttsmmores ^ ^ ^^^^ â l nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;bdbet mHltipIiccm mdtcridmjttclut drebiteftonice. Num ^^^^r^^,.*y;L. tÂ»Â«

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Cdmomnibusc^uitytvntmiiedificioutilid^uerfdturt Efc~â^ ^

cÂ£ldturd,ciUÂ£duro,drgento,drc,ferro,olt;pcYdefÃcit9^'^f^Jj^Zgt;, 1 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ã¼dnifculâpturdetidntlignu/m,ebur,mdrmoriUitru,gemi-. a/^t^a rv^â'gt;-^'Z I

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;WiÂ«, prÃªter ed qwsc fuprd dixi, comfieCHtur. Nec lpro^^^â^^â;^^^^^^Ã'/h.

\ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;trniKnonelimdteridrhetoricesyffvneddcmuerfdturtttâ'^ â ^quot;'â^â^2,^ 1

\ , ^d{i'iis^dmftlt;^ugrÃciUÂ£ÃtmdteridÃdtUdrij,diceturtes:'^Â°^â^â^â^'^ 1 'Â«quot;^^f P jj^^^j q^jj fjt Ã«xciiforiSyid eSiÃ¨iusfdbriclt;e,c[Ud Gr* ^t^*9*â j,^^,Â» ciuocdÂ«txÂ«^âlt;^'2'Kip, fimiUter Â£s c^erc^Ã¶iednt. At

1 ^nlt;. c[uiflurimwmÃdtuisdiff^ivntudfd.Ãlccmcdicvndideoâ^^(/^^^-gt;sgt;^r'^â^' , I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Mon trit drSy quid u-nflio et exerciidtio cum pdUÃried/^T^^^^^. Ã^Â»

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cibonnn nero e^udUidS etidm cum coc[uoru ei fÃ¼ drtc cogt;'^ ^f-^-^^^^'''^ . b. Â« muws.Qwd nero de bono utHiÃuÃo diÃ'erere,^hilofa^^^^t^^r.^ V'^Ã^ F^â* o^Â«Â» f/ff dicMLnon obÃdUNdm cupbdofopbum .^lt;7.Â»-^

148 M. FAB, QVINT. INSTIT, t orij^ -y^t^ l aJiirf^^Aictvntfhoc dccipi uolimt^uirum bonum, Cur igitur on Æ \^^-^torâ¬nt,quem 4 bono utrojionje^drOi m eddem mdtertd ^CL-TtZX^X-M* uerfdrimirer^ CuMprlt;efirt'm primo Ubro nm oftenie rim,philo[ophosomifldintÃ¯dncdbordtortbiupdrtemoc cifp^U^ 3 ^ ^^âtPJ^^^^ proprid femper fuiffet, ut iÃ¼i y.ty^^^^!',^ poitut in nolir^mdteriduerfentur.'Denit^ cumfit didle r^^^. .Ã³^C^ j,^^, ibices mdterid de rebus fiubieaisdi{^utdre,fitdutemdi quot;^yviâvÂ»^ p'yo â!Â£., , dleHices ordiioconcifd, cur non eddem perpÃ©tua c^uoi^ fgt;r^ ^^ â^ Â«^ Â»'-'-d^^l^ uidedtur^Sotet d quibufddm etillud ponLomni k^fgt;~f^ a^/â,y urn igitur drtw/a peritus ent:-ordtor,fi de omnibus d -^jf ~^gt;^iâ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dicendum e^. Pofiem bic Ciccronis refijondere uerbis,

i^nnf quot;^* ^Fâ*'^' 'âPâ^ ^^^'^ ^^â^ inueniotlAedc^uidÃ¨ fententid,nemo effe , tx^^-n, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;potcritomniIdudecumuldtusordtor,nifieritomniure

Jttvt- '^ ^^/y rum mdgndrum, dtq^ drtium feientidm confecutus. Sed ^l^X^^Xi ât ^â^^'^^^^ â^fii^i^ ^ff^ ordtorÃ¨ rei,de qM dicit,non mfii j cr^Mj ry^CÂ»Â» ^^^ uw.Nfgj enim omnesedufds iiotiit,amp; debetpoffie de o'' ^*'Xâ^â^X'**ââ'^â*^*^ââ^ ^^ ^^^Â° ^^^^^ ^ ^^ i^^^'^ dididt-y*Â»-. ^ .^Z^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Similiter de drtibus i^uo^, de c^uibus dicendum eritim''

^.^f^t^Q,^ t^^Jerim di/cet, cr de quibus didicerit, dieet. Qjtid ergo, â^,4^'^/^^^ââ- t^olt;f fiber dut defabried melius, dut de mufice mufiemi Aez,. ^ â^ â¢gt; â¢- gt;- jj' âeÃnt ordtor quid fit,de quo quxrdtur pldnÃ¨ meliaS' ^^tn ^litigdtorruÃicusiJUterdtus^decdufdlMme* nrhhvnr..,, 4/iÂ»J, Hi^f ^if^^ ordtor,qui neJcieiqwiCm Utefi^ Sed dccepti . â^ââââ¢â^^fânÃ^^g '^ÃlyQ^Ã^^^f. ^ litigdtore,melius ordtor,qudnt ipfe qui docuerityVeru erfdber cum de fdbried, or f^lt;^ HÃ§c daufu â ^â^â^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^ ââ*^^^ i'^^^ confirmdtionem defiderdue

la non erat ^h^'^,non crit quidem ordtor, JedfdciÃªt iHudfcpidÃ 'Ã¨mpiiri â' Â®^ââ'*' * ^^^^^^^ '^Ãquot;Â«1 Unpeutw ddigdbit, non erit

Uudim^tw 'm deUberdtionem, ne c in indicium lt;*tniutf^1f?âfâ^ff^j^ Ergo Â«wn defdciendo portu fioflienfidcliberdtum eR/-^^^ t^.^^

, non debuit dicere fententidm ordtor ? dtqui opus erdt/ - Ye ^*4^ * -^ t: i Z'Z''^â^^Â°^^drchiteltoriim. Linoreszir tumores'mtorpodf^fZZZsZi^^^^ .i4âe, cruiitdtis, lt;in uenenifignifint, non trid:At Â°'*'lt;â^'^^^'^ff^^* â^quot; tor?At eSi id ex rdtione medicmx â¦ Cired menlurdStOâ' â¢-Â«-iâ

numÃ©ros non ucr^dhtur^DicdmuthM geometriseffe ' ^irtes^ ^c^uidem omnid credo pojje ferÃ¨ cd^u dÃ¼^Mo MeÃ§..â^^^^.^9Â«âÃ, *â'â'Â® ^SÂ°^^^ ordtoris,(iuod ji non dccidet,non erimt 1''^/^^^ nfuiiedZitdficciuoci:re{lÃ¨dixmusmdteridmrheto^,-^i^T^

rices^tjjeomnesres dddicendumeifubictidX.Ciupd qui:^\,a^tfi^.^â.iâ , demprobdtftwm ferma commu/nis ,t?idmcum dUquii

deqio dicdmiK dCcefÃ¯mus, '^ofttdmnÃ³bK ^Jt^^^^^''^^ -^ ^â ^ ,-^,^, i ridm jrec^uenter etidm prdfdtiotfe tefdmur. GorgidS âf-^^/^Â«Â»^ Æ * quidemddeo rhetor ide omnibus putduiteffedicÃ©dum, ut fe m duditorfs mterrogdri pdteretur, qud quifq; de,''' âl*Lâ?fÃ¶;.?^*â'âââ.2?Ã¯â*f ^â'â^â*^gt;â*'^â^Â° wlt;ttfrfdwe^ mft!r.^A.~,L,^Zâ^ ' tiUfd,z!''m qui^ionibuSy omnes res fubieUMerdt com flexwSedqud^ionesfinegetddrhctorJcenpert'mere^f^f^^^ diffeatit d,nobis,Si Mtem dd rhetoriccn pertinent, dbm v'^â hocquoq dcliuMmur. Nihil c^ emm, quod non in cdui-~i ^^fr^^f',f!ffZ.'^ fim,dut 'm quefionem edddt. Ari^oteles tres fuciendo j ^^^^-^ pi.rtcsordtionis,iudicidlem,dcUberdtiudm,dcmonjird* tiui,m,penÃ¨etipfcordtorifubiecitomnid,nihilenmno nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;j

'm bfe cddit â¦ QufpetiW i pdueiÃ'tmis etidm de 'mfiru^tquot;''^ ^' fZ mentoeSl, in^rumentum uoco,fne quo farmdrj^mdtedâ^â/^â¢^ r ^^k^f Tidtt:^m quod wlmws effei opus non poÃit,'VerubioQy â^^

;, rX^/Â«, xr^*'*-^ tgÂ® ââââ ^^*ââ Â«Oquot; quot;^â^^ famp;retfÃªd artificem. J^eq} cmmfci 4 Ã© .l'Ã¿r^rrW nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;gf^i^ defiderdt mjlrumcntum, quÂ£ poteR effÃ©confumÂ»'* mitii^etidm Ã nihil fdcidt,fcd idc opifex, ut cfldtor Citt^-IwnijZ^ piUor peniciÃ¼d. itdq^ hiec m eum locu/m,quo de omtore diiluri fumm^diffirdmui.

VONIAM IN SECVNDO libro qdgÃtum efl quid eÃet Rbf* torice^Zy quis finis eius^drtent quoque ejje edm, qt utilem, or uir tutcm,ut uires noÃrg tukrunt, o* flendimus, mdteridmque ei res o'^

mnesdequibus dicere oporteret,fitbiccimus,idmhmc twde coeperit,quibus conftct,quo qugq- in ed modo in* ueniendd,atqi trdUdnddfint/xequdr. Ã¯ntrd quem mo* dunt pleriquc firiptoresdrtium conjliterunt ^ddeout ApoUodorus contente folis iadicidUbus fuerit â¦ NÂ«

fiwnÃ®g(tlt;inMbocÃ mcfrifdpÂ«e,qÂ«odbicn{)erwicbo4 ^^j^^^j^g Of m,^udiofos eiiK deÃderÃ¤ffe ^utâmi^uifitions opinion opiniSa re Â«Hin, qÂ»Â« diuerÃÃimx fuerwnt, longe difficilimim, itm infÃ©rÃ©. neÃio, An mmme kgeniihut futurum uoluftdti, quip pc quod prope nudettn pr^eerptorum trAditionem deÃ^ deret, in ateris enim Admifeerc tentAuimus dliquid nitorK, non iAÃAndi mgenij grAM ( n^nque in id eligi mAtmA potent ubmor) Ãd ut boe iffa AÃiccremut md gis iuwntutcmAdcognitionem eorum ,quie neceffAriA Ãudijs ArUtrAiAmur, Ã dudi iucwiditAte aUc[ua Icdio'^ nisiAcntiusdi[ccrcnteA:,quorumneieiuMA,Atc[ueAridA q?^Â®â^â? trAditio Auerterct Animos^ZT Aures{frAfertm tAm dc'f gerst uenu' licdtdÃ¯) r Aderet, ucrehAmur. Qui rAtione fe âLucretius ^^ metapho dicitprAceftA pbilofophig cArmme effe complexum/^â King; b4c,Â«t ed notivm,fvni'itud'me utitur:

Ac ueluti puer is AbÃiuhiA tetr A medentes nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Lucr.Iib. i.

AfpirAM mellw duld Ãduai^ liquore. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Quid libro

Et quie feepvuntur. Sed nos uercmur,nc purum bic liter fâÂ° Â«ef^af â¢ tneUis, Oquot; AhÃntbij multum buiere uidcAtur, Ãte^i fulu^ brior fudijs,^uAm duldor.Qum etium boe tmeo^ne ex eo minorÃ© grutium iMcit,quod plerA^ non muent A per me,fed Ab Alijs trAditA cont'mebit^^AbcAt etium efiofdum f^uicoiUrA fcntiAnt ,zy Aducrfenitur ,proptereA quod plurimi Autores,lt;piAmuis eÃ¨dem tende rent,dinerÃs tAf inuenerat menuiiis miwieriint, At^i in fuum qnf/q; induxit fequÃ© tes.tidi Autem prohAnt qudlccuqj ingrefi funt iter : nec fAcile incuicAtAS pueris perfiaÃones mutAueris^^MA

uar^sopwi ^^^^^^^^'^^^^^^^IJ^^^'^^^t^^i^^ '^fffdifcere. Eli autcm^ut embus. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;procedenteUbro patebit,mfinitÃ¤ dijfenfio autorwnhtn

mo ad Cd quÂ£ radia dtejae imperfe^d ddhtte erdnt, diij eientibui ^aod inucniffciHfcriptoribui^rnox, ut dUt^uii fui uidcrciuur dfjirre^etidm redd mutdntibut.Ã¯Hdm pri Prim' rheto ^^ ^Â°^ ^Â°^ â^^^^ PoÃ«ti trddidcru^t,mouijfc dU^uA dr nces. ^âÃ¯ rhetoricen Empedocles diciturt Artium dutem feri* ptorcs dnticjaiÃimi Cordx er ThyÃds Siculi,quos infe'' cutas eil uir eiafdem in^uU Gorgids Eeontknus, Empe'' doclis,ut trdditur,diÃipulus.ls beneficio logiÃmit in CÂ«one Â« ^^ ^^^^ centum et nouent uixit dnnos)cum multisÃmul Ludanus de floruit, ideoq^ et illorum,de quibus fuprd dixi/uit Â£ma Ionisais, hff^^ ultra Soerdtem ufj; durduit.Thrdfymdchus Chdl ^^^^^^Â»^^â^^^'^^â^^ â^^ fjoGCy Prodicus Chius^cr Abderites Pro K Laertius. tdgorM, Ã quo decern niiÃbus dendriorum didicijfc ar^ tem,qM,m edidit,Euithlus dicitur^cr Hippias ElÂ£us,(t quemPalamedd Plato appellat,Alciddmas Elcates.An^ tiphon quo^i ztr primus omnium orationem fcripflt, et nihilominus artem or ipfe compofuit ,0-profl: dixiÃÃ optime cd crÃ©ditas â¦ Etiam Polyerdtes, A quo feripteM in Soerdtem diximus orationcm.Et Theodoras Byz^* Logndsdali ^â^ ,exhislt;!:tr ipfe, quos Plato appellat 'koysd'eatS'a* ftruftores ix. ?iÃ¼lt;=.lÃ¯orum primi communes locos trad affe dicumtur, in'^m^^^ ^f^^â^ÃªÂ°''â^gt; Gor gios,Prodicus O' Tbrafymachus.Cice orationis Si ro in Bruto negat ante Periclcm fcriptum quicquam,qdâ fermoms, orndtum oratorium habedt, eius alidad ferri. Eauidem affentund nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1

cxPlatonis non reperio quicquam tdnticeloquentiie famadigmm. Phidro. ideo^ minus miror,effe qui nihil ab co fcriptum putÃ«t,

IâÂ« iutem qnÂ£ fcriwtur^ib alijseUe compoÃtd. Hw fuc f^ffcYc multi, Ãlt;^ dttriÃmu Gor gilt duditorifocr Mes, iterates. qiunquAtÂ» de prÂ£ceptore eiia inter dutores non conuegt; nit.Hos dutem AriÃoteÃ¼ credimus. Urne uelut diuerfo feedri caperunt uiit.lÃ¯dm etÃ¯foerdtis prdÃdwiÃimi di fcipulifuerunt m onmi Ãudiorum gencre^ eo^ idmfeni ore ( oUdimmenim qtnondgeÃmwmimpleuit dnnum) pomerididnis fcholis AriÃotelesprxciperedrtemord^ Praecipere^ toridm capit,noto quidÃ« Ulo,ut trdditur^ uer[u ex Phb lodctdÃefjuentcruius:

TMrpe effe tdcere,e:y ifoerdtem pdti dicere. in uetuftis Arj csi utriu^Ãd pluribusedm libris AriÃoteles com defideratur plexmeft. Bode tempore Theodedesfuit^decuiusope tatiiquot;***^^â re fuprd didum ed. TheopbrdÃus ^uoc^ AriÃotelis di fcipuliu,de rbetoriee ÃripÃt,dtqihmcuclÃiidiofiM pbi lofopbi epidm rbetores, prlt;ccipÂ«c Stoicorum dt(p Peri^ pdteticoru principes. Pecit deinde uelut proprium Her migorM uiifCpum plurimi funtÃcuti, cui mdxme p4r, dtq; Â£muiut uidetur Athengus fuiffe. tiultd pod Apol lonius M.olon,multd Areus,multd CÂ£cilius,z^ KdUedr^ Arius quern nd^eus DionyÃus. Pnecipue tdmen in Ã conuerterunt ^ââ Â® ââ' Pwcliit ApoHodoriÂ« Pergdmenus,cpÃ¹ preceptor Apollo nix Qxtdris Auguftifuit, ^3quot; ^heodorus Gdddrlt;tus,qui fe did mduit Kl!odiu.m,que Ãudiofe dudiÃe,cum in cX inÃlÃ¼nfeceÃiUetydicitur Tyberius CaÃr. Hi diuerf^ opinionestrddidcrut, dppeUdtiq;inde Apollodorci,et T.loeodoreifdd more certds in philoÃphid fedds feipccn

di.Scd ApoUodori pricccpu migis ex difcipuUs co^to fas, guorivm diUgentiÃimut 'm tr^dendo hfme fuit Cgt; VdÃ¯ginijgriece Atticus ^ Ã¯idm ipÃutfold uidctur drs eÃ td dd tAdtium,ciuid esteras,miffd dd Domitium epifloÃ¯i Animaduer ^Â°^ dgnofeit. Plurdfcripfit Theodorus,cuitu duditorÃ© te in Ã¦tatem Uermdgordm funt qui uidermt â¢ Korndnorum primiu, StinUhe'* lt;i^â^ââ''^ ^SP ^^i'^^i^ feidm, condidit dliqud 'm hdc mdtf tores, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;rid Vt.Cdtoille Cenforius,poA Mi. Antonius'mchoduit-

l^dm hoc folum opus dus dt^j idipfum imperfedum md nct,Secuti minus cÃ©lÃ©brÃ©s,quorum memoridmÃ quo lo^ ^i^^^Â°- co res pofcet,non omittdm. Prdcipmm uero lumenÃ^ cut eloquentie, itd precept is quoque dus dÃ©dit iwicuvs apud nosjfecimÃ« ordndi,docendiqi ordtorids dries M- nbsp;*

Tullius, poÃ¢ quem tdceremodeftiÃ'imum foret,nift O' rhetoricos fuos ipÃ ddolefcenti Ãbi eldpfos diceret, O' Lib.i.de m Ordtorijshecmmord, que pleriqi deÃderdnt,fdcns ^'^^^' omifijJct.ScripfitdeeddÃªmdterid nopducd ComiÃeius, Huius Calli dliquA Stert'mius,nonnihil pdter GdUio,dccurdtius utro eff^libroT^ P^^^^'^d Gdllione Celfus,O' 'Lends,or etdtis noÃre ver ad HereniC, ginius, Plinius, 'KutiUus. Simt er hodie cldri dufded j Chu? â^'^Â° operw dut ores, qui Ã omnid complexi erdnt, confuluiÃ

fenthborimeo,fedpdrconom'mibusuiueHtiumgt;Veniet Afuoiudi' eorumldudiÃmmtempus, ddpoflerosen'muirtufdii^ cio amp;nbsp;ratio. j.^j,jj. non berucnict'muidid.Mon turnen poR tot tdntos Â»e docendi. . . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, z. , â r

fcriptores pigebit meum quibujddm locis pofuijje jente tidm.Nequeenim mecuiufquimfelle uelutqudddmfu^ â¢ perÃitione imbutus,dddixi,er elelluris queuolemfd^, | denidd copii fuit. Sicut ipfe pluriu 'm twwm confero iÂ«* i

NEC diu nos moretur ^Uitjiio, lt;^HÂ£ rhetorices ori goÃt.Ã¼Am cui dubium eÃ^s^um fermonÃ© ah ipÃi reru niturigeniti protmus hommes dccepermt f ejuod certe pr'meipium cÃ eim rei^Huic Ãudium zr mcremÃ« twm dederit utHitds:fummdm,rdtio z^ exercUdtio^Uec Confutatio. uideoc^MrecurMdicÃ«di putintf^uidAm mdecÅpilfe, ejitod hi qui 'm diÃrimen AÃquod uocAbdntur^AccurAtii-us loqui deÃendendi fui grdtid 'mÃituer'mt.iiÂ£c enim ut honeÃior edufdÃtd non utique prior e}t,cii/m priefertim deeuÃtio preceddt defenÃonem ,nifi quis dicit etidm glddiimfdbricdtumdbeoprius,quiferriim 'mtuteldm p^^j^^j. ^^ fui,qudmqui'mperniciemdlteriuscompdrdrit. Initium Ã¦Ã¼j, ergo dicendi dedit ndturd^mitium drtis obfermtio. Ho rames enm Ãeut 'm mediemd cum uiderent dUd fdlult;-brid^dUd mfdlubrid, ex obferMtionc eorum eÃecerunt drtem.itd cum 'm dicendo^ dUd utilid,dlid mutilid depre henderent,notdrunteddd 'mitdndum,uitdndumqj^ZT queddm Ãewndum rdtionem coru ddiecerwnt ipÃ quoiâ que, hec conÃrmdtd fumt ufu, turn quit feiebdt quinque ^^ra s: ufu docHtt. Cicero quidem mitium ordndi conditoribus urgt; hum,dclegumlitoribusdedit, mquibusfuiÃeum dif muentionÃ¼. Cfndi neeeÃe eÃ¼, cur tarnen hdne pfmarn origmem pU'' tet,nonuideo,cum fwtddhucquÂ£dd udge,z^ fme urbi bus, dc fme kg^bus gentes, et tarnen qui fumt m his nati, Ãflegdtionibusfirngdniur, etdeeufent aUqua^dcdefen

ns M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. d^Â«t,^' dcnilt;^ dlium alio mclitis locjui credant.

OMnis autem orandi ratio, ut plurm maximi^ â i-autorestradidertwt^fiumtiuepartibusconfiat, inucntione,dif^ofttione,elocutione, memoria, promw* ciatione,fiue aitionetutroq; enim modo dicittir. Omnit cn'mi fcrmo,lt;^uo ^uidem uoltmtas aliqua enuÂ»ciatur,ha'' beat neceffe e^ rem O' uerba .AcÃeH breuis, O' U^ conclufionc Ãnitiu,nihilfortajjc ultra defideret.At ori tio longior plura exigit.^ion enm taniumrefert,quid, O' quomodo dicamus,fed etiam quo loco.Opus ergo eÃ O' dij^oÃtione^ Sed neq; omnia quÂ£ res poÃulat, dice* re,ncque fuo quoique loco poter'imus,niÃ adiuuantc me moria. Ciuapr opter ea quoq pars quart a erit. Verttni hiec cunda corrompit^ ac propemodum perdit Mecoa Confutatio. ra uel uoce,ucl geÃu pronimciatio,huic quoque tribut dus cd necelfariÃ quintus locus. Nee audiendi quidam, quorum ed Albutius, qui tris modo primas ejÃ: partes uÃ³lustt,quia memoria atq; adio natura, non arte contin gant,qiu.rÃ¼ nos prÂ£cepta fuo loco dab'mus,licet Tbri'' fmachus quoque idem de adione crediderit. Hw adie^ cerunt quidamfextam parti m, ita ut 'muentioni indicÃ© um fubnederent,quia primum effet muenire,detnde ia dicare Â» Ego porri ne 'mueniffe quidem credo eum, qui non iudicauit,nee enim contraria,communia,Ãulta inne niffe dicitur quifquam,fed non uitaffe Â« Et Cicero quidÃ© IRhctorkis in Topicis, iudiciumfubiecit 'muentioni. Mihi autem adeo pfimis tribus parlibus uidetureffe permixtH,nM

Â»cq; dij^optio fwe co, ne que clocutio fiKvitJAt pronuÂ« cidtionem quoqueuel plurmuw db co mutiuri putemÂ« Quoi boe duddciiÃ dtxcrmj,qÂ«od wi pdrtittonibiM ori torijj ddcdpicm, de quitus fuprd diftum eft, qurnque perwenit pdrtcs;N(tiM cum dupliciter primton diuifijjct in inuenttoncin atq; clocutionem, res de dij^ojitionem inncKtionjjtterbd er prontwicidtionem clocMtioni dedit, quintdm quoq; conÃitnit comtniwcnj, de Â«dut cujlodem omnium,memoridm.ldem m Ordtore, quinque rebus co Ãdre eloquenttdm dicit ,in quibus poÃcd feriptis certi* or etus fenientid eft. Non minus mibi cupidi nouitdtis Confutjtioi dlicuius uidentur fui/Jc,qui ddieccrunt ordincm,cum di Jpofitioncm Hxi^cnt^ qudÃ dliud Ãt diÃ)oÃtio,qudm re . rum in ordinem optimd coIldtio.Diott wtuenfionem moÂ« â¢ dÃ³ er diÃioÃtionem trddidit, fed utrdnqj duplicem,rcÂ« rum de uerboruWjUt fit clocutio inucnttoni$,pronuMcid tio diÃiofitionisibis quintd pdrsmemorid dcceddt. Tbc odorcifcrÃ¨inueiHionemdupIicem,rcrHw dtqjelocUtio nis,deinde triÃ¯ pdrtes cdterds. HermdgordS, iudicium, pdrtitionem, ordinem : que^ elocutions funt, fubiecit Oeconomiic, qÂ«Â« gÃ¯-cee dppcRdtd ex curd rerwn dome 0Â«onogt; Ãicdrum,cr bic per dbufioncm pojÃ¯td,nomineldtinocdquot;'ââ ret.Eft er cired boe qud:Ãio,quod memoridmin ordine pdÃ¯tiiMH quiddm inucwio)ii,quiddm dijpo/itioni fubiun xerum, nobis qudrtus eins locus pldcct. Non enim tdn* tuminucitfd teuere ut diÃ)ondmus,nec di]poftd,ut do* qudfflHr,fcd ctidtn uerbis formdtd,mcmoriae mdnddre de bemiis * Hdc enim omnid quiccwn^ iÂ« orutionem eoUdtd

Cohfutatio f^''^^gt;'^â^^^^^^â*^'^^^^^^ ^^^^ ^ ^â^ opinionc non pM per eÃ¶trariÃ¤ ci ^ Ut hM non rhetorics partes e(]'cexijlmarent,(ci iUationem. operd ordtoris. Eius enim elJe^muemre^dij^onerCy do qui,z^cÂ£terd. Quod Ãdedpimus, nihil dr tireUnc^itt* tniu.Eidm bene dicere eft ordtoris :rhetorice tdmen erit benedicendifdentidiVcl^ut dlij putdnt,drtifids e^ptt fuddere, uis dutem perfuddendi drtis ; itd muenire t^d* dem er diÃ^onere ordtoris, muentio dutem er diÃ^oÃi* tio rhetorices proprid uideri potent. Ã¯n eo plures dijÃn ferunt, utrilm ne hÂ£ partes effent rhetorices, dn duffe opera, dn ( ut Athenens credit )elementd, quxuacad * note so/xÃ«Â« â¢ Sed neq^ dementa rede (luis dixerit, aliocjui tdntum initid erumt, ut mundi, uel humor, ucl ignis, ud mdteria,uelcorpcrd infecdbilid,necoperum redenotd dccipient ,lt;lUÂ£nondb dlijs perfidumtur, fed dUud ipff perffdunt. Partes igitur. fiam cÃ¼ ex his rhetorice,Ãeri non poteR, ut totum ex partibus conÃet, lt;IUÂ£ non fint partes totius, ex quibus conÃet. Videntur dutem mihi, ^ui hxc operd dixerumt eo quoq- moti, quod in alia rur fus diuifione noUent m idÃ© nomen inddere,partes eniiii rhetor ices effe dicebant laudatiuam,delibcratiuaniffii cidlcm. C^ueÃ partes fu'nt,mdteriÂ£ fitntpotius, quant artis. t^ianquem his Ãngults rhetorice totd eR, quid (T inuentionem,cr diffofitionem^cr elocutionem,cr me'' moridm, er pronumcidtionem quitcunque earum dcÃ* derat. Itaque quidam genera ea tria rhetorices dicere maluerumt,optime autem hi,quos fecutus eH Cicero qd genera eau far urn.

SEd trid, an plan Ãnt, amUgituri nee duiie prope omnes utiq^ fummx dpui lintitlitosdutoritdtK feri^ ptores,AriÃotclem feeuti,lt;iui nomme tdntvM dlio con* eiondlcm pro dflikratiw dppflllt;lt;t,blt;lt;c pdrtitionc con* tentifuerunt.Verum er time kuiter eÃ tentdiivm^tum dpudGneos (iuofidm,twmdpui Ciecroncmmlihrk de Ordt.cr nimemdxmetemporenoftrorum dutorwin dc Orat lI. propÃ¨ impuÃ¯fwm,ut non modo plurd hge gÃªnerd, fed pe I jquot;^Â®'â nÃ¨mnumerdiUiduidedntur.t^dmÃIdudundide uitupe geneva. nndi officium in pdrte tertid ponmus, iM quo gencre uer{dri uideimurffi querimurjeonfoldmur^mitigdmutt concitdmutjterremuf,conÃrmdmut,prxcipmuf^obÃcuÂ«â

re didd interpretdmur,ndrrcmus,depreedmur,grdtidi dgimiK.grdduldmur, obiurgdmufimdlediemm, deffiri*-limuftm((nddmiK,renimcidmuftOptdmiK,opmdmurie2â plurimd AÃd, ut mibÃ¯ m iÃ¼d uetere perÃudÃone permd^ Â«ewi, Â«dut petenddfit uenid, quxrendÃ¼mque quo moti priores rew tdm IdteÃtÃdm, tdm hreuiter dÃr'mxer'mtt. Qtios qui errdffie putdnt^looefeeutos drhitrdutur^quod m bis ferÃ¨ uerfdri turn ordtores uidebdnt. Ndm er ku* dcs,cz uituperdtionesferihcbdniur,e^ lTetrei.lt;^âalt;^ di'Â» eere erdt moris, z^ plurimum in eonÃlijs de indiens 'm* fumebittKr operxjut feriptores drtiÃ¼ pro folk eompre* bendermt frequentiÃimd.Qui uero defendimt,tridfdei imi gewM duditorÂ«: iMniw quod dd ddeZldtioncm con ucniittjdltcriHH quod confiliu/m decipidt,tert'iu quad de eduÃs (Â«dieet, Mibi eundd rimdwi, tdlM qÂ«iedrt rdtio

coiiigitÂ°tria^â^^ââquot;*'^^â ^â*Â°^Â°gt;^^^ ordtoris officium,dutiniuHcijs . prscipua cfi,Mtextrdiudicid. Eorudcquibuiiudicioqujcritur, nera^^^'' ^^^ffiâ^Ã^^^^^^^â^^^I'^'^^'^^^^^icetn nonucniwtt, dut prÂ£teritum'hdbent tempui,dut futurum: Prdteritii lduddmiK,dut uituperdmundefuturis dcliberdmuf â¢ P^ omnid,dc quibut dicedum ell,dutcertd fintneceffi eSi, dut dubid:Certd,ut cuiqi ^^ dnmitfJduddtjdut culf^ii-ex dubijs pdrtim nobifipfis dd eleHionem funt libÃ©rÃ©,d: his dehberdtur, pdrtm dlioru fententiae comiffid, de bis lite contenditur, AndxmenesMiddle O'condandlens gencrdlcs pdrtcs effe uoluit. Septem dutem j^ecies borgt; tdndi,dchortdndi,lduddndi,uituperdndi,dccufdndi,de'' fcndcndi,cxquircndi,quod 0 c^^^TC^SlKdp dicitur,qui rum duÂ£primÂ£ deliberdtiu!,duÂ£ feqitentes demonÃrdÂ» tiui, trÃ¨s ultimÂ£ Micidlis generis funt pdrtes,Protdgo rdm trdn(co,qui intcrrogdndi,rcffiondendi,mdnddndi, precdndi,quod liXd^âAnp dixit,pdrtes folds putdt.Pldo in Sopbiftciudicidli,0'conciondli tertidm ddiedtit^o co/diAHTooip, qudm fdnÃ¨ permittdmus nobis diccrefer* mocmdtricem,quÂ£ A forenfi rdtionc difitmgitur, O' ^^ dccommoddtd priudtis diffiutdiionibus, cuius uis eidem \ pro fed Ã ed, quÂ£ didlcdicÂ£. ifoerdtes in omni gÃ©nÃ©rÃ© ACaoconTi ijjeffieIdudemde uituperdtionemexiftrnduitt iJobisÃ u tern 0 tutiÃimum ek dutores plures Ãqui, 0 iid uide tur rdtio diddre. Ed igitur, ut dixi u/num genus, quo Idus de uituperdtio contmetur ,fed ed dppeUdtum A pdrte meUore lduddtiuum,idcm dUj demonÃrdtiuum no ednt utrunque nomen ex grÂ£co crediturÃuxiffie â¦ Nlt;(W

ft ly)wp.ia.siK.op or iTTnS'^iStKop dicunt^Sci mihi tirt Ã¦^H^Kop Â»0Â» tdm dcmonfirdtionK urn hlt;Aere,lt;Ã¿tdm ogt; jicntdtionis uidetur, Oquot; multum db iUo lywyp^tastw^ diffirre: ndm ut cont'met IduddtiMim in [c genm^itd no mtrd hoc folwm conÃjUt.An t^uifijftim negducrit ^dnct coâ)^Ã¢' ggt;rtcoÃ®i7ricPlt;lÂ«,2-HouÃ§ cffefAtquiformdm jÃ¹idendi hd'^ wshoeno* bent, O' plermt^ de utiUtdtibut Grxcu loqunntur, ut Â«^^ tÃ¢* edufdrum c^uidem generd trid Ãnt, Ãed ed tum m nego'^ tÃ¼modo ad tijs,tuminoÃentdtione poÃtd.Ã¼iÃ forte non ex grlt;ecolff^^^[â^f, mutudntes demonÃrdtiuum uoedM, ueru id Ãautmtur, pum laudes quod Idut dcuituperdtioqudlefitejuice^ demonÃrdt: Ai j^fÃ¼furpaÂ» terton eH deUierdtiuufn,tertium iudicidlet Cditerd: Ã^e turn fit. cics in hec trid mcidunt generd. Nfc muenietur ex bw Â«lid,Hl qua non Iduddre dut uituperdre, Hindere dut diÃ' fuddere,mtenderc quid uel depeUere debedmusjUd quo que funt commimid,concilidre,ndrrdre^docere,dugere^ nimuere concitdndit,componendis 'ue dffÃ¨dibut unimos duiientium fingere. Ne his quident dccejferim, qui IduÂ« Confutatio. ddtiuimmdteridmhonefiorum, dclilcrdtiiu.mutiUu/m, iudicidlem iufiorum,qult;efiionecontmeri putdnt,celeri mdgis,dc rotimdd ufi difiributione qu'dm uerd. Stdnt e^ nm quoditnodo mutuis duxilijs omnid. Ndm et in hude iuÃitid,utilitds^ trdddntur, O' in conÃlijs honefidt,et rdro iudicidlem muencris edufdm, cuius non pdrte dli* quid eorum, que fuprd diximus,repcridtur. Offbusconfiitudturomnisrdtiodicendi. CAP. V. 0MÂ»K dut ordtio confidt,dut ex his qut fignificA

IÃ©t M. FAB. Q^V INT. INS T It, Hi^'FdcultM ordndiconfwmnutur ndturd, drie^exerci* tdtione,cui ^Udrtdm pdrtem ddijdimt quiddin imitdtio^ ^ubi^ar gt;^^^}^^gt;^ ^Â°^ drtifubijcimuf.Trid fimt item (jut pn^i re deiedt ordtor,ut doccdt,mouedt,d(leilet. iheceniin cldrior diuifio, qudm eorum qui totu/m oput in res, (J in iffÃ¨diM pdrtiutur. Non femperdutem omnidqn ant quftrdUdbiturmdtcridm eddent. Eruntenim quddM remotit db Ã¤ffedibuf, qui ut non ubique hdbent lociM, itd quocunque irruperint,plurimum mlent. PnÃdn^ tiÃimii dutoribus pldcet^dlid in rhetoried eÃe^ qud pro bdtionem deÃdcreitt,dlid quit non defiderent, cum qui* but ipÃ confentio. QiÃddm nero, ut Cclfta, de nuUd re didurum ordtorem^niftdequd quÂ£ritur exiÃimdiu, cui cum mdximd pdrs feriptorum repugnet, twin etinu ipfd pdrtitio, nifi forte Iduddre, qug confiet eÃe botte* jid^cr uituperdrc, qua exconfeÃofunt turpid,none^ ordtorif officium. lUud idm omnesfdtentur, eÃe qui* ftiones dut in fcripto,dut in non feripto: in feripto, fient de iure, in non feripto, de retiUud legdie, hoc rdtioMlf genat. Hermigordt, dtque eum Ãeuti, uoednt vo/diuÃ¨p zy TeoyiKoij. Idem fentiunt, qui omnem quiflionem po* QyÃ¯ftiÃ¶es. nuntin rebut zy in uerbis. Item couenit quifiones eÃe dut infinit dt, dut finitdt. Infinitis funt,quitremotisper* finit, zy temporibut, zy loeit, atcritq; fimilibut m Â«â¦ trdnque pdrtem trdddMur, quod Qneci Ã¨itni} diewnt, Cicero propofitum, dlij qusfiionet uniuerfdles dui* les, dlij quieftiones philofopho conuenienies. AtheniU^ Nempe cum I^drtÃ« edufs dppeUdt,Hoe genui Cieerofeientidetddi^

ORATORÂ» LIBER 111Â» I^j Uf iÃ¯fiint.uit,ut ptfcicntii, dn brouideMid mu^tdui re^ Ãnipliciter

* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Qritur litres

^AtunAamp;ionKydn dccedendudd rempub.ddmmiftrdn^ cognofcaf. ddm.^rtM triu gencru: dn fit, quid fit, qiule fit,otnnid Aftione ue* tnim hxc ignordri pojfimt:Sequens duorum, quomodo ^Â«0?Â« jd ddipifidmur,quomodo utdmur.TcvnitÂ£dutem fimt ex co iptumetam f1cxurerwm,pcrlondÃ¯um,temporum, Meronmc^Jhie ^|m Â« a'gen Ã7roÃÂ£a'(j|5 i GrdcK iieuntur^edufi a nofirit: Ã¯n bis dis dum fit, qudfiio uidetur dred res,perfondx^ confifiere-Ampli^ or e^ fiemper infinitd,inde enim finitd defcÃªdit, Quod Â«t extmplo pdtedt, infinitd eÃ¯i,dn uxor ducenddfinitd, dn Cdtoni ducenddAdeo^ effe fuiforid poteH, Std eti* dm remotÂ£ d per fonts proprifi,dd dliquid referrifolÃ«t^ Eft f Him fimplex,dn refpub.ddmmifrAdd.'Rcfcrtur di Â«Ii^MidjdÂ» m tyrdnnidc ddmmifirdndd. Sed bic quoque fulcH uelut Idtcns perfond^tyrdmus enim gemindt quÂ£ fiioncm,fubeil^ cr temporis, er qudlitdtis tdcitd uiSt nondim tdmen boe proprix dixeris edufim. H^ dutem quM injinitds uoco,â¬t generdles dppeUdntur,quod fi eSl uerwnfinitÂ£ f^ecidles ertwtAn omni dutÃ«fipecidli uti^i inell gcnerdlis,ut quÂ£ fit prior, Ac nefcio, dn in edups quo^ quiequid in quÂ£fiionem uenit uelut qudlitdtis,ge9 nerdlefitMiloClodiu occidit : iure occiditinfididtorc, MÃ³nne boe quitritur, dn fit ius wfididtorem occidendii Quid m coieHurisinon iUd gener did,dn edufd fcelerit odium, tupiditdstdn tormentis credendu, tefiibuStdn dr gumentis mdior fides bdbendd ^ t^dmfinitionc quidetn comprebendi, nibilnon in usinerfumcerttm erit.QM* iMpMMt etidmedfipoffie tbefis dliquindo nommariÂ»

qwÃ perfonis aufuq; contmedntur, dUter tdmummoio poÃtMyUt cdufd fit CH OreÃes deeufdturtThtfiSydn W Ães veile fit dbfolutui. Cuiui generis eH, dn Cdto veilt Mdrtid RovtÃ¨fio tvddidevit. Ui thefirn d edufid fie diflln guwtt^ut iÃ¼d fit file Uiting pdrtis,hlt;ec ddiuittlllic enifti uevitdtis grdtid tdntu difÃutdvi,hic negotium dgi. Ciu^ qMin inutiles ([uidd ovdtovi putdnt uniuevjdles ^uifUt nes,fluid nihil pvofit ^Â«oJ cofict ducÃ©dd effie uxove, uel ddminiÃvdndd vempub ^fi quis uel Â£tdtc, uel udletudint impedidtur. Sed non in omnibus eiufmodi lt;iuÂ£fiionibu( fic oceuwi poteil,ut itlis,fit 'ne uivtus finis: vegdtur ne^ munduspvouideniid.QjiinetiAm in his, cltiÂ£dd perfoM refevuntur,ut non eÃ fidtis genevdlem tvdildfje quifilo nem,itd pevuenivi dd ffieciem, ni iÃ¼d pvius excuffd, uoH poteH.'Ã¼dmquomodo dnfibiuxov ducenddfitdeiibtvi bit Cdto, nifi conÃitevit uxoves effe ducendM^ Et ^Â«o* tnodo dn duceve debedt Mdvtidm quÂ£vetuv, nifi Cdtoni ducendd uxov cUfSunt tdmen mfevipti nomme Rermi govÂ£ libvi, qui confirment iÃ¼dm opmionem,fiuefiil[ut eÃ¼ titulus,fiue dUus bic Rermdgords fuit.t^dm dufleM effe quomodo pofjiint,qui de bde drte mirdbiliter muÃ¼^ Deinuctio. compofuitiCumficut ex Ciceronis quoq; Kbetorico fti mo mdnifeÃum eÃ¼, indteridm rbetorices in tbefis,et ciU fits diuiferit. Quod reprebendit Cicero, de thefirn nibÃ¼ ad ordtorÃ¨ pertmere cotendit,totÃ¼^ hoe genus qndÃl^ nis dd pbilofophos uoedt de referd Sed me liberduit re* prebedediuereeZdid, et quod ipfie bos libros imprÃ³bdti Dc Oratj. ^ iâ^^'^ â^ Ordtore ficripfit, er Topicis prdcipÃ¼f ut ^

(Â»â of rijf per/buK 4tcj; temforibus duoccmiw controMer, /ilt;tm3lt;jMi(t UtiiM hcedt iicerc de gcnerc,lt;lH4.m de Ãgt;f cie, O' quod in twiiuerfo probutuni eft, id in furte probutn fffe neceffe pt.StattÂ« autetn in hoc otnne gentÂ« watert.Â« * ijdcm, qui in caufoÂ« codttnt. Adbnc adijeitur, alias ejjc qw^Ãionej in relitÂ« ippj,alias qu* ad aliud referantnr: Illud an uxor ducedathoc, an feni dKccnda.intid,an for tts:boc,aÂ»fortior,etpmilia.Caufaw pnit AfoUodoms, Mt interpretatione valgq difeipuli eitÂ« Mtar,ita : Caufa Hatdineisin eft negotium omnibus fuis partibusfpeÃ¤ans ad ^^Â°J^^ quxftionem: aut,caufa eft negotium cuius pnts ten exem-eÃ controucrpa.lpfum deinde negotium pc pnit:Nego pl*â^** tium eÃ congregatio perfortartwn,locoruw,tcmportÂ«n, caufarum,niodoruw,cafuum,faftortHn,inPÃ¯wmentorM, fertnonttw,priptorum c non fcriptorum.CaHfaw nue BttcUigimus uTrdÃ¶io'i/j,negotium â¢ros^iscca'i/j.Scd ippiw caufarn quidam pmiliterpnierunt,ut ApoHodorus nego tiumafocrates caufarn c^fe ait quaÃionem pnitam,ciMiÂ» lem,dut rerurn controuerpam in perfonarum pnitarum in topicis. coptexu. Cicero bis uerbistCaupeertts perfonis,toets, temporibus, aftiottibtM,ncgotijs cernitur, aut in omniÂ» bus ,aut in plcrifquc eortwn.

ERgocum omnis caufa contincatur aliquo patH, .prius q diccre aggrediar, quornodo gentÂ« quod* que caufe pt traftddum,id quod commune eft omnibus, quid pt Status,er unde dÂ«catur,cr qMot,ct quipnt,tnÂ« tuendum puto, quanquam id nonnulli ad iudiciaks tana

turn pertmere nuteridt putduerut. Qyortim mfeiti^f^i can omnid trid gentrd fuero execute, res ipfd dep^c* hendet.Q^od nos Stdtum,id quidam conÃitutionemtgt;^ cant, dlij quiÃionem, dl^ quod ex qugÃione dpparedb Hoc eft ad T^^^odorut generale caput,id eft KupÃ¢^oUop Â«^Â«(^ uerbum.ca' rap,ad quod refcrutur omnid.Q^orum diuerft append trnmumâ' ^^^gt;^^ âAddern eR,nec'mtere{i difcentiim,quHtit quH^ que nommibus appeUetur,du res ipfd manifefta fistic turn GrÂ£ci SKirip uocant,quod nomen prmum ab HfJ'^ luaitismemagoratraditum putant,fcdaUfab^ucrate ifoerdtii daquot; Â«Inter difcipub,alij Ã Zopyro Cldzomenio. Cit^anquamuideÂ» Soentisau'tur Aefchmes quoque m oratione contra Ctefiphonein ditores rece ^^^^ j^^^ uerbo, dim Ã iudicibus petit, ne Demoftheniper fortaflisIe* mittantcMgariJcdetim dteeredeipfo cauftftatuco^ a^us 5Â«Â«' ^â^ â ^^ dppellatio dicitur duda uel ex eo, quod iU tij. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fit primus caufie congreffus, uel quod mhoccaufaeonf

fiiftat.Etnommis quidem hxc origo. NÂ»Â«c quid fidÂ» Statum quidam dixerunt primamcaufarum conftdi* onem, quos rede finfitffe, parum elocutos puto, Non enm ell ftatus prima cÃ¶ftidio,fecifti,non feci/ed quoi exprima conflidione nafcitur,id ed genus queÃio^ nis,fecifti, nonfeci, an fecerit : Hoc fecifti,non hoc fe^ ci, quid fecerit, quia ex bis apparet : iÃ¼ud coniedurd, hoc finitione quÂ£rendum,atque'm quo pars utraque infiftit, erit quaftio coniedurdits, uel finitiui ftatus, QÃ¿idCfi enim dicat quis,fonus ed duorucorporum m^ ter fe coftidio,crretpit opinort non enim fonus ed co^i diÃ¿,fcd ex couflidionciEt hoc lern', mteUi^itHr enint

Utdwi^ didwm. Me uero mges mule mterpretdntibns ittiuiusell error, ([ui^uid pYmimconfliclionemlegc^ rdntcrediieriwt jlMum femper ex print A cpigjUone du ccniu,m,c[uod ell uitioÃÃimum : nam (^UieÃio nuUd non bAbet uti^ Ãitum^conÃAt enim ex intentione er depul ftone,[ed AlUfiutt propre cAufArtmiy de epAib^feren'' dAfcntentiA cH^aU^ Addulhe exirmfeew, Alieptid tAmÃ© dd fummAm cAupe eonferentes^uelut Auxilid lt;piAdA,lt;iuo fit^ut in controuerpA mia plures (ptAÃioneseÃe diednÂ«' tur, ilArumporroplervMlt;ptel(UiÃ'mAlt;p(A([ue primo hcofungitur .UArnef iUud jreepiense^, ut eA ^uibut nimus conÃdimiu,eufln trAdAtA Ãnt,omittAmiKlmterim Ã^onte noÃrA uelut donAntes, mterim Ad ca (piA fwat po temiorA grAdum ex bis feciffe contenti-Simplex AUtem cAufA etidmÃ uArie defenditur, non potell hAbere plus wto de (pio pronuncietur, diepte inde erit Ãdtus cAuÃe^ epiod er ordtor pneipue fibi obtmendum, er iudex Ã^edAndum mAximeinteUigit. inbocenm cAuÃcon^ ÃÃet^CiteriMt epttÃionum poÃ'u/ntejj'e diuerÃ. Quoi UtbreuiÃmo pacAt exemplo,cumdicitreus,etiAmÃ feeÃrede feci,lt;plAlitAtis utiturÃdtu: eu AdijcityÃd non feci,coniedurAm mouet. Semper Autem Ãrmius eil non feeiÃe, Ideoepte ÃAtum eÃe in eoiudiedbo ^eptod dice^ rem,Ãt mihi plus epuAm wnwm dieerenon Uceret â¦ ReÂ» ftc igitur cH ÃppdUtd cAufdrum pr'md conÃidio, non ^Hf/ltontHn.Ndm er pro Rdbirio PoÃhumo Cicero primd pdrte ordtionis in hoc mtendit, ut Adionem (ompetere 'm e^wtem Romdnwn neget : Sfcuudd, 4

nuUdm dd cum pecunidmpcrueniffc confirms^ Stitimt tumen dicum in eo fuiffc^quodcR potentiut.i^ecmcM *Â®â' fa ^Mlonis dreu primus quxfÃ®ioncs.^uu fumt poSi pro cemium poÃtg^^iudicubo conflixiffe cuufiim, fed uii tof j tif umbus mfidiutor Clodius, ideÃ³cpie iure interfeUvi oftenditur.Et hoc eÃ¼ quod ante omniu conÃituere 'm i'' nimo fuo debeut orator, etiam Ã. pro caufu plurd didu^ rws ek, quid maxime liquere iudici uelit. Qgod tunteit \^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;' ut primum cogitanduM dtu non utique pfmumdieenf

A Lij flatumcrediderunt primameius, cumquo ageretur,dcprccationem uel depulflonem.QÂ£fi In Topidf. f^'^^utiam his uerbis Cicero compleditur : IÂ» quo pri'' mum mfiflit, quaft ad repugnandum cogreffa defenfo. vnde rurfus alia quieflio,an eum femper is faciat,qui n fpondet.Cui rei pnecipue rÃ©pugnÃ¢t Cornelius Celfus,a( ces non Ã depulfione fumi, fed ab eo qui propoÃtionetn fua confirmet,ut fi hom'mÃ« occifumreus negat,flatus db accu fat ore nafcatur, quia is uelit probare, Ã iure occi* fam reus dicit,tranflata probationis neceÃitatc,idetÂ» * reofiat,Gr Ãt eiusintentio.Cui non dccedo cquidÃ«MiÂ» eR uero propius quod contrd dicitur,nullam effeUtefl is cu quo agitur nihil refpondeat, ideo^fleriflatu Ã rÃ§ fpondente.tied tarnen fententia udrium id eii, Gr â^â^ââ^ dit pro conditione edufdrum, quid uideri poteR propo Ãtio dliqudndo flatum facer e,ut in conicituraUbui t^^^

pi,tttitÂ«r cm conieStunmigis qui lt;tgit.QKo moti ^Â«t dim^cundem d reo in^cUtem effe iixerii/nt,O' m /yHo* gifmo toU rlt;itiocinlt;itio db co cft qui mtendit. Sed quid Midetur iUw qÂ«o^ neceÃitiÃ¼em bos ÃdtiÂ« exequendt fd cerc qui ncgdt(w ewim p diedt non fed^ coget dduerfdÂ« riwm cotÂ»ieflurdMtt,o-/i dtcdt,non b-ibctlcgon/yHo^ gifmo) conceddmuÃ¯ ex dcpul/iottc Â«dpi ^dtuw^ibtlowi HiM enm res eo renertetur, ut modo is qui dgit,modÃ³ is cu/m quo dgitur, Ãdtum flt;tcidt,Sit envm deeufitoris m* tcntio,hommem oeddifli, Ã ncget reus,fAciet Ãdtum qui fegdt. Quod p conÃtetUY,f:d iure d p ddultcrum didt oedfum : nempe legemeffe certum eh, quÂ« permittdt, nip dliquid deeufdtor ei reÃ^ondedt nuUdlis cH,Non fu itjHjquit/duIter.Ergo depulpo incipit elfe dftoriÃ¯,ille Pdtum fddet.ltd erit e^uidem pdtus ex primd depulpo* nc,pd cd pet db deeufdtorc^non d rco.Quidfquod cidÃ© qud^io potcA eudem uel deeufdtorem Ãdeereyxi reum-. i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Qui dÃ®tc ludicrdm exercuerit, m qudtuordeewn primis

1 dierdm exerecreSi deeufdUtur tbcdtrdli lege, dcpulpo 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;erit Ã¯ci:p exdtdtusfueritdeÃ^eddcuUs^zy dgedmiu^

dccidet,quod eft d pluribuj trdditum. EPugcrunt bds qufÃioncs ,qui dixcrunt Pdtum effe id quod dppdrcdt ex (ntentione er depulponc,ut fedÃijnonfeci^dut rede L S

fed. Viderimut tdmen, utrum id Ãt ÃHM, dnintoÃi^ tut. Hermdgonu Ãdtum uoedt, per ^uem fuhirild m inteUigdtur, Oquot; Ad ^uem probdtiones edAm pArtium ft ferdMur. t^loÃrA opmiofemper h^efuit, cimi effent ft quenter in cAuft diuerfi qu^Ãionum Ãdtu^,m eo crÃ©iez re flut urn edufie, ^uod effet in eo potentiÃtmum, V lt;Â» quo mdxime res uerteretur ,ldÃ quis generdiem qud^ fiionem, uel cdput generdlc dicere mdlit, cum hoe mihi non erit pugnd,no mdgif qudmfi dUud ddhuc, quo iiM inteUigdtur, dui rei nomen inuenerit, quAnquAmtoti uolummd in hdne dif^utdtionem impendiffe mukos feb dm^nobis ÃdtZ did pldcet. Sed cum in dlijs omnihut W* ter fcriptores fummA diffentioeR ,tum inhoc uidetut rnihi predpuum Ãudium quoq- diuerfd trddendi fuiftÂ» adeo nee qui Ãt numerus, nee qua nominA, nee qui gt^ neredes y^qui'ue ffeddles fint ÃdtiKconuenit.Aepri^ Ecccelem?' *â^ Arifotekselementd decern confituit ,circA qui ta Ariftotez uerfdriuideatur omnis quiÃio oisr'iafj^quA llduiufcÃ Plautus hoc Ã'^tium uocdt .Nee fdnÃ¨ dUud eÃ¼ dus nomen ldtinumgt; uerbo pri' Sed ed quieritur^dnfit.QudlitdtemyCuius dpertm inteb ^âare*reftiÂ» ^^^^ ^^' Qdiâ^^^âi^t^i'^gt;â)tltâ^ dupliciter Ã poÃerioriii^ qui pro f la^ diuifd eH, quÃm mdgnum amp;nbsp;quim multum fit. Ad dÃ»* fo^Ã¼uunt t}uid,undedu{llt;etrdnfidtio,crcompArAtio.PoUbdc, ubi^et quAndoideindefdcere,pdti,hdÃ¯ere,quodeSl qÂ»^ fi drmdtum effe^cr ueÃitum effe: nouiÃme a'nyKeSâ^t quod eil compofitum effe, quoddmmodo,ut cdlcfdcerc, Ãdre, irdfei. Sed ex bis omnibus prmd quAtuor dd ÃiÂ» tus pertmere, edterd Ad quofdÃ locos Argumentori Â«â

tÃ³ur.Alij nowÃ« clemcnlt;4 po5lt;crMr;Pcrpn3,qiU de uni Wo,corpore, extra poÃtis ^U(erdtMr,^ilt;od pertinere ad conieHurx et ([uaUtatis inÃrumentauiÃ¤,eo:TepiK,(ptoi jgÃ³vejj uocant^ex quo ([mÃio, an is, (jum dum aidiHa eH mater peperit,feriMs Ãt nat usâ.Locus,unde contro'Â» uerfia uidetur, an fas fuerit tyrannum m templo occii-dere : anexidaucrit, (luidomi latuit i Tempusitemm, quod KM^dp appellant,hanc autem uideri uolunt j^ed'' em Ulins temporis,utÂ£fatem,uel byemem.'tiuic fubijeia tur tile in peÃHentia comeffator: Aaum,id eft 7C^Ã³^ip, quod eoreferu/nt,ÃienscommÃrit,an mÃiens-.ncceÃi'' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;j

titatis,an T:hrafylgt;ulo trigmta premia debeantur,(iui ^^q^^^'^^^ tot tyrannos fuÃulerit zCaufarn, cui plurmaefubiacent lites,(iuoties faSium non negatur, fed quÃ¼ wÃa ratio* neÃt fadiM defenditur-.r^oTsop/um id quod alio mo* do feri licet, alio diciturfadum, bate eft adulter loris eefusjtclfame necatusi0ccaÃonemfadorum,(iuod eSt e.pertiw,(pidm ut uel mterpretandu, uel exemplo Ãt de tnonÃratidwm, tarne Â«(pojiuÃ Ã§ tj^op uocant.Vii quo$ BuUuw (ptaÃionem extra hÂ£c putant. Quidum detra* bunt duns partes, numerum (y occafionem, ey pro ido qwm dixt adu fubijdunt res, id eft â n^iypt.oija. QuÂ« â¢Â» fraterilfe uiderer, fatis habui attingere. Caeterum ââw quot;fc ÃatiM fatis oÃendi, nee omnes contmeri locoi trfio,qHod uppurcht diligcntiiK legcntibM,c[UÂ£ de u* t Â«que re dicum.EruMt enim plura multo,c[uam qu Æ bw fkwe/wiÃ¯ fompre be nduntur. Apud pluref legi pUewiffe-

17t M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. ^uihuliim^wtiufMOwKmo jldtumcjje conieÃ¤wdl^f Sed quibut bhicucrit, nei^ue ilU trididenwt, netjiic c^P ufquAm rcpcrirc potu^KAtionem tdmcn banc [ecuti i^^ cuntur,(iuod re$omnii pgnis coÃ¯ligereturc^uomoio^ libetjCjftAUtAtis ^uoejue folivm Ãdtum fAceret, guiAubi^ que qiulii fit cuiufque rei nAturA qu^ri poteji,fied utto^ cunquemodo^ÃqueturfiummAconfufio, Nc^; intcreÃ wturn quis fiAtumfAciAt,An nuUwm,fiomnescAufitÃgt;^, conditionK eiufdem.ConieHurA eR a conie{iu,id cH i^ redione quAdAm rAtionis Ad ucritAtcm,wnde ctiAmfim Conieftura niorum, Atq^omnium enter frÃ©tÃ©s,coiedoresuoedmuf' AppeUdturn tAmen ed hoc genus uArie,fient 'm fequeni^ bus AppArebit.

Quotiedr quistAtus. CAP. vin, FVerwnt,quiduos fidtus fdeerentt ArchidcmuscoH iedurdient edr finitiuum, excufd quilitdte, quidÃc de cd quÂ£ri exiÃ'mdbdt, quid effet miquunt, quid inw'' fium, quid dido dudientent non effe, quod uoedt de eo'' dem,crdlio.liuic diuerfid fiententid eorum fuit,qui du^ bs quident fidtus effe uoluerumt, fed wnum 'mficiAlem,d terum iuridicidlcm. InficidUs, quan nos dicimus conies durdlem,cui db 'mfidendo nomen,dlij 'm totu dederu/id, AÃij m pArtem, quid deeufdtorem coniedurd, reum irfigt; cidtioneutiputAueruntMridicidlised, quiJ'iu.ou.cTiO* gt;nbsp;yiwÃ§ grÂ£ce dicitur, Sfd quemddmodÃ¼ db ArebidenÂ» qiulitds exclufd efi,fic db bis repudidtd finitio.Ã¼dinjub iffiimted iuridiciAli,quÂ£rendum^ drbitrdnturjufiÃ»iÂ»^ Ue fitfAcrilcgiumdppelldri,quod obijcidtur,uelfurtu,

bd dmeKtwm.QMd in opmione Pampbilut fuit: fed ^M ^jâ^^âj^, lit Atem mplurd pArtitw eA. piurimi demceps, mutAtis /t, iirnWa' tuntum nommibutjn rem,de cpiAnon conjict, cz w rem â¢â¢ 6quot;âf de ^iw conjiet. Nrfw eSl uerum nee Aliter feripote^, g jn fragmew dwt ut certum fitfA{lum effe fluid, AM non fafÃ non eR Het odiani certum,eonieilurAfit:ficertum eR,reli(jui fAtU5gt; Ndw bus^pr^s* idem dicit ApoUodorui,cwmlt;lUÂ£jiioncm Autinrebui extrA pofitK,lt;iuibuicoiellurA explicAtur,AM in nofris opimonibui exillimAtpofitAm,lt;luorvm illud -Tf^afy/xÂ« ZKop,hoc 7^1' ivvoiaio uocAt:ideq; aivd^op jy 7rÂ§oAH7Tjâigt; Kop dicitur,(iuo dubium, er prtefumptiwnfignificAtur, de quo Iiguet. Item ybeodorM, cpii de eo Anpt\ amp;â de Acciiemibui ei,^uod eÃe coÃAt,id eR ssc^i oJo'iÂ«Â§,i^j o^fx^i^HKorfiiiJ exifimAt gMÃ¦n, n3 m bis omnibus prb w genw coniedurAm bAbet,feciuens reU^ud- Sed b^c rÃ© UlM ApÃ³llodorus duo uult cÃc,qiu.litntem,amp; de nomi nedd ed fnitiuAm.Theodorus, fluid,^Mle,(iuintum,Ai aliquid.SH-Ht 27 qui de eodcm,0' de AÃio,modo qiulitd* temeÃe,modojinitionem uclmt. In duo erVoftdonius diuidit,uocem e? resjn uoce quÂ£ri putAt,An fignifeet quicquAmmultA,quomodo rebus coniedurAm, quod na Tasao'z/) uocAt,e3' qudUtAtem, e:^ finitionem,cui nomen d^tKotÃ¯ imÃ¼Kx.p,e3-AdAliquid. Vndeet dliAdiuifioeÃ,'^^^^ dlidefje fcriptA,AliA mfcriptd.Celfus Cornelius duos Zif ^^^^b^itllAtusgenerAles,Anllt,quAlefit.Vriorifubiecit ]^^tioncm,quiA xque quÂ£rAtur,An fitfAcrilegus, qui ni

* ^ ju^uliÃe de templo dicit,zy- qui priuAtAm peewni Ã©n ^ot'ftetuYfefuÃuUÃe 4 QMdIjfrttfm jn rem, ej frii

174 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT-ftwmdwiditt Scripta quatuor pdrteslcgiilei,(Xckli tnnfliitione: quintittitcm,cr mentis quiftionem conic* (lurÂ£ fubiecit. EÃ etidm dUd in duos diuidendiÃdtusrit tio,^UÂ£ docet Mt de fubÃdntU controuerÃdm eÃe, dut de qiuUtdte. Ã¯pfdm porrÃ c^Mlitdtc, dut in fummo gelte rc cottÃÃere,dut in fuccedentibus^De fubÃdntid e^ colt ieilurd-QjiiÃio enim trdHdtur rei,dn fdHd Ãt,dnÃit, anfuturd fitAnterdum etidmmetisÃd^ melius, f ^Â«o^ his pldcuit^qui Ãdtum eundem fdiH,nominduerut,tdnl depnetcrito tdntu,Qr tdntu de fddo quÂ£rcretur,?drs qudlitdtis, quÂ£ eÃ¼ de Ãimmo genere, rdro in iudiciu ue nit, cpidle eh, id 'neÃt honeÃum, quod uulgo Iduddtur. Succedemiu dut dUiS de communi dppeUdtione,utÃt ne fdcrilcgus,qui pecunid priudtd ex teplo Ãirdtus eH, dut de re denommdtd^ubi (^ fdHu ejje certu eÃ,nec iubitd turquid fit,quod fdHuest.Cuifubideentomnesdebone^ Ãis,iuÃi5,utilibus qu^Ãioites.His etidm exteri Ãdtus co tineri dicuntur,quid et qudntitds mode dd coniedurdin reÃ:rdtur,ut mdior ncfol q terrdt modo dd qudlitdteni, quAntd pand quempidm, quinto ue prlt;emio fit dfÃci iu^ Ãumicr trdnÃdtio ucrÃturcirciqudlitdtcm,c lt;If)ââââ* tio pdrs fittrdnfldtionis. QttiÂ« Qf coMrdrii leges,V rdtioemdtiuus Ãdtus, id eil fyUogifmus, C plerunque^ fcripti,c:^ uoluntdtis,iequo nitdntur, niÃquod hicterft tu diquindo conic Aurdm dccipit, quid fenferit legis co flitutor.Ambiguitdtem uero femper coniedurd cxplicd ri neceffe Ãt,quid cum fit mdnifeÃum,uerborum dupb* cem effe 'mteUtilwmÂ»de fold quicritur uoÃ¯untdte.A pittti

â¦Â»Â« frÂ« fwntfdÃi gmcrdlesÃlt;Uus,^uibui Cr Cicero in ^^^Â° Â®âââ* Qrdtore utitur.Â£t omnid,(^UÂ£ dut in cotrouerfidm, dut in contentionem uenidnt, contineri putdt ,Ãt'ne, quid fit,([uileÃt,(Quorum nomind dpertiord[untyf^udm ut do cenddÃnt. Idem Pdtrocles fentit. Tresfecit O' M..An* toniui bit cluidem uerbist Pduc^res funt,lt;iuibut ex ret: bui omnes ordtiones ndfeutur, fdiium^non fddumiiiKt miurid:bonum, mdlum. Sed ciuonidm i^uod iure dicimuv feeiÃe,non hunc folum inteUeilum hdbetjut lege,fed H* lum (luoquejUt iuÃe feciffe uidedmur, feeuti Antoniem dfertiuf uoluerunteofdemÃdtui diÃmguere.ltdc^ue dixermtconieaurdlem^egdlemiiuridicidlem^ Qui amp;nbsp;Virgilio pldcent.Horu/m deinde fecertvntf^ecics^itd Ut Irg4i fubijeerentÃnitionem, 0 dUos e^ui ex feripto diÂ«' eiwtur legum contrdridrwin,lt;[UÂ£ ^vÃ vopjx dicitur,Oâ fcrifpti,O'ÃntentiÂ£,uduoluntdtiSfideH uoHÃ Ãni/JjH^ hwiapjO M.Ã®.TÂ«ÃK4- i/),qiww nos udrie trdnÃdtiudm^ trdnfumptiudmjtrdnÃpoÃtdm uoedmut, (Ai^Ã¤yuffxSp^ quem accififnui rdtioemdtiuum uelcoUediunmdmbi* guitdtiSylt;[UÂ£ Â«piqxGoXia nomindtur. Quor pofÃ¹i,({uU 0 il^Ã i fikrifc^ Ãdtus dppeUdntur^ quibufddm Ã¯egdÃ¯es pottuÂ« qut^iones edsdiciplicuit.Qudtuor fccit Atbc ^ ^ niâ¬iM,it5o'Tft7TjâiHH/j sao'ipyUel 7ss9.^ctd.v'amp;Kvpy ided ex'Â« BoÃ¯t(ttiuS,qui fudforix edJgpriuSiO'our^'\lgt;fip,c[Ud coie flut dm ÃgniÃedri mdgis exbis lt;IUÂ£ fe^uutur, g ex iÃ§fo nomvat Ã¤ppirrt, mcC^oÃ¼amp;iÃ¨ip, edÃnitio edjmutdtioc tnm noiseÃ¶Ãdtjiuridicidbe^edde dÃÃeUdtioe ^tcd quJ Â«ff ri Hfm.iqow cft,Â«t dw^ wulfd m nvmwiVw HÃÃt

reittid.Stvnt (lui vT(!}:%ilt;c(gt;amp;.ni/j trunjldtionem e(fe cxi^H tneitt,fecuti huw muidtionis fignificdtionem. lecem/xi alij totidem ftdtuiyfed dUos^dnfit,(iuid fit, quilefit,^Â»* tuin fit,ut CdciUus o- Theon.Arifioteks in Rhetorid! etidmfic omne opus diuidit in ueritdtem,Qr petendd ic fugiendd,ciuod dl ftidforiie,^ de eodem,dtq; dUo pit^ tiendo dd hoc peruenit,ut dn fit, quid, qudle, qudittum, er qudm multum fit,quierendum putet.QjtoddmtdniKf loco finitionis quoq; uim intcUigit,quo dicitquieddmfK^ defendi: SufluU,fed non furtum fedtpereuÃi, fed non Li bri rheto iniuridm feci. Pofuerdt er Cicero in libris RhetoneKf j jj ^Ãibur U^igt;^Â°*^^'gt;^^gt;Z^*^^^i^iâ^^fÂ°'^^gt; ^^ lt;^ Ã^^^conie^urit in nomme finitio,m genere qudlitds,m dHione im intdif , gerctur,iurifubiecerdttrdfldtionem.Verumhiclegil(! quoc^ quaftiones dUo loco trdUdt, utffecies dHionis-Pucruntqui fdcerentqu'moi,coniedurdm,finitionem, qudlitdtem,qudntitdtcm,dd dliquid^Theodorm quoqne, ut dixi, ijfdem generdUbus edpitihus utitur, dn fit,quid fit,qiu.le fit,qudntum fit,dddliquid.lÃ®oc uitmunt mdxi^ me in compdrdtiuo genere uerfdriputdt, quonidmtnoli us dc peins,mdius demmui, nifi dUÃ¨ reldtd,non inte Sign tur.Sed in iÃM quoq^ trdnfidtiuus, ut fuprdfigndui,qiâÂ£ ? ftiones incidiunt,dn huic iutdgendifit, uelfdcere dliqnii conuenidt,dn contrd huc,dn hoc tempore,dn fic^omnii mm iftd refer ri dd dliquid nece/fe eÃ¼. Alijfex fcilicii fidtus putdnt,conieÂ£iurd,qudm '^iaâifi uocdnt,er qm litdtem, er proprietdtem-, id eÃ¼ 'âMrK}o:,quo uerbof nitio ofienditur,er qudntitdtem,qudm a^ixii dicwthcr

compdrdtionnÂ«, er tranlhitionem, cuiuf ddhucnoutim nomen muentiM eÃ¼ fj-zTasaa'iq, nounm wiquAm in ^d tu, dUoi^ui ah V-cmtigora inter j^eciesiuridicides uÃ'^ tiÃ¼mm.Al^i ff^tem effe pÃ¯icuit,d e^nibus nee tnnÃdtio, neec^MntitM,nec com^^dratioreceptdcursedmhorÃ¼ trium locum [ubditi c[iMuor legdes, ddieHiH^ iUis tri bui rationdibui. Alij peruenernnt ullt;^ dd, odo, trdnÃd tione dd feptemSuperiores ddiedd, A cÃ¿Ã¹bufddm dein*^ de diui[d rdtio eÃ,ut Ãdtw rdtiondles dppeUdrent c^m^ Ãionesyi^uemddmodwm fuprd dixidcgdlesSm iUM de re^ mbis deÃriptociuÂ£rerctur,QuiddmwidinerÃum,hos fidtut elÃeSÃ¼ds ejutÃiones mdiuernnt Â» Sed dUj rdtiond* les tres putduerunt, dn fit, c^uid fit,^udle fit. Hemfdgod-ns folum qudtuor,conic{iurdm,profrietdtem,trdÃdtio nem,lt;lUilitdtem,lt;lMm per decidemid, id eil Kara aV/x SiSaioq noodt, bde interpretdtione, dÂ» iÃ¼i dcciddt uiro bono elfe,nel mdlo, Hdneitd diuidit, de dppetendis,(y fugieniis,([ue dl pdrs delibcrdtiud,de perfond, cd ofiÃª diturlduddtiud,negotidlem,ciMm 'n^ay/djoSoAii uocdt, w qM de rebus ipfis quiritur remoto perfondrum cont plexu,ut fit'ne libcr,ciui dl m dffertionetdn diuitije fit* perbidm pdridnt,dn iujlum quid,dn bonum fitSuridicid. lem ,wqudferÃ¨eddem, fed certis defimdtisq- perfonit quÂ£rdntur,dniÃ¼e iufic hoe fecerit,uel bene.lJec mefdl* lit wi primo Ciceronis ^betorico,dlidm effe loei negotie lis 'mterpretdtioncm,cum itd feriptufittÃ®Ã¼egotidUs eil, 'm qui. quid iuris ex duili more,Ã§r eequitdte fit confide* rdtUTf ouidiUgenti^ pr^ejfc dpud nos iureconfnUiexi*

Ãimintur.Sed c^uod ipÃm de his libris indicium fucritÂ» fuprd dixi.Simt enim uclut res regefig m hos contentif rios,c^uos ddolcfcens deduxerat jchold t Qs Ãc^Uielii^ his cul^dftrÃ¤dentis ell.Sine cum mouit, quod Uerni* gorus prim d in hoc loco pofuit exempU ex qutÃioniitif iuris ,Ãue quod GrÂ£ci 'fi^ayp.cÃ¤KOijq uociintiuris iu^ ter prÃªtes. Sed Cicero quidem his pulcherrimos iUos i( Lit Rheto. OrutorefubÃituit, ideo^ culpuri t.inqudmfalfsprid^ ^enii^*^Â°*^'^ ^^^^^^^^^^^^â ^^^â^'^ Ã¼^incigorani.TrdnfldtiotiÃ¨l^i^ primus omnium trudidit, qiunqium femind dus quti* citrd nomen ipfum,dpud Arifiotclem reperiuntur. Lf* gdÃ¯es dutem qutÃioncs hds Ãccit.Ãcripti cr uolu^tdis, qudm ipÃe iiocdt Klt;xrlt;x '^HTo'/j,KoÃ imScÃ ^cri/j, id eSl if {tum,ct exceptioncm, quorum prias ci cum omnibus ca mune ell,exceptionis nomen minus uÃtatumydtioetnS tiusim dmliguitdtiSylegum contrdridrum. Albutiuse0 dem diuiÃone ufus detruhit trdnÃdtionem,Ãtbijciesedni iuridicidli.lnlegdUbus quoc^ quxÃionibus nudum puni effe,qui diedtur rdtiocindtiuus.Scio plurd inuÃªturos di hue,qui legere dmiquosÃudioÃusuolet.Sed ne htc lt;pio que exceffermt modum,uereor. Ipfc me pdulum in âÃ¼d qudm prias habuerim opinione ,niwccÃe conÃteor.Ã¼ fortdffe tutiÃmumerdt fdmÂ£modÃ³ Ãudenti,nihilex eo mutdre, quod multis dnnis non ÃenÃÃem modo, uf^ rumetidm dpprobdÃÃem. Sed non ÃuÃmeoeÃeconÃitis mihidiÃimuldnti in co pr^eÃriim opÃ¨re,quod ad bonoÂ» rumiussenum dliqudm utilitdtcm componimusÃmulli parte iudicij mei, aamey Hippocrates darns arte met

ORATOR. LIBER III. 179 iicintyUidetur honeÃiÃimefeci Hey quod quofdim erro res fuos^ne poÃeriemrentjconfcHus eH. Â£tM.TuUi*^^^^*^â^â us no dubitAuit dliquos lÃ editos Ubros, alqs pooled fcri ptis ipH ddmmre.sicut CdtuHum dt^ tucuUwm^ct bos ipfos,de quibus modi [um locutiis,drtis rbetoriccs. Etc nim fuferudcuus forct in Ãudijs longior labor, finibil fucrit liccrct melius muenire prtteritis, T^eque tarnen ex bis quicquim,qud turn prÂ£cepi,fuperudcuumfuit. Ad edfÂ« demenim pirticulAsbtecquoi^tquantvnc pritcipidm, reuertciuurjtd neminem didicijfe panitedt. CÃ³Ã¼igcre tantum eadem,ac di^onere paulÃ [ignificantius conor. Gmnibut autemfatisfadum uolo,n6n me b^ec ferius detgt; monÃrare dijs,quam mibqpÃ demonÃrauerim de perd fuifcrim. SfeuKduw plurwios dut or es ferudbamtris rd tionalcs Ãatus,conieduram,Ãnitioncm,quilitdtem, umt Ifgdkm.Hi mibi fatus gÃ©nÃ©rales er ant-EegilÃª 'm qum^ que Ã^ecies partiebar,Icripti,cr uolumtatisjlegum con* trirUrum colLediuum,ambiguitatis,tranflationk'. nuc qiwrtittn ex generalibus 'mtefl/go poffe remoueri. Suffi* cit enim prima diuifio, qw diximus alios le gales, lt;tlioi rationales effe, it a non erit fatus, fed quttfioniim ge* nus,alioqui ^ rationalis fatus effet.Ex bis etiam quoi ftcciitlf j uocaba,remoui translationem,frequenter qui* dfm(ficut omnes qui me fecuti funt, memmiffe poffurt) tefatus^et iÂ« ipfis etiam iUis fermonibusme nolense mei j nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;g^tKjboctdmfn ccmpIrxiM.wxiÂ« wild controuerfiA

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;M t

18o M. PAB. QVINT. INSTIT-dufum.Ueqw ignora muUd t^dnsferri,cum iÂ« onwUiii ferÃ¨ cdufts, m quibia cecidiÃe quis formuld didtw, ^^ fint qu^llioneSjdn huic^dn cum hoc^dn hdc lege,dn lt;lt;?â* htwc,dn hoc tempore licedt dgere, crfiqud funt tifÃ¯Â«*' Sfd perfonlt;e,tÃªpord,d{liones j cÂ£terdqi propter dUc^^^ cdufim trdnsferuntur. Ittinon eÃ¢ 'm trdnÃdtioneeini^ fiio,fcd 'm eo,propter quod trdnsfcrumur, NoÂ» itia dpud Pretorem peterefidei commijfiim, fed dpud Con^ fuies,mdior enim pretor id cognitione fummd e^, (^^ ritur,dn mdiorfummdfitfidHi controuerfid e^. NoÂ» K eet tibi dgere mecum, cognitor enim fierinonpotuilÃ¼' iudicdtio,dn potuerit.l^ on dcbuiÃimterdicereÃcd pf^ tere,dn reÃ¼e 'mterdiÃ©lu fit,imbigitur,C^Â£ omnid[Md cedumtlegit'mis quxfiionibusÂ» An non pr^feriptiones etid 'm quibus mdxime uidetur mdnifejid trdnÃdtio,ei[' dem omnes Ãecies,hdbcnt quds eÂ£ leges,quibus dgitur, ut dut de nomine,dut fcripto,Qr feiitentid,ucl rdtiocind tione quÂ£rdtur,dc'mde Ãdtus ex quÂ£Ãionc oriturf TW flitio nonhdbetquÂ£Ãionem, dequdcontenditordtor, tpropter Ãd per qudm confendit.Uoc dpertius: OeddiÃi homi* nÃ¨m,i^on occidi,QjiÂ£Ãio,dn occiderit. Stdtiit,conie(iii rd no eÃ¢.TdleÃ¼ldbeo ins ddionis,non hdbes,utfit qut Ãio,dn hdbedt,Qr mdeÃdtus.Aecipidt enim ddione nee ne,dd cuentum pertmet, non dd edufdm, e^ dd id quoi pronumeidt iudex,non id,propter quod pronucidt.Hoc iUifimile eR,puniendM es,non fiM,uidebit index dn pu niendus fit. Sed non hie erit quÂ£Ãio, nee hieÃdtus. vit er^ofpunie ndus cs,hom'mem oeddiÃi,non occidi,An at

tiderit.HonordndiM fww,non c j,num Ã^tum bdbetfnoÂ» Mt puto.HortordndiM fuw^quid tgt;MHÂ»Â«Â«Â» occidt,non oc cidtÃi,qw fÃio,cr RatiÂ«, Similiter, non rede Ã¤gii/edc Â«Igo,non habet ÃatÃ¼.Vbi eft ergo?no rede agis tgnomt nio[iÂ«,quf ritwr an ignomlniofw Æ) t,aut an a gÃ¨re ignoÂ» mmiofo liccdt,Â©- qu^Ãio e ft,er Ãatiw.Ergo trdnÃati-Â» MÂ«m gernÂ« aufg^ut compiritiuum, amp;nbsp;mutug dcccu^A tionw.At cnimfmile cft illt,tiM babco,nonhixbfj,occidi Ãi,rf fte occidi,non nego.Sed ne hfc res Ãatu facit.Non enim [uni hg propojÃ®tiones,dioqiu cmÃ'a non expltcabt tur, pd cum fuis rationibm. See liw commi ft Horatiiw, fororem enim occidit,non commifit, debuit enim occidc rc cam j^MÂ« hofis morte mÅrebat, quicfio,an bece iufa cau(a.lta quilitas : At fmiliter ht tranfationc, non haÂ« tes iw abdicandi^quiaignominiofo non cft adio,babeo iiÂ«,qÂ«ia abdicatio adio non cft,quÃ¦ritur quid fit adio, fniemiM,non licet abdicaref[ios,rgt;tlogifmiM.ltem clt;etc ra per omnes/t rationales^et legales fatiw.Nec ignora fnijfe quo/aam,qHi tranfationÃ¨ in rat ion ali quoq; gene re ponerent,hoc modo,bominem occidi, iu^iu ab impe ratore,dona templi cogenti tyranno dedi,deferui temÂ« pcfatibiÂ« ÃuminibtÂ« jUalctndine impeditut ,td cft non per me fetit,fedper ilia. A quibus etiam liberiiw di/fen tio.Hon enim adio transfertttr,fed auf a fadi,quod de cidit penÃ¨ m omni defenfone. Deinde is,qui tali utitur patrocinio,nonrccedit Ã forrnd qiwlitotiSjdicit enim fc cHlpa lUcare, nt magis qiwlitatis duplex ratio facienda fi,alter a qm erfadumdefenditur, altera qua tantum

Tria cffe 5 rwÂ«CrfÂ£icwdÂ«w cÃ igitur bÂ«, quorum autoriMmft fquot;iXÃ¯Ã³ne ^â*^ââ^ ^fi Cicero,trilt e^e, qu^ m omni diÃiutitionc lt;pt quirantur, runtur, unfit,quid fit, quÃ¤le fit. Qttod ipf nobis ctM prn^umâdi' ââ*^ââ'^ Ipnferait. Ã®^dm prmu oportet fuie (fie iliquii, ftum. Arifto de quo umbigitur,quoi,quid fit,or qudlefit, certe non cauffam^n^ poteUgfimdrknifiprias ejjecoiiftiterit. ideo^eipri pc quart fit, mil quefiio, fid non fidt'm quod efie munifefam, etUm quid fit dppdret.Hoc quoque confiituto,nouifiimd qui* litds [upcreA,nechis explordtis dUud e^uUrd. Bis Â»fi nitic qutfiiones, his finit g contmentur. Horum aUqui in demonflrdtiud, dcÃ¯iberdtiud,iudici(ilimdteridutique trdddtuur. Hic rurfus iudicidles edufis, O' rdtioMÃ parte,et legdU continet.iJec enm uUd iuris difieptitio, nifi finitionc,quAlitdte,conicilurd poteÃ» expUedri. Sti infiituentibus rudes, non crit inutilis Idtius primo fifi ratio, etfi non fiatim reHifima Imeatenfa ,facilior ti* tneno'dpertioruia.riifiantigituranteomnidquidri* pertitam in omnibus caufis effi rdtionem,quam primsM mtueri debedt,qui aduras eh. Uam ut ! defenfore po* tifi'mu incipiam, longe fortiÃ'ima tucndi fi ratio efi,fi quod obijcitur,negari poteR.Proxima fi non id qd d'^ eitur, fallu effe dicitur.Tertia honefiiÃimd,qui re^t f* lia defenditur. Quibus fi deficiamus, ult'ma quidefii ii fola fupereH filus, aliquo iuris adiutorio elabendt cf crmme,quod nee negari,nec defendi potentat non w* deatur iure allio intendi, Hinc iÃ¼t quafiionesfiae lt;(^â onis,fiue transUtionis.Simt enim quidam non laudibi* lid naturdjed iure coneejfa, ut m XU tabulis debito^â^

wrpiM inter cYciitorcsdiuiiilicMt, ([Mm lege mos puÂ« Uiciis re pudÃMitÃft dUejuid Â£c[Mim,fed prohihitum iu re,utUbertdX te^dmentorum. AccuUtorinibiloplural 'mtuendd jwnt,^ ut probet fdÃ¤um e^c,hoc effe fdUwm, nonreUe fd{iu,iure fe 'mtendere. 1 td ciredj^ecies edfdÃ« Us omnis ucrfdbitur/rdnsldtis tdntum dUi^iundo pdrtif lgt;ux,ut Hj eduÃs, c^uibus de premia dgetur,re(leÃdSium petitor probdt,. RxcqudtuoruclutpropoÃtd fÃ¶rmig; idionis, qua turn generdlcsÃdtus uoedbum, m duo^ut oÃendi\generd deÃcendMit,ritiondle er legdÃ¯e.Kdtio* ndle Ãmpliciiu eil, quid ipÃus idntum natur a contemn pIdtioneconÃdt. Itdc^ 'm co fdtis ed oÃendiffe coniedu rdm,Ãnitionem,qudUtdtem.'Legdlium plures Ãntj^ed* es necejfe ed,proptered quad multa ^umt leges,er Udri ds hdbentÃormdstdlid cÃ cuius uerhis nitimur,dlid cuius uoluntdtc-.dliiu nobis,cum ipÃi nulldmhdbemuStddiimgf, mu,dlids inter fe compdrdnjus,dlitis 'm diuerfum mter* prctdtnHr.Sic ndÃcuntur bac ueluti Ãimuldcrd ex iUis tri biK,mter'mÃmplicid,mtcr'im er mixtd,propridm tarne fdeietn oÃendcntid,ut feripti, et uolimtdtis,qua Ãnedu bio, dut qudlitdtc,dut coniedurd cont'mentur, er ÃyUof-gifmus, qui ed maxime quamp;litdtis, er legK contrarie, quÂ« 'qÃiem, quibus Ãcriptum, er uolwntms conÃdt, er Ã /J4iig3ÃiÂ«gt;qMie femper coniedurd expbedtur. Fwitio Amphibo-q^oq; Utriq; gfÂ»fn,qÂ«odqj rfrK,qKodqj feripti conti* ân^qu^ pldtionc conÃdt,eÃmu/nis eÃ.Uec omnid etiamft 'm iUos utmicg bo-ti^Â« Ã-itw uemut,tarnen quid,ut dixi, babent dUqufd ue quot;J^us defw lâf pJ'opnâuw, Â«ideWHr demonÃrandd diÃcewibut, er di poteft.

154 M. FAB, QVINT. INSTIT, permittendivm ca dicere uel fiAtui legAks, uel ([UijiioÂ» nes, uelcApitd quxdAin mmorA,du fciAitt,nihil nc m bit quidcm,prxtertriAj(litÂ£priedix'mut, ^utri. Atipnf t^m,^ quAin multum,c^ Ad Ahquid,zj- utnomulli pÂ«* tAi^crunt^compArAtiuos, non eAndemrAtionembAbeittÂ» Sunten'm hitc non Ad uArietAtem iurii^fed Ad foUmri tionem referendd. Ideo^ femper in pArte dut conie^it rie,dut qudUtAtis ponendd Ãmt,ut epu, mente,er tpto te pore,et c^uo loco. Sed deftngulis dieemm quejiionibut, cum trdfbdrepreceptd diuifionis eoepenmut, Hoc w* ter omnesconuenit, in cdufisfimpUcihutfingulosjldtuf effe edufdrum, queflionum dutem que uelut [ubideÃ«tes, Cr dd illud quo iudicium contmetur, referu/ntur, (ept in unAm eddere plures pofJÃ¨.EtiAm credo dliquindo iu iitdri, quo ÃAtuÃt utedum, cum dduerfus twdm mteiui onem plurA opponuntur, erficut m colore diciturnit rAtionis,eum ejjÃ¨ opt mu, qui AÃ¤or optime tuedturdU bic quo^ poffe dici, cum jldtu eÃe fAciendu^m quo tuen do plurimu Adhibere umupoÃit orAtor. Ã¯deo^ pro Wi lone dUud Ciceroni dgiti pldcuit^dHud Bruto, cum exer Bruti ontio^^^'^^^Â°'^^ grdtid coponcret ordtionÃª, cum iÃ¼e iure tdÂ»^ pro Milone. mÃdidtore occiÃm,et tdmen non tHilonif conÃlio dite rit,hic etidm gloridtutÃt, oceiÃo mdlo due. IÂ» coniudit ucro poÃe duos uel tres inueniri, uel diuerfos, ut Ã quit dUud fe nofeeiÃe, dliud rede ÃedÃe deÃenddt, uel gene ris dufdem, ut Ã quis duo crimind,uel otd neget.Qttoi deddit etidmÃ de und re querdtur dliqui, fed edm plu* res petAitt,uel eodem iure,ut proximitdtis^uel diutrÃo,

Â«t cum bic telidmtiiio,iÃ¼e proximitAtc nitdtur. Qjtoti* ts Mtem dliui dHj petitori opponitur ^ diÃmiks eÃeÃd tut neceÃe eH, ut m iÃ¼d controuerfidi TeÃdinentdlcgiâ)-iut f-d(id,rdtd Ãnt. tnteÃdtorum pdrentum Uberi hdre desÃnt.Abdicdtutjiei^uid de bonis pdtris cdpidtt No* thus dntekgitimim ndtus,kgitmusÃUutÃt,poll legi'^ timwinndtus tdntumduis. inddoptionemddreUcedt. Ciub.hoc in ddoptionem duto redire 'm fumilidm licedt, fi pdter '^^ ^âââ ââ' mturdhs fineUberis deeeÃerit. Qui ex duobus legitim mis dlterum 'm ddoptionem dederdt, dlterumohdicdi-uerdtÃuÃulit nothu,mÃituto harededbdiedto deeeÃit.

Tres omnes de bonis contendunt, vo9Ã¶|U,qwi nonÃt legi Nothw. timiÂ«, Gritci uoedntjidt'mum rei nomen ,utCdto ^Ho$ ^j â*Â° â j^â inoratiotte c^ud.ddmteÃdturtnonhdbemus Ãdeo^ utiÂ» Vetuno K murperegr'mo,SedddpropoÃitum.ildredi feriptoop Nonien* powÃKr lex, tibdiedtus neeptidde bonis pdtris cdpidt,Ãt Ãdtus ^ipti,^^ uolumtdtis, dn uUo modo cdpere poÃitt du ex uoluwutc pdti-w,^Â» b/rej feriptus.tÃ¼otbo duplex ft qiw/lio, quoi poft legitimos ndtusÃt, er quod non Ãc dnte lÃ©gitimas nutus. PriorÃyUogifmu hdbet,dn pro nonndtis Ãnthdbendi qui dfdmilid Ãunt dUendti: dlterd fcripti,er uoIu^t^UÃ® 4 Non en'tm eÃe hume nutum dnte legittrnm conuenit Ãed uolwntdte legis fe tuebitur, quÃ®

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dieet tdlem ÃiiÃe ^ ut legit'mus eÃet nothus, turn natiw,

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^P 'âtcludct dice ns,non utilt;^ Ã poÃed legit'tmus ndtM l nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«o Æ it, notbo noceycjUtftur^ boe drgumento: Ãnge folu 1 Â»dtiwi Â»otbion,cÂ«i(Â«conditiofjw crit^tdutuw ciuM^dt*

^Ki non erit poA legitimÃ¼ nitM,ÃliM,it([ui non frit ^ te legitimos mtut, i^Mre fi uerbis legis Ãdri no poU^, voilant Me Ãindam f A. Nfc quenq turbet, ^Â«od ex WM lege duoÃdtm Ãit,duplex eÃ¼, itd uim dudrÃ¼ hdbet:V.e dire mfdmUid uolenti diÃ turdbdltero;Prmum,ut titi redire licedt,hires fumjdÃ©fidtus^qui in petitione dbÃ cdtitc^uiritur enim,dn poÃit efje hires dbdiedtus.Ai* ijcitur comumiter 'd duabus^redire tibi mfdmilid non li* eet,non enim pdter fine Uberis deeeÃit. Sed in hoe pro* prid quifiji eoru quifiione nitetur.Altcrenim dieet,di* diedtu quoq- inter libÃ©ras cjje^fy drgwnentu ducet ex ip[d,qud repelUtur lege.Superudcuumenim fuiffeprobi igt;eri pdtris bonis dbdicdtu/m,fi effet numero dlienoruw, niwc cptid filij iure futur ut fuerit mteftati hires,oppo* fitdm effc legem, qui tdmen id non efficidt, nefiliusfit, fed ne hires.Stdtus finitiuus,quid fit filins. Kurfus no* thus effdem colligit drgumentis, non fine liberis pi* trem decefiffe, quitus in petitione ufus eÃ¼, ut probi* retfeeffe filium, nifi forte zy hic finitionem mouet, M tiberi fint etidm non legitmi, Cddent ergo in undtn con trouerfidm,uel ffecidUter duo legitmi fidtus,feript'f Cf uolumtdtis, er fyHogifmus, er pratered finitio, Â«d tres iÃ¼i ,quindturd foli fumt, coniedurd in feripto, C uolufntdte,qudlitds in fyUogifmo,er qute perfe eÃspet td finitio. Cdufd quoque er iudiedtio, er continens eÃ¼ in omni genere edufdrum. iJihil enim dicitur, cui non in fit rdtio,er e^uÃ¨ iudicium referdtur,cr quoi rein mi ruime coittmedt. Sed quid migis hlt;ec udridntur in litilub

Oâ fere trAditi fivnt ah bw, qui de iudiciilibuf cdufts ali ^Â«4 compofucrivntmilium partemdtfjirAmur. Nunc ^WA m triA generA cAufAt diuijl^ordmem fequAr.

AC uituperAtionc.Quod genm uidetur Arijiote les. Atqueeumfecutut TheophrA^M, A pArte negotiAli, hoc eh Tt^ciyfxcÃ¢mtiremouiffe, totAmq^ AdfolosAudi tores relegAjfe,lt;!3- id dus nommis, quod Ab ojientAtio^ ne ducitur,propriueSl.Sed mas KomAniK,etii negotqs hoc mimas mfcruit. Ndm Oâfimcbres lAudAtiones pen dent frequenter ex publico Aliquo offreio ^ Â«Ã§ ex fenAt tufronfrlto mAgifrrAtibus fepe mÃdAntur^ et lAudAre te fregt;n,uel contrA pertmet Ad momentu iudicioru^t^- ipfrs etu reis dAre lAudAtorcs licet, et editi m c0petitores,vn LtPifonefru Clodiu et CurionÃ«librÃ¯,uituperAtionÃ« con t'ment, CT tAmen in fenAtu loco fimt hAbiti fententite. Nf^ mfeiAS to,elfe quAfdA ex hoc genere mAtcriAS Ai foil copofitM ofrentAtionejut lAuies deoru,uirorumq;, quos prior A temporA tulenvnt.Q^o foluitur quÂ£frio fit prAtrAllAiA,mAnifefrum(^ eft err Are eos,qui numquAm orAtorem di^urum,ni(i de re dubiA,putAuerwnt. An lun dej Cdpitolmi touts ,perpetUA fucri cert Aminis niAteA rlAjueldubit fu/ttt,uel non orAtorio genere trAdAnturi V t dejidem dwtem Idiw, qÂ«/ negotqs Adhibetur,probA tionein,fK etiAm HlA quÂ£ ofrentAtioni componitur, hAA iettnterimiliquAm f^edemprobAtionis .ytqui RoÂ»

fnulum M-irtis filinm,':diicdtumqi Ã lupd dicdt,in irgÃ¼^ tnÃ«tum caÃ¯ejlis ortm uMur hif, i^uoi abieÃ¼ui m fro^ ÃueMem non potuerit extingni, quoi omnia fie egmt, ut genitum prafide beUorum deo mcredibile non fit,lt;li ipfium quoij} calo receptum temporis dus hommes non dubitaucrmt-Cluidam ueroetiam m defenfionis fi^ed^ em cddent, ut firn laude ilercÃ¼lis,permutdtum cu/m rt^ ^tm LydiÂ£ hiibitiim,etiinperiitd,ut trdditur,pen[d ori tor exeufet. Sed proprium laudis eSl res dmplificdre,(Jâ orndre,(pit materid pr^cipue quidem in deos ez hoon nes cddit,eR tarnen et aUoru animalium, eyr caremiiM anima, Verum in deis,generaliter primummaiefiatem ipfius eoru naturg uenerabimur, deinde proprium uim cuiupj;, c^ inuenta, qug utile aUiptid hommibus attule^ Ãm deo^quot;' ^^^â¢'^^ ofienditur^ut in loue, regivndorum hominu: inKdrte,beÃ¼i:'tntieptuÂ»o,mdris:l.nuÃ«td,utartiumin Mmerud'.Ã¯JiercurioylitcrdrumtmedicingyApoÃ¯Ã¯meiCo^ rere,frugumiLibero,uini. Turn fi ejud db his add netÂ»'' fias tradidit commemoranda, Addunt etiamdijs hono^ Ex prima ^^^ pdrentes^t fi quis fitfilius louis.Additanticpd^^â pmniÃ¼ re^Ã® Ut his (^uifiuntex chdo. Progenies ^uoc]^, ut ApoW^_ ^cHcRodi' ^'^'ââ ^ Ldtong. Laudandum in (piibufdam, (ptod gÂ«'^^^ ,n Theogo' immortaleSiinepiibufiddmtCiuodimmortdlitdtemM'i'tn^ W^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;te fint confccuti.i^uod pietas prmdpis nofirfiprijent^*

urn quo^ temporu decus fecit. Mdgis ed udrid Idfs ^^ minum.tdldmprimumdiuiditur in tempora,ejuoi^d'^ te cos finit,quo f ipfit uixerunt. IÂ» his autÃ« quifidtofiat'^ fundi,etidm quad ed infecutwm- A.nte hommemp^il^'^

tie pircntcs,nMioresq; ertwt,qunru/m duplex MdAtus ffl. Aut enmrej^ondijfenoUUtiitipulchrim erit ^dut bwrniltw genui iÃ¼ujlrdjftfidii.iUd quo^j interim ex eo quad dine ipfum fitit,tempore trdhcntur,(iuÂ£ ref^onfu tul dugurijs futur dm cldritdtcmpromiferunt. Vtewrnt ^^[^jjj^j qui ex Thetidendtm effet fmdiorem pdtre fuo futurwm Thetidis si ceemiffe dicuntur ordculd. Ip/Ã¯iÂ« uero Idui hommif ex ^'^'â^i ^Mâ*Â» lt;H0BO er corpore sy extrd, poftii peti dehet.^t corpo extat apud rif ouidern fortuitorumcii cum leuior, tu non wno modo Cafulium

' margonaii trdetdnddfst.NdwZT pulchritudmem mterim roiurq tids, profeqimur,honore ueriorti, ut Homer in in Agdment none dtq Achille, Interim confert ddmirdtioni multuni ftiitm infirmitdi,ut ctm idem Tyded pdruumjed beUd^ toremdicit fuifje,TÃ¨ortunduerOjtumdignitdtemdfjÃ¨rtj ut in regfbui principibiaq: n^q eft bÃ¦c mdterid ofledÃ« dx uirtutii uberior, turn quo minores opes fuerunt, eÃ mdiorÃ« benefdilis gloridm pdrit. Sed omnid qhe extrd nosbondfunt, qu^^ bominibtÂ« forte obtigerunt, non ideo lduddntur,(juod hdbuerit qÂ«K ed, fed quod bw bo fquÃ¼ neue fit ufm, Hdm diuitit, z^ potemid z:r grdtid,cum plurimum uirium dent in utrdnq pdrtem, certiÃmum fdeint moru experimeMum, dutenim meUores propter bec, dut priores fumut. Animi uero femper uerdldui, Sednott iwtd per boe opus uid dttcitur.Ndnquc dlids Â£td, tii i^ddus,ge^ArumqrerumordinemfeeptiJlpeciofmi fuUt Min primis dnnis Uuddretur widok s,tiwn difeipti Mf ,poft boe opcriwn,id cÃ fddorum didorumq contÃ©

diuis, iulHtix, contmcnfiÂ£,cd[tcrArumq;,dc fmgulii d^i gndre,quie [ecwnduqiunqi edrugeÃderut.VtrdÃtdut ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;hdru uid utilior,cum mdterid ddtbcrdiimtis,iu fcidmii

grdtiord effe dudiÃ«tibtis, qua fului qu(s,dut primMidut certccumpducKfeciffedicetur.fiquidpratcredfufiri Ãgt;c,dut expeÃ«idtionÃ«^pracipue qd'dlieud potiuf edufd,^ fud.yÃ«pui quod finÃ«bommis mÃquituryno fempertrdÂ«' Hare contmgit^non folu quod uiuÃ«tes dliqudndo Ãdud0 mufifed quod rdrd hac occaÃo eR^ ut referri peÃtnt ii umi honores,^ deerrtd,ut publica ftdtua coÃituta. W r A i^rquÂ£enttgt;ncrducrimmgeniorumtnonuniÃ«td,quafccu poft mortÃ© ll^ probdrcntur.'t^dm quidd,ficut Menddcr,iuÃiord po fingitmaio Ãcroru,qfuaatdtiiiudicidÃmtconfccuti.AjJrrutldU A PuK)NÃ¤ demlibcripdrÃ«tibut,urbescoditorib:{t, legesIdtoribiu, Juc fecures artes 'muentoribuSjtteenon wÃitutd quoque dutoribtu, pffrjcos^'Vn ^t:dt^umdtrdditumdeoscolere,d. PubUcoldfdÃespof populicÃ¶d' pulo fubmittere. Ciuiomnisetidininuituperdtioneor'' cÂ« fubmi' j^^ conÃdbit,tarnen in diuerfum.Udm CT turpitudo gfÂ» luxta hoc neris opprobrio multis fuit,et quofddm cldritds ipfd na rkh^^ani tioreseireduitid^Qr muifosmdgis fecit,cr 'm quibufit, mi uitiÃ¼ tÃ¢ Ut 1Â« Pdride traditum eR,pradi(td pernicies er corpo Minfeerp' ^^â^ fortuna:quibu^ddm mdld,coittemptum,utT'ber^ men habet, fita: At nero quibufdd bona uitijs corruptd odium attu quanto ma- lernst; ât Nired ^mbeUem,PliÃmÃ« impudicumfd PoÃ«tii pCC* , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;0* L

cathabef. dcceptmits. Btdnbni tottdemuittdy quoi uirtutcs ju^h Vhad Â« ^^â^ ^^â'^ ^â*^'^ ^^ ldudibuf,duplici rdtione trdÃ«iantur. Ã¯liad.gt;. E^ pÂ°^ mortÃ« ddieHa quHu'ddm ignemwid eH, ut Me btvi^ *** â'^ ^^â^^^â^ â^^^^ f^^^ lequitdMdrco^ Mdlio^ cuius prf

NoiNM i fnmililt;nmpojieru/mexcntptumcfi.F.t pirmtrt milorumodimtu, Cf fft conditoribM urlium iaifdmu, tontrixiffe dli^udm perniciofdm ceteris gtnttiUflt;Ã¿MlK eft prwnui iHddicÂ« fuperjiitionis autor, O' Gracebof- i^gej^A^^-rum leget tmiiff.7J:Ã c^uod eA exem^ium deforme poÂ« nÃ¦. ÃerÂ« trdditum,lt;juilc lUidmii uiT Perj'es,in muiiere Sdlt;- j*'^J^*X niAinlUtuere dulmdidtur primui^Sed in Uiuentibus quo^jiWicM bominum Â«flut drgumentA fur.tmorum^ 0 bonos dut ignommid^uerdm effeldudem,uel uitupe^' ntionem prohMMereffe tdmen ArijÃ¯oteles puM^uhi qwâ[que kudetur, dut uituperetur â¦ Ndm plHriwwn re* fert.qwi fint duiietuium moYes,lt;lux publice receptd pes' fudfw.utilld mdximc qut probdui effe in eo quilduddÂ« Utur^creddnt.dut in eo cotrd cpiem dicemui,ed qÂ«Â« ode rtwijftd non dubium trit iHdic;twn,qHod ordtionÃ« prlt;e* ce^etitjpforum etidm iudicum permifcendd IdM fern* pcr.Ndw id beneuoios fdeit. G^uoties dutem fieri pote* rit^cummuterie utilitdteiungendd.IA.inm'Ldcedgmo* neÃudid liter drum, quim Atbenit honoris mercbidwt pluspdtientid/ortitudo.'B.dpto uiuere c^uibufddmhone ^Uydbis curd kÃ¿m.VrugdUtds dpud Sybdritds forÃtdfi SybarÃ®tat* odio foret,ueteribus V^orndnis fummum luxurid cj imÃª* Eddem in fwÃ¿tUs diffÃ¨rewid. Kdxifmefduet iudex,epti fbi iieentem dffentdri putdt.ldem pr/cipit iUud qÂ«c^-, quodmox Cornelius Celfus propÃ¨ fuprdmeduinudf.t^ quid pt qK(tdÃ¯ uirtutdjus dc uitijs uicinitds, utendu pro xmd deriuitione uerboru/m, W pro temer urio fortemi prodigo libfrdIem,dMdro pdrcHW Â«oeemÂ»lt;, qÂ«lt; erfden!

etidm contre udlcnt^quod quidcm orator,id (Ã,itif^'â tiiu nunquint fadet, niÃ forte cemmuni utiUtate dvd tur.Laudantur autem urbesfimiUter atq^ hewwes.t^* pro parente eÃ¼ conditor,z^ multum autoritatÃ» iff^ uetuÃaf,ut bit qui terra dinmtur orti,amp;uirtutesAt''^ tia circa rea gejia;,eadÃ¨qi m fingulis, lUa propria,qÂ»^ ex loci poÃtione,aut munitione font,dues iUis,ut botÂ» nihus liberi, decori, EÃ laits et operum, iÂ« ^Hite Iâââ* nor,utilitas,pulcbritudo,autor ffedarifolett'Houotd^ in tempUsi'Vtilitas, ut m mÃ»ris : Pukhritudo uel autof, In Verrem utroUq^.Elicr locorwm,qui.lisSiciliÂ£apuddeeronÃ©, aftione 4. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^Â«/t^j fimiliter ffcciem,Qr utilitatem intuemur,flgt;t^

ciÃ«maritimis,planis,amcenis:utiÃ®itatÃ«,falubribus,fertile bus. Prit etiam didorÃ¼ hone flora faUoru^ laus gentri lis,cri t et rerum omnis modi.Ptam cr fonini,cr mortu fcriptttlaudcs,z7' quorundam Ã medicis ciborum-itiif ut non confenfi hoc laudatiunm genus circa foUmuerÃ ri honefli quaflionem/ic qudlitate maxime contineri pÂ» to, quanquim omnes tres flatus cadere in hoe opus pof fintfijs^ ufum C.Ca:far cm in uituperando Catonenoti uerit dcero. TotÃ¼ autem habet aliquid flmile fuiforqs, ^ia plerunq; eadem illic finder i,bic laudarifoleni,

DPliberatiuas quolt;^ miror Ã quibufdam fola utili tÃ¤te finitas. Ac fi quid in bis urumÃqui oportet ret, potior fuijfet apud me deeronis fententia, qui hoc materiit genus,dignitate maxime contineri putat, NÂ«

Subito quin bi, qui fiwt iw iHd priore [enientid, fccun* dum opwiioncm pulcbcrriwidm, ne utile quidÃª^ni/Ã® quoi boneÃum effct, exiÃimiriÃ¼t, Et eft bfcrdtio uerif* fimi,Ãi conjiliwm comingdtpmper bonorum, dtq; ppi â¦ tntum.'verum apui imperi toj, upui quos frequenter dicenda fentewia eft^popukwq; prÂ£ecipuc,qui ex pluÂ» r ibult; cotisÃ¢t widoftw, dipernenda font bÃ¦c, CT fecun* dum communes mttgis intclledus loqucndum.Sunt cnnn multi,qui etiam quf credunt boneÃUjnon turnen futis eu dem Htiliu quoque exiÃiment, quÃ¦ turpiu cjje dubiture non pojjiwÃ¯t,utilitdtis/})ecic dufli promeut,ut faiut Nu m(UMtnuÂ«t,iugum^C4udiÂ«uw.Nc quulitutw quidc )Ã®ââ* tu,'m quo er bonejiorum,cr utilium quxÃio cft/omple fticiÂ« futis eft.Num frequenter in bis etiimconiedur^ locus eft. Nonnunqwm etium truflutur cliqua fÃ®nitio, Abquundo etiS weidere poffiwit legules truftutus in pri tutu maxime couplid ,fi qiwndo ambigitur^dU lice ut.De coniefturd puulo poft pluribus.Iwterim eft fÃ®nitio upui Demo(lbcnÃ«,detHdlortefumPbiIippu$ unredddt.Apud j^ oiynthia

â¢ Ciceronem mPbilippicis, quid fÃ®t tumultus. Quidf non cis Philippi. indpmilK iwdicialiuwi quÂ£Ãio,deÃdtult;tSeri(ij Sulpitij^ ââ¢^Â®â Â«n bis demuw ponendu fÃ®t, qui in legutione ferro fivnt mteremptif Ergo purs deliberutiuu, quÂ« eudem fuufÃ´Â» riu dicitur,de tempore futuro confultAns, quierit etium de pruteritOjO^ifs connut duobus,fuudendi C7 diffin' proÅmium dendi. ProÅmio,qudlceft in iudiciulibus, non ubique delibtratiuS 'g^tj*!**Â« coneiliutus eÃ ci quif^ quem confulit.lnitium Â®^ demon' turnen quodctwique debet bubere uliquum proamifff)C# ^quot;^***ââquot;ââ¢

194 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlTâ , dÃ©mence enim abrupte,nee unde libuit incipiÃ©dumA^^^ eÃ¼ aliquid in omni materid ndturAUterprmumdnÃâ^^ tu,cr uti^; in condonibus eadem ratio, (pa dpui ifgt;^^* ces dequiredg fibi plerunlt;^ eoru apud quos diceniur beneuolÃ«tig^tiec mirti cu/m etia in Panegyrids pedi^ dudicntiiifauor,ubi emolument u no utilitate dlii^diir Ariftote,?. ^f'â^^^âââ^^coÃÃit.AriÃotelesquidÃ«ynceÃneeduÃf^ Rhct. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tat era noÃrd,et ab dus tpti dij]entiet,perÃ)nd dueiÃ^

queuter in conÃlijs exor diu, quafi mutuantibus bdc w* bis Ã iudidali genere,nonunq etiA,ut minor resmutÃ ue uideatur. Ã¯n demonÃrdtiuis uero proamid e^femi^^ me liberd exiÃimdt. Nam er longe Ã materia duci^tt^ Helenes laude ifoerdtes fecerit,cr ex dliqua rei uiciaHi utide m panegyrico, cum qugritur plus honoris corf'^ rum,q anmoru uirtutibus dari. Pt Gorgias in 0 Wlt; co laudans eos, qui prmi talcs inÃitucrunt conuentit-SaUuftil pro Qgoj fecutus uidelicet CrijÃus SalluÃius in hello WÃ¿^t thino et Catibnario, nihil ad hiÃoria pertinentibus fiÂ» cipijs or [us cR. Sed nuc ad Ãu,foriA,in qua etia cu prolt;^ mio utemur,breuiore tarnen, er uclut quoda capitetaa tum,ct initio debebimus eÃÃcontenti. Harrationemo^ ro nunq cxiget priuatd dcliberatio, dus dutaxit fd^ qua dicenda fententiacll, quia nemo ignorÃ¢t id de^tgt;[ confulit.Pxtrmfecus pofÃmt pertmensid ad ddiberado nem multd ndrrari. in condonibus [gpe ell etia illa,lt;jf^ ordmem rd docet,necefÃarid, ad aÃvilus,ut quÂ£^ Â»n^ ximepofluldbit.Hdmetcodtandd,ctleniendafi'eqdtâ'^ eÃ ira,et ad metum,cupiditatcm,odium,coneHiatiii^

ORATOR. LIBER Ill. 19$ bpcHfndi dttimi, NonÂ«iÃ¼t| etidm moÂ«cnd4 mifentio, pucHt Mxiiivmoi^tÃiifcrdtur.jMiereofpoYteiitfiue focit ciwitdtis cucrfioncm dfÃchhnw.Vdiet dut 'm conft lijÃ® dutoritÃÂ« plurmuwn.Ndm er ^ruientiÃimui effe bit beri^ V optimtM iciet,lt;[uifententu fut ie HtilibtM dt queboneÃis adere omnes uelitJn indicies enm wwlgo fdtbdbftwrwidMlgeretliquidÃuHo fuo^confiUdnemo ^riftott eft qui nfget fccivniwm mores idri.Grtcorwm quidem Rhet. plurwiiowttcbocoflÃ¯cium condondleeffc iudieduerut. er in fdi rcipublicie ddmintPrdtione po/uerwnt.Q^in er Cicero mbic mdxime pnrte uerfutur. I Jcoqj fuifu'' Q^llÂ° ââ * ris de pdee, kilo, copijs, opitus, McftigdlibtM.bÂ« duo prÂ«cipuc notd e^t uoluit, uires duitutis, er mores, ut ex ndtwrd tuin ippruw rcruin/iwÂ« dudiÃ©tium rdtio fuA dÃ«di duceretur.Nobis mdior in re uidetur udrittuenum er confultMtiwm,er confÃ¼iorum plurmd fwnt generu.

Qwre in fuddendo er iiffuiieniotrid pfmJtwnÃjeftd^^ â p'quot;j-pÂ® ddcrutiQuidpe de quo deliberetur, qui fint qui dclibe Bandau rent,qui fit qui /Ã®wdedt.Rem de qtid ddtkmtur,dut cer tumeÃ poÃeÃerijdut incertum.Si iÂ«certu,blt;ec erit que ÃiofoU, dut ^otentiÃimi'.fife en'm decide t,ut prias di camus,ne ft pof it quid? Ãer i,effe fudenium,iemieÃe rinon pojfe.Cum dut de boe qult;eritur, coieflurd eft,un iÃbmos mtereidi, unÃecdre palus Pontind/n portas ft eriHoÃiÂ« pofit ,dn Alexander terras ultra Oceanum pt inuenturus.Sed in bis quoq;, qua cohabit fofje Ãerii conieftumerit aliquando, ut p quaratur, un utique fuÂ» fur um ft, Ht Cartbaginem fuperent RomanijUt redeafc

Hannibal, ft Scipio exercitum in Africam tranjiitM ut feruet fidem Samnites,ft Romani arma depofueritif-Ã^uedam er fieri pojj'e,^^ futur a ejje credibileeii,!^^ aut alio tempore^^aut alio loco,aut alio modo.vbi con^^ durie non erit locuf,alia funt mtuenda.Et primunii/^ propter ipfam rem,de qua fiiUentiÂ£ rogantur,confi^^^ bitur, aut propter alias interuenienies extrinfecus^^ fas.Propter ipfam deUberantP. C.an fiipendiuMini^^' confiituant.Hac materia fimplex erit. Acccdu/ntciitfii aut faciendi,ut dÃ©libÃ©rant P. C.an Pabios dedantd^^ Sumptn id belliim mmitantibuts aut non faciÃ¨di,ut dÃ©libÃ©rÃ¢t CX^ r^^Ã¼b quot;7 A^j^â per feueret m Germaniam ire, cum milites p^ tefiamenta facerent.Uefuaforiiie dupUces funt.t^aÂ«* amp;nbsp;illic caufa deliberandi cji,quod bellum GaÃi minitent^'fâ e/fe tarnen quaftio potcR, dedendi 'ne fuermt etiiHââ ^â* tra hanc dcnuciationem,qui contra fas,cum kgatin^r effent,pralium miermt, regem^ ad quem mandata ac^ ceperant truddarmt.Pt bic nihil Ca far fine dubio deÂ»* beret,nifi propter hanc militum perturbationem, f^^^ men locus quarendi,an citra humc quoq; cafum penete^ dumm Germaniam fuerit,Semper autem deeo priai quemur, de quo deUberari, etiam detrodis fequenti ^ Partes fua' poffet,Partesfuadendi quida putauerumt honejhai^^ *âââ*ââ le,neceffarium,Pgo non muenio huic tertia

talibetenimuisingruat,aliquidfortalfepatinecefiâh nihilfacere,defaciendo autÃ« debberatur. QÃ¿odf ^^ uocant nÃ¨ccffitatem, 'm quam homines grauiorum iÂ» cogur.tur,utilitatis erit quafiiot Vtfi obfefihtÃ¼^ '^^

utboc JubtjcutttÃ¯jdlioquipcreiwidtvmeftjiMpyopteT idipfuwnoneftncce)]c,qÂ«t(tpcrirepoti!Â«licet,Dem^ non feccrut SdguMt'mi, nee in rite Opitergwidcircwm* uewi.lgitur in bis quo^edufujdut de foldwtilitdte dm* bigetur, dut qnf dio inter utile dtqjboneÃum confijlet.

At enim p quis liberos procredre uolet, neeeÃiebdbedt uxorÃ© duccre,quis dubitdt? fed ei qui pdter unit Ãcri,li quedt ncee Je eft uxor em eje ducenddm.Itdque mibi ne confitiiwnquidcmuideturjubinecej^itdÃ¯ eft,nonmdgis quim ttbi conjldt quid fieri omnino non po Je*omnw e* nm dcliberdtio de dubijs eft.MelitM igitur, quitertidm pdTtcmdixcruntd'ujÃ¼aiw,quodnoÃripoJ?ibilenomi* Â® â â ndittjqujeutdurduidcdtttrdppelldtiojtdmenfoldeft.

j edrumnutnenÂ« dugetur, d quibus ponuntur ut pdrtrs, quÂ« jeeies funt partium: Ndm fds,iuÃu,pium, Â«quotm, 1 mdnfuetum quoq;,fic enim fu^t inter pretdti to'Â«p-^op, cr fiqud ddbuc ddijcere quk eiufdem generis uclitjubij ti pojfuntbonejldti. An jit dutem facile,mdgnumjuciw*

^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;loei oÃ¯iuntur ex contrddiftione:cft quid? utile fed di J ^^ ^^ .^^^^^

â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;uidetur e (fe nonnunqudm de iucunditate fold confultd* ad AUxan

tio,ut fi de Â«difcdndo tbeatrOjinJlituendisludiSjdclibe ^'''âââ'' retur. Sed neminem ddeÃ´ folutMnlwxMputOjUtmbirw

cdufÃ¤ fmdendi fec^Mtur prÃªter uoluptdtem. wcii^ enim femptr aliqM neerffe e^^utm ludis honor dflt;* ru,in thedtro no utilif Ixboru remiÃio, deformis et i/nco modii turbiftfi id non fit,conÃi{idtio,Gr nihilotmntat* dÃ« iÃA reUgio^cum thedtru wluti quoddAiUim [dcri W* plu uoedbimtu.Sgpeuero er utiUtdtÃ« dej^icienddin eS'^ diemui^ut honefta fdcidmus,ut cum iÃK Opitergntn i^ mus conÃliu,ne fe hoÃibut dcddut, qMn^ perituriÃn^t nififeccr'mt,et utilid honeflit pr^efcrimui^ut ciM [if^^^ mut ut betto Ptwico ferui drmentur. Sed turnen nf$ ^ pldnÃ¨ concedendueii,efje id mhoneÃÃ¼.Liber os en^ n^ turd omneSfO- ijldem conÃdre elemenfifyCrfoti^llâ^^ tit^uif etidm nobiUbm ortos did poteli. Et iUic,nligt;Â»^^ nifeÃuM pcriculu ell,opponÃ«dd dlid, ut crudelius etiiÂ«* tSiuero ho perituros dffirmemut,fi fe dediderwt, fiuehoÃifi''â^ uerint fiÃ¯Ãª Æ feruduerit fidem,Ãue CÂ£Ãdr uiccrit,lt;iuod eH ueroÃ'Â»^^ fi Caftr. nbsp;nbsp;liut.aÂ£c dut,(pire tdntu inter fe pagHdnt,pÃ¯erivn^; ^

nihui deficili foknt.Lidm et utility ipfd expugndtue^ hif,lt;pii dicunt nonfolu potior d effe honend, j utmy^ ne utilid lt;ptidÃ« effc,i^UÂ£ non Ãwt honeÃd: er coiUrM^^ nos honejlumjiÃi udnu/m,dmbitioÃum,Ãolidum,uerlgt;i^ Ã reprobdbiliiis uocdnt.Ncc tdittim mutilibus compidâ^

mutjm tdtero quid Ãt minus.Crefat hoc ddhue.tidtn Â» term triplices etid fudforire incidtMtt,ut am Pompent deUberduit, Pdrthos,dn AÃ-icA, dn Aegyptim petera gt;nbsp;Stad, iM gt;^Â°f^ tdistum utrwnmcliusJed auidÃt optmtM p*

fMitrit iuUtAtio rei, ^u Æ iwilt^* fecundu nosjit.'l^Mt vbi contrAdmioni lociw non cH, qÂ«Â« poteft effecduft dubitmndi^ itifereornnKfuiforid nihil eft dliud,^com fintio. videndÂ«^ quid confecuturifimtUyCy propter quid. Ht it^imdri pe^ityflw m to,quod pctÂ»nKt,/it co* modi, dn uero wt to propter quod pttimiK, inconnnodi. E ft uero utiUtdtii (^ in tempore qutjiio, Expedit, fei non mwe.Et m loco,^on bic.Et in per fond,tion nobit, non corUrd hos.^t in gentre dgenii, Non fw.^ in mod do,Non tdnturn. Sed per/Ã´nlt;tnj fxpiut decoris cdufd in* Perfona de* tutmur,quÂ£ o' in nobii,0â in his qui deliberdnty^edlA jÂ°[ââ' j^* di eft. itdquc quimuis exempli plurmum in confilqs poJ?tnt,qHt(j fdcilime dd con Centiedumhommes duenna tur experimentis, refert tumen, quorum dutoritdi,0â quibusidhibtdtur.T)iuerÃ fumt enim deliberuntium uni mi,duplex conditio.^dm confultdnt nut plures,dut find gulfed m utrifque differentid, quid 0 in plttribus mul turn inter eft^outui fit,dn populus y'Komdni dn Tided mtesyOrtcidn'Sdrbdri-.T.tinfinguliSyCdtonipetendos honores ^uidcdmus,dn C. Mdrio.De r^tione belli Scipio prior dn Tibias deUbcret. Tromde mtuendus fexus,did gnitds,Â£tds.Sei mores prtcipue diferme dihunt.Ti ho ne^iquidihoneÃis fuiderefdcilimwmeR,Ã utrodpui twÃ¯pfj refti obtmere condbimur, ne uidedmur exprod tr^re diuerpm uita fedtimcduÃ«dum eft.Et Animus deU berintisynon ipfi honefi ndturd,quAm He non refpicit, permcuesdusfed liude,usdgi opmiontytt Ã pirum pro

200 M. FAB, oyiNT. INSTITÂ» uero migis obijciendo dUquos^Ã diuer/d fecerit^nutiK-Ndm fritter id ({uod hts leuiÃmi cuiuÃÃ intimus Ã^^ me terretur, neÃio un etium tiiituraliter afud plurimoi plus ualeat malorum timor,qudmjÃes bonorum,fuut Ã cilior eifdem turpiu/m,(iuim honeÃorum 'mteUeilus fÃ Ali^uindobonis quo^ue Ãudentur partim decordyiH'^ tur parum bonis confilia, m tj^uibus ipforum lt;}ui con[u* luntyj^eHatur Militas. Nfc mcfaÃ¯lit,quie Ãatim coÃ¿i^* Sl hoc fas ^^Â° Ã^^^^ l?Â°(fâ' ^'^ff^t^'if-Hoc ergo prÂ£cipis^cy ^^^ pietasf fas putasiPoterat me liberare M. Cicero t^ui itaÃri^ ad BrMum:PropoÃtis plurimis quthoneÃefuaderi^^ fart poÃent, Sim 'ne bonus uir,Ã hoc Ã^adeamimini^l^^' Suaforis enim eÃ¼ finis Militas dus/ui ^uiÃ^ findet, ^ rcila funtyCluis negatified non eH femperredisinf^* dcndo locus. Sed quia cR altior qutÃio, nec tantu/m fitaforias pertmet, defimatus eH mihihic locus duodei^ mo,qui fiummusfMuruseAyUbro.t^ecego quiequimÃ ri turpiteruelim, uerum intÃ©rim htcuelad fcholarut* ercitationes pertinere credantunnam or miquoru r^* tio nofeenda eR,ut menus aequo, tueamur.lnterim fi f'I bono mhoneÃa findcbit,mem'merit nonfinderetanqi** inhoneÃa, ut quidam deelamatores Sextum Pompent ad piraticam,propter hoc ipfum,quod turpis ac crud^* Color defor ^^ fii,MtpeÃ¼umt, Sed dandus iUis deformibus color,ie^ mibusdan- etiamapudmalosmecenm eÃ qui(quimtammAlus,i*^*^ deri uelit- Sic Catilina apud SaÃ®lufiium loquitur, ut r^ ficeleratiÃmam non maUtia, fed Mignatione uide^^^ audere.Sic Atreus apud yarumt

Quinto mugis eis quibusfuit dliqui curdfime^confcrÂ« Â«indus eft bic uel dmbitus? Quire,cr cum Ciceroni dd bmius confilium,ut Antonium roget,ufletidm ut Philip pices (itduitdm polliccnte co) exurdt,noncÂ«piditdtcm lueis dUegdbimus. Hoc enimfi miet in dnimo eius/deen

bbnHr.HiJc idi opiw eft occd/ionc, ne euwi tdltuw preeÂ» pwdedt. Et C.CiCpri (MUtesre gnum,dffirmAbimiu ÃÂ«Â« re idmRfmp.mÃ iworegente non pojJe.Nctni qui de re ncfirU dflibcrJtjd foluw qMÃrit,qwomodo qtwmminiÂ» mum peccurc Â«idedtur. Multiwn refert etw que fit per fond fnudentK,quid dntedad Â«itd,fi inMÃrw fwit/Kt dd TilÂ« gcniM/Ht etd?,dut fortuMdjd^rt expeÃdtionem. Prouidendwm eft,ne que dictwitur, db eo qui dtcit,difgt; fenfidut. At bw contrdrtd fummifiorem quenddm wo* dum poÃuldnt.Ndm que in dlijs libertÃ©s eft, in diqslice til uocdtur.Et quibufddm fu^cit dÂ»toTitdlt;,qÂ»ofddm rd

TciÂ«,dccedit etidm perfonÂ« diff cultes.Ndnqjidem iHud^^^Ã¦* Aliter Cdfdr,dlitcrCiccro,dtitcrCdtofndderedcbebitÂ» Vtilifimdttero bdc exercitdtio,uclqÂ«od dupltciscft opeTiSjUelqKodPoetw quoque, dutbiforidrom futuris fcriptoribiÂ« plurimum confert. Verwm ZT ordtoribus ffee IJirid.Ndm funt multd d GrecK Ldtmisq; compop te ordtiones,quibtK dlq uterentur, dd quorum conditio item uitim^ dptdndd,qud dicebdiMur^fucrunt. An co*.

202 M. FAB. QVINTÂ» INSTiTÂ» dem modo cogitait,Mt edndemperfon,m wiM^^^^ ro,cum fcriberctCnt Pomf^eio,zTcumC.DomitiO}^ Appio^cÂ£tcrifÃ¼c,iic non uniufeuiuf!^ eorum fortiÂ»^ diggt;titdtem,res geÃdi intuitui omnium quibut uod ^ bdt eMm imagine expreÃit^ut meUut (puidcm,Ã^ ^^^ ipfi dieereuiderentur.tiec^ enm mmosuitiofi (^ (''â^* tio,Ã ab homme, lt;^udmÃ Ã re, cui decommodiri i^^^â diÃidet. ideo^ LyÃdf optim e uidetnr in hii ^UÂ£ (lt;^^^^^ bat tnioÃ¤iSyÃrudfÃeueritdtii fidem. Enimuero pri^^' pue dedumitoribus conÃderdndum eil, quid cuilt;^ p^ fanÂ£ conuenidt,qui pdueiÃimdi controuerÃ^ iM Utidf tit dduoedti, plerun^i filif, pdtres,diuites, fenes, dj^^^h lenes,dudri,dÃ©niai fuperÃitioÃ, timidi, deriforesÃ^nh ut uix comoedidrum ddoribus plures hdbitus in prow' cidndo concipiendiftnt,quÃm bis in dicendo,quÂ£owi^i^ Profopo' uideri pofÃintprofopopoeiÂ£,quds ego Ãudforijs ÃtbieÂ«â f Â®'*â nbsp;quid nuUo dUo db bis qudm per fond diÃdnt,QuMqiilt;^

hoc dliqMndo etidm 'm controuerÃds ducitur,quie ex bt Ãorqs compoÃtÂ£,certis dgentium nommibus confmen' tur^ ^eque ignora, plerunqi exercitdtionis grdtid pont er poÃ«tieds biÃorids, ut Pridmi uerbd dpud AchidÃ¨, lt;(Â«f SyUjediÃ«ldturdmdeponÃ«tis 'm condone, SedbÂ£cinpit tem cedent trium gencru,m quÂ£ cdufdt diuiÃmus.^dââ* e:y rogdrc,mdicdrc, rdtionem reddere, er dUd de qni' bus fuprd didum ell,udriÂ£,dtqi ut res Milt, in mdterti iudicidÃ!,deliberdtiud, demonÃrdtiud Ãtbqeere folemns, ^ueroPrcqueiitiÃ'me tdmenin bis ut'tmur ÃHd perÃMquot; rwn,qu,v. ipÃfubÃitumus, ordtione, ut dpud Cuwi^

OR ATO. LIBER ill- I05 pro Cf Ifo in Clodiw, cr Cxcws Appius, er Clodias /rlt;t ter, ilk in cuÃigit ionÃ«, bic in rationem morum compop fus (dloquitar. Soient in fcbolk fingi mdteriÂ« dd dclÃ¯bc-rdndMnfwiiliorcÃ¯controaerfijfjer ex utroque genere commixtÂ«, ut cum dpud C.Cxprem confultdtio de poc-ndTbeodoti ponitur. CoÃdt enim deeufdtione er defen pone edupe, quod eft iudicidliuw proprium. PermixM dutem eft et utilitdtw rdtio,dn pro CÃ¦/dre fucrit occidi Pompeis,dn timcndm drcgebeHuw.p Tbeodotus ft occifuSjdn id minime oppor tana boe tempore,^ peri-culopm,cr certetongumptfuturum. Qufritur er de boneÃo^ecedtne CÂ«fdrcm ultio Pompeij,dnpt uerendu ne peiorem fdcidt fudrwm purtium edupmji Pompeiww mdignum morte fdtedtur .Quod genus dccidere etu ue ritdtipoteÃ. Nonpmplexdutemcircd fudforids error in plerip^ decUmdtoribus fuit,qui dicendi genus in bis diuerfum,dt^ in totum itli iudicidli contrdrium eue exi Jlvmducrunt. Ndm er principid dbruptd, er concitd-tdm femper ordtionem, er in Â«erbis ejfuporem (ut ipp wacdntfcultuw dUeftdueruntjCr edrum breuiores wtiq^ commcntdrios,qudm iudicidlis mdterix flt;n:erc cUbo- nbsp;nbsp;*

rdrunt. Ego porrÃ³utprooemiouidcononutiqjoptts Dkendi ge' eÃe fw^orijs, propter quds dixi fuprd edufdSjitd cur ini nus in fuato tio furiofo pt cxcldmdndum nonintclligo,cÃ propoptd '''â â eÃ¶fultdtionc rogdtus fententidm, fi modo eft fdnHs,non qudritet, pd qudm mdxime poteÃ ciuili er bumuno in-greUu,mercri dUenfmndeliberdntis uelit. Cur dutÃ¨ tor tens j^r Hti$ Â«qudlitcr cocitdtd pt in eu dieÃ«tis or dtio,

204 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT-cum ud pmcipuc nioderdtionem, rlt;itionÃ©m(iue conji^^ deÃderent f Neque egonegduefm fxpi'M fuifiii^Ã¯^*^ controuerfijs impetum dicendi proamio,nArrAtione,if gumcntiSyCiucm Ã detrlt;ihM,idferÃ¨ fupererit, c^uofuijo f jqualita ^â^ confiant. Verum id quoc^uc-hec^mihiK ent, non tu* tis _ multuoÃuidtcpieturbidiHt.'Verborumiiutentntigniji* gnj'^/min â^^ntid. non udidiui cR dffvUdndd fudforiM dccldintiiiti* ^aforns ae bui,Ãd contingit mdgis, Ndm er perlons ferÃ¨ mignf ^3tÃ¼Ã¼is^^^ f^^^^â^â^ ^^â^â^^^i't'^S^^P^'^^^t'tvin, populiJcnM et resdnipliores,itdcumucrbd rebut dptcntur,ip^oigt;ii teriit nitore cldrefcut.AÃ¼d ueris coÃlijs rdtio e^AdtoÂ» ^ue Theophrdftui qudmmdximc remotum db omni dffi* {litionc^mdeUberdtiuo genereuoluiteÃe Ãmioncm, fecutut 'm hoc dutorUdtem prieceptoris fui, qudne^utm diffentire db eo non timide folet. NrfÂ«$ Arifoteles Ho nedm mdxime dd fcribendÃ¼ demonÃrdtiud proximdtu* que db ediudicidlem putduit, uidelicet, quonidm prior iÃ¼d totd eÃet oÃentdtionis, biccfecudd egeret drtii,itd quod ddÃUendumÃ itd popofeiÃet utilitdt,conÃlioÃ* de,prtidentidq- conÃdrent, Qjiibut 'm demÃ¶ÃrÃ¤tiud colt fentio.Ã®^dm et omnes dUj feriptores idem trudideruntt In 'ludicijs dutem confiiqsq;, fectundum conditionem ipf ut quieirdUdbitur rei,decommoddnddm dicendicredo rdtionem^'^dm or Philippicdt 'DemoÃhenis 'Ãfdemqui* bus bdbitds 'm iudieijs ordtiones, uideo em'mere uirtuf tibus.Et Ciceronis fententie,^^ cociones,non m'inuscli rum qudmeÃ 'm deeufdtionibus de defenÃonibut elotjuÃ© ^iÂ£ lumen oÃendwtt â¦ Dicit tumen de fuiforid idem ioi

Â»lodojTotA dutfm ordtio /implex er grduw,er fcÂ»UcH* tijj debet e/Je ornatior, quim Â«erbÂ«. V fum cxcmploru Â«uHi mdterif mdgw conuentre, merito fcrÃ¨ omnes con* fcNtiiMit, cum pleriwtquc widedntwr rc|/)ondere future prÂ«ttritt5,bdbclt;ttÂ«rqj cxpermeHtum, Â«flut quodditm rdtionw tcpwnoniiwn.BrettitdÃ¯ qwoq; ,lt;tut copid non ge nere materie,/cd modo conjldnt.Ndm nt in eonplijj pk TiMiquc /implicior quf Ãio c A, iM fiepe in edufu minor * QÂ«e omnii utn e (fe fctct,p qnk non ordtioneÃ¯ modÃ¨, fedbiÃoriiÂ« etidm ( ndnqj inbis conciones de fcntcnttlt;Ã¨ picrunq; fuddendi dc dtjfuddendt funguntur ojpcio)kÂ« gere m4lHcrir,qÂ«dm in commentdrijs rbetorum confenc fccrc,lnueniet enim nee in confilijs dbruptd initid,er co titdtim fepe in iMdtcijj diÃ³liÂ«n,ct ucrbddptdtdrebiw'irt Utroq; genere, et breuiores dliqudndo edufdruw ordtio nes q fmentidrum.'Ne iHd quideminbis uitid deprebe det.qwibiw quidam dccldmdtores laborant,quod er con tri fentientibut inbumane conuitidntur, er ita pleruq;

^ieÃ¼tjtanq dbbk qui dÃ©libÃ©rant,utiq; di/fcntiant.ltaq^ obiurgintibu^jfimiliorcsfunt qfuadcntibut.Hiec adok feewej fibifcriptdfciant,nc aliter qdiAuri/int exerce ri uclmt,er in de/Ã¹e/cendw morentur. CÃ¦teru euw ad* Â«oedri capermt in con/ilid amicoruw, diccre fententia w [endtUj/uddere/i quid confulct princcps,quod prdcc ftn fortd/fe non credunt,ufu docebuntur.

205 M, FAB. QVINT. INSTlT. depKlfionis.Cuius partes ut plurimis autoriius pUewt, qu'moi funt,pro(xmium, narratio, probatio, refutotiOt peroratio. Kis adiccerunt quidam partitionem, piâââPÂ® fitionem,cxcej/um. Quarum priores dun probatiom fuccedunt:KamproponerequidemqugfisprobaturuSt nece(Jceft,fedc^ concluderen Cur igitur Ã ^ââP^'^^ cauff eR, non CT hic fit Æ Partitio uero dij^oÃtionis eÃ¼IpedcsJpf( dijÃofitio pars rhetor ices, et per onnets materias jtotum^i earum corpus aqualitcr fufa,f(^^ inuentio er elocutio. IdeÃ³que earn non orationis tattoo partem unam efecredendum eil,fed quifionwieMÂ»* fingularurn-Oiii nanq^ eÃ¼ queftio,in qua no promi^â re poÃit orator,quid primo,quid fecudo, quid tertiopl^ loco diHurus fquodeÃproprium partitionis. QuaOf ergo ridiculum eÃ, quiÃionem quidem Ãeciem effe pro bationis, partitionem autem que fit jÃeciesqufÃionit, partem orationis uocarif Egrefio uero,uel,quod vfiti Exceffus. tins efÃe ccepit,exceffus,fiue eft extra caufam, non po' tef ejfe pars caufe,fiue eÃ 'm caufa,adiutoriuingt;uel or' namentum partium earum eÃ,cx quibus egreditur. Namfi quiequid 'm caufa eÃ¼, pars caufe uocabitur, dtf non argumentum, fimilitudo, locus communis, afÃ¨duh excmpla,partcs uocentur f Tamennequchis affenti^' Refutatie, ^ni detrahuntrefutationem,tanquam probation! f â^ ilam,utAriÃotclcs. Kec en'm eil quecoÃituat,ilbtlt;l'â^ deÃruat. Kocquoq- idÃ« aliquatenus nouÃ¢t,quod pÃ¯olt;* mio non narrationem (ubiungit, fed propofttionttfquot; PtopoRtiOi ycrum id facit quiapropofitio genus^narÃ¯Ai^^l^^^^^

Â»idftttr,cr bdcttott/ftMffr,ttllt;tfetÂ«per Cr Â«bic^ue credit opMj cjje. Verum ex bwj^itiÂ« con^itui pdrtibMf,non Ut ^uieq; primum dicendum ,itlt;t prmum cogitttndtmi cft. Sedunteornnwintueri oportet, quod fit genus c4ufÂ«, quid in eu qu^rutur, quf profnt, quÂ£ noccunt, deinde quid confrmundm fit de rcfeHenduwÂ», turn quoinodo nurrunduwi. Expof tio cum probationuw cH prupuru tio,necf/feutilKpote|l,mf prias confitcrit quid de* bedt de probdtione promit tere. Pofremo intuendum, que mudmodum iudex ft conciliundus, Ne que mini nif tÃ´t is edufÂ« pdrtibut diligÃ«tcr infiediSjfciTc pof uwtus, qudlem nobwfdeerc dnimum cognofeentis expedidt,feÂ» ucrum dn mitem,concitdtudn remifum/duerfum grd* tiÂ«, dn obnoxium.Nec ideo tdmen eos probduertni,quÃ¯ fribendum quoq; prooemium nouif ime putunt. Num

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ut conferri mdterid omnem oportet, er quid quoq; loco ft opus conf dre debet^dnte quam dicere dut feribe* re ordidmur, itd meipiendum db bis que primd funt. l^dmnccpiMgercquifquAdutfngcrccocpit upedibtÂ«Â« Nee deni^ Ars und confummdtur ibi.umdc oriedum efb* Quid f et dlioqui f Jpdeium componendi or dtionemif gt;nbsp;' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;lo no fucrit? nÃ¶nne nos bece inuerfd confuetudo decepe* i Â«te inficicndd igitur mdtcrid cft,quo prucipmus or-* , ^we^feribenduquodiemus.

Æ ' AEterum edufd omnis, in que pdrs diterd dgetÃ¼ f^jdlterd recufdutw, dUt Â«niiÂ« rei controwerfd

confldt,dut plmumMiec fmÃ§lcx dicitur,illlt;i coniuÂ»^ VÂ»4 controuerÃd tÃ¼ perfefurti,perfe ddult^^j- P*^* i res dutem eiufdem gei.erK, ut in pecunijd repetteniif- 1 dut diuerfi,ut ft quid fdcrilcgij ziT homiddij[itÂ»ul^'^â^* fetur, quad mme in publicis iudicijs non dccidit, quon^ am Pretor certd lege Ãortitur,principuwi dutent C^r natm cognitionibutfrequens eil,Ã§r populi fuit â¢!*Â«lt;â* td quoque iudicid, ftepe unum iudicem hdiere inuÃ¯tif Â£7 diner fa formulis folent, nee dlilt;e jjgt;ecies erMt, (M^^r u/nui d duobuddimtdxdt eundem rem,dtq; ex cddctH** fd petet,dut duodb two,dut plures d pluribuf,quod lt;i^^ dereinhdreditdrijslitibuiinterimfcimuf,quidqud^^ Â» ud in multii per fond,cdufd tarnen und e firniÃ couditi^ perfondrum qujeÃiones udriduerit.Diuerfum bis terÃ¼* tim genM,quod didtur compdrdtiuum,cuiu^ rei tn^^ tm in pdrte caufefrequens efl, ut cum apud Centiiiifââ' ros poft dUa qudritur zy hoc, uter dignior hdreUt^^^ Ãt.Rdru eil dutem,ut in faro iudicid propter idfolu'^ Diuinatio. conÃitudntur,Ãcut diuindtiones, qut Ãwnt de deeuÃi')

re conÃituendo, ZiT nonnunqudm mter delatores, d^^ prÂ£mium merucritAdiccerut quiddm numero mutuitgt; Antkatigo uccafdtionÃ«^quf o:vâ^KKTHyoÃa uoedtur, dlijsuHeaei^ na. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fuccedere hanc quoque comparatiuo gencri exifiÂ»gt;^

hut, cui Ãmilii erit petitionum inuicÃ« dinerfarum, quoi accidit nel frequemiÃime, id Ã et ipfum noedri debet ifgt; ?MaTHyo^!Â«,ndm proprio cdret nomine,duo ernt gC^ ; rd dut,alter um, quo litigatores idem crimen inuicÃ« iÂ«* ' tentdnt;alterum,qHo aliud atq^ aliud,cui etpetitivtttiii* l

conditio p^r eft.Cum dppdrMf rit genws cdufig, turn tÂ«* tMfbwnMr,ncgctKr ne pftuw^quod ttitfgt;Â»ditMr,dÂ» dtfen diitur,dnitlionomine AppeUetur, dn dgenerc dSlionis

HIÃ¯ inÂ«f MK, intwe Â«duw dewee p^ Hermdgorte ui ietur,qd fn (pit^io,rdtio,iudicdtio,contmens, id eft o-ouiXop, Mfl ut dlij uocdtu,^rmdmentwm. QUiC QuÃ¦ftioÂ» Ãio Utim inteHigitur omnK,dc qiw in utrdnq; pdrtc,Hcl Wplurej iici credibiliterpoteft. iniudicidUautmdtc^ vid duplicitcr decipiendu eft : ditcro modo, quo dicimuÃ® multiÂ« quÃ¦pioncs bdbere controucr/idw, quo etid mvno res omnej complet iwur : Altfro^quo ÃgniÃeamus Ãumt-mdm iHimj/n qua cdup Â«ertitur, de lade nwne loquor/x qua niwicndfcitur pattÂ«, dnfdHum pt, quid fd{lwm,dn rede fdfl uw fit. HiK HermdgonÂ« ez AponodortM,er

dlij plurimi feriptorcj proprie queeÃiones uoedut.Tbeo dorult;,ut dixi, edpitd generdlid, peut iUiÂ« minores, dut ex idis pcndr(Â»tes,pgt;rcidlid.'Ndm CZ qu/Ãionem ex qiiÂ« Ãione Â«dÃfczÃiccirminÃircics diuidiconucnit.Hdnc igitur qweÃionem ueluti principdlem Â«oedwt Ã¿TKpLÅ, Ratio dutem eft,qÂ«4 id qÂ«od fdftwm effe conÃdt, defen^Â®*'Â®' ditur.Et cur Â«5 utdwur codem,quo finit ufi ferÃ¨ omnes cxewplofOreÃes matrem occidit. Hoe eonÃdt. Dicit fc iuÃeÃeiffe,Status trit qualitatis: QÂ«ieÃio,dn iuÃefeee nt.Ratio,quod Clgt;tcmneÃrd warituw pMlt;w,pdtrÃ¨ Ore Ãii occiditjboc miop dicitur. Kjivo'/i^o/j dutem iudi ludiatio.

(Atio,dn oportucrit tul nocetc mutrÃ¨ d Ãlio occiii-OÃ¿ dirÂ» diuiferut Mriofi CT MTiapjUt effet alterd propttt quant iudicium confitutum eH^ ut occifa Clytemue^rit alter a,qM fadum defenditur, ut oedÃu AgMemnoifÂ» Sed tanta eÃ circa uerba difjcnpo,ut dij MTiccjieaufitH^ iudicij,MTiop autemfadi uocenttahj eadem in contran wn uertant. Latmorum quidam hoc mitium, emdtt^ nem uocauerumt,quidam utrunq; eodem nomine ipd^ lant.Caufa quoque ex caufa,id eR Mnop 2/^ curigt;i nt* fd uidetur,qtule eii^occiditAgamcmnonemClytemiKf Ãra, quia iÃ¼e Ãliam communem immolauerat, C Â«^P^** Mm pellicem adduceiat, iidem putant er fut una ^Â«^ Ãioue plures effe rationes, ut ft OreÃes er altÃ©raiÂ» ^ rat caufarn matris necat^, quod reffonfts fit impi^f'^^' Quotautem caufasfaciendi,totidem iudicationes.i^^ â erhtceritiudicatiotanre^onfispareredebuerit'^

er twa eau fa plures haltere queÃiones er iudictttion^â ut ego arhitror,poteÃ¢,ut in eo,qui cum adultÃ©raiÂ»^ prehenfam occidilfet,adultertt qui iam effag^niip^i^ inforo occidit.Caufa enm eÃ¼ una,adulterfuitgt;lt;Pâ^i''.. nÃ©s er iudicationes,an iÃ¼o tempore,an iÃ¼o loco Ã¿d'^, occidere. Sed ficut,cum fini plures quaÃiones, owW fuosÃatus haieant,caufie tarnen Ãatus umts fit ad lt;jf^ referu/ntur omnia,ita iudicatio maxime propria,dfâ^ pronuntiatur,Ttw'xÂ°/J autem quod, utdbii,dgt;Â»^ Firmament ahj,firmamentu,m alijputaiit,CiceroÃrmiÃiiÂ»anidi Khetori tÂ»entationemdefinforis,etappoÃtiÃimamadiW^^ cÃ» Ub. j. nbsp;nbsp;nem,quibufda id niddw rffe,poÃ¼ qusd nihil fff

qiÃ¹lufcl^m id quod 4d iuUcAtiontm firmiÃimwn if^^ tur.duÃi fidi non in omnÂ« controuerfjAS eddit.Ndw Jââ^âyÂ®â* t^ue Nutrit auf A fidenii uii fAÃum negAtur^ At Â«bi caufa trafte cdupi trAdAtur^egAnt toie loco effe iuiicAtionent^c[uo Â«Â»r â¢ Nc^ic. qÂ«lt;eÃioÂ»fm,id^ Cr tw ^hetoridf Cicero, et in PArtido ^ââ ' mbw dicit-Ndw er in coniedurA cd qutjlio ex illo,fAÂ» dum^o fAdumiAnfAdu ft, ibi ergo iuiicAtio,ubi c^Uit pioi^uid in eAiÃ« re primA ({uÂ£fio,Ã¼' extremA iifceptd do. At m c^UAlitAte,mitre Ore fes occiiit,rede,non re* (ie,An rede ocdierit,eiuiefio^nec fAtim iuiicAtio,^Mn do ergo sâ iHd putrem meum oedierAt. Sed non Ã¯deo tu Wdtrfm dflgt;Â«i7Ã¯ioccidfrc:(trtdcÃ¯gt;HCÂ»âit,biciÂ«diclt;Â«tio.Fir wdiwwam dwtfm uerbis iC'f'M Ã§onAm : Si Hflit Orr^fS dief re dufmoii inmum mAtris fun'm tpAtrem fuum, in feipfum AC forores, 'm regnumim fAmAm gencfK Ac fA* nibÂ£,ut AbeApetnAi liberi [ui potiÃimwrn petere delue rmt.VtwfiturAlij ey tiHbus fxonpIÃ»sQtti bond pater* nicon[wmp[erit, nc foncionctnrtm opera publica eon* funp[tt,i{utfio,An quif^ww con[ump[crit,probibendM [Ã¼, iuiiatio ,Anlt;{uifc, uelut mcAufA militii Arimc^, qui tufwn âTribwnwm urn [ibi 'mferentem 'mterfedtt queÃio AU iurefcccrit,ritio,lt;[uod is u'm AjJcrebAt,iudi catio,an indemudtu, an Tribunum Ã milite oeddi opor tueÃ¯it.AlteriiMctia fitus e[UitfionÃ«,Alterius iudicAtio* wÃ¨ futit.Quf^io ciuilitAtis,An rede Clodiw Milo occi*

Identjudicatio e oiedurAlis,An Clodius infdiis feccrit^ Ponunto- illud,[Â£pccAu[Am'm aliquaremdimitt^qÂ«# Bon ft propria quaÃionw ^ Ã§r de ea iudicari. A quibM

w ult um diffentio .V^Mtc^ idÃ¤, (^uÂ£!iio,An omtits ^JJ* P temd ioitd confump[erint,concionc fint prohib^w^^ bedt oportet Ãtdm iuilicdtioneni,Ergo non dlU (pf^râ . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dUd iudiedtio erit^fed plures ^MfHones, (J plu^^^^^ â

edtionei.Quidfnon 'm edufd JAilonis ipfd conieH^f^^ fertur dd lt;:^M,litdtem ^ Ndm Ã eA mfididtm CloHv^ quitur ut reÃ¤e fit occifm.Cum uero 'm dli^udr(Hgt;lt;^'li cdufd,eR recejÃim d cp(Â£Ãione,quÂ£ erdt conÃiM^^^ Ãio ubi iudiedtio eH. Pdulum 'm his fecum etidin CKtf^ difjentit.t^dm 'm Kbetoricis (quemddmodumfuprdi-^^ xÃ³Uermdgordm eil fctuties, 'm Topicis ex Ãdtu eÃm^ coittcntionem n^ivÃ³/Mvc/jcxiHimdt ,id^ TreidtiO) ^â' iuris erdt confultuSjdUudens^qud de re dgitur ipplt;^^f ejuihus id commedturyCont'mcMid^quAÃÃrni^ineitti Ã fenÃonis,^uibus Ãubldtis defenfio nulfd fa^ ^ wgt; P^^^^^ tionibus ordtor'ijsÃmidmentum, quad opponitur Ãoni^quid cont'mens quod primum fit,db deeuÃtot^^^^ cdtur, rdtiodreo,ex rdtionis Oquot; ÃrmdmenÃ¤lt;lMÃ*^ difeeptdtio fit Miedtionum. Verim igitur v bfti^f^^ qui Ãdtum,cr cont'mens, zy' iudicdtionem,ideine[Ãgt;â'^ Continenj. lucrimt.Coni'mensdutetnidcffe,quofubldtoja5elÃlgt;ââ'^

pof it.Hoc mihi uidetur utrunque edufdmeompkdihf^ quod Orefies mdtrem, et quad Clytemnefird Agit^eM'' nonem occiderit.Udem iudiedtionem orfidtum confia* tire femper exifiimdrimt. t^cque cn'm dUud eoriM f^* tioni conueniens fuiffet. Ver urn hicc dfiÃ¨ddtdfuUdit^f cired nomma rerum,dmbitiofo Idbore a nobis 'm hodÃ fumptdfolum, ne partim diligenter'mqwÃlf de opef^t

quoi i^grfj?i fumiÂ«,uiJcreiÂ«Kr.Simf licitÂ« dutew mÃi* tucnti non eft nfeeÃi, per um minutaÂ« rerumpdrticu* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^^. lÂ« rdtionem dicendi concidcre Â» Quo uitio multi qw*^â dem UboÃ¯driwit,pr Æ cipuc tarnen HermagoraÂ«Â»uir alio* qui fubtiliÃ¯jCr mplurimÂ« a4mirandiM,tanfÂ«/m diligen* tic nimiwm folicita:, ^tipÆacitMrcflrcbcnÆÃ®olaudeal^â¦ qua non indignapt.Hxc autem breuior, er nel ideo luÂ» cidior multÃ¨ uia, nee di[centem per ambages fatigabit. wee corptÂ« orationÂ« in parÂ«a momenta didueendo con fumet. Nam qui uiderit quid pt quod in confrouerpam ueniat,quid in co, er per quÃ¦ udit ejpeere pars diner* fa,quid noÃra ( quod in primis eft mtucndum^nibil co* Tiwnignorare,de quit/Â« fupra dixiwus poterit.Nce eft fere quifqtwm,modÃ´ non Pukus, atque ab omni prorfuÂ«

upi dicendi remot us, quin feiat, er quid litem faciat, quod ab illis caufa uelcontinent diciturjOquot; qua pt inter litigantes quaÃiojer de quo tudicari oporteat,qult;e ota idem font.Nam er de co quaÃio eft,quod in controuer pam uenit,er de co iudicatur,dc quo qu^Ãio eft.Sed no perpetuÃ´ mtendimus inb Æ c animwm,er cupiditate Uu* dis utcun^ acquirend/,ucl dicedi uoluptate euagamur, quando uberior femper extra caufam materia eft, quia in confrouerpa pauca pint extra omnia, er bic dicitur

dÃ©bit qua acccpimuÂ«,illic de quibus uolumiM.Ncc taboe pracipiendu eft,ut quaePionÃ©,cotinens,iudicationÃ« in* Hcniamm, na id quide facile cft,q ut intucamur femper, aut certe p digre^i fuerimtMjfaltem recipiamiÂ«,ne plan fum a^ftantibus armacxeidant â¦Tbeodori pbola,ut

Â»4 M. TAB. QVINT. INSTITÂ» iixi,o'n refert id cdfpiti.Ã¯Ã®if plurd intcUiguntui' â¢ '^â^^ modo funtmi qu^Ãio, item utÃituMlterocÂ£terit, lt;P^ id fummÃ¼ referutur: tertio propofitio cuiffirmdtione, Caput. ut diximuf.Cdput rei eii apud MjtnddrumjKitp^'^^^^ Ã¨^Tt IÂ» uniuerfum Mtemquicquid probindumefi gt;nbsp;^^ tdput, fed id mdius dut mmia. Et quant a qu^ de his etst difcriptovibus drtiivm traditn, uerbofius etidm qMm w (cfje erdt expofuimus. Entered quis pdrtes effent iuii* cidlium edufdrumffuprd didu eiltproxmm liber,pti* amid^id eÃ¼ exordidconcipiet.

^^M^FABn-* QVINTILIANI DE INSTITVTIOÂ» ne ordtorid,dd MdreeUum ViÃ©loritM liber qudrtus,qui eff de exordia,ndrrdti ^^t ^SX^Ãioue^propofitionet pdrtitione.

] E R F E C T O MdreeUe Vidori â operis tibi dediati tertio libre,(7 1 idm qiurtdferÃ¨ Idboris pdrte triff \dild, nout infuper mihi diligentia __( edufdfZT dltior foUcitudo, qiule in ^^J dicium hommum emererer, dcceff fÃ¼Mhuf enim uelutÃudim inter tws conferebeunus, ttff

^ilttwn no^rd inÃitutio f robdretur Aetteriit eoittenti fort denitpico Â«pi ui4eblt;imÂ«r,Ht tui met^ fiÃ¯ij difeipU^

T1A N V S AugHÃtM fororis fuÂ£ nepotu delegdKerit curdm,nortfdtKbortorfmiÂ«dtctorÂ»mcalc|liiwniÂ«tent* gdm,mpexboconerts mdgnÃ¹udme metidr.QwwemttÂ» mibi dut morÂ« cxcokndi /itmodw, Mt cos no mmento probduent [tUiiUÃimus Â«nfor ? dut fludid,ne ftftUiff^ 'm lois uidar prmciptm.ut m omnibus,itd w Hoqurntid que^j rmmcMi'Ãiwdim i Quod Ãi nemo mirAtur poetix WdximoÃ® (Â«epe feciffe^ut non foluw initijj openww |mo* ruw MufÂ« muocdretujed prouecli quoq;longtu5,ciÂ«n dddliqucm grAitiorÃªucni^entlocum, repetfrentuotd, er uclut noiU preedtione utcrentÂ»r,mibi profeHo po* terit ignofei fi quod iÂ«itio,qHo prim um bdne rndteridw inebodui, non ficerm, nunc omnej in duxilium deoj, ipfÂ«m$ in primw^quo neq; prAfintw Alwd, ne$ pudi is mdgis propitium numcn fft/muocfm, ut qud ntum no bis expeftdtionis ddifeit, tdntuw mgenij djptrft, dex* tcr$ de Holes ddjitjCr me qtwle ejjc credidit,fdcidt.CM iu( mibi religionÂ« non blt;ec fold rdtio, quÂ« mdximd eft, feddlioqui fit procedit ipfum opus ut mdtordprlt;etert* tis,4c mdgis drdud pnt, que ingredior. Sequitur enim, MtiHdicidliwMcduprum,quÂ«fuÂ«t mdximc Udrif de mul tipliccs,ordo explicetHr,qHod proocmij pt o(ficitMn,qtt(e J^Â°^â^^^ rdtio ndrrdndi, quit probdtionum fit fits, feu propo* ptd conprmdmus, feu contrA diftd diffaiumus, eptAuiA w in perorAndo,few rtpeiedd brent repetitione rerum.

M^. M. FABÂ« Q_VINT. INST1TÂ« metwrid eA iudici!,fiue affvAutC^uod eA lange potili* tiÃimum) commouendi.De quibui pdrtibutfingtdis .^ dam Ãpirdtim Ãriberemdlucrimt^elut onia totiin cot para uenti^ (^ Ãc (iMO^ complureis de twaqiu^ue ref rum edrum libras ediderunt, quM ego omnes dufta coÃ¯t texere propÃ¨ infinitum mihi Idborem prof^icia,cr ipÃ cogitdtione [ufeeptimiatera fdtigor^Sed durdndunt cAjC^uid coepimustcrfiuiribusdeficietnur,dnimotdincit perÃuerdndum.

QVod principium uel exordium dicitur, mdore qudddmrdtione Griteiuidentur 'Tt^ool/xic/jno mindffe, ^uo d, nafiris mado mitium fignifiedwmÃ^ tit cidrepdrtemhdne effe date ingreffum rei,de ^m dh cendum fit, ofiendunt. Ndm fiue proptered, c^uod oi/dÂ» cdntia cA,O' cithdroedi pducd illd,(iLiÂ£ dnte^mmleÃ¿^f mumcertdmen inchoent, emerendi fduoris grdtidcc* nunt,proaemium cognominducrunt ; ordtores quoq; ci quÂ£ prias quÃm edufdm exordidntur,dd conciUdndosÃ bi iadicum dnmos prÂ£loqatiittur,eddem dppeUdtioncft gndrunt, Siae quad ol/xop ijdem GneciuidmdppeUini) id quod dnte ingreffum rei ponitur,fic uoedre eA ii^ tHtum,certe prooemium eA, quad dpud iadiccntprinfi qudm cdufdm cognouerit,profit. Vitiofe^ in fihoUsfic . cimui,quod exordia femperfic utimur,qudficdufdiÂ»iK* dexidtnnouerit.CuiutreilicÃªtidexhoceA, qdMedc cldmdtionÃªfiUd uelut imdga litis exponitur.Sed mfico quoque contingere iflud prindpiorum genat fecuÂ»^'^

(tftionibiÂ« potcjlgt;primw quidfm rlt;tro,nÂ«Â«qÂ«4Â»j nifi for tf dpud fiHH f Â»t rw dliiwtde imm not a Ãt^dicmiK.CAUifi ^rmcipij twUd rtlw f il,quÃtH Â«t mUtoYcm, quo/Ã®t Â«ob w ^ju^,âquot;*' in cxteris pirtibiK Accomoiitior,1priepAremtK, ld Ãeri tribut mixte rebtw inter Mtores flurmos contÃ¢t,Ã be ncuoluw, Attentum, iocHÃ« Ãeari/muttnon quid i/li per totAm Ailionem non fint cu^oiieiA,Ãi quid ini tij s prÂ« cipÂ«e Â«eccjJÃ®riXpf r qwÃ in (initntt tudiewtut procedcre Â«ItrÃ® poj?{mÂ«MdmtttimMr .Bcnruolentti, dut Ã perfo* Â®'quot;*âÂ°^quot;â* nw ducimnSjaKt i cAuÃs decipinnÂ«. SedperfonAvum no eft (ut plcriq; crediderunt) triplex rdtio/xlttigdtore, dduerfdrio,Â©- iudice. Ndm exordium dud nonnunquA BeneuolÃ«tii etidm ut dftore cAujt fokt .Quinqud enim pduciord de i perfona alt;-pipfo dicitjCr pdrctiMjplurwnM timen dd omnidmomen^'â^â^' ti eft in boe po/Ã¯tum, Æ( Â«ir bontÂ« creditur : fic enim con tinget,ut non jludium dduoedti uidedtur d^rrejed pe .

1 dgendududw o^cioÂ«elcogndtionis,Â«fldmtdtite,njd-1 xiweq; fi pcri potcrit,Reip,dMt Alicuiut certe no medio \ crit exempli.QÂ«od pne dubio multo mdgw ipiu litigdÂ« \ toribut fAcienium cft.ut dd dgendum mdgnd dtqj bone 1 Ãdrdtione, dut etiAmneeeÃitAte dccepijjÃªuidedntur.

l Sei ut prÃ¦dpHd in boe dicentw dutoritÂ«, ft omnis in j fubeundo negotio fuÃiido fordiu,AUt odiorum/ut dmÂ« i bitionis dbfucrit ,itdqÂ«ddd inbw quo^ comenddtio td 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;citd,ft noj infrmoÃ¯, er impures dgentium contrd inge

i nijs dixerimus, qudlid funt pierde McÃdlÂ« proamid, 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;EÃ enim nuturdits fuuor pro Idbordntibus.cz iudex re

\ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;O V

â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ligiofus UbentiÃmc pdtronum dudit, quem iufiitU fui nmime timet. inde iÃ¼d ueterum circd occukMÃ do^ quentidm fimuldtio,multum db hdc noÃroru temprut^ idÃ¤dtione diucrfd.Vitddum etidm ne contumelioft,nii* ligni,fuperbi,mdledici in quenq homme ordinÃ©mue ui' dedmur,prxcipue eorum, qui Udi niÃ duerfd iudicii/lÂ» uoluntdtCj non poffunt. Ã¯^dm in iudicem ne quid did' tur, non modo pdUm^fed quad omnmo mteW^ipoÃd, Etenim Ãultum erdt monere, niÃ Ãeret, Etid pdrtis diuerÃ veÃ¯f^pirtts. P^^^^^^^ ^â^^i^ exordia mdterid,mterim cum honore,Ã cloquentid eiui, de ^dtidm nos timcre Ãngedo, ut eiÃ I^eÃ¯ldfintiudici^feccrmui. Interim percontumehuiu, fed hoc perquA rdra,ut AÃmus pro Vrbiniit hteredibm, ÃÃbienu dduerfdrijpdtronum inter drgumentd eduÃ mdÃ¯epofuit.tJegdthÂ£ceffeproamid Corn.Celfus, eluf Ãnt extrd litem.Sed ego cum dutoritdte fumtnoru tutu rum mdgis ducor,tum pertmere dd eduftm puto, quit' quid dd dicentempcrtmet,cufitndturdle,utiudicesbb quos libentius dudiuut,etidm fdcilius creddnf. IpÃui dÃ A perfona Ii Utigdtoris perfond trdÃ¤dndd udrie elt.Ndm turn ^Ã¿'^ Agitons, f^ i-ii^ uUegdtur^tum comcnddturmfirmitdf,nonnuiiq contingit reÃ¯dtio merit or urn, de quibus uerectmdiui ^^ cendimi eritfud quÃm dlicttd Iduddnti. Ulultum dgftÃ' xus,Â£tdStConditio,ut in foeminis, fenibus,pupidis, libâ' ros,pdrcntcs,coniuges dUegdmibus. Numfold reSuiu ' quoq; iudicem mclindt mifenttio.DeguÃdndd tdinchif A rfotaPâ^^^^^^'^^^quot;'^^*quot;^'^' AduerÃrijueroperjo* ^ducef^Ã¼, M propÃ¨ iffdem amnibuSi fed Ã¨ contririo^ duitii Ã¯^^'^'

^ArtfoIcL NAmer potcweyJÃ¨^uitMrwiutdÃ¹jCzbÂ«* wilfÂ£ dbicilosq; con^emptio, Â©â turpesdc nocetÂ« odiS. Qu^tridfuntrtd dlifniindosiMdicnM drttmoj potentip-fmi, NrqjbÃ¦c Hare fitis eft,quod ddtur etiS wnpert tu,plcriq; (tugenda dutmmucdd,utexpediet,hoc enwn ordtow cft,illud Â«uPe, ludicem conciUdhimus nolif a perrons won tint urn Uud4ndo fum^quod e^jieri cummodo de* iudicis. bet,er eft timen pirti utriqj comunc^cd Ã liudem eins nd utilititem ciuÃg noÃn coiumxfrmms, ut aUcgcmus pro boneÃw dignitdtew iUi fiwm,pro bumititus iuÃiÂ« ^ mje^n, tidm.pro infelicibus mifeneordii^proixftsfeuerititSy Ã¼fimilitcrc^terd.Morcsquoq; (fiÃcrtpotcÃ)iudtcK MelimnoJJe.NdtM prout Â£i]^eri,kneÃ¯,[ucuMd!,grdueÂ£,du ri/emi^i erunt/ut d(Jumerc in cinfirn ml uris corum,

bit. Accidit dutem interim boe quoq;, ut dut nobis mmÂ« eus,dut dduerfdrio Ãt dmicuÃ®,qui iudtcdt,qu(e rej utri* que pirti trdadndd eft, de ncpio,dn et ci ntigisjn quÃ¯ Â«idetur propenfior. Eft enim nonnunqudm prduis bic dmbituÃ®jdduerfus dmicoÃ®,dut pro bis quibufeu fimultd* tes gerdiU pronuwidndi fdctcndt^,tniujle nc feeiÃe ut 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dcdntur, Ã¯uerunt etidm quiddm rcrum fuurum indices.

1 Kim et inlibris ObferudtionÃ¼ d Septimio editis/jfuif* fe Cicerone tdU edup inuemo.Et ego pro regtd Bereni te dpui ip[dmcdufdm dixi*Similisbic quo^ duperieÂ» ^ ^^^^ Ã¯ibÂ«sritioeft,iduerfiriu!cnim Ãducidmpdrtisfuieid ft it,pitronus timet cognofeÃ«tis ucrecundiÃ¯.Pr Â«tered

domo uidebitur iudex dttuUffe. MetUi etidmnonmVUi cR amouenduit ut Cicero pro Milone, ne irmd ?lt;^ dij^ofitd contri fi putdrent^orduit.'i^onntwcliid ii^ bibendutjUt idem 'm Verre fdcitSed ddhibÃ«di niodm â Aftione fecS teritlefre^uens eSl CT fduordbili(,ne mdle fentidt,â ^ f^ ^ pastor ' f^^â^ 'R-omdnut, nc iudicid trunsferdtuur : Alter duteio dj^ercT rdruf,lt;juo mmdtur corrupt is dccu[dtioitetn,lt;^ id quidem m concilio dmpliore,utcum(^ tutius, tilt;ttgt;^ ^ mdU 'mhibentur. O' boni guident. Apud Ãngulos uctÂ« nuejudm fudferim, niÃ deÃecerint old^i^ud neceÃiH^ ^^^ git.Non erit idm ex drte ordtorid^non mdgis 5 lt;lt;ppâ'^ re^etidm Ã id ^uoq; f^epe utile eH, dut dutd^nd proHH^ ciet reum fdccre.t^d Oâmindri,O' deferre ctÃ¼ non oft torpoteÃ^ Si cdufd concilidndi nob is indicts mdtertiin ^ 'â â* ddbit,ex bde potiÃmu dUt^ud in uÃim pr'tncipij,c[nd ngt;^ xime fduordbilid uidebimtur,decerpi oportebit. Odi^ m loco Virginias fdUitur, qui Theodoro pldcere tr^^ dit,ut ex Ãngulis qufÃianibuSyÃnguUÃenfus 'M pto^' mium conferdnturi-tSidm iÃ¼c non hoc dicitÃcd di p^ tiÃ'mds quseÃiones iudicem prÂ£pdrdndu. lÂ» qno nidj '^ hilerdt, niÃ'm uniuerfum id prxeiperet^qd' nee oÂ«Ãgt;^ dÃ¤io pdtitur,nee 01s edufd deÃderdt-tSid protiniÂ» lt;* r titore primo loco, du ignotd iudici lis eÃ, quoex^ni^ Ãionibus ducemus feutentidsinmiru res eruntiuiied prias.Demus diiquds,nd id exigit rdtio nbmmq, ttt* â potentiÃimas oÃªs,id eÃ,totd eduÃtmi Ãc erit'M pt^^ mio perdit d ndrrdtio. Quid tier o Ã (ut Ãe^uenteriÃ^ 4dt 'm proamio) pdulÃ´ cÃ durior cdufd,non benew en

ritd^zquiffirc^tefcmpcr ttiitio dicendi trdftdremur, nibil prooemio opiM eJJet. Ali'qud ergo nonnuuq^uX, qÂ«Â« crunt di concilidudum nobis iniicem potentipind, non inutiliter intÃ©rim ex ^ndÃionibtÂ« in exoriio locdbiw-tur. Qwffint porro in edups pdwordbtlid, enumerdre non eft ncce^e, quot'd c nidnifepd erunt cognitd eu* iupjj comroMerpfe eSditione, er omnid coUigi iw tdÂ» lt;â cawK td litium udrietdte non poOunt. Vt dutemboe inuenirc er dugfre^fd quoi Iddit/ut omnino repeUere, dÂ»t cct tcminMere,excdu)deft, Miprdtio quo^j dliqudndo ex eddem Â«cnit, pue quoi pd^i fumtÂ« grdue, pne pdjptrt.

Nc^ enim [um in Etc opintone, qud quidd^ut eo diÃ¨dre proocmiHm db epilogo creddni,quod mboe prÃ¦teritd,in illo plt;turd diedntur. Sei quoi in Migrepu pdrciiM er modeÃtiÂ« prÃ¦tentdnid cÃ iuiieis mifericordiddÂ« epilo go ucro licedt totos cjjwiere dprftiw, et pftdm ordtid ncmiÂ«duereperfoni$,er irfumdos excttdrc,er pigno rdeorum producere,qÂ«lt;icminus exordijs funt Ã¹ptd* td. Sei bdc quicfuprd dixi, nontnoucre tdiituw, ueruni ex diuerfo dmoliri quoq; prooemio opus eftÂ» Vt duteW noÃram miferdbilfm,p uincdmur,exituÂ«, ttd diuerfd* riorum fuperbunt,p uiecrint, utile eft errii* Sei ex bis qwoq;, quf non funt pcr/ondruw nee edufdrum, uerwrt diiunftdperfonis er cdufi$,iuciproamidfole(tt.Pcrgt; Abadinflis fonis dpplicdntur no pignordmodÃ³,de quibus fuprd ii* perfonis Â« xi Æ d propinquitdtesjdmicitiÂ« interim, regioej etium.

in M, FAB. oyiNT. INSTIT. ^ ciuitdtes^, zy fl fluid ediud eim, quern defendmuf^^i^ CaufÃ¦v Itdipotcji.Adedufdm exirdpert'mettefus, widef^ cipium pro Cfclio.Locus, unde pro Deiotdro. H^tiWgt; Wide pro mlone. Gpinio,undc in Verre. LeincefSÂ»^ ontnid enumerentur, fdmd iudiciorum, expeUdtio u^^' ^i,nihil enim horu in cdufd ef,dd cdufdm tdme pertind' AdijeitTheophre^us db ddione principium,quite uH^ tur effe Demofhenis pro Ctefiphonte,ut fibi diceref^ potius drbitrio Ucedt rogdntis, q eo modo quern ieeup tor dHione pr^efcripferdt. Lidutid ipfdfolet opiniei^ ^.f*^^^^Â®*â drrogdittiieldbordre.Tdciuntfauorem^iUdpenecon^ fnMid,non tdmen omittendd:uel ideone occupentur^ ptdre,dbonÃ»ndriyrogdre,foUcitumdgere,CiÃ iplerlt;*^ dttentum iudicemfdcit, ft res dgi uidetur noud, tu^i^ dtrox,pertinens dd cxempluy pmeipue tdmen ft iui^^f dutfuduicCydut Keip.c0niouetur,cuiusdnimufS^^gt;^' tu,ddmonitione,precibus,udnitdte deniq-âfi H Pâ'T^ rum credemus,dgitdndus efl^ Sunt z^ itid exeitdd^ dudiendum non inutilid,fi nos neq; diu mordturos,^lt;^ extrd cdufdm diÃ¤uros exiftmentt Docile fine iuHo^ DoohtaJ. j^^^ .pÃ pneÃdt dttentio,fed er iÃ¼ud,ftbreuiter amp;nbsp;' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tucide fummdm rei, de qud cognofcere debat,mH^^

rimus, quad Homerus dt^ Vergilius operun fteâ^ prindpijs fdciunt. J^dm iftius rei modus eÃ¼fit (â''^If' fttionifimiUor fit, qudm expofitioni^ec quoniÃ qp^ fit ddum, fed de quibusfit didurus, ordtor ojlenif^' Llecvideo quod huius rei dpud ordtores pofd f^fât, ri melius exemplumf qukm Cicercmnpro Agt;^^^

okÃTOK. Li'fetk Â«n. . Â«5 Attimidufni indice! omncm iccufdtorw ordiioncm/n dHiÂ« diwipm eÃe pirtes^qudyum dltfrdtuibimti.cr mx ^nopcre con^dete tttJebdtWjinutdid ixm ittUftCTXW iu dieij lunUni : dlterd tontwinmodo confuctudinis exufdj timide cr diÃidertterdttingere rdtioncmuenejieijeri* minumjC^udderelf^ebjec cÃ cjufÃioconÃttutiX. id td* men totum reeuwde nti, ficilius eft,qudm proponent!, quiAbiclt;Â«dmortcitdwstHdex,illicdoccndujcft. Neeme Semper atti qutnqium magni dutores itt boc duxerint, Mt non fernÂ« *w^d^Â»' per fitccrcdttcntHmjdcdocilemiMdiceinMelimjnon quid ^^a^x. nefeiimid quod db illÂ« dicitur/Ãe pro wdlt edufa, qud 1Â« ed jit,non intctligi,ueru(juii iÃnd non negligcntid iu ; dicK continet, fed errorc: dixit enim dduerfdriuj, cr i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fortiÃe perfmfit,nobis opus eft eius diuerfd opinione^ â \ qÂ«Â«mMtdrinopotcÃ,niÃillufcceriwusddcdejUitdicc

â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;inus,docilemcrdttentMm.Quidergo?imminM?ddlt;^tÂ« ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ddma leMAdd,o-^M4KontenenddcÃeconfentio dd Â«Â«Â«Â»

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;remittendi intentionemittdicis, ejudm dduerjdrio pr o ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ãdt ,ut fccit pro Li Jdrio Cicero â¢ Quid emm dgebdt â' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dliud ironiditld,^ut Cefdr minus fe in rem tdnqul non ' noudmintenderct^ QÃ¿d proCdio^ukmut res expe-â ftdtione minor uidcretur ? Ver-u cxbÂ« tjuÂ« propo|ui. â 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«Uudin dlio genere cdufx deÃderdri pdUm eft,GenerdCeneracuH,*

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;poTYÃciufirumplHrimilt;|uinlt;5;ffcerunt,bone^u,bunÃ¹* ^ââ'^

' H nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;le,dÂ«biujueldncep$,ddmirdbilc,obfcMru,ide[t,tvcro^op,

t a(Ã®'o^opâÃ¢p,($i(f'o^op,^Ã trÃ»|op,iLutf^(XKo7Cs6KTop, Suntc^busrefteuidedtur diijciturpe,qdâ dlijbiwÂ»ili,dlij

2X4 M, FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. fritter ofmonem bommu conÃitutttm,M dneifiti wi'' xime beneuolum Mice: in obfeuro docUeninn bumHiit tent urn pdrdre debemuf. iidmhoneÃum t^uidem di cot* ciUdtionemfdtis perfc Udlet.ln ddmirdbili, ztr turpi,t^ tnedijs opm cH^Et eo quidem exordiu in dudi diuidudt Principium. pdrtes, prmcipium,etinfinudtionent,ut fit principijttt InCnuatio. ^^ leneuolentiit, er dtteittionis pofiuhtio,quÂ£ effeiif fors ^â^â'^P^ S^tt^te cduft non pofiitjnfinudtio furrcpdUtu' tnii,mdxime ubi frons edufie non fdtis bonefid edi, hâ quid res fit improbd^ud quid bominibus pdru proictut' Aut fi fdcie ipfd quoq- pnemitur, uel inuidid confifitt^' tis ex diuerfo pdtroni, dut putris, uel mi feruUlis [(Â»'gt;gt;gt; etcid/nfidmis. Et quidem quibus dduerfus bte niodis ft , medcndu,uerbofius trddunt,nuterids^ fibijpfifiui^tnti er nd more dHionum profcquuntur.Sed bte cu oridH^ tur ex cdufis,qudrtvm ffecies cofequi cÃ©s non poffunxb nifi generdUtcrcoprebenddntur,iM infinitÃfunti^^trt hÃ«dit.Qudrefingulisconfitiuexpropridrdtionenip | tur.lUud in wmuerfum pneeperim, db bis quf i^^âquot;^â dd ed qut profint, refugiumus. Si edufd Idbordbiniquot;^â^ perfond fubuenidt:fiperfbnd,cdufd:finihilquo^''^â iiineterit,quÂ£rdmusquid dduerfariumledut-t^'^' i optdbilecRpiusfduorismereri,ficproxmwn,oiijt^â' nus.ln bis quÂ£ negdri non poterunt, cldbordndu ut ft ' tninordqudmdiilue{l,dutdÃidmeittefddtd,dutnibi lt;nbsp;J prxfentem qutflionÃ« pertinere^dut emenduri pflj^ P â¢ ttitentid,dutfdtisiumpunitduidedntur. ^det^^ff^ \ aduoedto ^UtigdtorifdciUus,quid^Iduddtfnttdt

ORATOR. LIBER lin, tlÃ glt;t*Mtlt;e crminfjCr aliquando utiliter ftwm rr prebende te poteft. Nam fe qwoque moMeri mterwÂ« Ãttgtt, Â«t pro Ribirio PoÃbumo Cicero duw ddituwpbi lt;lt;d dures pt* cit,ct dutoritittem induit uerd fcnticÂ»tw,qÂ«o mugis ere ddtur,ucldcfendcti eudem uel neguntt. Idco^ prirntm boe wituedmurJitigdtorK undduoedfi perjondfitutcn* dum,quotirs utrunqueÃeri poteH. Ndm id infeboU li* beruw cH,m forordrum ,utpt idonrusfux rei quifqite iefenfor, DecUmdturus dutem mdximc poptds in affigt; flibus cdufiW, proprijs per fonts debet inducre. Hi funt enim qui mdnddri non poffumt, nee eudem ui perfcruÂ«* turdlicnidn(Â«ii,qiW,fui motus. Hisetidm de eduÃs tnp* QuandotnÂ» nuitione uidetur opus ejje,p dduerfdrij adio tudieu dni gquot;ââ^** mos occMpducrit,p dicendu dpud fitigdtos eÃ, quorum Â«tltertwn promittendo noÃrus probdtioncs, er dduerpÂ«

clucndo,tÂ«tdbiwtM;dltcrumÃ)ebrcÂ«itdtis,erbis qui* teludendo but dttentiwn peri iudicem docuimus. Et urbdnitds op* portundrefecit dnimos, c umdeeunque petitd iudicis uoluptiÂ« Icudt tedium. Non inutilis etidm eft rdtio oc* occupatio, cupdndi, quÂ« uidentur obÃdre, ut Cicero dicit feire fe, mirdriquofddmquodbisqui pertotdnnos defenderit multos,beferit nemiÂ«cm,dd deeufindum V errem defeen darit. Deinde oÃendit bdnc ipfdmfociorum defenponÃ«, quoi febemd prolepps dicitur, ld cum pt utile dliqudn* P^ol^pl*âÂ« do.nunc Ã decUmdtoribus quibufddm penÃ¨ femper djfÂ» mttuÃ¯,qHi fits non putdnf ,nip d contrdrio MJcipcrc.Nc* gunt ApoBodorum (ecuti,trcs ejfe ( de quibtÂ« diximus) pr/pdrindi iudicis portes, fed wultds ÃieciesenumcÂ«

nnt^ut ex moribui MicK^ex opmionibut dd cdufiniei tra pert'mentibut, ex opmione de ipfd eduÃ, ([MfM^ propÃ¨ mfinitie, turn his ex quibus omnescoÃdnt contrat ticrÃf^per[onis, fd(iis,diilii^cdups, temporibuf, iix^f ocedfwnibui exteris, ^uds uerdi ejjÃ¨ fdteor, fed in bd( generd recidere,Ndm ft iudicem beneuolum, dttentvn^ docilem hdbeo, quid dnipltus debedm optdre, non rept'' rio,cum metus ipfc,qui mdxime uidetur effeextrd bd^f Ã¼quot; dttentum iudicem fdcidt, Cf di dduerfo fduore it* Ãerarione terredtiVerum quonidmnone^fdtisdemonfrirti^* txordrj. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fccntibtu,quÂ£ fint m rdtione proxmififed diecniuni tit

am quomodo perfid fdcilime pofimt^hoc ddijcio,ni i^f durus intuedtur,quid,dpud quem,pro quo,contrd qi^tt quo tempore,quo loco^quo rerum fidtu, qudMilgifiquot;â^^ dicendum fit,quid iudicemfentire credibiiefit dntttjf^^ ittcipidmus,tum quid dut defideremus,dut deprectnititi ipfd iUum ndturd eÃ¨ ducet, ut fcidt quid primu/n i^ dumfit, At nwitc omne quod expermt, proamufd p^ tdnt,O' ut quicquidfuccurrerit, utiquefi dliquifen^ ' tid bldndidtur, Exordid dutem muUd fine dubio ex df purtibuf funt, dut dlijs pdrtibus edufa communiÃ©, ^ tduritur turnen in quoquAmmcliiis dicitur,qudtn quod Â£lt;idt^.

ne diciuUbi no poÃit.Multum grdtiÂ£ exordia ^^^f t promnio^* ââ^ t^^tone dduerfÂ£ partis mdteridm trahit, hoe ipfâ 1 gratia. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;non compofitum domi, fed ibi,dtque ex re ndtum,

cilitdtefdmdm ingenij dugeti^fddefimpVeis fu/^P ^7 ex proximo fermonis fidem quoque dequirit, ddeo n

re non debedt. Odit eniw iudex ferÃ¨ litigdutis fecuritd tem, ewn^ ins fuMW intefligdt/dcÃ¯tiÂ« reuereWidm po* puldt.Nec mintÂ« diligenter, ne fuj^eftifimtÂ« uUd pdr* te uifdtiduw, propter quod minime oÃentdri debet in principijs curd, quid uidetur drs omnÂ« dicentis contrit iudicem ddbiberi.Sed ipfum iÃud euitdre fwmmlt;e drtK. Ndw id fine dubio db omnibus er quidem optime prie* ceptwm eft, Herum dliqudteniÂ« tempor um coditione mu tdtur, quid idm quibufddm iudieijs, mdxiwe^ cdpitdli* bus,ut dpud Ccntuwuiroj,ipfi indices exigunt folicitdt C dccurdtds ddioncsjcontemniq; fe,nifi in dicendo eti* dm diligemid dppdrcdt,creduÂ«t: nee doceri tdwum, fed etidm dekduri uolunt.Et eft diÃiciUs buius rei modern tio,quÂ« tdmen itdtemperdri potcft,ut Hidedmur dccurd te,no edUide diccre.lUud ex preceptÂ« uctcribus mdnet, ne quod infolens ucrbum,nc duddeiut trÃÃdtum,ne dut obfoletd uetuÃdte.dutpocticdlicentidfu/mptuminprin

ripio deprebenddtur. Kond urn enim recepti fumus, c QuÂ« in prÃ³ euÃaiit nos recens dudiemium vntenfio,mdgts cottcilidocmio tatMi tw dnimiSjCr idm cdlentibiÂ« bec liber tds feretur,mdxi'^^'ââ'â* we^ cumin locos fuerimtÂ« mgreÃi, quorum ndturdlk ubertds licentie ucrbi notdri circunfufo nitore non pdti tur.Kee drgumentw distance locis,ncc ndrrdtioni pmilk

225 M, FAB. QVINT. INSTiT. ejjein procemio debet ordtio. l^eque tdmÃ« dedudi (Â«^ per dtcjuecircunldtd ,fcd f^pe ftmplici dc iUdhordte /Ã¯* milii^nec uerbd mltu^ nitnid promittens. DiÃimuidti enim,z^ Â»t Grlt;eci dicumt Amripoerl^ ddio melimft pe fubrepit.Sed h^c protttformdri dnimum iudicum tx pediet.TurbdrimemoridiUelcotuinuAndiuerbdfdciiU tdte deflitui^nu/qudm turpius,cum uitiofum proeeminfi poÃit uideri,ut cicdtricoÃi fdcies, ZT peÃmM certe gÃ¼ berndtor,(pii nduem du/m portum egreditur, impeff(' Prcocmil Modusdutemprmcipijprocdufd. UdmbreuiusftmpH^ Â«âwlâÃ¯â cesdongiusperplexiefufpeilie^ et enfumes deÃderdntâ Kidendi uero^ qui uelut leges proxmijs omnibus d(de^ ut Â«tÃ³ ter fn^t ut intrd audtuorfenfus termmdrentur^ NÂ« iÂ«^^ nuseuitdnddeH immodicdeius longitudo,nemcdpt excreuijfe uidedtur, Oquot; quo pr^pdrure debet, fdtig^t, Prott mioÃ§i Sermonem d per fond iudicis duerfum, qui Ã irosjÃ´ifi Ã Ãgurx, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^-^1^^^ quiddm 'm tot um d proamio fubmouent, nonnu^

quidem 'm bune perfudfionem rdtione dudi^'t^dm prof* fus ejfe hoc mdgis fecimdum ndturdm confitendum t^t ut cos dUoqudmur potiÃ'mum, quos concilidre nobu^'^ demus. Interim tdmen et eH hoc proamio neceÃdrinHb fenfus dUquis,Z!r is dcriorfit,dtque uehementior dd ftt fondm diredus dlterius. Quodfi dcciddt, quo iure, dut eloqui qud tdntdfuperÃitione prohibemur dure per hdneji^^ gurdm ÃntentiÂ£uircs^Nequeen'miÃud feriptortsifit um,quid non licedtfcd quid non putent utile,uetant. W fi umeet utilitds, propter cundem edufdm fdeere debt t mus,propter qudtn uetumur. Et DemoÃbencs AUtaÂ»^

forrnd eftiHdbes igitur Tubero^uod eft decupitori nid xime optdndiwtt,cr etterd^conucrUt dd ludiccm. T uni cnimMcredMcr/d wiJedturordtio ,o-ldnguf[cdt iiK o* mill's jdiccfuibws nobkiHdbetigitur Tubcro,qwod ejl de cHpitori mdxime optdndm: lUo entw modo pre)?it,dtgt; que mÃititjioc tdntivm 'mdicd^Jet.QMod idem ht Demo Ãbene Æ Ãexm iUi mÂ«tduerK,dccidet. QKidfnon SdUu Ãim diredo dd Ciccrottem, in qÂ«cm ipfom dicebdt,Â«pÂ« eft principtOjCr quidem protiniÂ« ? Grduiter er tniquo dnimo mikdiftd tiw pdtercr M.TuUi.Sicut et Cicero fe cerdt inCdtirindrniQttottfqtte tdttdem dbutere pdtiewid noÃrdi Acne quw dpoÃropbe miretur,idem Cicero pro Seduro dmbitiÂ« reo,qMlt;e edufd eft in commentdrij$(ndM cumbis eundem dÃ©fendit ) profopopoeid loqucntis pro reo utituripro Rdbirio uero PoÃbumo/odemque SedÂ» rorcorcpettwiddrinnjCtidmexemplis ipro Cluentio, ut modooÃendi,pdrtitione .Non tdmenbee, quid pofÂ» (wntbene dliqudndo Ãcri,pdÃwn fdeiendd funt Jed quo

nc,dwmbrcui,er trdnÃdtione,dtque dlijs tropw,quie o* nmid cduti illi dc diligentes prohibent, utemur 'mter W, niÃ cui diumd iUd pro Ligdrio ironid,de qud pdulÃ³ dntc ^^^^^-^^ dixcrlt;Â«n,dij^licct, Alid cxordioriAm Â«itid ueriiw tradÂ» uina.

derunl:. Qttod in pÃ¯um cduÃs dccommodiri foUâi VulgÃ¤re. VMfg4re dicitur. ld mmiu fMorAlUe, dUcjutindo WiWfâ* non mutiliter affumimusji mignisfepe ordtoribut lt;^^ Commune. euitdtum.Qjio zy dduerfirimutipotesl/ommit^f â¢'P*

feUdtun Quod dduerÃriusm ftamutiUuteindcÃ^^ Commuta* ^gpoteli,commutdbilciQiiodeduÃnoncohitr(t,l({^* 5*eparatum. rdtum i Q^od dUunde trahitw, trdnflitum. Wteii^ TrÃ¤natum. quad tongum, quad contra prÂ£ceptlt;i eA : quorum f^^* PromnkT' ^^âlâ*^ nonprmcipijmodo Ãmtuitid, [ed totim oratio* non femper nK.liÂ£c de proxmio quoties crit dut u[ut, non [emf^ *â*ââ* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dutem e{l.Nantir fuperudemm aliquando eH, utjip

prlt;eparatui fat is etiani fine hoc iudex,Mt f res pn?^* ratione non egeat, Arifioteles quidem 'm totum Ã¼ ^^^ ceffiiriumapud bonos indices negat yiliqudniotitnÂ«^ Uti,nec fil Helmut,eo licet,cum index occupatui,eum ^^ gufid fiunt tempord^cum maior potefiiu db ipfi f^ ^ââS^ 'tndpere, Contraque e A interim proamij nis etidin Â»lt;â'' w exordio.'Nam indices et 'm ndrrdtione nonnunqigt;i^gt; er in drgumentis,utdttenddnt,er utfiMednt,rogdmuiâ Qgo Prodiem udut dormitantes eos excitdri pui^^^â qiulc eÃ¼: Cum Cains 'Varenus, qui afiamitia Anebif^^ na occifius eil, hoe quitfio iudices diligenter attenid(lt; Vtiquefi multiplex caufia efi/ud quibus^ partihus da proefiatio eÃ¼ ; ut, Audite nunc relique : er, W'i^'^ nunciÃ¼ue.Sedin ipfiisetiam probationibusntultiÃ^ guntur proamij uice, utfideit Cicero pro Chieinio,ii^ durus contrd Cenforesipro uiHrena,cum Seruiofi ix^ (ufiat,Verumidfiequeniiuiefigt;quMUtCKCWp'gt;^â^^â

OR AT OKÂ» LÃÃ5EK 1111. IM pÃ¯nwnÃ¨lttm fit. Quotifs dutem proamio fuerimws uft, turn fl w dd fxpofitionemtrdnfibHniM ,fiÂ«e protmiM di probdtiortcm td debcUt m prinetpio poÃrcmitm ejfe, cui commodifime iuwgi mitiwm fequenttiwn potcrit.il U ucro frigidd,et ptterilw cf in fcboliÃ® d^ildtiojUt ipfe trdnfitiÂ« effciat dliqium Â«tique fente Â»wtdÂ»Â«,er buiu^ Â«e lut pr^Ãigiic phufum pctdt,ut OuidtiMUfctuircin Me j^^tamor^ tdmorpbofifoletjqucm tdmÃª exeufare necefit^w poteft, phoGsOuÃ rej diuerpfintdt in ÃiectcmtwitiM corpora coHigcntc.

Ordtori ucro quid eft neceffe furripcrcbdctrdnfgrcfi onem, ey iudicem fullered qui ut ordini renwÂ« dnimuin MÂ»tenddt,ctwmcommonendÂ«t eft, Peribit enwn priwd pdrs expofitioniÃ¯,fi iudex nonduin ndrrdri fcict.QwdÂ« propter,ut non abrupte eddere in ndrrdtioncm,itlt;t non obfcure trdnfcendcre,eft optimum. Si ucro longior fe* i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;quetur de perplexd magie expoftio, ad earn ipfam pr Â«

\ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;parandtÂ« iudex crit :ut Cicero fcpiite, fed boe loco fccit

\ pAulÃ´longiueÃxordiivmrei demonÃranda gratia repe | nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ta,quod quÂ«fo lHdicej,ne mokÃc patiammi: Principijs

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'N Ã ^â*'â* naturale eft,Â©- Ãerif-equentif iwe fÂ» * nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;AN V let ac debet, ut praparato, per blt;ec quÂ« fupra â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;difti furt,indicÃ©, res de qua pronunciaturtÂ« eft,indice 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tur, Pd eft narratio,in qua feiens tranfcurrafubtilcsni 1 miumdiwifionesquoru'ndam,pluraciue gencrafacienti 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tun. No enim (oUm uo^eJJe ittam negotijjde quo apud

252 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT, iudices cltiÂ£ritur,fxpo(ttioncm,Ãcd perfonx^ut, M. At# ^^^f tiliM PdUcMiu humililoco Piceiiyloqudxnrngisij^Mni ^Si.Ã¯^l fdcimdM.Loci^ut^oppidum eÃ¼ m IlcÃ¼eÃiontoLMpfi cum iudices.Temporis,utf

Georg, iij. ycyenouo gelidut cMK cu motibui humor Li(luitKfâ Cdufdrum quibw hiÃoricifrequentiÃime utuntur, citfn exponumt wnde helium, feditio peÃUentid, PrÃªter bi(gt; dlÃM pcrfeilMydhdi imperfedids uoedti quad quisigno rdtfAdijeiumt expoÃtionem,^' prsteritorum effe tem por urn, c^ux eÃ¼^ freeptentiÃimd : er prÂ£fentium, ^v^^ In oratione eÃ Ciceronis de difcurfu dmicorum:Chry[ogonM po^^ proRofdo. qii^f^cRnomimdtunEt futur or urn, quÂ£ folit diri^* ticindntibui poteR. Ndm 57roTÃ7T(Ã¼oâi!} non e^l hibei^* An femper d^ ndrrdtio.Sed nos potior thus udeemus, Pleri^ue Ãmgt; narrÃ¤dum. ^^^ ndrrdndum putduerunt, quodfdl[um effe phtribuf codrguitur .Suntenm dnte omnid (iUÂ£ddm tdm breath cdufÂ£, ut propoÃtionem potius hdbednt, tptim ndrt^^ tionem. ld dccidit dliqMndo utrique pdrtfeum Hfl 'âââ* ld expoÃtio eil ,uelde re conÃdt, de iure quirif^f â¢' *â* dpud Centumuiros, Ãlius dn Ã-dter debedt ejfc iifttp to hÂ£res.Pubertds dnnK,dn hdbitu corporis Â«e/fÂ»Â»Â«Â«Â®quot;'' AM enim eR quidem iure ndrrdtioni locus,fed duUÂ«^^ iudici notd funt omnid, dut priore loco reiie expoÃ^' Accidit dli^Mmdo dlteri, er fepius db dilore eduÃ, i* ej^uid fdtis eÃ¼^pponere, uel quid mdgis Ãc expedit, ÃÃ eil dixiÃfe, certdm creditdm pecumidm peto ex Ãipi^. oneÃegdtum peto ex teÃdmento.r3iuerfÂ£ partis exf^

fxpf dit fie iniiciire, Dico ih Horatio fororem fuam m tcrfe^am.t^Mi^; cum propoÃtione iudex crimen omne cognofdtiisr ordo^et caufafddi pro aduerfario magii fft.Rctw contra tue narrationem fubtrahit, cu id c[uod Ã³bijcitur,nclt;^ negari^na^ excufari poteÃ/ed in fola in ris ifieÃionc conÃÃit^ ut 'm co ejui cum pecunu print' tarn ex tde fiera furripuit,ficrilegij reut e^, confeÃio uerecundior e^ g expoÃtio. No negamut pecuniarn de templo effe fublatA,cilumniatur tarnen aceufator aHioe facrilegij,cum priuatafuerit, non facra. 'Vos autem de 1,0e cognofcetis, an facrUegium Ãt admiffum^Sed Kt hM du^uanionon narr'adicaufas puto^Ãc ab iHw diffentio^ qui non effe narrationem exiÃ'ment,cureut,lt;^uod obij' citur,tantum negat. in epaa eH opmione Cor.Celfus,lt;]ui coniitionis huius effe arbitratur, pleraf^ Ådis caufasÂ» (S' omnes ambitus acrepetundaru.Hon entm putat effe narrations, niÃ epagfumma ermmis, de epio indicium tftjcontmcftt. At demde fatetur ipfe pro Rdtirio PoÂ» Ãbrno narraffe Ciceronem:atlt;pai ide o- negouit perwe -niffe adi^abirium pecuniam,c[ua de re erat epaxfio con ^ituta,c!' 'mboenarratione nihil de crimme expofuit. Ego MÃ© m^tgnoÃ¯ aliorpiifecutus autores ^duas effe'm^^^^^^onÃ¼ iudiciji narrationumffecies exiÃ'tmo,alteram ipfius can^^^'^^'^^ **â** fÃ¦gt;lt;tltcrlt;4tÂ« rerw lt;td caufam perfmentium expÃ¶Ãtionemgt; Nlt;â* occidi bombte, nun^ narratio eSb/ouenit^. Sed erit ^^w,Â©-interim ctwm longa circaargumenta ciuÃ¯ contra ertminis de anteadauitaÃe cauÃs, propter quit inno-ffrtÃ® WpericMlwm dedwe^tKr, dlijJ, qwtbwj incredibile id

t^uod obijcitur, fiatjieij^ enim aceufdtor hoc tantum dl citjOcc^diÃi, fed c^uibus id probet,narr at : ut in trigÂ«' dijs,cuin Teucer vlyffemreum facit Aiacis occifi,iicÃ©i inuentum cum mfoUtudine iuxta exanime corpus mmi ci cu gladio cruento,non id modo vlyffesrej^ondetyW effeafe idfacmus admiffum, fed fibi nullas cu Alice itÂ« micitias fuiffe,de laude inter ipfos certatum: deinde flgt; iicn^t,quomodo in earn folitudinÃ¨ uenerit, iaeentÃ© cxi^ nimemfit confnatus, gladiu Ã¨ uulnere extrixeritt fi^ fubtexitur argumentatio.Sed ne illud cpiid Ã« fine nirri' tione eR,dicete accufatore,fuifii in eo loco, in c^uo tuns mimicus oedfus eÃ¢, non fui,dicendum enim uiifiiffi^ Quire ambitus c^uoc^ caufde et repetundarumfioceta . flures dufmodi narrationes habere poteruntyCjns f^**' ra crimma.ln quibusipfa qddem neganda fitnt/i iÃ¯' gumentis expofitione contrariarefifiendum,^ ii'^â'^^ dum fingulis, interdu uniuerfis. An reus ambitus ma â tfarrabit,lt;iuos parentes habuerit,lt;iuÃ«admoduipfi ^^^'^' rit,quibus meritisfi-etus ad petitionem defcÃ«deritfl ^ fi quis repctimdaru ermine infimulabitur, nuitf ^quot;^^^ Ham uitam,amp; quibusdccaufis^uel prouituiam unnf^f fam,uel aceufatorÃ«, aut tefiem ofiÃ¨nderit^on munâ^^ exponed QuÂ£ fi narratio non eH,ne iUa quidem CK^^

tius hitbitus:nihil enm bic de uenefuio/ed de auÃ^ lm ei mater mimica fit, didt. lUx quoq; fint tes ad caufam,fed non ip/iuscdufienarrdtiones, Â«^ââ^^ Aft.TÂ« â'^^P^''S*quot;**^*^^ W Ve^reÂ»} de Ã¯,wio DetnitiOi ^'*^i^

tfm,quod K dpTum, quern ipfi miwicri obtulerdt, exce-ptum e JJe Ã fe ue n.ibnlo confe^M eÃetim crud fujlwlit: Velexcutiendi dlicuiuj cxtrinlecm crwnâwiWjHt pro Ret lirio PoÃbuwo, Ndniut ueutum Alcxandrium cft,tÂ«dt ces,bdEc und ratio Ã rege propofitaPoÃbuwo eft conf :if wande pccunie, fi enrationem, er qunfi dij^enfationem regiem fufccipiÃet. Vel ei(gcndi,ut depribitur iter Ver rif .Fifta interim narratio introducijoktjUel ad cocitan Aft. j, dos indicÃ©;, ut pro Rofcio contra Cbr^fogonow, ewius paulÃ³ ante babui mention?: ttclad/Ã³lwendos atiquaur--banitate,utproClÂ»eÂ»tio,cotraJratrcj Cepapos. Inter dum p digrepione decorÂ« gratia, qualk rurfus invert rÃ© de Proferpinatlnbk quondalock mater pliam queÂ« flip dicitur. QÃ¶Â« omnia cÃ´ pertinent,ut appareat,nott Â«ti^ non narrare eu qui negat, fed illud ipfum narrare quad negat.Ne boe quid? pmpliciter accipiendÃ, quod eft Ã me pofitM,)Ã¹perÂ«acuam epe narration? rei, quant iudex noucrit. Quod ficlntclligiMolo,fi nonmodofa-dum quid pt, piet, fei it a fiHum etiarn, ut nobis expe dit,opinabitur. Neqjenimnarratioiwbocrepertaep, ut tantum cognopat index, fed aliquanto magis ut con fentiat. Quire etiamp nonerit doccndiÂ«,fedaliqwo modoa^cicndus,narrabnnuscum prÃ¦parationc qua-darn, Scire quidem ewm in fummi quid aftumpt, ta-wenrationem quoq; fiHi cuiufqj cognofeerc negrauc-tUT, Interim propter ab'quem mconpliuinadbibitunt nos repetere Ã¼U pmulcmiÂ«, interim ut rci,qua; ex ad* Â«erp propowtur jiniquitatem omnes etiarn circus-

Ãantes mtclUgÃ¤nt^ in quo gencre plurimu figtirii ^â¢^ __Utirilt;indA expofitio dd effugiendum tedium Mdt^gt;^* fin^Jou auâ ^=filt;^ mcminifti,o-,fortiiffefuperUAcuufiierit ^ dienti. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tnordri:Scd quid ego diutius^cam iu optimentfruni^

quile fit,tu feiÃ¤s^et bis fimiUd.Alioqui fi dpud iudtcciOt cuinotdedufd eÃ, ndrrdtio femperuideturfuperMO^f

fubnciatur rid. Alterumellydcquo pcqucMiui quentu^}^â^! narratio, ^f/^. ndrrdtioproxmiofubijeiendd^Quodquiopm^'^* tur,non poffuitt uideri nuUd rdtione duUi* i^^lt;â ^. proamium ideirco compdrdtuÃt, ut iudex dd rent deet pienddmfidt concilidtior,docilior,Qr mteMior,ty f^'^ bdtio,nifi edufd priai cognitd,non poÃit ddhiberi,prlt;gt;^ â tinui notitid rerun mÃruedui uidetur.Sed boe mternÂ» mutdt conditio cdufdrun, niÃ forte Mdreui 'Tul-in ord tioncpulcherrimd,qudm pro MiloneferiptdreUqdttt mdle diÃuliffe ndrrdtionÃ« uidetur tribui prdpoÃtie qdÂ£ Ãionibundut profuiffet exponere,quono mfididd Ã¯dtn nifeciffet Clodiuifireum, qui d fe hominem occifmf teretur,defendi omnmo fa nonfuijfet,dutfiidni pf^â'^ dicio fendtui dindtui effet Milo., dut ft Cncui Vopeid^â qui propter dliqudm grdtid indicium etidm militib'Jd dt rmtiieluferdtytdnqdduerfm^Ãimdretur. Ergobdidf modi quoq; quÂ£fiones uim proxmij obtinebunt,cttni lt;gt;â¦ wnes indicÃ© prÂ£pdrMerint,Scd dUter pro V dreno red poÃed quolt;^ ndrrduit,cum obieÃ©ld diluit, quoi pet uti^ liter, quoties ermÃ© non repeUendum tdntum, fd e^â^ trdnsferendum erit, ut prim hit defenfis uelut tWi^dA

uibiÃ cirwnÂ«!;Siw onemtÂ« ,qÂ»f pritÂ« nmouendn funt, ut propitius iudex iefen^onem ipput negotij ,c!iiw ^0* prix quxÃio cH,tudixt: mÃ iefeniÃ¨diK eft W.C-tliut, nonne optime pxtronUÃ® oecurmt print couitijs luxurifi petuUnti Æ, impudicitiÂ«, q uene/Ã¯cij? m quitus Jolis oÃ¯s Ciceronw uerptur orutio^Demde turn turret de bonis, pxuldÃ¼mq; dein explicet exuftm, quÃ¦ eft ipfius aftiortÃ© defenfx, Scd nos ducit febobrum confuetudo, in quibus certi ponuntur, qÂ«Â« tbenutx dicimus, prÃªter qux nihil eft diluendum.ldcoq; narratio prooemio Jemper futiurt

^. gitur.lndcIibertiitdccUnixtoribuSjUtctixm pcudopxr tis fux loco nxrrxre uidcdntUr.'Nxm eu propetitore di runt,er expoptione, tdnq prius dgant, uti folcnt,0' Co ^jj,^^, tTxdiÂ£lione,txrtqux rcjpondelt;tnt,id^ Ãt non rcfte.Ndin cum fit dccUmdtio forenfiutn dftionu meditdtio, cur 110 utrimq; protinus locum exereext? Cuius rxtionis ignA* ri,ex morc,cui xjfucuerunt,nihil ih foro putxnt eÃe mu txndum.Sed in fehoUÃieit quoq; nonnuqudm cuenit, ut pronirrxtioncfrt propofitioÂ» Nxm quid Ã«xponct, quÂ«

dpudcenforcÃ¯reumdeinorihusfdcitjCutnjotumcrimÃª ^ wno uerto ,in qu^ibet dftionis pdrte pofito,fxtis in- quot;^ Wâ^Â«ââÂ® diccturtsedbfchdflenus.'Nuncquiefitndrrdndirdtto futiiwgdiÂ«. t^yy^fig j^ xeifddiÃ«j dÂ«t non fdftÂ« utiliÃ¯ Narratio.

rtd perjMdendum expoÃtio.Vd, ut ApoUodorusÃndi Narrationis Â®â'^^âÂ® docens Mditorctn,(Ã¿iid in coiMroucrÃiÃiâ ^^â^ propnstates pl(riq; feriptores^ mdxime ^uifunt db iÃacmte ,uolwiit cffe lucidAybreuÃ«jUerifimilÃ«.^ec enm rcfcrt,dn pro te* cidd per]^icuA,pro ucrifitnUi proMilÃ«,cr'',dibilcinue d* cdmm.Eddem nabis pUcetdiuifto. QMn^ er Arifiote les Ai iÃacrdtc pdrte in iwd diffâ¬n/crit,prÂ£ceptum bre^ uitdtisirridens,tdn^necejjefitlongdm,dut breuÃ« c^ cxpofitionÃ«.ncc Ucedt ire per media, Theodorei ^tiolt;^ fcholÂ£ foldm relinqiMint ultimd pdrtem, quid nee breid' ter uti^ nee dilucide femper fit utile exponere.Quo Ã * ligentius dif mguendd fint ftngtdd, ut quid qttoq; loco Narratio toPââÂ°A afenddm.'iiidrrdtio eR dut totd pro nabis,dut to ta pro nobis td pro dduerÃrijs,dut mixtd pro utrif^Si erit totd pro nabis,contenti fimus bis tribus pdrtibus,per quds eÃeif tur,quo iudex fdcilius intelligdt,memigt;ierit,creddt.bic( quifqud reprcbenfionc dignuputet,quod propofueritÂ» CA,qtiÂ£ fit totd pro nabis,debere effe uerifmilÃ«,cu und fit,Sunt enim plurimd uerd quidemfed pdra crediiUid) ficutfdlfd quo(^ frequenter uerifmilid, coudre non tui' nus Idbordndum eit, ut iudex, qua uerd didmus, f ^ frngimus,creddt.Sunt quidem bx^qudsfuprd retub,ult' tutes dlidrum quoq; pdrtium. iJdm cz per totdm d^io' nem uitdndd eH obfcuritds, er modus ubilt;f cufoUtn' dus,et credibilid ejfe oportet omnid,quÂ£ dicutur.Ã¯idxi me^s hitc in ed pdrte euflodienddfunt, quÂ£ primd iuH' cem docent,in qudfi dcciderit,utdut non mteUigdt, Â£tt non memmtrit, nut no eredut, frufrdin rdiquis liiori

fetÂ«. Brit Â«wtÃª rtirrÃ¤tio Â«tpertd dt^; diluctild,/! fiicrit Â«^^^â^^

f rimiwn cxpofiti uerbis proprijs, cr figniÃ-CAntibusÂ» 4- seid Ggni* o- nottfoÃ¯diÃ¢w qHtdfm,nont(tmeitexqtti/Ã¯tw,ct Â«^ wfâ fiÂ«ââ^ TemotwÃ¯tiww diÃmit^ rebusjperjottw, tÃ¨poribuSjloc^i cdufiSjippt ettetrÂ« pronuKewtione in boe accontoidtd^ut iudex, quÂ£ dieMMurjqMdnj flt;tctllifflcdccipt(it.QÂ«iÂ« lâÂ»-* dem uirtiÂ« ncgligitur 4 pÃ¯urtmis, qui lt;td cUmorÃ© dij^o pi Æ Hfl cti^m forte circimfufÂ£ nmltitudinK compopti\ won feruntiUud mtentionw fdentiu,nee pbi diferti uidÃ© tÂ»r, ni/Ã¯ omniet tumultÂ», de Mociferdtione coneuÃerinti rem indiedrejfermonw quotiduni,Â©- in quenetwq^ ett* mdoftorÂ» adentis cxÃtmduf, eu interim, quod tdnq fd eilc cotemnunt ,nefcidt prx(bdrc Â»clint minus,dn poÃint â¦

reperient, quim td qÂ«od fe difturos fMtJ?e omnes putSt nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

rd.Tum dutÃª optime dicit ordtor, eu uidetur werd diee re. At Â»Â»ne Â»dut edmpum Wddt cxpoptionw,bie potiÃt* mum er uoeem Redunt, er eerttieem repowunt, er brd ebiÂ» in lotus idÃ dnt,totoq^ er rcrK,er uerbor w,er eowt poptioK genere Idfeiuiut. Deinde,td quod fit monÃro ft mile,pldcct dflio, edufdWo inteUigitur. Veruboe omittd mus,ne minus grdtif prlt;Â£cipiedo refld, q o^nfe reprÃ© bendendo prdud meredmur, Breuis crit Wdrrdtio ontc omnidjfi inde eaperimus rem expowere, unde dd iudt^ tempertmet. Deinde f nibilextrd eduftm dixerimus, turn etiÃ¯ ft reciderimus omnid,quibus [uhiMKjuec eogni tiowi quiequdm nee utiliUti detrdbdtur â¦ Sokt enim efi

qujcdiitn pirtium ireuitlt;K,c[Uiie longAm Mne effidtjM num. in portumueni, ndunn proj^exi ,^udntiticbcrct interrogdui, depretio conueni, confcendiJuUdtflin^i dncor^^foluimid ordm^ proueilifimia. '^ihH hortini d ci celerim poteÃ^fed fufficit dicerc,e portu nduigmi-Et quotics exitm rd fitis oftendit priord,dcbeinta bo( effe contenti^quo reUqud inteUiguntur. Qudre cum d' cere licedt, e^ mihifiUia iiMcnis, omnid iÃd fuperui' cud,cupido ego liberorum uxorem duxi, nutum fuÃi^b filium educMi,m ddolefccntid perduxi. ideo^; Grti:^' CircBcifa ex rum dliqui aliud circumcifdm expofitionem,id cÃ, a'â^' pofitio. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;rop-op,aliud br euern putducrunt, quod itld fupcnutui^

laudanda? ^ââ^ dutem breuitdtÃ« in hoe ponmus, non ut mimu, Ã^ ne plue diedtur q oporteut.^dmiterdtiones quliffÂ»â^, '' Talt;j'io7.Ã¼y!aq G^ ^ioso'Xoym(=, qudt in ndrrdtilt;Â»it^ tandde quiddmfcriptoresdrtiutntrddiderunt,trd''r' Suntenim hitcuitid non tdntubreuitdtii grdÃ¹^^Ã¿^^* dd. tlt;on minui dutem eduendu erit, qm nmiu cornfâ'^ tes omnid fcquitur,objcuritds. Satius^ dliquid eÃn^, rdtionifuperefje qdeeffe. NdWfuperuicud cum i^^^ dicuntur, necejfdrid cum pcriculo fubtrahuntur. QÃ¯^* Salluftms. ^^ ^l^^f^^^ pj-j^^ m^ SdlluÃidnd (qudnq in ipfo uirtiâ^'^ obtmet locum) breuitds, er dbruptum fermonisg^*^â quod otiofum fortdÃe leÃ¼orem minuifdUdtfdiiiio^^^ trdnf(oldt,nec dum repetdtur cxpeÃ©idt:cum pr^f(^^ leUor no ferÃ¨ Ãt,nifi eruditus, iudicem rurd plertilt;lgt;^^ deewids mi(tAt,dc co pronMitidturu,quii intcll(X^^'â'gt;

nutu debet eÃe breuitutjUlioqui ft widoftuinum cr fuU Ut HoluptuSjC mwjus longu,quiE deleftunt,utdentur :Ht urnanum uc molle iter, etiumfi eft putij umplior is, mi* nut futigut,qKÃm dMruw urduumqj compendiiwn.Ncc aridumlt;$ enirn mibi iMiqium tuntu fuerit curubrewitutis ,ut non eu, quf credibilem fuciiwit expoptionem, inferi uclim.

Simplex ciiim,cr iwidique pr^cip^non turn nurrutio Â«o cUri poteft,quum confwfio.Sumt porro multÃ¦ conditio* ne ipfu rei longf nurrutioncs,qwibÂ«s extremu, ut pruce pi jprooemij purte ud mtcnticncmpriepurundiw cft iÂ«* dtx:demde curunduw, ut omni urtc, uel ex putio eiw detrubumm a'iquipufl ex t^dio, ut minus longu fn,rff i ' ci!imiÂ«,quiepotcÃ¯imtMdi(fÃ¨rendo,nontumcnfinefflen* tione corumqtte diÃeremui. QuÂ« cuufu occidendibu buerit^uoj uÃumpferit confeiot, qucmudmodiwn dipo fuerit mfidius jprobutionw loco dicum * QudedumucrÃ³

, ex ordme pnetermittendu, quulc cft upud Ciceronem:^*'Â®^â]Â® DVoritHrÃ¯ulcmiusÃ¯Multuenm qu(C funt in rc,quiureÂ« motu fmt u cuÂ«fu,prÂ«termittum. At purtitio tÃ¦dium le uut.tiicuM que uftu fint unte ipfum rei contruftwm, di*

, 1 dicituiifbwÂ«tuTnurrutioneÃ¯,quumuMulongu.lntcritn expcdietexpofitioncÃ¯ breui interfutione dijlwiguereÂ» ^j^^j^|j^^

' t4Z M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. ^ Rcficictw enim iudex priorum Ãne^ (^ Ã uclutdy uurnrurfMimtium priepdralit .SitÃ¤menddhiW^ * quo^uc drtihus m longuM exierit ordo remn,^^^^^. inutilis in extremd pdrte commonitio, quad Cicef^ f^^ dm in Ireui ndrrdtione fdcitz Adhuc^Ciefdr^Qc,^^ us omni culpd edret^domo cR egreffM, no modo ÃHÃââ^^ dd beÃ¼umjed ne ad minimdm quidÃ«MiÃÃition(^) es terd CredihiUs dutem erit ndrrdtio ditte omnid,M us confulucrimus noÃrum dnimum, ne quid ndturd mus dduerfum: deinde Ã eduÃs dc rdtiones fdHi^ Pâ'^ pofuermus,non omnibus,Ãed de quibus fonds conuenientes his,qusfd{ld crediuolemus, eoj ' erimus,utfurti reum,cupidu/m : ddulterij,libidi^Â°r â homiddij,temerdriivm,ucl contrd,Ã defendemus Â» P^ teredlocd^empord,Ã¼' fmiUd. nbsp;nbsp;dutem quidam ^â^^

dudus rei credibiUs, qudlis in comoedijs, V ââ 'â'ââ'^ Aliqui enim ndturdlitcr fequuntur, lt;!:!r cobsrcn^â bene priord ndrrdueris,iudex ipfe, quod poÃedÃ quot;â rdturus,expellct.^c idud quidemfuerit igt;^flt;^â^^gt;gt;:^ qusddm probdtionum Ãdrgere,uerMnÃe,ut ndd ^^ nern ejfememinerimus,non probdtionem.Ã¼onn0i etidm drgumeitto dliquo confirmdbmus, quad PââââfAf^ rmus,fed fimptici Oquot; breui,ut in ueneÃeijs: Sditf^ Ãdtim concidit,liuor de tumor confeÃim edl coy '^ Hoe fdciunt ez ills prspdrdtiones,ctm reut diâ^ buÃus, drmdtus,foÃ¯licitus,contrd inÃrmos,W^^^â'^ ros.Omnid denilt;^,quÂ£ probdtione trdiidturiÃâ^â^^ fondm^edufdm,locum,tepu^,inÃrtimciitiim,o'^^ÃâÂ°

Â«tt Â«luire mirlt;iri,fed probituros.Optimx urro prxpd nes rdtiones crut, quÃ¦ Uturrint,ut Ã Cicerone fiwit quidem utiliÃimd prddiftd omntlt;t,pcr qux Miloni Clodiu5,non Clodio Milo 'rafdidtiÂ« cjfc uidcutur : plurwKum time ft cit tWicdllidif mut fmplfcitdtw imifdtio: Milo dute/tmi infendtufuijjet co die, quoid fenutiÂ« eft dwiiffiÂ«, do* mumucnitjCrtlccoÃ® er McJltmctdmutdMitjpdMliJ^cr duw f Â«xor,Ht ftjCompiirdtjComordtiÂ« cfl:quÃ m nibil prlt;egt; pdruto, nibilfepindto feciffe uidetur Milo {Quod non folum rebtM iffÂ« uir eloqucntifmuÂ«, quibus morlt;Â«, er Icntum profcÃ©ioiJK ordmem ducit^d uerbis etiem wd gdribus er quotididnÂ« ,er drtc occulta confccuttÂ« eft: qua ft aliter difta cjfcnt,frcpitu ipfuin iudicem,deinde pdtroniwn cxcitA^cnt. frigida uidentur if a plerifquc, fed boe ipfum manifef um eft quomodo iudicem fef Uc rmt ,quod uix Ã left ore deprebenditur. HÃ¦c fivnt quÂ« credibilem fdciant expof tionew, nam ne contritrilt;i,lt;tut fibi repugnantia in narratione diclt;tmiÂ«,ficÂ«i pr^cipien dwn ef, Â« reliqÃ¯U fufra docctur,ctilt;tmf quidam feri quot;nbsp;flores (trtium,boc quoq; tandem tanqiwm occultuw,cr

Ã fe frudenter erutum,traduit. Hw tribus narradi uir An pluratrj, tutibiMddijciunt quidam magnifcenfiam, quarn p.%7Â«* j^J*^â*'âf* AoTt^Ã¯-nlap uocaiw, quÂ« neq; in omnes cau/Ã¶s cadit(na qwdin plerifquc iudicijs priuatÂ«,credito, locato et con dÂ«fto ,interdiftw, babere loei potef fu^rA moiwn ^

244 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. tollens orlt;itio^)nec femper eft utilis,ut uel proximolM loniinoexemplo pdtct. Et memmerimus multds efftc^u ftss,in quibus confttendum, cxcuftrndum^ftibmitteninin fit, quod exponimus, quibui omnibus aliens til iUitni* gnificentU uirtus.Ciudre non mdgis proprium nurri^ tionts eR mdgniftce dicerc^quim miferdbiliterinuHio^ fie,grduiter,dulciter, urbane i quÂ£ cumfuo quaque lxÂ» fint laudabiliii, non fivnthuic parti proprie aÃigniti, or uelut dedita. iHd quoqilc ut narrationi apta, ita ci^ teris partibus commuais eRuirtus,quam TheodeSt^ huic urn proprie dÃ©dit:non enim tnagniftcam modo tfÂ«^^ efie^uerumetiam iucumdam expofitionem. Sunt quiai^ ijciant his euidentiam, quÂ£ c^x^y^x uocatur. Nf^â^ , InTopkis. ego quenquamdeceperm ,utdifiimulem Ciceroniquo queplures partes placerez l^ampr^terquam plamm, quot;nbsp;er breuem^et credibilcm,uult efte euidenteni,nugt;Ã¯'^^ cum dignit ate,Sed in oratione mor ata debet effeÂ«^ cum dignitate qute poterunt. Euidentia in narraiio^^gt; quantum ego mteUigo, eH quidem magna uirtus, Â«** quid uerinon diccndum,fed quodammodoetinnoÃt^l dÃ¨dumcdl,ftdfubijeiperftticuitatipoteR.Cluainlt;igt;^ * etiam contrariam interim putauerunt, quid in dam caufis obfeuranda ueritas ell, quod e^ rWÂ«^*'**^' iiam qui obfeurare unit,narrat falfa pro ucris,et in w qux narrat falfa pro ueris,debet liborare,ut uidtai^^^ qudm cuidentifima. Sed quatinus etiam font quad^ Narratio to peruenimus ad difficilius narrationum genut^^ ra contra ig^uamurfm quibusrescontranoserit:q^Â° kconon

Â«Â«Hi pylt;eterci0idlt;iÂ»i Mmitionem ^uiduerunt Â» Et fdnÃ¨ iJibil ellfdciliw,nifi frorjwstotdm cdufdm ornnmo non dgereSd fi 4â^ iuÃd rdtionf (ufeeperw Utem, cuim dr tM fftmiUm ejje edufim ÃÃ»entioconjiteri^ ni fi forte tdm bebes futurm eft tudex, Â«t fecu/nium td prontmei* et, ^Hod feiet ndrrdre te noluiffe. Ne^uc t/nficidS co, 'm ndrrdtione,utdli(pu,negdnid,dUlt;ptddiijcienid,dU(iudi mutinid,fic iUejui etidm tdeenid. Sed tdeendd qÂ«Â« tdÂ« eere ot^orteUt, tz Uberwm erit^ Quoi fit nonnwtcpnm breuititii qÂ«oq; grdtid;^Â«*^ itod cft: RcÃiondit quoi ci uifum fft.DiJÃ®mgiumuÃ® igitur generd cdufdrurn. N* que in quibiÂ« non de culpd e[uieritur,fei de d{iione,eti* dmfi enmt contrd nos tbemutu, confiteri nabis Ucebit, Peciwliiin) de tcmplo fu^ulitjed priiwtttnj, non ideo flt;t* crilegui eft.virginetn r4puit,uort tamen optiopitri dd bitur. Ingenuum jlupruwit, er Ãuprutm fe pj^endit, nontdmenideofiuprdtorf:dpite, utmortKcdufdpU'' quot;bâ*â* Â«ilt;itur,fed decern Â»liliu, qÂ«Â« poenit Ãuprdtori conÃituW eft,diibit. Verum in bis quoque confeÃionibus eft nliÂ« quid,quod ex wiuidiu, qtwm expoptio dduerfdftj fecit, detrubt poteft,cumetium ferutnoÃndepecedtMfuis niolliusloqwntur. Qu/ddmenim quip non nurrdÃ»tes witigdbimut. Non quidem (ut uduerprius dicit) conpÂ« bum prtimtemplwm dttulit, Â«cediuedptdutt eimrei tempiÂ« ,pd occdpone Q- dbfentid cupodwmcorruptiw, lt;t pecimid, qMÂ£ nimirum in dn'm'K bominum plitrimum t3teft,uiaÂ«j f ft. Sfj quid refertipecedtum O' furtum tft. Nibil dttinet id defendere jcuini pandm non reelÂ»

24^ M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlTâ funuijnterdum qiuÃ dÃ¤mnemMipÃ- Vis teiiclt;gt;'gt;gt;gt;^* no impulfumP errorddpÃum^ nodic deceptu^ ucrijK^ iftiifortiilÃe,tu tmen ingenuum ÃuprdÃi, fiiutiitt^* milid. Ã¼onnwni^ propoÃtionc pr^muniri poteÃ ^^r et deinde exponi. Contrdrid funt omnid tributÃ^^^A^ iÂ« mortem pdtris coiurdrdnt, fortiti nodcmÃug^^ P^ ordm,em,cum ferro cubiculim intrurunt pdtre doTlt;igt;^* ente^cum occidereeum nemo potuiffet, excitdto o^^'^ indieduerM'.t.Siturnen pdter,lt;iui diuifit pdtrimoniu, ^ reos pdrricidij dÃ©fendit ,fic dgdt * Quod coatrd l^Sl^ fuljicit,pdrricidium obijcitur iuuenibus, epiorurd p^^^ uiuit,dtlt;Ã etidm liberis fuis ddeÃ, Ordinem rei mef^^ quidem nihil neceffe eÃ,cÃ dd tegem nihil pcrtiiie^^' ft cofeÃionem culpx i me exigitis, ego fui pdter i^^fquot;^* Cr pdtrmonij,cpiod idm melius db his ddtmniÃâi'â^â''^^^^ terdt,tendx euÃos. Deindefubijcitur, Ãimuldtot db ^uorum mdulgentiores pdrentes erdnt ,fentp^^^^^ eum hdhuiffe dn'mâMtt,(pii fit euentu deprehen{^gt;^^ cidere putrem nonpoffent. Nf$ enim iureiufdio ââr fuijfet,ft uli(lMndo hoe mentis hdbuiffent,necfoÃ¯i^^^ quoi fe quiflt;Ã eximi uoluer it.Omnid htee ejÃ^^g^ plucidioribus unimis uccipientur^iUubreuipropop . nis defenfionemoUitd^AteumquÂ£ritur,unfdÂ°lt;ââ J â uel qudlefddum fit, licet omnid contrd nosfuti^ (lt; do tdmÃ« euitdre expofitionem fuluA edu^t musiNdrrduit dccufdtor,nec itd,ut que eÃemd^'i turn indicdret,fcd udiecit inuididm, rem verbis â*i*^ rAuit^ucceÃ'eruntprobAtiones,perQriW'i^''ââ'^' â

retur Ã . notiis,fi nihil expoUMniMjIId cjjc quf dduerfirt m dixit,et tdlid qiulia dixit,credit neceffe cÃ.Qwid er go cadem exponemm^Si de ^iwlitdte dgetwr, cuiiw turn demutm quinto ejl,cum de re confit elt;tdew,fcd non eo dem modo,ctliiÂ« cdufiWjdliftm rdtionem dabo.V erbiÃ¯ de wc qwedjmliccbitJitxuÃ¯Ã¼hihÃ¯itdtis, 4Ult;tritid pctrpgt; monix ,ncgligcmii funplicitatw nomme lenietur. V uiÂ» tu dcniqMc,uoce,bibitu,uel fuuorw ^liquid, ucl mi/cruti onis merebor. Solet nonnuqiwm mouere Ucbrymlt;w ippt tonl'e^io. Atque egotibenter interTogem, fint ilU deÂ« ffnfuri,quxnonndYrdncrtnt,nec nc; Num ft needefen dcrin^nccnurrUMcnntjtotcicuuJÃ¯tprodctur* Atpdo fenfuri funt, proponcre certe pkriwquc id, quod con* frmuturi fumiw, oportet. Cur ergo non exponumiÂ«, quod cz diluipoteft f Et ut hoc contmgut,utique indi* tundum cÃ. Aut quid inter probutionem, er nurrutio* nem mtcreÃ, nifi quod nurrutio rf probutionis conti* wupropofitio; rurjut probutio nurrutioni eÃ congru* ent confrmutio: V ideumut ergo num cxpoftiobtcc 13 unde gior dÃ©muni eÃe dcbeut,ct puulÃ´ ucrbofior prupurutio ne,er quibufdum urgumewit ( urgumentis dico,non ur gumentutionejcui turnenplurimiwn confertf-equens uÃirmutio) efeduros nos quod dictmiw, non pofe uiw renwii oÃendi primu expofitione,cxpcÃ´tent, cr opinio nes fuÂ« diÃerunt, er bene Jf erent. Ornique utiquc nur rundum tÃ^quiequid dÃ¼tey quimuduerfuriut expofuit, nurruri poteÃ, uni eo ettum prowmiu funt in bis edufu

fnpmilt;icM^q!iÂ£ t^uid migK dgwit, ^uÃm ut cognitioni rcrim dccommoditiorem iudicem fucidnt f At^ui con^ Ãdt nufyudtn cor um effe nmiorem ufum, quÃm uii tnU mm iudicit ah dliqud contrd nos mfitd opmione fielten , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dmcA. CoieHurules duteedufte, in ejuihm defddo ipi

ritur, non tdm fiÂ£pe rei, de qm, iudicium ed, ijudm Â«Â» rum, per quie res coUigendd ed, expofitionem h^ei^â '' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Qa^ lt;^^ deeufidtorfujpiciofÃ¨ ndrret,rem leMrefuj^i*

cionem debedt.AÃiter db hoe, Atq^db iÃ¼o dd iudicem f^ ferri oportet. At enim quxddtn drgumeMd turbd uilÃ©t, diduUd leuiordfiunt, ld quidem non eÃ¨ pertinetjUtclUt ^ d'''Â«quot; F nbsp;nbsp;^'*^â*^ ââ^^ ndrrdndumjed quomodo ndrrdnd'dmfttgt;^lt;^^^

ma,Â° '^â^' eircongerereplurdexpofitionequisprobibet,fiidgt;â^^' le cd edufe f er promittere ,fed er diuidere ndrrdtie* ncm,erprobdtiones fubitungerepdrtibm,dti^ Udtrin^ fm dd fequÃ«tid,tlt;tdm ne hts quidem dccedo, quifiemt^ eoputdiit ordme, quo quid ddum fit,effendrrdnii^^â fed co modo quo expedit,Q^od fieri pluribm fiÃ¿*^^^ . cet.t^dm et dUqudndo excidiffefmt(ldmm,eii/tn qf^ â liore loco reducimm, er interim nos reduduros qmim ordtnem tefidmur,quid fic futurd fit enufi u^^ or, interim re expofitd, fubiurngimm edufds, ^Â«â^ lt;nbsp;cejferunt.ttiei^ enim ed twd lex defenfionis, ^'^â^^ ^^ pr^fcriptum, pro re, pro tempore intuendi qnty ^^^ fim,dtque ut er it uulnm, itd uel curdudu/m pi''^'â y^ fi curdtio diffirri potcll,mtcrim dcUgditdum ' nbsp;nbsp;^

finreindum pinf ndrrdredixerimnefm, quod Cicero pi'ââ pius^ ââ ^ fecittefique non conceffum modo Jed AHqfi^'^^'^

â¢ifcf fflt;triuw,ut w cAufis repctMn4ariÂ«n,omttibtÂ«^ qÂ«Â« fimpVcrs non funt. Amentw cÃ enimjuperÃitione prÂ«-ceptom/m contrat rationem MÃ¼Ãe trahi, Narrationem i if o (tnte probationcs pontre cft mÃituttwn, ne index, qui de re qu^ratwr, ignorct. Cur igitnr fi finguU probanda aut rcfÃ¨llenda ernntjnonfingKla etia narrentur ? Me certe ,quantacÃq; noÃrw experwnentis hatendaeft Ãdes, feci^e boe in faro, quotiej ip/d deader abat utili-talt;,probai(tibtK er erMditis,er bis qui iudicabant,fcio, er (quod non arroganter dixerim, quia funt plurmt, quibufeuni e gi,qui me refcUere poÃint ,p mentiar)ferÃ¨ ponendf Ã me canfÃ¦ oÃiciiwn exigebatwr. Neqj ideo ta men non fapiiwfocere aliare oportebitjWtrertwn ordi*

i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nem fequamwr. Quadam uero etiarn turpiter cÃ¶uerttwx ExpoRtio

1 tur,utÃ peperiÃe narres^demde concepiÃeiapertu te- âp^^*'â** k nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ãamentum,deindeÃgnatum .in qnibiw,fi id quod poÃe l nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;riiÂ«,dixcrw,de priore tacere optimu eft. Sunt quidam 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;er falÃe expofiti5es,quariMn in foro duplex genus eft;

1 alterumquodwiÃriwnentis ad[uÂ«atur,ut PÂ»ClodiuÂ« adunatur i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ãdutia teÃium,qua nofte tneeÃu RomÂ« comiftrat,inte 1 ramne fefwiÃe dicebat: altcrum quod eft tuendu dicen I tu ingenio. Id interim ad foUm uereeuwdiam pertmet, 1 unde etiam mibi uidetur dici color,interim ad quÂ«Ãio-

Htm. Sed utrumcunq^ erit,primaÃt curaru, wt id quod Fmgendi Â« f*'*amp;miÂ«,Ãtri pof it: deinde ut er pcrfonÂ«,er loco,er ^JJJ^^*Â® tcmpoÃ¯icongruat,er credibiiemrationem er ordinem babeat.sic continget etia uerÂ« alicui rei cobarcat ut ar giÂ«nento,quod in caufa coÃrmetur. Na quÂ« tota extra,

zÃ§o M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT-tprobant y^^jj petits funt^meniiendi Ucentidm produnt- (^^^^'^ dum prxeipue (eptod fingentibus frec^ueter excidit) m ijud inter fe pugnent, Qu^dd pirtibus bUndiuntuTi^^ in fumnidm non confentiuni. Pnetered ne bis, cj^gt;*^^ elJe conÃdbit,dduerfd Ãnt^ IÂ» (cbold etidm,ne color c^' trd themdtd quÂ£rdtur, Vtrobi^; dutÃ« ordtor memtgt;Â»Sl[ debebit ddlione totd quad Ãnxerit, quoniumfolent erlt;^ gt;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dere qua fdlfd funt/terum^ eSb iUud, quoi mlgÃ¨ lt;Jlt;^

turt menddeem memore eÃe oportere. SeidmusititÃ¯,!^ mor fit^ quot;'^ â^^ ^^^fâ^^ finierdtur,wnum nabis dUtluod effe iilt;^^^ dÃifidediienOymittcreinplurcsIâujpiciÃ¶eslÃ¯cere.i^^ men in ^uibufddm feholdÃieis cotrouerfijs, in i^idbus fâ' nitur dUepiem non ref^ondere qug mterrogdtur, iib^[ , tdsomnidcn'jmerddi,(lUÂ£rejÃonderipotui(fent-Viiii^ dd turo meminerimui cd,lt;piÂ£ no cddeni in teÃem. SnÂ«^ dutÃ« (piÂ£ noÃro dicuntur dnimo,cuitK ipÃ tdntii conÃ^ fumus. Item quod d de fÃªtait, nee hoc eÃ¼ qui mff^â item^ db eocui idem expcdiet,is enim non negAitgt;^ dduerfdrio quoip,quid non hdbiturm eÃ¼ in negdnior dem. Somniorum et fuperÃitionum colores, ipÃ i^r cilitdte dutoritdtem perdideruni, Non eft dutemÃ^^ in ndrrdtione uti coloribiK,nifi per tot dm dÃ«iioneiii (^ fentidne,cum prxÃertim quorunddm probdtio ÃhiÃ^ dÃeuerdtione er per feuer dntid:utiÃepdrdÃtus,quigt;^ ' â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dbdiedtum Ã diuite inuenem er dbfolutum, tinq Ã^

ÃliumdÃcrit, hdbebit quidemcolorem,quodicitgt;^, pdupertdtem fibi edufdm exponendi fuiÃe, CT1^^ ^ fepdrdfui perfondm eÃe fufceptdm,quiiinSli^ ^*'*â

ORATOR. UBER IIII. 1$! Ãliwni bitkret, er Ã¼co ilium innocentem ter abdiai' turn,quid filiiw abdicAntis noneÃet', niÃt timen omniiut uerhisjet imorem pitriumjdtq; biMtc quidem irdentip fiiÂ«umoÃcrtdent,er odium diuitts^zymetu/m pro tw-Â«cne,qÂ«cm periculofeminÃurwmin iUi domo,inquet tm muiÃutÃt,[ciit, fuÃ^icione fukiedi petitoris no ci rebit. EMenif dtiquindoin pboldÃicis controuerÃÃt quod in fora un poÃit iccidere^dabito, ut codem colore pin utritq; utdtur,deinde cum pro p quifq; dÃ©fendit Mt in Uli controuerÃn Vxor mxrito dixit, ippeUitim fc de Ãupro Ã priuigno^er JibiconÃitutÂ« tempus er b-ciim, cÂ£tdrmcontr4.|iliui detulit de nouerez, editotitn ea de re tiwnilio tempore, de loco, quid pdter in eo, quem uxor predixerdtjfilium inucmt,inco quem/Ã¯liu$,uxorcm,tllS repudiduit, ^uiticenteÃUumibdiat, Nihil diet poÂ» tcjiproiuHenc,quodnonidemptprortouercd. Ponen turturnen omnid communid,deinde ex perfondrum tompurdtione, er iwdicij ordine , er filcntio repu-didtic drg'dwentd ducentur. NeiHudquidcmignord-re oportet, quedum cj?e qux eolorem nonrecipidnt/cd tuntuTO deÃendendi fint,quilts eR iUc diucj, qui ÃdtuS

pduptris inimicifldgettiscccidit.rcus cR iniuridriwn. Nim fdftiwn eins modejlum nemo eÃe dixcrit,fortiÃe, wtfittutum,obtincl)it* Quodfi pdrs expofitionis pro

2$t M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. noÃrdm ddiwidbunt, expoÃtis z^ cÃ¶Ãrmitis, diuerÃt reUlt;iM utiremedijSyde quibw ÃupridiÃ¤umeii. ^/pU ra proderunt^etiam coniuvgcre Uceiit, ut c^ue olÃnU, in medio uclut auxilijs noÃris poÃtayminus bdheMtiÃ¼^ riumt Ciult;e tarnen non erunt nuda ponenda,fed, ut ff noÃra,diqua argumÃ©tatione firmemut, er diHerfi,cur credibiUa non fint, adijdamut : quia nifi diÃinxerimiSi ^ uerendum e^^nc bona noÃra permixtis mdit in^uintti â ^Cauenda in twr.lIU^Mo^ denarrationeprlt;Â£cipifolÃ«t,ne^udexe^ narrationr. Ã^t cxcurÃo,ne auertatur a indicÃ© ferme, ne aliÃ©nÃ© fti fane uoeem dcmus,nc argumetemur. Adijciunt quHnO ctiam,ncutamuraf}Ã¨dibus. (Quorumpleraqifunt^t^ quentiÃme euÃodienda, mo nwnq, niÃ ratio eoegentf mutanda,ut Ãt expoÃtio perfficua er breuis. NiW ^ââ dem tam raro poterit habere rationem, ^ excurfio, x^'' untjua debebit effe niÃ breuis, er talis, ut ui ^tuiiÂ»â â* Excurfio. deamuraffvcli,ueÃ¯utre(to itinere dcpulf^cptaliscl^^^* ceronis circanuptiM SofiaiiOmulierisfcebtsincff^^^* fro Cluctio y^^ prÃªter hanc ivnam,m omni uita mauditut 0^*^* dmem effrenatam er indomitd,Ã¶audaciamfinguhfÃ^^ non timuijÃe,Ã minus um deorum hommum^; Ã^^ . mam ipÃtm node, faces'; ipfas nuptiales,nonlitÂ»^ biculi,non cubile Ãliie,non parietes,denilt;j^ ipfos Ãi^''^ rum teÃesnuptiarumi SermoueroauerfusÃ tuH^^Ã ' breuiusindicat Ã¯nterm,er coarguit,^uadereiM 'de procemio dixera,fcntio. Sicutde ffopopodaiiii^ qua tarnen non Seruim modo Sulpitius utitur pro ^'âif

prfjÃ®iwnf Et MireuÃ® qttoÂ«jTulliuscortty4Nuumbos;^^|^1 Nitmcdquoljjrcicxpoptioefl.VtudCitsturMttTOdilIjis,

quium, nÃ³ntte ad credulitatem plurwnu Oquot; Ã^lt;^gt;^ f^o** eeleritatÃª fert^ QMfncfj^ciJJc/ine obferMunttuquudAUtdeutHr (quunq boe m iUo credibile nS rfl)in Purtitionibus pr^ ciptt,ut bibcst mrriitio fuMititem, lt;idmirationcj,cx- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,^

pfÃ³ldtioKfs, exitus mopwidtos, colloquia perfondrum, omnes (t^Ã¼tw. ArgiimcutÃimur, ut dtxijHunq, drgu* mcittumponemuidliquitndo* Quod ficit pro Quinto a rgumenta Ligirio Cicero,cum dicit, fic eÃ¼prouincix prlt;ffuiJJc,ttt in namtiSÃ© illi piccm elfe cxpedirct.lnfercmus expo/Ã¯tioni er brc* uem^am res poftet,defenponem,er rdtionÃ« fuftoruw.

Rei ordo per Ã tilis eft: Q^Ligirius legutus in Africa cumC.Confidio profedus eft. Quid ergo Marcus Tul bus^ Qjnwn,inquit,Liglt;trius, eu ejpt udbuc nuUd belli fwjpicio,legatu4 in Africain cum C. Confidio profedus eft, Alibi: Non modo nullum id bcHu, fed ne ad minima quidem fuÃiicionembcUi, Et cuejfet indicanti ptis, Q^ LigariusnuUofeimplicarinegotio pajfuseft. adieciti Dornum j^eftans,er ad fuos redire cupims. Ita quoi cxponebat,cr ratione fecit credibile, er a^ftus quoq;

in narratione a^Ã¨ftibus: qui fi boe dicunt,non diu, hc^ narrationÂ«, ut in epilogo,meewm fentiunt .Sunt enim cjfugiendiÂ« mo Ã¯Â« .Caterum cur ego tudicem nolim, cu ewm docco, etia InoHcrii Cur quad infirma partefumaftionis petitu#

2Ã4 M. FAB. OyiNT. INSTIT* rus, non in primo jidtim rerum ingrcjfu^Ã fieri W^ confequdrfCum prÂ£firtim aid 'm proidtionibusf^^ re firn dnâmo dus dbufurus occupdto,uel ird,uclinifif^ SVââ¢ done. An non M.Tuttius circa uerierd duis Ro.Â«^ breuifi'me mouet dffidus^ nonfolum conditioneipi^â loco 'miuriie,genere uerberum,fi:d animi c^uo^ (^quot;^ ddtione.SummÃ¼ en'im uirum ojlendit,^ui cum uirÃ¿df deretur, non mgemuerit, no rogduerit, fid tnituW Ã¶' uemfe 'R.omdnu efifi cum 'muidid codent is, er- fiddle '^ ^^' Jâ ris cUmducrit. Qjiid Philodamicdfiumc nÃ³nne cum f^ tot dm expofitionem 'meendit 'muididm,tum infitff^ ipfi Idchrymis, impleuit,cum fientes non tamturn^^'â g ofienderet,putrem de morte filij,filium de putrit- illi ^^'^ â ^ â^' epilogi pofifiunt mdgis hdlcre miferdbiÂ»' Scrum cA enim dduoedre bis rebus affidum in perai* tione,quds ficcurusndrrduerit. AjJ'ueuitiÃ¼isiudeX)'^'^ eus fine motu mentis dccipit, quibus comotuf neuot w^ eR,et difficile eÃ¼ mutdre bdbitu unimi femel con^i^^â^ nuftanda de ^2Â°â^*'Â° ('â^^ ^^ diÃimÃ¼ldbo iudidum meu, lt;P^'^^ center. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;id c^dâfum didurUS,exemplismdgis 5 pneceptiiâ'

continetur) nurrdtionem, utfiuUdm partem ortt^'^'^^'. omni qua potefi gratia c^ uencre exornanda puttâ plur'mu refert,quÂ£ fit natura dus rei, c^uÃ expotgt;^' , IÂ» paruis ergo,etudes funtferÃ¨ priudtÂ£,fit ideptVâ er uelut applicitus rei cultus: 'm uerlis fu/mma ddiÃ¿^* tia, qua 'm locis impetu feruntur, er dreumie^^ '^'^^^ tionis copia latent,bic exprcffia,c^, ut uult 2cne,P^ tmdd effe debebuntteompofitio difimuldd lt;lMdein,r

t^Wfn qH4mtHciwtdiJ?miÂ£t, figure non iUit poetics, er coittrlt;t ration? loqucndiautoritatc Â«rtcrÃ¼rcccptÃ¦inam debet effe (jÂ«ampitri/?imttj fermo, er qui Mrietate tX'^ dium cjfugilt;tt,cr mutdtionibuÃ¯ attimÃ¼lcÂ«rt,nc in ch-m-dÃ« cafion.JimilÃ« cowpofnionÃ«,pares elocutionÂ« trapus wieidawMs.Caret enim ettert lenocinijs cxpofitio/t nt fi comendetKr bacuenuÃitc Jaceat necc^e rft. Nee in una parte intentior eft iwdex/o^ nibilrcfte dift Â« pe* rit.Pratere a ntfeia quomodo ctiam credit facilius,qua: etudienti iMcitudafuntjCr uoluptate ad Jidem ducitur. Vbiucromaiorrcserit,cratrociainuidiofe,er trivia Â«li/crabiliterdicercliccbit. Non ut cortfuTOmantur afÂ« feftusjed tantÂ» uelut prlmk lineis deftgnentur,ut planÃ© qualis futuraft imago rei fatim apparcat. Ne fen-tentia qÂ»idem,uelut fatigatÂ» intentione fomaekum iuÂ« dicis refccre diffuaferim, maxime quidÃ© breui intcrie* aione,qualts eft itUiÃ¯eceruntferui Milonis, quod fuospro Milone. quifq feruos in re tali facere HoluiJfct. interim pAulo'^'^o Cluttia libcriore,quali$ eft: Nubit gencro focrus, nullis aujpi-cijSjHuUis autoribus,funeÃis ominibus omnium. Quoi ownftfaftumbisquoq;tcmporibtts,quibus omnisai Wilitatcm potius ,quam ad oÃentationem componeba- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;j

tttÃ¯ oratio, et crant adbuc feuer iora ludicia^quanto nuc faemdummagis .cumin ipfacapitis Æ ut fortumarum

' pericuU irrupit uoluptosi Cuibominu defidcrio quan* tumdanicbcat.aliolocodicam. Interim dliquidin* dulgendum eÃe conf tcor. Klultum confert adiefta ueÂ» ris cTfdibilw rcÃ¯Â«mimag!),quÂ« Â«dut in rem prientÂ«Â»Â»Â»

2$6 M, FAB. QVINT. INSTiT. pf rduccrc duiientes uidetur, qudiii cR HU AL Ci^P^ Antonium defcriptio, Ã¯^dnq; ipfum offvndunt tM^H^ foporc profligdtum^totis prtecordijs Ãertetittm,ritHÂ»gt; fosj^iritiagemimire, pracldm^q; contubcmdles ti^ mniim I^ondis trdnfuerfM incubdrc,ct reÃ¯icjult;gt;f Hrctn^^ ccrepdÃm,(^ult;e tdmen exdnimdt-Â£ terrore, bojiiu Ã ilt;â tu percepto,excitdre Antoniu condbdntur,noniÃªiw^' mdbdntfiuÃrd ceruidbui toUebdnt,bUndiut dHni^ rem inuocdbdt,uehementiuf etid nonnuUdferiebit, i^^ mm cum omniu uocÃ¨,tddumqi nofcitdret^proximt^^' iufq; coUu dmplexu petebdt, nee dormire excitdtut, quot;^^ uigildreebrius poterdt/ed femifomno fopore interuil' nutcenturionum,concubindrumqiidildbdtur. NitÃ³lâ'^ net^ credibiUutfingi, neq; uehemÃ«tiiM exprobriri,âgt;â^ mdnifefliui ofiendi poteÃ, Nc id quidÃ« prtetcrtbo,lt;Ã^* tdm dffvrdt Ãdem expofitioni ndrrdittis dutorihUif^ mereri debt mui diite omnid c^uidÃ© uitdeed o- ifÃi^^ re ordtioK. C^uod epto fuerit grduius,Ãn(iiut, bof hdbedt neeeÃe eR m dffirmdndo quoq; ponder^. EF giÃ«dd igitur in hdc pneipue pdrte omnii edVUitw^, Ãicio,(neq- enim fe uÃqudeuÃoditmdgis iudex) Â«t^^^ dedturfiaum, nihilfolicitu, omnid potim d etotÃ, f ordtore profeÃ«ld creddnturSed hocpdtinoirpoffitn^^ et perire drtem putamui,nift dppdredt,cum defindif^ eÃe,Ã dppdret.Pendemui ex Idude, dit^ bic hb or is ff firi duemut fummd.ltd quÂ£ circunÃdtibut oÃentdn^^ lumufjudicibui prodimuf.ERci'quiddmrepetiid'^ rdtio,qi{Â£ UMywi^ dicitur,fdnÃ¨resdecldMtoiâ

Wdgk quim foÃ¯cups .Ã¯dco dutem re pcrW,ut 4**'^ WdnriX tiobreuk debet cJ)e,ptpiM er orndtius res po jet expo ni^uodptjudinuidiie grdttdjUcImiferdttonk. Idem rd ro fdeiendum iudico, neq; pc iwqudm, Mt totus ordo re pctdtur;licct enimper partes idem confequi, Cdtcrunt quiutitTriJ'iH^KT'^ uolctjtidrrrtticisrenilocoPrwigdt, er contcrttitÃ³ mdiedre quid fddum.quo ptmodofddÂ», j^j^^jjJqjjJj pleniusfclocojÃ¼ocxpopturÃ¯ttncpepromtttdt. iwitiu/m initium Â«drrdtionk quidam utiq^ fdciendtwndperpndpHtdnf, edmq; p ijoÃrd pt,orndnddm,p dliertd,tnpimdiiddm Ãd-tiwiboc fdnÃ¨ pc quentipimum eft,quid perfonÂ« funt inÂ» ter quds Utigdtur.Sed bÂ« quoq; interim cum fuk decide tibusponendifjCHmidproptturMweft^MtÃ¯ A.Cluemius

i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;bdbitus puit pdter buiupe iudicesjbomo Â«on folum mÂ«-

â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;c Hicinitdtk,uirtute,!Â£pimdtionc,nobilitdte facile prwt

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ccps.lnterimpncbk,ut:CitLigaritMcwHc)fet,rrcqÂ«Ã« pfoLig.

â' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ter ucro er Ã re:pcut pro Tullio, Cicero: Ã¯umdum bd- Pro Cecinna

â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«es pro CteppbontciTS) yj' qxÃ¼KitÃ³ emsav cPÂ©-* â ssoRs

1 /db. Depne narrdtionk own bis contentio eft, qui per-i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;duel expoptionew uolunt eÃ´, unde qudÃio oritur. Hk ) rebus ita geÃk.P.HolobellaPrdtor inferdixit,ut eft co ', fwtudojde ui bominibus drmotispne ttlldcxcrptioe,tdÂ« il â turn ut unde dciecipet,rcjlitueret: deinde repitttiÃe di* t nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;xit,]^onpo foftd eft, bac dcÃjonponc uobk iudiedo-i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;diwneÃ, IdÃpetitorcfemperperipotcPjÃdefenforc ( nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«onfemper,

OR DIN E ip fa nxrrÃ¤tlottcm feijuitur conp'^ ^^ tio.Proiandii fuut enim lt;iug propter ^Â°^^^^ j^ fuimut. Sed prius quÃ¯m ingrediiir hitte mihi de quoru^dim opmione dicendt funt- Pkril^jf'quot; ris eÃ¼, proUto rerun ordmeiprotinus uti^ iÂ» ^^^â?. hetum dtq; pUuÃbilem locum ^udmmcixitne poÃint j uordbiliter excurrerc. c^^od quidem Mtum dh oÃlt;^'^^* tione dccldmdtoridjdm m forum uenitjpoÃtlinit^â^^'^ edufds non dd utilitdtem Utigdtorumffed dd pdtroiilt;^ idddtionem repertum ed:ne ft preffje illi(lt;lttdÃ¯is pP'*^ deÃderdtur) ndrrdtionis grdeiUtdti, comiMdddrÃ¿^'^ tor um pugndcitds fucrit, diUtis diutiuf dieedi uoW^ tibus,ordtio reÃigefedt, in ^uo uitium Ã¯llud efl, fine diÃrmmeedufdrum dtq; utilitdtis, hoc ItdnlÃquot;â' per expedidt,dM etidm neceffefit) fdciunt:eo ^^' fumptds ex his pdrtibus, qudru/tn dliui erdt loens, P^ â' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tentids in hdne congerutu,ut plurimd dut iteru/nt dP^*

dd fint, dut quid dlid dUeno loco diÃd fuut, dicifno tv^ poÃint.Ego dutemfdteor hoe expdtidndi genus,nonto^ do ndrrdtionis fed etidm qudefionibus,uel uniuerfads' interim fingulis opportune poffe fuUungi, cm res pgt; Ãiddt, dut eertÃ¨ permittit: dtq; eo uel mdxme Hbtlirtdi orndri^ ordtionem,fed Ã (ohierct,etfequitur,noft fet vim conetur,Gr qut ndturd iundd erdnt,diÃrdhit, Ni' Inlenim tdm cA confequens,qndrrdtioniprobdtio,c 1^ txcurfut die,uel qudÃ Ãnis ndrrdtionis,uel qudfi mitinni probdtionis efl,Erit ergo ilU nonnunl locus,ut ft expo

fitio circa finem atrox fucritjprofequamur earn, uelut Excurfionit Jpiritu crumpente, protinus indignatione. Qitod tamÃ« ita fieri oportebit, fi res dubitationÃ« nÃ¶ babebit, alioqui prius eft,quodobijciaSjUcrumcfficere,quam magnum, quiacrimmummuidia prorco eftpriufqua probatur. Dijfcilitna eft enim grauifmi cuiufq; fccleris fides. Secundus, idem fieri non inutiliter potcft,uti fi mÃ©rita in aduerfa

Ã¯im Ãqui fxpofum'Ã®jin ingratum wiucbxrw,lt;tut fi UA het item crimmum ndrrdtione demonÃraufrw, quantÂ» ab ca pcheutum mtcntctHr,oÃcÂ«diÂ«. Verum bÂ«c breui ter omnia, ludex enimordme audito fermÃ¢t adproba tionem,o- quamprimum ccrtiwcJprfcntctMiÃ¦cupit. Praterca cauendu cft,nc ipp expo/itio Â»anrfcat,aucr- QuaÂ«us. fis in aliud animiSjCZ inani mora fatigatis. Scd ut nS ejl femperneccjfariapo(l narrationemiUa procurfiojta frequenter utilis ante quxÃionem praparatio. VtiqjJi prima f^ccie minus erit fauorabilis,fi Icgcm afpera tueÂ» biinur,autpocnarias aftionesinferemus, EHbiclccuÂ« uelut fequemis exordij, ad coneiliandum probationibuÂ« no(lris iudiccm,mitigandumconcitandu.Quod liberiut bic,er uebementius fieri poteÃ^quia ludtci caufa iam no ta eft.His igitur uelut foment is Æ quid erit a(pcru,prÂ« woHicmus,quo facilius aurcs iudicum, qux poft difturi erÂ«mÂ»gt;admittant ne tus noftrum oderint.Nibil enim fa tile perfuadetur muitis. Quo loco tarnen iadicis quoq; natuTanofcendatft,iurimagis,anaquofÃ¯t appofituÃ¯.

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Promit enim magis aut minus boe erit nccc(fariÃ¼.Cate Quintus* i Ã¯HTCj eidÃ«^^ poÃ quaftione poratiois uicc fungiturÂ»

ZÃ©o M. FAC. QVINT. INSTIT. nunc pirtem ^{.nSacn/j uocdntGruci jLdtinu^e^' fum,ucl egreÃionem, Sed hie funt plures, ut dixi,lt;{iH per totitm cMfdm udrios hibent excurfui^ut kus boni' num locorum^, ut defcriptio rcgionu,cxpofÃ¼ioa'it:f3 dim rerum non folu geÃurum^Ãd etiAfdhulofdru. OSâ ex genere ell in ordtionibuscoMrd Verremcopojitiit SiciliÃ« litiSjProferpins rdptunpro C. Cornelio pofiii ris iÃ¼d uirtutuCn,Pompeij comcmordtio.ln c^ud illeiÂ»' uinus ordtor,uelut nomine ipfo ducis curfus dicemii ti^ neretur,Alrupto,quÃ« imhoduerdtjÃermone diuertit'A^ tdmen ^iKCKoâ!^ eH (ut med epiidefert opinio) dUenf rei, fed dd utiHtdtem edufe pertinemis, extrd orintf^ excurrens trdHdtio. Qudpropter non uideo, cmbÂ«â^ ei potiÃimu locum dfignÃ«t,qui reru ordmem [eejuiwt) non mugis g iUud, cur hoc itd demu proprium putentj' ali^uid in digreffu Ãt exponendÃ¼, cum tot modis 4 f^' Ho itinere dcclmet ordtio. nX (luiend dicitur^pr^^^^^ las quinc^ (cptds fecimits) pur tes, egreÃio ell, aiH^' tia, miferdtio, inuidid, conuidu ,excufdtio,concili^^ââgt; mdlediHorum rcfutdtio:fmilid his, ^Uit no funt in t^f' ftione,omnis dmplificdtio,minutio, omnediÃaus i^''gt;âh discedmdxime iucunddm e^orndtdm fdeiuntorido^ nem,de luxurid,de dudritid,de rcligione,de officijs,!!!*^ cum fint drgumentif fubicHd fimilium rerum, ^m^^^ herent,egredi non uidentur.Sed plurirndfuntj^if^^^' lus nihil fecum coherentibusinferuntur, c^uHusiui^ reficitur,ddmonetur,pldcdtur,rogdtur,lduddtm-Vgt;gt;d nerdiilid funt hac,quorum dUdfic ut prep^rt^d dp^

ORATOR. LIBER nil. 161 tMiMjqudCcliimexoccctponfjUclcxnccej^ittttedicwniÂ«,^ ^d nobis djcnt ibus noui (iccidit,t-ntf rf eUlt;ttto,ttiterÂ«rn-tus lt;ilicuiiM,tiÂ«nultM$. V nde Ciccroi (juo^ in proamio, cu dicerct pro Milone,digredi fuit nref jjc,Ht ipfiowÂ« tinncuU,qui u/iÂ« eft, pdtet, Potcrit dutcpdttlo longitw exire^ni przpirit ^liquid iwe qult;e|itonem,er qui fini tit probtUioni udwt cowtndiitionÃ« ddijeit, at qui ex me diA frumpitjcito ad id redire debet, iwide diuertit.

S Vut quinarrationipropofitionefubiiwgiWtjtitnÂ« Lib.3,Caâ, quam partem iudiciolis materie, cui opinioni reÃso dmiKS.MiiÃ¯i outem propoÃtio uidetur omnis confirma-tionis initium, quod non modo in oÃendenda quaÃ ione principolijfe d nonnunquS ctiarn in fingulis argumentis proponifolrt,maximeq; in bis, quÂ« tTrixf^K/aKTa uo-cantiir.Sednunc de prioreloquiwur. EanÃ¶ femper uti propoCtiÃ¶i necefje cft. Aliquando enim fine propofitionc Â«liqua fagt; non femper tis quoq^maniffÃucft,quid wi qujeÃionc uerfeturzutiq; 'Â®âââ* fi narratio ibi ÃnembabctjUbiBiitiamquieÃio, adeout aliquondo fubiungatur expoptioni ,quÂ« jokt in argu-mentiscJPefummacoUcflio.Hitcficutcxpoptijitagcpa ProMilont funt indices,inpdiator[uperatus cft,ut uiHituis, ud po p^moÃ®*â tilÂ« oppreÃauirtute audaciaeÃ.Sed nonnunq Â«aide uti f fine lis f ft,Ã§rÂ«cipÂ«c ubi re s defendi non potrÃ,c de iure qutrituTjUt pro eo ,qÂ«i pecuniam priuatam de tempb fuÃidit,facrilcgij agitur. De facrikgio cognofcitur,ut iudex intcUigat, id unum ejje oÃieij jHi,qu(ercrc, an, id, quod obijcitur,|dcrikgitwn fit* Itemincaufis obfeurk

^Terdo. â^ f'fi^^i^P^'^i^Â«^- ^ec femper propter hoc folu/m,utjgt;i eMfd lueidior, fed liliqmndo etidm ut mtga mouat, Houet Mt cmfi protinm fubtexintur diclKit, c^ue fto' fint. Lex dpertefcriptd eR, ut peregr'mn^ tltti wÂ«rwii dfcenderit,mortemuliletur, PeregrmuteelfecerttX^

eR,ciutn dfeenderis murum non (fuxriturttjuid fuptrefi) nifi ut tc puniri oportedtf Ute enim propofitio confiÃ© flauem dduerfdrij premit,o- quodÃ¤mmoio iuiicitÂ»^ mordm toUit, nee mdiedt lt;iufÃionem,[ed ddnutit-Sind dutem propofitiones, er fimpUces er dupUccs,itcl nn^ tiplices. Qt^od dcciditnon unomodo : ndm Ã¼' f^^^ lt;nbsp;â¢ :..' \, ur, utcumSOCKAT^Sdccul^uf eÃ¼, lt;^uod corrumperet iuuentutem, er noud^ fuper^'' ttones inducerct. Etfnguld ex pluribus coÃ¯Uguni^' ut cum legdtio mdle geÃd obijcitur Aefchim, tpioiiquot;^ titus fit, quad nihil ex mdnddtis fecerit, quad mofd^^ fit,quod munerd dccepcrit^ Keeufdtio quoq; plurci^ rim propofitiones hdbet,ut contrd petitionempetuwf' Hdlepetis, procurdtorienim tibi effe nonUcuit-r^ nee iÃ¼i, cuius nomine litigM, hdbere proeurdweto-fed ncq; es bares dus, d quo deeepiffc mutuu Hcor, Â«'* ipfidebui. MultipUcdri hadnqudntimlibctpofw^i fed rem ofiendijfe fdtis eÃ¯l. HiC fi pondntur fnÃ¿d^r iedis probdtionibus, plures erunt propofttioiKt' f coniungdntur, in pdrtitionem cddunt. ill lt;3quot;^^ Gdwo P^Â°PÂ°fi^^Â°^âi'*^^f^^ ^ conieÂ£lurdlibuS)Clt;ciif^iâââ.

furtumobijcio. LÃrdtione fubie{id,utmdieÃdteiÂ»'lt;^ nuit Cdius ÃorncUus^ndm codieem T:ril?mKfp^^^'^'^gt;â

ORATOR. LlBtR HU. ^^5 fTOconcione kgit. Prater bocutimur propofitionc, Â«ut noÃrÂ«,ut Â«dultcÃ¯ium objeio: dut dduerprij, ut Â«dulterij meem d^tur : Â«ut communi, ut inter me er Â«duerfarim qudtÃio cft,utcr fit intefuto fropior. Nonnunqudm diuerfu quoqjconiungmuÃ¯Â« Ego quo^j ^^^^^^^ boe dico^duerfurius boe. Habet interim uim propof-tionis/tidmfiper pnoneflpropofitio,cumcxpofito rerumordinefubijeimuj: Debts cognofcitis,utfitblt;Â«c commonitio tMdtcis,qÂ«o fc ad quafionem acrius witcn* dit, O' quodamudut iaftuexcitatus fnem c(fe narrd* tioniSjO initiumprobationts inteUigdt, er nobis conÂ» Jirmdtionem ingredientibus ,tpfc quoq; quodammodo nouiwn dudicudi fumÃ¢t exordium.

PARTIT 10 eft noÃrdruWjdut dduerfarij propofi pj^^jfÃ¦nÃ§ tionum,dHt utrdrumqjordine colldtdcnwmerdtio. neqifcmper HacquiddUtendu femper pwtdut, quod er â¢ââ fÃ¯^t Â«^'â¦flt;âul^ndum^ lucidior, o iudex intentior de docilior,fi feier it er de quo dietMius,er de quo difturi poÃeu fumus .Rur fus qui dam pcrieulofum id ordtori drbitrdntur duabus ex cdÂ» fis,quod nonnunquarn excidcre folednt quÂ« promifi* mus,er fl qud in pdrtiendo prxtcricrimus,occurrere.

Quod quide ne mini dccidct,nifi qui plane uel nuUo fue-, Titmgemo ,ucldddgcndÃ¼nibilcogitdti prxmeditati^ detulerit. AlioquiqudctdmmdnifeÃderluciddfunt,q rdtioreftÂ«partitionist Sequitur mim ndturdm dueem, ddeo ut memovix id mAximum fit duxiliwn, uid dicendi

Ã®Â«4 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT* non decedere. Ciudpropter nciUos quidemproidHf^ rim,ciuipirtitione uetM ultnl treis propoÃtiona c^' tendere.Qt^Â£Ãncdubio multiplexfugictmemoriiiiÂ«^ dicis, c^ turbdbit intcntionetn.lioc tÃ¤menntMero,!^ lut lege,non e^l dHigdndd, cum poÃit eÃ¤uÃu pluris i^r demre. Ahd funt tmgis, propter lt;IUÂ£ pdrtitioni'*^^ Prima eaufa Ã^tfip^f lt;^^ utendum.'Pr'mu,lt;^uid plerdq; griitioÃ¯i^''ââ non utendi Ã muentd fubitÃ³, nee domo dllitd, fed inter diuiiÂ»Â»^ partiiionis. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;-^^ ^^^^ uideMtur, umde iUd non midcunid f^^

tdiPenÃ¨ cxcidit mihi, zy,fugerdt me, V, redti^^'^^' nes. Propofitis enim probdtionibuf,omnisin rclilt;l'âââ^ grdtidnouitdtisprlt;ecerpitur. interim ucrofillÃ©ilt;lt;^â iudex, er udrijs drtibus fubewndus, ut dhui dgi,lt;Ã¿y quod petmus, putett Ã¯^dm eÃ nonnunq durd pf^P^r tio, qudm iudex, ft prouidet,non dliter prgformiM. qui ferrum medici, prins qudm curetur, dÃpexitt ' re non date propofitdfecuru/in, de nuÃ¼d denumci^^^ in fe conuerfum intrdrit ordtio, effeiet O,uod P^^quot;^^, .^ ti non crederetur * Interim refugiendd non ^^^^^ Ãmilioqu^Ãionumes^ffedomnino trdÃ¼dtio : ^IÃ * bits perturbdndus, er db intentione duferedus duidO' NoÂ» enm fol-vm ordtoris cd docere,/ed pbu ^^i^. tid dredmouendum udlet.Cui rei contrdrid ^^quot;^^L. tenuls itld,er fcrupulofÃ¨ in pdrtes fe(heiiiiipâ^ ^^ gentid,eo tÃ«pore,quocognofcendiiudiciueondnn*i _^ ferre.Quid,qdâ interim,qua per fe leuidfuntitJâ^r^ md,turbd uilentfldeo^cogerendd lut eruptione pugnt^du : quad tdmÃª

Oquot; ex necefitate demwm,cum ipfumboc, quod difimili rationc cft,coÃ«gerit ratio. Prater bac in omni partitionâ'Â®â**' Â«e eft utique aliquid potentiÃimwm, quod cum audiuit iudex,calera tanquamfuperuaciw grauarifoktjtaque fi plura,uel obijcicndafunt,uel diluenda, er utilw,Â©- ia cimda partitio cft,ut quod quaque de re difturi furnus, QuÃ¼do par* ordme appareat. Atfi imÃ¼ crime uariÃ¨ dcfcnderimiw, r*^Â° ftâ^'^â

quem tue or, ut m co creditik utclcrt poj?it bomictdium: diciimoccidcndi edupunbuienott fwijjÃ¨ : dicdmbiwc co tempore,quobomo occifw cp,trains mire /MiÃc.ommA quÃ¦ dutcqium id ^uod ultimum eft^xequdTbjmiiui ui deri neccÃe eft. PeÃmit enim index id id quod potenÂ» tiÃimum eft, ty uelut obligitum promiÃb pitronum, ft ep f iticiitior,ticitiw ippeUitifi uel occupatiM,uclin dit qiu poteÃite,Mcl etiim ft moribm mcompofiti^jcum co uiciocf)llt;igitit.ltlt;iq;nort defucrunt,qui Cicerone ilUm Cicerono* pro Cluentio pirtitionem improbirent, qua fc diftuÂ» tiweÂ» rum eÃe promifit Â»Primurn,nemmem miioribiM crimmi

' biÂ«,grituioribm tcÃib!M,wi iudicium uocitu, quÃm Opi 4nicum;deiÂ«de,prlt;Â«iudici* eÃe fafta ibbifipfis iudiciÂ» '1 bWjiquibiM condemnitm fit.PoÃrcmo,tudicium pecuÂ»

\ niinon tcutitum Ã Cluentio,fed coirtra ClucnttM.Quia ft probari poÃet,quod eÃ tertitÂ«n,nibil necefje fucrit di

\Â«rc priori-Kurfm nemo erit tam aat toiujÃ¯w .aut ÃuU tut, quin eu fateatur optime pro Murena eÃe partit ut Ã®nteUigoindicÃ©s trestotiaÂ« aeeufationtÃ® partes fuifje, lt;7 carumunamin reprebenfone aitÂ«, alteram in congt; R S

i66 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTI'^' Æ tentione dignitatis ftertiam in ernnmibus ^^ t^f partir^fioc CT nihil fecit aUero fuperuacuwn.'Deilloqaoi'''^r!f, cidi refte fe neredefenfonispleriquedubitant:Siocciii,f^^^.\^ ci, fed non â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nr

ocejdj. ^hpd non occidi : quo enm print pcrttner(gt;lgt; quens firmum fitfhitcinuicemobfiarejCrUt^f. tentibutin tteutro haberi Ãdem.CluoiPâ^^, jij uerum ell, er iUo fequenti ( ft modo mdubitabn^i ^^ folo utendum : at ft quid in eo, quod eilfartififÂ»^ imiit, utraqueprobationenitemur.Aliutenitni^^ ueri folet, er qui fadumputauit, iuftnmereilte, ted, qui tanquam iufto non mouebitur Jadam fe non credct. Vt certa manus uno telo pallet eff^^ tenta,mcerttepluiM Ifargenda ftvnt,ut fittjfllf ne loeutt EgregiÃ¨uero Cicero pro UiHoneM' ' torem prime Clodium ofendit, tim addit tt ââ^'** ianti,etiam ft id non fuiIfet ,talcm tarnen Ã***â?

[umma, uirtute mterf^cÃ¢orK er gloria ncciiri pÂ«*'' fe, Nf^we iUum tarnen ordmenttdet^uo print HA^^ nauerm, quid (padam, er Ã ipfa fimt dura, if Â«^ 'ââ men Mlent, ut ea moUilt;int,lt;juxfe^uuntur. wolt;^ no fine ratione eRid ^quodu/nigo dicitur: vd^ petendu/nt, ut tequum feras. Quad tarnen nemo }ai^ _ cipiat, Ut omnia credataudendat Kedi enim amp;(' priecipitmt, nontentanda qunefficiomnmo wof^ flinty Scd quotieshac, de qua loquor, dupUci itfuf one utemur, id laborandum e{l,utin iUam partonic quentem fies ex priore ducatur Â» foted enm Â»ii^

Ã¯i)C|uitutÃ³ etUm confeÃuriM fwit.meiuiertdt caw/dtn 'm negindo nonbibcrc. Et iUud Â«tique pciendum eft, Â«t quotics ful^icdbwnur Ã iudice aliim probitionem do fideriri,quim de qwloqujmur ,promittlt;ttsiw nos pleÂ» nÃ¨ ,er (lutim de co futw eÃe fafturos, prÃ¦cipuÃ©que fi de pudoredgitur. frequenter intern dceidit,ut cuu# fd piriwi Â«crccwidd, iure tutu fit, de quo ne muiti iÂ«* dices iiÂ«diilt;i^, q- dducrfi,frequentius funt ddmonen* di, fecuturdm defcnfioncm probitutis dc dignitdtis , expeftent pdul iw^cr dgi ordme finditt. Qttfddm mte rbn nos,er tnuitislitigitoribtÂ« fimuUndum eft diccre. Qttod Cicero pro Cluentio facit cired iudicidriimleÂ« gcm.NonniMtqudmqiwft mterpeUemur dbbis fubfiÃeÂ« fruftintre re.Sdpe dduertendd dd ipfos ordtio. Hort and tut finÃt nos Â«tinoÃroconfilio. ltd furrepetur dnimo iudicis,er duin j^rdt probdtionem pudoris,d(^cr ioribiw illis mi*

or, cired modeftidw iuris probdtione prodiuior. Sed ut Partitionis ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;non femper nece(fdrid,dc etidm fuperudeud pdrtitio eÃ, 'â^âw.

tie confert. Heque eniw id folum eÃiett, ut cldriord pint que dicuntur Â»rebus uclut ex turbd extraftis, er ? in conÃicftw iudieuw pofitis, fed reÃeit quoque dudiÂ» . entern certo pnguldruw pdrtiuwÃneÂ» non dUter qudm 1 fdcientibus iter, wultm detrubunt fdtigdtionis noo

Nota, ^''^fortiia exequendd/cire qMMu ÆMp^ârÆ^^N^Ã3^i fÂ«â longwm uidtri necefje eÃ¼, inquo quid ultimum fit,Ã tuvÂ» dl. liÃ©e immtr ito multum ex dUigentiti f^^^^â\ tuUtUudit QÃ¿intut UortenfiuiyCuim tdmÃ«diitifioii in digitot diduilum,nonnunqM,m Cicero leuitcr fw* ' In diu^ado ^^'^â ^^ â^^^^ ^â^ modut, O' eftitdudd mdxlmeco^,^ ne. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fd ntmiurnjO uelut drticulofd pdrtitio.Ã¯Jdm O Â«(Â«f^

tdti plurmum detrdhunt mmutd iÃ¼d, nee idm fed fruftd, EthuiMgloridecupidi^quofubtilituG' piofiui diuifilJe uidedneur^o fuperudcud dlfumu/nb qux ndturdftnguldrid fwnt,fecdnt^nec tdm plurii^ â qudm minor d. Deinde emn fecertwt mille pdrticul^gt; edndem meidunt obfcuritdtem, contrd quimpdtWfââ\ fEt diuifa uentd e^. Diuifio^o Ãmplex propofitio,quotierâ*â^â liter ddhiberi potcÃ¼,primuin debet effe dpertd cidd.Ã¯Jdm quid fit turpiui, qudm id effe obfeuruifr^ quod m eum fiolum ddhibetur u[um,ne fint edteÃ¯d o^C rd^Tum breuK,nec uUo [uperuieuo onerdtd ueÃ¯bgt;â enm quid diedmuf, fed de quo dilluri firnut oficnili^' Qbtmendum etidm ne quid in ed defijt, ne quUfo^^i^ Partitio dl' Superefi dute fic ferÃ¨^cuM dut mfpedes pdrtinltt,^ fffÂ®âââ jjj generd pdrtiri fit fdtis, dut genere pofito Ã^^^^^

Ipeties:ut,fi diedm de uirtute, iufiitid, contmentii, r ^Partitio uirtutisfunt^ecies. FdrtitioproponitjquHÃ^^^^.^ q^T '^ conuenidt,quid de quo dmligdtur. in eo quoi cotiUlt;^:^ quid dduerfidriusfdtedturtquidnos.ln code quo

ORATORÂ» LIBER V. 2^9 gÃ®tÂ«r,qtt Æ iidun ÃnitK,^ue noÃrie propoÃtiones, c[UÂ£ pirtis Aiucrfx. 'TurpiÃimvmtKro^non codemmime exquij^MO ^Mtc^Mc propoÃuerk^

V E R V N T er cUri (piiddm dtH torts, iluibusfolum idderttur Ord torisoÃÃciwm,doccrc. Niinquecr 1 dfÃ;diK dupUci rdtione excludeÂ«Â» I doe putdidnt Â« PrimâwÂ«,quid uitiu J effet omnk dnimi perturhdtio: de^ inde, quid iudieÃ« d Ueritdte depe^ mifericordidjuel ird, âââtfimilibue non oporteret,cr ttoluptdtcm dudientium ^f^^ytwmumcendi tdntwm gnÃ¼id diceretur,ânon mo'Â»' Â° 'â?''Â«i fupenwcuum/ed Â«ix etiam uiro dignwm drU dutur, Flures Â«ero,qui Â«cc dl iUk fine dubio pdrti* *ââ*tionctB ofundi fulmouerwit,loc tdmen proprimn * J f''â Â«cipuum eredereM opw^M conÃrmdxttty ffÃ^

270 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT* ex aduerfo proponerentur^refutdre. VtrwKU^ (neq; enim hoc loco medm mterpono fcntÃªtidtn) hic^â^ liber illoru opinionc ntdximenecejjdriuf, (^uo totobii fold trdih!uttur,quibm fanÃ¨ct ed.quf de iudiddUbi^ ^^^ fis idm diHd fwnt,feruiiMt. lidm neque proamij, ntlt;llt;*â ndrrdtionis ell dliits ufas, qudmut iudicemprfp^^^'^' Et Ãdtui noffe, dtque ed, de quihui fuprd ÃripÃmu^i'^ tuerifupertuctmm foret,niÃ dd hdne perueniremui-^ nique ex qumque,qult;is iudicidlis mdterif Ãctmuijl^f^ tib'M,quecimque alid poteH dliqudndo neceffirii cdiiif non clfe,Ã¯is nulU eÃ¼ : cui probdtione oput non fit Â« Elt;i* prdceptd fic optmediuifuriuidemur, ut prim ^*^^'^ commune dd oÃªs quitÃiones pertinent, o^Ãªddtnitf,^^*^ de qut in quoc^ edufe genere proprid fint,exeqMÂ»^^'^' Ac prmd quidemilld pdrtitiodb Arifoteletrdiit^l'â'^ fenfum ferÃ¨ omnium merMt,aiiM ejjeprobdtiones,q'gt;^ extrd dicendi rdtionem dccipcret ordtor, dlidt, ^^ cdufd trdheret ipfc,^ quodimodo gigneret,lico^gt;â^ 1Â« oLTiX.v'ii^Jd ell,mdrtificidles,hds t^riXil^/^^^ drtifiddles uoeduerut. Ex iÃ¼o priore genere fu/ntff^^ â iudicid,rumores,tormentd, tdbule, iufiurdndu/mfK' In quibus pdrs mdximd contentionum forenfiu^^^^e flit. Sed ut ipfd edrew drte, itd furnmis eloquentii lt;*^''** buSjty dUeuindd funt plerimquc,zy'refeÃ¼endd.QÃ¯'^ mhi uidentur mdgnopere damnandi, qui totum beci^ nut d prÂ£ceptis remoueruntt tgt;lectdmenmdÂ«'Mi0â^ omnid, qux dut pro his, dut contrd dici filent,coiv^â* di: NoÂ« tnim tomunef locos trddtrf defii/nan^ gt;nbsp;Ãââ*

GKATOK. LIBER V. 171 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«

fJJet offris BilwitQed Mlm qiMndctnijdt^urrdtioncm.'''â''â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1

Quibus df monÃratw, non modo inexc^uÃ«do/Â«lt;Â« 4ââP que uires debet udbibere, fed etidm inueniendo fjmilÃ¯dj Mt quieque conditio lit iurn fofcet. Neque enim de omni* bus ciufis dieere quifqwm fotcH, pltem frxteritis, UÃ ticfumde futur is.

TAm prxiudiciorum Â«is omnis tribus in gencribus .Â«erf((tÂ«r;rfbÂ«s,qttx uliquando exp Â«tribus edups funt iÂ»diclt;(tx, qÂ»x cxempld reftius dicuntur, ut de refci^is p(ttrumte(l(tmerHis,HelconSrd^liosconJÃ¯nÂ«lt;ttis : iÂ«di* cijs, Â«ld ippm edufum pertinent ibÂ«s, unde etium rtomett duftwin eft ,qÂ«ilid in Opidniem fi^i dicuntur, er 4 fendtÂ« dduerfus Milonem: dut euro de eddem edufd pro nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â\.

ritdte eoruw qui pronuntiduerunt, er pmilitudine reÂ» ruw,de quibus qUicritur.RefcHuntur dutÃ« rdro per ton tumclidm iudicum,nip forte mdnifeÃd inbis culpd crit. Vult enim cogno/ceÂ«tittwquif$ firmdmcjfedlterius fen tentidm, er ipfe pronuntidtHrÂ«s,exfmpliMnnottlibcn* ttr,quoJin fcfortdjfereciddt,facit.Confugiendum er go eji in duobus fupf rioribus, ft res ferct/d dliqud dij?t

ftmilis.Si id non contiÂ«gct,dc eddem edufd erit,dut dito ru 'meufandd negligÃ¨tid, dUt dc infirmitate perfondru defoÃ¯rtiiÂ»

â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;quxrfndwm, Â«mra quas crit iudic4twÂ»,4ut de jrdtid/â

^MX tejics corruperit,Mt de muidiÃ¤^Ã¤ut de iÃ¿iordittii, aut mueniÃ¨dum quid cMfÂ£ poften decefferit, Quontid fi nihil eritjicettiunen diceremultM iudiciorwn eMidSt ad inique pronuiitUndum tulereAdeoqi ddmnitiM Rquot; tilium,ib(olutosClodi'MÂ» dtque Cdtilindin.'R.ogdniiii^ dm indices,ut rem potim intuedntur ipfdm, qu^ iurdndo dlieno,fuum donent. Aduerfut confultd did^

1 fcnitus,O' deerctd principu/myUelmdgijlrdtuum,^^â'^ dium nuUum eR,nifi dut inuentd quintulictwqfi'^â^^y fciufdem diffvrentid,dut dUqud uel eortmdem potefidtis pofleriorcoflitutio,qult;e fit priori contrdrid'.qn^p^ ( nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ru'nt,lis noncrit.

J/tdtis,er uelutpublicumteflimoniMUoedtfd fiermonem fine uUo eer to dutore dijficr[um,cui iquot;^^ .â tM mitium dedcrit^mcrementum credulitdt, qd^\ . non etidm innocentiÃimo pofiedeciderefidude (Â»lt; ru/mfdlfid uulgdutium. Uxempld utrinq^ non d(etgt;*'^' '

DeTormentis. CAP. BH. x Siewt in tormentis quoque,qui eR locutfit^^'^'^^ muSyCum pdrs dlterd qunfiionem, uerdfidif^^ ',^ ceÃitdtemuocet, dlterd fiape etidm cdufdmfdlfidn quad dlijs pdtientid fiddle menddeium fidcidt, dliji mitds necefifidriu. Quid dttmet plurd dehis^ ^^^quot;I^j^ ordtiones uetcrum,dc nouorum.Quieddintdinen^ ; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;pdrteerivntpropridcuiufiquelitis.Ndmfiut^ f

poÃuletjdut o^ritjOquot; âm quoÂ»,er ex qÂ«lt;t Ã§lt;tHflt;i:pHe tX ent bdbitd^wii ei prÂ«fMcrit,qÂ«k, er quomodo pt tor-tiM,4tt credibiliit dixcrit, dn inter fe conjlintid, ^feuerd

uerit in eo quod cape rit,dn dliqd dolore mutduert t,pri md pdrte qw^Pienw, dn procedente crucidtu, quÂ« u* trmq; tdm in/initd/unt, qip/drertnn udrictdÂ«.

CONtrdtdbuUquoqj (Â«epe diftuwi,fjepe dieÃ«dtm eft Æ um ed5 non folum refe^i, fed etidm deeuÃrf, fcidmm elle ujÃ¯tdtuw.Ciwn ft dutem in bw dut fctluifÃ¯' gttdtoruÂ»i,dut ignordntidjtutiw de fdcitiiÂ« id,quod fc-eudo loco dixÂ«nHlt;,trdÃ³ldtur,quod pilicet pduciorej rei funt.Sed boe ipfutn drgtwnentd ex edufd trdbit, f forte dut incre dibile eftjid dÃ¤um eJJÃ¨,quod tdbulÂ« continet, dut (ut frequenttus cuenit) dlijs probdtionibut Â«que m-drtifcidlibu! foluitur,/Â« dut M,in quem fgndtm cjt,dut dUquwfigndtor dicitur alfuiffe ,uel print eÃe dcfwngt; ftu!,fi tempord non congruwnt, f ucl dnfeeedentid, uct infequentid tdbuliÃ¯ repugndnt.Inj^cdio ipfd frpe etidm fdlfum deprebendit.

* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1 Ã¯ccipiunt obUtum,dut db dduerfdrio exigunt/ut re ii nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cufdntcumdbipfÃ¯cxtgdtur.OÃÃ¨rrefuufine indcott ulla 1* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ditione,utddutrfdriu{ furet, fcrÃ¨wnprobwineft. Qui i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tarnen id fdcict,dHt uitd JÃ¨ tuebitur,ut eu non ft credibi |I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;le peierdturSjdut ipp ui religionw. In qud er plus fdei Â»â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;confequetur Â»f id egerit, ut non cupide dd boe defeew

* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;S

Â»74 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlTÂ» dfre, fei ne hoc fluidem feeuffreuidaturt MtÃc^l^^ modo pitiitur litis, propter lt;lMm deuoturus fe ip[âgt;'ââ filer it, dut fi prÃªter dUd edufe infirumentd, diijÃ¢i fX dbunddntihdne eptof^ confcientiie fux fidutidm.ClÃ¿gt;^ recipiet inifpam conditionem,(y Ã multis contemni in^ rifiurdndi metum dieet. CÂ«wi etidm plnlofophi fpiH^'^ fint reperti, epd deos hebere rerum humdndru/m cut^^ negdrent. Euw uero qui nuUo ofiÃ¨rente iurdrefit pitti tuSyZy fiipfimi ueUe de edufd fM pronwneidre, (:rqK^â^^ id quoi ofiirt leue defdeile creddty ofiendere. At is ^i** defert,dgcre modefie uidetur, cum litis dduerfirhivi iÂ« dicemfdeidt, cf eu/m, cuiut cognitio est, onere Hiettit qui profeÃ¼o dUeno iureiurdnio fidri qu'dm fiioindii'â^'igt; quo difficUior reeufdtio cA,nifi forte res eA ed,qM ^â dibile fit notdm ipfi non ejfe. Qji^ excufdtio fi ieerih hocuntt rdinqueturjUt inuididfibi qu^ri db dÃiietfi'^^ diedt, dtep id dgi, ut m edufd, m qud uitteere non pof'^ queri pofit, Itd^ hominem quidem mdum occupÃ¤lt;*^^ hdncconditionÃ¨fuilfe,fedutemprobdremdUe,qMV met,qudm dubium cuiqudm relinquere,dn peierdrit- ^^ nabis ddolefcentibus fenioresmdgendo fddipneif^' re folebdnt, ne unqudm iufiurdndum deferremus ,fiâ^ necoptioiudicis dduerfdrioeffet permittenddfnedâi dduoedtis pdrtis dduerfit iudex eUgendus. iidmfiiist^ re contrdrid turpe dduoedto uidedtur, eertÃ¨ turpii^i^ bendum,fdcerequod nocedt^

ipfd pfrfond, mfdwdre figndtorcj licet. Tdcitd prxto redepuddm fignijÃ®cdtionf rfÆrdgdMtur b is omnibus j^dâ MÃ©mo per tdtuUddt tfÃiwoniiMnjWifi fui iwluntdtc: quo ipfo non rJJÃ¨ dmiciwn ei fc,contrd quem dicit, fdte* tur. Nec Urnen protbtw cedent ordtor, quo mmiM cr dmicus prodmicojCr mimicut conard mimicianpoj?it Â«ernÂ«t(fi intÃ©gra pt ei Ãdes)dicere. Sed UtÃ¨ locm Â«ter* que trdibdtur, Cum priefemibiM uero ingens dimiedtio efludeo^ uelut duplici contra eoÃ® ,pro^bw deie con^i gitur diSionum C7 mterrogationum. 1Â» aftionibtw pri*

â¢ mwi generdliter pro teÃibus, dtq; iw teÃej dici foict. Eft bic commimK locus, cum pdrs diterd nulUm Jirmio rem probdtionem c^fe cowtedit.qudm quÂ« Jitbominum feientid nixdt dltcrd dd detrabendam iÃÂ» ^dcm,omnid, per qua Ãeri (olediit fdlfd teji imonid/numerdt.Sequenj rdtio cft,cÂ«m (pecidUter quidem,fcd tarnen multos pari ter iwudderr patroni folcnt. Nam cr gentium fimul uni

' uerfarum cleuata teÃtwonia ab ordtonbus fcimÂ«Ã®,cr to â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ta genera teÃimoniorum, ut de auditionibtÂ«, non enw

: nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ip^seÃc teÃesjfed wiiurdtortwn aÃerre uoeestutin edit

â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fis TepctuÂ«ddrum,qMi fe reo numeraÃe peeuwias jurat,

t nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;litigdtOTumnontcÃiumbabendosloco.Interimadurr* xaioinfiw

futfingulosdirigitur aftio. QÂ»od In/eftationis genus, guios. ft P'rinixiudefenponilcgimus in orationibus plurimwÂ»

â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Si

17Â« M. FAB. oyiNT. INSTIL, er fepdrAtm cditum,Ãcut 'm VAtmium teÃen gt;nbsp;â*'â igitur excutiAmut locwm,i^Mndo imiuerfAtn 'tÂ«p^^ * Domitn A' nein AggreÃifumuf^SuffideiAnt AVoc^ui libri duo A1^ fri libri. mitio AÃo'mhAncremcotnpoÃti,^ucmAdolefc('^^ fenem coluil ut non leÃA mihi tAntum cAjed pl(tAlt;^ ipfo Ãnt cognitAt Is ucriÃime prÂ£cipit, priwtifo t^ ' hAc pArte officium orAtoris,ut tot Am cAufion fAmiH^^^ ter norit:quodÃnedubio Ad omniA pert'met.ld c[A0igt;ilt;gt;^ do cot'mgAt,explicAbimut,cum Ad deÃ'tnAtum huiepAf^ ti locu/m uencrimâM. Elt;t resfuggeret mAteriAm gAtioni^cr ueluti telA Ad mAnum fulm'miÃiAbit- E^dc docebit^d (fUit iudicis Animus udionefit prÂ£pArAnd^â riebet enm uel fieri, uel detrAhi teÃibus ÃdesorAtioiX perpetuA, quid Ãc quifquc didiis mouetur, uteHAd a^f Teftia duo ^â^^^â'^gt; ââ^^ ââââ credendum ante formutut Â« Et lt;p*o^^* genera. nbsp;nbsp;Am duo gener A funt teÃium^Aut uoiuntAriorum,AUt f^

rum quibus iudex in publicis iudicijs lege denumciArd let,quorum dtero utraq; pArs utitur, Alterum Actufii'^ ribus tAntum conceffum eR, fepAremus officiu/m d^fi teftisbiter^ tcÃ^A,(:tr refeUentis. Quiuolumtdriumprodtuit,l^^ rogandi ra' quid is diHurus fit,poteÃ¼: ideoc^ fAciliorem ^^ *'Â°' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;rogAndo hAbere rAtionem.Sed hiec quo^ pArs acÂ»Â«^^ â

Gr uigildntiAm pofitiprouidÃªdum^ ne timide,t^^^* timpudicus confias,ne imprudensfit tefiis. TurbAMur cniw,(7^ pAtronis diuerfepArtis 'mducutur âm Idqueum.'Sedp Â«^ deprehenÃ noceitt,quÃm firmi er 'mterriti profriffn^' Hult urn igitur domi Anteuer fundi, AeuAr^Apwlt;gt;^ tionibus, quaks hAberi db AduerfArio poffunt/^S^^

di [iwt.Sic Jit,Mt (tut conjiciM fÃ©^dut Ji ^d titubdMerintÂ» opportiwi Ã¯MÃ¯fiM cim, 4 quo produÃ³ti fiMit/witcrrogd tioncjuclut in gr/dum rcponumur.ln bis qÂ»o^ ddbuc, qui conÃitcrmt fibi,uitMdÂ£funt inlÃ¯Hi: mmJrequenÂ» ter fwbijci Ã ddMcrprio folcitf,cr omniAfrofutuU pol liciti diÂ«f rfu re^oÂ»dÂ«(,o- Â«tutor ititonbibent non dr joentim ilUJed coti/jtewiiiw .Explordndrnnigitur, quÂ« eÃ¤u/iÂ« Udfndi dduerfdrimn i^nM : nee id fHK eftjinimicosfuij/ejed dn deperintjdn per boe ipfuW re eoitcilidri ueIiHt,ne corrupt! put, ne pÅniteniidpropo Jitu mutduerint.Quod cum inbis quoÃ§^, qui cd,quÂ« di* duri uideNtMr,rc uerd fciun t, nceejjuriwm eft prlt;ecduc re,tu multo mdgis inbis, qui fe diduros quÃ¦ fulp funt, poniefutur-Ndm er frequeutior eoriwn pÅnitentid cÃ, er promi'^m pj^fdiiW,cr JÃ¯ perfcutrducriÂ«t, repre rÂ«fponÃ¼o benfio fdcilior.Eortnn ucro,quitus denucidtur, pdri te ^âquot;quot;^^ Ãium eft,quÂ« reukdere Uflit,pdrs quÂ« nolit. idij intc di forma. Tim feit deeufdtorfmtermt ncfcit,ftngimus in pnefenfid fcire,mtttro^ entjngencre fummis drtibiMWiterrogl âÂ®quot;''â* tis opus eft-.Â»dm ft bubet teÃem cupidum Udendi^dueÂ» re debet boe ipfum,nc cupiditÃ© cius dppdredt: nee ÃdÂ» tm de eo quod in iudicium Mcnit,rogdrc,fcd dliquo cirÂ» cuitu dd id peruenirCjUt illi,quod mdxme dicere uoluÂ» itgt;uiiedturexprc(J[Mn.Nec nHMiumÃdre interrogdtio# ni,nt di omnidrejpondendo teÃis Ãde fudm miÂ«u4t,fcd in tintiwneuocdrc euw^quAtum fumer e ex uno fdtisfit. At in eo, qui ucriwn inuittw diÃ³lurus eft, primd fclieitdÂ« WtcÃ¯Togitw eft/xtorquere,quod K noluerit. Hoc non

Ã lio modo fieri patelle ^Â»4w longÃM mtemgdtione ft petitd. Keffondebit enim ^ug nocere eduft non irlM HMrÃx plurihm dc'mdc,quÂ£ confeffm criheo ftritict tur^uti^uod dicere non wilt, negdrenonpoÃiti Mimit W ordtioneffdrfd fikrtvnij^ coUigimw drgttmenti, ft per fc nihil reum dggrdMre uidedntur, congregdtiont deinde eorimfddum conuincitnut, ÃA huiufmodi tefii multd de Anteddk, multd de infecutis, loco, temport, perfonA,cÂ£terifque eR mterrogAndw ,utm lt;Ã¼ifoi ft ffonfum meiddt, po A quod illi ud fAteri quÂ£ wlitmin necefJeÃt,uelhif,qult;eiAmdixerAt,repugnAreAdfinoigt; contmgit,rcliqwtmerit, uteu/m noUedicere mimft Ãum fit, protrAhendÃ¼fqueutmaliquo,uelextrici''â^ fdm deprehatdAtur,Tenendw etidm diutiw,ut omniigt; AC pluvA quÃm res deÃderdt pro reo dicendo, fujftilâgt;^ iudici fidt,quo non minus nocebit,qudmÃ uen in ftit^ dixiÃet. AtÃ( quad fecundo loco diximus ) ntfeittif (lor, quid propoÃti teflis Attulerit, pduldtim,cr,ni â'â,* citur,pedetcntim mterrogdndo experietur dnimtiw^^* us,crAd id reffonfum quad eliciendum erit, per f^* dus ducett Sed quid nonnunqudm funt hlt;e quoque tv KW Artes,ut primo dd uolumtdtem reffondeM, iore fide dinerfd pofied diednt, eSl orAtoris,fuff^^'^ 1 teflem dom prodek, dimittere. Pdtronorom in P^^ Deftnforis expeditior,in pdrte diffidUor mterrogdtio tfi^r Â«rrogan'do. Â®â' ^âââ^â ^*^ ^â^^^ tvnqMm poffunt Ante iaditii^ f^^

eft,curd er m^uifitione opw eft,Ã§tis reu premdt,q:uÃ® er quillÂ« ex ciuÃs mmiicitiiM bilcdt, cd^ in ordtione t)TÂ«(licen(iddtq;dmolicncldfuÂ«t,fiÂ«codioconfldtojtcÂ» nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.

0Â«,fittemuidid JiuegMtidjpuepecunidutcioâiuoltt* ce.ipÃ¯uÂ«o. niw.Et fi dejicictur numero pin diiicÃ¯fd,pducitdtcm;fi 4lHddlit,con^)trdtionÃ©:fibHmtlesproducet,utiIitdtfnj: fi potÃ«tes,grdtidm oportebit iwccjjÃ¨rc.PliÂ« tdinÃ« prode rit edttfitt, propter qwÂ« reS UdSt, exponere: qui: Æwit Writ,et pro conditione cuittjqilitw,dMt litigdtorÂ«.Nd eontrd iIld,qMie fuprd diximiM ,fimili rdtionc rej^onderi loeit commimibiM folct^quid et m pducis,dtq^ buniilibiÂ« dccufdtorpmplicitdtegloridri poteft, quid neminem, prÃªter eos quos putdrit [cire, qudperit, er multos dt ^.^â^ po^'âÃ¯ que bone^os commÃ«ddre dliqiidiido cH fdciliiÂ«. Verum interim er finguloÃ¯,tttexorndrc,itd deÃruere con* tingit, dut recitdtij in dftionc, dut nomindtÂ« tcÃibiÂ«, QijodbKtcmporibiM,quibtÂ«teÃKnonnip poft Ãni* tittdflione$rogdbdtur,cr fdcilitÂ« erfrcquentiiÂ« fttit. Quid dtttem in quenque teÃium dicendum fit, fuminiÃ db ipforum perfonk non poteft.Reliquie interrogdndÂ« funt pdrtes,qiid in re primum eft nouÃ© teÃem: Â«dm timi dtÂ«terrcri,(iultiM decipi,trdciMidiM cortcitdri,dmbitio fw inÃdri,longiM protrdbi poteft. Prudens nero er co Ãis.ucltdnquAminittiiciMcrpertticdx dimittendiÂ« Ãd

. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tim,ud non intcrrogdtione,fed breui intcrlocutionc pd

troni refutindus eft : dut dliquo, Ã continget, urbdnÃ¨ dido reÃigerdndtÂ«; dttt Ã quid in eitÂ« uitdm dici pote* nt jittfdinid crimitwm deÃrufndiÂ«. Probos quofddm

cr uereciwdos non ajjirrÃ¨ mcejjereprofuit : niUtt [^f^ qui diuerfus mfeduntem pugndjfentjmodtfinnitti^ tur^Omnit Mtc mterrogdtio cd dut in cdufd,iut extri tie in^atÃ³. lt;^fintÂ» IÂ« cdufd,ftcut deeufdtori prÂ£ccpimiu, p^i^o* nuf quot^ dltiut, grÃ¼nde nihil /itj^edifit,rcpetiti pc^ contdtione priord fcquentibuf dppUctUtdo/ipe eopn* ducit hommes, ut muitis quod profit extorquedt â¢ Ei# reifme duiio,neq; difciplmd uUd in fMis,net^ txeta tdtio trdditur:cr ndturdU mdgis dcumme, dut ufucoÂ»^ tingit htc uirtus. Si quod turnen exemplu/m dd imitido nemdemojirdndumfit,folu cd, quod ex didlogÃ¼ Soerd ticoru,m,mdximeq- Pldtonis dud potedtiÂ» quibus di(o fcitÂ£ fitnt'mterrogdtiones,utciimpleri!'ty benerej^on^ dcdtur,res tdmÃ« ad id, quod uolumt efficere,peruemdt. lÃ¼ud fortumd interim prxftdt ,ut dliquid, quod inter [t pdrum confeMidt,d telle diedtur: interim (quod[tpiÂ»i cuenit) ut tejlis tefii dinerfd diedt. Acutd dutem Â«dem gdtio dd hoc, quod eufu fieri filet, etidm rdtioneperid fumÃ¯^ ^â^ cf^Extrd edufdm quoi^ multd, qui profint, ro^^rifi lent,de uitd tefiiian dliorum,de fud quifqi, fi turpitdd'gt;i fi humilitM,fi dmicitid deeufdtoris ,fi mimidtit cÂ» delt; in quibus dut diednt dliquid, quod profit, dut in medÂ»

â **' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;mismterrogdtio dÃ©bet ejfecireÃ¼fieÃ«id,quid muhieod j

trd pdtronos uenufii tefiesfiepe refiondent,eiq^ pt^u* j pue uulgÃ³fduetur,tdm uerbis, quum mdxime exmeiie fumptis,ut qui rogdtur ( is dutem eÃ¼ fiepius ty ^P^^ tuifimteUigdt^dut ne intcUigere fc negct,quod imÂ»^^

ORATORÂ» LIBER V'. l8l nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;i

uitluis nonkue frtgiÂ« fft â¢ 10Â« Â«ero peÃiwx 4Ã¯tcÃ¯, tw FrigujÂ« item (iiborndituwinfubfelltd idwerfarij mittere, ut mde cxcitiitiÂ« plus nocedtjUel dieÃ«do coiurd rciww,cwin quo fcdcÃ¯it,ucl ewm dditwiJJe teÃimonio uidebitur, fielen* do ex mduÃrid multd immodeÃc dtque Hitempcrduf ert per lt;pwnon Ã fe tdNtmndiSw detrdbdt Ãdem, feiet* terts quoquCj^ui projÂ«erdÂ«t,dÂ»ferdt dutoritdtem^uoÂ» riÂ«Â«mentionembdbMi,non ut Jierent, fed ut uitdrÃ©tur, S/pc inter fe coHidi folent, inde teÃdtio,binc teÃesjo* ColÃfio inÂ£ eus Mtrm^ue.HÂ« enim fe pdrs tureiurdndo,iUd confenÂ» ^^^âquot; fu pgitdwimtuetur. Sfpe inter teÃes, er drgumewd inter teftem ^ueÃtum eft, inde Jcienttim m teÃibus, er religtonem, Â®^ â8â ingenideÃe in drgKmentis dicitur : bitte teÃem grdtid, metu,ptcunid,trd,odio,dmicitid,dmbituÃert,drgumetd

l fonper^ idftdbuntur. AlitJiuindo utrinque fnnt teÃes, inter teftem \ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ã¼qucÃiofe^uitHrexipÃSjMtrimelioresuiri.ExcduÂ»Â®^ teftem.

â . grdtidffldgis luluerint. Hk ddijcere fi quw uolet ed, ' qud diuind teÃmonid uoednt, ex rej^onÃt, ordculk, ujuina tefti l ommibut, dupbeem fidt cortwn eÃe trdftdtwm: gencrd monia.

i quÂ«pK in queÃionem eddit Â« Aliter enim ordculortwn, i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;aliter HdruÃiicum ,dugurwm, conieftortwn Â»CT Â«wÂ«

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tbemdticorivmÃdesconÃrmdri ,dutrefellipoteft,ciÂ«u

Jnftrum?'âÃc rerum carum mtio diuerÃ. Cired dufmodi ^Â«0$ inuentd firmdndd,uel deÃruendd, multunthdbctopitii ordtto,fi c^uÂ£ fint uoces per umumfomiwmfementiifH emiÃÂ£,ucl excepta paruidorum mdicid^quoi pin iii' ^^Ã¢a^c h^â â'â^ ^â^â^fingere,alterd nihil iudicdrc^diUurd eH. NÂ« geL^poten t^dntum pruefiari hoc genus fotefi/ei etiarn uH non c^, ^er defidcrarifolet.?ecwniamdedifii,(iuisnugt;ncÃ¯iuitiii^ deMtrat?'* ^^^' 'Venenumarguis,uiiemifA^uo^^Uintiip^ quem dedif epto confcio^ Qt^it ferÃ¨ omnii pro Clncntto Cicero in crimine uenefidj excutit. Kxc de 'mirt^ hut quamhreuiÃime potui.

PARS altera prohationum, (pa e^ tota iÂ« id^i confiatq^ rebus ad faciendam fidem dppofitis,p^^' Odifs.Ã¯x. run^sautomninonegligiturfOut leuifimÃ¨ ittinÃ¿gt;'â^ Odifs.xij. 4amp; his, (ptiargumenta ueluthorrida cr conlrigoliH' tantes,dmxnioribus loeit defident i neep aliter,(p^^ quitraduntur 'a poetis guftucuiufdarn apud mtoÃ^^ gos grammit, et Sirenum cantu delmiti, utdupttquot;*' luti prietuliÃe,dum laudis falfam imagmem perfof^*, tiirppfa propter quam dicitur,taAoria cÃ©dant- ^^i^ elfter a, c^uecoiinuo magis orationis traitu dccntrn''^' in auxiUum at^ae ornamentum argumentorum eo^^ parantur, neruls^ iÃ¼lf, ^uibuscauÃcontinetifr,iÂ»t dunt mduch Ãper corporis Ãedem : ut fi firt^f* fadum ira, uel metu, wl cupiditate diedtur, Idtin F

cuiufque dfJÃ¯Ã³liK niturd pt propquemur. Ã¯i^cm Uu-dimiw jMicwpmtÂ«, (tugemm jnmumtÂ«, defertbimtw, deteÃ¯ycmtts,qutrnnuÃ¯,confobnur,bortÂ£imttrÂ» Sedbo rum eÃe opera Ht rebus, nut eertÂ« , dut de quibu-s tan-quamcertkloqMtmur,potcp, Nee abnuerim eÃe all-quid in deleftatione,nmltumÂ«ero incommouendis afÂ» fe^libiÂ«. Sed bac ipfa pliÂ« Â«aient, cm Je didteiÃe iudex putat, quod confequi nip argumentattone, abaque omni pdererum non pojpwniw. Quorum prius quant partiorpjeciej/mdicandum reor Â»quidam in omniVÂ«*â genere probationum communia. Nam neque uUa qute-pio eft ,qÂ«Â« nonpt, aut in re, aut in perfona. Nee ejÂ» p argumentorum loco poÃunt, nip mbiyque rebm, aut perfonw accidunt. La^ aut per (e mj^ici folcnt,aut nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

ad aliud referri* Neque uHaconpÃ¯matio,nip aut exCofirmatio, antecedentibuj, aut ex confequentibus, aut ex pugnan-

tibw. er Lite neeeÃe eft, out ex prfterito tempore,aut exconiunfto, aut ex fequentibut petere. Nee ulla res probarinip ex alia poteÃ. Edque pt oportet, aut ma-ior, aut par,out motor. Argumenta uero reperiuntur, ^rgumÃ®ta# aut inqua(lionibm,qux etiomfeparatÂ« Ã complexÂ« reÂ» rum,perfonarum$pgt;eftari perfe poÃint taut in ipfa coufo,cum inuenitur aliquid in ca, non ex commuai ra* tione duftum ,fed ciut iudicij de quo cognofcitur, proÂ» prium. Probationum pretere a omnium alte fuutnoProBationn ccÃaTia,4liÂ« no rÃ©pugnantes. Adbuc omnium pÃ¯olâatio^â^'^â^''* num quadruplex ratio eft, ut Â«cl quia filiquid eft, aliud non fÃ®t, ut diej eft ,twxnon eft t nd quia eft aliquid.

284 -M. FAB. QVINT, INSTlT-er lt;diud. fit,ut fol ell fuper terr dm,dies ell: uel ^Â«'^ quid non ell,d,Uud fit,ut nox non ell,dies e^:uel ^w^^ quid nonell,necdliudfit,utnonellrdtion:iie;iec^ ell. Bis in wtiuerfum pridiHis partes fubijeiM.

QMnis igitur probatio irtifcidlis confiiÃ¼ itt^ gnis,dut drgwmentis,aut exemplis,Bec igfo^Â°gt; pÃ¯erifji uiderifigm partem argmiÃ«torum, ^Â«^ 'Â®^ l parandi ratio bac fuit,prima, quad funt penÃ¨ ex iÂ® ii* artifcialibus.Crucnta enim uefis, er clamor, tiT^^'âââ er talia, funt mÃrumenta, quaHatM^e, ru,mortsgt;^â' fles nee inueniuMur ab oratorc,fed ad eum cu ipf ^^i deferunturi Alter a,quad figna fuemduiitatafwii^ funt argwmenta,quia ubi 'iÃ¼a funt,quÂ£fio non ell: i^Ã¯'^ . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;meto aut,nifi in re cotrouerfa locus effenon pottpir

dubia,non funt argumenta,fed ipfis argument tglt;â^' Diuiduntur autem in bas duos jpecies, quad eoram funt,ut dixi, que necelfaria funt,qut Graeci uocani'!^ fj.d^ilt;x,alia nonneceffaria,quÂ£ oân/j.amp;ix.PrioraiHil^â^ quÂ£ aUter baberefc non poffunt, quÂ£ mihi uix pe^ figta ntetf re ad prÂ£cepta artis uidentur, NdW Â«Wf/Ã¯/âgââ*^ . lubile, ibi ne lis quidem ell. ld autem accidit,cu q^^ . necejje ell fieri, faUiaic effe,aut certÃ¨ omnino nopeiv fieri,uel effe faUu/m-.quo in caufis poftto,lis non eamp;, Â®/ faUi.Boc genus per omnia temporapcrpendifolct-Cr coijffe cam cum uiro,quÂ£ pcperit,quod ell peitef' ti,er ftulius effe,cwm magna uis uenti in mare inewi^ ' quod coniunHi-.er eum mori,cuiuscorejl utdn^^tui^â

^Kod futuri nmffe fft. Nfc Jicri poteÃ, M tbi meÃii fi^iUbi fitum non eSl tut quit RomÂ«Ãt, cÂ« oft AtbcnK ;

. Â» Ãt Ãmo wi]ner(^uf,lt;[ui Ãne cicAtrice ejl. Srd qw^dS tr rctrorÃumident uileM ,ut uiuere hommi quij^irdt, C ^liÃ¯drc qui uitÃ¼t. Qwxddmwi contrArium Â»oh recur runt:Ncc enm quid mouetur qui mgreditur/tu mgre-ditur qui mouetur.Qgdre poteÃ er coij/fe cu wiro,qMje non pcperit,cr non effe uetUiu 'm mAri^cu effet Ãu^M^ HfcHtiq;coreiuiuÂ«lÂ«fr4ttnÂ»c{fe,quiperit. Ac/imili-tw ^tum [wiJJc potejljUbi Â»oÂ» fmt meÃis^nec Ãuiffe Ro me,qui non fuit ktlnenie^nec fui ffe ferro UMlnerutUjqut bitteteicAtricem.kliAfuntÃtgnAnonneceffAnA,i^Â£ w Signa nÃ¶nÂ« KOTaGrxci uoc(tÂ»f,quÂ« etium/j ud toUendum dubitutio '^ j^jJJji nemfoU non fufÃeiunt, turnen udiunftu cÂ£tÃ¨rK plu* rimatn mlent.Signu uocAnt (ut dixi) fHfxÃ¿op, quunqul id quiduw indicium, quidura ueÃigium nominducrunt, per quod uHu res intcGigitur, ut per funguinem cÃ¦dcÃ® : AtquiufunguKuelcxboÃÃ¼ veficxftffe ueÃempotep* uel Ã¨ nuribuÃ® profuxijfe,non utiq^ qui ueÃem eruentAni bubucritjbomicidium fecerit. Sed ut per Je non Ãiffleiti itActterii AdiunÃ¤u teÃimonij loco ducitur,p mirnieufj fi Ante mnAtux^Ã eodemloco fuit Â» QuibtÂ« ÃgnÃ¼ cum tie ccÃit,c(Ãcit ut ([uxfuf^e^A trAM^certA uideStur. Abo-

, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;qui funt qurdu Ãgnu utri^ purti c5muÂ«ilt;l,ut liuorej,tU

, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;er uulnus m peftor e,fuA mAnu cr lt;tlicÂ»lt;t periÃe dicen-

tibusjnquoeft, BÂ£cfi:r'mdtÃrmAhAbcntur,At^ex-* trmfeem Â«tdinuÃ¯tur.Eoru dWem, qÂ«Â« pgunfunt quidÃ©,

i86 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT- , fed non neccjfirid,genus Herrndgonu putdt:no (j)^ ginem AtJidntdni, eptid cum iuuenamp;ut per [yluds vi^ tur.Qttodfireceperimus^uereorneomnidcpiÂ£fxf^'â ducunturjignd fdcidmusteddÃ« tdmen rdtione,lt;piifiS^ trdildittur.'iicc mihi uidentur Arcopdgiti,cUK iiÂ»^ uerunt puer urn coturnicum oculos eruentem ,diii*^ *â, ^â^ff^^ Ã ^â^ ('^i^^gt;^ effe pernidoÃÃimie mentis, w^M mdlo future, fl ddoleuiÃet^ Vnde Spurij Mf!i/,M-'â'â'? Mdnlif populdrUds,fignum dffeAdti regni fuit td^^ tum.Sed uereor ne longe nimium nos ducdthtemd^ Udm fl eH fignum ddulterit,ldudri cum air is,erii Ct uiuerecum ddolcfccntibus, dernde etidmfdmUidritef^ cuius dmicitid uti,dut fortdÃe corpus uulfum.jrdi^gt;^*^', eeÃum^ueÃem muliebrem d ixerit moÃ¼is,0âp^^lt;^ Â«Æ fâ^ttd , fi cuf cum fignum id proprie fit, quod ex eo, i^ ' quo qutritur, nutum fub oculos uenit,ut funguis ex ei' de,itdiÃ¼deximpudicitid Ãuereuidedtuur. ^epo^ qut qdplerunq obferudtdfuntjWilgÃ³figndcreduiitith ut prognofiicd t vento rubet dured Phaie-Ctorg.r. Etcornixpicndplustidmuocdtmprobduoce. Bodem hb. Si cdufds ex qudlitdte cali trdbunt,fdnÃ¨ itd dppeUei^' ndm ft uento rubet lumd,fignum uenti dl rubor. ^M â Midem poÃ«td coUigit, denfdtus Cr Idxdtus dÃ«r fisib^, fit inde lUe duium concentus, idem fentiemus, SuiUiigt;^â fignd etidm pdrud mdgnorum,ut hicc ipfd cornix, 1^^ mdiordminorumelfcnemo mirdtur.

tÂ«r omnia,^MÂ« Graci (^6u/j.K/xo;7a:, Ã¯Tnx^ftÃ§K-MaTajCtTrotrti^eK? Â»oednt : quan^ apud iUos eÃ aliqua borurn nommu differentia, etiarn fi uk eoiem ferÃ¨ ten dit.Nam cntbymema (quod nos comentumÃdnÃ¨,aut corn g^jj^j^j^j mentationnn interpretamar, ejuid dUtcr non foÃumust graco iwlius ufuri) wnum mteVfHum Habet, quo omnia mente concepta/igni/Ã®cat.fed nunc de to non loquimur* Â«Iterum, quo/ententiam cÂ«mratione:tert(Â«m,quo cer-* tant quandam argumenti coclaponcm, url ex confe^uen tibuj, Â«el ex rcpagnintibiÂ«: quanqua de Hoc par um co Â» wnit. Sant enim qui ilÃ®ud pritÂ« cpicHirema dtcant,p!Â«-res^ inuenias m ea opmione, Â«t id demum, quo pugna conJlat,entHymemaaccipittclint. EtideoiHwdCorni* |Ã¯ciÂ«jcontrariÂ«m appellat. Uunc eilij rhetoricum fyl^ logi[mum,alij m^erfedum ^yUa^i^mum woeancrunt: quianecdiÃmdwnectotidem partibus conduderetur, quoi fane no utiq^ ab oratore dc/Ã® Jeratwr. Epiebirema

V allias aggreÃionem uocat. Verrius antem iudicat ng Epkhirem#Â» noÃramadminiflrationcm,fcdip/Ã¤mremqttaaggredi* mÂ«r, id eÃ argumentum, quo aliquid probaturi [urnust etiam/Ã¯ nondum uerbie cxplanatum, tam tarnen mente ronceptum,epiebirema dici. Alijs uideturHon dejima-t^,uelincboatam,)Ãªd perfedam orationem Hoc nomc ^tÂ«Â»e,lt;3gt; ultimamÃjcciem.ldco^ propria eins appel â '^ââgt;â3-ttiixittie inufu pofitacÃ,qÂ«a Jigni/icatur cer ta qâ* ^fententije comprebcnfio,qujefx tribusparti-*

i88 M. FAB. C^VINT. ^^^^^^\|^ Cicero mcUus rdtiocindtiiMimi qMn^ faille nom duxifje mdgis d fyUogifmo uidetur-'i^â^ntC!'Ã^'^'^'^.. logijlicum rdtiocmdtiuÃ¼ dppeÃ¯ldtjexemC^ff^i lofophorÃ¼, Ut quonidtn eÃ quitddm inter fy^^^i'^^^^^ e(gt;icbircmduictnitdf,potcftuiderihocnomineren e fut. AttÃJ'^^k^, eÃ euidens proidtio,ideot^ dpui g^Â® Apodixis. trdsy^Â«/j./xHMgt;aa.mJ^l^amp;i^dietvntur.Ã¼lt;tncCy^ ât chiremdte CxciliutputdtdiffÃ¨rrefolo genere coi^^ P ^ nii,et eue dpodixim imperfeau epichiremd, ediÃ©i^ ^ fd^c^ud dixmut,ey enthymemd d fyUogifino di^it'--ar epichiremdfyttogifmi pdrseÃ. QuiddinineÃre^i^'^ remdti dpodixim putditt,cr ejfe pdrtem eiw 001111^1â tem.Vtcwiqi dutem, qudn^ diuerÃ dutores eodem do Ãniunt,utfit ordtid,pcr ed quit certdfunt,Ãdem K iqs afferens, qut ndturd eÃ omniu drgumentoru â Xf$ enim certd incertii decldrdMurthtc omnid generidit^ miself dppeUdnequod etfi proprid mterpretdtioneii* tere Ãdem pofumus, dpertius tdmen probdtionem. W' j. terpreidbimurt Scd drgumentu quoq; plurdfig^r^' Kdm zyfdbult dd dflut [cendrum cÃ¶pofitt dicuntur,cy ordtionu Ciceronis uelut themdipÃ^ nens Ptdidnut,drgumentÃ¼,mquit,tdlc eÃ. Ut ipÃ^ . dd Brutum itd fcribit.Veritus fortdÃe ne nos in Ãt^''J Arguments noÃrum trunsferdmus iUinc mdU quid,O' fi irgunitm'^ fimile non erdt^ Quo dppdret,omnemdd feribendu^ flindtdmmdteridmitddppeÃ¯ldri. l^ecmirum,entniÂ»gt;^^ ter opifices quo^'uulgdtunt fit.Vnde vergibst Ar^â metum ingens. VuÃ¯go^ pdulo numerofiat opus ^â^^^

batiOjCr fides efficitur non tantu per bfe, qwÂ« funt ra-tionwjfedettdm per martificialtit. Signum autem, quoi itte miicium wo cat,ab argumentÂ« iam feparaui. Ergo cum fit argumentum ratio probationem prÂ«Ãans,qua colUgitur Â«liquid per aliud,Oâ que, quod eft dubiu,pcr id quod dubium no eft,confirmat,neccffe eft effe oliquid in caufa,quod probatione non egeat* Alioqui nibil erit quo probcmult;,nifi futrit quod aut jit Herum,aut uidca-

tur, ex quo dubijs fies flat. Pro certÂ« autembabemus Pro certis prmu.que fenfibus percipiuntur,ut quÂ« uidemm, au-'^abenda. dimus, qualia funt fignaidcmdc ca, 1Â« qux comuni opi* nione confenfum ef^dcos effe^pneÃandam pirtatem pa* rentibiM.Praterea que legibus cauta fmt,quÂ« perjua-fione etiomfi non omnium bommunbeius turn? ciuitatÂ«, aut gcntk,m quarcs agitur ,m mores recepta funt: pie* raq/iniure non legibus ,fci moribus confiant â¦ Si quid inter utranq; partem conucnit,fi quid probatum eft,de ni(^ cuicunq; aduerfarius non contradicit. Sic enim pet argumentum,cum prouidetia mundus rcgatulr, adminiÂ» llrandaeft re]^ublica:Â«t admini(Irania Re jf)/rit,ftliÂ» qwbit mundu prouidentia regi. Debet etiam nota effe Â«ft* argumeta traHaturOjUis et natura omnium reru, ^ |^â*Â«lt;^earuplcriÂ«iq; e^iciat, Hine enim funt quÂ« liKOTadicuntur.CrcdibiliumaÃ¼tgenerafunttriatVnucredibilÃ®a f rniif imum, quod fere accidit, ut liberos Ã parentibwsââ genera

256 M. FAB. QVINT. iNSTlTÂ« Ainiirit AÃtcrum uclut propcnÃm, earn ^ui reUf ^'^ Â«i crÃ¤Ãmum perlten turum: Tcrtiumtdntuinnenf^Ã¯, ^gt;iAi,m domo furtum fdHu db co, ^ui doimfi^â 1 ^ t AriÃoteles in fecudodeurte KhctoricdUbroddi^^'^ Ãme cH exccutur,^uid cui^ rci,cr fluid cuilt;^ kat lt;iccidere,Zi7' ^Udf reSf^uofy; homines,iuibiu gt;* â nut hommibui, ud concilid/fet, uel diendfet ipf rd,ut diuitiM lt;iuid fcqudtur, dut ambit urn, M/wpquot;/' tianem,fluid boni probent,fluid malt pct At,fluid Â»uW quid ruÃiei, quo quÂ£q; modo res uitdri,uel dpplt;u jâgt;'^ kdt. VerumhocexequimittOt i^on enimlougui^^ fed etidm mpoÃibile,dut potins infinitum e^, ^^^^â pofitumm commiwii omnium inteUedu. Siquist^^'^ â ^PÂ°f^'^{?S defiderAuerit,Ãquopeteret,oÃendi, OmniddUteuKf ioates! ^** dibilid, in quibus pars mdximd confiÃit drgumtiÃ¼^^^ nif,ex huiufmodifontibus fluunt, dn credible Ãtir putrem occifum, ineeÃum cum filid. commifium, amp;nbsp;â^'^ trA,ucneficium in noucrcd,dduÃ¯tcrium m luxurioÃd-lÃ¼d quoq;,dn fcelus pdlÃm fdÃ¤um,dn fdlfum dixffdf^'â pter exigudm fummdm,quid fuos quifq; horu res habet, plcrunq; tdmen non femper, dlioqui'tdd*^ ' td effent,non Argumenta. ExcutidmusnuncdrÃ¿ibf^^ rum locos, qudnq quibufddm hi quoq;, de quibiuj^*? Loei argu' dixi,uidentur.Locos.ippeUo, non ut uulgo nuw â¢âÆ mentorum. gimtur,ut in luxuridm ar ddulterium,arfitmilid,pf des drgumentorum in quibus latent, ex quibus Ãutf^^ dd, Ndm ut in terra nonomnigcnerdniuroninii,Â»^\ duem nee fer dm reperidS ,ubiquÂ£c^ ndfii, lt;uii uidt^

ORATOR. LIBER V. 251 folcdt igndriM. Et filcium qÂ«o5; gentri iUipldnK gut dfutÂ» fill'd fixoÃis,regionHtK ctidm UttorHusÃ©li difcreti fMtit,Â«fc dopen noÃro mdri, dut fedrum dueMt Itd non omne drgumentum wndiij^ nenit, ide 0^ non pdj?Mn ^MÂ« rendum eft* MultiÂ« dlioqui error tSl,cr exbduÃo ld* tore, quod non rdtione fcrutdUmWy non ^oterimus 'm ufuire niji cd[u. At Ã Ãeierimw Ã¼bt quic^j ndÃcdturt cu dJ locum uentum erit,fdeile quod eo trit^peruidei'imw. In primÂ« igitw drgumentd fepe Ã perfond ducendd iperfona. funt^cum fit,ut dixijdinifio, Â«t omnid 'm hxc duo pdrtid, mur^res dtq; perfondc^ut cdtifd,tempnt,lociit,occdÃoÃM ÃrumentumjWodm, er eiterdiremm Ãnt decidentid^.

Verfoniidutemnon quiequid deeidit,exeouendummihi P^foquot;â* fftjUtpleri^/fcfrunt, fed wide drgumentd fwmi^of- j genere fimt.'Ed porro funt genm, ndm fimiles ^drenlihut de md iorihut fuis flij fkrwnt^ creduntur, er nonnim^ dd bo nefleturpiter^ uiucndum,'mdeeduflt;Â£fltwnt. Ndtio,, nÃ¯ er gentibui proprij morÂ« funt, nee idem m idrhd- â quot;ââÂ°ââÂ®' ro,Romdno, GrÃco^probdbilc cft.Pdtrid,qHtd jimilitcr ^ patria. ftidmciuitdtumlfgccjinÃitutd, opMMonÂ«bdbcnt differ ifexu rentum, ScxiMjUtldtrocwiiumfdcilius m uiro^encjidM Abeducatio 'mfam'inderedds. Aetds,(^uiddliud dlijsdnnismdgis ne. conutnit.Educdtiâo er difeiphmd,lt;iuonidm refert Ã qui* j^â^JJJj bui,er quo qui^q; modo fit in/lituttM.HdbitUicorporK, ducitur ctiim /requenter 'm drgumentÃ¼j^eeies libfdmw, robur pctuldntidC.Hw contrdrid in dinerfum, 'SortuM^

Â»fq^ tHimidÃ© erfdibile eÃ 'm diuite depdupere ^propin* ^Â«KjfffniciSjcliftrtibiÂ« dUndAtf, erbw oibw deÃituto.

Coditionc. Qan^itionii etidm difidntid cR, ttdin cldruf dn oifeM, mdgijlrdtut dn priudtiK,pdter dn filius,ciuis dn ffffgÂ« ntajiber dn femus^ mdritm dn alcbs, pdrensliberorÂ» Natura ani- lt;*Â» Â°^buiÃt^plurimu diftdt. Animindturd, etenim dui'

Studiis. ^^ fimilid,dffpruntfrequenterfidcm,dutdetrdbut'.[tcitt Affeftibus. uiitiujlnxuriofui,dnfrugi^dn fordidti^y^Uicriiur-StuUi Ã¢a!quot;^?'^â iuo^Â»gt;fdm ruÃieut,forenfis,negocidtor, miles, Â»duig^' tor,medicus,aliud dtlt;^ dUud ejÃeiunt, IntuendumctiM quiddffÃ¨iletquif(j;,locuples uideridn difertus,^^^ dn potens.SpeUdntur dntedild, diHd^^. Ex preterit enim teflintdri folentprteÃntid.Uis ddijeiunt qtiidimcd motionem,hdncdccipiHolunttempordriudnimimotiiiii, feut irdm,pduorem.ConÃlid dutÃª,cr prefemis crf^* teriti O' futuri temporis,qM mihi, etidmÃ perfonis dt cidunt,referendd tdmÃ¨ dd iUdin pdrtÃ« drgumentoru ui' dentur,qud, ex edufts dudmus'.Ãeut hdbitus quidi Mimi quo trdddtur inimicus,dn dmieus.Ponunt in perfiu ff nomen, quad quidÃ©ei dccidere neceffe efl,fcd in drill' mentu rdro cddit:niÃ cum dUt ex edufd datum eli,utfd^ piens,mdgnus,plenus,dut et ipfum dlicuius cogitdliuun^ dttuUt edufdtn: ut Lentulo coniurdtionis, qiiÃ¨d lAil^ Si byJUnis, hdruÃiieum^ rej^onÃs, domindtio daritrihut Cornelijs dicebdtur, [Ã©queeumtertium effe credebdt In phorniP poÃ Sylla,Cimdmq;, q o ipfe Cornelius erdt. Ã¯^dm ff ââ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;iÃ¼ud extdt dpud Euripide,fi-igidum fdnÃ¨,quod nomÃªPo

f tarnen ^^^'^â â^ drgumentÃ¼fi-dter morum incefit. LocorM i- enim ex eof-equÃªstnaterid,qua Cicero,in Verre non

ORATOR. LIBER V. 195

^clÂ»fus cS.HiCc fere circa per [oiws (Â«ntjdMtbw fmi li4.Nc^ cmm cÃ¶plcfti oWjUclW m partejUdin cÂ£teÃ¯K p o)]umÂ«Ã¯,contcnti rationem plura quxfitwrw oÃeder e. Nanc adres tranpo, in quitus maxime funt perfonis ^^^âj'quot;^â mfta quo: agimus/dcoq; prima trad anda. inomni- Arg.Ã reb* lus porrÃ³ qua punt, quxritur aut quarc, dut ult, aut âÂ®Â®â¢ jj^ ^^_ quindo,aut quomodo,aut per quÂ« fada funt.Oucuntur ao,.um ud igitur argumenta ex caupsfaÃ orumatel futurorSquo futuro^Ã®-rum moteriam uÃxp aUj, Ãcoja/xip alq nommaucrunt, wduo generated quaternas utriu/q; diuidunt J^ccies. Nam ferÃ¨ uerfatur ratio faciendi circa lonorÃ¼ adeptio nem,iiwifefflcntÃ¼,conferuationÃ«, ufum: aut mdioruettita tioncmjilerationemjimmmtttioncjconucrfionemjnanc^ lac in dclibcrando plurimÃ¼ ualcnt.Scdbas caufos batet

fftbis,initiumcxbis,quiecredunturlonaautmalaunÂ» de errorcs exiÃunt, er pefimi afleftus/vn quitus funt, wa,odiumÃ¤nuidia,cupiditas,]^cs,amlitu$,audacia,mc tus,cttcraeiufdem generis. Accedunt aliquando for-tuÂ«a,clTictAS,ignorantia.QttÂ«Htterim aduemamua lent,Interim ad prolationem crimmum. Vt p quis dum atj infidiatur, alium dicitur witeremijfe. Coupe porro CaufÂ«. non ad conuincendum modo, quod obqcitur,fed od de* pudendum quoq excuti folent : cum quis fe refte fecif* feÃ¤dcÃJ)oneliacaufa,eontendit,quadcrelatiu$inteif tioWiTo diftum. Einitiones vntertm ex edups pendent, ^ p^rj^f^Qj^^, Ant5Tannicida,quit5Ã¯annum,Ã quo deprehenfus m ftdultcno fucrot, occidit. An facriiegus, qui ut looses

294 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTI'Ã'â urbe expeUerct, drmd templo affixd detrdxit- ^^ââ^â tur argument tl cf ex loco.SpcÃ atur enim ai jiieixf^'^ iationif,montanus an planus, maritimus an mciitf^^ neus,confitusan mcultus, frequens on defertus, pÃ¯lt;â' pvntpMis an remotus, opportunus conftlijs anaiatt' fus, Quam partem uidemus uehementiÃmepro AIÃâ' netrada/fe Ciceronem. Ethlt;ec^idem,acÃniilia'^ conieduram Ãequentiut pertinent, fed intermaiiaf quot^j priMtus an puilicus,facer an prophaniu, ne^tf an alienus. Vtm perfona, magiÃratus, pater,ptre* gr'mut. Hwe enim quaflioncs oriuntur.Pritiatainfe^ cumiam fuÃuliÃi, uerum quia de templo, no furtum,Ã^ facrilegium ek. OccidiÃiadulteru,quodlexpermutÃ©-fed quia in lupanari, ades ed. Iniuriam feciÃi,(ei ^ magiÃratui, maieÃatis adio cd, uel contra, lieuit,c[aii pater erdm,quia magiÃratus, Sed circa fadi contre' uerftam, argumenta pra:Ãant, circa iuris Utes, materU quiÃionum. ÃdquaUtatemquoqi frequenterperi^' net locus. Keque enim idem ubieÃ, out licet, aut itee' rumeÃ, Quin etiam tn qua quicq; duitatequititie', Â» intered Moribus enim or legibus diÃant.Ad coigt;it^^ dationem quoq; er muidiam ualet, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Nam er AtÂ«

Ante rates agimus caufam,er mecu confertur ViyÃeS' Et Miloni inter cetera obiedumeÃ,quodCEODN^ in monumentis ab co maiorum fuorum effet occifus.

dcnilt;j;prÂ£tcritum,iÂ«Jlan$jfuturum. Hoc fc^ucnsba-bct O' conÃitutadi)crimina,lt;e(latc ,bgt;ârmÂ£ ,noHu,iii-terdiu-.^r fortuita,Â«Â» pcÃilcntia,inbcllo,m conuiuio.

d-^t inorurn c^u i d im ftt is f gm ft ari putaucrunt^fiiUud â gÃ©nÃ©rale tempus ,boc Ãicciale, tempora uoearent. Quorum utrorum^ue ratio, er inconÃlijs quidem^ CT in ido demonÃratiuo genere uerfatur, fed in iudicijs IrcquentiÃma eft. Hom er iuris quÂ£Ãioncs facit, er quolitatcm diÃitiguit,ez ad conirfturam plurimum con fert : ut cum interim probationes incxpHgnabiles aÃc- cap.de ta-rat,qualesfunt,fi dicatur (utfupra pofui) ftgnator,bulis. qui ante diem tabularum dccefit,aut commifijfc all-quid ,utl cum inf arts eÃet, uel cum omninonatus non eÃet. Prater id, quod omnia facile argumcnta,aut ex bis,qua ante rem fafta funt,aut ex coniunftis rei, aut

* confequentibus ducuntur. Ex antecedentibus : Mortem minatuses,noftucxiÃi, projieijeentem dnteeeÃi-^i, Caufaquoqjfadorum prateriti funt temporis. Scd tempus fubtibus quidam,^ neeeÃe er at diuiferunt, ut eÃet lundi,Conus auditus cft:adb(Â£rcntis,clamor fub latus cft.infcqucntis funt illa,latuiÃiâpfugiÃi,liuores, ty tumores apparucrunt. lifdem temporÃ¼ gradibus de fenfor utetur ad detrabendam ei, quod obijcitur pdlt;mÂ»

29Â« M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlTÂ» inhis omnit fdHorum, diilorutn^r^itioucrfMthP dupUciter tilt;wtfiunt qu^dim, quid dUud police fÂ»^' rum eÃ¼, quxddm, quid aliud dtite fdHum elt : ui ^gt;â''' dijciturreo knocinijj^eciofemdrito, quodj^eiofdtn ddulterij ddmndtam quanddm emeritsdutpdrrtcid^ f^^ luxuriofojquoddixeritpdtrijnonmedmpliusoiiur^i^ bis. fidm z:r iUc^non quid emitjeno eÃ¼, fed qd kno criii emit-^cc hk^quid Ãcerdtlocutus,occidit,fed quider^ A aCu. ocdfurus^fic locutus eÃ¼.Cdfus dutcm,quiamp;ipffff^' fdt drgumentis locum, fine dubio ell ex infequentHus: fedquddÃ¤mproprietdte diÃinguitur: utfidiedniinKÂ» lior dux Scipio quam Annibdl, uicit enm Annibdioi. Bonus gubemdtornumqudm fecit uduÃagium. Bonus dgrieold mdgnos fuÃulitÃudlus. Et contra, fumptuo fus fuit,patrimonium exhauÃt, turpiter uixit, udomm Af nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;busintiifuselljntuendiefunt,prdecipueqfmconie^Uâ

ris^O'fdcuItdtes. Credibiliusefienimoccifosdpbiri' bus pauciores d firmioribus imbecilliores, d ui^iknU' bus dormientcs,dprÂ£pdratis inopmantes. QSÂ»^ contraridin diuerfum ualent. Hiec er in dekberi^o intuemur, cymiudicijsadduas res folemus ref^â dn uoluerit quis, dn potuerit. Uam er uoluntaini^ fdcit. nine iÃ¼d dpud Ciceronemconiediurd: infiH^

. ellClodius Miloni,non MiloClodio, llkcumfe^ j robuflis,hiccummuÃ¯ierumcomitdtu. llkequis,bicni , rhedd.lUeexpeditus,hicpenuÃ¯d irretitus. Edcultdtiiii' temUeet inflrumcntumconitwgere. Sunteniminp^f' ' metoâ^â¢^ iffifÃ¼^ilt;kiftÃr copiÃ©e. Sedexinfirsanento oliqndisdo '

Hk dijcitur modw.qncm T^oTTop dicunt, quo quxri* ^ âÂ®â^Â°* twr,qucmidmodum quid fit fuftamtid quod ad qiuliti* tempriptumq; pertmet-.ut fincgemiKudulterumucne no occidijfcjcum ferrolicui(Jct occidcrc, fed uel oportÂ» itfeitittnildconieauriÂ« quoq;,utfi dicim ,boni mente fmamddeo^ pdUmimaU ideo ex mfidijsjnoftudn foÂ« litudinc. inrebiw dutem omnibut de qiuiruinui dut ndtu rd qudritur, quÂ«^ etidm citrd complexuw perfondru, Ã¯dtcÃ¯OTivm^,exquibult; fÃ®t cdufd ,pcr feintutrtpo(fuÂ«

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;wiÂ«,tÃ¯idfwe dubioruYfiM(pcadddfu'Â«t,dnfit,quid fit, gquot;**J^2^

\ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;funt.DucunturcrgodrgumeiUdexÃrtitione ,ffufiiieÃ¯Â£xfinitto'

\ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ndmutroquemodotrdditur.Eiut duplexrdtioeft.Aut*quot;^â^^''^â'â

turn fimpliciterquÂ«ritur,fitâne boe uirtut: dut dtitece* deÂ«c jinitione,quid fit uirtucid dut m uniuerfum ucr* bis sompUaimur,ut rbetorice eft bene dicendi fcieitt id:

dut per partes,ut rbetorice eft refie mueniendi, cz di f^onendijOÂ« cloquendi cumfÃ¯rmd memorid, er cwm di* gnitdte dftioniijfcientid^Prdtered fnnnus,dut ui,ficutTinimusut fuperioTd: dut Iru^oXo^!Â«, ut df iduum db fre ddngt; K etymolo* ^Â®gt;O- locupletcm dlocoruw,pccuniojuw d pecoruw co affe ^'^^ââ¢ââ¢ifub!cftdmdximcuidcntur,gcmÂ«,Ã)ccics,^R^â^5^' â¢lFÂ«n!,propriÂ«.Exbis omnibus drgumentddueÃtur.xproprio. G^niuii probdddm Jpeciem mmimwrn udlet,pluriwÂ»/nt wrcfelknddm.itd^nonquideft drbor.pldtdnus eftt

A ^^ede/ â^^ ^â^â^ ^'â^ ^^ arbor,uti^ plitmui non c^. Net ^ A iPprio. noÂ» 0Ã¢ uirtuSjUtiq; pote A effÃ¨ iuÃitia. ttÃ¤quc Ã ^mtn perueniendum eil ad ultimamf^edem: ut homo csi unit tnal,non e^l fatis(id enim gentu cR )niortdle:etiiuttftl^^ des eÃ¼^cuM alijs tarnen communis finitio. RationiÃ¯e,iii hilfupcreritad demoÃranduid,quÃ¶d uelis. Contrij^ des firmam probationem habet generis, mfirniM r^f^ tationÃª.Nam quad iuÃitia efl,uti^ uirtus cA:quoi noU eAiuflitia^poteA effeuirtusi utfieÃ¼ fortitude,cotiiiai tidjConflantia^'Nunquditaq^ toUctur Ã /Ãede genus,niji omnesfsedes, quafimt generi fubieda, remoueantur, hoc modotc^od neq^ immortale eR, neq; nioÃ¯tde,^Â»^* mat non eH, ais adifdunt propria er di^rendi' ^^ Proprium, prijsconfrtnaturfinitio,diffÃ¨rentibusfoluitur.Prop^^ urn aut edi,autquodfoli acddit,ut hommiferino,fifus-aut quad uti^ accidit,fid non foli,ut igni alefdetf^'^ funt eiufdÃ« reiplura propria,ut ipfius ignis tu(efe,s^^ re.lta^ quodcunq; propriu dÃ©crit, foluet finitioni.x^^ ud^ quodcunq; erit,eonfirmabit.SÂ£pifime Ã¤HtqnUld proprium cuiufq- quaritur, utfi per etymologidind'^^ tur: Tyrannicida proprium eH tyrannu Gcdder(gt;^^ mus. Kon enimfitraditSfibi eurn carnifex oedi^'^â^^ ranidda uocatur,nee fii)ftprudÃ©s,ucl quitus .Qi;^^^^^. propriu non erit, diffÃ©rÃ©s crit,ut aliud c^ feruu effi udferuire,qualis effÃ¨in addidisquafiofold. QÂ«if^^ ^^lt;^â^â- uns cÃ©l,fimanumittatur,fit libertiÂ»us,nonitideigt;tadigt;i^ amp;fferens. ^ifS,erplura de quibus aUoIoco. iVudquo^ differ^ KocaiK, eurn genere inffedÃ© didadofreies iÃf â^âF

OR AT OK. LIBER V. 199 nitur: Animil gcniÂ«, mortale j^ccirs, terrent Â«d bi* {X!,dif^rcns .Non dim enim proprim rS^fed inm dif* fert Ã mirmOjUcl qiwJrupedf .Quoi non tA id irgÂ«mÃ© tuwpeTtmct,|id diligentetnjinitionKcomprcbciiÃo* â ntm.Ciccro gernÂ« er ji^fciem, quam einde formirn Â«o* Â® Â«t,*{inittoncdidHcit,er bK,qÂ«Â£ idaliquid funt, fwbij Â«f.ut fi is,eut omne irgrntumlegitum cfl,pctitfignigt; timi quoq;,utitur ge nerf. At ft quts corn Icgutu/m fit fiÂ» que uiro mitcrfimiltÃ¯s e(Jct,nf get deberi ei,qux in mi numnoncouenerit J^ecie: quonum duÂ« formdepntmi trmonioTim.Oiuifione autem idiuuari Ãnitionem doÂ» A diuifione. eet jeamqjdiÃerre Ã pirtitione : quodbic fit totius in pi'ftcs,itU^enerwin formas â¦ Partesincertise(fe,ut Democratia qubus cÃ¶jlct Rej^ubliciJormas certes ,ut quot fint j^e eiesrcrurnpublicarwiw. QuaÂ« tres accipimits.qua: popÂ« b,quÂ« p4ueora,ffl,qÂ«Â« unins poteÃate regcrÃ¨tur .Et iUe quidemnonbis cxemplw utiturjqnia pribens ad Trebi biw^xiare ea ducere maluif.ego apertiora pofui.Pro ^onicCturÃ§. pniuero ad cÃiefturÂ« quoq; pertinent partem, ut pro priameRbonirefte facere t iracumdi uerbis excandeÂ» (cere. Ac contra, quidam in quibufdam utic^ non funt, e ratio,quamuis ex diwerfo.eademeftÂ» Uiuifio,er ad VAani'jm fimiU uii ualet,et ad refcUendum. Proban Ptobatt5i tÃ©iWwn fatis eft iMWWi habere,boe modo: Vt ft ciuk

Mr urn. Totufdtfam eÃ¼,hoc modoiPecunii if crfO^^ fe diets: aut habuifti ipfe^dut db dU^uo dceepijli, dut iÂ«Â» MniÃiydut furripuifli. Si ne^ domi hdbuiÃi,nf(l; db dSio ^^ dccepiÃi, nec cÂ£terd, non credidiÃi. Relii^uuinÃt ut* mm fie: Hic feruus, eluent tibi um dieds, dut uernd tuns eR,dut emptuStdut dondtus, dutteÃdmetoreli{litf,dUt ex haÃe cdptuf,dÃ¼tdiienus. Deinde remotis priorÃ¼di, mustcum ri/u ^uo^ totd resfoluitur. Tutim ^uoi CiÃ ro pro Cecmndfdcit,cum mterroga/i hdcdUionolth quit Ãt.Simulenim remouentur omnid. Vel cum duofÂ» nenturinter fecontrdrid, quorum tenui(fcutrumH^ fuÃicidt,qudle Cicero^ eÃz vnum quidcm,certentei^ erit tdm mimicus Clacntio, qui mihi non cÃceddt,fi(0^ ruptum ittud eR indicium,dut db Hdbito, dutdb op^ eo e/JecorruptmSi doceonon db Hdbito,uitteo db0flt;^ nico: Si oÃendo db Opidnico,purgo Hdbitum-^necefte eft ^* duobuf quorum neceffdrid ck dlterutrwn elii^â' aUeru ueÃ§e dduerfurio poteÃdt:eÃicitur^,ut utru eÃ¯egerit,ftlt;x^^'^

PdcithocCicero pro Oppio: vtrum cum CoUM^ til[et,dut cum ipfe fefe condretur occidere, teSt* t nibus ereptum cH.Pt pro Vdreno : Optio uoiii di^^^' utrum uelitis cdfu iÃ¼o itmere Vdrenum ufum eÃt^ , ius perfudÃu er mdudu. Deinde utrdi^ fdcitd^j^^ (ontrdrid.lnterim duo itd proponuntur,ututrulii(^â dam,idem eÃicidt,quile edlzphiloÃophddum non e^ phUofophdndum.it iHud mil^dtum: Os^f^

ORATORÂ» LIBER V. 501

Mi.fi mtclligÃ¹wÃ¯ ^ (Juofi nonintcUigitur ? C: MewÃ¼ ttuT m tormentw, ^wi dolorem piti poteft, mentictur* quinonpoteft. Vt fiwtdutemtrid tempori, it dor do rerum tribiu momentis confertut eft Â» Hdtent eni-m o# mnidmitiom, Micrementum, fummdimut turgiumi/e*

inde cÂ«dcj,o- (Irdgej^Eft ergo bic quoque argument o ^^ ^^^ riwnlocut mHicem probdtUium. Nam er ex Imtijs fumÂ» ma coUigitur.t^iule efttHon pofjum togam prftextam Ã)rr Jre,cutn exordium puUwm uideam.Et contra, non dommationw caufa SylUm arma fumpfij^e, ar gument tÃ© tft diftatura depoÃtu. Similiter et ex incremento in Â«Â« ^^ incremÃ® trant^partem ducitur rciÃ¯itio, cum in conieftura,ttvm^Â®â etiamm traftatÂ« Â«quitotis.an ad initiufummu referen da,id eft,an ei cades imputandafit, Ã quo iurgium cÅ* pit.EÃ argumeNtorumlociÂ« ex pmilibtw.Si contineittia A. fimiUbusi ttirtiWjUti^ cr abÃinentia.Si fidem debet tutor,er pro curator .Hoc eÃ ex co gcnere,lt;^uod er iTra^w'yÃ¹p Gr a ^^ j^pj^ij ciuocarntCiceroindHaionem .Exdifmilibut Ã® Non p AdiHimiU* Utitiabonu.cr Holuptoc.Non quod mulieri,idfm pugt; ^- . piUo.Excontrarijs:frugalitacbonu^luxuriacnwitma AcÃ¶tralies. lum.Simalorumcaufabelluweft.critcmendatio pax.Si

ueniom merctHr,qui imprudes nocuit,non meretur pr Â« mium^qui imprudens profuit. Ex repugnantibus : Qui ^* repugn! eÃ Htw,fixier.! non eft. Excofequenttbus.fiue adiun Ex'confe* ftK:SiittjiitiafÃbonum,Teae iudicandum.Simaluper quentibus pdia^o ejl fatUndu.ldem^ retrotNee funt ilia bis difÂ» pmiliaddeo^buicloco fubijcienda,cum er ipfa natural liter congruantt Q^od quis nonbabuit ,nonpcrdidiU

fini Indubitdtd, urn habent pent- fignomm mnmtiiik^ um.Sed hiccconfequentid dico Â«;lt;oA!s9Â«.'f^^f''^ ^'â'âgt; â quÃ«s ppientU ionitdt:iUd fequentid ÃTrayd/dV/^^i^l^^ fofledfdÃ©ldfunt^dut futurd. tjeefim denommbuf^^ xiiHiUocet enim^ut uoluerit,lt;}uif^,dum uis rm^ 'fâ^ mdnifeÃd fiti dppdredtq; hoe temporis, itlud ejÃ Â»^ rnedtdq^ non dubito htecquoq^ coÃquentid, qiumuiii^ prioribus dent drgumentum dd ed qud: fiquÂ«it(iir:qgt;âgt;' â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;rum quiddni duds Ãjccics effÃ¨ uolucrut: Axioms,utff^

Oppio : Qt{osedncercinuitosinprouincidninoiifigt;t*^ ' Ad,in, it,eosinuitosretinere quipotuitf Temporis,iiiVerri' _ Sifinem Pruetoris ediÃ«to a^rtmi cdlcndÂ£ Idmur^ ^ non Piitium quoque ediÃ¤i ndfidtur d calendis htutUtr Quod utrunque exemplu td!eefl,ut idem in diuf^ft^. Ã retro dgus, Miedt. Confequens edi enim cos, ^^ dud non po tuer uni, inuit os non potui/fe rctintri. i^^, quoque qute in rebus mutudm confirmdtionemprsfl^ busductintur,quÂ£propri/generisquiddm uido'^ De inuentio lunt, cruoedntU'^os^d^txid^HAÂ«, Cicere^'^â^ **^â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fub eundem rdtionem uenientibus, fortitertt^/^âi^^'^*

tibusiunxerim: Si portorium Rhodos locdrc^lt;gt;^^iâ*^ eÃ¼, erHermocreonti conducere : er quod dift^tt^ neflum, er doccre, vnde Hld non bde rdtione didi,r endens idem, Domitq A fri fintemid dl pdehrÃ¤ : dccufdui,uosddmndflis.EdlinuieÃ© confequens,cri'ââ^ fx diuerftsidem aÃendit, ut quin/udum ndfei dicihi'^

ÃRÃTÃR. LIBER V. 505 bocip/Ã¹m et dfÃcerefigniÃcdt: quid iefieÃ¼ omne quod ndfcitur.Similimd eÃ bis drgumentdtio, quid colligi fogt; ais,Ãue i lent ex bÂ« quiefdeiunt/d qud eÃieiuntur, dut contrÃ¢t eaufisÂ« quod genus d eduÃi uoednt. Hf c interim neeeÃdriÃ¶ Ã* unt,interim plcruÂ«que,fcd non neceÃdrio.Ndm corpus Ab euennsÂ» in lumine utique umbrdm ficit, cr wmbrd ubicunq^ eÃ, ibi corpus eÃe oÃendit. Alid fuwtjUt dixi, non neeeÃdÂ» rid,Hel Htrinque,uel ex dlterd pdrte: Sol colordt,non uti qÂ«f qui cÃ eolordtus, dfole eÃ. Her pulucrulcntum fdÂ» eit, fed nee omne iter pulucrem mouet : nee quifquw eÃ puluerulÃ¨tusjcx itinere fÃ.Quae ittrm^ put tdlid Ãiwt. Si fdpientid bonton uirum facit,tonus uir eÃ utiq5fdpi* ens.ldeo^ boni eÃ boneÃe fdceretmdli, turpitertet qui boneÃe fdeiunt, boni: qui turpiter, mdli refte iudiednÂ» fur. At exercitdtio plerunq; robuÃu corpus facit,fed â â'** bot 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;non quifquts eÃ robuÃus, exercitdtus t nee quifquis exÂ» ercititm Â»robustÂ« eÃ Ã® NÃ©e ^uid fortitude f rachat ,nc WÃ¶rtern tiwicitmtw, quip^uw mortem non timucrit, uit fortis erit exiÃimSdus.Nec Ã capitis dolorem fucit,iwÂ» Â«tills bominibuÃ® fol eÃ.Et bÂ«c ud bortdtiuum genus mÂ« xime pertinent. VirtuÂ« fdeit Iiudem, fet^uendu igitur t at uoluptÂ« iMflt;tmi(tm,fugiendd igitur. Kefte dutem ma nemur, edufds non utique db ultimo ejfe repetendds, ut Meieat vtiwdmttciwnemorePelio.

504 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT^ Ciuomodo pcrucnirequo Ubet,retroaufiia legcntAa licet. His iUui ud^ccre ridicul'Mt putdremjnifi co Cico A comuga ^.^ uteretur,quod coniugatum uoclt;!utt,ut:eos quireoiiu Ãum fdcidntjuÃe facer et quod certe non eget froiilt;i'gt; ne.Quod compafuumesl,compifcere licere. QÃ¿ui^ hiec^quit uelexcdufis, uel ex ejfcientibusdmmâdf,^â no nomine uocdnt iK^aiacrÃd efi exitm * HdmntclÃ¹t usuH com- â^^â*^ trdÃ¼dtur.quÃ m quid ex quoque euenidt,A(if4â*

paratiuis. td uei comparÃ¢t lud dteutur, quit mdiord ex mmo'i^âââ minora exmdioribuifpdridexpdribusprobdiittCo^ Ad conieftu ^^i^r conieHura ex maiore : Si quis facrilegiumf^b Amaiori. fdcietc^ furtum.LxminoretQjti facile de pdÃwiiK^^ ; A minori. titur,peierdbit,Â£xpdritC}uiobremiudicdnddinf^^^ ^ Pâââ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;niam accepit, or ob dicendum falfum teÃmonium^*

[â terum occidere licet,c^ loris c^dcre. Ex mmoreSir rem noilurnwnt occidere licet,quid latronemi Ex P^f'' Ojiit poena aduerfus interfedorempatris iuÃd til, ^^* demaduerfus matris. Quorum omnium traflatus uer^ Ad finition Ãttt(rittfyttogifmis.lÃamdgisfinitionibus,dut q^^^ nmâ; . busprofumt.SiroburcorporibusbonumnoneÃiâ^ Amaiori' Ãnitos.SifurtumfcelitStmagisfacrilegium-Si^'quot; .^ A. pin. tiauirtus,GrcoiuinetMia.SimundttsprouideiiÃ¹^''âi , tur,adminiflranda efl rejfublica. Si domus sediÃt^'^r ) ne ratione non potefl, quid agendum in naudhunt cur Cr armorum fAcmihi quidem fufficerethocgtnu!,j( inffeciesfecatur.Nam ex pluribus ad unum, (ytx'ââ' ad plura(itttdeefl^quodfemel,crfepius)ftlt;^^P^^â^^

ORATOR, LIBER V. 50Ã totum, fx gfttrre lt;td j^cciem ,exco quod coWwet, ad id quod towmeturj Â«t exdifficiUoriiiK di ficiliord,cr tx longe foÃtis di propiord, z^x di omnid qÂ«Â« contrd Pâ'Â°P*'*â Ixc funt/idem ratione drgum(ntd ducutur^ Sunt entÂ« cr bxc maiora er minora, aut certe uim fimilem okiÂ» tient:qux fi profcqiutnur.null)Â« mt ed condiendi mo'^ Comparati diM,ln)initaejlt'nMÂ«rcriMn compdrdtio,iucuiiord,gYd omsfpecies. tiora,iBag(s tiecejpria,boneÃiora,uti[;ora,Scd omittd* ^^^^ muf plurd,ne m earn ipfamjqtMm Â«ito,loqiMcttatcm inci Exemp^u. da. Exemploru quoq; ad bxc mÃnitiK eft numerus : Ãei paueijJimaattwgam.ExmaiorejproCecMinat QMi ex A maiori., ercitmarmatosmowet, isdduocdtionemtogdtorum.no ^^dj^^i^iigi. HidcbiturtHoH[j)c/Exfaciliore,iwCloditÂ«ner Curios ri.

Item; Ac Mide.an fdcHe Ãeri tu potuerK,cum is fd^w no Ãt,cuituconceÃiÃi.'^xiijÃciliorei VideqUiCfoTube- mouet,idad to,ut qui de meo Ãd^o non dubitem, de Ligarq audcam âquot; â âÂ°4jÃâ¢ confÃ®ttri.Et ibi: An Ãieradi Ligario eduÃd nonÃt, cum mouiffee Â»W apud te locuÃ®/it, etidm pro altcro deprecandi.^ Ex ^ ^jj^^^^Ã§. mmoTt.pro Cecinna : Ita'ne Â«ero feire effe armatot fat f)l,ut uim fartam probes, m manut corm inciderc non

tÃ fdtki Ergo,ut breuiter contrabam fHWimam,ductwiÂ« Argumenta tur argumenta Ã perfonis, cduÃsjlocis, tempore ( cuius ^ RÂ«Â«Â«Â» tres partes diximiÂ«, pr/cedens, coiiwiftuw/in/equens) facidtaiibutj quibus mÃrumentum fubiecimus, modo, id fÃ,ut quieqj Ãt fafluwi,/initione, genere Ãpecie, diffiren ttbm,propTqs,remotione,diHi)ione,iMitio,ineremcnttf, pmma,fimiliLiÂ«jdi|?;miltbus,pugnantibus,confcquenti tff/fltcitmibuSje^jSjeHÃ¨tWjiMJdtiSjCompardtiwteÂ»

qua in plurcsdeduciturj^ecies, lUud adijci(nitgt;'^''â^â tur, duct Ã¤rgumentd non Ã confeÃis tantum,Ãi ^^^** A fiftionc' Ãdigifp^ qMm Graci kkÃ¶^ V7cd^tfifj uoeÃ¤nt. Et quii^ ex omnibus ijfdem Iods, quibus[uperiorÃ¤, cuidtotH^â^ Ã^cdes effe poffunt fidÂ£,quot ucra.NÃ¤mfingere fnx ^ co, id eÃ proponere aliquid, quod fit uerum fit, Ã¤ntp Mtquaftioncm,MtiidiMiet. Deinde id de quoqdn^ tur,fiteereidifiunile. idquofittciliusdccipidntitment^/ ; nondum ficholum egreÃi, primo fidmiUiribui nhtgiiy ufiitdis cxemplis oflendÃ¤m : Lex eR, Quipurentcs nequot; , alucrit,uincidtur.TSton uUt quis,^- uinculn ttibÃ¢mi^ i

_rccufidt. Vtiturfidionc,fiimiles,fi'nifi.insfit,firtip-^ ^-opmioetc ^^^^i^^^^j^pi.^ jll: i[l^contrd optionemfiortiii/in,p^ J mnnidem pettit,fit tetnplorum euerfiionem. Plurbnnm'} â eet resuirium habet coiftrd/criptum. Vtititrb^^^ pro Cccinnd:Vndetu,dut fidmilid,dut procurdtot tutti' Si me uillicus tous fiolus deied/fiet, nÃ¶ fdmilid deiedH^^ ut opinor,ficd dliquis de fiamilid. Si ut ro ne habeat qquot;i'^â fieruu, prater eum,qui me deiecerit. Et did in rodt^. plurimd.VerÃ¼ eddÃ¨fidio udlet er dd qu^Htdett^fi'^

, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Und corn fito confiUo nefidriorum hominÃ,quolltâ'

Philipp- quot;â¢ xit,hdcdcrepoffiet iudiedre, codemndrctLiitiii^^quot;^ nam.Et dd dmplificdtionem : Si hoe tibi mterKfquot;quot;'â'''^ illis immdnibus poculis tuis dccidi/fict. Sic ter fit ^i^i?â^ ' eÃ« hdberÃ¨t. HdSfierÃ¨ cades dccepimusprobdtioninn Â«* uniuerfium, quds necgcncrdtimtrddcrefidteil, ett^e^ qudÃ¼bet edrum innumerdbilis drgumentoru copia od

â ORATOR. LIBER V, 507 TuÂ«i,(juod qui funt ficere comti^duo paritÃ© r [ubienvnt VRcomodi,ut er nmiv,m dicermt^er tdmen totu. vndc plurimi CM m bos mexpItcAWIcs laquÃ© os incidcrut.ownÃª ttii quem ex Â«igenio fuo fotueut babere conatu, ueIwt Â«Jlrifti certk leg!Â«Â« Â»tMCMlw,pcrdtdenwtt,f t mag^rtwtt yfÃ)icieHtcj,natHram dweÃª /equi dc/iertMit. Nam Ut per fc non fu|5cit [dre^omnes probationer, aut Ã perfonir, Â«ut rfbm pfti;qiiia utruq; in plutÃ´t diKiditur,ita ex an* tccfdcntibiÂ«, Ã§^ iwmS w,ct infequentibus trabenda e)Jc Ã¢Ã¯gttmcnta,qui accfperit,protMiÂ«4 in bocpt mÃrufl uc, Â«t quid in qiw^ caujÃ¢ dicendm pt,f x bis feiot, prefer Hin cum plurwie probationer in ipfo eaufanwn coplexu reptÃ¯i4twr,ita ut put ewm alia lite nulla cSmtwier. EÃ¦Ã§ pnt potemiÃimf, er ngt;vamÂ£ obuiÂ«, quia communibtÂ«

ex precept 15 propria inuenirnda/Hnt.HocgcniÂ« argu periftafis mÃ©toruwfanÃ¨ dicamiM ex circHnÃanlt;ia,qMia7r^Isao'ipGf?cisapptl dicere aliter non poÃuniMtnirl ex biSjquÂ« cuiufq^ dufo qu^d itaad-propria furtjUt in illo adultero facerdote, qui lege qua hsrÂ« rei. ut wniiÂ« feriwndi poteÃatem babebat,fc ipfe feruare uoluÂ« ^aâtrahiquot;poamp; it,proprium cA controuerftje dicere: Non uniwÂ« nocenfe uideatur, tcmferuabi{,qMiate dmliijbjadMiteramoccidere nonli^â¢quot;,'ââ¢â celit.Hoc enim argumÃªtuw lex facit, qua probibet ad-/ cft.qreTheo ttUcratn fine adultcro occidi.Et iHa in qua lex cft,ut arÂ« j]jâ^â,J^ gentarij dmidium ex eo quod debebant, folucrentjcreÂ» lUÃ Ammo* ditumfuutn totum exigÃ¨rent. ArgentaritÂ« ab argenta ââfj*â*** rio foliduw petit. Propriu ex materia eft argumentum peUat, id ertditOTK*. idcirco adieftum f jfe in lege,ut argentarius *Â°quot;j^\d'rem totum exigent. AduerfuidiioÃ® enim non opus ftijfe dKipoffit,

508 M. FAB. oyiNT. INSTI^^,^ kge^cufin omnes pnierqium ab Ã¤rgnit^rijs ^Â°^â!''' j gendi iuf hdlcrcnt. Cum multii Mtem noui^i^^^ genere materie, turn pr^cipue in hit qufÃioÂ«i^^^gt; feripto confiant ^ quii uocum eÃ¼ infinguUs lt;^''^Â® â , frequens,ddhuc in coniunilii miigK- Et h^c ipr P ^^ tm legmn,dliorÃ¼mue fcriptorum,uel congrueMiâ^''^gt; repugnantium complexu uArientur neceffe e^, e^'^ rei,dut ita iuris,qiu ÃÃgnum eÃ¼: tJon debui tibip( nidm, nunqudm me dppettdÃi^ ufurdm non dccepip, lt;* tro d memutudtuies. LexeÃtOuipdtripÃ¯oiitibid^ non dffucric^exhdres fit- Ã¯^egdt niÃ pdter dbfobttuflâ Â» quid ÃgnifLex dlterd:Proditionis dAndttiS,euin di^ cdto exulet. Cicero pro Cluentio P. Popilium,C^ Ti riumCutidm dicit non iudieij corrupti,fcd dmbttm qi ddmndtos,quid Ãgnifquod deeuÃtores eoru/m, fgt; ^^ er ipÃ dmbitus ddmndti,Ã¨kgefint poÃ¼ hdneuid^ reÃituti. Uec minus in hoe curÂ£ debet ddhiieri,^^^ proponÃªdum,qudm quomodoÃt quod propoÃerupf^ bdndum.bÃ®ic omnino uis inuentionk Ã non indior,c^^ Et Ariaote' prior, ^dm ut tcldÃtperudcudÃnt nefeientiquidpit^gt;

^â^ pEd^uideris cuireiddhibenddfquot;^^ A^nx Â«oh boe eÃ¼, quod comprehendi drie non poÃit. ld(e^^^ titeff^rem f^â*^â^^^^^^'^^â^^â^â^^^^Â»SP^^^âbus Argumenten^' 1** fuoloco^ milibus utentur, dUus tdmen dUo pturd, quibm Â«^^ nere amp;^ inueniet.Sit exempti grdtid propoÃtd coiuroueipi, hat re nuu' ^â*^ minime communes cum dlijs quÂ£Ãiones bubettCuÂ« rÃ¤ettemagi Thebds euerti/Jet Alexdndcr/mucliittAbulds.qi^ibÂ»^ ^edou'^ ^^^^^ iâ^^^â^ gt;^^buÃ³ The/JdUs dediffe thebdnosconÂ»

tinftitur.HiM.quicierdtufiMcommilitioTliffpiloyivmjn^unMpr*' I doniuitbis ultrÃ³, poÃcd yeÃitÂ«ti Ã CdlJindro TbeWi 31, Homero â Tepofcidt TbeJJalos, dpui Ampb^ftionÂ« 4gitur,cÂ£n* Aiphcftas

JliocxorituTjdeittrebellidicctUibusTbcÃaliSjbocreÂ» gna, populos, pnesgentiHmat^Hrbtwcotmeri.lnuentc duw cotri eÃ¢,quo diÃet bic caufa Ã exteris, qui in po tepatemuiftoris uenirent,neccircaprobationÃ¨re$bi retied circapropofnionem.Ã¼icamus in prmis in eo qd miuiicliÂ«ndedÂ«cipotcft,nibilualcreiusbeni,necarmisIâ$^VÂ®^''' â**.

1 ludiciumno eTepta,nifi armis poÃerctmen .ltaq^ttbiillaualeant,djducitur. non eÃe indicÃ©,ubi index fit,itla nibil ualerc.HocinucniWnc ^'HâÂ« endÃ¼eft,ubi adbiberi po^it argumentw. ideo ciiptiuos g^'-pt'r j^, fi in patra redierint,liberos eÃc,^abeUo parta no nip ma,daufum codÃ© uipoÃidearttttr,?ropriu er Wui caufc,quod Am/^^y^âJ^â^g pbiagt;oncs indicant ,ut alia apud Ccntwmuiros,alia a* miles. , puiiudiccmpriuattMninijflem quiÃionibiÂ« ratio fit.iusmcorpo Turn fecundo gradunon potuiÃcdonariauiHoreiiÂ« Â»â'^^^* quia id de mum fit eins quod teneaf.iiw quod pt incorpo fpernnftnu xAf Â»apprebedi manu non potwiÃe, Hoc repenre diÃteiâ^^j^^ quot;â

510 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT' tins, ^uim aim inueneris, argumentas adiuuart, nt^* UdÃt conditio hxredii, alia uidoris, i^uia ai iSâ*quot; '^ ad hune ra tranÃat. Proprium demde nnwi^f^^^ â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;publicicrediti tranfire ad uidorem non potuiffe, ^iigt;lt;

quod populiu crediderit, omnibus debratur : CZ ^ââ'* diu quilibet unus fuperfuerit, t^eeum totiiu fuigt;',nif creditorem, Thebanos autem non omnes in Alexinit^ manu fuiffe ,aocnon extrmfocus probamr ,([ue i^ ed argumenti, fed ipfum per fe ualct. Tertij loei fiti prior magis uulgarii. NoÂ« in tabulis ejfe ius, idÃ©^ âÂ»gt;^* tis arguments defendi poted, J^ens quoqiu Alcxnt^ t? h^^^^a ^^^ ^â^^^ ^*^^^^ â^ dubium, honor ar it cos, an dcceperitlt; uana aliqÃ¼a lUudiamrurfutmateriieproprium^cg-uclutnoufcoÂ»* fptdonatio troucrÃÂ£,quod reÃitutionerecepijfeius, ctiamfu^'to^ ^^^^^^f^trittttTbehimi uidentur, Hiccr^uid Ctff^ rct, quod fei ueUtqu^ritur. Sed udpotentiÃima apud Ampbi^y^ poffeJUos ^â^ â^i'*^ tradatio ed. H/c non idcirco dico, lt;iuoi iÂ»* aÃ¶texiftima atilem hor um locorum, ex t^uibus argumenta dutuii^ Ijui^^ilÃ¯o' tur,cogmtioncm putem, aUoquinec tradidilfemÃ qui non po -ne ft qui cognoucrint iÃa, ft citera negligant, petf^ xerant. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^^ Ã protmus at que confummatos putent, v niftiquot;

cÂ£terK,qui mox pneipienda fuut, elaborauti^Â» j mutam quandam fdentiam fe confecutos intcHii^* I Inuentiones Nfc enim artibus editis fadum ed, Ut arguments* nbsp;nbsp;(

rerumXar ueniremus,Ãd dida funt omnia anteoium pracip^ cumentoRt nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, . ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

anrearteui reiitur,moxea fcriptores obferuata, eg coÃ»tai eiu faiffe, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;derunt â¦ Cuita rei probatio ed, quad exemplis eoriun

HuUuw Hoiwm, er quod diftiwn non Ãt^mueniwnt. Ar* ti^cf Ã® ergo itli, qui dixerunt. Scd bubendu bis quoque gÃ¯lt;tti(ifft,pcr quos Ubor nobis detruduseftÂ» Num quÃ priores benejÃ®cio mgenij pugub inucncrunt, no* ^*^^ bis er non funt requirendu, er notu omniu. Scd non Ta JâÂ«Ã¯Â«TÂ». mugis boc fit eft ,quÃm pulit(iruni didici/Jc, nip cor^-pus cxcrcititione,cont'mentii,cÃ¼gt;K,dntc omniiM* turu iim:tWâ ÃMcontra,nelUi quidem futis fine urte profuerint. lUudqMoquc ÃudioÃfloquentideco* gitentjueque omnibus in aufs en quÂ« demonÃruui* inusjcunftu poj}e reperiri, neque cum propo/itufucrit Yj.|,â; ^f^jj muteriu dicendijerutundu /ingulu.eruclut ojliutim tim.Quodil pulfundu, ut feiint, un ud probundum id quod intenÂ» BjÂ»Â«Â«* Hâ* diffl!Â«,forte reÃâondeunt, nifi cum difcunt, er udbuc â¢dÂ«niius'* ufu curcttt.lnfinitum ennn fuciet ipfu res dicendi turdiÂ» AM* quÃ§rÃ»t tutcm,/i femper ft necc^e, ut tentuntrs uwwnquodquc ft,; uKos sc eoruw quod fit upturn, utque conueniens, experiendo domos in* nojeumus. Nefeio un etium impedimento futurs |Â«nt,^oftiain* niÃer unimi quxdumingenitu nuturu,er ftudioexÂ» terrogandi ercitutuudocitus, reftu nos udeu que conueniunt cuuÂ» omma pul-fejennt, Nurn uteuwus uocis plurbnumiuuut fociuÂ» fant. tu neruoruw ceneordiu, ft turnen turdior munus, ni*

1 fimÃicftis, dimenpsâque pngulfs, quibus quÃ¦que uox j nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ÃÃ¼bus iimgciidu /it,dubitct, potius fucrit effe conten'^

tum co ,quod Ãmplex cunendi nuturu tulerit. ItubuÂ« gt;â eo quo iufmodi prÂ«eptis debet quidem uptuc/fe, ercitburu! modo intrntu rutio doSrinx , fei boc exercitutionÃ§

JU M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. multi cofe^uendum,ut quemidmodum iUorum irtifiaif etidmÃ iUÃ¨/gedient, mdnuf tarnen itU if fa confueMii^ ttead grauci,acutosjnediosqi horu fonosfertur,fic ori torii cogitationem nihil moretur hue uirictat argimtn torum er copia, fed (puft offrit fe,er occurratâ.tJ^^ liters fyUibiiÃ feribentiumeogitationemnonexi^xti fie rationes j^onte quidam fequantur.

DeExemplis. CAP. XI. TErtim ef genus ex hif qui extrmfecus adiucx* tur m caufimfirjeci uocant m^i/^y/iac, quo no taKfupra^ Â»line O'generaliter ufi fwtinoinnifimiliamappofitio modÃ¼ expo ne,etÃecidliter 'm his,quÂ£ rerum gefiaru autoritje nt didtuG^c ^ttnturÂ» fjofriferÃ¨ftmilitudmetnuocaremiduerunttq^ quodexenr abiUis ^ci.SoÃHdicitur,hoc alterum,exemplum,quitiq me^Ãerify'' ^^Â°^fi'â^^^eÃ,eriÃ¼udexemplu.tiosquofaciUiUptO j Iet faftS eft poftum expUcemui, utrunque ^Â«tP^y/icc ejfeerti^* txtmploca ffftt^ifi^ipfi appeUemiM exemplum, Nee uereor,nelt;^^â piatur.para arrepugnareCiceroni, quanquimcollÃ¢tionemfp^'^ quid fn^S^q ^exemplo. UamidemomnemargumentationemHui^ padio ufurz ditmduMparteis,'mdudÃ¯ionemerratiocinitioneitt,xi CMia Eraf P^'^'''^ây Grlt;ecoram 'm f^xd^lyfixro:, er iTeiX/Ã¼^ Cicero de in rÂ«,dixerunt^ f^xj^amp;y/j.lt;xjHT0^iKiv Imyorfl''^ ?quot;â*â¢ â/ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ilia, diu plurmum eÃ Socrates ufus, hanc habuit m^â

fonat ag CM plurdintcrrogÃ¤ijcl:, qu^efdUn dduerfdnonec^jr greffionem, effet,nouiÃimc id de quo querebatur,in ferret,cuif^n^* nulTnieÃ¼to leconceÃiffet.ld cÃ'mdudlio.Hoc'mratioc'taationefÂ» nÃ©,^d eaarf rinopoteÃ, Sed qdâiÃ¼icinterrogaturficfcrÃ¨fumiixf' nbsp;nbsp;'

OK KT o K. LÃ^EK V. ^Ã jmtaamv rofij^ mum; nÃ³nne qiwd optimum? concedezetur .QÂ«â âu aductU' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Vl

t^uws gencrofiÃimiM t nÃ³nne qui optimus ? ez pluruiw numcoprc' tivnicm modÃ¼. Deinde cuius rei grutiurogutum cÃ,qd 'j^^^^j^ Â®* homo i none is gencrofiÃimus qui Optimus ? Futendum sic Ariftotc l ent. Hoe in tedium mterrogitioe uJet plurimu, in ori ^â^^â'^*^ tione pcrpetult;tdij?imileeft,etcnimfibijpfc rc(^5dct ord aj^jj pj^adi tor :quod pomum gencrofij^iwÃ¼ ? puto quad optimugt;CZ Bâ¢? ââ^j, equus, qui udoci^imus: itu bominum, non qui cUritute junejm Ã¯du *u[ccndi,pd quiuirtute maxime exceUct. Omniet igitur ftionf Soera ex boe gmere [umpta,ncce(J'c eÃ aut fimilia cJ]c,dMt dif ^^âfpuutwni fimilii, dut contraria. Similitudo ajjumitur interim CZ busK quoti ad orationis ornatum, Sed iUa cum res exiget. Nunc ca quot;Jj^^^â ^*^' 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;que ad probationem pertinent excquar. PotentiÃimum miliaris efti

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;autÃ« eft inter ea,qult; funtbuiu$gencrKgt;qdâpropric uoÂ« hoepeeulia*

1 o â¢ n nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;n nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, ntergautwÂ»

camus exemplum, td ejt rei gejte, aut ut geÃiCjUtuts ad ^^^ ut ex ov terruadertdum id quod intenderis, comemoratio. Intuc busPUtoni* * nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;r f p nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. cisinquibus

dumtgitur totumfimileJtt,an ex parte,ut aut omma ex ,r,ducit per' co[umimus,aut que utilia erunt.Simile cÃ,iure occifus fqna Soera* eftsaturninus.ficut Gracebi.DiÃimile t Brutus occidit ^Â«uap* liberos proditionem molientes,Manlius uirtutÃ« plij mor paret.

te mulftauif.Contrarium, Marcellus ornamenta Sgt;ra- vwequot;Appia* \ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;eufonis bojlibu s rejlituit, Verres eadem focijs ab(lulit, ni lia. de bel

tt probandorum er culpandorum ex bis confrmationÂ® to^dtwgradusbabet.Btiaminbis quic futuradicemus, utiUs ftmilium admonitio c(l,ut ft quis dices Dionyfium l ideirco petere cujlodes falutis fuse, ut corum adiutus ar i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;mis tyrannidem occupet,boc referat exemplum,eadem

5â4 M, F4B. 07INTÂ« INSTI'T' funt cxfmpld interim totaÃmiUdjUt hoe proxiigt;iiÂ»^gt;r tnterim ex mdioribus ad minora,ex minoribus ai '^^^ ra ducuntur:Si propter matrimonia uioldti urba (i*^ ExLÃ¯uÃ¼ li, f'^f^^^yl^^^^fiff'iadulteropareil Tibicineseuindbf^'^ Â»â¢ ab urb. he diÃeÃiÃent, publice reuacatifunt, ^uStomdgifpff^ cipes duitatis uiri, ey- bene de repub. meriti, emn ii^' diÂ£ ceÃerint,ab exilio reducendHAd exhort at ionium roprifcipueudlent impdrid, AdmirabiUormfamine quam 'm uiro uirtut, Quarefi ad for titerfaciendu lit' cendatur dUtjuis, non tantÂ» darret momenti Hordtim er Tort^udtus, quanta illamuUer, cuiusmanu FyrrhdS edl mterfedut^ Et ad moriendum nÃ¶ tam CatoerSt^ pio,qLucretid.Quod ipfum eÃ¼ ex minoribiuad maio'' ra. Smguldigiturhorugencruex Cicerone (nam utdi potiur:')cxcmpld pottamuf.Simile hocefl pro Muraria. Etenmt mihifpÃdcciditl ut cum duabur patritijSjdtero improbifimo,dltero modeflifimo at g; optimo uiropdc rem, fuperaui tarnen dignitate Catilinam : gratia Gab tam.Mdius mmariaPro Milone: Negant intuerilucoii fÃ^fas ei,qui afe hominÃ©occifumeffe fateatur, In^ad tandem urbe hoc hominesÃultiÃmidiÃutantiitempe^ eaqueeprimum indicium de capiteuidil Mareidlt;â'ââ* tiffortiÃmi uiri,qui nondum libÃ©ra eiuitate,tarraÂ» fÂ«' puliRoma. comiti/sliberatusedl, cumfuamanu [orore effe mterfedlamfateretur. Minus maioris: Geeidinon $P, Melium,quiannond leuadajadluraqi reifamiliari!, quid minus ampledliplebem uidebatur, infifrieionÃ«iii' fiuÃâP^'^fff appetendi, Cf cteterdi deinde: fed eiiin(aKf

4fÃ¯ctcnimdiccrccupcitrilt;tmpâ¬TicMloH6crlt;tJJct')cwiMlt; ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;y

ncfindum AdwltcÃ¯ium in pulwimribiw-L^totuj in Clo- ^^^ J.^^^ ^â^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

diumlocus .DiÃmile plurcs ciu^w b^ct,JÃ¯t enim gene- teft. Pomp'. rf,modo, tempore, loco,ciÂ«tcrisc[;,t)cÃ¯quÂ«fcrÃ¨ omniA Cicero prÂ«iudicilt;i,quÂ« de Cluentio uidebAtur fu^A, fub uertit.Contrdrio ucro exemplo cenforiJ notAm,UÂ«ddn

do cenforem Afriednum, qui eum, que peierdj/e conto ptis uerbis pdldmdixiÃetjteÃimoniH ctiim pollicitus,p quis contrddiceret,nMÃo dccufunte trdduccre equu pdfÂ« j^on f^;,, â¢^ fw effet. Qttf quid crunt longford, non fuw uerbis ex* contvanÃ¼ eft pofui. Breue dutem dpud V ergibu contrdrij ^ââf *âiÃ^*ââ^Ã¨rbo cÃ¶ at eft: AtnoniUefdtumquotementirisAcbilles, autorisatieÂ« Tdlis inbojle fuit Pridmo. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^tÃ³nÃ³lv

Queddmdutemexbis quÂ« gc(ld[unt,totdndrrdbinvM, tumguidem ut Cicero pro MilorteiPudicitiu eum eriperct militi tri- 'Jjquot;^â'â*^â*4 bunusmilitdrisin excreitu C.Mdrif,propinquus eins fuisautÃª, cÃ¼ Imbcrdtorts interfedus db eo eft, cui uim dfferebdt. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nofttw ibis

Ã¯deereenimprobus ddole(cen$ periculoje,qudm perÂ» ^^m, lemen petitUTpitermdluitjdtq^bunciUe fummus uir federeâÂ»exprimir folMtumpcriculolibcrduit.Quf ddfignifcdre fdtis crit,quot;quot;â^ ut idem de pro eodemitÃ®eque enim poffet tUc Huid Scr-uilius ,dut P. Udfed, dut L. Opimius, dut me confute, fenitus non nefdrius bdberi,fi fcelcrdtos mterfei nefds epet. KÂ£citddiccrttHr, pront not dcrunt,uel utilitds edufx, tot decor pojbuldbit* Lddemrdtio eft eorum, quffxpoÃ«ticu fdbults ducuntur ,nifi quod bis minus _ Â«jfmutionis ddbibetur, cuius ufus qudlisejfe deberet, Ã¼qn Optimus Autor, de mdgiÃer eloquentie oÃendit Â«

â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. 5'^ Wâ ^A^â OyiNT. INSTif', 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«,â¢quot;^^3^ ^^^âffiffo^g^Â«e4jemmor^otKrfptÂ»^ U nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;miginer tlo fxefnpÃ¼mutit^ hoc indices,nonfinecttufti ftuUif U quemix /Chulis doiiliÃimi hommes mcrnorixprodiderufit/'^' i â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^m PutrisuldfccndicMfÃ¤ mstrein neciiui//et,if^gt;'â^'^, â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;homtMm/Ãªtentifs,non folum diuma, fid etiÃ¤in fip^^ â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ãma dexfcntentildiberdtum.IÃie quo^fdbuhe,^!*^^' I guidas ait ^â^fiââ^ -^^f^P^^^ightemnonacceperunt (iiMliiâ^^ * HeUodum ^1*^ ^â^^â^fffprimus Mtor He/iodus) nominetMien Alpâ fabuhsfcri' ^â quot;^^^^â^f't^ifff^^^^of foknijpricipm paffe, getii ^â^flfâ^lt;gt;rumcrimperitorum,quicrÃmplicii(S^UieÃ^^ ^gf^gquot;i,â f^â*^^ââ*â^â^gt;^ ^ââP^^^^^^'^P^dtrffÃ¤cite bis ^uHus delf' riorfult^No dbMiur^eonfentitint.StquidemerMeneniusAgrippai Iwlade^ ^i ^^^^^^â^â*''^Pâ*dffhuihigrdtidmtrdditur reduxiffe,Â»'â pim etphaÃ´^â^^â^^^^^ds humants aduerfus uentrem difeordÃ¯ snela. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tibus fabulÃ¢t Et Hordtius, ne in poemate ^uidc/i/bgt;ef'Â»^ ^Alrv^uide ^^'quot;^â^usgenerisu/Ã»mputduithis uerÃbus: prxfa.Chil. ^ oHm quoduulpesagroto edutd leoni.

^'f^^^Ã^tg' â d^'^Â°i^^^'^â^d UOcStfCr cUCÃ¼i'ffTTOiHTÃ¤fj,et ut dixi,^drid ex Arifto' lU-uStKÃ¢i/^^NoflrorumquidamnonÃmereceptoiuuÃm phaniscom nomme tipQlog4tioncm,cui confine edi tisaeoi/ilÂ«?i'^ nientariis m nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;d

heiligt datÃ¢t ffuf mad quod edi fabeUd breuior,cr peraPtegan-eâ^ fabubsw' quot;Pf^^^^^- i^osnofirum, mquit, onus,bosclitellas.P''âââ' fabant q^st- l^f^ff exemple uireshabet/imiiitudo,priecipue^d^Aâ** (Stpdeirra' ducitur citrauHamtranslationummixturdexreb^^l^ . a^hhbuseÃ¶' ffparibusiVt, quiacciperemcampo confiteuei^t^ pofftx erÃ¤t, candidatis,^quorum nummosfiipprefiosefiÃªputanb quot;â^ Vt^'h^Ãªn fÂ»ilt;^'Ãf^fffâdfâffPf'//^gt;/f^huiuÃnodiiudicesinfi'fiiffâ^â' fer mottes fÃ nam â ^aSaÃH,quam Cicero coBationemuecat,lo^^'â^

o K AT OK. LIBER V. 5'7 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;]

VcjjCjUdt pitrentur,Tcfctfrefokt. Ne^bowwiMm modo inter fe opern fimiliiÃicaÃtHy, ut Cicero $ Mur^na ft cit-.Quod fi Ã¨ portu foluentibu$,âqui iiim in portu ex 41-to wuebuntur jprxdicere fummo ftudio foknt, Ã¼quot; tfW* fcjldtum rntionenijcr prÃ¦donunÃ®.Ã¼- locorum (quod Â«4 tuÃ¯4 fcrt,Â«t bk fduedmUt,^ fade pericuU, quitus nos perfiMiftifum/mgrcdiantur) quo me tandem durno t^t oportet, propÃ¨ wm ex mdgnd idftitionc tcrrcim utÂ» dcntem,in butte,cuiuideomdximiÂ« tepeÃdtes effe fubeu dÂ« ? Sed 0- 4 mutk, dtq; etittm wwntww interim buiu/gt; modi ducitur.Et quonidm/Ã¯milium dlid faciÃ¨s, in tdli rd hone idmonendum eft,r4rius eÃe in ordtioneiUud genus,quod tinova Greci uoetnt (quo exprimitur rerum, dut perfoMdrum imago,ut Cdfius;Quk tÃ^m fdctc pkÂ» nipedk fenis torqucns)q id quo probdbilius ft quod in tendifflu$,utfi dnimumdiedÂ« excolcndujimilitudine utd rk terriÂ«, quÂ« neglcftd fentes dtq; dumos, cxcultd fru* ftweredt: Autfiddcurdreipublicieborterk ,oÃenddS

dpes etiomformiciÂ«^ non modÃ¨ mutd,fcd etidm pdrud pto Cluctia 4niffldlid,incomuHc tdmcnldbordre. Ex boe genere du flum eft lUud ciceronktVt corpa noÃrd fine mente jtd ciuitds finekgc,fuk pdrtibustut neruk de fangume, o* wtmbrk uti non poteÃ.Sed ut bac corporis burndni pro c.\uÂ«ntio,Ã®td pro Cornelio cquorum,pro Arcbid fdxoru quoq eft u[uis fimilitudine Jlld,ut dtxt,propior d,ut reÂ» â¢âffâ fâÂ« guberndtore, itd milites fine imperdtore nt-bil udkre. SolÃ«t tdmÃ« fdUere fimilitudinÃ¼ Ãiecies,ldeo^ idbitthium ta l]is indicium. Neq^enimMthfWM Uti-Â»

518 M. FÃB. QVINT. INSTIT, Hor noud qtixm uetus ,fic dmicitiii: uel ut UudÃ¤niiiiiit pccuniim fult;m pluribut Urgitur, itd quieformM. VK bu funtm his fmilia.Urgitionis,^ uctufiutÃ»yUisqitiit longe diuerfit, pecunia amp;nbsp;pudicitia. ItAq; in boegenÂ» re maxime quaritur, an fmilefit quad infertur. Biinm itt Hits interrogdtionibui Soerdtii, qudru pduli intefe d mentioncgt;n,cduendum,ne inedute reppondede^t dfni Aefchinem Socrdticummdlerebondie Afidfu Xeno' phontis uxor,quod Cicero his uerbis trdnjfert: Dtemi hi quafo ICenophontis uxor,fi uiemd tud meliusbniedt durum,qudm tu habet,utrumne tuiim,dn itliui main- H' liuf,inquit. Orndtum muliebrem pretij maioris bdliâ^i q tu habet, tuumne, dn iÃ¼iut maUs- rÃ©pondit, dhut nero-^Ãª^fis ,inquit,puirum iÃ¼d meUorem hdbedt q tubai^jâ utrumnetuum uiru mdlis,dn iÃ¼iut f Hicmuliercruiuit, merito: male enim rejponderdt, fc malle aUenum 1 fimm.'Ndme^l idmprobuni.Atfirefior.dfietfiâ^^ le duru fuum talc efie,quale illud effet, potui fit puiâ^ rcffiodere,mdUc Ã uirum fuu talcm effe,qudlii tntliot^ fet^Scio quo [d dm inani diligentid per minutiÃinti^-^ tet fid Ãccuifie,zj- aliquid efiefmile minui,ut fi'^ mini,er marmorddeformatdprimd mdnu-.aliq'â^^ ? ut illud :'Kon ouum ta fimile ouo,'Et diÃmiUbiu Wr nbsp;nbsp;,

mile,ut formica er elephdnto, genui, qafunt anifi^ Etfmilibui difimile, ut canibui catulot, et mdtrUxt^ dot,diffÃ¨rut enim atdteXontrarioru quo^ aUter ÆÆ pi oppofitd,ut node lucii aliter noxid,ut aquafiÃ¿ febrimUter repugnatia, ut ucrufalfa: aliter ^^*

tit dura non durk . Sed quid bxc eld prÃ¦feHÃ® fropopi tummignopcrf pfÃ¯tâiÂ«fÂ£int,norfperio. lUudcftdnnoÂ» tiindMjdÃ¯gunicntet mdgk dwei ex iure fimili,Mt Cicero in Topick Ãi cui domus ufus Jruftus rclidus fit, non reÃi tuÃ¯ubxrcdi,fi corruerit, quunonrcÃitiwtfcruufi dcgt; ce (]f rit .Ex cotrdrio, nihil obÃdt quo mwiiw iuÃÃ¼ indtri moniu fit iuÃe eoeuntium/tidmfi tabulae fgndtac no fwc rint.NibilcnimproderitfgrtitjJetdbulaKjfi men tem nu Tabuls.qnt trimamp;nijnonfuiÃcconÃabit.Exdifimili^qudlccftCicc Tonis pro Creinna, ut: Si quk me exire domo coegif et lt;rmi$,bitbcrc dflionÃ¨fiquis introire probibuifet, non baibfÃ¯cm.Difimilidflcdeprebfndllturjnopiqukatrgcn -tumomne lcgatuit,uideripoteÃ Ãgnatamquoqjpecu-nidmreliqui^e,ideoftici(iuodefttti nominibusddriuo bife creditur. AvotXo^Ã®ap quidÃ Ã fimili feparduerunt Â«os cdm fubieftdm buie gentri putdmus. TSdm ut uÂ«um dSSto ad dÃ©cernÃ©e deeem dd centu^pmile certe eft, er ut bo- rchii fubidc Ãis,Ãc malus ciuk QHanqudbaecHiteriusquoiÃ¿procc ÃgjwfitÂ» Aert (blent .Si turpts dominÃ¢t confuetudo cum fcruo,tur fis domino cum anciUd : p mutis dnimalibus Ãnk uolu-ftiÂ«,idcmbomini. Cuireifacilime occurrÃ®t exdiÃimiU-bus drgumentdtio.Non idÃ© cÃ dominu cum dncilla coif-fc,quod domina cum feruo.Nec fi mutk jink uoluptdS, rwionobilibus quo^j, imÃ´ ex contrario, qa mutk, idea Â«bntionabilibus,Adbibctur extrinjecus wedufam et du toritw.Hitc fccuti Grxcos, d qbus aÃ§io'^t? dicutur, iudi cia dut iudiedtioncs uoednt Â» no de quibus ex edufa diHd Ãmentid tft Ã§nam ed quidÃ« w exemploru locum cedut)

;tO H, FAB. oyiNTÂ» iNSTIâf' fed Ã ciuid itd uiÃum gentiiin,j^ofulif,fifi(t^gt;'^^^quot;, â cldris ciuibuijiUuÃribui poctii, referri pote^, ^'â^^ quidcmuulgodicld^ er receptd perfudÃone . ftneufufucrâmtieÃmioni!i.SuntenmeluodAmoudfÃ tiord,etidmquodnÃ¶cMfis dccomoddtd,fedlib(ri^Â° ' O- grdtid mcntibui, ideo tdutum diÃ¤dfdÃ¤d^t ^ââ^ hoiicÃiÃimd.dut ueriÃimd uidebdntur. An uero nv Vide Chil. incomodK uiu differentem,non iuudbitedruniplt;^r nafdquot;'*'quot; '^^^^ ndtionum,^Uie fletibta ndtos, Mtid deÃm^ios pOf feqwintur^ Aut Ã miÃricordidm comendcibo biiififi' hlproderit cjuod prudentifimdeinitdi Athtnt^* animo no edm pro dfjvitu, fed pro numme dccepiti N*'^ feptempr^ceptd fdpientum,nonne^uofddgt;nuittW^ exiÃmdmttsi Sieduftm uenefdj diedt ddulterd, dn i^^ HXdtonis iudicio ddmndtd uidedtur, lt;ftti nutUmd'^â ^ rdm non edndem effe uenefiedm dixit^ Idm fentenli]^ dem poetdrum non ordtiones modo funt re fertile uf bri etidm philofophorum. Q^ qudnf inferiors omn^d prÂ£ceptK fuis dc Uteris credut,repetere tdinm^âf^ tem d plurimis uerfibus non fdÃidierunt. Nf^ f/i bUe excmplum,Megdreosdb Athenienfibus cumif, vide Laerz lumme contenderent^uiÃ¼os Ã¼omeri uerfu, 5 tdUttd'Hi Sol2m^ââ^ *^o^ w* ogt;K^i editione reperitur,ftgniÃcdns Aidct^^^^ uesfuds AthÃ©nienfibusiunxiffe,ed quoq^ t^uf mdgÂ»'^ ceptd funt,hocipfo quad meer turn dutorem hdbent,^^ lut omniumfiunt,qudlee{lt vbidmiei,ibiopes.it''â ^ m7v^m7 feientidmiÃ¼etelles.'EtdpudCiceronemtPdresdute^

maxime 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

^mtttr, Neq; enim duri^ent bÂ«c in Â«ternum, nift uen omnibw uidcrentwr.Ã¯onitMÃ¯ Ã quibufditn/t quidem m parte prmW,clcoru)Â« autorit.Â«,qwÂ£ cft ex rcÃjonfis, ut Socratem efje fapicntij^imu. ld rurum eft, tarnen utitur eo Cicero in libre de HaruÃ^icum reÃ) onps, er in cocio ne contraCatilinam, cumpguum louis columns impop turn populo oÃendit.Et proLigario,cum caufarn C.CÂ« faris mchorÃ«,quia dij hoc iudiemr int, coptetur. QjÂ«Â« cum propria caufÃ¦ funt, diunia teÃimonia uocantur ÆÂ« aliunde arcfJ?untur,argutncnta.NonniMiq eontingit iÂ« dicK quoq; aut aduerfarq, aut eitÂ« qui ex diuerfo agit, diflum aliquod aut faÃ´lum apumere,ad corum quÂ« intÃ© dimult;,pdcm:Propter quod fuerunt qui exempla,et bas autorittucsjprobationuminartipcialiÃ¼cÃearbitrarcn.' tur,quod eu non inueniret orator, fed acciperet. Pluri* mumautemrefert.'Nam teÃis er quaÃio,cr bis fimilia de ipfare,que in iudicio eftjpronuMciant. Extra petita,nip ad aliquant prafentis dijceptationk utilitatÃ¨ in-gtnioapplicantur,nibilper fe ualcnt.

Ã¼eufuargumentorum, CAP, XIL HAEc ferÃ¨ de probatione uel ab alijs tradita, uel ufu percepta in boe tempiÂ« feiebam.Kee mibi Ã* 4utiatft,tttcafolaej?econtcndam,qutniÂ«iÃ¨ bortorod, qtttrcniuni,er mueniripoÃe fateor,qudC tarnen adiefta l nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fucrini jÂ»on multum ab bis abborrebunt Â»Nunc breuiter

quÃ«admolu fitutendÃ¼bis, fubiiwgaÂ» TraditÃ¼ ferÃ¨ cft, argumenium oportere eÃe confeÃum. Dubqs enim pro bari dubiaquÃ® pof wip; Q^t dom tarnen,qux w alteritÂ»

JiÃ® Mi FAB. Q^VINT, INSTIT*, rei probdtioncm ducimiu, ipfa probindÃ¤ funt,ocdii^ uirum^erdi cnim ddukera. Priai de adultcrio cci^^ tendam e^l, at cum id cerperit e/Je pro certo,fiAi^ ti argumentum. Spicutum tuum in corpore ocdjt fini^ turn eR: negat fiium. vtprobationi profit,probini^ eÃ¼. Iliad hoc loco moncre inter neerffiria ^1,11^1 firmior.i,qtu qm ex dubiffadla funt certit.Cfdt^*^ commi/fa e^l, cruentam cnim ueflem habuifÃ ^ââ'^ tarn grdue argumentu ftfatetur, q ft conamcitat- H^, ^dibi^fum f^ f^^gt; '^â^^â^^ ^x cduftspotuit cruentd effe ueÃi!gt; ^â tnfi caputm negdt,hiccdufecdrdmcmponit,inquoftuillt(sft^â faXxDf.AatS^li^ifj ^ fcditrntibui ruit.tlon enlm uideturmitl^f ^ cant. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;mentituruifui/fe, nift dc/ferd/fet td pofte deftniU,i'

fiteretur â¦ Firmiftimis drgamentorumftngulis inÃ^'* dum,inftrmiord congreganddfint, quidiÃ¼d ptrfp tidno oportet circunftdntibu/obfturdrejUtqiiJ^^I^â'^ dppdrcdnt,hxc imbecilld natard, mutuo juxiboffiâ'^' tur. 1 tag; ft non poftuntudkrequia mdgiidnofaâibâ^' kbut quid multdfunt, quÂ£ dd dufdem rei proilt;dilt;Â»f^ omnid /pedant,ut ft qua h^reditatif grdtia hoinio/^ cidifti dicatur:Htereditdtcmftierdbdf,(y mdgi^'quot;'^ 1-tarnen reditatem, et pauper eroi, amp;â tumdxieaerdââ'ââ'â^â dppelldbarii,cr o^nderoi eu,cuiu{ hdres erÃ¼,^ ''â^^ taturum tabulas feiebat. Singula leuia faut er coÂ»quot;'ââ' HocL Head ^^'^quot;quot;^quot;^/^quot;quot;^^ffcJcetttfetMHftnottutftM^ff^ feribit Phale UtgrandinexQuÂ£ddm,argumentaponerefatiiaoÂ»quot;quot;â nr^umftora ^ââ^âââ^ funt,ut cupiditas edufd /cclerfffait,^ââ^ lemaqutdiÃfl 1^^ f^a ^rd, quantum eftÃ¯ciat in anitnis Miiii^t^

CK KT OK. LÃ®BtK V. Ã^ mScoviofÂ» 1 lis dOrftioÃ¯iw c pÃ¯miori crunt ipf^C Ãl^s Hlt;ttf biwât Â«fient necc' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fl

dfcoTW .fi non nudes lt;?â¢ uclut edme Ã3oli.itos ATtlM eÃe re ut grandi nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;l

dennt. Multumetilt;lt;mKfeÃ¯t,fidÃ¯guniÃ«tonitcÂ»nÂ«r Â°^âiâquot;outfuâ'mcn utTum boe ex inuidiÂ« fit ,dn ex iniurid, dH f* dmlitw, jouis qui Â«5 Â«etus dn nowtint, dducrfMsinfcÃ¯iortnijpdÃ¯rmjfMpeÃ¯io- Â«amp;Â«â¢ Ycm, dlicnutn,f rep 'niquÂ«m.Suos bdtent onmid iÃ d trd* ftdtiM jC dd Mtilitdtem pdÃ¯tis etus ,qÂ«dmtucmur ,Ã¯c-ferenddfunt. Keetdmen omnibus fcmpcr^i^ux tnuene* rimuSjdTgumentis onerdndus eft iudex^uid c tddiuni Â«ÃtTUÂ«t,cÃdem detrdbunt.Neque enitn poteÃiudex credere pris eÃe ed potentid, t^Uit no futdnnMfuÃtecYf, qui dicimiU' in rebus ucro dpertis drgumentdri tdm ft Ãultum,qudmtrtcldrif mum folem mortale lumen tn-ferre, His quidamprobdtionesddijciHnt,qUiWroÂ«NH* Mortale Lu TiKÃ Ã§uocdntjduftds ab aÃeflibtÂ«. Atq^ AriÃotelesqui^'^^u^j'J,'*^ dem potentiÃmum futat ex eo qui dicit,fiÃt wr opti- morttur Lee mus,quodut optimum cÃ,itd longe quidrm,fcd fcquitur XmfXr7 turnen uideri. indc enm ilia nobilis Scauri defenfio: Q^qd nurq tx* Varius SucrontnÃs dit, Aemilium Scaurum Remput. â^fquot;,jiâe'uÂ» populi Romdni prodidiÃe, Aemilius Scaurus negat. xta id Euri' CuiÃmile quidam feeiÃe Ipbitratcs dicitur, qui cumAri ^ââj^^ââ^^,â Popbontem,quo accufunte Ãmilw ertwinw reuÂ« crat,^Jej^.J,^^ wterrogaÃet, an is accepta pecunia Rempublicam pro 9dÂ»i. diturus eÃet, is^ id negaÃet. Q^cd igitur, Miquit tunonfeciÃe$,egofeci? Intuendum dutem, C? qui fit dpud^ufm^jjfpjjj^ ,0-,'^quod iHi maxime probabilc uideatur,Ã¯t(juircndum. Qua de re locuti fumus, er m proamij y- fudjoYiÂ« prucctptis, Altera ex ajÃrmatione

5Z4 . M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. probdtioe^^ Egohoefeciftutnihihoedixijii, itÃ³ji* cinmindignum, a- ÃmHÃ¼, quxnon ddcntieeÃcilÂ»^ dem orationi, o- fi devint ,niultum nocent, non ti'^ hibendii funtinter mugnd proefidid^cumhocindi^ edufd fieri ex utrdq; pdrtc fimilitcrpofiit, lUeÃnnii* res ex fud cuig; perfondproidtiones,qutecrcdiiilni''^^ tionÃ« fubiedÃ¯ hdbÃªt, ut uulnerdtus, dut Ãbo orbaujuo fuerit dliu deeufdturm g nocentÃ«jqudndo fi negotii^ W' nocentifacitJiberet eu noxd,qui admiferit. UX^ ^ P^ tres dduerfus liberos,zr dduerfus fuos ql^ neeeÃdrioh dutoritdtÃ« petunt. Quffitu etidm, potentiÃxxd dri,igt;' mentd primÃ³ne ponendd fint loco,ut occupÃ«t iÂ»iigt;quot;gt;Ã^^ fummo,ut Me dimittantidu pdrtitd primo [untmojâ Komeried dij^ofitione in Medio fint 'Mfirmd,â^xiiii^ *ââ nirnif crefcdnt.CiUÂ£proutrdtiocdufiecuiufiÃf^rquot; .

bit,ordmdbuntur,uno,ut ego cenfeo,excepto,xt^r ti/fimisddleuiÃimd decrefedt ordtio. Ego 1^^^^âquot; demonfirdfie cotentus itd pofui,ut locos ipf^â^^^r^ ^^)i poÃ^tndpertiÃimeoflenderÃ«, Quidiex^^x âI - nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;uerbofius, lt;}uibus pldcuit,propofitd locorucoH^^ ^^

M.iterid,quo quÂ£q; rcs modo dici fofiftgt;Â°fi^j Â» ^^aOo^Ea^ *â'^f^P^^â^â^â^^^Mdlebdtur. ^dMZr feredpP^^ ^[J biuf ufurpet Miuridm quid in dudritiam, quid in teÃem ^'^/% ,jf, locos coles. tesdtHicÃ¼Sdicendumfit,EtdehifoiddicereiX/ 'L^ r,ca CkeroÂ° t^^ff^ hercule,qficontrouerfidru,quÂ£funt,qx^^lji^, nis aliquato funt,quÂ£ftiones, argumenta, fententidf uerfamuramp;â^Pf'^â^â*^quot;âââ^Ãª'^â^^gt;f^Â°rumuelutfi:des,^^^^ magis 3cd' ocs oftendiffe confido,plurimas tarnen-QlP ^iumurt

OKATOK. ÃBER V. 51$ tins fdiieniufuât, quid iecUmationej quitus dipugnd forenfem udut pr^piktis exerceri fokblt;Â«wws,olinj id dk lid uerd imdgi ne ordnii reeeÃerut, dtq; dJ foUm copo pj^p^jtj ea fut uoluptdtcm Herwis eurent, non dlio mÃ©diusfidius ui tdl quitâ ty tio iieentiÃ^ quo mdneipiorÃ¼ negotidtores formÃ©e pue ^ââ^^ roTUinuiTilitdtecxcifdlenocindntuÃ¯. Ndm ut iUirobur adpiU mit' de lieer tos ,bdrbdm^dnte omnid âo* dlid,qujendturd *^JJ^*^ propridmdribus deditjpdrumexiJlwndnt dccord,quÂ«^ ut f ibms. fortid^i liceretjforentjUt durd moUiutjitdnosbibitutn oritionis ippm uirilem, o- itUm urn grifte, YobuÃe^ dice ndij tenerd qudddm clocutionis cute operimus gt;nbsp;O' , d um le wilpnt ,icnitidd, quantum unie dnt nibilintcr- Cofutatio. eÃe dÃ¯bitrdmur. Sedmibindturdm intuentinemonon Â»irj^ddoneformofioYerit. Nectdmduerfdunqudmui nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;\

debitur db opere fuo PYouidÃªtid,ut dÃ©bilita inter opti mx muent iÃt. Nee id ferro J]^cciofumÃeriputdbo,qdâ prouidentia fi n iÃcr etur, mo nÃ rum er it. Libidmem iuuet ipfum *â^^,^ro^ cjfammiti fexus tÂ«enddcium,nuÂ«qudm tdmenboe con- pfo Deo. tmgit mills moribus regnum.ut fi qud pr Â«tiofd fecit, fe Ã©crit o-boni. Quipropter eloqucntidmlicet bdne (.ut fentio enim diedm) libidmofim,refupini,uoluptdte dw- ( ditorid probent, nuUdm e(fe exiÃimdbo, quÂ« ne mini-mumquidemiÂ« fe indiciummdfculumincorrupti, ne di tim gfiuis,cr fdnfti uirijojlendct. Anuero Ãdtudrum

Â«tijucj^piftores^ cldrifimi,cum corpord qudmj^e-ciofiPimi jtngÃ¨do,pingÃªdÃ³uc effngere cupe rcnt,nun^ inbunciiK;iiq.unterrorÃª,ufBdgodm,dut Megdbyxum Ã»s^xuxÃ¢dri A^'l^^w exemplum opÃ©rÃ©s furnere fibi,fcd dorjpboron

JiÂ« M. FAB. QVINT. INSTITÂ« nnchi Bi' iHum, dptumuclmilitig^udpjiljefir^fdlio^Â»^'*^^'''^^. fÂ°nt,^tncnÃ¼â^â^gt; beUicoforum, et dthletdru corpora ueredKon fÂ» nit fubindc Ãmiuerint. Nox quiordtorÃ«fludein:u cffiifgere^iS^' gaby^s unâ iquot;^gt;Ãd tympMi eloquentie demus. ig^r (tr â^^y^â^ 'â exducibus Ãitu:mit,ddolefiens,quA^xxiepoteÃ,copoMt[^^^â''ââ K^mÅl^ t^tionÃ« ueritdtK,mituruiqi frequenter forcnfinti etm tang paruin minu pu^nlÃdimn feboU uiÃ©loridfreilet,Crfrgt;^â^^'â' hocâThucy- tdHd^c tuerifridt, (y preceptor id miximet*iS^^gt;^ didis lib. i. inuentu precipue probet, tdx ut âtd peiord imienesi^* q^e^'^fa^ ^^ ducuntiir,itd Iduddri'tnbonis gdudent. Ã¯idcidtdquot;^ Truya vi^vu U eR,qdânecefrdridplcrunq; Ãletio trunfeunt, neetÂ« gt;nbsp;'M^xTi^nnjcendouideturinterbondutilitdi. SedheedrÂ»^'â^ ^^x^^.^d^d' bistrdHdtd funt operc,o- in hoe fepe repetedi' ^^ i Ã§/MÃMuojKÂ«' dd or dmern incept urn reuertdmur. tti^ aii^U^. CAP. Â»* n^Ttinea/i' TT^ E^utdtiodupheiterdccipipoteÃ.t^dmCi T âÂ»^{^ZÃ¼^ JLV defenforii totd csl pofitd in refâ*t^^âlt;âf.â^Z Ã§iÃosSxxtif que dicldÃtnt,ex dinerfo debent utrinq;diÃoânâgt; âoedorypL ^^ P'^o^rie difrolui,cui in edufu qudrtui rocoMtSui cui.Sedutriufq^Ãmilicconditioedi. tgt;}eq;nero Jib.^4.*a s. ^lt;^'isrdtiodrgumentorumin bdePatriefrtijot^l^ confirmdtione,neclocorutn,dutfcntcntidrH,iiii^ i^

conprfnd[ione,neciocorum,dutjcmeitiiAiÂ»,-~ L^ rum ey Ãgurdru dud conditio efr A fr Uns P^^^^ rdi CoÃ®latiocle pdrsmitioreÃ®hdbet. iJonfinecdufdtdmÃ©difr'-i â SSÃ P^reMitum (quodeicerofepe^dM^ fumSidiffiÃ re,qdccufdre.Pri)nu,quodeRre{iud/tinpnei ' A^ kdefendire fiiturenimtmoinodoMriedifroluiturjeudecfr Â« ^Uim ac.u ^^ ^^^ plerun^i uern eÃe id,quoi oeietenCâ^'^^'^

Jft,Jfftnlt;iâ't, wnJprÃ, cxcÂ«ft,deprfcrtur, moKi.tt, mi'nmtj.tufrtdt,dcjjiici.it,dfridccit. QÂ«dre mdireftitfe Ã¯f/tqjeut pc dixcrim) dimoli eft dftio.Hiw mille Ãc* xiÂ« et dÃ®tes defidcrÃ¯tur.TÂ« decuptor prfmeditdte pie mq; domo dj^rt-PatroniÂ« etiÃ® moptndtw JrfquÃªter oc currittAcettptor dut tcÃc.PdtroniÂ« ex rc ipfdrefeUit. Accuptor crm:Â«Â« inuidÃ¹, et p pilpt pt,miitcri S dicedi tTdbit,dfpiirricidio,ptcriIegio,mcuePdte,quÂ« pdtrono Ufitu Â«fgÃ¯dd fHUt.ldcoq; dccupctiontbiM etid mediocres in dicendo fuÃreerut,bonus defenfor ficmo,nip qui do-qucntipÂ«nus ptit.NÃ ut quod fentio pmclpniS/unto cÃ lt;iccuf4re,qÂ«dm defendere,quinto fime^ q (mire uvl' Â«en, fdcilius. Plurmum dutÃ¨ rcfcrt,zy quid protulerit AiucrpriiUjCr quornodo. Primum igitur intuedum esb â id,cÂ«i rejjionfuri ptmus, propriumpt cius iudicij, dn dd Â«upm extrddecerptum.Ndmp proprium, dut negdtt-

, dHm,iÂ«t dcpndendum,dut trdnjpcrcndum:extrdblt;ec in ludicijsferenibilcÃ.Dcprecdtio quidemquÂ« eftpneuk hoeÃ¯M*n5 Uj^tciedefenponis ,rdrdddmodum,er dpud cos fotos exformulis indices ,q!{i nuUd certd pronuÂ«cidndi pormd tfuenturj^^^j'^J'pjj' qÂ«dnqiIlÂ£quoq;dpudC.Cieptrrm,cz Triumuirospro atbitrioamp;x i diMfrfdiâumpdrtiumbominibÂ»sddlioncs,etidmp preci- Jâ'^â?*â* i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;bus utMntur,ddbibent tdmen pdtrocintd,nip boe non por cognoftuat.

1 bP'miedfPfndcntisesb^diccrf, Quid dliud egimus Tu l bcTo,Â«ipmt quodbic potep,nos poÃemus ? Quodp l nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;qunnio lpÂ« j prineipem,dliÃ¼mHc,cui utrum uclit liccdt,

1 iictmwij^^UK^ quidem morte cum pro quo loquemur, 1 0fiÂ«etitMt4mcn|erMdndiÂ«ncpcucl t4fm. PriwuM

JiS M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. omnium non er it nobis cum dduerfdrio, fid eutÂ» iuine, . deinde formd deUberdtiute mugis muter ie, q iuUddit, ( utemurtfuudebimus enim ut luudem humunitutis potitu, J qu'dmuoluptdtÃªultionisconcupifiut,ApudindicÃ©sqÂ«^ demficundum legesdiHuros finteiitium,deconfiÃu i pr^cipere ridiculum cR, Ergo quÂ£ neq; negiri,neqid

tr Ms fern poffunt, utig;, defcndendi junt, qudiMgt;n^ RfuMntc^fi^^^'*^^â^Ã'^^^^^**^^* NegMdidupUcÃ«ollendiiiKif (a cadcdum, formAjMt Uo effefdHUiMt non hoc eÃe,quoi fnÃ¤uÃtÂ» ÃÃ´tabelo' ^^ncq;Ã¿fendi,ncq-trunsferripoffunt,uti^n[s^ cum,cum po dÃ¤^nec foluft finitio poteÃ effe pro nobisfed ctuftnU' non an^iÃ© ^ â^fi^Ã¯'^tio fuperek.TeÃes trurdMulti in cos iÃ¹^j I Ã um patron licet. Chirogrdphu defimiUtudmc Uteraru diÃerenii' I fedcedÃ©dum ^^^^ââ'^^^â^^^ââ^icÃ´fcfio.Vitimd eRidioniff^ pot? ne nos troucrfid^cu defendendi negMdtue,n5ed locus, f-â''Ã^ aliquÃ¢do te' tio.Atqui qu^dim funt,qud; nec negdri,ncc defi^^'^ ^aniteu. tnnfferri pofunt.Adulterij red ed,quÂ£cuiniioW^â^ fuiÃet^enixdcÃ¤Ãis non erit.QudrciUud ÃtÃ¤tiÃiniff^ cipitur,qdâdefendi non poÃit,ftlentio diÃmubni^rquot; \ quidem eÃ id,de quo iudex pronuntidturus eA.AtÃ^ tn edufdm fit ddduilu,cr tdmen coniundu, imhi'i f' , demdicere,iÃ¼hiliddd quÂ£Ãionein,neccÃcinhii''â^^ dum,ty minus eÃe^quim dduerfdrius diatftdÂ«^*^ nbsp;nbsp;( huicfimuldtioni obliuionis ignofedm. Debet eniÂ» lt;)0' j Kus dduoedtus pro rei fidute breuem ne^li^cntieff' f prehenfionemnonpertimejeere. Videnduinetidm,llt;' | mul nabis plurd dggrediendd dn,dmolienddfing^!^-^^ j

pfHi forint,lut timmoleÃi^ut pedem conferre cm Pâ*^,^quot;^,^ gÂ«liÃ® non expcdiiit.TuwenimtotocorporccnitÃ«diÂ«Â«, Batumi re er ut fte dixcrnUjdetcftafronte puonindum eft. intc^mibuâr'.quo rim ft Ã¯cfohfYcexplÃ¯tc diuerp diftl difftcidiw erit, turi ewnm* MojlriKiTSumcntitcuTO dduerfiriorm urgumentÂ« con Voftemap/ fercmw .fimodobfc Htiulcntiortt uidcintur^ffici poÂ» amp;â*Â«â*âÂ» ttrit.QuÂ« ucro turk tMlcbiMit.diducenda eriwit,ttt pin 10 diite dixi. Erit blt;eres,cr pauper, er mignd pcciMiiA rtppfllÃ¢biirK Ã creditoribut^er offenderÂ«, er mututu* ruwÂ» tibuliÂ« teÃimentifcicb^K. VÃ¯gent uniuerpt. At Ã finguU que q; diffoluerwditm iHiÃimmiiquÂ« mdgnd co

i Vt ft uclnwximx Ãummimriuos diducewtur ,lt;fiwlibtt trinfitu prxbent.ltiij; propofitio (^uoqj/ccumdumbic

i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;utilitdtcmiccorttrtiodÂ£ibitur,utcintMicfinguUoÃcrtdiÂ»

\ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ut fi multiÂ« c.tufit ficicndi quod ir guit, re o dieet dccu*

\ fÂ«0T fuifje, noj non enumerdtis fmgulis femelboc in* \ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tuendunegemut, quid non quifquw edufdm fdciendi Ãe

lerKbdbuit.erÃcerit.Sdtpiuitdmequiddccufdtoricon , gtrere dTgHmentd,rto diJJbluerc expediet. ld dut quod

\ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;erit db dduerfdrio dift tMÂ«,quomodo refutdri dcbedt,inÂ»

J nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tuenl'M eft.Ndm ft erit fdlfunt,ncgdre fdtis eft,ut pro

530 N. FAB. QYIKT. INSTIT.

dere neccffe eA. id quo^,ob/curim tlt;ocaiK,^uodfi^ fo, er ftne tc/lcjdut argumemo didturfadum, fMÃ¼^ turafud infirmÃ¼ed.Sufficit mm^uod aduer/driufiioit probdt.Itcmftad edufamnonperdnet. SedtMenind^ rim ora tarif eiIcffifcrejUtgdiddKtcontrÃ¤rium elft) Autdcdufddiuerfumjdutincredibilejilutfuperilicmitii, (tut narrte potiuf edu/i uidedtur e/fÃ¨ coniuudiHn. (^i dtur Oppia,guod de mÃ¼itum eiktri/s detrdxcrit:A/}gt;e( rum crimen, led ideantrurium ofiendit Cicerajguifgi^Ã© dccu/dtores abiecerunt Oppia, guad hif uolucritldrsi^ endoeorrunpercexerc/tum. Teflesin CoriieliiuÂ»ââeeâi

fator ledid tribuno codicif podieetur, fdcithoe Ciee( InDluini' ^Â°f^P^^â^â'tttf^)^âttdipfefdtedtur. PetitdccufdtieUtf tio. lege Af ^n Verrem Q^CiedUuf, guad fuerdtguie/lardusdpfââf conticom' Cicero ut pro feuideretur,e^dt. Ctetcrdgudprepe/iil fnentar. tur,comuneis locos hdbent. AutenmcoiedurdtUt''^^'^ tur,dn uerdfinetdut/Ã¯nitione,dnproprid:dutgit^di^'â dnmhone/Ã¯djÃ¼iigudj^probdjifihumdndjCrudeliitfCftf terd^guiC eigeneridccidunt.Eag; nonmodofitpeept/' tionibus,dutrddonibuf,/ÃªdintÃ¼toge/jeredilienit^fâ' ,

. Ã^ cndd,dn)jtcrudelis, utLdbieniinBdbiriufiilegtpâ^â^^ ellionis:Inhumdnd,ut TuberonÃ©s^Ligdrium exulf^f^ cufi/ids, dtg; id dge/fdif^fte eiCdfirigno^^dt: inf^y ut in Oppium ex epiflola CottiC reatn fudum. Pet^ / prtedpitesdân/idiof^fimpatentes deprebenduntur â¢ ^ ^uibui turnen/Ã¶rti/Ã¯tmeinud/criSjguad edldutammiiti periculo/Ã¼m,ut didt Cicero pro TuSid: Quis beefââ^ ft ungudfff, dut cuicgnccdi/tue/Ã¯ifnma tnff/u'uftipfP'^^

Ufoteft.ttt cum iure Ãotucrit oceiiere, Ã ^xÂ® â¦wetuiJlâc fe dicutjUe ipfe pojlcriuÃ® oecideretur ? Aut ipÃs iudici* lÂ»iM,ut pro Oppio monet pluribiÂ« ,ne Ã¼lud xJtionw go mw m eejuej^rem ordmem udmittunt. NortuunquAm tuÂ« tncit ^utdim bene coutemumtur ,Â«cltdrt^u4,m kuit, ttcltmt^uA'n lt;(d edufxm nibil pertmeutix, Mdew hoc bÂ» cis fxeit Cicero. SedbxcpmuUtio mtcrim bucufq; proÂ« cedit, utqxÂ«dicciidorcfutlt;ire non pojjumtÂ« ejuxp fuÃt nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.

diendo cxlccmxs.Qttonix uero mxxtw.x pxrs corupmili ââjX^ttto' bits cottÃxt.riwxnducrit diligcÂ«tiÃtme,quid fit in quogt; unda. que quod iÃumitur diÃmule. Id in iure facile depreben ditur.Â£Ã ettim feript w de rebus utiq; ditterps,tanto^ wigs ipfxrertrtit dijjereutix poteft eÃe mxnifeÃa.lUas uero fiwlitudines quxduciMiturcxmutk xnimxlibus, tWtinxmis,facile eft cludere. Exempla rerÂ« uarie tra ' ftxndx funt, fi 'locebunt'.que ft uctcra eriiÂ«t,fabÂ«lofa di cereliccbif. Ãucrx,maxime quidem diÃiwilia. Neque Â«im f cri poteÃ ut paria fiut ornai a,ut Ã NaÃea poÃ oc cifwGrxecb xm defendatur exemple Halsc, Ã quo Meli useR'Mittrfctlus,McliumregniaÃc5latorcmfuiÃe,X Gracebo leges modo Utas eÃe popularcs.Hxlam magi* ÃTÃcquitumfuiÃi',MaÃcapriuatÃ¼eÃedicatur.SidefeÂ» temt omnia,'tient uidÃ¨dum ent,an obt meri poÃit,ne il Vai quiittn reft e fad: um. Qu'i de exemplis, idem etiÂ»

gt; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;am de Uiieatis obferuauium. Qu id autem pofui,refer requoquieque aceufator mododixcrit,buc pertmet. Ht Ã'^ mints ejÃeacitcrlocutus ,ipfaeius uerbaponan tunfi xeti ct webemeiUi ufus fuerit or.ttio!tc,calliÃ© rem

5JX M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlTÂ« noÃrif uerbk mitioribut proferdmiu,M Cicero Cof^ hOy Codicein dttigit^c^ protmus cum ^tuddui defrop^^ ne, utÃ pro luxuriofo dicendum fit, obicÃ¢d eil p^^o^ ierÃ¤lioruitd. Sic er pro for dido pdrcitm,V profK^^^ dico liberal dicere licebit. Vti^ nMtqMm commUt^^ d'Miefl,ut dduer/driomm didd cum fud confimutiK'^ ne referdmui, dut ettd loci dlicuim executioneddiigtfb nifi corn eludendd.Apud exerdtam mihi fuerif,^^^ââ' tot dnitis forum non uttigerit, dbfucris tdndiu, Oâff tdm longo interiullo uenerif, cum his quimforo hildi runt,de dignitatecontenddS.Prjetered in conirididi^^ nibuf, interim totum crimen exponitur, ut Ciceropr^ Scduro contrd BoÃdrem fdeit, uelut ordtionem Hn^fr pdrtis nnitdtut,Aut pluribus propofitionibusit^^'^' ut pro Vdreno:Cum iter per dgros,amp;locd folitfââ^^^ cum Papulenofm fdmiUdm Anchdridndmincidijl^'^ââ^^ finie runt,deinde Populenum occifume/fe, s-illico Vifâ'^^^ uindl:um,ddfertutum,d!im hic oÃenderet,quid^reop ri uelJct.C}uod ellutiquefdciendum,fÃ®eritiÂ»crt^â^^ rei or do, er ipfd expofitione fidem perditurus â¢ ^^ rim per purtes diffoluitur, quad contextu noctiâ^ plerunque id eil tutius. dÃ¿eddm contrddidiigt;'â^{ ' turufunt fingulrjd excmplisnoneget. Conit^ ne dpprehenduntur non tdntu quidutriufquefonÃ^^ pis, jÃªd quid plusprofunt refjondenti. Nequeen^P^ gebit,quodfiepe tÂ»onui,reficrre,commune qui prior ' Ã§it,contrdrium fdcit.Ell enm contrdrium qito fiuf benc utipotcH. At enirn non uerifi/mlf ^^ ^^â^

|ctliÂ« M.Cottctmc(]ccommctMum-Qui(i; bocuertfimi* le cjl tiintwm fccltw Oppiwm cJJccontitu/m? ArtiÃcw duÂ» tem eft inucnire in idionc dduerfurij^u Æ âm femetipfd pU5!,neM,dut pugnire uidedntur, quÂ« dliqiwndo ex re* Iw ipfis mdnifeÃd fuÂ«t,Ht in edwfd CfUdUdiClodid du* TwmfeCitliocofflmoddJJc dicitjquodjÃ¯gnmn nidgnÂ« fd milidritdtk rft/ueticnofibi pdTdtwm,quod [umnnodij drgumentum cft,Tubcro Ligdrium deeufut, quod k in /fried fuerit, et qucritur quod db to ipfe in AfrieS non fit ddmiffut. Aliqiwndo nero probet eitÂ« rei occdfionÃª, miniÂ« confiderdtd ex dduerfo dicentk ordtio,quod deci 4itpTlt;cipuecupidis fcntcntidriwn,ut duftioccdfione dirtndi,nonrrÃgt;icidnt quid dixerint,diwnlociwnprlt;e* fouem. non totum cdufdm mtUentur. Qwd turn uidcri poteft contre Cluentiwm qudm eÃ«forid notd? Quid tdm contr* eundem,qu*m filiwm db Egnutio corrupti iudi* ni,quo CluentiiÂ« Opidnicwm cirewmueni jfet,crwnine eje bertditum ? At bfc Cicero pUgnarc wuicem oÃendit.

Stdlu Acciconfidercs,ccnfro,diligrntrr,utruwccnfoÂ» nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'

rium iudicium grdue uelis eÃc,dn Egrtdtq.Si Egnutij^le uc eft quod cenforesdeccterk fubferipferunt. Ipfu/irt wim Egndtium,quern tu gr duem eje uis,de [endtu cie* tnutiSm dutem cenforim, bunc ipfum Egndtitwi,que nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. ;

pdltTcenforid fubfcriptione exblt;ercddUit,cen[orcs Ml p''0wip0 feniitu,campitremeiecijfent,retiÂ«ueTtwit.llldW)dgk ui Â°quot;*â tiofe dicwntur,qudm deute reprebenduntur, drgumen* turn dubiuMpro ucro necefprio, controuerfum pro co fejfo,coniintMie pluribw pfÂ® pToprio,uwlgdre,fMperu*

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;5Ã4 FJIB, QVINT. INSTIT.

| nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cuum/onÃitutum contre fidern. i^dm er Ã¤U Ã¤cciM

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;par um cautK^ut crimen augcant, qued probÃ¤ndum ^

| nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;defailodiJÃutent,cttmdedutoreqMrAltir,impoÃiii' nbsp;à¥¤

| nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^'^ dggrediantur,prp effÃ¨Ã©Hi reltnqiunt uix dum md^

! nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ata,de homme diccre, qudm de eduÃd mdUnty honiimd*

uitdm rebm aÃignetu ,utfi quk Decemuirdtum itti^^ fet,non AppiMm,mdniffflis repugnene, dicdittquoii^^ ter dedpi poÃa/ummdm quteflionk non intuedinur^o dd propofita rtÃfondedtk. Qtiod urum dHqudndo red^ pi potedl, cum mdld eduÃ ddhibitis extrmfecKi reifet' is tuendd e/l^ ut cum pccuIdtKS Verra reiufortitdG' mduÃrietutdtus contrd pirdids Sicilid dicitur- Sddei^ uerfus contrddidiiones nabis oppofitds prdceptdfuff' Hoc tdmen dmplius, quad circa eds multi duolufudiÃ diuerÃs labor dut Â« Ham quidam etiam m forottÂ»^'^â'' etenim ^ol^fl^ftt rem er odioÃm pratereunt^ cr hispbgt;^''* que, qua: compoÃta domo attulerutit, contc/ui,Ã^^^^, fcilicet uerfdrio dicuiit,eti-Ãlicetmultomagism/choÃs,inf'

. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;bus nonfolum contradidliones omittuiitur,uerunatiââ'n

^ tera parte poÃitt Ali/diligem'alapÃ, uerbtsed'nnâ^'' fcntentiolis omnibus reÃ^ondendum puta/u, f~^^^ ^ â¢infinitum er fuperudcuum: non enim eau fa repf(^'^â tur, fed aÃ©lor, quem ego femperuiderimalimdifertliingt; ut fidixeritquod rei profucrit,mgcnq credatnrhm effe,non caufesfiquandoforte laÃ¼iat,cauff,no/iiiig^^ cu/pd- Itaq; iSc reprehenfiones, dutobfiuritatÃ¼,qui!igt; tRutilium fn tUkBum/uitgaat infifttiiif iti dicendOgqMÃs inFgt;Jigt;^

HfW,dUt mfcitilt; return,ttfrtorum^,et lufulptiltM etiJ, qiulii in Antoniu eft, deeSmoduwur luÃK odijs, ftwU^j^^'*'^'^*' ââ* utiles ddconciliinduwbis,quosin!lt;i'psfdccre uolufrif, odiwin. Alidrej^ondendipcttronw rdtio, er dliqudndo tdmen coru non ordtio modi,fed uitd rtidm,wlttM de* ni^fincfJfttSjbdbitiÂ« rede meufdri fokt. Vt dduerfus Quintimn Cicero non bÂ«c folu/m, fed ipfim etidm prf gt;nbsp;textdm dimijfdm dd tdlos infedutus ed. Prcjferdt enim turbulentÂ« concionibuj Clucntitim QuwtiiÂ«. Nonntwt qium eleiundx inuidid grdtid.quÂ« uff eriw didd funt, eluduntur,ut i Cicerone TridriiÂ« euw Seduri eoltwnndS per urbein plduÃrÂ« uedat e(fe dixitÃgo poÃ¯rÃ³dnqiut, (^ui Albdnxt bdbeo eoldmnds ,clitclltÃ¯ cas dpportduiÂ« '1â^ Et wdgis boe w dccufdtores conceffm cd, quitus con* Â«icidri dliqiuindo pdtrocinij fdes cogit. lUd Â«cro dduer fut oÃ¯s er Ã¯cceptd, er non inbunidtid conquepiogt;fi edUi dequidtdcMi)fc ^breuiifc, obfcurd)fc,di(lulijfe dienn* tur .'Defcnfionis quoq; permutdtio reprebeditur fepe, ut fedt Acciut dduerfm Cluentium,Aefebines dduerfut Ctcfipbotem,civm iUc Ciccroncmlege ufuruw tnodo,bic mmimedclegc didurdmDcmoJlbcneinqueritur.necU nutores ucro in primit funt udmonendi, ne contrddidi ones eÂ«pondut, quitus fdcilime rej^onderi pof it, new ''^quot;' fitlllultmdducÃ¯fdTiuwfingdnt. Ã¯demtw dutem,quoil indximei4icÃ¯e$loct,populdrcs^ fententiÂ« ndfeuntur, miteriim Ã¼cvndi notie quo uolumus duccn(ibm,ut non fit notisamtilis uerfus:

ipÃs nobis, rej^ondebimus. Aluni Accium ^^^âJ.*âjjy Non eft in ^â*' ^(tufM non tigeret, cim dj^ud evm inâ l^^ ' exempio. Â«wr/Jet optime rcfpÃ¼ndcndioptMWf ^^^ â. amp;nbsp;rdtionem,quod illic ed d!cereiuur,quÂ£ ipÃ â^â^jf^ ro eÃent diÃ¼uri dduerfdriÃqui minime ueÃ¼et- R' ' .^ lum eH in exercitdtionibus t^ui faro pripi^^^'Ã^^ us cogitdre ejuid ref^onderi, ^Udm quid ex diuttÃ poÃit.Etbonus preceptor non minus dÃcipuhim ^ re debet,fi quid pro dinerfd, qudmÃ quid profile p^l^^ deriter excogitduit. Kur fus dUquid in feholis pi^ tendu femper,mforo rdrÃ¨, Ã¯idm loco d petitorepn ^^ contrddiilioneuti qui poÃumus, ubi uerd resign^â aduerfdrius ddhuc nihil dixerit^Inddunt tMKUr^ in hoe ultiem,uc Ã¯confuctudinedecUm.Ã¼orii,'^ââ cupiditdtedicendi,ddtit^de fcrelfondentUm^^ ÃiÃmos lufus, cum modi fe ucro nihil dixife, n^d ftulte diÂ£luros,modÃ³ bene ddmonitos db dduerÃfâÃ tigere grdtids,quod ddiutiÃntÃocdntur.Vrequt'Hâf'^ uero, id quod firmiÃmum eil, nunqium bis iâ^S^^âL aduerfdrium fuiffc,quf propoÃtd non effent,Â»if ^ Old uerd e/fe, er ud fdtendum eonfeientid effetf'^ . fus,utproCluemioCicero:'NamhocpcrfÂ£peiÃ ââ i biÃerenunddri, mehdberein di imocdufdmbu^^i , Ãdio legis defendere, itd quot;ne eÃ¼^db dinicis imptn^^t^^^,^ prodimur,ereil nefcio de bis, quos dmicos nabis ss ' trdmur,qui noÃrd cÃ¶Ãlid dd dduerfdriu deferdt.Offf ndm tibiboc renunciMit: Quis tdm improbut fr^- â

lt;utfm f ^0 narrÃ¤uifnemOjUt opmor, wi culpd eÃ¢, nimtÂ» Tm titi i^Kd kx ifji renuMciduit. At quidam contraÂ» diflione non contentijtotoÃ¯ctiiim locos cxplkant.Scire febocdifiuroÃ¯aducrpirtoÃ¯jCritaperJccutHroÃ¯.QuoA . fuftum uenuÃe teporihÂ« noÃris clufit VibiiM CriÃsut, ^â^âÃg^'s uirin^enijiucundicr degantk .Hgoucro,inqu!t,iÃi declamator, non dico.Quid enim attmet iHa tk dici? Nonnurqudm tubs Se* tarnen aliquid pmik contradidioni pont potc A,ft quid neca,Sunt a db4dÂ«erfartoteÃationil!Utcomprcl)enftÂ«n,inaduocdtiP?^Â®quot;â.Â°âiÃ¤' enibut idfldtiwn.KrÃiondfblmiÂ« enim rei nb iUk dida, tilinam qua no Ã nobk cxcogititÃ¦/ut ft id genus erit caufÂ«, ut pro ^^*^'^j^ poncÃ¯c poÃimus ccTtd^extra que nihil dici poÃit,Â«t eu vlot vibio rts fuÃ¯tiiu in domo deprehenfafit,dient nece(Je eft reÂ» conktiptai. w, 4ut fe ignorante iHatam, aut dcpofitam npud fe/ut tlonatam fibi,qHibtM omnibus etiam fi propopta no pnt, Ttf^onderi poteft. At in febolk rede,lt;7 interpeUdtioni but er contradiÃ¢ionibus occurremus/t wtutrunqjloÂ» Â«lt;Â«1141 eft primivm er fccuÂ«dtvm,fimulexcrceamurÃ®qÃ¦ â'^'fÂ«eTimiÂ«,niÂ«iqu4m utemur coMradidione. Non cÂ» Him erit cui repjondeamus. Eft er iHud uitium niwiiunt foliciti/tcircaomniamomcntdluftantk.SuÃieanentin facit iudici caufarn, et frequenter qua Ãatm difta omnÃ« ^itotionem fuÃuli Jent, dilata ipps praparationitm

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;f^'lf'-Ã¯idutiam igitur orator prÃ¦ fe fcrat,fcmper^ itd

dicatjUn^ij jjnpi(j^tj,âg fentidt.Quodjpeut omnid, bt Cicerone prÂ« cipuum e ft. Ndm illd fwmmd cur d fecu* *ââlt;*K tft fitnilkjtdntd^in oratione dutoritas/t pro*

Idtioni^ locum oltincdt, dubitdre nobis nonduictif^' Porro qui fdcrii-^quid pars dduerfd, quid noÃn l^^^ UdlcntiÃimum,facile iudicdbit,quibtu maxima Ã¯tiufgt; ^â occurrendumfit,uclinfldndum, Ordoquidemi/ff^^ nuUd minus affÃ¨rt laboris^ t^dmf dgimuf^noÃn Â«^''r^ mdndd firntprimam, turn qux noÃris opponuntur, futdndd.Si rr^iondcmus,prius meipiendum eH ^ fT tdtione.i^dfeunturdutem ex bis, quit contriidiftioiuÃi pofuimus,dliÂ£ coturadidiottes, custt^ interim louff^â Secundf mu ut vlddidtortmi mdnus,ciu^ fccundÂ£uocdntur,fiinii^ torura. tertiÂ£,fprmd dd euoedndum dducrjdrqinum eritfOr qudrttÃ©,/igemindta edpidtio eÃ¼, ut bis eÃ¹^^ ucre,bis repetere oportuerit.QuÂ£ ratio er ultra Sed iHdm etidm quant fuprd oÃendi,fmplicem ex a/P bus,dtq; ex affirmdtione fold probationem reeipdrrr tdtio^ qudlis eÃ¼ iSa Scduri de qua dixi fuprd. GÃ¿'^j

Hoc inquit, /^â^tt etidm frequentior ubi quid negdtur. quafcunq; in prÂ£cipue utriq; parti,ubift reifummd. Niffridtf^â tur^'ethmR â^^âââ^^^^âââ'^â^^ diedntur, depdueisiudicetur- tf'^ txtranea nbsp;nbsp;probandi refutdndi^rdtioeil, fed ddiuuddduirH^

^um audi eciiti^,ct adomandd. Quamlibet enim fut ad Ã¼t^quot;^ tnrium para quod uolumiis dccommoddtd, tarnen er uni inf^ menexhds '^âââÂ°^^ ^^Â°dam oratory/firitui/npledntur.Ã¼f^ .^ captanda c' iÃt commuÃ¢tes loc^eteftibuSidetdbuliSjdeargui^ ' forte n^ta ââ^^^^d nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;iudieBm ^S^'

tl poffttoc' ^ feâproprifquibusfadlum quodq; lauda/itusfgt;'iâ^ Â«'âO- trajuflum uclMuflum docemus,maiusautwiÂ«iufP tionÃªm^^' ri(ffMtti^fKf,ExhÂ«Mtem(tt^((4 prlt;^lt;^'

ijdKW dnimum iudiciÃ¯, fuÂ«t qui conjirment â¦ Scd prÂ«* hoe Â«ft conÂ«

*ââquot; Jâ^^kIkik qudpionibiu futijciendi eJJent loei ,ut Tkodoro pldcetjdn prius docedus iudex,quammouenÂ» dus,ut pTfeipit Apollodoyult;)tdnqudm perierit txe rd* tiomedidjO- Â«MewmippusedufÂ« utilitdte Jit delibco ydndum.Hlt;cprÂ«cipiunt,qui ipfinon dicuntin foro,ut dÃ®tes * JecurWjOciofisqi conipojitcc/pfd pu^nÂ« neceÃigt; tute turbentur .NdÂ«^ omnes ferÃ¨ qui lege dicendi qudft qult;ddm mjÃeyid trddideyuÂ«t,certis non mueniendoru Myfiftiatra modo dygumentoram lock, fed concludendorum quoqs^âÂ®â ^^ nos prÂ«crptk dUigduerunt, de quitus treuijime prdlo rent quaoâ tutiu.ouid ipfc fetUidn),id eft,quid cUriÃimos ordtorcsâpâgnaÂ«'âst ftÂ«[Je uideam^non tdeeto. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;noXÂ«V

â¢ Quitus conftet Ãpictirenid, er quoniodo yeÂ» nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;mns.no inlt;-

AGituylrÃ¶u'/xx/xajCrdyguinentiwnipfumjdeftyenijlutiruperd* ,que probdtioni dlterius ddbitetur dppcUdUt, er lt;iT*^f^Jj^ ^mtmi clocutionem.Edm ucro dixi duplicemÃx conÂ» nt doctetÂ» f'qwntftus, quod tdtet propoptionem ,coniunft dnjq; Â« pTofmui probdtionem.qudle pro LigdriotCdufd tim igt;*tid,quoj cydt uliquid in utrique pdr te, quod protd* â FiF* ^nunc mclioy cd iudiedndd e ft, quant etidm dij

i4O M. FAB. CLVINT. INSTlf-adiuucrunt.Habetenm propojttionem,nonhibctcont ZaÂ£ ^^â^^^^^ UaeAHlemtperfeatafyttogifmuf .Expn* tek omnem gnAttbm uerotjuod etÃ¼mfoluM enthymemÃ¤ tjuiditrn^ ^â(ff^fortiqrmultÃ³probatioeil. TaleeÃ¼ Cicerone lgt;rgt; trarijs, jd^ Mtlone: Etuf igitur mortis/Ã¨detis ukores, ctiiuf uit^ tuTÃ´nnÃ ret f^P^*^^^^ /*** ^^ r^fiMpoffi, fiolltis , Quoi guidon v/lJj^K^x uo fildmab'qudndomultipb'citrifolet, uteÃ¼dbeo^, ff tabanc. proeodemreofitdlum: QÃ¿emigitur cumiliijtiigrtdii noluit, hutte uoluit corn Ã¤b^uorum guerebt, ^uemiurt, guem loco,quem tempore non efl Mfus,hunc iitiurilt;i,iiii quo !oco,dbeno tempore, cum pericub capitis non didi Pro eten' ^â^'^âi oecidere, Optimum autem uidetur enthymenuHt phonte. genuscumpropofltodiflimili,uelcontrario,rittiofiili* ,

iungitur,quale eH Demoflhenis : Nonenim fiquidunt ortum ^y^^ contra leges fadlum edl,id^ tu es imitatiitidcif cote conuenit poena tiberari, quin Ã¨ contrario diin^^' multo magis. Nam ut flquis eorum damnatuse/fli gt;nbsp;* ha;cnon/cripflfl'es,itadamnatutnifltufueris,nonfo'd ^a'^ide^ ^^^^^^^' ^pbhirematos,crquatuor,crquinqu^t^^ rhetorica at bib'll fÃ¼llte funt partes Ã quibufdam, Cicero m^^ quinq,- deflndit,utfltpropofltio, demde ratio ent^ quidditfe' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. ' , . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, .

rat,ab en' djjumptto,^ etusprobatto,qumtacomplexto.i^ ^ymemate rointerim erpropofitio nonegeatrationis,err * â ^ ptioprobationis,nonnunquametiam coplexioneepigt; nonflt, ey quadripartitam,ey tripartita etbp^rtit^quot;' quo^ fleripoflÃ¨ratiocinationÃ¨,mihietplurigt;nif gt;gt;ieââ^ FfolSmodo tubus Mtoribut trÃ¨s F ad flummum uidentur.

ktur, tertium, ii^d potcft Hclut ex confenfu duoruni Â«MCccdewiion.Uit erit primd 'vntentio,fecwnii i^um* ptiojtertwcowiexio. Ndmeonjjrmdtio primÃ¢t de JÃ¨ciw dÂ« partÂ» exorndtio/i/Jtm tedere po^uMt, epiÃ¯but (Â«b* jj^hetor t ijciiwJtur.SumdmiÂ« dute ex Cicerone e^ume^ pdrtiu ex* emplum:MeIiiÂ«gÂ«bcrnd(ftÂ»r cd, quÂ« cofiÃ¼o regwntUTt quim quÂ« /ine con/Ã¯Ho ddminiÃrdiUMr Â» Hdnc primirn pdrtÃ¨ nwmerdt/dm dtinctpj rdtionibtÂ« uir^s^e^ qÂ«S* copiofijimis ueriK dpprobdri putdt oporterc.Hoc ego totS cum [ud rdtiane wnimi puto, dltoqui fi nÃ¼io pdrÃ¯ Iquot;lt;gt;ta ra* tft, eft dutem udrid rdtio, pUres pdrtrs effe iiedniurÂ» AlJumptionem demde ponit :Nibil dutem omnium rerÂ« mdiiK, q omnis mumduf ddmmijlrdtur Â« Huitw djjumptt onis qudrto tn loco idw porro wducut dpprobdtionem, de quo idcm,qÂ«odpprd.,dico.QKmto inducut loco com plexioncitt,qMÂ« dut mfert foliwn quod ex omnibus pdr* tibw cogitÂ»r,boc modoÃ¯ConJÃ¯lio igitwr mtwtdiÂ« ddmini jbfdtÂ«r:dÂ«t twtti wlocÂ» cum conduxcrit breuiter expo wdufÂ«rit Ãtionem er dj^umptionÃª, ddiiwgit quid ex bis conjicid tur,dburc modÃ¼: Qijod jÃ¯ meliiw gcruntur quÂ« confi lto,q qw fine confiÃo ddminijbrdmur,wbil dutÃ© omniS rtrum melius qomms mÃ¼dus ddminiÃrdtMr, cofilio igi tur mundus ddmmi^rdtur. Cui pdrti confentio.ln tri# bus dutcm,qÂ«d$ fecimw pdrtibiÂ«,Â«on cft forma, femper edian Jcd um 'm qud idem concUditur: Animd immor* tdlw tft. Nxni quiequid ex pipfo mouctur ,immortdle r^ Â»dnimd dutem ex feipfdmouetur, mmortdlis igitur *^|âÂ»wgt;d,HQc jitnon fÃ¶hnt in fingulis drgumemisÂ»

54t M. TAB. QVINT. INST^ fed in totis auÃs, c^ux [unt ÃmpUetf, er *â Ã j^iÂ» bui.l^dm er hx primdm hdbent propofitioiK^* ^^^^ legiMcommiÃÃi.Uonlt;iuifquMhomMÂ»gt;tocait gt;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;à¥¤

reustenctur.Deinde rdtionem,Sedl}Xce{t'mcigt;^r quxÃionibus longiort fluim in Ãngulis drguix^i^^â fkrun^ fummel complexione ,uelper emunerW^'' ^â uel per breuem conduÃonem teÃanturijitii efi^^^ ' In hoe genere propoÃtio dubid eR. De hdc enim lt;i^^^ rituriAlterdeRcomplexionon pdr mteiiiioiii,^^^^, tlnVargugt;' Metttpdremt uiors nihildd nos .IJdm^uoic^^'Ã¯* mentatio in folutum, fenfu edret : ejuod dutem fenfu cdretinihdi Axiocho. fjg^^ jâ ^i^g genere,non eddem propoÃtio fÃ,^wâ'â'â^ nexio t Omniddnimdlid meliord fumt ^udm 'uUK^^^h nihil dutem'meliut eR mundo, Mumdus igitur llic poteR uideri de re contentio, Potuit emm Ãceofi filtuirdtiocmdtio : AnimedeR mundus, omniiilt;^lt;^^^ nimdlid meliord fumt quim indnimd,Ceetcrum heepto^ poÃtio, dut con/eÃd eR ut proximd^ dut probdnid,Â»^ ^m bedtdm uitdm uiuere uolet, philofophetur opt^^' Ã¯^onenim conceditur,cÂ£terd fequi, niÃ conÃrindti (fi^ md pdrte, non poffunt. pR er dffimptio interiÂ»(â^ fe/fd, ut omnesdutem uoltmt bedtdm uitdm uiiurt'^''^ rim probdndd,utilld: QjiodeÃdiffolutumÃnÃ(i'lt;^gt; turn folutd corpore dnimd,dn fit immortdlis,uel di W* ( pus certum, mdnedt/it in dubio. Quumdjfumptionein, ' dlij rdtionem uoednt, dlij epichiremd. Ppichiremd mÂ» temnullo divertd fyllogifmis,nift quod HHerphirts f^dbent/^ecies, er wrd coUigunt uerÃ} epidiircuuHf

frfiJuefUtor cired errditilid eft u/Ã®w Â» Ndm fi cofUwige* ret femper coiuroucrfd confej?Â» probdrejUix eJJem wi boe genere ufiw ordtorK.âNdm quid ingenio eft of iKjWt dicdÃ®.bondddme fertinent^SoliÂ« enmfwmfUiw ie fun ai,ucl foilÂ« bercs, exm iure honor um f o fflt;^Ãio witc ÃdÂ« je,;.ft:,.: ^ tÂ« fecunduwi tdbuliÂ« teÃdmenti deturjdd me igitur fer teftamento tinetw.Sed ciwn ipfd ratio in qaxÃionem utnii^Ã§ffteim'^ ft^âjquot;quot;âj-^Â® dum eft certm id quod probdturi fumtÂ«, quod incerÂ« premam uo turn eftjUtÃ ipfd forte mtentionedicdturjdtttjiliiÂ« non'âquot;â:'âquot;â* fÃ®.dut non ei Icgitmnw/ut non es pIiMjtdq^ dut bxres nonej^dut iuÃiwnteÃdmenttMnnoncft, dutedperc non poter, dut buks cobdredej.EÃJetfnduweÃiuÃw^, pro pter quod bond ddiudiedri nobis debedt. Sed turn eft ne Â«)fdridilldfummdconnexio,ciÂ«n mteruenit ordtio hr* gior. Aliqudndo fuÃwiunt intentio de rdtio. Silent leÂ« ad lined ges inter drmd.nee fe expeftari iubent, eum ei qui expe ftdre uelitjdnteiniuÃd p er na bend d Ãt,qMdmiuÃdrepc tendd.ldeoq; id entbÃ¿memd quod eÃ ex eonfequentibtÂ« (. wtioniÃtnile dixerunt.Sed er Ãnguld quoq; interim re ftc ponurttur,ut ipfm iHudtSilent leger inter drmd.Et, irdtione fdteÃ inciperc, deinde conduderc ibidem: Cicero pro Quoi Ã duodeeim tdbuk noaumum furem quoquo mo MÃ¼one. dojdiurnum dutemJi fe tdo defenderet,lnterÃci impuÂ« ne uolucrHnt,quis eÃ qui quoquo modo quit interfeftm

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ft .puniendum putet: Vdridnt dutem bic ddbuc, er rur fus rationem tertio loeo ponunt.cum uidednt dliquando gltdium nobis db ipÃs porrigi legibus. Prioris dutem pi^ii duxit erdtnem â¦ mpdidtori dutem c Utrow,

â¢ â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;t^si^âÂ°^'qÂ«lt;epotcÃmferrimiufldnexfHÂ£cinten{io. QÃ¤'^^ ,

I' noftrium fuitdtuf noÃri^t^uidglddij uolutttfHiec rÃ¤tio.CUiO^^^ â ; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â^^'^â^Â°^âââ^ berecircate nonliceret,fiuuilliiÂ»u0o piHolic^^' ,

â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ã¼'^c^xintefttione er rdtionccSnexio.Huic genen (^fâ'

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;bdti onÂ» tribut occurritur modisjd eH per omnefp^n

t- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tes.AutenknexpugndturmtÃ«tio,dutlt;tlJ(miptio,iti(tco

| nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;elupo^nonnimqMmomnid.Sed omniet hdctridfnnt-^''* i

1 â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tentioexpugnettur:lureoceidieiim,(}ui'mfididtut^gt; I

NixmprimdfltttimproMilonequeeflioeiliAnfiteif^ / lucem intueri, (jui i fc hominem needtum effefdteittnf' Æ Expugndturd/j'umptioomnibuthit^.quiedcrefutiitiorte -diximut. Et rdtio quidem ttonttunq eÃ¯l uerdjcSeiiufee pofitioucrdnon fit. interim uereepropofieioitisfdfâ^* tto edl: virtue bomÂ»Â» e/l,ueru edl^fiquit rdtionÃ©fiiij* , cidt,quod ed locupletesfdcidt, uerÂ£ intemionitfilfifi i rdtio. Connexio dutem ucrd negdtur^eum dliudediig'^ guimid, quod exprioributeonfidtur, dut nihiltitji*^ fiionem dicitur pertinere. Uon ed uerdfic: inÃdhnef à¥¤ iureoedditur : Ndquicurduit,utum d^rdtuthe^d, , debet etidmut hofiÃ» repedii Rede igitur ChnHidÂ»^ hofiÂ» oedfili ed. Non utique. Nondum enim CleiÃ¼Â»* nbsp;nbsp;.

nedoduÃÂ°^^^â*^ââ ^^^^âlt;^Â» ertdmen fdlfdintentiocrdtir, ilhfjid itdfiiliduerdfuÂ»t,nuft^udmedlfdlfdconfiexio-Entbe fMt,niiqij3 tnemddbdliftordtoriut fyUogifimiijdhdUftp-^etdidf neido.^*^^quot; derÃ'lloSâf'^'Â» proptered^uodÃUogifimUddiffOdlo

ORATOR. L1BÃ.R V. 54^ fioncrn er pÃ¯opofitionÃ«biBct,er per omÃ®tes portes effi cit ,cjuod propofuit, embymcmi tantum intentum intcUi gicontctumfit.Syllog,ifmiÂ«tlt;ilw: Solumbonumuirtus. i Nom id demu bonum eft,^uo nemo male uti potc(l. Vir tute nemo male uti poteÃ^onum eft ergo uirtus.Entbgt; mernaex confeqwntibus. Bonum eft uirtus, qua nemo male utipotcÃ.EteontriiNoneft bonum peciwia.Non enimbonum, quo quifquam male uti poteÃ .Pecunia poÂ» teÃ quit male uti,Non igitur bonum eft pecunia.Entbji xegetum n-mema ex pugnatibus: An bonum eft pfcunia,qua quifqj gnawm Â«Â«Â« poteÃ male uti? Si pecunia, qwÂ« eft in argento fignato, uoeÃ¤runt.ne 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;argentum eft,qui argentum omnelegauit.er pecuniam pe qd figno

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;que eft m argÃªto fignatolcgauit. Argentum aut omne *^â5iâS?Â»Â»quot;S

â conÃiretotam,autccrtcconfcrtamcjjeaggreÃionucr Nonanxie entbymfmatumÃipatione,minMne uclm.Dialogw entmeonquirtdo* tr dialcfticis dij^utationibiÂ« erit fimilior, q noÃri ope ris aftionibtK,qux quidem inter fe plurimÃ¼ diÃerunt Â»

'Nint^iUi hommes dofti,cr inter doftos ucrum queren tes ,mmutim Â«y fcrupulo/Ã®us ferutantur omnia, er ad li quidumconfcjjitm^perducurtt,ut quifibi et inueniÃªdi, cr ludicidi uendicent partes, quarum alter T07eiKjip,al teTamK^l?^^j^p^(,Ã§(^â[,^^P^j^ ^^ aliorum indicia compo

54lt; M. FAB. QVINT. INSTiTÂ« nendd eÃ¼ oratio,cr f^pius dpui omnino imp^riw^' que dUdrum certe igndros liter drum loquendu fA:^Â«^ niÃ et deleUdtione dllicmus,z^ uiribus trdhmuSjG' ^ nunq turbdmus d^uUbus, ipÃ quit iufld de uerdfunt^ itÃ¨re non po/Ãumus, Locuples o-JÃeciofd uult ejÃ ^0' quentid^quoru nihil confequetur, ÃconduÃonibus^' tii,cr crebris, er m undpropÃ¨formd cddentibuscoi^^ fd, er contemptum ex humilitdte, er odium ex ejudi^^ feruitute,er ex copid fdtietdtÃ©,er ex dmplituHneÃjH' dium tulerit, lerdtur igitur no femitis, fed edmpi!,Â«quot;* utifontei dnguflisfifluUs colUgunturfcd utldtiÃinti^' tnnef totisudÃ¼ibuf fludt,dc fibiuidmfiqudndo nadeel rit,fdcidt. t^dm quid itld miferius lege uelut prÃ©fet'_ Adagium, f^ mfdntibus literdiperfquentiu, ut Gr^ddien^f lent,quem muter dmiÃ©lum deditfolicite cuÃaHedlid'^^ PropoÃtio,dcconcluÃo, ex con/cquentibusert^f^^â'^ tibusnon tn/piret^nodugedt,non millefiguris udn^f nerfetjUtedUdÃi, er ipfdprouenire nuturdtioeidUfr ad,er drte fufeptdjtndgiflrufdteri ubiq; â^'^^^'ââÃ, Quis unq Ãc dixit ordtorfnone dpud ipfum Deux^r..

. ihuius ar^ nem pducifimd huiufmodi reperiSturtâ Oll^^g tu SC wruÃ Gr^cimdgis (numhoe folunobiipeaufd(^^_^^ nut Iigdnt,er inexplicdbiliferie conneduut,^'quot;quot; tdtdcoÃigunt, er probant confefd, erf^i^^, ÃShtatio hocÃmilesuocant.DemdeinterrogaÃnunq d^^ aliÂ». nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;bunt quem imitentur.Sed de figurÃ© alio loeo. 1^'

lud adi/ciendum^nc bis quidem confentire me,qâ''â^ ^mentdfer/tgt;0nepuro,erd(lu(ido,erAÃm^âgt;/â^â^

Uimnnc Uto orttito^ putint eue dicendav.NAnq; ea di-fl'mSaquidcmjacpcrÃjicmdcbcre cue conÃtcor/inrc bus Hero mmoribiM ctiam fermone, ac uerbk quJmaxic pToprijSjCrexufu.At fi maior erttnwterw.nuUum or* nitumbk (qui modo non obfeuret) fubtrabendum pu-to.Nimo- fiepeplumumlucts dUertipfatranÃitio, turn ctiim ipp iurifconfulti .quoru fwmnius circa ucrbo-rum proprietdtemlabor eft ,littw cue audcant dicerc, qui Puftus aUudit.Qtto^ quid natura magk aj^crum, in quibufsa bocpluribuscondiendumeft uoluptatibiw,Â©- nwnk f***^^^^5 j^tSa ir^umcntdtio diÃimulationc, lt;7 multum ad pdc aiiuuit wdientis uoUptas.Nifi forte cxiUwnawiK Cicc ronmmdeinbacipfa ar jumentatione dixiÃe : silere kjcs'mtfTirma,cr gUdium nobis interim ab ippspor ââ *amp; Ifgibus^uk tarnen babendus modus ^ut pnt orna- * Adieau ^cnto,non impe dimentoÂ» nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;âÂ®**

gxtimihi, fedulo ldbordbtim,relpicienstMcn ti^ ^ HKÂ£ uoluptAtiÃ¯,quod filio cuim eminens tdm quoq; pdrentls ditigentidmmerebdtur,^^â[^j mdm pdrtem reUÃ©luruf htereditdtif uidcbdr,utjtlt;âââ leqimm er optdbile fuit) fdtd intercrpijftntjf^^^^â^^^ re tdmen pdtre uteretur. A t me fortund id dgexi^ bat de noÃ¼ibuifiÃindnteinqi metu meÂ£ mortdUi^^^ â fubito profirduit, ut Idborii meifruÃ¼m dd nemiÂ»^ nuf q dd mepertmeret. lUum enim de â}âtofuigt;igt;ââ^â eeperdm, er in quoJ^em uniedm feneHutii bdm,rcpetito uulnere orbitÃ¤tit dmifi.Qjiid nufK^g^* dut quem uitrit effe ufum mei dijs reprobdntibut ^ ndm itd fortÃ¨ dccidit^t eum quo^ Ubrum, lt;1^^ â/f^ â â¦Â»Â«âff fis corruptie eloquentite emift, idmferibere ^gg^h fimiliiHuferircr. Tuneigituroptimumfuit opia, er quicquid hoe eÃ¼ in me infeUcium per immdturum fuma confumpturis uifeerd mii r^ ini)cere^neq; hdne impidm uiudcitdtem nouis infill ^ ris fdtigdre. QÃ¿is enim mihi bonus purent igdOri fludere dmptius pojfum f de nS oderit hune dnieii'â'^^ mitdtcmfi quis in me eÃ¼ dlius ufus uods, qui ut deos fuperfles omnium meorum^nuUdm terrui di/t ^^ re prouidentium teÃer tâ fnon meocdfu,lt;uitiiiii^'^. obijci,ni/t quod uiudm potefi,dt iUorueerte, ques^ r intmeritos mors dcerbd ddmnduit,ercpti mihi pf^^ rundem eA muter,que nondum expktoetdtis uÂ«^^^ fimounno,duosenixu flios,qudmuis dcerliÃwÂ»* ptd fdtis,Jrlix decefit. Ego uel boe uno mulo fKlt;^

lt;^ftiÂ«,ut mew nulla/brtiMtapojJct encore felicem. Niim eu omni uirtute, quÂ« in fxmmM aiit, fwniici. pt, infdnibilem attulit marito dolorcm,tum Â« tÃ¤te ca fuel ^ taÂ«* Uri,prÂ«ferttm mex eompaydtd,potejl Â©- ipfd numerd* ri inter uulnerd orbitrftw,libÃ©rÃ©s tame fuperÃitibuj oble ftibdr cr quod nefds erdt,fÂ£Ud, fed optdbdt ipfd,mc fat no mdximos crucidtus prxcipiti uid effugit. MibipliuÂ« minor quintum egreffus annum^ut in mdlis dgerc,prior dltcrumex duobus eruit lumen. Nonfum dmbitiofus in mdis^tcc dugfre Uebryrndrum edufos uolo, utmdmq; ef ptTidio minuendi. Sed dipimuldrc quÃ® poffum, quid ifli piti* m uultu, quid iucunditdtis in fermonc,quo$ in-Vâ^ijniculos, q praÃdntidm pldcid^jCZ (quod feio fubftahtiÃ¤ *â PâlJt credi) tantum ditÂ« mentis oÃenderit f qudlis dmorem quieunq; diirnus infant mereretur. Illud uero Â«ifidiontis, quo me udlidius crucidret,fortune fuit int il le mibi blindij?imus,mc fuis nutricib(w,mc duiÂ« eduedtij ** omnibus qui foliatdrc foknt iHd* Â«tdtes, anteferret. ^tâOpter illi dolori,quem ex mdtre optimd, dtq; lau lt;^â¢ omnoii fupergreffd paucos ante menfes Â«perd grd ^âlor. Minus enim eft quod flendum meo nomine, qUim quoditbus goudÃ©dum eft.VnapoÃ bÂ« Quintilidni mei Quintilians Ãf'ic uoluptdte nitcbdr,et poter at fuÃwere foldtio. No^'*âÂ®' 'â'Mo[culosficutprior, Jeder decimuaetatwidmin-WÂ»J Â«mum,certos dtq; deformatos pudus oÃende* â^â¢â*âÃ¯Â«indUmcd,pcr infclicem confeimtiam, per â¢ 5 'ââi'gt;fs,numind dolorÃ©s mei,bdS me in illo uidiffe uir fâ â¢âÂ£'âgt;ij) nonmodÃ¨ ad percipiÃ©das dijciplindt, quo

ÃÃO M. FAB. OyiNT, INSTIT. ,Â» _ Studia quf nihilbriftMtiusco9noui,plurimâif^xtcrtitS)'^P^^ cosaifaunttf^ifitumnocodHi (fauntpriceptom) Pfâ¢â\;^f ti peeftores pictatii, humdnitatK,libcriilitdtis,ut prorfus fÂ®/'â^ cjje tantifulmmis metus, quod objeruittumfcT^^^gt; rius occidcre feÃmutum mdturitdte,crcÃ[( nclcio Ã§*'*Â» quiel^es tdntM decerpdt^muididm, neuidehectuM bomini ddtum eR,noÃrd prouehuniurt 'EtiâiÂ»i i^4â'^^* me dderdnt omnid^uocis iucuiiditd^,cldritd!^,orii[^^â tds,cr in utrdcÃ¼q; tingud, tdnqud dd edm denumn^ effet,expreffdproprietds omnium literdruitit ^âquot;^^^ f^es ddhuc/lU mdiord,conÃdntid, grduitÃ¤s, contre ^'â' lores etidm de metus roiur,Ã®idm quo illednmo,^iâ^^^ dicorum ddinird^one^menpum oÃo udlctudimati^quot; â¢ ut me in fupremis confoldtus e^ldqudm etidm dej^'^^â qudm^ non tune ipfumiBumdliendtie mentis ersâ'^ circd folds literds hdbuitiTuofne ego omettfpei'^^ tdbentesoculosjcumfugientemfpiritumuidiieico^^^ frigidum exdngue eomplexus, dnirnd recipere, dif^ communern hdurire dmplius potuiidignus bis cr^^â^^' bus quos fera, dignus h/s cogitdtionibus. 'rÃ©itf('â'l' ' â Apttus tsiri nupcr ddoptione, dd omnium fpes honorteÂ« ^^ trisadmotum, tedunnculo Pr^torigenerudefH'^^^â''â ^^^ teomniumfpe Atticlt;e eloquentiie cMdiddtiai,i'^' fies pdrcns hdliturus edi tdntum dd pcendsiEtfit'^ ^ pido lucis, certe pdtientid uindicet te reliqud mei d^^ te^ E^dmfruÃrd mdld omnid dd crimen fortuM rdt!^ mus.Ã®\cmo nifi Ãd eulpd diu dolet.Sed uiiimu5,C*^' qud uiuendi ratio qu^renda efi,eredÃ«dum^ dcÃ¼f^

ORATOR. LIBER Vl. 55* Uniâ¢'lii(Ã§,qui u-nicum dduerforum foUtium liter lt;Â« pu-tdMfTHt.Siqwiindo timen iti refederit prÃ¼fens impettw, W Â«liqud tÃ´t luftibus ilia co gitatio in [tri poffet^non in* iuflcfcttcrmmorieuenidm, QHKcntmdiUti Ãudi4 miretur,quie potiiw non ibrupti mirindum cH^ Turn Ã quim'mwfuermtc^ftil?iÃ®,qutÂ£ kuiiKidbuc i^ifli eÅptÃ¯dmiM,impcritide,lt;iÂ«t fortunt retnittintHr: c,iu Ã quid mediocrium dlioqwi noÃro ingenio uirium fuit, ut Â«o extinxerit jdcbilitiuit tlt;tmÃ«. Sed utl propter hoc nos eontuffiiiciuscrigiinuM, quod iHÃ ut perferre notw diÃt Ã³k eftjtdfictie cotemnerc.Ntbtl ctiim ftbi iduerfui mÃ© fliquitjOÂ« mfelicem quidem,fcd certi^mii timen ittu* litmftiiexbk mills fecurititemÂ« Boni iutemconfulcrÃ©

' â'Â»(iTUffihborÃ« Uf 1 propter boe certum eft, quod ht nut luw iiiM fropriÃ¼ ufum perfeucrimuÃ¯,fed omnis bic cu* Â«id dienos,ut ilienis utilis (f modÃ¨ quid utile feribi-Â«tus) j^eftit. Nos miferiÃcut ficultitcs pitrimonij no jlridtiboc opus ilqs prÂ« pir imus,ilij$ relinquemus *

DeConcluftone feuPeroritione, C APÂ» 1. ijorm prim^ PLroTitiofequcbitur,quimcumulum quidim,con appdlauit

clufioncm ilij uocint.Eius duplex ritio eÃ pofti,^j^Â° pâ3â â^ Â«ut in rebus,iut m iÃriSibus.Rerum repetitio er con- nimirS oÃ¯m ^lÂ«io,quÂ£ GrÃ¦ce dicitur avaK.iqgt;aAotZwa'Â»S,qHibufÂ« â^fiâÂ®^^ i^Wmorum cnumeritio,er memoriim iudiew ref- tionem.quÃ« ^^Qrtotunifmulciufimponit inteoculos,etctiimft p^â¢^jâ^|'g P^ Pâ juli minus mouerit,turbi uilct. In bic quf repe hominem dÃ« temus quimbrcuifme dicendi funt,er quod grlt;eco uer ââP^fijdecurrendum percipiti* Nimfitnoribimurjinittimasi

ist M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT' ^ non idm cnumrrdtio,pd ultcrd ijUdÃÃ(t o^^^' .^ dutem cnumcrdndd uidentur, cum pondcre dbfO* da funt,cr dptis excitAdd fententijs, erÃg/frifÃ^ rianddidhoqui nihil eÃ odioÃuf redid iÃ¼d rtpttition^ lut memoria iudicum diffidentis.Sunt dutem inm^* nies, optime^ in Verrem Cicero: SipdteripÃlâ^^^^ ret,quÂ£ diceret cum hac probdrentur: CS demifl^ cit enumerdtionem. A ut cum idem m eundem fw gt;â^^ cdtioncm deorumÃiohdtd d pratore tcmpld dmimi^^' Licet c^ dubitdre num quid nos fugerit,(y quid ^H^^ furiÃntdduerÃrq his er his,dut qudÃgt;em dccuÃiof^ bedt omnibus itd dcfcnÃs.illd uero iucundiÃwd-Ãe^quot;*^ gat dliquod ex dduerfdrio ducere drgumcntuni,utP eM:Rcliquitucrohdncpdrtemcdufe:dut,irgt;uiilidp^* ^^^* meremaluitdut,dd precesconfugit, ermerdiâ'''^ fiirethlt;ec ethac. Sed non funtfingulaJ^ecies^^^'i'â dÂ£,ncfold uidcantur,qua forte nunc dixerotcuui^d*' pones er ex duÃs, er ex didlis dduerfdriorum, Cd ^ , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;quibufddm fortuitis quoq^ oridntur. Nee refcrend'â^

* do nofird, fid pofluldndum etidm db dduerfdri/!gt; quot;^^ quaddmre^ondeant, ld dutpddlionisfuperenli^' cr Cd propofuerimus,qult;e refelUnon pofunt'l^i^ â t qua dÃ©tÃ®nt ff^g^jf ^ ^^^ j^jj^ fortid, non drguentis edited f'^â^'^ tis, Id unum epilogigenus uifum eflplerifq; Atticoâ^'quot;quot;.â Cr philopphis ferÃ© omnibus, qui de drie ordtond f^' Vide Arifio ptumdliquid rdiquerunt.IdÃnÃÃe Atticoscredo,^^ telcinprinci^fljc/jfsd^dtusmouereetidpcrpraconemprohlâoiâ^' wr^l^^^ndKrordtor, Philofophos minus miror,dpudquos vif

eft loco,djjici.nÂ« toni mores uiientur/K Ã Â«ero iMdicc Â»uerti nee conwenire bono wro uitijs wti.NceejJkrios t.c men nffi^us fdteiuntur, fi dliterobtweriucrd er iujla, CZ in commune profuturdnS poJ^int.Cictcrum illud con Ãitit inter omnes,ctidm in dlijs pdrtibus iÃ¼ionK,fi mul tiplex cdufd fit,er pluribus drgumemis defenfd, utilitcr ttvaw(pa'\Ã¼toc'i/j feri folere. sicut nemo dubitducrit niÂ«ltdse)fccdufds,inquibusnulloloco ft nccejfdrid,fi breues er pmplices fucrint .Hecc pdrs perordtionis dccu fdtori,pdtronoq; Ã¦que comunis cf^ Ajfedibus ejuoejue Â«Hem fcrÃ¨ utuntur/cd rdriusbic,dt iUc fepius er md-gis .Ndm buic concitdre iudicc$,illi fe Acre couenit .V cÂ« rumet deeufdtorbdbet interim ldcbrgt;mds ex mijerdtice

' tidi rciquÃª ulcifcitur, er reus de indignitdte cdlumniÂ« con/pirdtionis webementius interim queritur. Diuidere igiturbxc oflicid commod ifimum, qu Â« plerunq; funt ,ut dixi,Proocmiofimilid,fedliberiord,plcniordq;.lnclind-do enim iudicu dd nos petitur initio pdreius, cum dd ^ p^^j^n, W'HtiselljCrordtiototdfuperef. Inepilogouero idtmcÃ³fi' fPi^Kiltm animu index in confliu ferdt,er idm nibil Hofecerat dmplius difturi fumus,ncc refdt quo feruemus.Ef igi* tur utrifq; cÃ¶munc,concilidrc fibi,duertere db dduerfd* 100iudieem, concitdre dfretus er componerc. Etbre-wj5imÃquidem boe prjeceptum ddri Utriq; pdrti potef, *^ Roti's cdttflt;e [ne uires ordtor diitc oculos pondt,er cÃ¼ wulfÃ¯it quid inuidiofMm,fduordbile,inuifum, miferdbilr, du^it in rebus dut uideri pof it, ed diedt, qbus fi index 'Ã'^ipfe maxime moueretur.Sed certius eft ire per fn

5?4 AI. FAB, QVlNr. INJfl^^ ^uld. Et quÂ£ concitidnt quidem dccuflt;itorÃª,iÂ« piquot;ÆL exordijidmdixnÂ»Ui.(:itiÂ£ddmtdmen,qMillicr^ rcfdtise^^'mpcrordtioticmplcnddfuitt,m.igigt;Ã^'^\ hnpotentcm, muiÃtrn, pernidofum fufeeptd dUl^ â â fitudicibm tpÃi dut gloriÂ£ ddmndtio rci,dtit dqÂ»^ , ti futurddbfolutio. TSldmegregiem VatiniumC^^^^ Edilum, mquit, dmlitum feitis omnes, cy htdiosr^ omnetÃiunt, Cicero quidem m Verrem etijm i^iÂ»^^^ poffe infdmidm iudiciorum ddmndto rco,dicit,^i^^^ h^be^doopti 1^^âfâ^^^ÃP^âtdidHs^ MetutetidinfteAddbibendiiiÃ me precipjt fdcit idem,hunc hdbedtlocumfortiorem,q m proeei'^' Arilio. h.i, QÃ¿^ jg y-f. qiff^fentirem^dlio idmlibro expofui- ^'âquot;^^ tdre quoc^ inuididm, odium,irdmÃberiui in perord^^ nc eÃ¶tingitiquorum inuididm grdtid^ odium tiirÃd'^^â irdm offÃ¨nfio iudied fdcit,Ã contumdx, drropMf^ rut Ãt,qui non ex fddio modÃ¶jdtdvuedliquofi dul^^ hdbitu,d/pedu mouerifold. Egregic^ nobh^dolef^ tibus dixi/fedccuÃtorCo/futidniCdpitonii uideb^^^b GrÂ£ce quidem, fed in huncfenfum: Erubefeit Cdf^ timerc. Summdtdmcnconcitdndidfvdltudeeufi^^'^ ebtertt f^^^ ^^1^^ -^ ^^^^ ^ obiecit, dut qudmdtroaÃii'^^ etidmÃ fieri potefl,qudmmdximemiferdbilc(f'â^, tur.Atrocitdf crefeit ex his, qdfddlufit, iqnoM'*^â quo dnimo,quo temporc,quoloco,quo modo,qudoU *â^ finitos dnfi-ddlus hdbent, Pulfdtuquermurtde repriquot;â t comÃ©ptui âPf^ dicendu,tumÃfenex,Ãpucr,Ãmdgi/lrdtiu,fif^ bui,ÃbenedeRep. meritm, etiÃ¨l fiE pereuf/tufd dliquo, co/ftempto^j uelexcolrdrio i potentf/ifiÂ»quot;^â

Â«TcntMr,4Â«tinfoIicitociÂ«Ã¼(aiÃ¯^4tu. Urmintbedtro, w tcmplo, in concionc erefeit inwidu. Et JÃ¯ non errore^ Â«cc ir4,udcti4mp fortcirA,fe d wiiqM4,quod p4tri 4|fu ijfet, quod Tf)J)oÂ«di jjet, quod bonores contra pc teret.

Et fi pb etiarn widcri poteÃ uoluijjc,q fecit, Pluriwium tamraaÃerct atrocitatis modus Æ grmuiter/icontume' liofcjUt DemoÃbenfs ex parte peuÃt corporis, ex wultu centra Mi* ferientis/xbabitu inuidiam Miditequarit.OccifuscÃ, diam. utruferro,an i^nc,an ucnenotiMio uulnere an pluribus, fubito an expeftatione tortus, ad banc partem maxi^ ^ tertius tnepfTtmet. vtitur frequenter accufator er miferatio ff jcam 4Ht cius cafum quern uleifei tur,aMt liber or urn,aut parentum folicitudme coqueritur.Etia futuri temporis marine indices mourt, qui maneant cosca{us,qui deui er iniuria queÃi pnt, niÃ uindicentur, fugiendu de dui nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â¢

âate,cedendumbonis, aut omnia qurcust^ inimici ani-â¢âfeÂ»t^pcrfercnda.Sed fapius id eft accu/atoris, auer tere iudicÃ« Ã miferatione qua reus fit ufurus/tq? ad for titer iudicandu concitare,Cuius loei eft etiam occuparc, qua diflurufafturumue aduerfariu pÃ»tes, Nacreau-twesadcuÃodiafult;rcligionis iudicrsfacit,cr gratta S'j^onfuris Ã¤uÃert,cum ca pradifta funt ab aceufatore, iaÂ« ft pro reo petctur,no Jint noua, ut Seruius Sulpitiws tontra Aufdiam,ncfgnatoru,utabipfs difermen Aufidjumut obipaturfb^py^iHonct.Necno ab AcfcbtÂ«c,qualift 8t pofteÂ» ft* ufuTus DemoÃbenes aftione,pTa:diftum eft. Docendi'^^''^'^'

5SÃ M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. ejuoq; interim iudices^quid rogdntÃ¼usrcfpoiiicrtit'' bÃ©ant,quod eÃ¼ tmu repetitionis genus, PericlitantÃªut ro commendat dignitaSyO' Ãudid fortid,et fufeepttid lo cicatrices, isr nobilitds,cr mÃ©rita maiorum.Ã¼oc quoi proximedixi, Cicero atque Aftnius certatim funtuji, pro Scauro,patre hic,itlepro filio. Commendat ctcuuÂ» fa periculijt fufeepiffÃ¨ inimicicids ob aliquod fdilum fcâ nejium uidctur,prÂ£cipue bonitds,bumanitiis,Â»tilericot^ iuftiui dia. luÃe enim tuc petere ca quifque uidetur Ã ludieti qut alij ipfe prxÃiterit, Referenda pars hac quoq; d utilitatem R eipu.ad iudicugloriam, ad quÂ£ exempbm,

. , admemoriampoÃeritatis.PlurimumtdmenudletiuiÃ^^ inÃ´ ^uÃ¯dL ^'A iudicemÃeHinon tantum cogit,fed motumquu^^^^ anitnifui lachrymis conÃteri. Hec pctentur,uut ex wgt; qua paffus cA reus,aut bis quÂ£ turn maxime pidtur,^^^ hisquÂ£ damnatum manent ,quÂ£ er ipfa dup^effltut, cum dicimus Ãª qua illifortuna,ct in quam recideniup'' AffÃ¨rt in bis momentum er Â£tdS,er fexus,Ct pigiorh liberi dico,er parentes, er propinqui, qudommuif^^ dariuarie folent. Uonnunquam etiam er ipÃf^^^ nus bas partes fabit, ut Cicero pro Milone o 0 luc^l rum, Ãªteinfeliccm. Reuocaremetuin patrio potuifliper bos, ego te in patria per eofdeni f^*â nonpotero f Maxime^;fi (uttuneaccidit) non ecn^f nient ci, qui deeufatur, preces. blam quis nemprocapitefuofupplicdtem, quidfeuirunobi terfedum,quia id fieri oportuiffet,fdtereturi E^^^ illccaptauitexiHaprÂ£fidntiaanimifduorÃ©,erinââ^

IicbrywArH ciiw ipp fweeeÃit. Hw py^cipuc toets utiles flint profopopaiÂ« ,i(i eft,fÃ¯ftÂ£ dltciwru perfotidru ord-tioiifs,quilles Ã¼tigittorcm decent,uel putronum. NuiÂ« tintum res mouent, dut cum ipp loquiwur, dut eu ipfds loquifingitnus. Ex perfonis quoque trdbitur d^Ã¤tÂ«. Non enim nudire index uidetur dliettd mdld dezentes, fed fenfum de woeem duribus deeipere mifcrorurn, quo ââ*âÂ® , rum etid mutus dj^eftus Idcbrjmds mouet, qudnto^ cf-|Ãªnt mifcrdbiliord,ft ed dicerent ipfi.tdnto funt qudddiw fuxportione dd dj^iendu potÃ«ttord,eÃ¼ udut ipforu ore diciMitur,Ht feeniek dclonbus eddem uox,eddem^ pro nuwidtio plus dd mouendos d^diM fut perfond udlct. Itiqidem Cicero, qudnq preces non ddt Miloni,cum^ potius mimi prieÃdrttid comenddt, dccommodduit ei td* wmuerbd,Â©- conuenientes etidm forti uiro conqueÃio nest o ÃuÃrd, inquit, mei f tfeepti Ubores, 0 J^cs fut-kets, o cogitdtiones meÂ« indne s. Nunqudm turnen de-btte(Jetlortgdmiferdtio,nccpnecdufddiduiMeft :Ni-bil fdcibus qudtn Idcbrjmds wdrejeere. Ndm cum etidm Ã³tKr,mÂ«Te uerosdoloresmitigettempus,citius eudnefedt nceejfc fcunt.uide Â«ft illd,qudm dicendo rÃinxitnus Imdgo ; in qud ft moÂ» rimur, fdtigdtur Uebrymis duditor, er requiefcit,o-lib ilo, quem ceperdt tmpctu,dd rdtionem redit Â« Non pitiwiurijitur frigefcere boe opus, crd^Ã¨ftum, cum dd fummum pcrduxerimas,Ã¯clinqudmus, nee Ãoeremus fort,ut abend quifqudm diu ploret. idcoqj cum Ml dlijs, turn rndxime inbde pdrte debet crefcere ordtio. Quid quiequidnon ddijeiv, prioribus etidm detrubere ui-

5$S M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIÃÂ« dctur, O' facile deficit affeilm, ^ui dÃ©pendit.

AdhucdeA^ilibufttiouendis. CAP- 'f' v A A n ^^âJC)Nfolumautemdicendo,fedetiMficiciolt;{gt;^ faiePbryne^ L \i damjachrymat mouemui,tinde o proii'^â^ ^'^Â°Ã¯quot;dquot;'âquot; ^^^ ^tiipcriclitentur,fquiilido!dt^defimiKf^^ ante annota ^Â°^ lt;^orumj de parentes inftitutum, o ab aeeufitof^ turn eÃ¼. oftendicruentumgladiu, crie^iaeuultteribusolÃâ^ ueÃesfanguineperfufas uidemui,o tmlitera refihââ^^ uerberata corpora nudari-Quxrum rerumiit^^'â^fââ run^ ais eH^uclKt in remprxfentem, animosbo^ Lege Saeto' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^ populum RomanÃ¼ egit in firoreuf^^

mum m uita xta C.Ci/dris prolatd in foto cruentaSciebaturi^^ ^^ adert fi^'^'^i^^ofpitt dÃ©niai ipfum impofitum kilo Â«'A*^, fik tamÃ¨illa /anguine madens ita repr^fentamt M*^ fcelcris, ut no occifus e/fe Ca far, fed turn maxiiff*â^. utderetur,Sed non ideo probauerint, lt;^uod fadi^^ lupra fo' go,0' ipfe aliquando uidi depidam tabulant Ãfj ^^ ifitdginemrei, cuiusatrocitate iudex

uendus. Qua enim critadiorisinfantia, qua runts'Â»^ e/figiem magis quant orationÃ¨pro fe putet loottuf* Sordesfordi At fondes, o fquatoreSfO propinquorumquo^/^ dat{ueftes. Icm habiturn fcio profui/fc, o magnum ad fak^'^ mentumpreces attuU/fe. Quare o obfecratfi â¢^'^^. cum pcrcharif:mapignora, utiq; fi opoo fintll^'â coniunx,parentes, utilis erit. Et deorum etiant iwio^^' tio,uelut ex bona confeientia profeHa uidert fokt- ^^^ turn denique iacere,ct genua compkdH, nifi tomen j^f' fonanos, o anteailauita, ar ra conditio prohibtkt'

OK AT OR. LIBTJK VL ÃS9 Oufd^nicniwtdmfortitcrtucn(l4,quÃ®m fdfta funt. Vcrum fic eftbÃenJidutoritdtk r4tio,nc Ãt inuifd fc-curitdÂ«. Tuitquondiiminterbxc omnidpotentij^nnum id, (juo Lucium Murxndm Cicero, dccwfdntibtn cUri^i WKuirK/ripuiJJe prxcipuc uidetur :pcrfudfit enim nibil ejjc id prxfentem rerum ÃdtS utilim, ({Â«dm pridie Cilcnd.Umtirwi mg^rcdiconfuldtum. Cittod gcniMno Ãris temporibw totumpene fnbldtwm eH,cum omnid eu rx tM!cIx ^ twiiiÂ« innixd, pcriditdri nuUo iwdicij cxitu poÃint. De deeufdtoribus er rek (um locutiu , quid ut ptriculÃ¹ mdxtwe uerfdtur djfeÃ³liw. Scd priudtx quo*

. queemfxutrunqjbdbent perordtionU genus,er iUui quoi {^ ex enumerdtione probdt ionum,er boe quod ex Ã¼ebrjmK, [i dUt Ãdtu prriclitdri,dut opinionclitigdtor uidetur. Ndm in pdruis quidemlitibus bdÂ« trdgoedidÃ¯ moucre tule cft.qudlc p pcrfonumHerculis, er cotbur- ^^'^^ ChitiaÂ»

nos dptdre infdntibtÂ« uelw. lUud ne indignum quident dimonitione, ingens inepilogis meoiudicio uerti dijert wn ,quomodo (e dicenti, qui exeitdtur, dccommodet. Ndm er mpevitid, cr rupicitds,er rigor, er deformi* tds dffcruntintcriÂ»nfrigiÂ«,diligenter^ beefuut dfiori prouidendd. Equidem repugndutcis cos pdtrono,er ni biluultucommotos, er intcmpeÃiuc ridentes, er fdao

â â¢iiquo ,uclipfouultw rifum moumtes, pepe etidm uidi, Â» ^ pTddpututrocumdliquduelut fccnicc punt.TrdnÃu cadum ld pdtroniu dliqudndo pÂ«clldm,quÂ« foror e)Jc dduerfd* rijdiÂ«b4tÂ«T(iidmdebocliserdt)in dduerfd fubfcUid, tdttqudmmgremiojrdtrisreliftHriw. AtkdnobUprÂ«

monitui deceÃerdt.TumiÃ¼e,dlioquiuir fdcimi^Â»^ findtie reicdfu obm!ituit,zyinfMtefudtnfriffiiÃi^'^ reportduit^Aliiis mdginem ntdriti pro red proferre mi ^ni putduitfdt Cd fepius rifumfedt.iJdm CT bi,lt;pÂ«gt;tÂ»'* officij erdt ut trdderent cdm,igndri (fuid eÃet epilogui, quoties eunt rejpexiÃet pitronui,offÃ¨rebMt pdlM,C proldtd nouiÃime deformitdteipfd, ndmfenis edda^ infufd, prteteritdm quoi^ ordtionis grdtidm perdait-^ Nee ignotum quid Gliconi, cui Spiridion fuitcognomi, is dcciderit. Huiepuer, quÃ« in ius produdum qdd^'

ret mterrogdbdtjex pfddgogo fe ueUiedri rÃ©pondit- SephÃ¼os^^^ nihililld contrd Cephdfios Cicerpnit fibtdi^f

dui dd periculd epilogorum.Omnid tdmen hite tolni'â' lid^quibus dclionÃª mutdre fddlc eR, dt qui d jlyi^i^ '^ cedunt^dut conticefcunt dd hos cdfus,dutÃeque/idÃâ fdlfd dicuut.lnde eÃ¼ enim:Tenditdd ueÃrdgeUi^Ãâ^ plices mdUuSjCrth^ret in complexu liberoru ntÃf^â^' reuoedt ecce me,etfi nihil horu K, de quo dieiturf^^ Etfeholis hic uitid,in quibus omnid libÃ©rÃ© finget*!â^' impune, quid pro fddo eR quiequid uolutnuf gt;nbsp;'*ââ'! â mittit hoe idem ueritM fori. Egregie^ CdÃitud' ddolefeentulo t CyuidmctoruomltuintuerisÃ^^^^

Non mehcrcules inquit/dciebdm/edfjcfcripir' fidami ce^eyqudmpotuittruculctiÃimeeuindÃexitd^' .

cipuc moncndum, nelt;^uifniftfwnniiiiiig^gt;^âl'*^â'^^ ^ mouendiÃ¼lichrymiUdggrcdidudeÃ¤t. uchementiÃimui bic cu inuduit djfcÃ¼in, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'^

gititionibiM rcliquiÃct.âNittn er tMtltiÂ«,er uox,C7 ippt eu cxcititi rei fdeifÃ®, Uiibrio cti^m pkrun^; font boÂ» w'rttibiÂ«,(}it9J non pcrmoMfriwt. Outre metiitur/e dÃ® lijcitfcr Â«Ãimet Hires (uÂ« dftor, er qi/Antu/m omw fubt tunÂ« ptjintenigit,Nihil bubet iÃircs mediu/m, fed dut Ucbrgt;mÂ« meretwr, dut rifuw. Non intern commouere

. diets dd iuÃitidm redHcdt,tiÂ«n etidm quibufddm Â«rbdne diftit,quilt tft:Ddte pHtro pdnem,ne ploretter corpÂ« j kMolitigdtorijCHiiÂ« dduerfdrius item pHer,circd indiÂ» ', nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ces trat lt;tb dduocdtoldtus.Owid fdcidmfego te bdiuldre

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;quot;O'â pojJiwn.Sed bfc timen non debent eue mimied. Itd Mimica kÂ» _ i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«eque ill^in probdMcritn,qHi inter cUriJ^i mos pit tempo f^,quot;^,^^ qquot;^ ' ris orxtores fuit, qui putris in epilogtwn produÃ©lis,tdÂ» quam quic' â los proiecit in mcdiH,quos iHi diripere capertMit. NinÂ» ^^âjjj'j^ ; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;qutbÂ«ipfddifcrwninis fuiignormil potuit cUe mifeÂ« omnibâ grÃ ', nbilis.Ncduc illiwn,Â«iui,ctÂ«n effet cruentus glidius eiÂ«Â«;Â«Â® 8c quaÂ«

Â« deeMidtore proUtus, quo is hominem prohibit occiÂ» fim,fubitoex fubfcIlqsutterritiwfugitjCrcdpiteex pirte uclito cum ld dgentem ex twrbd profpexiffet, in terrogiuitjin iim iUe cum glidio recefiffet. Fecit enm rif^mUedridiculusfuit.Difcutiendietdmcnordtionebu iufmoii feent^Egregieq; Cicero, qui contrd imdginem ^quot;rnmi^g^^j^jg grduitcr,cr contrd iitÂ«enem,cw sus fubuiie uidnus miudicio refoluebdtHr, pro V dreno quot;quot;â'â^ dixit urbdne. Sunt er inilcnioresepilogi,quibiÂ« diiterfdiio [itisficimus Æ forte ciusfit perfom tails,ut

5ÃÃ M. FAR QVINT. INSTlTÂ« lia deleatur reuercntia,autcum amice ilnjuidcf^Â»'â*^* ncmui, (y ad concordiam hortAmur, c^uod eH g'^ fgregie tradlatom Ã PAÃienotCum Domitiie uxorisp pecumiariAm litem aduerfui fratrem eim Aenobarbih^ Ageret, Ã^am eu de neeeÃitudme rnuItA dixiffetÃtfoâ^'f Â»A quo^f^iu uterq; abutidabAt:,Adiecit; Ã®^ihÃAobii W'* nui deed, quam de quo coiUenditif â¦ Omnesdutem^^ AffÃ¨Hut, etiM Ã quibufdam uidentur 'm proamio, d^^ in epilogoÃdem habere,m quibus fanÃ©ÃmtÃeqiif'quot;âP miÃAmen alia: quoq pArtes recipiunt, fed breaiomiâ'^ feruenda cum exhiiplurima fiiu-breferuandA. Athic,fluffig

Â«s a 1^ a^e-* dixlmui rcliquA^poÃidcmui ia iudicu animos,c^âb^r ââ â^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;goÃs atq; A/perK eueflftota panderepoÃumus uâ^â

cum fit maxim A pars epilogi amplificatio, uerbis d^f ca iSâoÃ¯a? fintemijs uti liceat magnificK Atq; otvAtis.TiuÂ«lt;f^'^ ijxcautcm_ mouendum theAtru/m,cumucntum eRad ipfÂ«^^' dÃ³quidem^ ^âbÂ° ueteres trAgxdiÂ£ comcediaf claudumtur, fl^â* ca gus po- te.lnAlqsdutem pArtibus trAdAnduaaffÃ¨dliifO'di'b^ un t ur^d^u^' ^^ifâf nafcetur. NAm ncque exponi fine hoc res afo^ tinimi inha et miferabUes debent. Cum de quilitate alicuiustdl*^ d7nda Ãbo eR probationibus umiufeuiufij; rei rede fibÂ«quot;'!â'* ra fft.ut qua tur. 'Vbiuero coniundamexpluribufcaufam rimf^ruV ^^ neceffe erit uti pluribus quafi epilogis, ut iÂ»'l^* ' fiatm Ptmus. rem Cicero fecit. tramer Philodamo, ty naiurcbÃ¹,^ cruciate ciuibus Romanis, (y Alijsplur'nnisfidtbÃ ^ tuas dÃ©dit. Sunt qui hos ta.i^inoJÂ§ iTriA^^ 'â'^^ââ ^quot;â partitam perorationernfignificant, Uiibi olt;^ ^t^

â¢ OK AT OK. UBER-VI. 5^5 tf$eiiKqÂ«ÃmJ^fcicjÂ»tiefttUÃ¯.SiijHtdcm blt;ecepilogtct ^'^ pfÃ¯or4tionw nommdipfitdpcrtc ÃtwoÃendwÂ«t ,batic t^e confummitionem ordtionis.

VdmakfWtempirsbjec wdicialtmcdufitrim pt fwnmtjprxcipue^ conÃet ijji^ihws, Cr dÃ» qwde bw neccjjiriÃ´ dixerim ,non timen potÂ«i,dc ne de butquidemlocumiÃumiwtuiimJ^cciecoclHdcre. Quilnmam rpe re idbuc opw fupereft,Â«â¢ id obtmcdn^Uie uolnmiÂ«, pUef/^*â^Â» potcittiÃiÂ»nxm,tivinptpriidiilK multo dtpiciliu{,moucn fi cÃ¶pendio. diiudicumAniwos ,Atlt;[ucmc^ qÂ«emuolitmult; bibiÂ«'J^'Jââ^'?^â^^ tiwfoTm4ndi, er nclut triiufgurindi. Qui dc re piu dtne,ut sc in 't^ue poÃuUbit bic mitcrii, Ãc ittig^ut migw quid *;^^âf^Â£i' opoTteretperi ,quÃ®m quo id modo confequi poÃennw, em. pro pan o|lcndcTcm. Nunc dltiusomnw rci rcpetendiritio eft. Ã´sâÂ«'gt;â.

Kirner per totim'ut dixmus^ciufimjocus eft iÃeSi bwiCr eorumnon pmplex nituri, nec in trinptu tru* ftinla,quonibilmiiiw if}trreuK orindi poteft.Num ^jfferri 01Â» cetenforfitm tenuis quoque,cr mguÃi Ingcnq item, ti poteft fl modouel doftrinijUel ufu fit idtuti,generirf, dtque

*i pu jem iliquim perducere queit.Ccrtc funt femper adco fluxu. ^ fuerunt non piruw multi, qui fills peritÃ¨, que cfÂ» ^âââ^ng^ $'quot;âpiobitionibiÂ« utilii,rcpcrirent,quos equidem non nn.

â^J*ijnotum,itquc ( ut dielm quodfentio) digitos Ã ^ââi'gt;Wcmf(H diferti doccreiitur.Qui ucro iudieem riÂ» F'K,Â« Hl ^n5 neHet bitit u iniwi po Jfet perducere, quo

5^4 M. FAB. QVINT. INST^ diHo flendum crirdfeendum effet fririiKP^- â¢ i hoc ek, quod dominetur 'm iudieqs, hitc eloqufi^^^^^ gwnb NÃ¤nquc argumenid plerunque nd[Mtur ex e fd, ZT pro meUore pdrte plurd fu/nt femper, Â«Æ F f ^, htec uicic tdntuM,non defuiffefibi dduoedtiiW pt^^' ^ uero dn'mis iudicim ua dffprendd eÃ,ZT db ipfi '^^ templdtione dbduceitdd mens,ibiproprium Â°'^^^ââ^^. ^ Hoc libellis put eR.Hoc non docet litigdtorfioc libcÃ¼it non tur.Probdtioneten'tmelficitintfdnÃ¨,ut edufdmnojo quafi pro' meUorem effÃ¨iudiccs putent,dffeilut priejtdnt m n ^P' uelmt-Sed id quid uoÃ¯uitt,crediwt quoque.Udme^i'^â cumdictum nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. , â¢ .

fepetiopro fci,fMcrc^odiffc,inifcrcriceepermt,dgiidin^^quot;âi ^ eo quodeft^ exiftmdnt:ZTfioutdmdntcsdeformdiudicdrenoigt;pâ p^S^non fiint,quid fenfum oculorumprlt;emitdinor, iUlt;mtittgt; poteft^duftÃ¼ quirende ucritdeis rdtionem index dmittit, Â°â^^^-^c^Â»^9 dffeÃ¤ibut,eftufertur,ZTuelutrdpidoÃum'mioilT^ bus folcnt,p tur:itd drgumeutd, de tefies quid egermt, promntti^' bationesde gÃ^u^^i. c^f^gfi^ dutem db ordtore iudex fedensddhucdtq; dudiensconfitetur, Ancu/miM^

Quo quad qiuir,8CniÃ©^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

tuftraditum dccep'nKUs,dM fient ffccies,dberdiiilt;^^^ (iftit oratio nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, â r j nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;a.i^nroWl ucgetisetipi Cl â stx^^uocdftt,qudmnosuertefUesrettelt;icpTi' (antibus. affÃ¨Ã¼udicimuttdlterdm HS@^,cuiuinonÃ¯nie,ute^o'i

Â«IJ; inde pm quo^wc iBrf pbloppbide k^ikh woralw eÃ difti.Sed ipptm rei ndtÂ«rlt;(m ÃjciSdfMimibi,non tm mo , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.

rcj Jigm/icdn MtdciuÂ«r,qMdm inorum (juÃ¦ddm propric py^u, Agrico tÂ«, Ndmip/iÃ¯i^uidemomnesbdbitiwnifMM coiwwicnÂ» la quart inÂ« tur.CdutioresuotnntdtewcotÂ«plcÃ¤i,qÂ»Am nomina m'^ bi^hÃ¦Kfi? terpretari malHcrunt. a^Am igitur bos concitato$,tl non mores los mites at^j compofitos eÃe dixenwtt. In altcro webeÂ» g^aioftWi mewer commotos, in altero lenes,demq; bos wn per are, feu difpofi-, illosper[uaderc,bosadperturbationem,tljosad beneuo pÂ®quot;â-*^^ kmiam praualere. Adijciut quidam peritoru â ssa^@^ pre tarifs temporale eÃe. Quod ut accidere frequemiits fatcor, VÂ°^Â®' itanonnullas credo eÃe matcrias,qÂ«ie co win num de/iÂ« AereÂ« aÃefluMt. Nee tarnen minus artw, aut ufus bi leÂ« â'iorejbabentjUiriuwiatqj impetus non tantundem ext guw.ln cauÃs uero etiam pluribus uerfantur, imp fecu dmquendam inteUcftum irt omnibus.Nam cum nip cod illo Oâ hoc loco nibil ab oratore traftetur, quicquid de bonejlis, q- utilibus, deniq; faciendis cz nort faciendii AidturJioc uocari poteft. Quidam commendationem^ atq; excufationem propriabuius oÃieÃ putaucrtwit,ncc abnuo eÃe iÃain bac parte, fed non cocedo ut fok put, â¢Â»â¢ ^miHudadbucadijcio,â5S(xÃ¶Â©gt;,atq;S0Â©-' eÃe inte# ^jiÃ¦qyi â'Â«nexcadem natura,itaut illud mains fit,bÃ´c minus,ut

*w -BÃ soÃ§^cbaritas Ã¢^Ã´Ã, Interdiwn diuerfa inter p, fâ'â*wcpilogiÃ®.Kanq; -Ã¦aOÂ©-^ concitatpii'^ folct mi d^are .Pfop^j^ j^^^jj ^j|,j ^-^ âQ,âiuÃ CT exprimen*

^66 M. FAB. OVINT. INSTlT. , Â«esTuTÃ³e *â^â^ defiderdmui, id er it, quod Mte ontnU boiiit^^ deftris qusE-' fnendabitur,non folu mite dc pldcidwittfedp^^y

^ââ^i^ bum.in.um,o- audiettubui dmabile,lt;itlt;p iÂ«Â«â* non in gra' dam. IH quo exprimendo fummd uirtut ed ctt, mr M^nnbm nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^ Hdturd renmi hommuii q; uidedntur, jWÂ»â

tas4;uoiun' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;J nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;âJnicM

tatesamp;ua' resdicentiscxordtionepcIluccdnt.ctqtwdAitoauâ!, rotates ex'^ Iâc^itfur, quad cR pne dubio inter coiUUti^dS m^^^ I^âfedb^n pcrfond^.quoties perfermui, ignofdmut, pfÂ»/lt;'^** do quodam tnonemut, proeul db ird, proeul db odio. Seitdin^^, m^uâaniâ Pâ^^'^^dduerfmfilium,tutorh-dduerf^pupiSÂ«Â»^^ misaudien' tidduerfm uxoremmoderdtiocÃ¼.lÃ¯ienimpf^rP'^ tur'amp; quafiquot; ââ Oâ''Â«Â« ipferum^d quibui Ifdurdur^chdritdtÃ«, ^^ ^^^ quandam ui modo inuifos COS fdciiM, q quod dmdreipfi fuetudinem ^^^ cumfenex ddolcfccmis, dlid cuM conutMfK^^, tffin^at. flits inferiors fert.Bic euim tdntum concitdri,i^^

dntdfflei debet. Sunt er iOd ex eddem ndturibfli^^ ddhuc minoris, uenidm petere fddotefcemiiedfÃ§ ^

. amores, Kom:ti-r.q cti.tm kuis dheni calorie lt;^^â'â^ ^^ hdc formd uenit,fld non his ex lock tdinti/midif^^ qudnto mdgkproprid: funtuirtutcsfltnuldtioH^^'j fdciendi,rogdndi er ti^oniag,qtu diuerÃimdrquot; cit,tnteUeÂ£tiim petit.BmcetidtniHemdiorddtd'quot;^^ dum odium ndfei affÃ¨duf fokt,ctm hoe ipfo, ^^ uerpdrijsfubn:ittimus,mtelligitur tdeit/eimp^^^^ /^ probrdtio.Kdnqpcosgrdues,er inteUctdbik^^ 'b^^p, detnoÂ»flrdt,quod cedimus, erignordittcupij^â''^.^

ORATOR. LÃBER VI. 5^7 facit. iHc jam penemrditÂ« iffÃ¨diu f fl ex dworitiw, cz depderijÃ¯ Miconm,!^ neceffiÃ¼onmzndm er boewet ior fÃ/t iÃ¼o minor.NoÂ» param ÃgnificMtcr etum iUd in fcbolw H6K,dixfrwitÂ«,qKtl)HÂ« plcriwcj; ruÃieoj Æ (per PitiofoSjaltÃ³roSj timidoSjfectwidum conditionem pro* ^y^uj^ci pofitorumeOÃ¯ijgiwtM.Nam pdeH mores fwnt,cwm boe ifflitamurjCrcxbKdncimiÂ« ordtionem.DeniquebÃ³e omne^bonumo-comemuirum pofcit,qua4tttrtÂ«tÂ«cuw ftiaiM in litigatore defeat ordtor/i fie ri pote fl,appro* barejUtiqjipp ant babeat^aut babcre credatUr .Sic pro* dent pUrimu canpe, qaibu-s ex fM bonitatc fielet fie,

Nam qui dum dicitgt;mdliM nidetur ,utiq; male die it. NoÂ» TOmuidcfuriwÃadicerfjalioquiHS^ Â«iderrtnr.QKa Ã¯cipfumetia diccndigfÂ»m,wÂ»bocplacidtÂ«n debet effÃ©, de mite, nibil fuperbum, nibil datum faltcm ac /ublime defilieret. Proprie, ixcimde, credibiliter dicere fat efl.

ldco^ er meditwiUe orationÂ« modtÂ« maxime conue* ' nit-Liuerfum eÃ buk quod ilt;Ã¯a6Â©-' dicitur,quodq; KÃ¶j ^^^^,â^j afjiftuwproprie MocamiM,er ut proximcutrtufqidif* neSuida, fereiÂ«i4mÃgncm,iÂ£lMd coniÅdif, boe tragoedia pmÃe. ffââquot;''â? ^â^' HacparÃ¯circairam,odiiMn,mctum,iÂ«uidiam,miâerat!o^;ây,~,j;^, nem, ferÃ¨ tota uerfatur. Qua quibtÂ« ex lock ducenda Ã¯K.TEdvwr W,Ã¼- manifeÃum omnib[M,er nobk m ratione proob* ^^^^g Æ ââquot;i)â'q;epilogi diflum efl. Et metuw tarnen duplicem inteUiguQiQjqijff^pjjfj^yyj^jr quem facimustEt 'mui* diam. Nmque altera inuidum, altera inuidiofum facit, Hoe autfwbominkjiUud rei eÃ/m quo et pltÂ«babet ope rw oratio, iqam quidam uidentur grauia per f-, pari*

56S M. F7ÃB. QVINT. INSTIT. ^^ j cidMin),cadcs,tieneficium: quttdam cjfidenduÃtf'i' J dut contigit 3 cum magnis dlioqui mdlÃ¹ gr Mint T '^â^^â '^' quadpdÃifutnui,oÃenditur.Qudlee^tdpi*i^ff?'

HoÃHead tumulu TroiitÃtb manHufdltis lii[[^'^â''â'^, Q^dmmiJcr enimcdÃtt AndromdchiS,ficoinp^ fclix Polyxend^ Aut cum itd exdggerdniui 'wiuii^'quot;''^^ Ãrdm^t etidm qui multo minord fint, mtolcrdW^^ mui:SipulfdÃcs,defendinopoterd{,uulnerdjiiâ^^â* ,j^ diligcniiui,ciim dd edm dmplificdtionem ittntrifii^ cemut,Ã¯iuerimnotdlJ'ecoiKen(Uffiwn,nonid(ob'ilt;' .^ re a/fidut, ut que fuut oÃenddntur dcerbd Ã f^^ l fed etidmutquietolerdnddhdbcrifoÃ¯enftgrdui^'â.^^ I tur,ut cum in makdido plm murif,^ in nidnih gt;^i^^ mid p1ut pana diciwut,qudm in morte. l^tOKff^ eloquent U uk eÃ¼, ut iudiccm non dd id tdmuÂ» âquot;.'^ tipfa rÂ« na Idt,in quad-tip fed rei ndturdduccretur,fed diitlt;Ã^ tara ductC eÃ¼,dut mdiorem quam eÃ¼fdcidt a/fiilum. Uk^^'^^ qua Ã^/vamp;a'l(=uocdtur,reb{ts mdignkfuÃiefi!,^'''^ fis addons um ordtio. Qua uirtute,prdtcr dho^âÃ/ muDemoÃhenesudluit.Ciuodfit MditamibiÃ^^ ccptdfuff wer et, fit is freer dm huic parti, mbilf^ j^j iegi,ueldidici,quodmodoprobdbiiefHit,omitilt;^ ' ^ , mihi in dnimo eÃ¼,quts Idtent penituf,ipfd rire penetrdlidtqute quidem no dliquo trddenttÃ ^.^ perimÃªtomeo,dcndturdipfdducedccephSuw''â^ (quantum egoquidem femio)ciredmouendosd^ in hoc pofitd eH, ut maueamur iff. ^ ^

OR AT OK. L1BÂ£R VI. 5^9 irf/tiwdignttttonK.dlii^itÃ³ndo ridiculdfunit mitdtio, fl utrb(i,Â«Â«UwÂ«q; tiÂ»ntiM)i,non etiitm ttniwiwn Â«icconimo diUicrtwiM.Quid fnm dliud eft cdufejUt lugewes Mti^ inÃ¯teewi dolore difcrtijjjmequÃ¦ddmcxcldmdrc Midc* dHtur, c irlt;tÂ«onniÂ»iqu4m mdoftK ^uoq/loquemivtm fieldt, quim quod iHis ineft uw metwis, er Â«critis ipfi morum? expire mbw, qm HerifimiliicJfc uolemtWjpÂ» wiÂ« ip/i ffflileseoÃ¯UTn,qui uere pitiiwtur (i^ftittK,er i till mimo profcifcitur oritio,qu41em ficere tudieem Â«okt. An iHe dolebit,qui ludiet me, cum hoc dicim,nort dolemÃ«?irifcctur,finibilipfÂ«,quiwiiÃ¯imconcitit,id^ Â«i jitjfimile pitictur^ fleets igens oculis Ucbrjmis del ^ lit?jierittonpoteft.'Ncctticenditnifiignis,necmidcÂ» ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fcmiiÂ« nifibumore,nec res uUi dit ilteri colorem,quern

nd ipfibibct. Primum eft igitur,ut ipud nos luleit el, qÂ«z wlcre ipud indicÃ© m uolunnw,dflicidmur^ intequX ijjicere conemur. At quomodo fct,ut ifpciimur ? Nn^ mm funt motusinnoÃripoteflitc .Tcntiboctiimde boedictTe,quis (pavTao'Ã®o(Ã§Grdeciuocint,no$ fine ul'* fioncs ippcUemus,pcr quit wnigmcs reruw ibfciuiwn ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;itireprefcntintur iniwo,ut cis cernerc oeulis/cpri#

fÃ®tes b Acre uideimur. His quifquis bene cepcrit, is Â«k w aOtftibus potentif imus .Htwe quidam dicunt ti ^WitoT0jj,qui fibi re$,ttoccs,iftÂ«s feeudum ucriwn Â®pbmÂ«5in jet,quod quidem nobis uolentilus fieile con* 'â¢â*amp;rt.KaniMt inter otii intmorwm,cr ftgt;ts ininr$,er Â«flut fontnia qutdim uigiliwiwm, iti nos bee, de qui* bus loquâunuir imijiiics profequun(Hr,ut peregriniri,

570 M. FAB. CLTINT. INiTlTÂ» , fflt;iiiigdre,prfUdri,populosdUoiiui,diuitiMni,lt;li^'\ hdbemut,ufum uidedmur difponere, nee cogitdrc,p i^ no(lram c^^^'^ocdnimiuitit^dd utiMdteminontrisff^^â^' Ac vt hominem occifum t^ueror,non omnid^di'tnrif^^ ^ofum^f^'^^dccidi/JÃ¨credibikcR inocuUshdbebofnon^ modo tem' euffor iUe fubitm ermtipetfnott expducfectfcircidgt;gt;^ aeÃ¤dk â^fed ^^ exctdmdbit^uelrogdbitfuelfÃ¼gtet ^ nonferiem^â omnta qux non conddemem uidebo^ non dnimo fdngtiis, udr,eygemitut,extremittdeni^exbirdntishi^tin^' peculiari detflnfequctur ^cc^yiicc^quig tb Ciccroneiunp'^^^^^ formulT^^ ^â^ââ^^^ââ^^Â°*^^â^^â*^} c^udtnontdmdiccreuidftu'^f^^ Â°'^â^'â â' nbsp;nbsp;oÃendere, er dffrÃ©luf nondliter qudmfirebuiif^J^'

fdticepit imdginem, ut diceret ; Et didcis nx^ ^^ minifdtur Argot f vbiueromiferdtioWâgt;Pââ' J nabis edÃeqtiibusquerimur, deddi/fe credan^ id dnimo noflro perfuddedmus. iSSositli/iniiii,^'*^^^ uid,indignd, triflid pd/fos querdmur. t^ec qud/tdliendm,fcd d^urndmus pdrumper idiii^^^^^ HucreferPo Itddicemut, qurin fmilinoflrocdfu diHnti^il^ nemTquÃ³ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fd!pehiflriones,dtquecomÂ«dos,ogt;Â»^

egredi. Quad flin dlienit firiptis fol^ itd falflsdcceditdflÃ¨dibus, quid nos f'^^'igf'

Sed âm fÃ oUrebw quoÂ«]^ ipps Â«Dici ecuenit/i^Ã©jjUcrAÃ® fibi Ãngrrc,boc magw.quod iHic ut litigdtorcj loquimur frequentiui^ ut (tdMciH.Orbum dgimiK/t ndufrigu, er p(Ã¯iclitlt;wtcm, quorum mducre perfon^ non utti* ^^â net,nip Â«Dfftm Ã¼JJu-rmwdHfe dij?imÂ»Undlt;t mibi non fucruÂ«t,qÂ«ibiÂ«ip(c,qu4HiufciMtq;ttfÂ«lt;fuit(nÂ«mptrHeÂ» ni (JÃ© me Â«d Â«liquod nomen ingenij credo^Jrequeneer wo tiÂ« fttm,ut me nonUbrjimÂ« folum dcprebcndcrint,fcd

IJ Vic diutrJduirtut, quÃ¦ rifum iudick mou?do, ^ââ'^ aXc iUoJ trifles foluit afjÃ¨Ã³biw, c unitnum ub in* temionererum frequenter ducrtit,(y ultqiwndo etidm âf'f'eitjCt ipitietdtCjUcUfdtigdtione renoudt. Qudntd ft WÃ© m ei difficult 1Â«, uel duo miximi oritores, alter

?ecÂ«, alter latinÂ« eloquctiÂ« prmcipes,doccnt.Nd plc Ã¯ittÃ¼emoDbeni ficultdtÃ¯ buitÂ« rei defuiDe crcdunt,Ci â¢NamPlutar 'eronimodMm.Nec uideri poteÃ noluijje DemoÃbenej, chus in pro' euwvaucaadmodildiftijnec fanÃ© citerU fitMMirtutb'^j'^'^^-,âÃ§,sÂ® bus rtÃmndent id, palam oÃendut, nee diÃilicuiffe iUiio Ciceronis tos,ftdnoncontigilfc.NoÃrrucrononfbluextraiudi-Â»Â®j^j;^'^l 'ii,fediÂ«ipfis ctidmoratiorilusbabituacÃnimiusrifut toMcs,utio' âl^Ã¯litor, Mibi quidem,f]uc id refte iudico,fiMC dwo* jâ^^^âjjjJ Â«Â«KimodicopricipuicloqucniiattirilabcÃ¯o jWirdqucuiat modÃ©ra ^omulÃ nurmeo fuifje urbdnitos. Ndmerinferwo*â^Â®^â'^â â' S^^diiano multi, er in dltercationibus er mterro* X^ilbttjbijn^ ^luraqudm quifqudwdixit fdcctc,CJ* Â®* 'Pjlt; qui funt in V errÃ© difl a frigidiiÂ«,dlqs df?tgnit

uit, t:^ teÃimonij loco po fuit, ut quo fuut migi! gt;t^iâ* rid,eo fit credibiliuf illd ah ordtore non fi{ii,!lt;:i f^Ã^ bbertus^^s^/fiilt;^^lt;f* VtinittnCiÃ¿tntui, c^Ã®ibertusdus'iif'ââ Tiro. dut dUus quifquis fuit, qui trÃ¨s hdc de rc libros ciâiâb pdreius diHorum numÃ©ro mduÃ®filfenhcr plus iuÃ¼^ f eligendis,qudm in congerendis fludij ddbibuijfeiit-^ nus obieÃ¢uscdlunidntibusforet,qui tdmennuwi'â'^ utinomni dus ingenio,fdcilius quid reijei, quÃ®m^^'* ddijcipofiit,mufnient.AffÃ¨rtdutemfuwmdmrciiiiP' cultdtem,Primum quod ridicultm di^um plcruu^r fum eÃ¢,hoc femper humile, fiepe ex indufirid tanquam tum, prÂ£tered nuÂ»qudm honorificum, turn uirU b^ num Micid in eo,quid non rdtione dliqiu,fei motu ddm,ncfcio dn endrrdbiUiudiedtur. lJeq^ hoc di

. tis explicdri pu to,licet multi tetduermt^ V nde ^^Ã¯iocâ¢itbum ^'^'^^Â°â^ folumfdÃ©lo dliquo diÃ¼Ã³ue, fed mteriuH^^ nonene inquot; ddm did corporis trdÃ¼u ldccÃitur. PreeteredÂ»^' uttudo CO' rdtione moucrifolentttJeq; enim deute tuntum^quot; *^'â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fte, fed flulte,irdcunde, timide diHd dUtfuHd

Lib.ii.de euldbcArifus.'Hdbetenim,utCicerodicitifeifâ^^^^ oratore. formitdtedliqud,0'turpitudine;queciimindV Â«(1 firdntur^rbdnitdstcum in ipfum dicentÃ« titid uoedtur.Cuuidedtur dut res teuis,et que ul ^^ tnimis,infipientibus denied fiepe mouedtur,tdmoU^^^^^ ulm nefcio dit imperiofifiimd, er cui repugndrt m ^ potcR, Erumpitenim inuitis fiepe, unitus modo dc uods exprimit confefiioi}eiigt;,pâ

corfw ui ÃÃ¼ coiicutit .Rfrum dutem flt;epf, ut iixi mixi Minwn momenta uertit, cum odium irdm^ jre({itentiÃi wejrungit .DocumentÃ³ fmt iiwencs TircHtmi^qui mul ti de Pyrrho rege fecHrim inter coetJttmlocutijCumrd* tione fufti repojcereÂ«4Â»r,et neej; neguri res ^neÂ«^ iefen di Ãoffet,rifu font et opportimo toco cUp/i .N^tn^i unm exbiJjImojinijMitjniÃlUgctiddffccijJ'etjOccidiJJemiMtc. Ei^ urbdniute tot* eft inwidid criminis dijjblwttt .V c* rÂ« hoc quic^d eÃ,Mt non iufim dtcere,clt;trere omnino dr tc,qÂ«id nonnuHdm obfcriwttoncbubet,Junt^ dd id perti n?tid,et d Grlt;ecK ct Ã Ldtmw copofitd pr^ceptd^td pld Â«Ã¨df{inÂ«o pr^cipue poptu e^e iÂ»ndtÂ»rd,ct in occdfio* tw .Potto ndturd non tdntu m hoc Â«diet j Â«t dcMtior quis ââââÃlâibiliorfit dd inueniendutn : num id fdnÃ¨ doftrind pojet dugerijjf d ineft proprium quibufddm decor in bi bb dt^ mltu, ut eddem idd miniw dicente dlio uideun tUT urbdnd ejJe.OecdJioni Â«ero ct in rebut eft tintduw, ut ffpe ddiutiedno indofli modo,fed etidm ruÃiei fdlfe dicuUj ut cum quit dliqitid dixerit prior. Sunt enm lo q^iJ aUgd di gewenujliordomniditt rcj^ondendo,qÂ«dmin prouo^xentprior, cundo. Accedit diÃteuUdti, quod eius rei nuUd exercitd* tio fft,tiutli pr/ceptorej.vtique in conÂ«iuqj,er ferma uibutmulti dicdcet,fed quid in boc ufu quotididno pro* 5âquot;â¢Â« ,ordtoridÂ«rbdnitlt;Â« rdrd, nec ex drtc proprid, f'i ii\nnc confuetudinem decommoddtd. Nibil dutem Utt Alt,Q. componi mdteridt in hoc idonedtjUt contra *'ââl'* {Â«rmixtis fdUbw jingerÃ«tHr,ucl res proponi fm* tulÂ« dd ii^cjj f^ifu, exercitdtionem â¢ Quin illÂ« ipfÂ«Â».

centix diccre fokbumuitfi pAubm ddhibiti rMowp^^ ^erc!itur,dut aliquid in hk ferium qtiO(^(SJâ^lt;^'â^'â^ fiurim-Mn potcrut utilitdtis al]im,que luuKi^. nelfibi ludentium exercitdtio e^i. Pluribtts MicÂ» 'quot;â nibui in eddem re uulgo utimttr,qujetdgt;nenÃiâ^'â^^â[^ Vrbanum. dmpropridmqMnddinuimoflendeiu.tiMCri^fb^

tas didtur, qM quidem Ãgnifi:dri uideo ferntonemf^ fÃ©ferentem in uerbk,^ lÃ¨najCT' t*fu propfkn ^Â«^ guÃi'im urbk^ Grfumptdm ex conuerfdtione iodor'gt; tdcitdm cruditiwem,Demq; cui contrdridfd Â«f/^* Venuftum venuÃuMeffe, quodc'MngrdtidqMddtn(Tâ^â'^ .

SilÃ¼tm. edtw dppdret. SdlfummconfuctudincprorUi^quot;^^ tdm dccipmui.ndturd non utique hoe e^jqiunqn*^, De Orat. n. ri^iculd oportedt eÃe fdlfd.Ndm er Cicero, omiUrj^ fdlfu/m fit dit eÃe Atticordin, non quid funt mi^

i^uHd in tdmmdgnoeA corpore mied SdUf' dicit, nihil in corpore eins eÃe ridiculum â¢ Sjlfint ig erit quad non erit mfulfam, uelut quodddntftiiilgt;^^J^ tionis condimentum quad fentitur IdtenteiuiiciOâ pdldto,excitdt^,et d ttedio dÃ©fendit ordtionent' i^â men ut ide in cibit pdulÃ³ liberdlius dÃerfuf,fi tÂ»''^^ ^ fitimmodicus, dÃert dliquid proprif uoluptdtif- it^ quoq; in dicendo hdbent quidddm, quod noUtp^ ricetum. diendi fitint. Fdcetem quoq; non tdntunt cira ridiâ opsnor confiflere. Ã¯^e^ enim diceret Hordtiuffieetâ

OK AT OR. LIBER VL i^S Vincm.i^is er exculte cuiufJiitHckgituiÂ« dppcU.itio* nem Ã§uto, UeÃ³que 'm cpiflolis Cicero bec Bruti refert uerti ;\e uUi fuut pcdej f^ccti, Ac delicijs in jrediewi

moUc j,tpod conutnit cum iHo HordtiAno, Motte A^ucfdcctâ¢, Vergilio. locum ttcro Ac* cipimutj^wd eft comrArium ferio. NAm er fingerc/t teYTeTf,r promittere 'mtcrimiociw eft,DicdcitAt fine Dkadtas. dubio /dicendo,(jHÂ« ex omni genere comimi dufte eft, propt ie temen figniÃcAt fermonem cum rifÂ« eliquos Â«iÂ» ct (fentem.ldeo DemoÃbenem urbAnum fuiÃe dicumt,di tAcemnegAW. Proprium Autem WAtcrie, de que nunc 1^Â«Â«Â«Â«, eft ridieuhw. ldcÃ³(|ue bec tote dij^utAtio Ã GtÂ«ck â¢amp;! yiXoi'a 'infer ibitur. Biui prime diuifiÃ³ tre 5tcniiw t ditÂ«reAdcm,quecftomnisorAtionw, utfitpofitumin rfbiÂ«,AHfinHcrbw. Vfut Autcmmeximcfimplcx. AMt turn cx elijs rifum pctimw, dut ex nobk, eut ex rebiw medijs. AliÃ©nÃ© AUt reprcbendimiÂ«,AMtrcfÂ«tAmiÂ«,Attfc cleuAmm.Autrecercutimud.AutclttdnniMtNoPrAridicÂ« - I' Deortto.Â«Â» Umdicemui, er Â«t uerbo Ciceronw Â«ter, dictmu* eu* qui fubebfurdA. NAnque eAdem, qÂ«e ft imprudentibtM excident, (lultA fÂ«nt,fifimulAmiw ,ucnuÃe creduntur* Tertiumeft genuCjtÃ³ idcmdictt,'mdecipiendk expeftd twnibiÂ« diftk Aliter Accipiendkjceterk'que que neu* '''ââ¢wperfonAm confmgunt. ldeo^ Ã me mediA dicun* *Â«rattfli ridicule,AUt fecimiw.Aut diejmue.Ã¯Afto rifus coneiliatitf'mtcr'nn Admixtegreuitete ,ut M. CeediuJ ^^^^Â»cwdfettAmcius curulÃ«Conful ifdttricujjregiJ* P gt;^Â«Tim pofuit lork mtetem-'OietbAtur Autem ConÂ»

57Â« M. FAB. oyiNT. INSTIL' fuU pitre dliqMttdoctefut fligrit. interim fine rfjr-* Pro Cxiio. ^n pudorityUt in Old pyxide Ctcliindj^nod naine er.ne ri,neqHeuUigrMiuiroconueniit. idemiutcmdeuultn amp;^flâ*^ ridicuh didlim fitt,in quibut eH StudentfnmnH a^nw g^dtii,fed mMorcumciptdrerifitmttonuidlt;iitur.lit i Am non up hil enim ex hit lt;iuÂ£ dicunt fiilfi,dictwt mfilfiiigt;Q!i^ j A/enimex ^lt;eetmiutegrittypluritttirtndidliffeueritmifirtfit^ 1 his qux di' ridiculiM id ippm, quid qui dicit non ridet, ei tMin I cuntur inful j^fff^ Ã§yafpcdlut,(^ hdbitUi oriStCrgefiutnos ifflit I bdnut, cum hit modus contigit. id porro quad Ã®ieM j dut ell Idfciuum or hiUre^qudUd Galbiplene^Mtcon , tumcliofiim,quAlid nuper lunij âÃdÃitdutdf^enm, q^ j lid CdÃq Seuerbdut lene, qudlid Ttoniitij A/ri, ReP hit ubi quit utdtur. Ã¼dm in conuiuijs e^ quotHi^ejee moneldfciud humilibus,hildrid omnibus conuenient' derenunqudmuclmus, langc^ ibfitpropofitnie^ â¢ potius dmicum qudm diiium perdidi.ln hd(qâlt;'^^'''^^* gnd foren ft mdlim mihi lenibus uti licere : tpi^ contumeUofe, cr ijlere dicere in dduerfries fersnip fum cH^cum dccufdre etidm pilim, Cf eipni ilterin'^ fie petere coneeÃum fit. Sed hie quoq^ tanen mbigt;ââ^. uidcri folet fortune mfeSldtio, net quid eulpd edtfâ quid recidere etidm in ipfos qui obiecerunt, poitngt;r's^ mum it dtp confiderindum ell,(^ quit, in qui cdtifitT dpud quem,e^ in quem,cr quid diedt. Ordton mim''''^ conuenit di flortus uultus gejiusp, que in mintis riim folent. DiedebdS etidm feurrilis ctrfeenied huic perfid dÃeniÃimd ell. obfcoenitd( uero non d Herbis tints*

ORATOR. LIBLK VL 377 tbejp debet,fed etidmdpgrtipedtiorte. Ndmpqudndo obijci potep,non in omni loco exprobrundd eft.Ordto-

U pUnÃ¨ nolo. Qg-tpropter ne dieet quidÃ¨ pl/Ã¨ quoties poterit jC diftum potiiw dliqu^ndo perdet,^ minuet du toritiitem, Hcc deeufitorem dutÃ« dtroei in cdup,nec plt;t trotjuminmiferdhiliioedrttemferetquijqudm. SuntetiÃ¯ iudicei quidim triÃiores/j ut rifumlibenter pitidntur. Salet interim dcciderCjUt id quod in dduerpriÃ dicimw dut in iudieem conuenidt, dut noÃru quoq^ litigdtorem, qumqdliqui reperiuntur, qui ne id quidÃ«, quod in ipfos teciderepoÃitjCuitent* Quod fecit Longos Sulpitiiw, quicumipjÃªfÅdiJ^imiK eUctjeumjContrdquem iudi-Â«0 liberdi dderdt ,ne fdciÃ« quidebdbere Ã¼beribominis iixit.CuireÃiondes Domitius AferÃt tu,inqt,ex ini* ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;s'fententid Longe? Qui mdldmfdeiembubet,liber non

â''tempore dlienum,ne prÃ¦pdrdtum ez domo iUnuui' lt;Uur,quod dicimus. Nu dducrfusmifcros,|icut /Ã»prd d:xerim,tÂ«bHmdnuscftiocus. Sedquiddmitdfuntrece ptÂ« dutoritdtis, er notÂ« uerecundiÂ«, ut nociturd pt in tos dicendi petuUntid. Ndm de dmicis idm prÂ«ceptum quot;^AHudno dd ordndi ferÃ¨ conpliujfÃ¨d dd omnid perÂ« homines ââ'*h UcefJutboe modo,quemlÂ«derc pt pcriculofum, â^â''ââ¢wumicitiÂ« grducs inftqudntur,dut turpis futijfd âââ¢*We etidm dicitur,quod in plures conuentt,p dut quot;â*twnes tot* inccJJdntur,dut ordines,dut conditio,dut pudw nwltorum. Ld quÂ« dicit uir bonus, omnid [dlud ^ f,ifj

â ^ '^'â^^â dignitdte de uerecundid decent, tumtum tnim ri^m pretium e^^ fi probitdtK compendio conÃit. VnietiÂ»^ tem concilietur rifuSjCr putbus ex locis peti fdat, Ã¼j^ cilimum eÃ¼ diccre, Ndm Ãfpeeies omnes perfcijitiiidi' mus^nce modum reperiemuf, erÃ-uÃn bbordbiirM, Ã¯^eq; enim numcrop mmus funt loei, ex i^vibus bic in' Ã©ld,qudm iUtex quibur c.e qudt fententi^ uocMiis,iii' euntur, neq; dij. }Jdm bic quoq; eA inuentio, tytlixt' tio,dtq; ippus elocutions us alid in uerbspi.i infÃ¿ij rif â¢ R ifus igitur oriuntur dut ex corpore eins in i^ni it emus,dut ex dnimo, qui faciis db eo diHisq; colh^^jt nut ex his qua f^nt extrapoptd. intrn bec cnim (H^ â treuerÂ» uituperdtio,quapgrduiuspoptd fit, feridfinfi^i^ ridiculdt Hac dut oflenduntur, dut nÃ¤rrdntur, dut it* Ho notdntur.Rdrum eÃ¼ dutem,ut oculis fiibijcerc cStiit tCraffoshÂ» g,dt,utfecit-i-C.Julius,quicuticluiom.tncipippigt;tol W ^^7a^ flf^p^ittipbidiccrct,idmoficnddmqudlisfis,isfP^i ' ss-a.^- ffiParetmter.rogdtione,qudlefetdndem0ÃiitÃriist' quam f^hdigito demonÃrduit imdgmem gdiÃ¯i in Ãiito Cimbt Ca HÃ¼ auem co piÂ£tdm,cuimdttceps-t turn pmiltniuseff'etui[iâs,lâ' intdHgÃ©quot;Ã¯b ^^t-rta dutem erant cired forum,dc fcutu iHudfyii^^^ fircpeiÃ¼ cm tidpoptum. tgt;:drrdrc quÂ£plfdfnt, til prmutit' ra ^dam^ iÃ¼tt QT ordtorium,Ut Cicero pro Clumtiondrrdtit^^ ribus jngra pdpo,dtq; Fdbricio,dc M.CdciliusdeiÃdD.LdHj^ PnCluÃ io^^^gt;^â^^^P^Â°â^â^^â^'âfi^^

his omnibus cum elegdns (y uenuÃd exigiturW fitio,tum id eH fefliuiÃimum,quod ddijeit ordtot- r* ty d Ciccrenepc eÃ¼ Ã¯dbricijfugd iHd conidi' u^r

Â«UM ciHidij^imc ff putitrct dicere, et cum illlt;lt; Â«erbd gr4 wÃtmi ex intima drti^cio dcprompfijjet: RfÃgt;icttr,trt-^uit,bomin'4mforttMtÂ«,rfJ^icitf Â«xrioj Juro^q; edfus^ reJ^iciteC.Tibritij feneftute. Cum bocref^icitc, ornS dlÂ« oritionij c4Hfii,ffpc dixijjet/eÃ^exit tpfe. At Pibri tiiÂ« Ã fubfcllijj demijo Â«pite iifeeffer.it/1 csetent quÂ« ddiecitjttim notus locur, cum in re bdc fotum effet, Ã®d-bntiumiiudiciorecejjifjc. Et C/liujcum omnÃ¹uc-nulUÃmcÃnxitjtumiHud ulttmumftcfubfecututt Quo modo triinfierit,utrum rdte, 4u pifeutorio muigio, ne* ma feiebdt. Siculi quidem, ut funt lafciui t^- iicAces^iÃ¼e* bint in dclpbino ffiiffe, Oquot; fic tinquim Ariom trunf* ueftum. In nxrrdndo uutem Cicero confiftcrc fdcetius P^tit^icicitiltem in tJeiendo, wire fuit in boe genere Â«enaPut A fer Domitiu s,cuius ordtionibuJ cÃ¶plures bu -infmoHmmtiones mfertxreperimtur, fed diftorum qMoq;xbfodfmurbÂ£trte,funtedttilibri . lUudquoqjgc \ nuÃ¯ eft poftum non in bic ucluti wculxtionc uerborum, ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;V induik breuiter urbinitdte ,fedin quodum longiorc

dSu, quod de CrujJb contra Brutum Cicero in fecundo de Owtorclibro er dijs quibufdamlocw narrat. Nam turn Brutus in aceufatione C. Planci ex duobus lectori* bus oÃendifjet,contrariai* Criffum patronumcius woTttione quam de coloniaNarbonenp babuerat, jua-Fff' bis qux de lege Seruilia dixcrat, tres excitauit cy ipfe bftores ,bisq; patrw eins dialogos dedit Ie gendos, q'aorumcum in Priuemati units, alter in Albano, ter^ tiaÃ¯in Tiburti [ermonembabitum complcftcreturave*

iSo M. VAJ}. QVINT. IN5TIT-quirebÃ¢t ubi effent htc poÃeÃiona.Omneis Mt /'itlt;f BrÂ« tiu uendiderat, er cumpxtern:tmMcipdrctprtii^,^''â^ pK hdbebdtur^ Similis in dpologis quo^jer t^uibuÃ^ etidm interim hiflorijs exponendis, grdtideonfe^idÃ' Ict.Sed deutior edl illd,dt^ ueloeior in urbdnitdte br(igt;â tds. Cuius ejuidÃ© duplex ed formdydicendi de reffonied di,fed rdtioeSmunis in parte, Nihilenminldceffetdn did poteÃ, quod no etidm in repercutiendo.At propm qudddmfunt reff ondentium,Old etiamird cocitati afif refflent, hre plerunq; in dltercdtione,dut in rogodis K ffibus.Cumfftitdutemlodptures,exquibusdilliriiii('* Id ducdntur,repetendum eh mihi,no omneiseos ordtof^

KieiocuseÃ¼btisconuenircAnprimisdiitemexdmphiboloÃ¿dini^â^ ^^t^^^ ^^â^ Â°lâfeurd,qnd; AtelldnÂ£morecdptAtur,nccqtfdidiiiâi ggt; uetercs qu go idÃ¤dntur,uiliÃimo quoq; conuerfd in mdlediHHf^^ accprofÃ©rÃ©s â^^^â^'^dc^NeilldquidemquÂ£ CiceronidUquid^Ã^ bÃ¢t. Donat* ^Â°^ ^ dgÃªdo exdderunt,ut dixi, cumisedndiddtid, jw in Adelphos coquifiliushdbebdtur,cordmeofuffrdeiunidbiitiâgt;(gt;^^^ tionÃ«faciÃ¨s ^^dEgo quoq^ tibtfduebo.Non quid excludeitiidli'ââ^ ^ââJ*- ^f Ãintninouerbd duos ffnfusÃgnificdntid,fedqdidrdi'â'lquot; referiieum l^^â'ffâ^gt;^^^^nt,nificum prorfas rebus ipÃsddiudiquot;^' q coquifili*â Qudre non hoc modo peneeripfumfcurrileCiâfâ^'â'''^ gAat^Tuâ^^^ ^ ^^^â^^^^^^ ?^ââ Ãp^^ dixid/duricum:Ni'!0^^^\^ queadcra^ Ãt, quodpdter tuxs homo coÃantiÃimuste nobis ii^â^â huiccaufÃ¦. reliquit.Sedidud ex codent genere prrcldru,cum obii^ fetes^coquus retMilonidccufdtor,in argumentumfdiUdrum VÃ per c lite'ififfdidrum, quod Bouidas ante horanonam diuertiffsb fif^ebatur. KPexÃcdfdretdumCbdiifsittflldÃkt cxiret, di^f/iii f

mterrogirct quo tempore Clodiu$ occi^M cÃct/rÃioÂ«* dit (tro,qHod folum fu^it,ut hoc genus no totum repu dictur* Nee pluru modepgnificiri folent, fed etium di-uerfd^tNero de feruo pe^imo dixit: NuUi upud fc plus pdcibikTi,nibil ti neq; inclufÂ«m,ncque fgiMtum effe, Peruenit res ufq; id Â«nigma, quule eÃ Ciccronii in Pk toriumFonteijlt;iccufi(torem,cuiusmdtremdixit dum ui xijfet lHdum,pojlqÂ«4m mortud cjfet mugi^ros Wtuijfc, Dieehiintur dMtÃ¨,dÂ«m uixit, infimes foemiwie dd edm co umirc fÃ¼llte, pof mortem eins bond uenibdut, qudnquA bidudus per trdnÃdtionem diftus ef ,mdgiÃri per dmbi guitdtcm.in mctdlcpfin quoq; eddit cddem rdtio dido- ^^quot;|âft'j g rwâÂ«,VtI(ibiusMdXimusiÂ«cufdn$ Auguficongidrio ambiguita.) âfÂ«'Â»gt;qÂ«eiimicis ddbdntur,exiguitdt?,bcmindridejjc di ^ââJw^ Â»t.Ndm congidrium cum ft comunclibcrdlitdtis dtque alicuius uen mtnfure,^ menfurd dudd imminutio cd rerum-Et bee jj^^jâ^^^^'f tdiÂ»i(rigid4,| cd nominumfidio/diedis, dctrddM,mu tonbus folue

1 nbsp;nbsp;tdtb Uteris, ut Acifculum,quidc0etpddusPdcifculum, â''^ gt;nbsp;â''^ ââ¢ C PUcidum nomine, quidbis deerbus ndturd effet, Aci Ãa utniret, dum,er Tulli urn,cum fur effet, ToUium didos iwucnio. ââÃâ^f ^â^ Scdbeceudemgencrd comodius inrcbusqinnomwii- ad Attic, De busTefpondcnt.AferenimucnHfcMdnIiumSurdmmul poffeffioni-tuminajendo difcurfdntcm,fdlicntem,mdnus idddntc,^Ã¼ââ^pâ,^,â^j ^f^^itijeientem er reponentem, non dgere dixit,fed dis bonis nia F'âm|lboc didum per feurbunum fdtdgcrc,etiA* SK^Â« p nulUfulfit dltcrius uerbi fimilitudo. riunt er detrd- disqi ex ed-

Â«b Cr iiicfti dffirdtionc, er bonis coniundis uerbis, ^riK^feri /imiuterfepiuj^igi^^, (di^M^ndo tdmen reeipicdd,cd- lokt*

iSz M. PAB. oyiin, INSTlT. dem^ conditio c^ in hit, qi{Â£ 4 nomimlus tnbntltf. Mult4 ex hoe Cicero in Verrem, fed ut abtilijs di{lii,ifio do futurum ut omniu uertcret, cu diceretur Verres:tiÂ«gt; BAio, iii. dc)Hcrculi,quÃ«expil4uerat,molcflioreR^Uiit!iiSââ(^^ Erymunthiofui/Jetimodo malu S4cerdoteni,lt;jui tM Â«^

ferdt. Priebet tdmen aliquundo occdfionem t^UitdiDiP citas hoc ^uo(]; genere bene utendi, ut pro CeciMd 0' cero in teftem Sex. Clodium Phormionem: Neetn'uuu'^ gcr, inquit, nee m^m confidens, q efi ideTcreiitiditiii Phormio.Acriord igiturfunt et elegantiord, t^ua tr^ tur ex ui reru, In his maxime udlet fmilitudo, ft^'* ad dliquid inferim leuiusg; referdtur, t^udidmueter^K ^aMsToTa' ^ââÂ°lt;^â^^âlt;f^tâ^r,c}uiLcntulumSpintcrem,^Scipione^ pionem. Serdpionem eÃe dixerunt. Scd cd non db hoininHufquot;^ dÃ¨ petitur, uerumetidm db dnimdlibus, ut nabisi^^^ luniut BdÃus homomprimisdiedx ,afmiitdlbiu doedij tur,cr Sarmenfus, feu Publius BleÃus itmiuigt;ibaiÂ«irgt;nd g(rendi 3/ ^â^â')Grmdcrum,crpdndum,fibuldmfeireiigt;'^^' H^s gignen' ^â^Â°â^ d^s^nc rifiu petendigenusfrctjucntiftKUiiiy, â^â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Adhibetur dutÃ« fimilitudo interim pdlamdtiterim^l.

folet pdrabolÃ¦,cuius efl generis id AuguflfquiiÂ»^^ belluni timide porrigeiiti:noli,inciuit,dubitdretddi^ aÃem elephdto des. Sunt qudddetidmueriflmilid. VÂ«^ Vdcinius dixit hoc diÃ¤um, cum reusdgentein euind uo,candido Ãontem fudario tergeretfd^ ipfum decs' fator in inuidiam uocdretiQuamuis reus fim,inqÂ«!f panem candidmn edo- Adbuc cA fubtiliar did ex f quot;lilt

Fungitur dniphibologiÂ« fimilitudo^ut L. GdWd,qui ca^^tan* \ piUm negligenier petenti, fa inquit^petis tdn^ C^fdris didatus pro*

rdudiddtus, Ndm lUud pftw dmbiguum eft,fccuritlt;Â« fl- Â«Â«'âÂ«Â«quot;â¢

wills .Quod bdÃ¢enus oftendifle fdtis cft. CÂ«terum)re-qutntiÃmd dliorum gencrucum dlijsmixturd eft, cd^Ã® opfmidquÂ« ex pluribus conjldt. Eddem diÃimiliÃ rdtio t il .Hinc eques Ro â¢ dd quem in fptft dculÃ®s bibentÃª cum wifijltt Augu(lus,qti diccrct^egofi prdndere uolo, do wÂ«meo:Tu cni)n,inquit,nontwnc$,ne locum perdds. Eemnium Excontrdrio non undfpteies: Neq; cnim todem modo dixit Augufus prlt;fcfto ,qucm ignominid notdbdt, âââÂ«bÂ« fubindt interponenti precibus: Quid rej^ondebo pdtri wtoi nie me tibi dij^licuiÃf Â»quo GdlbÂ« pcnuU rogdnti, nonpoÃmÂ«commoddre,domimonco,cÂ«coendcMlumeiuÂ« perpluerct. TertiÂ»mddbuciHud,fiqwidem,Â«t ne dutoÂ» rempondm, utrecundid ipfiuj fdcit t Libidinofior es, qusmuUusftiddo, quo fine dubio er opinio decipitur* Vitxcotrdrio.EtbocexcodÃ«locoeftjfedHuUtprioru â¢ v M',quoi dixit M.VeJliniu$,cumci niMicidtumcp pVobivÃ fet.Ã qiwndodefmet putcre. onerdbo librum exem- sinus,'autW pbsfâ¢ibm^bis,quirifusgrdtidcomponuntur ,fff- Â«umÂ» Â«Â«quot;Â»fi ptrfcqui uoluerofinguld weterum.Ex omnibuÂ»

Ã®84 M. FAB. QVINT, INSTiT. drgumtntorum locis elt;idi occafio cll-Ã®Ã®Ã¢m (y Ãniticitf ufiae^ AuguÃus de Pantomimisduolta,lt;iuiikcmigt; geflibm contcndebÃ¤nt^cum eorum dlterumÃltitore Ã¼' xit,dlterum mterpeUitorem. P.t pirtitione Gidbd^ penulam rogdnti refÃondit,non pluit^on (ft opustii'-fi pluitjpfe utar.Proinde genere,Ãeae,proprijs,Hlji' rentibus,iugdtis,ddiunÃ©iis,confcqucntiii(s, tinteceitnti bui,repugndntibus,cdttfts,effÃ¨Ã is,cÃ´pdrdtionepdriiâ!ii, mMorum,minoru,fmitK mdterid priebetur,Ãctlt;t in tr^ pasqua^; omncscddunt.Annoplurimd

De orat. tj. dicunturf cjualerefert Cicero de homineprolong), si' put eum adfomieÃ« Fabij oÃendiffe. Et quod P.Oppuj dixit de genere Lentulorum, cumÃ¤Ãidueminorespits tibus liberi effent nffeendo. Interim utriinq;.Qi{td ifO' â F proprie ^âquot;^^ ^^^^ ^'^ââ^'gt;i spuit ftt ueriÃimd, er ioci propsi^* pro nus cR^ Qj(d urbdne ufus eÃ¢ Afer,F cum Pidio^â ejui prouincidiÂ» dmbitiofiÃime petierdt,deinde impsiâ'^ td ed, tdnq coddus querebdtur, dge, inquit,âdiquid,G' Kcipublict cdu/deldbord. Qud^ CiceroufusÃt^u^^ tinij morte nuncidtd,cuiuspdru certus dicebutur iue^' Interim,inquit,uffrdfrudr. Idem per dUegorinquot;^^ Hum melius obijcientemcrimind q defendenteit,^^ dextrdm,mdÃ¯dm ÃniÃrÃ¼ hdberedicebdt. Empb^i^^'* â¢ItntiQttm Hus dixitferruiâ AcciumUduiutttcidiffe.Figiir^if'^, quementis,qut ^H/j.oiJx Z.iavo!lt;xi^ dicuntHr, res(i recipit omneis, in quds nÃnuUi diuiferuntffeciesditis)^ rum.Ndm er interrogdmus,^^ dubitdmuSjCrdffiââ'^* ) mus, er mindmur,et optumus: Ciiiddum ut miferi'gt;^^gt; 1

ORATOR. LIBÃR VL Ã®SÃ§ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1

O' qufditm ut irdfeentÂ« diciwiÂ«. Ridicutum dutem eft nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;l

omnc,quod dpertc jingitur. Stultd reprebendere fdcili-mum eft .Ndm per fe funt ridicule, Scd rem urbdUd fdeit Â«liqud ex notk ddieftio. Stube iMtcrrogducrdt exeuntÃ« dctbedtroCdÃ¯pdtbiMm TityiÂ« MdxiMÂ«M,drtJ^cftdp- Curius fet, fccit CdrpdtbitÂ« dubÃ¼dtione m eitÂ« pultiorem dieen Wanius, do;Non,fcd morcbcÃydpikluj!, Rc/ututio eu fit in ne gdttdojreddrgurndojdffcndendojclcudndo, ridicule ne gduit MdniuÃ® Curiuj. Num cum riw deeufutor in Sipd-rio omnibus lock, dut nudum eu in tier wo, dut db dmicis rtdemptum ex dlcdpmxijfct: Ergo egojnquit, Â«unquX wici.Rcddrguwnult; interim dpertc,ut Cicero Vibium Cw riummultum de dnnk dMtkfuÃ¦ mentientem: turn ergo eÂ«mitÂ«ddccldmdbdmuÂ«,noncrlt;Â«ndtusÂ» interim er fi-wuldtd dJJcnfionc, ut idem FdbiÃ DolobcUÂ« dicenti tri-gintd fc dnnoÃ¯ bdbcre,Vtrum cft inejiut. Ndm boe turn uiginti dnnk dudio.BcUc interimfubijeitur pro co quod negesjdliud morddeiu J,ut lunim Bd )Jult; quÃ¦rente Domi tidPdÃieni.quod meufdnj ciiw fordej, cdlccos cdm ucte res diceret uendere folcre: Non me berculcs,inquit,boc

1 nbsp;nbsp;unq dixi, fed emere te folcre. Defenfonem imitdttÂ« cft equesRo.qui obijciÃ«ti AuguÃo,quod pdtrimoniu come 4gt;(fet*,mcum,iÂ«quit,putdui. Elcudndi rdtio cft duplex,Eleuando q* w dut utniam qitk,dut idiSdntid mwiudt.Quemddmodu ââÂ° âÂ®'âÂ®quot;' C.CdfdÃ¯Pomponio oÃendenti uulnut ore exceptumiu feditione Sulpitidnd,quod ipfe fc pdjfum pro entire pu gndntem gloridbdtur, nung fugienj r cj^exerk, inquit.

^fndriuiPopiliÃ¤muirgmcmduxiÃet, Cr tu muUtmit '^nc|uit.Hoc genui di(iiconfcqucnsuociintciuiÃ¼m,it(^ ilUfimile,quod Cicero Curionem fernher db exeuÃtiont etAtM ir'.cipicntcntyfdcÃ¼im quotidie proamium beiert dixit^quid iÃd mturdfegui (^^r cobirere uideuntur.Sti ekuddi genui eR etidm edufdrum reUtio^ejud CiccroeH u/us in Vdtmiu.qui pedibm Â£ger,cum uclktuidericoiit tnodioris udktudink fddlm,ey diceret kidmUni wi' lidpdÃuum dnibuldraDiesbiÃn^uitÃongiores funi- Et AuguÃm nuncidutibui TdrrdconettfihupiÃ¼mdmmai eim cndtdm:AppdrctÃnquit,qÃpedcccnddiii. wn* Ãulit crimen CdÃiuÂ« Seuerm. !^dm cÃ oliurgirtturi Prxtore^quod dduoedtieim L^Vdro Epicureo eiÃd!^ dmico conuicium feeiÃent: Nefcio,inquit,qui comiddi Ãnt^e^ puto Stoicas fuiÃe^ R epercutiedi multi Ãquot;t gt nerd, uenuÃiÃmum quod etid Ãmilitudinedliqui iteri' ^â EreM ^â^^^^Cur.ut TrdcdUui dicenti SueOiot Si hoc ittt^gt; k in exilium ,fi non eÃ itd, redis inquit. EkfitC^P fiui Sctierus,obijciente quoddm quad ci domo fut ff^â^ kiusintcrdixiÃet,reÃ}ond?do: tstuiiquid egoÃ¤bii^ do^ sic eluditur et ridiculu ridiculo,ut Dims AiâÃª''c cum ri GdÃ®li torque durcum centum pondo dedip^i^,. Colobclld per iocu,tent dns tdmen iodfui euenUM Wl Ãt:Torque me dondMdÃ®o te,inquit,ciuicddondre,iâ^â* Vifloriatus ^^eMm quoÃ»; menddeio.ut Gdlbd, dicentequoddigt;i'^'â[ uiAorixR' floridtofeunomSicilidquinippedeslongdmKitrfi^^ gno infignp cmiÃetHihil,inquit, mirum, num ibi tdm longi wA^ *â^â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tur, ut hk piÃdtorcs pro yeflibus cingtntur. Contrini

fJlnfgdntie0fcJ?ionK pmuktio. Scdipfiquoq^niuitum Ij^rt urWnitdtK. Sic AÆer cum tigeret centrdlibcrtum ebudij Clt;prw,er ex diHcrfoquidimconditionis ciuf-dem CHIUS erfttlitigdtorjexcliimttj^c fertur tprÃ¦tered tit fempet in libertos Cjepris diets ?Ncc me bcrculc^nquit, qutequA projicio. Cui Â«tcinÂ«m eÃ ^non negAre quod obij citur, cum er id pdlÃm fulfum cjt, er inde mxteridfcf ne rfÃâondendi datur, ut Cdtwlus dice ntiPbilippo, quid U trÂ«? Fwrem Mideo,inquit* Infc dicere ,non cÃ ferÃ¨ nip fcurr ArHm,cr in orutore uti^ minime probubilc.Qnocl ÃcTitotidcmmodWjijUotinHliospotrÃ: Ideoqjboc qu* His frclt;ju?$pt,trunJco* lUud uero ctidmfi ridiculum cÃ, indignÃ¼timÃ« eft bomiÂ«iliber(tli,quod dut turpiter/ut Impotcnttr dicitur. Quod feeiÃe lt;|Hcndlt;im fcio, ejui bumiliorilibere ddHfrfusfeloquentijCoUpbMm/wjquit, tibi duedm, er formuUm fcribum, quod edput durum bdbciÂ«. Hie enim dubium enjUtrum ridere dudientes, an mJigniri debuerint. SupereH genus dccipiendi 0-pinionc ,dut diftd aliter intcUigendi, c^Ute funt in cm ni bac materia ucl uenuÃiÃimd, inopindtum er Ã . IdccÃrn te poni foIct,qwalecH quod refert CiccrotQ^dbuic fccii lt;bcft,niÃ res er uirtui? Aut iGud Api: Homo in dgenÂ»^Â® otafcwÂ» du Mufis optime ueÃitus* Et in occurrcndo,ut Cicero Â«wiitdfalfa Vdtinij morte, cum Ouinium libertum efuÂ« inttrrogaÃet,rcÃeneomnidfdiccnti reflet Mort nus eÃ ^ induit, plurimus dutem cired ÃmuUtionem er dif-Ãmubtionem rifus cÃ,qux funt uicindjer propÃ¨ eddem. SfdÃmHUiocÃcertdm opinionerndnimi fut imitant is,

388 M, FAB. C^VINT. INSTlT. , diÃimuhttiOj aliend pdrum fe 'mtemgerefin^entis- SiÂ«^ huit Afer, cumin edufd fubindc diccntibiu Celfin^^ ccre cognouiffettquje erdtpotensfainind:Cluis ed,iO' quitjÃe^ CclÃndm enim uiderifibi uirufiuxit, DifjÂ»^ huit Ciccro,cuin Sex. Anudlit teÃis reumheÃjÃtj^^''â Ãdret idÃ«tidem deeufdtor ei, DieMdree TuÃ¼ijiUf^i'^i pÃ»tes de Sexto Anudli^ Verfut tune dicere ca^i ^^ iro Ennij dnndlifexto:

CuiÃne dubioÃ-equeutiÃimd ddt occdÃone dinbi^uil^b C. Cxlio. ut CdÃclio, qui con fuit oridicenti, nduemdiuHer^âquot; to,pedes inquittSed duerti intetteilus etidtn diterÃldgt; cunt db d/ferioribus dd leniord inde ÃcÃ¤itur, ut quii^' terrogdtus,quid fintiret de eo qui in ddulteno d(Ãâ, â fus cÃet,tdrdumfuiÃc reÃondit. Ei confine, quid lt;^^' tur pcrfufi)icionÃ«,qudle illud dpud Cicerone quod uxor fudÃ¨ficofe fuJfendtffÃ©tjrogo des mibifr'^^ turn ex Old drbore,ut inferdnt.Ã®nteÃ®ligitur eniin qiââ^'^ dicitur. Et hercle omnisfdlfi dicendi rdtio in eo t^â dUter quant cdl,rÃ©Ã©lu uerum^ dicdtur, quadfit^^quot;,^ gendis dut itofiriS,dutdlienis perfitafionibutidd^^. quod fieri non potefl. Aliend finxitlubd,quitÃ^^ â qdâ db equo fuo e/fet djfierfus, qd tu inquit, fnelu{Ãâââ^^ tdurunt putdsi Sud, C. CdÃius, qui niilitifi fie Ãª^^â^ ^^ fiurrenti, heuseontntilito, pugno bene uteris iuqnquot;' Cdlbd de pifcibus,quicum pridieex parte dduÃi, (^ fdti, poflerodie dppofiti eÃent:FeÃinctiius,d!uÃ^â nantfinquit^Tertiunt illud Ciceronisdduerfiu iHquot;^

ORATOR. LIBER VI. 589 ricrieitHncertenonpoterdt,ut dccl.tm.trct or n.ttuj Â«orteJJct.E^erillicxironiitjiftiOjC^uiujuscft C.CÂ« \ flt;ir.NdmcumtcÃejdiccrctttd,rcofoeminlt;tfu(t ferro pe tiW,er efetftcilw reprebcnpOjCur itldm potifmum nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

f Â«temcorporis uulner.tre uoluif ft : Quid enmfteeÂ« Tct,mquit,cum tu gilcam or loricdm babcres? Vd opt i ml eft pmuktio contrafmuhntcm, quilts iUa Domitij Afi fuit; Vetus bibebit teÃammtu, or unus ex imicis recentioribiw fer ins iliquid ex mutitione tabular u,fal fun tibuhm mtulerat Æ onflens cum, an prmipilarw ci 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tcjlinicrtto fuaderct ordinÃ¤re fprema indicia, noli,in -

^gt;*it,ficere,oÃrrtdw ilium. lucundifiwafunt autemex bis omnibus lenia, er (ut pc dixerim) boni Ãomaebi, ut ^fr ingratolitigatori conjfeftum eins Â«itanti in foro, pernomcnclatoremmiJfumadcumtAmas mc,t)iqwit,qdâ te non uidi,er dif enfitori, qui cum ad rcliquanon re-f onderct,Jiccbat fubindc, no comedi panem er Â«quam bibo.Vafee er redde quod debes,quÂ« uKa^tu^Ã tâ uo-cantÃ¦ft gritiw locus,qui minus exprobrat qpotcÃ,ut idem diecti candidate, femp domÃ¼ tuam colui, c u poJfet palam negirc,credo,inquit,ez uerum eft.interim de fe iieere ridiculu cft,et quod in alium,fi abfentem dicerct, wbanum non erat ,quoniX ipfi palam exprobratur, mo-â''t Ã¯ifum,quale AuguÃi eft,cum ab co miles nefcio quid improbe petcret, ueniret contra wartianus, quem fujfi cabotur er ipfum aliquid iniuÃe rogaturu: Non magis, inquit,ficiam commilito qua pctis,q quod Martianus Ã t* petituTus eft, Adiunant wrbanitatcm,er utrfÂ« Â«o**

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Bb 5

390 M. F^B. QVINK INSTIT, tnodepofiti,feutotiut fuut,quad Ã¤deÃ¶fttHt^^)'*^^' dius ex tetruÃieho MÃ¤eri carmine lib ru in milot po^^ compofuerit. Quodfitgrutius^fiqudetHntidfigfiiti^ Arriam conditur, ut Cicero in Aecium hominem citHidmÂ» ^ uerfttum,cumK in quidu caufu fu^cÃM effet: Jitftf* Vly/fes mte cudÃt Luertius lt;nbsp;Seu uerbis expirtenH' tiitif,ut in cum,qui cum unten ÃukiÃimM effet hjUtnb poÃ Ã¤cerptumhareditiite primus fentÃ¤Ã¼mrosit^' Cuius bxredittu c^t^qunrnuocuntfapientidm,pro idoÃ eultns eÃ¤.Seu Ãi^is notÃ©s uerfbics^ Simile eÃ¼ quod re^' uerbs /xiec dicitur, ^ prouerbiu opportune ipti(tÃ¤,ut de ho mine in uquS lÃ¤pfo^cr ut aÃ¼euuretur rogMi: Tolhttt qui non nouit, ExhiÃoriu ctiumducereurbeinittitÃ©eri^ ditum,ut Cicerofecit,cum eiteflem in iudicio Verrit r^ gunti dixiffet HortenÃus ,non inteUigo hee fui^rutt' atqui dcbes,mquit,cum SphingÃ«domihubeus.Aeeeperti autÃ«illc Ã Verre sphingÃ« teneam^mugm pecuwigt;^'â^f uifurdu illu coflunt flultÃ©s fimili imitutione: tyqusV fingxntur Ãultd fuut, ut qui mirÃ¨ltibus quod huuiHer^ Sphinx i delubrumemifÃetjprunÃrumeritinquit.Sedillefi'^^

Hortenno. â*^fâ^gt;'â^^flottÃ©derid, quÂ£tdnqfine rdtione diUsfr^^' Fluarchus Ã tur,ut firuus Dolobcllx,cu interrog:ir(tur,u.â'i'^''quot;â Ks^ ^^âquot;Â°' eins duaionernpropofi(i^et,domu,inquit,uendiid'^f prehenfi interim pudoremfuum ridicuto dUquo ex^i' eut, ut qui teÃem dicentÃ© fi Ã reo uulncrdtum mterr^f uerdt,dncicdtriceshdberet, eumilleingentÃ«infietiorr â f-oppartugt; toflendiffit,ldtusinquit oportuit,Cotumelifiquo^igt;!â asus nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;belle dutur^ ut Hi/fo obifeientibÃ©s dcerbd criiifittei lt;ltt^

(4toyt,mcntiriÃ® mquit, Et rwUin: pyopi-n^UMÃ®lcgdto wterrogitntt, du in tÃwliÃ®, quÂ« proferchat, ebirogrd* fbÂ« cjpt.Et UfriWjinqititjdommc^HdÂ« dutdaepij^c-cics, dut mweni /Ã¯-quenti^imdi, ex quitiw ridicnU duce yentUT.Sfd repetÃ¯ neeeÃe efijinjinitiW e^etdm fdlfc di-Â«ndi,quÃmfcKcrÂ£,qwdÃ® prlt;eÃdt pcrfondJocuj^tcmpu-t, cdfiÂ« dcniqjjqwi eft mdxiwe Â»driui.Itdqj bxc ne omiÃ^e uiderer dttigi,illd dutÃ© qwÂ« de ufuipfo, lt;^ modo ioedn-di complcxus fum,idro b^rmd ,fed pldnc nrerjJdrid.Hts dJijeit Domiti:Â« Mdr/tÂ«, qui de urbdnitdte diligentiÃi-we ferippt, quxddm non ridiculd,fed cuitibet [eueriÃi' Wdordtionieonuenientid elegdntcr diftd, er proprio quoddm lepere iucundd.qux funt quidem Â«Ã¯bdnd, JÃ¨d ri fum tdwe non bdbent.Neq; enim ei de ri/u Jed de urbdm tdte efl opM mPitKtnm, qÂ«dm propridm c jje no^rÂ£ ei -nitdtiÃ¯ dit, er fero ftc intcUigi eoeptdm, po/lqudm ur-tij dppeUdtionem, etidm/Ã¯ nomen proprium non ddqce* rctHr,Komdmtdmertdccipi/Ã¯trfceptÂ«m,fdmq5pc/Ã¯nitÃ¯ VrbdnitiKea uirtui qu^ddmin treue diflum codÃ¢d, y^^^^^j^^j, er dptd dd dekftdndoj, mouendojq; bomines in omnem iffiHum^mAximt idoned dd repÃendum,uel IdecjJcndu, pront que $ rej de perfond dc/Ã¯derdt. Cuip breuitutis exceptionem detrdxerw, omnew ordtionw uirtutes co* fkxd pt. Ndmpeut iÃd rebm er per/Ã´niÃ® Â»er quod in Â«tyifqioportedt diccrc,pcrfeÃÃ eloquÃ«tiieeRicur MtÃ« ireuem am effe uoluerit^nefcio quidem. Ad qud in co-dem Ã¼ko diedt fuifje, z^ in muleis ndrrdndi uybdnitd-tfm,fdÂ«lÃ´ poÃ itd Ãnit gt;nbsp;C^tois, Â«t dit,opinion? [eeutus.

Vrbiittut homo er it, cuiut muÃ®tlt;i bene didi, rej^oâ^p'^ j erunt^zy ^Â«i in fermonibtM,circuVf,conitiuijsgt;it( ^ ^Â®'â j cionibus,omni deni^ loco ridicule,comoie^ dicaiRi' Æ fut erunt,quicuq; b^ecfdciet ordtor, Qudiftre^iptquot;'â^ à¥¤ finitiones^quiequid bene dicetur er urbdne didinomof dccipiet,CÂ£terumiÃ¼i,quihocpropofuerdt,con[cntdnci fuit illddiuiÃo,ut dii!iarumurbdnoru,dÃ¯idferid,âililt;iâ^ cofd,dlid medidfdceret. i^dm eddem ed omnut b^f^ â^ Ãorum. Verum mihi etidm iocofd quÂ£dd uidenturpojl^ nonfdtKurbdncrcfcrri.NdnjmcoquidÃ«iudicioillâ^^^ urbdtiitM,m ijud nihil dbfonum,nihil dgreÃe^ihUxf^^ ditum,nihil peregnnu,nec^ fenft^neq- uerbis, nÂ«^ â'â'^gt; geÃifue poÃit deprehendi, ut non tdrnfit iÂ»fmS^^ Æ dis, q m toto colore dicendi,qudlifdpud GrÂ£co!gt;^^^ cifmos iUe redolens Athendrumpropriufdporeiit'tlt;^ men indicium MdrÃ hominit eruditiÃuni fubtrdhÃ^ nbsp;nbsp;i

rid pdrtitur in trid generd,honoriÃcum, cotunicbo! â medium. Et honoriÃeiponit exemplum Ciccroâtuf'^ , pro Ligdrio dpud Crfirem: Qui nihil files olM^â fi iniurius.Et cÃ¶tumeliofi,quod Attico firipÃt ^â^^ peio er Ctefdrc:Hdbeo quÃ« fugidm, quemq; h'â^Â»f^ 1 hdbeo. Et medif,quod ii7roepbiy/d.camp;Kdp uoedtÃt , \ itd dixit: neq; grduern mortem dccidere forti uit^t fi,neq^ mmdturdm coÃuldri.nec^ mifirdmfdpâ^^^â' ^ omnid fint optime diÃ«ld^fed cur proprienomenut tdtif dccipidnt,non uideo. QuodÃ non detur,ordtionis color meretur, fed etidmÃngif^^ ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;)

gfnfris eiufdcm, que ridieuk dicuÂ«tuÃ¯, er Hmen ridi cull non ftwt,ut de PoUione A/Ã¯nto ferijÃ¯,tocK$ pdri* ter dccommoditto diftm eft/Ãc ewm omnium bordru. Et de dftorefuite dicÃ©te ex tempore, mgenium cum in numerdto bdbere. Etidm Pompe ij, quod refert Hdrfui in Ciceronem di^dentem purtibu^ : Tru/Ã¯ nd Clt;eprcw, me timebij. Erdt enim,fi de re minore, nut nlio nnimo, nut dertig non ub ipfo diftumfut)Jet, qwod poÃet inter ridicwld Â»Â»merdri.Etinm iUud,(}uod Cicero CoreliÂ« fen p/it,reddenjriitioncfncnr iUiC.CifiUris tepom tnm plt;t tientn toIerdrctÃ®HÃ¦c nut animo Catonie ferenda Jiwit, nut Ciceronis fomacho. StomaebtÂ« enim itlicbabet alt* Â«juid ioco finite. HÂ«c qÂ«Â« mouebant difimulanda mibi nonfwcruÂ«t,iÂ» quibiM,ut errauerim,legendes tarne non dfcepi,mdicata diuerfa opinionc,quÃM fequi magie pro baiHibiMlibcrume^.

A Ltercationw prxeepta poter ant uidcri tune inÂ« â XXcl)oanda,ctwn omnia, qÂ«Â« ad cominium oratioÂ« nem pertinent,peregiÃem: nam eft ufiw citw ordinc ui

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dijpof tionempof it, nee elocutions ornamentamagno i Ff'd'fiderct,aHtcircamemoriametpronunci4ttonem 1 Wilt;iTtt,ÃYiuf^m,âpcn^^(t,â qjtiuq; partium,banc quÂ« l nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tota ex prima pendet,traftaturiM non alieno loco uideÂ« l Â®â')'l'wÂ«ifcriptorcs alij ideo fortaÃe reliquerunt, quia i fotii etterÂ« praeceptis in bac quoq; uidebatur e Ãe pro ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Jf^am, Confat enim aut intefwionf ,lt;iut depulf onc,de

^uibus fcttiÃ¯trddittimeA, quide}uiclt;}uidiÂ»dctionejKi petM dred probdtiones utile e^,id zy in l^lt;t^ ^^^ ^i concifd profit neceffe eA Â« t^cq; dlid dicuntur iÂ» iltquot;^ edtiotte^ fed dUter dut interrogdndo, dut rej^ondeniot l,ib iap,iS^ââ^^^^ ferÃ¨omnisobferudtioiniÃ¼otefiuM locoes* cuff'd nobis eil, turnen quid Idtiuf hoc opus d^greÃi tnus^neque per fed us ordtorftnehde uirtute did poi^^â pdulum mpeudamus huic quoque pecuUdris operfgt;lt;P^ qui dem in quibufddm cdufis dd uiÃ oridm nd plur^ udlet. tdldm utinqMlitdtegenerdli,inquiredÃ©uer Hum quid^un contru fit,quÂ£ritur, perpetM donditdi^ Ã§rdtio^ er quicÃionem finitionis d^ionis plenumr tis expUedt, er omnid penÃ¨ in quibus de fudoco^r^â autconiedlurd, drtificidli rdtionecoUigiturfftdiÂ« 'â Ã§dufs, quiie funtfi-equentiÃimr, que udfolis extfi^^^ temprobdtionibies^ueltnixtiscofumenturjdfferriÂ»'^ hdc pdrte dimiedtio eÃ¼, nee dkbi dixeris MdgÃ¹ im^^ ve pugnuri .b^dmer firmiÃimd queque meniofidââ'â cis inculcdndd fuut, er preflundum quicquid m Iâ^^^.^ ene promtfiinus^ct reÃUendd menddcid.t^ufqudiK^Ã *^^^ lt;Ã®^i cognoÃit intcittior,nec mmeritÃ´ quidti^^ quem in dicendo mediocres, hdc tditten dltercindii. ftdntid meruerumt nomen pdtronorvim. Atquii^

ufi gdtoribus fuis ilium modo dmbitioÃm decldiu^dr^ dorem prefiiti/fecontenti, cum turbd Iduddtuidid â j-dctieiiori ÃituuntfubfeÃid, pugndm^illdim-dccertdtoridini^'d ^^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ritis dcfepe puUdtÂ£ turbe relinquunt, ltdq; uided^^

Â«,Â«liot id prohJtjonem.QÂ«Â« fi iMcnin fwttt officii, beefrte migii ncceffidnMi eft,pudendum que djftu.Ã plÂ«Iitig4inibiÂ« frofunt mmoÃ¯cst IÂ» publieÂ« eerie iuii tijs uox iUd prieeonÂ«, prtier pitronos, ipfum qui ege^ yitjcitdt. opui cft igiiur in iprimismgenio ueloci uc mo bib'jdntmopriejcnti er deri. NoÂ» enmi cogitiniwm^ fed diccndmnjldtinteftjCr propÃ¨ fub connu iduerfirij nan^t Â«igendd.Qudre cvm in omni purte buiu/cc ofÂ« ffiij plurimum fielt totiix noniUigenter nodo ,fed eti* Â«tm fdwilidriter noffe cMfie, turn wÂ» aUeredtione mixi* nicnectffiriumeSi,omniwm^erfonirum,inllrumcntoiâ rimdemporimdocorum bdberc notitidm, dlioqui er M Â«Â»daw eft fepe etidm ilijsfjhijcientibui, plcrnr.que iu tfm jludio loquendi fnue modo dccidendiwÂ», quad Muit qwmdcciditj nicredulitdtedlieni ftidtitii crubefcdÂ« ni crudely Â«uqncqj timen bw ipfis monitoribut cUrefeit.Quiddm ^^â^â3,-, ftciiwtt dperte quod rixemur. Vidcdlt; enim plerofqwe erubefeamÂ» iripercitoÃ¯ excld(Â»ditteÃ¯,ut iudex dudidt conerdrium id.

effi quod ddmonedtur, fewtq; iHe, qui promweidt unÂ« eftincdufd,miluw quod tdeedtur. Qudre boniÂ« dlterÂ» edtor uitio irdcundix edredt. Nuliiiw enim rdtioni mdÂ« gis ob^dt d^ftutjCr fert extri dufirn, et pkruMej de foTwid conuitid fitÃ¨re,ie mereri cogitjet ipfÃ³Ã¯ nonmwt -qu4miudicej incitdttMclior moderdtio, de noÂ»ntÂ«iqiM Ã¯tidmpitietttid.Ne^ enmrefutinditintwm qÂ»Â« Ã¨ con fr^no diciMitur,fcd cotÂ»inendi,eleMndi,ridendi funt, wc^fquitÂ« pliM loei repent urbdnitdS, odium mordet C pÂ«iJw,contrd twbdiwc} (UtdenAitmÂ» er impudentÃ¼!

fortiter rt[ifiend.m.Siwt enim (ftUdm ^rfduri in Ijot prii,ut oiÃrepÃ¤nt ingenti cldmore, tt meiios fermones intercipidnt^et omniti tumultu confiwddnt,^uos ut non imitiri/tc deriter propulfdre oportchit: er ipfonn iw probitM retimdcndd, O' indices, ndmdgiÃrdtuf d^fol Inndi frequenter, ut loquendi uicesferuemur. NitÂ« (^ resdnimi ideentis, Oquot; mollis fuprdmodnmÃofMsfii^ Htq; pieru'nq;,quod probitds uoedturtqut e^ mbeedi^^ tas,v diet dutem in dltercdtione plurmum dcumÃª, quoi fine dubio ex drte non uenit-tldturd enim non docetnr, arte tdtnen ddiuudturt in qud pritcipuum ellfeniptfâ in oculis hdbere, de quo quieritur,Oâ qnod uolumuf f^ cere,quid propofitum tenentes in rixdin nonibMifd^ cdufe debitd tempord conuitidndocontereimu,Sâ^^^ bimus^/i hoc dduerfdriuffdeit. Omnid idpo^^râ^^A rdtd funt meditdtis diligenter, quf^ dut ex ci,dut refÃonderi Ã nobis poÃint. Ã¼onnunqudâ^'^^,^^ folet hoc quoque effe drtis genus, ut quxddm lt;Â« '^ â â difimuldtdfubitÃ³indltercdndoproferdmur,^^^-, ndtis eruptionibus, dut ex infidijs citiffimof (Â»^1^ Umum.ld dUtem tumfdciendum e^l,cMH eÃ¼ y^s refÃonderi non Ãdtim poÃit,potuerdtdutemli ^^jj^ dd diÃwnendumfuiffet.NdmquodÃdeliterÃr^^ ff Ã primisÃdtim dHionibus drripere optimum c gt;L'^ piusdiutius^ dicdtur.lUud uixfdltempn^^^'P'^^^^^^it detur,ne tu rbidus O' cldmofus tdntum ft ^^cj^s Ã¯ quilesfdÃ©li Ãimt,qtii Uterds nefciunt.Ã¯Jdm ^^^f^^ Ã§et dduerfdrio molefldÃtÃudici innifd eÃ¼ lt;nbsp;^^^

Ã Â« pugtid in bw,^Â«lt;e obtinerc non po/?K.N4m uti winÂ« ri necejje eh, exfidit ceiere : c^tiAfiue plKrd /twit, de ^Mibiw qwieritwr, fAciUor eÃ»t in ctterisfiies-.fiuc twiÂ«, mitior fokt irrogAri poend uercciwidtie.Ndm cuIp4m, â¢quot;Â°^ prxfertim dfprfbfnpiM.pertwjdriter tMcrt,cÂ«Ipd dltrr 4 eft.Dumyat Acits^multi in rem conÃÃ¼ij dtqwe Arik eft, Â«t 'Ã¯riiiHciMddMcrfdrtwntrdbitÃ³jetire^udmtongi/JMnÃ© wgÂ« gt;nbsp;Ht iwnx interim j^c exÃ¹ltet Â» ideo qÂ»xddm bene difwiuUntur m^rumentd. Xn^Ant enim, cz fepe iiferi weÂ» omne committunt, quod deeffe nobw putAnt,^ fA tiunt probdtionibiw mieris AUtoritAtem po/Ã¯uldndo.Ex peilt etidm dire dliquid Aduer[Ario, quod pro fe putct,

' quoi dpprebcndfns mAiM dliquid cogdtur dimittere* lt;1Â«Â« iittcrwrej proponerc,qwdrtwÂ« utrdmlibct mdle ft tkaitrw: Qtjod in dltercdtionc fÃ®t poteiwitw, quini in itftioitr,quid in iUd nobw tpf re/pondewu^, in bdc Ai werptrium qm/i confc/fiwn tenemiu. Eft in primw Acut-tijuidcre quo iudex difto mouedtur,qutd re/f udt^quod eximltu ft pifttne, er dliqudndo etidm difto dliquo ,fd* ^Ã¶te riuj deprebenditurjCz in/tdre proficienthiK, amp;nbsp;eb btÃ¯,quf non AdiMiAnt, ([MmmoHiÃme pedem oporÂ« tet referre.ftciunt boe medici quoque, ut remedid per* 'quot;i'pTf/eufrent ddbiberc,uf 1 deÃmAnt,ut iZA rccipi hcl *'lPâiÂ«idew. NortUMqudm /i rem euolucrc propoficdw

'ââ*r'^mferendd eft dkd quxfio,dtq; in cAm/i Ã ^w,iii dcx duoedndw. Quid enim cunt retonde* nduw eftjUi/Ã¯ ut dliud inuenidÂ« cui ddÂ«

$98 M. FAB, oyiNT. INSTIT' Ã¤uoedndMi ut dixi, ([ui cired teflef, locos, C p(f[o^^ modo diflett, quad hie pdtronoruw inilt;^^ fr cert^gt; iVic pugnd inter teÃem er pdtronum, Extratduo u^'^ huim rei longe Ãuilior, 'Nam eÃ¼ utiliÃiÂ»gt;^^' fi^âi^^''^^! cant aliquo qui Ãt fludiorum eorundemjumere mitett^ dm uel uerr, ud etiam fidr eontrouerfic, Gt imt^r partes altereationis modo tueri, quod idemctidmuilâ^ plici genere qu^Ãionu fieri poteh. Ne iÃ¼ud quidÃ©t^n^ rare aduocatu uolo,quo quee^ ordmeprobatiofiNfHÂ» indicÃ©s proferenda^cuim rei eademin argumemis rHio eR,ut potemiÃimd, prima et famma ponaturAlla eriiH dd credendÃ¼ prÃ©parant indicÃ©,hac ad ptonucianinfÂ«'

De ludicio er Confilio, CAP. Vit Hls pro noÃra facultatc travat is, non duUtr tranfireprotinusad difijofitionem, qu/ori^_ ^PfÂ° fcquitur^nifi uererer, nc quoniamfuerunt,qii'â^â, dunt 'muentionifubiungerent,pr^etcrijjjehuÂ»c locÂ»f lufdam uiderer, qui mea quidem opinione dieoff bus operis huius omnibus connexits ac mixtus eHi^i^ Ã fintentijs quidem, autuerbisfaltemfingulispr' , par ari,nee magis arte traditur,quÃ m gufliis, aigt;iââ; / Ã¯deo^ nos quid 'm qMq; re fequendum caucniitK-'ifi , docebimus, ut dd ea iudicium dirigatur â¢ PneifVi ig' turfine quibus effici nihil pote^, aggrediamar, utcoâ'^ traria uitcmus,er communia, ne quid 'm etoqueniÂ»^ ruptum obfeurum^ fit, Keferatur oportet ad Ã^^ qui non docentur. Nee mult um Ã iudicio credo diÃarf

ORATOR. LIBER VL 599 tur,boeUwtitw, ft dut ownmo nondum rfpertw,(tMÃ dKbij! .Et iudicitÂ«Â« Ire([iieniiÃimc cfrtum cft, Conflit* urn Hero eft Mtio qu^ddm dite petitd, (y pIcriMi^j plÂ«* lrdperpeijJenj,c7 compdrdn^jbdbcÂ« j^j mfef:y- viweMi Ottern,er iudiedtionem. Sed ne bjecquidem pyÃ¦ceptd iÂ» ttttiuerfuMiJ^fftdudd fuMt.Ndm ex re fHmitKr,cMtlocM4 dnte dftionÃ¯m eÃ¢ /requertter. Ndm Cicero fummo con* filiouidctHrâm Vfyyffu Â«elcotttrdberc tempord dicendt ââââ'âgt;JJf,qtt4m 'm cm dÂ»nM,qMo erdt OJIortenftÂ« cort lgt;âifMtÂ«riÂ«jHicjdcyr.Et in ipfj ddionitiM priait de poÂ« tftttifittiuw obtmet locm. Ndm quid dicendm, quid t^Â«ndiim,qMid distenduÂ«Â» ft, exigere conflij eft: ne* S^tc Ãt futile defendere Ã®Vbi proÅmio Â«tendm,Â©* ^wb'.'Ndrrandum'nCjCr quowodo.lurcprtttÃ³ pugtidn* lt;1â¢,^ Â«quo: Qui Ãt ordo utili/?iwtt5,tm omnej cob â^'Ã¯gt;Â«j{ierr,((nlfn!tcr,drtrttdm fubmi/Jcloquicxpcdidt* SfdbxcqitoqueutquifquepdjJÃ¼scft locuijWouuiwtK, ââ^''tt^in fclqud, pdrte ficitmui. Pdued tdnieÂ» exemple P^^wponÃ¯jquibiÂ« mdniftjliin dppdrcdt, quid ft quoi Â«wofrdri pofe pr^ceptis Â»3 drbitror. Lduddtur coÂ» 1 nbsp;nbsp;I'uwi Eemofbenis, quod cm fudderct bcljiwn Atbeni*

ââvbw.piraÂ«, id projfereexpertiÃ® ,nibil ddbuc fd^iÃ® ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;til ^**^*'' *ââÂ°âÃâ'ââ*^* Poterdt enm emenduri negligÃ©Â»

non^' ^'*ââââ â^â^ fÃ¯rdtm, meUoris 'm poferm jf eÂ£ 'ââMtio. Idem cm ofÃ¨nfdtÂ» uercretur,f otiur* 8J^ populi fegnitiem, iÂ» dferendd libertdte rcipubli* quot;Wlorum hude uti mdluit,quiTem fortiÃ 'mf dimmÂ» , l^''^mAtn(3-fMlfs' â¢â. feoueÂ«

bitur,ut meliord probarucn, peiomm par,itÃ©rÃ©e .Cic(* ronÃ quidem ucl twa pro Cluetuio qtumUbet mdtis tx emplis filfficeret oratio^ Kdm quad in co confiUim iM* xime mirera primetm 'ne expofitionem, i^M nutrijcuiuf filiMnpremebdt(iMorit4f,dbfiulitfideiniAnlt;luodide'gt;i eorrupti iudicijcrmen trdnsferremdduerfiriummi^ luit,^ negdrc propter inueterdtdm,ut ipfie dtcit,iÂ«fi'âââ dm^An quodinreitinidiofidlegisduxilionouifiiiÂ»^^ ufiisfQuogencredefenfionisetiamoffvndiUetnorio^^ pnemoUitds tudieu mentes. An quod fie ipfomniK^^^f entio fdcere tefidtus e^iQuid pro Niloneiquodno^ te ndrrduit,q pneiudieijs omnibus reum hberdretii^^^ infididrum muididm in Clodium uertit,qiiinqiuntfâ rd fuerdt pugnd fortuitd, quodfddlum Gt iMdiiitdj^ turnen uoluntdtcm Milonis remouit, quad dcdit,etmedrum locumipfefuceeÃitfinfinity ^ mer dre, ut CottÂ£ detruxerit dutoritdtem, ut Pâ^^^^^j rio fÃ¨ oppofuerit, Ccrnelium ipfdeonfeÃioxif r .^ eripucrit. lUud diccrefdtis hdbeo, nihil ejfi in ordndo,fed in omni uitd prius confilio,fi'uÃâ^^Ã^^ co trddi caterds drtes, plusqi uelfine dodriiidP ^^ â¢ , Aptare tti tidii!,qtt dm fine prudent id fdcere doUrinum.Ã© f ^toSjSfi ^ ordtionem locis, temporibus, perfonis, efii

uirtutis. Sed bic quid Idtiusfufiis eÃ¼ locus, mi^ ^^^^ cum elocutione, trdUdbitur cum prÂ£cipcrc de xp

LibriSextifinis, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.

troY,fitK diftion c^. Nc^MC cÂ»wÂ» Cd df m!Â«n,lt;JÂ«iÂ« dd docendum per* tment/xccMtipmiM, HerumctidiÂ« motiM dnimoruw trdftdttimÂ«lt;.Scd Â®âquot;^â 1 ut operd extrumtihus fais non

J'aÃ¨re,niji Hj^ontniK ea cÃ³Hocdniisf^ drtificum md* quot;w '^Ii!l)f4tur,/Ã¯c m dicendo qiiSIibct dtunddnj rcruw âÂ°Pâââgt;tUMuUwt tdutuw bdbedt dt^j congejiumjnifi iUdi * .^'^'j^ofitio in ordinem dtgeÃdijdt^ inter fe corn*

â^Vopt^ fS^ejj^ Ãnt ti pno^ â;},;[ M4lf4t,NeÃ§ enhn, tÃ¯^â^â*quot;â /''/'^ ownibw wemtris ^dtud Ãt,niÃ coHoccÂ« Similibus

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;liurn^^'^'**ââ ^ Â®Â®âTÂ®gt;^Â«* Â«opris, dlioruw'ue dÂ»Â»Â«dquot;quot;P^Â®'ââ*

dem ^*â^ tWBWM dtlt;^ tr dnsfenu, licet bdbedt cd* loeo^^***^'quot;*quot; f*^ ^*ââ*â* ^^ âââ^ ^^âââââ ^'ââ^ ^â*Â° ââSâquot;â**â^ â/â**Â» ^ tWfbdti ex*

m r^^i^Ue ^*'*'â*â'â^, ^*quot; 'PJ^*â rinvin MturÃ¤m Ãdre ordiw faiH^i at natura. ^Ko confufo peritufd fint omttid, Sic ordtio edrem bde ttirtute,tumultuctur necefje eSi, er fine redore Ãnitet, Applkatio. nee coh fredt fibi,multdrepetdt,multdtrdnfedt,ueligt;t node in ignotii loeit errdns,nec initio,nee fine propos ArgumtniÃ¤^^^^^â â^â^fi^ntpotiutqudrnconfiliimfequdtur. Qifiipro'' hums libri. pter tottu hic liber feruidt difitofitioni : que quidemfi certd dhqM nid trddi in omnes mdteridt uUo modo pofi fet, non tdm pducit contigifiet. Sed cu/m infinitÃ© litiufd forme fuerint/uture^ fint, er tot fcculit nniÃ¯d reperd td fitcdufid, que effet totd dlterifimilit,fdpidt oportet ddor er uigiletfCrmuenidt^tyiudicet, crconfiliitind Ãâ^ pf^'^i- Ne^Â«e mficidt eo queddm effieque denton nbsp;nbsp;'

ftrdri pofhit^cAq; non omittdm. Sit igitur (utfuprdfi* AIt1 Re di' ff^fi^lt;^) diuifio,rerum plurium infingul.it pdrtitio, hinguunt, finguldrmn in pdrtes difiretiu ordo, er redd quidunt pJur^arum ^Â°^^^^ââ prioribuffequeittid dnnedent. Diffiofitio,utilit in Rngutas-, rerum de pdrtium in locosdiftributio.Sedmeminerimui gularamp;Â°^c! â^^'^^ diffiofitionem plcrunq; utilitdte mutdri, nee een* Quae quia dem femperprimdmqifefiionemexutrdquepdrtetrd^ didnddm.Cuiiureiutceterdexemplii pretercdniDetno reomnino ÃhcncsquoquCydtijtfeÃefchmespofftint effedocu^n^ feruan^ Â°^ ^â^*^ ^â*^^â'^Â° (Ã¼ofiphontis: diuerfiim fecuti ordinÃ«,cirtn tiuseÃ¼. ^Â°dccufdtord iure,quouidebdturpoteittior,cixperitpii* tronus omnid, uelpenÃ¨ omnie dnte iutpofuerit, quibui iudieem queflioni legu prepdreret. Aliud enim dUo do cerepriiu expedit, dlioqui femper petitoris driitrio

ORATOR. LIBER VIL 40$ feater^ue defends ,priuflt;Ã¿um ddutrfdrium orÃ¿utf^quot;^â^^}^ onniii/in neceffe eÃ rerum ordmtm effe diuerÃm tÃ¯git^ ualt;un pij' (Â«r, ^Kid fgo firn fecutM, lt;ptod pnrtim pneceptis, pdr^ âÂ« âÂ®Â« ha tra ufurpdtum cognouerdm,promim,ntc u^quim di^t to fujen^Ã©. Â»iHUÂ«i.Erlt;lt;t mihi cura in controuerpjs forenfAut noffe omid ^Mmedufu uerliiremur.t^dmm fclnoldcertn

Ãt^xaTO Grid uoedni^Cicero propoptd.Cum b^c m co flifflÂ» quoddwwodo coUocAuerdm, non tninus pro ad* w[i firte,^UAmpro me A cogitdbcim.'Etprimum (tpuoi Â«OB Ã¼ljicHc didu tji,fed tdmtn dme onmin mtumdum ) cotiÃitHeB^m, ^afd utme^ pdrs ueUet efficere, turn epui* i^mboctnodo coÃ¿tdbÃ,^uid prmv/m petitordiccretâ ld M emfe^um ernt^dut coniroutrfwm: Si confefjimy non potent Ai effe ^udftio. 'Trdnfibdm ergo dd re ff on [m pMÃ! dltcriut, idem mtuebdr, nonnuneMm etinm ^Â«od ifldf obtmebdtur,confeffwn erdLyli primum ex p^rÃ¼nonconuenire,tpudÃio orieldturjd tdleeÃi OcÂ» (iiijiibontmcm^occidiyConuenit/rdnfeo.Kdtionemred, dere debet reut (pure occident Â« Adulter um, w^wL cum ddubern oeddere licet,legem effe certum eil. Ter^ tium iim dlieptid uidendum eÃ¼, in epto pugna confiffdb '^^nfuerwntddulteri:Â¥uertvnt,^Udffio.Defdltodmbi^ amp;tgt;*Ã¯.coifdÂ«rilt; eR.interim ergo er tertium confeffwin ^^Mterosfuiffe Â« Sed tibi,inlt;juit dccufdtor,iUos non licuitoKidere.ExuIcÂ«Â»Â» enu crignominiofws,deiuÃ¯e ^neritUÃ¯^At fi protinux dicenti,occidiffi,reffondedtur, non oc(idi,Ãdtim pugnd eff. sic explonndum eH^ ubi

fugnii, uii controuerfia incipUt er confideriri i^t ^ua primant t^uiiftionem facit, Intetaio fimflt^ ^^â^* dit Satummum Kabirim. ConitimHa, Lege ieffiidj^ commiÃt L.Varenus. Ham CS^irenim occiit^^Â°gt; cr Cn.uuliterdndo,et SaUrium item occidâ¬ndo,caiitâ^lt;f''* ftc diuerÃe propoÃtionaerunty^uoidemde p(Wlt;Â» nibut didum Ãt â¦ Verum ex coniumda propoÃwiih plureseffe quifionesac fatut poffunttfiilitf^^^i^ reus, aliud de fendit, aliud Ã iure Ã¢Ã ionis excludit. W Quid quo lo quo genere dgendieÃ¢ dij^iciendum,quid quoque loco dom. **'*â^â diluÃ¢t, quad pertmetdd ddiorem. HonplanÃ© diÃemio d Celfo, qui Ãne dubio Ciceronem eRfecutus. infatta* men huic parti uebementius, ut putet primo firman aU quid effe ponendum ,fummo firmifimum, 'mbedSiord medio,quia er initio mauendus eH iudcx,crf''^'^Â°^ pellende, At proreo plerunque grauiÃinan ^'*^^* que primum mouendum eH, ne illud J^eÃ¤ans index,ft liquorum defenfioni Ãt duerfior. Interim ilt;^lt;^^ ^. boe mutabitur, Ã leuiora iUa palam falfaerunt, griuifi mi defenfio difflcilior,ut detraÃ¤a prius aceuÃtoriitufi de aggrediamur ultimumÃam iudiabus omnia nana e/fe credentibus. Opus erit tarnen pnefatione, quaert^M reddatur dilati crimmis,cr promittatur defnfio,nc ti quod non fatim diluemtu, timerc uideamur. Anteils pr;mum uitte crimma plerumque prima purgandafunt,ut idde ^fun quot;^quot;* ^'*Â° ^'*^â*^â^ ^^fententiarn, iudex audire propitius in* cipiatÂ» Sedhocquoquepro Vdreno cicero in ultmu/m diÃuUtf non quid ÃequentiÃme^ fed quid tumexpedit

^f^rntMiUt CMnfimbiexmteiKioerittUidendwmeR InfâââH'lt;âfi'âÂ» Â»Â«Â«Â«ttmtÃ³^MKire}pondeMiia,Mplurd:Sumum^ m dotraetÃ¤da. If ^iitjUonem mfiitMmut,M m fcripto.Si in rc, negdn gt;Â«Â« iimÃt ([uoi obijeitur, dn tuendum. Si fcripto, inijui fiitcie iwis pugnd fit ^ZT'wedde uerbis ^ dn uoluntdte lt;^i'erdtw.ld itd confequemur,fi intuitifuerimui ^UÂ£ fit If* qÂ«Â« Utemfdcidt, hoc eR, qui iudiciam fit confiitu* tiMH.N4(Â» qu^ddrn in fcholdllicif ponuntur id coniu/n^' ienddmmododilÂ£rdferiem, utpdterexpofitumqui futputa *^outrit,foltttis dlimentis reapidt. Minut diHo dudb entem fUumlicedt dhdiedre.Quiexpoptum recepit, â¦ttperift ei nuptidt loeupUtii propinquijUe ducere twit ^iw pi(Â«pew eduedtorit â¢ Lex de expofttis dd iffi* ^iâ¢ pertmet, ludidum pendet ex lege dbdiedtionis, NÂ« tdmen femper ex und lege queÃio eÃ¢,ut 'm wTivo^ ââ^âJ â ^/*^â* fgt;^ilt;ii.}:Usjpe(ldtis,dppdrebit drei qu^pugm fit. Con'^ kgum inter luniSd defenfio eÃ¯l, quilts pro R dbiriot Si occidiÃet,re ^â*â^'quot;^Â® ^eftcijf(t,[ed nonoeddit.vbi nero multdcontri umm profoÃtionem diemus, cogitindum dl pftmum quic'^ Defenfio,feu quid did poteR^um ex bis quo quiclt;^ loco dici expedi* ^âÃ¦^jÂ® *âquot; it ordmlt;indimi,in quo non idem fentio^quod de propos Ãtionibiu pdulo ante, quod^ drgumeiHis probdUonum lâxococeÃfdliquindo nosmeipere iÃrmioribM.Udm Â«B queÃionum percrefeere debet, er dd potentiÃimi i^^rmi finis peruenire^fiuefumt dufdem generis, figt;^eiiiurfi,iurisiutemquieÃionesfokntelfe nonnun* lujÂ« ei^ lt;l'âinexdqsdtquedhjsconjiilidtionibus,fd{li femper Â®*Â®quot;**' Ã¼mS^SiatjM Utroef^ gÃ©nÃ©rÃ©fimiUs ordo eÃ¼gt; Sed pri

at de diÃmilibM, ex quibm mÃrmiÃmvM ^1Â«^$ f^â^ MMH trid^ri oportet, ideo^ qMfdurn qutfiionts txt* cuti dondre folemui,zr concedere. NetVue enw iW'^^ adtiliM folemiKMt poÃumuf^ nifiomÃit priotii^* Quoiipfiim itdfieri oportet, non ut dimniÃttÂ» W* deMnur,fid omifijfie, (pud poÃimui etidm fine eis uiwt* re. Procurdtor dlicuius pectmÃ¼ petit ex fixnore bereue tdrio,poteji mcidere c^ueÃio, dn huic eÃe procurdtore licedt, Pinge nos^pofiqud trdildumus ed,remittere^^ti etidm conuincijSpheretur, dn ex cuius nomme Ãtigdtur, procurdtor hdbendtn fit Ã , Difcedtunus hme pioip re^ cipitmdterid quxÃionem,dnidecuitisnomine dÃ¿tur, res qui ^fo ^'^â'âfigt;^flt;^gt;^^t-dtoris,dn ex dffÃ© bxres. Ã¼dc ^uoip con* lus,8i in foli eeÃd fini. QjiÃ§retur dn debedtur. Contr'd nemotdmi^ dum hatres. f^fgnjÃuerit, ut etidm id quod firmiÃmum duxeritfi bd beretremittdtfOquot; dd leuiord trdnfeenddt.WicmÃbe d fimile edition dbiiedbis ddoptdtum,ut hunt quo^Ãââ'* uirum fortemptt etfortem,non quicunep uolt^idtUM non pdruerit^ut indUd omnid ÃubicÃ¤its fit,non propter opmionem,et numpropter tdlem op'mionem.^eturit qugÃionimt diffÃ¨rentid eÃ¼.ln fdÃ©lis dutem di identten demid finit plurd. Ex quibut ediquA atrifid^^ Ãonem remitti foÃ¯Ã©tyUt fi is cim quo furti d^itar, tei, probd te hdbuijje^probd perdidiÃe, probdfdttoptt i* diÃe,probdmea frdude. Priori enim remittiÃÃ^^'â tirndno poÃunt. SÃ³lebdm et hoe fdcerepreeipue, ut ue ab ultimaÃecie {ndm edferÃ¨ eÃ¼, quf continet edufim retrorfum quererem ufque dd primim generalem quc^

ORATOR. LIBER VlI. 407 ^ianem, ud i generc ai extremam Ãiedcm dejeende^ rcm,ctiim in fmforijSy ut dÃ©libÃ©rÃ¢t Ã®iumd, an regnum cjjiremibiii RomMii recipiat â¦ PrimÂ«-Â»Â» id e^ genut, M regnandimi, an m duitate aliÃ©na, an Komit,an latu* ri jint Komani talent regent. SmiUter ZT in controuerÂ» f^s.Optet enm uirfortis aliÃ©nant uxorent. vltima^e* da,in optare poÃit aliÃ©nant uxorent â¦ Generale eSi,an tj^icqÂ«id optauerit, accipere debeat. Inde an ex prim* to,Mnuptias,an maritum habentem. Sed hoc no^uentgt; iimoitm dicitwjta O' ^ueritur. PrimâMnenim occur dtfere, quod e^ ultimum dicendum, ut hoc, non debes Ã¤nimuxorcm optareAdeo^ diuifionem perdit feÃi* Â«itw.MoÂ« oportet igitur oÃirentibut fe conte uturn cf^ f^'' Ojirdter aliquid quod eR ultra, Ãne uidua qui'^ j^j quot;^â â^^ ^'^''f,aihucplits,finihilexpriuato^ltimumretrorfu.'my ** quot;* ^âloi idem 4 capite primum eSl,Ã nihil iniquuniAta pro fÂ°f^ioneuifa,quod eÃ¤faciUmum,cogitemus,Ã fieri po â'ftjlt;3Â«id naturale fit primum rejponderiAd fi tanquam quot;^â^ ^gatur, o nobiÃpfis ref^ondendi neeeÃitat fit, in* ^â*^^ilt;^itbterimut,occurrit. Si id non contigerit,[epona* ^tfiidquoi primum fe obtulerit^o ipfi nobifeum fie h V^Wr.QÃ¿od fi hoc non effet,id iter urn,0 tertium,et ÆÂ» nihil fit reliquiAta^ inferior a quolt;^ fcrutabimur,

^[^^'^^^ faciUoremnobKiudicemin fummaqueefii f^â^ent.'i^on diÃimile huk eÃ¢ 0 Â«ÃÂ«d praceptum, ^ P'''Â°P^^â^ neniantM.lcerÃ¨ enim corn* â^ieneralia fiant .Commune eil,tyrMnum occiditi ârW, 'Virie^um tyrannuin occidit, muUer oedditÂ»

uxor occidit^ Sokbam z^ excerpere fluid mibicuffif i^* uerÃrio conueniret,ft modo id promccrit,n(cÃ^^ premere conj-cÃioncmjcd pirtiendo multiplicacj)^ ** iÃ¯U controucr/iitDux qui competitorem putrem w pr fragijs uiccritjCdptm eil. Eurntes nd red'mcndMtu/fH kgntifObuiumhAbuerwnt pdtremreuertentemii bo* inquire amp;nbsp;ft^^^^^ kgdtk dixit,fera itK^ Excufferu/ntillipitrenft indajan. ft durum in Ãnu eiiti muenerwntjipfi perfeuerdrMt itâ quo intendenMy inuenerunt ducem crucifixum,cuiiif uox fuittCduete proditorem,reui ell pdter. Qut congt; ueniut^proditio nabis proditd eli,cr prididd 4 duce, querimuf proditorem,te ijffe nd hoÃes/dteris, er ^Ãf ^ ^^^^ cldm, ZT db bis 'mcolumem rcdiijfc, durum retulilJe,(t durum occultum bdbÃ¼ijJe.Ã¯Jdm quod fecit ,id noimtw* qudm potentius fit in propofitione, qug fi dniwsoccut pdrit,propt dures ipfie defenfionipnecluduntur-tn to^ turn dutem congregdtio criminum deeufdntem idi'^uÃ¼, fepdrdtio defendentem.Sokbdm id,quod fieri O' W ^t't gumentis dixi, in totdfdcere mdterid, ut propoÃt^ ext tm quig nihil effet omnibus, deinde ateris remotis, foÂ» turn id fupereffct,quod credi uokbdm,ut in pn^riedt tionum criminibus,ut dbfobutur reus,dut ianoeetidipfi us fit,dut interueniente dliqud potefidte, dUt n^*** ^Â°ââ* rupto iudicio, dut difficultdte probutionis, int prdMn cdtione^'Nocenteinfuiff'e confitcris,nuUd potefia oijik tit, nuUd uis, corruptum iudicium non qunreris, nulU probdndi difficultÃ© fuit,quid fuperell,nifi ut prurit idtio fucrit^Si oimid dmoliri non poterdin, tnnÃ© pbiri

ORATOR. LIBER VIL 409 imohÃ³ir^Uominem occifum confiait,non in foUtudine, Kt 4 litroniliM fn^iccr,non prized^ gratin,quidinj^olizt twen,non hareditniKinâ^,fluid pauper fuit.Odium igi* tnr m cdufa: i^uis inimicui / QÂ«Â« res autemfaciliorem iiuiÃoni uiam prgÃat, eadem inuentioni (luoc^ excute^ re t^icciuid dicitur poteÃ, er uelut reieHione faita ai oft'mm pcruenire^ Accufatur M.ilo,^uod Clodium oc* (iierit,iut fecit,aut non.optimum erat negare,fi no pa ten,occidit ergo dut iure,dut miurid.Vtic^ iure,aut uo iMtdteigitur,aut neeeÃitate.iJdm ignorantid pratendi Â«on poten. VolutM anceps eH. Sed fluid it a homines pM tint,iiiung(ndd defenÃo,utid pro Kcpublica fuerit. NcccJ?tof^ fubitd igitur pugna,no praparata,alter igi tÂ»rmfiiiitusell. vter^ profedo Clodius. 'Videfne ut ipn rerum neeeÃitas deducat dd defenftonem i Adhuc^ mt utif^ uoluit occidcre mfididtorem Clodium, aut not tutiw n nobtit.lÃ¨ecerunt ergo ferui Milanis, neq; iuben *^âlt;^lt;5 Ãdente Milane. At hac tdm timidd defenfio de-frlt;ilÂ»t autoritati idi^qui relie diceiamuf occifum. Adif ^tetur,^uoi, niosfUiifc^ feruosintdlircfdcereuoluiflett. ^oc eo eSi utilius,lt;iuod fape nihil placet,ey alilt;iuid di-^^^nmeH.intueamur ergo omnia,ita appdrcbit,dut ii W optiÂ«Mt)j c/l,lt;tMti'd e^od minime mdlum.PropoÃi-âââ^ iIiqMdndo dduerfdrij utendum, et eÃe nonnuneiui ^'tenunÃª earn [uo loco didum eft, Multis milibus uer* 1^ânjcio ipud f^uofda eÃe qnxÃtum eiuomodo muenire ^ 'Hn p^Ys deberet prior dicere,(idâm faro uel atro*

PoffefforT âiiâi^ore,^k poffe/foreconceffuntfit, Sdwpl*^â^â' hoqui fumiS ftji^ controuerfijs ne inucniri guident pote^ gt;Mt â¢*â¢ *^' to cuius ^d^ Q^itres liberoshlt;ibeb(it,oriltorÃ«,pMofophunt,crne' ^'Â°,quot;l^'Â°*' ' dicum,teÃdmentO(iMtuorpilrteffecit,(Tfi^Sf^^P' tur^ aftio-* Ãª'*^^ dedÃ®t^undm eitts effe uoluit,qui e^Ã¤ utmÃmw d' nÃ© fuftinere uitdtiâContendutit,quis primai dicdt incertum cÃ, ffÂ® de^poir^iÃ´e ^PâÂ® ^â^*^^'* certd^Ab co enim cuim perfoiu tuebimufi deturbetur incipiendu ent. Et h^c guident de diuidendo in uwer-fedefendit. fufitpr^i^poffuntÂ»AlicpiomodoinuenieinMetidiU^i

occultiores quiejiioestfcilicet e^uo modo [cntÃªtidiititt^^f \ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;figurdi,coloreiÃngeni0ycurd,excrcitdtionc,nontdgt;nen

' ferÃ¨ im^ niÃ imprudentem fugerint,Ã (ut dixi) Mtun fc^ui dueem uelit.Sed plerieÃ eloquentiiefdmd iÃidM' tesycontentifunt locii Ã^cioÃt modÃ¨, uel nihil dd fto i tionÃ« conferentibut.Alij nihil uitdtes,ed qut in oculos m currut^exqtÃ¼rÃ«ddputdnt.Quod lt;pto faciUamppdre-it^ unam de fchold controuerfidin non itd fdnÃ¨ nut noudm propondin in exemple t cpti reo proi^tquot;â pdtrinondÃruerit^exh^resÃt, Proditionisdd^n â cum ddnocdto exulet,Keo proditionif pdtri diÃ^ Uns dffuit^ruÃieus non djfuit,ddmndtus dbijt (lt;quot;â ^^^ cdto in exilium.Ruflicus cu fortiter fecijjit,pt^^^l mine impeirduit reflitutionem pdtris erÃdtri^f- c* ^ reuerfusiniefldtusdeeeÃit,petit ruÃieutpdrtebo^^^â'â ordtor totumfibi ueiidicdt.Hic UU elocluentes, ^ui udâp pos dred Utes rurdsfoUdtiores ridienU uidemuÃ¯) tnn

dfOt perfomsfAuordines, AÃ¤io pro rujiico cStu difer turn,pro uiro forti contre fmbtUcm,proreftitutore con tn ingritumi pro co ^ui pArte contmtm fit, cotn cum tpAijrAtrinihilddreexpdternisUelitz Que omnidfunt w ntitcriijZrmultum iuuMt, uifloridm tdmen non trd innt.tnhde cpttrcMr fentcntilt;t,f fieri potent,pried-' fÃ®tes Hfl oifeure, Ndw ed nunc uirtut eh, ut pulchre * f^eru CM niiterid tumultu c eldmore trdnfddu.iUi ueÂ» '^fxÃ¿iiibutpropofitucjuidem melius,fed curd in proximo eft, bite uelut inndtdntid uidehunt exeufdtÃ¼ effe rufiicu, qui non interfuerit iudicio nihil coUdturus pdtri ,fed. ^'''Â° â¢* difertHw c[uidem hdbere quod iffÂ»pÂ«trt reo,cum is dd ^quot;'ââw fit, Dignueffe hereditite refiitutore, dudrum, '^fi^oi)ingrdtu,qui diuidcre nolit cÃ¼ jr^re,eoc^ fic me f^to, (iui^ionem epto^ illdm prmd fcripti cr wluntd qua nunc tÂ«, qwj Â«MNc fxpÂ«gÂ»itlt;lt;gt;Â«on fit fcquentihus locus^ At *Â® Pâ8quot;â 5Â«i nxtur^m fecjueturJlU cogitdiit profedo primo,hoc difturntÂ»ruflicum-Pdter mtefidtm duos nos filiosrdi-5âit,p4rteÂ»Hrc gentium peto.Qjiis tdm impcritus^i^uis i^mproculdliterist^ciuinfiKmcipidtyetiA fittefeierit gd ^t propofitio f Hdne comunem omniu legem leuiter dd -orn^htjHt iufli: nempe felt;iuetur,ut ^uerdmus, ^d huic t^m tipte pofluldtioni reffiondedtur. Ad id mdnififium f^-Lex f^ q(4^ lull!; exh^rede effe cum epti pdtri proÂ» ditioBK Â»0 non Ajfutrit,tu dutem no dffuifii, Hdnc pro pofitionem nece^dridfeeptitur legislduddtio,cr dut fini non iffuerit,ttituperdtio.Adhuc uerfdmur in cofef* fih rtiea dnimus dd petitorc, numptid non hoc cogitet

neceffe e^^nift quisfit pline hebest Si kx objlit, mtlk Us eR ^ 'mane indicium efl : ntcjui cr kgem efJe^ijlâo^ quod eu punkt d ruftico failum extrn dubitiitioni tS* Quid ergo dicemusf Kufiiem er ut. Sed kxerAt,omntt co)npkÂ£iitur,nihilproderit.QtiÂ£rdmusergo,numinjit mdri in dliqui parte kx pofiit: quid aliud, fdpiui dich satura permittit, qut cum uerba contri fint,de Â«olÂ«Â«-tate qu^raturf Generadii igitur quejlio, uerbis on uo* luntate fit fiandum. Sed enim in commune de iure omni dijputandumfemper, nee unqfatk iudkatum cÃ¼.Que rendum igitur in hac ipfa,qua confilimui,M dÃ¼qiud int tteniri pofiit,quad fcripto aduerÃtur.Brgo quijquis w lt;ijfuerit,exhÂ£res erit' quifquis fine exception^ lantfe ilia uel ultra offrent argumenta. Vilius mfins tdr i^^Ãª^'f non affuittor qui aber at,a- qui militabat, et qui iÂ» iâ'S^ tioneerat. lam multum aÃ¤i edl,poffet aliquis oot^f

M fi,amp;'htereteffe.TranfeatnuneidemtTk,qiÃ¼flt;gt;!f^t fto MurjiÂ« ^^ ^.^ cicero,tibicinis luitimmodo,ad diferttm- Vt concedam, tu nee infans es, nee ager eras, nee shpfib nee militafti, Num aUud occurrit | itlud i Sed n^ fum,Contri quod palam eÃ¢,dicettVt agere nonp-'^^'* ris,afiidere potuifii. ut ucrum eil,quare redenndnnt ej rufiieo ad emmu kgum latoris.lmpietatÃª pÂ»Â«â*ââ ' â â¦ Contra'^ ego ^nicm impius non fum, Contra que difirtus : Tn ^k?^'*â impiefecijli,inquit,cuexhÂ£reditatiogt;Ã¼meruifi,lk^if* , pofiea,uel panitentio, uel ambitus ad hoc genus optioU adduxerit pretereaPropter te damnatus efl pater: ut' iebaris enim de caufa pronUtk/fe ,Ai bten^''^

kfro cdufd ddmnitionis fuiÃizmultos offrnderAt.mimi' citidi domui cotraxerds. Hxc coniedurdÃ¯id.lUud quo^ qÂ»od coloris loco ruÃieus dicit, fdtris fui/Je idle conÃ-Hum, ne wniuerfdmdomupericulo Ãibijccrct. Ã¼itcpri' M ([ueÃione Ãcripti zy uoluntdtis cotinentur. wtendu mus ultr'd, dnmu, uidedmus^; dn dUi^uid inueniri prÃªtez -tw poÃit^cpio id modo fidt,fedulo mitor quicrentem^ut untrere docedm, ey omiffb j^edofiore iÃ¼o ÃyHgenere iiutilitdtcmmcfuimitto difcentium.OnmesddhucijUie piones ex perfond petitoris ipÃus dUximus,Cur non dU luid dredpdtrem cpijerimus^ DiHum nero eÃ,cui quit *âââ '^^uerit,exHares er it.Cur noncondmur et hie qua 'â^^tUunicuicu $ non dffuerit^ Tdeimus hoc fape in hit ^^'â^'^ouerfijs^n quibus petunturin uinculd,qui pdren~ ^^^fâlt;osnondlunt, dneumquiteÃimoniuinfiliumim''^^^â^^^^ pWi#M reum dixit f dn eum qui Ãlium lenoni uendiditi in filium pe' â¢â fcoc de quo loquimur pdtre, quid apprehendi poteÃi regnnatioÂ» ÃÂ«WMhÂ«rÃ. nuquidigitur lexdddbÃolutostdntÃ¼{MeS^quia' ^^^! pertinetÃ®â Durd prmdfronte quaÃio cÃ,non deÃ^edam lenoni. Â»â Â«Â»Â«;,cred,(âjp ^jj f,^^ uoluiffe legum ldtorem:,ne duxi^ u Hberorum innocentibus deeffent. Sed hoc dicere rtÂ» HM uerecundum eÃ, quid innocentent fuijje pdtrÃ¨ fdte iit^^ ^^^^ Â«ifgHwentÂ« controuerÃd.'Ddmndtus pro*

âÂ®''Â« cuni dduoedto exulet.Vix uidetur paffe fieront ^ Ã i^ffi^^^fit, erfind djfueriti i^^tdfit. PrateredlexddexulesnuUd.pertinet:nd

414 AI. FAB. QVINT, INSTlT-dubiu fdcit. Difertus ey Herbu inhirebit, m ^wliKf *âlt;^ U exceptio either propter hoc ipfurn pattiunejle^o^?^ tutdm eis qui no affuerint, ne periculo exilij dÃ©tendu tur db aduoedtione, (^ ruÃieum innocenti no affiiiÃ^ lt;1* cett lUud protinus non indigftum quod dnnotetur,poflc ex uno fldtu duds generdles fieri queÃionessAU qutj^sÂ» *â coniunfta ^^ cuicunq;, hec ex dudbus perfonis qu/fitd fint, E tertid dutÃ¨ que eÃ¢ dduerfirifinulld oriri queÃiopottfi quid nuUd fit de fud pdrte controuerfid-Kondum titmcn curddeficidt.lÃd enim omnid dici pofient, ettimnonri fiituto pdtre. NÂ« fidtim eÃ¨ tenddinus, quod occurnt ultra,i ruÃico reÃitutum.Qui id fubtiliter queret,sli' quid jfieddbit ultr'd. Udin ut genus j^eciemfiquitur, iW fpeciem genus precedit-Tingdmusergo db dito reÃitU' turn, rdtiocindtiud dtq^ coUciliud queÃioorietur, Ã n t â¦ ftrt fiil^utio pro fubldtione iudicij fit,er pei^^^ fiiudidunon fuifict.^bi tentdbitruflicus petrdrequidemdliterpotuific fiorum premia,nifi pdtre permde defi deeufdtus non edtotque res dduoedti quoq; poenS. tdnq if fgt;Â°'' remificrit.Tum ueniemus dd id qdâprimutn Â°^â!â^nf^iit ruÃico reÃitutueffe pdtre. Vbi ruÃieusreÃitutor dccipi debedt pro dduoeÃ¼m^. ^^^ preÃitcrit, quad dduoedtus petijt, nee fimili dccipiquad plus eR. Reliqud MriusiuÃiusfitdefideriutn. id 'jpAquot;*, Ã®^fiÂ«iÂ»jÃ etu fi uter^ fibi totu uÃ«dicdret,nuc utiq^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cti*

ORATOR. TIBER VU. 41V ^Ã¿iummomentumhdlet apuiindicÃ©spatrit mrmo' ni,cum prj[[crtim de bonis dus quicrdtur.^rit ergo co idiurd,([ui mente pdter inteftdtus decefjerittfed ed per tinet dd (^udUtdtÃ«, ([Uie dlterius fldtus infirumentum eA. PlfrÂ« j dutem in fine cdufdrum de ^quitdte trdUdbitur ^idnihillibentius indicÃ©sdudiunt. Aliqudndo tdmen ixoÃ¯c ordmâ¢ mutdhit ntilitds ,utÃin iure minus Ãdu^ ht erUjtejuitdte iudicem prttpdremus^Nihilhdbui dm-pWj q^od in uninerfum pr^eciperem, t^nne edmus per fi^Ã¿dds Cdufdrum indicidlium pdrtes, quas nt perfei^ui lt;111 Â«ItwkÂ»Â» f^edem, id eH, dd Ãngulds Utes, controuerÂ» /iwq; Mo poffum,itd de gener^bus feribere licet,ut qug ^ 4'*â¢^ ^dtuÃccpientiÃme inciddnt,trdddm. ^t c^uid ff^^gt;(rd primd qatftio eH.fdilnmne Ãt, db hdc ordidr.

CONlECT Vr4 omnis dut de re, dut de dnimo eH, QQ^jj^f^j.^ Vtriufi^ trid tcmpord,prdeteritum,prtfcns,futn riiâ?Â«^, mm.Oerf)^ generdlescÃ¿ttfiiones funt,cr dÃ©finitt,id eHiZf qÂ«Â« non continÃ©tur, (y qm contmentur.rgt;e dni no clutrinon potcfi,nifii ubi per fond eA, cr de fddo co ^st.^rgocum de re dgitur,dut(inidfd(lum Ãt,in dnbiu Â»fuit, 4Â«t ^uid fidt,dut fluid fit futurum, Vt m generdt^ lifâMjiM dtomorum concurfu mundus fit effÃ¨Ã¼us, dn pro MiicMtii(rfg4tâ,..^^y5^ dÃ¯icindndo edfurus. IÂ» definitiSi â^^P^^ddium eMferifRofdus,dnregnum dfÃdet refie VerrÃ¨fit deeufdturus CiXtciUns. Jw i'^^'^sprtteritum tempus mdxime udlct. Nrmo fnim f^^d^Ãtflifi lt;iutfdSidfnnt,'hlAm tint fidnt,tÃ¿- ^ut fuM

4â6 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT- .^ rdfint,dtt prxteritii colligutur.Ciutritur et wiiff^ ortÃ¼yUt pejÃ¯ilcntid, ird deunt, dn intemferiecaU,^ ^^ ruf^tii depuis,dn noxio terne hdUtu. Et c^ue edufd^^â qudre dd Troidmquinqudgmtdreges nduigMenÂ»^)''^* reiurdndo dddili,dn exemflo moti, dit grdtiÃantes ^f ridÃ©s. Que duo generd non nwititminterfed^'^ uero,quÂ£ fimt prevent is temporis ,fi nondrgumcnl'^t qutnecelÃe eÃ¼ preceÃijfe^fedoculis deprebenien * fant,nonegentcoieHurd,utfidpudLdccdemcnios^igt;f rdtur,dn Athenismurifidnt. Sed v iÃ¼ud poteÃ uiieti 8enfre q- extrdhocpropofitumcoieiluregenus,cumdedbijdo^ rieur 3d fit fjomine quieritur quis Ãt,ut eR quxfitÃcontre V heredes,Ã is, c^ui tdn^ Ãlius petebdt iond,lÃ¨iguluf T ^Â» dn Sofipdtertndm er fubfidntid eius fub oculos uenit, ut nonpoÃitqueri,dnÃt. Qwmodo Ã¼ltrd ocednuingt;u(( quidÃt,nec qudlcÃt, fed dn quidÃt. Veru hoc lt;lâ*Â°â^ 2^ nus litis ex preterito pendet: An hieÃt ex vrbluidui* tus CluÃnius figulus, fuerunt dutem idles neÃf^ ^ ^â^ temporibus controuerÃlt;e,dt^ dlique in meuni lt;iuo^gt; P _ trocinium beider un t. Anmi conieHurd non duHeiu dura? **â*â Â°'^'^^â^ tempord eddit.QÃ¿d mÃ¨te Ligdrius in Aj^^^i^ rit.CiudmetePyrrhusfaduspetdt. Quoind^^^^'^^^ fit Cefdr,Ã Ptolomeus Pompeium occiderit. QH^^^^^^ per conieilurdm,sy qudntitds, er qudUtds cired ntoiu, IÃeciem,numerum. An fol mdior q terrd. Lundglobofd dn pldnd,dndcutd. Vnusmudusdnplures.Ã¯teni^extrd ndturdles queÃiones,Mdius bellum Troidnum, dn Pela ponneftdcu.Q^dlis clypeus AebSlis. AÃ¼ MUS Hercuiffâ

In I)K Auti ^MiÃ Accufitioe, dut defcnfione confidt^unum CÃ³ieftura Ã® tft gr nus, 'm ^uo quxritur er defiHo, er de AMore, aâ^^'^ qÂ«od interim coniundAm quffiionem l)Alct,er utrun^ fAriter negiturâAnterim [epArAtAmyCum fdilunsfit^nec HfjC? Ã defAdo ccÃet,A ^Â«o fAdÃ¼ Ãt,Aniiigitur,1plum i{Mlt;yfAdum AliquAndo Ãmplicem epaÃionent hAlet^An homo peneritiAliquAndo dupliccm^ ueneno Alt cruditÃ© te pnicrit. Aherum ed geniu de fado tAtum, cum Ã id eertumÃt^non poteÃ de autore duUtAritTertiude AU~ tore tAntii,cumfAdu conÃet,fed A ^uofAdum Ãt,m cÃ³' trouerÃA uemtSA qdâtertio loco po[ui,non eÃÃmplex^ Avi enm reusfeciffe tAtummo fe negAtiAutAliÃ¼feciffe dicit.Sed ne 'm AÃteru sptidÃ© trAfferedi efmimis wnA for t^tAe^.interduenim ÃibÃituiturmutUA AceufAtio,^ GriP d miKomyofiotp uocAt, noÃroru ejuidA cocertAtiuAm: Sulpitius re* interdS in AÃtpiAperÃonA ^ua: extrAdiferme iudicij fÃilpotogMi^ tnnÃerturyCt aHÃs eer tl, aUÃs meert a, 'Et eu 'm cert A,nÃ« appellat. dut iÂ« extrAriA,Aut 'm ipÃus g pcr'ijt uoluntAtÃ«,Ã®n qui *ââ^ ^flff^' biuÃmUis^Ate^ 'm avToioerJtrofux. perÃonArÃ¼,cAuÃAru, ca aut ipp qui terorucompArAtio cd,ut Cicero pro âVArcno^infAtniltA (j^'Ã¦ââ^^â* AnchiriAni pro ScAuro, cire A morte EoÃArK 'm mAtre wertes cr'mÃ¨fAcittEd etil iUud huic cotrAriÃ¼ copArA tioni: genus,in quo uter^ A fe fidueffe dicit, et illud 'm qÂ«o Â«5 f [oÂ»x intrr fefed ipfa res eolliduturjd ed, non titfffeÂ«rit,fed utru fidu ft.Cu defAdo,er deAutore tÃ¶ÃAt,ieiÃ¼o quart poteÃt munedepngulis,cu pAriter utrutp negAturJboe mo:Adulteriu non comifutyrAnidÃª

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Itoiffidiuidn cedis de ueneÃeij cAuÃsdequesrÃ lt;8Â«$ lt;**

418 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIÃâlt; ^ uifio^non eSl fiHu,^ fiÃÃ¤ u,ego non feci. Sd lt;^ââ ââ Mm,prosit hotem occifum^iccufitorii tMtu fif^^^f. ^rfo nihildici cotrii,prÂ£terdl!(^uA(fortune[â^^^'^â^^ nespoteÃ, qumf^Ã¤rgere quÃ¤rnÃ¤xteuÃ¤rieopotteid^ Ã MtuÃ¤liqd Ã¤ffirmÃ¤rif,probÃ¤nditeÃ,Ã¤utcÃ¤uÃp(^^^*^ dum.NÃ¤ Men inter id t^dâdb dduer[Ã¤rio,crid ^ij'^^ Ui^ppofitn eÃ,([uÂ£ritur,uideturutilt;^ Ã¤lteru ueru,'^^^^ ex diner fa unit eil quo defendhnur,reliquu eÃ q^ P''^ ntimur.At eu qu^rimui de Ã¤mbiguK Ãgnis crudiutis^ ueneni,nihil tertia eÃ. Ã¯deo^ utrÃ¤^ pars qdâ propo^t tuetur.interim dut ex re quÂ£ritur,uenejiciitmfnerit,^â^ cruditdi,cu dliqud ex ipfd eitra pfÃ¤nd quoc^ dÃ¯gunienti ducutur.Refert enim eSuiuiu prÂ£eefferit,dntrifitW bor dn otiu,uigilid, dn quies.Aetdi quoq^ eim q pw(^â^gt; difermÃ« fdcit.IntereÃ fubito defecerit,in logoff Hy' tudme cofumptmfit. Liberior ddhudnutrifp^^^f * jputdtio/i tdntu fubitd mors in qutÃione uenidift^^ ex pfÃ¤nd probdtio rei petitur,ut proptcred erdi^^^r ttenenu fuiffe, qd credibile eÃ db hoefddu uentfdÂ», ut contrd. Cu uero de reo (y de fdUo quiritur, ndturdii or do eft, ut prim fdHÃ¼ effe deeufdtor probet,dcii^lt;^ * reofdiÃu.Si tdmÃ«plures in perfond probdtioiM^^^^^' rit,conuertet hue ordmÃª.Defenfor dutem priut Mgmt ejfefdilum,quidÃhdcpdrteuicerit,reliqudnonneceÃt hÃ¼bet dicerc.ViSlo fupereÃ,ut tuen fe poÃit.tlHt Ãlt;^ que ubi de fÃ¤do tdntu eStrouerfid eÃ¼,q^fi probetur,Â»Â« poÃit de dHtore dubitdri.fimiliterdrgumÃ«td,(y ex per* fonditsr ex rf dMutur,fed tnundfdiâii quifionijfott

iÂ« l'Ã®Ã®d contrcurrfid ( Vtendum eft etiim O' lis ext m^ ^ Ã¿hj^âquot;* pfe {lut[untdifcÃ«tibusmdgÃ¹fAmilidrÃ»')AldicdtM me iumejiuduit^cu pdter eiw d:grotdrct,dc^erdntiliui de to ceteris medicis^ddhibitus fdndturu fc dixit,ft is fotio nem Ã feddtA bibiffet. Pater accepte potionis epota par tc,dixit uenemm fibi datu,Ãliiu t^d'reUc^uu erat,cxlau' jit,pater dcceÃit,iÃ¼c parricidij tew eÃ.UianifeÃum ell qwK potion? dedcrit,(pie Ã ueneni fuit, nulla epteflio de Mtore,âi-tantu anfuerituenenu exargumetis apjona tamcn duHis coUigeturSupereÃ tertiu,in quofaduejfeeeÃat Ãquidji ^uo Ãt fallu queritur,eiui rei fuperuacuu efl ponereexemplu, cÃ¼ plurimafint huiufmodiiudicia,ut fi lâonntiÃ« occifum efje manifeÃu efl,uel jacrilegiÃ¼cÃ¶mifÃ¼, ^ ââ ^i^uiarguiturfecifje neget.Ex hoenafdtur biUJiKce Tun^icf, vti^ 1,0e fallu effe ccuenit, c^d'duo tnuieÃ« obij (iuit In qÂ«o quidÃ« genere caufaru admonet Cclfui fieri id m faro nÃ¶ paffe, c^ued nemmi ignorare arbitrary Dc gt;*ââo tnim ff o confdiu cogitur,ct Ã qui funtq inuice accu j(nt,alteru iudicium preferre neceffe efi. ApaUodorws ^âââÃ¯; ditZnomraftaij duasefjecontrouerfiasdixit,^ [MreuerafecunduforenfciusdueUtes. Potefitamen â¢w goiut in cognitionem uenire fenatus, dut principis.

^'i in iudicio quo^ ntkil interefi aliionu, utrufimuÃ¯ de â^0$ pronucie tur,an etia Ãdewno fententia fÃ¨ratur. ^Â® in genere femp prior debebit effe defenfio.Primu, ^â^gt;'Hura potior ekfalus noflra,q aduerfarij pniciesÂ» ffÂ»Â« qdâ plut habelmtu in aceufatiene dutoritedis,fi

4X0 M. FAB. 07 IN T. INSTlT-tnum duplex eMfi erit. NÃ ([ui dicit, ego no occidh ^ bet reliquA pirtc^utdient^tu occidijU.At e^ui dicHi^^^ cidijli,fuperuneuÃ¼ hnhent paÃen diccre,ego noiij^^^ '* ' HÂ« porrÃ³ d^iones conÃÃt copdritione, ipfd cep^^*Â® non und uid ducitun Autenim totd edufdm noÃnci^^'â^ td dduerfdrij edufd eoponmus, dUt fmguld drgumÃ«tii^^^ pngulii: quoru utruÃtfdeiendu no poteÃ niÃ ex ipÃ^^_^ litit utilitdte cognofci,ut Cicero Ãnguld pro Vdreno fÃ¶ pdrdt in primo ermme.LR enim fupcrior,cu pfÃ¤nd aie ni,cu pfÃ¤nd mdtrÃ¹ temere compdretur. OJidee optimd eÃ /t fieri poterit,ut Ãnguld uinedntur dfinguUi^^^^ll quido in pdrtiius hbordbimui, urduerfitdte pugndnin eA, pue muicÃ«dccufdnt,fiue crimen reuicii^'^^^^^'*'^^^^^ nÃ« in dduerfdriu uertit, ut R ofcius in deeufdtores fios, quduis reos non ÃcciÃrt:fiue in ip fis lt;Ãios fid rndnupe' rij fie dicemusyfdÃ¼Ã¼ defleHitur^ non dUter j iÂ« ^^ ^*^ mutui deeufdtione hobent^utriufq; pdrtis Arguinenti M ter fi cÃ¶pdnnturAd dut genusjie quo nouifie folu in fcholis fiepe trdfldturficd etid infioro- ^dide in cdufid NfMl/ Aprunidnifiolu quefiuu: Precipitdtdneej â¦ cuius fet db co uxor,dn ficipfidfiud fionte iedfiet. 03^/ nÃ«equidÃª foUrn m hoc tempus emifierdm,qdi dfifie fidudÃ iuueniU cupiditdte glorie fdteoYlt; N^'â ^^ tere qua fiub noie mco fierutur, negligentid exafieniw nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;i

in quxÃlt notdrioru corrupte minimd pdrtÃ«tncibdigt;etgt; Eft ce dlid duplex conieÃ«turd huk av^uxi^yei^'*^ âââÆâ diuerfd^de premijs,ut in iUd controuerfidifyednitiii fin f^keitM dmeiiicofiuOfditumfibiueneniini, torfitamt

illf ditum ft Â«fncnÂ»m dixit,pd antidotum dAturum,i!3â dedit ft potiotlfm,qM4 fpoUjt^rdnniÂ« dfcf)?it.Dc prÂ«-wio duo me did contendunt : Ndm ut iKic fadum in Adâ utr^mum trinfferentium, itA hie fdgt;i uindicAntium per fdnt^cAu[e,fAcultAtcs,tcmporA,inÃrumctd,tefimoniAf fopirdntur.inui quo^,ctiiiM ft wort eft av^na'W^ojiÂ«, fimili timen rutionc truftutur, in ^uo citrA AceufAdonÃ© ^uieritur,Â«trum fAdum pt. Vtrult;j enw purs expoptio Â«cm fuum bÃ¤tet,deque caw tuctur^ut in lite Vrbintunu, pctitor dicit, Clupnium Ã¯igulum pUum Vrbimi* Acie ui ftd,m qud Ãeterdt,fugiJJc,tdftdtumqi cdftbw UdrijS,re-tenturn ftidm i rege, tundem in Itdlidm, Ac putrid fuAn Mdigmoj ufnijre,dt^ ibi dgnofei. PolUo cohrdferMiÃc eum Pifduri dommis duobtMjtnedicMidm fdftitd)?e,Â»idnw mpum, dienx Ã fAmdiie uemli mmifeuipe, de rogun-tern ut cis feruiretemptumtNoiie â¢T- totdlts contÃ¢t dud* tordotalis rum ciufdrum compdrdtiottc,0' conieftura duplici dtq^ diuerfd^ QuÂ« dutem deeufuntiu dtlt;^ defendentium, cd-dem pctentium er wtpeidntium rdtio eft. Ducitur conic Hurd primu d pr* tcritwJnbis funt perfonx cdufx,con fllid,Nd is ordo cft,ut fdeere uolucrit,potuerit,feccritÂ» ÃM^intuendum dntc omnid qudlis fit, de quo dgitur. â Actufitoris dutem eft effwerc, ut fi quid obiecerit,nott folumturpe pt Â»fedetidmernnini ,de quo eft iudicium, qÂ«Â«*nndximc conuenidt ,Ndm ft reumexdis impudicum, wl ddultcrumuocet,Uddt quideminfdmid,Â»Â«mus tumen hoc di pdem uiledtj^p (iHdlt;lcem,petuUntem,crudekm,

4Â« M, FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. temerdritim oÃederit. Patrono fiÃeripoterit^id^^' dum cR, ut oiieÃ¼d uel neget, uel defends, uel Miiii-ProximKeUjUtÃprÃ¦fentieiu^llionefepdret.SunttniA plerdlt;^ non folum diÃimilid, fed etidm dlicjUdndocontti rid, ut Ã reus furti, prodiges diedtur, dut negligent. Het^enmuideturmeundem o- contemptus pecunit, O' cupiditM eddere: Si deer ut hdc remedid^dd iÃ¼i iecH ndndu eH, non de hoe qutri^nec eum qui d^uinio pee eduerit, uti^ commifijfe omnid, o hune ÃdutidinfuiÃe deeufdtoribui fdlfd obijciÃ«di,quod lafum cr lUibterdtun reurnjperduere hdc muidid oppriw poÃe. Alid propoft tio eÃ dccufdtoris,contrd t^udm loei oriutur fepe Ã per fond, O'interim generdiiter. Prior ducitdrgumentdie fenfor, in credibÃ¼e eÃed filio putrem, di uxore uirti oc cifum, db imperdtore proditdm ho^ibus pdtridiÂ». PMile rejÃondetur,uel lt;juod old feelerd in mulos edddntÃdeo^ uel ^d in' fepe deprehenfdfint, uel quod mdignumfit ,crilt;iigt;^^ genifi fit,cr^ ip^ dtrocitdte defendi. interim proprie,quoi (^ i^^* trocitate de^ Â«Â»w. Ndw dignitÃ© O tuetur reurn, o nonnunq ipÃ *â** nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;in drgumentum fdHi conuertitur, tdnq inde fueritl^ts

impunitdtis, fed perinde pdupertM, humilitds,op^^i quot;^ eui^ ingenio uis eÃ¼, in dinerfum trdhuntur. Pfi^*^^ nero mores, o dntedHÂ£ uitiemtegritut nunquitd non plurimum profuerint Â» Si nihil obijcietur, pUsonM quidemin hoe uehementer incumbet. AceufdtordU' tem dd pr^fentem quxÃionem, dequd fold iuiieiwn fit, cognitionem dÃ¼egdbit, dicens neminem non dU' iqudndocoepifiepeccdre,necper Ã®yncefvKx. duceninm

fcclut pYimum, hoc in rej^ondendo. Sic Mtem prÂ£pd' nUt iSlionc primi iudicum Mmof, ut noluiÃe potim obijcere^i^MmnonpotniÃecreditur. Eo^ fitiui cH omni fc Mtnfix nits dbÃmere conuido ,qukm leid' Iu5,iut ÃiuoUs y dut mdniÃefto fdlÃs reum meeÃere, ([Mijides atcris detrdhitur : CZ t^ui nihil dbijeit, omi'' Ã^jo credi poteÃ mdlediUd idne^udm Ãperudeud : qui Â»iOM congerit ,conÃtetur uinumm dntcdHii drgumen tum, 'm (juihm uinci, ^udm tdeere mdluerit.Ceterd ejua Aperfonddud folent'in drgumentorumlocii expo fui' ww. Proximo eft ex eduÃs prÃ³bMio,in c^uibus htec Wttimc Ãwdintur, ird^ odium, rnetin^cupiditM^ef. N((mrfliqÂ«(( in hdt Ã^edes cddunt, quorum Ã quid in ^euconueniet, deeufdtorit eft efficere, dd quieqd fdden ^fÂ°^^^ 'Â° ^^ ilt;imcdufÂ£udÃ¯creuidedntur^cd,fquequiu in ArgumcU'^^ofutmui tÃ¼inÃmet^dugerei Siminus,iUucconfcrÃªdd eÃ ordtio,Yo prÃ¦ftÃ¢nP dut i^udsfortdÃe Idtentes fuiÃe, dut nihil dd rem per fi^iftmam tiwe curfecerityfifecÃ¯t.dutetidmdignius eÃe odioputat.quare fedus, quoi Â«0Â« b^buent edufdm* Pdtronm uero quo' ^JPg p/o'ba tiapoteritÃnÃdiithuicloco, ut nihilcredihile ftl fddutioni uocat, fÃeÃnecdufd'.quod Cicero uehementiÃ'wie multis ord' tionihm trdddt,prÂ£dpue turnen pro Vdreno,qui omni 11Â« mdw premeidtur,ndm e:y dimndtm cÃ^. At Ã proÂ» ponitur cur fdHu Ãt,dut fdlfdm edufim, dut Icuem, dut â¢ffwuÂ« pro reo dieet,PoÃunt eÃe dliqut interim igno iA. Anhiredemhdhueriti dn decufdturuifuerit eum Ã ^iw diotHr oedfut.Si dUd defecerint^no utiq^ ÃeÃ¼dddt fÃtcMfds, Ã¼dm quem paÃe reperiri,qui non metudt^

4^4 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT. oderit,j^eret^ PÃ¯ufimos tarnen hic falud innoctvd^P' cere^ Nf ^Â«c iÃud eA omittendum, non omneis cJi*[â*â â^ omnibus perfonis udkre^ijdm ut Ã©iUcuifttlitri^^, fdupertdS^non erit idemmTSurio,'edbriÃ¼ol^Â»ioâ''^* tum.Deedufd prins,dn de per fond dicendumfit, ^w^''* tur,udrie^ eÃ¼ db ordtoribus fuclttm, d Ciceron^tti^ prtldUjre^uentifime eduft^ Sed mhi,fifing uHeaiit^ conuicio proponcretur Â»fecundu ndturdm uidetur i^ pere i perfond. ISSdtn boe mdgit generale eR, reniotv tautnullfi diuifip, dutmnuUocrimen credibilefdutinboci^o crimen credi tefi tdmÃ¨id ipfumficut plcrdq}, uertere utiHt^-^^^ ^^ i e, aut oc ^^^ ^^^^^ uoluntatisfant qutrendfjed iatttiÂ»tt^ rorii,ut ebrietds er ignorantia.'Nam ut bdc wgt; te crimen eleuant,itd m conieÃ¼ura prÃ©muni- Et na quidem nefcio,an umq utiq^ m into aliu rei P/â^ cidere,de qua neutra pars dicat,de cdufisfre^â*â^â^^ amp;nbsp;n nihildttiÂ»et,utinddulterijs, iÂ»furtis,quidi^^^^,^ ipfa ermma fecu babent.PoÃ htc mtuÃ©da uHei^'^ nbsp;nbsp;.

filid,quÂ£litepatent,ancredibilefitreÃlfetar(f. ^^ fcelus effici po{fe,an ignordri cujÃ¨ciffet, on ratum non effet, dbfolui, ueÃ¯ pÂ«na leui tronfigh '^^fi^o diorejuel ex qua minus ineSmodi cofecuturus,Ãf:',.^^ gaudij uideretur,an etiarn tanti putdueritpeti^i.

Pof bxc on alio tempore, er aliter facere, udÃ ^^^ nel fecurius potuerit,ut dicit Cicero pro I^Honc, ^^ ^ rdns plurmas occafiones, ^us ai eo Clodim in^f cidi potuerit. Preterea cur potiÃimu Ulo loco, pore,iUomodo fitaggreffus, qui tyipfediHg-^T

ORATOR. LIBER VIL 42Ã tnditur pro codent loan. An etidnt, Ã nuUd rdtione du dm ed,impetu rdptufÃt,G dbs^ Ãnteiuid^tidm '^J^g^^j^^j ^g^, go iiÃ tur,Scclerd non hdbere conÃlium.An etidm con* ^^ââ1 non futtuime pecedndiÃt dÃ¼edm. ExeuÃd primd pdrte dit habent.

uoluerit/cquiturdn potuerit. Hic tm^dturlocuf^temt piÂ«,Â«t furtum in loco cliiufo,^^^^^ tempore,nd digt; umotcum tellesplurcs,uel no(iur)io,c'j,m mAior difficul t^s. b^UUnttw Uti^i diffieuk^tes 0- oceuÃones ^ c^ux, ÃintplurmÂ£,iieo^ exemple non egent. Hie feejuens la cm tilk c^jUt ÃÃeri non potuit,fÃ¹blitlt;i lieÃt :Ã potuit, Ãnutur ^fUo^ Ã;cerit- Sii h^c etium dd dnimi con Ketunm pertinentt. Ndm (J lt;^x bis eddigitur dn fÃerdt

Â«fritadco f^eddri deient O- mjlrumenteL, ut Clodij dc ^^o^comitdlui. OjieÃiodn feccrityiwipitd fecun* do tenpore^id cH pr^fentiAo demdeconiwndo, quorÃ¼ fiott fonut,(ltntor, gemitm, Utitdtio, metuf^G- Ãmilid, ^^^ Hw iecedunt Ãgni,de quibw trdddtum ed^Verbi eti* ^^ts-fidi,^^^ dntecelJirunt ,lt;iue^ infecutd Ãmt, ^e mt noÃrd fimt^t diiendSed uerbd mdgis nocent, M minut, ntigis nocent g ntinui profunt noÃrd (puint *licni,migK profunt G ntmut nocent dliend ([Udm no* ^''^â i-dkuMtemintcrtm mdgit profuntnoflrd^mtcrim ^â^ â^'M, ut Ã qyf^ ^âgj pyg nobiiÃt, diu(rfAriMfccit, ^quot;^ Hero mdgKnocent noÃrd epidmdkeni Â« Est er

V '''}^''^^diÃerentid,lt;luod dMdpertdfMt,dutdu^ â¢M'HKoJtrd^fd dliend Ãwt. InÃrmiord 'm utru^ Ãnt âiÃd^bid,tdme noÃrd. Ãepe mdgit nocent,ut in iUd Enobis

41Â« M. FAB. QVINT. INSTiT.â ubicM^ue e^uiuit, dt iÃ¼e in putto mortuus eSHiHiiÂ»^ tut. Aliend lt;juÂ£ funt duiU nuqudm poffunt noceit,^'fi dut incerto dutort^Mt mortuo.Ã¼oHe duUtd e^ Wf'f^ veto tyrMnicidM.Qr interrogdtui,cuiiituenegt;folt;xâgt;'lt;^ rctur rÃ©pondit, non expedit tibi fare. N^w ft (^ f* paffet iÂ»terrogdri,foluet dmbiguitdtem.Cum duteiÂ»Ã¼* (ld fddd^i noftrd defendi folodnimo pofint, tdi(M ui* rU refutdntur. De uno ciuidem mixmegenere contÃ©* (lurdUum controuerfidrum locuti uidetnur,et w onnes Depofiti.fur dUtjuid de bis cddit.tiid depafti/urti,credits: pecunif, cimiÂ»qu^ Cr 4 fdcultdtibui drgumentd ueniivnt, dn fucrit lt;itioi ie fiiones. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;poneretur,et d, per fonts,dit iWdm depofuiffe dpui bunC}

ri:Anreiiminfcidtoremelfe,ueÃ¯furem.Seietidtntnlut ti reoficut in cÂ£dis,lt;iuÂ£ritur de fd(lo,et de mtere-Cre ditier depofiti dua qnffioncs,fed nonnmtepUDnit'f Wulterfl. d^e^dn ddtum ft,dn redditMn.Ã¼dbeiit dÃipdit^^^f^â ddulterij cdufje,c^uod plerun^ duorum i^fcrigt;^^ ^ â^ de utriuf^ uitd dicendtiWyefUdn^udm cr

utruw^ue pdriter defendi oportcdt.CuiA reia^J^ ndfceturexciufd.'iJdmfddiiMdbitpdrs^eÃ¯i,eâgt;'^â i^ctupauo. ^^^Ãnocebit,fepdrdbo. Nf quis dutem

tnere excidiffe,quod pleriinlt;^ duoruM crimetf^lr teri'jimjnon femper dixerim, poteH deeufdrif^ ââ{^^ incerti ddulterij.Utunerd domi inuentdfiiÂ»t,p^â^â^ ius dutor non extdt,codiciÃ¼i,dubium dd tjuemfftp i.

TM. fdlfo i^uoq; ratio fmilif.Aut enim pluresinlt;^^ ^^r^ni (dnttiXgt;dMi.:''''jey'friptor guident fegt;npâ^^^^''l^^

ORATOR. LIBER VIL 417 twmnecelJehdhettÃgnMor fcriptoremiton femper^ i^Mis-decipipotuit.isMtcinquLhoiAihibuiffcyetcui idfidum iicitw, er firiptorem er pffutoret defend xynâiSSSs det. Uiem irgumentoritm ioci 'm eduÃs proditionit^er affedata: ^jÃ^itfi tyrdnniiis.Veriim iUd fcholdrum con^tutudo itwif'id forum poteik nocerc,c[nod omnid qux 'm tbemd te HM fwnt,pro nobis ductmut.Aduitcrium ob'ijcK,(juis tfÆl^i?c|K^f wdfxf ^Mod pretium^ quis confeimf Veno num,uli mifd ^uofcptdndoic^ddÃ¼ti^pcr quem dedi^'Pro feo tyrmnidK dÃidldtg, ubi fumt drmuf quos contrdxi ptflItefNe^ bxc nego effe dicendd,er ipÃs utendum Pâ'o plt;irtf fufeeptd.^idm er inforo, fiqudndo dduerfd *Â®^âââ*Â® Ã¯iiÂ« probdre non poterit, deÃderdbo Â»Sed'm fora tdÂ»^ iiM aiim fdcuUdtem olim deÃderdumuf, ubi non ferÃ¨ (ditfd igitur,ut non aliquid ex bis,dut plurd pondeur, ^wcfmileelk^quod in epilogis quiddm,quibutuolimt^ ^^^^e)s,pire;ites,nutrices dccommodditt,niÃquie mdgit lt;^onc/^crii Cd qute nonÃitt poÃtd, deÃderdre qudm db cere ^Dednimoqua modo quirdtur, fdtis di^um e^, cum itd imfermuty dn uoluerit, dn potuerit, dnfeco lit, ^imqiu,uidtrd{ldtur,dn uoluerit,eddemquo dni'Â» nofecerit, id mm eH, dn mdle fdcere uoluerit. Or do OrdoÂ» ^ât rn-dffljdut dffÃ¨rty dut detrdbitÃdem,multÃ¶ feiho j nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«t Â«4gÂ« f(j p^oyj congrmint,dut repugndnt, fed bite

^7' wipfo complexucdufdrum non deprebendumtur^ QS^renim,, t4^fâ Ãntper quid cuic^ conneiidturt e? ^iicuiconfentidt,

Sc,lt;iuÃ¹ur conieHunmfinitio. NJm ejui non foteji Ã¼ Tii4 luti nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cere nihil feci(JÃ¨,prox'tmumhiiidit,Ut dicit,^^'*

busUiibui *d feciffequodobijcid.tur, Itii(iueplerM([ueleid!Vi â¢*ââ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ijfdem,quibui coniedunuerfutur, defenÃoniftMtM

genere mututo, ut mfurtis, depofitiSyidulterifS. N^ quemlt;idmodtm dicmiit,non feci furtum, non iccefi ie Hsc uerba PÂ°fi(u^gt;ffo^^Ã³tnificidulteriim:itd,nonellhocfurn in pkrifque non eA hoc depofttwmjed mutuatio,Â»oÂ» eÃ hoeii^ bus dendâ? ^drium. Interim Ã quilitate ad finitionem defÃ©diW, rantur,8f ui Ut in ddionibui dementie,mdl^ trdÃ¢dtionu, R cip. lit Â»Hnteâ*ârc* ^ââ^' ^â I'*^^^^ f'^ ^^^^ f*^*^ effequiobijciirntur, did non tante adie- poteÃ¼,iÃ¼udfuccurrit,non eÃ¼ mule tradire B^emp-utr* Ã*â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;bd Iedere ^Tinitio igitur eÃ rei propofite,ptop^^â^ ^^

lucidd,cr breuitercomprehenfd uerbif enuntidtio. Con fdt mdxime,Ãcut eSl di{lum,genere,Ãpecie,dilffentit but,proprijs,ut ftfinias eqMim (notoenim md^^' ^*f exemplo)Genud eH dnimal,jpeciesmortdle,i'fi^^''*^* irrdtionubile.'tjiiunethomo mortdleerdt Propdotte, in mens. Heeddhibetur ordtioni m pluribus eduÃt turn eil cerium de nomine, fed ejueritur tjUii tes dr âI dendd Ãt, turn res eil mdnifeÃd,fed de nomine non con Ãdt.rgt;e re,cum dubium e il,interim conic^nrd Â®EVS tjuerdtur,lt;iuidfit deus.'t^dm cjui id neget, deuin ejje^t rit urn omnibuf pdrtibus immixtum,non hoe dieet pl^ ' effe iÃ¼''us diuma ndturte dppelUtionem ,Ãcut ^pio^tut, (juihummdmei formumloeum^ inter mumdosdeidÂ» fed nomine uterq; two utitur, utrum Ãt 'm re coniedit-

tÂ«iieniian bene dicendi feientu.Ciuod genut r/} Mj iu* ^gt;^ijsÃ'e(^uemÃ'mugt;Sic enim qujeritur^in deprebenfm Hi lupinm cMi idicnii uxore,ddulter Ãt^tjUM non deap fi^tione^fed de uifdÃ¤i eiiu dmbigitur,dn omn'mo pec wrir.NdmÃ peecduit^non potent dUud effe^ ejuxm ddul ^f^. hiuerfum cA geniM, cum controuerÃd conÃÃit in Â»omme^epiad pendetex feripto^nec uerÃdtur 'm iudidjSt ^Ã plquot; opt er uerbd^e^uic litem fdeiumt. An qui Ãe 'mterÃ^ ^itÃomiciiiÃt.An qui tymnnum 'm mortem compulit, ^yt^nniciid.Anedrm'mdmigoru ueneÃeium-Kesenttn â'lt;'^Ãj{d eUÃdtur^ non idem effe oeddere Ã^quod dit HUI- Non idem oeddere tyrdtinum, quod compeUere di quot;wtem. Hon idem cdrmind, dc mortimer dm podonem, ^^S^ritw timen, dn eoiem nom'me dppelldndd Ãtw, ^qiumdutÃ¨ dÃÃ;ntire nix dudeo 4 Cicerone,qui per ^Â»Itosfecutui dutorei^dicit Ãnitionem effe de eodem,et ^^ *ltero( Semper entm negdnd dliquoi effe nomen,di gfndolbQJ* Â«nduw quid Ãt podm) tdmen in edndemtreis hdbeo ue effe nomen. â¢Æ Ãgt;fcif 1,^4^ iÂ«tf rim Ãc conuenit quÂ£rerc,dn hdhene qu7d fit pod iiulterium 'mÃ¯updndri.Cumhocnegdmut,non ui, tarnen

^â^^!Ã eil Heere quid id uocetur,quid totum ermen in ^â^^^1Â«* poi^TOir.Imfrim qudritur,dn hoc furtum,dn fdcrilcgitifpeaa, Â«n^ qnj^ ÃlÃd^j- non effe fdcrilegium, fed quid nciâ quot;u' fit dicerc quid fit diiud,quo 'm loco utrunqi Ãnien* ^ fn.IiKq,,^ qiuntHr 'm rebut ffede diuerÃs,dn et Â°^^Â° 'm mod o Ãt dppeUdndum,cum res utrd(^ hdbed *f Iu^ name n,ut dntdtorium,uenenum. In omnibus dU ff ut mins generis Utibus quÂ£ritur,dn etidm hoc,qiiid na

4jO M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT. men de quo Ambigitur^utii^ 'm alii re certum cS- S^^^ legium eA rem fienm de templo furripcre. NÂ»Â» C^ priuAtdmf Adulteriumcum Ã¤Uemuxorc domiKit^'

An et in lupiindrU'ryriinntcidium,occideretyrMniiÂ»gt; Am etidm 'm mortem compeUere Æ idro^ on^oyltf/dÃ©^ de quo poÃeA diedm, uelut 'mfirmior ekÃnitio, quii iÂ« hdc qudcritur,dn idem fit huirn rei nomÃ«,quod dlterimt iUotdn pefmde hdbenddfit hitc dtqi illd-EÃ O' tiUsfi* nitionum dinerfiitAi, ut quiddm fintiut, num idem Hun fis uerbis comprehenddtur,ut rhetorice bene dicendifd entidfCr eddem bene 'mueniendi, Cf beneemMicidndiit dicendifectindumuirtutem ordtionis,vdicendiquid

fit offietfiAtq; prouidÃ«dtmi, dnfi. fenfiunon pugiunt, comprehenfitone difJentidnt,Sed de his dij^uUtur, non Utigdtur. Opus eÃ¼ uliquAndofinitione obfiuriorius et ignotionbus uerbis,quid fit cUrigitio.Erit Ct mitrlm notis nom'me uerbis, ut quid fit pcnus,quid litââ^â 02* utebaturâ'*^ â^^^^^^ fffioit,utedm quiddm coniediuri,qgt;gt;^^^^'^*

pater patra Utdti, quiddm legitimis qudfiionihus fubicccr'int. QÃ¿* tus,ut alÃ¼ Ã lufiddm nc pldcuit quidem omnmo fubtdis hiic,etddino^ eftTforte, rem didlediÃ¯corum formdtd conclufio,ut 'm dil^ut^ââÂ°^^ *fonehoM ^â^ ^^^ââ^ P^â^ Argument A uerborum cduiUHrir, ([ndm les agros in/ m ordtoris officia multum dÃ¼dturd momend.Uott tnm uadebant, uAledt 'm fermone tdntum,ut confiridum m limndu fu* â¢aNfov^oVdi hdbedt cum qui reffionfurus ek,cr ueltdcere,udeti* di.quiiure am 'muitum id quod fit contrd,cogdtfdteri,noneddein SfordS' ^^ ^â^^'^'^ ^Â«^ ^ ^â^^P^ utilitds.Pcrfiuulendtmt enimin^^ did cfi,qui etidfi uerbis deumdui efi,tdinen nifi ipfi rd

ORATOR. LIBER Vit 4^1 iKtlftrit, tiicituf dijjentiet. Agesui uero,^UÂ£ tiMA eÃ ^^iu^prtcifitcotnprehen^onii neeeÃitMf Anfi non di xtrojbomo tÃ Anmil rAtionAle^niortAle^non potcro ex poÃtis tot corporif Attimiq; proprietAtih.ldtiui ordtioâ* Â«Â« dufl^Hf! 4 dijs earn, nel 4 mutis difcemcre ? Quid^ ^doincemomodo definiturreseddcm,ut fdoit acet' yoÃ¯CiwidfMHM uui^o wniuerÃosfÃd ldtiore,MYioq; tri* ^dtii^t omnes ordtores plerwÂ«^ fecerwt * R driÃmA fwwi dpHd tos reperictur iUd ex confuctudme pbilofoÂ» p^oram duUA fcruitiu (eÃ enim certeferuitui dd certd Ã wtIa djifmgÃ¨di) id^ fdciendu m Uiris Cic.de Grd. Wftdt t^. Antonius. Ndw eÃ etid periculofum, cÃ¼ Ã ivKo j nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;w Â«erbopt emtum, toU edufd cecidiÃe uidedtur.Opti

ââ$ f/l ilU tnedid uid, qÂ«4 tÃ¼itur Cicero pro Ceemnd, ât i'ftpropoMtur,uerid no ptriclitÃ¨tun Ltenim reÃ§u* fentorts, non ed fold nis eÃ cÃ¿tg dd corpus noÃrumjui perMCHit, fd etidm multi mdior ed lt;piÂ£ periculo wortK miffla ^ forinidme dnimu perterritÃ¼ loco fape, ^ ^f^^ofidtudmouet.Autewm Ãnitionc prxcedit pro bdtio^ut in Vhilippicis Cicero Seruiu Sulpitium occifwm ii AMonio colligit,^ m cldufuld. demum itdÃnitt is ei proÃdo mortem dttuUt,lt;[ui edufd. mortis fuit. NoÂ« ne* Z'^rlw tdmen Intc cÃ¿M^,ut expedit edufd^eÃe freien*

P lt;{Mndo firms comprehendi poterityCr ireui co pkxÂ« Â«erborm finitio, ejft id twin eiegins, tm etidnt Æââ'tgt;Ã,/i modo erit iUd mexpugndhUis. 'Eins certut Â°'^^o ^fi quid fit, dn hoc fit,z!Am hoefcrÃ¨ Idhor rndiof ffid^finitiottÃ« confirmes ^mrcin finitionem dppUcesc

In co c^uid fit,dujplex opus eR.Niitn et nojirA co^fi^ dA eR, cr diuerj'de pdrtis dejiruendÃ¤finitio, idÂ«^ Â»Â» fchold^ubi nobiÃpfisÃngimus contrddiiiioneniiiiiOilÃ nere debemus fines, quAÃes utrint^ effÃ¨ optimi poim^â At in faro prottidendum,num forte fiuperudem^G' âlt;* bil dd edufitm pertinens,dn dmbtgM,dn conirdrii,in co munis fit finitio,quorum nihil nondccidere dgentid fâ'* pi potefl.Vt rcÃ e dutÃ©finidmus, itd fieifi prins iÂ«-^'â' mo confiituermus ^uid uelimus efficereSieenim dccotn modiridduoluntdtemuerbdpoterunt,dt^ntdnotiÃt gt;nbsp;mo exempb, ^uo fit res luddior, non receddimis- QÃ¿ priudtdm pccwnidmdetetnplo fumpitfficrilegijrriii eil,cuÃ¯pd mdnifefid.Quffiio ck,dn huiccrimmiiioiwn quod eÃ¼ in lege,conuenidt. Ergo dmbigitur,dnbocld^ crilegiumfit^Accufdtor,qtiiddcteniplofit[nrrcptipo ^art^por ctvnid,utitur hoe nomme. Keus, ^uid priuitdinfirripitt ftea d iuriP rit,negdt eÃfe fdcriÃ¯cgiu/in,fid furtumfdtetnr'^^^^^ ^JihuLkeamp;o^tdfiniet.Sdcrilegiume^

criminis co* Keus itdfiniet.Sdcrilegium eR [urripere ducÃ¿ttol Â» diAuSth^^^^^â^^â'^'â^Ãâ^â^^^^^^

crilegiÃ» tffe bus euertitur,fi dut fdlfd eii, dut pirum petite- ,. rXaam^â*^tertium,nifift

delocofa nempertincdt.Tdlfdell,fi dicdSiE^uusestinim abfruht^rem *^*^*gt;^ ^^ eqtcus MimdlJcd irrdtiondle.CISP ^^ primtam de tem communecum dUo eÃ¼, definet ejfe propruim-facro loco, fcnf filfam dicit eÃefinitionemdeeufdtoris. AconÃ gi^â ÃcÃ¯ftir- dutem non poteft dicerefdlfdm rei. Ndin turn coin' furripere tU^uid fieri. Dicit pdru plendm^tt^f^^''^

ORATOR. LIBER VH. 455 wÃ®tft,(tÂ«tfx/dcro.MitxwMÂ«Ã® atitem ufm m ipprobando nfeUenioi^ Ãne propriorum, de dt^rcmiumyttonnuÂ» tjuirn etUm etymologu.Ãiut tdmen omnid,Ãcut 'm ca^ ^^^if,confirmÃ¢t aquitdi,nonntmqMm etidm conieÃ¤urd mentit ,^tymologii mMme rm eÃt Qjdd enim efi aU ^ tnmultufynifi perturbatio tanta,ut maior timar oria turtVnie etidm nomen duÂ£ium eH tumult ut. Cired pro princ iifiÃ¨rentid magna fubtilitas^ut civm cluitriturtan iddidut, lt;piem lexfiruirc doneefioluerit iubet, ferims Addidi.qui f^gt; Altera pars finit itatSeruus eh,(iui ell iure 'm ferui* ^s ahVnum txtf â¦ Alters, qui (^fieruitute eÃ¼ eo iure t^to feruus^aut creditoribus W Â«iqÂ«; dixerunt, epti feruitutem feruit. Qjttfinitio tu â'*^ ***quot; 'iwmfi coHpjtt istpio^nifi tarnen proprijs er different i tdiRat ali' ^'^^iintietur,mdnisell.Dicetenim aduerfiariut feruit ^âÂ® ^â^â'mferuitutem,duteo iuretjuoferuum, Videdmut Ji^ ptopria,diffÃ¨ren(ia^ liberorivm,(ptÂ£ Ubrolt;ptmto 'Wtw iÂ« tranfitu attigera-Seruus cum manumittitur U

^s'muite domwo liber tatem non c o feepie tur,addidlus AddiflÃ¯. foluendo citra uolimtdtem dom'mi confeeptetur.Ad fier* ^Ãd non ^nt nulla if x pertmet, addidlut Icgem habet â¦ Â¥roprilt;c funt fus uo-â¢^,qitÃ³ Â«rmo bxbet ni ft liber,pranomen, nomen,coa Ãquot;^%Â®âb^ ^â'omfnjtriijuMijbdfcft hac addi^ut^ 'Excuffo eptidfit, muncribus fâ'Â°P' pfrafti e^ cpiÂ£fiio,an hocfit.lden'mt dgimut,ut prohibit! fer r^^'^jenofiraconueniensfinitio. PotendÃima autem f Â« 'm fa qiulit^jitÂ« amor,dn 'm fania. Ã¼uc perfmebunt Plt;'oidtiones, quoi Cicero dicit propriat ejfe finitiones, ^^ ^i^tcedendbttttconfetptentibuf, aditin(lis,repugnAit

454 MÂ« ÃAB. QVINTÂ» INSTIL' tibutfCinfii, effvilK, fimilibut, de quorum drgi''^^' rum ndtun didum ed^ ^reuiter dutem j^ro CcdlX^^ Æ ccromitid^cMfAt,cffrdA,Mecedciuid,coufrqiiet^â^^^'^^ pifXM ed.Ciuid igiturffugicbMt propter met^Oi^ metuebautiuim uidelicet.FotrÃis igitur principe w^i re^cum extreme conceddtÃ»tSed fimiUtudine qw^ t^r cd.cmÂ£ ^^ ^ ^^ÃÂ® dppclldtur. Cd MJ otio non tipped* Amitoriumbitur^Sed excontrdrio drgumentdducuntur,utÃqgt;^ ^ f\Tj (u. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fatur^dn dmdtorium, uenenu Ãt, nec tie,quid uenenuÂ«,

dmdtorium non jit,i.Uud diterum genut, quoÃt tminÃ* Ãim ddoleÃeutibui meK ( uicos enim Ãemper dioleÃenf tes putdbo) hic quot^ Ãthe controuerÃdUtdr exempleÂ» iiMcnes,qui conuiuere folebdnt,conÃituerumt ut m if* tore candrent.VniuSjqui coenx deÃterdt, nomen tumit* loque extruxerdnt,inÃcripÃerunt.Pdtcr eins *trdnlin^ rmd peregrindtionecum dd littus idem dppfdilf^^^^ nomine fuÃpendit fe.Dicutur hi eduÃd mortis Ãâ!f^' ^'/ Ãnitio ed dccuÃdtoris:Per quemÃddum eÃ ut quit ptstt rit,cduÃd mortis ed. Kem ed,qui Ãecit quidÃelegt;^^â ^â^ quad perire hom'mi necejÃe effet. Kemotd Ãnitione^f* euÃdtori Ãdt eÃ dicere:CduÃd mortis fuiÃis.Per nos enim ddum ek,ut homo periret,quid niÃ uos Slnif^r^f uiueret,ContrÂ£,non Ãdtim per qucmÃddum cH ut qua periret,is ddmudri dÃ©bet, Ut deeuÃdtor, teÃis, idiett set cdpitdUs^Nec undecum^ eduÃd fluxit, ibi eulpdeWÃ quis proÃedione ÃudÃerit, dutdd dmicumdcccfÃerittrdS mdre,ct is nduÃ-dgio perierit.Ad coendm muitdrit,et H (ruditdte iHic contrddd deeeÃÃerit Â» NÂ« Ãuerit in di^i*

mortis Jblum ddolefcÃ«tium failum, fed credulity fenis, (y iÂ« dolors ferundo wÃrmitM, deniq; Ã fortior fui/^ (a,tut prudeiKior,uiucrct.liec muli mem efecerwnt^et ilk potuil Â«ci ex loco tumuli, uel ex opÃ©rÃ© tumultuirio Ãj^iari non effe monumentÃ¼, Qjd ergo pu^iri deletie, in qwbiÂ« omnii fwnt homicid Â£,prÂ£ter mtinum .^EÃ w te rim certaÃnitio,de qui mier utntne^ petrtem conuenit, Finkio ^^^e ut Cicero dicifMaieÃi^ dl iKperio^^tq; in omni popu li Rowioii dignitittc.QuÂ£ritur timen,an maieft^Ã¿ minu tiÃt,utmciu[a Corneltj qu^Ãtum eÃ¼,Scd bic etiam Æ* ntduMderipoteSlÃnitiuie, tarnen quiadeÃnitione non eniligdurdudieatio cR qunlitae, atq^ ad earn potiui fia turn reduceHtj^^^j cuius fÃ³rtei^quadam Uenimus memio fquidem tiemfid O' erat or dine proximuf locus,

L st iutem quaUtas alia de fummo genere, at que ea A^quidemnon Ãmplex.t^am er qualis Ãt cuiuÃe^ rei Â«Kturd^ft qui forma quaritur,an immortaUs anima,an deus,ey de magnitudme ac numero,quan

tusfol,et in imut mwndus.Q_uÂ£ omnia quidem conieHu , ''^^^Higuntur,quÂ£^ionem tarnen balemineo,qMlii

jwt.^tc Â©â¢ mfueÃorijs aliquindo tra{larifoleM,ut Ã Â«Â«Â£1 ^*)w delÃfrr t/n 'Zritanniam impugnet, quee Ãt oceaÂ» â1 â'â*tÂ«ri,lt;(n 'Rritar.niawfula (nam turn ignoralatur') quanti in f^ ^^^^^ ^ ^^^ numÃ©ro militu aggredienda, m tof'p iwÃrendum Ãt^EidequAlitatifucceduntfacitnoâ '^â^^'^Â°gt;'ficiÃ¨da,'ippctenda, uitanda,quÂ£ infuaforias 5*quot; f Â»fixime eadut^Ãd im controuerfijs quog; [untÃ-e

^uentidJiAc fold dijfvrentii, quid iÃ¼ic de futuriftfâ^ ^ fdiiii dgitur. Item demon fr dtiuÂ£ pdrtis omniH'^^f ^ hoc Ãdtu,fdilumc[fe confiÃ¢t,qtule fit fdilum jH^'*âââ' i'K e^t omnis dut de pnemio^dut de pccnd,dut ie ^â^â' tdte.lgiturprmum genui cdufie^dutfimpleXyi'^^^'â''^ pdrdtiMtm. iÃ¼ic quid jequÃ¯im,hic quid tequim *Æ ^0 gquifilmum fitexcutitur. Cum depandiudidiM^^f* pdrte eiui qui edufdm dicit,dut defenfio efi crimwUi

VtgdÃ¤ die.) immmutio,dutcxcufdtio^dututquiddmputdn(ieffe^ Ã¯Ã¼sTheto^quot; t^Â°' idgt;efenfiolongepotentifiimdeR,quAipfi^P^'''f^ non putat quod ohijcitur,dicmui honefiÃ¼ ejfe, Abdiedturdli^gt; dquot; berÃ©'^au7 ^â^^'^ muito pdtre miUtdritfhonorcs petierit,itxorÃ« ^^ poffequote xerit,tuemurÃ¼uodfccimut,PdrteinhMciiocdÂ»f^^â'* Â«Sonraâ*^^ ^dgordi klt;^â o.vTi'KHq.ip, dd int elle dl UW H nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^â'

rcntes:ldtinead uerbum trdnfldtdm inuentOfdeii^ peUdtur.Sed enim de re fold qu^fiio, ii^^f^^^â^^ iufium omne contineturndturd,uel confiitiil'â'â[^â rd, quÂ£ fecunduin cuiufq; rei dignitdtem: W'^ f r^ tdi,fides,continentid,cr tdlid. Adijdunt d f^'^^ .

peruerfum pur,uerum id non temere intuenduw contrduim,Gr tdlid nihilhdbent dduerfiM or fecit iniufie,^' non quonium res pires fi^^j^ . ^ eH iufium quod dnteeeÃit. lÃd utrinq iuf^â ^^ ^ ? eddem coditio,dc forfitdn ne fint quidem pir^^â'l*^^, ^ .^ pirtefwnt diÃunilid. Confiitutio eR m lege,fierce,lt;'^ . cdto.pddlo.Altermn eR defenfionis genus,in qt^oP ^^ per fe mproldlilc, d/fumptis extrinfeeuf n*^* P ^ j Murfid weit 'n^oo^wrÃiii gt;nbsp;Litini boe qto^ quot;^

Â«frioHi tnnsferut, AffumptiMcnim dicitur edufaAn '{^ogenereforti^imZcÃ¼ficrmcncd.iipLfdai tuemur, ,, ^iwlK fft defenfio Oreftis,ordtio ^Ã¢ilonK, Ã vrtyK7gt;.H ^^^â^ *â*â* MÂ« iiciturytjuid omnis nojird defenpo conjidt eins deen fÃ¼ione^t^uiui/ndiedtur.Occifus eÃ,led IdtrotexcxcAtus, [tdwptor.Eft er iÃ¼d excdufis fdlH duÃ¼ddefenÃio pri ori cotÂ»fr4rid,in qua Â«ftj; fditujm ipfnm per fe, ut w db* folut(tqÂ«tfÃ(ofjc defenditur,nelt;j^ ex contrdriofd(io,fed ex d^ui, utHitdte Rnpwb. dut bommum multorum,dut etiimipÃtu dduerfdrij^nonnivn^uAm cy noÃrd,fi modo id trit quod fdeere noÃrd edufdfas fit, r^uod fub extrdÂ« Keo iemfitore ^ legibus dgente prodeÃi nonnutjudm pateft,;Â« iomefiicis difeeptdtionibus poteÃ^Ndm et fi* ^^ P^ter in iudicio dbdicdtionis,et mdritus uxori,fi ma ld tnUdtionis dccufidtitur,et pdtrifibus fi demÃªtiit cdu fitrit^ non muerecunde dieet multum [m mterfuiffe^M t^do tdmi mcomodduitdntis melior 5 commodd petentis fÃ edufdjijHitgj jimilid etid m tterd reru eptitfiione trd* ftiWur.Ndtti qÂ«lt; Â«1 fixons dbdicdtorujbiec 'm foro exd procÃfukÃ¯ bfrfa4toru4p4yf^({,â^j ^ iQU^ dpud confuiesrepe Nam confu' tÃªii ;Â« ntio eftj q^j^ mie mdU trdÃ©ldtionis,bic rei uxo ^^ |Jâ,2quot;^, TifjCiHH t^utritur utrius culpd diuortiÃ¼fddwm fit: tjUÂ£ bus cogno' itlic dtme;Kigt;j i;ic petendi curdtoris. Subidcet utilitdti [â^ââPâ ftwm au itfinfiofi peius dlilt;iuid futurumfuit.^dm 'm teftatur ex* fop^Ã¯jtione mftoriMÂ« boni loeu obfmet kuius, Â«t fi MÃ hÃ¯redationÃª ^âr^h^'^ ^'*â*^â^^'*âââ^^^ ^^f^n^^^it^l^od periturus Â«ntSuko^

Mion effet,fiserit exercitus Komdnus.iloc ge* judicium. WÂ« Â«VT'S0!a'(Â§ gnee nommdturtebpdrdtimim nofiri uo niminU^

458 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT.' cdnt.Hgccircd defenfioncm fdHi, ^Â»r Ã net^f^K^ ipfdm, nc^ dihiiitis Mxilijs idbitur, proxwÂ» 1Â« quot;^ 'â eiU'jm trMS ferre crimen,fi pofumus. IcifoÃ§ fWââ'â'*ââ l^os qui inm fcripti funt Ãdtilt;s,wfd eÃ¯l ediere tri^* Interdum ergo culpd in hominein rcligitur, ut fiGti^^ chui reus fader is liuniintini,cuius metu leges popâ'^* res tuliffe in tribundtu uidetdr,fnijf m fc db inperito* refuo dicer et^ Interim deriuitur in rem, ut fis is ^'Â« f^* Ãdmentoquid iuffusnonfccerit,dicdtperlcgesiill^'^* non potuiffe,hoe /xirxsacrrip dicunt.Exclufis c^uoij; bit excufdtio fupere^^ed e^Mt ignord'Uig,utfiquisf^Ã¿' tiuo Ãigmdtd fcripferit, eo^ ingenuo iuiicdto,negetÃ liberum eom feijfeidut neeeÃitdtis, ut cum miles di com medtus dient non dffuit, dicit fe fluminibiu interduÃo/m, ; dut udletudme. Fortund quoc^ fepe fubfituituredpt-^ Ã¯donunq mdle feeiÃe nos, fed bono dnimo Hdmâ^- ^^'^ uf^ rei multd et mdnifcjU exempld funt. lidrco non eji eorum neeeÃdridexpoÃtio. SedomnidqufÃoptdicri* ptd funt,deerunt,uidÃ«du/nt dn minui culpt pofittOic^ iÃ¼e qui d quibufdd diciturÃeri Ãdtus cum Ãt dut pana,dut honoris,ex qiuiitdtefd^ tuitur. EÃque nabis fubhoe eÃe Ãdtu uidetiirgt;fi^ âââ^ quoquequa dinumerum refertur dGrsed gt;nbsp;NXtÂ«C7 r^oioTHTce-jty Tsao'oTfiTCi dicwit,nosutrivnqi^^^^â^'^^ pelUtione copleHimur. Vltmd eÃ¼ deprecdtio,qdoi g' nus edufg pleriq^ negsrunt in iudicium unquirn uemregt; 0Â« jÂ» Cicero quoq; pro Q^dgdriodiem teÃdriuiiddt CM iicitiCtÃ¼tpu Cf fur egimidtdf equidemtecu/nhi'dii

te tn fora tenuit rdtio bonorum tuorum. Certe unq hoc Moio,ignofciteiudices,erriHuit,lip[u4 e^t, non pM^t, fi ims^Mm pofibic, (^ atcru. in fendtu nero, er dpui populo,er ipui prmcipem,^ ubicun([ue iuris clemÃ« tu eH^hibet locim deprecutio. In epu plurtmwn lulcnt tx ipfo epti reut c{l,hiec tru m uitd priecederc,Ã inno'i emsfi bene merit us,Ã fpes 'm futurum 'innocenter uiÃ¼u ri,Q- in aliquo u[u fiituri.PrÂ£tereA Ã ucl dlijs 'mcommo dis uelprtfnti perieulo, uel pxnitentii uidedtur fdtis plt;xntirjmdedijfe,p.xtrd,nobilitds,dignitM,prop'mtpiit Ãmici.ln co timen qui cognofcit,plur'mium ponendum, Ãt lius etm miÃricordis potins, quÃm reprehenÃo di ffo lÂ«ti conÃeuturd e^. Verum er m iudietjs, etidmÃ non toto gencff edufe,timen ex pirte migm bic locus ftpe tnHituri^dm er diuifiofi-equens cft, etidmÃ fecijfet, tgno^eniimfuilfe. Id^j Â»t eduÃs dubiÃ¶s fÂ£pe prxiulu* tt,er epdogi omnes m eddÃª ferÃ¨ mdterid uerfdri folent. Sfd nomiuÂ«^ etidm reus bic totius fummum conÃituit,Ã txbfredit;)Â« ^Æ(. Ãn.j^^ pister teÃdtus fuerit elogio, pfopteredquodismeretrieÃ«dmduerit. Ndm omnis bic qitefÃ¯io,in buc deliÃ¼o pdter debuerit ignofcre/t CfH t'Muiri tribuere debednt uenidm. Sfd etidm 'm formus ^â .nmpxnirii[imt dÃ¼ionesjtiaufim pdrt'tmur,dn tunmii^i Ãt pcend,dn exigi debedt.ld dutem quad iÃ¼i ui dcnHit,MtrÂ«)n eh, reum d iudicibia boe defenfionis ma doliberdnnon poffer Tiepriemijs dutem quirwntur iuo,in uiloft dignus qui petit, dn tdnto, ex duobus Udgt; t(Ã¯igt;Ã¿ti9r,ex piuribus qw digniÃmus.Ciwrum tretÂ«

ihitut ex ipfo ineritorum genere ducMitur. Et intn^* mnr non rem tantum, Ãue aUegindÃ¤ffiue eomftn^^^ eritjed perform quocjj.Ã¼am (^ multuim tntere^ffâ* ttumiiiuenit occidcrit,an [enex, uir an fceinint,i^^^ dn conitmUuitEÃ er ad locum multipUciter^m âi^^^^^^ tyrannis affueta, an libera femper, 'm aree an domi,ty ^uomodofadum Ãt^ferro an ueneno, er qwo temport) beUo an pace,an cum depoÃturm effet earn potejlattm, an cÃ¼ ali(^d noui feeler is aufurus. Habetur i meritis Ã¿i flibertas tia,periculu(iuoq;ac difficultÃ©. S'miUtcr bberalitat

4 quo profeda Ãt referte Ham 'm paupere gritior^ diuite,dante beneficium ^Â«iw reddente,patre (juim of boAtem cpiam rem dcderit,cr ^uo temport,cr ^Â«0 lt;^â mo,id efi num m aUt^uarnj^Ã« fuamffmilittr alia.Etiito i^torum et totalitÃ© maxma oratoris recipit opera, lt;1^^ lt;Â® oratorum que partem plurimum efi 'mgenio loei,nee uf^oMunM efficina. nbsp;nbsp;^fi^Hnf ualent. Ham coniedura extr'mfeem flt;â^ * * dudÃ© frequenter probationes habet, er arg^o^^^ ^^ materia fumit,ut quale quiclt;^ uideatureloqaentuoput ed, bic rÃ©gnÃ¢t, bic imperat, bic fola uincit. liuicpââf^t fubiungit Virginie caufat abdicationis, dementifiquot;â^* le tradationis,orbarum nuptiÃ© 'mdicentiiun -^^ ^ iudicium ferÃ¨fic accidit,muenti^ funt qui bÃ¼ wHtritÃ³ officiorum uocarent.Sed alias quoq; nonnundfUn It^s bÂ£,recipiwnt flatus.HM et coniedura ed aliqu^^^ pleriflt;p horum,cum fe uel non fitciffe, uel boM mente je ciffe contendunt.Cuius generis exempt funt multi.Ã ^Mid fit dementia, ac maU traditio finitur. N(lt;/Â« iuft^

tgÂ« fkrurt^ qwf Ãionw priccwrerc folent, Cr ex qM Iwmm/js non fin finutim. Quad tarnen fiHo defien *^fÂ°â â* di non poteritfiurenitetur, Z}quot; ^Â«ot O' quibiÂ« caufis ab Heinnon^ceatyOr Ã¯nc^ugcrminamaliS tradationis 4ftio detuTyi^y cui aceufare dcmentiie nonpermittatur.

AbdiedtionR jorme fiunt dux, alters ermine perfedi, ^'^^'^*'Â°â'Â® ut fi Ãdieewr raptor, ddwltfr: altera imperfiedi uelut pendentk, er 4dbMc in conditione pofiti^ qiulrs [uM m q^ibuj Â«bdiedtur filiM qui non par eat patri. iHd femper ijjicrdm dbdiedntk dftionÃ© bdbet, immuMbite eft fuim quod fuftum eft j b^c ex purte bUndd, cz Juddenti fi' milmd. MdUMkfnimpdtcrcorrigcrfjqdbdtcdre.At . ^^ pro Ãlijs in utro^ genere fiummififa,e^ adfalififiadendu, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'^

Â«ompofuA quo dijjeniuros fiio^({M kbf Â»ter putris Jto i.aramleiunt,i:[uodnonaufimdicerenun^efj'e faden' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;s-

dum (poteÃ dim mdterid incidcre, qÂ»Â« boe exigdt) * Citcrum uidendum cft, quoties dliter agi poteÃ, fed. de

i diedtionum uftionibiM funt mdU trdftdtionis dftioncs Â« i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ndmo'ipfâxijjitent eundemin dccuptionibus moderd*

r tionfm.DcmtntiÂ« quoq; indicid^dut propter id quod fd Dj^ientK, ^ 1 ftumeft,4utpropteridquodddbucÃeriuclÂ»oÃcripo nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

, tuuquictudineldpp miferedturfm eo ucro^cutusliberd **J*Ã¯utioeft,diurogcter fuddedt,er nouipme deinen-

( ââ'â'''^Â«ioniqaerdtur objbdre, nonmores, quos quunto **^1.Â« WpifXtcritumliWddueÃ¯itjtAntofdcilius probubit

44t M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT-worio effemutMoSt P^eut (^uotiesaiufdpdtictur,^^^ bit: effc in defmÃone madenUus, ^dfere iri, (^ concitdtio furori funt ÃmiUd.Omnibuf his ^od rei non Ãemper deÃenÃtone Ãddijed exeuÃddon^^ nenidÃ-cqurntcr utuwur. E/Ã® enim domeÃied diÃespti' tio^qud er femel peccdffc^et per errorÃ«,ZT i(gt;*igt;^ 3 ââ^â^ cidtur,dbfolittioni nonnunq fujÃeit. Sed dUd ^M^ lt;ââ'' Iniuriarum tlt;^ controuerÃdrum generd in (^udUidtem eddimt. IWÂ«' ââ¢^âo* ridrnm, e^ndmjndm enim rem aU^ndndo feeiÃfe nein) plerun^i tdmen h^c ddHofdUo dtq; dnirno contiwtuf^ ^c5Rh^^^Â° ^â^^^^^t^f^toreconÃituendo,guÂ£iudiciddiumdtionesÂ«9 do. edntur- (in f^uo generc Cicero lt;iuidem,(Ã¿Ã»mdnddntibd^^ fpefladfief Ãoeiji Verrem dccuÃdbdt,hdc uÃm eil diuiÃone'i-i-Ãf^^* a maxime

aut quid ^â^âf^gt; i-deiuo minime uelit is^epm dccuÃdtur. Vre^f Ãma tdmen ha Ãnnt quaÃiones, liter mdiorcs edtiÃd^ bi' bedt, uier plus induÃria, dut uiriumÃt dUdturusi^'^'^' Tutdf cuÃdndum,uteridÃdemelioreÃdÂ£lurus. Tutd^P^^^^' â âÂ°â red,inquoiitdiciofoletquari.,dndlidderc(juifiti(lt;^^^' citlis cognoÃcioportedt. Anfidem praÃdrc debatMi' MaiÃ¦ gcHf turn,non etidmconÃlium er euentus.CuiÃmile e^ ââ^ curationis.^ geÃa procurdtionis in fora negotiorum geÃoruotf nsm geftorum. ^ mdnddti dHio eÃ.Prater hacfinguntur inÃebob^Z^ Wadat i adi. Ãeripti mdleficij,in quibus dut hoc quaritur,^ Iet^^ fic^T* 'quot;^*'' fit,dut hoe dn mdleficiumÃt, rdro utruni];. t^ik gt^^ legdtionis dpud Gracos,zr' ueris cdufisfre^uens,ubi itt ris loco epiariÃolet,dn omnino dUter dgere, i^uim nâdtt' ditumfit Hccdt^zir Â»jnouf^ fit Icgitm, ijuwisw ibÂ« **

ORATOR. LIBER VII. 445 ren'intiindo^u tt^ ut in hoc,ciui teÃmonium in Verrem dixent poÃ perlÃ¢t dm Icgdtionem.Plurmu tarnen c^i in eoji^udlefit fd^:nm Keip. lefe^ nine mouentur quidcin fnidc iurii ciuiÃ¼dtionesjtpiid fit 'Kemp.lxdcre,^^ Ufi^ ntne^n profucrit,^ db ipfo^dn propter ipfium Ufd fitÂ» infiSto tdmen plurimnm inch, ingrdti quoei;, in ejuo Rentre queritur,dn is cum ciuo dgitur dcceperit benefit ^^^ntytpfodrdronegdndum eÃ»t ingrdtus efienim qwi Â«e glt;tt (jttdfuudccepcritjdn reddident^dn protinus cui non feddiderit,ingrdtusfit,dn potuerit reddere^dn id ijuoi fxigtbdtur,debuerit,cpio dnimo fit. Smpliciores iUx in w^i repudij^fub ^ud Uge can trouer fiÂ£ iUud propria hd lent,quod Ã pdrte deeufimtis defenfio eft,e^ defendetis i^f^ifitio. Frittered cum ejuis rdtionem mortis in fiendtit âreiUtj ubi and ^uxfiio efi iuris, dn is demu prolnibÃ¨dus fijt,iiuimon unit, ut fie Ugum dHtonibits fiubtrdbdt.Cxte nepMlitdtis.Vinguntur cy tefidmentd,in quibus de fiold ^'^erituruolunidtCyUt incontrouerfiid,c{udmfiuprd ex'^^ f Â®fÂ»i gt;nbsp;m qÂ«i do pdrte pdtrmonij (pidrtd quS plt;lt;tfr db gniÃmo exfiUjs reUquerdtfontendunt pbilofiopbus,me dicus,orator. Qgod item iccidit, fit orbd nuptids indi' ant pires grddu,et fit inter propinepios de idoneo epm wtur. Sod omnes nee mihi per ficelai mdterids in ato eÃ. Ã¯ingifnim ddhuc posant,nee cotes fiant aru eptefiioes, ^'^^^pofittionibus mut at tir. Hoe tinta admiror, blduiÃ¼y Ã¯MWÃ® upud me merito fiummd dutoritis, eu drtem fichaiÂ» tlt;tÂ»tumcomponcrct ,tdm dngufie mdteridm c^UdUtitis ttrnij/itififie, Qjtmtitds tpaoiji {ut dixi plerunejfi) etamfi

444 M. FAB. Q^INT, INSTIT. non fetnpcr,tlt;imen plerun(^- eidemfubiicet/cu moii (jf^ feu nummSed modus dUqueutdo conftdt itfimiAMit^Ã a^qudnidfit culpa,quAnttimuf beneficium', dbquii^^'^ re,cum id m controuerfidm uenit,qud quis lege punien' dus,uel honor andus fit.Stuprdtor dn deeÃ« miliA i^^ ^^ bedt,quÂ£ poend huic crimini cofiitutd e^k,dn quidfinf^^ n^Ã¯rrationb^ ^â^^'^ f^*!^^^^^^^^^^^^ pt*gt;fMi tAnq cAUjA mortis^ QBâ^ ' in genere fdÃ¯lunturyquiitddicunt,tdn^ interduAsltg,^i quÂ£rdtur,iiAm de decern milibus nuUd controuerfiA eil, quÂ£ nee petuntur. indicium redditur, dn reus cAufifâ1 mortis, In conieHurdm quoque cddem jfieciefcddil^^ perpetuÃ³,dn qumquenndUfit exilio multiÃ¼tdus, w atro uerftdm uenerit,num prudens clt;tdcm ebmifirit, q^f^^* tur. lÃ¼d quolt;^ qua ex numero ducitur, pendet exiAtf, dn Thrdfybulo trigmtd pramid debeAntur, Gâ ^^^ fures pecunidm dbjiulerunt,fepdrdtim quddÃ¯AplA qA^I^ dn duplum debedt.Sed hiefdÃ¤um quoq^ tfiimAtAi',^ ^^ men iusipfum pendet ex qudUtdte,

De Adionis quafiione. CAPâ ^^â QVI neq^fecijfe fe negdbit, ne^ lt;diui ^Sl^â^'â^ fecerit,dieet,ne^ fdÃ¼u defendet, iureconfiftdt.lnquoplerunq;d{lionisâl â fiio, qua non femper eddern eÃ¢, ut quidam pAt^^*^ . * tldm or indicium Antecedit,qudlid funt Pratur^ ^â*^âÂ° Prafcriptio fit confilid,cum de iure deeufdtoris dmbigitur, et nis contenu frequentiÃime iudicijs uerfdtur. PÃ enm duplex ^'^' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;difeeptationis conditio,quod dut mtentio,dut pr^

Jlitumficerent, temq eu non ijfdem omnihut., quibut * Â«ââÂ«Â«ilâ* eÂ£terieleges,quÂ£Ãionibut cont'meretur, Cu ex prÃ¼fen ptione lis pendet,de ipÃ re quÂ£ri no eft neeeÃe, ignomi ^ j^^^ ^oft pAtriftlius prÂ£ftribit,de co folo iudiCAtio ell An ^((liti erupties timen poterimut,effÃ®ciendumell,ut dÃ© ft quo(^ bene fentidt. Sic enm iuri noftro libÃ«tiut Mul gebit,ut m paffeftionibut,quÂ£ ex 'mterdiilisftunts i' iquot; fpÃ³fiohib* iwâÂ»)i non proprietdtis eH quieftioffed tantum poffeÃio f^is,timen nonfolum poffediffenosffedetidm noftrupof ftiiffe doccre oportebit, ScdfrequÃ«tiut etidm qufritur deintentione.'Vir fortis optet qua uolet,nego iUiddn^ Hum qMicqutd optiuerit,non habeo prlt;tfcriptionem,fei twn uoluntite cotrduerhd prÂ£fcriptionit modo uton iNWro^ MtÃ« genere ftatut idem fit, PorrÃ lex omnis, Legis poM AM tribuit,dut ddimit,dut punit,dut iuhet,dut uetdt,dut Â®â* permittit. Lite hdbet,dut propter fcipfdm,dut propter ^erim queftionem,dut in feripto, dut in uoluntdte, Ã¯n f'npto.dHt dpertumcll,dutobfcurum, dut dmbiguwn^ QuoH de legibus.dico, idem Accipi uolo de teftdmentis, fAllitjjlipuldtionibuSyOmni denies feripto, idÃ« de uoce.

Et quonidm quAtuor huiut generis qujiftiones,uel ft^ui fiemus, fmgulospercurrdm.

De Statu ex feripto or uoluntdtet CAP. VUÂ« SCriptf er Holunt^tw ,frequÃ«tiftimA inter confultoi '[ut^io eH, er p4rs mdgnd cotrouerftie iuris hine P^âHft,qÂ«o mânÃ®(Â« id m fehoUs Accidere mirum ell, ubi ^^tiinexinduftridfmgiturt'E.iut genus wnum eSl,in ^ud tiâicferipto,e2â uoluntAte e^uaerituTi Id tu detidit cuni

eÃ m lage aUqui olgt;fcuritai,Z7 in ea^dut uterq^ [tUtit W terpretdtionem conÃrtndt,dutdduerftri][ulucrtit,v^ hie*. Vur c^uddruplumfoludt, duo furripucrutit pdriUI dccrni mÃ¼Ud^petuntur ab utro^; quddrdgend,iÃ¼t pojiu-IdutjUt uicend cÃ¶ftrdUt.Kam er ddor dicit,hoc e^c ijUd druplum ^uod pctdt,O' rd boe c^uod offerant. Voluta f^uoi^ utrin^i defenditur^dut eu de dltero intcÃ¼cduccr turn cd,de dltero dubium.Ex meretricendtut,ne condo netur-. Quefiiiumhdbebdtjpro^dreeoepit. Probibetur ddolcfcens condonet Nrfw de dut filio^^ui anlepdrttm tneretrix fuit certum ed, dn cddem buitu edufdfit,iu' Hum ed,quid ex hdc ndtui^er blt;Â£c meretrix ed- Solct et illud cjurri, ^uo referdtur qd' fcriptu ed,bis deeddÃ« re itt*n nefitddio, ided,hocbiiddddorem,dndddClioncni.

Use ex iure obfcuro Â» AÃterum genus ef ex niddf/H, quod qui folum uiderunt,hunc flatum pldni,crgt;^^ââ'â^â^* tit dppeÃ¯lduerund IÂ» hoe dlterd pars feripto nitit^'^j^^' terd uoluntdte.Scd contrd fcriptum tribut general curritur. Vnum ed, in quo id ferudrifemper non pofe ex ipfo pdtet.Liberi pdrentcsdldnt,dutuincidntur't^^'[ enim dUigdbitur infant, nine erit dd dlid trdnfM^^ uifto,num qui-quis non dluerit,nu bic,Propterbo(p^^ ponunt quiddm tale genus controuerftdrum,in lt;{^Â° âY turn drgumentum efl,quod ex lege ipfd peti pofit,p de eo tantum,de quo lis ef,quÂ£rcndÃ¯Ã¯ ft. Peregrinutf 'â* rum dfendcrit,cdpitepunidtur. Cumbofesmurudfen dilfcnt,pcregr'mut eos depulit,petitur dd fuppheinin. Hon erunt bic IcparatÂ£ qurfiones, dn qui/quis, on biC)

quÃ¹ ttKlIÂ»Â») potf/Ã® ajjirri drgunKntumeontrd feriptum vthmentius to ijuod 'm lite eÃ^led hoc tMtum^dn ne fit mnde (guident ciuitdtii cduÃ.Ergo O' ic^Mtdte^o uo* luntite pugnindum.Vieri tarnen potefl,ut ex dlijs kgi^ im txÃ¨pld ducdmiUy per ejua dppiredt femper ftari feri f to noÂ« pojje,ut Cicero pro Ceemna fecit. TcrtiÃ¼,cu 'm ipfii ueriie legis reptrimm dli(iuid,per lt;^uod probenmt dimJ Ifgum Utorl uoÃ¯uiUe,ut 'm hdc controuerÃdtQui Atolle eu ferro deprehenfut fuerit^dUigetur^Cum anulo f^rno 'muentum migijlrdtusdUigduit, Hic quid eil uct tÂ«m in Ifgf, deprehenfut,fdtif etidm figniÃeatu uidetur Kon confmeri kge, niÃ noxium ferrum^ Sed qui uolun^ fdte nit(tur,fcriptum quotits poterit mÃrmdredeMit-, ^âi feriptum tutlitur^ddiuudre fe etidm uoluntdte ten' tdbit.in teÃimentis 0 iUd dccidunt, M uoluntds manife ^^ft,feriptum nihil Ãt,ut 'm iudicio CuridnoÃn quo na td L. Crifi (^ ScieuolÂ£ fuit contention SubÃitutM hx-^ *'$ fdit, f pofhumui ante tutclxfuÂ£ dnnos deeeÃiffetn Nonrftn4tâj,propmqMibondÃbiuendiedbant. CiuU duiitdYct,qut^t ed uoluntM fuiffet teÃantis^ut it Â«5 n^a fltohdnseffet,qui martuo^fedhocnon fcripferdt. i-ka 1^ ^Â«og; quod huic contrdriu eÃ¼^ccidit nuper^ ut effet fâ^t^tÃ¯q^quoddppdreret fcriptore noluiffe,qui feÃertiu âââJlt;âgt;Â»Â«MiH qMM^. milid iegduerdt, cu emÃ¨ddret teÃamen , ittyfuilm^ ;â-ert'ijsnum'is,drgenti pondo po fuit,qumlt;^ rtnunferut. Appdruit tdrnÃ« qumq} pondo dari ua

'm drgento legato modus 0 'mauditas erdtj lt;^ tncndibilit, Sub hoc Ãitu gcneÃ¯nles funt qmÃioesj

448 M, FAB. QVINT. INSTlT-fcripto dn uoluntdte Ãdndum Ãt, clUie fucrit Ãrit^*^^ uoluntdfytrdiidtui omÃ®tes (ladUtdtisdn coicÃ©inrifi^^^^' bus fdtis dielum drbitror.

DeContrdrijsLegiiuSt CAP. ^.â Antmomia T)Â®-Â°*^â*â ^^ ^^legibuscontrdrijs diecre,^gt;lt;â^â''^ Â«JUS fit expli i ter omnes drtium Ãriptores conÃdt in MtinoM^ annoUMn * â^â'â^ ââ^ feripti CT ucluntdtis Ãdtus, ne^ iir,merits,â'Ã Pandeftas. cum lex legi obÃet, utrintÃ contrd feriptum dieitur,C^ quicÃio eÃ deuoluntÃ¤tczln Mrdq^ id dmlgt;igitur,dnutilt;^^ iÃ¼d lege Ãt utendum.Qmnibus duti mditifeÃunt eÃ,nunl ^If^ legem legi cotrdridm iure ipfo, quidÃ diuerfumâ^ effet,altcrum dltero dbrogdretur,Ãd edS aÃt eoUidi (7 euentu.Colliduntur dutem,dut pdres inter fe,utÃepttâgt; tyrdnnicidie,cr uirifort is compdrentur,utrilt;^ ddld qd uclit petendi poteÃdtc.liic meritorÃ¼, temport!) ^^^''ââl coUdtio eli,Aut fecum ipfde,ut duorumfortiiiiÂ»''^'*'â^

duarmn tyrdnniciddrum, rdptdrum ,inquibusnon^^y^lr raptarum alid quÂ£Ãio,q teporis,utrd priorÃt,dut qutdÃ¤t^^/^^ iuÃiorÃt petitio. Diuerfe quoc^ leges conffÃ¿tnt,^r

aut duÂ» ^â^â'^* * ^quot;^f'^Â» ^^^ ^^^^ eitrd dduerÃm legetâ trd dici poÃit,ut 'm hde controuerfidMdgijlrttftt^t^ ^Ã^

NÃ¶ erat Ã® ue ce ne diÃeddt. Vir fortis optdto que uoleh **â ^ ' , tufto codier. jjyjj^ obftantc,gÂ«Â»rz potcÃ,dn quiequid 0ftirit,^ef pere debedt, e:^ d mdgiÃrdtu multddicentur,lt;lÃl^tul^ ptum expugndtur.Si incendium'mdrcefuerit,Ãtnbo' Similes, co Ãesrecurrendum, contrd quds nthil opponipoteÃ,â^*

I*Â®Â«Â«)Â« occiditt tiiim neq- muUeris irndgo uUo alio caiH foni poteji^ neq; tyrdnnidd^ uUo alio cafu fuimoucri, , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^Â»âl^im funt,cum abcri multi funt quit opponi pojfunt

Watem deÃrtoris petit,Uim contra legem uiri for tie, ^^[tipnoÃendi.multa dicutur,aduerfui defertores fcri pta non poteÃ nifi optionefubuerti. Item canfeffum ell fx Mtra^ parte ms^aut dubium.Si confeffum ell, btefe f^ ^l^itruntur-.Vtra lex potentior,ad decs pertineat,an Â«14 boiniues,Rempublicam an priuatos,de honore an de peem^de magnis rebut an de paruit,permittat an uetct, an bperet.Solct tradari et utra fit antiquior, cr uelut PÂ°^^MiÃvina,utra mmut perdat,ut in defertore cr uiro

) flt;^gt;i- quad iHo non occifo,lex tota toUatur,occifo, fit quo modo rebquiuiro forti alia optio,Plurmumtamen ell in hoc, 'â*rum^cri fit meliut atq; aquius, de quo nihil pracipi, ^'ÃpropoÃtamateria poteÃ. Si dubium, aut alteri, aut Bwicem utri^ de iureÃt controuerÃi, utinre tali: Pd-in iÂ« ÆÃ®liilm, patrons 'm Uber tum manus iniedio fit, K-berti btredemfequantur.LibertifiUum quida fecit ht^ tedem,inuieem petitur manui iniedio, amp;nbsp;patronut ne^ git int patrit SU fitiffe, quia ipfe in manu patronifue^ rit.DupIi'cfj leges Ãeut dut colUduMur,ut nothus ante

WK.Qnod Je Ifgitu^, idem de jenatuÃofultis didu: que Ã tut inter fe pugnent, aut obÃent legibus, non tarnen dliuJ fit eilÂ« Ãatut nomcUt

4^0 M. FAB. OyiNT. INSTlT' SXÃogilmus hcAetdUcjuidfiinilefcriptoamp;^ ^^^ tif^uid fempcr pars 'm co altem feripto ââ^ j\y hoc mtcrc^^i^itod iUic cotra feriptum feriptu^iÃic 5 uerba dÃ©fendit boe agit. Ut fat utilt;^ ^ fcriptumeÃ¼,bicneaUudq feripttmeR, Eimuo^'^^^ etiarn cum finitione coniunaiotliamfepejfifi^^^^^'^^ ^ ma eR,in fyllogifmum delabitur. Sit enm left

Spe pep capite puniatur, Sfpefeparanti amatoriu d(iât)'^^ ^*a?a1Â«bÃªt^â^^ââ ^*^P'*'^^^^^tjP^f prop'mciuosrogatautrii^^^^ââ'Â° Â«urn inopt^ cH reuerfa,fujpenditfe maritui,mulier uenfe'tj W * mo quodam]^ortiÃ^de{iaÃ¤iodicentisamatoriumuenenutu^11^, asufr^pÃ¨ te trit fnitio-Ãu^ ft parum ualebit,fietfyUogi[iÂ»^^gt;^y^^ paranti. Nee uelutremilfa priorecontentioneucniemuhau ffâ''â. inauditS eft nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1 r â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;irt -craomt

ixpe rationÃ© pt*gt;^tti debeat, ocft uirum ueiteno necaffet. pro dmortio Ãatuf ducit ex co quad feriptum edl, id ejuoi âââf[ â fed pro Ån'' ^^ ^â^âââ^ juouiam ratioematione coUigitur, tentioneiilatitttisdicitur. InbatferÃ¨fpeciesuenit;^xL inaufa^ft! ^â^ cR,idem (y fepitu. Ã¯ncefi damnitaamp;P^^^^^'^^^^^ Â«t haud bene de faxo,uiua repetitur. An quod 'm Wto, et (Â»p* inde Pn conÃ ^' ^âââ^ Â«Â«^ i^gt;^pore iymnos occidit, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;f,|

gio. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tit,. An quod ante ey poÃea.Kaptor profugv t ,^^

pfit,reuer[o iUo petit Optionen. An quoi Kt-^^^â in parte, Aratrum acciperc pignore non /Mf*Â®â^^^ aceepit. An quod 'm parte, idem 'm toto. UX^^ xe ^ Tarento non licet, ones uexit. in bis fyÃ¯logi[tnuFâf alter nititur,alter non fatis cautum effe dicit. Poflihlo W prxcipitetur meeÃa, lexeR, er rapta Optionen pe^b amp;nbsp;in one kn^funt ,fimiliter alia, SÂ«i i^i^ rej^oH^^

foffp, non fA fcriptum, ut bis prlt;tcipitetur ddmndttif tut e^mndocunc^ rdptd opM^dut tyrdnnicidd duo pn^ mid dccipidt, nihil dcuumcre edutum^ nihil de ouibus,ex ro^i mdnifeÃum coUigitur ^uod dubium cR, Mdioris pu^m cH^ex fcript o ducere o^uod [criptum non f^s^njq - nbsp;nbsp;^ -

quiahoe amp;nbsp;hoe. Qui pdtremoccidcrit,culeoinfud- jy^g todÃ¯Â«! tÂ»r,m4trfm occidit. Ex domo in ius eductreneUcedty extrd tdlorndculd cduxit.ln hoc gencre hue i^udrutun An tjuoties proprid lex non cSl,fimilifit utendum : Art id df lt;5Â«o igitur^n de c^uo friptum eÃ^ fimUe fit. Simile dutem t3- mdiut eÃ^ (y pdr, {7 minus' in iUo priore^dn fitu lege cdutumfit,dn etfi pdrum edutu eÃ,hdc fit utÃ«' dum. inutrcg; deuoluntcttelegumldtoris^fed de x^uo i^iHdtiupotentifimi.

M philofophorum ejuibufddm nullum uidedtur fJJf Wfrl^m^ ^Kod no plurdfignificet, generd dimodum plt;^nci, AÂ«t ei'.im uocibus dccidit finguUs, dut cclundK. Pinguid dÃirit^ errorcm,cum pluribus rebus,dut etidm hominiluf eddent dpprUdtio rR, o/xwvu/ji.!Â« dicitur, ut . , S^Hm. Vtrum erm duern, dn genttm,dn nomen, dnfotuni^sdi^o tunim corporis fignificet,inccrtum eÃ¼,CT Aidx, TfU- nij fgnifica wcnKidn Gilei filing, \crbd e^uo^ qudddm diuerfos w**^** plures, tfCfftiÂ« bkw ,Â«t cerno, (pud dmbiguitds plwimis mo* HsiceiiitxndeferÃ¨Utesprdcipue ex teÃdmentiieum dflibfrtatCjjjÂ«^ etidmdehitreditdtecontenduni hi ipM lii iiemnomen eÃ¼^dUt c^uid fit legdtum epuiritur. Altc^

rum c^,w quo dUd integro ucrio figniÃcitio ea,iÂ£'^ ^ uiÃo, ut mgenud, oquot; drmAmentum, zy corumum-1â'â* , nbsp;nbsp;, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ptxÃtnccMiÃ¼dtiones j ex qui timen Gried control'

iunÃ´imftu Ã^ducunt.inde mÃHr^ttÂ» iÃ¼duulgitdcumquttiWy tÃ³pofitu.fi' titrum duld qug ter ceciderit,dn tibicind, Ã ceeiierit, it mamfclhÃ¼' bedtpublicdri. Tertid eÃ¼ ex copoÃtis, utÃ quiieorfM firn,feu non puim in occulto loco poni iubedt, cired^ monutneÂ«' Ia teVnotat ^^'^ multum dgri db hiredibui in tuteldm cineruin,utÃ circa qd! et,leget, Ãt Uttut hoe cultu. Sic dpud Gneoscontenu Ã¯itoÃ¯SS*** nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cumferipturddM^

ndomnid Asova dnbondssoula.'Kiavu rtheidjmÂ» iÂ» comundis plus dmbiguititis eR.vit dutem per cdÃu,^-Aio te Aedcidi Romdnosumcere paffe.

per coUdtionem,ubi dubium eÃ¢ quid quo referri opor-tedtfdeÃ-equentiÃime cumquidem quod medutne^, utrinq; poÃittrdhi,ut de Troilo Vergilinst'Lor'itenens timen. Hic utrum quod tenedt terne lord, dit qMinuts tenat, timen trdhdtur,quÂ£ripoteÃ. ynde contrÃ´ler' ÃdiUd: TeÃdmentoquidimiuÃitponiÃdtud)Â» dureM hiÃim tenentem. QjiÂ£riturÃdtud hdÃdm tenens d^red effedcbedt,inhdÃdeffcduredin Ãdtud dlteriiifÃ^^ riÂ£.Pit per Ãexum idem migistCi^inqudgtntd^^â ^^ centum, occidit Achilles. SÂ£peutriduorutndnteee en* Forma lo'Â° tium Ãrmo fubiiMÃusÃtÃn dubio eÃ¢. vnieeSl tantra quendi ^cu uerÃd t Ufr es meus uxori meÂ£ ddre dimnis eÃo ir^en rcÅnfukos* ti,quod ekgerit pondo centum.y ter eligdt quÂ£ntur. pro eoqdeft verumidquodexhis primum eft ,mutdtionecijuttiÂ»gt; TÃJdamnÂ«Â» feqtKnsdiuiÃoiKuerborumjduttrdtfÃitione emenit*

ORATOR. LIBER VIL 475 ittfytcrtiÃ¼idieÃ¼ionc.AccuÃtiuigcmtndtioncfd^idiitn* phtiologid foluitur Mdtiuo, ut illud: Ldebetem dudtui fereuÃiffe Demed^fidt, d Ldebete perÃ§uffum Demedtn. Sei dbldtiuo ipfi^ut 'm primo diximui,ineÃ ndturdUi dm pljÃ®bologtd t CÅlo decurrit dperto.

'Vtrum per dpertum calum, dn cum caelum dpertum ep fct.'Ã¼iuil'iorcjjlirdtioneÃ¼'mordconjidt. Stlt;Uudm,dc' ^â^f i^uredn} hdlldm, uel Ãdtudm durcA, de'mde bdÃdin, Adtedio tdlis eÃt Argentum quad elegerit ipfe,ut h^ adiectiona '^^t 'inteUigitwr^tteUpfdutuxor. AdieÃ¼ionefddddm- *^ f^'lfgt;ologid(juiiijÃ(^figfÃgfttc^ iHof deprebend'mut, '^^''âj^ionefoluetur. FluribM uerbis cmendandum, ubi ^F idlt;{uod lt;pio referdtur dubium eÃ, (^ ipfum eÃ dmU ^â'â' Utres metis ddre lÃ¼i ddmnds eÃo omnid fud. in ^â*Â°'^^^gt;iits'mciditCicer0f lo^uem deC. 'Fdnnij foceri

11 â 'a^Â°^'''^^Â° i^Â°^ â¢ fcripto, or correptio 'm dubio ^AiuÃ eÃ dmbiguitdtis, utmbocCdto, diiud enim Ãlt;^gt;*f^lt;i fyildbd edp nom'mdtiuo,diiud '^â^fyUdbd produddedp ddtiuo,dutdbldtiuo. 'Pluri* â''^^'â^ I^^^â^^^^^â^ P^'i'Ãepii nihil necep

0^ â ^f^ââ'âA*'t e^uomodofdUdÃt dmpbibologid, dut V tfloludtur. Ã¯iuds enim res fignificdri mdnifeÃum en^ '^^^I^f^^^ff^xf pert'met,ut utrdni^ pdr

4Ã®4 M. FAR QVINT. iNSTlf' a cent ipfdm di noÃrdm fpurtem conemar uertere. N I id fieri potefi,dmphibologij.noÂ»efi. AmpbiboloÃ¿f^^^ ton omnii in bit erit (luiefiiOfelUqudndo uter Ãtfi^^ Mturdm migis ferma, femper Mrum fit jetfdut, U'-'^ if fjuifiripfit de dixit, fie naine rit: quiruminott^^^,^ pdrtem fdtis exhif que deeanieÃ¼nrd(J i^-t-diti^^ â'* XMH{i,prieecptum efi,

ES T dutem quedi inter bas fidtut cogifdtio- wm Oquot; in finitione, qnxfit ualutM naminif qmrdtit, Cr in fyÃ¯lagifma,qui feeunduf d finitiane fidtuf eÃgt; â ffieÃ©ldtur quid ualurrit feriptar, er ex cotrdrijs i^Ã¿ '** duos effefcripti,er uoluntdtisfidtia dppiret. R'lt;â'/â'^ er finitio quoddmmodo efi dmphibologii, eitquot;^ *'* â^â ** pdrtesdiduedtur inteUedusnominis. Scripting ^ ^^. luntds bdbet in uerbis uoeis queftionÃ¨,qdod idf^ ^ ^ lt;nbsp;nomidpetitur. ldeo^ omnidbdequidAferiptixtii^^^^ tuntdtemejfedixerut. Alijin feripta, Ã§ruoluftdtef^* pbibologidmcffe,quÂ«efdeitquiefiianem. Seidâfâ , funt. Aliud efi enm ob/curum ius, dUud dnibigfi^' '2' tur finitio in ndturd ipfd nominis qudfiianent^^^^ 2' nerdlem, er que effe etidm citrd eomplexuiÂ» ci^l^ fÂ°' fit. Seriptum,er uoluntdf de co diffutdt uerboA'^^ ? in IcgctSyUogifinus deea quad non efi. Ampbibohfff lis ut dinerfitm trdbit. Legum contrdridrdm ex iinetfi pugndeH Neqne intmerito er receptdefi ddo^iÃini'^ bec dÃfi rent id ^ dpud plurimos dc prudentifittaos^

Wt. Et de hoc c^mdem generc ii^j^ofttionif ^ etUm ft tdifapta' Â«onomnwtrddtjt^i/MntdliijMitpotMcrMrtt. SuÃ®it dltd,qMÂ« âÂ®ââ nip, propopitd, dec^M dicendum ep,miitmlt;i, uidm dicta di non prÃ¦kdÃ®f^NÃ¼ en'm cnt[d uniuerfd in (^Mpionts a: locos didneendi tp. Sfd bd: ipfit partes hibent rurPia ordintm fmim.Ndni er in prootmio pri/mum fÃ aliquid, CrfÂ«uttdÂ«m,Â£tc df tneopy* Et quteÃio omnw, de locus bd kt luim diÃjofitioncm, ut tbefeK ctiM pm^pUcts. Ac p porte fÃ¼K exit diuidendi pexituc, qui controuerpim inbuciiduxcrit, Momne ^xÂ£miimuiro forti ddndum fit,dn ex priudto,dn nupti^jdn cd quÂ«e nuptd fttyinbdd deinde cumfuexit de priiM ([UdÃione diccdum,piÃm, crut quicq; in nicntetn ucnict,mifcttfrit,non priwum in Cd feierit, eÃe tri^indum. Verbis legis Ãdndum fit, dit uoluntdtejbMiMsip/iuspdrticHlie dliquod initiumfect' rit.Deinde proximd jiibntÃ¼cns Ãruxerit ordtioneni,ut pars bominis eft minuSytim digiti,illorÂ«m quoq; drticu U.Ejl er boc,quodfcriptor dcmonjlrdre non pof it, ni/Ã¯ certd defnitdq; matcrid. Scd qd und fdcidt, dUt dlterd?

1 ptoris c(i,in dlio dtq; dlio genere quotidie o^Ã«dere quiÂ« ordofit rerum, er quÂ« copuldtio, ut pduldfnn fat wfiw, cr dd fmilid trunfitus. Trddi enim omnid quÂ« ars cfgt; 4^ feit,non pofunt. KdmqHiÃ¯piftoroninid,qutfinre-rumndturdfunt, ddumbrdre didicit i Sed percepta fe-wel mitandi rdtione dfimuldbit quiequid dcceperit, ^ tnuUtt^ Cyds enim non fiber udfculum dliquod,qudle nunquide titjfwi'Ã^iEddWcro non docentiÂ« funtjed difeentiuÂ»

N^m er mcdicui quid m quoq^ udletudmii genenf-â^^ dumfit^quid quibus^; ÃgnÃ¼ prouidÃ¨dum,docebity^ fentiendi pulfut ueniirÃ¼gt;cidoris motufj^iritm Â«f^ color K diÃiintiiitn,quÂ£ [m cuiafq; funt, ingÃ©niÃ© iJ'^lt;^* QjiAre plurimd petdmus Ã nabisjO- cum eduÃs dÃ©libÃ©rÃ© tnus,cÃ¼gitcmMcp homines dnte mueniffe drtÃª,quM io^ cuijje. lUd enm potentiÃmd, quÂ£^ uere didtur eecom mied totius eduÃe difÃoÃdo, qux cÃÃitui niÃuelut in re pritfenti no poteÃ, vbi d^umendu proxmiunt^nbi omit tendum,ubi utendum expoÃtione continud,ubi pdrtitd, Wore Home tibidb initijs meipiendum^ubimore Homerico d me' cusmosâX* â^^^ â^^ nltÃªmis, ubi omn'mo non exponendum,quindo i tore Home' noÃris, qudndo db dduerfdriorum propoÃtionibus mei S tr?buat ut ^ââ^^â^^^^â^â^^ ^ ÃrmiÃimis probdtionibus,(pnndo d le in difpofitio uioribuf, qudndo in cdufdproponrndieproxmijsqus' neacordineÃiones. QttdprÂ£pdrdtioneprxmuniendf,qdiiindi' dum folto ^^ animus dccipere poÃit, Ãdtim diÃ©lum, quopduldtm tus Rt, deducenduf. Smgulis, dn uniuerÃs opponenid refutd' tio. KeÃrudndi perordtioni, dn per tot dm ordtionem diÃ-undendi dffrÃ¤tts. De iure prius, dn de tquittte di' cendum.An dntedHd crimind,dn de quibusMicinmeÃ^ prius obijccrc,ucl diluere conuenidt. Si multip'deereM^ 5^ fe erunt^quis ordo Ãiciendus, qua teÃimonidgt; tdbulsM cuiuÃque generis in ddione recitdndÂ£,quÂ£reÃritindi. Imperatoris H^c eÃ¼ uelut imperdtorid uirtus copidsfudS pdrtientis toWs^^offfeiaâ^^ â'â^^â*^ P^^^^^^^^f r'ctinentis pdrtes propter ei' comparan- Ã^^lt;^ tuendd, euÃodienddÃue urbes, petendos commei' lt;âââ â tuStC^jquot;^'' itmerdf m^ri deni^, dc terri dMemii,

Sfd fc/c in ontione prÂ£jÃ®it omniet, cui djfucrint nutu* rlt;i,doilmi, Ãttdiim â¦ Quetre nemo expcHet, ut edieno tintumledeorefttdiÃrtuÂ«. Vigilindumducat,iteruin fnitendum,pi!lcnd'am cR,facienda fut cuique uis,ufui, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;*

fin ratio,non ref^iciendum ad hÃ¦c, fed 'm promptu bd* Igt;fÂ«i4,neqÂ«f tanepum traditi/ei taneptam mnata.t^am uiamdenumÃrare uelociter ars poteHi ft epiaeA,ueÂ«^ poteft*^**â* nm ars faits prierai, ft copias cloquentia: ponit 'm me*-dio. tiofirtem eÃ utieis feire, Relicpia partium eÃdea mm dijpofttio. Et 'm his ipfis primus alieptis fenfus,^^ fecimdus,cr tertius, 151Â« non mode ut fint erdme collo* cat^elaborandamcfifid ut inter fe iunÃ©H,at^ue ita co* herentes, ne commiffura pelluceat, corpus fit non ment lgt;ra,lt;poditacontmget,fi er eptid cpiicpteconueniatui* dermuSter ut uerba uerbis appUcemuspton pugnantiaÂ» fed epe 'muicern compladantur.Ã¯ta rcs non dinerfe di* famibus ex locis, eptafi muicern ignotee coUidentur,fed iUuM focietate corn prioribus ac feeptentibuSyCOpuUs te Â»ebuÂ«t,((c uidebitur non folum compofita oratio,fed eti aâncontmu.Vcr.m longius fortaffe progredior faUen te tranfitu, ej- a dijpofitione ad elocutionis praccepta lx tor,^Â«O(l proxi nw Iibcr 'mchoabit.

IS fere iUÂ£ in proximo! ^Â»^f libroscoJUtafMit^ratioiniieni^''^. di^dti^ue wuentd dij^oncnii co'*^* netHr,({MiÂ» ut per omnes numcroi penituf cognofeere, id fimquot;^, ________________feienti^ neceffiriim eSl,^^ i emibut breuius,iic (impUciut tridi migis conuenit-^'â enim difficultateinÃitutionK, timnumero[Â£itlt;^ââ^P^^ plcxÂ£ de terrer i folcnt^dut eo folent^dut cotempof^i'*'^ f Coknda prlt;ecipue alendd ingenii, dtÃ§j; MulgentU ^i*^'''^ triendi funt, dj^eriorum tnHitu rertm Aut Ã hxc fold didicerint,fdtis fe dd elot^uemiiti^^P^ Has drbitrdntur,iut qmÃ id certÃ¼ qMÃim ivttid' f tes iUegdtijCondtuAn omnem refortnidiitt'Vgt;^^'^^ââ'â tndlit ieddiffe, ut ^i diUge/ttiÃmi irtium extitertint,ib eloqueiuidlongiÃunefuermt- vUid^tti opus eÃ¼ in(ipientibus,fed ei plind,e:T cum ii iÂ«gâ'f ^â* nbsp;nbsp;'

endum,tum id demonjlnndum expeditie Eligitd^^?^ peritus iUe preceptor ex omnibus optimi, cr ttiiH t* demum in pr^fentid qu^pidcent, remoti reÃtinHa* â¦uexerÂ« i^fdmord.SeiÃ¿tutureuim difdpuU^uÃ´fduxfriflt; Max

cum robore iijicnii eremeet ctiarn cruditio. lidem pri^ WO foljm iter credAnt effeym quod Mueentury mox H Ui cognituri etidm optimen. Sunt Autem tteqi obfeurd, Â«r^j id pmipiendum difficilid, qÂ«Â« [criptores diuctÃn ofmionibm pertmiciter tuendii inualuerwnt. Itd-j; iÂ« toto irtis hm^ce triditu difficUiiu c^ iudiare quid docf x5,qiMm c%in iiidicdYis,docere, prÃ¦cipueq; i-n dwÂ« But bw pirttbw prrq fiwt piuedyared (jus fi is ejui m^i tneturnonrepugndU!rit,pron.Mdd esterdhdbiturut i^'.-x','.-:^lt;(\aigt; f^cwlum.Hefitpeenimplurmiim inhocldborKexhdu Â«sÂ»eoruin fiinutyUtojlendcrcm'dirhctoYicenbenediccndi â¢cientb hÃ âaÃ©n^tra lt;*w (?â MtilffHjCr drtÃ«/t WYtutem effe.mdterid rÃ!Â«, Yts dit a funt. O'S d' quibtÂ« diccudutw e^et, tri-m er flt;M wt tYihuffeYc Zncrihuf^iemo^rdtiuOjdelibeYdtiuoJudicidliqiYepCYi n â¢ OMtionew porro omnem conlldYe Yebut er ucYhis^

Â«fw, in Â«trifqj co!loclt;tttoÂ»Ãª, qÂ«ae mcmoYid compledcYe tUTjUftio commenddret- OYdtOYis officium docendi^ ma Â«fuiijdckftdttdt pdrtiboÃ¯ corttwert â¦ Ex quibtÂ« dd do* cendmex^oÃtio er dr^dmentdtio, dd mouendum affÃ¨ ftw pfrtwertHt, quo; pcr omnem quidem edufdm, fed mixiwc timen m mgYeffn dc Ãne dommdri.t^dm dde* fldtionoNj qiuwuM m utrotjuc Ãt eoYdmy mdgis tdmen nbsp;nbsp;,

i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;piropfiÂ« in elocutione jpdYtes hdbeYt. Qg eÃiones aUm nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'

Â«âgt;/Ã¯Â«itÂ«,iiIilt;t5 ÃnitMytjus ptYfonKdocifttem^oYibiK co tincÃ¯ciituy ^ It, o,ân j porto mdterid friet effi qusYendd^ ^^ /itÂ» quid pt, qiwk Ãt.HK ddijdebdmM^ demonÃrd* ti'wbdf 4c Â«itÂ«pcrlt;Uwffc fanÃdre, itte# qux sÃ¨

4^0 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. ipfo^dc quo diccrcmâM^qtiÂ£ poR cum dÃ¼d effintj^ dum. Hoc opus tradutu honeÃorum, utiUum^ Â«)lâlt;'^* Soi for ijs lUccdere tertidm pdrtem ex coniedurd, PÂ®)* fet 'ne fieri, er dn effet futurum, de quo deliberdretf^^-Hic prgeipue diximuf ffieddndum,quis, dpud quÃ«A'^', diceretjudidshu cMfiru,dliiM 'm fingulis,idids m plâ*âââ bui controuerfjs confifiere,cr in quibufdi fuffcere^'gt; do 'mtentionc,tnodÃ³ depulfionÃ«t PorrÃ³ depulfonÃ« Åit inficidtione duplici,fdilum 'ne jet dn hoc fdÃ¼ueffetfff^ tered defenfione dc trdnftdtione confidre,Ci^tjliÂ°âf^gt; Mt exfdUo, dut ex fcripto effet ExfdÃ«io, de rerumf^ de,proprictdte,qudlitdte: Scripto, dc uerborum Wt^ uoÃ¯untdte,m quibm uit turn au fr urn, turn ddioÂ»Â»^ ^ ff ici foledt,quf^ dutfcripti,cruolMitdtis,duti^^ââÂ°^^ ndtiuf, dut dmbiguitdtis, dut legum contrdridrdtnir de contmetur. In omni parrÃ¨ edufd indicidU^^'â^^ âquot; pdrtes, qudrtim cxordio concilidri dudienteixgt; i^ ne edufm proponi, confirmdtione robordfiy ^^r^. ^^ ne diffolui.pcrordtionc dut memoridm iudidj ^r^ animos moueri. His drgumentdndi, er

â er quibutgeneribus concitdri, pldcdri, refbâ' oportetfOdiectmus. Accefiitrdtiodiuifioitif- . ntodÃ³,qui difcet uelit, certdm qudnddm uidngt; ^Irff Â° multd et id fine doÃrmd pr^ftdre debedtprtf^f^ tura,ut hdc de quibus dixi, non tam 'muentd 'i p^^^ P ribusqcum fiÃ¨rent obferudtdeffcuidedntur- _ exigunt Idboris er curie que fcquuntur.âBi^^^'^'^ â ^locutionis rAtionemtrAÃ«idiimiiSfpdrteinoperiif^^*

^ ownrsontores conucnitJifficiUimAm, Nrfw er MÂ» A^ttoniutycuiiu fuprA htibtiimiK mentionem, dit 4 fe diÂ» fortos uifos cj^e mÂ«Ã¯toÃ¯,eIo^McnXf m 4Htf m Â«embtem. Dl prtK pt/y pMt4t diccre ijUte oportedtiOmdte AUtem di ^lt;^( proprium effe eloquentiÃmi. Q^Ã uirtM,Ã Â«{que *i fum in Â«Â«Ho repertd eSt^dc ne m ipfo cpÃ¹demydut Li CnjJo crrtÂ«m f A er in b/v, er m prioribw edm de^n^ ^^ â^Â®^ flfrdMm^qMid difficilimd fuit. Et M.TuKiÂ« inuÃ«tionem bus Â«Ham dÃ© qwdem 4c difpoftionem prudentis bommi! putdt, do* lt;WÂ«at8, qÂ«Ntilt;(m ordtoris^ Idco$ pracipue cired pdrtis buiut prÂ«cfpt4 cUborduit, quod eum merito feciffe, etid ipfo

Â«Ue qw loquimnr, nominr pdUm decUrdtur. Eloqui jioquj, fnim boe eÃ¯i,omnid quz mente conceperit promere, ut* ^Â«f Ã©d muantes per ferre,fine quo fuperudcud ftnt pria ^f^^vfimibd ^dio condito, dtque intrd udÃ¿ndm fudm bÃ©rfÂ«i.Hoc itdq; rndtime docetur ,boc nuUiÂ« nifi drte lt;(JfqÂ«i potfft,boc^Mdt4Â«l ddbibmdiwn, hoc exercitd^ tw pHitjboc MÂ«itdtto,boc omnii AtM conlÃ¹mitur,hoc mixime orator ordtore prxÃdnt ior,hoc generd ipfd di ecnid diiiitlijs potiord.Nf^jenim Afidni,dut quoewn^ mIjo gf nerc cÃ¶rrMpti^rci non uiderunt,dut cm non coUÃ³ ciMrimt,neque quos dridos uocdmui,^ulti dut 'm edufti cÃ©ci fwriwit, fed bw iudidu 'm eloquendo dc modut^ iUÂ» Â«irci icfucruntjUt dppdredt 'm hoc er uitiu/m,cr uirtH tewfjjÃ¨diccndi.Ã¯qonideo tdmen foldeddgenddeuri Â»erborum. 0ccKrr4m enim neeeÃe eH, er uclut 'm ue^i Woprotinuj dpprehenfuris hdne confeÃionim meatÂ» ft ff Ml his,qui omiffd veru (^Â«t nerui fiml: 'm eduftsy^i

ligentid^tiuodam indni circm uoces Ãudio Iene^cuiit,ii^^ f^ciunt grdtid dccoris,quod cR in dicendo,mci([iiiifOgt; opinions,pulchcrrmum:fed cum fecjMturgt;noncumt^ Hdtur.Corpord [und^Gr mtegri pnguinK,O'exercitie tione Ãrmdtd/x ijfdem his fpeciem dedpiunt, tx ([utiut uires. Ã¼dnlt;j; et colordtd^et dÃriHd^et Idccrtis expreÃii fivnt,Ãed eddem ft (pits Wilfd utquefuedtd muhdritir co ipfa forma mdt, fadiÃimd funt ipfo formte Ã¼bore. Et cuitut con* cukus 00^ ^^^â^ â^^^^ â^ff^^fi^â^^â^^^ homnibus, utgrecouerfd ceffos Ã¦Â°ue tefidtum cll,dutoritdte.At muliebris er lufurioÃu,noit Td^^h mi ^Â°^I?^ exomdtpfed detegit mentemSimiliter iÃ¼i triÃu nibâ.utCrÂ» ciddctutrftcolorcpiorunddm elocutioresipfdscjfccini ciunfusK' ndtjC^udiÃ¼ouerbcrumhdbituueÃiurdur-Curdinergo autoritstc. ticrboru/W, reru/in uolo effefoli(itudmevgt;iMÂ»i phtutt^

optimd rebus coherent,et cemuntur[no lumine.At nos querimus iÃ¯ld tdtupum Idtednt femper, fe^fidxiucditt. Itd numeptim putdmus dredid e(fe,de quo dicendum ef, fed ex dlijs locis petimus, et Inuentis uim ifÃdmus-bU iore dnimo dggredicttddclo(^ucntidcd,(infptotocorgt; pore wiet,ungues polire,et edpiUum reponere, non eÂ» fimdbit lid curdm fudm pertinere.Sedeuenitpb^^^'*^ ut hdc diligentid deter tor etidmfidt ordtio. pfMÃâ'J funt optimd, minime dccerfttd, er ftmplicibiK)^^^^ *^ ipfiueritdteprofedis fmilid. tiamiHd^uecurMfi* tcntur,cr fiild dt(j; compofitd uidcri etidm uolunt, nee gratidm con^equnntur, er fidem dmittunt proptcrii ^uod fenfu! obliwtbrdntjCruelutletogrdminefdtdPrd guldttt. Hdmer tjuod reÃ¼e dici pote^fdf^l^^f^^ ^^

w Â«freorHÃ¯u, er ^Kod fais diÃ³ium eH, reprtÃ®mtu, ZT ^woi Â«MO ucrlo pitettpluribm onerdmiit,0' plerdlt;j^ Ã* tneliut putiimuf,lt;iuAm dicere,Qtjfd.^lt;iuod ni^ Â»Mwproprtofli pldcet^iMpdrum creditur di^rtum, H'^oti ft dliui dixijJetfA corruptiÃmo lt;^uolt;^ poctdrufi Sâ^â'Â« Ãu trdnÃdtionei mutiumur, turn demii 'mgenioÃi RiÂ«t,/i dd mteUigtndos nos opm Ãt mgenio.At^ni Ãt ** Offrir Cicero pneeperdt^m dicendo uitium nel md* De orÃ¤t.tÂ« xwaw effÃ¨^Ã uulgdri genere ordtionK^dtlt;^Aconfuetu prolo* ^Wf cowmiwii dbljorrerf .Sc 4 iUe dwiis dtlt;j^ inerudittUi â*â* weliijÃ¯, qwtfciM fardent omnid, qÂ«Â« luturd diStduit^ non orndmentd lt;pidrimus,fed knoemid.ci^iÃ liera

F nflti Hertoriiwi, niÃ rd coh^rentiarni uirtus, (luit ut f^^pdiÃnt zr dilucidd, er orndtd^ zy dpte coUacen* ^''â^i^totiuitd Uiordndum dt^omnis ÃudiorumÃ-u* ^n* Mii^us eH.At^ piiroÃj^ uideM h^f entes ciredÃn SnUjO- dim Mueniu/ntfZr dum mue nt d ponderdnt de â¢iwnettuntMr. Ciuefi id circa fieront,ut femper optimit MeremnY^ ilommindd tdmen bte mfidicitds erdt, qwx (!f surfin iicendi refiâendt, et cdlorem cogitdtianis ex t'mguit mon er dijfidentii. Mi fr enim,et(ut fic dieSj PâÂ«pcr aruor eft,^mâ nuUiun Â«crBiwi Â«Ã§lMo dÂ»Â»no per ^ potefl^Sfd tte perdet t^uidem^c^ui rdtionem loqjMcn P^'Wiw cognouerit,tum leÃione muitd,ztr idoned ca

â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â'â^Â«Â»â wÂ»{Â»pcBeÃilcÂ«Â» compdrdrit, er ba# tfÆ wwierit irtem coUoedndi, ddnde hÂ£c emnidexer^ fiKhont plurmn rolordÃ¯it,ut femper m prumptuÃt^t

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^ *^f ocmIqj ^ ^ ^fj^yj ^ |jgc ^Â«t fiecerit, ei rÂ« ewÂ«

4^4 M, FAB. QVINT. INSTIT, nommibw fuis occurrent^Sed opus cA Ãudio pneti^ te,or acquifitdfMultiite^zir quAf repoftd.'^^nc^afÃ^ t^uMudi, iudicandi,compdrdndi dnxietds, dumiÃ^^^ tuns ddhibendd th, Hon civm dicimus â¦ Alioi^uifuut ^m fdtrimoniu/m nonpdrarwntfuiinde quirur.t,itAmori tione qui non fdtis ldhordruÂ»t,ft prtepdrdtd uis iieenit non fuerit,trunt inofficiofi,non ut requiftis reÃ^oniÂ» re,fed ut femper fenfibus mhitrere uidedntur. Atque ut taKeni tembrd corpus Ãquitur, tdmen m hdcipfd curi eHuH^ quid ft is cum Ã¯dtind,fignificAtid, orndtd,twitdptcfint coUocdtd,quid dmpUus IdboremusfQÃ¿ibufddtn tamÃ© nul lus finis cdl'Mnnidndi efi, et cum finguUs penÃ¨fyUilis co mordndi,qui etidm cum optimdfint reperti,qudrunt iH quid quod fit mdxme Antiquum,remotum,mopimtum, nee inteUigumtideere fenfusmordtionefmqudutrid lduddtur.Sit igitur curd clocutionis quimntdximi, iuM fcidmus tdmen nihil uerboru/in cdufdejJefAciÃ«dum,cunt uerbd ipfd rerÃ¼ grdtidfint repertd, quoru edfimt Â«uxt me probdbilid,quÂ£ fenfum dnimi nofiri optime promut, Atq; in dnimis iudicum, quad uolumus,rffcâU^^*^^'^jt 1-dficete bent priefidre fine dubio, er ddmirdbileiÂ»,cr ordtionem. Vertmi ddmirdbilem nonfic quoinoiÂ°P^Â°* digit mirdmur, cf iucumddm ordtionem non iefotm nbsp;nbsp;,

, (iutinelocutionel^eiidndd. CAP- 1Â« nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;à¥¤ ^fx/n. TQ-^^^ ^^^ Graeci (p^ien/j uoednf, Idtine dicimus do j

cutionem,edm ffieUdmus uerbis, dutfingulis tut con \ iuu^is, infmguUs intuendum e^,utfint ldtini,pctj^l* ;

ciMjOmdtijCr 4(1 id, ^Â«od efficere uolumM, iccommo* iitijn coniwnSOSyUt emcndiitii,ut coUoetÃ¼i, utfigurd t^: Sfd cit ^HÃ de rdtionc Utme dt^ emenidte loquendi fdiYwnt iieendd^m lihro primo, cmm de grdnmdticc io que rfmur,execHti fumia.Verum iUic tdMum ne uitioÃ ^ifent, prlt;ecepimiÂ«, hie dUenum non eÃ: ddmonere, Â«t fwt ([Mmmmime peregrind, z^ externd. Multos enim quibiÂ« loque ndi rdtio non deÃt, muenids, quoÂ« eurioÃe fotim !oqui dixeru quam Utine, quo modo or iUd Atti (dMiK Tbeopbrrf/luWjbomincm dltoqui difertiÃiinum, O'^inotdtduniui dffeitdtioneuerii hoj^item dixit,nee olio Ã id deprchendilfemterrogdtdrej^ondit, q quod t'imiumitticeloq^ueretur. Et 'm T. Liuio mire fdeun* diiÂ»iroputitfne(Ãe'PoUioAÃniutc[Mnddm PdtduiniÂ» ^â^*â ^â^^^âÂ»â¢QiidYe Ã fieri poteÃ¼,cr uerbd omnid,(y uox hu iw (dawnimi whis oÃ¯ednt,ut ordtio 'Komdnd fldnÃ¨ ui aiumna ur dfotur non ciuitdte dondtd. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;**â âÂ®â **â'^â

X tcm,fii proprietdt ipfdnon firnpiiciter dccipif proprictas tÂ«r. PrimiÂ« mim mteHeftw eft fud cuiuf^ rei uppelld* tio,qiM non fimper utimur,'!Adm et ohÃcoend uitdhmiK, ' Ã¼ [oTdiJdjCr humiUd. Sivnt dutem humilid inÃ-d digni

MtemrcriÂ»Â«, dut ordinisgt; In quo uitio eduendo non me dixritn tftiddm errdre fÃ³lent, qui omnid, qult;c Ãivnt in ufu, etÃ¹m fi ciuÃe neeeÃitds pofiulet, reÃormiddnt, ut

\ nbsp;nbsp;Â®*^ Ã* *â '*^ioÂ»c iheriedx herids hetidffeÃe folo ne^^^^l^eM

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Gg

46Ã© H. TAB. 071 NT, INSTILÂ» ta^nÃ©^âaddi- ^^^^'*^^^^^^Plt;^^^quot;^^^tcereuelieiudicdfflt;dgt; ^ tumm^ in nidcoqudreddrusordtor durdtosmurid modum )u- Â«j effe credideriMUdm ipfum id quod uitdidt â¢ W dum. dutpropnetdtis fiiecie,quÂ£nommibusipfiscdigt;gt;,v ,. De fpaeto utitur,nu]lduirtuiea,dtci:cicontrdriume^uitidâd'âgt;' curhifpam* , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. ca herbak- quoddpudnosnnpropriiimtOiiw^opdpudGrdt'Â» geapudCel tur,qudleeÃ¼i T'dntÃfferdredolorem. Autqooi^ xvit cap Jij. ordtione DolobeÃÂ£ emenddtÃ¼ d Cicerone dnnotdtÃ³yfiio'^^ K nomina tcmferre,dutqiiilid nunclduddtiturdquiiufdÂ£n,lt;liâ de cornice r^e^ de cruce uerbdeeciderunttt^ontdmÃ« q^cijdi non erit propriu,protinus et iwproprij uitio libordii lt;nbsp;Quid prmu omnium muÃ¯td funt,z^ grdcc et ld^f^ dcnommdtd.iqdm ey qui idculu emittit,idculdriiieâ^^'

t4 cdretjCr ut Upidare c^uid fit munifejluw, iti^^^^^'^â^^ tefidrimt^ iditus non hdbetnomc.vndedbufiÂ°4â^^^ TÂ«X'^Hoâi^ dicitur ncceffdru.TrAfidtio ciuoi^ 'â âiquot;^ miximut eA ornxtuitUcrid nafiis reim i(eo^'â^Â° â Ciudre propriety non Ã¤d nomen, fed dd uiwpÃ¿'âr ^^ refertur,necdtiditu, fed mteUeUuperpeddOâ^^^^^ eundo modo dicitur propriu inter plurd iiuf I nbsp;nbsp;^^^

dÃ¨nominii,id unde egterd duUdftvÂ»t,ut *â'**.. j^ tortd m fe dqui,uel quic^uid dUud fimiidtt Â»^ ' â de propterftexu edpiUorum pdrsfummd hoc quod ek inmontibus eminentifiitnu.P^^^^^^i'** xeris hge omnid uertices, proprie tdmen,unde ud^ eH. Sic folee,Qr turdi pi fees,c^ citerd,Terfiu ej ic diner fut modus,cam res comunif plurUmf^*^^

quokbft Momtu cxhuÃ¼im , ut armen fiwxlre j^roprie nenii,cr tubtruAculÃ¼ ducK,Augujiale^ item ^uod corn mwnt ffl ft dijs nomenjmteUeÃ¼u 'Hcui rei pecuUdriter trii)Wtur,uturicm'R.omiiccifimws, e^ uendles^nouiti os,Ã¼- Cormihid xriiycum fint wies AÃt (iuolt;^,t^ uenei ii multd, er tam Aurum et arguent urn ,g is Cormtiium. Srd nc tn Ijk qwdÃ« uirtus ontoris inf^icitur,At i^ui il non mediocriter prolgt;ddtwgt;i,^Â«od boe etiÃ¤m liuddri mo dÃ³ folet^t froprie diÃ¼u id Ãit, ^Â«0 nibtl mueniri poÃit fgnificimiiKyUt Cdto dixit C. Ctefirem dd euertenddtn RompJobritwi dcceÃfÃe,ut VergUiM, neduUu edrmÃ«f CZBordtiiKjAcrÃ« tifcidjAHwibdlfW^ dirum.In quo mo doinudqiioq; e^dt^uHufddmtrdditum proprij genus Â« Â«ippo/Ã¯tK^quf epithetd dicuntw, ut duke muÃum/t turn dfentw aIbM,dc quo genere dkU diandu eÃ.Etw quf bme tnnflitdftvnt propriet dici[oient,interim du* tem quefwt in quo^j genere pracipM, proprij locu de cipiwÂ«t,Â«t rdbiiK wter piures imperdtorids uirtutes Cu fldtor fft dppclldttK. PofJumt uideri uerid^quee phu ft* gniÃednt quim fIoquttiMÂ«r,m pdrte ponendd perÃpicui Utis.liueÃe^Ã¼ (nm ddituidnt.Pgo dut Uientius empiid EmphalÃ¹. fm retuiefm id ornitu oritionk, qd nc ut mteUigitw f Bgt;Â«it,ftd ut plÂ«Ã¯ mtehigdtur. At oifcuritiU Ãt 'm net iis ttidm db ufu remotis, ut ft commentdrios quis ponti nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.

ft^^i^uetuÃiÃmd faderd, er exoletosfcrutdtiu dU osinuitotâ* torfÃ¯,id i()[n^ pf(4t f x i,is,ut qua inde cotrixerit^non inttHigdnthr, Hme ruim dliquifdmdm eruditions affÃ¨* fidnt)Utquddim folifcire uidedtw.PdUwnt etid wrid^

468 M. FAB. oyiNT. INSTIT.' ud regionibiK quibufddm mdgis fdmilidrid, mlddiam pud^oratT P*'Â°Pâ'''^:gt;Â«^ Mdbuliu uentui^z^ ndUM ficcirid,vmmi Idcho fdnwm^quie ud uitdndii dpud iudicem igmrm fÂ» gnifiedtionum edru^ud mterpretdndd(iwt,jicutm\iii T3urus.quÂ£ hamonymd dicuntur^ut tdurui djiimdl Ãt,in nions, dn fsgntmi in coda,dn nomen hommis,dn rddix drioris, niÃdiHmdum, non intcUigitur.Plus tdmeneU ob[curi* tdtis in contextÂ» zy cont mudtione fermonis, er plurcs modi t andre nee fit tdm longut, ut em prolÃ©qui non poÃit intentionnÃ©e trdiedione tdm tdrdas, ut in hypers bdtonfinis eim differdtur. Citybus ddhuc peioreÃ¼nu^ xturd uerborivm,(pu.lis in illo uerfut

Aeneid.i. Sdxd uoednt ltdli,mcdijs quÂ£ in fiudibuidrdt^ Etidm mtericdionc,qud er ordtores er bifioricifieiue ter utuntur,ut medio fermone dUlt;luem mferdntfenfiwgt; mpedirifolet mtettedus, nifi ^uod intcrponiturb^e Ceorg.j.eil.NdmVergiliusiÃ¼oloco,quopuUwineiluindiu ^J^ bit,cum dixiffett nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;NÂ« udnos horret Ã^P^^^â

copluribus infirtis, dlidfigurd quinto demu âââ^r ^^.â â Â« i SiaMfonumbroculdrmddedere nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

Amphiboio nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1 râtn deciuusgt

giaomnibâ Vitdnddmprimtsdmbtguttds^nonMcjotUâ^ mfdcit, modis uitan ffe^e fuprd didum eR, que incertu/m â^^'^^f^-n^rttiof. ââ ut Chremetem dudiui pereuÃiffe Deniednt,P ' ^ ^^^ que,que etidmfi turbdre non potcRfenfon^gt;'^ â ., ^ men uerborum uitium incidit, ut fi quit ^^^L ^^jf fe hominem librum feribentem â¢ Ndm etidmfi homme fcribipdtedt,mdletdmencompofif^ââ^âlâ^ que ambiguum qiuntu in ipfo fuit- ^^ ^ â^

ORATOR. LIBER VllL 469 ilÂ« turk wioniwi! uerborumt t^ui dum commiwem lo# q^fnai moÃ¯cm reformdinty duÃ¼i fj^ede nitoris cir* (wmavut omnid copiofilo^MdtAte, lt;^UÂ£ dicere uolimt, ipfiiiÂ« deinde iUdm feriem cum did ÃmiU iiwgenecs.mi* fewÃ©/^Uftdtrd quimwIlM^ jj^iritui dmdrepoÃit, ex^ t^ndmt. lÂ» boe mulum etidmiejuUul'ddm lubordtw^

â¢w muenidm fuiffe ^rÂ£ceptorcm diejucm, qui dtptpw* loi obfeurdre qw^ dicerent, iuberet,grÂ£co uerbo utens âfiidria-ojj^-^tide iÃ¼i fdlicet cgregidlduddtioztMto me* Â«Â»Stutoii, hoc bar,ne ego e[uidem mteUexi. Alij breuitdtis Â£muU, ne* ^^**^*^âââ (^Ãdru lt;^uo!^ ordtionifubtrdbwnt uerbd, (y uelut fdtii P^ foiÂ« ipfoÃ¯ qw^e dicere uelmt, e^uAntum dd dUoi perti* ââ0ââigt;KibilpHMfl^ â¦ At ego otiofum fermonem dixerm, tÃ¿^nAuditor fuomgeniointcUigit.C^uiddinemutdtis in ptrnerfum didis, defiguris idem uitium confe^wm*

tnt .Pefma mYo fivnt Ã J'ravoxTa, boe cfl,qÂ«Â« uerbis ^ ^'j'Qâc'ijâ* lt;lpcrtd,occÂ«[to fenfu fumt, ut cÃ³dudut cSl exem fecut ui Ã ^fuerint nm Pire ,e3- qui fuos drtus morfu Idcerdffe fingitur m gt;quot;nbsp;^^^^^^ ola f'^^Â°^fuprdfecubdffe.ingeniofdbÂ£cetfortid,ut cxdito^fcuraquot; ^ ^^fiiidifertdcreddtur,perjÃ¯dut. At perudfite^uidÃ« idm fuwÂ« multos i^d perfuifto,ut id idm demu elegdnter,dtlt;j^ ex* quifite diftaw pHtent^quod iwterprf tendÃ®t ftSed dudi* toribiÂ« etu fionnuUÂ« griti bxc,qÂ«lt;e euw wteDexeriMt, ienm'me jiio deleftuwur,^ gdude/rt^noÂ« qiw/Ã¯ ((Â«diue* â^Wi qiwfj inuenerwjt, Nobw primdfit uirtut ferf^i P ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nerbdyedus or do, nom longu dildtd ebebt

470 W. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. probMUs, O' pUtiut impcritis erit, H^c e^ttloiu^fii obferMio. Nrfm rerum perj^icuitM ^Mo main prf^^^ ddfitjdiximut m pr^ceptis ndrrationK.SmliUX't^'^^ tio eR in omnibut, i^^mfi nei^ piuciori g oporfrt,w$ i plwlt;i,nelt;^ mordmitti, dut indijimdd dixertmut,crigt;^ dilttcidd, 0 negUgenter quaque dudientibm ip^t^ ^uididipfum in confiUoed hdbcndum,non femp(rtilt;^ ejje dcrein iudieÃ¼ intei^ionÃ«,ut obfcuritdtÃª dpui [c ip^t difcutidtyO tenebris ordtionis infent (ptodinn wffÃ gcntiefudclunien^led muit is eumfrequenter cogititioni bus duocdri,mÃ ti cldrdfucrtnt,quÂ£ dicemttsjitt in iniÂ» mum etut ordUo^utfol in oculos, etidmÃ m edin nan iÂ»^ tenddtur,mcurrdt. andre non ut inteiUgere poÃitjti ne omnino poÃit no 'tnteÃ¯ligere,curiniu. Propter quoi etidm repetimus fiepe, qure non fdtis perceptjfe cos,qm cognofrÃ¼t.putdmut. Que cdufd utic^ no^rd culpd adi obfcuriut eSl,qM cdufd dd pldniord, 0 commicnii md* gis uerbd defrendimus, cmi id ipfum optime fut, quoi nos dliqMndo non optime fecifre ftmuldin ts.

VÃnio nunc dd or nd tum, in quo fine duHopmi qudm in ceteris dicendi pdrtibus Ãb^ miulfft ordtor, Ndm emendute quidem^dc dilucide iictutiuM/e^ nue premium eR,mdgls^ uitijs edrere, qui tn ut dii^w à¥¤ mdgndm uirtutem ddeptus efre uidedris. lituentio ciM impcritis fepe communis ,difÃofttiomoiici doSirmi credi poteR, 0 quefunt dries dltiores plerum^ oe* cuUdtur^ut dries fintÂ» Denies omnid hec dd utiHM

e4upruw fohm referenilt;ifÂ»nt,CuÃ¯tu utro dti^ orndtit fe^Moq;commendit ip[c qui iicit, z^ mexttris indicÃ© uw doftoruwj/w boe uero etiim po^uUrem Idudem pcÂ» tit.Nce fortibus modo,[cd etufulgetibut Ar mis, pnUA, ^^ tlÂ« iÂ« cdÂ«/lt;( cA Cicero CoYnelij, qui non A^ccutus effet effet due doccHdo indicÃ© tdntwin,ZT utiliter detnu/m,dc Utine per do ut p.R. Ãgt;irÂ«r^ dicendo,ut populut Ko.ddmirdtionem fudm no âemfuTnon dcckwittionc t4Â»ttÂ«Â«,fcd etidm pldu[u confitereturSnb acclamation torntÂ« profeÃ©lÃ³tZy mAgnificentu^z^ nitor,z^ dutori* fed Â«isâ^au tÂ« cxprf/?it iÃ¼ihmfrdgorem. Nee trtm infoUtA Uw effet fu confitcre' prolecutd dicentem, ft uÃtAtA, ZT caterisftmilis Affa* *ââââ¢ iffet ordtio, AtÃ§ ego iÃ¼os credo qui Ader dm,nee fenfiff ff qiuifdcercw,Â«Â« ff ome iudieio^ ipiAufiffe, fed udut ^Weciptos, V (i^lt;gt; ^U^i^ ^ ^â*Â® ig^iifos,erupiffe m bme HobmtAtK dffÃ¨St'-cm. Sed ne edufdt quide pArwm co fert idem bic ordtionK orndtm.^dm qui libenter dudi^ wiii,Z3' WAgis Attendimt, ZT fdciUut credivitt, pk nwi^ ipfddekddtione edpiu^tur, nonnwtq ddmirdtionc auÂ» feruMtHr.^jdfti erfemm dffÃ¨rt ocuIk terror k dUquid^ V ffbnun ipfd non tdm nos confivnderentffi uit eorivtn tintum,non etidm ipfe fuigor timeretur.KeÃ©ieq-, CiceÂ» robÃ¼ipfisdd'amp;rutiemueriis quiddinepifiolA feribitt Nim floqMffMÃ¹m ^Â«ic ddmirdtionem non bdbet, nuUdm Uiieo, Ariffoteksquoqueedndempetenddm mdxime pKW.Sfdbicomdtw irepetAmenim) uirUif,fortifier Pquot;^!Â« fit, nee effeemmAtdm Icuitdtem, nee fuco emiÂ»

^^gt;'^Â»gt;i eolorem dmet, fdttgume ZT uiribtu nitedt, habest Hocdutew 4dcÃ³ KcrÂ«wi f|l,Â»t cum in idc mdxime pdrte

put uidnuuirtutibiauitid, etidm qui tii^sÂ»tititÂ«f^^ tutis turnrn bis nomen impondttt,Ciudrenemo Â«Â«ââââ pt is dicdt,me immic.m effe culte diccntibiis, NoÂ« Â«^SÂ® hdne efJeuirtutent/ediUis edm non tribuo,Anc^oi'^^ dum cultioremputem, in quo mihi quis ojienderii bh^j CT Molds, cr dmeenos fontes [urgentes, qudm uUfitM meÃ is,dut gr duesÃuHu uites eruti Sterilem pldM^'^f tonfds^ myrtos,qudm mdritdm uImivnkGruberesolai prdoptduerimf Hdbednt iUd diuites, licet quid effent, dUud nihil hdberentiUuUus 'ne ergo etid ffuUiferis ddt bibendus eÃ¼ decorfquis negAt: f^dmefin ordinem eet td^ interudUd redigdmmeds drbores. Quidemmi^e Quincunx, quincunce j[eciofiits, quid 'm qudmeun'^ pdrtemffedi

â¢ nbsp;nbsp;ueris rediusiSed protmus in ii qnolt;p prodep,ut tem fuccum Â£qt^litcr trdhdnt. Surgentid m ditum edetmin^ old ferro coercebo, 'm orbe fe formofim fundet apt o tmus ff uil urn rdmis pluribusferet.Ã¼eccntior eqiius,cd lÃ¯t iusdPri^dilidifiidÃ«uelocior.Pulcherdffeliui-fidtblÂ» td, cuius Idcertos exercitdtio expreÃit, idem certtmini utro pdrutior. Ã¯^unq uerdffecies db utilitdte diuiditur.Sed hoe quidem difcernere modici iudicij eil, iÃ¼ud obfem^ tionedignius,quodhicipfehoneffutorndtiisfffgt;ii^^* riÂ£ genere debet ejffeMridtus.Atq^ ut iprimdÃ¼i^Ãff^ ordidr,non idem demonÃrdtiuis,et deliberdtiuifSi igt;tdi^ cidlibus cdufisconueniet. Ndnq; illud genus oÃentÃ¼ioni compofftum,[oldm petit dudientiu/m uoluptdtem,ideoi^ omnes dicendi dries dperit,orndtu/m^ ordtionis expo* mt,ut qui non 'mfidietur, nee dd uidoridmÃed ddfolitnt

\ i^wjs popuhretUerUi nitidumfiguris iucundujtninÃel iionibus mignijicum,compoÃtionc elibontum^uelut wt ^itw ([uidim eloc^uentix mtuendum^zy p^nÃ¨ pcrtnÃi. dum ddbÃ¹.Nim cuentus ld ipfum non ld cMfim refen-iMr. At uii res igUur^z^ ueri dimicitio cSl,ultimut Ãt fitne lociK. Frittered non debet ([uiflt;iudm, ubi ni.ixmd f^Wmomentd uerfdntur:,de uerbit eÃe foUcitm.t^e^; ^oc cÃ´ f er t met,ut m bis nuUitsfit omitM, fed uti Ã§rgf fw,iQ' feueriorjeo mÃ¯nui confeÃui, prxcipuedd mdteÂ»

1 Ã®iitm iecÃ¶moditM. Ã¼dmety fuidendo fulUmtwi diie^tid f^tusyconeitltiut pofuiM,e3' miudieijs pubUegedfi^ ^âdfs^CitM/i pofcunt dccurdtius dicendi genus. At pri* MÂ«Â«m eonfibumjCdufdsÃ©ii ^ducorum,ut frec^uenter dcei-dit cilcuÃ¯orum,tpUYUi fermOt et diÃmUis ciirg mdgis de

dit poÃwUrfj^tHt cired fiiUicidid dffici, eut mind^Ã¯j red. hibitiortefudirf ^ Sfd dd propofitum. Et quonum orlt;t* tionis tim Â»mdtiw g per^icuitdSy dut in fingulis uerbis

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;f ft,4Kt in pluribiw pofitus,lt;[uid fepdrdtd, quid ebiunÃ¼d

;, fxig4t,conÃdf rrmMÃ®:qMilt;Â»| reHiÃme triditu eSt^per^ ^iMtitempropr'^Storndtumtrdnfiitis uerbif mdgis fgfÃ¯f. Scwm(Â«MjorÂ«4tHm eÃe eptodfit impropnum.Sei cKmidcm/reqHenti/^Hne plwrd fignificet,epuod o'ouÃ¼bvu-^^'Â« wocitÂ«r,wm funt dlijs dlidbonefiiordÃÃ¼biimiordf ^^^^iâ^'fiiucwndiordâuocdliord. N^mutfyUihgÃ¨litc* fit wclins fonintibtu ^um chriores, itd ueridÃ¨ fyUdiis quot;Â»^S^f Wc4t^, Â©â¢ quo pbi qw^^j JJgt;iritMi bAkt, (Â«Â«ditÂ«

474 M, FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. pulchrior^Â£t(luodfdcitfyÃAiiirum,idcmuerior^iio^ inter fe copuliitio,ut aliud alij iundum tneHuil'onctXii^â uerfm eji tarnen ujuf. ^am rebus atrocibiw uerii rtiÂ® ipfo auditu aj^era magis conuenient. In uniuerfum ^w dem optima fimplieium ereduntur, ^ue aut maxime ex* clamant,out fonofunt iucudifiima,lÃ t honeÃa qaiiÃ« tw pibus potior a femper, neefordidis unq in oratione ntt dita locui.Clara iÃ¼a atqi fublmia plcrunlt;^ materie mo' do eernenda funt. Quod enim alibi magnijicu,tttniiittm alibi. Et c[UÂ£ humilia circa res magnat, apta circa minÂ» resuidentur-Etficut in oratione nitida notabilccji bu' miUiu uerbum, o- uclut macula, ita Ã fcrmoite tenui [ab time, nitidum^ difcordat,Ãt^ corruptum (luia in pit' no turnet. QÃ¿iedam no torn ratione ^amfenÃt iuiicM' tur,utitlud: CaÃaiungebantfoederaporcai leeit elegant, pitio nommis, lt;luod Ã ÃiijÃt porco, u^^ erat,in ^uibufda ratio maniÃÃa cÃ. Rifmus (^ 'ââ^â^^ nuper poetam,(jui dixerat. PrÃ©texta in eiÃa nanff^^* fere CamiUi. At VergilijmiramuriÃ¼ud- Sepeexi^sus mus. Harn epitheton exiguus aptum propriu tfÃdtfi^ plus expedaremus,^' cafus Ãngularis magifi^Â»^ claufula ipfa unius fyUabe non uÃtata addidiiff^^^'^'^' Imitatus eÃ ita^ utrunep; uoratiustliafcetur ^^* â^ mus. Nec augendafemper oratio,fedfubmld^^'^^^ nun^uam eÃ.vim rebus aliquando ty ipfa uerborum Â« militas affÃ¨rt. An cum dieit in Pifonem Cicero t ^^'^ tibi tota cognatiom farracoaduchatur, mcidiÃeiu ^ pur in for didum nomen ^wn co conteÂ»â^ti^gt;'^ ^^'â'^^â^*

nis cuneoconifcdm, Vnie mtefm vf^^ti idiotie io^ co to-Cl, (jwilfs ejt tue 4pKÂ£t M.TÂ«IÃ(HfM Pujw, qÂ«i cum mdiore ^ in Ti,no* forore cubUdbAt, Zir Plduius, c[ui cornicum oculos con- ^'ââJ^ â*'^Ã¯*, |Â»xÃ¼,Cr pro MiloneiUudincuf tu Kufcio,zy ^rutiui 'cornutus Antorti^jlfr. ld t^mÃ« in declimdtionibiis e^ notdbÃ¯lius.

âLiuidri!^ nc puera folebdt,dA pdtri pdnem,ZT in code ctidm; ednempdfeis. ReiquidÃ©pricipue in (choUs dnt ceps^^edfreepienter edufdrifus^nune utiq- cum bec exer eititioproculd ueritdteÃciunUdÃ¯dboret increiibiUuer lorum fi^idio^dc Ãbi mdgndm pdrtem [ermonii dbfcide rit.Cum fint dutem Â«ertd propriit,/iÃ«l.t, trdnJljtd, proÂ» prijsiigniMtÃ© ddt dnti([uitM. Ndnq; er [dnHiorem ZT wigK dimirdbikmfdcit Qrdtionem,cpiibus non quiltbet fucrdtufurus,eo(^orndmentodcemmiiudicij P.Ver-giliusunice eÃ Â«fus.oUi eniwjjÃ¶â quidnAjOquot; mis,z^ poÂ» \ Â«c,pclluccnt dd dÃ^rrgendi itldin, quÂ« etidm in pidiuris tligriuiÃimd,uctwÃdtii inimitable arti dutoritatc. admitabUÃª SeÃ¯uttndummodo,neccxÂ»ltiniK tenebrw repetenddÂ» Sdtis cÃ uctÂ«j,qttÂ£fo quid necejje eÃ diccre opptdÃ´,quo fuut up pdululwrn tempore noÃro fuperiorest Vcreor ut iim non ferat quifqudm. Certe dntigerio,cÂ»iÂ«j caiem fi gnificatio cÃ ,nemo nip ambitiofus utctur. AcrumndÂ« quid opus cÃ^ tanq paru fit p diedtur ,qdâ borridu reor, tolerAiledutumo. Trdgicuprokin dicfndo,uniucr-'b duÂ«ndum firn cius propipi ijinfwljum.QÃ¤id mÂ»ltd^ totui ;ppÃ¨ mu-tdtus eÃ fermo.Qu^dl tarnen ddbuc ucterd uctuÃate ip pgrdtius nitÃ«t, qiwddiCttAneccjJdnÃ³ interim fumutwÂ»

En5cupare -E.mMcipAre,O' fdri,z^ multi aUd ettd dudiÃ«tibiÂ» gf^ td mfmpoffun/tjed itd demum, ft non dppdredt iffl^^ tio. in qud mirifee VergiUus Et CorMiorum imitot iÃeuerborum.

Cimber hie fuit,d, quo fdtrem needtum hoc Ciceroni! ii Ho notdtum eHiGermdnum Cimber oeddit- t^eoniniu noto SdUuÃius epigrdmmdte mcefiturt

Gdiofdeurd.Ud eH cuiUbet fdcilis,zy hoc pefimd,quoi rdÃudiofut,non uerbd rebut dptduit, fed res fxtrmfe' cut dreef it, quibus hie uerbd conuenidntt Ã©nigere, ut t conuenit P^^Â° ^'^^ dixi,Grads m.-igis cocejfum ell, qui fonts etidm quibufddm,cy dÃvHibus non dubitduerui notnind dptdre,non dUd libertdte,q qud iUi primi homines rebus dppeUdtionesdederunt. NoÃriduteminiungenio,M deriuundo, pdulu dliquid dufi,uix in hoc fdtis reciptun' tur.Udm memini iuuenis admodu inter PomponunnOquot; Seneedmetidm prafitiombus elfe irdcldtunij^n greens dmindt in trdgoedid did oportui/fet. At ueteres ne ex' peHordt quidem timuerunS, Et fdnÃ¨ dufdÃ©noheeHexs mimt. At in trdHu cy dcclindtione tdbd funt,quilii d' pud Cicerone bedtitdt Qr bedtitudo, qua durd quidein fentit,uerÃtdmenufuputdtpo/femoUiriÂ» HecduerUi.

d Cicerone fHbuadlt;itum,CTah Afinio fimbridtum, ^â11*ââquot;â V' figuldtum. Multd ex GrÂ£co formdtdiioud, de pluri' ^ Afranio ttxii Sergio llduiocy, quorum iurd c^uÂ£id dimoium Dura quoetÃ® Â«idfntur,Ht ens zy effent id: quÂ« cur tdutopere aff erne ^jjâ^j^j^Æ, ttur nihil uideo, nift quod miqui iuiieei dduerfus nosfu que ens amp;nbsp;ef Wjdeo^pdupertdte fermonisIdhordmus: QUiCddm lt;Â«quot;ââ?- ^âiP timen perdurent.Ndm er quÂ« ueterd nunc funt,fuerM bur^^Ã©^^ olim noui.Et quicddm w ufÂ» perquum reeÃ«tid, utM.cfJd Plauto, U prmuÃ¯ redtu,munerdriu Auguflus primus dixerunt^ Reitum nemo dnte Uleffdldm^^unerdriÃ¼ nemo ante AU guÃumdixerit. Pirdtiedmquoq;utmuÃamz:r fdbri-am dici idbuc dubitibint mei prtceptores^ 'Eduorem^ tS- urUnum Cicero noud credit. Nim er in epi/lold dd BrÂ«tÂ«m:Eum,iÂ«qMit,lt;lt;tKore,cr eurn (ut boe uerio utdr) fiKorem inconÃUu dduocdio,et di Appium pulchrumi Te hominem non folum fdpientem,uerumetid,ut nunc la ^^mv,rjurhcinum.liemputdtd,XereMioprimudi(lum BonÂ« putaR 'JJÂ®#qiÂ«UM.C(eciIÂ«Â»Ã¯ dd Sifenndm,Albenti cÅlo.CcrÂ« âAndrem tficeinuideturiiortenÃusprimusdixijfe. l^dmueteres poetsindied plMrdiÃ¯tcrdppcUdbdtU.Audcndumitdqj^Neqj enimdecÃ© S*^o^X do Celfo^ qÂ«j 4t ordtore Uerlgt;d.Ãngi uetdt^ Ndm eu Ãnt forum diid,ut dicit Cicero, ndtiud,ii e^,ciUÂ£ ÃgniÃedtd

1 fÂ«wprMnopnfu,dIidrepcrtd,qÂ«ieexl3W fdftd/untjUt i^mnolisponereAlilt;iud.quÂ£iÃ¼irudeshommes primii^ ^plrtiao fecerunt,fds nÃ¶ Ãt, ieriuire, Ãe(iere,coniungere,cptoi nitw pofiedconccffumeH^cpidio deÃjtlicere^EtÃÂ£[uii 1^(rieuioÃu5ÃnxifJcuiiebimur,cptibu[dd remedies prÂ£-gt;

muniendumeÃ: ut itudicum/i licet dtcerc^cluodilKoiOt m^fimti^ * ^^^â^ttâ^lt;^ tt^i^iÃc-QliOii Ã¯tl^^fÂ» f^ti^^ff ^ ^^ ^â^'â^ dam.ctiam tius trdnÃdtd crunt^proderit, c^u^ n5 tutÃ¨ did po^M-âquot; ^â* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;In ^uo non fdUi iudiciÃ¼ noÃru folicitudinc ipfd miniÃ'

flum erit. Qud de re Gr^cum erit illud degintiÃi' tnum,(iuopritcipituritd,-es^ci7ci7e?\.H(ff^THvm^So7oi' T rdnÃdtd probdri niÃm eStextu fermonis no poÃunt, Lib. i.ea, lo, Itdq^ defmgulis uerlic fdtis diilu,^uÂ£ ut dUo loco oÃot di,per fe nuUdm uirtutem hdbent. Scd ne inorndti funt quidctn,mÃ cum funt mÃ-d rei de qud lo^uenium eH di' gnitdtem,excepto Ã obfeand nudis nommibuf enuntifit tur. Qjiod uiderint qui non putdiit effeuitdndd, quid nee ÃtnoxuUd ndturd turpd,^^ Ãqud cR rei deformd tdc,dlid quoq; dppeUdtionc qudcunq; dd intededum ctin demnihilominui peruenidt. Ego Evomuni pudorismo' re contentut, utidm refÃondi tdlibus, uerccundiunfilen tio uindiedbo. Idm hmc igitur dd coniundi fermoni! ei tionem trinfedmus, Cuim orndtuf in bxeduopnniii uiditur, quim condpidmuf clocutionem,quo modo eÃeÂ» nmui t ^idm primum eil, ut liquedt dugere quid ueH* mui, fcilicet dn minuere, concitdte dicere dn modeeÃ^d Itete dn Ãuere, dbunddnter dn prefje, aÃerednlemtee, mdgniÃce dnfubtiliter,grduiter dn urbune. Eumquo tnnÃdtionis genere, quibudfiguris, qudlibut fententqs, quo modo, qud poÃremo coUoedtioe id quod intÃ©dimut efÃcerepoÃimus. CÂ£teru didurucquibiuorneturori tio, print ea que funt huic contrdrid lundi, dttingM. Nrt primd nirtus e{i uido arere, igitur dute omnii,ne

ORATOR. LIBER VIII. 479 ^frfmMfofndtrt omionÃ¨ fore,quÂ£ pYol^HUi non eritt VroheihHc Aut Cicero ii dicit^ejuod no plm mrnÃ»Ãue cÃ | dÂ«ct. Non c^uiA conti fxpolirt^ non delcAt (nA er bite omAtutpArseSl)fedc[uiAHitiutAubic^(luodn'miÃ¼eil It4^; uwlt effe AutoritAtÃ¨ m uerbis, fcntcntiAx,uei grd j^j^ IffÃ© autd-ncÃ¯,ucllt;ipt4lt; opinionibuthominuAemoribiu, Hw ewm ritatÃ©.inuer fdtuw,lieft Azurnere ca (juibiKÃluÃriÃeri orAtionÃ¨ pu* *ââ fÂ«âÂ«*Â»## tdt.Dcleftint trunpittd, (Ã¼pr^ktdjdd nomÃ¨ AdiunSiA^dtt pUciAjeAdem ÃigniÃcAntiAj Atlt;^ Ab witAtionermm non *(gt;boTrtitt w. Sfd ^Moniitm uitiA pnue demouÃrare dg* greÃi fum:Â«,Uflbof uitium JÃ¯t ^uoJ KaKÃ¯Zx$a7o/j uocA' turbine wuidconfuetudwe m obfcanum wteUeftum fer wo dctortiM fft,Â«t duftdrcf/frei lus, er pdtrm teilÂ« dpui SiHuÃik, didlt;i [Ande et antique ridentur Ã nobis^ Ã dijs pUctt,qu4 culpa non feribentium quidem ludico, ffdlcgentium/atnc uiMÂ«dagt;qÂ«dtiMtÂ« uerba bourra mo ribiÂ«pfrdidÂ»rtMÃ¯,CrfÂ«iwce?tttbiÂ« ctiÃ¯uiltjs erdendum f ft, fiue iunfturd deforwiter [onAt, ut fi cum bominibus notiÃ¯loqsinos dicitnus,m/iboctp[ufflbommibus me* diufitjin pÃ¯ffata uidewur incidere^quia tilthna priorij fjllabx litfra,qua exprimi ni[i Ubrw cocutibw non poÂ» tcÃ,aHt mtcrfiÃere nos indeeÃ«tij^ime cogit, aut cotiwwd ticuinIfquÃ«tcinnatwrAciuÃ¯corrÃ¼pitMr.AlidEcoiMnftio âwsdiqdfiwile ftciunt,quas pfcquilongÃ¼ c(d,in to uitio q'âo4uitidufdicHniM,cofÂ«orAtcs.SeddiÂ«ipo quo^jdf* fciiHÃ¼j fert tiniÃ¨ iniuriampudori.ut fi intercapedinis nto caf^ qs Â»Utur.Nce fcripto modo id accidit, fed etia fenp pic

480 M. FAB. QVINT, INSTIT, QÂ«f 4â ^^âââ^ tneUord putat Â« Ac ex uerOf t^ueliiâi^l'' finie ab obfcxnititc abfiint,occdfiioncm turpituii^K^ n HÃ¯cenima- ^^^^'^^^^^â^^'^^^^[â^^^^â^^^^â^tondpud VergliK^^^^â pud Vergilifl ^^^âpiuM dgitdtd tume[cere. quoi fit recipid^, Â«kf^^, de inari iien qui tt(tum eR.Defiormitdtiproxmunt eA humditittis ui cunfur. Â° ^^^'^ ^â*Â°lt;i Tcem'ivuxip uocdtH,qudreimdgnitiiioudii ex ea gnitdt mmuitur^ut fixed cR uerrued in jummo mon' Xne dixÃ¯ffe ^^ iiertice.Cui ndtun contrdriu,fiederrore pdr eH, pif CatonÃª au' tiisddreexcedcntidtnodÃ¼nomind^nificiiniexiniiijÃ¯rii tor Â£ Gelhâ. fj^f^ ^JJ|^^ cdptdmrjtdqi nee pdtriciddm nequa dixcrii hontmem,nec deditumfiorte nicretrici nefidriu,tiuoi d' terumpdrum, dherumnimuesit Proiniequdddtnhi' ber^fiordidddeiund^trifids.mgrdtdyUilii ordtio eÃ.Qud uitidfdcilimefiunt mdnifeftd contrdrijs uirtutibut^Ã¯^i'Â» primum dcuto/ecundum nitido,tertia eopiO)O,ddiiceps hildri,ii(cundo^dccurdto diuerfiunt e^i.'Vitddiet /dilatÃ© Cig^cum fiermoni quident decR dliquid, quo minus ple^ nus (it, qudnquA id obficurÂ£ pottus q inormte oritioms uitiumeR^ScdhocquoqiCunidprudentibusfitjfi^^ââ^ dici (Ã¶let, ficut Tamp;vÃ¯oAoyia., id eÃ¼, dufident utrUt^quot;^ quan^ ma Ã^^o^ij itermtio, uec enim, qudnq non inigno^â mis autorP fiummis dutoribus uitdtdjmterm uitium uiderifotdtJ'^ bus uitata, ta q^Q^i Ãp^ i^cidit etidtn Ciceroficcurus tdm pif ui Â® Æâ' nbsp;nbsp;)

iudiciffimilc indices non fuit. Interim niutdto nomine, ^TTMa'^H-big dicitur,dtq; eR ZT ipfiuminter fehemiti, quoru excmpld iUo loco reddd,quo uirtuteserut. Pdof hoc Ã¨iJ.oio?ioy!lt;x cf^quic milldudrietdtis grdtidhuit

tidiHm, dtqj rÃ Md coloris unius, ejux maxime depre* benditwr cdrtns Me ordtorid. Erf^j et 'm [ententijsyCr figww, er compoÃtione longd^non dnmis [olum/ed e^

Lfgati non impetrata pace retro iomÃ¼.imde uenerdnt^ abicrunt. Sed buic uicind periÃhrdÃs uirtus bdletur. EÃ er â BsÃiovow'/jioâÃ§ Â»itiujCK (Â«pernacHw uerbw onera fur oratio s Ego rneis oculis Â«idi* Satis eft en ini ,Â«idi.

â Emcndauitbocetiarnttrbanciit HirfiumCiccro: Cui Hirci1 cau' cum in Panfam dedamans, ÃHumd mdtre decern menÃ- p^^quot;Â°; je

. bus inutcro latum effe dixi/Jet. Quid sâ alitC,mquit,in damansfiliS 1 nbsp;nbsp;pcnula foie nt ferre ? Nonnunquam tarnen illud gernÂ«, â^^^^

\ cuius exemplum priorcloco pofui, a^irmationis gratia utero dixif* adbibetur: vocemqjbwauribtMbau/i. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fÂ«-

At uitium trit,quotics otioÃum fue r!t,Ã¼- fupererit, non cum adijeietur. Eft etiam qua TOi^^^la uocatur, cum (uperuacua (ut Ãc dixerim) opcrojitas, ut Ã diligenti cÂ« riofus,Q Ã religione {uperÃitio diÃat. Atq; ut femel Ã niamjUerbumornnequod ncq; witcllcftum adiuMat,nc-que ornatH,Hitiofum,dici poteÃ, KotKo'^HXopjid eÃ,mala Cacozelon. a^ftatiojper omne dicendi genus peccat. Nam er tu-miAa,o- exilia, er pr^dulcia, c abundantia,er arcef-

1 fitajO-exultantiafubidcmnomencadunt.Dcniq^ KaKO ?MZop uocatur ,quicquid eft ultra uirtutÃ«.quoties inge* nium iudicio caret, er J^ecie boni faUitur, omniu in do quentia uitiorum peÃnnum.Nam cetera parum uitatur, boepetitur.Eft autem totumw docutione* Nam rer urn

tntidfunt/Ã®ult!im,c5rnunc,contriir:ttrn,fÃ¹pcruicuiÃ®-Cor rupta oratio in uerbit maxime mproprijf,rcduniiiuiâ buf,coprehcnfione obfcurdycopoÃtioitefriidit^ uxanji milium, dut dmbigudrupucrUi eÃ¤ptatione confiait' Eil MtÃ« omne KKKÃ^HAop uiiq- fdlfum,ctidmÃ non ornntfii fumuxw^HÃo/j^ut eu dicitur dUter qÃ ndturdixigt;et,(T qudm oportet,zr qfdt eÃ. Totidem dute gmerihu cor rumpitur ordtio,quot orndtur. Srd de he pdrtc er Â«Â« dlio noÃro opere pleniios diÃÃ¼eA, et in hoc fipeirdUd bitur, zrctdhuc Ãgt;drgctur omnibus Iods. Lociuentes enm deomdtu, Ãubtnde quit Ãunt uitdndd,Ãinilid nirtU' tibus uitid, dicemus. Sunt morndtd ZT ha'yquodmdleii JÃoÃtÃ¼eÃ,id amp;'joiKÃ¼vÃ³^HTop:quod mdic Ãgurdtu,iiâd' KtmUdVâ ^d/J-ado/j: quad mdie collocdtu,id wxuoctwSaop noest, Scd de diÃgt;oÃtione diximud,dcÃguris et cÃ¶poÃtilt;âgt;^^^ cemus, Koivierpta'i^ quoq; dppeUdturqusdÃ¤tnoihdcx udrid rdtione lingudru ordtio,ut Attids, Ã¼oeieÃ lom^^ Cd, Aeolicd, etid diÃ¤d conÃindds.CuiÃmHenidn^l^ iip^ nos,Ã quisÃublmid humilibus,ueterd nouis, poetia uni gdribin mifeedt. id enim tdlc eÃ monÃru,qnilc Hof^'^ in primd pdrte libri de Arte PoÃ«tiedÃngit:

Humsno cdpiticeruicem pidor equindtn, ^i*''amp;^^ Ãuclit. EteseterdexdiuerÃsndturisfubip^^^' Omdtu eÃ quod perfÃteuo de probdbili plm e^-^iu^P texprimi ff,i Ãuntgrddus in co quod uelis exprimÃ«io eonctpicii do^,Tertius quihxc nitidiord fdeidt, quoi proprio it' xeriscultum.Udq; ivi^yda/jjcuiusinpnceptis ndrrd' tiondfeci mentionemf quid plus efl eiÃ¹dentid, nel ut t^

dicKtt^Ã¯fprrff ntdtio, quim ff )Ã?icuitA5, amp;nbsp;Â«Hud qui ^^ ^quot;jj^, drm pdtft,blt;fc fe quodSmodo oÃf ndt^intfr orHiinicntrf ^j patst,hoc poniimm. Magna uirtiw eÃ res ie ([uHiu lo([uimur,cli' Ã¯f, atq; ut efrni uideAntur enuncidre. Non f Â«hn ÃÃ¤tis cf ficit, Â«rij; ut debtt plcnc ionindtur ordtio,fi uf^} di du wuolctjdt^j edÃbi iudex de quibtw cognofcit,ndrrdri tTfdit,non exprimi/t oculit mentis oÃfndi,Sed quonia pluhbus niodKdccipi folet ,nenequidÃ¨ irt omnes edm in ea parti partifulÂ« ÃcAbo,lt;[tidrum dmbitiofe, Ã quibufdam nunte'â^â locabo VHS dugrtur, [ed maxime nreeÃdriM attingam. tÃ igi-turumumgenus, f^uototdrerum imago quodammodo

^Mttra^quf nolis iUdm pugiÃ¯umcongredientiudeiem i^doÃndunt,utnoncldriorfuturdfutritfÃc{idntiius.

PlHrimm in boe genere fuut in at eris eminetClCEt Citeto in hy vo. An quifquam tarn proeul Ã cencipir ndÂ« iwaginibuÃ¯ jâ*^g^sâ^'* verum Â«beÃ, ut cum ilia in Verrem kgit; Stetit foleatus rut artifex. Pvetor popu.Ro. cum paHio purpurro,f unicÃ¤^ talari, wwlirrcula nixus in Iittorr,non folu iffum os intueri ui-deaturjcz locÃ¼ ^7 hdbitum,Ãd qua dar turn ex bk quÂ« di^dnen^unt ÃliifÃ dÃrudt ? Egocertemibiccrnere âââ¢icoVjO' uultum,er oculoj, er deformes utriu'e^ Han digt;iÂ«,cr eorum qui adorant, tdcitdm duerfdtionem, dc ''âquot;'dimucrrcundiam. Interim ex pluribus effenur ^âi^iincondmurexprmerc fAcies ,ut eÃ apud run-â^'âââdunquead omnium ornandi uirtutum cxempluM XflwtKÃ¯ fuÃcidt)iniefcri^tione conuiuij luxuriofi

Videbar uidere alias wtrates, alias uero excites,quof eootatione ^^â'^ ^^^Â° uaddantest quafda beÃerna potatiow o^n tantes. Humus er at immunda, lutulenta unio, coronif languiduUs, er jaunis coaperta piÃeium. Quid fb wi' ret qui intraffet ^ Sic urbium captarum crefcit mistri' tia. Sine dubia enim qui dicit expugnata effe duitM, comple{lituromniaquÂ£cunqitalisfortunaredpit,Ãi ^x^bfs7x ââ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;âââ^ pÃ©nÃ©trÃ¢t breuis bic uelut nuntius. At /i

preffa ima- aperias hfc quÂ£ uerbo wno indufa erat,apparebut cjfa ^Â°â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fe per domos ac templa flamme, er ruentium tdiorum

fragor, er ex diuerfls clamoribiuumus quidam fonus, aliorumflugaincerta,alifiÂ»extremocoplexufuorumco herentes, er mfantin, fammarumqi ploratus, er malt nbsp;nbsp;|

ufq;in ilium diÃ© feruatifato fenes, turn dia profanoruÃ j facrorumq; dircdio,effvrentium predas repetentiumi^ difcurfus, er adiante fuum quif^ predonemcotenati, er conata retinere infante fuum mater, er f^ '**^'* lucrum cft,pugna inter uidores. Licet enim b^c ommi ut dixi,copledatur eucrfio,minus eÃ¢ tarnen totum dice re q omnia. Confequemurautemut mamftflifi^/'g rint ucrifjmilia,et licebit etidfalfo afflngere faeft^r ri falet.ContingiL eadem claritas etiam ex iccid^^^â ^' Aeneicl.it. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Mibi frigide horror nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.

Et trcpidx mÃ¤tra preffÃªrc ad paford natos, Atq; huiusfummit, indicia quidc meo, uirtutis fdciUma eJluia.fJaturd mtueamurJhdefequamur.Omnif tl^Ãª* tia circa opera uitx eÃ¢.Ad fc refert qui[^ ^â^^ (^^â^gt;^^

ORATOR. LIBER VIII. 48$ Uficilmc iccipiunt Mimi, quoi cognofeunt. PrÃ©dire MYO ii mfereniim rebm lueem repertx funt fimiUtU' Similitudo. diÂ»Â«,qÂ«itrM4liiÂ£ funt que proldtionis gretid inter dr-iumentdponuntur,dlie di expY'meidm rcrum imdginÃ¨ tÃpoÃte,quoi e^ buius loci proprium, inie lupi ceu Aneii 4. RaptorÂ« dtrd m nebuld^cri MiÃt duifimiÃ¯is,que cir cok'ttoM,dreu, PifcofosfcopuloshumiUs uoldtequo nmd. Quo in genere iiem precipue cuflodie niu,ne ii quoi ÃmiUtuimis grdtid dfciuimus,dut obfcurumÃity Mi ignotu. Hebet enim quoi iHufirUe dterius rei grd iiddffumitur, ipfumefjecldriuteo qi'iHumindt. Qudre ^oitisquiiem permittdmui fdnÃ¨ huiufmoii exempU:

QimIk ubi hybemdm Hycidm Xdntbi^j fluentd ^eferit, dUt Delon mdterndm inuiÃt Apollo, Non tdÃ¨ iecc bit ordtore, ut occultis dpertd iemonÃret. SfJiUMdqMog; de quo in drgumenth diximux,Ãmilitudi nu gtoKj orndt ordtionem, fdcit^ fabUmem, Ãoriditrn, iitcÂ«nd4()i,mir4bnc* Nlt;lt;m ^M0 quxqj longius petite eft, boe plus ifÃrt nouitdtii, dtq^ mexpeStdid mdgis eSt, IIJ4 uulgirw uideri poffunt,e:^ utHidtMtu di concilidn dim Ãiem,ut terrdm cultu,Ãc dnimum iifcipÃ¯inis melio rem uberioremq; Ãeri. Et Â«t medici dbdlicndtd morbit membre pritciduntjitit turpÂ« de perniciofos, etidmÃ no ^K fiHguinc cÃ³heredntydmputdios.ldm fubiimiui idud pw ATcbi4;S.Â«4 ut$ foUtuiincs uoci ref^oniet,beÃie f^piiÂ« immdnescdntufle{iuntur,dtlt;^ conÃÃunt,cr eg' tfMQjod quidÃ© genus d quibufidm iecUmdtorid mdt J'iweli'cftttMcorrwptwm ejt. N^m erfi^ utuntur,nec

iÃ¼ti hu ^mbus trndeÃmilu uideri uolunt^ipfU^^iâl''^ rum utrun^ in hu eH, ciux mc inucnc ubiq; eMtiri [oie bdnt:iviagnorutn flummum niuigdbilcs fontes fmt, O' generoÃoris drborÃ» Ãdtim plMtd eu ÃuHueSi.inoM dutÃ« pdÃ¯dboldjdut prxcedit ÃmiUtudo, c res fee^tur, Mt prÂ£ccdit res, erÃmiUtudo (equitur,fcd interim H' berd er fepdrdtd cR,interim quad langeoptmÃ¼eSlyCH re cuius eÃ¤ imdgo, connectur colldtione inuieÃ« ref^on dente,quod fdcit redditio contrdrid,quÂ£ ivlums^oini dicitur. Pr^cedit Ãmilitudocuiui modo fedmentionc: Inde hipt ceu Kdptorefdtrd in nebuld. Sequitur m pri mo GÃ©orgie on poÃ longdm de bellis ciuiiibiu dtlt;^ exter nis conqueflionemt nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1

Vt cum edreeribui fefe effuiere quddrig e, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;)

Adduntfeinffdtid, (yÃuÃrdretindculi tendens Pertur equis durigd,neque dudit currut bdbends.

Sed hitc funtÃne dntdpodoÃ. R edditio dut iSd rÃ« utri^ qudm compdrdt,uelut fubijdt ocuÃ¯d,er p^riter o^Ã«did Cuirn pncldrd dpud Vergiliumultdreperio exempli, fed ordtorijs potius utendum eA.Didt Cicero pro MU' rcendt Vt diunt in Grieds drtifidbus, eos dulxdosejfe, qui dthdrexdÃ® fieri non potuerunt, Ãc nos uidemus^ qui ordtores euddere non potuerunt,eos dd iuris jilt;sdiu ie* uenire. lUud pro eodem idm penÃ¨ poÃ«tica Ãiritu, fii ti mencum fudredditione,quode{lddorndtum dccom' moddtius. Ndm ut tempefidtesfape certo dliquo calift' gno comouÃ«tur,fiepe ex improuifÂ», nuUd ex certd rdtio ne^obfurd dHqud edufd cocitdiitur,ftc in hdf eomitiori

kmpf/ljtf popuUrt fepe mteUigM^quo pgnocommotn fit,life iti obfeur'a e^,ut fine exuft concitdtd nidedtur, Sunt amp;nbsp;iUi brcnes:Vdgiq; fcrfyludt rituferdrum^ Et illutiCiceroti in Clodiut Quo exiudicio uelut ex tnee^ dio nudui effugittOwbut fimilid pofunt cuieÃ^i etidm fx quotidiuno fermone fuccurrere, Huie fnbidcet uirtm non fltt dperte ponendi rem dnte oculos/ed dreumcife â¢tt^iidontcr. At merit6 Iduddtnr breuitd^ mtegrd, fed M miniÂ« prf/lut quoties nihil dicit,nifi quod necelfe fÃ ÃjaXâ^VW nocd,t,qude reddetur interfchcmdid-Blt Â«fro pukbfrrmti/M plKM pducis cÃ¶ple(imur,qudle tl-Ind SaDuÃg cRtlAitriddtes corpore mgenti pminde dr I WAtUÃ¯. Hoc mdle imitdntes fequitur obfeurihu. Vicind \ p'tiii^e,^ dmplior uirtut eft t/x(pc(criÃ§,dltiorem pr^ tens mtededÃ, q eptem uerbd per feipfd decldrdnt. EilÂ« duif funt precies,dlterd qut plmfignificdt 5 didt,diterd qÂ«Â« etidm id quod non didt.Prior ch et dpud nomeru, ^omt/ieneldusGrdioi m equum dfeendiffe dityndmuer'' ^otmomignitudmem eiiuoHÃ«dit, Et dpud VergiltÂ«:

Dfmijjum Idpfi perfunem. Ndm fic quoque did' Aeneid. t. tÂ«do demonUrdtd eh. idem Cyclops cum idcuiffe dicit ^fâ'â*' *â¢ per Mtrum,prodigiofumillud corpus f^idtio loci men' fus eft.Sequfnj pofitum eh tn wocc^nut ornnmo lupref--Kiwtrtiitm dbfciHd. Supprimitur uox, wt fedtpro Ligirio Cicero: Quod ft m tdntd fortund bonitdX tin' timon f(Jct,qÂ«A tu per te mqudm obtinestinteUigo quid Mâ!*:. Tdcuitcmwiliud quodnihilommuf dedpimuSf f^ottiteflc bomiftfs qui tui crwdflitntfm cum impf Hunt.

Abfeinditurper k-Kia-iaTTWip, qu^ quoniim^^Ãamp;â^' rlt;i,reddeturfuo loco, EÃ¢ m uulgiribus quo^tx^ t^i^^^^ Ã¼iuendum emphAftstVirum effe oportet,er hogt;fgt;lt;gt; ^^ ide,^'^^^

dendumcÃ¼.AdeÃ¨fimilKeilArtiplerunq;nituÃ¯i- Nou tdmenfdtii eloquentie cA, edde quibui diat, cUre iti^ cuidenter oftendere, fed funt multi ^udrij excolenit ordtionis modi.Ucim ipfa ilhi amp;(pi2.amp;ix. fimplex et imfji Adtd hdbet quÃ«ddm puru, qudlis etidm infantinK dmi' tur^omdtum. Etfunt queddm uelut Ã¨ tenui diligÃ©tid eh edproprietdtemfignifiedtionem^ munditie,Alidccpi locuplcs,dlid floribmUtdjUiriumno unumgenu:. N4Â« quicquid m {ito generefdtK ef]iAu eA, Udlet : Preciftti tdmÃª dus operd AdvaicriQ inexdggerddd mdi^didte, er in ceteris dltitudo queddimepwiiccria in concipien* dis uifionibus,^i^ylt;xa'lct in efficiendo uelut operepra pofito,cuiddijcitur t7ri^i^yxlt;f'/lt;x repetitioprobitids eiufdc,er cumulus ex dhunddti,ivsÂ°yalt;x confinis bis eji, db Agenda duAd,er cuius proprid fit uirtus not fie que dicuntur otiofd, eA er dmdrum quiddum, quoi ferÃ¨ iÂ« c5 enim ui ^Â°gt;fbumelid pofitum eA,qudle CdÃij: duidfucies cuin in bona tua M bond tud mudferoi hoc eA cum te docuero ne fare md Ctinrefpo ^^^^â^^^^- Et dcre,ut itlud CrdÃi: Ego te cofiilempiUem, fum i Philip cum tu no pÃ»tes me fendtorem ^ SÃ©duis ordtoris omnii ^^m t^^ ^ dugendo minuendo^ confifiid Viriep pdrti totiiem modi,cxquibusprecipuosdttingemus,rcliqui fmilts erunt^Sunt dutpofiti m rebus er uerbisSed que fit reÂ» rum muentio de rdtio trdAdumus, nunc quid elocutio sittoÃ¼dtfdut deprimdt, dicendum,

PR-Wi cft igitur AmpUÃcMdi uel m\nuenii species m ipjo rei nomine^ ut cum eum qÂ«i fit cgfia, occiÂ» firnteum qÂ«t fit improius,liitronem : contruÃ©^ eum ^wi pxifiuittittigijfe^tiui uulnerMitfijefiffedicimM. ytrigt; ^Ã$ f inter cxemfljm efipro M.C/ItoiSt uHm lihere, proterw petulxnter,iiucs effttfiÂ£,lÃ¯bii'inofii meretricio â¢wore uiucret,iiulterum ego futiremfi quw blt;tnc p^uÂ» 10 liberijw [uiutiffet^i^dm O' mpuiieum meretricem wo tiuit^o eum cui longior cum ÃU fiuerut ufutdtticriut fit ^iiSe,]ioc genus mcrefiitticfit mAnififiiui,fi umpUo* ^iuerlicum ipfix nommibus, pro lt;[uibus ed pofixturi fit tntK^cQnfirdnturtUtCiceroi/n'Verrcm: Noneniw fin* ttm,fiiriptoremi non ddulterum,fied, expugmtorem tlt;*iieitie:non fidcrUegwmtfiei hofiem fidcrorumreiigio ^'â gt;mlt;^:nanfiicdriâjM,fiei cruieUfiimtim arnificem dui* âwrociorum^ in uefirum iuiidu diiuximus, lUo enim ââ10,Ht fit muitum,bocetidm plus ut fiit^effidtur. Qu_d tHor timed maxime generibin uiieo confiirc umpUfied ^ioi'em^ncrementoycompdrdtione^rdtiocmdtionejcon* i^ne.incrementwm eft potentifimu^cum mdgnd uiien ^itetiimtjuic'mfieriordfiunt. ld dut grdiuwnofit,Aut P^KÃ¯ibueper td uenitur non moio ad fitanmum,fed mte â'âââ' lt;lHodammodo fiuprd fiummum. Omnibus his fiffidt â'1 Hnum Qiceronis exemplum ; Fiewui eÃ¹ umdre dÂ» **^'^^oin.fielHsuerberdrc,propÃ¨pdriddium necdrCt

â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Hb s

490 M. FAB. QVINT. TNSTIT-fdcmat, lt;itiod ent inferiuÂ«. EtÃ tintum ocd^i^^lf^* per plures grddui dfeendent. Cum aero dixcritrââfâ' pdricidium necdre/upri f^uod nihil ell ddiecit, f*^ âââ edm in crucem toUerefUd cum id c^uod mdxm ime^'^^ mpdffet, neceffe erdt m eo t^uod ukrd ell uerbd if^ re.Â¥it cr dlitcrfuprd fummum ddieHio, ut dpui 'If^Ã¿ liumdeLdufo: nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;(^o pulchrior diter

lion fuit^excepto Ldurentii corpore Tumi. Summum ell enim quo pulchrior diter non fuit. Huit it mde dUquid Ãuprd poÃtum cÃ.Tertim quo^ eji moiuit ad quem non per gradm itur,ut q^wd non eÃ pliuqW'â mdximumjed quo nihil mdiuteH: iJldtremtudmocdit Ãi^quid dicdmdmpliusfmdtrcm IMm oeddiÃd NMff hoc dugendi genui dl, tantum dliquid eÃieere, Â«t wt po^it dugcri.Crefcit oratio mmui aperte, fed nefcietÂ» hoc iplo t fÃcdeius, cum citra diÃMionem in contextÂ» er curfu Ãmper aliquid priore maiut mfequitw, lt;*^^ uomitu in AntonÃ¼vm CiceroM eoetu uero popuk^^â negotium publicum gerent, magiÃer equitum. Swgquot;'^ incrementum habent Â« Per fe deforme,uelnÃineeetgt;Â»i^ mere,in eoetu etiam non populi, populi etiant non Rom^^ ni,uclÃ nullum negotium dgeret,uelÃ non pubUtiini) finonmagiÃer equitum. SedaUut diuidertl^^^gt;f^ circa Ãngulot graduÃ© moraretur , hic m fiiihmtetiM currit, er ad fummum peruenit, non nixu,f(d impdÂ», V er.im ut hitc ampUfiedtio in fuperiora tendit, tW qâ^ fit per comparationem, incrementum exminoTibtuptt tit.Augendo enim quad cA mÃa,neceffe eÃextolUtii

^Â«oJ fuprd po/Ã®ttwn eft, Kt idem dÃ©q; in codem l )co : Si boc tibi inter cÅndw, cr in lUw immduibtÂ« poculw tuK AcÃ iilfet,lt;Ã¿tis nonturpeiuccret i incatuutro popwli Ro. Et in CdtiÃ¼ndintSerw mrbcrcle mei, fimei^o pado mtuerent,^ te metiwu omnes dues tui,iom'm meant TflmqnendtWi putdrem. Idterim propopto Me Int ftmili fxemplo ejjiciÃ«ivm ed,ut Ãt mains td quod Ã nobw ex* Â«igjcrdndumcftjUt idem proCluentio,câamrxpo'^uiffet Mib/Ã®wn qiwnddm 4 fecundit h^redihus pro ab or tu pc ciwiMm accepijjetduamo ed,mcpiit, OppidniciÂ« m est ^ew minna maiore fuppUcio dignusiSic^uidem lUd own fuocorpori uim attuÃ¯iffet,ÃeipÃa cruciiuit,t)icautent iÃud idem effidt per aUeni corporis uim dtqj erweidtu* ^â putf t c[uiÃiuAm boc,qM4nqu4m eft fmHe, iUi ex ars-Z^ntis loco qÂ«o maiora ex mmoribus coUigwntuvt idem e^e, lUic enint probatio petitur, bic ampUÃeatia, fient mOppidnico non id agitun biccomparatione, ut itte mde feceritfid ut peius^EÃ tarnen quanqium diuer fmm rtrum quseddm uiemia. Kepetam itaq^ bic qiioq; iieiÂ»,cjuo Ãm idic ufas, exemplam, fed non 'm eiwdcm nfunt.Ndmboc mibi oÃended'm eft augendi gratia,no totd modo tot'K,Ãed etiam partes partibus ebparar^Ã-Â» w boe loco: AÂ» Â«ero uir ampliÃimus P â¢ Scipio Pont.

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^â'â âVib.Grdccb ,Â«n mediocriter laheÃadamem Ãatum â'''publieÂ« priiwtw 'mterfecit, Catilmam orbem terra â'^' âquot;^ weendio ua^are cupientem nosconf niet per* râ^nifHic er Cdtilmd Grdcebo, er Ãdus reipublica ^^detrinimtet mediocrif labeÃadatio cadi et 'mccaÂ»

diÃ er MÃdtioni, er priudtus confulibut â^^'^^^^i^i^i^ qua ft quis dildtdre uelit,pknos per fmg^fl^ ^Â°^^^. j dt.Ciudt dixi per rdtioemdtiontm fieri amplified' uidcamusdn Ãdtis proprio uerbo ftÃ¿tduerinâ^^^' in hoc [olicitus, dumres ipfduokinihM redt.Hoc fum tarnen fiecutus,quod hac amplified bi pofitd eS,dlibi miet, ut aliud crefcdt,dliui dugettÂ«^ gt;nbsp;frationc du wdc ad id quod extoUi uolumus, rdtio dedneitur-^fâ^ durus Antonio Cicero merum CT uomitiMi'^UyWqx^, ' P'ââ iflisfducSusfifiislateribuStiftdgÃ¯ddiatoridtotiuteoe*^

' pimefunt aÃimdrc,quantumiUeumililHippuoi^Pr rit, quod firre esr coquere non pojfet iHd corporis firmitdte. Ergo ft ex dlio coUigitur tÃ¼^ â .^^ improprium, nee muÃt uturn nomen eS nis,ut quod ex eudem edufd inter Ãdtut quoq;^^^ â fic ex infequentibus dmpUÃedtio ducitur- S/^^f'ââ * td uit fuerit uini erumpentis,ut nonafum nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;gt;

di,Ã§y cibiu non mens,utdccidereinteritÂ»fol(()fâ ^^^ retur, fed qui ufq; in poflerum diem reiitni^', hoc pr^eÃunt qua dntecefferu^t.Ã®Jdm cam AÂ«â''^ â*' nonerogituf nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;*

Impulit in ldtut,dc uenti uelut domine fddo, QÃ¿d ddtd porta ruunt, Appdret quMtiÃtP^^ xd iepeÃat. Quidfcum ra dtroeiÃimdf, qudt^ â¢*Æ***

Ittim ipÃ txtÃ¹Umut 'muididmieleMmw cÃfulto, quo grd Â«:or4 uiieiintur qua fecuturd fivnt,utd Ciceronefa^u Aflio, vij. cft,cam iÃ¼d iieeret: Leuin Ãvnthiecin hoc reo crmimdi metuuirgdrÃ nduArchusnohiliÃimeciuitdtis pretiorÃ© imit^buminÃ¼eÃ,iiliit5 ne fecuriferiretur,pecunia dei iit^uÃtitu eÃ¼^nonne u[us'ejl rlt;itiocwtitione:,qui coUigÃ¨ vet ((M(ltÃ©tÂ«,qiWfÂ«M Hiud effet quod infereidtur, cUi co pirÃ¼ilatechumdnduiderentur, dt^ ufitdtdC Sicquoi^ fokt ex ilio dUud dugeri,ut cum Annibdlis beUids Idu* dAw impUdtur uirtus Scipionit^zt fortitudmem GdU ^orumGerrndnorum^ mirdmur gt;nbsp;quo Ãt mdior C.Cicfd* rif glorw. inÂ«d quoqi eft ex rehtionc dd dUquid^ quod non eilÂ« rei gr^tÃ¹ eÃ¼i^twi uidetur dtnpliÃedtionis ge* nw. i^onputdnt indigntim Troidni principes, Grdios Troidnesq^ propter Helent ffeciem tot muld^tdnto ted porÂ«Ãjdtio Iufftnere,qug ndm igitur iUdformd credeii dd fAtNon enim hoc dicit Pdris,qui rdpuit,non dliquii iÂ«Â«rnM,iut umÂ« c mdgoffed fcnes,amp; prudentiÃimi,et Priimo dÃiientes.'Verwm etipfe rex decenn^ beÃo ex* hduÃus, dmiÃis tot Ãberis, imminente fummo dfferimi* w, cui fdciem iÃ¼dm ex qud tot Idchrymdrum origo Ãu* tiffetj,nM[dm dt^i dbomindnddm cffe oportebdt, cz Â«tu (litbxc,o- MW Ãidm dppeUdns iuxtd fe locdt,Gr eXcu* fit etiim^dt^ Ãhieffe rndlorum eduÃdm Â»egdt.Nfc mibi Â«iietur m ÃympoÃio Pldto, ewn Alcibiddem conÃtement lt;Jf Ã qwd Ã Soerdte pdti uolucrit,ndrrdt,ut ilium cuipi rd,bdctrddidiffeffed ut Soerdtis muilldm continenti* dm oÃ(nieeet,quÂ£ corn/mpi ffecioÃÃinii hommis tdni

obuKi uolwntdte non poffet-Quin ex tnflrum(ittoâtÂ»''^ heroum iUorum mignitudo tejltmandu nabis Hatinâ' aH boe pr'met clypeus Aidcis, Ziy haÃn PelUs Aebamp;iK-^^ uirtute egregie cR ufus in Cyclops VergiUwi l^dm qnod illud corpus meute concipUm^uius Truned msnu pinus rÃ©git. nbsp;nbsp;Quid feu uix lorid iw

JAultiplicÃ« connixi humeris PerrentjClMtuus DÃ©molit oSyCjUi indutus edm Curfu pdUntes Trods dgebsti Quid M.Tullius de M. Antonijluxuria tantumÃltttf fingere potuiffet, quantum ofiendit dicendo f Combyt liatis Cn.Pompeijperifiromatis feruorum in cellisÃn* tos leÃ¼osuideres. ConchyUata perifiroinata,G!-Cnâ Pompeij, er m cellis feruorum nihil poteH dici ultra, er neceffecÃ¼ tarnen ultra infinito plusin domino cot gitare. EÃ¢ hoc fimile idi quod Emphafis dicitur,lcd ilia ex uerbo, hoc ex re coniciluram facit, tantoque plus ualct, quanta res ip fa uerbis eil firmior. Pote^ aferit tiampUficationi congeriesquoque uerlorum,ic fins tentiarumidem fignificantium, tlametiamft nonper gradus afeendantsttmtn uelut accruo quodamudeiuns tur. Quid en'm tuns itle Tubero dijiridus in ode Phar faUca gladius agebat Genius latusillc mucro pitebatf qui fenfus erat urmorum tuorum f qua: tin mens f ocus lifmanus f ardor anmi f quid cupiebas f quid optakaf Simile eR hoc figurÂ£,quam oâcu)Â«amp;^oia'/ao/j uocant. Sei illic plurium rerum eR congeries, hie unites multiplia* tio. HÂ£c etiam crefeere folet uerbis omnibus alt ins at* que altius infurgeitfibustAderatiatfitor carceris,cami*

ORATOR. LIBER VIIL 49^ ffx Pretorii^mors terror^} fociorum cr duium Rotwet Â«orÂ«m,Iiftor Stxtiut. 'Endern fere eH rntio mwuendi, l^nntotUem fwnt nfeendentihui e^uod defc ende nt ihm pidM. lde()([ue imo era exempla contentiu eim lod^ quo Cicero m orntione 'R.uUihoc dicittPaud tarnen qui proximi imiter dut,nefdo (paid iUum de lege agrdrid uo ^i^edicere fufpiedhdMur.Qjiod ft ad intcUtdu/m refc Ã¯iÂ«,miÂ«utio ehiÃ ad Ã³bfcuritdtem, mcrementam. Sda f^^Ãaideri e^uibafdam fÃeciem ampliÃcntionis hyper* tolfÂ» quoq;. NdÂ« cr hec m Mtrdwq'; purfetw wiet, fei ffiiiexeedit hoe nomen,dn tropos diÃeredd ed,Quos commuÃ³ fuiUngtrem,niÃ effet Ã exteris fepdrdnddn tio dicfudi^qwf conÃdt non propr'^s,fed trdnÃntis.De* ww ergo Ireuiter hoe deÃderio tam pcnÃ¨ publico, nee omittjmui cum (JÂ«fÂ« pM^ prÂ£dpuuni de pene folwn

TiegenerihiesSententidrum. CAP. V. Sentent SEwmidm Â«etewqnoJ dniwo fenfiffent aoedue*

fW(d.\d ewm eÃ apad ordtores ÃeepuentiÃmu, turn ttidmmufu quotididno epufdam reliepÃ dx habet * Ndm ts-iaraturi exanminoÃri fententid,^^ gratulantet tx Ãmentid dic'tmM .Non raro tarnen CfÃc locuti fwnt^ Â«t ffnfd fud dicerent. Nam fenfut eorporis uidebamur,^^^^' pdeonfuetHdo iam tenait,ut meute eoneepta fenfut Â«o* f^'ffmiÂ«,lMnjin44utcnj, pr^dpae^inclaafulii poÃta^ pwntiÂ«,^Â«^ miniÂ« crebra apad andepios,noÃr(s tem pwibÂ«t niodo edrcnt.ldeÃ³pue mihi z^ de generibiÂ« ed* âTÂ«Â»Â«deufaarbitror paacd dicÃ©ddt Awtp.iiÃim^fwni

lt;jÂ«lt;e propriit, g^muis omnibus idem fit nomen,[tquot;^^* tf/aiiJ-x- tU uocMtury^uAS Gritciyvd/jitx^dppeÃ¼ditt, Vtfi**Ã¯â tdmen nomen ex eo Acceperwnt^^^uod fimilesfv^t^^^r lijs dtq; dÃ©crÃ©tÃ©s.Ejl Mtem bÂ£c vox wiiuerfilift Ã*quot;^ ^ ^^ ProLigario. lt;^gt;tt citru compÃ¯exum edufje pofit ejfe liudMit, W^' rim ad rem tdutum reldtd, ut, nihil eUtdm pofu^ft quAmbonitds : Interimdd perfondm,cjUileellAf'â^^ mitij: Princeps (jui uult omnid fcire,neccjfe hibetmiih Nam ois ar tdignofeere.HdnequidAmpdrtem enthyinemitis,lt;iiâ^ gumentatio ddminitiumdutcldufuldm epiebiremdtis ejfe dixeruntt nmprimÃ¤ e:^^^ dUtjUdndo fimplcx,UtedejUim fuprddixi:lt;Â«K* tang uniuer qudndordtione fubieddi nummomni certdminetjui damfenten^ opulentior eÃ¼/tidmfi dccipit tniuridm,tdmen (juU fl^ nam habet, potent, fdeere uidetur .nonnun^uAmdupUcent: 0y ^^quot;MHonia/^^â'ââââ*'â'^Â®^ââ^â''^Â®'^*^?'*â''^ SiWtetidUf'jââ ^ na, uim ui cem generd fecerumt, fed eo modo lt;juo ferine' P '^'f repeiiere li' poUif^t^pef interrogdtionem, eompdrÃ¤tionciOjinp^*

tionem, fimUitudmem, ddmirdtionem, er eri^^^ ^^^'' fmodi.Per omnes enimfigurds trdildri pote^* l*^ âââ tdbile ex diuerfist Hors mi ferd non dl, dditus dd mor* tem mifer eÃ¯l.Ac rede cjuidÃ© funt tiles:Pdgt;n deeH^â^^ ro quad hdbet,lt;judm quad non hÃ¼bet. Sed mdiorem mm dccipiÃ¼tex mutdtione figurit, ut,uf(^ddeÃ³nemori mije rum ef^Acriut enim hoc,^ perfe,mors miftd noneÃ¹. Ex trdnÃdtione d comwni dd proprium.ndm cvmfit re dum, nocere fdcile dl, prodeffe difficile. Vehementim apud Ouidium Hededdicit:

Verrit dd perpudw Cicerot Nihil habet CÂ£fir nee for* Sententia j? tiwid tiu iÂ»lt;ttiK,qÂ«dm ut poÃK-.nee Mturi meUiu, e^ukm pâro ligan'a Muelii fenurc q^mpiurmos, lUejux erunt rerum fTot^rii,fccit homing, lÂ» hoe gene re euÃoiiendum eSl^ Vii lt;[iÃ¼ifmuiique,ne crebrx ftnt^nepilMfcdf^yt^ui* kÃ¯feejuenter Ab hts dicuntur qÂ«i hxc catholics uoeAnt, 5^^* Cquicquid procAufAuidetur^eÃ¿MfÃ¹ndubitdtumprot cuiuiscauf* Â«uwidiUj cr ne pAÃim,(y Ã (luociw^ue dicAntw.^A conuemen-gis fnim decet eos,m ({uibus eit Autorit At,ut reipondiÂ« tÂ« paffim. etiiin ptr^onAeonfrmet. QÃ¿if enm fer At puerum, Aut ^ * ^yoeun AioÃ¯efce)ttuhim,Aut etiAm ignÃ³bÃ¼cm,fi iudicet m dieen* *^^* â'â âquot;^* do, er c^uoiammodo pricepiAt t ^hymemA ^wo^ efl Enthymema omne quoi mente cocipimut, proprie tAmÃ© dicitur,(iu*e eSiÃmemiA ex contrArijs,proptered quad emmere uit' ietur inter etter At, ut Homerut poÃ«tA,urbs Rowd.De hoc in Argumentis (Atis diHwm eft. Non femper Autem Ai probAtionem Adhibetur, fed Alicpando Ad ornAtu/mt Quorum igitwr imptwiitOÃ¯ CtfAr tut elemÃ¨tit lAiu eSt,

' ^uiAfttrAtiodiÃmilis Â»fed ^uiAiAm per AliAutid min* \ nbsp;nbsp;Ãum AppAreret/ffÃ¨Hum er At, Et uddila in elAufuÃA c^

tpiphonemutw modo non tAm probAtio, ^KÃ m extrem A qiufi infubtio. Efl eÂ»iÂ« epiphodcnw rei nirrÃ¼t, Â«ci Epiphont' PâfobÂ«lt;ftrtÂ«Â«j((^cc|4,â4{:,o;

49S M. FAB. QVINT. iNSTlT* domrunt ei, tfue non dicunt,uerum inteUigi uohi^â^^ in emn quem fiepiut 4 ludo redement Ãoror ewm ed tdUonK quad ei potiieem dormiemi rccHijj^^' ^ra dignui ut haberes integrim mdnumt. Sic enbÂ» i^gt;** ' Cidufula, ^*^*'Â» ^i^ depugndres, Voedtur dliquid GT cldu/tdi, qgt;gt;f ft eÃ¼ quod conclujionem dicimut^i^ reac,et quibuÃi^^ in pdrtibut neceffdrid eH : Q_Ã¿dre prias defdiloue^t^

fitedmini neceffe cÃ, qudm Ligdrij culpdm uÃ¼dm reff^ henddtit.Sed nunc illud uolut,ut omnis locM^omnis t^gt;^^ fut in fine fÃ¨rmonis feridt durem.Turpe dutem er pro* pÃ¨ nefdt ducunt rej^irdre uUo loco, qui dccldmdtioncoi non petierit. inde mmuti corrupti^ fenÃeuli, er rx^^^ rem petiti. Neep enim poffumt tdm multf femeiUie elle, quimneceffe e^ mulu fint cldufiuhe. IdmbtcmdÃ¿sÂ»^^ ud fentÃ¨tidru/m genen ex inopindto,ut dixit ViÃâ* ^^* finit in cum,qui cum loriedtus in faro dmbtd^^'f^f^ tedebdtÃe id metufdceretQjtis tibi fie titiieroporrgt;âp . Etinfigmter Afriednut dpud EicronemÃ³e rsortc mit tris: Kogdut te Ccefdr GdHu tut,ut fÃ©licitÃ©e tuiWfot titer fient. Sutsi er dUo reldtd, ut A fier DowfW^â^ ClodmiÃ¼dm defiendtrel,cui obicÃ¤um crimoir, quoivn qui inter rebelUntes fiuerdt, fiepclififictiremifior^fi ut,in epitogo fiUoseius dUoquens: Mdtrewiit^â^^ â pueri fiepeÃ®itote.Et dÃ¯iiimde petitd,id eH,!^ lt;''*** Â®^^ exdliotrdnfldtd,utproSpdtdle Crifiasiq^uinqui t redem dmdtor infiituerdt, decefiit, cum bdberct MW duodeuiginti * O hominem diumum, qui fidgt;i ludup Edeit qudfiddmficfftentids fioldgcnundtioi qudUse^Ss*

HfCitwro fcripto yC^uod Åroid femtu/mwifit occi^ fiMre,cwm fe pericUtitum uideriucUet Ã® SrtlMwmmc f/fe ddbwc Â«f c credo, Â«Â« gdudco. KeUor cum ex com Ciceronis.

lgt;fo.Qttid,lt;âqÂ«o(J miler cum lolt;Ã¿Ã¹ non pallet,tdeere non poUrdtjErf uerojit puicherrwid, cum aUejUd cempdrd* tiow cldrefcit.rrdchdUm contra SpdthdlemVldcent ht

, ergo Ifgfj, diUgentiÃmt pudoris encodes, dfrWdÂ« Â«xoriktÂ« ddri, lt;[Udrtdt meretricihiK iulent. Srd herum c^uiitm gmeru er hont did poUiwt cr mdhedUt lemdâ fff Mtioli^ud d uerio,'Pdtres confer ipti,Ãcenim meid pirodum eft mibijKt memmeritis pdtrum, Peim ddhuc quo mdgii f^lfum fft cr longiut petitum. Contrd an* iernfororem glddidtoris, cuiut modi fccimentionemt Ad digituw mihi pugnduL Eft etidm generK dufdem, cuiufdain Â«fpio dn uitioÃÃimum, ({uoties ueriorum dmbiguitds tfi^nrwnfdildtpaddm ÃmiUtudmeiumgitur. Ã¢drum dMtorÃ« iuuenif dudiui,cum ledd m edpite cuiufddm ofÃi f^lt;'ââ ('v.lÂ£Ã¿â itiitenendimdtridedijJ(tâ At^fdiciÃmdiae fÂ»'nid nonius extuUÃiÃlium,Oâ ÃM olÃd legiÃiAd hoc H'â'â$ wmmiÃ® etidm 'muentinnculis gdudent, quÂ« ex* f'^Ufrifum hdhent,muentiefdcieingenij ilundiimtur, 0Â« fo qui nduji-dgut, V dwÃ¨ doorwin ÃeriUtdte uexd* ^^^^IchoUfÃngiturfcÃuÃ^enÃ¤iffe. Qtiem nee terrdre ^âN^Hfe mdrfjfendedt. Huie Ãmile m iHo de quo fMpri dixijcuip4t(y. luimemhrdldcerdnti uenenu de dit,did bÂ«fdiyf{,et boefcibere. Et in luxuriofum,^uiii.7ro* Â«Â«jTijurt^ fmu}dUe dicitÂ«r. Hefte Idqucu, bdbej quoi

^oo M. FAB. QVINT, INSTIT',^ faudbui tuii irdlcdrit, Sume uenenui dcc^i ^'*****'''â41# uaria bibÃ¨do morLAUn MnA^utfuAdentis pur^uriti^^^

xindrum Bdbylonis incendia fepelidnt^AlexiM't^'^ fcpeliojhocquifqMmj^cdabit Ã¨tedo^(jiufttttnn I' in re toti MigniÃim amÂ» Alia nimi^,ut de GerÃ¶nne eentem eptendim dudiui : Ciput nefcio ubi impof^^* Bt de uirofortit HeUd u/mbone propeUit. Scd finis non erit ,fi finguldt corruptorM profequdr forma â¢ potiiu, quad eÃ¼ mdgK neceffdrium. Dui font dincnl^ opmiones, dliorum fententidx foldf penÃ¨ f^eildntiu,na^ or urn omnino damnirUium, eptoram mihi neutram di* modum placet.Denfttm edrum obÃdt inuicern, ut in ft* farborum ^^^ omnibus fi'udibu(qi druorMn,^uoru/m nihil ad tuf* magnitudinem ddolefcere pateel,quad loco iÂ« qucin ere fcdtiCdret.Hec pidurd in eptd nihil circtwUtum eÃ¼, ^quot;tt net. ideo^i drtificei etidm cum plurd in unam tibuhm ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;contuleruntjj^dtijs difimguant,ne ambra in torpori

cdddÂ»t,Fdcit res eddem concifdm qÂ«o$ ordtionomtSub* fijlit enm omnir feHtentid,ideop^ pad edin Uiitptt d^ui eH mitium.Vndc folutdferÃ¨ ordtio,et Ã¨ fingulis noninÃ« brK,fed frufiii coÃdtd,{lrudurd cdret, cum iHd fauna dd er Mtdit^ circumcifd mfiftere inuiccmneipieiitt.Pre ter hoe etidin color ipfÃ¨ dicendi quamJibet clerus, Â«Â«ItiÃ¯ aferent lu' ^^^^ '^ ^^^1^ ^^^'^^ mdcuUs couffergitur. ^om ut men clariuj dffÃ¨rt turnen clduus purpura loco infertut, itd certe net htoi^ru. âquot;^ decent inter textd pluribus notie ttefis,Quire U eet hÂ£c er nitere, er dUqudtenut extdre uidednturpdt menGrlummdiÃ¼dnon Ãdmmlt;e ^ fed [cimiUis inter fit

HUM tmidintihuf ftmiUi dixeris, qÂ«Â« Â»e rffpiirejÂ«: qui* icm,uhi toti lucct ordtio,ut in foleftderi ipf^ dtÃnu'nt ctrni/t quÂ£ crtlris pdruisq^condtibui p dttollivnijtn* tquiUdtdntivm Oquot; w:lutconfrdgofd,nec ddmirdtionein ^on[cquunturemincntiâ.mif^pldnorumgrdtidmpcr* drat. Hoc ^Â«og; dccidit, quod folM cdftdnti fententi* que accent ^,muhM nccelÃe eft dicerc IfuesfiigidM^me^tM.^on tnm poteft effe deieduiyUli numÃ©ro libordtur.itdqi ui ^fiÂ« O' dmÃone pro fententid poni,Gf drgumeniu, Ã fi tamtn in !lt;lt;'Â»/Â« mclduÃuUcdlcepronucietur.OccidiÃiuxoreipfe daufub 8f_ Â«idultf r,Â«ofi ferrÃ© te etidÃ repudidffes,diuiÃo cd.Nii ^âtu^ 'Â°'quot;* Ãire uenenu c^e dmdtoriijm? uiueretbomoniÃ iUud li* ^^^i^^i'^rgumentum ed.l^ecmultdx pleriqi feniÃ«tiux di* ^'i^tyfeiomnidtdnqfeittÃ©tidx. H uicquHufddcotrdri -mine ^fludiu^qui fugiwnt dcreformiddm omnÃª Idnc in di* twdo HolHpMtÃ«,Â»ibiI proldtUes niÃ pldnÃ¼^et humile,et fwe con^M. iw dÃ¯wn timet ne dli'qÃ¯do cddlt;twlt;,fcmper id efHt.Q^od CKÂ»Â» tdittu m fentewid land crime eft; non Ã¯'*â^ prodeft ^nÃ indicÃ© mouet^non dicentÃ© comenddt?

At ejl quoddS genw quo ueteres non utÃ©ldutur.^ dd Â£Â« quod* ^Â«2 uf^ nos uocdtis uetuÃdtei t^idmÃ iUd extremijnul dam ta Demojlbenej qu^e dntc ewm nemo, Qtto modo poted probdre dcc ronÃ©,qui nilÃ¼ putet ex Cdtone GrdeebÃ¼^ ^â ^atandufSfd utu e bos Ãmplicior ddbuc rdtio loquÃ©di

Ego Â«cro bxc kmin^ ordtionis, uelut ociAos quof* ffle doquentu credo. Sed ne^ oculoÃ¯ effe toto cor Pw Kflb ,ne exterd mÃ©lrdfuum offcium perddnt. Et /i Ntef^ept jÂ«f{f rem iUij^ honore dicÃ©di mdUm^quamp;m li 5

iÃ^m MMm licentidm, Sed pdtet medii lt;jutiifÂ» lt;*^^K cut in cultu uiÂ£lu^ deeeÃU dUquif citri reprehenji^''^ *9âquot;^' nitor, !^ucmfw ut poffumut idijeiimm uirtutHtit''^*

M timen fit uitijs cdrere,nedumuolumusejjetnew'gt; neteribuffimM tiotum diÃtmUcs. Rcddiin mtiKA^ froximim cUcdixcrAm pur tern de tropts,lt;ltgt;o!'^Â°^â^ cliriÃmi nofiroru Mtores uoeint.Horum triderep^^ cepti (ygrimmitici (aient. Sc di me,caw deiUortiej!' do lolt;^ucrcr,dildtd pin hiec dij epdi de ornntu orit^ nÃ©s griuior uidebitur locus,et miiori operifirMditt'

T^Kopus ell uerbi uel firmonis Ã proprii pgr tionein ilidm cum uirtute mutitio. Cird

^xplicdbilis ar grimmiticis inter ipfoSiCT pW^r pugm di, qug fiat generi, slugj^ecies, ijui quis cui(Ã fubijcidtur.lSlos omiÃts quctnthilddin^^^ dum ordtorem pertmÃ«t eduUUtionibut, neceUdrid xme dtg; in ufum receptos exequemur, boe niodo in * dnnotdÃcconteti, quofddmgrdtid fignificitioniSjtli^r^ ddm dÃ©corÃ©s dffumi, et effeditos in uerbÃ©s propriÃ; ^ in trdnfidtÃ©s, uerti^ formas, non uerborum ^ '^*' CZ finfuum,cr compofitionÃ©s. Qt^drennbiÃ^^''^^'^ *'^fj^i lt;1^ non dUos crediderunt tropos,^lt;f^ ** Ã*' tierbum pro uerbo poneretur. Nf $ illud ignora,m ijp dem ferÃ¨ qui Ãgnifiedndi gr aid ddhibentur,ejie (T or* tidtum,fed na idem dccidet cotUrd, crunt^ qiuddintin turn dd fpeciem dccommoddti. Incipiiinuf igiturdb eo quicum fiequentiÃimusediftum longe pulchcrrmuti

ORATOR. LIBER VllI. JOJ if^^litionc dicOiflut fxiTalt;fo^Ã . gr^ce uoedtur. QwÂ« quideuf cio itd elk di ip fa noOi cocejja natur d, ut mdo di ^Mo^j de non fcMicutcs eafrcciucnter utdiitur,tu itd iÂ«cHÂ»ttld dt^ nitiix,ut in oratione (^udmUbet Hard,pro* friotdmrn lufuwic eluccdt. Ne^j enim Milgdris ejje,nf:c ^^nÃ¼ii^necmfMuis,rc{iemododfcitAÃt,poteSitCopb ^p^^f^jc^j^ lt;itÂ« qtog; fermonii duget permutdndo, dut mutuantâ j^ ^Â®4Â«d nonhdiet,(iuÃ³d(iuedifficilmi'amell, prlt;efidtne inutando *Â® rei nomen deeÃe uidedtur. Transfert ergo nomen.

^lit ueriian, ex eo loco m ({uo proprium eft, m ciwn in quo dut proprium deell,aut tranflatum proprio meUut fft-U facimus,aut ejuia neceffe eÃ¼,aut quiafignifcanti v^Aut^ut dixi^c^uia decentie, Vbi nibil horum prdÃd* tif.quod transferetur,improprium crit. Kecefitate ru Piet dicunt gemmam m uitibus, QÂ«id enm dicerait dli tii^ vftirefegetes, O'fruduf labordre. Ã¯flecefitate

Â«oÃ¯ durum boÂ»jtMctÂ«,dÂ«t d^eriMW.Non enim proprium Â«rot qwd ddremiÃ bÂ« affÃ¨ilibut nomen, lam ineen fum fri, er mÃdmmdtwÂ« eÂ«piditdtc, CT lapfum errorefiÂ» gnificanH gratia. Nihil enim borum fuis uerbis,([uam bis accerfitis magis proprium erdMÃd dd orndtuwjÂ«^ wen orationis^sy generis claritatem, er concionum ^.,0^^^^^ proeeHiÂ« c eioquniti Æ flumina, ut Cicero pro Milone num Clodium[o)ttcÂ»j glorijf dus Uocat,et alioloco fepetem, ^ wdteridm. Quicddm etiarn parum fpedofa Aihu per bincexpUcantur:

^^finwnt nmio ne luxu obtufior ufus Sitgenitdli druoft^-fuicQf oH^net mertet, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'quot;^^^

$04 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT, ^ IÂ« totrnn dutem metaphord breuior cR fimiUtuio, Â«$ difidt^quod iUd compdrdturrei qudmuolumuf exprimer rc,hgc pro ipfd re dicitur.Compdrdtio ell cum dicoft* ci{fequid hominem,utleonem. TrdnÃdtio,cumdioit homine Ico cÃ. Huius nis omnis quddruplex mixnne Ã¹* detur, cum 'm rebus dnimdUbus dliud pro dlio ponitUTÂ» ut de dgitdtorct

us Scipionem 4 Cdtone ddldtrdri folitum refert. wd* md pro dlijs generis eiufdÃ« fumuntur^t: nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;CldÃi^

immittit hdbends. Aut pro rebus dumdUbus wduimi: Verro dnfdto uirtus Argiuum occidit. nbsp;nbsp;Aut contrat

Sedet mfcius dito AccipiÃ©s fonitufdxi deuertice piÃof-t^^rmi' ^^^^^^^^^^ ^^ ^â^ ^^gt;*f t^fd fublimitds, ^Â«^ lt;âââ^ââ* me periculÃ¼ cu proximd, periculo trdnfldtionis dttoUitur, cum re* neittoihi ^^ f^Ã^^'^ edrentibus dilum quendim er dunnes ismust quiliseÃ: nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Pantern'mdigndtui Ardxes.

Et tUi Ciceronis:QtÃ¿d en'm tuus iÃ¼e r obere iÃt^^ in deie phdrfdiied glddius dgebdtfCuius Istus dl^ '^^ petebdt f eiuifenfus er il drmorum tuorum i Dupbedtur intÃ©rim hxcuirtusdpud Ver gib ums Perrum^drmdreucneno.

Kdm er ueneno drmdre,etferro drmdre trif^l'gt;tgt; tÃ-5Â« eitur hdc 'm plures, utd rdtiondli dd rdtiombiV id(Â»* de irrationdlibuSjCr hoe rntdeÃ«, quibus ftmilis rdtio eÃ, er d toto et d pdrtibus,fd idm non pueris precipmut, ut dccepto generef^ecies 'mteUigere non poÃint.Vtmo issus dutent dtyse opporttmuseius ufu i^Ãrdt oidt

ORATOR. LIBER VIII. $0$ tioncm^itdjreciucns ct Ã³bfcurdt,iy tÂ£dio complet.CoM tinwis uero in iUegoriiiin^O' Â£nigmdtlt;i exit.Sunt finiâ iim etiimhumUcs trdnjldtiones^t id de quo wodo dixt, fixed e^ ueYrt{Cii,zy fordidt. Non cnim ft Cicero rede fentinÃ® Keipublide dixit,foeiitÃ¼e hominumftgnifted!^ \dnxeo probem iUud quoq; ueteris ordtoristPerfecuifti RojÂ«AIiclt;e uomicdt.Optime^ Cicero demonftrdt edue '^ââ¦m,nt' ftt deformii trdnftdtio,(iudliA ed (ndm ipftseim ^^lt;gt;'f nempUs') Cdftrdtdm morte Aphiedni Rempu. er ^^few cwiÂ£ Glducid. Ne nirnio mdior, dut qÂ«od ftepiut ^^iÃ¼t,minor. t^ediÃmilK, epiorum exemple nimiufte qwtttfr deprel)cndet,(pii fcierit bec uitidefje., Sed et co P'^ iwo^ modum egreÃd uitiofd ed,prigcipue vn eddem Ãâ^Â«Â«.Suilt cy durf/d ed, d longmejudftmiUtudine du ^Â«,Â«t: Cdpitis nines, Ett

IÂ«ppitfr bgt;l,frnrfÃ¯ cdnd niue conftpuit dlprt. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;q^T^^ *

1Â« iÃ¼o Â«cro plurmu crrorw,qÂ«od cd (piÂ£ poetw,qui er oiNiiid ad uoluptdtem referunt,^^ plurmi uertere,etid tpP ^trineftitdte coguntur, permiffdftunt conuenire quidam ftiam profit putdnt.At ego in dgendo nee pajlo â'TO populi, dutore Homero dixcrm,nec uolucres pen* quot;Â« remigdre, licet VergÃ¼iiK in Apilus, de Dxddlo Ãie-'iofâ^iwr ftt ufus. lAetdpbord enim Mt Mednttm accu-F*Â« locum dekt, dut ft in dliennm uenit,plus udUre eo

i quem txpfUif^ Qyod dlilt;ptdnto penÃ¨ idm mdgis de fy^ 1ââÂ«docI)c dicaw.NÃ trdt^dtio permouendii dnmis pic

'âquot;$gt;Crftgndndis reins,de fub oculos fui^eiendis rc' ' f^f^ t^, lUc udridre fermwe poteft ut ex uno plureÂ»

inteUi^dmui, pdrte totum,jj^ccie genut, pr^cdentHiM fequentid,^! contra, omnid liberiord poÃ«tis tjuiin on* toribui.Ã¯^dm profd ut muerontm pro gliHo, Ã§r teSum pro domo,rccipiet,itd non puppm pro ndui,ne(dlictt{ prot.ibeÃ¼iÃ¯,^t rurfiu ut pro glddio ferrum, itdnÃ¶prÂ» equo quddrupedem ,'-Mdxime dutem m ordndo uMit numerorum iÃ¼d Ãibertds, lidm zy Liuimfdpe fic didt: 'Romdnus prjelio uiHor, cÃ¼ Komdnos uiciffe fgnifat, 'Et contrd Cicero dd 'Brutumt Populo, 'mquit, 'mpoluu tnuiiCrordtoresuift funtus,eumdefetdntumloquere' tur. Quodgenutnonordtionesmodiorndt,fedttidiÂ» quotididnifermons ufusrecipit. Cbuiiilt;ruii!Vf/iW uocdnt,cum o- id incontextu fennonit, quod tdcetur^t cipimui,Verbum en'im ex uerbo mtelligitur,quoiiÂ«teÃ¯ uitid Â£Â«AG4'Ã uoedtur: Arcddes dd portdf rueret trgo reddiMihi hdne Ãgurdm effe mdgis pldcet, ilHeer^â^^^'^^ *^mu^Im ^â^^^ ^^^'^ ^^*â*'^ inteÃ¼igitur ex dUo t

Â«Uu4 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â Ã^'^G â^ââ ^^ââ ^ ^^Ãª^ referunt fu]^enfdiuu(gt;^^^â

Vnde dppdret noÃ«ientdppropmqudre. idne^itgt;^'^ o^ tori conuenidt, nifi in drgumentdndo cum reifsquot;â Sed hoc db elocutionit rdtionediUdt. NÂ« pro^l^^ â^ gencre difcedit jtdilompcix, qua eH nominu p^â^ â^Â°'^â ne pofttio,cuius uit eft,pro eo quod dicitur,e'^^r^â^'^^. pter qudm dicitur, ponere. Sed ut dit Cicero hyp^^ rhetores dicunt. Uac 'muentd db inuentore, t^ f*^^^ db obfmentibu^ fignifedt, utt

HoratJAri Cereremcorruptdmundii, Pit Receptus TerrdÃ¯^eptumui duffes Aquilonibuiureet.

QÂ«od jit retro iurius. 'Kefert AUtem mc^uintum diÃM tropKi orAtori [ee^uAtur. N4m Â«t Vulcdttw pro igne wd Jo itHdiHimw, er Mrio lAArte pugnAtum, truiitus eft fcrmo,er Venmm 5 coitum mAgis Ã ixiffe ircet, it A Lt tcTHm er Cererf m pro Hino er p^tfif licentiiK, ^ut fori ffHfritlt;K ferAt. Sicutex co quod contmet, id quod con# ^mttAr,ufus recipit,ut bene morAtAi urbe5,er poculum fpotÂ«m,er feuÃ¯umfehx. Ad id quod contre cS,riiro Â«iÂ«dclt;itquKniftpoÃ«tAt tAmproxmwatietVcAegon. Ni/i forte hoc potiuj eft d.pojjcj)ore quod pofidetur^ Wbommem dfuorlt;tri, cuius p^trHnoniumconfumitur, quo modo jiunt innumeritbilf s J^eciet. Huius eniw funt gtntris,cumlt;tb AnnibAkdefAApud CAnnAs lexAgmtA âââdid dic'nnuSjCr dpud Tragicos dh EgiUo, er cdrmim Vergilij ucnijfe,cr Â«fWre commedtus qui d^rdntur fd# trilegium deprehfnfum^non fderik gMw,drÂ»Â«orum feien tiitml)dberc,nort drtk.lHud quoq; er poetk er ordtort W jTcquettj,quo cum quirfpeit ex eo quod e^citur oÃe dimiw.f^itn) er edrmwum dutorest

Et oTitor,priccipitcm irdm^ildrem AdokfcentiA,fegne otiu dicit, Eft ftiam buic tropo quiedd cum fynecdoebe uinnu. Kdm dico uultus hominis pro uwltw. Dico plurd ht'r qiâfinguldre cft,quod pnguldre eft,plurdlitcr. Sei **0 id dgo.ut tmu ex multis mteUigdtur (Â»dm id eft md# â¢âAPÂ»M) fed nomen immuto, ut cÃ duratd tcÃ¢Murcd^.

Ã§o8 M, F/B. QVINT. INSTIT. quÃanVeft Pââ/â^â*'â * * nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;difccdo, (luUnon cAniÃpiniiuri

pars auratu tum. Quie fin^uhperfequiminutiorise^curiejCti^ â¢^Ã¦ non ordtoreminfiruentilitK. AvfovofjMdxclutAliiitiii utroÃ§ ^*'ââ ^Â°â^tne pottit,poetis qiwq; modo frequentiÃwiit

f^ per epitheton, quid dctrdUo eo cui dpponitur, uM pro nomine, Tytider, PeUdet, zy ex bis que m quo^ funt precipud :

Crdtoribut etidm ft rdriK eita rei,nonnuÃ¼tu tdmen ufut eÃ¼. nX ut Tytiden zy PeUden non dixerint,itd dixerid â¦impius K * ttttpiumpro pdrricidd. PuerforemquoqiCdrthA^odi pamcida ^ ^umdntie pro Scipione,^}- Romdue eloqu^iepnÂ» cipem pro Cicerone pofuijfe non dubitent. Cicero ipÃ certe ufMeÃ hdc libertdte.Non multd peccA4,i)iqâ*âtdIlo fortifimo uiro fenior mdgiÃer. Ã¯^eutru eniiÂ» no'âââ^'^ PÂ® fitum ef,Ã§r utrunq; inteÃ¼igitur.ovo/j.a.loTeoiio-V^^^Ãâ* id efi,fiÃ io nomitti5,Grecis inter mdximtubdbit^ wVw tes, nobis uix permittitur. Et funtplurimdittipoÃtddb bis, qui fermonemprimi fecerunt,dptint(s^ÃtÃ¤ioM voce,lid mugitus,cr fibÃ¼us, et murmuriifdeinâ'^'^''^' Eicinde tdnq confummutd fint otd, nihil gentri '^Â»Â®f* mus ipft,cum multd quotidie db dntiquisfiÃ©Ã©d morutuh Vix mid que ^ayo^iva. uocdnt,que exuocibus tn ufumreceptisquocunq; modo decUndntur,nobis pn' mittimus, qudlid funt fuUdturit, er profcripturit, Atqm i^reati po fies pro Ulo fibred corondt!,ex eAdÃ«fidiotit

/Â«Â«t. Sf d boe fÃ©liciter eudluit, dt contrÃ©, uio pro eo Ewnuit. mfUcinf. In Greets oieUfeo coludumo z^c^ dure etu lungere uetdmur ^ui tolerdntcr uiiere feptentriones ui demur. Eo mdgis neceffdrid KÃ¶:7axÃ¯âlt;Â°''^Â»âÃ¯âââ^ ''^^^^ c^* titnm iiufionem, que non hdlentibus nomen f mm^ dc-eommoidt quod in proximo eÃ¼, fie:

^qâMmdiumdPdlUdisdrtc AediÃedntt erdpui T^gteoj; ^tidmleopdriet,dtpdtercji. Mille funt ^ee^O' dcetdbuld quiequid hdbet^zj- pixides cuiufeunq^ miteru funt^cf pdrricidd mdtris quoq^ dut frdtris m' terfe^or. riifcemendumÃ©^efi hoctotumd trinfutione geuw, quod dbufio dl, ubi nomen de fuit, trinfldtio ubi ^liud /uit. N4(H poÃ«te folent dbuÃue etidm i/n his rebus, qf^ibus nommdfud funt, uiemis potius uti,quod rdru m Pââlt;âp ejl. lUi quo$ quiddm xaTaxjHo'ftiâ ejfe uolunt,ci feotemeritdteuirtui^dutproluxurid liberdlitds dici* tur. A quibujbfcquidemdiffondntidfunt,quad 'mbit Â«Ott uertÃ¼rn pro uerbo ponitur, fed res pro re. Ne que fâ'lânputitquifqudm er luxuridzr liberdlitdtem ideni fignifedre^ueru id quod ft alius luxurii effe dicit, aliut bberalitatem^quimuis neutri dubium ft,bee effe diuer* [lt;â¢ Kaperef ex bis que dUter ftgnifiednt, (UtTaXH^zdÂ»* id 'li.trdttfH(Â«pti0j qÂ«/ ex dUo in aUud uelut uiam preÂ» Ãj'fjtifopiM er rdrif'mus,cr maxime improprius,GreÂ» eis tamenp-equÃ¨tior,qui Centaurum Cbirona, er VKirbS Squot;^? Ã´siiotÃ§ dtewnt. NoÃ¯ qÂ«M ferdt,fi Verrem fuem,dutJ^^f^f^P~^'^^ Lflittrndoftunirtomincmiwf EÃ¯lfrtimbfctÂ« metdlepfwirimTs^i-*wiwlt;(, ut inter id quod tranffevtur ft Â»nfdtiWÃ®widdm'quot;*â j^^^'^-j.^

full S qua soquot; gâ'^lt;^MSÂ«Â» wi ipfe pgiuficif/ed pr^ientis i^xs^d eft, a tropum magis af^damuf, ut habere wdeinMr,lt;jt**â fynonynwq wlocodeÃieremuil^dmeiusÃc^tientiÃmutn^xem dem funt 80- plum cR^ CAno,cMto,dico,itd edtto, dicot Wm f^ Â»f^' auti dÃ¯c?/^d ^^ ^^â^ â^â^'^^gt; ^^â^ diutiifs in eo morAndumt Â»ihlfquot;Â»^ nÃ¶folÃ¼ mo' uÃÃ¼Admoduuideo^niÃutdixiinniciijs,CÂ£tcrAiAt^gt;^^ dam^udox' fisf'âfi'^â^^^ Ãª^â'â^ââ^gt; Ã'^ ^d omAndAm mode) non Au^Â«^^ fed Â«hÃ¤lfte dAmorAtionemAjfumunturtC)mAtenimim^iJÃ´p,lt;Ã¿Hgt;i ^''quot;â 'P1Â°â' rodle dicimus AppoÃtum^d nSnuUii feinens diciturgt; l^ umitatÃ©^' poÃ¶l'^o ey fre^tientiui cy Itberiut utuntur, W^ Hli!P daflq^i. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tK dl coiienireuerlo cui Apponitur,(}-itAlt;Ã deleftÂ»

er humidA UMA in bis non reprebendmut. z^pnd orAto rem^niÃ ^liquid efÃcitur,rcdundAt. Turn AutÃ© cfÃattir, ÃÃne iÃ¼o quod dicitur minui dl,quAlidfunt: 0 Ã(^gt;^ abommAndum,o deformem libidine : ExornAturAUt^Â»* res tot A mAxme trAnÃdtionibut,cupiditi(effrcnAtA,Cf infAm fubÃruHiones. Etfoletfieri AÃtjsAdiundif'P^' tbeton tropii,ut Apud HergiliÃ¼,Turpis egefinjtJ quot;^^â^ fits fendlus, VeruntAmen tuliseA rAtiobuiufceuitUi' tK,ut fine Appofitis nudA fit, er uelut mcomptA orAtio, ne oneretur time multif. Na fit longA et itnpeditA,^ iÂ» quxfiionibus eAm indices fimilÃ¨ Agmini totidembxAS hu benti,quod milites quoq;, in quo et numerus (^ duplex, nccduplumuirium, quAnquAm nonfingulAmodofodc' tium plurA uerbA Apponi folent, ut:

Coniugio Ancbifi Veneris dignAtefuperboÂ» Sei hoc quoq; modo duo uerbA uni AppofitA, ne uerfum quidemdccuerint,SuntAutÃªquibusno uidoAturbic olno

^opUJ, qÂ«j4 nihil wrtdt. Neceffe eA enim femper ut ii qiwd fft dppofitum/t d propria dim fertig per fe Ãgniji ^^iOquot; fdcut dntonomdftdm. t^dm ft diedst Ilie qui Cdr ihigmem ^ NMÂ»Â«(lt;Â«tw euertit^dntonomdfd e^tfi ddie ^^ii,Scipio dppofitum, tJonpoteÃ ergo non effe iun-^utM.At cc^nyoficf. qudm muerftonern mierpreidtnur^ olmd uerbis^dliudfcnfu oÃendit, de etidm i/nterim coird Â«â¢*â¢Â».Vrim, Utt Onduis referent in mdre tenoui

TotHÃ®^ etidm iUe Hordtq locus, quo nduim pro republi ^i,Ãu(iuum tempeÃdtes pro bellis ciuilibus, portum pro i^fdtq^concordiddicit.'rdlc 'Lucretiust Lucre, iib. 41

PtVergilius: nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Georg, i.

Cf Me equiJftÂ« dudierdm,qudfcfubducere colles ^ââ¢fipiuiitjttiolli^ iugum demittere cliuo ^f^i ld dqudm,O' veteris confrddd edeumindfdgii ^'gt;tndcdrm'mibusueÃrum ferudÃe lAendlcdm.

Hoc ertint loco pr Â£ter name egterd proprijs dccifdfunt Â«Â«rbtf.Veyy,â 110 pdÃor Kendlcdsfid 'VergiUus eamp; iÂ»Â« *Æ '^dw.Hiibct ufum tdlis dUegorig jrequÃªter ordtio^ r^''^fototius,pleruni^ dpertis pmixtde^^Tolddpud Cicfrotifm tdUs: Hoc miror cnm,querorq- quenq bomt tiemitipe^Ãunddre dlteruuerbis ueÃ¼e,ut etidnduÃª pfoâ ^^^Â»inqudipft tilget,iHnd cÃ¶imx^tumf-cqutniifimui,

ÃU M. FAB. OVIN T. INSTITâ TE/c^MÃ tmceieriis tempejidtes Oquot; proccÃM in i^i^ xdtfludibitsconcionum femper miloniputiuifff^P^ Mtddi. liiÃddicciÃ'etduntdxdtflu(libuicof^^^Â°â^'â^^ i effet dÃ¼egondynunc edtnmifeuit. Quo in gÃ©nÃ¨re VF des ex dreefitis verbis uenit, et inteUedus ex froffij^-lUud uero longejjieciofftmumgeniK ordtionis,inlt;i^ââ trium permixtd eft grdtid ,fmilitudinis, dUcgorid,lt;^ trdnfldtionis. QÃ¿od frctum,qtiem ^ripum, totmoif^â tdntds,tdm Udrids hdbere creditis dgitdtiones, conmÂ»^^ tioncs^Ãudufytludntds perturbdtiones, Ã§r lt;lgt;â^Â°^ ^e^*^ hdbet rdtio comitiorumf Dies iatemuffus V/nuSydut noX interpofitd f^pe (^ perturbÃ¢t omnid^zy- totdmopoxo' nempdrudnonnunqcommutdtdurdrumoriSâ ^'^^' ^uo^i in primis eÃ euÃadiendum, ut quo ex gÃ©nÃ©rÃ©eÂ«^ peris trdnfldtionis,hoc de finds, tJlultidutein, tmnjntnu 4 tempefldte fumpferunt, incendia dut nuM^'^â^f eÃ in eonfequÃ¨tid rerun foediÃimd. Cderuin iHegorii pdruis quoqi ingenijscrquotididnoferinonifrfj*^^''' tiÃime feruit. Ndm iÃ¼d in dgendis edufis idtnieW^'i'y f^ dem conferre^ey iugulum petcre, er finguinem Mti^ reende funt,necoffÃ¨ndunttdmen.EfenimgedUâ''^^ ; quendo nouitds ef comutdtio,er mdgis ino^i^^ f ^* Hdnt. Ideo^idinin hisdmifimus moduin,C!'gf^^f^'f^ nimid codptdtione confumpfimus * EÃ inexeni^^^i Mt' goridfi non pr^diUd in ordtione pondntur. ^d^tW nyfium Corinthi effe,quo GrÂ£ci omnes utunturftdflu' rafimiliddicipoffunt. HgedUegoriuqu^eÃ obfeurior, Kiviy/d-ix dicitur, uitium meo quidem iudicio,fiijuiieni

Die ([uibut 'm terrU^er eris mihi mignus Apollo, Trispitat cÅU Ij^Mum non ampUusuinAs^

Etontoresnonnun^ut CxciUus*, QuAdrAntAriAmCly tenne^rÃ¯, er m trieUnio ChoArn, er 'mculiculo noUmt King; er nimc ejufdS foitmntur, er turn er Ant notiorA mm iieerentur,er xnigmAtA funt tAmÃ«, nee CA nifi ^uis mterprftftur 'mteÃ¯ligAf.in eo uero gencre ejuo cotrArtA ojÃ¯eniunturfii^ieiviÃA eR^iUuÃone uoant^gug AUt pro* â nuntiAtione inteUigitur^AUt perfonA,Aut rei ndtwr^t.N * Ãy([UAeArumuerlis disent it,App Ar et diuerÃm effe orA' tioni uoluntAtem,c^UAn^ 'm plur'mw id tropis Accidit,ut intÃ©rÃªt quid df quo dicAtur^ QuiA,(puod dicitur Alibis Â«crum cs^iMt idudifimulAtionc detrAhere,Aut uituperA tionilAudeconeelÃumeA. QjtAlet'il,(luod C. Verres Vritor urbAnus, homo fAndui er iiligens/ubfortitio^ nemeiut'meodienon heiberet. Et contrA. GrAtores uifi furnut, er populo impofuimut. rUquAndu cum rifu qÂ«o dom contraria dicuntur his,lt;iuÂ£ 'mtehUgi uolunt,c[ucm' Admodum'mQlodium i integritAitHAtepurgAuit,mihi erede,pudor eripuit,uitA AnteAÃA feyuMittVrÂ£ter hlt;ec

' Â«fw r^ AOrgoriit^ ut tril': iAdicAmw meUoribus uerbif, mtbont rei grAtiA t^urdi cotrAftjs ÃgniÃecmut, AÃui t'xtu,qux er enumerAuimitf. Htcfn^tis profedo igno fit, quibiÂ« Gr ici nom'mibm Appellent, c'ajKWo'MOAiia'quot; ^(ieâ^oij,a.vji(p^ctaâifi,^oi/x'iap,dicifciAt. SuntetHqui bic nonÃ)fcif5 Allegorie,fed ipfi tropos die ut, Aeri qui dÃ© rsUione^quod 1IJ4 obfeurior Ãt,er w bw oÃ¯laj Aperte

appiiredt lt;iuod uelimus. Cui .ucedit hoc clitocj;, ({Uod gf nus cum diuiditur in j^ccies,nihil hdiet fropYium,ut JC borisf^eciesfunt pinus,amp; okd,ZT cupreffus,^' ipÃâ*^ p fc nulldpropriem, Allegorie nero hibedt aU^uUp^^ prium, c^uod c^uo modo fieri potefi, niÃ ipÃ j^ecies eÃi Sed dd utendiinihilrefiert. Adijciturhis j^wm^iCiO-Ã³?) \ fimuldtut ^uidem/cd non Itiens derifus. PlurHus â(Â«â¢f'â* ' Herbis, cum id (piod uno dut pducioribus certe didpo'

' tefi^explicdtur, â ^!lt;pÂ°(xa'i/i uocdnt,circuitumlo^ueniif ^uinonnunqudm neeeÃitdtemhdbet, quotiesdiduit' formid operit,ut SdUufi, Ad reeptifitd ndturÂ£. Weriio orndtu petit folu, qui eÃ dpud poetds fiequÃ«tifiiwus,iii-

Tempus erdt quo primd quies mortdlibuf Â£g^i^gt; Jncipit^edrdonodiuumgrdtiÃundferpit- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;i

quot;Et dpud ordtores non rdrus, femper tdinen dÃruâiuÂ»'â Quiequid enim fignifiedribreuius potefi,V^^^^^'^^quot; tu Idtiuf ofienditur, â n^iip^cea'tgeii,^^ noiÂ»Â«^^ turn eltj non fine ordtionk upturn uirtuti, cit^gt;âgt;â^Â°^'^' ' ' ' tio. Verum hitc ut cum decorem hÃ¼bet, periphnfih '^^ cuminuitiumincidit,-amp;i^iasoAoy!ixdicitHfâ nm quicquid non ddiudidt.vm^Scclop quolt;^,ii^^^gt;. bi trunfgreÃionem ^ qudm frequÃªter rdtio cop^^ ' amp;nbsp;decor pofcit, non mmerito inter uirtuf^^ quot;^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;*

Tit enm fiequeÃ¼tiÃime djfierd,zy durd,^^ hidns ordtio,fi dd neeeÃitdtem ordinis fui i^^quot;^^^ â*. â^^ tur,Ã§^ ut quod^ oritur,itd proximis etiumfi uiwifgt;^^ potefi ^igetur, DiffÃ©rends igitur quidsmet nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

ORATOR. TIBER VIIL $1^ ^Ko^Â«tf^;conÂ«fÂ«ttponediM.NoÂ« fÂ«(w reddere ea,nec foliref0ffumus,lt;^uÂ£codgmentdti!ifemigii iungdnt,fci vttniumhistluedidfuntitligendieq'fedes. t^ecaJiud po tfÃ Inm^ntm fdeere numeroÃim^e^udm opponund or-ditiK mHtdtio.Nc^; tdio,K.a7Â£â¬K/j x6^ ^*Ã wejctiaÂ» PU tottiÃ® wMf Â«M (Â«fit (judtuor iUd uerhd, quitiK in iUa pub tberrimo opcrum wÂ» Pirdum defeendiÃe fignificdt,plu-riwtÃ³ modw [criptdsquad cum quo^j maximi fdccre tx-periretur.Verum id cum duolus ucrlis fit. AvaS^o^Â« diciturjrfucÃ¯/Ã¯oqMieddfnsqudlU funt wdgo^mecumyfe.-tum,ipud Rom^noj ordtores er ^i^oricos.dwiux de tc^iuA turn decor K grdtid cortirdbitwrlongiiM uerhum, propriebypcrbdtitenetnomcn,ut Anim^tduertt iudb Cfiownrm deeufdtorK ordtinneminduM diuifdm effe pmtK. Kam in dud5 petrtes diuifdfn c ffc,reÂ£ium erdt, fed durum,o- incomptum poefWjqui ftium Â«erborw di* uiponem Æ detunt, er tranfgeeÃionem :

' ' Hgt;ptÃ¯boreo feptem Jubieffd trtoÂ«i, quodordtio Ktqudqudmrccipict. At id quidÃ© eft propter quod cum dicitur tropusji t,quid componendus eft Ã¨ duobtM intcl-Vftibw. Alioquiubinibil ex pgnipedtione mututum (ft,er Ãrufturdfoldudridtur ,pgurd potiuÃ¯ uerbo-rumdicipoteÃ, peut multi ex bis ndrrdtionem longis mutdntbyperbdtis. Ex coufups quÂ« uitii dccidunt, fuo locodicamus. Ã®m^SoXÃp duddeioris orndtus fummo dertfuris locopofui, Eftbicc demcrttiensfupcricftto. VirtiÂ» â^^âquot;** eilÂ« ex diuerfo pdr dugendi dtque minuendi pt pluri-bwmodis: Aut cnimplus fdÃ©o didmus, pcuti

Ãi^ M. FAB. QVINT, INSTiT. Voinens,fruÃK e/iukntis premiumfuum,^ fotww tn* lundimpleuit.

Aut res per jlmilitudmemattottimufi nbsp;nbsp;Cred^ wiWâlt;â'^ reiMilfix CycUdes Aut per copdrtitionem,Â»tâ. iulminis ocyor alk* nbsp;Aut Ãgnis quufi ejuibuÃM, lUi uel intditit feget is per fummd uoldret Grdmind, nectenerds curfu lefijfet drifts.

Vel trdnfldtione/it ipfum illud uoldret.Crefit interim hyperbole dUd mfuperddditd,ut Cicero in Antomum dicit:^^^ Chdrybdistdmuordx^ Chdrybdim dico-tfH fl fuit,fuit dniwdl unum. Ocednut mediuffiduis nix ntdei tur tot res,tdm diÃipdtds, tdm diÃdntibuf in locispofi' tds,tdm cito dbforbere potuijfe. Ex^uifitim ueroÃgn' rdm huius rei deprehendiffe dpud principes lyricornnt Pinddru uideor,m libro que infcripfitufdvoei^dsndin^ Herculisimpetum dduerfus M.eropds,qniin infk^^ dicuntur hdbitdffe,nonigni,nec uentis,necindri,fdln mini dicitfimiletnfuijfe,utilldtninordhocplt;ir effet.

Quod imitdtus Cicero iUdcompofuitinVerreme ^^ fdbdtur m Sicilidlongomterudho^noDionyflies' ^ Phdldris (tulit enim illd quonddm mfuld tni^i deles tyrdnnos) ÃdnounmquodddntmonÃf'*'^ . re illd itnmdnitdte,quÂ£ in ijfdem uerfdtdlod^ iiciW,^ Uon enm Chdrybdim tdm mfeÃdm, neq^ Scyid^quot;^ ^ i hus,qudm iÃum in eodemfreto fuiffe drhitror. Hec p ciord pint genera minuendi: Vix ofibus bdrent,

SeJ tÃ³iw ^Mo$ rei feruetur men^urd ([unddm, quimuis fft cHHÂ» omnii hyperbole ultrdfidem,nontdmeneÃe de iet uUrd modum,nec lt;did mdgis uid m KWiH'K'Kxij iturÂ» Pigrt re ferre plurimd hinc ortd uitid,cum prdf'rtim mi nimefint i^totd (^ obfcurd. Monerefntis eA mentiri hyperbolen,neeitd utmenddciofiliereueUt. Quo md^Â» gw Muendum e^ qÂ«oÂ«f^ decent extoUere, eptod nobis tionereditur. Peruenit hÂ£c res frequentiÃime idri' fum, qui Ã dptm eli,urbdnitdtis: ftn diiter,Ãultiig no' captains quot;Â«Â» lt;iUÃªqÂ»itÂ«r.Efl dutem in ufu uulgo ^HoqÂ«r,er inter nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;''

â¢uttuditos, ^ dpud ruÃieos, uideUcet eptod ndturd eSi omnibui mgendi ra, Â«el minuendi cupidita mfitd, nee ^'iiftptim nero contentif eft. Sed ignofcitur, iptid non dffirmimut. Turn eA hyperbole uirtus, cum res ipfd

iici eptintum eSl,non poteÃ,meUMlt;^ ultrdf^citrdildtordtio^Sedie hne fdtis,cptid eundem ld cumpleniusmeoU broeptoedufdt corruptie eh eptentie

IÂ» quo diffÃ¨rdnt HgWie d Tro^if^ ^^^' , nomen, quad fint formai quod A modo, fun fx ^â^ ^ uertint ordtionem, unde (^ motus dicuntur, r^^ '^^ erit effe utrunq; eorum etidm in fguris^jus f^.^ idem.iJdm cr uim rdm ddijciunt,z^ grdtiau f'^^l NÂ« dÃ©funt qui tropis figura nomen imfoud)it,f'^ eflC. ArtoriusProcului, Quindde()fÂ«Â»i^ttuioiÂ»^^âi fid efi, utedm difcemerenonfit m promptu. N^w^quot;Â® modo quadum in hls jfiedes pÃ¯dnÃ¨ dijidnt, mdueifn^^ mÃ«generdiUUdfocietute, quod utrd^ rei 'd r^^^^ '^^ plia rdtionecumdliqud dicendiulrtutedeÃ^^'^â^â . quidam perqudm tenui limite diuiduntiir,!lt;^^^^^''' â tdm inter figurÃ© fententia,qudm inter tropo^ tept^ tur. Tti^ltp^Kcei/j dut, er 57ei^S:(fop,(y Ã´vop-^^'^^^'^* er i-7riamp;i!o/j, cldri quoq; dutorerfigurdf uerborunt,poÂ» tint q tropos dixerunt. Qua mugis fignundd ejl uW' Troput. ufq. fd diffÃ¨rÃ«tid. ^fi igitur tropusferma d ndtursli(T

tioNK gwtw, Â«ci (Â«t plcrilt;j; GrAmnatici finlunt} diHio dh eo loco iÂ« ^Â«o proprid c^trifldtd 'm cKm,in quo pro pridnonefl.VigurdJÃ¯cutnommeiplbpdtetiCofornidtio Â®âââÂ®â'. qWiCftvM ontionis remot d d communi or pfimum feof^ rente rdtione.ciudrc 'm tropK ponuntur uerid dud pro dlijSyUt 'm /jÃJlt;x(p3^a,fX'Ã®!a'mtd.iix,et Ã v7ovÃ´(W.ao'lt;agt;(W-t7Â« XK^ftjO'tUÃ¼KtToXHjKjJa?(SHO'(lgt;dJ2\.HrOÃIÃ»Â£,U7lgâ¬uAH pic rÂ«nq; A^^nya^ la nduq^ et rebut fit er uerbiSyOvo/xoiTa â^o'id.fb'^io eft Â»oiwmw.Ergo boe epio^^ pro dlijs poni^ tÂ«f,c[uiliut ufuri fuimiafi iUud no fr:gcrcmutA'ifiÃ§?x cfiigt;,etidm ff-eepienter er id, ipfum 'mcuiiit locZ dffmÃ¼ tur,nomen cÃ¶pledi fokt, utitur tdmÃ¨ pluribus pro imo^ E7ri6Ã¯fo/j qÂ«oÂ»:rfm pierwlig; babft dntonomdfhc pdrtem, ebimdione dut fit troputdn vT^Salw ebmutdtio eft or dmis. Idc0^ multi tropk hoc genus eximut. Trdnjferb quot;nbsp;filmen ucrbunijiiMf pdrtÃ« dus Ã fuo loco 'tn dUenum.Ã¯iO' rum nibil in figurds eddit, ^dmzr proprijs uerbiff lt;3quot; ordme coUoedtis fieri figurd poteft-Quornodo dutÃ« Ironiii dlid ftt tropi,dlid febemdtis, fuo loco redddm.t^o mime enim fiteor effe commune.Mdc fcio g multiplicem bubcdnt, cptdmqi fcrupulofdm dij^utdtionem,feded non pert'met dd prsifcns meum propofttu. fÃ¼ibilenmi refert quomodo iippcUcfKr utrumlibeteorum,fi eptid ordtioni frofttyAppdredt. Nec mutdtur uocdbulit uk reru. Et /Ã¯-ewt homme; fidUuidcceperunt g quod bdbuerdnt no* wen, H dm funt turnen, itd hÂ£c die cpiibut locpi'mur ,fiuc bropi,ftuc figure dicentur, idÃ« ef^ient. Non enm na* mmibw profunt^cd uffidtibm, ut ftdtu coniedurdlÃ«^dn

inficidlem,M fdÃ¤i,Ã¤n fubfidntilt;e,dn de [ubÃdntid nomi-ncmm,nihil intercA,dum ilt;ihnquÂ£ri feidmus. optimum ergo in his fequimdxme receptd,Qr rem ipfum quocun* que dppcU ibitur modo intcUigi. lUud tumen notin' dum, coire frequenter in edÃem fententids, cr tropon, O'Ãgurdm. Turn enim trdnftdtis uerbis, q proprijs fr gurdtur ordtio^ EÃ dutent non medioeris inter dutores diÃenfro^o qua uis nominis eius, o quoi genen,er q Figura quo njukÃ¦ funt fredes.QuireprimÃ¼intuendumeRquid Â« aaipienda. cipere debedmusÃgurdm. KOm duobus modis dicitur:

Vno,qudlifcuq} formd IentÃ«tilt;e,ficut in corporibus,in q busquoquomodofuntcompoptd,utiq; hubitusell ib' quis:Altero,quo proprie fchemd dicitur,infen[u uelfer mone dUqud d uulgdri er fmplicifrecie cu ritionemU' tdtio,ftcut nos frdemus,incumbmus,refricimus- ^^ââ^ââf cum in eofdem cd[us,dut tempor d,dut numÃ©ros/!*^ ^^'^ pedeSy continuÃ© quis dut certe nimium frequentst n^tur rit ,prÂ£cipere folemusudridnddsfigurdsefr uitMiÂ£ fimilitudinis grdtid. In quo itd loquimur, tii'iqlt;*^ '^'^''â^ ferma hdbedt fgurdm.ltem^ eddem fgurd iidnufffquot;^ frire, qui leiiitdre, id efi, eddem rdtione deebnitt-QuireiUointeUcHuprioreercommuninihdiff* r^ _ rdtumefrQuoÃcontentifimuSjnonimmeritoApofr

â¦ Ã¯dlio ^gynj^ Ã trddenti CxUo credimiis,incomprebtufr^bs pdrtis huius prÂ£ceptd exiÃimduit. Sed Ã hdbitus ^Mi* ddm,er qudÃ geÃus fiedppeUindi funt,id demu hoe lo' 1 accipi tto frhemd did oportebit, qdâfit d fimpliciie in prom ptu pofito dieÃ«di modo,poÃ«tieÂ£ uel Ontario tnutitiun-

Sicfn;ffl ucrumcritiAlidmelJe ordtionem Si^np^ixTit s%',iJ f/1 cdrentemfigwis, quod uitvjjm non mter mi* nimi cSi,dlid l%HfxoSi^ijSjjitij,id e^,Ãgurdtdm,VcriM. ii ip^M dngdjle tdmen zr CtcUiu terntinduit,lt;iui id fo* lam Ã§utducrit fehemd^t^w dUud fmuldtur did quim di* diwSdne MÃgÃ´ quoci^ficdcdpi [do. vnde O' Ãgurd* ttcotroderfiÂ£ c^uxddm^de (putbus paulo poft diC!XiÂ«,uo c4Â«tHr.Ergo Ãgnrdfit drie dliciuA noMtdformd dictn notati di.Genw dui undm quidam putduerumt^m hoe ip^o di* Mr^di opmionts Ãeud. Nam hi quia utrbor jm mutdtio

[ Â«f Ãnfus quoquf uerterent^ omnesÃgurdi 'm uerbis effe dixfn(t.llli,quia uerbd rebut dccommoddrtnturiOmnes

! mftnrÃ³iÂ«. 02 trÃ¼utraqi mdnifiÃdcduiUdtio oft.Nam Â«f tiÃ©tmiid folent dlittr atq; dUter, mdnttÃ©^ fenfut do rotione mutdii, itd i^Ãgurd Ãntcutix, plurci hdbere Ufrbonwi Ãgurdx poteft ^lUde^en'impoÃtd'm cond* pienja cogitdtionc,hÂ£c m cnu/nddndd,Ãd Ãcf^umtiÃi* Wf cociMU, ut inboctiamiam DolobcUa neque mc tui,ne qw taoram libcrum.Nam ordtio Ã iudice duerfd^m ftn* tentid iimidm,et liber urnjm uerbit Ãmt Ãhemdtd. inter ^bidmosenim,c[uod Ãidm,confenfum eft duos duteffe PÂ«tÂ«/Â«voiaÂ§ult;i eÃ mentit udÃnfat uel fententidrÃ¼,

; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«4*quot; bis omttibiM modis diliu eÃst 'X.i^wq,id eft uerbo

â'âMiiaionWjUflclocutiortWjUcI [ermonit,uel ordtio* ^'^â ^ints-uiridtur,crnihilrefert. Corneliut tdmen ^f fdt adijet ufrbw zy fententijs Ãgurdt eoloru/m, ni* ^pfofc^o cupiditate dudut .Nam quw ignord [feeru

fuum e/Je^ Coudre Ãcut omne ordtionein,itd Ãg,urd( ^w ÃW uerfdri neceffe eil in fenfu er in uerbK,Vt uero M* turd priiu e^ condpere dnimo res qMm entmeidre, itd de hii figurif diuÃ¨ loquendam eÃ¼ qui dd memem perti nent,(paru quidem utilitÃ©s tu mdgud^tum multiplex, in nuUo non ordtionif opere uel cldriÃime elucet, Hdw etÃ ninme uidetur perttnere dd probdtionem qui' Ãguri i^Mcej; dicdtur,fdcit tdmen credibilid qux dicimui,er in tmimos iudicum qud non obferMtur irrepit.NMtp ut in drmorum certdniine,(t aduerfos iciut, er reddi ddfim plices mdnus turn uidere^ty^ etidm cduere dcpropulÃ* refdcUe eH, duerÃe teHi^ minus Ãwt obferMbiles, cr dUud ofiendiffe qudm petdi drtis eH-.Ãc ordtio qin dÃu cdret,pondÃ©rÃ©,mole^er impulfu preUdtur, Smuldiniâ^ â¦incutcre fiantiq; condtus, in Idtcrd dtque in tergd'i-incurftfâ^â^ dduocdre,er uclut nutu fdllere.yi^ ââ^^â^ â afÃvlus nihil mdgis ducit.l^dm Ã Ã-ons,oculi,tiii^ââ^ â^'t tivin dd motum dnmoru udlet,^udtito plus ordtiÂ°^^ 'P'* us tmltus dd id quad intedmus efficcre compofdâ^â ^ rimum tdmenddcommenddtionemfdcit,fiusiÂ»^Â°'â^ tmotibus ^^dis dgciUis moribus,Ãuc dd promerendudHââ'^' uoremjluc ud leuddum udrietdte fdÃidiutn,Ãâ^ â^ ^ * ddm uel decentius mdieddd uel tutius. Sed dift^'i^^ ^**^ cuiq; rei Ãgurd conuenidt oÃendo,diccndHâin tÃ ^^^'â^* quam eÃe tdm multds, quÃ¹mÃnt d quibufddtn conpitu* t^e-ttieqi enm me nouent nomind iÃ¼d qudfin^ ^â^, Gviccis promptiÃmum eR ^ Ante omnid igitur iÃ¼t qfgt;* ^Ã§tidoÂ» figuras putunt quoi affÃ¨^us, repudi^di, noÂ»

ORATOR. LIEER IX. S^Ã jni.* Ã ^iliK non fit ^luHtM c^utditm mentit^ fid fluid ^gâlt;'^lt;lt;Â»qM4m noÂ» communUertfed froj^ne nommamiMÂ» Ã¼onfitfimplex rei cuiufiwm^ enwntidtio. Qa^propter M dicendo ird^dydolerCy mifcreri,timere,conjidere,cen iemnere^non fimtfigarx^ non wdgd ^ukm [MÃ¢crc^md ^dri,rogirc,excu[Are. Sed faUit pdrwmd iUgenter mtu^ fMeSffiitod inueniumt mj omnibus his lacis figurdx, amp;nbsp;tdrum excmpld ex ordtionibus excerpunt. Ne^Â«c enÂ»Â» piÂ»rÃ®Â«Â»(( dicendi esl^^uji nonrecipere cdt pofiit.Sed ali âd ffl ddmittere Ãgurdtn^dliud figurdmeffe.^efii enm ^creborexpUedndxYei grdtid frefiuentiarem eiufdem KomintÃ® repetitionem. Coudre ddbimt mibi dUfiMm tn infetnte, depreednte, miferdnte figurdm, [cio, fed non iieoinfeijmifereri, depreedrifignrderit. Cicero fluidâ dem omniet ordtionis lumMdm humc locum congerit,me dwm qiwnditm, ut drbitror,fecutus uidm, ut nee omnis firma febemd iudicdYetur,nec ed fold flux bdberent dUd qÂ«Amrewotdmlt;tb ufu commum fiÂ£lionem,fed flux effent, chriÃimi, zy dd mouendum duditorem uilerent pluris mitffl,qÂ«cm duobtÂ« db co lihris trdÃ¼dtum locum dd lite* Ydin fibied ^ ne fiduidrem legentes iudicio mdxmi du* toriÃ¯.iÂ» tertio de Ordtore itdferiptum eft:IÂ» perpÃ©tuÃ© lt;i*tcworlt;ttioÂ»e,c!iÂ«i CT coniumdionis lenitdtem^ er nu â¢fâ'âgt;'^w,qudu! dixi,,rdtionem tenuermus^ turn eft qu4 Ji Wnjitt^ difimguendd et jrelt;iuentdndd omnis ordtia fintemdry^ 4f^ Â»erboriMW.Ndm cz commordtio wnti â¢â ^^ t^rnuAtum mouet, er lUufiris expldndtio rerumf *^Ã 'i^fi Ã¿XMtM fub df^eÃ¼um pcnÃ¨ fuUedio^fiUiX amp;

m exponenda re plurimum udÃet, cr^d iHuÃrÃ¤ndtm Ã quad exponitur,^- ad ampliÃcand'M, ut bis qui dudi* etU illud quod Mgebmus,quantum efficere oratio pote^ rit,tantum effe uideatur. Et huic contraria f^pepraci^ Jio ettj (:^ adplui mteUigendum quant dixerisfigniÃ^ â tdiÃ»inÃ e catto,cr diflridlecondfa breuitat, a- extenuatio,cr Hlitfio, Ã prxceptit C^faris non abhorrÃ©s, ^^^^^ ^âSreÃtorm qua cum fucrit deleÃ©latio, turn r(* conueni(s diti^ ad rem aptut,et concinnui effÃ« debebit, propoft* do^ quid fit didurut, er ab eo quod eÃ¼ diilum feinta Uto, (y reditui ad propofitum, ty itcratio, (y rationis apta condufioftum augendiminuendi 'ue caufa ueritatis fitperlatio,atq^ traied:io,amp; rogatio,atquehuicfiititigt;iid qu^fipcrcStatio,expofitio^fententia;fit,e,tumill^iâ^^ maxime quafiirrepit in hominum memes, aUadii^^ frtmulintis^â'^Ps^'fiâ'â^^^'dâfiinjulatio,quieedperiucudiit!atiin orationis non conten{ione,fedfermone tradatiir.Defit de dubitatio,tum diftributio,tum corredioyUebmÃ¨uel pofiquamdixeris,uelcumaliquidÃ teipforei)cias.Fra muftitio cd etiam ad id quod aggrediare,cr reiedio in alium, comunicatio, qiued quaficum hisapuJqaosdi cas,deliberatio,morum ac uttte imitatio,uclinperfonis, uel fine Hits magnum quoddam omamentian orationis, cr aptum ad animos condliandos uelmaxime, fiepe au nbsp;nbsp;'

tem etiam ad commouÃ«dos, Per/onarumfidaindudio, uelgrauifiimum lumen augendi, defiriptio,errorisiÂ»* dudio,ad hilaritatem impulfio,aut occupatio, corn duo lila quic maxime mouent, fimilitado er exemplum,dige

ORATOR. LIBER IX. S1Ã jiioj/attrpeUdtio^cotftcntiOfreticentidyComcnidtiojnox ^Â«leddmlibcrd, dt^ae etidm ejfrendtior dugenii edufdf irdcuiid,obiurgdtio,pnmiÃio^Ã¤,c^recdtio,0b[ecYdtiOi iccimdtio hreuKA fropoÃtotttonut fuperioriUddi^ Zgt;'^Ãio,^urgitio,concilidtioylÂ£fio,otptdtio^ dt^i exwd Ho. ÃisferÃ¨ lummibiK iÃ¼uÃrdnt ordtionefn fajtentiÃ¤^ ., ^rlt;Ã¼ionis dutem ipÃiM idm^udm Â«trmoruw/Ã Â«cl dd Â«Â« fwm comnimdtio cr (p^Ã petitio,ucldd uenufldtÃ« ipfdni Hiditio. Ndm et gemmdtio uerborwm hdbet interdu/ni Â«imjeporew dUds,et pdululum immutdtum uerbwm dt^ dejlcxmÂ«, er ciuÃdem uerbi crcbrd turn i primo reptti â¢io,tiÂ«n ra extremwm conuerÃo, c^ 'm eddem uerbd hn* pctiw o- cocurÃo,i!:T ddiwiidio^zy progreÃio,i^ dufÂ» dem Â«erti errbrim poÃti quxidrn diÃmdio^zx reuoed* Ho Â«erbi.cr iUd ^uxÃmUiter dtÃnwnt, dut t^ux cddumt Ãmlitcr, dutf^ue pdribta pdrid refenwt ^ dut cpttÃiAit lt;^tcY Ãe ÃmHid.EÃ¤ etidm grdddtio cpixddm or conuer^ fw,o- Â«c rboym tontmud trdnÃgrcÃio,zr contrdrium y 'lâ)JolÂ«tM,er declmdtiOfO- reprehenÃo^ZT cxcldmd HOyZr 'mmmutio, e^ i^uod in muitis cdÃibut ponitur^ct quod de ÃinguHi rebut propoÃitK dudu refertur dd Ãn ^ââI^jOâ dd propo/Ã¯tiWW rdtio [ubiedd,^' item m diÃri^ fcwtk ÃuppoÃitii rdtio,cr permiÃÃio, er rurÃm did dubi pfomiffi0 tâ**wgt;O' improiiiÃu.m ({uidddm,zr dmumerdtio,(^.dUd cwtiiioj Ã§y diÃjHtdhb, er contmudtum, er interru*

Ã®xÂ« H. PAR. QVINT. INSTIT, rd etiimeffe poffimt^ciui feutentijs ordtionein,uerlot rum^i conforrndtionibat iÃ¼umment. Eddemfunt m ori tore plurimd, non omnid tdmen^ er p^ulo m^gis dijlm* Ã¼d,fluid po^ ordtionis z^ fententidrmn Ãgurtu, terti* um qucnddmlocum fubiecit dd dlid(,utipfedit,(iudfitiir tÃ»tes dieendi pertinentem. Et rdi^M ex cotUtione utr* borum, qu^ fumwntur quAplumÃ¯m, mdgnim dfÃrunt orndtu/mordtioni. Suntenirn fmiÃ¯diÃ¼isqutcrndniplo orndtu [cent dutfori dppettdntur inpgnid,non lt;iuid fo* Id ornent, fed ciuod excettdnt. Eddem rdtioeH horum qud: funt ordtionis lumind,, cr tluoddm modo infignid, dut cam dupUcdntur iterMiurÃ©^ uerbd, dut breuiter co mutdtd ponuÂ»tur,dut db eodÃ« uerbo duaturffpiuf ori tio,dui m idem eonijcitur,dut m utrim^ue,dut ddiungt^ tur idem iterdtum, dut idem dd extremum rtÃttut/^^^ continenter unum uerbum non in eddem fenteni^f^'^^ tur^dut cum fimiUter uel eddumt uerbd,uel defÂ»Â»^gt;^^ cum multis modis confrurijs reldtd conirdrii,dÃ»t turn ttendiwr Z^ddutim furfum uerfui reditur^dutcumdemftisan iumdienibut di/foiute plurd dicumturt dut cum inluid pritereurtes cur idfdcidmuf oÃedimui, dut cum com gimas nofmetipfos lt;lUdfi reprehÃ«dentes,dutfit^ ââ''^â* ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;excldmdlio,uelddmirdtionisuelconciueÃioitif,dutcum

dufdem nominK edfus/epius commutdntur. Senteutti* rum mdiord orndmentd funt, (luibus quidfrcciuÃ«tif'me^ DemoÃhenes utititr,fivnt (lui puteitt iddreo eim cloiiui tidm mdxnne effe Lutdubilem, Enimuero nuUtufere db eolocas fine^uddim eonfirmdtione fentenw didtur,

orator. LIBER IX. Ãlquot;? hÂ« lt;i!iÂ«d qw/qiMm csl dicerc,nift omnes, dut certe pk* ^ifejue dUc^iu ^ede iUum^Mre fenteMiM^CiUM cum tu optime Brute tendis,cjuid dtt'i/net nommibus uti,Mt CX'gt;â '^tiiflisf (Antummodonotetur locut. Sic igitur dieet iÃ¼Ã¨ qufm fxprtimtMjKt uerfet fÂ£pf multis modis eAdenj,ii:T in Ãre hircAt^iM eAdemÃ©ii comoretur fententiA. SfpÃ¨ ttiim utextenuet AUlt;iuid,ftpe ut irridcAt, Aut declinct i propoÃto, deÃeilAttlueÃententidm, ut propondt tpiid ii^urus Ãt, uteum trAnÃegerit iAm dUi^uid deÃnidt,Ut jeipÃe reuoeet,ut quod dixerititeret,ut ArgumentuM

fitione coneÃ¯udAt, ut Ã¯nterrogAndo urge At, ut rurÃiA ^'U-Ãdd'mterrogAtAÃbiipÃ reÃpondeAtiUtcontrAde diwt, iedpi Cf fei^iri udit, ut^Addubitet quid potius, AM qÂ«o modo dicAt, ut diuidAt m pArtes, AUt Aliauid re linqiMt,Â«t negligAt, ut AMe prÃ©muni At, ut Â«i eo ipfo vit qÂ«o reprebendAtur,culpAm m AduerfAriwn confer At,ut ftpe cum bis qui Audiimt, Â«onÂ»t0iqult;im etiAmcim Ad* Merfitrio qw/Ã® deÃ¯iberet,ut bomvnwni mores fermones^ dcfcriluit, Â«t mut A qifddm loqientiAmducAt, ut Ai Ã©o qtod AgiturAuertAt Animos,ut fxpe m iÃAritAtÃ« ri!Ã»mA utcouertAi,ut AmÃ¨ occupet qÂ«od pÂ«tdt opponi,ut com

pdret fwiiiitudines,utAtur exemplis,ut Aliud dlij tribu* tns ii^ertiAt,utmterpeUAtorÃ¨ coerce At,ut dUquid reti eÂ»e fe iicAt, Ut denÃ¼ciet quid edue At,Ut liberius qÂ«id dU dcdtjMtiripdtMy etiAm,ut obiurget dUqtdndo^ut depre cetur,ut fupplicet,ut medeutur, ut Ã propofito dedmet dUquntulu^ut optet,ut exxretur, utÃdt bis dpud quoi HdtfAmdiAris, Atqtc aUm etidm dicendi qtdÃ uirtutei

Ã§i8 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. fequAtur IrcuUntem/i res petet SÂ£pe eUam rem dieen^ do fubijciet oculiStfitpe fupr^ feret rem quimferri pop Haftenus Ã§/^^âfiÃ¿^^f^^^^^ f^P^ ^^â^ ^^^Â°^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ormtio, jape hilm

ceroms ucr- t^,f^peuitje nAturdrumq^ imitJitio. ilocingenere(M ^oon^^^'^â^^^ Z^^â^â¢ âââ^^^ ) Â®'ââ^ elucedt oportet elotpiemif rccitauit. fHdgnituilo,

EKgocuildti'McompleÃ¢i conformationes ucrio^ ru dcfententidru pldcuerit, hdlct lt;^uod p^uHtir, necdffirmdredufjm quiequd effe melius, fed bicdd pro ' pofiti mei rdtionem legdt, t:Jdm mihi de his femÃ©titrum figuris dicere in dnimoeR, e^Uie dh itlo fimpUci modo in dienndi recedunt, quod idem multis doHiÃimis unis ut deo pldcuijje. Omnid tdmen iÃ¼d, etidm quiefurd dlterius modilumindfddeÃ³fivnt uirtutesordtiÃ¶is,utfiuehisni-i ld inteUigi uere poÃit ordtio^ N 5; quo modoiud^^ docc ri poteÃ,ft dÃ©fit iÃ¼uÃris expldndtio,propDfitiâgt;âP'^Â°^âs

S-ieftiofio,fimtio, fei:inÃ©lio,(xpofitio,fenteft'ddP^^^'âÂ°''ââ^^ dptdconclufiojpriemunitiOjfimilitudOfCxeinp^^'^^^'^^' fiio,difirHutio,mterpeUdtio,mtcrpeÃldiitis(0^^^^ââââââ'^ tentio,purgstio,lffiof Qttid uero dgit omnuio clolt;iuen tid detrddis dmpUfiedndi mmuendiq^ redion^'^

.* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ru/m prior defiderdt iÃdm plus quim dixeris p^r'' *

tionem,id eH i^xenp, zy fuperldtionemUif^^^^^^^^ traiedlionem^, bhecdlterdextenuitionem dep^f^^^^^* ttemq-. QuiaffÃ¨iluserumtnelconcitdtfdetridduwe berd,ejfrendtiore irdcundid, ohiurgdtione, optdtione, cxccrlt;uionetuelillimitiores,nifiddiiii(dntur comment

ORATOR. LIBER IX. $29 i^une,concilidtione,dd hildritdtcm'mpulÃonc i Qji^ MeadtiOfdutcluoimediocriter fdltemdodi hominis indicium, niÃi dud repetitione, dud commordtione mÃ^ i^^idigrcdi d re, ZT redire dd propopoÃtum Ãmmfei ^Tit,remouere d [e,m dUum trd^cere,^UÂ£ reUm^uendd, ^''â econtemnenddÃwit iudicdre^ MotuseSl inhis on* tionif dt^ud ut, c^uibui detrddis idect, cruelut dgitdn tf corpw Ã^irituedret. Qmlt;c cum ddejÃe dt bent, turn di fpoHenda a^ udridndd Ãwt,ut dudit orem, lt;[uod in fidi ^VfÃeri uidemus,omnifono permuicedt. Verum ed ple ^'^([iredd funt,nec fefingwnt,Ãd conÃtentur. Admit ^x^t autfm,Â«t dixi,figurds,c[uod wel ex proximo doceri tÂ®^'ft. Quid enimtdmcommuÃ©e ^udminterrogdre, â*lp'Ã¯coÂ«f ari i Nam utrot^ utimur mdiÃer enter, cum Â®!fffÂ«tti noÃcndi,ditc rum drguendi grdtid uidedtur dd, ^âlâeri.At res utrocivnc^ modo diedtur, etidm multiplex quot;'âÂ«t Ãhernd. Ã¯ncipidmui enim db his c^uibus dcrior zx XtlifideiKior Rt probdtio,ciuod primoloco pofumus. ^^^^^^hÃerogdret

\ ^^^'^Â°sc[uitindem,lt;Ãiibusdut ueniÃisdhoris^ ^'amp;^^tMndutem,([uotiesnon feiÃitdndi grdtid dÃumi

*Æ gt;Rd mÃaHdi'. z^ii enim tms iUe Tubero diÃridus Interroga* âx^wPbarfrtljcagladtiw dgebdti Et: Ciuoufo[i tandemâquot;â¢ Â®Â®âÂ®

* â0Â« ftittifZ Et totUi denit^i hic locm, dudttto enim uoF 'quot;^'^'^â4â^âquot; P djff :^f twr : D:Â« dbutcris pdtiem id ^^ conÃlid.ittterrogdmus etidm qued

Â«o M. FAB. oyiNT. INSTIT, cuÃAniut Tdculii Æ Aut uii rtf^ondenU difficilif c^ ^^* ^^emfiwi ^^Â°â^^ ^^^gÃ³ uti [olentuf. Ciuomodo^quiÃcri Ã§ottnl poteftquot; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^'^I^ muidia grdtid, ut Meded d^udSencedmt

Aut miferdtionis^ut Sinon dpui Vergdium: HfÂ» quÂ£ me teUut, induit, que me equord poffwitt Accipere^ AutinÃdndi,etduferendediÃbr,iiÂ» IdtionK,ut Afiniut : AudA'nc, fmioÃm inquimnon inoffidofum teÃdmentum reprehendimm, Totumbot plenum eÃ¼ uArietdtis. Ã¯^dm Oquot; indigndtioni conuemt:

Et interim dcriut imperdndigenuti Uondrmdexpedient^totd^exurbefequentiir^ , Et ipfi nofmet rogdmud} qudle eÃ¼ lÃud TeremftÂ»Â«-

Refpohden EA dud etidm in rejÃondendafigurd,cuin diââ^ ^fquot;*quot;Â® di figura., gdnti,dd dUud quidftc utiUudfitjoccurrituty i^m dvgen dierminKgrdtid, utteflisinreumrogdtiif^dn^ f fuÃibuiUiputdffet:lnnocensinquit.Tudlt;^^^^ââ^ 'â^ eÃ¢ÃequemiÃiindm. Quero dn occidcrii^ââ.*Tââ^jj fpondetur,ldtronem.Anfundumoccupdit(f^gt;'^^nÂ° tur meum,ut confeÃionem preceddt defen[^Â°' '^tdpu ,

Cai eft confinis Ã¼Ãimulitio, non aUU quim bl rifu foÃ D^fHinuIÃ¢* ta, idfo^ iMÃaU fuo loco, Ndm fcrio ÃÃAt, pro con* ÃÃionc cR.CittcTAm ttiAm interrogAnii fcipÃos,zx re ^mienii fibi folent efje non mgrAtit uices, ut Cicero pro UgAriotAfud (juem igitur bÂ« Hco^ nempt Apud faw qui cam hoefdret, tAmen me Antec^uAm uidit, rei* publicf reddidit. Aliter pro CxUoÃilA mterrogAtionei DicftaliqKMiHiecigttHrfÃ tuA difciplwA? Sic tuwÃi* tub Ã¤dole[centesâ^^ totm locufydemdet^goÃ qÂ«w iu* dices hoc rolorc Anmi,Atc^ hAc Mole uirtutis,Ac con* thietv.iifuit^z^ exterA.Cui diuer[wm cÃ¯l,cum Aliwn ro gawerb, non expeÃAre refponÃuWt er Ãitim fulijccrez DomiÂ« tiki deerAd At habebAf.peewniA ÃuperAbAtfAt c* jutic^Ã¯o. ^flgt;lt;u,lt;luod[cbemAquidAmper (ubieliioncmuocAM.-KuggaÃ¼o* ^itzi-compArAtione.yter igiturÃAciHuifuie fentemiit*^â^

' nbsp;nbsp;âabt prffumptio, qÂ«Â« -Tt^Ã³âXN.pKâ dicitur, cumid lt;iuod PrjCumptio.-

| Herb tvniut,iiuerÃu tAmen fpedes hAbed EH eftim ^ua ^^ jj^j^ju^ damprimiwlitip ,([UAlis Ciceronii conird Q.CÃcÃ¼iuWjnÃ§,

\ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ll :

Ã52 M. FAB. oyiNT. INSTITÂ» tjuentiÃimd prtepdrdtio^ewm plurÃM uerbis, Â«f^ ^â^â* fdiluri quid figt;ma,ucl quire feccrimut dicifolehVerio rum quoque uit deproprietdi conÃmUuruel pr4'â'^* ptiona Ciudnqudm iÃd non pand, Ãd prohibitio[(^'â* risfuitidutreprehenÃoneiCiuesinqudiÂ»gt;Ã^Â°^^Â°^T pcUdri nomine fiÃ¼ eÃ¼, A ffÃ¨rt dliqudm Ãdem ueritdtii it Dubitatio. dubitdtio ^ cum Ãmuldmui querere nos, unde âÂ»Ã f^ dum fUbideÃnendum^quidpotiÃimum dicendum)^ omnino dicendvm Ãt, cuiufmodi exemplif pyuilÂ»^ omnid.Sed unm interim fufficitt Equidem quod ddÃ dttinet, qua me uertum nefeio ; 'tjegemfui/Ã iudidj eorruptifo- cdterd.VLoc etidm in prfteritunt let. J^dm er dubitdÃe nos Ãngimui.A quoÃbem^eito^ Communi'âprocul dieÃ¼ iÃ¼d qult;s dicitur communicitiojOti^^^^ Â«âÂ«Â«gt;â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ipfos dduerfurios confulimus,tit Domitius AÃ^Pâ'ââ.^^^

dntilld:AtÃ¼ldncfcittrepidd,quidlicedtfoeitiinfgt;^!*' folitudine i^f^g^ decent, forte aas in iÃ¼d folicitudine lt;^'â ^^ fus miferÂ£ ntulieri oltulit, tu frdter, uos p^. ..^^ quod confilium dutis: Aut cum iudicibus qt^Ã â^^'^^;(, mus,quodeÃÃcquentiÃimum-.Q^idfuidetiigt;^ ^^ terrogo,quid tldem fieri oportuit fut in eoloco efifetis^quid dUud feci/fetisfEtidt^*' ^^ g^j nem rÃ« dgi putdtote,dc uos huic reiprdpoÃ^^^ âu â r j^ ' nonnwnqudmcommuniciuttesdliquidmer,p^^^ â L iungimus,quod erperfe fchemd eR,utin Vemlt;^^ ^^ cero-.c^uid deindef quid cenfetisf furtum fori^jÃ§ pr^ddm dliqudm f Deinde cum diu Ãjfiendiffet ^^^â^^ dÃ¼imos^fubiecitquod multi effet improbius- Ãââ^ ^gt;

^tniitiontm uoedt. Eft dutem duplex. Nlt;iÂ»i contrd, SÃ¼ÃÂ«Â«:Â«Â»Â« ^f^Â«ezÂ«fr cum expeildtionemgxduiÃimorumfecimui, tld illiquid quodÃt leue, dut Â«Â«Ho modo crtmtnofiMn, f aliquid dffcendimiM,Sed quid non tdntum per communiedtio defendim* âitm ^eri[olett^ixlt;i^o^o}}dlijnomvnduerivntt id eÃ¼ iw*^'^'^ â â*â* opHiiitiHn. iHw non decedo, qtifehemd effe exiÃimdnt, ^dim Ã quid nobii ipÃs diedmut mexpeUdtu deeediÃet Â«t Kallio: Hu/nqMmforc credidi indices ,utreo Scduro Â«'quid in eius iudicio grdtid Udleret precdrer. Eft pc* He Hem fans iUius^qudm pernÃ¼Ãionem uocdnt,qui comgt; ^^''Ã¦'^iÂ°-f^wmationis^cu dliqud ipÃs iudicibtu relmquimus dÃiÂ» '^nii,dliqiid nonnunqudm dduerfdrqs quoq, ut Cuk â¢**w VntinioiPf rfried fronten,ZT die te digmorem,qui fi'etorjieres,qudtnCdtonem.Qjituero fumt dugendii ^(Uhus dccommoddtte Ãgurx, conÃdt mdxme ÃmuÂ» SimuUtio. l^tionf.Niwq; er irdfri nos,lt;:T gdudcre, (y timere,Oâ *imirdri,e2- dolere,zy 'mdigndri,etoptdre,qut^ Ãmt (ÃTOlÃ¹bis.JÃ®ngiftiu-s.Indc Ãvnt iÃ¼dtLiberdtut fum,Yefri* Ã¯^crlene bdbet,ZT quf dmentid eft h^d Et;0 tem* por J, o morÂ«, Ã mifer urn me, conÃumptis enyin Idchryt' ^i^^ntÃxws turnen pedorihitret dolor. Et:

1 ^Â«mr, fed ((j?Hni4ij(t4 ^ ^y^e compoÃtd prof Â«l dubio 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;febowu fr^t exifrmdndd,ÃiÃ¿pd idÃ© diÂ£ium Ãt deord

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â»one Ijbfriijqnj CorniÃeiws UeÃ«tidm uoedtfirxei wal* ^Â«Â«Hj;Â«,

t4X^ Sei frequenter fui hicfrÃ¤eUtet iiulutio.mtnCi ctro cum didt pro Ligdriot Sufeepto beUo Ctfrr ge^o idm ex pirte mUgnd^nuUd ui coddui, cÃ¶Ãlio dc uo^ddte nted,dd Cd drmd profedut Ãi/m,quÂ£ erdnt contrd teÃâ/d ptd. NoÂ» folum dd utiUtdtem Ligdrij refridt, fri nHÃ¿! Iduddre uidorif clementidm non potedt 1Â» iUd uerofn tentidiQttiddutemdliudegimut T Ã¼ber o, mÃ ut quoi bic potcd,nos pofrernutiâddtnirdbiliterutriUique pittig fdcit bondm edufum, fed hoc eu/m demeretur cuiiu mdi^ fuerdtAÃd ddhuc dudddord,e^ mdiorwin, ut Ciceroexi Proropo- ÃmdtÃdtcrum,Ãdioiies perfondrum, que -Tt^oifaTeof ^'*^**â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;TioiiKi dicutur.Mire ndntp turn udrixnt ordtionein,tdtd

excitdnt. Uis edum dduerfdriorum cogitdtiones, ueld fecuM loquentium proirdhimud, que tdmen itd demiM d fide non dbhorrent,ft ed locutos finxerimuf, âiâ^^^* gitdffreosnon fitdbfurdmn. TÃ tnofiroscMxbfir* mones, erdUorum inter fecredibiliter introiocuudft fuddendo,obiurgdndo^quirendo,lduddnio,^^[^'^'^^^^ rip^Ã¯^oc' p^^oUd^ idoneds ddmui.Ci^tn deducere decs 'mhocif C*u Â»wfSe nere dicendi, CT inferos excitdre, concc^uw ed. ^fr â¢MifUMK. y^^ ^^-^^ popuUqi noces dedpiwnt, Acfunt quid^quot;' ^â*â

hM dem um â cs^osâaTro7eoilcc^ diednt, mquibut^^ ^Â°'^f^ rdetlfuerbd fingmus. Sermoneshommutn ifiiitulitoi Dialogi. dicere XixTeÃ³youiÂ» mdlumt,qudm quad 14Â«**Â®â* Ãâ* ddm dixerumt,fermocmdtionem. Ego idin recepto more Utrumque codem modo dppelldui. Ã¯^dm certe ferma fio* ginonpoteA,utnonperfond; frrmofingdtur. Sed'm bis quxe nuturu non pennitfit, hoe modo moÃ¯lisrfrf^â^

M. Etfttim/iÂ»Â«eci0ttplt;(tn'lt;t,qÂ«ie 'quot;mitdintAmulto nbsp;fÃ chirior,Ã etvnÃA ItdUdfi omnif reÃgt;ub,Ãic lo([Mturt MircfTuHiqMÃ®ddgÂ«# lUud (tuddciw gernÂ«: Qitietw CiÂ«Â« CarÃ¤met Ãc Agit, er (^uoddmntodo tAcitA loquiturÂ» l^Â«BiÂ«n idm aliquot Annit fdem'M extitit niÃ per tc. Co woJe etidm dpud nos dlitpiAs ditte oculos effe reru per^ perfonaÃ§.. fondrÃ¼m Mf imdgmes Ãngmas ^ dut CAdem dduerÃdrijSt gmes dut iddicibus non Accidere tmrAmur,epuliA Ãwti Vide'^ tw mibi, z^i nonne uidetnr iibi^ Sed mignd e^iudAm MK floqueiwiie deÃderdtur. Tdlfd enm or tneredibiUA nawA neceffe eit dut mdgis moneMt, quid Ãtprd uerd (tÂ«,t: (tut pro Mnis decipidntur, quid uerd non funt, vt Ãftit (tutem quiddm/td feriptd quolt;y fingi foknt,quoi f^M AÃmius pro Uburnid : Mdtf r med, que mihi tum ^^mÃmd, tum dukiÃimd fuit,mihi uixit, bis^ eddem die mibi uitim dedit, ZT reUqitd, demde, exblt;ercc eÃo, HÂ« tum perfe Ãgurd eSi,tum dupUedtur, quotiesÃcut ^huciuÃdddmitdtionem dlteriiu feripturecornpoÂ«' â¢ââ¢tw- Nurn comrd recitdbdtur teÃdmemuwiiP.Nouuni W Gu!Ijo,eÂ«t ego omnid meritiÃimo uoio, z^ debeo,pro dus dnimi 'm mc furnrnd uoUvntdte, ZT ddi(Ã¤is demde *^s,hereseÃo.lncipitejfe quodAmmodo^cÃ§JK,quod'^^^'^'^^'

^^1 ^buÃm etidm 'm uerÃÃedtionis dc Ãrmonum 'mitA't ^ââquot;c fenutur. Sed formds quoqueÃngimus fepc,ut fd*

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Â«tf M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT.

I rio^* Â°'^^* incerta perfontfiHd oratio: HicaUquis.cr, Diat^* I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;quit-E fl er iaiiut fine per[bnafirma:

â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Hic Dolopum manui,bic fieuus tendebat Achilles.

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Quad fit mixtura figuraru,cum 'tt^oa'uTTom'ia Å

â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cedit ilia, finie eÃ¼ orationis per detraHionem, detra^i

1 ^Mtio\um ^^^â*^yiâ*^ diceret. Vertiturinterim p^aa-uTfOTfiÃ¯a I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;oratiorefer i^j^cciemnarrandi.Vndeapudhiftoricosreperiuntuf

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;intiZ^uTr Â°^âfiâ*^ââ^Â°â^â*^^Â°gt;^^gt;ââtin TitiLiuifprimoflatimlibro:

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;bis/edfinica '^^^^^âÃâf(gt;^t*i cetera ex infimonafii,deindei-quefia

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fententia. uirtus de dij luttent, magnat opesfibi, magnum nomen

u^cusacdQ Ãcefe. Auerfiusquoq-Ã indice firma,ejui dicituriquot;^ iuuerint s^Ã¶iplijmiremouetjfiueaduerfariosinMfimtistQuide^ tu^reSoquot;^' ^â^ t^^^â^c Tubero in ade Pharfalicagladius agebat^ tus.qnidici' Siueadinuacationem aliquamconuertimurtVosenim âquot;â¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;iamego Albani tumuli atqitelud.siue ad inuiJiefiiiiiÂ»f

plorationemiO leges Porde,leges^ Scmpronis.Sedids AuerÃo. ^uoque uocaturauer/io, que Ã propofitaqueficitc^^* ducitaudientem:

AuUdeiuraui. Quod fiter muleis cruar^^Ã^ Æ guris, cumautaliud expedafienos,autmaiusali^ââ'lt;^ Æ dmui/fiefimulamus, aut plus uideripo/feignorantibus,

Subiedio. eero)fi(boculos/Ã¼biedio turn fieri filet, cunt tes non ge. i fta indicatur, fedutfitgefta ofienditur, necuniuerfa, I fed per partes, que locum proximo librofibiedmuseui I Hypotypo' ^^'^^â^â^^ ^^V^f^ercnomen ifli figure dÃ©dit, abalijs nbsp;nbsp;1

ORATOR. LIBER IX. $57 ^pfiffa uerbis, ut cerni potw uideatur | audirii ipfo â^iiammatiK feiere acfurore mforum uenit, ardebant oÂ«Ii,toto ex ore crudelitas emicabai.Hec folum cptxfa ^afmt out fiant, fed etiam ^ug futur a fint aut futur a b^rintyimagmamur.flire traHat bec Cicero pro l^i* ^^^^^yS^uefadurus fueritClodiusfi Prgtura inuafiffet.

^ictroi HÂ£clt;ltienÃ´iiidiliisocu,lK,ttnimK cernereÃ§otc HjefanÃ¨de' |lÂ«.NoHi Mcro,cr pMeipKe decUm^torÂ« MdMut^nec ^âdJfidc* â1? bf rdf s fine motu c[uodim mugimnturyUt Senecd in ratur. coWroMfr/Ã¯tt/Â«Â«Â« fummi cRyC^uod ^iterfiUum (y no-Kfrc4m mducÃ©te niter oflia in eidulterio deprehifos oc niit-.riucyfeiiuor.AecipehAnc fenilem mnnnm,^ quo# fHâ^ uw imprime. Et p^ulÃ´ poU : Af^ice/m^uityCpiod iwnoneredidi^i. Egouerononuideo^noxoboritury (J-enficcdigo, Habet htee figura manifefliut aUtpaidy NoÂ» 'nim narrari res, fed agi uidetur, 'Locorum qÂ«o^ dilHcidit Ã§j- fgnificans defcriptio eidem uirtuti aÃigM tw a (Ã¿tibufdam,alij TO7eoy^lt;xlt;^tf.p dicunt. ^i^i^vwp in Topogra Hcni qui difmulatione uocarent, cpio nommey quia pa- phia.Ironia. rum lotus buius figura uidcntur uires oflÃ©di, nimirum fmi m pkri/qj, GrÂ£ca ermus appeUatione contenti, ^gââ^!^^â;;Â« qB^ eStfebema^ab iUa qÂ«je cÃ troptK,ge ââ7* âPfÂ® fibil admodum difiat, lÂ» utrolt;^ enim contra* Ã¯iMweiqMoj dicitur mteUigendu eft.Speeiej nero prw* Ã¶f^tlMj i^tMcntf dwer/^s effe, facile cÃ deprebenitre^

Primurn quod tropus apertior eÃ¼, gy quinqudm lt;lt;K(Â«J dicit de fentit,non tdmen dUudÃmuldt, Ã®^dm ty omnid circd ferÃ¨ reildfunt,ut illud in Cdtilindm: A quo repU' didtm dd foddlcm tuum uirum optimum utetcUum demi ^'TdÃi. m duobm demu uerbii cR Ironid,ergo etÃM ire Mor eR tropuit Atinfigurdtotim uoluntdtisÃdioeÃ¼ Ã¤ppdrens mugis q confeffd, ut illic uerbd fint aerbis di' uerfd, bic fenfus firmoni, er ioci, er totd interim ciu[Â£ tcum conflrmdtio. Tumetidmuitduniuerfdlronidmhdicre â ^Â°Tftâ Mdetur^qudÃ¯is eR,uitd Soerdtis. Udmideo didus v^ap

' ided,dgensimperitum,ctddmirdtordliorumtdnquM fdpientium,ut quemudmodum Ã i^ttyc^apfucit eÃ«tinut /d.Ã¼ot(po^x,fic hoe fchemd fdcidt troporum die cotextuf-Quxddm uero generd huius figura nuUd cum tropd b^ nbsp;nbsp;'

bent focietdtem,ut iÃ¼d fidtim primd qua dicitur d iâegun Apopbafis. do,qudnonnuÃ¼i uoednt iTrotpcunp. aondgumteeuiU'

re fummo:nondicA quodforfitdn obtinercm-amp;'f^^j ego idius decretd^ quid rdpiuM ^ quid harcddiii^ pof feÃiones ddtuei quid ereptus profcrum: Ett Mitto Ã¯h primum libidmis iniuridm. Et: Ne iUd quideteÃtmomi ^SeKceMis 'recitoquadiddfitntde fficrtijs feptiagÃ«tiimdiiilt;^lt;

Et:Polfumdicere. QuibusgeneribuspertotiU'mtermt quafliones decurrimus,ut Ciceroi Eloc ego fifie i?,^^ tditqudm mihi crimen ejfet diluendum, bac pluribus di' cerem. Ei^Ã¼ivi'ux eRe^cum fimilesimperiutibut uci permittentibus fiimus:

HiwMj CK^ Id acriutfit, cum eddem in nobis funi, lt;y 'â^ *ââ â^ ^'ââ â* miduerfdriononfunti tic^timoris

Quod idem contrd udlet, cum dut ed c^ue nobis dbfunty dutetidm ciuÂ£in dduerfdnosrecidunt,lt;iudÃfdtemurÂ» lie duce Ddrddnius SpdrtdmexpugnduitddultcrÂ» Nec m per fonts tdntum,fed cr in rebus uerfdtur htc co t^drid dicendi, g c[UÂ£ inteUigi ueUs, rdtioi ut totum pro ()J^igdrioprocemium, e^ iÃÂ£ eleudtiones ,uidelicett

Et ill? pro Oppio locust O dmorem mirum, o beneuoleit ti4m fmguldrem. Non procul dute dbfunt db hde fmuld* tione trenutfr feftmiles: ConfeÃio nihil noci turd, ([ud^ Confeffw. lÂ«eft.Hdbesigitur Tubero cpiodefidccufdtorimdxi' nKoptdndttm,conptentemreum: XitconceÃio,cumdU' Conceffio. quid etidm inii^uum uidemur edufx fidutid pdti : Metu ^fgirumndudrchusnobiliÃimxciuitdtis pretioferede ââutjlâuiMetttKcft.Et pro Cluentio de muidid:Gominctur in connonibus,idcedt in iudicijs. Tertid cbfenfw,ut pro Confentio. ^odcm.Ã¯udiciume^ecorruptum.liÂ£ccuidentiorfigurd f 3,turn ilicui rei dffentmur, qux ell futurd pro nobist. ^fruid dccidere fine dduerfdrij uitio nÃ potefi. Qjsedd f turn Hfi I^Kfi^fnii^jat Cicero in Verrem circd crimen utim ^P^Nij X)repdnitdni,Gdudeo etidmfii^did db eo dbfiu-. ââ(liÂ»Â©- ibj te dibit redius fddum effe dico. Interim duÂ» g^uicrimid-t, qa^e ex fdcilidut diluere poffumus, diA quot;^F^quod eUÃe^uentiw, 5 ut exfwplÂ«,n defideret.

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;V40 M. FAB. OVIN T. INSTIT.

F nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Interim hoc ipfo fidcin detrahmut illis, i^uod finttiÂ»!

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;grMid^ut proR o[cio Cicero, cum immitnitdtem pmici

[ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^gt;âlâ^ââtgt;^pcrfem(inifefld,t((mcnctiAuiorlt;(tionisexiig

ADonoperu.^^^* ^'^lt;^icÃ7rHoâi^,^udm idem Cicero reticÃ«titm, '^^^fitfobticentidm,KonnuiÃ¯iinterri(ptioneindppeÃlttitt, O'ipfd oÃendit lt;tliquidd^itusuelirÂ£,ut:

Quos ego, fid motos prtefldteomponere fludus, Velfiliatudinis,zr qudfi religions: An huius ille legis, ^'^lt;^Clodtus dfimuentdm gloridtus,mentioncmfdce' re dufus e/fit uiuo Milonc,ne diedm ConfulcÃ« De noÃrÃ enim omnium,non dudco totum dicere. Cuifmle eA in proxmiopro Cte/iphonte DemofihenistueldliÃ¨trÃ¤n'

Di reffio ^^'*^^^^â^'^^^^^^^â*^^^â^â^^ifi,iS^*âf^â^emilii ~ '^ * âÂ°'iudices.lnqua eÃ¢er illd(fitdmeninterfihetndtdiinme rdri debet,cum dlqs etidm pdrs eduÃ uidedtur) digteÃ fio. Abit enim edufi in Idudes Cn.Pompeq. Idf fieriez tidm/ine aTranaTTHc-a potuit, KldmbreuioriS^^i^dt Cicero,iredigreÃio plurimisfit modis,Sedhecexeingt; pilgrdtidfufiicientt TumCdius Vdrenus,isqninfigt;niâ' milid AnchdridÂ»d occifuscH^hoc quie/Ã³indices diligent ter dttendite.Etpro Milane: Etaj}gt;cxit meidisqiiidc/ii ocutis, quibus tumfolebdt, cum omnibus omniÃ¤minÃ¤iÃ¤' tur. Eil dHd non quidÃ« reticentid,quÂ£fit imperfeHifir nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

Et: Quid plurafipfimddolefientÃ¨ dicere dudifiis.Iini* tatiomorumdlienorum,qult;e Â«SazcoÃ«x, uel,utdli/mollit, ^IgiHiXf^ dicitur, idm inter leuiores d^Ã¤usnumerÃ¤ri

|gt;otfP.Eft fnw politiferi m Menio^fd, uerfitur or mfiflK^Cr m didKM ÃiOi^quod eft U7rÃ´ju7rwa'ft HI* cinMm.itt diilis, qÂ«dlc eft rfpwd TcrcnhÂ«m. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^ ^^^^^

Zeinofirorum qw^j didorumfddorum^ fimilis mi-titio cd per rcldtionem, nifi (juod freepuÃ¨tius dffeuerdty lt;pAm cludit.Dicebdm hdbere cos ddorem C^Cgcilium. Snot er iÃ¼d iucunid, z^dd comenddtionÃª cum udrieti* tc,tdm etidm ipfd ndturd plurmu pro[unt,lt;^uÂ£ Ãmplici ([uinidmo-nonprÂ£pdrdtd.mo^endÃ«do ordtionemmi ... mw nosful^edos iudicifdciunt, Ã¼me eft tpufi pÅniteh^^â'^*quot;^â tu didi,ut pro Calioi Sed (luid ego tdm grduern period nM mtroduxif Et ^uibus utmur uulgodmprudensvni' ciJi.Vf! cum (pisrere nos c^uid diedmuf fi/ngmusiZiuid reUipMim eÃi Et:NMW (juid omifif Et cum ibidÃ« inVer-rem,dit deeroÃ¯'Vnum ctidmmihireliiiuu huiuÃmodi cri-^^^^d,zr aliud ex dÃ¯iofuccurritmihi.Vnde etidm uc-tilt;ijiitrdnÃtuffiunt,nonciuidipfetrdnÃtus fit Ãhema, Ht deero narrata ?ifonts exempio, epÃ¹ anuiÃ¼ Ãbi cudi db auriÃce m tribundU fuo iulferdt,uelut bpc in memo-Â«Â«Â» idduJijis idiecitznic modo me commonuit Pi fonts

â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;*â'Ã¯ââ*SlÂ«o J totMM effiuxerdt, ^ multis iÃum putatis bo

ââââ 'âsboneÃisde digitK anulos dureosdbÃuliffe e Et cMâw lutjui uelut ignoramus.Sed edrum rerum artifictm

enim dunt aliud agcre uidentur, aliud effidmui, field hie Cicero confeejuitur, nc cum morbu in ftguis atq; tih^ oUjeiat Verri, ipfe c^uoq; earum reruÃudiofus elfecre* datur.'Et DemoÃhenes iurado per 'mterfedos w Mari thone et SalantÃ¯ne,id agit,ut minore inuidia dadii apui Cheroneam accepts laÃ¯orct.Taciunt iÃ¼a ^Â»ogj iucudam orationÃª, alic^ua mentione, habita difÃ¨rre,^/ deponere apud memoria iudicis^ZT repofcere tjUJi depofueris, (T feparare c^uxdam fchemate aUc^uornon enim eÃ ipfa per fe iteratio fchema, CT excipere aliepua, er dare aHioni uariosuelut uailtuÂ«.Gaudent enim res uarietate,et ficut oculi diuerfaruaj^edu rerum magis detinenturjtafen per animis praeÃatÃn lt;iuod fe uelut nouu,intendant,EÃ Emphafis. Â£,fjphafis etiam inter figuras, cum ex alic^uo diHo latÃ«s

Non Ucuitthalami expertem finecrimiiiteuitarn Degere more fierai Quan^ enim de matritÂ«egt;iilt;f queritur Ã¼ido,tamÃª hue erupit cius affidus, ut fiue tbi lamis uitam non hommu put et, fed fer arum. Aliud apud Ouid. Â». Cluidiumigenus, apud quÃ¨ er Miyrrha nutrici amorein , patris ficconÃtetun o,dixit,felicem,coniuge matrem* fmas sTfigu Muic uel confinK,ucl eadem cR,qua nunc utmurpbiri' rats contro mum.lamenimadidgenus,quod erfrequentifwiueÃf ***^â^^*Ã¦â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;er expedari maxime credo, ueniendum cd, in quo per

quandam fufpicionÃ«,quod non dicimus,accipiuolumiu, non utic^ contrariu,ut in ii^Ã¼ivillt;x,fed altud latÃ«s,et aU' ditori quafi inueniendum,quod ut fupra ofiÃ«di,iamfere folumfchcma Ã noÃris uocatur,er unde eÃ¶trouerftaÃ'

^ur4tlt; iicuntur.^uf triplex ufm cft, wnui p Heere p4 Urn pdrwm tutu cÃ: Alter,fi non deefUTertiwjjijtH we^ gt;iH^ilt;tK mod o ^nM dihiketnr, er ipfd nouitutc de ud^ iietite mdgis ^ Ã reldtio Ãt reSid, ieleÃ¼dt. Ex bw quod tft prtmu,/rfquf ns tÂ« feholis fft. NÃ er uftionej deÂ« pottennum impertum tyrdnnorum,ty poÃ duih leUum ÃndtuÃconÃdtd Ãnglinciir, c^ cdpitdlc eÃ ohijecre dntc d^d,ut quod w fora nÃ¶ expr dic,ill[c Â»cc ber^tfÂ» Scd feine W4tÂ«mcÃ¶ditiononeddemeÃ. QuÃiibctenim dpertuiti^ quod modo et dUter mteUigi poÃit, 'm Ãlos tyrdnnot he Â«c dixe rw,qÂ«f4 periculum tdntum non etidm ofÃnfd ui* t4tÂ«r.Qttod ft dmhiguitdte fententU poÃit eludi, nemÃ³ Â»on illifurto fduet. Verd negotid nuneptdtn ddhuc hd-twrut Ij;(Â»c Ãlentij nceeÃitdtein.fed dlidm huic ÃmHemi *io)âÂ«m multÃ³ didgendum difÃciliorcm,eum per fond: po tentes ohÃdnt,Ãne^udrÃ¼reprehenÃone tencri eduÃdno pojJit.idf 0^ hoc pdreius 27 circunfpediutfdeiendum^ quill Mibil 'mtereÃ quomodo eÃendax, zy dpertd Ãgum pfTÃt boe ipÃum quod figurd eÃÃdeoq; d quibufdum to td res repuiiiitur, Ãue 'inteUigdtur, Ãue non. Srd licit Wodum 4dbibcrf tin primis neÃnt mdniÃeÃje. Non crÃ»t ddtem,Ã non ex uerhis duh'tjs,ty ([UdÃ dupUcihus peten tu^quifisf^^ pi lqjjtâftunur:!. 'Duxiuxoreme[ue pdtri fl^cuit.Aut quod c/l multÃ³ 'ineptiiu,cÃ¶poÃtionihus dmhi gnKjMtiheontrouerÃd, 'm qua Ã®nfdmis dmore uirgmii ÃUe plier ruptJ edm 'mtcrrogdt,d(iuo uitidtdÃt'.Ciuii ^ j r a â '^^^'*?'^^â ^'^^^â' ^^^^^â ^^^ 'P^ pduedw indicÃ© MÃlt;jpieumij ey dmolidmw exterd, ut hoc[olu fupÃtt

Ã44 M. FAB. OyiNTÂ« iNSTlT'^ IB quo multum ctidin uffiilus iuudni^ct iattm^^l

. tio di{iio,cr cunUdtiones.Sic enmfi^t ^^ ^^^^^ â^'^^â^ ittud, nefao quid quod ipfe fondus non diret,cr d quod d fe muentum cxi(liiudt,crcddt.i( ft optima quidem ftnt^ejfe debentfrequente^fi^ ^ fit die ipfd figura dperiuntur, nee offenfia mnmbi f lt;nbsp;fed Mtoritatis.Kec pudor uidetur^quod no pâ^'^Â°^ cidifed diffidentidAn fiutmidjic mdximeMdex ere iV guri^finosputdtnolledicere, Equidemquddoq;lt;J per fonde incidi tales, e^^r in rent quoq^ (quod en Wâ** Subfleere te* rdrum) qua obtineri ni ft hoc arte non poffel â ^eMi f^Mer^quot;l ^â^^^^^fubiecijfedicebdturmdritotefidmentu^ ' furn ^ nero. ^eUur ebirogrdphÃ¼, mdrito expirante,barediiin e j fe,cr uerum erdt, Ham quid per leges infUtiti uxor poterat hares,id fuerat aHum, ut ad earn ^^ ^ taciturn fidei comiffum peruenirent.Et nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;j,lt;

* '^^â^^quari facile erdt,ft hoediceremuepal'amfeiif^^ ^j ^^ rÃ©ditas Ata ergo fuit nobis agendum, ut iit^^ ' .^ telUgerentfadium, delatores non pojfent ^f^^-itfi^ utdidlum,^^contigitutrunq;. Quodnon^e^'^â.^r^ ueritusopinionemia(ldtia,nifi probare uoluifen') ro quoq;effehisfigurislocum.Quidametialt;1â gt;nbsp;bare non pof is,figurapotius ff argenda fuut'â nbsp;nbsp;^^

nim nonnunq telum iftud occultum,et hoeipfo lt;1^ ^^ apparet,eximi non poteft^Atfi idem dicas palam^ fenditur, eyprobandum edl, Cum autÃ© oifiatnoinf fona r euer ent ia (quod ficudum pofuimus genus) tan cdutius dicendum e^l, quanto ualidius bonos inbibetpa

oor,^ mttM. Hic ver o tegere nos index ({uod feiAmm, ^uerlA ui i^uAdAmueritAtiserumpentiAcredAtcoÃ«r'

Â«Â«, Ndm quinto mmiK,Aut ipÃ in c^uos dic'mus, dut âam^q^ââ'â indices dut AÃiÃentes odermt hdne mdledicendi Idfci^ mAfi nolle nos credAntfAut lt;[uid intereÃ^quomodo diÂ» ^Â«ur,eum t:^ res (^ Animus mteUigitur^ QMid dieÃ«do ^fni^ proÃcimus,niÃ ut pAUm Ãt nos fdeere^c^uod i^Ãt Ãiimus nonejÃe fAciendum?Atc[ui pneipue primdteini^ tw prfeipfre caperAttempord hoc uitio lAiordrunt.

^iceiint enim Uhenter tAles controuerÃds qwÂ« difficult idtis grAtid pldcent^cumÃnt njultbfdciUores^ Nirn re-^nm genus dpproidri niÃ mdxmis uiribus non poteÃ^ htciinerticuldcrdnÃ-dilus Ãeffugid Ãmt tnÃrmitAti^ M^uicurlupdrum udlent^Ãexu eludunt,cuinhÂ£cque ifÃddtur rdtiofententidrÃ¼, non procul Ã rdtione ioedn di Abhorrest, Adiuudt etid ^uod Auditor gdudet mteUi Zâ^f.Oquot; fduet mgenio fuo,cr dUo dieÃ«tefe lAUddt.Udc^ Â«o fois fi per fond oiÃdret reÃ«ig or dtioni,^uo m genere fepivs modo q figures opus eÃ^decurrebdt dd fichemdtd^ fid fdeiebAntiUis locum etid uhi perfone inutiles de neÃt rit effent, ut fi pdter c[uimfdmern in mdtrÃ« filium fe' is

1 treti occidiffet, reus mdlÂ£ trdddtionis, idculdretur in i nxorem oblic^uisfententijs. ^dmcpiidimpwius gretiÂ»

\ tÂ»f Kw^iiM fummu ne fus fuf^iedtus de uxore uiiedtur, , Ã¯lt;â'dWfidip/ddcfeÂ»^oMc,qÂ«oddilMendMcfl? At fit J ludicum fumerent dnitnMwJcircnt g eiufmodi dHionem ! l4tÂ«rt wnfuiffent^multo^ etidm minus, eum in pdretes ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;WM

$4*5 M, FAB. oyiNT. INSTlTlt; abomininddertmindf^drgerentur- Et quitniM^'^^ dmnijpdulo flus fcholif demm. l^dm zy m kis dua^^'^ ordtor^Oquot; in eo i^uo modo decldnKtur,pofituin fji ^^â^â^ quo modo dgdtur. deendum ergo de kis quo^,in ^' bus non djjserds figures, fed pdlÃm contrdrids cdufÂ£ fÂ» riq; fcceruntt Tyrdnnidis d/^Hdtit ddmndtus torqis^^^ turent confeios indicet. Aceufdtor eins optet quad uoletgt;^ PÃ¢tre qui' Edtrem qui deeufduit, optdt ne is torquedtur. PUcf â^ dÃ¢dÃ¢nauit cotrddicit.biemofetenuitdgenspropdrteqtunfigtit^^ infiUum fdccret^tduq ilium confdum 'm tonnentis notni ndturus,Quo quidÃultiusf 'b^dmeum koe indices im^ xcrint,dut non torquebitur, eÃ¼ ideo torqueri uelint,dut torto non credetur. At credikile e^ koe eum ueUefor'^ tdffe^DiÃimulct ergo ut effeidt^Sed nabis (decldindton bus dico ) quid prodcrit hoe 'mteUexiffe, wÃ diueriâ^^ Ergo Ã uere dgeretur,Ãmiliter conftliu iHud Idto'^f^'â didijfemus. Qtiâd, Ã nec^ utic^ ucru ell,(!r k^â^'^ ^ â'*f bic ddmndtus contrddieendi edufts potejl/ul quod lege confcruMdH putet,uel quad noUt deeufdtori dekere le' neficiHm,uel (quad ego mdxhne fequerer) ut fe innoceii tem 'tn tormentis effe prÂ£tÃªddt^ Ã^udre ne Slud quidem femper faecurret Ãc dieentibusiPdtroc'mium boe uÃ³luit quicontrouerÃd,fmxit.Portuffeemm noluitÃcdt^ouo , lucrit.cont'muÃ³ne Ã iUe ftultecogitduit,nobis ^Â«o^Pi*^ tÃ¨ dicendum e^ e ^f ggg -^ ^^^Ãg dgendis Ãequentet non put o 'mtuendu quid litigdtor uclitdEÃ¼ et iÃ¼e'nibot genere Ã-equens errors putent dUud quofddm Heere, nbsp;taliquid dUudhelle,prdteipuecu'tntkemdteefi, :â\ .tutfdn

ORATOR. LIBER IX. $47^ ttwri lief at populdrejut w ilU controutrfid: Qui Autrui iofortiurfecerdt, z^T dVo leUo petierdt^ut militid ud- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^

WettxIfgf, ^Â«od ^HMjqMdgfndrfuj efjet ,dducrldnte filio irr tn dxiem codÃluidefcruit.Tilius lt;^ui fortiter co* dfm prxlio fecerdt^mcolutnitdtcm eiw optdt,cotrddicit tlt;tcr.Non fnMÂ»,wqK[Â«nt,gt;Â«ori vult, fed i/nuididm filio f^-. EdMicifm ridco^cued iUi fie timcnt,tdn^ ipfimo fituri^cr m confilium fuos metus fcrunt,Ã³bliti tot exem florum cired ucluntdridm mortÃ«, edufdrum e^uo^i c[udamp; fcstft fddtui ex uiro forti defertor. Sed de twd coiitro-Kfrpdloqui /Â«pfrMdcUMcft. Ego in uuiuerfum neg; or4 torisputo eÃe un^ pneudriedri, neque litrmmtcOigo, '*âââqua pars utrdej^ idem uelit,ncq- tdm fiultÃ¼ queny, ciu ft uiuerr uelit mortem potius mdle fetdt,^ omnino no pe tit. NoÂ» tdmen nego eÃe controuerfiM Vuiufmodi figu gt;'^Â«,utcsli[ia; RriM fdrricidij,(luodfidtreoccidiffett ^umudtHm iri uidchdtur. Vdter pro tefmenio dixit, eÃ¼ fe idlente feeiÃe. Aifolutu didiedt. Ãdmnee^ intotum filio pdreit, nee quod priorc iudicio dÃrmduit ,mutdre pitlim potfÃ,^ Ut non dwr^t Mltr4 porndm dldicdtionii

â¢M. Â«tÃ¤teÂ« Hmen^er ctJi'qud figvrd m ^drte plw -t-fd^ â*^*â fitquimlicft, m filio mmwSt Vt dutem nemo contrd id ^twiuuItdicitjiM potefidliqd melius ucUec^Udm dicit, QÃ¯Â® Wodo file dWicdtiw,^Â«! Ã putre Mt filium ex^pofitu '^ â^ fÂ» fdÂ«cdtÂ« folutis alimentif recipidt pofiuldt,reuo tlt;tri forti^f mduult,nÃ¶ tarnen qÂ«od petit nÃ¶ mtlt.E^l ld

Ã4S IVI. FAB. QVINT. INSTiT-fdcifedmur^fedper (judmidtn credibikm fuj^^o^^* ut m muit is controuer[iis,fed in hdc ^uot^- Rdftor nip intrd trigefmum diem, er rdpu pdtrem er^uum exo* rduerit, peredt. Qui exordia rdptipdtre [uum non exordt,dgit cum ea dementir. i^um Ã permittdt bkf^' ter,lis toUitur: Si nulldm jÃem fdcidt,ut non demtns,crn delis eer te uidedtur,er d fc iudicem duertdt .Ldtro iÃ¿' Occides tur optime. Occidet ergo ,Ã potero remiÃiw,cr ffÂ» fuo ingenio pdter GdUio, Durd dilimd bodie, durd, hen fortiorfuiÃi. Confinidfunt bis celebrdtd dpud Grtcoi fchemdtd, per quÂ£ res dj^erds molUiu ÃgniÃednt. row 'Tbemifloeles ÃK^ffe exiflmdtur AtbenienÃbus, ut ur' tem dpud deos deponerent, quid durum erdt dieere, ut reUnquerent, er qui uielorids dureds in ufum bellt eoH' fidri uolebdtjtd declmduit,uiÃ¼orijs utendum elfe-'^ot^ autÃª dÃ¼egorU Ãmile eR,aJiud dieere,dUud Ãe.QuteÃtumetidmeRquo modoeontrdÃgnnÃ^oÃ^on deri oportedt, er quidifemp ex diuerfo if^en^^^^^ f^ tduerunt,Ãeut Idtentid uitid refcinduntur.ldlt;pflt;gt;t^Ã¶ÃtÂ» quentiÃimeÃieiendum ell, dUter enim dilui obieUdnon pofjunt, utique eum qu^Ãio in eo eonÃÃit, quad Ãgurfi petunt. At eum mdle dmd Ãunt tdntum, ei' ^ 'â , ' gere intÃ©rim bonÂ£ eonÃeientix ell,dtque etiitn^t fvftigt;^ crebriores Ãgurte,qudm ut diÃmuUri poÃint, po^ubn dum cÃ,ut tUud nefeio quid,quod dduerfdrij obliquis Ãn tentijs ÃgniÃedre uoluerint,Ã Ãdutid Ãt, ob^p^ dutcertenonexigdnt,ut quod ipÃnondudentdieeref idiudiees non modo intdhgdntjed rtM ereddUtt

Vfife etiirn iUc^udnio diÃmtuUtio eH^ut m co Ãnotd e^ timfAiuld c^) ^ui cum eÃet contre cum iiHum ; lum per pAtroni tui cmeres,pArAtu Ã eÃe reÃoniit, er iu' dex conditionc Ujm e^,clAmdnte muitum diuocAtoÃche mAtAdererumnAturd toUi ^ut protmus etidrn prlt;ecc' ptÂ«m fit eiafmodi ÃgurK utendum tetnere no eÃe.Ter* ^ pQâitur tiÂ«m e^ genuien qwo fold meUut dicendi petitur occA fw, ideo^i id Cicero non put At eÃe poÃtum in condone, T4eejlillud,lt;iuoidemutiturinClodium. QtÃ¿butiÃe^ qui omniii fAcrificiA noÃet, fAcHe dfe dcos pUcAri poÃe ArhÃ¹rAbAtur.lroniA quoque in hoc genere mAterUÃe' lt;{AentiÃ'mA eÃ.Sed cruditiÃimumlonge,Ã per aUa rem (du miucAtur, ut cum Aduerfm tyr Annum, tpii fuh pd^ RQtamp;olitionisdominAtionemdepÃ¶ÃKrdtfdgitcompe^ titor, Mibt intc dicere non UcetÃu in me dieser po- *ââquot;**^ tej .Nuper tc uolui occidere. Vrequens mud eÃ^nec md* jnoperr cAptAndum, ^uod petitur Ã iureiurddo, ut pro erhtredAto-AtA mihi contingdt hgrede ÃUo mort.Ndm mtotttmiMwre niÃuhi neceÃe e{i,grAui uiropArum conuenit, ^teÃd Senecd didum degAnter,non pAtro^ norum hoc eÃeÃed teÃium. Ncc mereturÃdem epti fen~ tcntiohe grdtiA iurAt,niÃ Ãi poteÃ tdm bene c[uAm Demo Pro Calw fllxttcj, Â«tÃtpr'd dm. LcuiÃmum Autem lange genut ex uerho^ciiiiffjÃj fÃ ^p^^ Ciccronem iw ClodiAm: Prg^ fertmÃmm omnes AmicAm omnium potius,lt;piAm cuiuÃ lt;p*^'mmicAmputAMerunt. CompdrAtionemeeptidem rsparafo Â«idf0 jiguritm woÂ« eÃe^cum Ãt interim prohAtionis^mt Â° nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;*

cR pro Murlt;enx: Vigiles tu de node, ut tuit con[uito-ribui rel^ondetis, iUe ut quo contendit, nature cum cx' erdtu peruenUt, Te gattorum,ilium buccinurum antui cxu^citd, z:r cjeterd : nefcio emordtionis potius quim fententia fit, ld enim fblum mututur, quad non uniuer' fd uniuerfis, fed finguld fingulis opponuntur. Et Cd' fut tdmen, or non nÃ©gligent tutor VifeUiut,m hu am Lupus pdrte pofuerunt. RutiUut quidem Rufus in utroq; ^( nere,id^ Ã³-vllÃªiTop uocdnttPrÂ£ter iUd uero qut Cicero inter Ãumind pofuit fententidrum,multd dlid,et idi RÂ«' ^scuiâ^nÃ¢^*^'^'^^Ã¿â^fioutuÂ«,nonilium l,eontinum,feddlium num hodieofititemporis,cuiiii qudtuorlibros in mum fuumtrujlu âââriquot;'n *** â^}C:^ Celfus uidelicet Kutilio decedent,pofuerunt fehe' nibuieftjid mdtd,Confummdtionem,qudm Gncus 2joc^Â«W'^ mutiium SC cdt,cumplurddrgumentd idunum effÃ¨dum deduun' nonomnino â Æ

txplctum. tur.Confequent tik iTraoio%'is6naâip,dequonosiudrÃªuÂ» mentis dixim'ts,Colleilioneinqui dpud iHumeHo^^^* yicT/xÃ³i^. M.indt,id ell,KcÃ¯Ã¯sc7r'gt;,H^ip. Exhortidoni â ^oÃ¼ vÃ¤nop, quorum nihil non reilum eH, nifi cum dliquim exhisde quibuslocutifumus,figurdmdccipitgt; ^^^^^ hic Celfus excludere,djfeuerdre,detreildre,exdtdrdâ* dicern, prouerbijs uti, er uerfibus,er ioco, (7 igt;f^''^â^t er inuocdtione,intendere crime quod efi 2.tivÂ»â''?gt;â*^i^ ldri,ignofi:ere, fdjlidire,ddmonere, (dtiffuere,precitt, corripere,pgurds putdt, Pdrtitionem quoq; (T pfÃ¶pÂ® fttioncm,er diuifionem,et rerum dudrum cogndtionem, quod eA ut idem udlcdnt, que uidentur ejfe dinerfi, Â«t non is demumfit urne ficus,qui uitd dbfiuUt ddtd potiot^t

M chdw qui (Â«cÂ«/fiÂ«. Qttod cil in parte finitÃ®onis. RÂ« Â®us [me Gorgr'Ã¼tJjaya^KÃto/jjÃ vÂ« ^AVKc'f/jjÃ vSuTToqjoÂ» Ã®Â«(Ã¼jÃ v)iÂ§|Na'/^j,â^Â«u'^Ha'//j,-srjOÂ£Â«0i(n|U, quod cft diccre quid fieri oportwrit, deinde quid faitu fit, lt;^a.v2t.Ã³'nÃ¯tlt;x, ti^iefit ent}iymenu,wr mtixci/j, ^tOaXH^'P nar cu tlÂ«}! (tiim,lt;^uo fiatu aermigoms utitur.Vifidlius (pan qn^m paucifimas fadat figuras,facit lt;^Ã¨vp^Â»/J^a. tamÃ«^ qwod comentum uocat, er rationem appeUans,^^^^^* ^(winter eas habet.Quad qwidem recipit e^uoda mo' do cr Ceifius, nam confiecpeens an epichiremafit dubitat, 'VifieHius adijdt et fiententiarndnuenio qui AggregÃ«t bis 2uÂ«o't(6VÂ«^,a7rÂ«7ojtu(jâa(=,^a(r(H7Ko*ei5. Scd utbee Hou jiinf: ficbcmata/ic aliauelfuut fiorfittan et nosfugiut, nel etiim noua fieri adhuc pofifiunt,eiu(dem turnen natu-lt; twÂ« cuius funt cd de ^Â«tM didum efit.

VERborum nero figura,er mutata funt fiemper, Antique Â«5* er uteunep ualuit confiuetudo,mutantur,l.tapfi^'^^^^^'*^* dntiepmm fiermonem nofiro compare mus, penÃ¨ iam epeie cptiHoptmur figura cfi,ut huic rei vtiuidcre,non ut oÃ«s ueteres,ejâCicero pradpuc hanc rem,et incumbere idi, ââoÂ«in ilium, er plenum uino,non um, er huic no hune ââ^'ditri.Mw dicitur,er mille aUa,^ utinamq^ non peiord _ut5nam% Minc4nt.VfyHâj fichemata âXiSialt;^,duoru funt generum, quot;â^ ?âââ'* lt;ltfruÂ«i loque ndi rationem uocant,alterum e^uod coU maxime loe^twhc^^^jfj^f cxipiifitum, Quoru tarnetfi utrunlt;- adlt;oUoca^ qwfoftKfnitoMioni/umfftpQ/Ã¯wtaMdGritmmrfticwWjfuumrftT

hoc rndgK rhetoricum dicere. Prim Ãt: ij^cm genetibitt quibm uitid. Effet enlm omne hmuÃnodi fehernd uitWy gurS quo'mo/' gt;^opeteretur,fed deciderct, Veru dutoritite, mtu^d-do dtftndif. te^confuetudine plerunlt;j; defcnditur,fepe etidm ritio' ne quiddm. Ideoq^ cum fit d fimpUci redo^ lo^uenii ge nerc defiexd, uirtm ed, fi habet probdbile aiiijuid ([uoi fequdtur. Vnaidmenin re maxime utilis, utlt;iuotiiiiini cr femper eodem modoformati fermonit fafiidiumle* uetyOr nos d uulgari dicendi genere dÃ©fendit. Ojioji qu!s parce,lt;^ cum res pofcct^utetur^uelut aÃ^erfo (pioÂ» dam condimento iucundior erit^At qiÂ» nimium aÃidd' uerit,ipfdm iÃ¼am gratia uarictatis amittet.Qudnl [unt quÂ£dam figura ita receptÂ£,ut penÃ¨ iam hoc ip[um name ^ifugerint,lt;iua etiafi futrint erebriores,auras confite' tm mmm frrient, Nam ficreta, ar extra uulgarcufitm pofita, ideo^ magisnobilcs, utnouitate auremexcitifi ita copia fiatiant, nee fe obuias fuifje dicenti,fii comiui' fitaf,amp; ex omnibus Utebris extradas cÃ¶gefiaj; iâlt;^^'^'â _. rant, Eiunt ergo ^ circa genus figurÂ£ in noini/nibus. genus in no* Ntim er oculis capti talpÂ£, e:y timidi damÂ£ dicuntur d minibus. nbsp;nbsp;Vergiliofed fubed ratio, quia fexm uterji alterafigni

Per genus f^^^*'''* Tiamenimmdreseffetalpos damas'^,Ã¯ ff^ââ^quot; in uerbis. nas certum ed.Et in uerbis,utfdbricatm efi glaiium,tt

inimicos punitm efi^QÃ¿od miru minm efi, queimMU ra uerboru efi, e:;r tputfacimm patiendi modo fiepe dice re,ut arbitror,fuffiicor, CT contra faciendi, c^ag pati' mur,ut uapuin,idcoq;freqtiÃ«s permutatio efi,et pleralt;^ utrolt;^ modo e^runturfiuxuridtur luxuriatfiuduatur

ORATOR. LIBER IX. ÃÃJ p'^^Mt^iffemioraffentio.E^ Ãgur tl O'M numero,uel?er name^-^iimÃngiiUri plurdÃ¯is [uhiimgitur : Glddio pugnciciÃigt; '^f^g^nsKomtmi. Gens culm ex multKt VelÃ© dinerfot

, nbsp;Ex iÃÂ« foiÂ», aui non riferc^ nÃ¶ divndtw deM,nec ied tWe quelÂ«

1 ^tnoÃrwniÃuduiwretriÃe, Aj^exi, cum n^nito nerbofa ufm pro dppeÃdtione. ^oÃrnm enim PÂ« partes-Wd wilt mteÃ¼igi^Vtimtir Oquot; nerbo pro pdrticipio^mt

iMijMinferendt/m. Et pdrtlcipio pro uerbo, Volo dd^ tlt;im,\werimetiddubitdripoteÃ¼,cui fimileuitio fitfehe flt;ii,nt'mboc: nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;VirtuieHuitiimfugere.

^M tnm pirtes ordtionismutdt ex iUotVirtiK eSlfn* Hor.i .Â«piÃ. gititiorim,dutcdfiti ex iHoi VirtmeSl uitiumfugereÂ» Percafus. WmIm tarnen boe utroc[} excitdtiiu. lungwntur interim ÃlnmUdStbendut feiÃ¨s pugnie. Eft enim feiens Sthene l^i^pngnindi.Trdnsferivntur etidmtempordi Timdr^ (blits ntgit e^e ei periculM d fecuri. triefens enim pro Per tÃ©porx' praterito pofitnm elt,ut VergiUust Hoc ub-iciM uelit. Et tic morer,per omnid generd, per c[UÂ£ ft foloeeifmut, Wec eft quoque qwdtÂ» kTi^actip uoednt, cum diÃimilis Hetwofis^ e^^cugmidicjtMrjttt dpud SdÃ¼ufium :Ne$ ed res fdU

tgt;oâJtÂ«em,lireÂ«it4s etidm peti folet. Vnde eoufepte pro eejfm fH,nt UQ,, poeÂ»itÂ«riwn,pro won dÂ£two poeniten t^impSquot; uifuros^dd Â«tdewdÂ« miffos idem dntor dixerit,.

QÂ«/ lÃ¼c quidc feccrit fchemM,M idem uoedri forint uidendum^quiu receptd fint^ Ndm recept is etidm wulgo lM^^^i lt;gt;'^I^Â°^^ eonicitti fumas. Verwm futur d euAluit dgentiÂ» tibus. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;lgt;iis,quod PÃ³llio in Luhieno damnat, er comumdiimf

cit,quod Ã Cicerone reprehendi notum eÃ¼. Afjici eni/n . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;confumeUiidiccbdnt ,.Aliiicommendiitiouetu^dtis,cu*

Vel om fe pduidum contra meaiurgia iadati Progenic fed enim Troiano Ã fangume duci Audierat. Quorum fmilia apud ueteres tragicos, comicosq; funt pÃ¯urma.lÃ¼ud etiam in confuctudinc remanfit.Pttifnuea ro his amplius apud eundemi tiarn quit te iwienum confidentiÃime, cum quis fermot niswitiumÃtjCn

Georg; 4, j^^ mugis ilia tremens,amp; triÃihut effera flanmif, Quam mugis effuÃ crudeÃunt fangumepugif^' Q^odeduerÃmexilloi nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^â*â'?^S

Qt^dm magis lt;erumna uiget, tarn magis ad tualefacieiu Pleni talibus antiqui,ficut mitio Eumuclfi Icremius: Quid igitur faciam,inquit.

Sed prias dum,ÃgniÃcat quoad,fequens,uÃieo. Ex gr^ co uero tranflata uel SaUuÃij plurma, quÃ¤le eUttmlgiU *â** amat Ãeri. uel Ãoratij.tdam is maxime probat hoc CiÂ» trua(Ã¼Â°hfc ^^^Â°^^' Nec longe inuiditaucnÂ£.

ORATOR. LIBER IXÂ» 5$f tMefigurArMn diditio ^ abicHio cft.lUd^ prior w* ilfri poteft [uperMeMfid non fine grdtid eÃ»t

Pole ft mm dteÃe ultcriwn.Et rfpwJ Hor^tum illud: Ã¯AbrÃ¹ium^ liunc,z:j-tntonÃsCuriumclt;ipiUK. ^Etdetra' Eft ftidm ddicHio, c[UÂ£ m complexuftrmonK Autuiti aiones uw bdletyiutfigurdm! Accede dd ignem bwicjim caÃ¯eÂ» fees pb ptM,plus enim quam fatis eft.NÃ de dite ai^Vfupaiquot; ril qÂ«Â£ detridio eÃ^plurHuf dicendueÃ.Vtimur wdgÃ´ funtj ft com^irdtiuK pro dtfoÃ®ntw, Â»t cam fe qÂ«Â« 'mÃrmiore f^edixerit, duo inter fe compdrdtiud comittimiKiSi te Cdtitnidcomprehendi, Ã mterÃei iuffero^ credo erit '*âÂ®'â Â«frmdiwn mibt, ne non potitw onmes boni ferius Ã mc, quim qaifqiUiM crudcUus fddÃ¼ effe diat. Siwit iJU Â«on stc a ilia fmJix foixeiÃno t^uidem ,fed tdmen numcrum mutAn^t tin, qalt;e er tropw dÃigndri foment, Â«t de nno plural* t^iiedmust

H4Â«d feew dc pdtrijs deer R orndnus m drmif, specie dwerfdjed genere eddem zr bÂ£c furntt

Nec imbi turn moUii fub dio edrpere fomnos^ Nee nofla ^fxdorfonemoris Ubedt idcuiÃe per herbds, moUss ^ât filitn nefcio cui edij prins, nee poÃcd fibi umiy fed, ownibuspy^fi'pjfEj. dc nobis Ãoi^uimur tdnepid de alijsi Owt SerailÂ«, NegitxuHijÂ«. Â£tnoÃrd per fond uti'^ ^'^^ptodbendfif dUosprodliffagirniiSi Vtriuf^ rei

exemplum pro CeemnA; Pifonem diuerfe pirtif ^^ cat urn uUoquens Cicero dicU: ReÃituiffe te dixtilt;^^^ me ediÃo prgtoris reftitutum tffe.Verim enim ^ ** flituiffep.butiutdixitt^egomeCeemMedidoP^^^'â* â â r!crcjiitutÃeffc.vbiamp;ipfu,mdixti extritA^y^Al'i,l^ gWA in uerbo cRaUa quoique ex eodemgenere po^'^^ uideri, lt;pum nas mterpoÃtionem, uel mterclufionem Â« Parenthefis. cimuifir^cixsix^Ã¯vuia'iiJ uocAiit^dumcont'tnMtioniÃf monif mediut AÃiquis [enfin iÂ»teruenit:Ego cm te(tnef ciimeÂ»imflt;epiÃimeloquitur)pdtriÂ£reddidilfemXiÂ»

/. yper ato. ^j^gf^f, nypcrhÃ¤ton, non iÃ¼ud lt;^uod inter tropos eÃe uoluerunt, fed dUerum quad eH eim fgurf femeitdit* riM^quiie ^Tcos^apÃ¹ diciturÃmÃ¤e^ cum nonfenf^i i^gt;^* Utur,uerum formel eloquendi: Decios,t/ldrios,mdgnos^CdmiUos.

Qtii tdm pdriu. momentd nominibus difcreuerwt, /xtÂ« Tlt;xSoinâi/j uoednt, qudm v dUter fieri putdnf.OÃ¿^^o* quor,dut ubi fumfConiunxit dutÃ« xsoi^Ã³i^ip C Â«t^*

Acneid 9 â^'âââ^ proeul inde cita Mctium in diuerfd qudirigc DiflulerdntCdttudiÃ¼liiAlbdnemdneres) Kdptdbdt^ uiri menddeis uifcerd TuÃM.

idirAtoncm, dftrddÂ«oÂ»fw,ordiÂ«fgt;Â«,er coHMcrtu^t wÂ» Je AuHtorem^ncc Unguere pAtiwntur fuhindc aU^m no titlilifigurÃ© cxdtdtwmt^ hdheni t^Mnddm ex iÃ¼d uitij fmUitui'me grdtidtUt utÃ¯ncibis intÃ©rimdcor ipfeincivil dut c/l.QMod contmgetfi nec^ fitprd modwm muhie fuÃ¨ Twt^nec eiufdÃ« gcncris,iut ivmdiydut frecpieittes,c[uid Idtietdtem ut udrietM edrÃ¼,itd rdritM effugit.iUud ell^ ^nut geniu,^uod non tdntum in rdtione poÃtum eh lo ^iieniijtd ipÃs fenÃbm turn grdtidm, turn etidm uires iKonmoddt. E ^Mibw prwntww Ãt (pwd Ãt per ddiedio Â«tm, plurd funt generd ,ndmcf uerbd gemmdmur nel impiiÃcdndigrdtid,ut occidi,occidinonSp, iiieUum^ EpÂ»nodos4 Altfrimeftcnim ^wod indicdt,dlterwm eptod d^rmdt, 'Veimiferdndi, ut'. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ab Corydon, Corydon:

0Â«Â« eddem Ãgurd nonnMicpum per ironidm dd eleudii dion conuertitur. SmiUi gÃ©miHdtionis, poh dUcpidm in i^tiellionem,repctitio eh,^cd pduloetidm uehemetior: ^ni,miÃfu^ me (conÃmptK enim Ã¯dehrymK, tumen mÃxwi in'mo baret dolor ) Bond, mipidm, Cn.Pompeij ^trbiÃima uoeÃ® Ãubiehd praconift. Viuis,z^ uiuis non *ideponenddni,Ãeddd confirmdnddm duddeidm.Bt db ijfdfiw uerbis plurd dcriter er inÃdnter MpiwntiNÃ¼ bd ne te noflumiHn praÃdium pdldt'ij,nihil urbit uigii b^ÃtBuor populf, nihil confenjut bonorum omnb coticurfuÃ¯ Â«ân.âiibilbicB,n^ft,yjj,BiÂ« bdbÃ«di fendtiu Ãocitf,nihil boÂ» fmonuultm^. mouerundEtijÃdemdeÃnumt: C^uis ^Â°^l^Â°Hidt^AppiiM,CtjÃ¿sperduxidAppiui.iiudn^

TÃ®S M. FAB. OyiNT. INSTiT.' inter fe (:^ fines ijiem ^ti'nt,quis Oâ lt;}uis,Af fills CT ^P pius-duile efiiQjii font qui faderu liefe ruftrutiCÂ» thdgmenfes. C^ui funt qui beUwm crudelifimef^cjfmii CÃ¤rthdgmenfcs. Qui funt qui ItalÃ¹m dcfornuruK Cif thagmenfes.Qui funt qui fibi igyiofiipoliuldiKfCdrtbt ginenis. Etidin in contrdpofitis uelccmfurdtiuis,filet reffodere primorum uerborum alternd repetitio,quoi modo huius ejfe loei potius dixi i Vigilas tu de node,ut tuis confultoribus rej^ondeas ,iiÃ¯e,ut eÃ¨quÃ¨ intendit, mdture civm exercitu peruenidt. Te GdlÃ¯orum,itlum lue einarum camus exufeitant. Tu adionem infiituisdÃ¼e a* cicm mfiruit. Tu edues neconfiltores tui, iÃe neuriet, aut cafird edpidntur. Sed hac grdtid non fuit contentui quot;^ ordtor,uertitmcontrdriivm eandemfiguramdlletenet O' fcituthofliumcopiie, tu utdquitplusiiidrcedmur. lÃ¼e exercitatur in propagandis finibus, tu in regendis. Po/funt medili quolt;^ reffondcre,ucl primif/t' Te nemus Angitiie,uitred te Eudnui unda. ^ â T-cum et ipra ^ ^^ ultimis,ut:Ã¼lt;ec nduis et onufid pneda SiÂ«lifÂ«PÂ»'^^â effets prx' ipfd quoq; effetetiampriedd. Ã¯^ecquifquantduUtduit idem paffe fieri iterdtis utfimp; medijs, 'P.efiondentprt mis o uitimd: Multi ey graues dolores inuenti paren* repetidi' tibus,etpropinquis multi,Efl et illud repetendi genus, gnum, ^^^^ femel propefitaiterdt o diuiditt

Jphitus crPelidsmecim,quorum Ã¯phitus^uo Jam grduior,PcÃ¯ids o uulnere tardus VlyÃiÂ» sTToevoJ^ot^ dicitur gr^ce , noftri regreÃionem uoednt, Hcc folu in eodem fenfu,fed etia in dinerfi eadem uerli

wwr^ fumu/ntur i Pfmcipum dignity erdtpenepixr, Bou pir forti ffe eorum qui fiqueb^ntur, liiierim iw# ^^â5â^(5^^* mtw afibui hiiec O' s^ntribus iterAtio.MagtiM cÃ id h^c K gene lor dietndimdvnci res rH. Et rfbwd RÂ«tiIitHÂ« longiort H** retraÃa 'n nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tio.magnus

ce^uJ a er bÂ£c wild fententidrum funt: Pdter bic tu'' cd labor di-ut^pdtremhiittcdppetlM; p!itrKtulnuiMÃliM estait âMâ. magna cdÃbm modo hoc fchcmii,cptod zsoTi.u-nftSloi} uocd,ntgt; Co fpatris tui Jliit Cr dlijs ctiim modK,ut pro duentio : Quod dutem films eft. tepiÂ« utneni ddndifVndt iUd p'cqutwUfper c[uÃª porri ditH?Â«Â«de fumptu/mfepix porro interceptio poculi,cur Bon de mtfgro nut ddtiwn^ Hanc rertwÂ» coniunfinm d i wrfitdtÃ¨ CgciUia /j.iTKSÃ¼'XviJ uoedt, cptilis dl pro ClÂ» ^'i^^Â°^** tiKio locm m Oppidnicui'iUumtdbuldx pubUeds woliffÃ¨^ ctnforiM corrtipiÃc,dtcurioncs ivniuerÃ Micduerimt, cum iÃ¼o ntmo rdtionÃ©^nemo rem Â«BÃ coiHrdhtbdt,nemo illuwcx tarn muit is cogndtis 0 dÃinibui tutorem wn^

liberis fuis fcripfit^o demceps ddhuc nmltd .Vthdc in Diffipata-Â»Â«Â«9Â» congeruMur,itd-i-contrd iUd dijfcrÃiÃint,lt;piÂ£ 4 'â¢quot;^^ Cicerone diÃipdtd did putot

biicftgttts^iHic utniuntfÃ¤idus uuf, Arbordfatut. odemeepSi lUduero Â«ipud Ciceronew mirdÃgurdrwm mixturd deprehendi^ txif jâm qm cj- primo utrbo longo poft interiuUo reddi* tâ¢ eft ultimum.o- medid primist tt medijs ultimd cott gruum, VejlriÂ«n idm biefddum deprebenditur. P.G. nonmeuwjtte pukberrimiÂ«Â« quidem fddwm, Â«ertwÂ« MÃ©

Â«âÂ»Â«oBmcaw ftd ueÃrum. Herne freopttmiorem repcf' titionem wxÃKiy nocdtit, i^ug Ãt ex permixtw Ãguridf^^^^^'

Ut fupm dixi, ut^ habet epiÃola ad lirutum : EgoÂ«Â»* w gratia redicrim earn Appio Claudia,et redierm Pquot; Cn.Pompcium,te ego ergo cum redierim â¦ Et ifl ^1^^ fententijs crebrioribm mutata dedmationibui ittratio* neuerborum,0'apudPerfiumÃ¯ vfc^adeÃ³nt Scire tumn nihil e^,niÃ te fetre hoc fciat alteri Et apud Ciceronem: lieque enim poterat indicia tx bif damnat is qui iudicabamur. Sed fenfas quo^; totiquciÂ»^ adinodumcixperunt,deÃneiit:VcnitmAfta,bocipÃ'^ quant bonum fTri. pl. uenit ex Apa.ln eadem tarnen ft^ riodo^uerbuM ultimum primorefertur,tert!umiaÂ»f abiÂ«aum fermone adieHum eiliVeruntamenuenit.lnieriÂ«gt;[âgt;' tentia quidem repetitur ,fcd eodem uerborum ordint^ Qjiid Cleomenet facer e potuit flio enim pojfum quel infimulare falfotduid inquain Cle amÃ¨nes feere patuo it^Priorts fÃ¨ntentiee uerbum ultimum ac [equemt^ pn* mum frequenter eÃ¼ idem, quo quidem fbemaie uturn* turpoÃ«teefepiuti

Pieridet uot heec facietis maxima Gdilo, GaUocuiufamor tantum mihi credit inhor at- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

Sed neoratores quidem raro:Hic tarnen uiuit,uiuii-â^Â° uero etiam in fenatum uenit. Aliquando feut in gemtna done uerborum diximut,initia quoq; e:^ clauflf AÂ»lt;w tiaru alijs, fed non alio tendentibut uerbis inter fc con^ fanant. Initia hoc modo: Oederm periculis omnibut,ou tukrim mftdijt,obiecerim muidig. Rurfiu claufult HÂ»^ Metonym ^ffff yÃ¯^fj^; y os enim fatuiflis,uos fententiam dixifrh D^undio, tÂ«^i Micaflis, Uoc alij ^iTetiW/jtlcep, alij difundiuif^quot;'

ORATOR. LIBER IX. $61 McM,utrwn(lj(.cMmfi efi diuerÃu/myrcde.Ã®fidmeli no nimu/miiemÃgniÃcdntiuim fepdrdtio. Congregdntur qÂ«oq; turididem ÃgniÃedntidi Qmie cum itdfiw Cdtigt; IiÂ«((,pfrgf quo cecpiÃi.Egredere dUt^mndo ex uric.Ed tent fortiijprofici^ccrc.Et in avndem dUo UbroiAlijU cxccÃit^erupitfCUdÃt.iioc CdcUio â ^s7\.^ovxaâ/xÃ´q uide* tÂ«r,id fA, dbunddsfuprd neeeÃitdtem ordtio,Ãcut iUd : quot;Vidi oculis dnte ipÃc mets. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;In Ã®Ho cnr/n uidi, wie ft Ã®p/f. Verum id,ut dUo qHoqÂ«c loco dixi, cum fuperM* em onerdtur ddie{iione,uitium didturtcum dutem du* ietmdnife^dm fcntentidm,ÃKUt li}ic,uirtu(: Vidi,ipÃe, Vidct ipfe inte oculos,ciuot uerbd,totidemfivnt uffÃ¨Ã©luttCur time t^yÃªm fe* 11Â«proprienomwJf tdlinotdrit/ionwdeo.tiamcr get tus H!in4t!o o- repetitio Gr qualifctMjq; diicclio wAtovaa' tJ-o^uideripoteH. Nec uerl)dmodÃ ,fed Ãnfu^ queque HemÃicientes deerudntur: Eerturbdtio iÃum mentis,et nbsp;nbsp;'

queddm feeler um offuÃdcdUgo, er dr denies furidrum f^^esexeitdrivnt.Congeruntur or diuerfdi MÂ«I[fr,tgt;* âfâââÂ»âifÂ«iwcrÂ«delitlt;Â«,pfitrw dmorÃrd frÂ£ceps,temerig idf,dementia, Et dpud Ouidiumt

Srd grjKe Nrrriduwi numen,fed comiger Ammon, ^'d qÂ«e MifccribiÂ« ue nie bdt beUM fonti ^â^uranddmeis^ lnwÂ«iqyiÃ§j.jjQÃ§âoÃ§^yp^ -kXok^'jj rui non dÃÃentior, Ãâtt urii^ ÃgurÂ£,mixtd quoque^GT idem et diner* l^ K^^fiedniii ,qMod er ipfum d^iai^Ã³iynii uoednt. ^^Â°âgt;binmicK ,Ãni'ne b^emueÃigdtd,compertd. Diallage. e*^^i*^d,fu,mti^ifl^tii^ fxtmUd per me. Et mueÃi*

rÃ¶t M. FAC. QVINT. INSTlT* gdtd,compertd,pdtcfdild,dliud oÃenduntiSubliid, iâ* Idtd, extindd, fu^t inter fefimiUd ,fed non etiim pr*Â®* ribut. Et hoc dutem exemplu/m, CT fuperiui dliM ^f*Â®* que efficitmtÃgurdm: qug quid coniunHionHui cdreti Diffolutio. ^^ffÂ°^â*^fâ^ uocdtur^dptdeum quid mÃdntiui dicWlUf num ce Ãnguld meukdntur^er qudÃ plurdÃwtdi^^^ que utimur hde Ãgurd non in Ãnguld modo uerbis,Ã'^ fententqs etidm, ut Cicero dicit coiurd concionem Ho teUit Quiindiedbdntur,eosuoedri,euÃodiri, diÃnif BraeMo' ^*^ ddduci iuÃi, in fendtu funt poÃti. Et totm hie Io* gia. cui. Hoc genns ^^Â«xu^oyiav uoednt, que poteH e^e copuldtddijfolutio. CoiUrdriumeÃ Ãhemd, quoi cor/-Pol^/^'dâ ^'^'^âÂ°^â^^ dbunddt.iUud ^c!'c0jKrov,hoc-3!o7iVdWi* Â° ^ ^quot; ' J^TOv diciturjhoc eil uel ijfdemftpim repetitii:^ti

Adueriu quoque c pronomina MrUntur. nie iUum uidi itmenemi nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;BiÃinos oÃ¹ not Ãrddief.

Sed utrtwe^ horum coicerMtio t etenim MÂ«Â«iiwiÃ4 dut dijjblutd, omnibus feriptores fud nomini ieierwiit, fed udriÃ¤^ctutcuit^ ÃiigcMipiicuit.FonstluiiemiviW., quid deriord fdeit, (^ inÃdiuiord qute dicimm, er ww

ORATOR. LIBER IX. ÃÃ©? iff irlttn, er migis o^vUitum, idfo^ tffe rdrier dc^ Ict.E/l dWtm ip(d ^ue^ ddiedionis.Kepctit en'm c^ua ^1^4 fimt^crpriuftiudmdd dUud defcenddt,'tn prior id itÂ« refijlit, EftÂ« fxf wpÃ®ion fx graeco notiÃimo trdnsfe ^^|^j^ Mtur: Nfc b^c dixi fluidem, fed nee fcripji, nee fcripfi nbsp;nbsp;â qwdfm ,fe d nee obij legdtionem^nee eihij t^uidem/ed nee perfuifi T:Mdn(i,nec perfudfi epiidem.Stvnt tdmen eru* dit^ Cr Idtmd.ÃÃ-'icdno uirtutem mduÃrid,uirttK ^0Â» nim,glorid itmuloscompdrduit. Et CdlwÃ¼Nonrygo wdgÃ peciMiidrutw rcprturd^rÃ¼w quim mdieÃdtiSi ned qufmÃ¼iejidtK mJgwqÂ«4m Pldutilt;elcgis ,nequePldUd fif IcgK m^gii quÃm lt;imlittÂ«,nf q; ambitie nidgis quÃ m wmiium IfgMw wdtcM pmeruwt. InMemtMr dpud PoÃ« lt;tÂ«Â« Â«ft. tÂ«qÂ«oquf,Ht4pMd Homcruw df feeptroeÃ¿ioddÃ¯oue Â«d Ag^mcmfionem uf^wc deducit^^ dpnd noÃrwn eÃ¼d

loue propÃg.iÃ®iw r/Kut pfr!7ikÂ«t)T4iitaliw, Ex Tdutdlo PflopÃ¯/x Pflopc dutem fdtut Atwu^M noÃrftm porrÃ³ propdgdt geniw.

At^itperdetrAlHonem fiwnt Ãgurji, treuitdtii nod uitdtitÃ¯^ mixime grdtid pftuntur.qitÃ³rum wnd eh Â«,^^2^â** qiumitbroproximo Â»1 figure diÃuU fynecdoeiie ,cwm syneedwÂ» fK^tTÃ¤ftum Merbum dliqMod fdUs ex etteru mteUigid 'ââ*â¢ . ftt*'gt;ittC(cIfiM in AiMomiwn : Stuperr gdwJio GrrfciÂ«. Siwul enm duditureoepit. deerodd Brwtu-m ; Sermo nuUMfedicet niÃ de te. QjÃ¹d enim potiwf TumPktti* wtErm inquit tdbenarif/1 ego iiidem orans inter cÅ Will txoTAui.Cui Ãmilidfwtt lUd meo e^uidem tudiciojiÂ»

$^4 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTiTÂ« ^uibiu uerba dccctuer pudoris gratin fubtnbu/ntitÃ¯i Houimus zr ejui tetranfucrfn tuentibm birtiuift Et,quo,Ãd faciles Ã®^ympha rifcrefaceUo.

Hane quidam apofwpefim putantfrujlra.KimtHi Ãââ3 taceat incertum eÃ¼, dut eer te longiore fermone expb'^^ divm,liicumu/muerbuâm,QrmanifeÃumquidenidef^^* ratur, quÂ£fi dpofiopefis eR, nihil in quo deelt dlilt;Ã¿^gt; non idem appeUabitur. Ne ego idud quidem apofiopef firn fempcr uoco,in quo res quxeune^ relmquieur intelh genda, ut ea quainepiftolis Cicero : DatalupcnalÃ¼ui quo die Antonius CÂ£[ari, nihil obticuit,luftig qi*^^ Â«^ bic aUud inteÃigi poterat,quamhoc,diadeMaiigt;ipoluitâ Altera ell per detraHionem figura, de qua tnododiltu ell, cuiconiundtones eximwntur. Tertia quedicttuÃ¯ (rtwi^S/y/aSjJo/}, in qua unum ad uerburn pluses femeâs tiÂ£ referuntur,quaruunaquÂ£lt;^ defiderarctilludtl'r^ poncretur. ld accidit aut prÂ£pofito uerbo ad qud i(u* qua, refpiciantsvicit pudorem libido,tiitioi'csa audacia, rationem amentialt; Aut iÃato,quo plura cUuiu'aiUs^l^e que enim is es Catilina,ut te aut pudor unquam a turpi* tudme,aut metus Ã periculo,aut ratio Ã furore reuocaue rit. Medium quoq^ potell effe,quod or prioribus (T Ã queiuibus fu^iat â¦ 1 tingit autem (^ dinerfosfexM, ut cum mare faminam^ filiosdidmust^tfingulariaplu ralibus mifcet.Sed hÂ£c adeÃ¨ funt utilgaria,utftbiartein figurarum afferere nonpoÃint. lUud plane figura eUf qua diner fa firmonis forma coniiwgitur:

ORATOR* LIBER IX. S^S ^iico^^dimiellum cwm gentegerenium. ^lUnuiienimpars leUipojlerior pdrticipio inÃjidtt Wn^ timen conuenit iUui edico^nim utric^ detnaia* Nwgntufidi coniu/ndio. XiMoiKi'ioia'ip uoeau^ejuÃ¦ iuMresdiuerfas coUigitiTimdeeÃ duirolt;[uod hiiett quim qÂ«od non bibet.Uuie diuerfdm uÃ³limt effe diÃmiâ ^io^m, CM dint nomen ^Ad^iocsoycvp, ({MÃmUid di^ Ãfenwitur, cum te pro dÃnto fdpientem ippeUes, pro ^ojidente fortem,pro iÃ¼iherili diUgentem, lt;[uod totum prndet ex Ãnitionejdeo^ dn Ãgun fit dÃ¹bito.Cui con^ tririi efl ei cpiÂ£ ex uiemii trdnfit dd dinerfd dut firniÃ 1*1*5 'Rrcuis efiie Idioro^ dbfiurut fio,cr qwx fenuuntur^Tcrtium ed genui figurdrum,lt;[uÂ£ dut fiimb ÃurfineKliqtu uocum,iut pdribui,dut contrdrijsuertut wfe dwej ct cxcitdiuAiuic nomen cd 'Jt^oo'a,vofxao-itXj qÂ»f didtur ignomÃ¯mtio. Ed non wno modo fieri fioÃ¯et, fed ex uiemii c^uidi prxdiili nommis dudi afiibui de^ ebmitur^ut Domitim A fer pro CloitiUa iituÃ¯ier rerum omnium impen'td, iÂ« omnibut rebm mfelix.Et cum uer bo idem uerb-m plut fignificinter fubiu/ngitur: Quin^ do bomojboJlw homo. Quibutexempiis fum m iliud u* f^ ,fed in two fidiis efi geminitio. najcÃ¼vo/xao'ia ft contrurium fft, qwod eodem uerbo epufi fdlfim dugeÂ» â**5' * OttÂ« kx priuAtii hommibut effe lex non uidebi* twr-CMicon^rttf eft oiVTlt;xvigt;tKlt;xlt;Ã¯ii=^eiufdem uerbi con* ^f^^'^hnificitio , citw ProcHleiiM qu^reretur def^o^ quod kmortemJuim expeUiretyCy Ã¯Ã¼e dixifiet fie uero tion fxprftuj-f ;]^^ iM^Â«tÃ¯,rogo expeHes * Non eodem

S^fS H. PAB. OyiNT. INSTIââ'* fed ex diuerfo Mcmxm dccipitur,^^ fupplido d urn dicoi, ^uem lÃ¼ppUcAtione dignu aidiatrit. AÃW quotp noces AM e^dem diner(d 'm fignificAtioneponu/n turtAM prodnÃ³lione tAMÃ nel correptione w^MW,?**Â®. ctiAin in ioeÃ¯f frigidem, equidÃ« trAdi inter pr/eeptA w ror, corum'queexemplA uitAndipotiMcjnAmimitAnii â¢ grAtiA pono:AmAri tucundum eÃ,Ã curetur ne quid iÂ«* fit AmAri.AtÃ¤um dulce Ad Auinm ducit. Ef Apud OAiH^ tergo unf.LudeMemcur egonon dicAmfuriAreFuriAm.Cot nijiciuf hAnc trAdudionent uocAt, uidelicet Alterius Â«â¦ teÃ¼eÃM Ad Alterum. Sed degAinius^qitod eÃ pofitum iÂ» diÃmguendAm rei propriet Atem: llAnc reipub-peÃen pAuUl^er reprimi, non in perpetuum comprimi poÃe-Et que prepoÃtionibut in contrAriu/m mutAntur- NoÂ» emiffus exurbe,fedmmilJ'usm urbem eÃe uideAtur. Eielius Atque Acrius, quod cum ÃgurAinen^^'^^ ^^Ã^ am fenÃu Miet. Emit morte immortAlitAtem- t^ ^^â*^Â°''' eÃ¼tijon Pifonum/ed piÃornm,^' exArAtore orAtor. PefiimuM nero: t:Je patres cofcripti uideAntur circumA fcripti.Rarocuenit fed uehementeruenit.Siccontingit, utAliquif fenfusuehemenscracerucnuÃAtein aHquAin non eindÃ© ^^^fi eo^g/ff exuerbo non diÃâonAmAccipiAt-^tcurme Paw lt;^in prohibe At pudor uti domeÃico exemptai P Ater meut to tiliwidedu trAeumqui felegationi mmorAturum dixeÃ¯At,iÃ«mA ;

de uix paucis diebus infumptis re infeda redierAt, nott exigo uti immoreris kgitioni,mmoriAre. t^Amiyii^ let fenfus ipÃ ,(;rin uerbis tantA/m diÃantibus iucunie (onfonat non, pre fir ton non cAptAta, fid wlut obl^h

ORATOR. LIBER IX. Ã^7 tliwdltfro fuo fit ufut,dlterum di dinerfdrio dcapcrit, MdgÂ»Â« utttribui cun fuit, 2â^dtidm dicendi Ã¨ puribui Pâ'âââ contrdrijs dccjuirertfiorgiiu in hoc immoiieutt copiaÂ» fm utilt;[ue primd ittdte ifocrdtes fuit, Dekddtus ek his ttiimtu.TuUitK^uertim O' modum dihibuit non ingn tt [nifi copid rcdwndet)uoluptdti,0- rem dliocpui leuem fiuentidrum pondÃ©rÃ© Implcuit .Vidmperfe frigidd Ã§y irnnii iffr^dtio cum m dereis incidit fenfut, wndtd uiÂ» detur-i-effe non dccerfitd.SimiÃ¯iwmferÃ¨ quidruplex rdÂ» habcre tw eft-Ndm rp primu'mylt;juotiâ¬s uerbum uerio, dut non Similia. dipbilc iwWcqM^rÃ MrjMf: Puppes^ tuÂ£ puies^ tuortvm.

Etfi in bic cilumitofd fdmd, cpufi in dU^ud pernitiofiÃi mijidmmd, Ettl^onenm tdmj^es Iduddndd ^ res cft. AÂ«t certetpir e^i extremis fyUdbis confondsitÃ¼on uer apparet bw (cd drmis t Et hoe t^uoi^ equaties in fententids der es wcUit puÃ¯chru eH: C^udnti pof is in eo femper expert Â«Htprofis^hoceSi â osa^ia-op^ut plerifq; pldcuit. CleoÂ» pj^fen. PfkiÂ« Tsi^ufop exifimdt,lt;juod ft Ã¨ membris non difiÂ» CieoftolÂ» ^Iibw.Sfcii^dtiW ut cldufuld fmiUtcr cdddt,uel ijfdÃ© in '*'ââ Â«ItiwimpdrtctÂ« coÃ¼dtis/o/d.oioTÃ.'XQropfmilemdudru Hemetotw ff'Ã¼cHiixrÃ¼n; Â«H plurium finem â¦ NoÂ» modÃ¨ dd fdlutem ''âtoo* rilÂ« extnguenddmyfed etidm gloridm per idles uiros in f^^amp;ftiditnj. Ex^uibusferÃ¨ funt,non tdmen utfmpet Â«Ititniscon/bnfntjqMX! â r^iKagt;7\.ct. iicunt: quot;VicitpudoÂ» rem libido^ timorem duidcid, rdtionem dmentid. Sed at qitÃ³tfrÂ«iÂ« qnoqitc, de plures hitc rdtio ire[cmemiM po ^jj^^j^j ^^â¢^iitÃ¼dm finguUs Â«erbÂ«: H(Cc cÃ¼bdt,iolet,piietf hoc dolst

quod non pudet.'Et:Abijt,cxcâ¬Ãit,crupit,eudÃt.Tcrtiu/mtll-i-lt;[i in codÃ© edfm ceidity0/jj)i0TÃij)T0jj dicitur.Sed net^ (^uoi Ãnem bibet pmilem^eil op^oioT^uTopi tttilt;^ w eÂ«dfm Ã HomÅoptÃ´ i^fniuenit0/jj)tOTt'XS^To/j-Citiidbp.oid-rÃxTop,e{l Ult *oââ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tum cdfia fimilK,etidnifi diÃimilid Ãm qut dedmentur,

nee tdntum in fine deprebenditur, fed rejpodentuelfri mit inter fe, uel medijs, uel extremii, uel etiM permit tdtis bis, ut medidprimis, er furnrnd medijs dccomnio^ dentur, er ^uaetw^ue modo decommoddri poteriwt, Ã¯^ecenm femper pdribut fylldbisconftdt,utcil dpui Aframt AmijJb nuper mfeUcis dule Ã non pr^fidioin* Eius fere ter periculd,tdmen foldtio uite inter dduerfd. 'Ed uero uidentur optimd in quibus mitid fententidrum er Ã* nes confentimiti ut hic pnefidiOjfoldtiOyC^ut peniÃ* milid fintutrbts,crpdribu( edddnt^er eodem defiant modo * Etidm ut fint,quad eÃ¼qudrtum, mtnibriselt;}â^ IfoeÃ´lon. UbiiS,^uodâiaâÃ³naAopdicitur:Siqudntwmind^rolocucj^ de fert is duddeid poteÃ¢,tdntumin forodtijue iudieijs impudentid UdleretpCoKSisAop eÃ¼, er bp-oii'iÃ^'^^P ^^* bet. Non minus numcin edufdcederet,A. CeemndSÂ» xti Ebuti mpudenti^yffudntum in ui fdetÃ©dd eeÃit dudd eig ,âiaâÃK.a)Aop,bpLotÃ7ÃfuTop,bpiiOTiAamp;!Top, Atetdit er ex iÃ¼d figurd grdtid, (jud nomind dixi mutais aÃ* bus repeti.Non minus cederet ejudm eeÃit. Adhucbp.i9 tÃ®ASutov ey â ^wvopi.xa'Ã¯x eÃ¼ t tiem'inempojfedbtti dure mdtrimonium, nifi quem penes fit pdtfmoniuÂ»iâ ContÂ«ntio. Contrdpofitumdutem,uelut quidamuoednt, contentif (xnl^iTopdicitur')nounofitmodo.'!i^dttfitfifÂ»famp;^

5Â«gÂ«lÂ« opportÂ«tMr,Â«t in co quod modo dixitVicU^uio rmlihiio^tmoYcmMiicidt EtWnibwiw:Honno^ri â¢Â«Zlt;âÂ»ijgt;MfÃrtdMX(lij eft. Et fcntentiie fententijs'. 'Domi* Â«ftlir in concianibuijiiceat 'm ludic'ijst Cui cÃ¶modiÃ'tme fuhiungitur o' clt;lt;I^ecies,([uiitm diÃinSHoncm diximui: Odit popwliw RotMittui priumA Iuxuri4m,puiilicdm md goijicftttiiitn dtl/git.EtqÂ«# funt ÃmiUedfu, diÃimiliÃen tfiitiiiin ultimo ioedtd^ut: Quod in tempore mult fuit^ iiibiloiÃt,nuin c^uod 'm eduÃdboni fuit,proÃt. Nee fern-percomrdpoÃtum Ãibiungitur^ut 'm bocEft igitur in* dices Mferipid^fed ndtd lex.Verum, peut Cicero dicit, de ÃnguUs reÃM propoptw rcÃ:rtur dd Ãnguld,ut 'm co qnod fequitur.QÂ«^Â« nÃ didic'muMydccep'mtKdcgimut^ Â«erÂ« ex ndturd ipÃd drripumuxJoduÃmM/xprcÃimwsÂ» Nec femper quod dduerÃum cft contrdponitur,caudle tÃ opÂ«d RutiliumtNobK primw dij immort diesfruges de* dcrunt,nos cpuÃoU dcccp'imui in omnes terrdi diÃribui ww.Ã®it ctidmdÃumptd iUdÃgurd, eptd uerbd icclmdtd

â'f pttutitur,qMod âav2i/.^OaSoAH diciturt^on ut eddm ui AntimewÂ» Â«o/fd Â«tuiuitmedo. Et quod rfpud Ciccronem Conner' ^Â°''' Ãm itd eÃ^ut cum mutdtionem cdÃis bdbedt,eÃ¯Ã®dm Ãmi-

â Â«Ip* wuidiit punilt;itÂ»r,qMod Oâ codem cxcluditur Â«cr-tojUiquod dicit de Sexto Rofeto: Etenim cum drtifex riuJmodiÃtjUt foitw digniK uidedtur effe epti Ãcendm in'

to noniccedilt.Eft o 'm nornmibus ex dinerfo coUocd' i'^fw grttt^iSi ConÃAAntonius3'ÃrutMboÃi5,Ãcon*^

feruMor Reipuilicte ÃrutM^hoftii Antonius.Olm pM de figures I nceejj'e ermtyCf ddhuc erit, qui putei effiji' giiram-Ancredibile eÃ¼ quod dito,fed uerum,Ã ,vÃ -Kolt;Jio' ^^a/j uocMt i Et uUquK hoc, Semel tulit, ego bis, ego tcTt 2s.k^oj^o/} Â«ipod^ofjt Longiuseue{liis(um,fedre' deo ad propofitum Â« Qjiedam uerborum fgun pM' lum figuris fentÃ©tiarum declmMtur,ut dubititio. tÃ¼M cum eÃ¼ in re,priori parti aÃignada eÃ¼,cum in uerlo quÃ¨ti,fiue me malitii,fii(e fultitiam dicere oportet.Uent eorrediSis eadem ratio cd. tAam quad illic dubitat, bic cmendat.Etiam in perdant fdione accidere quidam iiÃ« futauerunt, ut in uerbis etiam effet hu figura: CrudeÃ¼ tatis ed mater aMritia. Et apud SaUufi.m Cicerone: 0 Romule Arpinas:quale ed et apud ÃAenandru,Oedipus Othryafjus, Hu omnia copiofius funt executi, qui na ut fartÃ© operis tran fourrer ut, fÃ¨d proprie libres buic ope ri dedicauerunt,ficut Ciecilius,E)ionyfius,V.Kiâ^â^^â^Â°^ nificius,VifeÃ¼ius,alijq^ no pduci^fed non minor erit eot rum qui uiuunt gloria, Vt fateor autem uerborum fi* guras poffe plures reperiri Ã quibufdam, ita his qut ab autoribus claris traduntur, meliores no affentior. t^am inprimis Ã¼.TuUius multas in tertio de Oratore libra pofuit,quas m Oratore pofiea fcripto tranfeundo uiie* tur ipfe damnalfe,quarum pars cd, quÂ£ fententiaru po tius q uerborum fit, ut imminutio, improuifa imago, fi-bijpfij rcfiionfio,promifiio,digrefiio,cotrarium. Ã¼oec' tiim puto quod dicitur c/jcuAidTu^fumpta ex aduerfop* hdtio. ciugda omninono fwtfigurÃ©e, fient ordo,dinue

ORATOR. LIBER IX. $7Â» nentioycircunfcriptio/tuc hoc nommeÃgniÃcutur co* prebenÃi breuiter fcntcittid, ÃueÃnitio. Nrfm CorniÃ' cius,dt(^i 'Kutilius fchemci xfewS putdnt.'Verborum emt conc'mnitrdn^greÃio,id cH^hyperbdton^c^uod Cd^i tHs ^KoÃ§ pHfdt febemdji nabis eÃ mterpoÃtd,^^ mutd tiOiOâÃed e^^epidm KutiUusamp;vo/j.oioiaâiij uoedt^diÃi^ fxditudinem aÃendit hominu, rerum^fddarnmey, Ã ld' ^i^^Ãitjigurdnoed:ÃdnguÃius,m Ã -vriÃ¨Hof} eddet. Siii^robxcdppelldtioÃgniÃedt v-n-di^cicK/1,Ãdtii deed diftw c.Quoci nerofebemd eÃ ddjppoÃeu 'uhieddrdtiaf Quod KutiUus Â«.TroXo^/a/j uoedt^utru {ndm deiUodu bitiri poÃit dn ÃeberndÃt) diÃributis fubieÃ¼d rdtiosqdâ dpud eundem primo loco poÃtu eÃ, â Bs^ocraTvad^omij di cii,({tiÂ£ ut mdxtme feruetur, fdnÃ¨ eÃ pluribus propoÃi* iK,lt;^i dut ÃngulisÃdtim rdtio fubijeitur, ut eÃ dpud C AntoniMWjSed net^ deeufdtorem cum metuo, ^ui fum m Moeens,nec^copetitorem Hereor,(iui Ãim Antonius,ne* 4Â«' CQS.ÃicrOj^Mt eÃ Cicero. Aut poÃtis duobus uel tri b^t,(oii ordine Ãngulis contmui redditur, lt;[udle dpud quot;^tutum de diildturd Cn. PompeijiPr^Ãdt enm nemini itnperdre, ^ dlicui feruire : Sme iHo enm uiuere bone* Ã'fcrt, cum boc uiuendi nulid conditio eÃ. Sed uni rn '^'^bipltxrdtiofubijcitur,utdpud Vergiliumt

^Â»c mdc occultds uircs Cir pdbuld terre ^'^gdiuconcipiunttÃue iUis omne per ignem ^âquot;oquitur uitium. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Et totus locus.

dut iTravo/'op, dut ivTi^'^aQa'Atip dicit,deomnibtKl'gt;* cuti fumits.Sed quicc^uid^id eR,neqÃ¿ hoc, neqifupcriori in Ordtore repetit. Sold e^ ineoUiro poÃtdpdrittrin Exchmario terÃgunts uerborum,excldindtio,(iudmÃentetitepotiit( puto.AÃrdui enim enter cieterisomnibutconÃntio Adijcit his Citcilius T^'(p^Kaâi/j, de cpid dixi. CorniÃeitU interrogdtionem,rdtiocindtionem, fubiedionem, trM' Ãdtionem,occultdtionem.Pritteredfeiuemidfn,nfât)ibtu, drticulum,mterprctdtione,coneluÃoncm,quorumprio' rd alter ius gener is Ãwtfchemdtd/equentidfcheindtiO'

' tnninonoÃtnt, Ã¯temRutiUusprÃªtered^ufidpudolios ^uoepte fÃ¹nt f:hemdtdt^op.oâ\oy!ai},amp;vc(i'iicttofj,iiio â ssoiilt;xp,2iJK.Mo'\oy!lt;x}}t Tr^o'^H.l.ip, 'Xa^siuCili^K'â/^Pgt; ^^ocxuXoyltxfj, ^aa'itaTTHo'ip, â¢csa^'^ho'lap ,de t^uihM idem dico.t^dm cos quidem dutores^qui nuUunt prapep nem fecerunt exquirendis nominibus, prifteribo, qiâ '' tidm qua Ãunt drgumentorum,figuris dÃertpÃâf'*'â^'^^â^ iÃ¼ud de his etidm qtiÂ£ uere Ãunt, ddijeiam breoii^^jr^^^ omit ordtiones opportune poÃtÂ£,itd ineptiÃiigt;^^uâ* cum mmodice pctuntur. Sunt quinegkdo return pon' dere,er uiribus fentemidrum, Ã uel mania uerba 'm bos nodos deprauarint/ummos Ãe iudicentdrtiÃces,ti^Â°Ã? f fubftantia non deÃnunt eas neuere,quasÃne feiuemiafeitan t* efl ridiculum, q quÂ£rere habitum, geÃum^ Ãne corpo re. Sed ne hÂ£ quids que reibeÃut,denfandÂ£funt niwKi Ã®^amer uultus mutatio, oculorum^ conieibus multu 'm aibu ualet,Ãed Ã quis ducere osexquiÃtis modistesÃon iisdclum'mum'tm '' id trepidarcnon deÃnatfriied

ORATOR. LIBER IX. 575 lur.Et oratio b^r^t reft^m qiwndam Â«dut pcirm^qwÂ« ut Pupw immoiHi rigore non deMit, itdfxpins m cd ^dimnAturAdedityjj^ecie contÃ¯nendd ell. SciÃ«dum uero m primw qui J qÂ»i/gj mj ordndo poflulet locut, t^uid per fottlt;lt;4Â«i(l (cmpiw.Mdior enin pdri hitruni figUYAru po ptd cÃ m deleddtionc.Vbt uero AtrocitAtejfnuidiA,mife Y dtione pMgndnda eft, qÂ«w fcYAt contYd^ofitis, amp;nbsp;pdri ter Â«if ntib'M,z^ conpmiUbut iYd[centem,flentÃ«,Yogdn nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;jjj

t^m^ cam bw Yelm cuYd ueYborum dcYOget d^Ã«iibM /Ã¯ gentia corrÃ¢ demper Â«bicM^j dYS o^entdtitY, ueritdi dbej/e uidtdtUYi Pâ* artem.

Hum fcYÃbeYÃ© dudcYÃ«, cui nefcio dn uUd pdYS ope rn buim pt migif eldboYdtd,ni[i et eiufdem ttdtif bomt Â»Â« fcriptK ad ipfum etidm literÂ« reprebendere id coUÃ³ cdniigenusdufifuilj'cntjO'i^o^fumpluYes muUd di ^iniemYempertinentidmemoYittYddidiffeni, ua^j ac cedam m plcri/^j CiceYoniidtlt;^ 'm bÂ« era, cÃ¿ix 'mdubitd ' tdfuntbreuior, 'm ([uibufdum pdulumfoYtdjJc diffenti'di Nam etiim cum iudidum meum o^endeYO, fuiim tdmeti Ifgcntisui relinlt;{Udm.Ueqi ignoYO quofddm e(fe,c[ui did f^momnemcompoÃtionis exclnddnt,dt(j^ iUum borridu fermonem Â«t forti effiiixerit, modo mdgis ndturdem^ Â»Â«odo Â«tam magÂ« uirilem elfe contenddnt.QjÃ¿ fi id deÂ» mm natny^j effe dicunt,lt;iuod Ã ndttird pr'tmum ortuni fÂ»iZr ^ualcuntecultumfuit, totdhxc drs orddi fubuet ^*'â.^'Ã âquot;^ lo'^xti funt ad hdne reguUm et diligdi quot;*^'^'^^^nmes,nccprooemijspriepdrdYefdoccree)i'

pofitionc^drgumentis pTobare, affrÃ¤ibm ccmoucrc/cic runt. Ergo bis omnibuf,non fola compofitione edruerut' quorum fl fieri nihil melius licebut, ne domibus quiient v nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cafM, dut ueftibus petlium tegmind, dut urbibus montes

h nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;uc/yluMmutdrioportuit. QjtdeporrÃ´drsfidtmfitiiti

quid non cultu mitefeitd cur uites coÃ«reemus munui enr i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;eds/odimui:' rubosdruisexcidimtuiterrdtyhdcgcni

rdt, Mdnfuefdeimus dnmdlidf mdomitdndfeuntur, Vt rum id e^l mdxime ndturale, quod fieri ndturd optime quid pdtitur. Fortius uero qui incompofitumpote/l efie, q lundi um ^ bene coUoedtum f Kequefi pdrui pedes uim

Caltima' detrdhdnt rebus, ut Sotddeorum, Cf Cdtltmdehorum, â' er quorunddm in ordtione fimilipene lieentid Idfiiuien tium,compofitionisedliudicdiidum.CÂ£terumqudntou: hetnentiorflummum curfus efl prono dlueo/c/iullds mo rus obifcicnte,qudm inter obfldntidfdxd/rddlisdedquis reluÃ«tdntibus, tdnto qu^conoxdeA, er totisuiribus, F quot;f'^'s^s^ fluitfirdgofd dtqueinterrupt.imeliorordtio. Cur ergo uiresipfids/ficciefolui putent, qudndoresitee ulldfi' ne drtefitis udledt, er comiteturfimperdrtem dÃ©corÃ© texcuffa -AnnonedmquÂ£ emifidoptimeedl^hdfidmfiiceio/Ã¯fii^ mecontortdm firriuidemusi er dreudirigentiumte^ ld quo certior mdnus, hoe edl habitus ipfe formofiorila in certamine armorum, atep in omni pdl,e/ird quidfitis nor^deÃ¯e^aÂ° ^^^'^ cduetur dcpetitur,cui non artifex motus, ereerti tacS uerum quidam pedes ddfint S' dudremihicompofitioneuelut ^g^f^^^â'^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^stibu/dam neruifue intendi creoncitdri fen^

Ifre CM (luAmplurmum, non id ddeditionem modo^ fed d motum quo^ cinimomtn. PrimÂ« quid nihil intri' Â» poteÃ 'm lt;iÃi(ium,lt;piod 'm dure uelut quoddm ueÃAu toÃitim offendit ; dewde quod mturd due'imur dd mo' doj.Neq; enim dUter euenird, ut iUi qÂ«oqj org^MorS [o wijqMiinqH^oÂ« uerbx no exprimunt, in dlios timen itejue Â«1105 motus dacfrent iuditorem. incertiminihui ficris Â«oÂ»edfmritionecodtintinmosieremittuni,nec Eodc mogt; fOrdern modos idhibent enm heUicum eft anendum, cy ââÂ° a'^hibenÃ© tam poÃto genufuppUccmdum.l^ec idem Ãgnorum co-ceiitw oft procedente id prtliu exercitu,idem receptui tirmen.Pythigoriei! certe moris fuit, er cum euigilif-gt; pythagorjo fent, dNimos ad bram excitire, quo effent id igendum rum mos. rreftiores/t cum fomnum peterent,dd einde priusleni remtntcs,utÃ cjuidfuiffetturhidiorum cogititionum^ componerent. Quad Ã numeric et modis mell eÃt^dint UdU uiijm oritioneeo uehementiÃimd,lt;Ãnntu^ mter cÃ ffttfiMidcm qitÃxM uerhu eÃenturÃdntu uerhi ade qiM rompo/itiotw Â«ei 'm exitu iungintur, uclÃne cliudd tur. Nam qu^dÃ¯ cr fententijs pirui,amp; elocutione woÂ« dic4, uirtus hxc foli commendit^ 'Deni(Ã quod cuieÃ ui^ firn exit uthemeter, dulciter Ãpeciofe diilu,foludt,et tw betjdbierit ots uisducuditit, decor. Sortit qu/dÃ¤ fui 'm Ontorc Ciceroi NÂ« net^ me diuitu mouent, qaibtÂ« oes Ad BrÃ¼t um AÃiemoi er 'Lilios, multi uemlit'Ã meratoreseÃ fupe rixum, erfe^uentes deinceps periodosuÃidxÃidiUu modu pturtej ^ â, ig^j Ã.^(i^ ^j^j. tr^fut^fd teld proiece-Â»'M. Ur (orxigit quiC^d Gracebo eÃ¤poÃÃ¼ durius putiti

$70 M. FAB. oyiNT, INSTlT* iÃ¼um decet, nos h^c Ãmus proldtionc contenti, qÂ«oÂ« â¢* fmbÃ¨do quÂ£ Ã nabis folutiord obtulmnt,component^' Quid enim dit inet earn exempld qutcrere,cp(Â£ fibim lt;jue experiri potefli lUud notificatif hÃ¤beo, tjuop^f chriord a- lenfu^or elocutione diffGhtcnsldc ordtiont tudgis deforme fore, quid negUgentid coUoedtionis if/' uerborumlucedeprehenditur. ltdq; ut conf tear ftif^ ultimdm ordtoribui dr tern compofitiois,qud de perf (bi fit,contigiff,itd iUis prifeis hdbitdm inter curdffnquii turn ddhuc profecerdnt, puto. Nf^ mihi qudmlibet mi' gnus dutor CiceroperfudferifLyfidm^lierodottini,Tbn cididem,pdrumftudiofoseius fnijfe. Genus foftdff Ã'*b fecuti non idem quod Dcmofthenes,dut Pldto, quinq O' ij ipf interfe dtfmilesfuerint.t^dm neqi iHud m tyfi dicendi textu tenue,dtq^ rurum Ã¹tioribus numeriscor' rumpendum erdt. Ferdidiffet enm grdtidni} qÂ»^ ân eo mdximd eR,fimplicis dtq^ muffididti coloris,P^^^bdiÃ fet fdem quoq;. Ndm fcribebdt dlijs, non ipliilt;^^bit,ut oportucrit effe iÃd rudibus er 'tneopoftis fn^ibbi, quoi ipfum compoftio cR, Et hifloru (que currere icletic ferri) minus conueniffent interfifentesclduful^,^ ir* bitd ddlionibus reffirdtio,cr cludendi inchodniiq; fu' tentids rdtio.ln concionibus quidem etii fmiliter a ieu tid quigddm cy contnpofjtd deprehendds,in tieroioto uerocumomnid (ut ego quidem fentio) lenitcr fuint, fut latenter tumip[d2sia7i.iKT@-'hdbetedmiucunditdtem, utll' complexe ui tentes etidm numÃ©ros complexd uidedturSed de propos deatur. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fitorum diuerfitdte pof pdulum. Ã¯^unc quf prius bis qtd

Ifftfcomponrre noient, dipcnddflnt. ElUghurMte ornnt'd ontio^iÃ¼iA iundu dtqj contextlt;i,foiutii olid, lyin' 1Â« in fermone cr epifiolii^niÃ cum nSÃ¹yÃ¹iÃupni nnturn fw trdiSdntjHt de philofoyhin^dc repuiUed ÃmiUbus^, Quod no co dico, cytid non iUui c^uoiyie^olutumbdicdt 1^05 lt;yiolddm,v forÃitdn difficUiores etidm yedcsmec^ tnim Aut hidrefemper uoedUbus^dut deÃitui temporibut Â«olwntÃrmo c:y epifiold, (cd non Ãuunt, neccobarentt nnuerbdde uerhis trnhunt^utpotius Idxiord in bis um euli 5 nullitÃnt. Nonnnn^uJ in eduÃu quotjj nimoribui iecet eddem fimplicitM,quÂ£ noniÃK fed dlijs utltur nu-ncrii^iiÃ'muUt^i eosy er tdntum communit occultius. At iHd c5nexd feries trÃ¨s bdbet formdSymcifdycyig K_0/jgt; (dÃ Saiicuntur,membÃ¯dy(ytÂ£ KwAaj^gy â¢Ã®Ã®tÃ§Ã®oJ'o/jjquie eft Hfl dmbitus^el circundu(ium,uel c0tinudtio,uel con dupo. In omni porro compoÃtione trid funty neceffd' * gÃ©rera rUjOrdOjiunftHrdjCr numerus, Primuigiturdeordi' Â«f. Eiws obferudtio in uerhis eil ÃnguliSy er contexts, SinguU Ãmt tytee diximus hco'cioAiS'ilcc, \nbis eduendune decrejcAi ordtio, er fortiori iugdtur dUcyiid mÃrmiuSy utfAcrHegofu,r,dut Idtroni petuldns. Augeri enimdc- Philipp.n, lent fementU er mlurgereyUt optime Cicero:T'UyVn 5t, â¢ iÃis fdUcibiK, iÃts Idteribtu, iÃd glddidtorid totius cor-pwÂ«firmitdtc*Aliud enimmdius dUo fuperuenit,Atft expira i toto corpore,non bene nd Idterdfduces^ de-fcendertt,Â£fl ^ ^jiyj âdturdUs ordOyUt uiros Ac fami Â®J^Â° *âquot;** nMy tem nc noftew, ortum et ocedfum diens potius,âl re^^ ââ twjHw.Q^jj^ifj Pj.jjj^P yermutdioÃunt fuyerudeud.

Mt frdtres gemini, lidmfi prxeefferint getmaitfi^^ adder c non eÃ neeeÃe. iUd nimia quorunda fuit obfirui tiOj ut uocdbula uerbis, uerba rurfm aduerbijs, nomi^^ appofiÃ¼K^et pronominibm rurfm eÃent pnora.wf^ contra quac^ frequenter non Mecore.Nec non (y Hit^ nimix eR fuperfiitionii,ut qu^q; fint tempore, ed fid* re etiarn ordme priori, non quia fiequenter non fit boe melius, fed quid interdum plus ualent ante gefia, Utoi Verbo dau' lenioribusfuperponÃ¨dafunt.VcrbofenfuincludereinÂ» dÃªdi ora tio, tÃ ,fi compofitio patiatur,optimu eR. in uerbis enim fit monis uis me^i.At fi id alteram erit,cedat bee ratio mt meris, ut fit apud fummos Grecos, Latinos^ oratoret fiequentiÃme. Sine dubio enm ornne quod non eludet, hyperbaton eÃ¢.lpfum hoc inter tropos nd figurÃ¢t, qui funtuirtutis,receptumc^. No enim ad pedesuerba '* mÃ«fa funt.Ã¯deo^ ex locatranÃ'erunturinloeu,ut^ââ''amp;* tHr,quocongruunt maxime, ficut in Ãrudut^Ã^^fiâ^ rudium,etiarn ipfa enormitas inuenit cui apfbcari, et iÂ» quo poÃit infiÃere. YeUeiÃmus tarnen fermo efit ^'** ^ rÃ©Ã©lus ordo,Gr apt a iundlura,zy cu bis numerut opf^ tune cadens cotmgit.Clu^dauerotrdfgreÃiouetf ^

â¢ nbsp;nbsp;gÂ£ funt nimK,ut in fuperioribus diximus librit) tJ rim etiarn copofitione uitiofÂ£, qua in hoc ipfmtt petuuf tur,ut exultent atq^ lafciuiit,quales ida Mecanatis-^o er aurora rubent plurima, interfacra mouit aquiir^^ nosneexequiasquidemunus inter mifirrimos meas. Ã§^od inter hac peÃmÃ¼efl, quia in re triÃi^ai compofitio. Sape tantetf^finthemcnsdliquisfenf'^i'â'

terlo, ^Mod fi in medici pArtc fenienlu Utet , trdnfiri intcwiotifjCr oifeurdri circumidcentiius fokt, in ddu^ ^idifofuumciÃigndtur duditori O'infgitur,(Ã¿idleejl iHui Cictronin Vttiii neceffe effet in conf^eÃ¼u popuU Ronuniuomcre. TrdnIfcriloc ultimum, minui ucilebit.

Nitm totiw JmÃmj bic eÃ c^udf muero, ut per fc fadÂ£ ^jÂ®*^jâÂ°f* wmeniinecrÃitdti,idmnibilultrdexpe(tdntibiK,hdnc fitas ^wog; iOjeeret deformitdtem, ut cibui teneri no poffet pofiriHci Solebdt Afcr DomititutrcÃ¼jcereincldufulds Mrbdtdiuum dÃ^erdnda compofitionis grdtid, o- md' xme in prooemijs,ut pro ClodntiUd: Grdtids dgetm conti nuo.cypro LitUdi Ew utrijeÃ dpud te iudicem pÃ©riclita tw Lrlw. Adeo refugit tener dm delicdtdm^ moduÃ¼di nt)luptdtem,ut occurrentibui per fc numeris, quo cos in hhrrrt obijceret. Amphibologidm c[uoq; fieriuitiofdlo edtione uerborum,nemo efi qui nefcidt.Uccc drbitrorjut in trewijde ordinefuiffe diccndd:qui fi uitiofm efi,beet tS'imdiifit, Ã§^ apte endens ordtio, tdmen meritÃ© inco po/itÃ¤dicdtHr. iHUdurdfequitur,'Edefi inuerlis,inciÂ» fis,membris^periodis.Omnid ndnt^ ijld c uirtutes, e^ uitid in complexu habenttAtej^ut ordinemfequdr, pri-ntum quÂ£ mperitis quoq-, dd reprebenfionem notdbHicl nidnturjtd efi,qusâ commiÃisinter fe uerbis duobm ex ^i^in'dprÃQYÃ¯f^^f. primd fequentisfyUdbd,de forme dUqd^ nomtn (jfduntSurn uoc^ium concur fus,qui cum dcci* dit,bidt Zf interfijiit, (3- qudfi Idbordt ordtio t PeÃime loÂ«gfgt; qÂ«Â« enldem inter fe literds committunt,foncibut.

$So M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT, maxime ore effÃ¨runtur.B plenior literd eR4 anguUioft idcog; obfcuriusm hts uitiumt ^Hinuspeccdbit^uilon^ gis breues fÃ¼bijciet,et adhuc qui praponet longi breuÃ«. Minimd. ek in duabus ireuibus offenfio. Atq; cum ilie fubiunguntur dlijs perinde aj^eriares crunt, prout oris habitu â^ ^^'^tu fimili, dut dinerfo pronuncidbuntur, NoÂ» tÂ»

id ut crimen ingens expduefcendum eR, dc nefcio negli gentid in boeman foUcitudo Ãt pcior.lnhibedt enm necef fe cil bic metus impetu dicendi,et Ã potioribus duertdt, Qudreutnegligentige^pdrs hocpati,itdhumilitdtis ubiq; perhorre/cere, n'miosq; non immÃ©ritÃ© in bac curd putdnt omnes ifoerdtem fecutos, prgeipue^ Theopom pum.Ãt DemoÃhencs er Cicero modice re^exerut di hinc pdrtem. Nun er coeuntes liters,que cm^Aok^h dicitur, etiam Icniorem fddunt ordtionÃ«, quant fi ontnid uerba fuo fine cludantur, er nonnunq biuled etiant de cent, fddunt^ dmpliord. queda, utpulcbrdordtionÃ«^ ptd omnino idUdre, turn langt per fe, er Â«'^^â^ fyUdbe aliquid etidm medij temporis inter uotdla w interÃÃdtur dffumuntiCitfd de re utdr Ciceronisp^^n ftmum uerbis: Ã¼dbet,inquit iUe, tanq hiatus (T uocalium molle quiddam, er quad mdteet, noi^ff negUgentiam de re hominis magis quant de uerbn

, rantis.Cgteruconfonantesquoq;, eÂ£^prif^P^ât ^|^fflgygJ^â ^f^fÃ¿ff,iUl^f^ uerborumrixdntur,G'^^ ultmta cum x proxima, quaru triÃior, etiamft dantur, Ãridor eÃ¼, ut ars Ãudiorum, que fuit edufa Seruio,ut dixi,fab trabide s Utere^quoties ultimd ejf f

ORATOR. LIBER IX. $81 iUi^ con^othinte fu^cipcretur, ejuod rcpreltendit LM' TMitis^Keffidti dÃ©fendit.mm neq-, LuciUum puunt uti tidem Ultimi, cum dicittSerenuâ fuit, cy dignu' loco. Ciumetiiim Cicero in Qrutore plures cinti({uoÃ¯um tnl-Ã¼t flclocutos i

inde Veiliger ure poâ meridiem, o- iUu Cenforij Cito*' nis, Dfeâ jiMCttecpiem liter A in e molÃ¼tA, qÂ«Â« tÂ« ueterb iuslibris repcrtA mut Are imperiti folent,et dum HbrArio rum infeitiAm infeliAri uolunt,fuAm conftentur, Atqui fUiem HIa literd epiotics ultimA cft, o- uocdlem ucrii fe qÂ«fntK itA co tingit,ut 'm cAm trAnfre poÃit,cti'A ft feriÂ» Hfur, tumen purum expr'tmitur,uttMultum iUe, t^y z C^uintumerdt. ddeÃ¨ ut penÃ¨cuiufddm nouxliterx fo Â«Ã¼ redditt.Neqj entm eximitur,fed obfcurdtur,zj- tdntÃ¼ ililt;{ud inter duds uocdles uclut not A eH, ne ipfe coÃ«dnt. Viieniam etiÃne fyUdbx uerli prioris ultimlt;e,fmt pri' me fetpiitis.ld neeptis pracipi miretur,Ciceroni 'm epi ÃolisexcidittRcs mihi muife uifÂ£ funt 'Brute.Et 'm cAr ââÂ«â: 0 fortundtdm nAtAm me confide 'Rorndm.

^tidm ntonofyÃ¼dbd plurd mdk cotinudbuntur,lt;{uiA necef fe esi compofttio multis cldufulis cocifd fubfultet.ideoi^ e turn breuium uerboru ic nominu uitAndA contmudtio, vr ex Huerfo epwep longorum.AffÃ¨runt enim cpiAnddm ^^^^iitirditdtem- lUAc^uoq^uitiA funt eiufdem loei ft cd ^^iwpmiliterjO- ftmiliter deÃnentid,!^ eodem modo lt;lf di^ iungdtttur. Nee uerbd quidem uerbK,Aut nold Â«omitiibmjj;ââ[,'4^ bis cot'muAri decet, cÃ¼ uirtutes etid W^'^^iumpAriAnt ^nift grutid UArictAtis ddiutd.iAÃª

troru mciforumq; iunÃ¤urd non eo modo eÃ obferuSii, ^uo uerboru^qudnq er in hls extreme er prmi coÃ«unt. , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'' Sed plurimum refert compoÃtionis, que quibiu Mtepo

nesâMdm er nomensÃ-uÃts efculentis uinum redolenti' bus premium fuum,ertotum tribumsl impleuit.Etcoii' trd(ntim ÃequentiusutÃ¤riffdem diuerÃrumquoqjre' rum exempts, quo Ãnt mugis familiuriu) Suxe utq; foli tudmes uod rej^ondent, beÃie fepe immunes cuntuÃe Guntur utq^ conÃflunt. Mugis id inÃurgebut Ã uerterct turt 'N um plus ek Ãxu q beflius comoueri,meÃ tunen cS Namen in poÃtionidecor.Sed trunfeumus ud numÃ©ros. OmnisÃr'U ontione. ^j^y^^^^ dimenÃo.,et copulutio uocutconflut uut numeris

(numÃ©ros joS/j.otjg uedpi uolo ) uut^iT^aÃd eÃdimeit Ãonequudum. QuadetiumÃcoÃututrunq; pedibtuÃu Mnnumcris bet turne noÃmplice diÃerentiu, Numrhythmi. ideÃ, numeri Ãgt;utiotemporumconÃunt, metru etium ordme, ideo^ ulterum eÃi quutitutis uidetur, Ã¤lteruigt;iquââ^â^â^^ R-hythmus. tis.P\i9iU.o!^uutpureA,utduHylus.Vnumen'imfÃ^^dm purem breuibus hÃ¼bet. E^b equide uis eudem (T ^^^ I?^' dibus,Ãd nomen iUud tenet, Longum e/feduoru tempo rumÃreuem imius/tium pueri fauntt uut fefiup^te, ut peon^cuius uis eil ex logu et tribus breuibus,qui^ ^^ ^ââ trurius ex tribus breuibus er longue ud ulio quoquo inÂ» do,temporutriuud duo rclutufcfcuplÃ¼fuciunf. AÃt du' plex,ut iumbus. Nurn eil er breui er lougu, qui^ (Ã â t enim ^^^^eirius. Sunt hi et metrici pedes, fed hoc intereÃ,qu rhythmo indi/Ãrens eÃ, duÃylus'ne ide priores hÃ¼best

J luhUtioe Ai pofitione ijfdem Ãtf^dtijs pedu. IÂ« uerfu m Ã fublatio fro diftjlo poni non potent AnAp^Ãus, Aut f^ondeuf^'^^fj^^^/^^^ nee pson eAdem rAtione Ã breuihut meipiet Ac df/Ã®net/patÃ¼sTroÃ¯* Nf^- [olun Alium pro Abo pedem metrorum rAtio no re dimcnfionl rif it,fed ne dAdylum e^uidem^Aut forteÃ^ondeum, Abc* in ucrfu pro rum fro eiter o. UAlt;^ Ã qMÂ»Ã®$ cotHiÂ«os dAÃyÃ¯os (ut fit non p'Â°,gÂ°,quot;â Ht iHo: PAnditur mtereA domus omnipotÃ©tis oÃ¯ympi.) anapaftus, ConfunidSj folueris uerfum. Suntt^yiÃA â^'^ââ ^^ââjKe/pj^^s^cz ^uoiÃ¯hythmisliberA f^AtiA,metric ÃnitA funttC^-bisindemtMo eerteciAu[uÃ¯ee, ilU eiuomodocaperAntcurruntufciucf^^^-.^ Ã¯â7quot;^ rtd fx^cc^Q^nij^id cn^trdnptwn m dlmd gewKs rbgt;tbmi. ac deC Et OMod metrum wi uerbis modo, rbytbmos etiA in cor- sic forw motucR. Ã¯nAniA ^ko^j tÃ«porArhytbmi fdcilius Ac cipient,(p(Anlt;fuAm beec er m metric Accidunt^ mAior tA* men Hic UcentiA eH, uli tempor A etidm Animo metiun' tur, er peium,er digitorum idu mteruAUA Ãgndnt qui bufiAm notis, At^ue eeÃimAnt quot ireues iÃ¼ud Ã^Atium bAieAt, mie 'n't^vo'H/AÃ¼p, -esivSixtrH/AOf}. DfHiccpÃ¯ Ion-gioÂ«j fmt pereuÃiones.KAm c'K.ugo^y tfmpw r/l mÂ»m. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'

incompoÃtione orAtionis certior,er mAgis omnibus lt;t* fertitferuAri debet dimenÃo. Eft igitur in pedibus. Et Wftrici quidrm pedes Adeo reperiutur m orAtionc^ut m 'â* fgt;âcqÂ«eÂ«tEr non fentientibus nobis, omnium generUm fxeiiint uerfus.EtcontrÃ,nibil eÃprofA feriptum c^uoi woÂ» redigt poÃit in lt;[UÂ£dÃ uerÃculorum gencrA. Sei membrj iWitdcÃ¶nioifÃo^ j^j.,j^j(fQrfmtmAticos^ ejuorumfue 4ââquot;â âTMWtjqHiljricorK,Â« q^^j^ujf^Pffjjujj^jj^P,'^ mfÂ»^-â^^^ ^âfgfrwnt. At Cicepo fre^uentifime didt totu boe

confire numero, ideoq- reprehenditur 4 quibufdifUt tMciUAmoriitionÃ¨ ad rhythmos nuisait NMtfunt nuttin ri rhythmi^ut O' ipfe cÃ¶ÃitMt.o ÃcMi earn VergiUu^) nbsp;nbsp;i

OHordtius NumÃ©ris q; fertur Legefolutis. Inuddunt ergo hdne inter externs uocem. Neq^ enim Dt mojlhenes fulmim tdntopcre uibrdÃe diceretur,niÃ flÂ«Â» meris eStortu ferrÃªtur. Ã¯n quo ft hoc fcntmus,rhythiÂ»ii contortd^difjentio. Ndtnrhythmi,utdixi^elt;^Ãneni nbsp;nbsp;,

Per Â«y Â« ji qud coeperuntfubldtione dc pofitione^dd finem uÃ^ii ^blm6e3c nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^tilt;f non defcenditddftrepitumdigito'

ter fiquod numerofurn fit querere, ut mdgis non SyuJ i /xd/j, quod eÃet mfeitum dtque dgreÃe, qu'un tJjuÃÂ» j p.dp, quad poÃ«ticum eÃ¼^ efje compofitionem uelit, ficut ' etidmquos pdUÃritM ejje nolumus^cosquidhââ'^^ââf oern'AMS^oU. Verum edquiefficiturexpeiibuftqud conclufto,nomendliquod deÃderdt. Q^dÃtigiturpo tins qudm numerus, o ordtorius numerus,ut Ãntbymi md rhetoricus fyÃ¼ogifmusC Ego certe ne in cdbunninn edddm, qudneM, quidem Tullius cdruit, poÃco boe m- nbsp;nbsp;,

hi,ut cum pro compofito dixero numerum, o ubieun' que idmdixi ,ordtorium dicere inteUigdr. CoUoatio dutem uerbd idm probdtd, o ekÃ«ld, o uelut iÃignit td Ãbi debet conneiiere : ndm uel durd inter fe com-miff'd potiord Ãsnt inutilibus,tdmen o eligere qius idm, dunt ex bis qute idem Ãgnificent dtq^ idem Udkant,

ORATOR. LIBER IX. Ã§SÃ§ pcrmiprÃ¼n, Â©- idijeere,dum non otioÃ^ z^ detruhere imnonneceffdriciScd figurK mntdre ^y cdfin cz Â»Â»* merof, quormw uirietMfret^uenter gntu compofitio* Â«K id[citd etum fme numero [olet effe itteunda, etidm Â«bi dliud ntio,aliud confuctudo po[cit, utrum uolet fu^ mit compo/ttio, Vitiuiffe uel uitdoe, deprehendere nel deprenderc.Coitm etidm [yUabdrunon negdbo,e^ e^uic ^wâdfeitttniijs dut elocpientie non noedit, Pnecipmim tintenm hoe opia e9:,fcire quid quoque loco uerborum mixime qmdret^Atque is optime componet, qui hoc [o ^?'^ââ iMcomponÃ«digritidfdciet. Kdtioucro pedwm^mord utis nume.-tionc f A multo q m uerfu dijjicilior. Prim vm lt;jMod Â«er rus in foiuta Ãwputeisconiimetur,ordtiolongioreshdhet fxpeeir* busbgatlr ewtw.Dmde cjwod uerfus femper Ãmilis Ãbi cSl,et wna ntione deeurrit, ordtionis compoÃtio niÃ lurid eSl,^'

1 oÃiniit fmHitudi}te,Oâ iffÃ¨^dtione deprehenUtur. Et momniquidemcorpore ,toto^;, ut itd dixefm,tridu numeris vnfertd cft,Ne4ae emm loqui pofÃurma Ã¨ ÃyUd* hts brcuibiÂ« de longa,ex quibus pedes Ãunt,W.dgis tda men Z3- decider dtur 'm cliufulis, et dppdret,primu quid fendus onmis hÃ¼bet fMimÃncm, poÃidetq^ mtunle m^ teruillum qua i Ãquentis 'mitio diuiditur.Deinde quoi imescontmudntuocem ÃcutÂ£,du(lieqi uelut prono de currentK ordtionis Ãum'me,tusn nagis iudidt, cum tUe iwâpttiwJlctitjCr mtuendi tempiÂ« de ditÂ» Non igitur da ruwi fitinequc dbrupttwÂ», qao duimt adat reÃpinnt dc Vfed Ã¯c/Ã¯etimtur, if^c efl fedes ordtionis, hoe Auditor expea ^dt,hi(liitsomnis decldinit^Proximdcldufulis diligent

Ã§8Ã´ M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT, tidw poÃuhnt mitid ; ndm ty id hfemtentm duditot eii.Sed eorufdcilior rdtio eSl.Non mm cohÂ£rent dlijs, nccpnecedciuibut feruiunt, fed nouttni exordium [d* nbsp;nbsp;j

niMityCumiUdqudmlibct ÃtcSpofitÃ¤,ipfdmgritiimptr det,fl dd edm ruptd uid uenidmM.fidn^ cum ftt,uhtide tur, feuer d DemoÃhenis compofttio,â7t^iTO/jft^(^a.v* Ã©'^ilt;gt;ci6Hvou,oi To7g 6io7^ivXP7^^ 'ssS.u'iri^'ssaa'dt)â, et Old quÂ£ db Mio,quod feid Bruto minut probdtur, ate rii pldcet, nap p.H7va ibx/i^oi/'J-Hp Â«ui' fii/i. NoÂ» dÃ©funt qui Cicerone edrpdnt in hifi'Pdmilidris caperdt eÃe bil nedtoÃ¯i,^non minus durd drebipirdtf, ndm bdlnedtori et drchipirdtÂ£ idÃ« finis eR^qui isAoâ! hj â ssicean^, et ([ui Â«UTO quot;fiptfed priord funtjideo feueriord. BH in eoquolt;^ ^ '' nonihil,quod hic fingulis uerbis bmi pedes ebtinentur, qd'etid in edrmmibus eH permÃ³He,nec folu ubi lt;ltiinÂ£fyl ldbÂ£ neÂ£iM)tur,ut in histBortiÃimd rynddridiruniifed etidm ubi qud,ternÂ£,cum uerfus cluditur, A^er.nxe,v eirmdmentis,et Oriond, Qjidre hoe quoifi tut^âquot;quot;^ f^, ne plurium ÃUdbdru uerhis utdmur in fiiK-lif^V 4âÂ®* nbsp;nbsp;i

que non cd modo curd fit, ut inter fecohÂ£rednt, fidM figrd,ne longd fini,ne quod nunc mdximum uitium efi, nbsp;nbsp;)

breuium contextu refultent,dc fonwm redddiU ftÂ»' pi^Â® rilium crepitdeuÃ¯orum. i^dm ut initid cUufuh^ plâfâ* mum momenti hdbent, quoties incipit fin fits dut dÃ©finit, pc in medijs quoque funt quiddm condtus quileuiter in* terfifiunt. vt curremium pes etidmfi non mordtur, tit men uefligiimi fdcit.ltdque non modomembrd dtlt;^ incit fd benemcipcre dt^ indudi decct,fed etidm in his qM

hoN Jubtf context Afu/nt, nec ref^irntiane utuntur iÃ¼i ^'^ââ/j'gJj, Uflocculti gr^diM. ( auisenm duhitet wtum fen^M dus

O' iwiiM fpiritut effe Æ ) Attwidduertt indices, omnem P''Â° Clucn* tccnfutorK orAtionem wt dwiÂ« diuifxm effe portes. Td* nifn Ã? duo primd uerbd,zy trid firoxitnd,^^ dfmeeps dnorw[us^dc trid , fnos c^udfi numÃ©ros hdhent f^iritom ft^^mentesficut dpudrhythmicositfimdntur hie pdrti* fmIa prout fumt grMes, Acres, lentÂ£, eeleres, rem ffa^ txultdntes.Vroinde id quod ex Ulis confieitur,dut leuc* riÂ«Â«, dut iuxuriofum, dut quidrdtum, dutfolutum erit^ Ciutddmetidm ddufule fivnt cldudx dtque pendentes Ã reirnquintur ,[ed Sequent Aus fufeipi uc fufimeri [olent^ to^ fado uitium quod erdt Ã¯n fine, contmudtio emend dit. Non twit P.R. obfoktis erminibus deeufidri Ver* **'*H. rfnedwriÂ«Â« fit defindS, (cd cwn eft contmudtum his qua leqmntur,quinqud nAturdipfiddiuifidfint,Uoud pofirn ^tAmuiitddefiderit, fdiims eÃ¼ curfits. Vt ddeds tdnd turn dibit, mdle cludcrft : ndm er trimetri uerfas pdrs Mltimdeft^cxcipitjVt cibum uefiitumÃ©^ mtrofierre liced dt tAntin^preceps ddhue firmdtur de fufimetur uÃ¯tmd, '^(citfdbitnemo.Verlu/m inordtione fieri multofadiÃi Â«um eft totum ,ficut etidm inpdrte, deforme utique fi P^fs poflcrioy tn cldufuld depreheddtur, dUt rurfus pri or mwigrej?Â«, Him quoi ek contrA,fepe etidm decetf ^ââ 'â't dudit jjjtfyj^ optime primdpdÂ« uerfiK,dum tÂ» f â^Â«cÂ« Ãdut^f, prlt;ecipue fendrij dtque oÃ¼ondrij. in A^w fuiJJir^ mitiiwn fendrij eA,primum pro Q. Ltgd* â'âÂ®â^*PWdudit, t-ffeuiiedtw, l^ldmnmis fi^quem

Ã§dondrium inchodt.Tdlidfwnt nemcllhcnis,7:a'fi'â^âj â !sa.aâMigt; KOt zs^cftfi vpjp oa'Hpivvoiap, Cr totuffipfO^ prmcipium. Et ultimd uerfmim mitioconutniwt on* tionis.Et Ãuereor iudicos.crtdnitMduertiiuiices.Sci tnitidinitijsnon conueniimt.TitusLmui hextuntiri exordia cÅpitÃ®EdÃ¼urui'ne opentpreUim Ãm-i^MiU edidit,eÃqi meliiu c^uim quo modo cmcndAtm.lscc diÂ» ÃtU cldufulis,ut Cicero: Q^Ã³ me uertdm neÃiojqui tri* fpromifeuo metri finit eÃ¼jtrimetruMamp; pro mifero dicereUcat: Sex enim pedes tres pereuÃiones bdbent. Edtii dMUt finis bexMetri, ut Brutus Mt epifiolis : Nf que enim iffi Â£onftiterat multvnthdbcrc tutoresdut dejenfores ,quAnqMm fit^ Mit pÃ¯dcuiffe Cdtoni.iÃlic mmus fivnt notdliles,quii hoo^ genus fermoni proximum eÃ¼, Ã¯tdque er uerfus bifere excidiwt,quos Brutus ipfo componendi dudufliudiofe fnon tam piÃime fdcit, non rdro A finius, Sed etidW Cicero non* ntvnqudm,ut in principio ÃdUm ordtionis in ^^â^^^ ^ fonem : Pro dij immortdics, quis bic illuxit iiâ^ ' ^Â°'â minoredutem curd uitdndtmieR,quicquiii^^'^P-ep, qudle eH dpud SdUufiiam iPdlfo qumtur de nitunfi^-Q^dmuis enim umfld fit, tdmen folutd uideri debet ord tio.Atqui Pldto diUgetiÃimus compofitionis in 'FitneÃ primd fidtim pdrte uitdre iÃd non potuit. Fidin v initi urn hexdmetri fidtim inuenids, er dndcreontion protu nus colon efficids,er fiuelis trimetron,er quod duoitU ' pedibus, er pdrte, usivlH/Xi^iq d GrÂ£cis dicitur, ff 5C hifc omnid m tribus uerbis, ut Thucydidis,vi t^Ã³pult;^' iici^iigt; i(fmlt;iâap,ex moÃ¼iÃimo rbythmoru/m gÃ©nÃ©rÃ© ex

tiiJint. SedqMUordhoncwumconÃrfrc pfditiMdixr, idiqiu de hw quoq;, ^Horwn Â»ominx qMÃ¶nwrn mrideffe tritdi0ttMr,coÂ»pi wendiwn eft quo que Â«que apprUcwufj er quide Ciceronemfec^Mr'Mm is emmentiÃmoi Grx corum eft fecutus, excepta qÂ«od pedes mihi trifylldios KonwidftMr excedere ^eptAmnumide plotte dochimÃ³^ ^x^gt; quorum prior m quatuor, fecundta 'm qu'mejfteex* furntjUtatur^Nce tarne Â» ipÃe diÃimuht c^uibuÃim nu-^ ' Â»teros uiden non pedes,ncque 'mmento. Quicquid c* Â«im fupra tris ÃyUdbM, id ell ex plurihus pedibus. Er# go cam conÃet quatuor pedes btMK.ofto ternis,Ãponde^ wÂ« longÂ« dudbus,pyrrbichiwin,lt;juem alq pirtambumi Â«Ã oautjlrcHitiMjiambum breui Iowgaq;,buic contrdrium e tonga er breui, bu/nc choreum nos,ut alq trocbÂ«eiwÂ«,nd winemtu.Ex bw Mero qui ternes ÃyÃ¼dbM bdbcnt,ddCly^ Um,longa duabiw$ breuibus, buic temporibtes pdrem^ frd retro aftum, appeHari conÃdt umpteÃon.Medm 'm tfrlongaÂ«breuw fMettimph'midcru/m,fedÃ-e^uenlius quot;' tiw nomen eft ereticus. l-ongii inter breues, dmpbibrd lt;bgt;Ã®. DiiabuÃ® longw Breuern fequeimbua baeebiuÂ«, totiÂ« dem longÂ« breueÂ« pritcedentibus, buic contnirius pa# limbaccbiuÃ® erit,TreÂ« breues trocbÂ«etwH,qMÃª tribracbgt;n dici Molunt, qui cboreo troebai nomen imponumt, toti* demlonglt; moIojJbne^ctiMlt,HoriÂ»n pedum Â«uHutWon Pedcslongl in orationem uenitt Sed quo quigj fumt temporibui pleÂ» â mores,longÂ«^ ÃyUibis mdgis Ãdbiles,boc gnuiorÃ¨ fel* ei^t oratioÂ«cm,jâ.fâf j eelerem ac mobilem. VtrMMq; lo

V90 M. FAB. QVINT. iNSTâ'â'* ,p fcgrte,z^hocuhi pondut exigiturtprjeceps^^ff^ tuns mer it Ã ddmnetur. Sit in hoc t^uoque alilt;lÂ»i^ momemi, efuod zy longis longiores, CZ breuAit^ j breuiores fyllabi, ut qudmuis neque plut duobut i^ poribi(t,neque umo minus habere uideantur-O^toif''^ metrit omnes breucs longÃ¦ 'c^ue inter [e obfeff^f^^^ Â« res ) Idteat tarnen nefcio quid ,p quicquim Ãp^^r^ dÃ©fit. Nam uerfuum propria conditio eÃ/deoque W ' quatdam etiam communes.Veritas uero quid paMâ^^f que breuemeffe uel longamuocalemctm eUfo^, âiâ*^''* cum earn confinantes una plures ue procÃ©dant,Â«^tte i^ dimenfione pedum, fyÃ¼aba qua eH breuis mfeqi*^^^ alia uel breui, qua tarnen daas primas confonantes W* beat,fit longa,ut:

Nam licet grebreuis,facit tamÃ¨longamapriorilt;f*^â^ igiturilUaliquid ex fuo tempore,quornode^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^

plus q qua breuifima, qualis ipfa effet dctri^â^''^''iÂ°^ nantibus,nunc unit tempus accommodÃ¢t priori,ti dccipit Ã fequente,ita dua natura breuestpoÃtioÂ»^^ l-t3mtn temporumquatuor.Miror autrnhacopmioÂ»^'^^ y fimos hommes fuiffe, ut alias pedes ita cligerc^f ,^^Â°^ damnarent,quafi uUut effet quem non fit neced^ ^ Â®âââ** tione deprehendi. Licet enim paonemfeqmtur EpW rus muentum Ã Thrafymacho,probatu/m ab Aripoff tgt; daHylâjm^, Ut temperdtiores breuibus, ac longis,

J atffondeum or throchaum, alteriiu tarditate,alterne eeleritate damnata^et herous qui eÃ¼ idem daÃ¢yhis, ^^^

Ilotcli (lt;mpIior,MmbiÂ« bwminior uiiedturjtroch^u/m ut Â«mk cumittem dimnet^d^ choridcis nomÃ© impondt, tdiemt^ didt Theodedes de âTheo^hrdjiut/mUid po^ tos 'ii^cdrndlJiut DionyÃMy imminent etidm dd mui tos,âÂ«^ femper iÃ¼is heroo dut pÂ£one fuo:quem qÂ«Ã¼ uer fut riro fdcit,mdxime UuddntyUti liceiit.Vt fnu tdmen d-isjs dlij creiriort s,non uerhdfxcicnt^c^iiÂ£ ncque dugcf^ *lt;gt;'!Â« niinÂ»i, Â«cc Ãeut moduldtionc produci dut corript fourni,fed trdnÃnutdtio zr coUocdtio. Plerie^ enm ex (ommi^uris eortvm,uel diuiÃone Ãwnt pedes, c^noÃt ut fjfdem utÃ¯bis dlij dtc^ d^ uerfutÃdnt, Ht^memiMi quenÂ« dim Â«on ignobikiÂ« poctim itd-vluÃffei nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp; dÂ«claraffe

HifcenJi ergo fuut,curdndumÃ©^ ut fint plnrej qui pl.t* teintais- cirewmfuÃ bonis dÃ©tÃ©riores Idtednt^ Nec Â«ero mil ter it fyUdbisc^ndtun mutdtur, fed refert^ua cum ^if'iqi optime cocat.PlMrimw igitur dutoritdtis (Â«t dixt) O' ponderk babent longÂ£iceleritdtis breuesilt;[UÂ£ Ã mit Ãemurepiibufddm longis,currunt-.Ã contmudntur,ext â'^Â«nt. Acres qÂ«* ex brenibtÂ« dd longÂ« iÂ«/Hrgunt:le* ââlores quÂ« ilongk in breuts defcendwut. Optime inÂ« oâpdar Jtlotjg^^yf^f rtliqmndo Ã breuibus,uti Noweni crime C.Cepr.leHiM^^utJ Animdduerti indices. Sed pro C â'*gt;orefte,qModmtt(Â»m duspirtitioni ÃmHeedi 1â* quot;Ifritdte gdndet Â« ebtefttU quoque Ã¨ longk qÂ«Â«

592 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlTÂ» ÃrmiÃimd eÃ¼,^ cludet zy 'm treues, qMinuis Mt^ mdiffrrens ultimo, Ne^ac en'im. ego ignore 'm pÂ»tp^ longa aci ipi breuem, quod uidetur aUquid uicMitmtÂ» pori,ex eo quad 'mfequitur,accedcre,dures tdmeneon^ fulens meas inteÃigo muit urn referre, utrum ne logip^ quÂ£cludit,dnprolongd. tjequeen'mitdmfienume^^ cere And(lientcin timere,qudmiÃ¼ud:Aufuse^cÃft(fâ' Atqui Ã nihil refert breuis dn longd fit ult'nnd,idegt;nflt;^ erit,ueruinnefdoquontodo fedebithoc, iMfuhfiÃf^f quo mod quiddm,longÂ£ Ultimi tria tempord dedertvn^i ut idud tempus,quod breuis ex longd decipit fuie quo^^ dccederet.lAecfolum refert,quisclduddt,fdquis dritte ceddt.Ketrorfum dutem ne^ plus tribus fq;ÃââÂ°^ ^^!Ã nos fyUdbds habebumt repetendi funt (dbfittdmenpo^^^^ ce obferudtio) neque m'inus duobus, dHoquipf^^^^â Â» numerus. PoteH tdmÃ« uel imus effe diehoreus/f^f^^^ qui conÃdt ex duobus chords, itemq; p^^â â ^ââ^^i ^J ! chorea er pyrrhichio,quern dptum mitijs PÂ«^, tra qui cR Ã¨ trains breuibus zy longd, cm d^r . ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;!

gnant, de quibusferÃ¨ duobus fcriptoreshidus , *^^â quumur.s-Alios omnes quotcunq^ fim tempor^â â ^^ Dochimus. dd ordtionem pert'mednt,promis dppeUdnt,^ ^^^^^^ ch'mus,quiftexbdcchio,zyidmbo,uelidinbo(J Spondeus. co,Ãdbilis 'm cldufulis zy feuerus.Spondeus

plufmum en DemoÃhenes ufus, mor dm femp^'â' I* habet,optime pneedet eurn creticus, ut'mhee- 9 ego nihil dicam niÃ depeUendi criminis edufd. l ^Mod fupra dixi multu referre, tmÃ³ ne uerbo Pâ¢âquot;^'

lt;nmis cdufi ,moUe, drebiptrdtje, moUiM ft tribnebys fritceiityficiliMeSytemeritiites.lS,^ enm ^uodditm Ml if ft imficne uerborum Utens tempus,ut 'm pentÃ¤metri medio,Ãiontiro,qui nift diterius wrbi fne, ^Iterius 'mU tio con^t,uerfum non effcit.PoteH, etUmft minus beÂ» Â«tjpMponi dÂ»4p(e3iM : Multere Â«oÂ» faiuM nobiU, ue* 'rymetiinnotii. Turn dudpf/itM et creticusÃMtbus quo ^âfj qÂ«i ch utroepte fyUAbA minor, pnecedet enm tres longÂ« breuwjfed etjj^ondeus limbo rede pneponiturt 'ipew in irmis fui. 'Temspondeus er biccbius,ftc entm fff Â«Itimw doebimtw : Ãfdem 'm ir mis fui. Ex bis qwÂ« fnpri probdui, dppdret moloffon qitoque cUufuU con* â'niÂ«, duw. hdtedtex quocunque pede intefebreuemÂ» ^^i[c'imus,ubicimque funtjePfe pro nobis.Ninw gri^ 'âÂ»eritjJiondetM pritcedente pyrr'hichio,ut-. ludicij tu* â*wi,t7- ddbuepeitM priore pÂ£one,utt 'Brute dubitiui, *ââ¢/' potim hoc eÃe Â«fl(Â«HM ddiflgt;luw er bicebium.tyuo frondei nonferi conitrngi pitiumtur, qÂ«lt;e iw uerfu quo ÃÂ» notabiiis c!im[mU eSi, nift cum id fieri poted ex tri ^â^ ^â* ^w/i mrmbrwtCHr de profugis noflris copiM com* t*Â« is contri nositvM fyUibi,dtu.ltis^i, Ne didy* '^ qÂ«idtntÃ,ondeo bewe pneponitur, quid finem uerfuÂ» . ââmnimm in fine oritwnis.Bicclnius,ej' cUdit, e^ftU â^^â^ââ¢t'.VtncniHÂ« t'meres. vititeboreum, (bonde* Vel chores

Â°!'*â^â'âf'oqÂ«oq!qÂ«Kcludet,niftftulUmimlonoim'^eMnumtU , nbsp;nbsp;quot;nbsp;''^^'gt;^,optime^bibebitMtefemoloffott^^^ bquot;^

Ã94 M. FAB. QVINT, INSTIT-Ã^mis rej^erfitm,dut bdcchiu:Ciuoi hie PÂ°^'rgt;â'y.^j^ femui. Sed ueriiu erit clduderc char cum nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

dco.^dmhic potins eÃ¼ nunter un ntdnusfum.Cldudctftdichoreiu,fipesidentfibijllilgt;^^ ^etur, ejuo Afidnifu/nt uÃplurmum â¦ CWM ^â^ââ^f ^' Cicero ponitt Pdtris diÃ¤um fdpienstemeritiU^hjCi!Â»^ probduit.Accipiet dntefe choreus et pyrrhichiMU 0' propÃ¨ciues,uirtute,glorid,dignitdte,fuperdbdttCW Cf ddHylui, niÃ eim obferudtio ultime creticuiif)^* uttMuÃ¯ierculd nixus ht Uttore.Hdbebit dnte bene eret^^ eum er idmbum,Ã)ondeuM mdle,peiut choreum, CW* dmphibrdchunQJjgdritM in Afi-icifitijle/monf^ . nidlum'di effebdechiittn. Nonoptimusell trochnufi^ tirnd e^ breuis, quod certe Ãt neceffe eH, iUoquiqne* modo eludet qui pldcetplerifque dichoremHildobÃni* tionc ex trachea fit dndpefiiu. idem trochfus prend detuelongdfitpiton,qudÃ®eeiljSipotero. cr,di^â^ ^ Cicero.obfidt muidid,Sed hoc mitijs deierttntÂ» dut cr pyrrhichius choreo precedente. iJdin Ãe peonen, Omneshiquiinbreuestxcidmtt, nMiuemut ÃibtbÃ ncc dUbi fierÃ¨ fdtK dpti, quÃ¨m ubi citrfui oritionis exit gitur, cr cldufuÃ®is non interfiftitur â¦ Creticus eÃ¼initiji optmui : Q^od preedtuf d diji immortdlibnt Ã^ â¢ ^ cldufuUs t Inconjpeilu populi KorndnittomerepoÃrid die : Appdret uero quem bene eum prÂ£ceddnt,nd0^^^ p^ftuf, uel iUe qui uidcturfini dptior, piton. Sed C^Ã ipfefequitur: Serudre qudmplurimos â¦ Sic melius, qMi^ chareo preteedente, c^tts non turpe dueeret fÃ^

hâfttK pro longd Ãt.StijingAmutÃcjnon turpe duco ^ Pââsflt;:Â®^Â«n* m.Sfd bie fft iUwd wAne quod dixÃ¯.Pjulukm enÂ«Â« mo Â°quot;^â Ã¯lt; dumwi inter Â«ItimtwÂ« lt;(t^ proxmwn Mcrbum,cr tur fe iUud intfriwilo c[uoiAm producimutiAUotluifit exulÂ» tiwtiÃimion^^y trimetri Ãni^.C^uis non turpe ducerett pewt illudjoref^iritum exapere licmt,fi iuv^MUfei-i-Â«i edrmmis eft ,fed Â»iterptMifltf t^uHufdiim, er tribuÂ« qw/i initijj Ãt plenum dutorititit.tiec ego cum priceâÂ» dentes pedex po[ui,legcm dedi, ne Al^ effentJed ([uidfe ri Accidere t,qÂ«od in prifemiA uideretur optimu,oÃen di. Et qw'df m optime eÃ ÃH iundui AnApieÃus,ut qui fÃ®t pWitmetri Ãnis,uel rbytbmox, qui nomen db co trAxitÂ» NdmÂ«bilibido dommAtur/wnocentiileue priÃdivm tfi.Ndm fyndlcepbe fAcit,ut Ultimi fylUli pro umd ÃoÂ» ntm, MoHior Æ et pneedente Ãpondeo uel bAcebiOjUt Ã mutex idemdeue mnocemii pnfidium eÃ¢.NonmecdÂ« p^on, pit (ut i mAgnis uirk diffemiAm') pion, epui eÃ¼ ex triÂ» buxbreuibux er longd.Nxmeft ipfe umAplm breui AnAÂ» pejlo, fdcili txx er AgilitM, qÂ«od quid it A plicuerit bis nonmico^niÃ quod ilium fere probAuermt, quibax loÂ» qucÂ»dimdgtxqM4Hiordndi Ãudiumfuit, HAmerAme Ã breuibw guudet pyrrhiebio et eborco, meu uel noÃri pcilitiÂ«. At pneedente ff ondeo turn pldneÃnis eft tri nâftrgt;,ciHnptpcr feepsoepteeicontrAriiK, Prindpifs Â«icritÃ¨Uuddtur.Nam er prÃ®mAm Ãdbilem er trÃ¨s eeleÂ» Qjjypj,;^ reshihtt^timenhocquoquemcliorcsAliosputo, To* in loco,K ne tm uero bic locm non ideo trailAtur A nabis, ut orAtio âÂ®â*â qui fern debet Ac Ãuere, de me tiende fcdibitx, de per*

Ã9(Ã® M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. pendendis fyUdbii confenefcAt.Ndtn id turn mifcrhiWi^ in minimis occupai eÃ. tic^ enm g ff totumh^euf* cSfivmpferit,potioribut Mcabit, pifuidtiH rdiUornvii* pondÃ¨re,de nitore cotempto,telf(rulAS ( ut dit LwiM Ãruet,et uermiculdte inter fe lexis committet. NÃÂ»W ââ^ ^. go refrigeretur fle cdlor, cr impetus pereit,-tut et^fi'f curfumdenâ ^â^ curfum ^ui dirigit tnmuit,Cf p^ffus epti Â£^uit,cigt;f cati minutis fumfrdngit, qMÃ uero numeri non fuerint in compof^ gunn^^ *ââquot; ^âÂ°**'^ deprehenfe^Sicut poeind nemo dubitduerit petitÂ» quoddm initio fufum, er durium men furd, crfÂ»tt^i^â^ decurrentiuM fpdtiorum obferuitione ejfegencritiini, mox m eo repertot pedes. Sdtis igitur in hoc nos coinpÂ» nit multd feribendi exercitdtio, ut ex tempore etidmÃ^ miUdfiwddmus. Ã®^eque uero tdmfint mtuendi pedes, umiuerfdcomprehâ¬fioiutuerfimfdcientes,totii/inill^ i pedÂ« dccurfumnonfexuellt;iuinq} pdrtes,ex ^uibtuconÃdt â uerfui,d]piciunt.AntÃ¨ enm edrmen ortirm efgt;f^'^ Â°^ nbsp;nbsp;(

quid m ora' Ergo quem m poemdte locum hÃ¼bet uerpfodtio^um m *âÂ°t^fâ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ordtionecompoÃtio. Optime dut de H'diudiednt dures,

qua er plend femiunt, er pdrum expletd iefider.iÂ»tgt;^t Ã'dgoÃs offÃ¨nduntur,er lenibui mulcemur, amp;quot;nbsp;fÂ»^^f* tis excitdntur,et ÃdbiUd probdut, cldudddeprehendid, infelIigSt rcdunddutid et nmid fdjlidiunt. ldeo^ doPirdtionem Ã¼iuoiw'^^â â'â^PÂ°^^^lt;^^â^^^f^itvnt,erinda(liuolupidtem.QS^ ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â nbsp;ddm uero drie trddi non po/funt, Ulutdndus eH cdfus,ft

Â«wex ^Â«Q pr^cipt potfÃ¯J^âFiguÂ« lAbonintittiAm com foÃttione uAriiÃ¼A fope fuccurrut^ Q^ieicum ontioniSt ifmetiint ÃnttnÃ¼tinwm prxfcriptiwn dut rei utlum 'ft$â Occifionibututeniu/mtCfcumre pnefentideli^ bcrini'xmt'E.n'miieYoj^niiiip[AquÂ£ mlxuciuiiem pM te piuÃ¯imwm Milent, quod poffunt nifi durium hibere ia diciumf Cur tiUd fAudoribut uerbis fdtis flcM, wl nb tnin/n^d^d phribut breuidiOquot; dbfcijjd fwnti Cur 'm dr*â ^Mtdudionibuf etidm cumfenfut finitut eÃ¼, dUiluid ti* tnenloci Medreuidedtur f Nemmemue^rum ignord^ ^e irbitror iudices, hunc per bofce dies fermonem uul^ gidt^Mc bine opmionem popuU RÃ¶mern fui[fe. Cur bofce potim ({Udm boj^Neqwe entm erdt Ã¼^erum. Rd* tioncm forU^c non redddm, fentidm effe melius. Cur nonfÃ¼is fit,fermonemimlgifuijJc^Compojitioenim pd gebuurt ignordbdm, [ed itd utdudio, boe dnimut det^ tipit plenum fine bdf gemmdtione noneneÂ» Ad fenfum iÃ¿tw referendd fu/nt. Ncquflt;w fdtis forti cpiÃ feue* fomiCpiidiucwndum ftijmteUigere,fdddt lt;[uidem ndtu* n dwe mtUut 4Â«im drie, /Ã©d ndturÂ£ ipfi drs 'merit Al* bid pror^ut ordtoris,lcire,ubi quo^wc genere compofi* tionÂ» fit utendum. Ed dwplcx objer Uitio^dterd quÂ« dd ftdes refertur,dlterd qÂ«Â« dd cbprcbcnfiones, quf eff* fiiWur ex pcdibut.v de bis priut.Dixmtut igitur e^e tdciji^rnenibrdtdrcuitus. Ã¯ndfum ( qtWKluMt med fertlndfum.qd opinio) trit fenfus non expleto numero conclufus, plc*^Â«*ââ'*â^* tift^ Vlt;K membri. Tdle fft enm qiio Cicero utiturs ^^'^VdtibideerdttdibdbebdX. feewnid fupex^dtidt

fgcb^i-Viunt dutcm etidm Ãngulii uerbif wdÃiiti-^ Membrum xintut,teÃesdureuolumM.incifumeli,dixitniUâ ^'^^â^ truni dutem cH fenfm numerii condufut, Ãd d toto cof poredbruptm, cr per fc nihil rfficiens. ld enim, 0 (âd* lidos homines,pcrfcÂ£lwm edl,dt remotum d cxtcrtidiio non hdbet,ut per fe tndntts, er pes, er cdput: er 0 rfÂ« excogitdtdm,Qudndo ergo meipit corput eÃeUu/n Â»lt; nit cxtremdconclufiot QuemejudfonoÃrumfefeUitiid nos itd effe fdduros i qudm Cicero breuiÃimdin pvtdtgt; Itd^uc ferÃ¨ meifd er membrd mixed funt,ty condujio* Periodus, nem utique deÃderdnt.Periodo plurimd nomind dH Ct^ cero^dmbitum^circuitum, comprehenfionem, contmui^ tionem, circunferiptionem. Generd eim duo fmt,dite* rum Ãmplex, cum fenfut tunut longiore dmbitu circuits dudturi alter urn quad conÃdt membrii, CZ iÂ»t'f'^gt;iâ*f plures fenfut habent.Aderdt idnitor cdrceri5gt;cr t^^â'^^ fex Pratorir,er reUqua.Habet periodos ntendât'^ tnini^^ mam duo. Mediua numertts uidetuniuituor gt;Ã^ ^^^^' pit frequenter er plurd, Nlodm eins d CKiromAtt^ ^{* tuorfenariji uerfibits,MtipÃus J^iritutntodotttmt^ natur. Pr^Ãare debet, ut fenfum concluddt,Ãt d^ttÃ ut inteUigi poÃit,non immodied, ut memorid com^^^ Â«â Babikeft MembrumlongiutiuÃotdrdum,breuiut-biliÃ^, !,

Vbicunque deriter erit er mÃdnter pugndcitet qde cendum^emirdtim citfim^ dicemut. Ã¯ldm hoe in â¦aBoqui tione plurimum lalet, ddeÃ³que rebut dteonmoddÂ»

HetMlrdtim plertw^uc Â»imlitmtM ^dwt ipf^i periodo t niioriiutmteriudlisÂ»e3' ueiuthxioribM noOs rÃ©solue* miÂ«,cxcf ptw quÂ£ Â«on docendi gritii^Ãed ortundt Â«(tr* Ã¯ittt{Hr,Mt in 'Verrem'ProftYpmÂ£ r.tptu-s. Hlt;ec eniw k* Â«K C Ãwen; contexts decet. Veriodos dptd procemiji M-tioywn cdufdruw, uH foUdtudine, commendÃ¤tionc, i^ilÃ¨rdione res cg? t. item commiwitlnÂ« Ãocis,iy tn omni implificiitionc,fed po^dtur turn auÃerd, fi Accuses,tum Ãtfiji UudfÃ®. Multum er in epilogÂ« pollet. Tottwn dw tfmddWbendiwwcft, quo/Ã®tamplitMcompopuonisgo Â«IK, cum iudex non fuUm rem tenet,fed etidm cdptiÂ« eft oy(it(one,er fe credit Adori, er uoluptAte iAmducitur^ âVifionAnontAm fnitos numÃ©ros^epiAmorbem quen* dim cogt;tiextKmqÂ«e defderAt. Manque omniu dus mem brd connexd funt, quonidm Ubried eft,de ÃÂ«it,ut bomk nej, qui mdnibuÃ® Â«wweew upprebenfs grddum f rrndnt. coHtinetit, er contmentur. DcmonPrdtiuum genui oÂ» mnefufiores habet liberiorÃ©fquc numÃ©rosÂ» ludicule er concionaleut mAteridUirium ewijfieetiAmipfdcoUo* edtione uerborum: ubi tarn nobw pari ex duabui ( qudi modo fecHHUs) fec^ndd trdftdndd eft. Ndm quk dubk tilt alid kniui ,.dlid coneildiius, dlid fublwnius,alid ptt* .^-pugnÃ¤tius ^ndciusjdlid grAuiuseffe dicÃ©dA? Grduibui, /ublimibus, oyÂ«dtK,longd5 mAgis^Udbdi couenirei itAut IcnidJ^d â¦â'âW, fubliwid er omAtA eUntdte quoq; uoeuw pofeSt, P'ixsqudmbM contrAriA. Mdgis kuddrem ,brfuibui ââWwd, partitionÂ«, locos, er quiequid eft ferma*-w quot;âgit fimile. Udque cowponemus proamium lurie,

inline ut fen fin dus pojluUbit. TSleque enirn Accefferm CeÃ®fo, quitwdmqMnddmbuicpÃ¢rtiformimiciitttT , optmun compoftionem ejfeproamtj^utdpui Afwii ivm, dixiti Si CÂ£^Ã¢r ex omnibuf mortiUbus, qui finten fuerint,pojfet huic enufa difeeptitor Ugi, non quifqui te potim optundut nobis fuit. Non quid negem hoc bene e/fe compofitum, fed quid legem hune effe componenÃ¼ in omnibuf principijs recu/Ã¨m. Neun iudicis dniinut m* rie prigpurdtury turn miferdbiles effe uolumm, turn mo* deftijtum ieres ,tum gr Mes, turn bUndi, turn flederci turn ad diligentUm hortdri. Ã¼iec ut funt diuerfd mtuÂ» m, diÃmUem componendi quoq; rdtionem deftderdut. I An fimilibus Cicero ufus eH numeris m exordia pro tii nbsp;nbsp;]

lone,pro Cluentio,pro Q. Ligdriof Ndrrdtio ferÃ¨ un i diores,dtquc(ut Ãc dixerim) modeÃioresdefiderdtpei des,0- nommibus maxime mixtos. Nam et uerbi5,utf^ pias preffd cil, ita interim mfurgit,fed doeere cr gere animis res femper cupit^ quod minime feÃititmiu opus eÃ¼. Ac mihi uidetur tota narratio conÃif^ ^^^^'^ nbsp;nbsp;j

ribus membris,breuioribus periodis. Arguments dtridt cr excitata, pedibus quoq^ ad hanc naturam acconadaÂ»^ datls utentur. Non tamÃª ita ut trachitis que celertt^f dem, fed fine uiribus funt. Verum qtumuis futt ^â^^'*' longis^ mixta,non tamÃ«plures longas quant breues bentia, lÃ¼afublmia,ffatiofas cUras^ uoces hdbentÃ* mant ampUtudinem. Dadyli quoque ac peones, etidinjt maioriex parte fyllabis breuibui,temporibM tarnen tirpleni. A ff era contra, iambis maxime condtdiuu^

â'Ort/Ã´lwnj quod Ãnt e duiim modi[yUabis^eo^ frÃ©tÃ©e twrfm quiÃpulfumhAbent,quÂ£res knitdti contmrii fft,fed ctiÃ¯ quoi ornnftiÂ« p^rtibiÂ« iwprgwnt, er Ã bre rtibÂ«lt; m longiM nitnntur, er crefcunt: idcÃ³qHc meUorei ebortk, gut A loÂ»gw mbreueseddunt, Summiffd,([itdlid in epilogkjlfnt^j er ipfd er mmm excldmdntrs exigSt* Vult effe Ceifm dÃ¼qudm er fuperiorem copofitiontm, ^KÂ®i (iquidÃ« ÃdremuSydoceremtUyffd Ãt nneffe eÃ tdv â¢^ CZ fÂ«pW4. Verum nifi ex uerbis dttÃ¿te fentent^s per pronStiÃ¯tio feÃeid lt;[utritur,fdtK odiofd effe non pateritt Dcntqj,Â«t fingutarum ffmclÃnidm,Ãc ferÃ¨ componendu, quo modo pronuewn fionis.*âââ iwm erit. An no in proÅmqs plerwnqj fubmiÃi^ niÃeum bl deeuÃthne coneÃ¼dndus cÃ index^dut dUlt;{ud Mignd tioÂ«f copkndiwÃ¯â Inndrrdtionr pkni deque exprej?!? in Â«rguwentk citdti,dt^uc ipÃoetidm motu eeleres furnuii Â« in lock de deÃeriptionibus ÃuÃ de ÃuentesÃm epilogk plfrunq; deiedi er mfrdHii Atqui coporis quoq; mo motus âibw [m quicddm trmpord,er dd Ãgnd pcdum,no mwiiw fdltdtioni, q moduUtionibuÂ« ddbibet muÃicd rdtio nuÂ« ^ ââ(âjrorll *rtf os.Qgid non Â«ox dd dilm dccommoddtur ndturdt k artus âpfirMmdequituc dicinuÂ« rcrumfQBo minus id mirum b* pedibui ordtiortk,cÃ¼ debednt Ãublmid ingredi.knid d'^gt;dcndcurrere,deliedtd/luerc. ItdqjubieÃ neeeÃÃe^ W^Â«Â«iM etidm.Tumor rerum etidmj^ondeit deque Â«{

\ tlu â¢tquot;quot;â'â^â** âÂ®$*Â® fortdrius, quem trochdicum uocdtit, 1 t Tl WÂ«borek,qtrocbietdbdlijÃ¯dicutur.Pgt;nbichiÂ«Â«

lt;02 H. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT, quidem decurrit, fed quantum ccleritatis habet, taniUfii ^rauitatis amittiti

Ci^d igitur factam^ non eam^ ne nunc quidont dixit etia â ^j^ere uero,^^ mak didum etiam tn carmineiimbii iamSsaat^ '^'^ffâ^â^^' QM^^^Â°^pot^Ãn^lt;^^f^'i**^fÂ°^^l^^^â' fantur. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^Ã impudieuÃ® O' nor ax, 0 akot

in uniuerfum autem,Ã fit neceffe, dura potins atlt;^ ij^t ram compofitionÃª malim ejfe,quam effeeminata 0 eint uem, qualis apud multos, 0 quotidiemagis lafduimtis-Scilicet in tonoru modis faltitantcs. Ac ne tam iona lt;pd dem uÃ¼a erit,ut debeat effe continua^o Ã¯deo eofdifmt f modus per pedes ire. Kam o uerÃÃeandi genus efl unamle gern omnibusÃrmonibus dare,O' id cummasiiÃfkaSe flatione,cuius rei maxte cauÃ«da fuÃ^kioefl^um ena ta Ã ium ex ÃmiUtudme ac fadetatÃ¨ crÃ©Ã¢t. Quod^ e Â« dus magis perdit,amittitq; 0 Ãde, et omnis,qui efl in hac cura dcprehenfus,nec pote _quot; dere, nee propter eum dokre, o-irafiitti^^ ? hoc uacare. Ideoq} initia quedam quafifti^^ Ãria funt,qu.edÃ¤ ita maximilaboris,nelaboratiui^_ tur. Scd neq^ longioribus q oportet i^yp^^^^^^^'^^ptef tioni feruiamus, ne qut dus gratia fecerimuhe^^^^^^ earn fed Je uideamur^ Ef eer te nuttu aptum ^t^ ^^.^ f^snitwnÂ» ucfbum prgtermittemusgratiaknitatis-

er it uÃ¼u tam difficile,quad non comode infeed ^ 0^! qdâin euitadk dufmodi uerbis no docorc qua;rimus,fcdfacilitatÃ«.NotamcmirÃ bortatni .^ gitmdulÃffecÃ¶poÃtipi, q Atticos,qâ^auis miui^d

i[ueÃ^ Ã ifjÃ¨rentunojlrigcuciq; fermonii ,expliciliit lummusHkcr. Compofitio^nAmfinmi/mponcreegref-fo deÃin^tum modura moImitihii fejlino) debet effe honc- pj^cs^^â^ Pâlt;,i*:Â«ndd,u4rw.EiÂ»j trÃ¨s pArtcs,ordo^coniun{iio,nti

*Â«frÂ«s,Ratio iÂ« Adieilione,detrActione,niutdtione^ufu, 1^toniWrirerum,c[UAs dicimw-CurimAgM ut fentiÃ¨di dtj Ioqncndi, prior fit. rtifimulxtio curx prÂ£cipui, ut Â«Â«Â«cri fixante fiuxiffe, nondreefiiti z^ cotSii effe w-dcitntur. Libri noni FINIS.

ED bicdo^uendi prÃ¦ceptd pcÂ«fc cognitioni funt neceffdrid^itdnan fais dd uim dicendi Â«aient, nifit il-lis firmd ([UÂ£ddm fdcilitM ,qÂ«lt; 4Â« pÂ»dGrlt;ecoÃ® X^^iÃ§ nontinafur,dc-. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;--------cefferityddelUdmficribÃ¨dopluSydn

e^ti'v'^ ^'^ââ^Â° ^Â°^f^^^^^^^fÂ°^'^^^ Ãâ*^* fiio.Quod quot;nbsp;â Ã¿ntiuj nobw exdmmdndunt,fi t^udUbet edrunt â** FÂ°JftÂ«u$ Â«Â«a e^e contentive mm ita fiunt wier

Ã©O4 MÂ« FAB. QVINT. INSTlTÂ« xuse^ÃS de? ^ ^Â°^^^^^ ^ Mifcrcta omnia, ut fiquii ex bis ie^ fucrint mt,fi'uflrafit'mc^terisldbordtum.tiAnee^[olidilitlt;^ roiufldfuent un^ eloquentie,nifi multoflylo uires ecce pent, ZT citrd teilionis exemplum labor Ule edrens re' ilorefluit.Qui dutem feiet quo fint quÂ£^ modo dicciii, nifl tdnq in procmHu pdrdtdm quidÃ«dd omnesedfut bi iueriteloquentidm, uelut cldufls thefdurif mcubdbit.^ ijon dut ut quicq; pneeipue necejfdriu cR, fle dd eflicie dum ordtorÃ«mdximi protmut er it momenti.tidtfi eertt cumfit in eloquedo pofitum ordtoris o/flciu,dicere dnt( omnid edl,dtq; bic initium eius drtisfuiffe mdnifeflit eSb proximdm deinde imitdtionem,nouifiimd fenbendidB gentidm. Sed ut perueniri dd fummd nifl ex prindp^i non poteft, itd procedente idm opere minime meipiunt effe quÂ£ primdfunt. Verum nos no quo modo fit inflitue dus Ordtorshoe loco dicimust ndm id quidÃ¨ dutfitif^^nf tomnia certcutipotuimus,didlÃ¼e/l,fedutdthletdqiii't'Â°^^^^ idm perdidicerit d prdceptore numÃ©ros, quo i^f'^^ ^^ Ita ercitdtionis dd certdmind prdpdrddus fit.'Hffllt;â'^ qui res muenire e;r dijflonere feiet, uerbd quoq^ cr ^u' gendijCr coÃ¼oedndi rdtionÃ¨ percepcritjinjlrusmuf i^'^ in oreitione dicere fdcere^ optime quemfdeilime pop â¢ â¦ Ã¯^â^ ItSon ergo dubium eÃ¼, quin ei uelut opes fint quidixf pdrdndf,quibus uti ubieunq; defiderdtum erit,poÃl^,^^ cofldnt copid rerum de uerborum. Sed res proprii P cuiufq; cdufeput pduciseSmunes,uerbd in ttniuerjdip^ rdndd:quie fi rebusfingulis effentfinguld, mmoremtu* Xdin pofluldrent^ndm eunitd fefe cum ipÃ^ protÂ»^^''

Iw ofjvrrent.Scd cum Ã¤Ujs Ãnt dlu dut mugis proprid, tut mugis orndtii,dut plus efficitntidtdut mcUus fondtid^ dÃ©lient effÃ©non folum notd omnid, fed in promptu^dte^ue Ht itd diedm, conlpeUu, ut cum fc iudicio dicentis aften derint,fdcilis ex bis optmoru ft elellio, Ec[uidem fcio f^,*^ ^Hopi coUeftitjqwie idem ftgniftedrent uodbuld/oUtos nymis colli â¢ edifcete, epio fdcilius c^r occurreret wnum ex pluribUs, ^SSSs m^* VeumeffentuÃ dUcpuo/i breue intrd fpdtiururfus de* tumopÃ©rs ftderdretur,effugicndÂ£ repetitionis grdtid fumerent d'' PÂ®*â**** ItHd, quo idem mteUigi poffet: c[uod cum eSl puerile, c^ cuiufddmmfelicis operÂ£,tumetidm utile pdrum,turbdni enim modo congregdt,ex epid Ãnc difcrimme occupet ^p ximuni quod^j. No U's lt;lt;Â»tenj copid cum iudicio pdrddd tll^um ordndi,non circuldtoridm uolubilitdtem ÃpeSidn tibusi id dutem confeejuemur optimd legenda dt^ dudiÃª do. Non folum enm nommd ipjd reru cognofcemus bdc eun^fed ^uid lt;[uoi^ loco Ãt dptiÃimu, omnibus enimfe^ tÃ¨ uerbis^pr^ter pJMd ^ux funt pdrÃ¼ uetecundd,in or A tione lociÂ« cfl.N^m fcriptom epuidem idmborum uete^ rÃ¤j coined iiie,etidm m ilUs fepe Iduddtur, fed nobis nÃ ftrum opus intuerifdtis eÃ¯l .Omnid Uerbd,exceptis de intÃ©rim q^ibui dixi,funt dlicubi optimd: ndm es- bumUiius inte* â*quot;.

Â»1Â« o- uulg^ribus eft opus, et ^Â«e nitidiore in pdrtc ui denturJordiditjWilt res pofcit proprie dicuntuf.}iÂ£c ut piimtts,it^; corum non ÃgniÃedtionem modo, fed for' mÃ¿ etiiÃ¼n menfurdsq; nor mus,ut ubicunlt;^ erunt poÃtd eoueniMt, niÃ multd ledione dtep; duditione dffeepui nul wmodo poffumusj cum omnem enm fermonem durtbiH

Â£o6 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTITÂ« primum dccipicimus,proptcr quoi infantes 4 mutii nU' tricibut iuffu regum in folitudinc ednedti, etidwft ucrld quicddm emififje trddunturddmm h^uendifdcultite ci rueruntSunt autem alid huim ndtitm, ut idem phribm uacib^ dÃ©clarent, itd ut nihil figniÃcdtionis, ^uopothit titdrii, interfit, ut en fis er gltdiustdlid (iuÂ£ etidmfi f^ru prid rer urn dliqudrum fint nomind,T^o7eiK.Klt;^ tdmen ii eundem inteÃ¯leÃ¯iumferuntur,ut ferrum et mucro. W^^ /pud uetc' per dbufionemficdrios etidm omnesuoedmus^ui cieicfi res telum ,p f-^io quocuni]} commiferint: dud dreuieu uerborumfd' armisfere amp;^Ã¯i^t^t oÃendimus, qudle eR : Et preÃicopidlddu-gbus I edere^ plurimd ucro mutdtione figurdmustScio,non ignora,et, dfR^rÃ¨ho nonmefi(git,nonmeprÂ£terit,(:y^uisnefcitineminiiii ftiumuima biumcil. Sed etid ex proximo mutudriUcettudmet in' musaâce^k' ^^^âSÂ° ^ P^^âÂ° ^ ^^â^^Â° ppeidÃ© Udlent quodfeio^â^ batur. Na ut rum nobii ubertdtem de diuitiM ddbit Ã¯e{lio,utbisnoja tus dus fign?â^ ilt;^lt;Â»^Â°'^Â° occurrerint,fed etidm quomoiio spartet, ficatio latif utdmur.Eion femper enim hjtc interfe idemf^Â»^^ Smepuibit. p^i^^ jj, ifiiflt;]ip{iu inimi rede dixerm uideo, itd de uifn oculoru intettigo nee ut muero glddiu,fie mueronemgii dim afendit, Sed ut copid uerborufic pdrdtur,itd non uerborum tdntum grdtid Icgendum uel audienduni dt. tidm omnium quecunij; docemuf,hÂ£e funt exempli pa* tentiord etidmipftsquÂ£trddunturdrtibuscÃ¼eo,lt;piidi' feit,per dudui ed,ut mteiligere cd fine demonÃrite,^ fÃ¨quHdm fuis uiribus poÃit, cuid q!iÂ£ doÃ¼or pridpib ordtor oÃendit. AUd ucro duiicntcs,dlid legentes nnÃ¿^ adiuuintt Excitdt ^ui dicit,jÃiritu ipf^nce inuginc cj

tok'tH rerun,fed relusmcendittwuunt enim onnUet fnouentur,excipimui^ nouu iUu uelut tuifcentiiyCu fdU9 re dcfolicitudineinecfortunii modo iudieijyfed etia. ip fa rumi^uiorintpcriculoAfficmur, Vrxter bÂ£cuox,e3â dftio dfcoMjCommoddhi qwd quifc^locuspoÃuhhit^ 'Pronmeiindi uel potentiÃmA 'm dicendo rAtio^e^ ut fe wel iieim,omniA docet.ln leSlione certiui iudiciu,(luoi i^udientiflt;c([uenter,AUt fuiis cuiq^ fduor,Aut iUeÃ¯dudAn tiumdimorextorcjuct: pudet enim diffentire, (^ uelut iidiAi^uAdAtn uerecundiA 'mbibemurplut nabis crede^ return z^ 'interim uitiofd pluribus pldcednt, (^ a carra giltK liMdentur etidm c[uje nan plicent i fed Ã¨ contraria quoqi iccidit,ut apt'tme didis grAtu prAUd iudiciA nan reÃrAntXedio hberd cd, nee ddionis 'mpetu trdnfeuv rit,lcirepeterefepiuslicet,fwedubites,fiuementarix fenitus dffgere uelis, ^epetdmus duten zs- trddemus^ et Ht cibos mAnfos de propÃ¨ lie^uefddos dmitfimus, quo AeiliHj diger Antun itA ledia nan crudA,fed multd ite* Mtione moUitA,CJ' Â«flxt can fed A memarie 'mitAtiani^ triiAtur,Ac diu nan mÃ apt'imus qui/q;,Ã¼*qMt credentâ ^rmftÃ mmime fdlldt,legendus ed^fed diligÃ«ter,o- pet â' id fcribendi falicitud'metmnec per pdrtes mado fern t^ind* ogt;imiA,fed perkdus liber utilt;^ ex 'mtegra refumc ^^^ipredpueeÃ orAtia,cuiu5 uirtutes ^ec[uÃ«ter ex 'mdn Pfw qHoq; occultAtur, Sxpe enim prÂ£pArAt,diÃimulAtt Â«BÃ¼^ur ordtar^'P eA^ 4 primA pte Adianis dicit,c[UÂ£ it^j in fuut forte 'mfummA^pfuturA,itAlt;^ fualocom'mus pÃ¯deÃ«tjfââ'^ *ibMc nobÂ» qM4re 4,-^^ jj^j. ignordntibtw, id,eo(^ erunt

tognitif omnibus,repetenddAÃud wro titiliÃmu,mjjc CM edu^M qudrum ordtiones M mdnus [umpferimut, (S' quoties continget utrini^ bdUtM legere ddiones, ut Dt mofiben^ dtcj-ArÃmts inter fecotrdridf.Et Ser,Sidpitif dtq^ Meffdbe, quorumdlter pro AuÃdid, contrdiixitii tcr^EtPolUonts zy CdÃijreo ÃÃgt;crndte lt;Â«//lt;Â«$ f!Â«n' miii. Qumetidm fi mmia pares uidebuittur,dliipte tdW ad cognofendam litium quieÃioncm reiie reiptiriw,^ contra Ciceronis ordtiones t Tuberonis in (^LigdriKt Crilortenfijpro Verre. Qumetidm et^demciuÃsid ^âflÃÃ egerit, utile erit [dre : nam pro domo Ciceroni! dixit CaUdius, crproMilone ordtionem Brutus exit' citdtionis grdtidÃeripÃt, etidmÃ egiÃÃe cum Cor. Celld fdlfo exiÃimdt:cr PolHodc MeÃdld defenderuntcoÃcâ ) Et nobis puerisinÃgnes pro Volufeno Cdtulo,'Demit^ Afri,CrijÃi PdÃieni,Decimi,LÂ£lij ordtionesÃrebdmr.

t omnts ^^^' '^ ^ââ^^ legenti perfudfumÃit, omms gni dutoresdixerintyUtii^ elÃeperfcildmÃ¤ntO'^^^'^' ! tur dliqudndo,cr oneri cedunt, er indulgent iniemoru fuorum uoluptdti:nec femper intendant animosity ''âquot;^ nunq fdtigantur, cum Ciceroni donnitdre interim ^^' mofibenes. Hordtioueroetidm Homerus ipfe wie^' Summienim funt,homines turnen, dccidit^ bis,lt;jui lt;[UiC' t repctitur'^â*â'^ ââ^'*^ â^^^ ^ repererunt, dicendi legem putintgt;lt;Ã dÃ©tÃ©riora mitenturnd enim eÃ¼ fdcilius,acfeabuniejgt;^ tnilesputent,ftuitiamagnorumconfei]uantur.ldoitp^ tarnen er circunJpeUo iudicio de tant is uiris pronuosn dunt efi,ne ^Md plerif^ accidit,damnent que

Igunt: de fÃ® neceffe e^ in diterdm errdre pdrtemfimnid torum kgÃ¨tÃ¯buspldcere,^ wkIw dij^liccre rndlucrim^ * dtfpiccre Phtrimuni dicit ordtori conferre IheophrdHus Icdio' Â»fm foetdrum,multi^ tins indicium fec^uiintHr, nec^id, immeritÃ¶rndn^i db bis cr in rebusfj^iritus^Zir in utrbis fubUmitit^f^- in dfjvliibus motus omnis, Â©â in per [oms ^lt;^sorpttitur,pritcipuc^ uclutdttritd ^tiotididno dHu forcnfi ingenid^optime rcrum tdlium bÃ¯dnditid repdrdn fw,ideoej^ inbdcÃ¯edione Ciceroreejuiefeendum putdt. Hicminerimus tdmi no per oid poctdx effe ordtori feepiÃ¨ ios,necUbertdtcuerboru,nec Ucentidfigurdru, totuÃ©^ iUud [udiorum genus oflcntdtioni copdr dtum, c prÂ« -ter td quoi [oldmpetit uoluptdtem, edm^ etidm fingen

\ dono filfimodo^fed etidmeptxddmincredibilid fedd-iw^pdtrocinid e^uoe^ dlilt;[uo iuudri^epiod dUigdtu dd cer idmpedumneeeÃitdtem nÃ´ femperproprijsutipoÃitf fed depulfum Ã redd uid neceÃdrio dd chcpiendi eptitdd. diutrticuliconÃugidt. tieemutdreeptdeddmmodÃ³uer' bdyfd extenderejeorripere^conuertere, dimdere cogd tun nos nero drmdtos Ãdre in deie, zgt;r fummis de rebus decernere,^^ ^d, uidoridm nith Nf^ ego drmdfcptdle^ ^efnuic rubigine ueÃ¯im,fedfulgorem ineffeepti terredt qiwlis ffl fcrri,lt;pio mens fimul uif^Ã©p perfiringiturpso ^âÂ«Iw iKri drgenti^ imbcUis,Zir potiiu heihenti pericut *Â°M'Hij1orÃ¹quo^ diere ordtionÃ¨ c^uoddm molli iucun do^f^eopoteÃ:Hfrum er ipfdpeedlegendd,Ut fcid-Â«âÂ« fIfrdf^ eiÂ«f mVtutf Æ ordtori effe uitiddSied enim proxiwd po^fjj ^ ^ qwoddwwodo edrmen [olutum edt

Â«lÃ³ M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT- , ' erfcribitur ad nlt;irrdndum,non ad probanium,totgt;ilt;gt;lt;1? , nbsp;, opuinonad aHuinreipugnain^ipÃ¯Â£^Mcm,fti^^'^â^

intuitani ^^g^^^f^ poÃeritdtKyet mgenijfamicomponitur,iiÂ«y Ã§^ uerbis remotioribui^ZT liberioribut figure narrais tedium euitat. Ua^ ut dixt, nec^uc SaUuÃianabrewtiÃ¼t f^ua nihil apud aurcs uacuas ati^ eruditie poteÃejfe fff feiiius, apudoccupatuin narijs cogitationibunud^^f' er fepius incruditumcaptanda nabiseSl-.ncque iÃ¼a T-'Liuij ladea ubertas fatis docebit eum qui na jpeciem et' M^TdP^ l?Â°Ã^^Â°â^^Â»l^'^Ãâ^^â^qusrit. QuaddicercfortiusiU' Vide Laer deo,quia M^TuJUus ne ThuddidÃ¨ quids aut -XenopboX tium in uita tem utiles or atari putat quanqua ilium belUeum canert, XenophÃ¶ris y^.^ ^^^ ^ufaseffe locutas exif met. Licet tarnenno' bis in digreÃionibus uti uel hiÃarico nontinq nitoreÃn in his, de quibus erit queÃio,mcminerimus nonatbletiâ rum tharos Jed militu lacertos nec uerficolorÃ«^gt;^* Demetrius Phakreus dicebaturuti,ueÃenilgt;eneidfo'' renfern pulueremfacerc. EÃ er aliusex hiÃef^f '^r^f er is quidem maximus, fed non ad prefentem perlens locum,excognitionc reru exemplorum^, quibus mptt tuis mÃrudus eje debet orator mee omnia teÃtmania ex pedet Ã litigatore,fed pkraq; ex uetufiate diHÃª^'^^^^ r bicognita fumat,hoc potÃ«tiora,quod cafolaerifnvni us, odif,eygratisuacantt Aphilofophorum ueto^^^Â°â'^ ut effent nabis multd petÃªdd,uitio fadum ed oratorum, qui quidem illis optima fui operis parte eefferunt. N^'â* f^de iuÃis,honeÃis,utilibus, quxq; funt iÃis contrin^t amp;â de rebus diumis maxime dicunt, erdriuin^Â»^^^'^^

Ãeritfi-jO- aitcrcdtionibiK Hc^ut mterrogitionibut ori toremfuturu opitme Soentid pr^pttrantSf d bw ^Ko^j *dlMbrn(jMm rfl pmilc iuUdum, Â»t ttiiim cum m relui ^Â»Ãtmur ij^dcm,non timen andem ejfe conditions feid IiHm de diffgt;utdtionu,fori ^ duditorijyfrteceptoYH

^ i^eiculorum, Credo exdduros pkro/^jcura tdntHm ââJ^xtilitdtw inlegendoiudicemus,v.tid lt;^iioc[ueddiun* 2âlt;wufopfrt,qÂ«i Ãnt legendi,([Uie 'm dutore quo^we pr# t'pH-i uirtuf^Ãd perÃejui fmgulos 'mÃniti fuerit operw, ^Â«ippf film in Bruto M. TuBiuj tot miliibiÂ« uerfuum de RomdtiM tantum ordteribw loqudtur, zr timen de omnituÃ¯ dtit'is fu^e, quibtw cum uiucb.it,exceptw Ce-Ãrt Â«^ MireeHo, fiUntium egerit : quw erit modui Ã C illoj,cr d.Â«i poften fnerunt,zr Gmeos omnes, et pbih^5 Â«Â«in lofopbos, Ã¼ poÃ¨tes perÃe^ui ue]imC Fuerit igitur Ire exemplar}. MitÂ« ini tutiÃimi, e^ue rft ilt;pÂ«d Liuium 'm epiÃoid id Ã liuiÂ« Ãripudegend os DemoÃbenem, nqi Cicerone jtum Â«UÂ«t Â«jKi'quc eÃet demoÃheni er Ciceroni ÃmiUmus. Noneft time diÃimuldndinoÃri (pto^ iudic'fj fummiÂ» FiueosenmiUelpotiusuixuUum exbis epti uetuÃdtem pertiderunt,exiÃ'lt;mo poÃe reperiri, qui ludicium ddW-bentibwi non alUtinuÃ¯ Ãt utilitdtis alicpuid, cum fc Cice ro it lÃ¼is quo^i wtuÃiÃmis dutoribw, âmgenioÃs qui-dem,fed drie cirentilus, piur'mum fitatur idiutum, Nee multi differ de nobis fentiot quettw miÂ») epiife^in* Â«fMiri turn dÃ©pens pote/b, epti ne m'm'imd eptidi ilicuius eert/)Ã¯(li(ti4 partis memot ii peÃerititis Ãermeritf Finit ^^Ã 3^ ffl, mtruprimos ÃHim uerÃts deprebÃ©detur,

Cz citius nos dimiuet, quint ut dus noils nugnc toH-pork detrimento conÃet expermentum. Sed non ^W' quid ad uliquiun partem fdentU pert'mk, protmus si fudendim etum phrdfin,de qmbquinlitr^iccommoii^ turn eR.Verum antequi definguhs loquir,f)iucx in Wii uerfum de uurietiiteopinionunf dicendufunt.THim qui' diun fobs ueteres legendos putint, net^ in uUis dijs efft nuturdlemeloquentium, cr roiuruirk dignum,drbitri tur: Alios recens h^c la fluid delitiÃ¦^, er omnidddito luptdtem multitudmk impÃ©ritie compofitd dMint. Ipfos etidm qui reHum dicendi genus fcqd uolunt: Alij preffa demum er tenuilt;i,et quit minimum db ufu quoin diano recedunt^fand eruere Attiedputdnt. QuoÃM f fpurdtÃ¼s eldtiar mgenij uk^er msgk condt diel' piOf'l â f'firitut cdpitiSunt er lenk, er nitidi, er compofiti generis no pducidmdtores'.dequddiffÃ¨rcntiddiffcrdindibgentius, cum de genere dicendi qutrendum erit. interim fm' mdtim quid 4 qud leHionepeterepoÃint, quieonfrmi' re fdcultdtem dicendi uolut, attingdm. Pducos enim tpf funt eminentiÃimi excerpere in dnimo e^fdcile eH dut Audio fis,quifmt hk Ãmilimiiudiedrcincquifquiqu^^ turomiffosfortÃ¨ dUquos corfquos ipfe nulde,pbet^b^' tear enm plures legÃ¨dos e/fe, qqime noldbuntur-Sei nuncgeneraipfdleÃ¼ionuquÂ£ pnecipueconuentremte h Ait Ã©fx.b dentibus^t orator es fiat exiflime,perfequar. Igitur ut ^ tiomerus. '^i^â^l'*^ * llt;gt;uc mcipiÃ«dum putdt,ita nos rite ecepturidÂ» Homerouidemur. lÃ¯icenm,qâtemadmodumexoeediio dicit ipfe animfiuimfontiuqi curfus witiu (dpere,omiin

Hwnc nemo 'm mdgnis fuilmutdtc, in pdruK proprieti* tefuperdueritt idem letuidcpreffui^iucundusdcgrd-UK,turn copu IKW ^reuitdte mir dims, nee poetied mo' do Â»fed ordtorid uirtute cminentiÃ'mus^t^A ut de Idudi^ ^'^^Â»exbortdtionibus, confoUtionihui tdeedm,nonne **1 Â«Ws liber,quo mifjd dd AchiUem legdtio contmetur, **^ M* primo mter duces iUd contentiojucldiUdi in feeun ^ofententie,omnis litis dc confiliorum expUednt drtesf ^fjÃ¨^ws quidem nel idos mites,nel hos concitdtos, nemo ^it tdm indoilas,qtii non in fud poteÃdte hunc dutorem bibuijfefdtedtur.Age uero,non utriuft^ operis mgref* fusmpdueiÃ'misuerÃbus legem proamiorumnondi^ to Ãruiuit,fed conÃituit i N^m ey beneuolum mdito* tem 'muoedtione dedrum, quds preÃdere udtibus credit turn eft, er wtentKW propoÃtdremm mdgnitud'me,e3â docilem fummd celeritercomprehenfd fdeit. Narrare xero quw breuitÂ«, quitÂ» ^ui mortem nwneidt Putrocli? ^XK Ã^iÃutius potcjl, quirn qui CKretÂ« AetolorÂ«mq^ Pâ'^iiÂ«mexponit? Ilt;lt;m /Ã®miIitÂ«diÂ«fÃ®,lt;tmpIi/ÃMtiortcÃ®, exempt,digreÃlus,Ãgndrerum, er drgumentd, cete~ r^q; probmdi dc reÃdtdndi, funt itd mmtd,ut etidm qui ** Â»tibiufcripferunt,plur'md edrum rerum teÃ'mionid Â»Hoc forti petint.Nitm epiloguj quidem quw Â«Â»quam tâ^'ritiUjj pridmirogdMis AchillepreÃ¤busequdrif ^^^âmuerbis,fentet'tjs,Ãguris,diÃpoÃti totius operis âÂ°''''âÂ«milt;ni ingenij modum excedit, ut mdgni Ãt mrif â¢â^^i rim non cmnl^tonf, quod Ãeri non poteÃ, Ãed, 0.1 5

intclleilufequi.Verum bic omneifmc duiio,cr iÂ» ^ ^encre cloquentig proeul k fe reliquit : Epims MWÂ«* * Â«Sul Pâquot;â^Â«Fâf, uideUcet qua diriÃimi m mitcrij.(imilis co pdratioed:. Rdro lt;iffÃ¹rgitiÃ®efiodus,mÃ¢gndqÂ»epdr! etuunnotninibiu eH occupdid,tdnKn utiles dra pre' ceptd fententie lenitd^quc uerborum, CT compoÃtionis probdbibs : detur^ ei patmi in iUo medio genere dicen Antimechâ, j^p^ contre inAntimdeho uit er granites, ZT minime uulgire eloquentie genus, habet laudem. Sed quamuis ei fecundas ferÃ¨ GrammaticorumconÃenfus dÃ©fÃ©rÃ¢t, (T Ã¤ffedibus, er iueunditate, er diÃpoÃtione, er omnino arte deÃdtur,ut plane manifesto appareat quanto fita' Fanya Cs. liudproxmumeffe^aUud fecudum.PanyaÃmexutros^ mixtumputant,in eloquendo neutrius equareuirtu' tes, alterum tarnen ab co materia, alterum difponendi , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. rationc(uperari, Apollonius m or dm^m a Gramtnatids

Apo omus. pi^^^^jnQfjuojit ,quiaÃriÃarchusatqueAriÃopbanes poetarumiudices,neminem fui temporis in numerumre degerunt, non tarnen contemnÃ¨dum edidit opits,eq^cdt Aratut. quadammediocritate^ Aratimateriamotucaret,utin qua nuÃ¼a uarietas, nullus affedus, nuUa perfona, mdl^ cuiufquam Ãt oratio, fuÃidt tarnen operi cui fe pdrem Theocritus Admirabilis in fuo genere Theocritus,fed HÂ» fa iÃ¼a ruÃica er paÃoraUs,non forum modÃ¶,ueruipÃim etiam urbem reformidat. Audire uideor undiq; congÃ©' rentes nomina plurmorum poctarum. Quid f Herculis adra non bene PifandrostQuidttiicandrufruÃra fecuti Mocer atÃ§^ VcrgHiusf GiuidC EuphorionefruÃrani*

/itwiui^ qurm niftprobaffetVerÃ¿ÃuSyidcm tiling cate (oniitorum Cbxiciiico uerfu cArrnmu feciffet m BMcoIi cw mentionem. Quid i Pontius fru^rA yyrtÂ£um HoÂ« Wfro ^Uikiungiti Nfc /tWe qBi/qwS eft um procwl Ã co-gnitionc eormÂ« mnotus, ut non indicem certe ex lihUo ^^^ei^umpi^ tnnfferre m Ubros ^uos po^it.Ncc ignoÂ«. ââ 0 igitur quos irAnfeo,nec wtiq; ddmno, ut lt;[ui dixefm in omnituj utiUtdtii AU([uid,U dd iHos idm perfcHis co )5'^tÂ«q; uiribiK reuertemur, quod in canis grdndibm {^p(fdcimw,utcuopt'mK fdtidti Ãmuf,udrietditdfnen Â«obw ex iiilioribut grdtdÃt. Tkc Oquot; elegiam udedbit in indnuffiiincrc^cuiuiprincepshdbeturCdllimdchutt fecu Catiimachâ, dÂ« eonfeÃionc plurmoru Pbilif tlt;M occupduit. Scd dilt;m Ã¯â^ilacws. lt;i)JcqMimÂ«r ili-Â»Â» firmd/itdixi.,fdcilitdtct optmis dffue-)â Ãenium e^^iy multi mdgis 5 multorum ledione form'd d w cr ducendus tR color,UdeÃ ex tribus receptis, Ari P^rebi iudicio, feriptoribusiAmboru, dd bexmmdxvmÃ¨ fWinebit Â«Â»Â«Æ Archilochus.Summd 'm hoc uis elocution.

*'K)CM MÂ«[idx, turn breucs uibrdntes^i fcntÃ¨tiitjplurimÃ¼ f'^'^Ã¿inis dt^i neruoru ddeo ut uidedtur quibufdi quoi ^xoqu^nj minor esl,miteriÂ£ effe, nonmgenijuiti'u, No Â«cmueroLyricorumlonge ?Mdirusprmceps,fpiritUt Pindarus. ^^gniÃcentiA,{'ententijs,Ãgur'K,beitiÃ'musrerum uer' boruw^ copid^z^ uelut quodi eloquentide Ãumi/ne, proÂ« t^''â'JlÂ«Â£HorittiwsttcmMUcrfdit eu'tmitiibilÃ«. SteÃcho' StefichoruÃ¢i â^â* If# ingenio uilidus, mitcru quo(^ o^endut, mdxi w^btHd^jj. ^^fiÃij^Q^ ednentÃ© duces,et^pici arminii Â°^^^htiÃuÃmeMcm;rcddit emm per fonts 'm agendo

^l6 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. fjmul lo^uendo^ debitdm dignitdtem, defitenuiffet mo dum, uiditurcmuldri proximus Homer urn potuiÃ^,^^^ redunddt dt^ effi(nditur,quod uteÃ reprclKndeÂ»iwgt;i, Mexus. itd comitÃ© uitiueÃ.Alcaeus in pMc opens Mrcoplcciro meritÃ© dondturj^uityrdnnasinfeildtus, mubumetUm moribus confert, in eloquendo quoq^ breuis cy nugni' nbsp;nbsp;i

akior fuf et dmores defcendit,mdioribt(f tdmen dptior Simo Simonides, ff^^gj tenuif, dliaquifermoniproprio.zy iucuditate qui ddmeommenddri poteÃ,prtecipud tdmen eins in coni' mouendd miferdtione uirtui,ut quiddm in bdeenmpir* A ntfqua Co ^^ omnibus eiufde.m operis dutoribiisprÂ£fcrit.Amiqui â¢nadii. comoedidcum fyncerdmiUdm fermonis Attici grdtiM prope fold retinet,tum fdcundiÃimÂ£libertdtis,etÃeÃ in tnfeddndis uitijsprMipud plurimum tdmen uirium e* tidm in exteris pdrtibtts hdbet, Hdm cr grdndi5,cr (if gdns,cr uenuÃdjO- nefiio dn iUd, poÃ Homermn tymnet quemut AchillemfempercxcipipdreA, nafMUorÃ ordtoribus, dut dd ordtorcs fdciendos dptior^ ^lgt;*^f eius dutores, A rifiophdnes tdmen et EupoUs CnUnuff Aekhylus. pneipui, Trdgadids primum in lucent Aefchytiupf^, lit,fublimis er grduis cr grdndiloqtMS fepeufq;^'^ tiurntfed rudis in pleri/^ cr incopoÃtuf, propter ilt;jo* corredlds dus fdbuldsmcertdmedefcrrepoÃerioriin^ Poet is AthÃ©nien fes permifcrc,funt^ eo modo multi co^ randtd Sed lange cidrius illuÃrducrunt hoc opus Sopi^ Sophocles ^1^^^^^ Euripides^ quorum in dijpdridicÃªdinid uterff Euripides, PoÃªtdmeliorf interpiurimotqifieriturÃd^ego f^^

^Â«onum 41 prrfpÂ«lt;fw mdteridmnÃ¯hilpertMet^miuiit (Ã¼ivm rclmquo â¦ iHud ^Milem nemo no fiteitur neceffe tft, bis qui fe di dgeni um com^drent, utiUorem hnge fore Zmfiiem,ndncinc is z;^ in fermone,c[uod rcprebÃª duÂ«t.qÂ«ibult; gr4Â«it45,er cothurniKjCr fonuf Sopbocto wieture^e [ublmior^mdgisdcccdit ordtoriogenerijet fcutfiteijs ienfut,zr m bis ([uxdfd^ictihut trdiitd fwnt pf Â«f ip/Ã¯Ã¯ pdr,cr'm dicendo de ref^ondendo^ cui libet f. ciuiiiter fJÃ¯â¢ qui fut runt mforo dlfertijCom^Ardndtu. In dfjÃ¨ (iibus ucro ewn omnibus mirus, turn 'm bis qui miferd* t'ion: con^dM facile prdcipiMs.nwnc etddmirdtus md xmf eft,ut fdpete^dtur, zy fecutus quAnqiwinm ope*

i nbsp;nbsp;K iiuerfo Mfndnde r,qMi wl unus^ meo cÃ¿Ã¹dem tudicioÂ»^^'^^^*^â

diligenter kiftiW/d ciÂ«iHu qUÃ frigcifmus,efjingendd fu^Mt. itd omnem uitic 'tmdgmem expre^it, tdntd in ta 'mueniendi eof^id^eloe^uendifdcultM Ã® itd eA omnibus rebus,^er[onis,dffi;Ã©iibus decommoddtus. Mec nibil pro

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fefto uiJfruÂ«t,qut ordtiones ,^Ud: ebdriÃj nomimeedwn Charifi^ ors

tHrAMenundro feriptus putotÂ» Sed mibi longe mdgis âiâquot;ââ ordtorprobitrÃ¼nopÃ¨re fuouidetur,nifi fortedutffld will iudiciu^quÃ¦ l7riTÃÂ£7rovTot(â3'^quot;^^â?^?gt;â*'^Â°^Â°^Â»^'*^Â°* b4(Ã®ct;4utmediMtiortfÃ®iÂ« Pfopbode,cr Nomotbete,Hy pobolmiÂ£o,noft omnibiM ordtor^s numeris [unt dbfolu^ **âÂ£got4(Hctj plusddhucquidddmcoÃ¼dturtundecldmd toiribÂ«, puto,qÂ«otjiÂ£Wj bis neceffe eli feewndwm conditio

Â«Â«trouer/Ã®iiruiH pluresfubirc perfonM, putrum, )âââ''ââ''gt;âgt;writt)r^ffl,miÃ®itii.ni,rnPit:orum,diw!tumjpuu* V'â'***ââ)ir(i[ccÂ«(iuw, prec4witwM,wittiMtt,lt;iÃ,eroytÂ«ngt;

^^uÂ«orPÂ°'^ ^â'^â^ omNffcjM mire euÃoditur db hoepoÃ«td decor. At queiUe quidem omnibuf dufdem opÃ©rÃ©s Autortbui i^^^ Ut nomen,O'fulgore quodam fua cUritatis tenebra ob dttxic. HAbent tarnen ahj qÂ»oq; coinici,Ã cum uema legs Fhilemon, tur,quÂ£dA quee poÃts decerperCtO preecipue Memo, qui at praui fui temporis iudieijs lÃ¼enandro fepe pnl^ ^â^â^ tin rÃ©i,it a confenfu tarne omniu meruitUredifecundi^. litftoriam multi fcripfere pnclare, fed nemo dubitat lo gt duos cÂ£tcris prÂ£fcrendos,quoru diuerfauirtudia^ dem pene eil parÃ«confecuta, Defus o breuis et femptr Thucydi-- it^ÃansfibiThucydides. DulcisocandiduiOcÃ©fuiiti Hn-^ociotus ii^rodotus. lÃe concitatisjiic remifis affÃ¨llibiumclior'. TheopÃ©pus. lÃ¼e (Ã¶cionibus,hicferinonibuttlÃ¼eui,bicuoluptatcSbe opompM his proximtn, ut te hiÃoria pradidis minor, it a oratori mugis fmilis, ut qui aMe quam dt adhoco^ Philiftus. pj^ folicitatus,diufucrit orator.PhiliÃm quoc^ merctur qui turbÂ£, quamuis honor u poU cos autoru, eximotur, Imitator Thueydidif,o ut multo infrmiorjta tUfitt Ephorus. nuslucidior. Ephorus, utiifocratiuifum,cilc^d^^ â^ Ciitarcbus. get.Clitarchi probatur mg(hiu,fidcs infamatur.tongo Tinugtnts. ^^^ interuaÃ¼o temporis nalm Timagenes, ud kocipÃ^ probabilis, quod intermiÃim hiforias fcribÃ«di indupi am,noua Uude reparauit. IZenophon non exci^^i fed inter philofopbos reddendus eÃ. Sequitur oritorum ingens manus, ut cum decern ftmul Athenis Â£t^ U/na tÂ»* lâEric,quorum longe princeps DemoÃhencs, ac penÃ¨ bi orandi fuit,tanea uis in eo,tam den fa omnia, ita quM* dam neruis intenta funt, tam nihil otiofum, is dicilt;gt;^

WÂ«.PlfÂ«wr Aefihines zy msgis fufm^ or grunHorifi^^^^^'^^^' milÂ«,quo miniÂ« firidux eSi,cArnK t^men flat habet,U

certoni/m minui.Qulcif m ^rimis z^ dcÂ«t w Hype ride $, Hyperidcs^ fed mwioribm cMjis,ttt non dixerm utilior,mAgK par.

Â«M,Ji oratori ptÂ« fit dicere, qn^raÂ« fperfiediM, mbit enim eft mine,nihil tirccfiit:wm,puro timen fiomi quim tHignofiummi propior. iÃocntesin diuerfo genexedi'' ifocrates. eendt nitidiÂ« 0â compo/itMi,er pak^rÃ¦ quam pugnÂ« tromptus magÂ« OccommadattÂ«, omnej dicendi ueneres fiditm cft, nee Â«nmerito, auditories enm fe, non indicies comi pmrat.m vnuentionefiiciUs,honefii fiudiofutjm com* poptione adeÃ³ diligent, Ht curd etiÂ« reprebendaturÂ« Nequcegom bÂ« dequibtÂ« pmlocutiÂ« ,bas loUxwrÂ» 1 Wes, fed blÂ« pratcipHdS pMto,ncc etteros pirum fuijje w^gnos, Qametidm Pbalered illiwn Dcmctriuw,quangt; Demetrius, quamÂ«primus mdiMi^c cloqucntidmdicitur jinultum Ph*lÂ«'^Â«âs, wgenijbabMijJÃª er ficu/ndia fiteor ; Â«cl ob boe memo* dt dignum, quod ultimus eft fere ex AtticÂ«, qui dici po/Jit orator, qurm tarnen m ifto medio gencre dicen* diprdfert omnibus Cicero. Pbilofopboruw ,ex quiÂ» kâs pkrtmum fe traxijje eloquentie Marcus TuUius

^ conpetur, quit dubitet pUtonem efle praEciptMim^ flue Plattx acumme diljiycnji ,fiÂ«e cloqucndi facultdte diuma qua dam cr Homerica Ã® multiwti enint fuprd profam oratioÂ» wÂ«, CT quim pedeÃrem Graci uocant, furgit, ut mi* bl non bomink mgenio, fed qiwdatn Delpbico uidcotwr

^20 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT, Xenophon o^^cutoinftmÃ¼iis. Quid ego commemoremXenof^^ tu illtim iucuditiltem m^dfeHatdm, fed t^uim Â«Â«HÂ«* PÂ®r fit adfeilitio confequt ^ ut ipfefinxiffe fermonem Gri* tia uideantur. Â£2 c^uod de Pende ueterU coniaiU U* fiimonium e^i^m hiMtc trdnsferri iujliÃime poÃitjin Ã¯^* brU eiuf fediffe qudnddm perfuidendi dedm.Qud f^''* AriftoteIcs. quorum Socrdticorumelegdiuidmfquid AriÃotelenâ quem dulito feientid renvm,dn firiptorum copii,dti(^â^ quendi fuduitdte,dn inuentionum dcumine,dcUirieUtâ Theophrafl, ^I?^^^*^ cldrioremputem.lidminTheophrdfotdnicl^ eloquendi nitor iÃ¼c diuinut,ut ex eo nomett quoque tri''

xiffe diedtur. tJiinut mdulfere eloquÃªnÂ£ Stoici uetcrcsgt; fed cum hotte fia fudfenmt, turn 'm conigendo, probdÂ»^^ do^,quÂ£ infiituerdnt plurimum udluertunt, rebm tiO'^ dcutimdgUqudmid quod fditÃ¨non ddfe{ldruÂ»t,lt;Â»'â^â'^ ne mdgnifici, idem nabis per R orndnos quoque dutores ordo ducenduf efi.itd^ ut dpud iUos iioiner!(ifoââP^'^, VergiliuÃ¯Â« ^^j VergiUus dufficdtiÃâmum dederit exorUt^^h urn eius generis poet drum, Gracoru noÃronh^^ iubieprox'imus. Vtdr en'tm uerbis ijfdeni, ^Â«^ quot;^^e'â Domitio iuuenis dccepi^qui mihi interrogdnti,')'^'ââ ^^^ merocrederetmdxime decedere,ficuduSitniÃi^^â^^^^^. giUus,propiortdme primo qudm tertio.'Et bereitÂ«N t ndturlt;ecalefiidtque 'mmortdlicefferiinuSfiU(gt;â'^^' diligentiÂ£,uel ideo 'm hoc plus efl, quod fuit Â« Â»ââ^Ã¨^â bordndum.pt quinto plus eminentioribuiumcitgt;turgt;r tdffie xqudlitdte pÃ«fdmus,Cigteri omnes longe fiff^â Ãditt MdeerÃ§r Lucretius legendi quidemjei'^^â'

Ova'll},ii cSicorpiM docluendie^fAnAnt. ElegAnta iÂ« fw qui/que mAteriiJed Alter humilis,Alter difficilii. Af ^AemwvArro wi bw per qÂ»Â« nomen eil AdfecutiK, in*

tfrprn operie AUcni^non l^cmendiK qMicm,ucru.m Ad t'^geniAmfAcultAtem dieendi pdrum locwpicj. Enmuw Ennius. pcHt fAcros uctujlAte Ineos AdoremusiM e^Mbux greidiA lt;3- (t'wii^u roiorAyiAm non tAtttAm hAbeM j^eciem quan Umrfli'gioHffM.propiorÂ« atq, dtq; ad hoc de quo loqui nurmAgis ntiles. âLAfciiMsejuidem mherois quoqj Oui Ouidius. ^WÂ»Â©' Â«imiÂ« AmAtor mgenij fM,lAudMdui tAme pAr Ã§P^jJJ^jj# tihus. Cornelius AuteSeuertu etiAmfmerÃficAtori^uAin poetAmeliorfi tAmen,ut cÃ¤ didimi. Ad excmplArpr'mi Wgt;ri bellum Siculjm ferferipftÃet, uendicAret Ãbi iure Ãeundwn locum- VArenâAm conÃMmAri mors ImmAtu-^ Varenus. VitNort t^A^A rft, pucriliA turnen eius modo operA er mA itmAm mdolem oÃendunt et mirAbiltm,prAecipue iÂ« xtA tedlAredigenerisuolutAtcm.tAultum 'm VAlerioVlACf Val. FhcA co Â«Â«per dmiÃmus-Vehemens et poetiewm mgenium Sa ^Jyj?^Â®â lei BaÃi fuit,nee ipfum Ãenedute mdturum. RabtrttÂ« etPedoi Pfdo HOÂ« mdigni cognitione Ãt udeet. tucunus ardeni^ââquot;ââ* er foBfitdtue^er feiuentijsclAriÃimusjet ut dicum quod ffntio,Â»MgK ordtoribus qÂ«Ã w foetis imitAdus. Hos Â»Ã¶ Himawimm.qMij GermanicÂ«Â«Â» AugÂ«/}Â«Â«Â»abmP!tulisQjfjj^j(^;j.4. Ã**dijsdfjl(.j(jjj.yj.^ff^^yjj^^p^y^^qyf jjjj uiÃumeil f^Ã^^'inmiximum poetArumiduH turne ipÃseius ope rib(M,iÂ« qÂ«ftJonato imperia iwuenis ÃueeeÃÃerAt^fubA cIeuatÃ¼S Imn'ui.doftiHj, omnibus deniquenumerw prtÃuntius^ QÂ»!Â« enmi canerct bem melius quam quiÃc geru {t^ui

prxfidentcs Ãudif! dcx proprius dudirent!cui mi^lfdt pmatfuM artes fdmilidrc numen Mmefu^^Di^^^^*^ plenius futura fecula^nimc enim cfiter arumful^orenr tutim lausifla prfiÃrmgitur. Nos tarnen facra litcrarÂ» colei/es feres CÂ£^ar,fnon taciturn koe prfiterimu5,(Jâ V ergiliano certe uerfu teÃamur:

ElcgdaGrficos^uoeii prouocamus cuiusmihiterÃi Tibullus, atclue elcgans maxime uidetur autor TibuUtts. Sant ^w ^*^Â°âcaUus*

rior Gallus. Satyra quidem tota noÃra cll,m qwf Â« Lufilius. musinfignemlaudemadeptusLucilius.Qjtofdamitait betam^to^ ^^^Â°^Ã^^'^^'^^^^â^^^h^^^lt;â^-^Â°^^^'*^^â'^'ââÂ°^Â°Â°P^* m nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ris autoribusyfed omnibus poctis prfiferre non dubitÃ«t.

Ego cfiAittwm ab illis, tantum ah Horatio diffencio,^iti Lucili urn Ãuere lutulentum, er ef[e aliquid quod toÃ¼ere pofis,putdt: nam er cruditio in eo mira,er libertas,at que inde acerbitaf,er abumde fdisMulto efl tlt;^tfior ac Horatius. purusmagis Horatiuster,nifj labor dus ainorc,f^rtciÂ» Perffus. puus-Mult m er ucrÂ£gloria,quamuistwobbroPerÃ us meruit. Samt clarihodie quoq;, er qui olimnomna^^ bumtur.Alcerum illudetiam prius fatyragenus, feino Itr. Varro./^^â* carmm im Mrietate miÃ '-m,cÃ¶didit Terentius Vit ro,uirKomanorjAneruditifimus,plurimosbiclibrot erdodiÃtmos compofuit, peritifmus ImgualaMr, eromnis ainiquitatis:er rerumgracarum noÃrirumt que, plus tarnen Ãientia coUaturus quam cloqueniia* Umbus non fanÃ© Ã Komanis eelebratuseÃ ut proprium

io,BiwcttIo, Uordtio, qudnquimiUi Epodos mterueni'^ Ã¯t non reptridtur i At Lyricorim idem Hordtius ferÃ¨ fobs legi dignustudm 'mfurgit dliqudndo, amp;nbsp;plenus e^l iucunditdtis (^ grdti^^Oquot; uirijs figure, or ucrUs fdi eifl'me duddx. Si quem ddijcerc uclisjs erit CifÃus EuÃ CÃ¦fius B?f. f^iyquemnuperuidimus/fedeumlongepr^ecedurtin'', 2lt;^â^iduiuentium. TrdgcediiefcriptoresuetemmAcci ^'''ââ' Â«f df^i Edcuuius cldriÃmi,grduitdte fententidruw, uer Pawuius. ionm ponders, dMorUdteperfondrum. Cceterum nb tor Zy fumnid in excolcndis operibus mdnus, ntdgis ui^ ieripotsU tÃ¨poribusqu'auipÃs defuiffet uirium time Accio plus trihuitur. Picwniim uideri doiliorsm,qui iinndicare f^eio(iia(jv(ldni,uoluÂ»t. idntVdruscuilibetGrjecoi' Varus. rum rampitwt poteÃ.Ouidij M.edcd uidetur mihi o^en ifrcj qÂ«itÂ«lt;!MB uiriUe praÃdre potuerit ,Ã ingenio fuo mperdre,qudm mdulgere ntdluiffet.Eonmi quos uide'-tMonge prmceps PompÃ³nius Secundus, quem Ãnes Pomp Se* pitrumtrigiciMK putdbdâit, eruditione dc nitore prÂ£-gt; ÃdreconÃtebdmur. incomosdidmdxineclduiicdmus, ^ctVdrroiicdtlAufds, AelqStolonis feitcntii,Pldu^ PlautuJi fmo fermoKf loculurdis ÃuiÃe, Ã Idtme loqui ueUenttU* âtCeciliimi ueteres Iduiibus ferdnt: licet Teremij feri TerentiusÂ« pti^dSciptortcfM Aphriednumreferdutur, qui timen funt in hoc gertere clegdtttiÃi/nn, er plur ddhuc hdbitn ^â^^!idtitfiâ fj^^Y|^f^f.fÃ^f trime trosÃetiÃ'sui.Vixleuein tofequtmur umbrdni,dde6 ut mihi ferma ipÃ Romaius Bon redpexf gide ^t^p iU^nÂ» [oUs eweeÃdm Attica ^fi

nercm,lt;lUAnio eum ne Gritciguident in nUo gmerelm* Afr; nius. gâ^ obtinuerrnt. Togitis exccUit AfriniiM, ut'viiÃ®.mlt;{ue non mtiuiniifjet argumentÃ¢t, pucrorum fadis amoribus, mores fuos fajjus, At hiÃaria non cejftrit Grtcit gt;nbsp;Â«â^ opponere T huddidi SaW^Ãium ucrear, nec indigntW T .Liuiuj. Ãibi Herodotus Â£quAri T. Liuum,cum m narrando wit rÂ£ iucunditatis^cUriÃmiqi candor is, tuM in conciow^ busfupra quam enarrari potcH cioquemem- Uiqu^^^* cumtur omnia cum rebusdu/tn perfonis aceSmodati-^ affedus quidem,prlt;ecipuequc cos qui ftunt duldorcs, Â«lt;

' pareiÃime dicam,nemo hiÃoricorum commendiuitm^* gis.ldeoq; immortalemiÃ¼am SaUuÃij uclodtatcmÃii^^f fis uirtutibus conÃecutus eÃ¼.Uam mihi egregicdixilÃ^ Serait No uidetur SeruiUus Houianus, pares cos magd quantrâ^ uwnus. nbsp;nbsp;lest qui c^ipfea nobis auditus cÃ clari uirir.gt'tii, 0â

fententijserebertfed minus prelfiis,qu'amhiÃofi^^â^^ BaffÂ« Au ^â^â'^ poÃulat,quam poulam atatepracedes Â«dius. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ajifidiuf/gregie utique in libris belli Germdtn^^ f i^

tit,gencre ipfo probabilis in omnibus, fii h^ i^'^*^i ^^ fuis ipfe uiribus minor. Supers A adhuc (j exornd / tisnoÃre gloriamuir feculora/m memoria diguuhl olim nomiwabitur,numcintetligitur, Ã¼dbet^ Â° Ã®

â¢â¦ imitatores Mc immerito,ut libertas, quanquarn circuntijd ^^ xi/fetei nocuerit,fed elatum ab'MdeÃgt;irita'W,G' ces fententias deprehÃ©des etiarn in bis qua maneut' cr alijfcriptores boni, fed nos genera dfÃ¿^haÂ«Â»fgt; bibliothecas excutimus^Oratores uero tinameloquentiam parem facere Grace poÃi.t'dt

ORATOR. LIEER X. Ã©iS ^fUwque fonwn Ciceronemfortiter oppo^MCriM. NÂ« Cicero, â¢gnoro qiwwdm mihi concitem pugnMi,cu/m ^igfertim â¢i Â«OH fit propojiti, Â«t euw licmoflhcni compdrem hoe tonporrineque mÂ»Â« Mint t, cum rgt;cmojlhcnem w pri* â¢WW IfgfBduwijttfl edifcenium fotius Ã§uttm, Ciuprum f go minutes pkrd/que drUtror fimilts,confilium,ordi^ Â»fw dtuidoid i,prÂ£pdrdndiy proidtidi rdtionem,omnid ^fâ'$ ?â* f^^ inuentionK. in eloqucHdo cH dU^iu di **^Ãtdf'denÃor iUc,hic copiopon iUe concludit dd^ri-Â» ^iut,hic Idtius :pÂ«gÂ»lt;lt;t iÃ¼e dcumhiepmptrjhicfrttjucn ter^^-pondercnUinihil dttrahi poteSi, huk nihilddijt ^i-curt plus in inojin boe ndturÂ£gt; SdUbus ctrte,(^ corn nijerAtione,(iui duoplurmu dfftausuilent,umcmust Et fottdflcepHogos Â«IK mos ciuUdtis dipulcrk ^fed Oquot; Hotk itli, qwie Attici mirdntur, diuerfi Ldtmi nomiÂ» nisYdtiommuspermiferit, IncpipoUs lt;iuidcm,([Mn* ^wm funt utriup^^nuUd contentio cft. Cedenduw Â«fro in boe quidf m,c(Â«od cy iHr prior fuit, amp;nbsp;tx mdffid pdr te Ciceronfm,qiWÂ«tiM tPfcck.lidm mihi uidttur Mdr# ciM TmUiim eufm ft totum dd imitdtiontm QrÂ£corwn (oiuuh^et, effinxi^t Â«bÂ» Demoflhtnis, copidm PUtot nis,iMwnditdtem Ã¯focrdtÃ¯s.lficc utro quod in quoque o* ptimum fÃ»t, fudio confecutui t^ tdni urn, ftd plurk mu Hel potiiÂ« omnes ex feipfo uirtutes extulit immor^ tdUs ingenij batiÃmd uiertdx. No cnlm piimidf^ut dit PiÂ«ddrm,(tqu4t colligit,fed uiuo gurgite exunddt ,do* no lt;{uodimprouideMiÂ£ genitus, m ^uo totdi uires fuds elo^HeWMexpenretHr. Hdmfjuis doctre diligemwa

Cui M. rAU- QVINTÂ» 1NS'(1'^â mauere uchementiiupotvflfcui tdntd unt^uimin^^ ^' tid affuit,ut ipfa iÃ¼a quÂ£ extor^uet,impetrare Â«i^ ^ datier cum tranfuerfum 'm fua iudicern fer at,tamely i f non rapt uideatur ,fcd fequi. tam'm omnibuf lii*^ ^â* cit,tanta autoritof 'mefi, ut diffentire pudeat,nec aiuÂ» catifludiiim,fed teflif aut iudicis affÃ¨ratfidem. Cu/wiÂ»* tefim hxc omnia,({Uie uixfingula quifqtum 'mtentiftn^^ cura confequipoffet,fluunt illaborata t er matlat Â»â^^ pulchrim auditueR oratio,prÂ«efefert tarnen feliciÃilt;gt;^â fadUtatetn. c^uare non immer ito ab hornâmiha fi^ ^^^^^ tif regnare'm iudicifsdHtm eH, apud poÃerosueraii confecutut, ut Cicero iam non hom'mif,fedeloquentit nomenhabeaturt Huncigiturffeilemus. Hoepropa* fit urn nobiefit exemplum. lUefe proficiffe fciat,cui Ci^ ^^f^'i^ ^oÃ¯' cero tuide placebit. Malta 'm Afinio PoOioneinuemiai fumma dUigentia^adeÃ³ ut quibufdam etiam n'imia ddef atur^amp;confilifcfan'nnifatd, Ã nitorecfiiicnnditate Ciceronif ita lange abeR, ut uideri poÃit fecitlo prior, KeffÃ¯li. j[t Meffila nitidiu amp;nbsp;candidm, CT quodammodo prf fe ferensmdicendonobilitatem fium, uiribm m'tnor. C,Cxr3r. C.uero Ctefarfiforo tantum uacaffet, nonalimexitoÂ» ftris contra Ciceronem nom'maretur,tanta'meo uit eÃ, id acumen, eaconcitatia, ut ilium eodem animo dixife quobellauit,appareat. Exornat tarnen hac omniamiri firmonitycuiut proprie ftudiofut fuit,elegantia, Miib Cxlias. turn 'mgenif in Cxlio, er pr^cipue in aceufando, multi urbanitat,dignut^ uircui crmensmelior,cruitatom tCiluum giorcontigi/fet.lnueniqui CaUimt praferrenlomnit

ORATOR. LIBER X. ^i? ^WjWMfttj ^Â«i Ciceroni crederent, etmi nmii contre fc . Â«limmM uerum Idnguinem perdidiÃe. Sed fft er fin* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. ^^engi^uii omtio^er edfiigiUy er frf (pienter uche^ ^ ââ wml q:Â«o^,lwitlt;(tor dutÃ© r^ Atticorum,fecit^ iÃ¼i pro perdtd mors 'miwidmfj cptid ddiedurut, non ft tptid de in^uruxfuit.Et Seruiu^ Sulpitiud mfignem non Â»nmeÂ« Scr. Sulpit^ Ã¯itÃ¨fTOm tn'fcw ordtionibiK meruit. M.uUd,fi ai/m iu* âââ¢ didokgituryddbitimitdtione digm CdÃim Seuenui C^ff-Seuwâ. ^Â«i/ÃMtfrKttirtuttbm coloremct ^duitdtem ordtio rds iiieciljct,pontndus mter prxcipuos foret.Vidrn CZ mgfnij pInymuTO eft m eo, er dcerlitds mirdjer urbo.^ uitÂ« eilÂ« fumtKet./fd plus Ãomdcho qwÃm confUo deditz praered ut dmdri fades, itafreepsenter dmdrituio ipfd Ã¯idicwU fÃ.SÃ¼Ht (dij multi diffrtt,qÂ«o; perfeepii longum e^.Zegt;rm,eptos uiderim,'Domitiuf Afer/t luliiM Afri Domitius Â«mÂ«longe prlt;ePilt;twiJ?iiKt. Vervorm drie iHc er togt; ^^1^Africa* to gencre dicendi prlt;eferfndtÂ«,cr ^won wt numero uea nus. terumbilbere non tittieiM.Hic cocitdtiorjed in curd Â«er lorum nimius ,er compofaione nonnuwpum longior, Q tnmÃdtioniliw pitvum modictÂ«. Erdnt cUrd er nu* permgenid: Â»dm er TrdcbaUiw pier unqucJwb!mis,erTr phallus, fatis dpertus fuit,er quew MfHc optima crederestaudi^ tiK tarnen maior Ã¯ndm er Â«oew, qwdntdm in tiuHo cogno Â«i ,fÂ«lintdÂ«,er pronwidtio wel fee nis [uffÃ¨Huri, erde conomnia deni^ ei qu* funt extrd fuperfucrunt.Et V i lilÂ« CriÃim compoptiw, c iucundtis, er deleAdtioni vibiÂ» Crifp. ndtusjpriiutis tarnen edufis quim publicis mclior. lulio SeciwdoÃ longior totigijjet dt4?,cldri/?iÂ«tww profedo^'d.SeeCdus.

628 M. FAB. OyiNT. INSTlTÂ» nomen oratorisapudpoficros foret. Adicci^eten^t deque diijcicbitcÂ£terKuirtutibiitÃiti,quod defider^ poteÃ¼jd eÃ¼ dutem ut effet muito migii pugnix, tJ P piusidcuramrerum abelocutionc ref^ieeretiCdteriiii^ interceptmquo^imagntmÂ»Ãbiuendiedtlocum, ii^^ quot;nbsp;fdcundid^tdutd in ex^iedndo, quad vellet, grdtii, t^ edndidum f^ylene^ ffeciofiim dicendi genut ,tiii(^^ uerboru,etidmquÂ£ dffumptd fHnt,proprietdf,tMietti in quibufddin ex periculopetitis fignifcdntid.wieli^^ qui pof nos de ordtoribus fcribent,mdgnd,eos qui nwK uigent, mdteridm uere Iduddndi. Sunt enimfumni hot die,quibus iUuflrdtur forum,mgenidi Hdnque e^ cont fummdri idm pdtroni ueteribus lt;emuldntur, amp;nbsp;eos u^^ num dd optimd tendentium imitdturdc fequiturMut frid, Superfunt qw de philofophid feripfrunt, ^uo ut genere pdueiÃimos ddhuc eloquentes litert V.o^i*f tuierunt. Idem igitur M. Tullius, qui ubiqu^t ^^â'^ hoc opere Pldtonis amulus extitit, Egfegius udo ^^*

orationibus rum,fcidseMn fentirequadicit, Scnpftnonp^i Brutusquot;'^*Â°'' ^^^^^ Cornelius Celfus, Scepticosfecutus,nonfgt;ieeu * â quot;nbsp;â tu denitore. Pldncus m Stoicisrerum cognitlou^**^^ itgt;

In Epicureisleuis quidem,fed non mlucundwit^i^*^ non crat tor eÃ¯l Cdutius. Ex mdufrid Senecum in ontni^eKre rta?â'* ^*' eloqueittiit ucrfdtiM difuli,propter unlgdtdtnfdljo t Seneca. me opmionem, qui ddmndre eurn, CZ inuifum quo^^e hdbere fum creditus â¢ Quod dcciditmihi, dumcottU*

W4dÃeumorAMiciAcontendo : cm dutent foimferc fcie m minibus ddoleÃccMtÃ»fuit, qÂ«cm non cqwde omni no(oniidrtxcutere,fedpotioYihut prxferrinon fine lÃ¯j^Wi ilk noÂ« dejliterit meezere^ciM dinerfi fibi co* (cmÂ« gentrii pldcere fe in dicendo poffe, triant iUt pU* ccTentjdi^jfyft^ Amdbdnt dute ewm mdgis | {Â«HtabdÂ« tw, tintion^j db co defluebdnt,lt;iMntum iUe db dniiepiis iffeendenti foret enim optdndwm pdres,dc fditem pro ^mosilUtdrofieri,fed pldceba propterfoldMtid,Ã§r lt;nbsp;J Â« fe cptifpie dirigebdt effingendd^que potcrat. DeiÂ« de ciwn fe idhdret eodem modo dicere,Senecdm mfdmd^ ^itjcniut cr multÂ£ lt;tlioqum iy mdgne nirtutes fuerut, â¢ngenittm fdcile cr copiofum, piurimum ftudii,multd re Turn cognitio, in cpid tdmen dliipiAndo db hit epuibud in* quirendit qweddm mdnddbdt, deccptiK eft. Trididutt *tiilt;m omnem fermÃ© fiudiorum mdteriim. Ndw Â©â¢ ord* tionei eiut^e^ poÃ«mdtd, o' epifiohe, 0 didlogi feruntâ tw.ln pbilofopbtd pdrm dingen;, egyegim tdmen ui* tiorwm'tnfeddtor fuittmuUie in eo cldrx'tpne fententU^ muitd etiirn morum grdtidlegedd, fed in eloepuendo cor ruptiplcrdqwcÂ»dequeeo pemiciofifimdÂ»quoddbum* dilue dukibiÂ« vitijs. VeUes cum fuo ingenio dixiffe^iUe noiudicio.Ndm JÃ® dli(pu,contempfiffet,fi pdrum con* f^il2qÂ«a

WMtiJ?(wiÃ¯ fententijs non fregi ffet,confenfu potiuf cru* ditonmupiim puerorurndmorecomprobdretw. Vc* rum fic quoqwe idm robufÃ¯is, 0 feueriore gencre fiÃ¼is ^dtiSjIfgcdiw,Â«el idep, quod cxcrcerepoteH MtriÂ«$

Ãjo M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT, , iudicium,fÃ tiitA enim,utdixi, probMdd in eo,ntt^^^^^ tint admirMddfunt, f tigere modo curf Ãt,lt;fioi MM* ipfe feciffet. Dignd enim fuit itU Mturi quÂ£ ntcHoU Â»fl letf^UÃ©t quod uoluit effidt.

EX hitfCgterif^ ledione dignis dutorihut, amp;nbsp;**^ ioru/m fumendti copid eft,cr uirietit fgurdriiâf*gt; cr componendi rdtio,tim eid exemplum uirtutum omi^* urn mens dirigendd , btcqueentmduibitdripotelllt;[**i'^ trits ptrs mdgnd continedtur mitdtionetndm ut uiM nire prmum fuit,eRq; prdtcipwtm, fu ed que bene in^ tic/Ut fivnt,utile fequi-Atq; omnis uitt rdtioftc confit) ut quis probtmui in tlijs, fdcere ipfi ueUmus- Sic Vttr^ rti/m dudus, ut feribendi fidtufus, puerifequuntur tfe mÃ¼Ãet uoeem docemium^pidores operd priorutniT^f'^ ei probdtdm experimento culturdm, in exempli'Â»* ^'*** eittur. Omnis deni^ difeiplin^ initid,dd propofM'Â»*^ li pritfcriptum formdr i uidemus, Et berclc necefe est, tut ftmiles,dut diÃimÃ¼es bonis fimus. Similem *ilt;tÃ¯o **^tii rd preÃet,frequenter imitdtio.Sed hoe ipfum,qMi ta tofdciliorem nabis rdtionem rerum ommiimf^^^^ fuit his qui nihil quad fequerentur, hdbuerunt, nificdu^ telt;ycumiudicio ddprehenditur,noeet. Ante omntd igitur imitdtio perfe ipfd non fu^ittuel quin pigt* T ingenij eontentu ejfe his,quÂ£ fintdb cdqs muentd.Oii* en'm futurum erdt temporibus illis, que Ãi*Â» exempt fuerunt^fihomines nihil, niÃquodiM cognouijjentÂ» faciendum fibi dut cogitundum putdffent f nempenml

* nobK,qHod dtrte non fuerit f An SU rudes foU meiKis mtun dudi fwnt mhoctUt tim mult A generArent, nos id querendm non eo ipfo eoncitemur, quod eerte fei* Â«iM imenijje eos e^ui t^u^fierwnt f Et cum SU, qui nulÂ« Ium CHm/qium rei hAiuertmt mAgijirum, fbtrimA 'm po Ãeroj trudidermt, nobw ufus SlArum rerum Ad ernenn dÃ» aUÃ» non proderit, fed nihil hAM'mw nifi benefietj Alienii Quemidmodum ^uidum pittores 'm id folum fin dfW Â«t deferStere tAbuÃAS mÃ«furis Ac lineÂ« fciAitt. Tur* pc ctiAm iSud cft, cowentuwi effe id confet^ui ejuod imi* terumAm rurfus quid er At futurum, ft nemo plus efjit ciffet eo eptem fecpicbAturt Nihil in poÃ«tis fuprA Liuium Anironicum : nihil'mhifior'tjs fuprA'PoKtificum AnnAÂ« lesbiamp;cremus'.rAtibusAdhuc nAuigAremus,non effet pi* Hure, nifi que ImcAS modo extreme u/mbrx, qÂ»Ã¨m co* ford m fole feciffettt,circunfcriheret. Ac ft omniA per* Â«nfeÂ«, nulld fit Ars q^lw 'inuentA cft, nec'mtrA miti* âw Ãftit, nift forte noflrA potifmum tempor A dAmnA^ Â»1Â« buius 'mfelicitAtis,ut nivitc dernum nihil crefcAt, ni'gt;^ bil Aulem ere feit folA 'mitAtione^Quod fi prioribus Adlt;j etref^ non cft, quomodo f^erAre poffumus uHuw orA* torem perfeUtmitcum 'm his, quoj niAx'mos Adhuc no*

â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Mini!Â«, nemo fit 'muetuus, ht quo nihil Aut defideretur,

I ÃMt ââ fpâfebenddtur.Sed etiAm qui fummA non Appetent, contendere potiut qudm/cqui debenttni qui Agit ut pri ^'''Ã^^^tfitAntCtiAm fi non trdJÃ¯critjequdfcit.Eum Â«cro Â»wo poteft equdrejCHUM uefligijs flbi utilt;^ 'mfifiÃ¨dum

putiiMccejJ'e ejl enim femper fit pofierior ^uifilt;f^â^^â Adde quad plfrim^ ÃeiUm e^ pim fixere 5 idem,W* tdm enim difftcuUitem hibet fimiÃ¼tudo,utneipjA^uiii quxRmiu^^ tflt;^tttflt;i HJ hoc iti euAlucrit, ut non rctfimpUdÃiiatt mÃ¦ uidean^ quÂ£^ pires maxime uideitur, difer'mme dbijuo ii^df nMtur.Adde quod quicquid dlterifimile e^,neceffe fft minus fit co quod imitdmur,ut umbri corpore, GT iiÂ»i* go finde,or adus hifirionum ueris afiÃ¨dibus â¢ QJilt;^^ *â ordtionibus quot^ euenit: ndnque his qui m exemplun dlfiummuiifubed nxturd cr u^rd nis. Contri onttfis inn tdtio fidd ed,eydd dUenum propofiitum dccommoix* tur. Qt^o fit, ut minus fidngumis de uiriumdecUii^^ nÃ©s hdbedut, qudm ordtiones ,quodinSlis uefd, tÂ» â^ dfimuldtd mdterided. Addequod edquf 'ntordtd* BÃ¼faciÃ®itas TemdximdfiiM,imitdbilidnonfunt,ingeniMfgt;'^ââ^''fi

pÃ®eriÃ§^ cuM uerbd quxdxm ex ordtionibM exe^W â dut dUquoscompofittionis certes pedes,wr^^fi^ gerunt efiingi drbitrdntur, cum cr uerbd â^^^ mudleficdnt^ tempor ibus, ut quorwneertiÃi^^ I^^^^ guld in confiuetudme, ed^ non fui nxturd fiââ ^ mdldtndm per fie [oni tdatum fiiM,fied nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fe

proprie^,dutficuscoÃ®locdtdfiunt,etnÃ¿i bus deeÃ«moddtd fit,tum ipfid udrietdte grduiÃ^ -^ propter exddliÃtmo iudicio cired hMc pdrt^F ^^^^ exdmindndd funt omnid Â» PrirniwÂ« liuod imitcitgt;gt;* ^-^^^^ fiuntplurimi,qui fitmÃ¼itudinempeÃimicuiuj'^fi^ -^ ptiÃimi cocupiefmtt tum in ipÃf ^

fit ii quod nos efficiendum compAremns. N^m ntAgnit 5!Â«$ dutontut modÂ«Â«! ^lilt;ntlt;ivitiofA,cr a dodis, m* tn i^fos etiim nwtuo rfprebenp^Ã¤tg; Â«tmum tdm bond iwitdWff dicerent melius 5 muli ^eius dicMt. Nec uero [dtembÂ« c^uHius id euiHndiuitii iudieij fais fuit/tffi dit imigmÃ« uirtutis effngere,^^ folim^ut fc dixermt cutem, nel ^otius iUa EpicuTifigurM,c[UÂ£ Ã¨ fummis cor foribus dicit effluere.tioc iutem his ieddit^c^ui non vn* tro^edis penitus uirtutibus id primÃ¼ fe uelut ifpedum mtionis iptirunt, et cum his feUeiÃme ceÃit mititio, tterbis dt^ numeris funt non multum difjerentes^wm di Â«ndilt;tt$ muentionis non Affa^uuntur^ fed plfrwnq: dje dmunt 'm peius,Cr proximi uirtutihut uitii coprehen^ imtfimteli pro gnndibus tumidi,preÃis exiles,forti' b\u temer drij,lÂ£tii corrupti, compofttis exultintes,fint plidbusne^gentes.-i- tdeo^eptihorride itej^ incompo Adeois ptf quidlikt iUud jrigidum or 'mine extulerunt, inti' qwK fepirescredunt. Qui cirent cultu iteÃ fententijs, Atticis fcilicet,lt;{ui prafeiÃis conclufonÃ¯bus Ã³hfeuri, S4 UÃiHm 4t^ TbiÂ«:ididf m fupennt, trines ie ieiuni Pol-liontm tmulintunotioft ic fupini/ quid modÃ³ longttÂ« ctrcuniuxerunt,iurint iti M. Ciceronem locuturÃ¼fuif fe. HoueMm spiofdim, 41Â« fe puldrre expreÃiffe gcnKj illud cÅlc^iÃ® buitw tÂ» dicendo uiri fibi uiderentur, ft 'm cliufulipofuiffent,effeuideitur. E.rgopr'mumed,ut

1 (ptodmititurutell([uifc^'mteÃ¼igit,e:y ([UirebonÃ¼fit i fcidt,tum 'mfufeipiendo onere confulit fuis uiresdHim

twnfufficitit,Mt diuerfitof repugnet. NÂ« cui tenue 'mÂ» genium ent fold uelit fortin O' nbruptd^cuiforte quiiÃ© â ffubtilitat/s ^'^â^ '^^^^ââi'h Ã¤inore fublimitdtii o uim fuum perdit, O' elegMtidmqud cupit,nond/fequ!itur:nihtl efteniÂ») tdm indecens, q cum mollid durefiant, Atq; ego iHiftf eeptori,quemin{iituerS'tn Hbro fccu'hdo, credidinonei fold docenddeffÃ¨,dd qud quÃ«lt;p difcipulorutidturdcoin^ pofitum uideretmam is o ndiuunre debet quÂ£ in quoip eorum muenit bondjO quanta fieri potefi^ddifierequf defiant,o emenddrequÂ£ddcrmutdre,'ReÂ£lor eniin eÃ Ã¤ltenorum ingenioru atq^ format or. Difftciliiu e/i enim naturam fitamfingere,fied ne ide quidÃª dodlor,qaanqui omma qug refta /Ã¼nt ueUt e/fc in fuis auditoribus quant pleniÃimd,'m eo tarnen cuinaturam obfiareaideritfibo rabit.id quoq^ uitadamfim quo magna pars errat, nein orationepoetas nobis amp;nbsp;hiftoricos, in idis operibus era tores dut deelamatores imitandosputemus. Suaenique propofitaIex,fuusdecorefi.Neecomcedidin(Otburnos ^/furgit, nee contra tragadia focco ingreditur. Uitbet tarnen omnis eloquentiaaliquidcdmunefidmitemurq^ commune edi. Etiarn hoc fielet incomodiaceiderehis qui fiÃ© um alicui generi dedidcrunt, ut fiafigt;eritas hispi^euit (dicuius,hanc etiarn in leniac remijfo caufarugenereno exuant : fiitenuitas out nuditas in a^eris grauibia^eau fis ponderireru param rejfiondeant, cumfit diaerfa ne cauftrum modo inter ip/Ã¢s conditio, fed in fingaHseUa caufis partium, fint^- alia lenitcr,alt'a afiiere,aliacondta ^^ai'a ftâmific^ alia dpeedit alia mouidigratia ditendti

Quorum omnium diÃmiUtAtt^ diutrfe inter fe ratio fÃ,IWc(Â«f ne hoc lt;}uideinfuAfirtm,tMti fe aiieui proprie, quem per omnia fec^uatuniddiccre.lJogc perfediÃimni Gracorum Demo^haus, aUtjuid tarne dliquo 'm loco me litÂ« alij. PlHrimd iHe, fed non qui maxime imitandus, e^ folus mitandus ed. Quid ergo ? non edfatia omnia pc dicere c^nemadmodum M.TuHiuÃ¯ dixit? Mibi quidew fa tÂ« eÃet,Ã omnia eonfequi po/Jem.Quid trfmen noceret, uim Gatfaris, af^critatem CÃ¦lq, dikgetfum PollioÂ»i$,iu^ diciumCdlui quibufdton in loeit azurnere t Num prater id quod prudentw eft,quod in quoqj optimum efl,fi pof ftt,fMm facere, tu in tanta rei di^cultute.iMiH intuen* tarnen tcÃ®,uix utiquii p^r^ fequitur.ldcoq; cum totum exprime re que eIegerMgt;pfÂ»e fitbomini meoneeÃum, pluriumbo Md ponamuj unte oculoj,ut uliud ex alio beredt, er quo quic^ loco conueniet,aptemus, \mitatio aut,nam fepiut ide died,no pt tuntu in uerbis ,itluc mtendedd mes, qudn tumfucrit iUw uiris decoris inrebue dtq; pfonw,qdâ con filiu,qult; diÃiofit{o,q omnid/tiS que deleftdtioni uideX turddtd,dduidoriA^edent. Quid agaturprooemio, que ratio,er q udrid ndrrddi,qud: nit probddt acre fellÃ© di,qÂ«dtdin d^dibiw omnis generis mouedw feientia, quamlt;Ã¯ qudntd^ldiM ipfd populdrk, utilitdtis grdtid djjumptd, que tue(l pulcberrimd eu fequitur ,no cw dreepitur.Hre fl peruiderimu5,tu uere imitdbimur .Qui uero etiS pro# pridbubond ddieerrit ut fuppledt quÂ£ deerdt, circunÂ» tiddt fl qd reduddbitjW crit, quern qufrimtÂ« i^erfeduA Â»Tdtor, que nutte cofummdri potipimum oportebdt ,ch

6}g M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT, fdnto plum bene dieÃ«di exempU[uperfunt,^ iÃ¼ii lt;Ã¿Ã¹ ii hue funtmi funt contigerunt.Ã¼Mt erit htc lt;piolt;^ iMs ca rum, ut priores(upemffÃª, poÃeros docuiffe diantur,

ET feite quidem MxilU extrinfecus ddhibentur, w hts Mtem quf nobis ipfis pdrundd fuut,ut libori! fie utilitdtis etum longe plurimum affirt Ãylus. NÂ« iw mÃ©rita M,. Tullius hune optimum c/fiÃ¼orem de mdÃ¿' firum dieendi uoedt, eui fementit perfondm. L. CrdÃi in difi^utdtionibus (lug funt de ordtore dÃigndndo, iuii dum fitum eumilUus dutoritdte eoniunxit.Scribcndunt ergo lt;iudmdiligcntiÃime (^ (ludmplurmu. Ã¼dm ut ter' rd dltius effoffd generdndis dlendis^ feminibus fxcun' diorfit,ficprofeilus non d fummo petitusfiudiorufru* dus er fundit uberius,er fidcUus continet.^d fme bdc quidem eonfeientidJUd ipfd ex tempore dicenÃ¼f^f'^^'^ indnem modo loeiudcitdtem ddbit, cr uerbd in Idbris nd fcentid.lÃUc rddices, iÃ¼iefunddmentd funt. iHicapts ue lut fdnUiore quoddm grdrio eonditÂ£, unde ii ptito^ ^uoq; edfus,eum res exiget,proferdntur. Viresficid* mus dnte omnid qug fufficidnt hbori eert dminutn,et ur non exhduridntur. tiihil enim rerum ipfd ndturd uo uÃ mdgnum ejfiei citÃ³,propofuit^ pukherrimo cuii^ of cd difficultdtem,quÂ£ndfcendi quotp hsne feeeritÃ¯egcigt;i,ui^ mdiord dnimdlid diutius uifceribus pdrentum eontmere tur.Sedeu fit duplex qugfiio,quomo,et qusmdxnnefed bi oportedt, idm hineordmemfequdr. Sit primouel^ dus,dumdiligcsftyl({s,CluÂ£fAtni{SPptm!tiâ'ceproW*!

b^mtiius ft giudeAmus. AdhiTytitur iudicium inuen tis,di^ofnio probatÂ», DcIc^Mi enwn reru uerborume^ igendm c^^O' pondcrdÃnguloru exAmmmdd, piÃ amp;nbsp;ewminan fdben ritio coUaednii, uerfentur^ omni modo nume^ da. PoU fub ri.Non ut c^uod^ ft proferet uerbu,occupa locum,qÂ«Â« â quot;p^j*^â^* qÂ«idÃ¨ Â«t diligcntius cxcqudmur, repetendd f^pius crÃ»t feriptorum proximdt Na prefer id quod Ãc melius iun guntur pnoribiw fcquentid^cdlor quoq^ Ã¼le cogitdtiois, ^Â»Â« ÃrÃ¼endi mord relrixit,recipit ex integro uircs^Oquot; velutripetitoj^dtiofumitrnpetu^quod mcertdmme fd~ Icndi Ãcri uidemus^ut condlum longius petdnt, er dd tl lad quo contenditurÃpdtium curfuferdnturtutq- in idâ eulindo briebid rcducmus,0- expulfuri teldy neruos re tro tendimus.intcrlm tdme ÃferetÃdtus,ddndd funt Â«e KiumnosrndulgentidiUdnonfdUdt-.omnidcnimnoÃrd dumniÃuntur pldcenttdUoqui neeferiberentur.Sed re^ iesmusdd iudiciu, et retrdHemus fujptÃ¤dm fdÃ ÃtdtÃ¨i Sf ilt;^âripÃjfe SdUuÃium dcccpimus,et fdnÃ¨ mdnifeÃus eÃ aidmexipfoopere Idbor.Vergilium quot^pdueiÃimoi die compofuiffe uerfus,dutor eflVdrus. Ordtoris qutgt; de dUd conditio eSt,itdlt;^ bdc mord et foUcitudine mit^i â¢wpero. Nam primÂ«hoc cÃ¶Ãituendu hoc obtinendueÃ¼^ **^ ^optime Ãribdmus,ceieritdte ddbitcbfuetÃ¼do,pduld tim res fefucihus oÃendet, uerbd reÃpondebunt^compo Ãilo (equttur, cunÃ¤d denies ut'm fdmiUd bene mÃitutd â¢Â» officio erunt^Summd bÂ« c eft re^citoferibendo non Ãt Â» bene feribdturtbene feribendo Ãt ut cito.Srd tum md

658 M. FAB. QVINTÂ» INST1Ã'â^^^^ mus, efferen icamus efferent is eciuos,ditosfrenis quHuÃ^quot;^'â SiX^' gt;Â«Â«Ã¯.QÂ«od non tdm mordmfdciet,quÃm coer. ddbit.l^clt;^en!mrurfuseos(iuiroburMilt;jttolt;^âquot;i' ccrint, dd infiUcan cdÃ¯umnidndifeptxndm dÃ¼i'^^ ^ââ to.Ã¯^dm (^uomodo fufficere officijs poÃit ciidlibu!} ^/â^ guUs dilionum pdrtibus infenefedt^Sunt dutÃ© ^uAu! n^ bil fit fdtif, omnid mutdre, omnid dUter dicere ^ occ^T rit, udint ; increduli quidem, amp;nbsp;de ingenioÃo P^Ã^ meriti, qui diUgentidm putdnt fdcere ÃbiÃribcndidi^ cultdtem. Nee promptum eH dicere utros pecedreum^ dius putem, quibus omnidfud pldcent, dn quibus Â«M Accidit enim ingeniofis ddoÃ¯efcentibusfrequenter,ut If boreconfumdntur, et in fdentiumuf^ defcenduntninuf bene dicendicupiditdte,CiÃ¿d de re meminimrrdjfemi'' hi lulium Secundum iOu lequdlem meum, dtlt;^ d me,ut no turn eÃ¼, fdmilidriter dmdtum mirte fdeundid utrum, in' ftnitÂ£ tdmen curie,quid effetÃbi d pdtruoÃo itHumÂ» isfuitluUus florusiÂ» eloquentidGdÃ¼idrumjq^^^i^ ibi demumexercuit edm, pfmeeps, dlioqum inter pm' cos difertus,cr dignus iUd propinquitdte. is cum Steun dumfehohe ddhuc operdtumtriÃem forti uidifet,^^ obdufta terrogduit quie edufd font is tdm ddduUd : nee HÃ' mulduit ddolefcens,tertiumidmdicmeffe exquoomni tdboremdteriieddÃribendumdeÃindtie non inueniret exordium,quo fibi non pnefens tdntum dolor,fed etM deferdtio in poÃerumÃeret.Tum Fidrut drridens,nun quid tu,mquit, melius dicere uis qudmpotesi Itife res hÃ¼betfCWUndum eH, ut quAmoptime dicdtmsÃiar.im

ORATOR. IIBER X. Â«55 hwen profAcultAtetAd profedumenm optu eÃÃudiÃ¶, non indignAtione, vt poÃmw Autem feriberc etiAm plu rA er celeriHs,non exercitAtio modo pneÃAbit, in epi AÃ ne dubio multum cd, fed etiAm rAtio,fi non refupiniÃ^s dAnlesiptedum, er cogitAtionemmurmure Agit Antes, expedAuefmus ([uid obueniAt,^uid respofcAt,e^uid per fonS deewt^quod Ãt tempus, qui iudicis Animus intuiti, bumAno eptodum modo Ad fcribendum Accefferimw. Sic nobit er initiA,Qr qn^ (equMtur nAtwA ipft prxfcribit^ OertA funt enim plerAq;, ernift conniueAmus, in ocuios incurrunt.ldeoÃ©p nee indodi,necruÃici diu quf rnt unÂ» de incipMnt,qHÃ pudendum ed mAgis,Ã difÃ:ultAtcm /x citdoÃ rinx. Non crgoputemiÂ« femper optimum effi qnod Utet^ne immutefcAmut AUatpii, Ã mbit dicendÃ¼ Â«t^ dftMr,ni/i quad non inuenimtu. rtiuerfum eft bÂ«tc eo-

MlociÃimo uohiUt, lt;y [et^uentescdlortm ac impetutn tx tmfporcfcribuntyhAnc lyludm uocAM^V.epetnnt de# SyluÃ¢s inde,o- componunt c(Â«lt;e cjfuierAnt, fed ucrbicmcndM tur (T numcrijnAnet in reint temere congeÃis iJÂ«Â« fuit ituitAsyrotinus ergo Adhibere curAm reditu erity At^ Ab initioÃc optÂ« dHcerc,Ut CdekndHW,notJ ex intÃ©gra ft briwndumÃt, AÃ¼^nxiido tlt;ttÂ«eÂ» AÃ^dux feeÃiemurjim quitw Ãre fbu cAloY Â«juim diligcntw Httlet. Sittw dppiX ret ex eo,ijÂ«od bJc feribendi negUgentiAm dAmno, quid de Ã®Dis diÃ¤4Â«di deUc^s,fenti4m. Nlt;Â«m in Ãgt;Io eiuidem, tjUAmÃbet proper Ato, d At AUquAm cogitAtionimorMt

640 M. FAB. oyiNT. INSTIT' urget^dt^i interim pudet etidm dubitdre, out rcjip^gt; Mt milt;tdre,qudfi confciumnojlrd inÃrmitdtis timo^^^â C^uo Ãt,ut non rudU tdntum etfortuitdfid impropn^ interim,dum foU eH conncÃ¤endi fermonii cupiditÃ© fÃ ÃuMt,quÂ£ nee feribentium curdin, nee dicentium igt;npâ' turn confequdntur. At idem iÃ¼e tpii excipit,Ã tdrUofi^ incertior ftribcndo,dut mertior in legendo uelut ofÃnÃtotÃ^ erit,inhibetur eurfus, dtlt;^ omnis (puÂ£ erdt concepttnx tis intentio,mord Gf interdum irdeudid excutiturtâ^^â^ altiorem ^lt;^ i^â^ dptiorem dnimi motumfequunturf^dti^ ^fr dnimum quoddmmodo eoncitdnt,quorum eH mddren^ num,torquere wtltufimul aertere Ãdtus, Gf interint lt;gt;nbsp;iurgdre:quÂ£^ Perfius notdt, eum leuiter dicendi^iigt;â^ }igniÃedt,'Kee pÃuteum,inquit,eÂ£dit,ncc demorfosÃp^ Migues. Etidm ridiculd funt,niÃ eumfoUÃoi^'^t fÂ«rÂ«S 5d ^^flt;^1Ã^â^potaiÃmian,iieM, ftcrtti^ diaandoeÃ´ Ã¤dndoperit.Ati^liberumdrbitrislocum, crqu/imduu petit, atÃ§ li. Ãff,n^filentiumÃ:ribentibus mdxime couenire mmo Â» bitduerit, no tdmen protinus dudicndi qui erduni dftij Ãmd in hoe nemord Ãyluds^ ,quod iÃ¼dcali libertdfgt;locf rumq; dmanitdi fubUmem dnimum et bedtioremÃ'âCâ^â* parent: mihi eer te iueundus hie mdgif, ^Ãuitmr^ ^ tdtor uidetureffe feeejÃti, ^dm iÃ¼d ipfd qui icu^ gt;nbsp;neec/Je eil duocent db intentione operif deÃin^i, Nf^' enimfebona fideinmultd fimulintenderedtiimustoM pocefl,0- quoeunq^ refpexit/efmit intueriquodpn^ fit urn erdt. Qudre fyludrumdmoenitdf,(g'pf^^crbcn tidflHmin(ifyinJÃirdntesrdmi{drborult;turÂ£Uoliictult;^

tintut,zrip[lt;ilaccirc^iciendilihcrtlt;!ix id fetr^hunt, utmihiremUttrepotiusuoluptMifin uidedtur cogUd^^,^^^^ ^ ^ tioHcm qMÃm mttndere.Dcmofthenes mcUui,lt;pti fe m Io ^j^^^ j^quot;^â turn ex quo Â«uHd exdudiri uox,^ ex quo Â«ibil pro^ici po^et^recondebdt, ne dhud dgere mentemcogerent ocu li.ldeoj lucubrntcf ,fdentium no^U, cr cldufum cubit-eulum, O' lumen unum uelut redos niixime tenedt, Sed cu in Ã§mni jiudiorum genere,tum in hoc prxeipue bond udlftudo, quf^ edm mdxme prlt;tfidt frugdlitds neceffd rid eft,cum tempord db ipfd rerum ndturd di e^uicte re* fedionem^ nobis idtd^in deerrimum Idborem corner-timux, cui tdmen non plus irrogdndum ed, qÂ«Ã m quoi jornno jupererit,dut deerit^Qbfidt enim diligcntiÂ£ jeri* btniietidmfitigdtio,e:Tdbunde,ÃudcetÂ»lucis Ã^dtii fÂ«^iÂ«nt, occupdtos, in nodem neeeÃitM dght Eft td* tÂ«c lucubrdtio,lt;juoties Ad e^ 'mtegri ac refedi uenimuSf optinitt [eereti genust Sed Ãlentium et Ãeceffux^et undi^ LIjcy itnitBUÃ¯jUtfunt mdxme oftduid, itd no poÃÃunt fern per cotmgereAdeo^ non ÃdtmÃ quid obÃrepet db^Ã Ã© di Codices erunt^tj- deplordndus dieSyUerum mcomodK Yffugu^dum, is- hiefdeiendus ufux, Â«t omâwqMlt;e m-pedifnt,uinc4t intentio, quiÃ totd mente 'm opus fuut ipfum direxerwjUibiJ coyÂ«m qÂ«Â« oculis uel duribw mcurfdut^ ââdlt;wimuinpfrÂ«enirt, AiÂ»Â«oÂ» Ã-equenteretidmÃor*'^^ââquot;'^'^^ tuitibÂ« co^itdtio prtÃdt,ut obuios non uidedmus, ^ itinere deeyyf ââ^j? Now eonfeepuemur idem Ã er uolue* rmuti Noncft indidgcndwcdM/jj df/idi(e,Â«dm Ã no niÃt ^(Ã^ii non nifi biUrÂ«, non niÃt alijs curis udedntes Ãw

(54X M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlf* dcitdum exiÃimMcrimus,fcmper crit propter ipui ^' bis ignofedmus, Cigdre m turbi, itmtre,conuiMp^quot; condone etidnijfdcidtfibi co^itMio ip^dfecretuW-QÃ¿quot; dlioquiÃet, cum in medio foro tot circunÃdntibudi^^^' cijs,iurgijs, fortuitis etidm cldmoriius,erit fubiticon' tinud ordtione dicendum,Ã particulds e^uds Ã©cris mtnii mils,nip m foUtudine reperirc non pojfumtis^^ppter ^â^ idem ide tdntus dmdtor fecretiOemoÃhenes, inUttore, inquo^emdximocum fono Ãu{iusidideret,meditiintt confuefeebdt condonum fremitus non expdueÃere. idd quoc^ mmordfred nihil mÃudijs pdruum eÃ,n3fHnttri fcundd,frribi optime ceris, in t^uibus Ãidlimd ell rdtio delendi, ni ft forte uifus mfrmior membrdnirum potins ufum exige t,quje ut iundnt deieÃtd crebro reUtione tpio dd int'mguntur cdldmi,mordntur mdnum,^ cogitdiois impetum p-dngunt.Relmqucndie dutem Â«lt; utroHbetge--nere centr'd udeui tdbeÃ¼ieÃn quihus liberd diijeiendiÃt excurÃo, t^dm interim pigritidm emenddÃ¼i nnguÃie fdciunt, dut certenouoruminterpofrtione prioricont fundunt. Ne Idtds quids ultrd mod u effe cerds ueliin,ex' tpertus iutienÃªÃudiofumdUoqui, pnlogoshtbuiffefer mones,quid ittos numero uerfmimmetiebdiur/i^nitm quodfrequenti ddmonitione corrig'' non potuerit, tun' tdtd codidbus cfrefubldtum. Debet udedre etiim loan in quo notÃ¨tur, que feribentibus frient extrd orditietiif id ell, ex dlijs qudm qui funt in mdnibits lod,occurrere. Irrumpunt enim optimi nonnunq frnfus, quos nei^ mÃ rereoportet^ne^diffirrfiit(Hntefr,quidfrim^^^

ORATOR. LIBER X. 645 tWfjWteriwmfniori Æ /Â»lt;e mtentos aI aUa wuentione de ^hAnt, idrog; optime (nut in depopto.

SElt;}iÂ«tÂ«r tmeniAtio,pArs jiudioru longe utiUÃmAi gt;'^lt;^enmÃnecAufAcreditume^Ãyltm non mmtu ^i^f^gt;cum delet.Uuiui Antem operis eÃ Adijcerc^delri boTjiwutdre: fedjÃtiUns in bw fmpUciust^ iudiciu ^Â«le ^fpKndA Hfl deijeiendd [unt,pr(mere nero tumentidjou [ wlidextoUcre^luxuriAntid A^rmgereÃnordindtd dige* f^rt,Ã)lutdcoponere^extiltdntid colt;:rcere,duplicii ope* ''f: mm cr ddmndnddfunt ([Uie pldcucrAnt,e^ muenien dd([ut fugerdnt. Nec dubtum efl optimum effe emen-ddfidi genus,ft Ãcripti in dli'quod tempus repondtur, ut *i fd po(l iÂ«tcrÂ«dKÂ«m,Â«dHt nowd dtg[; dUend reiedmus, He Nobij fcriptd noÃrd tdÂ«^Hdm rÃ©centes foetus ildndid tur. Sed neque hoc contingerc femper poteft, preefertim ^ât'Ã¼ori,cuiftpiusfcrÃ¯bcredd prtfentes ufus neceffe eft* Et ipftemenddtiofnemhdket,funt enim c^ui dd 0-wnid fcriptdtdnqudm uitiofdredednt, er ^udft nihil fdf fit return effec^uod primum eSl,melius exi^iment quicquid efl dliwd, idlt;^ue fdcidnt c^uoties librum m md-fusTefumpferunt ; fmiles medicis etidm integrd fecunti twÂ» Afcidit itdc[ue utcicdtricofd fint er exAnguid^er ^nei peioTi. Sit igitur dli^udndo qÂ«od pidcedt dut cer-fl quod fug^cidt 5 Ht opus polidt Ãmd, non exterdt. Temporis quoque effe debet modus, NdW cjHod Cinndt ^myrmmnouem dnnit Accepimus fcriptdm,er Vdnegy ntHftÂ» ISQCRATIS, ^uipdreiÃime,decern dniiK

Â«44 M, FAB. QVINT. iNSTlfÂ» dicunt chiorittim^dd ordtorem nihil pertinet,cUM Â«w lum erit,fi tam t^rdum fuerit duxilium,

CluÂ£fcribenddprlt;ecipuefint. CAP- ^â PI Koximum eH ut diedmus quÂ£ prÂ£cipuc feribeoii fint,Hoc exuberdntis quidem eÃ¼ aperts, ut ex^b' cemus quÂ£ fint mdteru, quÂ£ primd dut fecundd,dut i(' inceps trdÃ dndd fintindm id fdHum eA etidm primo b' bro,quo puerorum,^ fecundo, quoidmrobujiorumÃigt; dijs ordinem dedmtus,fed de quo nunc dgitur, unieco* pid zy fdcilitdS ntdxime uenidt,VerteregrÂ£cd in l^i^â ueteresnoftri ordtores optitnu iudicdhdnt. ld fe L.Cr4 fus m itlis Ciceronis de Ordtore tibris dicit fditdfie.ld Cicero fud ipfe per fond frequentiÃmepneipit: QÃ¤*^' etidm libros Pldtonis dtq; Xenophontis edidit boe gene retrdldtos. ld IÃ¼effdlÂ£pldcuit,muÃ¯tÂ£qifuntdbeofcrH ptÂ£ dd hune modum ordtiancs, ddeo Ut etidm eu Hyp^' ridis pro Phryne difficilimd Romdnis fubtibtiieconten deret,E.tmdnifefideR exercitdiionis huiuferdtiO'^ni er rerum copid GrÂ£ci dbunddnt, er plurimum drtis m eloquentidm 'mtulerunt, er hos trdnfferentibuSj uerbis uti optimis licet, omnibus enim utmur noÃris, Pigf*^'^ uero quibus mdxmeorndtur ordtio,multds dcuiriif ex cogitdndi etidm neeeÃitds quÂ£ddm eÃ¼, quid pkruifi^ * GrÂ£cis Romdnd diffentiunt. Sed er Hld ex Ldtink eon uerfio,muit urn er ipfd contulerit,Ac de edrminibus ej^ dem neminem credo dubitdrÃ¨, quÃ³ folo genere exerdl^ tionis dicitur ufus effe Sulpitius,tJdm er fubtimisl^â^' tus dttoUere ordtionÃª poteÃ, er Â»erbd poÃ«tied libsÃ¯idi^

ORATOR. LIBER X. 64s i(Â«JdcioÂ»'rfj nonpr^fumunt edniein proprie dicenii fSt fiaAidtem, fed z^ ipÃs fententijs ddijeere licet ordtorM

Â°*^^SJ^ fi^Ppyre, O' ^Ã¯fuf^ fubÃringere^ Nc$ fgo ^Â«(fjatn^ effe interpretdtionÃ« tdntÃ¼ uolo, fed cir '^.^^^f f^^f^ certdmen dt(^ Â£muldtionÃ«,lieo^i db iUis diyftitiojqMi uertere ordtiones Idt'mdi uetdnt, eptid opti WW occupdtit^f^uic^uid dUter dixerimM, ncceffe fit effe ^^^^tiui.Hdm ne^ femper eft dejperdttdunt,dli(iuid ilUs ^Â«^ didd funt melius poffe reperiri.Neq^ ddeo ieiundtn de pduperem ndturd elo^uentidm fedt^ut und de re iene Aid nifi ferne fnon pofit,nifi forte biÃrionu rnulw cir t mutus clt; Mocfj edfdem Udridre ge^tu poteÃ^ordudi minor uiSt ^tiicdtwdUcptid, pofcpiod'meddemmdteridnihil di' quot;Â»^Â«/it.Scd efo^ei^; melius,^uod muenmus, effe^neq^ P#^ft certe proximo locus.An nero ipfi non bisde fÂ£' piw de ediÃ« re dicimus,^ ifuidem cotmuds nonun^ fen dntidi^ nifi forte cotenderenobifcum pojfumus,cÃ¼ dlijs â'Â® pofjumiit.Ã¼d, fiuno tdntÃ¼ genere bene dicerctur,fdt ^'^dt eriÃimdri pnclufdm n^is d prioribus uidmy nunc Mn mnumerdbilesfunt modi, plurmiÂ£^ code uu dU' fut^Sudbreuitdti grdtid,fud copiit,dlid trifdtis uirtus, olw proprijs. Hoc ordtio reddy iUudfgurddecl'mdtd co niiidt : Ã¯pfddeni(^ utiUÃimd eSl exercitdtioni difficult ^^-Qtfid^ quod dutores mdxmi fic diligentiui cognac 1 RWur, ÃHonen'tmfcriptdledionefecurdtrdnfcurri-

t^M,fei trdildmus finguld er necejfdriÃ³ introfpicimuty lt;y ^iMUturn bdbcdnt uirtutiSy uel hoe ipfo cognofcimus.

re,fed etum noÃrd plttribus modis trAdmirÃ© proingt;igt;^ ex MuÃrid furndmus fententids qiaÃnn, f 4J$ o^^' mus i^udm numeroÃÃime, ueluti eddem cerd dUe ^^^'^ dliÂ£ formne duci folent-.Plur'mumdutempdrdrificdlt^* tisexiÃimo exfimpUdÃimd ^ud^mdterid. NiWiÂ«Â®^ multiplxi perfondrum, edufdrum, temporum, locordflt;) ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;didorum, fddorum, diuerfitdte,fdcile delitefet inj''^'

m:tds,tot fe undii^ rebus,ex quibus dUcludni dpprebiH* dds offerentibus. lUuduirtutÃ¢indiciumed,fudi^'^ f fmilibuj flux ndturd contrdddfunt, dugerepdrud, udrietdtem fimplicibus, uoluptdtem expofitis ddre, er bene Hci^ multd de pducisM hoe optime fdciÃ©t mÃiiit^iu^^h ^udsuoedri ^ItTS!^ diximus,lt;iuibus ciceroidinpriu^ ceps'mKepubUcdcxcrcerifolcbdt. His conÃniff^^' Ãrudio er conÃrmdtio fententidrumt ndm cum fÃ®t Ãf^' tentid decretum quodd^m dt^ preceptum, (lixxi de rc, idem de iudicio rei queripoteÃ. Tu loci comuiu^!, lt;P*ââ^ etidm fcriptos db ordtoribus fcimust ndm lt;iui ^^^ '^^^^ â¦ c5pofitj3c tdntu,er in nullos Ãexus recedentid copiof tri^^t rit, uti^ in Hits plures recurfus recipientibus md^n^â ddbit, erit^ in oÃ¨s cdufds grdtus, oÃ«s enim genen^bus ^uiÃionibuscoÃdtÂ» NÃ qd mtereSl,Cornelius quot;inb-f â¢ qdâcodicÃ¨ legerit,reus Ãt:dn querdmus moletur mmi' ieÃds,ft mdgiÃrdtusrogdtionefud populo ipfertc^f^^^ ritf Milo Clodiu reil Ã©ne occiderit,uenidt in iuUdu, ilt;t | oportedtne infididtorem interÃci,uel pniciofum reipub-due etidmÃ no mfidietur^ Cdto uidrtÃ¼ honeÃine trM derit Hortenfio, dn conuenidt 'ne res tdUs bono wtol 1*

ORATOR. LIBER X. ^47 perfonK iuUdtur, fd dt rebus comenditur^ Ã¯icclumA-tiones wra qwitÃ¯fj iÂ« feboUs rbetorum dicutMr, fi moio fÂ«nt id ueritMm dccommoditit, ft ordtionibÂ«; ÃmUcst non antwn dam dole feit profeSlus, funt utUiÃimgt qui irtuentioRffw er diÃpofitionem pnriter exercentÂ» jed etiam cum cA confummutus^Ac idm in foro ckrus^ iditcrenimutcj^cnitefcituelut pibulo letiore fucudidÂ» tf dÃidudeotentionum df^eritute fatigdtd, renoudtur. Qaiproptcr hiÃarite nonnunepiÃubertds in nUeptd exer cendi ÃyU purte ponendd, er dtdlogorÂ«m Iibcrtdtc gc* pirndKw. Nec edrminet^uidemluderecontrdriumfued tit, Ãcutdthlet^remiÃdquihufddm temporibus ciboru itf^M exercititionum certd neeeÃitdte, otio e:^ iucun' dioribwcpÂ»lwreÃeiuntur. (dfo^ mibi uidetur M.TmI tH! tdKtum intuUffe eloquentie lumen,quod in bos quo-^ queÃudiorum feeeÃus excurrit. Num ft nobis fold md^ terufuerit ex Utibus, neeeÃe cA deterdtur fulgor, er durefedt irticultis,zy ipfe iUe mucro ingenij quotidiMd pMgnd retanddtHr.Sfd quemudmodum forenÃbus certd minibus txercitdtos,Gr qudÃ militdntes reÃeitderepd nt bee uelut figind dicendi: Ãc ddolefcentes non debet nimium in fulfd rerum irndgine detineri,zj imnibus fi-wuIdcrK u^queddeet, ut diffeilis db bis digreÃusfit, df-fuefdeere, ne db idd, in qud prope confenuerint umbrd, ^f^diferimind, uelut quenddm folem, reformident, QiÂ°diccidiÃcetidm Portio Ldtroni, qui primus cldri nominis profeÃor fuit, trdditur, ut cum ei fummdm in ÃboUs opinionem obtinenti edufd in foro eÃet orundd^ 3s 4

648 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT* impenfipetierit,uti fuifcUidin buÃUcimtrin^^^' tur, Ud iÃ¼i calum nouumfuit, ut onmis dus doi^unM contmeriteHodc pdrictibusuiderctur. Quittitna* nis qui rdtionem inueniendi eloquendique 4 pnetpi^^ finiti 'â'^^â^ diligtnttr dccepcrit, quad non c^ injmiti o^^gt; ris,fidocerefcidnt,lt;^ exercitdtionem quoque moi^* cdmfuerit confecutus Â» ordtoremfibi dliquem, quoi ^' pud mdiores fieri folebdt^deUgdt, quern fequdtur, qu(lt;^ imiteturjiudieqs interfit qudmplurimis, er fit certdiui^ nis cui dcftindtur,frequenslfiehdtor,tum cdufiix udc^* dem quds dgi dudierit,fiylo er ipfe compondtjuel ftinu alids, uerds modo^zy utrunque trdHet, Et quoi wg'^quot; didtoribus fieriuidemtu retidrijs exercedtur, utfiduâ Â» Erutum diximui pro Kilone, melius hoc quim re fid* \ here ueteribusordtionibus,ut fecit Cefiiuscontrd ace' j ronis ddionem hdbitdin pro eodem,cumdlteriiiitpir' tem fdtis nofjenon pofjet ex fold defenfione- (^quot;^ dut idoneus erit iuuenis, quÃ¨ preceptor eoegerit mit cldmdndo qudmfimilimum effe ueritdtit er ptt ^Â°^^ âÆ mdteridf, qudrum nunc fdeiUmdo- mdxime fiuor^f' lot o lid decerpunt. Obftdt huic, quad fecundo bbropt' fui^ fi-equens turbd difcipulorum, er confuetuio (^r fium certis diebus dudienddrum,nonnihiletidmp(rl^\ fio pdtrumjnumerdntiupotius decldmdtiones quiui t?â mdntium. Sedquoddixiprimo,utdrbitror,libro,uet iUefebonuspreceptormdiore numero, quÃm fifimt' re po fit, onerdbit: er nimidm Ibqudcitdtem reeiieb ^ omnid qufi funt in controuerfid, non ut ^Ã¹idmw^

ORATOR. LIBER X. ^49 ^Kx mrfraw ndtuni diedntur.Zt ucllongiorc potiM di frum j^dtio Ãdxibit dicendi neceÃitdtem^uel mdterids di uidcre fmitteti wnd enim diligenter eÃend pUu pro derit, quim pkrÂ« iuebodtÂ«, er qiw/j degu/ldtÂ«, proÂ« pkr quod daidi t, ut nee fw loco c^uicejudm pondtw^nec illlt;ilt;Ã¿ieffmAfuntferuent[Mm legem, imienibtaÃoÂ» jculos omnium partium 'm ed c^uxÃmt diÃ¤uri congeren tibtu,lt;Ã¿u) fit, ut timentes ne fe^uentu ^erdM, priorlt;t confmddnt^

DeCogitdtione, CAP. VI, PRoxiwd Pgt;lo cogiutio en, qÂ«Â« er ipfd uires db hoc dcapit, O' PÃ witPr feriiendi Idiorem,extern* fonlcm^ fortwMm medid cÃ¿Åddm iOnefeiodnufw fretjuentiÃimi, ^Mferihere nee ubi(^^c femper fof* (nmux,cogitdtionitemporK de lociplurimum eh. Hiec pdMCK ddwoduwÂ» borw nidgndi etidm edufM compleHi* tw.H/c quotiÂ« 'mtermiffiK en fomnut ipÃs nollis te* nebr'K idiuudtur. Hiec'mtermediosrerZdnus dUejuid inutilit udewi^rtee otium pit it w.accrue uero rerum or* dmem mode, quod ipfum fÃ¼is er At, 'intrdfeipfd dif[o* mt^ed uerbd etidm copuldt, totdm^ Ã¼d contexit ord* tionemjut ei nibil prÃªter mdnum dÃ©fit. Ndm memorise quoq; plcrunqj inbdrrt fidÃ©Uia,lt;[uad nuÃ¼d feribendi fe cHritdttUxdtur, SedneddhAnefluidemuim cogitindi periwniri poteft^dut fubito,dut cito,Ndm priwumfid* enddnuitofiyloformd en,que nos etidm cogitdntes fie epiAtur,turn dÃumidm ufm pduldtimjut pAucdpr'imum topleddinw An'mo,lt;imt reddifideUter poÃ'mt,mox per

ÃÃ§o' M. FAB. oyiNT. INSTIT* mcreMtttti.timmoiicAyUt onenrifelaborittcnonp* tiAt,Atigenda ufuet excrcitdtionc tmUd contmenii (?i quÂ£ quidem tHAximA ex pdrte memorid conjidt, Ww$ mihi dUqud in mim locum difÃrendt funt^dio time ftt ucnit,ut id cui non refragetur ingeniiim,dcri jiuHo â^^ iutHdjidntum confequAtur^ut etidm que cogitirit,qtgt;i * que fcrip[crit,dtq; cdidicerit,m dicendo {idem fertiel^â Cicero certe GrAcorum Metrodorum Sceffium, CT Â£â¢Æ phyltm Rhodium^ noÃrorum 'que Hortenftum tnUdd quit cogÃ¼ducrditt, id uerbum 'm Agenda rcttili{fe Â» Sei fi forte dUquii inter dicendumeffulferit extempordit color, non fuperflitiofe excogititis denurn e^ 'mhdren dum. Neque cnim tdntum huhent curt, ut non fit diu* diK(y fortuma loeuf,cvm fiepe etidm feriptis ei qutfu titÃ nAid fient,mir dntur. idcoq^ totumbocexereititio^ nis genw itd mftituendum, ut (^digredi ex e0tamp;^^^ re m idfdcile poÃimm.'Ndm utpriiiiiim efi ioâquot;* ^^'^^ re pdrdtdm dicendi copidm z^ certdm,itd refutire tem paris munerdlonge flultiftimiMneA. QÃ¿drecoÃ¿i^^^'^ inhoc pritpdretur, ut nosfortund decipere non poÃit, adiuudre pafit. iddutem fiet memorise uiribuf, utdl'gt;' quiscoplexi dnimo CumutjfÃ¯udntfecurd, nonfioheitosGquot; reffiieiÃ¨tes, er und {fie {u{fiÃ¨fos recorditioni!,nÃ¶fini'gt;t prouidere^dUaqui uel extempordlcmtemerititentmilo^ quÃm mile cob^rentem cegititionem. Peius enint quis ritur retrorfius,quid cum iUd deÃderdmus db dbjsiueri t'mur, er ex memorid pot lus repetimus Â»quAmexnUe ierid-Plurifunt dutemfi utrunque querendem efi,qfit

MAxiniiw mo jiuiiorwm jruUut rÃ, er Â«flut pr^wiM quodddtÂ« (trnplifÂ« logt laborK, ex ten port dteendi fjcHktKr^uAtÂ« lt;jut non erit conlÃ¨cutuf^meii

fcrUxnH ficuititem potim id dltx operd cottertcUVix efitm bon e Jidet uiro conucnit (tuxtitiwn in publicÂ»Â« pol licfrt,qMod in pYfi[entiÃwgt;is quibitf^j periculw dÃ©fit, in trlire portÂ»Â« lt;td queiMnuttw decedere nif lenibui uen* tkufftitnonpofit*Stqitidfm tnnwmcrdbtlfi dccâdunfc fuiite neccfttfttcÃ®jWeldpttd ni((giÃrdtiÂ«,Â«elreprie/c(jÂ« tiitkiHdtcijt,con*Â«*â*0 dgendi.Qtidrtwn fi qudjion dico cMicunquciHnoce.wÂ»Â«Â»duium^feidmicorM^de pro# pinquoriHÂ» dlt'eitt euenerit,jlcihit'nc mtitw (^ /dlutdrem pftciHibiÂ« Hocein,PdtÂ»Â«$, f non fMccHrrdfw, pÃ©ritÂ«Â» rK,morlt;Â« or fcceffiim ctfikntitwn qMÂ£ret,dÂ»m iHd Â«er bd fibricewur, Cr meworix Infiddnt, er Â«ox de htus prxpdretur^ Q^x wero pdtitMr hoc rdtio,Â«t quifquS ft ordtor iwpdrdtiÂ« dd afux^ Quid com ddÂ«crfdrto rejpo dendia erit,fetf Ndm fepe ed qÂ«Â« opindti fMrru5,cr co trique Ãri^Ãmut .fdUtntt ,dc totdfMbttcgt;cdttfdinÂ«tdÂ» tur, itque ut gubemdtori dd BtcurfiM tempefdtum, fc dgemi Â«d uiriftutem edttfdruw rdtio mutÃ¯dd eft. QÂ«td porri multiÂ« Ãgt;lÂ« er df idiwleaio, er longd ÃudioÂ» rum Â«tÂ« fdcit,fi m-tnet eddÃ« qwe fuit inciptcni ibiÂ« difÂ» fuultxt ? pcrijjfc profe^o conftendum eH pr^tterituw

Uborem^cuifemperidem Uboundum eA,iif^ âIP^ ago ut ex tempore dicere maÃ¼t,fed ut poÃit,ii M^^ ^^ xme hoc modo confcquemur z Nota fitprimtM ii^âlt;^^ uia^e^ enim prius contingere cur[M poteji, ^uM^^â rimui quo Ãt,cr qua perueniendum â¢ Neefatis e^ non ignorare qua fint caufarum iudiciaUivM partis,iut lt;\ni ftionum ordinÃ« reÃ«le dijÃonere,qMnqMnt iÃafu/nt ftf f arque cipuaJÃ¨^quidquoi^lacoprmumfiti quidficMtiuin) ac deineeps,qua itafumt natura copulata ut mutarhtÂ» intcruelli fine cofufione non pofimt, Quifquitatitttn Â«i am difcet,ducetur ante omnia rerum ip fa ferie^bf^ ce,propter quod hominesetiam modice exercitotifio^* limetenorem in narrationibmferuant.Deniieqni'ii'*^ que loco quarant^feieni, nee circumÃgt;cÃ¤abiirt,ntio!F rentibusfe aliunde fenfibut turbabuntur,nec conpn i ex diuerfis orationem uelut faUentes, hue i^â ^^^Æ ^ infifientes.Poftremo habebunt modu et finemA'â nbsp;nbsp;^ lt;

tra diuifionÃ« nuUits poteÃ¼. Expletis profaon^^^^^^^^.^ bus qua propofuermt, peruenijfefe ad ultunnn^r'^ ent. Ethae quidemex artet ilia ttero exfiudioA^^Â°f am fermonis optimi,quemadmodum praceptum ef f paremus. Multoac fideU fiylo fio fottneturot^^ââ'^^ feriptorum colorem etiam qua fubito effuÃ ^^ dant, ut cum multa feipfeftmus, etiam multa diam â¢ Nam confuetudo cz exercitatio facilitatemmiio^'^'^t^ rit:quafipaulum intermiffafuerittno uelocitat iÂ«â^^^ do tardatur,fed ipfum coitatque ooneurrit-OJl'^'^^ ^nim opus efi naturaU quadam mobilitate anitnlt;gt; â¢* *

JiroxiMi iicimiKifiruert ulttriord poÃimM Â»femper^ noÃwm wamprouifdcr formdUcogitdtioexcipidt, uix tdmen dut niturdidut vdtio m tdm multiplex officie umdidwere (tnmum qwfdtjUt muentionii dijpofitioni^ tlocutionifirdmi uerioru/m rerum^Jtu/m hts tpidi didt, t[Uf pdnim^urus eft,Â«}Â»Â« wltrd Ã)eftdÂ»dd ftvnl:,ddhÃ¼gt;iÂ» ti uocii,pronivncidtionis^geÃws ohÃrudtionc^iwd fufÃÂ» cidt. Longe eiiiw prxceddt oportet mtentio, dc pne p

tiino prorogetur, ut donee peruenidmus ddÃnem^non miniÂ« pro/peftÂ« proceddMiw quÃm grddu/i non mterÂ» jiflcntes offinfdntes'^ hreuid iUd dt^ concifdfingultdn* tiuw modo eieÃuri fitmus.^ igitur uÃus tpitdim irrdÂ» ttoÂ«4l)iIÂ«,qH4m GrdciaT^oyop^iQilp uoednt^eptd mdnui w fcribehdo decurrit, qiw oculi totos ftmul m ledione â¢â¢'Ã¯fiÂ« ÃcxiM$ eorum Gr trdnÃtus intuentur^Gr dnteÃc lt;[uxntid uiient ^udm priord dixeriwit,qMo conÃdnt mU pjj^^j^ Ã¯dculd iHi BI [cetiK pildrtoÃ¯Â« dc uentUitorum^ut ed ([UÂ£ vÃ«tilatores; ^iffrmt ultro Â«ernre m njdnu^ credits,er lt;[Ui tuhentur decurrere. Scd bic ufus itd proderit tfiedde qtW locuti fumiWjdrj dntecefferit, ut ipfum iUud lt;ptod m fe rdiio* quot;ââ^ tiottbAetjHjrdtiottc uerfetur. Nrfm mibi ne dicere ^widemuidftHir^ Bift qui diÃpoÃite,orndte, copiofe^ di* ^t^cd ucj tumHltiidrij, nee fortuiti fermonis contextti tnirdior utiqiMBJ.qMcm iurgdntibiu etidm muiterculis [u f frpHcre u^fg ^ Quem fi cdlor dc Spiritus tulit ,Ã*et VftfrrfcniiY ât fucceffum extempordlem cojeepti curd â** i^Ãiiidfvm twite dAfwffe^ id cue ni^et/KtÃ©rd

omtorcfyUt Cicero dicit^aiebÃt.Sed ritio mÃ¤nif^Ã^ ^y nam bene concept adfeHus, (^ rÃ©centes reruw itn^S^ nes continuo impetuferuntur,qug iwnrKr.ijMinmori ÃyU refingefcunt,et dilata non reuerturdur-Vti^ ^^â^ cum infeUx iUa uerborim cauiBatio aceeÃit, cz cgt;*4â^ ad ftngula ueÃigia reÃitit,non potedi fcrri cotortmi!) fed ut optime uoctim Ãngulamm cedat eledlio,non con* timta.fed compofitaeÃ¢. QuarecapieitdaftvntdU,if putbus dixi^rerum mtagiivti^tat uocari tfovraZ/Â«?Â»â dicaumus^ onmiaq; de quibus didturi eriraut, perÃlt;gt;^gt; quaÃionesjÃjes.mctuSyhabcnda in oculis^m aÃeihu t^^ cipienda^Pehut eÃ enim ejuod difertos facit,(^ nis mo^ tis.ldeo^ imperitis quoque,fimodo fiuitaSqito^^ codtati^uerba non dÃ©funt.Turn intendÃ¨dut anitntu wif iiialiqtumremunam,fedinplures ftnulcoiUiiiti^^Â»''^ ft per aUquam redarn Hiammittamm oadohf^^ mnia qua funt in ea,circaq;,intuemur,ncn'aât'a^â^'^^^^ turn uidemus, fedufq; ad uithuumt. AdditadÃd^i^ etiampudor fiimulos:Uabet CT dicendorum expiUtti laut^mirwmqi uideri poteÃ,quodcum Ãj^fttff^i^ deat,atq^ omnes arbitras reformidet^exteporsds ^dto astditorum frequemia^ut miles concentu fgnorti/mt^* citatur.i^anqie^difficilioremcogitationemtxpriiin er expeÃ¯lit dicendineceÃitasgt; v fecundos impetus ^f get pltcÃ«di cupidoi adeÃ¨ pretium omnia j^edaiUiUt ''^ quentia quoque,quAnquAm plurimum habest in fe Â«^ ptatts^maxime tamÃ« prÃ¼fend Ãquot;'du laudit opmiafd^

^frrtwcipifwj/ldtjffl po/fecowwgcrf.ffJ ficutmco pÃ4ttortf pr/cfpimm, itd fAciUtutcm ^M0^ extempore km i pdÃ¯MK Â»^itÃ®Æ^, pikUtim perduermtw ad fumnumf qu* nee per/Ã¯ci, nee continm niÃ Â«fÂ» poteR. Cxteruwt prrweniri to itbet t utcogiUtio non uti^i melior Ãt ed^ ^tutjer fti KtiltorjCuÂ« b^nc fAdUtittmnon in pro^d modÃ³ tfclidtat? multi Imt coNpcHtijfcd ttUm m cdrwinf,Â«t Arniputer, SUonita ty Liemitu ArchiMtcreienÃ¤wm cÂ«imCicero ni cÃ, non qui.i noÃris ^Â«o^ ternporibut non er ftee* runt lt;juidlt;im boe er fdd^tt#,quod turnen ip/ton non tint probubik puto, nc^ue enim hÃ¼bet dut ufum ves, dut nt^ cf)?itlt;ttfm,^uimexbortÃ¯dK m hune j^em.qid fora prÂ« puruw, utile exemplum. Keque Â«ero tdntdmtffe un j Ãimum fdÃ¢Ã¼tdtis weltwi, ut non breue [altern tempuft quoi nuftpumfere ittrit^di td qÂ«lt; didurifumui de* f^icienidfumdmuf, lt;plt;od quidem m iudicijs de fora du* tur fempfr.Neq; enon qui/qiwm eft quiedufum quam no

' didicerit xgdt. Deeldmutorcd quofddtn pcruerfd ducit quolt;S umbitio, ut expoÃtd controuerfid, protiÂ«Â«Â« dicere ueÂ«â lint,quiÂ« etidm.quod eft in prwnw /riuoluw de feenieu, uerbumpetdntquo incipidnt. Sed turncontumeHofos in ft ridet inuieem eloquentw, er qui ÃultÃ¼ truditi wide ri uoluÂ«t,f{ulci eruditw iudieuntur.Si qui tdmen form uidsntuf nutum fubitdm feceritdgendintceÃiidtrnifniobmore quodum opat trit ingenia, er uit omnis mtendendd red bw, er m ortfentii remittendwn uliqutd ex euru Â«er-j boruWj/Ã¯feqwi utrunq; non d Abitur. 'Tdmcn er turdt tum or pronuntidtia worÂ« bubet/t Ã^ei^n dt ueluti dubt*

6^6 M. YAJi. QVINT. INSTIT* tuns ordtio, dut tdmen deliberdre, non b^fitdreimf^ mur. Hoc dum egredimur Ã¨ portu,fi nos nondum dftigt;^ tis [dtis drmdmcniK dget uentus.Heinde paitUtimj^ eimtes dptdbimus ueld,er dij^onemut rudentes, tJ gt;â^^ fieri /inus optabimus. td potiUs, ^udmfe indni uerio^ rum torrenti ddrc,qMft tempejidtibus, quo uoknt,a^r rendum. Sed non minoreÃudio continetur bdcfaculti^ q pdrdtur, Ars enim femelperceptd non rdpitur â¢ St^ lus c^uaque mtermiÃione pdulum ddmodum de celerity* te perdit,promptum hoc er in expedito poÃtimexefd tdtione fold coiuinctur.Hdc uti fie optimiMic^,ut qit^ tidie diedmus dudientibus pluribus, mdxime de quone^ fimus iudicio dtq; opmione folicitbrdruw e^ cnimuti tb fe qui/que ueredtur ; uelfoli tdmen diedmuf poMl non omnino diedmus. EÃ dud excrcitdtio cogitditUdo^ quaÃ dicattds'quemdteridsuelfilciuio,dumtdmend-dicdt'mtgt;'lt;gt;P â contrite' ipfMi,perfcqucndi,quÂ£nullonontetnporelo^Â°^^'\ do non dUud dgnnus,explicdri potefi,Gr eÃ 'm ptrtf ^ tior qudm hlt;gc proximd. Diligentius enim componimf qudm iÃd, in qua. co ntextum ordtionis mtermitterem^ in alia remur. Rurfus iUd prior plus confert, uods Ãnmrt/^ plus prior tem,oris fdcilitdtem,motum corpora,qui er ipÃi^^ xi,excitÃ¢t ordtorem,et idildtionem mdnus,p(dk fiff ^

dendum uero fempcr er uU^. Uet^ uero tam uW? diesoccupatiK^ut nihil lucrAtiu^,ut Cicero wM^* cere trAdit.operx ad [cribendum, dut dd legeniiiHgt;gt;^^ dicendum rdpi dlilt;juo momento temporif po^it Â» ^^

dem C.Clt;trbo etidm 'm tabcrmculo folcbAt bdc Â«ft exfÃ¯* citAtione dicendt.Ne td ^uidtm Ucendu/m eft, qÂ«od W dem Ciceroni plAcet^nuÃiim nojlrum uflt;Ã¿tim negligent tem e^e [ermonem, e^uicc^uid loeÃ¿tentWjubicwn^Jit ^ro fa faicet ^ortione ferfe^um. Scribendum certe nwn* qwmeflmdgw qÂ«4m ciiw mulu dicemmex temport, ttienimfauibitur pondtÂ«,Â©- witranj Hhi uerborumfa tiUteii m altum rtducctur,ficut ru^iici prox'mdx uitk ri dices Amputim, quÃ¦ ilUm in fu/mmum folum ducunt:, ut 'mfaiores penitiu defandendo firmentur, Acnefcio etn HtrwKj; cum euro, cr fadio fecermus, 'muicem profit. Kt feribendodicAmus diligc ntius,dicendo firibAmus fAd ^Â«.SertUndum ergo ipioties licebit : fi id non ddbitur, ^ogitAndumiAb utroc^; exclufi^debÃªt tAmen Anniti,ut ne qideprebrn/ÃM ordtor ,neq^litigAtor defiitutuf effenU dciitHr,Pknwi$ dutem mwlia Agentibui Accidit,ut md* ^menecc^^AriAe^Utici; 'mitid fcribdnt exterdepteedo'^ WO A^rAM^cogitAtionccomplcÃ©tdntur, fubitis ex tensââ pore Qccurrint.Ciuod feci ffeM..TuUiAmcommetttAf^i ippiÂ«lt;(fp!tret,fedferi(Â«tMr tilioruw quog;, er inuenti forte Â«t cos diSiurus epiififi compofiierdt,^^ m libros di infant cAufacmnpAdifivnt AÃeeASeruioSulpitio/uiut tres orationcj exUnt.Sed bt de quitus bquor cowmeM* *âÃ¯â^i it* fient exAdi^ut db ipfo mihi Â«i memoridm pofie* ritdtk uidciiuur compojÃ¯ti.-Ndw Ciccronic dd pr^fenj modo tepm aptfitoÃ¯ kiertui Tyro contrAxit, Qaoj Â«on idea excufo,qÂ«td Â«oÂ» probem,fed Ut fint mdgis AdmirA* *âÃ¼fÃ¯UÂ» boegenere pros fa redpio bdne breum dnnotd

tionemyliieUos'ilue qui ucl mmnu tcneintur, GT Â«i^ lââ^ wtcrimrc/jiicercftu fit. lllud quad Licifdipriecipitii^ rcripVimâ, S^^^â^^^ â^^^^i '^^^â^fcriffierimuijm fummdf fint (Ãmmi ucl in fum' rios et apitd cÃ¶fierre. Ydeit enim et difienii ne^UgM* ^mmenu' ^â^'^^PÃfidutid^o-Idcerdtdedefornidtordtionem-ip/f rios dutem ne ficribÃ©dum quidem futo quad fitmut mentorii, hic proficuturi. Udm hoc quoq^ dccidit^ut reuocet nes cot gitdtio dd iÃ¼d eldbordtd, nee findt prtefimetn fortunM experiri.Sic dnceps inter utrunque dnimus ijiiutjCdin Cr ficriptd perdit, Gr t^on quÂ£rit noui. Sed de memorii definidtiu efi proximo libre loens,nee linie pdrti fibinn gendus,quid funtdlid priusnobis dicendd. LibridecimifiniSi

A R A T A, ficutfuperiortbbro ^Â°^*netur,fdcultdte feribendi co* gitdndi^,et ex tempore etiuncdin _ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;rÂ« pofcet ordndi, proximd eSl en*

flMtjqutfÃ§ rft mco guident indicia nuxime MceffiriÃ¤^ Ndm cum fit OYMtw orAtionK MriM Oquot; multiplex,can Mftiidt^ Â«{(iM dlij, niÃfuerit Accommod Atm relut dti^ue pcrfon($,non modo nen iL'uPrdbit fAm,fed etiArn de^ru tt,t3'nmrerum m cantrArium uertet. Quid enimpro dfft effcuerlA ar htmA^o- fignificAmiA, C7 nitidA,fi^ gurÃ© etiArn numerisc^ elAlorAtA, niÃ cwm hit m e^ut in dicem duciformAriÃ©^ uoiumw^confemiAiitfSi genm fub Ime dierndi pdruw w cAuÃs, â ^ImitAtum^i grAndHu^, f limatum^ Uturn triÃihutJicneAÃ^eris,mvnAx fttpflicttgt;ut,ÃimmiÃâ fiHti concitAtis, trux At^ue Â« wUfUttm tucu^dw ddhibedÂ«

Â«nÂ«fÂ«t woÂ»ilibiw,CZ mArgAritif,Ac Â«eÃe ISgj^qux Ãmt ammentA fexmWArum, defarmentur uirii nee bAlitut triâ¢pbdis j^Ko wbilcoptdri potfft AuguÃiutJoemi* KlÂ« dccMt.Hiwtc locuMÂ» Cicero Ireuiter m tertio de Orit tore libre pcrprbigit, ne^Hc tAmen uideri poteÃ¢ e^uic* qwm omiÃ^e,dicedo non omni cAufie, nee Auditori,nco perfondjitec tempori congruerf orAtionis unum gernÂ«,

cwm dpud furnmor orAtores, bommesÃ©^ eruditiÃmos di cAt,fAtis habet partem banc Â«elaf not Are inter Agnofeen tej. Et hie Cicero aHoqucns Brutum teÃAtur effe bte ei Â«ota.ideoÃ§ brcMitÂ« Ã fe diet, ^Â«anqiwm Ãt ÃiÃuioewSt traftatuT^j Ã philofopbw Utiw. Noc inÃitutionem pro feÃiynon Ãlum fdentilut iÃA,fed etidm difcentilut trA diÂ»iiÂ«,ideo'qMepdMlÃ³ pluribiwuerlit debet baberiaeÂ» WA. QuArenotum Ãt nolitAnte omnidqaid condU* Anio,docendo, monendo iadici conuenidt, quid quaque

660 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTITÂ» . â firte orÃ¤tionii petAmm ,ltinccuctcrii,^^^^'^^^i â dut ÃÃ¤d uerbd mcipicndo^nArrAndo^ArgAmei'AAAo,^^^ Hdbimuf^nci^iic decurrent is coiuexto mtoreuf^^^ uii diuidendd er it edufd^et in pirtes fuis dig^^^^ ^'* que humile, dtque quotididnum fermonit ^âgt;'^gt;^^Â° pofitione ipfd diffblutum epilogif ddUmuffit^^ ^Â°''â^ ^ chrymds,uii opus erit miferdtioneficcdlimuf-^^'^ Â® .^ nutus omnis non tdm fud, qudm rei cui ddhibctift,Â«)^ tione conftdttnec plus refert quid dieds, q^in q^o o^'ââ Sed totum hoe dpte dicerc^on elocutionis reconÃdtjed eRciml inuetMionecommmie:^lt;iy' turn bdbent etidm uerbd momentum, quinto ^^^y^Ã§^ iusiQudrumqugeffetobferuitio,fuislocisfubin f/^^ iedmus.lÃ¼ud cÃ¼ diligemius docendum,dim cere dpte, qui non folu/m quid expedidt gt;nbsp;Ã^ deceit infj^excrit,Keeme fugit plorMtqdt^^^^^i ^^ iunUd. Kim quod decet, fere prodeil,ntq^^^â'^ .^^ gis dnimi iudiciM concilidri,dut firesin tulitydUendrifolcnt. Aliquindo tumen crbit^nl unt. Quotiesdutempugnubunt,ipfm cet quod decet. Kdm quit nefeit nibilmigi^ f^. rumdd dbfolutionem Soerdti fuiffe, quitÂ» fi^li^^ .^^ illo ittdicidligencredefenffoniSiCrordtioiio concilidffet iudicum dnmos fbi, crimen^ ipiU'O'f ,^ te redurgui/feti Verim id min'me cum decebit, lt;nbsp;^^^ que fie egity Ut qui pandm fam honoribus teÃimdturus. Miluitenimuir fdpientiÃmusqdoÂ»!^^ pere/fet ex uitdfibiperire, qu^ qfod pneterijf^â

ORATOR. LIBER XL Â«^1 ^lUrtJodb bommibui fuitemporis pirvm intt^Ã¿ciiÂ» tÂ«r,poPcroruw fe iuUdjs referMuit ireui ittrimtn* to wm ultmw fcneHutii gmnt feculorum omnium cono ffcHtiÂ«. Udqwe qiuwMM Lyfux, qui tum in iieenia *âquot;ââ prÂ«Ã4*Mij?imM4 bibebdtKr, iefenfionem iUi feriptum ohiu^(t,utiei ndluit yCumbomm ^uidemt^edpAt Ã¯iÂ«Â» lia conuenimtem iudiaffet Â« QÂ«o Â«cl folo pd* tet, Â«on pcrÃu^icnH, fed lene dice Â»di finem 'm or Ã¤tore feruinium ^cm mterim perfuidere deforme fit. NoÂ» fuit boe utile nlfolitioni, fed(^Â«od eft mAiiK}iommifu it.EtnoÃ¯ fecwndumcommwnem potiuxlo^nendi con'' futiudmem, ^wim ipfurn ueritAtis reguUm diuifione -bic Htimwr, ut ib eo quod decedt utiUtitem fepAro nuÂ« : nifi forte prior iHc AjricAnws, qÂ«t pAtriA cedere^ qwim cum Tribiwioplc. bwmiltmo contendere de 'mno^ Â»ntiifuAmdluitjnutiliterfili uidetur confuluiffe. Aut PRutiliiMjUfl cum Ulo penÃ¨ SocrAtico genere defenfio^ KB eft Â«fiWjUel cum reuocAnte en P.Sylld munere 'm exi* lio milÂ«it,qÂ«id fihi mAxime conduceret nefcielAt, Hi wÂ® ro pirwilÃ¼,quf AhieSliÃmut tj/tiÃ^ An'mm utUiA ere* dit,fi cum uirtute coferAntur, dejpiciendA iuiicAuerut, Ã¼eo^ perpettu feculoru Admir Atione cclebrdiÂ«Â«r.Nc^ Â«Â« fwMiÂ« tdmbHmilcÃ¯,Â»t qux liudimw, Â«lutilid credd# KiiÂ«.Sed boe qÂ«lt;ilfciMi$ di/crimeÂ» nroddmodw euenit. Cdteru idem ferÃ¨,ut dixi,m omni genere cAufArum z^ proderit q. dccebit. Eft dutem quod omncÃ®/t Ãmpe r^ tir uU^ perfuidere Ac dicere boneÃe, boneÃeq- fAcere ^^^%eontrA'^ nemmem wn^mm Â«Bo m loco turpiter.

lilijUt dlijsfint concedendÃ¤, dlijs non fint. Aut pro ffi* fond,tempore, loco,cdu/d, mugis de minus, udneuj^i* debeunt uideri,uel reprehendendd.Cum diedmus dutton de rebus dut dlienif,dut nofiris, diuidendd eH rMo tot rum,dMn fciumusplerdip neutro loco conuenire. Htpn mis enim omnis fut uitiofi. idiidtio efijelo^ucntiitirfUd in ordtore prxcipuc,dffÃ¨rt^ dudientibus nonfdfinf''^ mode), fed plerun^ etidm odium. Habet enim mens not fird natura fublime quiddum amp;nbsp;credium, ttr impdtitiis fuperioris. Ideo^s abiedios dut fubmittentesfe libenter alleudmustcjuia hoe facere tan^Mm maiores uidemurft quoties difeeÃit temulatio, fuccedit humanitas^At ^mfe fupramodum extolUt ,premere dedejficere creditur, nee tam fc maiorem, quam minores citteros fucere- inde guident humiliores; nam hoc uitium edlcoritm,lt;}nii^â^ cedereuolunt,nee po/fimtcoittenderc, rident fnperio* reSjimprobdnt bonos.Plerunque uero deprehendss art rogantiumfadacem de fe opmionem,fed in neris quaff fitfficitconfcientia.Reprehenfusedlinhdcpdrtenonme diocriter Cicero, qudn^ is quidem rerum dfegefidmÂ»* maior,^ eloquÃ¨titefuit in orationibus utif idHdtor.Ac plemn^ illudquoque non fine aliqua rationefedt-Ant mimtuebatureos,quibuscratufusddiutoribusinoppri gt;

rum ^uaegerutin eo/tfulatu /requÃªscomemonitiafof* fit uidert non glorite mii^if,^Â»4m defeÂ»fionid4ttlgt; iilt;^

^Uf fKÃ®^m ({uiiem cum plcniÃmim diucr^in pdrUt'^iuo MtK conecderet, pbi nwncnnm m igendo mmodice dr-Â» togMit, lÃ¼ttÂ« fwnt enm: Siquid eft in me mgenij iudi^ ces,lt;[uoiÃeiKio qÂ«4m Ãt exigmm^cri N^m quommiw ingenio fo^nm ^ÃulÃdio mihi diUgeiUiim compdnw^ QÂ«!Â«cti4m cornu Q^Mili-jm de uccufutorc m verÂ» yem conÃituendo,c[Mmuis muhueÃÃet 'm hoc qwoq; mo* mcntijittcY id ugendum mugis idoncus ueniretydicendi tiwn fdcuUitem mugis iÃ¼i detruxit, c^uum urroguuit Ãt hijÃq^nottconÃâcutum ,Ãcd omniufecijj'eKtpo^et cum conÃlt;[ui, dixit. Ir epiÃolw aliqiMudo fumHUriter upui dmicos,nonnwitlt;{dim 'm diulogis, uUenutumen perÃoni, Â«cruw de cloqueKtÃ¼ jdi dicit, Et uperte turnen gloriu* Yi^neÃio un Ãt mugis toleruhiic^ nel ipÃu uitij huiiuÃm* plicitutc.qHim 1114 iudutionc pcrucr[d, Ãi uhimduns opi Igt;iÂ«jp4Â«pcrem fe neget,nohÃ¼is ohÃurumyt^ potens inÂ« |iriÂ«Mn,qMim Ã Ãe diÃertus mpcritum plunÃ¨ z^ mfunic nocct.AmiitioÃÃmihm gloriundi genus eiietidm deri* dere.Ab dlijs ergo luudemur. N4m ipÃos{utriemoÃhe^ ttej (lit) crubcjcere etidm cum uh dlijs Uuddmur, deat, Keq; hoc non aliqudndo de rebiM 4 fe geÃis ordtori eÃe dicendum, ÃuM cidem riemoÃheni pro Cte/ipbonte, quod Urnen itu emenduwt, utneeeÃitdtemid fdeiendi oÃenderct^muididniq; omnem wt cum rfgcrerct,qui boc P Â«'ginct.Et M.TwHitM fuepe dicit de oppreÃu coniu^ rdtione CdtibnÃ¦jfed modo id uirtuti Ãcndtus,mod() proÂ» uidemiitdtorum 'mmortutium dÃigndt^ plenmcÃ¿iccon hu inimicos utq; oBtreftdtores plw wendiedt fibi.ErduÃ©

6(Ã4 Â«â¢ F4B. QVINT. INSTIT. cnimtucndÃ¤ cimi obifcereiMur.m cÃ¤rminibu^ utmim ^

ilium Ã quo m concilium deorum aduocaturjOquot; Miners Mm qua earn artet edocuit,qute fibi ide fecutus quadd:Â« Grtecoram exempla permiferat. Ver urn eloquema ut i indecoraiÃ¤Hatio^/icnonnunquamconccdendÃ¤/idutii Æ edi. Nam quit reprehendat hteef C^uid putemfeonmÂ» , ptum ne met'non uideo nee in uita, nee mgratia, mein rebut geflit, nee m hac mea mediocritate ingeni/, quid de/^icerepoÃit Aittoniut. Et paulopoÃ¼apertiiu t agt;.n decertare mecum uoluitcontentionc dicendit' Hoequid â dem beneficium eU. Quid enm pleniutfquiduberim, quimmihipromecr contra Antonium dieere:'airre^ gantes er ilU, quife iudica/fiedecaufa, nee allier fu* turosfuifieproponunt. Nam er inuiti indicÃ©s audiiuit Æ pr^fumentem partes fias, nee hoe or aten com inhere i, inter aduerfarios,quod Pythagone inter difcipnloscoit tigit^poteil: lpfedixit^Sedifiudmagis minus'ne mdoÂ» fum efiproperfonis diceneium.Definditurenlin ^ tenus, letate, dignate, autoritate, qut tarnen uix inudo ! tanta fuerint,ut non hoeaffirmationisgenustÃ©persndK j fita!iquatnodcratione,fieutomniainquibuipmroi'gt;m ^rgumÃ©tum exfiipjÃ³ petct,quodfiiiff'ettumidiiii,^^ minis loco eÃe negafiet Cicero,equitis Romam c/fi^bs ^fi defimdente. Atidefeeit hoe etiamfauorabilegt;rââ'' lungedo citm iudicibus dignitatemfuiim, Equitis ibKÂ»^

RofMini (jj'eÃ.lium, ermmii loco poni abiceufdtoribu^, nc^j bw iuiicMtibw5 o!portuit,ncc defenientibui nobii. Impudcnj, tumuliuoli, incundi dÃ¼io omnibtu indeco-n^^edut qiiifij letÃ¼CjdignittitCjUjupriecedit, rÃ©agis in cd TcprcbendfrtdiM. VidfM Mtem rixAtores quofddw, neÃ§ iudicum reuerentiA^nce^ Agendi more de modo con tinf ri, Ex quo ipfo mentis bdbitÂ» minifejium fit,tAm 'm fufeifiedis, quim in Agenda cAuÃs mbit pen/j bdbere. prs fe fcrt Profertenimmoresplerwnqj or4tto,crlt;tniwt fecretA detegit. Nee Ãne cah^a Gr^et prodidcrunt, ut uiudt, quenq; eMm dicere,bÂ«miliord ills Â«itid, fnnumffA Aduh tio, A^ji^AtA [currilitAs 'm rebus Ac Â«erbis pdrum mode Ãu de pudieis Mtlw pudor, in omni negotio ncgledd dU-toritiÂ«.duie ferÃ¨deeiduntbiSjqutnimium dut bidndtâ â 1 ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;* * nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;- nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;diculi efle uo

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;duddx,ct pr^eeultum, fenibus conuenerit,qudm prelum, 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;C mite, crlimdtum, 27 qudle inteHigi uultCieero etiS \ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cum dicit ordtionem fudm eoepijje edtiefeere ,peut ueÃi-' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;blÂ« quoq; non purpurd eoeeoq; fulgcntibus iHd lt;nbsp;tds fd-tis dpufit.lrttuucnibus ej uberiord pdulo,cr pene pcÂ»

ritiwiwmdturdinddolefccntibuj ereditur, SimpUciord militdÃ¯ejdcernt.PbiloiopbidmexprofelJo (ut quid* fd dunt) o(lcntdntibu$,pdrum deeori funt plcriq; ordtiow Â«TndWJjWdxiwe^ ex dÃeftibusjqwos tUi uitid dicunt*

Verbtt lt;iuoiiuecxciuÃ¯fttiora,0âcoifipâgt;fi^lt;^^^^^^^â^^^ Ãi propofito diuerfÃ¤, NoÂ« enim folum tlU lietiorii,^^^^ Ã Cicerone dicuntunSaxd at que foUtudmes uod rej^on dent,fed edÃ¤m iÃ¼d qudnqudplend fdnguinif, Voscniin idin Albdni tumuli,dtq; luci,uos mqud implora itciue d^ Ãor,uos^ Albdnorumobrutte drf,fdcrdru PopultRai facile er tcqudler^non conuenidnt bdrbÂ£ iÃ¼i dtque tnjld tilt;e,At uir ciuilis ucrc^ fapiens, qui fe non otiofis dij^^ tdtionibus, fed ddminiÃrdtioni RdpubliciedediderUA qudlongiÃimciÃi qui philofophi uocdntur,recefferunti omnid qult;e dd efficiendum ordtione quad propofucrit Â«dient, libenter ddhibebit, cum prius quad boneÃumfti, eÃieere in dnimo Ãio conÃituerit. EÃ quad principes dccedt, dUÃ non concefferift Imperdtarum de triumpbd Hum Ãpdratd cil dUqud ex pdrte rdtio eloquentie,feut Pompeis dbunde difertui rerum fudrum ndrrdtor, lt;7 hicquibeÃ¼ociuili fe interfecit Cdto, eloquem fendtor fuit. Idem diÃ¤um flt;epem dUo liberum, in dlioÃriofum, in dUo fuperbum eil,Verbd dduerfm Agdmenmoneind TherÃte hdbitd regentur: dd iHd Diomedi/di 'ue cuipd ri,mdgnum dnimim ferre prie fe uidebuntur: Ego te,in quit, confulem putem L, Crdflu Philippo,cum tu me na pÃ»tes fendtorem câ Vox honeÃiÃimic libertdtis, non td' men ferres quencunque dicentem. Hegdt fe mdgni fut' re aliquis poÃ«tdrum,utrum Clt;efdrdterdndlbu{hogt;no fit,mfdnid. Verte, ut idem Ciefdr de illo dixcrit, drro' gdntid cA. Mdior in per fonts obfrudtio cA dpud comi (ââf iregicos^, Multis enim utuntur,^ udrijs. Ediem

^ (OYum qui outioncs dijs fcrMMt,fuit Viltio,i!:y ie Ã¤twuntium eft. Non mim temper wt Aiuocitiyfed pkÂ« mq; utlin'gdtorefdi'ciwuj. Vernmctwnjmbwcdu/ir, ^KtbiÂ« iidwocdniMr, rddem diffÃ©rente diligenter eft eu' jlodiendd. Vtwwr enirnjiciioneperfondrum, z^ uelut ore dlieno lotjuftmir, dimdi^ fÂ«nt bw qutbiw uocem dC' conmoddmusffui mores. Aliter eniw P^Clodins, dUter Appius CecM^dliter CxciUdnusiUc,aliter TerentiaÂ» nus pater Jingitur. Quid aÃgt;friusliftorc Ver ris i Vt adeas, tantum dab is. Quid fortius ido^ Cuius inter ipp uerberum fupplicia una uox audicbatur,ciuis Romanus fum. Quam dignÂ« Milonw wi peroratione ipfa uoces co Â«iTo,qÂ»i proRcpublicafeditiofum einem totics compc-feuifjet^ qitiq/mfidias uirtute ptperafjet; Oenquenon modi quoi in caufa,totidem in profopopocia funt uarie tatcs,fed boe etiam plurcs, quod in bis puerorum, fami nirum, pupittorum, mutarum etiam rcrum a^irnuUmus lt;3tftu5,qMibus omnibus debetur fuus decor, Radem in bi5proquibu$agcmus,obftâruanda funt. Aliter enim' pro alio kpe dicendum eft, ut quifq; boneÃas, bumilis, inuidiofus^fduorabilis erit^adiefta propoptorumtquo-Â«lutiO- anteaftdc uitÂ« dij^rentia, lucundiÃima uero in oratorebumanitas, facilitas, modcratio,bcneuolett-tgt;*gt; Sed ilUquoq;diucrfabonumuirumdeccnt,malos Â®dijfe,publicauicecommoueri,ultumirefccleÃ¯a CT inÂ« iurias, er ou ut in initio dixi,boncjla, Nee tatum quis, C pro quoted etia apud quÃ« dicas^ntcreÃ. Ã®aeit enim at fortuna difcrimÃ«,et potejlas,ncc cade apud principe^

tantum Mdgifirlt;itutn,fendtoretn,prâUÃ¤tu tdmen liberum rdih e^l,nec eodem fono publier iudicitt, er drbitrorum difee ptÃ¤tionet Ã¤guntur.^^X ut orMÃ« pro cupitefolicitudo de cedt, e^curd^er omnet dd dmpUftcdddm ordtioitÃ¨ qMÃ gt;ndchmg,itd m pdruis rebut iudieijs^i udnd finteddcmgt; Ridedtur^ meritÃ³ quidpud difeeptdtorÃ« de re leuiÃi* md/Ãªdens dtÃ«iuruiutdturilld CicerottisconfeÃione, no f quanta ^â^â^^^â*^^^^Â°'fâlt;âueri,/ÃªdetM corporeip/operhorre feere. Quisuerottefcidt quindliuddicendigenuspO' f uita fedtgrduitds Ãndtorid^dHud durd populdrisfeumetii fngulis iudicdntibus,non idem dpud gr duet uiros,quoi leuiorer,non idem dpud cruditum,quod miHtdremderU flicum, deceut, ftq^nonnunq femmittenddcr eStrdheu dd ordtto,ne iudex edm uel intedigerejUel edperenSpof fit. Tempus quoqi de locus egentobferudtioneproprid. Ndm er tempus turn lÂ£tum,tum trifte, turn liberum, turn duguftumedl. Atqui dd hÂ£c omnid componedusordtor, Cr loco publico priudtoue ne, celebridnfecreto,dlicnd ciuitdte un tud, in edftris deniq;, dnforo dieds, mtcreH plurimum,defiidm quic^ formdm,et proprium qucddin modum eloquent^ pofiit. Cum etidm in cÂ£teris dHibuf uitÂ£ non idem in foro, curid, edmpo, thedtro, domifie re conuenidt, er plerdq; quÂ£ ndturd nonfunt reprehend dendd,dtq; idea interim fint necefidrid,dlibiqudmmos pcrmiferit,turpid hubeuntur. Illud idmdiximus,quMo plus nitoris er cultus dcmonfirdtiuÂ£mdteriÂ£,ut dd de' (edldtionem dudientium compofitÂ£,q quÂ£ fintiuodu ^eontentionCffiidfiriiciudicidles^ permittunt, Hot

Idhwc ddijetrndu, dli^MdS etum quse funt cgregia iicen di MirtMtÂ«,qK0 mbiJM deceMt/ffid conditions cAufdru^ An ([Mli^uA tulerit rcum in difcrmine edpUKi pnei^ue qui apud uiclore et principe,pro feipfe diedt, freeptenti trdn^itiotte^fidis o' repetitis ex uetu^dte uerbii,com pofitione cpie Ãt mdxime d mdgdri uÃuremotd,decurri tibuspiriodis,^lxtiÃmKiocK ÃentemiÃq; dicentem? Honperidnt h^c omnidneeeÃÃdriÃ¼ pericUtdnti folici' tudinis colorent,petendumepetidm^nnocentibuimiÃe-f ricordii duxilium,Comouedtur'ne c^uifcpid eiut fortund ([utmtumidutn^dc fui idadntÃ©, et dmbitioÃum inÃitorem Inftitor dÃ¶' HoquÃ«tiie m dneipiti forte uidedtf nonfÃ©mo oderit reum ifâciÂ«ro^^ Ufrbd dKcKpdntcmjCZ Â«tnxiÂ« de fdmd ingenij, et cui effe Luianus Cu diferto u.icft.QÃ¯(od mire lÃ¼iCttlius m defenÃone edufg duct.^Jin f[Mreu5deuifuit,copreloendiffemibiuidetun Necui guam uena-Â«fÃrMm,lt;(tg; etidm omnium, ^ui dd rem dgÃªddm djfunt, ^7aa^**â mÃ©s,dut uultiM moleÃior,dut uox 'mmoderdtior dUc^ud, fertur.

Â«Mt dcÂ«iq;,qKod nimiu eUpdddntior geÃus fuiffe uided tur* Atqui funt ejuidd dHiones iÂ« fdtiffd{lione,deprecd tione, confeÃione poÃtÂ£, Sententiolis'ne Ãendum erit^ fpipl)oncm,(td, dUt enthymemdtd exordbuntfnon quic* quidwerK ddijcieturdffÃ¨ilAusomnes eorum dilurt ub tes, er miÃrdtionefecuritdte IdXdiit ? Age ft de morte Ã''j [Â«.Hfl miurid (qÂ«Â« morte Ãt grduior'idicendu pdtri fuf rit,4Â«t in ndrrdndo grdtidiUdm expoÃtionis^cphe co hugetfermone puro Ã¼q; ditucido, quxret breuiter deÃt gniÃednter ordinÃ¨ rei protuliffe contentÃ¢t, dut drgumÃ« u diaHcef in digitos, lt;7 propo/itionum de partitionum

B nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;670 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTlT.

H nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;aptabit kporem Æ er ut pkrun^i in hoc gencre moris

W nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;esi,intentione omni remijja kn^uMurfQÃ¿Ã© fu^mt inte

E nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;rim dolor iÃe^ ubihichrymx fubfiiteruntf unde fein ne

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dium tÃ¤m fecurd objeruntio artium mi ferity bSon ab cx'

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ordio uf^i dd nltimam uoeem continuum quid a gemtus,

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;er idem triflitiÂ£ nultiu feruabiturd fiqtudem uolet io'

1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;lorem funm etia in audientes trdti/fundere,quÃ«fufqui

â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;remiferit,inanimumiudicdntiumnonreducet. .:iued

prxcipucdccldmdntibux (neg; enim mepanitet ddboe Â« nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;gmg; opm meum,e:y curdfufeeptoru femelddolcfcentin

rcjficcre) cuflodiendue^l, quo plures infchokfingnn' tur d^dluf,quos non ut dduocdti,fed ut pdÃifubinui-Cum etiam hoc genuifimuldri litium foledt,eumiuiinor tk dfendtu quidam, uel dliqudmmdgndin infeUcitatenfj uel etiam pcenitentiam petunt,in quibm non fohon edit' l-perCaafie tdre,quod uitiu peruaft, dutldfciuire,fcd/iedTgunc tdriquidemnifmixtk, er quidemitd^tinipfdptolgt;^' tionemdgiseminedntjdffÃ¨Ã©iibufdecet, NdmqnUnter'

Aceufitor ^â^^^^^ â^ agenda dolorem potefl, uideturpoffe etiant tngJeonÃ d^po't^re.Nefcio tarnen an huius,de quotoqui)iiur,deeo denter de en rk euflodid maxime circa eos,contra quosdiciÂ»iiiigt; f^f ^fteffÃ©rtart tuinanda/it^ Nam fine dubio in omnibuefatim aceufdtia Seneca. Qui nibui hoc agendum eil, tie ad coi libenter defcendi/feuk iidad^d^gra ^^^ttit^iquot;* ie^fo^t fâihi Hlud CdfigScuerinon medkeriter uateadniodn diJplicettDg boniuiuo, er quo me uiucreiuuet, A firent lummamb'^^'quot;^^âemuideo. Nonenimiuftaexcaufauelneccfiarid omncmfaci i^ideripotefipo/lulaffeeumjfcdquadamaceu/ambaelu leeuitabit, pf^(f^ PrÃªter boet,wen^qu^d cHcem/fmiie,ftfitl.'i^

noiwtionÃ« quidum eduffi iefider At.Quipr of ter f^' qui curdtionÃ¨ bonorum fdtrit fojiuidlit, dole At dut UA lcfH(Iine,cr cjudmlibft grduidfiUo pAter obiedurus mi' ferrimA [Ai o^enddt ejfe hdne ipfdm neceÃitAte,nec hoc fdtheit modo Herbis, fed toto colore dilionis, ut id eum nondicere modÃ³,fed etiA uere dicer e Apfdredt. Ncc cau fdntipupiUo ftc tutor irdfedtur umc[UA, ut nÃ¶ remAncAnt dworis ueÃigidyt^T fderd qÂ«Â«edÃ¯ pdtrÂ« dus memorid. iS qÂ«o modo contrd dbdiedntÃ«pAtrem.querentÃ« uxoremj *gt cAufdm oporteret,in Ubro.jut Arbitror,feftim o dixi, Quindo etii dduoedti uoce uti deceret, e^uArtus liber in f^Mproamij prtceptd funt continet. E^c (y inuerbis f[d!deccdt,dut turpe fit,nemÃ¯ni dubiu dl. vnum idm igi tÂ«r bme loco, ^dâcA fdnÃ¨ fumme difficultdlis^ddijciendlt wdetury([uibus modis ed efse funt ndturd pdrum fpecio* Kqu^gj non dicere,fi utrumlibet effet liberum^mdluiffe musjton tdmen fint indecord dicentibut. duid Afperio-remhAberefrontem potef,dut quid Aures hominum md* gw i'fÃ)uunf,quÃm eu ekfUofli] 'lu dduoedtis in mdtre pcronutdum? Abqwindo tdmen neceffe dl, ut in eduft CImcntij Hdbitii Sed Â«on femper iUd uid ^ud contrd Sd-^ firn Cicero ufusdl,non cjuid nS iÃ¼e optime,fed qniÃ¤ phi Ã¯tMtumÃ¯ffcrtjqÂ«4 in re, es- ^uomodo laddt. Udep iHd cu ConfiliÃ¼ CL Ãbj cdput piUm impuondret,fortiter fuit repeUendd. Â«ronis in ad UMO Mmen^dxfoUfupererdt,diuineCicero feruduit. ipcontraint PrimÂ« ne obliuifceretur rcucrÃ«tiÂ£,lt;lUÂ£ pdrÃ«tibus deba *'^Â®â¢â tMr;dc(ndc Â«t repetitis dltius editfts dUigetiÃime, ofÃ«de â^,| id ^derdt in mdtre didww^ non oportcret modÃ¼

672 M. FAB. QVINTÂ« INSTlT-fieri,fed etiUnecejfeeffet, Prima^ hiecfxfofitiop^i qunnq id pr^ffntem qu^fionÃ¨ nihil pertinebiit, lt;Â«1Â«* caufi difficili Atlt;^ perplcxa,, nihil prim wtueniufi c^^* didit,^ quid deceret.Pecititiii^ nomen pmniis nenr lio inuidiofurnffed ipfi in quÃ dicebiitur-Potejl MWfÂ«''quot; qudndo mater e:x in re leuiorc,Ã¤ut minus infefa cetfir liu flare,tu lenior atq; flummiÃior decebit oratio. N^ ^ fatiffaciedo,aut noflram mmuemus inuidia, aut etian wj diuerfumeamtranffercmus, er ft grMiter doleref^a palam fuerit,credetur abeffe ab co culpa, fietq; uitroeit ferabiUs.Auerterequoq; in alioscrimendecet,utfan* dcaliquoruconcita credatur,cr omnia nos paffuros,ia hil affere di(iuros,tcflandu ut etiafinon poffumt^ i^^^ , conuiciari,nolle uideamur. Etiam fi quid obijeiedu ent, officium ell patroni,ut id filio inuito,fed fide cogentefa i- ducatur ^^^^ ^ credatur. It a poterit uterqs laudari,(iuoi de mat Hoc eft cum tre dixi,de utroq; parente accipiendudl.liant inter f a folutus iegigt; trÃ¨s etiam filiosq;,cum interueniffet cmanÃ¤patio^tigaf quafiatknus ^â'âfâ^^Â°' ^^ ^j^ i^Â°^ propmquitatibut cufiod.iet!dMi fiericepit. esl,utinuiti, (yneceffario, e^parceiudieemurdixiffe, ^^6110^^11^ *^ââ^^ â^^^ ââ^ minus, ut cuiq; pfloof debetur renerentia. diu in parfis Eddi pro libertis aduerfus patronos obferuantii, O' nt contraVum^ f^^^^P^^^ ^^P^^dlar, nuq decebit fic aduerfus tales age aÃ¢iorÃ« in* re perfonas, quo modo contra nos agi ab hominibus con tendit. ditionisciufdeiniquo animo tuliffcmus. Praflaturhoc aliquado etia dignitatibus,ut libertdtis noflrt ratio rd datur, ne quis nos aut pÃ©tulantes in ladendis his, out f* tiam ambitiofos putet.ltaqi Cicero quanq erat in CotU

gMKi^ime iiÃ¼tirw,nc(^ nUtcr Agi P.Oppij cau[a pote' ntylongAtAmen prtfAÃone excu^AuÃ¹ offidj fuinteeÃi Utfm.AltÃ§(Â«dndo etiion Ã¯nftrioYihm.pYdicipuc!^ Aiole' fantulif pircere Aut meieri iecettVtitur loAc moder AAâ tione Cicero pro CeeUo contrA AtrAemu^ut eum non mi^ mice corripere.fed pene pAtrii menere uideAtur. Ndm U itmenii (^ nÃ³biUf, C Â«oÂ» miuÃo dolore uenerAt Ai iiccMpRdM.Srd iÂ« bw ejuidem m quihut ucl iudici,uel etH Afi^ÃªtHus rAtio noÃrÂ£ moderAtiÃ³i^ proiAri ielet,mi nor efl IdtorjtUtc pitÂ« difficultAtif^uli ipfos contrA epeos offenfionii iicimuspteremuroffÃ¨ndere.'DuiefmulluiufmodipfonAt metusquo' Ciccronipro lÃurxnAdicentiolfliteruntylH, CAtonK g^ndus.'quot;^'^** Sfruij^ Sulpitij, ^w^m decenter tAmÃ© Sulpitio cu omnes (oncefiffet uirtutes ,fcientiAm petendi confuÃAtus Aie' niit. c^uidenimAliudelfetcpto fcuiÃumhomonolilit, O' iurn AntifiesmAgKferret^Vt ucro rAtionem defen* /loDK ÆÂ«Â« reddidit, cimfe Ãuduiffe petitioni Sulpitij co twEonorem Mwr^nx, non idem delerc AceufAtioni con trAcdpMt,Heeret^ QuAWmoUiAutemArticulatrAilA* uit CAtonemteuiM nAturAmfummÃ¨ Admir Atm, noipÃut uitio,fed Stoicg feda^ cjuilufiAm in relut fA^Am durio rem uidf riuolelAtput inter cos nonforenfern conientioA nem,ffd PudiofAm difputAtionÃ¨ crederes incidiffe, HÃ¤c f ft pÃ¯offftÃ³ rAtio,o- certiÃimÃ pneceptorum genutjH' liui uiti olferuAtio, ut cum Aliejuid detrAlere fduA graft'd ueyt,concedAt aUa ommAfm boe folo ucl minus peri' turn, j Â« ceteris,AdieSiA,fi poterit Ãeri,etiAm cAufA cur itAftpcel pAulo pertinAciorÃªptel credulumjud iritÃ, ucl

Â«74 ^- FAB. QVINT. INSTIL, mpulfutÂ» ab etUjf.lioc ilUs comune rentediu (ÃÃ lt;Â« ^^^^ dHioncgquiliter dppdreatnonhonormodÃ³,[ed cMiÂ» chdritdijpratcred cdufd fit nabis wÃdficdtcendi,nÂ«l^ ks difficUP * '^ gt;^Â°lt;^lt;^tdtÃ¨ tdntu fdcidiWK, fed etH ncceffdrio. Wt' mÃ¼ effe pnta fint db hoc,fcd fddUuStCUm hominfidut dHoqui turfiidÂ«gt; laudatun?^^â^ '^^^^ i^itiforfiqu^ddmfdAd Iduddnddfunt. CKd rum. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;enim rent ipfdin prabdre in qudlicuiji per fond. Ult;*'^

cero pro Gdbinio, er PtVdtinio inimicifimisinte^P hominibus,eyinqnos ordtioncs ctUfiripferdt. VerinÂ» edufd iujld fit fdtcndo,non fe de ingenij fdmdfed defi^ ci eÃe folidtÃ. DiffidUor enim rdtio m iudido CliiÃ«iidlin fuit,cu Sednundru neeeÃe hdberet dicere nocentÃª,cliid egerdt edufimtVerÃ¼ itlud clcgdtttiÃme, earn eoru Â» Ãâ* bus ipfe product as eÃet preces,tunt etidm ddolefientdiÂ» fudm excufdt detrdkurus dUoqui plus dutoritdisgt;fiÂ» cMfiprdfirtimfificdd, fe eum eÃe qui temerem^^^^^ reos fifdperetfidteretur^Apud indicÃ© nero, qd id^t^ pter dUenum eSmodu in cdufd qud fufceperimuÃ¯,^^fi'*Â» ut perfuddendi drdud rdtiofid dicÃ©di expÃ©ditif im^-^^' dutidenim iufiitiÂ£eittt,no edufe^ nihil nas timcrefnÂ»Â»^ bimus. Ipfe erit glorid infidndus,ut tdUtoclirior fiÂ»^'* offenderif fit fides,dc religio in pronunddndOj quduto mintit Â«Â« oÃinfietUel utilitdti fix indulferit. Hoemodo (7 lt;lt;?** cos d quibus dppelldtu erit (fifartÃ¨ dd eofdem remitted tur) ddqeiendd rdtio^uel neeeÃitdtis dlicuiuf,fi id c^r ecdit,uel errord^uel fufiidonis.TutiÃimu ergo pofwic tilt;e confeÃio, er futifiudio culpa, perducendus^Â»'Â»^* modo index dd ira pudorem^Accidit etidin nonnnnqÂ»*i

Wn if m cMMpm de qM4 pronwcwwÃ¯jWt co^olcdt itcrum turn iÃÂ«d (^uidimcomunfjdpud aliimt noÃ¯ iudiccm dtj^u t^turoi de iÃ¼ius fententid non fuiÃe.f^etji fKim cmÃ«drfri Â«b dlio q ipfo fdx eÃe. C/teru ex cdufdut ^Â«f^ permit* tet.dHt ignordtd ^Â«lt;edlt;tm,lt;tMt defniÃe tc^es,dut qÂ«od ti midiÃme,z^ ft mbil dUud pidnÃ¨ fuerit,dicendu eÃ¼,pd' tronosnon (niÃfcciÃe. Succurret etu Ã npud dlios iudi ees Agetur,utin fecundd aÃertionc, dut in CentumuirdU lut tudicijt dÂ«pl(cilÂ«Ã® pdrte uidd, detÃ©tius erit ^Moties cotigerit ftrudreiudicÃ¼pudore^ de lÃ¿tdreIdtiut in pro btionum loco di/tu fH-Potejl eue nire,Â«t in dUÃ repre-Ifndenddfmt,lt;[nt ipÃÃecerimus,ut dijcit Tulero Q*. Ligdrio,quod in Afried fuerit,T.tdniiitus e^uidd ddmnd tirfcMpcTd)id(f dignitdtis gntid^reos dufdemcriminis dfiulcrunt, Â«t in fcholis luxuridntem pdtrem luxurious â¢pR iuwrnit deeuÃdt. Id ^ decenter Ãeri poÃit, et^uident Â«3 inuenio, niÃ dliquid reperidtur quo interÃt per fond, *iigt;ii,tempusjcduÃd^locus, dnimus.âTÃ¹bero iuuenÃ«frpd' tri blt;Rj?f,ilJM 4 femtu miÃum no dd ieUu,frd dd frumÃ© turn coeniftidu dit, ut primulicuerit 4 pdrtiius recefr aut ut pri* Rj^^jLigdriMft per [euer Ã¤Ãe,et no pro Cn. Popeio,intcr âââquot;* ^uÃ© C Ct^rÃ¨ dignitdtis fuerit cottntio,cu [Aud Hter$ rcpublcÃ¯ uellet, pd pro iuld dteÃ Afrif inimieiÃiKK po puloRoPftijJf. CdterumuelfdciUmueUiiiidlicnicul Color^du P^'^ecuÃxe,u'hifdterislud. 'Veruididin indiciecli,no i^'âÂ®^ nafta ^lioTis.qjiodÃinuUdcontingitexcuÃdtiOtÃoldcoiorcttt ^3^5 ponft ^dictpernitentid. ?oteÃrnimuiderifdlieetneddtus,qui ââ* aligdcffi wodiumeorum,in quilui errduerdt,ipfeconuerfus eft. oradonÂ«.quot;

Sunt enim quidam, qui hoc natur a ipU rd nogt;f mitet^^ faciunt,ut cum pater ex meretrice natum,quod mtt mc retriceminmatrimonium, abdicate Scholc^ieamaierib fed non qua non poÃit accidere.Uic igiturtmdtinoU' lt;nbsp;formitcr dicet.uel quad omniu fit uotum parentu,ut lt;gt;* neftiores qfmt ipÃ liberos habeant. tiarnty fUi ^ meretrix earn mater pudica ejfe uoluiffetSel qi^^^^ milior ipÃfuerit (licet enim hoc dicere) uel quoi w hierit patrem qui moneret, quin eo minus fcieniup'^ fuijfe,ne renouaret domus pudorÃ¨,i!^ exprobrard^*^ tri nuptias,matri prioris uita necefitatÃ«,nedeni^^lâ quandafuis quoq; fubindeliberis daret, ^â'^â,^â j rit etiarn propria quada in iÃ¼a meretrice turpit nunc hic pater ferre no poÃit: Alia P^^^^^f'^^J^uCf (Â« nunc dedamamusfed oÃendimus nonnunq W^ comodis dicentem bene uti, lUic maior aÃus,^ â ^^ ^^ denda quaritur, ut Ãupru pracipue m ^^'^[.^Lj^ d 3 profanatÃ¼,non dicof loquatur ipfe(natn q^^ ^ .^^^jj gemitus ac fetus er execratio uita coueni^ â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.

inteUigat potius dolorÃª iUit q audiatyfedpit'^^â'^^^^, pfimiles affÃ¨dus eundu erit,quia hoe miun^^ nbsp;nbsp;^

recundius mell paÃis q aufis. MoUienda eÂ» *â r , alio colore aj^eritas orationis, ut Cicerodâ -^of^' rumliberisfecit: Qiiid enimcYudeliiisi^h^^^^^^^:^ fis parÃ©tibus ac maioribus natos Ã repubu-ja ^ ^^ Itaq^ durum id ejfe furnmusiÃ¼e

feomineri artif(xconftetur,fcditalegibusSydf'^fÂ° turnt wint is aj^rmat, ut hitfolutisfi^^W ^ Â»

A^fecutM itit^i eft, ut ^Ut^uii corum ^uo^j cMfA uidere ter ficere^contri quoi dicertt.lllud etH m iocis monui, quim terpÂ» c^a fortune mjeadtio^ er ne in totoj or- nIkrquot; Dez dines,dut geÂ«tfs,dHt populo; petuUntiA incurreret.Sed mefthene intÃ©rim ^deÃ¯ pdtrocinij cogit qÂ«Â«Jd de untuerfo genere SÃ^^J dlt^iwrÂ« bominum dtcfre,Â«el libertinoruiÂ»,ucl miUtum, naturÃ¦ inc5 wel pÂ«bh'cdMorunj,ueI ÃmiUter dlioru, in quitus omnihin âÂ°r1 autcon e3(MÂ«nerejÂ«ediHmeft,uteiiqHlt;eIxdunt,nonItberttertrd temni debet Sireuidtirii^nec in ownÃ¼ impetum fidix^fed in id lt;ldâ^^'^^^^^^ txfugmndum cft, er reprebendcns,dlid liude compen quÃ¤ fint inge fes.Si milites cupido; dieM eÃe, no rairum, quod perieu bru de fditguints mMor^Ãhi deheri prtmiA putent,eop qua propen dem petuUnteSjCZ boe fieri quod bellis rndgis q pdei df- fiff*â'âÂ®*Â®Â®â fueuerint. Libertinis detrdbendd cft dutorftds,licetbis tejlimotiium reddere mdufiriÂ£,per qu3 exierint de fer' uitute. Quod dd MtionesexterÃ¤f Ipertme tracer o ud-rie detrdfturus GnecK teÃihw fidem, doSlrmihis conÂ« cedit de literds, feq; eiw gÃ«tis dmitorem effc frofitetur, Sdrdos contemnit, AUÃ³brogdi ut hofieti in/cftdtur,quo rum nihil tune cum diceretur,^Arum dptu, dut remotum cun decorii fuit, Verboru etium moderAtione detrdbi folet,/Ã¯ qud eft rei muidiifi df^cru dicM nmium feucru, iniupÂ« perfud/Ã¯oncldbi, per findet tdtrA modÃ¼ tendcem ^]^ P'^opo/itijplerunq; uelut ipfos coneris ntione uince re, quod cft moUifimu. indecorum cft fuper bitc omne nimiuy idfoÃ§ etidm quod ndturd reifdtii upturn eft, niÃ modo quoq; temperctur,grdtidm perdit.Cuim rei oifet wtw iHdioo mdgii quodJ fentiri, g preceptw trddi po

teÃ, quantum fitis fit,^ quantum redpunt aurtf.Noii hÃ¼bet hic res menfura, etr quifi pondm^quix ut 'm cibis, ^Ux alijs migd copient, AdijciendÃ¼ etixm breuittruiit-tur^quodferÃ¨ dieÃ«di uirtutes diuerÃÃime,non folu [nos Ã¼mxtores hxbeixntfid xb cifdemfepe Ixudentur.Ã¯ii Cicero quodxloco fcribitid effÃ¨ opfmuquod cum te facile crediderit confeqm 'tmitxtionc,nonpoÃis.Alioutro^o Ã ^â^ ^amp;ff*^i^^ '^^ diceret,quomo fe quihbet pojfe eÃ¶fidt* ret, fed quornodo nemo, QÃ¿od poteÃ pugnxre 'interft uideri. Verum utrunq; de meritÃ© Ixudxtur, CxÂ»fx cn'nn modo diÃxt,quixÃmplicitxt iÃx, et uclut fecuritas 'tÂ»4' feUxcte ordtionts^mire tenues exufM decet. nxioribits illud xdmirxbilc dicendi genus mxgis couenit. lÂ» utrolt;^ eminet Cicero, ex quibus alterum mperitife poÃe tonie qui credent,neutrum qui inteUigunt,

MEmorixm quida nxturx modo flimxuerunt,eR(Ã 'm ex non dubiÃ¨ ipfxcxcoledo,ÃcutxUxomnix,xugetur,crioigt;â^ ^8 diximut, xdhuc mxnis labor, nifi extern petits boe lutÃiiritu contmentur.^Jxm er omnis difeip^^ âquot; rix conÃxtjÃ-uÃrx^ docemur, Ã quiequid terfluxt,etexempbrum,legum,refÃonforuigt;i,di^â'^ * lene^ fxÃ³torum,qute uclut quxfdxm copixf^'*^^ ^ dxre,quxs^ 'm promptu femper hxbere debet ch^u^e ^^â^ '^ '*^ reprefentxt. Neque immÃ©ritÃ© ^^âÃ§^nf^ Ã¼Ktiuius. eloquentiie dicitur. Sed non firme tantum eontm gt;nbsp;runttlixm citÃ©perdpere multxxduros etporteh^^ Ã¯

fenpferw modo itenU Ic^ionc complet/, fei 'm cogitd tÂ« qwoq; re rum de uerborum contextulee^M^et qw^e fint db ii uerfd pdrte HHd meminijfe^ nee Mic^ eo qÂ«o diftrf Juut ordmf refutdre,fei opportunti lodi ponerc.Ciuii txtemporilis omtio ^ non alio mihi uidetur mentÂ« ui^ gorf coÂ«^(tre.N4m dunt dUd dieimui,epiÂ£ diduri fumiit 'ntuendi funt. itd eum femper cogitAtio uUrd id cpioi fft longius ([Uitrity (ptici^uid interim re pÃ©rit,c[uodAm f auttm Wodo dpwd memorid deponit, quod iUd qw^fi medid lt;[UÂ£ diim m4))Hj deeeptum ib muentione trddit clocuiiont.

Non drbitror nntrm mihi in boe Ã¯mmordndMm, quid Ãt quod memorwrn fdeid t, (pidntpii pleriq^ imptmii ^ux' dum ufÃigiu no^ro dnmo, lt;pu^ uclut 'm ceris dnuloru * ^^^'â

ttm^-vziuidutemtiuoddddnmumpert'mettmdgii dd- Ea autem mirer ndturi/ubito res uetuÃM tSto ex mterudUo repe pertânÃ©V.ma titÂ« reddert fe er oÃvrre,nee tdMum recpiirÃ«tibus,fed gis admirera etium jponte interim, Â«Â« uiÃ¿ldntibtK,fed etidm quifte compoptK mugK,rog; iUd quoq^ dnimdlw eux erfrere in telleflÂ« Â«idfmÂ»Ã¯,memiwrrÂ«nt er dgnofcunt,amp; ejUdmUd ^j^^j ^ j^f^ bet longottincrc iHudd dd dffuetds Ãbi feics reuertu* aus memoÂ«* tur.QijidfnortbiecwurictiWmirdfft.^fXcidercproxt- ris â mu, Meters 'mb^rerefbrficrnorim âmmiemores ddd pue* rititreeorddri f Quid^ eptoi (pugddnirccptifitdfeoc' euUdnt,z)- eidem forti fuecurrÃ¼t, nee mdnet femper me morid,fed iUiptdndo etia. redit.^efeiretur tdmen qu'dÃ» uit effet eins, qw Atd diKinitui iÃ¼d, niÃ 'm boe IxmÃ¨ orundi

68o M. FAB. QVINT, ÃNSTIT, Him extÃ¼lijfet:non enim reru modojed etiMuerionn ordinem pr^ftut, nee eti pducd contexit,fcd dur^fro- nbsp;'

pÃ¨ m infinit u, er m hngiÃmif ndionibns prim MH^Â» . dipMientiti, g memoriae fides deficit. Quod ey ifÃM drgumentum c^^fubejfii- drtem dUquM, iwiri^ ritiot In Euthy* ^^â ^^^gt;^gt;'^â*gt;^1 id^^tt domfiicere, illud mdoRity mexet phfone. ,citlt;Ã¼inonpoffumus. QuinquÃrnueniodpudPUtonM obfidre memoriae ufum liter dru, uidelicet quodiddeptt feriptis repofu'mus,uelut eufiodire definimuf, (T idtfi curitite dimittimus. Nec dubiu eA quin plurimu m ha pirte uileat mentis intentio, et uelut dcies luminu ipro f^cAu rerum quis iÂ»tuetur,non duerfi.Vnde iedditfit Bidem pro- 4*** 1?^^ plures dies Ãeribmui edifiÃ«di edufd, cogiUtioe didit Cicero ipfd contmedt. Artem dutÃ¨ memoriae primus ojlendijfi dicitur Simonides, cuius mslgdtd fdbuli eA, eu pKff^ ^Â° rondto cdrmÃª,qudle coponi uiftorihus filet mef^^'^ f^ Ad firipÃfifit, dbnegdtd ei pecHnia pdrs eA, qi^d more poÃ«tis frequctiÃimo digreÃfus in Idudes Cdjloris ât Pol tpetere lgt;*^i^^xierdt,qudpropterpdrtÃªdbhis cdperej^uoruin .

fdAd celebrdjet,iubebdtur,ey perÃolueruntÃi ^^^fi^^^ i cA-iidm cu effet grÃ¼nde conuiuiu in honorem emfiÃ©ia Aoriie,dtq; ddhibitus ei canif Simonides,weio eA Â«Â«â¦ tut,quad eu duo iâMenes equis dducAidefiderdremno' , nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;rem in modum dicebuntur, er iÃ¼os quidem non muemt,

fuiffe tdmen grdtos ergd fi exitu compcrit.^^'n â'â' ^'^ ImenegreÃo,tricliniumilludfuprdcouiudScorruitai^ j â¦ confadit ^^â^ * oontudit, ut no ord modo opprejfiru, fed memin , ctidm Old requirÃ©tes ad fipultwd propinqni ni^gt;gt;^^^ ;

polfent difcemc Â«.Tm SbnonidfÃ¯ iicitur memor orii nit quo ^Â»tj$ difcubuerttt,corpou [uis reiiUiffe. Eft Â«ut m4grt4 mier Mtores iiffentio,GUuco'ne C^ryÃto, un Lcocr^ti.drt Ag4tbxrcbo, dn ScopÂ« fcriptufit id cAt men,O' Pbdir/dlt futrit bate domiM,Â«t ipfe qnoddm loco pgnijicdre Simomdes wdetur, n^ Apoflodoru^/t Er# tojihenes,zr EÂ«pborion,cr LAriffeiK EÂ«rgt;pgt;l[Â« tridi dertmi,iitCrinone ut ApoUdc Ct^im.ichuf,lt;iuem(Ã¨cu^ t(Â« Cicero bdne pmi UUws fuUt.Scopim nobilÃ© Tbc(J# lm perij/p in eo conwiHio con^it.diijcitur fororit pli* iÂ«,piitdfÂ»t er ortos pUrofqj db Ã¼lo Scopd.qui mdior #td te pÃ©rit: Qwm^ mibi totÂ» de TjnddridK fdbulofm ui Xyndarifi' detÂ«r.NeqMcomrtmobÂ«iu4rcimeminittÂ«5poÃ¨âtdipfc, 1Â« caftorK propfto non tAciturut de tAntA luA glorid.Ex boe Simo ?â'*â*â¢ nidÂ« fdUo, notAtum uiietur iuuAri memoriArn ÃgnAtii dnimo fedibuÃ¯jfd^ eredere po ^MifÃ§^ experimeto.NdÂ« cm m locd dli^Md poH tempÂ«Â« reuerfi pmm, non ipp ^gnofemtHi tAntufid etiAtn qÂ»Â« m bis fecerimutremmi Rmur.perfort Æ ^- pbeiwt/tomwi^ tdeitx qwo^j cogitdÂ« tioneÃ¯ in mcjttÃ« reuertimtur. Ndtd eft igitur,wt in pk* Â»â il^AÂ« db experimeiuo Â« Locddifciwt quim mdxnne ft ttiofd,mMltd udrictdte Ãgn AtA,iomu forti mAgnAmjet w nwltoÃ¯ didufti receff^An eA qnic^uid notdbik cft, nobile dnimo diligenter d^gitar, ut fine cum^Ationt Ac mord pdrteK eiÂ»5 omneis cogitAtio pofit perewrere* Et pri

i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;M:Â« bic labor cft,non b/rere in occur fu.?lut enim tjuim

aUo pgno quo moncmmur notdnt: quad effe ucl ex re ta td poteÃ¼,ut de nMigdtione,militid,uel ex uerbo dliquo. Hdm etidm excideittes, uniat admonitione uerii w me^ nioridm reponuntur.Sit autem fignum nauigdtioniStttt eineordimilttiÂ£,ut dliquid ex drmis.li^c itdq; digeriwt, prim m fenfum uel locum ueÃibulo qtufi dÃigndotjecu d:m dtriOytum ia pluuid cirameut, neccubiculii moio Exedrac. dut exedris,fed Ãrdtis etidm ÃmiUbusq; per ordinÃ« cont mittuat^lioc fdUo cum efl repetendd memorid^ incipit iwt db mitio locdhiec recenfere, amp;â quad cuiq; credided ruat,repop:uat,et eorumdgme ddmonÃ«turyUtqudlibet multd Ãitt,quoru meminijfe oportcdt,fidttt Ãnguld eSne xd quoddm charogne errent coniuagentes prioribui fe* quemid folo edifcendi Idbore. Quod de domo dixi et in opcribuf publicis,et in itmere longo^ut urbium dmbitu, Cr piHurif fieri poteli. Etidm fingere Ãbi hdtrndgmes licet.Opui eil crgolocis,quÂ£ uelfinguntur^ud fumwi* tur,imdgfiiÃ¼}Ut,uelfimuldcrK, qu^utiq^ fingendd fint, imdgines notlt;g funt, quibm ed qux edifcendd fiint,notd mut,ut quo modo Cicero dicit, loeit pro ccrdfimuldcrit pro literie utdmur. Ã¯Ã¼ud quoq^ dd uerbum ponere opti^ mum fuerit.Loeit cH utendummultit,iÃ¼ufiribut,expli* f autem cdtir,modicis interUdlUt tlmdginibut dliquid dgÃ«tibutt dcribut,infignitii, qiiÂ£ oeeurrere ederiter^ percurre^ re dnmu pofimt. Quo mugis miror quornodo Metrodo rut w duodeeim fignis,per qut Sol medt, trecenos etÃ Xdgenos inuencrit locos, udnitds nimiru fuit dt^ idddd lio cired memarid/udm potins drte ^ ndturd gloridiuis*

Ãtluidcm hxc del quidam pro deffe non negduerimyUt ft reram nom'ind mÂ»ltd ptr ordlncm Mditd reddÃ¨da fintÂ» NuÂ» J; m hif lt;iuÂ£ didicerutdocis rrponunt res iÃM,men fim,ut hoc utdr,in uefiibuÃ¯o,in dtyio pulu'mu,et fic exte rAideMde rclegc:itcs,inucnitM ubi pofuermt. Et forfi tdn in hoe funt adiuti, e^ui duUione dÃ©mijjd,ciuid cuieiue uedidiffent, tcfiibiu Argentdrioru tdbulif reddidcriwtÂ» Qj^od prXjUtijJe Hortenfin dicunt^MmM idÃ© prodcrit 'm cdifiÃªdts,lt;iue orAtioms perpÃ©tuÃ© crunt-^dm zy fen fut non edndÃª mdginem epti ra hetbent, cum dlteru fin gendum fit,z:r horu tdmÃ« utrunq; comonet. Sed firma Si rum fer* nisAUcuiuihdbiti uerbonmeontextus cademdrte dKo*quot;Â®?â*?âââ

. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;lt;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;lushabitu

modo comprehendeturdMitto i^uod e^uedÃ¤m nudis jimu Uchrisfignificdri pofiunt^ut certecoiunHiones.liAbed, mus enm fdttÃ¨,ut qui notis firibunt,ccrtds 'midgmes o^ mniAm er loed fiilicet 'mfinitd, per que uerbd que fient 'm quinque comrd Verrem ficunde ddionis libris expli eentur, ut meminerimus etidm omnium qudfi depofito^ ruM^nonne mpediriquide eorum que didt, decurfum neceffeeH duplici memorie curdi Num quo modo pote funt copuldtd fluere, fi propter finguld uerbd dd fingu^ ^ format refiieiendum entfeitidre cr CdmeddeSter ^t^^pfiuSyde quo modo dixi,Metrodorus,quos Cicero diFabi, confiÃ¢t ufos hic exercitdtione,fibi hibedut fui,nosfimpUcio gâ^âj^^j^Q w trdddmus. Si longior compleÃ¢endd memorid fuerit na. ontiOjproderit per pdrtes edifiere(libordt en'mi mdxi me onere)iamp;he pdrtes non fi n perexigue, dlioqui ni* fois muite erunt,ty cum difimgueitt Hq^ cocidem, nee

Milt;p cerium mperMerim modum,fed mdxme ut c^ui[(^ finietw locM. Ui forte tint fit numerofiu, ut ipfe ^Â«o$ diuidi debedt. Ddndi fiunt certi quidam termini,ut cond textum uerboru,(iui eH difficilimut,cotmuet crebrA nc ditdtio,pdrtes demceps ipfu rÃ©pÃ©titif ordo coniivngitÂ» Uon ell inutile quo fdeiUushiredt dUqudt dpponereno texerceat tdf, qudrum recorddtio comonedt or qudfi excitet me moridm. Uemo enim fere turn infeUx^ut quad cuiq^ loco tradcndus Ãg^ dejlmduerit, nefcidt,utfierit tdrdui dd hoejeo quoq; ddhuc remedio utdtHr,utipflt;e excitent not^e.Ã¯Hnc tattÃ©tus ad ^^ â^ â^ ^^^'^ â^^^ inutile dttendere fignd dd eos qui ros qui exek exciderunt fenftu^ncordm,ut fuprd pofuiji de ndue di dunt fenfus, âffjf^^ effett^iculumfi de prlt;elio,uiultum enim fignd fdcitvÂ»t,(^ ex dlid memorid uenit dlid,ut cum trdnfdtut De anulis dnulm ueldUigdtm comonedt nos cur id fecermui Hdc disÂ« alÃ¶gS fÂ»'^^^'*^^^^'^^'^^^^*^^^'^^ memoridindb dliquo fimili dis nÃ³nuUa trdnsferiVKt dd id quod continendÃ¼ efi,ut m nommibus, p^nius. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Æ i^^^ifif jr^t^ Ãf. tenendut,referdmus dd ilium CumUd^

torem^qui excidere non potell,dut dd dliquem dmicum, qui idem uocetur,quod dl fdcilius in dpris, cz Â«Â» nrfis ey Ndfone,dut Crijpo, ut id memoriÂ£ affigitur, wide fuut nomind. Origo quoq^ dliqudndo declindtorum tepÃª ii migis edufd dl,ut m Cicerone^Verrio, Aurelio,fi de aiiflt;cn bet mferilUud neminem non iuudbit,ijfdÃ« quibw fcri* pferit ceris edifcere. Sequitur enim ueÃigijs quibuÃdm memoridm, er uelutocuUs intueturnonpdgindi modi, fed uerfus propÃ¨ipfos,qui turn dicit ftmiUs legentUdm â¦Swa wro fdUturd^dut ddidlio dÃiquA,dut mutdtio interuet

itiit,pgnA fivnt quitidm i^ux intuentrs erntre non fof* fumM.E^ rdtio^ut iUi de qui primu locutm fumydrti no diÃimilitJtiCÃ quid me exjperimeitti docueruntyt ex* feditior cr poteMior,edi[cere ticite.^imid quot^ c^ quad tiMnent optmu/i non fubirent uelut otiofum ani wum pterunqi iUtecogititiones,propter quit excitan* dm eft uoce, ut dupUci motu iuwtur memoriit, dicendi t:^ iudiendi.Scd h^c uox pt modici,et migis murmur, f^uidutem legenteiUoedifcittiin pdrtetdrdlt;itur,quod NegathoÃ© icrior efl oculorum | durium fenfus:in pdrtc iuudri po ^^^ ^^f ^tli,quod cum femel dut bis dudierit,continuÃ© iUi memo purSoefa^ fidfuimexperirilicet,etcum legente contendere.'mm *â Apoph* 0â dlioqui id mdxime fdciendum cA, ut nos fub 'mde ten nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â

t^mus^quid continui leAio t:^ que mdgis^cr que m'mut herent equiliter trdnfit. Xn experiendo,tenen 'ne^et me lor 'ntentio csl,o- nihilfuperuicui temporis perit^qua ftidmque tenemus repeti folent : itd fold que exciderut XnAintur, ut crebrd reiterdtione firmentur,quinq fo* lent hoc ipfa mdxlme herere,quod exciderumt.lllud edi feendo fcribendo^ commune eA utriq;,plurimum con* ferre bondm M,lctud'mc,digcflum cibum^dnimum cogite ^ionHustilijs liberum.'Verurn in his que fcripfimus com pleAendis multam Mlenttet in his que cogitdmus conti nendis propÃ¨ fole, excepte que potiÃtme eA exercitd* Xione^diuipo et copoÃtio.mm qui rede diuiferit,nun^ poterit in rerum or dine errire. Certd funt enim non fo

686 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. h^retq; omnis reram copuiatio, ut ei nihil nee fubtrM fine manifeÃo mteÃ¼eÃ¤u.nec infiri poÃit.An ueroScX* Lu Tu duo Je , 1 nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, r , J â r - nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;t

cimfcrupo' ffOMmlujuduodeemtjcruporu^cumpriorcMculupro^ rum,hunt lu mouiffet, efjetci^ uiduf, d:im rui tendit, repetito totiuf ca!whr?uni ^l^MMUS orditte, (j^uo dato errÃ¤ffet,recordatusredijt uocat, non ad eam,lt;^ui cam lu fir at,is Ã©j; ita fadum effecofeffm ed, tumTbfimL âââquot;'^ ^^^ Â°''''â^Â° Mlebit ia oratione,prffertim totm noa lis eft iiii. firo arbitrio confiitutui,cam tantu iUe ualeat a'tcrm',~ dupbeatum ^^ââââ^ ^^^ ^^^'^ compofita erunt,memoriafieriefui dua nonanum cent. IJamficut faciUut uerfm ediffimutc^uÃ m profim appellant. orationÃ«,ita profam umdam ^uim diffolutam.Sic con^ t 'mgit,ut etia qui ex tempore uidebantur effufa,ad uer bom repetita reddantur, ^uod met ^uo^ mediocritate memorit felt;iuebatur,(pando inteructui ali(ptorum,lt;jui bimc honorem mererenturfiterare dedamitionis parte Vtilepratte cocgiff'et.'^ec cfimendacioÃocui,Calu(squiinterfacrutâ ptum quod Si quis tamen unam maxmam^ Ã me artem memorise nes ctiam nbsp;nbsp;latrat,exerdtatio eH et labor,multi edifiere,malta co

commÃ©dat. gitare,zy,fifieri potcd,c[uotidie,potiÃimam eA, NiWI tipte uel augetur c!ira,uei negligentia 'mtercidit-QuaÂ» re cz pueri flatim ut prtcepi, quamplurima Ã©difiant,et iputcumj; ttoi operamiuuandt fiudiomemorie dibit, deuorct 'mitio tÂ£diu illud,O' firipta er If^a ftpiut re uoluendi,et cptafii eimdÃª cibu remandendi. Qjiod ipfu/m todium ^Â°â^ fi^l poteA leuiut,fit pauca primum,et qufHediam non affÃ©rant,caperimm edificere,tum quotidie adijcere^ fingulos uerfui,quorum aceeÃio laborifienfiam mereme â¦Â« ti non affÃ¨rat,m fummam ad infinitum ufq; peruenut.

ORXTOR. LIBER Xl. ^Si Ef poÃ«ticd priu^ytum ordtorwm,nouiÃmte etidm folutia td numeriSiO- mdgK nbufa dicendi rcmotd^qualid fwnt iurifconfuÃ¯toru.Cifjiciliord enim deient effe quit cxer* cent,quo Ãt kuins ip^um iÃ¼ud in quod exercent,ut dthlÃ© tt pondcribuf phrnbeis affuefdeitmt mdnnt,quibut M^ tuis ey nudis in certdmine utendum eÃ¼ â¦ NoÂ» omittdtn etidm quad quotididnis experiment is deprchenditur,mi nime Ãdelem eÃe pdul6 tdrdioribus mgenijs reeÃ«tem mt Moridm. Kirum didu ell,nec in proptu rdtio,qudiitunt Uox mterpofitd affirdtfirmitdtif, fiue quiefcit Idbor ib b^cui'M Ãbi ipfd fdtigdtio obÃdbdt,fiue mdturdtur de co quiturjeu ÃrmiÃimd dut pdrs eH recorddtio, quÂ£ fid* tm referri non poterdnt,contexuntur poÃero die,con* Ãrmdt^ memoridin idem iUud tempus, quad eÃe in cm ft fokt obliuionis, ^.lidm Hid pnuclox fere cito eÃluit^ ey uclut prÂ£feMi officio funÃ«ld,nihil mpoÃerum debet ^t^nq dimiffiidifeedit â¦ Ncc eÃ¢ mir um mugis hÂ£rere ^^ ediken^ unmo^quÂ£ diutius uffixdfint.'E.xhdcmgeniortidiuert da fit, fddtendtd dubitdtio eR,dn dd uerbum fit edifcendum di

Huris,un urn modo return dtqi ordinemcompleilifdtis Ãt, de quo fine dubio non poteR m tuniuerfum pronun* cidri.tHdm fi memorid fuffrdgdtur,tÃ«pus non defit,nul* Id me uelm fyUubd effiugidtiAlioqui etid firibere fit fit* perudcuu.ldq; prÂ£cipue 4 pueris obtinendu,dt^ in hue tonfuetuimem memorid exercitdtione rcdigcndd,rie no

bis difedmus ignofeereAdeoq; ddmoneri,iy dd libeUu/nt rtffiicereuitiofivm,quodlibertdtcm negligent^ fdeki necquifqtum fe pdru teuere iudicdl, quod ne fibi exei*

dAt non timet.Inde mtcrruptui adionis impetuf^Cf vf* fiÃens tic [aUbrofd omtio, er qui dicit edilcemi ftmiUfÂ» ctidm omnem bene feriptoru gratil perdit, uel boe ip[o modÃ³ ^^^^ I^^^i^Ãff^ fi cofitetur. Memorid dutÃ« facit et prom pti ingenijfdmdm, ut iÃd qua dicimus non domo dttu* fumpfifle liffe^fed ibi protinui propfiffe uidedmur,quod er ot^ tori,er ipfi edufe plurimuM confert.^dm er mdgM mi raturiez minut timet iudex, qute non putdt dduerfn ff prtpdrdtd.ldeo^ in ddionihm inter prxcipud ferUinÂ» iunximus dum ed,ut quidam etid quie optime-i-u'mximiif,u.clutff lutd enumciemus,er cogitdntibui nonniimq,et dubitdini bui Ãmiles querere uidedmur quie dttulimui. Ergo quÃ¼ fit optmwm,nenimem fugit.Si uero dut memorid ndtu* rd durior erit,dut non ffffrdgtbitur temput,etidm mu* tile erit dd omnidfe uerbd dUigdre^cum obliuio urniui eo rum cuiuflibet,dut deformem hgfitdtionem, dut etidm ff ^iniKitlentium mducdt.Tâutiui^multOfCoprehenfudnimore but ipfifjibertdtÃ« ffbi eloquÃ«di reUnquere.^dinetmui* tut perdit quifq^ id quod elegerdt uerbu,nec fdcile repo nit dUud^dum id quod fcripferdt,quierit.Sed ne hoc qui* dem inffrmie memoria: remedium eil, niff in bis qui ffbi fdcultdtÃ« dliqudm dicendi ex tÃ«pore parduerÃ¼t-Q^od fft cui utrunq; defuerit,huic dmittere omnino totu ddionu IdborÃ«tdc ff quid m literis udlet,dd fertbendu potiut fud debo conuerterc.Sed hÂ£c rdrd mfclicitds erit. Cteteru/m qudntum nuturd jludioc^ luledt memorid,uel Themifto* tiet teffK,quem umwm mtrd annum optime locutum effÃ¨

^Uot Hdtionibui impcrdldtytrÃ¤diturnotit fuiffc:ucl Cnffiu iUc diues^quicum AÃt pr teÃet, quinque grtfâ ci fermonis different iiu fie tenait, utquiquifqueapud turn ImgM pofluUffet, eddem ias fibi redditum ferrett uel Cyrm, quern omnium militwm tenuiffecreditum eH nomind, Qum femel audit os qiumUbet multos uerfut protinus dicitur reddidiffe Theodedles-Dicebuntur eti Hunc effe pu dm effe nunc qui fdeerentffed mihi nunqudm at ipfe mÂ« J*^â^ ^'Ã¦^ tere^em contigit, hahendd tarnen fides eÃ¼ uel 'm boc/tt ftotdis Rhe quicrediderit,cr fferet. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;toricafcri*

men 4 uoce,fequÃ«s Ã geÃu uidetur dccipere^Nant^ adionem Cicero dlids quafi fermonÃ«, dlids eloquentidm quindi corporis didt. Idc tarnen duts eius partes facit, qua; funtetdem prontmeiationis, uocem atque motum^ Cittapropterutraq^ appeUatione 'indiffÃ©rÃ©terutilicet, Habet dutem res ip fa miram quand din orationibus um depoteftdtem,Ã®^eq; en'm tarn refert qualiafint,quÂ£ 'mt trd nofmetipfos compofumus, qu'am quo modo effÃ¨rant tur.tdiam ita quifq; ut dudit,mouetur.Q^re,nequc pro batio uUa qua modo uenit ab oratore, tarn firma eÃ¢, ut non perdat aires fuas,nifi adiuuetur affeuerationc dice tis.AffÃ¨Ã«Ã®us omnes langtefednt neceffe cÃ¼,nifi uoce,wul tu,totius propÃ¨ habita corporis 'mar de fiant, Ã®Ham ewm bec omniafecerimus, feUces tamÃ© fi nofiruM iÃu/m ignÃ© iudex concepcrit,nediim earn fipmi ficuri^ moueamut oc non cj' ipfe nofira ofeitatione foluatur. Documeitto

Â«90 M. PAS. QVINT. INSTlT.^ funt uel fcenici d^ores,^ui er optimis poÃ«tarum titM Adijdut grdtij:, ut nos inÃnitc mdgis eddi iUd duditA Ifd^ dele{lent,er uiliÃimis etidm quibufdd impetrit AÃ¼ res,ut quibus nullus eH in bibUotheds locus,fit etidm frâ quens in thedtris Â» Qt^d ft in rebus quds fiUds effe fd* museer mdnes,tdntiim pronuncidtio poteÃ¼,ut irdm,lA* chrymds, foUcitudinÃ« dffÃ¨rdt, qudnto plus Udledt neceffe eft ubi etcredmusfE.quidÃª uel mediocre ordtioni comc ddtdmuiribus dHionis dffirmduerimplus hdbiturdeffe momemiÃf optimsm eudÃ© iUd deftitutdm.SiquidÃ« er ii^^ f primum mofthenes quid effet in toto genere dieÃ«di fummu/m,i'gt;^ terrogdtus, pronuncidtioni pdlmdm dedit, eidemÃ©^ ft(^f dum dc tertium locum, donee db eo quttri defterit,ut ed uideri poÃit nonprÂ£cipudm,fcdfoldm iudiedffe. ideoÃ©^ ipfe tdm diligenter dpud Andromcu HypocritÃ«ftuduit, ut udmirdutibus etidm eius ordtionem Khodijs, non im^ ^â audiaentnt^riiÃ³Aefthines dixiffeuideutur: Ã^id ft ipfMi dU^ diffetis^ Et Ul.Cicero undm in dicendo dÃ ionem domi^ â¦Hinc u^Yi putdt Hdc Cn.Lentulu plus opmionis confecutu i eloquentidtrddit.Eddem C.Grdcchu in deftenddfrdtrii nece,totius populi Ro. idebrymds concitd/fetAmoniuM er Crdffum muitum udluiffe, plurimum uero Q-HortfÂ» ftum,cuius reifides eft,quod eius fcriptd tdntum intrdfA 5 olim *^^ fMt, qui diu princeps ordtorum, dliqudndo itmit princfps lus Ciceronis exiflimdtus eii, nouiftme quodd uixitfecA dus:ut dppdredtpldcuijfc dliquid eo dicente,quod legttt tes non muenimus.Et herde cum Udlednt.....' 'i nftbd nbsp;per fe,er wx propridm uim ddijeiut rebus,et geftus tÂ»^

ORATOR. LIBER XL Ã©Ã¿l ^'^Ã Ãg^Ãect liquid,pro feil Ã perfedum ^uiddim fie Ã¹,cumi omniii coiertnt,neccjfe ed. SiM tamÃªqui rudem ilUm^O^ ({Mlem mpttiu cuius^ animi tuUt,i(lionem iu dicem fortiorem.cr [oldm uirif dignAm,fcd non alij fi fi,l qui etidm m dicendo curant er artem,er nitorem, er quiequid Ãudio paratur,ut a fJrdatdyCr paru/m natu rdia folcitt intproiare,uel qui uerborum ati^ ipfim ctigt; am foni ruÃicitatc,ut L. Cottam dicit Cicero feciffe^im i tationem antiquitatii affilant. Verum iili pcrfmfione ^ f-uantur,qui hommibuf ut fint orator es fatis,putant naÃi^noÃro labori dent ueniam, qui nibilcredimuseffe perfedum, nifi ubi natura cura iwietur. in hoc igitur non contumadter confentio^primas partes effe naturae, Ndw certe bene pronweiare non poterit,cui autmfiri pik memoria^aut in hk qux fubito dicenda erunt, facia btas prompta defuerit,nec fi memcndabUia ork mcoma modi obfiibunt^Corpork etiampotefi effe aliqua tanta deformitaSjUt nuUa arte uincatur. Sed ne uox quidem ni Ã libenlk adionem habere optimam poted. lamp;ona enim firmaq^^ut uolutnu^,uti licet,mala uelm beciÃ¼a et mhil et multi, ut mfurgere, exclamare, er aliqua cogit ut fuma mittere,deflcdere, et raucas fauces,aclatusfatigatu de formi cantico refcere.Sed nos de co nunc loquamur,cui nonfiuÃra pradpitur.Cum fit aut omnk adio,ut dixi^ induM diuifa partes,uocetn geÃum q;,quorum alter ocu los,alter aures moue t,per quos duos fen fut omnk adani mum pÃ©nÃ©trÃ¢t a ffÃ¨dus,prius ed de uoce dicere,cui cti* amgefiui accommodatur t Ã¯neaprima Ã³bferuamp;tioed

VOX. quAÃemhdbemxtSecwndd^tiuomoio utdrK.Ã®JdturiiUwii j^cÃ¤dtur qMiuitdtc er quanteltet. Ã§^dneitM e^ Ãmpli cior.lnfummacnirn grddÃ¤ dut exigui eR.Sed inter hdi extremitittes mediae funtfÃecies^ er ab imiidd fummi, dc retro, multi funt grddm â¦ QjialitM mdgiiMride^-tidm eil er cdndidd,er fufcd,er plend,er exilis,O' 1^* nie,er Ã¤j^erd,er contrdild,er fufd,er durd,erflexia lis,er eldrd,er oltufd.spiritus etium longior Ireuior^Â» Nec edufat cur quiclt;^; eoru dÃ©cidÃ¢t, perjequi propoÃto operi neeeÃÃsrium eA,corum neÃt diÃerentid in quibut durd iÃ¼d cocipitur, dn eoru per (jux uelut orgdnd medt, dn ipÃ proprid ndturd, dn prout mouetur,ldteris peilo ris 'ne Ãrmitds, dn cdpitis etid plus ddiuuet * t^dm opus eA omnibus, Ãeut non or A modo fuduitdte, fed ndrium Ffgeritur ^â^ojhpertludsquod fupereAuocis egreditur.Sulcis tdmen effe debet non exprobrdns fonus.Vtedi uoce mul tiplex rdtio.Udm prigter itldm diffcremium, lt;jue eA tri pdrtitd,dcutÂ£,grduis,flexg,tum intentÃ©, turn remiÃis, inflatis tym etdtK,tum ittferioribus modis opus eA,fÃdtijsquo que Ictioribus dut citdtioribus.Sed hiÃpÃs media inter* ideent multdier ut fades,qudnq ex pdueiÃimis conÃdt, inÃnitdm habet diffÃ¨rentiam,ita uox, O' Ã pMCM, qua nominari po(Ãtnt,cotmetfÃedes, proprid cui^ eA,er non hge minus duribus,q oculis iÃ¼a dignofeitur^Augen tur dutÃeut omnium,ita uocis quoq; bona,curd, er ne* gUgentid mmusintur. Sed curd non eadem oratoribus, que phonafeis conuenit, tame multa funt utriÃ^ commu nid^rmitas corporis^ nedd IÃadonum,et mulieTVW)t3â

^grorum exiUtatem uox nojira tcnuctur,i^uod dmbuldt tio,ivKÂ£tiOjUenerifelbÃinetttici,fdciUs ciborum digefiio, id cR^frugiUtdi prÂ£Ã(it. Pratereaut fint fauces into gra,id cA molles de leurs,quorum uitio zy- frMgititrjet obscurdtur,^ exaj^erdtur,et fimditur uox, ÃM ut ti biÂ£ code j^iritu dccepto dUu cldufis, dUu dpertis fordmi tubits^dUu nÃ¶ (dtis purgdtÂ£,dUu (juffie fonu rcddut,itd fduces tumetes jirdguldnt uoccm,obtufie obfcurdt,rdlÂ£ txdfj^erdt,couulflt;e frdilis funt orgdnis fimiles.Pinditur rtidf^iritiu obieÂ£lu dUquoficut Idpillo tenues d^UÂ£,(jUd, rum fludus etÃ¼ fi uUrd pdulum coit^dUeptid tdme edui trpiritus relmquit paÃ id ipfum qd'offenderdt.Humor quolt;^ uo* eem ut nimius impedit,itd confumptus defiituit.Ã®Jdm et fitigdtio corpord nodd pnfins modo tempus, fed etid mfuturu dfficit. Sed ut comuniter (y pbondfeis^zy ord toribus neceffdrid ed exercitdtio, ^uid old coudlefcumt, itdeurdUo idem genus .Ndmneq;certdtÃ«pOYddd figt;d timdum ddri poffunt tot ciuilibus officijs occupÃ¢t o, nee quot;Ãâlt;*'andu prtpdrdre db misfonis uocem ddfiimmos, neefemper ^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^^^

4 cotentionc cocedere licet, cum pluribus iudidjs f^pe â^ââ1 cotJ' dieÃ«dum fit.t^e ciborum quidÃ« eÃ¼ eddÃ« Ã³bferuitio.tion quiefcere tnimtdm molli tenerdq; uoce,q forti de dur dbili opus eft. CÃ¼w omnes illi etidm dltiÃimos fonos lenidnt edMu or is,nabis pierde^ dfferefint concitdte^ dicendd,cr ui giltindg noiles,Grfuligo lucubrdtionum bibendd,ey m fuddtd ueÃc durdndim, Qudre uoeÃ«delicijsnon mollid mus, nee imbudmur ed confuetudme, qut durdturd non fit, fed exercitdtio dus tdis fit, qialis ufus, nee fdeiuio

fiAIUMy^ed Ãrmeturcofuctudme, ^ difflcultM omitif leMtur. Edifcere autem quo exercedriierit optmwmt ndm ex tempore dicenti Moedtur curd uodi, die qui ex veiiM ipfis concipitur,dffÃ¨{lui,et edifcere q mdx'me,uA rid^qii^crchmorem,^ dijj^utdtionem,^^ Ãrmonem, er ftexut Mednt,ut fimul m omnid pdremur. Hoc fdtis e/l, dlioqui mtiddiÃ¼d, er curdtd uox infoUtimi Idborem reeufdbit, ut dffuetd gymmfqs et oleo corpord,quilibet fmt in fuis certdmmibtu jÃeciofd dtq^ robuÃd,fi militdre iter,fd[ces^,er uigilidS impdres, deÃcidnt,er qu^rdnt fquidem wtHoresfuos,nudumq^ fudorem.lUd tdmeninhocope re predpi quis ferdtiuitdndos foies dtlt;^ uentos er Â»gt;(* bild etidm deficcitdtesjtd ft dicendum in fole^dut uento fo,humido,cdlido 'ue diefuerit,reos deferemm iNd cru* dum quidem, dut fdturwm, dut ebrium, dut eieSlo modo uom!tu,qua eduendd quiddm monent, decldmdre nemi* nem qui fit mentis compos,puto.lllud non fine atufd eil dh omnibus prÂ£cept'.m,ut pdrcdtur mdxime uod in Ulo

peditur,no,ut drbitror,propter cdlorcm, quod quiddm ' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;putduerunt(ndm eR mdior m dlijs)fed propter humorÃ©

potiuf.'t^dmhoc Â£tds iÃ¼d turgefdtjtdi^ ndres etidm,de peHus,eo tempore tument,dtc^ omnid uelat germindnif eo^ tenerd,ty iniurit obnoxid.Sed ut dd propofuu re iedm,idm confrmxtx confitutg^ uocis genus exereitd , tionis op tint Mn duca, quod eA operi ftmilmum, dicere Fronunaa f^no^i^icÃ^ut dgimus.Ndm hoc modo non uox tdMu con Ãrmdtur,er ldtw,fei etidm corporis deceit er dccom

ORATOR. LIBER XI, 69Ã tnoiÃ¼ui ontioni motm componitur.t^on aUirÃ dutem ratio pronwiciitionii,^ ipfim orAtionii-t^i ut iUd erne iatm^Ã¢ilucidA^orndtA^AptA ef[e debet,itd htc quoq; erne Adtd (rit,id eÃ¹ uitio cArebit/tfuerit os fdale,explAnA* tiim,iuctÂ»idim,urbdnu,in,id eÃ¢, in quo nuUd net^ rufti* eitM,ne(^ peregrinitds refonet.tion enim fine cdufd di* titur barbar urn grgcum'ue.UAm fonts hom'mes,ut dirA tinnitu dignofcmiiu. itafiet itlud quod Ennius probat, ej,m dicit fuAuiloquenti ore Cethegum fuiffe, non quod Cicero in his reprehendit, quos ait latrare, non agere. Stmt enm multa uitia,de quibus dixi,cum in quidam If* bri parte pueroru ora formarem, opportunius ratut in ta Â£tate facere idorum mcntionem,in qua emedari pof* fwit. itaq; ft ip fa uox primumfuerit(ut fic dicam) fana, a ell nullum eonim de quibus numc dixi, patietur mcoa modim-.demde non fubfurda,rudis,imntdnis,dura,rigi da,uAria,prxpinguis,dut tenuis, indnis,dcerbd,pufilld, mollis,effaemuiatd: Spiritus nee breuis,nec parum dura Ulis,nee in receptu difficilis.Vilucida uero erit pronun eiatio primi(,fi uerba totd exegerit, quoru pars deuord ri,pars defitui folet,plerifc^ extremas fyUabds non pro ferentibus,dum priorum fono indulgent. Vt autem ell neceffaria uerborum explanatio, ita omnes computare, V uelut annumerare Uteras moleÃum er odiofum. Nd er uocales frequentiÃmie coeiwt,et confonantium que dam infequente uocdli diÃimuUntur, utriufque exem* plum pofuimust

multam ilk er terrkt nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Vitatur ctiam duriot

69Â« M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. wter Ã congrejjÂ»s,wide pcÃ¼exit,et collegit, et i^fi dito loco diHi Iwnt. ideoq- budatur m Catutto fiuuis tippel* Idtiolitertirti.SeciwiÃ¼e^l, ut fit oratio dijUnÃAjdellf M qui dicit,etincipiat uii oportet,et defmattObfirudn divin etiam quo loco fufimÃ«dut,^^ quafi fuj^Ã¨denduiÃf mo fit, quod Gneci V7eoj'iaso7\.ii/], uel vma'uso'AHp, uel viras ly/j-ip uocant,quo dcponendiu fufpenditurz ArmdfUinvmq; cano. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;quid iÃ¼ud uirivm,(id fequen*

tia pert'metyUtfit uiru Troiiie,qui primus db or is. Et bic iterum.^dm etiafi aliud eÃ¢ unde uenit q quo uenit,non difimguendâM tamÃ«, quia utrun^ eodÃ« uerbo comme* tur,uenit.Tertio ltalii,quia mteriedio eÃ¼, fiatoprofu gus,et cotmuum fiermonÃ«,qui faciebat,ltalia,Laumâi^, diuidittOb eandem^ caufiamt quarto profugus, deinde Lauma^ uenit Littora, ubi ia crit dijimdio, quia inde alius mcipitÃnfus.Sed in ipfis etiam difimdionibus tem pus alias breuius,aUÃ¢s longius dabimus. intered enim Ãrmonemfiniat,anÃnfivm. Itaqu^iUamdiÃmdionem Littora,protinus alter o Ãiritus initio inÃquar, cum il* lue uenero. Atq; alt te mÅttia Romte.

Deponam,et morabor,crnoiium rurfus exordium fact am. Sunt aliquado er fine refinratione quada morte etia in periodis,ut in ilia: in extu uero po.Ro.negotium pu blicum gerÃ«s,magijler equitum,er cetera,multa habÃ«t mÃ«bra.Senfus enim funt alij atlt;^ alij,er fiicut u/na dreun dudio cfi,ita paulum moradum in bis interuaUis,na 'm* terrumpÃ«dus efi contextus,er Ã¨ cotrario Ãiritum inte fm recipere fine mtctledu mor a neceffe ed, quo loco

^UdÃ farripiendu! ell, nHotiui Ã mfeite redputur, non nuntii dÃvrAt obfeuritdtis, ^ uitiofd diÃmdio.Virtus dti tem diftmguÃ«di fortdffefit pdrud/me qud tdmÃ« efie nul ld dUd m dgendo potefi.Omdtd eit pronucidtio^cui fuf~ fÃ¨dgdtur uox fdcilii,mdgnd,hcdtd, ficxibilK,firmd, dul-â cis,durdbilK,cldrdypurd, feedm dÃ«rd, duributfiedens^ ^ jreÃ¼a Eft enim eptedd dd duditu dccommoddtd non mdÃ¿Ã®itu^ dme^fed proprietdte dd hocuelut trdÃ©ldbiÃ¯ii,utique hd* bens oes infe ^ui deÃderdtur fionos/iue mtentiÃ¶cs,cpiÂ£ totOjUtdiutyOrgdno'mfiÃ¯UÃdyCuidderitld.eriifirmitdi, fj^iritus,cu Ã^dtio pertindx,tu Idbori non fdcilc eejjitrut. Nf$ grduiÃmui dutem in mufiedfonui, nee dcutiÃmiM ordtionibm conuenit^ nieyhicpdrucldruf,nimium^ plenus^nuUÃ¼ dffÃ¨rre dnmii motÃ¼ potefi,et iHe prÂ£tcnuii t^' immodiciie cldritdtis,cÃ¼ eH ultrd ueru, turn neep pro' nuneutionefleÃ«ti, nee diutiut ferre intentionempoteji. NÃ uox ut nerM,lt;luo remiÃior,hoc grduior er plenior, ^Â«0 tenfiorÃ^oc tenuis ty dcutd mugis eH^ Sic imdu'tm non hdbet,fummd rumpi periclitdtur,medijs igitur uten dumfoniSy hi^ eu dugendd intentio efi excitidi cu fuin t ^' âlâÂ®?â' mittendd,funt temperdndi.ni primd eH obferudtio rC' innntirae ftf pronundidi Â£e[udlitM,neferma fubfuitet impdribus f^^^f^'Ã^ f^itiisde fonis,mifcenslongdbreuibus,gxduiddcutis,eld fint, tempt* td fummifiis^er'nitlt;iudlitdtehoru omniumftcutpedum, randi'$. eldudicet fermo. Secundd udrietds eÃ¼, c^utfolu eH pro nuncidtio. Ac ne lt;puis pugndre inter fe putet lt;e(pidiitdtÃ« er udrietdtem.cu ilU uirtuti cotrdriumfit uitiu 'mxqud-btdSjbuic 5 didtur/j.ovo^dii^ e^udfi quidi iw.mdfpeduf-

Ars parr Ã MridnH cum grdtUm prtclet de renoUit M- ' r-cs,tum dieentem ipfd Idboris mutdtione reficit^ut jidii^ nmbuhndi/edendijidccndi uiecsfunt, nihilq; horu pdti tmu diu po^fumus. lUud uero mdxmÃ¼ (fed id pdulÃ¨ poÃ trdHdiimuf) qdâfecundum rdtionÃ¨rerum de quibus did nMS,dnimorum^ hdbitus,conformddd uox eÃ¼^nc db ord tione difcordet.Vitemuf igitur iÃ¼dm qux grxce /xovolo via. uocdtur,umd quidS, f^iritus de foni 'mtentio,non fdu ne diedmus omnid cUmofe^quod mfdnu eA, dut mtrd lo* ^Ã«di modum, quad motu cdret,dut fubmijfo murmure, quo etiam debiUtdtur omnis intentiOj ^cd ut in ijfdÃª pdr* tibus,iifdemq; dffÃ¨Â£libuf,fmt tdmenqutedd non Ã¼dmd' gnt uocis declindtiocs,prout dut uerboru dignitÃ©s, dut fententidru ndturd,dut dcpofitio,dut inceptio,dut trdU' fitus poÃuldbitjUt qui ftngulis pmxerunt eoloribus, did tdmÃª cminÃ«tiord,dlid redudiord fecerut, f te quo ne me tris quidem (Ã¹ds Une ds de di ff ent. Propondmusenmi no iis lÃ¼ud Ciceronis in ordtione nobiliÃimd pro milone frmeipiu,nonne dd Ãngulds pene diÃiniHones,qudmuis ineddÃ« fdcie,tdmen qudft uultus mutdndus eRi Et fi ue^' reor indices, ne turpe Ãt^p fortiÃimouiro dicere incipiÃ« tem timere. Etid Ã eÃ totoppoÃto contrdRu dtq^ fubmif fum,qd er exordium eR,cr foliciti exordiu,tdmÃ« fuerit neceffe eR dliquid pieniuscr ercRius,du dicitt Pro ford tiÃimo uiro dicere,q,etÃ uereor,cr,turpe Ãt^zy, time' re, idmfecundd reffirdtio merefedt oportet, et ndturdU quad! condtu, quo minus pduide dicimus quje fequutur, ^ quo mugmtudo dnimi Milpnif oÃenditur; Ã«iinime^

iecedt,cu T. Annius ipfe indgii de reipub.fdlutc ^defud perturbetur.Vxinde ^udfi obiurgdiio fui eÃiM.e dd dus edufdin pdre dnimi mdgnitudinc djferre non poffe. Turn inuidioftord: Tdmen hdc noui Micij noM formdterret oculos. iUd uero idmpenÃ¨dpertii (utdiunt) tibijs. Qui ^uocumji inciderut, ueterem confuetudmeformer pri' fiinum morem iudicioru re^uirunt. Ã^dm jeejuens Idtu defiderant etidm dte^fufum eft^ i^oenim corond cofeffus ueÃer ein dus eÃut folebdt. Quod notdui. Ut dppdrerct no folum in membriseduÃe, fed etidm in drticulK effe nUquÃ pro* nuncidudi udrietdtÃ«, fine qud nihil nee minus, nee mdius tÃ.Vox dutem ukrd uires urgenddnon cÃ.tdid et fuffo^ tdtd fÂ£pâ¬,cr mdiorenifu minus eldrdeH, cr interim cli fd in ilium fonu erumpit, eui Graeci nomen db immdturo gdllorum edntu dederunt. Hec uolubiUtdte nimid eofun dendd quit dicimus,qud or diÃinclio pÃ©rit (^ affcHus, e:t^ nonnunq etidm uerbd dliqud fui pdrtep-duddtur.Cui eontrdrium eR uitiu nimia tdrditdtis.t^dm amp;nbsp;diffieultd tem inueniendi fdtetur, er fegnitid foluit dnimos, er it ^uo eÃ dliquidyteporibuspriÃnitis dqud perdit.Promgt; ^^â^^, pium ft os,no priceps:moderdtu,non lentum. Spiritus tutum tÃ© pus ^oq. neccrebro reeeptuseoceddtÃcntetidm, nee cou f^ ââ âquot;^ depfy trdhdtur,donec defeidt. Nd er deformis eÃ cofumpti il tur perorarÂ« kus fonus,et rej^irdtio fub dquddiu prefi fmilis,ct rece ueteres. ptus longior,er no opportuuns, ut 5 fint non ubiuolu~ mus, fed ubi neeeffe cÃ.Qudre logiorÃ« diHuris periodii coUigendus eRffiritus, itd tdmen,ut id neq; diu,neqi eu fonofd(idinus,nelt;^ omnino ut mMifeÃÃ fit relias ptibui

s 700 M. FAB. OyiNT. INSTIT. optime inter iundurds fermonis reuocnhitur, Exercen das dutem eÃ¢,ut fit qudlongiÃimus, c^uod Demofibenei KtefficeretjfidniÃ«sindduerfum continKtdidt^pojfet tÃ§oÃ§ine a pinf-^QjffiYiânf^i^ffftquofdciUusuerbdoreliberoeX' primerct, cdlculos lingud uoluens dicere domifolebdt. EÃ interim er longus,etplenui,er clerus fdtis j^irituif non tdmen firmÂ£ intentionis,ideo^ tremulus^ut corps' rd que dfiieÃu integrd neruK paru fujiinÃ«ttir, id Grad %Â«?XÂ°iâ uoedntt Sunt quiÃiiritu cum firidore per rd* ritdte dentium non recipiuntjed reforbent^Sunt qui ere bro dnhelitu,er introrfum etid cidre fonunte, imitentur iumentd onere er iugo labordntid. c^uod affeUdt quo^ tdnq inuentionis copid urgedturimdiorqi uis eloquentie ingrudt, q que emitti fiducibus poÃit^EÃ¼ dliÃ concur fus oris,er eu uerbis fuis coUuUdtio, la tuÃire er expuere Jrocleis ad' crebro^zT db mo pulmonepituitd trocleis ddducere,er ak^udndicet oris humore proximosff ergere, er maiorem parte ffi* r **Â« ^onaw ^â^â*^ ^ eloquendo per nares elfundere, etiamfi no uti^ tx imis pup ^^â^i^ funt tiitid, quid tomen propter uoeÃ« dccidunt, pO' monibus edu tiÃimu huic loco fubijcidntur.Sed quodcunc^ ex hts uitiu yel^dingut ^â^Ãª^ tuler'm,q quo nÃc mdxieldbordtur,m confis omni |urt Â«ufeemo bus fchoUs^ edntdndi, quod mutiUus fit dn fadius, nc' ^fi^quakm fdo-OdÃd enm minus ordtoriconucnit,qmoduldtio fee fokt dÃ» hau nicd,O'nonnunq ebriorum,dut comeffdntiu liccntiafi' Eft autÃª'tro ^^^' â^â^ â*^^Â° mouendis affÃ¨Hibus contrdriu magif, fles rota pu' q cumdolcndum,irdfcendu,mdignddum,cbmiferdndum V4lw. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fit,non folÃ¼ db bis affÃ¨Hibus, in quos inducendus efi iu*

^centid foluerci Ndw Cicero iUosex Lycid et Cdrid rhe tores pens edntdre in epHogis dixit, liosetid edntÃ¤ndi feueriorem pdulo modum exceÃ'miu i Q^ifyud ne, non dico de homicidio,fdcrilegio, pdrricidio, fed de cakulis tertedt^ rdiionibws,quifquA deniq;,ut femel Ãnidm,in Utecdntdt^ QuadÃomninorecipiendHeR,nihilcdufle tuteur non iÃ¼d uocis moduldtionem fdilus dc tibijs^imo mehercules,quod eÃ huk deformitdti propiuf,cymidlis tdiuuemus.Tdeimus tdmen hitc libenter. Ãdm nee ciaqmÃ¶ne cui# Ãntiniucundd queedntdnt ipÃ,lt;^ Idhork in hoc,q in d^ gÃ¨do minus eÃ.^t funt quidÃ qui fecundu dlid uitÂ£ uitid, etidm hdc ubiq; dudiendi quad dures mulcedt uoluptdte ducemtur. Quidergofnozy CicerodiciteffedliquÃªin ordtioneedtum obfcuriorc t Et hoe quodd ndturdli ui^''^^^ tio uenit.oÃendd non multo poÃ,uii (^ qudtenus red-^ piendus fit hie flexus,zy cdntus quidÃ«,fed (quod pleritÃ inteUigere nolunt) obfcurior. Ã¯d enm tempus eÃ¼ dieÃ«di que Ãt dptd pronucidtio,quÂ£ eer te ed eÃ,qult;e hk de qui* bits dicimui,dccÃmoddtur,quod quidÃ« mdximd expdrtÃª prdÃdt ipfi motus dnmoru, fonatq^ uox utferitur. Sed cum fint dUj ucri dffÃ¨dM,dlij Ãdi or mitdii^uerindturd liter erumpunt,utdolentiu,irdfcentiuiindigndntium, fei cdrent drte,ideo^ non funt difciplinig trdditione forma di.Contrd qui effinguntur imitdtione,drtem hdbent,fei hi cdrent ndturd, idcoq- in hk primu eÃ¼ bene dffici, er concipere imdgines rcru,Zir tdnq uerk moueri/tc uclut medid uox,quÃ« hdbitum d nobkdcceperit,hunc iudicuni

Ideo% ^c totidem quoi Hh mutdtioncs hdbet. Udt^ UtK m ri bits plena,ÃmplcXt et ip fa quoda modohilam Puit. At 'm certdm'ine ereÃ¢d totis uirtbus, or uelut omnibiu neruit intenditur. Atrox 'm ira er dfperd dc denÃ^er refpin^ tione crebrd. ^elt;j^ en'mi poteÃ efje longus Jpiritut, cunt mmoderdte ejfunditur.Pdulu 'in muidid fdciÃ«dd lentioÃ¯ quid non ferÃ¨ dd hac nip 'mferiores cofugiunt,At 'm bid diendo,fdtendo,fdti(fdciendo,rogdndo,lenis er fuhmiÃ quot;nbsp;fd.SuddentiH,er moncntiiim,er potlicentiÃ¼^ef conpUn tiuingrduisiin metu et uerecudid cotrd{id:ddhortdtioni bus fortis,dipgt;utdtionibut tercs,mifcrdtionepcxd er P^ bills,er confulto qudp obfcurior,dt 'm egreÃionibus pt' fd er fecurr cldritdtisÃn expoptione dc [ermonibus re' Ãd ey mter dcutufonum er grduÃ« media. AttoUitur aut condtatis affedlibus,cÃ¶poÃtis defcÃ«dit, pro utriuf^ rei modo altius uel mferius.ciuid dutÃ« quip^ 'm dicendo po Ãulet locus paulum diffÃ©ra,ut de geffu prius dicd,qui er ipfe uoci cofcntit,er animo cu eapmul paret, is quotum habeat in oratore momÃ«ti,fdtis uel ex eo pdtet,quod ple rdi^etiacitrauerbapgnipcat. Quippenomanusfolu, pd nutus etia declarant noÃra uoluntatem, er 'm mutis ,p fermone funt,er falutatiofrequÃ«terpne uoce mteUigi tur,dtq} dfficit,er ex unltu mgreffu^ per/^idtur babi' tus dn'morum,er anmaliu quoq- fermone carÃ«tium ira, lÂ£titid,dduldtio,er oculis, et quibufdam alijs corporis p gnis deprehenditur. Nee mirupifld,quÂ£ tamÃ«'maliquo popta funt motu,tantu m animis ualÃ«t,cu pidura tacens opus,er habitw femp eiufdÃ¨,pc m mttmos pÃ©nÃ©tret '^pi

Um, ut ipÃm um dicendi nonnunq fuperare uidedtufÂ» Contri Ã geÃtts dc uultm ab ontione dilfentiir.t^triÃiii dicdmut hildres,dffirmemus dUqud renuctes, non autori tdi modÃ³ uerbiiyfed etUÃdes deÃt.Decorquoq; 4 grÃu dtq^ d motu uenit.ldeo^ Demofibencs grande quoddam jjpeculu intucns coponere dÃ¼ione fokbat. Adr Ã quauis fulgor itte ÃniÃrax mÃ¤gmes rrddat, fuK dimitm ocuUs rredidit,quod effierret. PritcipuÃ¼ urro in afliorÃeut in nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.

corpore ipfo^ caput eil^cu ad ipfum de quo dixi dÃ©corÃ©s turn etiaadÃgniÃeatione deeorKtÃ¼a funt, ut Ãt prima reHu (y Ãecundum naturttjam (y deiedo humilitÃ©s,et fupmo arrogantia, Oquot; m latus inclinato languor,et pre duro ac rigente barbaria queda mentis oÃenJiturt Tu accipiat aptos ex ipfa adione motus, ut eu geftu concor det^zymanibusaclateribus obfequatur, Aj^edusenim Ãmp codent uertitur quo geÃus^exceptis que aut dana^ te,dutconcedere^autÃ nobis remouere oportebit,ut idc Ulud mdtu uideamur auerfarÃmanu repeUerei

Raud equidem tali me dignor honore, ^igniÃcat uero plurimis modis. Uan^ prater annuendi^ renuendi,conÃrmandi^ motus,Ãunt ce ucrccundia,ey dubitationis,ty admirationis,indignationis noti, ey co munesomnibus.Solo tante eofaceregeÃumÃceniciquocÃ dodores uitiofum putauerUnt. Ptiam deques dus nut us non caret uitio,adeo iadare id,cy cornas excutiÃ©tem ro tarephanaticumed. Dominatur autem maxime usil-tus. Ã¼ocÃupplicesfhoctnmdcesjhocblandiihoctriÃes^. vhitus

hoc hilitres, hoc creÃ¼i, hoc fuhmiÃi fumus, hoc pendent omne s homines,hune intuenturjbunc f^eHetnt etu Mte g ii' cdmus,hoc quofdd dmdmus,hoc odmus, hoc plurmd in' teUigmus.iiie cR ftepe pro omnibus uerbis. Ud^ m bis qua dd feend componuntur fdbulis, drtiÃces pronuciM di d p fonts quoqi dffÃ¨clus mutudtur,ut fit Ã¯^iobe in tret' gÅdid tri fits,dtrox Mcded,dttonitiK Aidx,truculcntus quoque Ã¼trcules. in comcedijs uero prÃªter dUÃ ohferudtioni, qud fcrui,lenones,pdrdfiti, ruftici, milites, merctriculee, anciÃ¼ie,fcnes,dufieri,dc mites,iweencs feueri,dc luxurio fi,mdtronÂ£,pueÃ¯lie,inter fe difcemutur. Pdter iUecuius preecipuee pdrtesfunt,quidinterim cocitdties,interim k' nis eil,dltero ereÂ£lo,dltero copofito eA fupercilio, dtqi id ofiendere mdximc Idtmis dÃ¼oribusmoris cft,quod cu hisqutu dguntpdrtibuscongrudt.Sed in ipfo uultuplu^ Ocult. ftmu Udlent oculi,per quos mdxime dnimus emdndt,utci trd motÃ¼ quoc^,cr hUdrUdteenitefcdt,!:^ trifiitid quod ddm nubilum ducdnt.Quinetidldchrymds hts ndturd mÃª tis indices dÃ©dit,quÂ£ dut erupunt dolore,dut hetitid md* ndnt, Motu uero mtenti,remiÃi, fitperbi,torui, mites, ^11â^i'i fiant, qua ut dAus popoficrit fingentur. Kigidi uero ey extenti,dutldnguidi,cttorpentes,dutfiupÃ«tes, aut Idfciui er mobiles,dut ndtdntes, (y quddd uoluptdte fÃ¹ffufi,dut lmi,er,ut fic dicd,uenerei,dut po fientes dU' quid, poUicentÃ©fuenonnunq effe debebunt, bid opertos compreffofieeos in dicendo,quis nifi pUnÃ¨ rudis et flut tus hdhedtf Et dd hete Ã³id exprimendd in pdlpebris etH ZT ingenis eA quoddd feruienshis minifieriu. Multum

ty [upcrcUijsagitur. Nam^y oculos [orntM Alic^uate* SupercHit^ WSyOquot; fronti imperdM. Kii conirdhituridttoUituryde' wittitur^ut nuUd res m ed plus Udledt. Sdnguis iUe, qui Mentis hdbitu Mouetur,0â tu infirind uerecundid cutew daipit, effunditur in ruborcm, cum metu refugit, dbit omnis, er pdUorefrigefeit,temperdtus mediuquoddÃ¤m ferenum efficit, Vitium in fupercilijs^Ã dut immotd fÃ¹nt omnino, dut nimium mobilid, dut mxquiUtdtc (ut modo de per fond comied dixerd ) diÃident,dut contrd id quod dicimufÃnguntur, Â£tenim contrddis triÃitid, diduilis bildritds^rcmiÃis pudoroÃenditur. Annuendiquot^ re nuendiue rdtione demittuntur dut dUeudntur. lildribus librisq; non ferÃ¨quiequddecenter oÃendmusytdmetÃ derifuSyContemptuSyÃdÃidiu ÃgniÃedrifolet. Nrfw et cor rugdre ndref,ut Hordtiusdit^or inÃdre,t:^mouereyCr ^Â«ts. digito inquietdre,(^ mpulfu fubitoffiritu excuterc,C}-diducerc Ãepius, Cr pldUd mdnu refupmdreÃndecorum cAj cÂ« emunilio etid Ãequentior non Ãne cdufd reprehe ditur. Ldbrd,cr porriguntur mdle,c^ feMuntury^ j^^j^^^ dÃrmgunturyet diducutur,et dentes nuddnt^^ in Utus dc penÃ¨ dd durÃ© trdbuntur,Z!r uelut quoddfaÃidio repli edntur,^ pendent, (j uocem tdntu dltcrd pdrte dimit^ tuntXAmbere quoq^ ed ZT mordere deforme eÃ¼,cu etU in efÃrendis uerbis modieus eÃe eorÃ¼debedt motus.Qre enim mdgif qldbris loquendu eÃ¼yCeruicereHd oportet Ceruix. (Ãe,no rigidd dut fupind,Collum diuerfd quideÃed pdri Collum. deformitdte er contrdhitur et tenditur,fed tenfo fubeH er labor, tenudtur^ uox defdtigdtw. AfÃxum pedori

Wentum. mentum mmut ehr dm, er ^udÃ htiorem prefjb guttuYt Humen, p^-^^ Humcrorum ruro decens dUeudtio dtlt;^ conirdBi^ eÃ¼,^rcuidtur cuim ccruix, etgeftu quendii humilÃª dtlt;^ feruilem,et qudfi frdudulentufdcit, cum fe in hAUtu ddu Brachia. ldtionK,ddmirdtionK,metui fingunt, 3rdchij modernd proiedio remiÃis burner is dtq^ expUedntibus feinpro' ferendd mdiiu digit is ,cont'muos er decurrentes locos mdxime decet. kt cum Ã^cioÃus quid uleriui^ dicendu eÃ¼,utitludtSdxddt^folitudines uoci ref^ondent, expi tidtur in htus, et ipfd quodimodofe cu geÃu fundit ord Manui itÂ°*^igt;fâ*s^^'^Â°Ãgt;^^lt;lâ^^^â^truncaeffetd{iiodc debiUs uix dici poteÃ quot motui bibednt,cu penÃ¨ ipÃdm uerbo rum copu perfequdntur, b^dm cictcr.e pdrtes loquÃ©tem ddiuudut, h^ (props eR ut died) (pflt;e loquantur. An no bis poÃeimusf poUicemurf uoedmus^ dimittmus^ minde-muri fupplicdmus^ dbommdmur^ ttmemufi mterrogd' musfnegdmusfgdudium,triÃitid,dubitdtione,conÃ^io ttem,pcxnitcntiÃ,modum,copid,numerum,tempuioÃeM dlmui f NoÂ« cÂ£dÃ« concitdut? inhibent f fupplicdnt^ pro* bdut^ ddmirdtur^ ucrecunddnturfÃ¯io m demonÃrdndis K uÂ«rbo?i ^Â°^^ â^*'^ perfonis dduerbiorum dtq; pronominum ob amp;nbsp;pnonunS tment uicemf ut in tdntd per omnes gÃ«tes ndtionesq^ lin gut diuerÃtdte,bic mihi omniÃ¼ hominum eSmunis Ãermo uidedtur,Et hi quidem de quibus furn locutus,cu ipÃs uo cibut ndturdUter exeutgeÃus, dlij funt qui res mitdtioe Ãgnificdnt,ut Ã Â£gru tentdtis uends mediciÃmilitudinc, dut cithdradum formdtis dd modum percutientis ikt* uof mimbfts oÃendds, quod genus qudmlongiÃimc in i*

tiionc eft fugiendtim. Aie Ife enm plurimum Ã feiltAMC deist oreitor,ut fit gefius ad fenfui magK ^ad uerba ac eommodatui, ^Â«od etia bifirionibui paulo grauioribus facerc mor it fuit.Ergo ut ad fe manti re ferre cum de fei ffo loquatur, Cf in eumguÃ« demonfret intendere^et ali ^ua bitfimilia fermiferim,ita non effingere flatus ([wfi dam, cr e^uice^uid dicetyoflenderc^tieq; id in manibus fo lum,fed in omni gefu ac uoce feruandum eR.Hon enim AM in itta periodo: Stetit foleatm Pretor populi Ro,tu* dinatioincumbentis in mulierculam verris effngenda efi,autin iUatCeedebatur in medio foro Keffant^motus laterum,lt;piaUs effe ad uerbera folet,toreiuendus,aut uox qaalis dolore exprmitur, eruenda, Cum mibi comoedi ^uo^ pefiimefacere uideantur^qui etia fi iMicnc agat, sum tarnen in expofitione^aut fenis fermo,ut in Uydrifi prologo,aut mulierist ut in Georgo, incidit, tremula uel effoeminata uoce pronuciant. Adco in Ulis quoq^ eH ali-e^ua uitiofa imitatio, quoru ars omnis cefiat imitatione. E ft autem gefius ille maxime comunis quo medius digi'-tusin poilicem contrabitur,explicitii tribus,t:y princi' pijs utilis,cu leni in utrattef parte motu modice prolate fmulcapite ate^ bumeris fenfirn ad id qui manus feratuv olfecudantilus,e:y in narrado certusjed tupdulo pro' dudiortes-in exprobrando^cy coarguendo acer atq-, 4explor5do infans.Longius enim partibus bis er liberius exeritur. Vitiofc uero idem fmiflrum quaft bumerum petens in la tus agi folet, quanq adbuc peins aliqui tranfuerfum brat' fbiumproferuM, Ã§^ cubitopronundant. Duo qwq^ mc

dij M poUicem ucniunt, er c^l bic ddhuc priore ge^ui 'wÃdntior,principio er narrdtioni non dccommoidtutÂ» At cum trÃ¨s contrdili pollice pnemuntur, tu digitus Hit c^uo ufum optime Crdffum Cicero dicit, cxplicdri fokt. Ism exprolrdndo et mdicdndo,tmde ei nomÃª eH^udktf cr dlleudtddcj^eildntehumcrumdnupdulum mclindtui affirmÃ¢t.Ver fus 'm terra amp;nbsp;quafi pronus urget,et ft dk^ quandopra humeroeffi idemfunmoarticulautrinq;lt niter apprebenfoffiuobusmodice curudtis minus tamcit tn'inmo aptus dd diffiutandu e^.Acrius tarnen argumen tari uidentur,qui mediu drticulu potius tenent,tanto co tractioribus uhimis digit is,c^uato priores defenderut-EÃ¢ er Hie uerecudje ddioni dptiÃimus,quo quatuor pri mis kuiter 'm fummtim coÃ«untibui digitis non procul ab ore, dut peÂ£lore fertur ad nos manus, er de'mde proud dcpaululu prolatalaxatur.Uoc modo capiffieDemoÃbt nem credo 'm iUo pro Ctefipbontet'tmido demiffo^ prin cipio:fic formata Ciceronis mdnum,cum diceref.Si quidi cR 'm me 'mgenij indicÃ©s, quod fentio quarn fit exigiuu. Eodem aUquatenus liber lus deorfum ffiedantibus digi' tis eolligitur 'm os,e:Tfufius pdulÃ´ 'm diuerfa refoluitur, ut quodammodo fermonem m ipfiim proferre uideaturÂ» Emos mterim digitos diflmguimus,fed non mfertopok lice, paulum tarnen mferioribw 'mtra ffiediantibus, fed neiÃ®lisquidemtcnfisquifuprdfunt. Duo mterimextre mi palmam circa 'ma poUicis premuntjpfe prioribus ad mÃ©dias articulas iungitur,intÃ©rim quartus oblique repo nitur, 'mter'm quatuor remiÃis magis qua tenfispoUict

WfÂ«; incUn^to^hililÃ¨ in lutu demonftr(indo,dut dijUn' giundo^quf didmui, mMu fdeimtu, cum [upind in Ãni' flrum ldtut,prond in dltcru fertur. Sunt et iUibreues ge fids, cu munus leuiter pdnddtd, qudUs uomentium cA^ fouentium pdruis interudllis,et fubdlJentietibus humeris mouetur^ nidximedptd,pdrce er qudfi timide locptentibus.EÃ dd* mirdtioni conueniens iÃ¼e geÃm^c^uo minus modice fupi ndtd,dc per fingulos d minimo coUeUd digitos redeunte fiexu ftmul expUedtur dtej^ couertitur. NÃ©e uno modo in terrogdntes geflu coponmus,plerun^ tdmen uertentes Wdnum, utcun^i copoÃtd eÃ¼, poUici proximus digitus, medium^ c^ud dexter e^,w}guÃ« poUici Ãummo Ãuo iun^ gens,remiÃis c et er is,e^ er dpprobdntibus,amp; nurriti lus,et diÃinguentibus decorusSui no diÃimilis,fed co' preÃis tribus digitis, quo nunc GrM plurimu utuntur, didm utrdc^ mdnu,quotiesenthymemdtd fud gcÃu udut cornu tondunt caÃm, Hdnus lenior promittit er dfjen tdtur,citdtior hortdtur,interim Idudit.^H er iUe urges ordtionÃ« geÃus uulgdris mdgis 5 ex drte, qui contrdhit ditemo celeriq; motu,et expUedt mdnu. EÃ et iUd cdud, er rdrd,et fuprd humeri dltitudinÃ¨ eldtd,cum quodi mo tu uelut hortdtrix mdnus,d peregrinis fcholis idm pro ^ ^^^^ pÃ¨receptd.Tremuld ÃecniaeÃ^ Digitos cÃ¼ fummicoie~ vunt,dd os referre,curquibufdi diÃilicuerit,ncÃio. NS amp;nbsp;id leuiter ddmirdntes, et interim fubitd indigndtione uelutpduefcentes etdepreedntes,fdcimus. QiÃncorn-preffdmetidm mdnuminÃgnu pxnitertlt;iÂ£uclirg,pe* doriddmouemus^ubi UQXUcl inter denies expreffdnon

710 M, FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. ititeti-, Qgfd tinne dgim^ quid fdcidtit? Auerfo lattice demonjlrdre aliquid, receptu migK puto quim ordtori decorumSed cum omnis motui fex pdrtes hdbedtjepti' mui^; fit iÃ¼c qui in fe redit orHi^uitiofd eÃ¼ und circlin' uerfio,reliqui dnte nos (^ dexterd kud^, Gr furfum,Gr deorfum dliquid oÃendunt.ln poUeriord geÃusno diri* gitur,interim tarne uchit reijd folentt Optime dutem md Â»US d, finiÃrd parte incipit, in dextra deponitur, fed ut deponerenonut ferire uidedtur, qudnqudmo- inÃne interim cddit,ut cito tarnen redeat, Gr nonnunquam regt; filit ucl negantibus nobis, uel admirantibus, Hie uete' res artifices itlud rede adiecerunt, ut manus cum fenfu Gr inciperet,ct deponcret, Alioqui enim aut ante uocem erit geÃui,aut poÃ uocem, quad edutrunq; deforme, in Ulo tapfi nmia fubtilitate funt, quod interuaUum mo' tus tria uerba effe uolueru!:,quod nee obferuatur, nee fie ri poteÃ, fed illi quafÃ® menfuram tarditat is cekritatis^ aliquam effe uoluerunt, nee immerito, ne out diu otiofd effet manus, aut, quod multi fadunt, adionem continua motu conciderent.Aliud ed quod amp;nbsp;fitfrequentius, GT magis faÃ¼it. Sunt quidam latÃ«tis fermants pereuÃiones. Gr quaft aliqui pcdes,ad quos pÃ¯urimoru geÃus cadit, ut fit unusmotus, Ã¯^oMimcrimen:alter,C.CÂ£far: tertius,, Et ante hune diem: quartus, Inauditum,deinde, Propin quits meus. Et: Ad te Q^ubero detuUt. Vnde id quoique fluit uitium, ut iuuencs cum fcribunt geflu primo' dulati cogitationem fic componant, quomodo cafura ma nus fit. inde et illud uitium, ut geÃus qui in fine dexter.

iffe delet^in finiÃmmjreciuettter dÃ©finit. Mtliuf iUud, ^umfintinfermone omni ireuii qnxdim mcmlri,ii ^UÂ£ fi necejje fit,reciperc j^iritum Uccit^id hxc gejium dij^onere, utputu Homm crimenCt Clefdry habet per fe fincrnquendamfttumyCpuiii fequittirconiundio.âDeinde: Et inte hunc diem induditumyfdtiicircunferiptum f^. Ad hec commodindi minus esidd^i dum irrumpit, frit prima etcompofiti dHio.At ubi iam cdlor earn cona eitduerit,etidm gefius cum ip fa ordtionis eeleritdte cre-brefet.Alijs lads citdtd,dlijs preffd conueniet protiiina tidtio. lUdtrdnfcurrimus,congerimus, dbunddmus,fe.-liindmusydcinfidmus,inculcdmusy infigmus. PlusdUf iinfringim teafirHus habent Icntiord.ldcoq: KofeiuscititioryAeÂ« [opusgrduiorfitityquod Ole comÅdiis,hic tragoedids egit. Eidern motus cjuolt;^ obferudtio eR, Ud^ infdbu-1Â« i!tuenum,fenum,militum,meitrondrH, grduior ingref fdsest.Serui,ancÃ¼lc,pdrdfiti,pifcdtorcSyCitdtiu5 mouen tur. ToUi dutem mdnum drtifices fuprd oculos, demitti infid peUus uetdntyddeo d cdpite edm peterCydut ddmu uentremdiduccreuitiofumhdbetur. At fmiflrdmintrd humerum promouere,ultrd non decet.Sed eum duerfan-tes in leudm pdrtem uelut propeUemus mdnum, fini fier humerus prof erendus, ut cu cdpite dd dextrdmferentc confentidi. Minus finifirdnun^uimfoldreHegefiutn facit, dextre fc frequenter dccommodit, fiue in digitos drgumentd digerimus yfiuc duerfis tn ftnijlrum pdU mtsibomimmur y fiue obijcimus dduerfa ,fiue in laus utrunq^ difiendmus,fiue fdtiffidentes dut fupplicdies^

DiuerÃ funt Mtem hi geÃut, Ãue fubmittiiimt^ue iio^ rimes ittoUimuSjÃuc aU^M demojlritiom^Mt i/uuoa* tioni protedimuisVosAlbinitumuli dte^ bid. Aut Grilt;i chMm itlud:CiuÃ¶ me mifer confenrnftpio uertÃftÂ» Ci pitolium 'ne^ dt Ãdtris fdttgume redunidt, in domumi Plut enim affedus in bis iunihe exhibent minus, in rc^ bus pdruis,triflibus,mitibusjbreuesimdgnis, lÂ£tis,dtro extcriorcs cibus extenfioresfunt. Vitii quoique aru fubijcicndi funt,qufquidemdccidere etidmexercitdtis ddoribus folent. Udm geÃum poculum pofcentis, dut uerberd mi^ nintis,dutnumerum qumgentorum poUiceflexo efficigt; entK,quÂ£ funt d, quibufdi fcriptoribus notiti:, Â»^ 'm rn Aut m^.^i^ quident uidi. At ut brichio exerto mtroÃpiad* tur Idtus, ut minivm dUus uUnfinum pro ferre non du* dedt,dUus in quintum pdtet logitudo protenddt,dut ii te A urn erigdtjdut repetito ultn Ãxuum humer urn gefu iti in tergu fiigeUet, ut confrere poR eum pirmn tutu fitidut ÃniÃrum ducit orbern, iut temere^drfd munu in proximos offcnddt,dut cubitu/m utrumc^ m diuerfim Idtus uentilet,fepe fcio euenire. Solet effe^r pigrd,C!' trepidi, t^fecinti ft mild, interim uncis etidm digitis, duticipite ddjddtur,dut adem minus [upmiti 'mfu* pcrion iddetur,Pit et ide hdbitus,qui effe in Ãituis pi cificdtor foÃ¯et, qui incHndto in humerum dextrum dpi te,brdchio db dure prÂ£ten[o,mdnum infeÃo poUice ex^ tendit:qui quidem mdxime pldcet his,qui fe dicere fubli ti mdnu idAdnt..AdijcidS licet eos,qui fentemidsuibri* tis digitis iieuÃ¯inturt 4Ut minu fubliti denuncidut^^^i^

ORATOR. LIBER XL 715 (tjUodper fe interim recipiendum cR)^uoties dUquH ipfis pliicuitfin ungues cxiguntur.Sed uitiofum idfici* unt^dutdigUo f^MUto plurimum poffunt eredo, nut eti dm duoim Mt utrd^ minu ud modum dUi^uid portunti v/m compofitd. Uis uccedtmt uitid non Mtur^yfed trepi idtionis^cum ore concurrente rixarifi memorU fefeÃe rit,dut cogitdtio non [ujffdgetur,lt;^udfi fducibus dUquid oh^itcrit infondre, in dduerfum tergere ndrestoldinbu Ure fermone imperfc{io,refiliere fÃ¼bitÃ´,amp; Idudem po feere fdentio, qtiÂ£ omnid perfequi propÃ¨ infinitem ell. Suienim eniq; ftintuitid.Peilus dc uenter ne proqcidnt tur ob feruMdum.Pdndd!it enim poÃeriord,o'eil odio p omnis fupinitds. Ldterd cum geÃu confentidnt. Pdcit enim dliquid ey totius corporis motus, ddeÃ³ut Cicero plus iÃ¼o dgi,q mmibus ipfis putei. Itd enim dicit in Qrd toreÃ¯NuttiÂ« drgutic digitorum,non dd numerum drticu Iw cddens,truÂ»co mdgis toto fe ipfe moderdns,Gf uirili UterumÃexione. Pxmur ferire^quod Athenisprimus feciffe creditur Clean, er ufitdtum dl, ce indigndutes decet,zr excitdt Auditorem.ldq^ in CaÃUHo Cicero deÃ derdti'{HonÃons,mquit,percuffd,non foemur, qMnq,Ã licet,de Ãonte diÃentio. Nrfw etidmcomplodere minus fcenicum ell,et petits cÂ£dere.iUud ^Â«0$ ruro decebit, cdM manu fummis digitis pedus dppetere,Ã quddo nof metipfos dUo^uimur, cohortdntes, obiurguntes, mife^â rAntes,quoi Ã cjMndo Ãet, togdm quoefi inde remouere non decebit. IÂ« pedibus obÃeruMtur Ãdtus e}quot; meeÃus.^edts, Proldto dexter o Ãdre,amp; edndem rndnum de pedem pro yy s

ftrre,dcforme cR, IÂ« dextrwm mctimbere interim dd* tur,fed Â£lt;iuo peHore, qui tdmen comicut mdgif q ordt^ viuigejlus eU.mle etidm in finiÃrum pedeminÃÃenti um dexter,dut dttÃ³Ã¼itur,dut furnmii digitis fuÃteditur, Vdriedre Ãprd modumyZy in Ãdnda deforme eR,cr dc cedente motu propÃ¨ ohfeanum. Procurfio opportMd, breuit,moderdtd,rdrd,conuenit etidm et dmluldtio qufi ddm propter immodieM Iduddtionum mordt,qudnq Cit cero rdrum meeffum^nee^ itd tongum probdt.Difcurfd* tManlio re uero,et quad Domitius After de Surd fidnitio dixit, fdtdgere,ineptiÃimum.Vrbdneq^ PlduiusVirgmiusiÂ«* terrogduit dequoddm fuo AmfophiÃe,quot miUid pdÃ fuum deddmdlfet. Pr^cipi ^ iUud fcio, ne dmbuldntes duertdmur d iudicibu5,fed fint obliqui pedes Ad concili'' urn nobis reÃieient tbusAd fieri iudieijs priudtis non po teil. Verum O' breuiord fintÃdtid, nee duerfi diu fi* mus.Interim tdmen recedere fenfim ddtur. c^uiddm O refdiumt, quodeUpldnÃ¨ ridiculum. Pedis fupplofio ut loco eH opportund, ut dit Cicero,in contentionibus dUt indp tendis,dut finiendis,{td crebrd o inepti dl homU nis, o dÃ©finit iudicem m fe conuertere. Eli o iHd in* decord in dextrum dc Itcuum Ãdtus uiciÃ¼dtio dÃ®temis pe dibus infifientium. Longifime fugiÃ©dd mollis dHio^qM lÃªinTityo Cicerodicitfuilfe.Vndeofiltdtionisquod Tityiis. ddm genus Tityus eH dppeUdtum. Reprehendendd o iÃ¼dfrequens, o concitdtd in utrdtique pdrtem mutatio, iPrÂ«tore qu4^ jm Curione pdtre irrifit o lunius qugrens quis i/n Untre loquereturtO Sidniui. Kdm cum dfitdentecol

ORATOR. LIBER XL TU ygi,lt;lui erdt propter uiletudmem z:r deligdtut,cr pin ribui medicdmeittif propter dolorem drtuum del^u^ tm, multumfe Curio ex more iiildjjeti NuncpiAmin^ tjuitfiUduij college tuogrdtid rÃ©fÃ©rÃ©s, (lui nififuiffet, iÃhic hodie te mujclt;e comediffent. l^cluntur cr humeri, (ptod uitiam Demofthenesitd dicitur emenddjje,ut cu/m ^^gttÃo c^uodim pulpito fluns diceret,hdftd humero de^ pendens immineret, ut fi cdlore dicendi uitdre id excigt; diffet,offÃ¨nfdtioneiÃ¼dcommoneretur. Ambuldiitem loÂ» ^ui itd demu oportet,fl m eduÃs public is, in (^uibus fiMt multi iudices,(iuod dicimus, (puft Ãngulis meukdre pc* euUdriteruelimus. lÃlud uerorefeÃ¼endwtn,(iuodpib ^nonreh' idm reieHd m humcrum togd, cimt dextrdÃnwm ufque Â«Ki Ijmbos reduxerumt, ut ÃniÃrd geÃuM fdeletes,Ã^uti futur (^fdbulÃ¨tur, cum etidm hud reÃringere proldtd logins dextrdÃt odiofum. Vnde moneor ut ne id quidÃ« trifedm meptiÃime fieri,cum inter mords Iduddtionum, dut in durem dUcuius loeptuntur, dut cum foddlibus io* edmur, dut nSnuneptdm dd librdrios fuos itd ref^idunt, ut j^ortuldm did ure uidedntur, inclindriddiudicem cum doceds,utcpÃ id de cjuo locpidris fit obfeuriut decet. incumbere dduoedto dduerfis fubfellijs fedenti contume Uofum cA. Rechniri etidm dd fuos (y^ minibus fuÃine* ri, niÃ plunÃ¨ iuÃd fitigdtio eÃ, delicdtum,ficut pdldm ffatigatiÃ¶Â« moneri excidentis,iut legere.^dncpie in bis omnibus et uis iÃ¼d dicendi foluitur, e^frigefdt ijfidlus, er iudex pdru/m fibi pr^eÃdri reueremix credit. Trdnfire m dl* wrfd fubfeUid pdru/m uerecundum eH.^dm cy CdÃiui

Seuerut urbane diuerfut hoc fdeientes Imedm popofeit* Et fl dUc^Mndo cocitdte itur^ nun^ non frigide rediturÂ» Mukd ex bis ^ug prÂ£cepmuf, mutdri neeeffe eH db bit ^ui diciwt dpud tribunaUd.KA ar uultui ereÃ¢ior ut eu

dpud lt;juem diciturf^eÃ©let,^ gefiia,ut dd ewndem ten* dens eldtior fÃ®t,neeeffe eÃ¼,Qr dUd ejug occurrere etiant me tdcente omnibus poffunt. Item^ db bit (pii fedentes dgentÃ^dm or ferÃ¨ fit hoc in rebm minoribui,o- ijdem

impetui dHionis effenonpoffivnt^etipigddmuitid funt neceffdrid. Ã¼Aet dexter pes Ã IgUA iudick fedentis pro ferendui eR,Ã§r ex dlterd parte multi geÃiu neceffe eÃ in ftniÃram eant, ut ad iudieem ff citent. Eejuidern pk* tofff CT dd fingulaa cÃ¯aufulM fententiarum uideo affut gentes ftbi,cr nonnuUos fubinde alipiid etiamffitian* ta,quod an deceat ipÃ uider'tnt,civm idfdciiint,no fedÃ© tes agunt.Eibere,aut etia effe inter agendum,quod mul tis morisfuit, c^ eH quibufddm,ab oratore meo proeul dbfit.Uam fi quit aliter dieÃ«di oneraperferre non pof* fit,non ita miferum eA non agere, potius^ multo quant t::r Operis er hommu contemptum fateri.Cultut non eÃ fin ora P^^P^t^ orator is ali quit, fed magis m oratoreconffi citur.Qjiarc fit (ut in omnibusboneÃis debet effe) fflen

diduser uirilis. i^amet togd,er calceus,et capiUus,tdm nimid curd,q negligentia funt reprehendenda. eA ali* quid in amiAu,quod ipfum aliquatenus tempor urn con* ditione mutatam eAgt; tiam uetcribus nukifinus, perqua breues poA ittos fuerunt. Uaque etiam geÃu neceffe eA ufm effe in priwipijs eoi dio, quorum brachium fet^-

Crucorumuejle contincidtur, Sednosdeprifemibwi loquimur. Cui Idti cldui itu non eritjtd c'mgdtur,ut tuni CH priorihm oris infrd genud pdulamt poflerioribus di tnedios poplitÃ©s ufque peruenidM. b^dm mÃ-d mulierum esljuprd Centurionu, Vt purpurn reÃ¤e defcendant^le uis curd esl.Uotdtur mterim negligentid.Ldtum hdben tium cUuum modus dl^utfit pdulum cmÃ¼is fubmiÃion Ipfdm togdm rotiwdd clfe,0- dpte Åfdm uclim. Aliter enimmultis Modis fietenormis. Fdrseius prior Medijs eruribus optime termindtur, poÃerior ediem portione dltius 5 cmdurd.Sinus dccemiÃimus/i dliquinto fuprd mAm togd fueritgt;niiM^ certe fit inferior.lUe qui fub hU Mero iextro'di finiÃrusn oblique ducitur,uelut bdlteuSf ^ec Ãrdngulet, nee fluit. Pdrs toglt;e quiie pofled imponiÂ» ^'^âfit mferionndm itd e^- fedet melius, er continctur, ^i*bducendd etidm pdrs dliqui tMticÂ£,ne dd ideertum in *^u rededt,tum finus mijciedus l)UMero,cuius extremÃ ^eimreiccijje no dedecet.Operiri dut humer urn ewm to ^Â° iugulo non oportet. Aliotpii dmiHu flet dnguflus,et ^amiftÂ» gef ^âgnitdtem quÂ£ eR in Idtitudine pedoris perdet â¦ Smit anguftior firum brdchiiim eouf^ dUeuindum ed, utqmfi normd* ^^M ilium dngjilÃ fdcidt,fuper quoi ord ex togd duplex ^quiliter fededt.Minus non impledtur dnulis,prÂ£cipue Medios drticulosnon trdnfiwtibus ,cuius er it habitus Optimus, dUeuitO poUice et digitis leuiter inflexis,nifl ft hbeUum tenebit,quod non utilt;^ cdptdndiim td.Videtur ^nimfAteri memoriit diflidemiiyCt dd multos ge fused ^pedimÃªto.TogA ueteres dd cdlceos itfq^ demittebdntf toÃ©^

Kt Gr^ci pillium.Ã¯d^ ut jut, qui degeÃu fcripferut cif Cd tepom iJllt;i,Plotius t^igidim^ prxcipiur.t.CiUo md^ pjs miror Plinij Scewtdi dodi hominK,zy 'm hoc uti^ U bro pens etu nimium ettrioft perjiufione^fpÃ¤folitum Ã¼ fitcereCicerone ueldnddrum {UricugrÃ¤ticttrddit,cum hoc dmiditt gcmi4 'm ÃdtUK eoru ciuolt;^,qni pod Cicero ncmfuertmt,dppdredt. PdUioluÃeut fdfeiM quibm ern rd ueÃiwntur,cr foedUdtO- durium ligdmctdjoldtxcu fdre poteÃ udlctudotSÂ£d hÂ£c dmidui obÃrudtio,du 'm^ cipimut, procedenteuero ddu idm penÃ¨ ab âmitionarri tionifÃnuf db humero rede uelutj^onic deldbitur,et ei ad drgumÃ«td a.c locos uentu ed,reijcere d ÃniÃro togi, deiÃere etil Ã hiercdt,Ãnâdm eSueniet. Lxna, dfducibus defummo pedoreabducere licet. Ardent enim idm old, tttrntuox uchementior dc mdgisuArided,Ãc amidtÂ« quo^i habet ddum eptendam uelut praliantÃ«. Ua^ ut la udm muoluere togd^zy imngi,penÃ¨ farioÃm eÃ/mum uero 'm dextrum humer u,ab 'imo reijeere^ folutum dede licdtiM eÃfiunt^ ddhuc peius dliqudÃtd cur IdxiorÃ« Ã^ ttvjtn ÃniÃro brachio non fubijeiamus ^ Habet enim acre quidda dtq; expeditu, er cdloricocitdtioni^ nonâmhda bile.Cttm uero magnd pdrs edexhauÃd orations,utiq-ajÃinte forttwa penÃ¨ omnid decent, fudor ipfe CT fati^ gdtio,cr negUgentior amidus, er folutd ac uelut lobÃ©s imdicÃ togd, duo magismiror hanc quoeÃ fuccurriÃe Plmio curdm,ut ita fuddrioÃontem Ãccdriiuberet,ne co fnlt;e turbdrcntur,qudscomponipod pdulwm,Ãcutdi* gp^erdt^grduiterer [euere uetuit.Mihiuero lÃ¼t quo*

5Â«Â« turbdtjeprig fe ferre illiquid dffvHui.et ipfd olUuib tie cur it huim commeddri uidentur. At fi mcipieinibuf, dut pdiilum progrefit deciddt togd, non reponcre edm prorfuf ncgligcntrs dut pigri,dut quo modo debedt dmi cm nefdentis cÃ.H^c funt uel iUujlrdmentd pronuncid tionii.Kcl uitid, quibui propoftis multd cogitdre dÃ©bet ordtor. Prinmm quid:,dpudquos,qtiibMprlt;tfentibui iquis fit dilurui.Ã¼dm ut diccre dUd dijs^or dpud dUos mdgis conceffum eÃ¼,Ãc etidmfdeere. Uec^ eddem in uoce,ge* Ãu,inccjfu,dpud principe,fendtum, populum,mdgiÃrdiâ ttm,priudto,publico iudicio,pofluldtione, ddionefmU liter decet, Qudm diffÃ¨re nd dmfubijeereftbi quiflt;^ qui dn'mum mtenderit,poteff,tum quddere dicdt,O' effice ce quid uelit.Rci quadruplex obferudtioeÃ.Vnd in totd cMÃ^ Sunt enim triffes,l)Hdres,folicitie,fecurie, grdnt â^es,pufiU.e,ut uix unqudtn itd [oUcitdri pdrtibut edrum ieoctimuSjUt non fummi memmerimm. Alterd quit eft $Â» differentid pdrtiam, ut in proamio, ndrrdtione, dr^ gumcntdtione,epilogo, rertid in fenternqs ipfis,in qui busfecwndim res et dilut udridutur omnid-Ã^udrid m affeflui uerbi!,quoru ut eff uitiofd,fi efficere omnid uelimut,inii tiÃ¼io, itd quibufddm nifffud ndturd redditur, uit omnis dufertur.lgitur in lduddtionibut(Â»ifi ft funÃ¨bres erunty grdtidru dilionc,exhortdtione,ftnilibus^ Utd er md^ gnifed zy fublimis eH dHio. Punebres condones,confo Utiones,plerwnlt;^ cdufx reorum, tribes dc fubmiffe. In feiidtu conferuindd dutoritis, dpud ^ulwm dignitMi inpriudtis modus â¦ DepdriibuscAu[Â«,z7 fententqu

710 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT, ucrbiiq;,(luÂ£funtmultipUcid, pluribus dicedum, TrU Me prÂ£Ãdre debet pronuncidtiOjeoncilietfperfuddedt, moucdt,quibM ndturd cohitrety ut etid dcleilet, Cond' Udtio fere dut comenddtione moru,(^ui nefeio^quo modo ex uoce ettS, dtlt;^ dilione pcHuccnt,dut ordtionii fuduitd te conÃdt. Perfuddendi uÃ¹ djfeuerdtione, qua intet bn pluiipftsprobdtiombiaudlet: An iÃd (inquit CaUidio Cicero) ft uerd ejfent,ftcdte dicerentur^z^tTdntu dbd eÃ,ut infldmdres noÃros dn'imos,fomnum iÃo loco nix te nebdmm.Pidutid igitur dppdredt,Qr conÃdntid, utiq; Ã dut or itds fubeÃ. Houendi dutÃ« rdtio^dut in reprcfentin dis cil,dut mitdndis iffÃ¨dibus. Ergo eu iudex in priui tis,dut prÂ£co in pubUcis dicere de cdufd iufferit, leniter confurgendu,tum in ebponendd togd, uelfi neceffe erit, etidm ex integro mijdendd, duntdxdt in iudicijs (dpud pfmcipemenimGrtndgiÃrdtusdctribimdlidnb licebit) pdulu eÃ¼ commordndu, ut cr dmidus fit decentior, er protmus dliquid Ã^dtij dd cogitdndÃ¼.Etid cum dd indicÃ© nos conuerterimus, Oquot; confuÃ¯tus permiferit dicere, non protmus eA erumpendum,fed ddndd breuis cogitdlioni mordMire enm nudituru^diAuri curd deÃ¯c(tdt,er iu' dexfe ipfecoponit.Ã¼oc prÂ£cipit Homerus V lyÃii exÃ©* plo, quem Ãeti/fe oculis 'm terrddefixis,tminotoq^ fee* ptro,priufqud iUdm eloquent proceed effunderet, di' cit.Ã¯n bdccunildtionefunt quÂ£dd non indecentesut (dp peÃ¯ldnt fcenici) morÂ£:cdput mulcere,mdnum intuerifm' fringere drticul^^,fimuldre condtu,fuffirdtionefoliciM dinem fdteri, dut quad quenq^ mdgis decet^ co^ diutim

ORATOR. LIBER XI. 721 [âliudcxnondumintcdit Ã¢nimum.StAtwfltrcÃ©lu^^tet^M Gâ diduili pdulum pedes, uel procedens mmmo finb J,â^^â¢â ^er,geniu, reda/ic tdmen ut non extendatur. Bumeri femiÃi,u'nUM feuerus^on maÃiu,nec Ãapens^nec Un* guidas, ^rdchia 4 Utere modice remota,mdnus finiÃra, ^Udlem fupra demonÃrMi, dextra cum Urn Ãncipicdim erit,pduluvn proUta ultra fmum,geÃu qiummodeÃiÃi* Ma,uelut expends quando mcipiÃ«dum Ãt. VitioÃi enim fwnt iUd, mtucri lacunar id, perÃ-iedre fadem, er quaÃ improbamfacere, tenderc confidentia uultum, aut quo Ãt ma^is toruus,fupercilijs dÃringere,cdpiUos d fronte eomrd ndturam retro dgere,ut Ãt horror iÃ¼e terribilis, tun id quod GradÃ-equentiÃine fadivnt,crebro digi* torum labiorum^ motu commemdri,clare excredre,pe demdlterum lange pro ferre, partem toga finiÃrd tene retire diduÃ¤um, uel rigidum, uel fupwurn, uel meur* num,uelhumeris,ut ludaturi folent, ad oedpitium du* ^Kâ Proamio ÃequentiÃime lenis conuenit pronuncia tio.BihileU enim ad condUandum gratius uerecundia, non tarnen femper. Nee enim umo modo diewtur exor dia,ut docui. Plerumlt;^ tarnen er uox temperdtd,ic ge* Ãus modeÃus, CT fedens humero toga, zy laterum lenis in utranc^ partem motus,eodem f^edamibus oculis,de* ^projjtun, cebit, Barratio magis prolatam manum,dmidwm red manu ami-dcBiem, geÃu/m diÃindwm, uoeem fermoni proximam, ^^â de tantum apâ¬rtiorr:m,fonivmÃmplicemÃ-equentiÃiiM uoeem,(er-â poÃulabitm his durtdxat:Ci.igitur Ligarius,cum effet quot;âÂ®quot;â *ââÂ®ââ* adbucnulU beÃ¼ifuffido,Ã§r A.Cluentim Habitus pater tT^riorem 2z

huiufce. Aliud in e^dÃª pofcent affiÃ©lut uelconcititi.t^^ bitgrnerofocrm^uel ÃebUes. ConÃmitur in foro L^to* dictie I^eddculum dcerbum (^ miferum toti AÃe pro^ nincie.M.dxme Mrid amp;nbsp;multiplex dHio cR probdtic'' Â»um. Nil proponere,pdrtm,interrogdre,fcrmoni [uni proxmd,Z!r coutrddifiionem furnere. Ndm ed qÂ«o$ H uerfd propoÃtio eÃSed hec tdmen dlieludndo irridetes, dHqudndo imitdniespronucidmuÂ«. ArgumÃ¨tdtio plerun f^tte dgilior,ty dcrior,cr inÃdntior,conÃ;ittieMem ord tioni poÃuldt etUm geÃum^id eÃfortem celer itdiÃ«, inÂ» Ãdndum quibufddm in pdrtibut,O' denÃndd ordtio.E'' greÃiones ferÃ¨ lenes i er dulces, er remiffe, ut rdpttn proferpuhe,SiciliÃ« defcriptio,Cn. Pompeijiciu.tÃ¹cc^iie *'*^ enm inirum,miniK bdbere contentionis ed ^uefunt ex trd i^ueÃionem.NioUior nonnwn(^uim cum reprebenÃu ne dinerfe pdrtis imitdtio: videbdr uidere dlios intmn tes,dlios dut cxeuntes,(iuofddmexuino udcilldittes.'Vbi non diÃidens 'd uoce permittitur geÃus,dt quo^ in uw que pdrtem tenerd quedAm, fed intrd niAnus tAmen, tj fine motu lAterum trAnÃdtio. Accendendi iudicis plures funtgrddus. Summus ide, er quo nuUus eR in orAtore Acutiort Sufeepto bedo Cefdr, geÃo iem etiArn ex pArte mAgnA.Predixitenim : Ci^diitum potero uoce content dem,ut populus bec KomAnus exdudidt.PAulum mferit or,Gr hdbens Aliquid etidm iucunditdtist Qt^d enim tu us ide Tubero in Acie PbArÃUcA glAdius AgebAt^ PleniÂ«' us Adbuc zy lentias, ideo^i dulcius: In coetu uero PopuU Ko,negotium publicum gerens, ProducendA omniA tru

ORATOR. LIBER XL ^i^ ^ndi^ turn uocaks,dpericndlt;e^ funt fauces,pleniore timen h^c edmUfiuumt-.Vos Albdni tumuli dt^ lud.iiSi tdntici epuidddm hdlgt;ent,fenfimqi refupindfunt.Sdxd dt que foUtudmes uod refpondent. Tdks fumt itti mclindfÂ» tionesuodi, qud( inuicem'DemoÃhenesdt^ Aefchmes fxprobrdnt, non ideo improidndte, Cum enim uter^ue dteri olgt;ijddt,pdldm cll utrunepue fedjje. Kdm neq^ iUe per Mdrdthonis cr Pldtedru, O' Sdldmink propugndÂ» tores redo fono iurduit, nee bic Thebds fermone deÃet dt.Ed bis dinerfdttox,et penÃ¨ exirdorgdnum^cuiGrÂ£ ei nomen dmdritudinis dederMtt,fuprd tnodimt depend Uiturdm uods burndnt dcerbd. Qwn cempefdtis uo'' tem iÃdmmdicemÃultitiie, teÃem prduitdtis. Sed id ^dâ txcederemodu/m dixi,m idd pdrteprimdeÃ,Qum com pe[dtis.Epilogus,Ã enumerdtionemrerimt bdbet, dfÂ« *Â®8Â®** Ãierdt epunddm condforum coiumudtionem:fi dd ton'Â» titindos indices eÃ dccommoddtus,dÃ¯i(piid ex bis quie Ãt prd dixit Ã pldcdndos mclindtdm quanddm lenitdtemfi mifericordilt;i commouÃ¶dos,Ãexim uods oÃebikm fud uititem.qud prlt;ecipue Ã-dngwntur dnkni, tjUit^ ed rnd^i xime ndturdlis. i^dm etia, orbos uiduds^ uideM in ipÃs funeribus ednoro quoddm modo predimdntes.Uie etit cinifuÃd iUd uox,SpÃ¼lern CiceroÃiiffe m Antonio dicit, mire fdciet.Udbet enim in Ã s^uod imitemur.'Dupkx eÃ timen miÃerdtio, dltcrd cum muidia, ^mlis modi didd de ddmndtione Pbiloddmi,dlterd cum depreedtione de* miÃior. coudre didÃ eil in ilUs quoc^ edntus obÃcurior, 1Â« catu nero populi Kom-lilonenim beec rixdntis modo

dixit^Ori'Vos Albani tumuli. Nc^j enim (juafi inclamt^ teftarctur f^f.^ dut dtteftaretur locutus cR, tdmtn mfinito md^is

iUd Ãcxd er cirewrndudd Ãint:Me miferum,me mfelicÃª. EttCiuid rej^odebo liber if meisterâ. Keuocare tu me in pdtridm potuiÃi lAilo per hos,ego te in ende pdtrid per eoÃem retinere no poterofEt cum bond C.Kdbirij uno feÃertio addieit 10 meum miferu deerbum^ prÂ£coniu, ilid lt;juolt;p mire facit in peroratione uelut deficientif do lore, erfatigatione confefio, ut pro eodem mUonaSei finis Ãf.neq; enim prie lachrymis id loqui poffm. Qtii^ fimUemuerbis habere debent etiam pronunciationein, Poffunt uidcri alia quoque huius partit atlt;^ offeÃreos excitare,puerosdttoUere,propinquosproducere,uefies laniare,fedfuo loco diila funt.Et quid in partibmeauÃ etiam alijs eÃ udrietas/atis apparet accommodanda jin tÃ¨tijs ipfis pronivncidtionem,ficut oÃedmus.Sed uerbis quoq;,quod nouifiimedixeram,non femper,feddliquan fAt do. Annonhiecmifelluserpauperculus,fubmijfdateÃ clatio contrdcla: Sortis,er uehemens,er ldtro,ereila er co citatd uocedicenda funt i Acceditenim uis er propriet tax rebui tali dÃipuldtionei qux nifi ddfit,aliud uox,ali udanimus oÃendat. Quid^quodeademuerbdmutata pronuncidtioneindicditt,afifirmdt,exprobranf,negaiif, tnirdiuur, mdignantur, interrogdnt,irrident, eleuanti nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1

gni. Et: Cantando tu illume Et: Tud ndUeAenedst Et:Meq;timoris ArfftetuDran^ ce. Et ne morer,mtra fe quif^,Hel hoc^uel aliud quoi

Kokt, per omnes ijfeHut uerfet, uerum effÃ¨ quoi dieb nia fcietlt; Vtfjm idm hit adijciendum c^t, cum prlt;tcipue w ddione j^eHetur decorwm, fepe Aliud dUos decerct Eft enim Idtens ^uedum m hoe rutio, cz menArrAbiUs, Â®*âââ*quot;* CZ ut nere diHum eilt cAput effe ArtK decere quad fuel A^/td id nee fine Arte eÃe, nee totim Arte trAdi poteH^ ÃÂ« quibufdAnt uirtutes non hAbÃªtgrAtiAm,iÂ» quibufdAm ^itiA ipfd dekdAnt.MAximos Azores cotnoediArum De netrium Gr StrAtoclem plAcere diuerÃs uirtutihut uidi nta. Sed illud minus mirum,quod Alter dcos^etiimmcs, amp;nbsp;bonos pAtreSyferuos^t Gr mAtronM^et grAues Anus optime. Alter Acres fenes,cAUidos feruos,pArAfitos,leno tits,Gr omniA AgitAtoriA melius. Tcuit enim nAturA di* agitatiora uerfA.tÃ¼Am uox quoq^ Demetrij iucundior, illius Acrior ent.AnnotAdr mAgis proprietAtes, qune trAnsferri no poter AM,mAnus iAd Are,Gr dulces exclAmAtiones theAgt;

tri cMfA producere,Gr m^ediendo uentum concipe'. egrediÃ©do re ueUe,^ nonunq dextrolAterefAceregeftus,quod ne nmÃª aUu prÃªter DemetriÃ¼ decuit. Ã¯^Ani^ in hiecomniA ^AturA Gr mir A fj^ede AditMAbAtur.iÃ¼iimcurfus Gr Agi litiis,Gr uel pArum conueniens per font rifus,quem non ignArus rAtionis populo dAbAt, gt cotrAdA etium cerui chU: quiequid hortim Alter feciÃet,fcediÃimum uidere tw, Qg4re norit fe quislt;^,nec tAMum ex commumbus pTAcepttSyfed etidm nAturA fuA cApiAt conftlium formAn dt Adionls. Ueque illud tAmen ed neÃM,ut Aliquem uel omniA uel plurA deccAnt. Uuius quo^ loei cIauJuIa fit eA dem neeeÃe cd,quit cAterorum eÃ regnAre mAxme ma

diM.Nott enim contoedum eUeJed oratorem uolo.Qud re nee in geÃu perfe^uemur omnes argutitu, nee tÂ» lo* quendo diÃm^lionibM, temporibus, e^Ã³iionibut mokt lx EunuÂ«- ft^ utenmrjafifitm Ãem dicend'j,mt Quid igitur fdd Â«â¢âÂ«ââ¢ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;dinCno edm^ne nunc quidemt Cum dccer[or uitrol dn po

tim Ã¼d me compdrem. Now perpeti meretricum concur meUdt^llic enim dubitdtionis mords, uocis flexut,udri* M munufydiuerfos nutin dUor ddhibebit. Aliud ordtio Ãpit, nee unit nmium effe conditd * Amone enim con^ Ãdt,non imitdtione. Qudrenon mmerito reprebendi^ tur pronuncidtio mlt:uofd,etgeÃiculdtionibut moleÃd, er uods mutdtionibui refultdns. Nfc inutiliter ex GrÃ Ã bonis cif ueteres trdnÃulerunt, quod db hit fumptum temÂ» fiocofain popiliuÂ«poÃit,cffe hdnc motiofdmdHionem, Optime igitur idem,^ui omnid Cicero prÂ£ceperdt,clugfuprd ex Ordtorepofui. Quibiu fimilid in Bruto de M.. Antonio dicit. Sed idm receptd eÃ¼ ditto pdulÃ dgitdtiar, er idm exigitur^Oquot; t^uibufddm pdrtibuf conuenit, itd tdmÃ« tem perdndd, ne dum dUoris cdptcunus elegdntidmi perdde-muf uiri boni er grduis dutoritdtem.

B N T V M eft dJ pdrtem operisl-ius â diffi' ieÃmÃ¤ti longe grMiÃimdm.CuiM ef^uidem onui ^ Ã tdittum opmionc primd concipere potuifJentyqMnto me premi ferens fentio, mdturiut

pK^or omittÃ«di qus promiferdm tenuit^mox epidnq per fngulds quotji pdrtesldior crefceret, ne perderem ([UÂ£ idm effÃ¨dd erdnt, per omnes difficuUdtes ditimo meÃt* Ãentdui. coudre numequolt;^ Ucet mdioriqudm umqud ^^âJÂ®^^ Woleprentdr, tdmÃ« profficienti finem mihi conÃitutum les premat fft ud deÃcere potiat qudm defferdre. Â¥efeUit dutem, gwod initium i pdruis ceperdinui,mox uelut durd folici* tinte prouedi longius^dnnii tdntu notd iUdiOquot; phriÃ^ ttamen AÃ¯tium feriptoribuf trdditi pritcipimus inec ddhuc Ã littore procul uidebdmur, cr multos cired uelut ijfdÃ« fe tiemis credere dufos hibebimus. Hm cum eloc^uendi n* tionem nouiÃime repertdm,pduciÃimis^ tentdtdm im Irtcitatani greÃi furnus, rdrutquiidmproculdportureceÃiffety reperiebdtur. PoÃi^uAm uero nobis lUe, quem inÃituebd mut ordtor,d dicendi mdgiÃris dimiÃus^ dut fuo idm 'm petufertur,dut mdiordfibi ciuxiUd ex ipÃs fdpiÃ«tix pe Â«Â»â'* netnlibut petit, | in dltu fimut dbldti,fentire cap'mtut. Tienne cxlijMundi^i t^ iwdiq^ pontut. Vnum modo 'm Ex Vergil. idi mmenfd uiÃitdtc cernere uidemur M.j:'uÃ¼ium,qui tdmen ipfe quimuis tdntd Hq; itd 'mÃruUd ndue hoe md re ingreffui,contrdhit ueld, inhibetÃ remos, zydeipfo demwm genere dicendhquoÃtufurusperÃÃ¤ut ordtor^

fdtis hAbet dicere.AtnoÃrA temmtM etidm morts ei co MiUur ddrCjZr aÃignxbit officidAti nee Anteccdeittem confequi poffumus, ey logna eundim eH.Vt resferet, probdbiUs timen enpiditM honeÃorum, lt;y tutioris Alt* dAciÂ£ eR tentAre^quibus pArdtior ueniA eSl^

S it ergo nobis orAtor,lt;iuem inÃituimits, is qui Ã M-Citone Ãniturjuirboniadicediperitus. Verum id quod ty iUc pofuit prius, er ipfu nAturA potius Ac mi* iuf eH.utiq; uir bonus,id no co tAntum, ut Ã uis iÃA di cendi mAlitiAm inÃruxerit,nihil Ãt publicis priuAtis^ re bus pernicioÃus eloquÃ«tiA,nos^ ipÃ qui pro umli pArte quotl conferre Aliquid Ad fAcultAtÃ« dicendi conAti fumus,peÃi me mereAmur de rebus huminis, Ã Utroni compAremM h^c ArmA,no miUtiQuid de nabis loquorf Kerum ipÃ Â»AturA ineaquad prÂ£cipuemdulÃffe homÃ¯niuiietur, quo(^ nos Ã Ceteris AnimAlibus ÃepArdffe, non pArens, fed nouera fuerit,Ã ficultAtem dicendi,fodAm fceleru, AduerÃminnoeentiXfhoÃem ueritAtisinuenit. Mutos enm nAfci, or egere omni rAtione futius fuiffet, quÃm prouidentumumerA in mutuAm perniciem conuertere. Longius tedithoc iudicium meumtNe^ enim tAntum id dico,eum qui fit orAtor,uirum bonu/m effe oportereffed ne futurum quidem orAtorem,nifi uirum honum. Num certe net^ intelUgetiAm concefferis his,qui propofitA ho cum '^^(^^^â^ ^ turpium uiA,peiorem fiqui milintmeq; pru dentium qui in grAuif mAS frequenter legum, femper wromAheconfeientisepanASA [emetipfis improuifo re

yÂ« exitu Muintur. Qttoi ft nemine inilunt effc nifi jlul turn euniem,non moio i fipientibiu didtur, fed migo 5Â«o^j fempcr cR creditZ, certe non fet unq fuUut ord* tor.Adde quodne fudio i^uidÃ¨ optrii pulcherrmi uticd re nuns,nifi otbus uitijs Uber a poteÃ,PritÂ»u (juod m eo^ den pedore nulUi ed honeÃorum turpiunc^ confortiZ, amp;nbsp;cogitdre optimafmul amp;nbsp;deterrmix, non mugis eft wins dnimi,^ eiufdem hots bonZ effe de mdlum.Tum iZd qÂ«o^ ex ciufd^ejuod mente tdntte rei intentÃ© uocdre 01Â» bus dijs etid culpd cdrentibus curis oportet.Ã¯td demum enim Uberd, de totd nuUd diÃrmgente dte^ dUci ducente edufdj^eddbit id folumdi lt;juod deemgitur. Quod ft torporZ nimid curd, et foUcitior rei fdmiUdris diligÃ«tid, er uendndi uoluptds,er ddti Ã^eddeuUs dies,multZ Ãu^ dijs duferunt (buic enim rei pÃ©rit tempus c(Â«odcM$ dite â¦ agrorum ri ddtur) ejuod putdmus fddurds cupiditdtÃª,dudritid,in uididm^ qudrZ mpotentiÃm^ cogitdtionesfomnos etÃ¼ ^P^os, er iÃ¼d per quietÃ« uiÃd perturbunt. Nihil ed enim tdm occupdtZ,tdm multi formeJtot de td udrijs dÃvdibus eoneifum Mq; Idcerdtum^q mdld mens.Ndm et cm mftdid tur j^e, curis y Idbore dijirmgitur, eir idm cumfcelerk compos fuerit,[olicitudine, poenitÃ«tid,poendrum omniZ expeddtione torquetur.. Quis inter hÂ£c literis, dut uZi bonte drti locusi no herde mdgis q Ãugibus in terrd fen pra tibwic rulÂ»Â» occupdtd. Age, no dd pferendos Ãudioru Idbores necefdridfugdlitds ? Quid ergo ex libidine de luxuridj^ei^ Non prtecipue dcuit dd cupiditdtemliterd rundnor lundis i NZigitur mdlis ImudÃ© curÂ£ putdmusf

J4m hoc quit non uidet^mixmÃ partem orMionis iÂ« fM Ã©lu Â£(iui honig; conÃÃere ^ Dieet 'ne de hK/ecunduif' litdin rerum dignitdtem ntdlm digue iniguus ^ Denig; ut mdximd pdrtem guÂ£Ãionie eximdm,demiu id gdânul* lo modo fieri potefi^dÃ« ingen!j,ftudij,do(irtnÂ£,peÃimo dt^ optimo uiro, uter melior dieetur ordtor t nimirum gui homo guog; melior. NoÂ« igitur ungudm mdlus idem homo, zy perfeÃ©lus ordtor. NonenimperfcÃ©tumguieg guo melius eA dliud, Sed nc more Soerdtieoru nobifmet ipfis re/fionfum finxifie uidedmur, fit dliguis ddeÃ con' trd ueritdtem objlmdtiu, ut dudedt dicere eodÃ« mgehio, fiudio, doÃ©lrmd prÃ©ditÂ» nihilo dÃ©tÃ©riorent futuru ord' toremmdlum uirum g bonum.Conuinedmus huiusguo' gue dmentidm-Ndm hoe eerte nemo dubitibit, omnem â f' fQrationem gy^fof^ffj jj^ dgcre,ut iudici guÂ£ propofitdfuerintgt;uerd cr honeftduidednturt Vtrum igitur hocfdcilius bonus uirperfuddebit,dn mulus^Bonus guidem er dieet fÂ£pius uerd dtg; honefid. Sed didfi guida dliguo duÃ©lusoffiao (guod dccidere,ut mox docebinius,potefi) fdlfiohxe dffir mdrecondbitur, mdiore cu fide neeeÃe eÃ¼ dudidtur. At mdlis hominibus ex contemptu opmionis, o- ignordtii reÃ©li nonnung excidit ipfd ftmuldtio.Ã¯ndc immodefie^pd ponunt,fine pudore dffirmdnt.Seguitur in his guie certu cA effici non pofie,deformis pertindcid et irritus Idbor, Nd ficut m uitduid in cdufiis guog; jfies improbds hdbÃ«t. freguenter dutem dccidit, ut his didm uerd dicentibus fides dÃ©fit,uidedturg; tdlis dduoedtus mdlecdufic drgU' mentum. Nune de his dicendu eH, gue inihi gudfi cong^if

Ydtionc quxdlii'dlgirfclxmxrL uidentur. Ondorcrgd âDemQjihenesnofiÃ¼t^AtqmaliluirÃ¼iiccepimus.'tioCice^ rof xtqui huius quo^ mores multi reprci}enderut,Quid^^p^^^^^^l^t dgA Æ mAgni re^onfi muidix fuheundd, mitigandg funt prius dures.Mihi enim nee Demollhenes tdm grdui moA rum dignus uidetur muidid, ut oio. quie in eum db urnicis (ongejld funt credi^cu et pulcherrtd eins in republia co fiUd^et fine uitÂ£ cldru legÃ.Ã¼ec Mi.^ulUo defuiffe uideo m uUd pdrte duis optimi uoluntdtÃ«. Teflimonio eft dUus nobiUÃime cofuhitus, integer rime prouindiddminifirti td,zs' repudidtus uigfittiuirdtus^cr ciuilibus bellis, quÂ£ in ittdte eius grduiÃimd inciderunt, neq^ffie, nc^ metu dtclindtus dnimus, qua minus optimised eil, reipubliea feiungerct.Pdrufortis uidetur quibufddiC^uibus optime refj^odit ipfe,non fe timidu in fufdpiendis,fed m proui-dendis periculis,(fil probduit morte quoq^ ipfidj^uH pra jldntiÃimo fufeepit dnimo. Quod fi de fuit bis uirisfum mi uirtus,fic quÂ£rcntibus,dn ordtores fuerint, ref^on^ debo quorno Stoici,fi interrogentur,dn fdpiÃ©s Zeno, dn Cledntes,dn Cbryfippus,ipfi rejfodeint, mignos qdem illos de uenerdbiles,non tdmen id quod ndturd hots fum' numhibet^confecutoStt^d Oquot; Pythigonsnon fdpientÃ« fe,ut qui dnte eu fuerunt,fed fiudiofum fdpientiÂ£ uoedri uoluit. Ego tdmenfecundu commune loquendi confuctn dinÃ¨fÂ£pe dixi,dicdm^ perfeHÃ¼ ordtorÃ© eÃe Cicerone^ Ut dmicos zy bonos uiros,et prudetiÃmos diemus uni-go,quoru nihil nifi perfede fdpienti ddturSed eum pro prie,zy ad legÃ« ipfimucrititis loquendu ene,eum quie*

wm ordtoretn,ciuÃ« o- iÃ¼e i^mrebM.quMq enint ÃetiffÂ« eum infdfligio eloquentie fdteor,dc uix quid ddijci fO' tuent muenio^ fortijjeinucturm quid ddhuc dhfeiffurÃ¼ futem fuijje. NÃ ferÃ¨fic doHi Mieduerunt, plurmu ut eo uirtutu, nonnihil fui/Je uitioru/t fe ipfe multd ex iUi iuuenili dbuddtid coÃ«reuijje tejidtur, tdmÃ« qtudo nee fd piÃ«tisftbi nomÃ« minime fui cotemptor dfferuit,et melius dicerecerte ddtd logiore uitd, cy etdte ddfe copVnendÃ¼ f ffeuriore * ffgt;*^t-iorepotuilfet, no mdlignc credidcrim defuijfe ei fummdilldmjddqudnemopropriusdccefit, Â£tliceidt fi dUter fentirÃ«, fortius id liberius^ defendere.An uero Mt Antonius neminÃ« d fe uifum eloquentem,qcltdnto mi J)e oruore fii^f erdt,profejfus eÃ^ipfe etiA ^Ã¯.Tullius querit ddhuc f'quot;^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;â eum,et tdntÃ¼ imdgindtur de fingit, ego non dudel dicere

^liquid in hdc que fupereÃ eternitdte inueniri po(fe, eo quod fuerit pfedliust TrdnÃo iÃos qui Ciceroni de Df* moftheni ne in eloquentid quidÃ« fdtis tribuunt,qudnq ne ipfi Ciceroni DemoÃhenes fdtis uidedtur effe perfeÃ¤us, quÃ« dormitdre interim dicit, nee Cicero 'Bruto Cdluo^ qui certe compofitionÃ« iÃ¼ius etid dpud ipfum reprehen' dunt,nee Afmioutri^, qui uitid ordtionis dus etid 'mi* mice pluribusin locis infeqiiuntur.Conceddmus fdnÃ¨(q^ minime ndturd pdtitur)repertu eÃe dliquem mdlu uirum fumme difertu,nihilo tdmen m'mus ordtorÃ« eum negdbo^ Ndm nee omnibus qui fucrint mdnu prompti, uiri fortis nomen conceÃer'mt,quid fine uirtute 'mteUigi non poteÃ fomtudo. An ei qui dd defendendM edufds dduoedtur^ non eil opus Ãde,quA nee cupiditÃ© corrumpdt, nec^d

ORATOR. LIBER XII. 7J$ hit MertM:,ncc metm friingitt,Ãd proditorÃ«,MnffugA, priudnelitoremidonabimut ordtoris iÃ¼ofacro nominee Q3od /Ã¯ mediocribui etidm pdtronis conutnit hlt;ec, ^ihc Milgo dicitur bonite, cur no ordtor itte qui nondufuit^ fed poteÃ effe, tdm fit moribui 5 dicendi uirtute perfe' ^m^ NoÂ» enim forenfemqudnddininfiituimus operdmi nee mercendridm uoeÃ«, nee (ut dÃierioribuf uerbis pdr^ edmui) no inutile fdnÃ¨ Ã¼tium aduoedtu, quem denies edit fidicum uulgÃ uoeM^fed uiru cum mgen^ndturdprx-Ãdntem,tum uero tot pulcherrimdx dries penitus mentÃ© eompkxum, ddtum tdndem rebus humdnis,quAÃem nuUd dnted uetuÃeu cognouerit,finguldrÃª, perfeÃ¼u^ undi^f opt'md fintietttem,optmeq^ dieÃ«tem, Ã¯n bocquotd pari erit,quod dut tunocentes tuebitur,dut improhorum feo lerd compefeeti dutinpecUnidrijs qu^Ãionibus ueritdti eontrd cdlumnid dderit f Summus iÃ¼e quidÃ« in bis quoqÃ operibus fuerit,fed in mdioribus ctdriÃ¼s elucebit, cum rÃ« Zenddfendtusconpltd,^ populdriserror ddmeliord ducendus. An non tdlem quendi uideturfinxiffe Vergi quÃ« mfeditione uulgiidm fdces etfdxd idcutdntis mode rdtorem dÃ©dite Turn pietdte grduÃ« de mentis fi forte uiru quÃ«j Conjfiexcre,filet,drredis^ duribui ddÃih Udbemus igitur dnte omnid uiru bonum,poÃ b^c ddiecit dicendi peritu : Ã¯Ue rÃ©git diÃ«iis dios et pcÃord muket, Cltddi non in bellis quoq; idem iUe uir,quem inÃitumusi fifit dd prilium miles cobortdndus, ex medijs fapientii pneeptis ordtionÃ« trdbctiNdm quo modo pugnd ineuii mus tot fimul mctusldboriSf dÃ³loris, poÃremo mortis

, ippus rxcidcrint,nip in eorum locum pictM^et fortitu-do,crboneÃiprlt;efcns imÃ¤go fuccefferit f Que ccrtc mcliMpcrfuAdcbit AHjs,qui prins perfudferitfibi.Vrodit enim [c^qudmUbet euÃodidtur fmuktio^nce imqudm tdn tAfucritcloqucudipicultAs, ut non titubet deheredt, quotiesdbdnimouerbd dijJentiunt.Vir dutÃ« mdlus^dHui diedt neceffe eÃ qudm fentidt. Bonos nunqudm honeÃus fermo deÃeiet, nunqudm rerum optimdrum (ndm ijdem etidm prudentes erunt) inucntio,que etidm Ã knocinijs deÃitutd Ãt ,Ãdtis tdmen ndturd fud orndtur, nee quieq nondiferte,quodboneÃedidtur. QudrelunÃ«tus, mo omnis eids (nequo enim reÃ«le uoluntdtiferum eH tem' pus uUum) totis mentibus huctenddmus,m hoceldbore' mus,forfdn cz confummdrecontingdd Ã¯^dmÃndturd non prohibet, ZT eÃe uirum bonum, e^ eÃe dicendipegt; ritum, cur non dliquis etidm umus utrunq^ confeoui pop pdeurdutem non fe quinque ÃeretforeiÃ¼umdliquemf ad quod Ã uires mgenq non ÃtÃccerint, tdmen dd quem tetiam uÃjuemodumproeeÃerimuSimeUoreserimus exutro' que.Ã¯loc certe prorfus eximdtur dnimo,rerumpÃ¹l' cherrmdm eloquentidm cum uitijs mentis poÃe mifeeri-TdcultdS diccndi^ÃinmdlosincidityGfipfd iudicdndi ell mdlumtpeiores enim illos fdeit, quibus contingit^ Videor mihi dudire quofddm(ncc enim decrunt unqudtn qui diferti eÃe qudmbonimdUnt) iÃ¼d dicentest Quidgt; ergo tdntum drtis eÃ in eloquentidicur tu de eoloribus, VdiÃicilium cduÃdrum defenÃone, nonnihil etidm de confeÃo loqmtus esj niÃ dliqudndo uis tiT fdcultd/s di'

quot;tenii expugnut ipfdm ucritdtemf Honus enm uir non dgit nifi bonos coufos, eos pom etiom fine doHrmd fd-twper fe tuetur ueritos ipf. Qiiibus ego cum de mco primumopere rej^ondero,etidmpro boni um officio, fu^uÃ¤ndo eumod defenfonem nocentium rot io duxerit^ fitiffdeiom. Pertrdildrcenimquo modo dut pro folÃs, dut etid pro iniuftis dliquondo diedtur, non c^ inutile, Ml propter hoc folum, ut cd fdeiUtu er deprehenddmui errefeUdmus,ciuemddmodHm remedid melius ddhibe* bit, cui notd i^ud nocentfuerint. Heq^ enim Acodemici, cum in utrdnq; differunt pdrtcm,non fecundum dltcrdin uiuunt^iieque edmeddes iUe, ejui Komiie dudiente Cen~ forio Cdtone,non mÃ¯noribus uiribm contrd iuÃitidm di dtur differuife, qudm pridic proiuÃitid dixerdt,iniU' Ãutipfe uir fuit. Verum er uirtusc^uid fit,dduerfdÃ©i mdlitid detegit, er dt^uitos fit ex mitsui contempldtio-nc monifefiior, er plÃ¼rimdcontrdrijs probdntur. De* lent ergo or dt orifice ffe dduerfdriorum notdeonfilid, uthofiium mperdtoritVerumer illud cpiodprimd prO ^ppjj.j.^ pofitione durum uidetur, potefl cffe rdtio, ut uir bo^ nusindefenfione edufe uclit duferre cliquondo iudici ucritdtem. (^od fi eptis d me proponi mirdbitur (tpidn cpidm noneSlhjecmedpropriefententid,fed corÃ¼quos grduiÃmos fdpientixmdgifirosietds uetuscredidit) fic iuiicet,plerdq;effc,quÂ£non tdm fddiK,(iudm edufis eorum uel honefid fidnt,ucl turpid .t^dmfi hominem oc^ ciderefepe uirtus, liberos needre nonnunq pulcherri' mum efi,dfpcriord ifuM ddhuc didu/i cÃ¶miwis utilitds

75^ M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT, cxcgcrit,fiicere conceditur,nc hoc (luidem nudum ell in tuendu^qudkm cdufdm uir bonus, fed etid ^uare, or e^ud mentedefenddt. Aeprimuconceddntmihioesoportet, t^uod Stoicoru quo^; dÃ^errimi conftentur,fdilurum dii qudndo bonum uiru,ut menddeium dicdt,e^ quidem non nunq kuioribui cdufis, ut in pueris Â£grotdntibus utiliti ^Â»naciam* ^^ ^^â''^gt;gt;f grdtid multd fingmus,multd nofdduri pro mittimM,nc duftdb hole occidendo grdjfdtor duertedus ftt,duthoÃk pro fdlute pdtriÂ£ faUenduSyUt hoc ^d'dlidS in feruis quoij} reprehedendu ell,fit dUds in ipfo fdpiÃ©te Iduddndum.Ãfi confiiterit,multd idm uideo paffe eiieni re, propter ^UÂ£ ordtor bene fufeipidt tdk cdufa genus, qudk remotd rdtione honeftd non fitfcepiffet,iicc hoe di co, quid feueriores fequi pldcet leges pro pdtre, frdtre, dmico,periclitdntibus, tdctfii no mediocris hafitdtio ed, hmeiufiitia propofitd imdgÃie,indepietdtis, nihil dubij rclmqudmus * Sit dliquis infididtus tyrdnno, dtque ob id reus,utrum 'ne fdluu eum uolet is qui Ã nobis finitur ord-tori dn ft tuendu fiufccperit,nb tdmfdlfis de findet,q qui dpud indices mdld edufim tuctur. Qt^id fi quada beitefd Ãd ddndturus ejl index,nift ed no efiefddd couicerimuf, non uel hoc modofirudbit ordtor non innocente modÃ¨, fid etid IduddbilÃ¨ einem i Qjcid,fi quaddm infid ndturd, fed coditione temporuinutilidciuitdtifeiemus i blÃ³nne utemur drte dieÃ«di bond quidÃ« ,fid mdlis drtibusfimili-^ At mdi Ad hoe nemo dubitdbit, quin fi nocentes mutdri ^^â**â^ mbonimentÃ«dliquomSpoÃint,fientpoÃemterducSee diturffidnos e/Je eos m.igis Ã¨ repu.fit q puniri. Si liqucdt

ORATOR. LIBER XII. 757 igitur ordtorifuturu bonum uiru, cui uerd obijeientur, non id dgrt,ut faims Ãt ^ Dd nunc ut er imine mdnifeÃo fremdtur dux bonus, O' fine (^uo uincere honefie dui^ tax no poÃit,none Ã cols utilitds ordtorÃ© dduoedbitXer te Fabricius Cornelium Rufnu.dlioqui o mdlu ciuÃ«,o' Ãbi inimicu,tdmen quid utile feiebdt duce imminentcbcl~ to, pdlkm confute fujfrdgio fuo fecit, dtq^ id mirdntibus quibufdi reffondit,^ ciue Ã fpolidri malle,q db bofte ut dre. itd hieÃ fuiftet ordtor, no defendiÃet cundÃ© Ru-ftnu, uel mdnifefti peculdtus rcuiMultd did poÃentÃmi tid,fed uel unum ex bis quodlibet fujftdt^Ã¼on enim boe ^gimus,ut iftud iÃ¼i,quÃªformdmus uiro fitfepe fdciendu fed ut ft tdlis eoegerit rdtio,ftt tdmÃ¨ uerdfinitio, ordto vÃªelfcuirum bonu dicendi pcritu, Prifdperc uero de di feere quo modo etid probdtione dijftciUd trd{ientur,ne eeffe fÃ.NÃ¤ fre quÃªter etid optimitcdufe ftmiles funt md tis,O' mnoeÃ«s reusmultis ueriftmilibuspremitur. Quo ftt,uteddÃ« ddionis rdtione defendÃ©dusftt, qudft nocens effet.Ã¼ 'mnumerdbilidfunt bonis cdufts mdlis^ coÃ¯d,tc' ftes,Utere,fulfidones,opiniones.^on dUter dutÃ« ueri' ftmilid, q uerd et cofirmdtur orefeÃutur.Qudpropter ut resferet, ftedetur ordtio, mdnÃ«te boneftd uoluntdte. CognofeÃ«ddeffeOrdtoriqbus mores formÃ«tur. Cd.lh QVdndoigitur ordtor eÃ¼ uir bonus,is dutÃ« citrd

uirtutÃ«mteUigi non poteft, uirtus etidmft quof dam impetus 4 ndturd fumit, tdmÃ«perftciendd dodrind ed, mores dnte omnid ordtoriftudijs erunt ex colendi^dt^ omnis bonefti iufti^ difdplindpertrddein-

â7^8 M, FAB. QVlNT. INSTIT-Ã djfme ^Mit nemo nee uir bontu eÃe, nec dicendi peritdi foteÃ, nifi forte dcceddmiu hu, qui ndturd confdre tgt;^^ res,^ nihil dHuudri difciplmd putdt/cilicet ut ed qi^f q^Â£ mdnufunt^dtq; eoru etid contemptiÃimd,confite A* tur egere dodoribiu. uirtutÃ« nero, qd nihil hommi quo dd deos immortdles propius decedere ddtÃ¼ e^l,obuid amp;â iÃdbordtd tdntÃ¼ quid ndtifumiu hdbedmiu.AbÃmes erit, qui id ipfuni quidÃtdbÃmetid ignordritf Etfortif, qui metiu dolor Ã¼,mortis,fuperftitionÃ¼ nuUd rdtione pur^U uerit. Et iufiiu,qui aqui boniq; trd(idtu,qui leges,qu^ ndturd funt otbiu ditÂ£,qu.e(Ã propric populis c^ g^utb btu coflitutlt;ie,non eruditiore dliquo fermonetrdÃdrit^ O qudm ijlud pdrum putdt,quibuÂ« td fdeile uidetur. Sei hoc trdfco,de quo neminÃ«,qui literds uel pritnis (ut diHt) Idbris degujidrit, dubitdturÃ¼ puto,dd iÃ¼ud feques reuet Ur, ne dicendi quidsÃtis peritÃ¼ fore,qui no or ndturd uim oÃ©m penituspj^exerit, et mores pr^ceptis de rdtioe formdr it. Ã¯^cs^ enim ÃuÃrd m tertio de Ordtore lib. tÂ» Crdffiu ctwild qui de Â£quo, iuÃo,uero, bono, de^ hÃ qugfunt cotrd poÃtd,dicuntur,proprid effe ordtore uf firmdt, de philofophos eu ed dicendi uiribus tuentur,uti rhetoru drmis,non fuis.ldÃ« tdmen c5ftetur,edidm effe i philofophid petendd,uidelicet quid mdgis h/tcilliuidetUT in poffefioneedrurerumfuiffe.Ã¯lincetiditlui eÃ,quoi Cicero pluribus libris ti:^ epijloUs teftdtur,dicÃ«di fdcul' tdtem ex mtmis fdpiÃ«tilt;e fontibus Ãuere, ideoq; dliqud^ diu pritceptores eofdÃ« fuiffe morum dtq; dicendi-Oud-propter hdte cKhoridtio men no eÃ³ pertinrtf ut effe ord*

ORZTOR. LIBER XIL 7)9 brew philofophu uelim,guindÃ© non alia uita feÃ¼ti loft' Ã¿M Ã ciuilihtM ofjicijf^dtiJi ab omni munerc omtorii re* eeÃU. Ndw quis philofophoru dut in iudicijs fi-equÃ¨s,dut tldruf in concionibuf fuitf Quk deni^j in ipfd, quA md' xme plenty eorÃ¼ nitdnddm prtcipiunt reipub.ddmini' firdtione uerfdtus eil fAtqui ego iUu quÃ« M^ituo^Romft numquendAUclinteffe fdpicntÃ¨,qui non fccreiit dif^uti tionibm, fed rerÃ experimentis dtq^ opcribm uere dui* lern uiru exhibedt. Scd i^uid defertd db his qui fe dd elo' quentid contulcrut^ftudid fdpientiÂ£,non idm mddufuo, dtq; in hdc fori luce uerfdntur,fed in portion et gymnd fd prmu,mox in conuentuifcholdru recefferut, id quoi eft ordtori neceffdriÃ¼, nee Ã dicendi pneceptoribus tm iitur,db his petcre nimirum necejjÃ© eji,dpud quos reml ft.iuoluendi penitus dutores, qde uirtute pneipiunt, M ordtoris uitd eu feientid diumdru rerum fit humdnd' rum^ cbiundd.Ciult;e ipfe quAto nidiores dc pulchriores Mderctttur,fi HlAs hi docerent,qui etiS. cloqui pr^fidn fciUat tiÃmepoffent. Vtmdmq; fit tempus unq, quo perfedus dliquis,qudlÃ« optdmus,ordtor, hdne pdrtÃ«fuperbo noÃ¯e, et uit ijs quorundd bond eius corrumpentiZ inuifdm uen dieet fibi, de uelut rebus repentis m corpus eloquÃ«tite dd. ducdt.Qjt^quidÃ«cumfitintresdiuifapdrles, ndturd' lem,mordlÃ«,rdtiondlem,quÂ£ tdndÃ«non ed cu ordtoris o pere coniundd P Hd ut ordinÃ« retro dgdmus, de ultimn md,quÂ£ totd uerfutur in uerbis, nemo dubitduerit,fi ty proprietdtes uocis cuiufq^ nojfe,cr dmbigud dperire/t ptrplexd difcemerejet de fifis iudiedre^^ eolligere dc

74Â° M. FAB. QVÃNT. INSTIT, refolucre qu^ uelis,orntorÃ¼ cR^ qÂ«(Â«Jg e4 Â«3 ta, eÃ mintl te dtg- cocifÃ¨ m aliionibut utendÃ¼, g m difj^utationibun Ãi no docere modo,fed mouerc etiai de ddedire audiÃ«tet dÃ©bet orator, ad qdâmpetu ^Mq; e:^ uiribuf, ac dÃ©corÃ© ed opuf,ut uis amniu maior cd altii ripii,multo^ gur' gitsi tradufluentia, ^ tenuis dciuÂ£, cr obiedu Ã®apiUorit numÃ©ros tefultantis.Et ut Palijlrici dodores iÃ¼os quos neruos uocAt, non ideirco difeÃ«tibus tradunt,ut bis oibut hi qui* didicerHt,m ipfo ludandi certamine utantur, plus enim podere^Oquot; firmitate,zy Hdritu agitur,fed ut fubfit copia i!la,ex qua unum aut aÃ¯terÃ¼ cuius fe occafto dederit,ejfia ciant.lta h^c pars dialedica,Ãue iUa dicere malimus di' ffiutatricÃ©,Ut ed utilis fepe,lt;y' Ãnitionibus, (y coprehÃ© Ãonibus,(^ feparadis quoi funt diffvrentia,^^ refoluÃ«da ambiguitate,etdiji'mguÃ«do,diuidendo,iÃ®liciÃ«do,implicA do, ita Ã totÃ¼ Ãbi ucndicauerit inforo certamÃ«, obÃabit meUoribus, cr fedas ad tenuitatÃ« fui uires ipfa fubtilita te cofumet. ItaÃ§^ reperias quofda in diffutadomire caUi dos,cÃ¼ ab iUa uero cauiÃ®latione difcejferint,no magis fuf Ãcere in aliquograuiore adu,q parua quida aÃ¯alia,quÂ£ manguÃijs mobilia,eampo deprehÃ«dutur. lam qdÃ« pars iÃ¼a moralis quÂ£ dicitur Ethice,certe tota oratori eÃ act comodata. NÃ in tantd caufaru,ut jÃ¼pcrioribus libres dit ximuf,uarietate,cu alia coniedura quÂ£rantur,alia finit tionibuicocludantur,aliaiure fummoueAtur,uel tranffe rantur,alid coÃ¼igantur,uel ipfa inter fe concurrat^ud in diaerfum ambiguitate ducantur ,nÃ¼Ã¼a ferÃ¨ diei poteft, cuius no parte m aUquatradatus tequi t;^ boni reperia*

tur. PlcrdÃq; ucro effe ^5 nefcit^^Uie toU in foU ^uditi te cofijidnt ^ IÂ« conftlijs uero, qux rdtio fuddendi cH db honefti quitÃionc fcpoÃtd^Qjiinctid iTld pdrs tertid,quÂ£ yuddndi de uituperidi oÃieijs continctur,nempe in trd* ddtu rciUprduiq; uerfdtur.An de iuÃitid,fortitudiney Â»â illmcntidjtÃ«perdntid^pietdtc no plurimd dieet ordtorf Sed iUe uir bonus,(pii hge no uocibm tdntu Ãbi notd,dtlt;^ ^ommibus duriu tenus in ufum Imgut percepcrit, fedq fiirtutes ip fas mente coplexw itd fentiet,nec in cogitddo itd Idbordbit/cd qd'jcietuere dieet,Cu dUtem Ãt ots ge* tierdUs (piitÃio Ãieeidh potentior, quid umuerfo partes ^iaentur, non utiij^ deeedit pdrtiquod uniuerÃum ell, profeHo nemo dubitdiit generdles qutfliones in iUo md ^me Ãudioru more uerÃitdsAd uero eu Ãnt muUd^pprijs ^ftuibui^i eoprehenÃonibus finiÃ«dd,wnde etu Ãdtus edu Ãrum dieitur Ãnitiuus,nÃne dd id quoq; mÃrui db -idlijs hij 5Â«! plus in hoeÃudij dedcrunt oportetiQjiidfnon queÂ» Ãio iuris omnis dut uerborÃ¼ proprietdte, dut aquÃ® difpu tdtione,dut uoluntdtis coieHurd eontineturl quoru pdrs lt;^d rdtiondlÃª,pdrs dd mordiÃ« trdÃ«ldtum redunddt. Ergo mturd permixtd eH Ã³ibus iÃis ordtio, quÂ£ quidÃ©ordtio fft uere. Ã¼dm igndrd quidÃ« huiu[ec doÃ«lrind loqudeitds ^rret neeeffe eH, ut que uel nullos, uelfdlfosduees hd' bedt.Pdrs uero ndturdlis eu eH dd exereitdiionÃ« dicendi tdto eeteris uberior,qudnto mdiorefpiritu de diuinis re bus I hurndnis loquendu eH, turn mdm etid mordemÃne qud nuUd effe,ut doeuimus, ordtio poteÃ, totd eopleÃ«li' tÂ«r.N4 Ã regier prouidetid mudus,ddminiÃrAdd eerte

ionii uirii er it R.ej^ub^. Si diuini noflris Mimii orlgo, tendendumad, uirtutem,nec uoluptdtibM terreni corpif^ rif feruiendum. An hoc non frequÃ«tcr tnUdbit ontort Urnde dugaru rej^onÃs, rcligione deniq; omni, de qui* but mixirnd fxpe in fenutu confiUd uerfdtd funt, non erit ei differenduf Siquidem (ut nobis pldcet ) futur us eR uir idem ciuilK.QjtiC deni^ mtcÃ¼igi fdltÃ« poteÃ eloquentii hominis optirnd nefeiÃ©titi Recfi rdtionc minifeÃd non ejjent,exemplis tdmen crederemustSiquidÃª et Peridemf cuiut cloquent iÂ£ etidmfi nulld dd nos monmÃ«td uener^, uim tdmen qudndi mcredibilem eu hifiorid, turn etid Ã¼* berrimum genus hominucomici ueterestrddunt,Andxn â¦pWlofophi Ãªlt;^lt;^ phyfici conÃdt duditorÃ«fuilfe^cr Igt;emofihenein principe omniu Grtecig ordtoru dediffe operd Pldtonit Ndm M. Tullius non tdntu fie debere fiholis rhetorum, qudntum AcddemuÃidtijs,frequenter ipleteÃdtuseÃ¼^ tic^Ã tdntd in co unqfudiffet ubertds,fi ingeniu fuum confepto fori, non ipfius reru ndturÃ¦ finibus termindp fett Verum ex hoc dUd mihi quÂ£Ãio exoritur, qux fedd conferre plurmu eloquentiÂ£pofiit, qudnq ednon inter multds potefi effecontÃ«tio,tidm Epicurus in primis nos Ã fe ipfe dimittit,qui fugere oÃ«m difciplind nduigdtione quiuelodÃime iubet.t^cq; uero Ariflippus fummu in no luptdte corporis bonu ponens,dd hunc nos UborÃ« ddhor â¦ Patronus tetur. Pyrrho quidÃ« quds hdbere in hoc opere pdrtes poteft, cui indices effe dpud quos uerbd fdcidt, cz reunt pro quo loqudtur, erfendtu in quo fit dicendd fentÃ«tid, Â»9 liquebit: AcddemU quoeÃ quidd utiUÃinfim creduntÂ»

qiwJ mos in utrAi^ pdrtem differendi nd exercitdtione foren/ium edufdruproxme dcceddt.Adijciuntloco pra^ IdtioniSifluod ed praÃdntiÃimosin elo^uÃ¨tid uiros edi^ derit.Peripdtetici fludio c^uoq- fe quodÃ ordtorio iddÃt. lidm theÃs dicere exercitdtionis grdtid, ferÃ¨ db bis eft in^itutum. Stoici Ãeut copid nitorem^ cloqucntiie fcrÃ¨ prxceptoribus Ãiis defuiffecoceddnt neceffe eÃ¼, itd nul los dUt probdre dcrius, dut concludcre fubtilius contenu dunt. Sed bte inter ipfos,lt;^ui uelfierdmento rogdti, uel etiÃ fuperÃitione ebÃriÃ¼i^nefds ducunt d fufeeptdfemel pfudfione difcedere^ Ordtori uero nihil eR neceffe in cu iuftjudiurdre leges^Mdiusenm eÃ opus,dtg-, praÃdtius dd lt;jdâipfe tendit,cr cuius eÃ¼ uclutcdndiddtusffiquidÃª eH futurus turn uitg, turn etid elo^uentu Idude pfcilus. (^dre in exemplÃ bene dicedifdeundiÃmu quenq^ pro ponet Ãbi dd mitdndu,moribusuero formddis ^Â«2 bo ^quot;Â»lt;8 tieÃiÃtmdprÂ£ceptd, reHiÃmdq; dd uirtutÃ« uid deliget, Pxercitdtioe qdÃ« uteturomni fed tdmÃ« erit plurmus in nuximis qbufji dc ndturd pulcberrimis. Jlt;IÃcluÂ£poteÃ mdterid reperiri dd grduiter copiafe^; dieÃ«dÃ¼ mdgis d-bunddns,^ de uirtutÃ«, de repub.de ^puidÃ«tid, de origine diorum^de dmicitid^ Hdc funt qbus mÃ«s pdritcr dtq; om tio inlÃ¼rgdt,quÂ£ uere bond,quÂ£ mitigÃ«t mctus,coÃ«rcedt eupiditdtes,eximdt nos opinioibus uulgi, dÃ¯mqi coeleÃÃ«.. Nf $ ed folu quÂ£ tdlibus difcipUnis cotinÃ«tur, fed mdgis â¢^^idquÂ£funttrdditddntiqtus, diÃ¼d, dcfd(tdprÂ£cldre, fiT nojfc^ct dio femp dgitdrecouemet. Qiio^pfcilo nusq plwd mdiord^,^ in noÃret ciuitdtis monimÃ«tis reperien

tur.Att fortitudmefidonjufiitid; continentidm,frugiÃ¼ tdtem,contcmptu doloris dc mortis, melius dUj docebut, | Â¥dlgt;ritij,Curij,V.egu!i,Dcci'j,^\utij, dlij^ 'mnumerdbi lesf duiititii f^^ Gritd pntceptis udlct,tdntu RomAni (quad eUmdiui) exempUs, tdntumqdânon cognais id Ã¨ rebus ddmoneri,qui non modo proximum tempus,lucÃª^ prdfentem intueri fdtis crcddt,fed omnepoÃeritatisme morid.j^itiumuitd hone^a, (y curricululdudis exiÃi' met.limc mihi iÃÂ£ iuÃitije hduÃus bibdt, hme fumptdÃ' bertdtem in edufis dtlt;^ couplijs praÃet. Nfq^ erit per' fedus ordtor, nip qui hone pc dicere er piet et dudebit, NeceÃdridlurisciuilisOrdtorieÃep:ientidi Cd. IIl.

IVris quolt;^ ciuilis neceffdridhuic uiro fcientideÃ,cr morum de religionu dus reipublicÂ£ qud edpeÃet. nS quilts eÃe fudfor in couplijs publids priudtifuepoterit, tot rcrum quibus prxcipue ciuitds continctur ignirusi Qua dutÃ© modo pitronu fe edufdrum nofdlpj dixerit, q quad eA medups potentiÃmÃ¼,ptdbdltcropetiturus, penÃ¨non diÃimiUs his qui poetdru feriptd pronuuditi t^dm quodimodo mdnddtd perferet, Zif fd qudpbi d iu dice credi poÃuldturus eÃ¼,ilicnd pdc dieet,et ipfe litigd autem t^i^fftduxiUitor egebitduxiUo^Quod utperinonnunq minore mcomodo poÃit,cu domi prdceptd er compopt td,etpeut cÂ£terd qudinedufd funt,m dipÃ«do cognitd dd indicÃ© perferet, quid pet in his qudÃionibus quÂ£ fubito inter ipfds dHiones ndfei folent ( non deformiter reÃeÂ» \ nbsp;nbsp;Het,or inter ÃubfeUid minores dduoedtos interroget^

nc^uhi occurrendu continueÂ», nee libÃ©ra ad difcendu mo Ti eÃ¼^(^id fi forte pÃ©rit ut iuris iÃ¯le non aderitf Quid fi (^uis non fatis 'm ea re dallus yfalfum aliquid fubiece^ rit^iloccn'im efi maxtrnu ignoratia malum,^uod credit fum fdre qui moneat. Nc^ ego fum noftri mor is igna* Tus,oblitus'ue ear urn,qui uelut ad arculas fedent,^' tela igentibus fubmmijlrant,neq; idemGritcasquae^nefcio fillita{fe,wndenomÃ«his Pragmaticorudatuek.Sedlo Pragmatici, qÂ«or de oratore qui no damorem modo fuum caufis,fed ^au^id^^osââ omnia qua pro futur a funt,debet. itac^ eum nee 'mutile uocant. fi ad horafortÃ¨ cofiiteridne^ 'm tefiationibus faciendis fffe imperitum uelim.Qjtis en'm potius pr^parabit ea, que eum aget effe m ciufa ueUt ? Hifi forti 'imperatorÃ« quit idoncueredit m prelijs quidÃª firenuum et forti,et oim que pugna pofcit artifice,fed neq^ delelius agere, nee copias controbere ate/} 'mfiruere^ncc;pjfiicere cornea tus,nee locum apere cafiris fientcipriM ell en'meer* te parare beUa q gerere. At qui fimilimus buic fitaduoÂ» citusyfi plura que ad umcendum ualent, alijs reliquerit.

Cum preferfm hoe quad eH maxime neceffariu,no tam fit orduu qprocul 'intuentibusfortajfe uideatur. Hanlt;^ omne ius quad cHcertu, Out fcripto,aut moribus co fiat, Dubium equitatis rÃ©gula exam'manduell.Que fcr'ipta fimt out pofita m more duitatis, nullam habet difficultÃ© temicognitionis funt en'im,non 'muentionisi at que con fultoru reffibfis expUcantur, aut m uerboru 'mterpreta

tionc funt pofitd^dut 'm refit praui^ difcrimmc.'ViHi cÂ» iuflt;^ uocit tntcU!gerc,Mtcomii^c prudetiu eH^Mt pro prium omtoris^fepiitM optmo cuiq^ notiÃimd cÃ.Nof porrÃ´ er battu uirdm,er prudenti 'm primis ordtorem ) putdmuSf^ui eu fe dd id quad ell optimu ndturd direxe'' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;\

diÃefttict^eum ipfis iÃK diuerÃix 'mter fe opmones me^ ticocelftijm ft. Sed etidm ft naffe quid quif^ fenferit^w let,leflione oput eÃ,qui nihil eÃ 'm Ãudijs m'mui Idlorio fum. Qttod fi pltri^i dej^erdtd fdcultdtedgendidd di'' fcendÃ¼iui dcclindueruntiq id fcirefdcile cA ordtori,qd difcimtqui fudquo^cofeÃioncordtores effenen pop fNeque ftmtf Veruet M.Cdto cum 'm dieÃ«do pr^ÃdntiÃimut^

turn iuris fuit idÃ« peritiÃmus.'E.t Sclt;euolte Seruioq^ SuU pitio coeeffd eÃ etidfdcimdilt;e uirtut. Et M.,Tullius non modo 'inter dgendum mmq eil deÃitutus feiemid iuris, fed etidtn componere dliqud de co caperdt,ut dppdredt poffe ordtorÃ© non difcendotdntu iuri udcdrc,Ãd etid do cendo.Veru cd qua de moribus excolÃ«disÃudioq^ iuris prieciplmus,ne quis eo creddt reprehÃ«dendd,quod muh tos cognouimus, qui tadio hboris, ^em ferre tendenti lus dd eloquentid. neceffe eÃ,confugcr'mt dd hac diuen. ticuld defidia,quoruim alij fe dd dlbu dc rubrieds trdÃud lerimt, er formuldrij, uel, ut Cicero ditÃegulei quidem

1 agentfs ffff mdluerimtjtdnq utiliord eligentes ed,quoru fold fd nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;t eilitdtem fequebdntur,dlij pigritia drrogdtioris,qui fu* bitoponte conffld 'mmilfdq; bdrbd, uelut depexiffent Wiorid preceptd, pdulwn liquid federet 'm fehoUs

ORATOR. LIBER XIL 747 p^ilofophorum^utdeittieinf'ublicotrifieSjdomidijfa^ luti,cAptdrent dut or it Atem contemptu cater or um, Phi^ lofophid cnim Ãmuldri potcRjCloquemid non poteÃ-^ ttecelfdridOrdtoricognitionÃ«HiÃoridru. CAP. IIII. J N promis uero dbiwdxre dÃ©bet ordtor excmploru co pidjOm ueteru turn etu nouoru,ddecgt; ut no cd modo ^UÂ£ conferiptd funt hiÃarijs, dut [crmombw, uelut per nidnut trdditd,quÂ£^; quotidie dgwntur debedt nojfe^ue tÂ« ne cAquidÃ¨ quafuMdclArioribM poctiifiild,ncgli-s. gfrc.NiÂ«m iUd quidem prior a,dut teÃmonioru.dut etid. iudiedtoru obtmem locu.Sed hac quoq; dut uetuÃdtii Ã de tutd Ãwt, dut db bommibui mdgnis praceptoru loco ÃÃ¼d creduturScidt ergo quimpÃ¯urirMtiinde etidin Ãni but Autorit At mdior eA,qdâplurd noffe et uidiffe credun tur, qdâHomerut Ã-equetiÃime teÃdtur.Sed no eli expo il Add ultmtd atdSjCÃ Ãudid praÃet,ut quAtu dd cognitio ^ ptmet reru, etid pratcritii feculis uixifje uidedmurÂ» dueÃntOrAtorisinÃrumentd. CAP. V, HAec futtt qua me redditurum promiferdm inÃrti

meiitA,non drti5,ut quiddm putAuerut,Ãd ipÃus. ordtorit. Hac drmd hdbere dd mdnu^horiim fciemid debet eÃefucctnilut, Accedete utrboru Ãgurdrumqi fAciÃ¼ copiA,^ inuentionit rdtione,et dijponÃ«di u^u,et memo viaÃrmitAte,et Adionis grdtidSed plurmu ex his udlet dnmiprtÃAntid,quA necmetiu ÃdngAt,nec AccUmdtio. terredt^nce dudientiu Autorit as ultrd debitA reueremiA tdrdet. liAm ut dbommdtidd funt cowdrid hit uit id,co fiientia^temcritAtif,mprobitdtit,drrogdniiÂ£,itAcitrAL

748 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTIT. eonjldntiiim,fidutidm,fortitud'nKm,nihil drSy nihil ÃuH um, nihil profedus ipje profucrit y ut (i des drmd timi^ dis ey mhellibus.Inuitus meherde dico(lt;iuonidmcrdi Vfrecundia, ^^^ licdpi poted^ipfam uerecwndid,uitiu quide^Ãd dmd bile,et qux uirtutes fdciUme generet,eUc interim dduer fdm,multisq; in cdufifuiffCyUt bondingenij ftudij^ in ÃK cem non proldtd,fitu ejuoddfecreti confumerÃ©tur. Scidt autemfi ijuis hÂ£c forte minus adhuc perituf diÃinguedi uim cuiu^ uerbi,legdt,non probitdtÃ« 4 me reprehÃ¨den di,fed ucreciMdid quie ed timor quiddm reduces dnimu db bis qua fdciendd funt.Ã¯nde ConfuÃoy c^ capti pani tÃªtid,cr fulitufilentiu. Quis porrÃ¨ dubitet uitijs dferi iere dffÃ¨ilum,propter que fdcere honeÃe pudet Æ Ã¼eq; ego rurfus nolo eu/m qui fit diHuruSyet foUcitu furgere, Cr colore mutdri, e^ periculu mtclligeretquÂ£ fino dcci dentyCtid ftmuldndd erunt, fed mteUeSlus bic fit operis, non mctus,mouedmur^,non cociddmus. Optimd ed dut emÃ«ddtio uerecudii fidutid, er qudlibetimbecilldfrons Mdgnd eSfeientid fuÃineturSunt er ndturdlid,ut fuprd dixi,quÂ£ tdmen c^ curdii(udntur,inÃrumeittd,uox,ldd tuiydecor,quÂ£quidÃ« tdntum Udlent, ut frequenter furnd ingenij fdeÃ¤t. Hdbuit ordtores letds noÃrd copiofiores, fed cum diceret,emincrc inter itqudJes Trdchdlus uideÂ» tgt;dtur,ed corporis fubUmitds erdtyis drdor oculorfrfron tis dutoritdt,geÃus prÂ£Ãdntid,uox quidem non ut Cice ro deÃderdt, penÃ¨ trdgeedorum, fed fuper omnes, quos ego quidÃª dÃ¼dierim trdgoedos.Certe cum ist bdfilicd M^ Hd diceretprimo tribundliyqudtuor dutÃ¨ iudicidyUt moÂ«

Yis efi,cogcrentur,Atqi omnid clamoribm fremerent^iy duditu eim,(y mteilc(iu,zy quod dgctibm ceteris coin meUofum fuitt Iduddtwm quoq^ex qudtuor tributidUbiK mcmini. Scd hoc uotum cÃ,(y rara fclicitdc qua: fi non ddÃt,fane fufficidt ab hk quibm quit dicit,dudirhTdlid cjjc debet orator,zy hdc feire, Q^odfit'mcipiendicdufMagerctempM. CAP. VIÂ« AGendi ante mitium fine dubio fccwidu uires cu* iu/cÃ fumendu eil,ncq; ego annos definiam^cum

TiemofibenÃ© puer um admodum ddiones pupilldres hd popuIarM buiffe manifefiu fitiCdluttt, C^fdr, PoÃ¼io, mÃ¼ltum ante quifioridomnetlÃ©tdtÃª grduifimidiudicid fuÃepermtt Prxtextdtos cgijfie eofidÃª fit trdditu * Ctejdr Auguftut * ^âÂ°'^*'** duodedm natm dnnos duidm pro rofiris laudduerit.Mo dw^mibi uidetur quiddm tenendus,ut neq; proepropere diÃringdtur imindturd fros,zy quiequid efi iÃ¼ud ddhuc deerbum proferdtur Â« N4m inde zy contemptut operis innA(citur,zy fimdametd idciimtur impudcntije,zy(qdâ til ubii^ perniciofiffimum) prÂ£uenit uires fidutid.Hec rurfus differendum efi tyrocinium in fieneHutem Â« NdW quotidie metus ere feit,maiusq^ fitfemper quod dufuri fu t^uaet dum deliberdmusquddÃ³ incipiedum fit,wcipere ldm ferum eÃ^Zitidrefrudu fiudiorum uiridÃªyt ddhuc dulcem promi decet,dum zy uenid,et ffes eil,zy pdrd* tusfiuor,zy oudere non dedccet,zy fi quid dÃ©fit operi fdpplet dtditzy fi qM dida funt iuueniliter,pro indole dccipiimtur, ut totui iÃ¼e Ciceronis pro Sex, Rofcio lot f^iOiÃd enint tdm commune quornffiiritui uiuif,terri

Iuaus ffiortuis 5 mdreÃuiludntikut, litttit ciedis^ Qui tun ! fex er uiginti ndtus dnnos, fdwmis dudientium eÃ¯dmo^ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'

rik Ui dixcritjdtferkuijfc tempore, er dnnii U(jMtd i^m fenioridemfdtetur, Etherde qudntwmUbet fecretdÃd* j did contulcrmt, eÃ tdmen proprim quiddmfon profes diKimilis nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ââ'^^ ^'*^^ â^^ââ' ^^^^^ difcriminl$ fdcies, plm^Ã[e*

pdresjufui Ãne dodrindyqu^mdtrd ufum dodrmd ui* IcdtAdcoq-nonuuUi Ãnesin fcholdfddi Ãupentnouiti te cum in iudicid uenerwit,er omnid fuis exercititioni* bus fimiUd deÃderdfit^At illic er iudex tdcet, er,lt;idueÃ¯ fdrius obÃrepit,er nihil temere didum pÃ©rit,er fi (fuid tibi ipfe fumds,probdndwm eÃ,er Idbordtdm congefdm que dier urn dc nodiu ftudio ddionem dqM deficit, et o* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;(

miffo mdgnd femperfidndi tumore, m quibufddm edufis loqucndMn,quod iÃ¼i diferti minme fciunt.ltdqi nonnttl los reperids, qui fibi eloquentiores uidedniur, qudm Ut edufas dgdm .CiSterum iÃ¼um quemiuuenem teneris^ adhucuinbus nitentem in for urn dedux'mus, er incipe requdmmdxime fdcilidc fduordbUiedufd uelm,ferdrtm uti cdtuli moUiore pr edd fdgmdntur, et no utiq- db hoe initio cominuire operdm, zy ingenio ddhuc diendo al* Iwm inducere,fcd idm fdentem quid fit pugnu, et in qud rem Ãudendum fit,re fid dte^ renouiri, Sic er tyroemij metum dumfddlius eÃdudere, trdfierit,necdudendifd ^ cilitdtem ufquedd contempt urn operis ddduxerit. vÃt eÃ er hdc rdtione M. Tullius,er cu/nt idm dd^ u meruifi fd inter pdtronos,qui turn erdw,nomen, in Afidmudui ^duitffec^ er dhjs fine dubio eloquÃ©tin dc fdpienM md*

ORATOR. LIBER XII. TH ^iÃrK,(cd pradpuc umÃª ApoUonio lAoloni,c^^cm qua que dudierÃ¤t 'Rhodhrurfus reformdndum,dc udut reco quendum dedit.Tum dignum opcrÂ£preti'.t/in uenit^cum inter fe congrmitt praceptd cr experimentd.

CVm Ãtis âm omne certdmen uiriu/m fecerU,prlmi ei curd 'm fufeipiendis eduÃs eritjn quibut de fen dere quidÃ©reos profedo q fdccre uir bonta mulet, non turnen itd nomÃ© ipf^m deeufdtoris horrebit,ut nuUo neq^ publico neq; pri'Mto duci pofit offeio, ut dliquÃª dd rei dÃªdum rdtionem uitÂ£ uocet. 'Num er leges ipfe nihil ud l^nt,nifi dutoriiidoned uoce mimitÂ£â.e:y ft peenus fceleÂ« titwi expeterefds non eH, propÃ¨ eH ut [eelerd ipfd per^ miffu ftgt;ti,er licentid mdUs duri certe contrd bonos eSl^ Q^ure netp fociorum quereldf, nee dmici uel propmqui necem,ncc er upturn m rempubUedm conj^irdtiones In^ nltus putietur ordtor,non pxnÂ£ nocentium cupidus,fei tmendundi uitid,eorrigendic^ mores. i^dm qui rdtione truduci ud meliord non polfunt,folo metu contmentur* Ituque ut deeufdtoridm uitdm uiuere, er dd deferendos. reos prÂ£mio duci,proximwmldtroc'mio eft,itd peÃe w* teÃmum propulfdre, cum propugnutoribus putrit com purundum. Ideo prmcipes 'm republied uiri non detrd^ Hduerwit hunc officij purtem, creditiq; funt etium cldri iuuenesobftdemreipublicÂ£ dure mulorum duium deen fdtionem,quid nee odijfe 'mprobos, nee fimultutes prod Medrejiift ex fdutii bQ^x mentis uiMuniwAdÃ©^ cwA

Ab llorttnÃo^Lucullis,Sulpiiio,Cictrone,Cteflt;ire,fluri* mit uliji, turn utro^ CotonefadueH^tjuoru Alter if pel litui cA fipiens,Alter ni ft creditur fuijfe, uix feio cui re Uciucrit huita nommii loeu. ^dn(^ defendet omnii ori* tor,ide^ portu ilhim elocpientiie fax fAlutdrÃª^nS etii fi ntk pAteficiet,ducetur^ in AduocAtione mixime au* fi.QuonÃA tdmÃ« omnes qui non improbelitigdbunt,quo ru certe purs cA,fujl'mere non pote A unu^.dUquid etii comenddmiu per fonts ddUt^cr ipforu qui iudicio decer nent,dut optmi cuiufq; uoluntdte mouatur: ndn^ hos V dmieiÃimos hdbebit uir bonus.Submouendu uero cA utrunt^ dmbitus genus, ucl potÃ«tibus contn humiles uÃ« ditindi operd fuitn,uel ittud etii idAdntiuStmmores uti que contrd dignitatÃ« AttoUendi.tJon enim fortund cdU* fds uel iuÃds uel improbds fAcit.Keq; ueropudorobÃct, quo minus fufeeptÃ^ cum mclior uideretur, litÃ«, cogniti inter difcendu iniquiate dimittit, cum prius litigitori dixerit uerii Ndmerm hoc mdximu,fi aqui indices fu* musjbenefidu cA,utnonfdÃ¼imus Mnd fpeUtigdntÃ«.He que enim dignus open pdtroni, qui non utiturconfilio. Et certe non conuenit ei quÃ« ordtorÃ« effe uolumus,iniu* Ãd tuen feientÃ«.mm ft ex Ulis quis fuprd diximus cAut fis fdlfum tuebitur,erittdmÃ« honeÃum quod ipfe fdeiet, Gntis'neei femperdgendum ft,trdd.tripote A.Qj^oi exprimd Ãdtim fronte dijudiare imprudentiumeAt Hdm quis ignordt,quin id longe fit honcÃiÃimwm,dc li* qumdÃ´ cd? herdUbus difciplinis, O' Ulo quem exigimus Animo di* tiniuj, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;gnifiimu,no uÃ«dere opcn,nec eleudre tutti beneÃeij M

ORATOR. LIBER XII. 7TJ toritdtcm ^ Cum pkrd^ue hoc ipfo poÃmt uideri uUid, quod pretium hdlgt;ent.Grlt;ecis hoc ut iitut,fatK cldru eÃ, necquii^qui fuffidentUÃbi(modieddutemh^cfunt) poÃideiit, hu/nc qudÃum fine ermine fordium fecerit. At fires fidmiUdris dmplius dUquid dd ufm neceffidrios exiget, fecundum omnesfdpientium leges pdtieturfibi grutidm referri,cum cr Soerdti coUdtum fit dd uiHu/tr, lt;;r Zenon, Cledntes, Chryfippus mercedes Ã difeipuUs deceptAuermt. Neq^ enim uideo qua iuÃior dcquirendi rdtio,q ex honeÃiÃimoldiore, er ab his dequibus opti tne mcruermt,qui^ fi nihil inuice praÃent, indignifue rmt defenfione, Quod quidem non iuÃum modojed ne eeffdriu etidm eÃ¼, cum hac ipft operd tempus 'ue omne â¢dienis negotijs ddtum,fdcultdtcm dUter dcquirendi re^ eiddnt. Scd turn quo^i tenendus eSl modtts,dc plurimum fefert,er d quo dccipidt,er qudntum, ar quoufque.Pd eiÃendi quidem iUepirdticusmos,cr mponemium peÂ» riculis pretid proeul dbomindndd,negotidtio etiS, Ã me* diocriter improbis dberit, cum prafertim bonos homi* Hesbonds^ edufids tuend non fit metuedus ingrdtustqui fifuturus, mdlo turnen iUe peccet. N/M ergo dequirere uolet ordtor ultrd quum finis erit, de ne pduper quidem tMquAm mercedem Aecipiet,[ed mutud beneuolemid ute tur, cum feiet fie tdnto plus praÃitiffie, quid nee uanire hoc beneficium oportet, nee perire. deni que ut grut us fifi,lt;id eurn mdgis pertmet qui debet.

PKoxtmti difcend^ cdufx rdtio, cid'cÃ orAtorK fun dAmentu. Nf ^gt; enm fiuis^ tAm mgenio tenui rtpe YietUr,qifi cu omniA qua fiwt in cAuÃ,diligenter cogna uerit,Ad docÃ©dum certe Mice non fujÃdAt.Sed eins rei pAudÃimA curd eft. NrfW ut tdeeS. de nÃ©gligÃ© nt ibut,qio rum nihil refert uhi litium edrdo uertAtur,du/m fint qua uel extrd edufm ex per fonts dc eSmuni trAdAtu locoru ocedfonem cldmdndi lArgidtur,dliquos ey AmUtio per* vertit,qui pdrtim tAnq occupdti,fotnperq nUud h^bÃ©tet, 1 quod Ante Agendu fit, pridic Ad fe uenire litigAtorÃ«,dui codent mdtutmo iubent,nonntvnq etidm inter ipfd fubÃ^ li A dididjfe fe gloridntur: pdrtim iddAtid 'mgenifutres cito Accepijfe uidedntar,tenere fe et wteUigere penÃ¨ pri us 1 Audidnt mentitiyC'jM multd,et diferte fommis^ d^ moribus,qua neq^ dd iudiceni,neq Ad Utigdtorem perti fuadtntes neAnt,decdittduerimt, bene fod Antes, heneq comitdti perforÃ© reduciintur,t^e iÃ¼as quidÃ« tulerim delitids eo* rAm,qui doceri Amicos fuos iuhent,quAnquA minus mdU efifi iÃ¼i fdltem rede difcdnt,redeq docednt.Sed quit di fcettdm bene quAmpdtronusf C^nomodo AutÃªfequefier iÃ¼e,et medidUtium mdnus,et quidd mterpres impendet aquo Animo IdhorÃ© in dlicnds Adiones, cÃ¼ didurus ipfo non fitfPeÃima uero cofuetudinis,UbeÃ¼is ejfe contemui quos componit AUt litigdtor,qui confugit dd pAtronums quid liti ipfo non fufficit,AUtAliquisexeo generedd* noedtorum, qui fo non pojfe dgere confitentur, deinde fdciunt id quod ed in Agendo difiieilimum. Udm qui M iiedre quid dicendum, quid diÃimuldndum Â» quid deefie

ORATOR. LIBER XII. -7Â« tundum bnitdndum 'uc^Ãngendumetiam fit,poteil,cur non Ãt orAtor,lt;ludndo quad difÃciÃ¼ui eii facitC Hi por ronon tamtinocerent,ÃomniA fcriber?t,utigeÃÃ¤Ãiwtt Nwwc conÃlitim ^ colores ddijeiwnt, er dUepu, peiord ueris,quÂ£ plcriq; cum deceperunt, mmutdreneÃu hdigt; bcnt,cr uelut themdtd in fcholispoÃtdcuÃodiMtt..DeÂ» indereprehertdti*itur,er edufdm qM diÃere ex fuis Ã¼ti gdtoribus nolucruntydb dduerfdrijs difeunt, Libern igi* tur demus dtue omnid bis, quorum negotium erit,tepus dc locÃ¼,exl}orteÂ»iur^ ultra, ut omnid qudmUlet uerboÂ«â fe,er undeuolent repetitdextemporeexpondnt.JÃ¼on rfpctÃ®to enin tdm obeÃ¼ dudire Ãperudeud, qudm ignordre ne* ^^o^^ore cejfdrid. frequenter dutem er uulnus, er remediumin bis ordtor inueniet qua Utigdtori 'm neutrum purtem bdbere momentum uidebuntur. Nec tdntd Ãt dÃ¤uro me GloriaÃdutid,ut fubferibere duditd pigedt.Nec femel du ^i{ÃÃt fdtis, cogendus eddem iterum dicere, dc fapius litigdtor, non folum quid effugere dliqud primd expoÃ* tione potuerunt^prafrtim hominem,quod fape euenit, igt;nperitum,Ãd etidm ut feidmus dn eddem dicdt.flwim i tn'im meminntur, er tunquim non docednt edufdm, fed ^gdnt,no ut cum pdtrono,fed ut cum iudice loqimmur, ^d,propternu/nq fdtis credendum en-, fed dgitdndus omnibus modis,er turbdndus,et euocdndus,Ã¯id ut medi ois non dppdremid modo uitid curddd fumt, fed etid 'm* ueniendd qua ldtent,fape ed ipfis qui funundi fuut occu iontibusyitddduocdtusplurdqu'dmoÃedwntur dÃicidt^ iaedpiat 1^5 cum fdtis'm dudiendo pdtienda 'tmpÃ«derit, 'm dlidm

rurfui ei perfonAm trinjewndum eR,AgcndMq; idueri fdriM,proponendiim quiequid omnino excogitAri cond trA pote{l,lt;pticquid recipi m eiufmodi difceptitione M tun. Ã¯nterrogAndm g mfejliÃmc,Acpremendui. NdW dam omnid lt;ptgrimuf,ilicpu,ndo ad uerÃ¼,Hli minime ex peUdumuifperuenimui. In fummii,optimut e^indifcÃ© do patrottuf 'mcreduluf.Promittitenim Utigdtor omnid, tclle,populÃ¼,pArAtiÃimiÃ¼conÃgndtioncs,ipfumdettilt;Ã dduerfdriu qutdd non negdturu.ldcoqi opiu efi mtueri omne Utis wflrumemu, quod uidere no eÃ¼ fdtis,perlegÃ© du erit. UdmÃ-equetiÃime dut no fuM omnino qu/t pro mittebiintur, dut minus cotmentidUt cu/m dUo dliquo no cituro permixtd [uni,dut nimid fu'nt,z^ Ãde hocipfo de trd{lurd,quod no habent modÃ¼. Denitp Imum ruptÃ¼,dut turbdtd cerd,dut fine dgnitione fignd frequenter inueni es:qute nifi domi exeuÃerisÃn foro mopindtd decipiÃªtt plus^ nocebut deÃitutd, q no promt ffd nocuiffent.N.ul td. etid quÂ£ Utigdtor nihil dd edufdm pertlnere credideÂ» rit,pdtronus eruet,modo per ocs quos tndidimus drgu mentoru locos ent,quos ut circufÃeÃ¤dre in dgendo, tSquot; dttÃ¨tdrefingulos minime couenit,propter qMs diximus cdufds,itd in difeÃ«do rhiidri neceffdriu cfl,quic perfoni, quÂ£ tÃ«pord,quÂ£ locd,inflitutd,infirumentd,cieterd^ ex quibus no tdntu iUud quod eH drtificidle probdtionis ge nut coUigi poÃit,fed qui metuendi tefies, quo modo fint refeÃ¼endi. Ã¯idmplurimurefertinuididreuSidn odio,dn cotemptu liboret, quorum ferÃ¨ purs primd fuperiores, proxmdpdres^ tertii humiUoret premit, Sicedufdm

perlcrutAtm, propoÃtis ante oculos oibm lt;iuÂ£ profint nocetiHt'ue, tertiS, demde pfonH induit iudicis,Ãngit(pi ipud fe agi caufam,cr c^dâipÃm mouiffet de eadÃ« re pro nudaturujd potemiÃmu apud quceuw^ agetur,exiÃi met jet Ãc eu raro fallet euetut,Mt culpa iudicii erit.

QVÂ£Ãntm agedo firuindajtoto ferÃ¨ opere exe cuti fumui^pMei tarnen propria huiut loci,^uÂ£ Â«S tarn dicedi arte,q officijs agedi cotmentur, attmgat Anie omnia,ne (quad pleriÃ]^ accidit)ab utiUtate eu cau fe prgfentis cupido laudis abducat.^a ut geretibtu bei la n5 femper exercitut per plana et amana ducÃ©dut eÃj fed adeudi plerunt^ aÃperi colles^ expugnada duitates, fiuimlibetprÂ£ciÃs-i-poÃtÂ£ motibut,aut operÃ¼ mole diffi ^J^tuf** fdestita oratio gOitdebitquidÃ« occaÃone latimdecurÂ« lÃ¦tjus fÃ«di,et Â£lt;iuo cogrejfa capo,totax uires populiriter ex* pUcibitiat Ã iuris anÃeiÃm^ aut eruendÂ£ ueritatis late bras adirÃ© cogetur, non obe^uitabit j nee illis uibranti* bus cocitatis^ fententijs uelut miÃiUbus utetur, fed ope ribus, ZT cwniculis, er inÃdijs, er occultis artibus rem i.eret.Q^Â£ omnia non dum Ãunt laudantur,fed cumfa (la funtjimde etia minus cupidÃ³ opinions, plus ÃuÃus nenit. Ã¯^am cum iÃ¼a dicendi uitiofa iadatio inter plaufo resfuosdetonuit, refurgit uera uirtutisfortior fama, nee indices a t^uo fins moti diÃ mulattt,cr doft is credi* turjnec eH orationis uera laus,niÃ cum Ãnita eH.vete* ribus quidem etiarn diÃimulare elotjuensiam fuit moris, id^ M. Antonius pracipit^ t^uo plus dicentibus Ãdei mi

nia'que fufj^cd^ diluocdtorum inÃdix forent â¦ Sei OU diÃimutdri quÂ£ tara ena potuit: nondum enm tdntK di cendilumen decefferdt, ut etidm per obÃdntid eru/tnpe* ret.Qudre drtes quidcm,O' confÃ¼id ldteit,O' ^uicipi fi deprehÃ«ditur perit. HdHenm eioeptentid fecretum hd bet.Verborum eptidem delcÃ¤utygrinitM fentenddrumt figurdn/m eÃ¯egdntid,dut non funt, dut dppdreitt/ed uel propter hoc ipfu/m oÃentdudd non funt, lt;p(od dppdrett dutfi un:^ Ã¨ duobm eUgendum, cdufd Uudetur potius qudm p.UronuftVmem tarnen htme pnejldbit orator,ut uideatur optima causam optime egiffet Ã¯Ã¼ud certÃ¼ erit, neminem peius agere, g qui dijfUcence can fa placet,nef eejfe cA enm extra edufam fit quod placet, Uec iUofafii â dio laborabit orator,non agendi causas minores,tanq in â fra eum fiat, out detradura fit opmioni minus liberaHs materia,Ndm or fufeipiendi ratio iuftifiimd ed,officiu, . cz optandu/m etiam ut amici quamminimas Utes habeat, *^ or abude dixit bene, quifquis rd fatisfecit. At quidam etiam fi forte fufeepermt negotia paulo ad dicendum te nuiora,extrinfecus addudis ea rebus circu/mliniivnt: ac fi defecerint alia,conuicijs implcnt McM caufarutfi con tingenua tingit,ueristfi minus,fidis, modo fit materia ingenij, mereatur^ clamorem dam dicitur, Quod ego adeolon ge puto ab oratore perfedo, ut etvm ne uera quide obie durum, nifi id caufa exigit,creda, Eaed enim prorfus canina,ut ait Appius,etoquenfia,cenfuram maledicendi fitbire,quod facientibus etia male audiendi prefumenda patientia cd.n^iam et in ipfosfit impetus frequenter:^

*gfÂ«wit,et certe pitroni petuhntidm Utigdtor luit.Sei biCc minord funtipfoiUo uitiodnimi, quomdltdicMi Wdlefico no dijidt^ifi occdfione.Turpif uolupt^p- nt^ humdnd^et nuUi dudientium bono grdtd, d Utigdtoribm ^wdep-equenterexigitur,lt;^ui ultionÃ©mdlut, ^deftnfto nem.Sed nelt;^ dUd multd dd drbitriu eorufdeiendd fivnt^ Hoc quide quK bommu tiberi modi fAngumK fujlineat, pctuldns effe dd dlterim drUtriu^Atciui etid in dduoed^ tos pdrtis dduerflt;e Ubenter nonnuUi iniuhwntur^ciuod tÃ¼jndicanÃª niÃ forte meruermtyO' inhumdnu eA, relpeUu comuni wn offciorÃ¼,cr cum ipfi qui dicit mutilc(itdm idem iniâ tisrejponfuris ditur,tnm cdufÂ£ contrdriMr,,c[uu pldnÃ¨ dduerfdrij Ãumt er inimici, er quintulwrnanji his uiriu eSi,cotumelid dugetur.Super omnid pÃ©rit iÃ¼d quie pluri mÃ¼ ordtorigt;et dutoritdtis/tfidei affert modeÃid,Ã d, ui ro bono in rdbuid IdtrdtorÃ«^ couertitur, eopofitus non dd dnimÃ¼ iudicis,fed dd ÃomdchiimUtigdtoris.Trequen ter etid jpecies libertdtis deduccre dd temeritdtÃ« folet, non eduÃs modi, fed ipÃs quaq^ qui dixerunt penculoi fdm, t^ec immeriti Pericks folebdt optdre,ne quod Ãbi uerbim in meiitÃ« ueniret,lt;iuo popuius o^nderctur.Sed tpiod iUe de populo,id ego de omnibus femio,qui tdutun dem poffumt nocere, l^dm qu^fortid du/m dicuntur ui-Â» debdmur,Ãultd cam heferut uoedtur.Ã¯June quid udriimt ferÃ¨ propoÃtu dgentiiem fuit,er quorundS, curd tdrdi* tdtis, quorunddfdcilitds temeritdtis ermine Idborduit, quÃ« creddmfore in hoe ordtoris modÃ¼, trddere non dUe Â»WÂ« uidetw â¦ Afiret dd dicendwin cunt femper qudn*

turn plurmu poterU-.nec^) cnim folum negUgentiStfed et nuUyCr in fufeepu edufd per^di ilc proditorit ed peiut ^amp;â^'â'â 3 poÃÃ¼.ldeo^ ne [ufcipicndÂ£ qnidem Ãvnt cMfÂ£ plures,^ cjuibui fuffÃ¨Ã©lurum fe feut. Dieet feriptti | res pdtieturplurimifCr utDemoÃhenesAit,Ãeotinget fcul ptd.Sed hoe etut prmne irones, dut que in pÃ¹blicis iu* dieiji poll mterieÃ©los dies diintur permiferint. At cum protmui refÃondendwm eH^ommÃ¤ pirdri non poffunt, ideo ddeÃ Ut pduÃ¯o minus proptis etu nocedt fcripfijfe/t l-mrKt^l-^ ^^ ^inf^^Q ^ fjp^^dfucruntiOccurrerintAnuiti c* nota cnim recedunt i prepirdtif^Oâ totd dHione reffictut, requirut^ nÃ¼ dliquid ex ilUs interudJUs, dtlt;^ ex tepore dieÃ«disinferi poÃit.quod fi Ãdt,no coheret^nce comiffu ris modo^t in opere mile iimlio hutibus, fed ipfd cola ris mequdlitdte detegiturÃtd nee liber eH impetus, nee eure cotextu^cr utrum^ dlteri obfldt. l/U enim que feri ptd funt^rctinent inmÃ.nÃ¶Ãquuntur. Ude^ in bis dlÃ¼o nibus,omni(ut dgricole dicunt)pedefldndu eH.Ã®idm cu in propoÃtione de refutdtione cdtifd cofiÃdt, que noÃre pÃ¤rtis funt/criptd effe poÃunt,quÂ£ etid refÃonfuru dd uerfdriucertum eH^eÃ enm dUqudndo certu)pdri eure refeUuntur.Ad dUd unÃ¼ pdrdtu dfjÃ¨rrepoffumus^utedu S-fummope' fdm bene nouer mus,dlteru ibi fumer e^ut dicentem dd* uerfdrium diligenter eudiemus. Licet turnen precogite re plurd,^ dnimudd omnes edufds eSponerejid^ eÃ tu tins Ãylo,quo fdeiUus et omittitur,et trdsfertur.Sed fuse in rejÃodendo fuerit fubitÃ dieÃ«dÃ¼, Ãue que dUd itd exe gerit rdtio, nunq oppreffum fe, ec deprebenfum credet

ORATOR. LIBER XIL 761 oritor, cui difdplini z^ ^udium or exercitdtio dcdc-rit uim etUm fMilitiitis,qiicmq;irmxtumli:mpcr,cic udut in procmHu ftMtem non natgis iw^ inedups ordd tio^epidm in rebus quotididnis de domeÃieis ferma deÃ-net^nee fitmq propter hoc oneri fubtrihet^modo fit am fie difeendi tempus^ ndm aeterd femper feiet.

SVpcreRut diedm de genere ordtionis.Ã¯liccrdt pro pofitut d nabis in diuifione primd locus tertias:ndm itdpromiferd me de arte,de drtiÃce,de opÃ¨re didurum. Cum Ãt dutÃ© rhetor is dtlt;^ or starts opus ordtio,plurcs(^ ehis forme,Ãeut oÃendd,in omnibus his et des eÃ,et drti fex,pÃ®urmu tdmen muieÃ« diffirunt, nee folum Ãpecie, ut fignum figno^zT tdbuldtdbulÂ£,Qr dHione dilio,fed ge* nereipfo,utd Gneis Tufednin ÃituÂ£,ZT Afidnus clo' ^uens Attieo.Suos dutÃ© hec operum generd que dico,ut Autoree,fie etid dmdtores hdbent,dtq} idea nondu eÃ per fedus ordtor,dc nefcio dn drs ulU,non folÃ¼ quid dUud in dUa mdgis eminet, fed quod no und omnibus formd pid' cuit, pdrtim conditione uel temporu uel locoru, pdrtm indicia cuiufqi dcpropofito,PrimiquoruquidÃ¨ operd non uetuÃdtis modo grdtid uifendd funt, cldri pidores fuiffe dicuntur Polygnotus dtlt;^ Agidophon, quoru firn* pkx colortdm fui Ãudiofosddhuchdbet,utiÃ¼dpropÃ¨, rudiddeuelut future moxdrtis pr'imordid,mdximis,qui poÃ eos extiterunt,dutortbiK preferdnt proprio quods intelJigendijut med opinio fert,dmbitu, PoÃ Zeufis steÃ fdrrhdÃuSi no multu etdte diÃdntes. Cired Peloponefid 6 s

^6i M. FAB. QVINT, INSTIT, ambo tempora : nam cu Parrhafio ferma Socratis apui ^enophontÃ¨inuenitur,plurimÃ arti addtderut.Cluorii prior lummumumbrarurn^ muenijfe rationÃ¨/ecnndM examina jfe ÃubtiliM lineat traditur, Uam Zeufis pita tnÃ© bris corporii dedit^id ampUus atq; auguÃius ratut,atlt;^ ut cxiÃimantyHomcrÃ¼ fecutus,cui ualidiÃima quf^ for ma etiam infamms placet, Ã¯Ãc uero ita circumferipÃt omnia,ut eumlegumlatorÃ«uocent,quia deorum atq bea roum effigies, quotes ab co funt traditie, ateri tanq ita neceffiefit fequuntur. floruit autÃ« circa Philippu, et uf' que ad fucceffiores Alexandri,piÃ¼urapracipue,fidex diner fis uirtutibusmam cura Protogenes, rotione Pom-^ philui ac tialanthius,facilitate Antipbiluf,concipiendK uifionibus (quas tpwlcecrÃ¯Â«^ uocant) Theon Samius, in' genio er gratid,qua ipfe in fe maxime iadat, Apelles eÃ prieÃantiÃmus^Puphranore admirandu facit,quod ty CÂ£teris optimis Ãudijs inter prÂ£cipuos,cr pingendi fin gendi^ idem mirus artifexfuit. Similis m fiatuis diffi' t CaUorentiamamet duriora,0â Tufeanicis proximo Calon atq- Egefiat,iam minus frigida Calamis, moUiora adbue fupradidis Myronfecit,Diligentia ac decor m Polycleo to fupra esteras, cui quanq a pleriÃ^ tnbuitur palmde tarnen ne nihil detrahdtur,deejfe pondus putat. flam ut humanig formte decorÃ«addiderit fuprauerum,itanon expleuijfe deorum autoritotÃ«uidetur, quin letatÃ«quoi^ grauiorÃª dicitur refugijfe,nihil aufus ultra leucs genos. At que Polyeleto defuerunt,Phidie atq^ Alcameni dano {ur Phidias tam dijs | hominibuf effidendis meUor arti*

fix tnditur, in ebore uero longe cited amulum, uelfi cf eJitur nihil niÃ ^Unerndm Athenis^duc Olympiu in Elide iouc feciÃfct,cuitK pulchritudo ddicciffe dliqd etid ret eptÂ£ re ligioni uidetur, ddeo mdieÃM operis deum icquduit, A d neritdtem Lyfippu ct Prdxitelem deeeÃiÃe optime affir mant, iJdm Demetrius tdn^ nimius in ed reprehenditur Affuit Ãmilitudinis tÃ¿idmpulchritudmis Amdutiort. IÂ« ordtione uero ÃjÃecies intueri ueUs,totidem penÃ¨ repe-riesingcmorum,quot corporÃ¼ formas,fed fucrttnt qute* ddm generd dicendicoditione temporu horridiord,dlioÂ» quimdgndmidmuimmgenijprefeferentid, time funt Lilij,AfricAni,CdtoeS:,Grdcchiq^,quos tu licet Polygno* tosucICdlonesdppeUes. MedidiUdm forma tenant L. ^f^us, QJdortÃ«fius.Tum deinde efflorefedt non mulo turn inter fe diÃdntium tempore ordtoru ingens proue tus, bitte uim CÂ£famp;ris,indolem CAij, fubtiUtdtÃª CdUid ij, grduitdtem Bruti, dcumen Sulpitij,dcerbitdtem CdÃij,di Ugentid PoUionis, dignitdtem McÃale, fdnUitdtÃ« Cdhi reperimusAn bis etidm quos ipfi uidimus, copidm Sene-a^uires Africdni,mdturitdtem AÃiduenditdtem Criffi, fonum Trdchdli,elegdntidm Secundi. At M. TuÃ¼ium no Ã¼lumbdbemus EupbrdnorÃªcircdpluriudrtium fÃecies prxÃdntem in omnibus qud in qÂ»o$ IduddnturyCminen-^ tiÃimu. Quem tdmen ez fuoru hommes temport incep fere dudebdnt. Ut tumidiorem, O' AÃdnum, o redun-dintem, o in repetitionibus nimium, o in fdlibus dU^ ^ududoÃigidum, o in compofitionefrd{Ã¯um,exultdn^ tem, depenÃ¨, (jnoi prowl dbÃt,uiro moUiorem,

Pojleduerot^uimtriumuindi profcriptione c6[umptui ell,pdÃ(m ([ui oder Mt,([ui 'muidebMt,cjui xmuldbitUTÂ» ddubtores etÃ¹m priefenth potentie, non rej^onfuru tÂ« fKiÃrunt. lUe tdmÃ« qui ieiunm 4 quibufddm dtq^ dridus , hiibetur, no dUter db ipÃs inmicis mdle dudire, | nimijs Ã^^ibm et ingenij dffluentid potuit,fdlfum utruq^ fed td men iUdmentiendi propior ocedfo. Prlt;ecipue uero pref ferut eÃ¼ qui uideri Atticoruimitdtorescupiebt. BiC md gt;nbsp;nud qudfi quibuÃd Ãeris 'mitidtd ut (dienigend,et uirum fuperÃitiofum, deumÃ¤umqi itlis le^bus mfequebdntur. Vnde nune quoq; dridi,Gr exuHifZy- exdngues. Bifunt enimq fuÂ£ imhecillitdtiÃnitdtis dppeUdtionÃ¨,qu^ eÃ md xime contrdrid,obtenddntiq quid cldriorÃ« uim eloquÃ«tifi uelut folÃ« ferre non poffunt,umbrd mdgni nomina deli' tefunt, quibuf quid multd, er pluribut locis Cicero ipfe rejpondit,tutior mihi de hoe diffcrendi breuitdf eriLEt MtiqudqdÃ«iÃ¼ddiuifio inter Atticosdte^ Afidnosfuit, cu hi preÃi er mtegri,contrd mÃdti iÃ¼i er indues hdbe' rent tir,m his nihil fuperÃueretyiÃ¼is indicium mdxime dc ^ Satyra anodin deeffet, Qj^od quidd,quoru er SMtrd dl, hoe putdut dccidiffe, quod pduldtim fermone Gmeo m pro^ ximds Afiieciuitdtesinflucnte,nondu fdtisperitiloquen di,fdcundid concupierint,ideo^ edqut proprie Ãgndri poterdt,circuitu coepermt enuncidre,dc deinde ineoper feuerduerint, Mihi dutÃ« ordtionis diffÃ¨rentid fecijfe,er dicentiu etdudientiundtur^ uidÃ«tur, quod Attici Imdti quidetn er emundi,nihil indne dut redunddns ferebdut. ^fdudgens tumidiordlioquieridÃ«ldtiortUdnioreetid.

ORATOR. LIBER XII. 7^5 ikeiiglorU infiitd eA. Tertiti max qui hÂ£c diuidebAt, ddiecerut gcniu Khodiu, quod uelut mediu effe, Mq^ ex utroq; mixtuuolut.Neqi cnim AtticepreÃi,nelt;^ Afidne funt abundHtcs, ut ^liquid hdbere uideitur gentK^tUqi autoris. Aefehmes enim qui hune exiUÃ³ deUgerdt locui intulit eÃ¨ ftudid Athemrum, quÂ£ uelut futd quÂ£dÃ cala tem^ degenerÃ¢nt,fdporem lUÃ AtticupÃ¨regrlno ini-[eueruni. Lenti ergo quidc de remiÃi, non fine pondÃ©rÃ© tdmen,neq; fontibut purK,nec^ torrentibm turbidis^fid Ãenibui fidgnis fimileshdbentur. Nemo igitur dubitdt â *â l'^^TjiiÃ® tterh longÃ© effe optirnu genus Atticoru,in quo ut efi dlu quid mtÃ©ripfios comunejd eR iudiciÃ» dere terfumq^, itd ingeniorÃ¼ plurmÂ£ forma. Qudpropter ntibi fdÃ¼i mul^ turn uidentur,qui folos elfe Atticos credunt tenues, et lu iiios,c^ fignifiedutes, fed quddd Ã©loquente ÃugdUtdte contentes, defemper mdttu mtrd pdUiu continentes. N4 iuis erit hic AtticUi^ fit Lyfids, hune enim dmplcÃ¢utur dmdtores iÃimnominis modum. Ã®Jon igitur idm u[q^ dd, Loccum, (g- AntocidÃ«remittemur. interrogdretdmen i*elm dn ifocrdtes dtticÃ© dixerit, nihil enim td eÃ¼ LyfiÂ£ ^iuerfum,negdbunti At eins fchold principes ordtorunt ^^dit. Q_uÂ£rdturfimilius dUquid, KyperidÃ©s Atticusf gt;^frte.At plus mdulfit uoluptdti.Trdnfco plurimos,LyÂ» ^urgu,AriÃogitond,e3' bis priores ifeuni, AntiphontÃ©i quos ut hommes inter fe genere fimUes^difiÃ¨rentes dixÃ© ris fpecie. Qjiid iÃ¼e cuius modo feemus mentionÃ© AefeÃ® ties^ nonne bis Idtior^Ã§y dudentior,0' excelfiori Quid denii^ Oemofihenes^Ã¼one cundos iUostenues (y circii

f^eitosfMintitdtc.ui^im^etu.cultu, compofitione fupe' rduit^ non infurgit lods^ non figure gdudeti no MnÃd tionibui nitetfnon ordtionefidd ddt tdeentibus uocetnf no iUud iufiurdndu per citfos in Mdrdthone de Sdldmine propugndtores rcipMicje ptis mdnifefto docet price* ptorem dus PldtonemfieiÃei c^uemipfum, num AÃdnii dppeUdbimus, pÃ¯erunlt;^ inflinilis diuinofpiritu udtibus copdrundu^Quid Pericles: fimilÃ¨ 'ne credimus Lyfidd grdcilitdti, quÃ« fulminibus, er cceleÃi /rdgori copdrdnt ^juf comici^dumilliconuicdntur:â Qitidestigitur, quad in his demum qui tenui uenuld pcrcdlculosfluuntAtticH fdporem putenti ibi demu thymu redoleredicdntiCiU,os ego exiflimo,ft quod in his Ãnibus uberius inuenerint fo hm, fertiliorem'ue fegetem negdturos Atticd eÃe,quad plusqdceeperit feminis redddtÃ¯Ciuid hdneeiustemÃ dem Mendnder eludit. itdq- nucfi quis dd eds DemoÃhe nis uirtutes,quds iÃ¼e furnmus ordtor hdbuit, tdmen qui deÃtiÃe ci,Ãue ipÃusndturd, Ãue lege ciuitdtis uidetur, ddiecerit,ut dÃvHus cocitdtius mouedt,dudiim dicentÃ©, non Ãecithoc DemoÃhenesi er Ã quid exieritnumeris d ptius,fortdjÃenonpoÃit,fed tdmenÃquid exierit,non eritAtticumi Melius de hoc nomine fentidnt, creddnt^ Attice dicerc, eÃe optime dicere. Atq^ in hdc tdmen opi nione perfeuerunies Gneos mugis tulerim,Ldtind mihi fucundiu, ut inuentione,diÃgt;oÃtione, conÃlio, erteris^ huius generis urtibusÃmilis Griecie,uc prorfus difcipU' lu dus uidctur,itucircd rutionem eloquendiuix hubere t danot imitdiionK hcum^Hunt^ ipÃs cÃÃdUm fonus duleior,

i^ududo or iucundiÃimM ex Gracif literm no hdbemuf^ uocdlem alterdmtdlterdm confonantÃ«^quibus nuÃÂ£ dpud tos dulciusfjjirdnt, qudf mutudrifolemus, (^uoties iUo^ rum nominibus utimur^Qtiod cum contingit,nefcio quo modohildrior protinus renidetordtio, ut in Zephyrif, Zopyris^: qux noflrie literis fcribdntur,furdum quidgt; ddm^O' bdrbdru efficient fonum, ey uelut in locÃ¼ edruin fuccedunt trifles,er horrido,quibus GrÂ£cid edret.Ndm iÃ¼d quÂ£ fextd eR nojirdrum penÃ¨ non humdnd uoce, uel omnino nb uoce potius inter difcrimind dentium effiddd eH, quÂ£ etidm cum uocdlem proximS, dccipit qudÃd quo ddmmodOyUtii^quotiesdliqudm confondntem frdn-J-fâ^^eig,it,ui git,multo fit horridior. AeolicÂ£ quoq; liter Â£ qud feruu g^Â°multVfit ceruum^ dicimus, etidm fi formd Ã nobis repudidtd eff^ horridior. nistdmennosipfidperfequitur, Durds ey iÃ¼d. fylldbds fdcit,quÂ£ dd coniunz^ndds demumfubieddsfibi uocdles â nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;;

est utilis, dlids fuperudcud, ut equos de equumjcnbi- ueteri codicÃª mus, cum ipfi etidm uocdles duÂ£ efficidnt fonum, qudlis hst diftioi (tpud GrÂ£cos nullus ed, idcoq^ fcribi iÃ¼orim literis non potefi, c^di quad plerd^ nos iÃ¼d qudfi mugiÃ«te liter d cludimus m, qud nuUum Gr/ccuerbueddit^ At idi/i iu-lundi, et in fine prÂ£cipue qudÃ tinnientem illius loco po nut,quÂ£ ed dpud nos rdriÃimd in cldufulis^cmidS quoi fylldbÂ£ nofir Â£ in bliterd,ey d innituturi die Ã dffgt;ere,ut pleri^i nb dntiquiÃimoru quids,fed tdmen ueteru mollit re tentduerint,nb folu dpuerfd pro dduerfis dicendo,fei ^ in propofitione b liter Â£ dbfiondm et ipÃm f fubijeien io.SeddcÃ§entusquoiffieurigorequoddftumfimilitudinÃ¨

ipfimmui finucshAbcmus,lt;iuid ultimo fyUnidnecdcutd unq excitAtUTynceflexa circunducitur,fedm graue,ud duos graues cadit femper. itaq^ tanto cR ferma Grteuf Latino iucundior, ut noflri poÃ«tÂ£ ^uoties dulce carmen effe uolueruntflUoru id nommibus exornent. Bis Sia po tentiora,(juodresplurmÂ£carentappellationibus,uteas necefje flt trafferre out circuire, ctu in his ^UÂ£ denomi nata funt, fumma paupertas in eadÃ«nosp-equÃªtiflime re uoluit,at illis non uerboru modo, fed Imguaru etia inter fediffÃ¨rentiucopiaefl,. Quare c^uiÃ Latinisexigit iÃ¼a gratia fermants Attici,det mihi in loquÃ«do eandÃ¨ lueur* ditatÃ« O' parem copiamt Quad Æ negatu efi,fcntentias aptabimus his uocibus quas habemus, nee reru nmia te* nuitatÃ¨,ut non dica pinguiorSgt;uS;fortioribus certe uer' bis mifcebmus, ne uirtus utraq-, pereat ipfa confuftone, Ham c^uo minus adiuuat frmo,reru inuentionepugnan dumeh.Senfusfublimes narijd entantur. Permouendi omnesaffÃ¨dus erunt.Oratio tranflationu nitore Slumi-nanda efl.Ho poffumus elfetagraciles^fimusfortioresgt; Subtilitate tutteimurf ualeamus podcre. Proprictatis pe nesSlos eR certior copiai uincamus ingenio.Griecorum etia minora fuos partus habent, nas plcruncj; maioribut uelis moueamur, ualidiorJ^iritus flnus noflros tendat, non tamÃª alto femper feremur: na o littora interim fe* ^uenda funt. llUs facilis per c^uxhbet uada acceffus, ego illiquid no mult a tarne altius in quo mea cymba non conft dot muenu.Heq; enim ft tenuiora hlt;ec ac preÃiora grÅ ci meliusfla eo^ umeimur folo^o idea in comoedijs non

ORAT OR. LI BER XII. 70 ^ontendimui, prorftis urnen onnttendd pars hac oratio ^isjcd exigenda, ut optime pofjumus, poffumus autÃ© re fftm (Squot; modo er iudicio eÃe fimiles,uerboru gratia qua in ipÃs non ha'betnus,extrinfecus condienda e{i,An non w priuitis,Gr acutus,et non aÃer, ztf non indiÃmdiis, Cf non(upra moduelatus M.TulHus^non m M.CaUidio infignis hxc uirtus^ non Scipio, La;Ã¯ius,Cato in eloquen do uclut Attici Romanorufueruntf Cui porro non fatis e^ quo eÃe melius nihil poteÃ^ Adhuc quidam nuUa eÃe naturale put ant eloquentiam,nifi quÂ£ fit quotidiano fir taoni fimiUma, quo eu amicis, coniugiius, libcris,firuis loquimur,contenti promere animi uoluntatem,nihilqi ac eerfiti Cf Ã©laboraiirequirentes ,qKicquid hue fitadic-Ã¼um,id eÃe aÃvÃ¤ationis, er ambitiofig in loquendo ia* Nantit, remotum Ã ueritate, fiÃ¼umq^ ipforu gratia uer horum,quibus folu Ã natura fit officium attribute, firui^ fe finfibuifficut athletaru corpora etiafii ualidiora fiant txercitAtione,cr lege quada ciborum,non tarnen eÃe na turalia, atq^eiilla Ãecie qugfit coneeÃa hommibus ab-horrere.c^id enim inquiunt,attmet dreuitu res ofiÃ¨de re,cr tranÃatiombus,id eÃ aut pluribus,aut alienis uer* lis,cÃ¼ fita cui^ fint aÃignata notai Denii^ antiquiÃimu quenq^ maxime ficundu natura dixiÃe contendunt,mox poetis fimiUores extitiffie,etia fit parcius,fimili tarnen ra done falfa cr impropriauirtutesdueentes. Qitamdi' Ãutatione nonihilueri eÃ¼,ideo^ non tam proeul, qÃta quibufda, recedendÃ¼ Ã proprijs at^ comunibut. Si quis tarnen, ut in Ulo loco dixiicompofitionis ad neceffiaria^

^uibu( nihil mmut e^, iliquid ntclius ddiccerit, non erit hac calunid rcprchcndendus.Hdm mihi dlid c^UiindA uidc tur hdbere ndturdm ferma imlgdrii, dUdm uiri periti dc eloquent is ordtio, cui ft res indiedre modofdtii effet,ni* hil ultrd uerborum proprietdtÃª eitbordret, fed cum dc' bedt deleddre,mauere,in plurimdt dnmu dudientisjfe* des 'impeÃ¯lere,utetur hit quoq; ddiutorijs, que db eddem funt nabis conceffd ndturd ^ Ã¯^dm er ideertos exercitdr tione conftrmgere^er dugere uircs,er eoloremtrdhere ndturdle cÃ¼. Ideoqi in omnibusgentibm dUus dliofdcun dior hdbetur,er eloquendoduleismdgis. Quadfinon cueniret,omncs pdres ejfent,er idem omnes deceret. At loqunntur,er fdludt perfondru difcrmen,itd quo quifq; plus efficit dicendo, hoc mdgis fecundu nature cloquen* tid dicit. Quipr opter ncillis quidc nmiurepugno, qui dundumputunt nonihileffetemporibus dtlt;^ duribus,niti dius dliquid atq; uffÃ¨lldtius poÃuldntibus. Itaq; non fo' lum dd priores Cdtonem Grdcchosq^fd ne ad hos quidc ordtorem dÃ¼igdndu puto.AtiÃ id feciffe M.,Tullium ui* deo, ut cum omnium utilitdti, turn pdrtem qudnddm dele Hdtioni ddret,cu er ipfdm fe rem dgere diccret (dgebdt dutÃ« mdxime) litigdtoris. 'Ndm hoc ipfo proderdt quoi agi pldcehdt. Ad cuius uoluptdtes nihilequide quad ddH poÃit inuenio,nifj utfenfus nos quidÃ¨ diedmus plures^ i\cq; enim fieri poteÃ falud trdddtione cMfe,er dieÃ«di dutoritdte,Ã crebrd hec lummd et cotinud fucrint,no in uieem offreermt. Sed me hddenus cedentÃ«nemo infequd mgra tajur ultrd,do tÃ«pori,nc erdffd toga ft, na fried,ne ttt*

ORATOR. LIBER XIL -771 tongum caput, non in gradus atc^ anulos totum com^ ftflum ptum,cu in co c^ui fe non ad luxuriain,icUhidinereferai cadentjfcciofioraqucq;fint,ciutehonefiord. Caeterunt hoc quod unlgc) fentÃ¨tiM uocamus,ueteriluf pnecipue^i Critcis in ufu non fuit,apud Cicerone enm inuenio dum ^ ^^^ rent contineant,cx copia non redundent,C7 ad uido-riant I^edent,quis utile neget^ Yeriunt animuni,^ uno idulrequentcrmpcllut,^:^ ipfalreuitate ntagis haret, O' didione persuadent. Ac funtquihiiecexcitatiora'^ ^^'^^^^â^^ lamina etiaft dicere permittat, Ã componendii tante ora tionilusexcludendaarhitrentur. Quocirca mihinchic quide loctu intadui cd emit tendus,quod plure$ erudito rum alia effe dicendi rationc,aliam ferihendi putaucrut, ideoq-, in agendo dariÃimosquofda nihilpofteritati ma furis^ max Uteris reliquiae,ut Periclem ^ Remade nit. Purfus alios ad coponendu optimos,adionibus idoncos nonfuiffe,ut ifocratem. Priieterea in agendo plus mpe^ ins pleriiq^,Gr petit as uel paulo licentius uoluptates. Co mouendosenim elfc,docendos^ animos imperitoru. At quod lihris dedicatur^GT m exemplum editur,terfum ac Umatum, ar ad legem ac rcgulamccmpofitum effe opor tere, quia ueniat in manusdodcrum,Cf indices artis ha heat artifices. Quin iUi fuhtiles, ut fimiles,ac multi per* fuaferunt magifiri ^Ã¢J'amp;y/axdicÃªdo, t^Ã¨v/au/aix feri-â hendo effe altius tradiderunt. lAihi unum at^ idÃ« uide-tur bene diccre, dc benefcribere, neque aliud effe oratio fcripta,quammonimentuma(lionis habita:.tteq; nul* las non,ut opmor,debet habere uirtutes, dico non uitlat

772 M. FAB. QVINT. INSTI T, thim imperitK placere alicptando qu/euitiofa funt fdÃ´. Quo diffÃ©rent igitur^i^uodÃ mihi descoÃlium iudicup pientum,perlt;iua muit a reddam ex orationibut, no Cice^ ronis mod6,ffd etiarn dut qui eil Ãridior multo Demo' Ãhenii. Ueque enim affÃ©dut omnino mouendi cruntfnec dures deledatione mulcendÂ£j cum etia proamia fuper' uacua effe apud tales AriÃoteles exiÃimedlio enmi trd' hentur bis Slis fapientes,propric crÃgnificanter rÃª int dicdre,probatione coUigere fatis ell.CÃ¼ uero iudex det tur dut populus,aut ex populo,laturiq; Ãententiam Mot di Ãepius,atlt;^ interim ruÃid, omnia quÂ£ ad obtinÃ©dum quod mtendmus,prodeffecredemus,adbibcdafunt,ea^ etiarn cum dicemus promenda, z^ cum Ãeribimus ,ut do ' ceamus quomodo did oporteattAn 'DemoÃhene maÃ¼cin fi^ ^S^ÃÃÂ»^^ ÃripÃt,aut Ciccronc,aut cos prÂ£ÃatiÃimos oratores alia q fcriptis cognofclmusilAelius egerunt igi tur dn pdus^l^am fi peius,Ãc potius oportuit did ut fcri pferuntt Ã meUus,Ãc oportuit Ãeribi ut dixermt. Quid rrgo,Ãempcr Ãc aget orator ut Ãeribitf Ã licebit,Ãcmper: quod Ã impediant breuitate tempora Ã iudice data,mul' turn ex eo quad potuit did recidetur,editio habebit oU, QuÂ£ autemfecundum natur am iudicantiu dida Ãunt, no it a poffer is tradentur,ne uideantur propoÃti Ãuiffe non temporianamid quoq; plurimu reÃert,quo modo iudex dudire uelit, ati^ ei uultus ÃÂ£pe ipÃe redus eil dicentis, ut Cicero prÂ£cepitddeo^ mÃandum bis quÂ£ placerein tetlexeris, reÃliendu ab bis quÂ£ non redpientur. Sermo WÃ igt;*^flt;*dle iudicem doceat, optandus. Hec id miruni

fit, cum aidm tedium perfonK dUt^ui mutenturtpruden ttr enm, qui cum interrogdffet rufticum tefiem^n Amgt; phiondf iJegdute co^detrMit dfpirdtionemj^rcuiduitqi ficunddm eius nominis fyÃ¼dbÃ, or tUccum fie optime no rdt^Uuiufmodi edfus effidunt, ut dliqudndo diedtur dU^ t^r qfcribdtur,eum dicere quomodofcribendumfit,non ^icett Alterd ell didfio,quÂ£ Ml trÃ¨s pdrtes ^ ipfid de-fcendit,qud difeemi poje etidm reHe dicendi generd in terfe uidentur.Udmqi unum fubtile,quod âi^vdfjuocdtt dlterum grdnde dtq^ robufium, quod cofiituunt ad'fop, tertium dUj medium ex duobiu, dlijfioridutn, ndnque id Â«v^K^o/] dppeÃ¼dnt,dddiderunt,quorÃ¼ tdmen ed fere rd^ tio ell,ut primu docendi,fecundum mouendi, tertium 4 admonedi illud utrocunq' nomine delccldndi,fiue dUudinterconeb Hindi pr^fidrcuidcturofficiu, Ã¯ndocendodutÃ© deumÃ¨, w concilidndo lenitds, w mouendo grduitds uidedtur.

itdq; iUo (ubtili prfcipue rdtio ndrrdndi probdndi^ co fifiet/ed quod etidm detrdÃ¤is ceteris uirtutibus fuo ge* fiere plenum. Mediui bic modus,G^ trdnfidtionibus cre^ Irior, amp;nbsp;figuris erit iucumdior, egreÃioniius dmanus, compofitione dptus,fententijs duleis, lenior tdmen,ut d-mnis lucidus quidd ell,Gr uirÃ©tibus utrinq; fyluis inum^ bÃ¯dtug. At iÃ¼e qui fdxd deuoludt,etpontem Mignetur, t^T ripM fibifdcidt,multus er torrens indicÃ© uel nitentÃ© contrdferet,cogetqi irc quit rdpit.Uic ordtor amp;nbsp;defun dos excitdbit, ut Appium Clt;ecum, dpud bunc er pdtrid ipfd excldmdbit, dliquddo^ Cicerone in ordtione contrd Ãdtilmdm in femttu dÃ¼oquetur.Uie er dmplificdtionibus.

extollet ontioncm, er ui Ãtperhitionutn c^uocitte engetÃ® Qu je chirybdis tA uorAxfar occAtun mÃ©diusfiditu ipf^^ tiotd funt enim Ã¯Am fiudioÃs biec htmim. Htc deos ipfos tneongre/jum prope fMmfermomm^ deduceUVose' tt'mAlbAttitumuUdtt^luci: Vos,mlt;iuAm, AlbAnorÃ¼ob' rutÂ£ dns, fdcrorÃ¼ popuU R.omdni focis Oquot; Â£lt;iudles.}iic irdm, bic mifcricordidm mjÃirdbii: Htc dieet: Te uidit, Cr Ãeuit,eyr dppeÃ¼duit,et per omnes AffÃ¨Hus trddAtur. HicitdqueiUuefequetur, needoceridefiderdbit. Quire fiextribusbiigeneribusneceffdriÃ³ ÃteUgedum unum, quis dubitet bune praferre omnibui, et uilidiÃtimu dUo' qui, z^ mdximis quibufe^ cduÃs dccommoddtiÃmumi Hdm er Homerus breuem quidem Animi iucundUdtem, er proprium (id enim eÃ¼ non errdre uerbis) er cdren* nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^

tem fuperudcuis eloquentid M.eneldo dedit, quÂ£ funt uir tutesgeneris idius pfmi. Et ex ore i^eÃoris dixit dul' dorem meUe proÃuerc fermonÃ«, qud certe deleUdtiom nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'

nihil Ãngi mdius poteÃSed fummx dggreÃM^ut m Vlyf fe,fdcundiA,mdgnitudmc idi iunxit, cui ordtionem mui bus hybcrnis,et copid uerboru,dtq} impetu pdrÃ« tribuit Cum hoc igitur nemo mortdlium contendet, hue ut dcum hommes mtuebutur. Hsne uim er celeritdtem,m Periele mirdtur Eupolis,bdnc fulmmibus AriÃophdnescompd* rdt,bsc eli uerd dieÃ«di fdeultds.Sed neq^ bis tribus qudÃ formis inclufd eloquentid cA. Hdm ut inter grdcile, udU nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;4

inter fe dum^,tertium dliquid conÃitutu eHJtd borum inter' â*â^â nbsp;nbsp;uiÃ¼d funt.At(^ inter bre ipfd mixtum quidddm ex duo'

ORATOR LIBER XIE 77Ã fibtSiutf^ uehementi remiÃius dtej; uehementius inuc* nitur,ut iUud lene aut afeedit ad fortiom, dut dd tenui-^ ord fummittitur, dc Ãc props imumerdbUes IÃecics re* periuntur, ^ug uti^ dUquo momento interfe diÃerdnt, fient epidtuor generdliter uentos Ã totidem mundi edrdi nibusdccepimui Ãdre,eÃ¼ interim plurimi medijeorÃ¼^ud-rietdte regionum dc fluminum proprie deprehendutur4 'Eddem^ muficis rdtio c{l,qui cum in cithdrd quinep con Ãitucrunt fonos, plurimd demde udrietdte copient jÃd' tid iÃ¼d neruorum,dt^ hts quor interpoÃteruntdnferuitt dlios,ut pduci tUi trdnfitm multos grddus hdbrdnt,Flures igitur etid eloquentie fdcies, fed ÃuhiÃimÃ¼ querere nd qudm reilurus fe Ãt ordtor, eu omnis Ifecies,quÂ£ mo do reHd eR, hdbedt ufum dtq^ id ipfum omne Ãt ordto quot;Â°â ris, quod wilgo genus dicendi uoednt. Vtetur enim ut res exiget omnibus, nee pro edufd modi, fed O' pro pdr tibui eduf^.iidm ut non eodem modo pro reo edpitis^o w certdminehereditdtis, ode inter didtis dejfonfwni* bus,o de certd re crÃ©ditÃ© dieet, fententidrum in fendtu OconcionumyOpriudtorumconfilioruferudbitdifcri mmd^uitd ex diffirentid perfondrum,locoru te mporu^ mutdbit,itd in eddem ordtione dUter concilidbit, non ex '^fdem pdrtibus irdm o mifericordid petet, dlids dddo-cendum, dlidsdd mouendu ddhibcbitdrtes. ^oiwus color proeemij, ndrrdtionis, drguinentorum, egreÃionis, perordtionis ferudbitur. Dieet idem grduiter,feuere,d-criter,ucl)emcnter,cocitdte,copiofe,dmdrc,comiter,re-wilfc,fulitiliter,blddc,lenitcr,dulciter, breuiter, wb^e,

non ubiÃ§ii fimuljfcd ubicunÃ§i; pdr ÃbiÃc Ãet,tum id pro' pter quod rnixime report m ufus omtioK, ut diedt et uti liter,et dd eÃteiendu qdâintÃ¨dit,potenter,turn IdudÃ« quo que nee doHoru modÃ³,fed etid uulgi confequetur.lcdUu tur cnimplurimu,qui uitiofuincreorruptu dicendi gc^ nut,qSdutuerborulicentid reÃdtdt,dutpUâ¬riÃ¼Tgt;ui fentÃª tiolis ldfciuit,dut immodico tumore turge feit, dut muni' but lacis bdcchdtur,dut cd[uris,Ã kuiter excutidntur,fla fculis nit^t,dut pracipitid pro fublimibus hdbct,dUt Ã^c* de libertdtk 'mfdnit,mdgis exiÃimdt populdre dtq; pldU Ãbile, c^ttod qdÃ«pldceremultisneeinÃcior,necmiror. Eilenimiucundioris dc fduordbilis qudlifcunlt;^ eloquÃ«' tix, et dddueitdnimos ndturdli uoluptdtc uox omnis ne' quedUude itli per ford dti^ dggerÃ«circuli, quo minus mi rum eH, quad nuUi no dgentiu pdrdtd uulgi corond cÃ¼. Vbi uero quad exquiÃtius diÃ¤Ã¼ dccidit duribus imperi* torum,qudlecun^ id,quod modofe ipÃ po/fe defperent. kdbetddmirdtiÃ¼nÃ«,nelt;p immeritoindm ne tUud quidÃ«fdÂ» * ^ââ^Â° cile caused eudnefcut bac dtqi moriutur copdr dtione me Uoru,ut Idnd tinÃ«ld fucco citrd purpuras pldcettdtÃco tulerit etid ldcerni,conÃeilu meUoris Ã³brudtur,ut Oui dius dit. Si uero iudiciu his corruptis dcrius ddhibeas,ut fuccinisfulfurd,id iÃ¼ud qdâfefellerdt,cxudt mentiu colod: rem,er quddd uix endrrdbilifxditdte pdttefedt. Lucedt igitur hic citrd folÃ«, cr ut quÅdd exigud dialid igniculi uidentur in tenebris. oeniq; mdld multi probdt,nemo im probdt bond-Neq; uero omnid iÃd de qbus locutifumus, orator optime tantu,fed etidfdcilimefdciet- Nf$ enim

ftis Ãmmx dicÃ¨di efjet ddmimtionc digfU,Ã infeUx uf^ id ultimu foUcitudo perfei^uitur^iic ortitorÃª miccrit et coi^uit^agf^ uerbi uertentÃ«,et perpended^ codgmÃ«tM dii^ eis intdbefcentc.t^itidus ide etfubli/mis etlocuples, circufluÃ¨tibus u/nditp cioquÃ«tiÂ£i-copijs imperdtiDefinit â Â»'PÂ®Â®Pâ enim m dduerfd niti,lt;^ui puenit in fuMmÃ¼.Sca,dcnti cired md libor ep^exterii qitdutu^pccfferis moUietur diues et kti!Â« Æo^M,Et fi hdc (ptoep u leuius fupremd ppuerdnti bus Pudijs eud[erit,mde frudus iÃ¼dbordti offÃ¨rut [efe^ tuertcris O' Old j^onte proueniunt, (jug tdmÃ¨ quotidie nip decer pdgt;ttur,drefcunt.Sed lt;0 eopid hdbet modu,fuie ^Â»0 niÂ» bil nee Iduddbile^nec fdlutdre ed, 0 nitor ide cultum ui rilÃ«tO inuentio indiciu-Sic erunt mdgnd non nmid,fub limid nondbrupid/ortid non temerdrid, feuerd non tri flid,grdiÃ¼d no tdrdd,lctd no luxuriofd, iucudd non luxu dijfoÃ¯utd,plend non tumidd . Similis in exteris rdtio ed. Tutifimd ferÃ¨ p mediu Wd,lt;j.d utriufl; ultimu uitiu edÂ»

Hls dicendi uirtutibus ufus ordtor in iudicijs, coÃ lijs,eocionibus,fendtu,in omni dÃ©niai officio boni citiisffinÃ« quo(^ dignu 0 optimo uirojet opere fdndiÃi mo fdciet^tto cpuid prodeffe un^ fdtis fit,et iUd mÃ«te dtlt;^ iUdfdcultdte prxdito non conuenidt operis pulcherrimi tpumlogiÃimu tÃ«pus, fed ^uid decet hoc quoeji proffiiee re,ne eptid peius ^fecerit/dcit^ Ue^ enim fciÃ«tid modo conÃdt ordtor^lt;^uÂ£ dugetur dnnis,fed uoce,ldtere,Ãrmi -tdte^eluibus frdÃ¤is, dut imminutis dtdte feu udletudine, eduendwm ed/ie lt;puid m ordtore fummo deÃdereturpit

interftjldt fdtigdtut,ne quit dieet pdru dudiri fentidt,ne fe quardt priore.Vidi ego loge oim,^uos mihicognosce re cotigitfwmmu ordtore,Domitiu AfrumtUilde jenem, quotidie dU^uid ex ed qud meruerdt dutoritdte perden tem,ctM dgente iUo^quem prmcipemj'uiffe quondd fori non erdtdubiu,dlij (qdâindignu uideldtur)riderent,dlij erubefcerent,^ult;e ocedfio Uli fuit dieÃ«di, mille earn deÃ cere g deÃnere^iieqi erdt iÃ¼d qudlidcuqi mdld,jed mino rd. coudre duteq in hdf Â£tdtii uenidt mfidiM ^ receptui ednet,(^ in porta integrd ndue peruemettneq; enm mi nores eucum idfeceritfiadiorafruiliu profequentur, Aut illemonimÃ«td rera poferii^dut ut L.CrdffM in U'' â¦reddet J^fij CiceroisdeÃind!bdt^qaiieretibui trddet,duteloiptc tia componet drtem,dul pulcberrimit uitÂ£ pr^ceptis di gnu 0! ddbit.'frequÃ«tdbumt uero eiu4 donsu optmi isme nes more ueteru,et uerd dicendi uid uelut ex ordculo pc testt.Hos illeformdbit qudfi eloquentu pdrens,cr ut ue tui guberndtor, littord or portin, t^ qua tempefdtii p fratum gnd,quidfecumdis Ãdtibui, quid dduerÃs rdtii pofedt, docebit,no humdnitdtis folum connimi duÃut ojfcio,fed dmore quodd opern. Nemo enm minui ueUt id, in quo muxmuifuit. Qjiid porrÃ³ ell honeÃiui, q docere quoi optime fcidi^Sic ddfe Cilia dedullu d pdtre Cicero pro Ãteiur,fic Pdfdm,liirciu,Dolobelld in morÃ«prieceptoris exerÃ§ait,quotidie dices dudiÃ©s^.Ae nefcio dn eÃ¼ tuc bed tiÃmÃ¼ credi oportedt fore,ca id fecretuset confeerdtut, liber inuidid,procul d conteiuionibusfdnid in tuto collo

ORATOR. LIBER XII. 779 [alct.ucncrAtionc^C^ i^uid Apud softer os future fit ub debit.Cofeiut firn inilji,^Mtti mediocritAte uAlui^c^iixfi Anted filer tm^c^KX^ aperts huilt fie gratid potuerim wi^ rerCyCAdUe me itlt;^ fimpliciter in notitie, eorufi qui for te cognofiere uolitijfent,protulijfi,lt;st^ id uiro bona fd^ tis eH docMffe,qdâfiierit.Vcreor tdmÃ« ne dut mdgnd ni miu uidedr exigere,qui eundc uirivm bonÃ¼ effe^et dicen di peritÃ¼ ueÃ¯im, dut multd, qui tot drtibuf in pucricid di fiendis moru quoq; preceptd, cr fiientid iuris: ciuilis, prÃªter ed que de eloquÃ«tid trddebdtur^ddiecerim,qui^ hec operi nojiro necejfdrid efficrediderm^uelut podut rei phorrefidt,dc defiierÃ«t date experimentu.Sed hi pri mu renuncient fibi,qudtd fit hum mi generis uis,q patÃ©s tfiieiendi quf uelit,cum mdrid trdfire,fideru curfus nu meros^ cognofiere^ mumdu ipfim penÃ¨ dtmetiri, mino ves fid dijficiliores drtes potuefmt.Tu cogitent quitud. rem petit, qui^ nullus fit hoc propofito prlt;emio Idbor recufdndus.CHiod ft mente cocepermt,huic quoq^ pdrti fdcilius decedent,ut ipfum iter,net^ imperuifineq^ filtÃ© durup.itent.'iid id quod prins,quod^ muius e^,ut bo^ ni uiri fimus,uolutdte nuxime confidttqud qui uem fide iniuerit,fdcile edfdÃ« quÂ£ uirtutÃ« docent,drtes dccipiet. Ne $ enim dut td perplexd,dut tdm numerofd fumt,quie prgmâMtt,utnan pducoruddmodudnnoru/m intentione difcitur,longA enim fdcit operd quad repugndmus-Ure uiseÃ¼ infiitutio uitlt;e honefig bedtÂ£q;,fi credits, tidtut rd enm nos dd mentem optlntdm genuit, ddeo^idifiere meUord uolcntibus promptu efi,ut uere 'mtuenti mirvxit

fit iÃ¼ud mdgis,mdlos effe td multas â 'Nd ut dfiud pifeibus^ ut fieed terrcnis,circtifufus nabis ffiritus uolucribia con uenit, itd certe fdcilius effe oportebdt fecundu ndturd,^ . nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cotrd ed uiuere.Cneterd uero etid ft ittdtÃ« noÃrd na Ibd*

âFcorporc nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;t nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;t f

adolefcenti/ itofenettutK, fed tepore ddolefcettx mettdmur,dbui^ a'n nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;multas (ld difcendu dnnos hdbÃ«t.QÃ¯d enim breuiordrei

h detordo,etrdtio,et modus. SedculpdeH in pneeptori ter def inent bus primd, libÃ«terdetmÃ«tibuspueru,pdrtimcupiditdt quos occupa te diutius exigÃ«di mercedulAÃ¯,pdrtim dmbiti()e,quo dif* UerUnt nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Zlil^l^nnii'^nl-nv

negligÃ«tÃ®d-.proxmi in nobit, ^ui momri m eo quoi no umiis,q difcere que nondÃ¼ fdmat^meUm putdmus. NÃ ut de noÃris potiÃmuÃudijs died, fluid attmet td mul* tit dnniftfiuin^ in more eft plurmoru (ut de hit d qbm mugnd in hoc pdrs Mtis dbfumitur, tdced^decldmitdre in fchold, cr tdmÃ¼ Idboris in rebut fdlÃs cofumere/ufd tis fit modico tepore irndgme ueri difiriminis,etdicÃ©di leges coperiffe^Quod no dico,qd fit tm^ omittedd dice di exercitdtio, fed fluid nofttivnd eim f^ccie confenefee du.Cognofcere enim or pr^ceptd uiuedi perdifeere^ZT vnforonosexperiripotuimus,dum fcholdÃici fumus.lÃ«ii Ã§Ã©di rdtio tdlis,ut nÃ¶ multas dnnos pofcdt:qud:libct enim ex bis drtibus,ciudru priai hdiui mentionÃ¨.'m pducos U* bros, cotrdhi folet,ddeÃ infinito j^dtio de trdditioe opus na eH.KeUqud eÃ¼ ciux uires cito Ãeit conflict udo,rerÃ¼ cognitio quotidie ere feit,et tdmÃª multoru ddeds librotu neceffdrid leUio eH, qbus dut reru exÃ«pld db hifioricis, dUt dieÃ«di db ordtoribus petwitur. Philofopboru fluors

tofuÃ¯toru^i opmionej,ftcuti aUd, uelimui legere nceeffd ria ell. Qj^a (Ã¿ddÃª pojjumut old ^ fed ireue nobu tepm nos fecimui,qMntu]u enimfudijs impertimurdAliM ha TM udiiM fdlmddi Idbor, dliM ddtufdbulK otiu,dUdS fpe (ldculd,dlids couiuid trdhut.Adijce tot generd ludÃ«di,et mfdnd corporis curd. Trdhdt inde peregfnidtio^rurd, cdlculoru dnxiit foUcitudmes, multx edufd UbidmÃ¼jZT umu/tfldgitiofus omnigenere uoluptdtu dnimus, ne ed (luide tepordidoned, lt;IUÂ£ fuperfunt. ClUitftotd Ãudijs impendereturÃd nobis logd Â£tds,ct dlude fdtis dd difee dufpdtid uiderentur,etdiurnd tdntu coputdntibitstÃ«pÃ³ rd,^ noites^gitdru bond pdrs omni fomno logior eft,dd iMidrÃ«t.'tJHecoputdmusdnnoSino ([uibus ÃuduimusÃcd (piibiu uiximus. Nee Â«f ro Ã geometrie er grdmitid^ce terdru^ drtiÃ profeffores oÃ«m fuduitdmcjUdUbetlogd fderitlm fingulis drtibus cofumpferumt/eejuitur ut plu* res(ptd[dd uitMydd plurd difcÃ«dddefideremui.^elt;^ iÃ¼i didicerÃ¼t hec uf^ in fenedutÃ«ffed ed fold dididlfe cote ti fuerut,dc tot dnnos in utendo,no in pcipiÃ«do exhdufe rut.Ceteru ut de Homero tdeed, in quo nullius no Artis, dut pfedd,dut certe no dubid ueÃigid reperiutur,ut EtÃ© um Hippid trdfedm, ^Â«i Â«3 UberdliÃ¼ modo difciplmdru prefe feientidm tulit,fed uefiÃ«,et dnuiÃ¼,crepidds^,quÂ£ , otdmdnufudfecerdt,inufulidbuit, dtq;Ã¼dfÃ©prÂ£pdrd â¢ ^^* uit,ne cuius dlterius opÃ© cgeret,nÃ©ue ullius rei. GorgidS quo^i fMimÂ£ fenedutis id quÂ£rere Auditores,de quo qf que ueÃ¼etjiubebdt.Ãlue tddÃ«drs dignd litcris Pldtoi de

tofophos dt^ ordtores ptmet fciemid ccplcÃ¤crcturj^d dntÂ»ndli Â« fatoru^ ndturdf oÃ«s pquirerct t Jfiw enim bme miKniÃ©dd fuerut, nabis cognofcedd fwtt.Tot nos pr^ce ptor thus,tot exÃ«plis inftruxit diui^tds, ut poÃit uideri nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,.

nuÃ®ld forte ndfeÃ«ditetds feUcior 3 noÃrd^cui doeÃ«difpri ores cUborducrut. M.,CÃ«forius CdtoidÃ«ordtor, idÃ«hi* ftoriit coditor,idÃ« iuris, idÃ« rerÃ¼ ruÃiedru pitifmutfu it,inter tot operas militi^ytstiis domi cotÃ«tiones,rudi fe euloJiterdS gneds it tÃ¤te id dcclindtd didicit^ut effet lot bus documÃ«to,ed quotj^ pcipi poffe que fenes cocupifÃ«tÂ» ^ QaS multd pene oit trddidit Vdrroi C^od 'wÃrumenÂ» turn dieendi M.Tullio defuiti Qjtid plurd^cÃ¼ etil C.Cel fuimediocriuiringeniOjnofolwmdehisoibMeofcrip^e uatticodke ^^^ drtibus^fed dmplius rei militer is,er ruÃicig etid, et

medicina prlt;eceptd reUc^ueriti dignus uel ipfoppofito, , 1 Ut eÃ¼feiffe otd iÃ¼d credumui. At pfeere tltu opus drdu wn eR,et nemo pfecitfAnte oÃ¹ fufficit dd exbortdtionÃ« fludiorÃ¼,edperc id reru ndturl, ut qcq^d no eÃ¼ failu,ne fieri ^dÃ« pofit,cu oÃ¹ quie mdgnd funt dtep ddmirdbiUdf tÃ«pus dÃ¯itidisiuo prima efficerÃ«turJhdiuerint.Qultu e^ nim poÃ«ps db Homero et Vergilio,tdntu fdÃigiudecepit eloejuÃ«tÃ¹ d, DemoÃt dtlt;]^ Cicerone.Denio- qc^d eÃ opti tnu,diue nofuerdt.VeruetiAfi qsfimmd de^eret(lt;piod cur fdcidt,cuiiÂ»gcniu,UAletudo,facttÃ¯tdi, preceptor no deer ant i)tdtnÃ« eÃ,ut Cicero dit,pulchru in fecudis terti imbeciÃ¯!is ii^ cofiÃcre. lieq^ enim fi ^s AchiUis glorid-i-in beUicis

cofequi non poteÃ,Aidcis dut Diomedis IdudÃ« affernabi tunne^ ^ui tiamcri^no Tyrtei.Ciitmmofi bic cogHd^

ORATOR. LIBER XIL 785 ttoÂ«c hoies hdiuiÃiittfUt nemo fe meUorefore eo g. opti mw fiiijjet,drbitrdrctur,hi ipÃ ^Â«ifunt optimi^nÃ¶ fuift' fent.^^ei^ pof Lucretiu,dc Mdcrtim Vergiliui,nec paÃ Crdffem et HortefuCicero^fed necdUjpofed uicermt, Veru ut trdfeumdiff es non fit mignd,tdmÃ« eu dignitds fubfespiÃ«di. Art PoÃ®lio et Ke(fdld,lt;Ã¿ii id Cicerone drcÃª te neme eloquÃ«tiiS dgere cceperÃ¼t, pdru m uitd dignitdtis hdbueruntfpdru dd pofieros glorist trddiderutfAlioqui pefime de rebut humdnis pduÃie in fuminÃ¼ drtes mere rctur,fi qdâoptimufuiffet,defuiffet, Adde e^dâmdgnos mo dicds^uoi^ eloquÃ¨tid pdritfrudusidefi qs hitc fiudid uti Ãitdte fold metidtur,penÃ¨ iÃ¼iperfedx pdr cA.Ne$ erdt difficile^uel uetcribuf,uel nouis exÃ«plis pdld fdcere,non dliÃ¼de mdiores honores,opes,dmicitidt,ldudÃ« prxfinÃ¯c^ futurd hoibus cotigijfe,fi tdmÃ« dignu Uteris effet,db ope re pulckerrmo,cuius trdcldtus dtlt;fi ipfd pojfeÃio plcnif firnd fiudijs grdtid refert,hdc m'morÃ« exigere mercedÃ©, more eoru,lt;iui dfeno uirtutes, fed uoluptdtÃ« lt;^ fit ex uirtutibus,peti dictÃ¢t. Ipfdm igitur orddi mdiefidtÃ« ^ud nihil dij Itnmortdles melius hommi dedcrÃ¼t,et i^ud remo td mutd funt old,et luce prxfemi^zy memorid pofieritd tis cdrÃ«t^oto dnimopetdmus,nitdmur^sfmp dd optirndi e^dfuciÃ«tes dut euddemus infummu, dut certe multos in Ãd nos uidebimus.Pldbes MdreeUe Viiloritqbus preece ptddicÃ«di,p uirili pte ddimidri poffe p nos uidebdntur, tjuoru cognitio fiudiofis ittuenibus fi no mdgnd utilitdtÃ« dffÃ¨ret,dt certe,^uodmdgis petimus, bondm uolutdtemt

t N D E X.
â¦ranflÃ¯tioni qus fint neceffaria ttanflationequandoutamur	nt
tranflata qux dicantur uerba	328
â¦ricola
tropus quid fit	^Â°*'8{ Ã¯is
tropus continuas in allegoriam Ksnigma exit
tropi Ã figuris quid diffÃ©rant tubx in R-o exereitu quid agant	51$
tumultusquidfit
tyrtxuinHorat.Homerofubiungit nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.	Â«15
quot;T yAlernFIaccilaus
\ / uaUfn S Fufi1,qui nunc Valerq K Furfl	3d
V uareni laus	621
uaii poe tx laus	Â«2)
uentilatores in feenis	Â«5$
uenus armata apud Lacedatmort.	92
uenuftum quid dieatur	374
uerbis quidam funt deuanda	a4T
uerbis cuiufmodi utendum	ys
uerbalia qux	35
uergilius primo Icgcndus d pueris	et
uergilius paucifiiinosuerfus diecompofuit	lt;3T
uergilÃ¼ principia	222
uergiliflaus	620
Werginius xtate Fabil	754
uertere grxca conducit plunmum ad comparandam elo-
quentiam	Â«4*
uibius Crifpus	3Ã¯T
uibh Crifpi diftio Si laus	Â«2*
uifellius (criptor	SS*
ulyfiis oranris fiatus apud HomÂ« uitx anteadx crimina quoinodo traffanda fint	72d
	40
uitia qux circa geftum accidunt	711
uitia quxdam puerorum ferenda funt	9J
uopifcusunde dieatur	3Ã
uox prxceptoris ut fol tft	2t
Â«oxquaiiifitoratori	Â«Ã¯