�S'^^rinijn qua primo exponunlur caufiar, *'*�� lacobiAndree manus amp; lingua,inftarlLnbsp;f fit contra omnes.Deinde diluunturnbsp;� * criniinationes, quas in poftremis fuisnbsp;'�'^'ptisaduerfus D.Io.Iacobum G ryn�um,nbsp;P�^itnin Marcum-Bcumlerum , partira in

^�Huldrichum Zuinglium.partim de-nique in incIitamRempub.Tigu-nnam,fine fronte amp; men-tCjConfinxit.

Vcnwrtt mihi mifericordi� tud; kbo� *�lt;i filitt tua fecundum fermonem tuum.nbsp;ff/^on dcam probro me afficienti vernbsp;^um.-quia confido verlgt;o tuo,

vrbe Tigurina. Antiftitibus j Dom� ��Patronis,ac Preccpt�ribusfuisin Chrinbsp;ftolefa fibi plurim�m amandis,falu�nbsp;lem,paccm,S� gratiam � Deo p�tre luminum.precatur.

rijTtmi T^ttraniac Tr� ceftores flurimiim rt�t�tndi^nbsp;^onditiintyifUa Eenbsp;clefia nejira fgt;of�_ rtjhr�unt

lt;ultatiln(f} quilw tjuod.tmrr.Qtio :en:lgt;eriin* tur,non carent. ^onn ^utde/n itltaJemfffnbsp;fu�pax,funima coficordi/t, cen�anxin �lt;j'nbsp;LiriM confenj�o, njuruui docendwin amp;ili'nbsp;fcentium minimsjjfucatux am^r,Alacre y(fnbsp;ium �DeipromoKendi�udiuin.'Ivlagnfnbsp;fe^o bonA liberAlirate �)ei Admirabdi coii'nbsp;ceffa. Iniuem�n� en�m non fcliim 'fictMSnbsp;T^l^ub.fedetiam anitn^ y�jlr�lu/lfAti (Onbsp;fttm rgrrarum orbem: Aiquemodonbsp;fa bona ntnoiniy ita �Vt nobds,eueniffecogfquot;'

. Qw) amem pneclariora t�dafunf j quo pauaoribtix ob�ngunt , eb ardiJt^^^nbsp;Deuxnobfsorandus amp; exorandttff^� V

hutf, fobrieute, mode�ia, con�antta,^ ftifilio 5 indii�rittj 'vigilaniia. pr�l'.ixerinr,nbsp;adomnenbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;genta quafifacex

i^xtulerific : fi deni^Ue nes iuniores egre^ ' ^^�uilUsTairum ^Tr^ceptorum yirru^,nbsp;gt; quxhaclema, ab�e a/�entution� �u-^nbsp;l^ieia b^dobfcure emicuerune, ex^rtme^'nbsp;amp; con�et^uijedulo laborauerimM.

�unt illa feminafu , hitc �tnr funda-^ ^enta fttlcra , qutbta res�oreneespro-l^ganrur, con�rmtintur, auge�cunt amp;�a--.nbsp;^uuntur.

� Ad htec 'Merb�udid ex�tabimur e�- prt ^betnur omnes gt; � cogitAuevitnia i�a, e^ui-^nbsp;liberali�imo t)ei muntre fruimur bo^^nbsp;*id,fuas quoque habere difficultates ,neiiuelt;'nbsp;^xtra emnem teli ia^um, ye e^�^inyecerinbsp;f^outrbio, po�ta effi : fed � �itribia op^�-^nari, quam yulgttf exi�imare p��ic : ar^nbsp;^ueidcirco nob�circum�e^'e agendum efCnbsp;K 2^am quotidie audimus non folum nostnbsp;fedetiam maiores no�ros, heroas illos nun^nbsp;fjuam fac�laudatos tper quos Deus yeramnbsp;�uangelij lucem nob� reeididic t abbotni-J

intolerab�libu^ eon ui cijs onf rari, ^uitii�imorum errorum accu�irt,f^^'nbsp;forum criminum in�mulari, dtru ini^�i^nbsp;^nAthematifmit feriri i omnium hartites'^nbsp;rumhominec natos fe�imos naceactfnbsp;fmos jflgt;roclamari amp; �vbtj^^rofcribi.nbsp;^ue^er�baciPonrificijs Joliim, ^uosnbsp;tnM a nob� capirali ad^AXaxT�nbsp;4i�idtrt, fed etiam amp; ^uidem multi) nta^lt;fnbsp;tir immodtftiits abijs, ^uiiu?um Tani�'nbsp;(turn abiectrunr , amp; 'Vr.d n^ifium dtE^nbsp;�an^tlia Chrifio mediatoreglori�'^'^nbsp;tur ,ftrfttm�turi tea yf ab 'dits non m�*nbsp;t t^uam ub hu nobts merutndumnbsp;uendumfit. Hifcbtec funtilUtnbsp;Yneeeptorts reutrtndi^ quet nos adnbsp;am pacts , mutui timortt exufeitare ifnbsp;ienti bdcfunt, quee nosddi^tntiam ero'nbsp;feras coniungendas inuitare debtnr : bs�nbsp;denitfuefunti ^luce nos ad domefiicas inifHfnbsp;�eids f ad clandefiina odia , ad priusttinbsp;fmultafes , � quadam inter nos exi�*^^fnbsp;deponendas amp; extinguendas imfellerfffifnbsp;rieb debent t fi/jui d^m nob^ ip�, �^�iit^nbsp;ton*

*'^^f�ilar t yt oferasnoJlrASconiungnmu^, in exfernos bofi�s ^ropulfanios eon-gt;nbsp;^��^tamus. �t cert� ytmtllum optatiuf,nulnbsp;Y^pta�antiat f nulhtrn deni^ue iucundiufnbsp;*^fiufn bominibus obtingit tn hae y tratnbsp;Jx�� fratrum fimul habttantium confiantnbsp;Concordia amp; mutuua mintmed fucaw a^

? ita nulla res eilf, efie debet, ipa iU tanri tam^ ntceffdnj boni vinculumnbsp;*^^iusconfiringat, fide�ns contineat tfor-corrobor�e quam externorum ho�iumnbsp;'^folentia, iniuria, amp; impetus. Huiufet retnbsp;alia quot;yirbts amp; ^fbub. multa, rum ye.,nbsp;fiorenti�imum illud T^manorum [mpe..nbsp;luetdentifiima documenta nobis dede-.nbsp;^�*ftt.Ham dum abexttrnii hofiibusinfefia

rewfwr amp; exercerentur T^mAni coh^Ans inter eos colebartir concordtA, coniunili�i-�nbsp;m'e amp; dmAnt't�im'e yiuebant, operAS inu-,nbsp;tUAS jUi A�iivie prA�a^Anc,conJ�iA commitnbsp;nicAbdntfJe mtiruo tolerdbant: AtqaeiiAc rA 'nbsp;tione (ortim ret Ait^ebantur amp; incremetitAnbsp;fiimebant, �t ''ierb,excerntf hefiibM �dttti-

, rebitf omnibw terra fftari^j^AcatH amp; iji tuto cellocdt�, in propria rttsbant 'vifce-ra, ciuilia amp; inte�ina bella, ^ag n'tin^UAtnnbsp;non tri�i�imas calamitate's p'ortentlufi'tnbsp;tnouebant, d� dominatu hojiiliter dimita^nbsp;bant. QMbtuetiam rebtit�^r moribtit tffe.-^um ejl, ytpotenti�imtim �llud Imperium,nbsp;^uod dum ctuet concordes erant , inui^ttnnbsp;p'utabatur j amp; omnibus inflar Qorgonif,nbsp;terr or em incutiebat, non fol�m labefa'nbsp;^aretur , fedplane de�orefceretfunditu�^'nbsp;^ueperiret. Vbi �gt;ierb exteYntj eliam hofti'nbsp;bw in^ruentibtis aninii �nti�ituni ambi'nbsp;ttoneturgentcs, T�^iovi^ic�infanientes,�-inultate laborantei difirabuntur drfcot-dant ,ibi,ibiinqitdm ccrti�ima trijU�t'nbsp;ma

trt iiuina amp; TrvbvoXi^Qxti� /nox fuif� ^turx indicia fefe o�endunt. hxc ita,nbsp;prim�m �theniei�um �/^�uh.tempo-fe �btni��henif (irThili^pr.^o^eayere Itt-�.nbsp;^^�oruwipoF^ Cbri�itin in ctelumfublatum^nbsp;btculenti�ime demon�rarunt. Qax cum tutnbsp;noflri,HuUrichum .^inplium ptito,nbsp;^(onem ludxjHenrichum ^ulUn^eru^ Odnbsp;\^neni ff'tierdmullerum, Conradum Tellica.

Theedorum 'Btbliaadrtim, lahannem. b^Ublfiutfif'Petrum �M'artyrem,Iofiain Sint.^nbsp;^^^um,amp;ye�ruin que^ nonMUos,quos iXcitSnbsp;^iiSenns fiiper/iites ej� yolftirr con�derainnbsp;nuUirei�bi ta accurate�udenduiudinbsp;^^nnt,iju�m mutuo amorkqudmpaci amp; c�nbsp;^ord�� dome�icx'.nihilj^fibi tamprficauen�nbsp;exi�imarunt,^udm cau�as contentionnbsp;^utn ^ dtj�idiorum amulanonumj^inte�innbsp;*^arum. jfntslligebant enim homines altanbsp;i^adam mente prxdtti�e nuHaalta rationenbsp;�noletn negotioru amp; periculorum^ua ab exnbsp;ho�ibitf parabantur�u�inerenbsp;f^�arepoffe. Quamyero egregi� amp; lauda-biliter �it^ illttm laudabilemfinem, quem

�ii ^r6f�niilt;tne otnnes^ conftcuti�nt, wtt filiim HOI nottimttf ^cum mttgnt yolupM'nbsp;tt rtcorJ^Mur: federiam exttn homines�tnbsp;fenumtro mihi narrare amp;in mtmoriam ft*nbsp;ifocarefolent.l^tinaat yrinam �)ttM,in (�*'nbsp;issr manu omnia funr amp; cuius nuiu omni^nbsp;re^untur, noh� omnibus earn metem donet�

in fo�trum ^uoifftonf^ivemiHX quando^^^*quot; dem intellipimusaduerfarios non modinbsp;tnitefcere,fidindies ma^� ma^�^ exa/jftf^nbsp;ri.�dhuncmodu�hac mala,lt;iuibus �D*'**nbsp;MS exercec^yfurfauerimusire^i�imi dtnbsp;its sUci foterittquedalicubi Tlurartbquot;^nbsp;Utter, frudenter, eleunttjue�milinbsp;tf^Qd-mp Tiut/JuoXi'^ttsinbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;uiXti to dp[

fs.hmror ǫpoi�5� P sppovntaof'^ ly� dbet^fp*�'dv�t'a)p*y^nbsp;mvTngt;^dKip �/x�ai'7i ^�nfs,ov du

^Ict4 fr.clla � tbymo ^mari�imt t!r �cdfi �tno lonficiunf.fic amp; cwdAti ho-minei � dtf-*nbsp;rebtn �tfenumero magnum com-^^oilum amp; �ru�uttt cafiiunt. Quodautem^nbsp;y OS omnts, maitu commodttm tx im.-portutiH aduerfariorum no�rorum damo.,nbsp;^�^i*sadnosredtat, quam animorum no�rotnbsp;coniundio amp; mututu amorfqut quan-bo�it,ex i� qua badeaua dixitmt^t cofnbsp;i^ifcttur. E.t itrte in yira humana ita cannbsp;prouide �mnino nobif nectffario^ agtftnbsp;ffl�quide bene beate ytaere yolumua,nbsp;^ttnim afiSpu7ri^agt;v�9flt;�fr^Tate,�Vtidenbsp;^luear. yenu�i�im'efcrip�t,i{it^eipov ��* ��nbsp;Kl� duiy��, ei:^'�aquot;xtp zsr piua^xn �ape^inbsp;l^'�Tyo/ icd^ o^d�.: �e eT�nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;lt;rgt;ee*

��TO i(si) a^tavet y^fJ./tisi'rct.�Aua-inoi �T� ypSpia�sp-nnbii � ^d'tt�y. dutrytpa�nbsp;i�tf Vtso^^yee* y

O�i'ta i(�i istfitt.yia-uTta't.^ Ide^^yfn Tfbwi bumanss mhil^urum amp; fynceru. Sedqueuenbsp;admodum in quot;^u�canbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;funt foni �*

muta. ^u�cM yero Grammaticitfsf^^^ qui altertttrax^r� fer faut fugit)nbsp;mnia trd�are amp;y�liter temferare potes�-/dem yfuuenit in rebns humant�nbsp;res Ixtx amp;trijies per^ecao tem^erantur:^^nbsp;dens ergonbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;qui yerafq, infuutn comoditgt;^

conuertere neuit. Talem asitem fuifje ex Effi.adnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;inteUigi^f^_�

'�d.am ego didieidnquir,in quibta futn,i]^t-, ffis ejfe �ontentus. 2^?o�i autem depiff^h^'*nbsp;ui edatn abundnre feu extolldybiq, amp;nbsp;mnibits ioitiatofftm, amp; adfaturicatem amp;nbsp;ddefuridenem, rum adabundeindnmytn^nbsp;adinopiam.

Cutnyero meno fugiat,yos omnesffi�^ tno fludiojpofihabieis omnibfu im^edttnsfifnbsp;td,ad banc met am,de qua dixi,contendere',nbsp;�opojfiin intermittere,quin hancmeam Atnbsp;fo�ogiatn aduerfusimmoderatos lacobi Annbsp;dretx farcafnos, amp; iniquas criminadones,nbsp;quas in yldmdfud fcriptd aduerfu4T)Ao.nbsp;lacobu Grynxum,non fol�m in me, alum-num amp;dtfcil/ulu}n ye�rum,fed etiam tn Ecnbsp;clefiarum no�raru ^formatorem con�attnbsp;d�imum

fi-�m in ilium, fed etiam in tot am no�ram ^tcle�tamamp;T^m^ub. impotenter etiomttir,nbsp;�� tlari�imoye�ro omnibttt^ pijs iucundif-�no nomine apparere curnrem. Idyer 'o yenbsp;^^libri.'tiui�jT audaciitifacerem^ duxnuoep^nbsp;caujfx acee�erunt. 'N am prime nancnbsp;quam tuendam fufcephyobtf yn�nbsp;commtinsm e�e neminem ye�rumnbsp;^t��gt;irare,nedum in�ciari arbitrer, �^fuurnbsp;^xtn^hocleconon mea fol�m fama,cnamnbsp;Andrea,hommead calumniandum nato,nbsp;^trodi baud xgr�fero, fed muit o magK do-^rtnx,ijuam ex '^erbo quot;Dei profitemur yerinbsp;' �cclefx quot;Patrix^ no�rx exifiimatio,

�^tanlncbomonon fdiitnextenuat ,fede-pa�im in futf fcripttf bo�iliterintta^ dit,atlt;}j totimundo inuijamfti�eblamjjridnbsp;dire conatur. Deinde �Tcefirx egregix ergxnbsp;*^e'^oluntac�i amp; �udij tot iam tanta^^connbsp;fiant documenta,''vt ingratitudints nota minbsp;bineee�arib fulfe�ndaforet,ni� tandem a-ii^u�dogratimei erga yos omnesanimi�enbsp;(Wien aliquodedere, Etemm no folitm dominbsp;apud 'Vox dum yixi, me ^uam optime infii.�

'tui curAui�tS'.fedpoflea ynanimtc�ii* fenfugraui�imojj iuilicio,exi erasnbsp;demias.^rtmbTitbihPenfem,^o�ed 'Sajtlitnbsp;fem^nunc yerb Heidelbergenfemt nonjecitfnbsp;AC� in meam �ilutem con�tra�et^ omnes�nbsp;mihi inuifenddS freifuenundas^ dttxt�tf*nbsp;ita (amen yt mei abjentts n^n minottm cu*nbsp;tarn rationemi ifuam frafent^babtatif*nbsp;itd(^ accifite ye�rorZ in me meriiomm amp;nbsp;beficioru �vnS'u��v: exiguum tjuidem ilifi^nbsp;�y�f fdnJ�iu�� iuTippoTFOvi me� eamthfiyoSnbsp;�ngulos ohferuantix ar gratitudinsi te�i^^nbsp;nium'drlt;{j meorum findioritm earn,nbsp;Uenia fujcipite cnramiid^ytfac�tte matenbsp;rem in rnodurn ro^e amp; objecro� Detnnbsp;bmninm benorum de(nobif eatnibMf y tintnbsp;iitemui bendmmilitiamifememuf�dttn amp;nbsp;lonam confcientinmt ttir�tm cofumtntmttttnbsp;AC tandem confetitiAmurcoronami ��* rtd'nbsp;det Vominw in illo die, et/mibttf ^xi txftttnbsp;titruntillufiremillijtfilluttt adnentu�nbsp;Htidelbtrgte Ced.Feb.Annii^i

I B V S D 1 S P V T A T I C N K M ��f ^ucharifliA in^cademia Hetdelbergettfih�nbsp;pr^c�de D. loAvnelacoboGr^nt�nbsp;trimiHAturi Mir � Bettmleri

^xponufttur in hoe Cnpite aliquot edit lt;iuibiu idcobuf Andrew compnlfutinbsp;Optimo cuilt;^ lifHd�t ntdledicit.

O S T E A Q.V A M. bina i�gt; cobt Andrr� fcripta, qu� ad^nbsp;urrfus orbodoxam , modonbsp;ftam,piolt;jftudioinftitutamDinbsp;putationem , de �itchariftianbsp;j�^�Jlt;iberbcngc!�etn iracuildc fonfecit, legi*nbsp;quot;lodulo ponderaui.'animurn mcum v�nbsp;animaciuerti.

, Nam pfimd non par�um animo mco cagt; Mu I '''nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;vidercm hominc iftiim,

d ' quot;odic in Ecclefijs reformatis primss adie attpfiiM concedi flagifat, edconnima�nbsp;tjjnbsp;nbsp;�mpuJcntix procelsine, vtnc^pud�/

ti� publicsf.neq; vcritaiiS ill�ftrand� vllaW �* tioncmhabere, autvlloftudioduci, faciU*nbsp;quouis deprebendatur.

Proindc in hifce fiiis iracundis fcripttSjCUquot;* veritatem nullo modo obfcurare.nedum expgt;*nbsp;gnare pofsit(in quod tarnen fumma animi lt;0�nbsp;tentione inciimbit)non fol�tn in ipfum au^�'nbsp;tem,cuius candor,pietas, amp; eruditie � plan'nbsp;bus.qu�mfortaflc velit Andr�as, commend�'nbsp;tur, virus acerbitatis fu� tffundit, eum(]j mul^nbsp;torumfalforum criminum inf�inulat.-fed etia*�nbsp;rnalios bonos quoslibct,quipartim ante luul'*nbsp;lt;os ab bine annos ex bac mortali vita innbsp;ftempatriam commigraniht,paf tim ver�nbsp;clcfi�Reit�pub. vfmornamento'cpfunt, at*?nbsp;dum vitae huius vfura ipf�s concedetiir, eruni�nbsp;inftar Herculis furentis incitato curfu, fertu�nbsp;debacchaiur,amp; varijs conuitijs inuehitiir.

Etcnim Eeatifsima: memorix Frideriquot; ebum tertium,comitem Palatinum,amp;:c, Zui�'nbsp;glium.OecoIampadium, Caluinum, Marty'nbsp;rem,Bullingerum, Melancbtonem, Eraftuin�nbsp;caeterostp eorum in verbo Dei propagando.i�nbsp;Eccle�ainftauranda, in Paparudemoliendo�nbsp;in bonis Uteris repar�dis fidelifsimos focio^�nbsp;magna prgclara^ Rer�p.Slt; ecclcfiar�luminanbsp;� coluinina, � fepulcbriseruere, de carlo de'nbsp;tiirbarc fuistp conuicqsin tma tartara prid'nbsp;pitare conatur.

i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

, apologia; � 1�? tnagnis Dei donis ornatos, qui egregi�nbsp;� virtutc,nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;crudinonclacobi Andreas lumi

'�US minime luminofisplurimuni obftruuHr, jcotn,ujj,,nfequirur, iniquiseontuznbsp;. 'Ms laecratjfalfis crimintbus tanquam lapi^nbsp;�. S(me�,onruere, homoiracunduscontennbsp;r�^'Guiufniodifuntinufthfsiinus Friuceps lonbsp;�fjoes Caf�niir�s, Ele�lorali? Palatinatus,nbsp;ji_�'enteDeo, inuito Andrea, Adminiftratornbsp;alter noftr�etatisIofias,Eccle^nbsp;n^�einiitricius, quod vehementer vritAnxnbsp;/'^nr.conftantifsimus amp; prudcntifsitnus,Fr�nbsp;j'��*�us�hcmiMS Canc�Uarius 'eius celf�tudiznbsp;ftgt;agnififusFridci�cusVuidebramus,Chrfnbsp;*9phorns Bezeli�S,Cafpar Cruzige r, Theo-� rus Beza.Lambertus D,anxiis,Iacobus Grynbsp;v'rs.Dani�l Toflanus, SC alij quifc ad pedesnbsp;D�x Vbiquitatis.quam nuper lacobusnbsp;, *�drex � fuis anteceflbribus tonceptam,? niznbsp;?*nfclicitcr exc!uf�t,abijcere,eamlt;^ cxoftulanbsp;��'�cufanr. Neqjverd crudclis Andrea� aniznbsp;iftij commemoratis platan, aut fedar�nbsp;��ttft;fedinfi'.per(immane facinus) clafsicura'nbsp;'�nit,at^ controuerfiam non aibplins arnica'nbsp;'pHationefen tentiarum, fed poten tia Princiznbsp;P^uiatcj;adc�armisdifCeptandam , adi�eiTa*nbsp;�'orumcp dogma reprimendnm efle, baud obznbsp;/quot;r�innuit.A:pr�fcfcft. Namnonfatishaznbsp;. roti mimdo probafic, fe ipfo Pataccione ma'nbsp;�rlicenriorcni efTc-'fed ctiam vult de fe dici.

amp;ipii�fp7i Tr'itn�ae)X,�fJLa,^� �r.nppnfidt n�6�H'6C it� ttJZ�� lt;^/�AĀiv xaxamp; TUl*

S�6 ifta furgit �jr,c�itK 9t Cgt;irebi:tcflio,Vi:lt'ns �udacia,nbsp;quot;rurbic obfclt;jucns imperitaraudjc�e:nbsp;Q�/ orationKpc�ettlcqucn itcnbsp;vel ip-os principes inuoluere.

Hxc,hxc,)nqu2ni,fi.nr, qu�inihiin ptislacobi altidrec dolorcmatrukrunt,^ lt;!�?nbsp;omnibus pijs mcntibus feri� lugendadfpl^'nbsp;randaip eHe non fine graiiifhma caufa tnih* igt;*nbsp;dicare videof. Id quod omnes pii, quibusnbsp;fti� ilia lofepht contndo ferio�dolet,nbsp;vn� nircumfatcbuntur,fipnus meeum cauf�'�nbsp;vndeproficiRuntur. amp;: f�nem ad quemtanq��nbsp;ad feopum propofu�,tendunt,recognoutrgt;'�^'nbsp;Nam rem quamlibec noflc.eft in cognitio�Ki�nbsp;caufarum eius peruenire. Cauf� verd quib�*nbsp;Andneastmquam furqs exagitatus ^v/uv�i x*nbsp;�ttA� aperto capitcjd cft impudica irepudidnbsp;tia amp; �iva �'�f�.aTt effrmato ore in �P**nbsp;mum quencp graffatur, fexponfsimum.n� 0'nbsp;mnesprscif� conledlcr, percenferi pofi�v�'nbsp;demur.nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Pria�*

Prima eft contemptus verbi Dei,qui in ip* �^'}�De�mttdandat,amp; ex quo tanquam pud*nbsp;��siino fonte,oitinia flagida promanant. Sinbsp;Andreas verbum Dei in pret io a*nbsp;habrndum 3; obfernandum exiftimaret,nbsp;��^otiq-jam cam r�m�r�, ram immani audacia.nbsp;iinportunofcelerein fcruosDei, tam vi*nbsp;qu�m mortuos, tot tantidonisauftosnbsp;^�rqatos, linguamfuaniiracundamftnnge*nbsp;�'*gt;nfcorcfuocrfr{Oi,amp; in fublimipof�to,tannbsp;�l'*�tninflatopIcnociffolle,�jlt;Aj jcsuxio�x^ O�ernbsp;Trrew, Cxcias Si calumnias fpiranbsp;neqj temeregarricndo, duritcr loquendo,nbsp;�^'thrafonic� ladlitado tantas tcpeftatcs connbsp;^��*ret. Qiiandoqu�d�non ignor�t Deum frannbsp;p'tntaf Si audaci linguae grauifsimc fuccen*nbsp;nec folum fucccnfcre.fed etiam grauifsi*nbsp;�?*sp�nas comminari : nec folum commina*nbsp;. � fedetiam quotidi� irrogarc fepenumeronbsp;^fOgaflTe, 6L in pofterum trrogaturum efle.nbsp;^'*�1 tarnen, quod ego fat fcio.acquehis mei$nbsp;'quot;lis vidi.non feipcl.maiorem temporis parnbsp;'quot;tin equili quim in Mufxoconfumat,Si ac*nbsp;quot;ratiori Audio equos alat, qu�m facras lite*nbsp;traft� Si euoluai, id quod etiam ex Seri*nbsp;etus colligitur, qux equifonis potius le*nbsp;p�tem, quim Theologi grauitatem redo*nbsp;'quot;t.fuggeram ei trium iftorum,quorum mo*nbsp;** memini teftimonia SC. exempta ex facra*nbsp;literarum thefauro deprompta.

De indignatione igiriir SC odio Dei in pet�� iantem 8^ fraudulentam IiUguam luculentus.nbsp;iS^grauislocusextat Prouerb. y.ver.j^.iy.tSnbsp;�p. quam totius Ecckfi'� SC publici comniod*nbsp;lt;:aufa etiam atq; etiam l�cuinperpendcre SCnbsp;puci ariimum fuum deponere peruclim�

Sex fun t(ait fapienuajqu� odii Ichoua,tnifl' feptem fiint abominanda eins anitnx.

Oculos fubhmeSjlinguam n�endac�. SC ma* nus eifiindcntes fanguinem innocencem.

Qui loquitur mcndacia, teftem jnendaeem� amp; iminittcntein iiirgiaipter fratres.

Nam ibiplufqua*��^*'^ decim genera, Si illa quidem baud leuia enu-'nbsp;merantur ; quarlacobus nullo modonbsp;poterit.nif�^ijt ncupo� mature Si feriap^nbsp;nitentia fibi ab iila xctxonamp;eiet� infants ten''nbsp;pcret,atqueelleboro fumptoad rnentem^*'nbsp;deat:quod vttandemfacerc pofsit.itanbsp;us bene amet ct�c/t'aA�-.'�TTO� continent*�'nbsp;exanimoprccor;

Pr�fice fuper eu (inquit Pfaltes proph�te impium,Siaduerfarius ttet�dcxtriscius:nbsp;Dum iudicatur ipf�, exeatiniprobusnbsp;c�scius vcrtauturinpeccatum;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;-

Sint filij eins pupilli:8i vxoreius vidua. . Etvagando vagcntur filii cius �d mcndic�t;nbsp;�^9uarrant � locis fuis yaftatis,nbsp;jJjUqneat focneratorqu�cunqjfuntilli.* S�nbsp;f*piant extranet labprem eius.

Exempla po�naritmfidef�deret Andreas,in */'*noriam fibi reuocet, fii modo iracundia 8C.nbsp;^'lancholia monaftica permittat, qu�m tri.�nbsp;'sexitus habuerint.Sd qu�m ingrat� fui me.�nbsp;J ^riam reliqucrintSimei filius Gera,t.Reg,nbsp;J^chitophcl 2.Sam.cap.i7. Haman.Efter.7.nbsp;^^cnfatores D3nielis.Dan.7 Duofenes iudigt;nbsp;K 5 qni Sufannam falf� adulterq ream agebantnbsp;�Janicl y,

Commemorabilc quorp eft Sd pofteriatis ^'nioria dignum,quod Plutarchus de calum.�nbsp;*3toribus Socratis eorum'cpp�na Utens pronbsp;�dit his verbis:T��^8V az�x,^Tamp;t

��K� xo/v�i��r vlt;yt�*'r3� gt; et^'iiiayiist^^iv x��9 c^^��y T�� o^;;k�Talt;, �i;nbsp;fjSgt;{jyov, Hoc eft , Cos igimr qui Socrate�'*nbsp;fuis calumni]�' opprei�ervnr, tanqium ad ex-�nbsp;trematn tnalitian, profli'gatos tanto odionbsp;buerunt ciucs arque ira abliorruei'unr abf�'�nbsp;vtnequeignem acccndcrcpt, ncque interro*nbsp;gaiitibusrefpondcrent, ncqueeiufdein aq�'*nbsp;cumiis inbatqeo participes elfe vellent.W P*nbsp;rachytas cam cHiinderc cog�rent tanquai�nbsp;contaminatam.

Hxc omnia �um lacobus Andreas fits'! deqj ferat,fine omni religione ncgligat, nih�*nbsp;que adfe pertinerepuret,quotus quifrpeftjf*''nbsp;f� quis ipfe quoqne hellcbon potu indig�*'�nbsp;qui anirtium indiicerepofsit, aliquani fai�*'�nbsp;timoris �ei emrcp iudiciorupin ipf�us aniquot;*�nbsp;reftJere.ac n� pcnicus excindam elfe.nbsp;tarnen non eft,quodanimi fecurusf�binbsp;deat.fe extra omcm teliiadlum pof�tunieynbsp;at�g injpunittimfore.�cusenim�xcr/xovnbsp;f�Anbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;TmiTO.

craCjfcmpereodem modo cxcandefcit pef^�^ ti� attp aduerfuj ea indicia fua iufta conftaf**^nbsp;cxercet.�c fivcro p�nitennam noftram eXP*nbsp;aaquot;�

A P O L O � I A � ftans S! �xpeitns poenam difiert, non tarnennbsp;*ain aufeire patanduseft. Quifqjigiture'�cnbsp;�TI �ta/�j; duni tempus eft, Dei iram � ft dc^nbsp;�liiiarc ftudeatzne feram poenitentiain agensnbsp;�pehatur ld quod prouerbio dtcitur;na6�vnbsp;j'^v�jjSnjItus accepto damao fapit.nbsp;Altera caufa eft confciehtia vulntrata amp; aniznbsp;�^usnullo loco fubfifteiis, fcdfufpicionibus,nbsp;��f tUjOdio perpetuo fluAuans. Nam confeiennbsp;l�f�c 8i animi multorum facinorum fibinbsp;�onfeq ea eft confuctudo natura vt non foDnbsp;quot;�nfeiplumcontinentcr cxcruciet 8C � feipfonbsp;f^nisJ'taTS��vvTw� rcpctat.-fedenam vtfsnbsp;Penumcro inftarrabidiSi furioft canis extranbsp;fuumi]; domicilium, tanquam fqualidifsi^nbsp;�*ium triftif$imumi� carcerem euagatus,a^elt;nbsp;(�nediferimineobuios quofqjinuadat.arnbsp;mari mifceat.horribilcsqj tempenbsp;��tesexcitet. Animus quandoquidem �g-fnbsp;�^��per errat , necvnquam quiete vUa frninbsp;Poteft,

At(^ li�c reuera ita eflc reftanntr pluriml *�ni facrarum quam cxotericarum btctaruninbsp;*xempla;quac reif�e outtpo; 7S appellannbsp;��t,SicenimCain�confcienriaeius Ixfa �lt; a�nbsp;��tnodefuoftatudtturbato , nonfolt;nmf�ipxnbsp;lumtorfit amp; triftibns cogitationibiis exedit;nbsp;^�detianijVt fibi videlicet medicinam afferr�r,nbsp;A f

impetum in immerentem Abclem fccit 3tqult; perfumirj�fcelu�vit�lnciscj; huias vfuraprinbsp;uauit.Sic Saul animo eius � Cua poceftate egre^nbsp;fo attp multorum ncfandormn facinorum coUnbsp;fcicntia ad infaniain rcda�io , non folumin^nbsp;ftarcrudelifsimitortoris fcipfum mins nio-'nbsp;disfatigauit.'fed etiaminnocencam Dauidemnbsp;Bfomnes quieibene volcbantdi bcnigncfa-'nbsp;ciebantinexplebiliodiojmportuno fcelerc.d^nbsp;itnmani furore dcbacchatiis fuit; nee quicqu�nbsp;de co reraif�t,donec fuq ft gladio in fuga miftfnbsp;rime' trucidafct.Sic Diony��us Tyrannus connbsp;fcicntix angore �J fraudunifcelerumijcru'nbsp;ciatu impulfus iranftierfum aiftus, optimunbsp;quenquc vinculis, verberibus.fuppliciocpnbsp;cruciatum nccandiicurauit.-exiftimans ft co�nbsp;fcicntia: ftimulosliac ratione fedaturumnbsp;Sic Nero,monftrum poft homines natos cru'nbsp;delifsimurn fcelcrum.malcficiorumq} fuorui�nbsp;qiix pluritna 3d grauifsima commiftt, accrbifnbsp;fi'marccordationetortuSjSdconfticntia; foH-citudinibus exagitatus nonfolumftipfnmeX'nbsp;carnificauK,atqjfibi violentas cxitialeslt;�ma^nbsp;nus attulitzfed etiam ob Icuifsimam quamfj�nbsp;ortam fufpicioncrn, in optimum quenl^ cxqutnbsp;fitis Sc inaudicis/iipplici)^ vfus fuit.

Sed quid opus eft plurafAnimieorumquo ruin conftieritia ir.cxpiabilibiis flagitijs inqu�nbsp;nata SC po'lura eft. ronfolumfolicitudinibusnbsp;qu�� Deo fuppUcij caufa importantur,diesnbsp;noiics'c�

APOLOGIA. tf ^�3�escp exeduntur, fedetiam irnmanirabienbsp;^lt;�ca audacia in obuios quofuis feruntur.nbsp;quod Ifaias Capite j7,cgregia ilmilitudinenbsp;^ominonftrauit,ad liunc rnodum : �mpijfuntnbsp;mare impulfum:nam quiejcere nonponbsp;**ftjpropell unttp aqux cius(non fecus ac An�nbsp;^��eas conuiria Si calumnias^ cocnmn amp; lut�.nbsp;. Caufas antem tanti niali,fi fcire defiderasgt;nbsp;�a promptu cifc fine negotio animaduertes.nbsp;^am cum ij,quorum confcientia aliquo morznbsp;I�olaboratSicoquitur fibijpfis non parcant,nbsp;acutiisimis curarum ftimuiis fefcpungantnbsp;niacerent: quomodo quxib alijs parceren tfnbsp;quomodo benigniores in alios quam in feipznbsp;fos eifent^Quandoquidem vcrum cftillud vernbsp;quod vulgo dici folefOmnes fibi meliusnbsp;��alle quam alteri.

Deinde cum animus �ger SC confcientiy ^ala in perpetuo metu f�t ; atip nunquam nonnbsp;fdup�nas vcl impendere, velceleri pede ap-'nbsp;propinquarcimaginetur : cuihocmirum viznbsp;deatur, fi vcl iftas � fe declinare, attp in alios,nbsp;quos odit Si � quibus fc lacdi piitat deriuarp,nbsp;*el qwamplurimosfecum in exitiumtraherenbsp;foneturlt; Nam dolor SC �gritudp non nihil vinbsp;detur leuarijf� quam pluritnos habeat eiufdemnbsp;mifcri� focios. Perpcfs/o enim Cinquitillcj)nbsp;c�terorumfacit, vteaqu�acciderintmultdnbsp;hiinora , qu�m quanta funt exiftimata viznbsp;deantur.

Prxtercacum con fcicnna mala fcmpersf dear tra ftoinacho,quo nihil Ren, ni^nbsp;hil cont�deratepOuft cui (nirum videatur,*!nbsp;om iKonatuirn: St ftomacho yhionis SC vio'nbsp;didt�cupido.�tisfacercannitarar.nbsp;?gt;P5lt;firjuo;Cprudenter inqutt Plutarchu�J -n*nbsp;J'iKcua,nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;jtMTpia,

7P� �vAtof fiiTroJl�vdf/^� : � j� lt;5^ p 6y* p.o�T�tTeiv�Trp�Tfet'r�� ^ptva(nbsp;�nt�.Hocei^Vt Olim ratio iuftaagitSd mod�nbsp;rata,ira Si furore procul fepoi�to.�ita furor ifnbsp;iracundta iniqua agit,tnente d luo loco tranf*nbsp;kra.

Tertia caufa St ilia omniumgrauifsima ouic, quati Andreas propngnandam fuft*'nbsp;pit.defperariOtCum enim ammo fuo St con^'nbsp;(cientjaintelligatfuaserrorcs.cuiufmodifuninbsp;vif�Si/is Si localis corporis Clirifti fangui'nbsp;r.ijqj du ; in pane St vino,inuilt;Ibilis Si ill��*nbsp;li� liKluf�o: eufdcm in fardifsima can� Sinbsp;eorum ora ingeilio : eiufdem non modo in O'nbsp;(nnrhut locis obfc�nis.iedetiaminipf�snbsp;raris St diaboHs exiftentiazomnium proprio'nbsp;rum !)ettatis inhumanitatem transfuffo :arti'nbsp;cu! lt;riim ridei m tnifcfta violentaip dcpraua'nbsp;tio,nf c ftare nee def en ii nec vile� amplius co'nbsp;lore tegi poferipffsomifsiS, aut faltem leu*nbsp;braebto traftatts.indignaii.tumuiniari.ipii*nbsp;perfoaas tnceflerc.aduerfariosdirisconuitii�nbsp;inodiui*

APOLOGIA. T. *�gt; odium SI inuidiam vocare ccnatur�nbsp;b.��d ii�� hxrcticoTum machin� lun(�inq)]it

. d�perfidia ad tnalednfla fcconf tant. 1* idem ibidem inquit , Guircfponderenbsp;^opOfliintjCaput auferunt.Item omifTa caufanbsp;��{uperflua criminum obicAione verfantur,nbsp;ibidemteftatur.Atquchxc itafe ha*nbsp;/^��Oninib�s temporibus SC locis expericn*nbsp;3^0c�ipletifMma cernfsimatp teftis, doemt,nbsp;^otenim qusfci SC quantos conuitiorum cunbsp;ft �10� m orthodoxes pnmitiu� Ecdef�f.quxnbsp;?Oni poft vi�ioTiam � Chrifto parram SC a*nbsp;/��u triumphum illuftri SC locali afeenfionenbsp;*quot; ''^lum extirit,doftorelt;,^�gp/hxretici o*nbsp;^''ibus arms alijs fpoliati congeflerunt�nbsp;Sc quanta crimina inChnftianos inquienbsp;bomines, conftantifsimo omnium iudicionbsp;J�^ifsimorum errerum conuifticonfinxc*nbsp;t Tot profefto , quot fi enumerarenbsp;tempus me potius tjuam materia de*nbsp;^^iveroar^ot^ay*z^gt;tov eft. Schomintsa*nbsp;. quot;ft inuem�.ciim videat errores fuos otrni*nbsp;tecl^ fcniientium corfeientia ita ton*nbsp;teneri, v t nullo amplius artiftcio pal*nbsp;�ft . nullo colore fucari'pofsint, ii$ reii�ris,

il.ft ** �^us.neerraffe vidratur,neDeoglorii *'*gt;ne Eccleffppactconfuterc netefle habcar�

iontinuo ��ipatA�i 8(. pcrfriftafronte in^fas perfonas qui fuis conaribus obeiTe^nbsp;�fficer� videntur.linguam ftringerc.conuitij�nbsp;infequi,fid f�deformarenonpofsit�tarnen eo�nbsp;al�quo modo fufpeiflos reddcre,ijs(^inuidiainnbsp;apud iinperitos conflarc.

Nam ita inter homines comparat� ciTe non ignorant ifti tencbriones, vtp�erunqjdedo-(^rina ex vita fid moribus eorum, qui ill�pr�nbsp;f�tentur.iudiciumfaciant. Ita Pharifxi SCc�'nbsp;teri, quituminlud�acrant, feduftorei, vtnbsp;Clirifti miracula extenuarent, ciu�^ dodri/nbsp;nx f�dem derogarc portent, efus perfonam,nbsp;�nam doctrinam erroris argiierc conuincenbsp;rc non potcrant�3ggrefsi,dxmonium habere,nbsp;lucroncm eflc,Cumpeccatorib�s coUudere yonbsp;cifetibantar.

Sed quid opus cftp�ura^ Non eft artipi�t' 'Tijifx.�iQjt.ov, non ao�ipaA��pv afif�^iov,nbsp;non verior nota animi erroris conuifti qu�tnnbsp;l�,rationibus omifsis,coniiiti}s pugnet.

Interea tarnen in mentem venire debcrer.i'' ftis cfciarum et fycophantiarum fpiratonbus.nbsp;eius quod dieirur in Pfaimis : l�i makdieunt,nbsp;tuvero Domine benedicis. Item illius,quodnbsp;vetcr�proucrbiodiciconfueuitmeminiflede-berent.f/x� wg^txAe�jfruftra Herculi. Nai�nbsp;nihil promouenr, fed oleum �doperam pel'''nbsp;dunt, qui virismagnis �C cxcelJeniibus virt�*'nbsp;tibu�

pr�ditis ma�cdicunt;quippc c�i eor� v�rz apud bonos inmaiori prctio fint,qu� vtnbsp;��Claudiana ifta tonitrua cleuare pofsint.

profc fto verifsimuin eft illud, quod 5'*�dam prudentcr dixit :7onbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;�� r^cTo�

^^pa.eTtp�f'j fi�uKari� eilt;fiixv�i'reu,ral(utA 5 fiftum probrurtt.non vitra aures penetratenbsp;abaunb�s quidetnpercipitur, fed abnbsp;��11110 refpuitur,atqiief�mul atquc prolatutnnbsp;�'fitiinftar fiirei euanefeit. Etenim vt ignis*nbsp;Sued verc fcribit Cicero,in aquam conieftusnbsp;'�ittinuoreftinguitur amp;rcfrigcratiir; fiereznbsp;'�^Uens falfutn crimen in puriftimam SC a�ifnbsp;quot;�gt;ani vitamc�llatum fiatim conciditamp;exgt;nbsp;g�itur. Vtenimobfcuratnr 8C offunditurnbsp;**'* folis lumen lucernx;f�c commentitia cri�nbsp;��13fplendore virtutis obfcuretur SC obruannbsp;intereant necefle eft.

Quapropterpiiomnes aduerfus venenaz **obtrcdlatorum fpicul�tanquam pr�fctitifsinbsp;�j�ni amp; va�idifsimumai'Tz/'oTorfemper fib�nbsp;�Oculos mentis proponant,anre� illud Hicznbsp;�^��Ymi diftum,quod eft in cpiftola ad Celannbsp;: Beatus eft , inquit , qui tam fanznbsp;�stanque graiiiter/vitam fuam difpofuit, vtnbsp;pf co finiftri aliquid ne fingi quidem pof*nbsp;�^dum aduerfus obtredtatorum libidincmnbsp;P**gnat merit! magnitude , ncc fingerenbsp;'�gt;fqnam aufus eft C excipio tua pace Hicznbsp;^onytne , omniumque bonorum venia laz

M. BEVJ�iBRI cobum Andream)quod � nullo pucat crfe crt*nbsp;dendum. Quodf� id aiTeqiii difficile atquear/nbsp;duutn nimis eft.faltcm adhibeamus, hanc vit*nbsp;nofirx diligcntiam,ne malse mentes, occafio^nbsp;neminucriiantdetrahendi. Ne ex nobis fein''nbsp;ri Ila procedat, per quam aduerfus nos finiftr(nbsp;famx flamma ronflecur. Si autem nobis dili^

genter acqj folicite' omnia adhoneftatem pro' Bidcntibus, cundislp aftibus nofiris timoremnbsp;Dei prxfercnribus illi niliilominus infaniunt�nbsp;confo�etur nos confeientia noftra , quxtuinnbsp;maxtmc tuta eil,maxim� feciira eft, cum ne oinbsp;cafioncm quidem mak'de fefentiendi dedit.nbsp;Nos modo id agamus, vt male de nobis netndnbsp;loqui abfqj mendacto pofstt. Sed redco ad cx*nbsp;pouttoncm quintxcaufx.

Caufa quarta eft fuperbia eX profpero rerum ftatu,omni� rerum abur.dan'nbsp;tia, ntmiootio fiCvoluptate, quafruiturAn'nbsp;dreas quam fibt pcrpctuamforeconfidir,nanbsp;w.Nam quialialt;ftenus eumfortuna tanquan�nbsp;fiiiim in finii molliter amp; delicate fouit, nequfnbsp;vliasreriun aduerfarum tempeftates �ubiuit�nbsp;ncqj vnquam crucem Chnfti portauit, atqjf*nbsp;hiimili tcniiitp amp; obfeura conditione ad aliif'nbsp;fimo : apud iuos bonorumgraduquot;:, tanqU'��*nbsp;fca'mo ad tnbnnal afcendit : nunc oifi�t�nbsp;IS S; affliiffiones aliorum abliuionet��nbsp;ruens,atquc volupiatibus cbrius tarn

APOLOGIA. 9 qiiofiiis iniiadi t, affl ;lt;ft�s infuhat, atip v�nbsp;^P'arum fuarum virus tamcopiofceuomit.nbsp;�tiam ijs Rcbnfpub.parcir, quarum virznbsp;��c, liberaliiate amp; cpe is cum fiiis focijs fXnbsp;�'iimis anguftiis amp;: rebus deiperatis ad tantanbsp;�^'�citatem,qua nuiicliberaliterfruunriir.perznbsp;Sedhoc pcrpetuofere fieri fofet, vti)nbsp;vel c renui abie�^a fabror� Fortuna adnbsp;��^gnos honores afcenderunt.aut res defperanbsp;*�sreeupcraruiit,non folum incommodis monbsp;f'bus fiant.cxterorum nhferi� infiiltent,omznbsp;�'5 prat fc contemnant:fed etiani cos quorumnbsp;?'*�!ilio fua bona confequuti funt.omni gcnftcnbsp;'�iuriarum afficiant. Cuius rci nobis inAnznbsp;Si fratribus eius exemplum tnftifsimumnbsp;PfopOniiur�

Interea tarnen cogitare deberent ifti foWtiz ��filij.quos fecundus amp; florens rerumftatnsnbsp;��fd infolenres reddit,fuam gt;ftani,eui tantopenbsp;��'conftdunt, matrem fortunam lubricairt 8inbsp;*��tabilemefre:ade� vtnemofapiens Si fanusnbsp;**fut�innitipofsit.O niiz�Q'nbsp;��v 'n, oux ianbsp;�^^avr��ei �{VTt^��v Circn'us rerumlniznbsp;��'anatum circumuoluros no finit eofdem fernnbsp;Pfr bona eile Fortuna. Achqnanto miferiorisnbsp;;**n(n�ftra�tateChriftiarii eibuicis , qui fibinbsp;'nfecunda Fortuna,fn rerum terreftrium topianbsp;*3niuinpr�fidij coilocaium exiftimantiprafer

tim cum verbum Dei id tam feuere probibcat Neconfidatis in iniuria;netp inrapin�met fiJnbsp;tis vani-.diuiti� l�proucniantne apponaiis eornbsp;Pfal.�i.v.iO.Verifsimumautctn eft amp; inhif-'nbsp;cellominibus elucet, quod alibi Cicero ino*nbsp;nuit:Nonfolum ipfafortiina cxcaeftjed eti'nbsp;am eos pleruntp efficit c�cos.quos complcxanbsp;eft.Illi enim efferuntur fere faftidio amp; contu'nbsp;tnacianiecquicquam infipienti Fortunato in.'nbsp;tolerabilius fteri poteft. At^hoc quidcm vt'nbsp;dere licet, eos qui antea coqrmodisfucruntmonbsp;ribus,imperio,poteftate,profpcris rebus im-'nbsp;murari.fperni abijs vetercs amicitiaSjinduPnbsp;gcrenouis. ,

Interim tametipii,qiii ifta vident amp;perfegt; runt,non eft quod aiij aduerfus alios ingetnPnbsp;fb^t.'non eft quod d�clinent pedes eorumaiiinbsp;greflus effundantur.N� iudex eft pra? foribus^nbsp;Qiii quidemaliquandoiuftofiioiUdicio (Oti'nbsp;cedirimpqsamp;fuperbis vtviuantinproipcri''nbsp;tate.-vtnon fint conftridtiones ad mortem ip'nbsp;forum.'Vt fi'rmum fit robur ipforum;vt in molenbsp;itijs hominuin non finr.vt cum hominibusnoHnbsp;flagellentur : vt tanquam torques circumdet �nbsp;cos fuperbia,amp; operiat eos tanquam amidiuSnbsp;violentia : vtpromincantpr� pinguedine o' !nbsp;culi eorum : vt fiipcrent cogitationcs cordis:nbsp;vtdiffln.int amp; loquanturmalitiofc : vtiniu'nbsp;am � fublimi loquantur : vtponant in ccrio oSnbsp;fuum: vt lingua eorum perambulet terrain.

. � b i O 6 I A� iS ^f.ver� repenrc r vcftigio, ipfis nihil talcnccnbsp;P'-r�brim.net per lonnium fogit�ntibus.lednbsp;F*x,paxcft,fi j)nii�ntibus,filt;ut gramen �xcirinbsp;filt;ui iicrba virens marcefeunt. Ad^'nbsp;non �xtabnl�elcratus;amp; a,znbsp;�^b lesad 10'uin tia*, amp; nen�xtabit.nbsp;J Qiiuitataufa eft immanis amp; inexpicbili'snbsp;*pdre�(-[ude!ir3s,5i odium iniatiabile .-quonbsp;le a ibOvIeftia Chriftiana reccdcrc:nbsp;�'''(blumrecedere ibil�a, fed eiiam ferifsiznbsp;�**�8 amp;' trucifsitrias beiluas inimahitate fuperdnbsp;qudd pSucis 5; euidcnrihns argufnentisnbsp;quot;��onftrabo Nam primo Ebc�efiaftici fcptl^nbsp;j*'? ^pert� dicoin.quot; Ne im�ultes mortuo, eiianinbsp;/quot;niici�inio tuo, lcd memento omnibus moznbsp;�^bdum efl'c.Laudatur enam ac m�mo laudanbsp;fnitiisim�Tinotiini Seyihopoleos �pifcoinbsp;y �ngenium Si fatf^�, � qiio iongifsimo abeftnbsp;i quot;dreas inter�allo.Cnm entm, vttr�dunthKnbsp;Ectlefiaftic� in Synodo nonnulli, Anznbsp;J'�f�miles.ipfi autbor�s eflentjVt Ong�nen�nbsp;l^7^gt;'iantiiim �am defiuiftiim anatb�mati fuznbsp;gram�imr refpoiidit : Qiianquarrinbsp;^��bifsimus furti ab crronbus eins, nolo ta�:nbsp;�la�fjtza'n^i' tou �miXaj. 'Tidi'nnbsp;*7^ , damnarc lam pridernb�nemOrtuum.nbsp;J- his cumdiuerfa Andr�as fcntiat,amp; loqiia-amp; fertbar, qiiis ambigat earn Chriftiam bonbsp;J�bis modefti�, qu� tantopere nobis remmennbsp;�bt S.Litcr�, omnino ex aninio fuo amifiife ?

Noncnirh eifatiseft viuosDeifcruojgraulf' 1 � f�mis contumeliisafficerc.fedetiamnionui� tnbsp;condcmnandis,at(p ad tribunal Oeijnftar U'' | jnbsp;uilsimi apparitoris.pertrahcdis fefe oble^lat, jnbsp;atlt;p txdium quod ex folitudinc Bebcnhufiani jnbsp;capit,alteuareconstur.nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

Deinde ettam Barbarx gentes^qtixa culru j E^humaniratclongiusabfuiflevidentur, odi�nbsp;fuum ati^ iiuerem in viuos tantum cxercue*nbsp;runt,eum morientibus veto extingut cenfue/

etiamhodieveraeflecrederentur, nifiv^/O' ; I (ftuo'nc�f Si monftrofa lacobi Andrex eiufquenbsp;grcgalium cxempla rcpugnarcnt.nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;**

Pafc itur in riuii liuor,poA f�ta (juicfcit: nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;J

Tutnfuta cx mefiro,^uenlt;^i tucturhonofltetfi: j Scripta placent � morte ejuieie : quia ledere viuos ,nbsp;Liuor,cr inuifo carpere dente /�let,nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Itei� j.

'nfra fc po/jcac,exttn�uf amabitur idem. j Ita Cicero in Orationc contra Saluftiuiu mofnbsp;tuos dicit omnt odio inuidia carere. Q��' ,nbsp;propterl� Ouidiiis.f� Cicero, fiexreri Ethnif* pnbsp;in quibus vt mica quidetn cliaritatis Cbrifti*''nbsp;nsv fint,ab Orco reuocarentur.fiiperasq? eui^nbsp;derent ad auras,�i Jacobum Andreammagn*nbsp;doffrinatn.magnanj humiiirateni, adinirabi' |nbsp;lem charitatem prx feferentem : totegregijfnbsp;viri�,qui iam faro luo conceilerunt, infultaff

^��alediccre viderent, rei indignitatc com* ��i in hanc vocem, qua: eft apud Euripidemnbsp;dubio emmperent: Oatii Tmu�aJ'�-o: rce^�AoicTew^ift�ompe*nbsp;.''�compefccos illudefFr{nat�,niortuis enimnbsp;(.��uitiatuseft^Cumigitur qu� natura ipfa minbsp;^fos amp;; cat cos ethnicos docuit .videlicet mornbsp;non contumelia fed honore afficiendo^,nbsp;�*�odio fedamoreprofequendos efle.Andrenbsp;' (�^SRcellarius nullis hiimanitatis canccllisnbsp;I�f'Umdatus, tarn impudenter violet, Si ex. eonbsp;Indern quarrarquotufqaifqj per Deum im*nbsp;j^��lein antmum inducers pofsit,hominemnbsp;. �quot;n non folii luce verbi Dei, fed omni humanbsp;'��f 6i naturali lumine priuat� no efte^uipnbsp;J'^uiunulla humanitatis fcihtilla,triftifsimanbsp;�M fax imroanis crudelitatis in eo eluceat.

?��ttiam leones SL vt{os,fer3S immanifsi* natura grauifsimum odium aduernbsp;j^*gt;ominum genus indidit. Si qux fanguin*nbsp;[��rij humana pafcuntur. eiecflis cadaueri-P3rcere,ne� etiam ea fame diuturna pref*nbsp;^ilaniare.Quo cent naturafnos docuit.ne*nbsp;J'l^e in mortuos contumeliofc' gralTari. Nenbsp;^^�verdquifquam fibi perfuadcri patieturnbsp;( �^icinaferrana prodirealiquem humananbsp;�'��apoftc.qui immanitate ipiasbeftias vinnbsp;,'iHifiquifcripta Andre� legerit,eiufq? mo*nbsp;*^ognitos Si perfpeftos habeat.

C�ter� hoc loco rcuocat mihi inf�gn�ter�n* ' fignis lac Andre� crudelitas in mctnonam trinbsp;tumilkidproncrbiii.-Corunsabaquila reliiflis 'nbsp;cad^ueriba? ve�itur.lr� illud; Aut yulturautnbsp;jCoriius.'N� corui �f vultures,auesparitcrra/nbsp;paces eumbclles.OiTinibusq; lioniinibusexo'jnbsp;pdaueribus putridis amp; fccndisabaquilisgc^nbsp;nerofisambusreliclispafcuntur, f� credimuSnbsp;rcr� phyf�caruni perins Jta hic ecclef�� CoraJtnbsp;Si reipub. Vultiirius.n� fol� morruor� cadaiiCnbsp;ribus.fcd etia fpermologi inftar corumcineHnbsp;busanim� fu�iracund�pafcic,aflt;:podi�infam�nbsp;cxplercfanarccpcoqatnr Hoc ver�ipfodeg� |nbsp;nereinfu'i tiipidii anim�orriuibusiapie��'*' 'nbsp;bus probat Andreas qui maiiultc�abfcnnb�^nbsp;qu�prffentibus pugn�re; quandoquid�tac�l*^nbsp;ek vincerc abrtntes.aicp aderf n� r�pugna�*�� ,nbsp;�i eiiiinglo''io(i milites' Joco fibi cauere poil^^nbsp;�^poftprincipia cfl�c ; fi itcgallus galliiia�*'** jnbsp;in proprio fterquilinip crociraretrttiusefi* 'nbsp;uit.�fiquocptimidi lepores mortiioinluli�!*�nbsp;ni, vr vetera habet prouerbiacquismirecur�� ,nbsp;tum thfoiog� no ijfdc artibus vti fibicp canC** �nbsp;{sorte.Sic enim (iiperioribus annis abfetife�**^nbsp;inger� atrpeibus iniurijs lacefsiiut, amp; eo��!^nbsp;vero Tigur� veniret,vn�nbsp;Bulling. amp; Giialtheri copcione tanqu� lef^�nbsp;doriniens tympano terrcfalt;flus,fefeomni3nbsp;iefta inorajindeproripuit.nccpminiftrori'*^nbsp;clefiacco�Ioqiii� fuftin�rc aufijs fait.Antebi�j|nbsp;nium verc� cutn Tubing�.in fua videlicet annbsp;magniffee dirpuiafiretjatq; omnes aduerfaP��

� *pl� crcdimus,proftraujflet,tandc in hare ver �^�rupit;O vMnam,vtinam,gt;nqu�, Bsia.�a*nbsp;��us,amp;; T ;urini lue �or�tn adeflent.atcp me.*nbsp;**gt;1�) de conirouerfi�articulis collo querennir.nbsp;Ql'antum verp defid�rium ferij cum noftris lt;nbsp;'�i!oquii teneat iftum,nouum Vbiquitatis anznbsp;erronem,nunc monachum.non cft difficilenbsp;S�'lik�re ijs,quibus cius iiigenium, mores, c3nbsp;^ka,di(fta amp;C faf�a nota perfpedacj funt.

Sed venio ad fextam Si vltimam modefti� rhiimanitatis lacobandric� caufam ,cquanbsp;�Periores omnes promanant. Si in cuius cSznbsp;fkxu c�tiu�ntur. 111a autem cft extrema Si d�nbsp;P'orata�lus malitia. Namhomin�ad malitianbsp;^f�fligatorum propria nota Sicertifsimumf�nbsp;eftjnimicitias cum optimo quolp habe�nbsp;** Si ��^Actxra� exercere. Atq; hoc non monbsp;^^lacr�literw, fedetiamexotericor�fcriptanbsp;faniflus hic monachus Bihenhuf�anusnbsp;^fofuafanftitatc tam nonattingere,qu.imoznbsp;quot;n Pharifxi panem illotis manibus tralt;flare,nbsp;J'-'ldiefeftoinpr�torium ingredi niillo moznbsp;''^audebanr) luculentiftim� teftantur. Cuiusnbsp;*''Plutapcliumgrauifsimum teftein produca,'nbsp;'quot;�Us hxc hint verba in commenrario ju-i

��i/�;VTfspSqA� Tit� (pavAowT�':� x�^Ti�'ot� f^�pov ctv/zt, Ornnem neznbsp;^***�310 excedit, inimicum efTc opfimis viris.nbsp;�^nc vert) fu� vcrifsitn� fentznti� riutuichn^jnbsp;**1111110010 Sicxemplo illulhat atqidtnxfti a!:nbsp;B 4

tSTiiv Ibamp;p tS nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ZBLKIAI

�Tn�uibCip�i; Tno/.-j�S'iviamp;poiii, ^.^i/noptpo)' cr�;T�v�ri-r5 �dii� p(fi;(^�ine)(tr cruuwroixt�TA

p{.^�llt;^\^V �/'�oeTvA''' ai)!. Id eft. Qti3pr�pter etiam Homerusnbsp;iniiltit modis inultislt;^ verbij corporis vitiumnbsp;quo laborat Therf�tes.exprcfsjt.'ingenq vcrdnbsp;maliriam brctiiGime numero compicxufnbsp;eft, hoe modo;

Summe erat exofui ?elid^,exo[iu Vly�i. EtDetnofthcnesiiimmam Aefehinis improbinbsp;tatem atqr malitiam amplificare voIens Oe�nbsp;Ki� �v�pa)7ramp;rj �-ytScSv i^Qpov: Dei homi^nbsp;numcpbonorum,hoftem appellat. Atquehisnbsp;egrcgierefpondent.multa pr�claradida Pfal Inbsp;monim qutbus inipij ab eo potifsimum deferi inbsp;biiiit(ir,Sf irapietatis conuincuntur, quodliu' /nbsp;miles corde defpici�r.quod afflidlis infultent, inbsp;quod fidelibus Dei feruis retia tendant,hoe et^ !nbsp;gt;nftdia;ftruani.,6i^ elandeftina eruentatp conenbsp;filiaaduerfuseoscapiant; quod in innocentesnbsp;lingiiam fuam dolofam tnftar gladij acuant-Solet etiam facra leripturajmpiorumhomi-'nbsp;num malitiam deploratam nobisproponere jnbsp;defcnberc odio in bonos Deo^ eharos ho'nbsp;mines.SieCainimalitiaSi Efa'ui improbitas inbsp;nobis � facra feriptura inodio aduerfus fra^'nbsp;frespi�^ I

apologia. �If r^Spios confpicicnda proponitur. Huius auznbsp;caufamfi quxrasinpromptu eft.Namnbsp;*Utn inimiciria?, quxfufcipiuntur Si cxeinbsp;'quot;tur in bonos.Dci amante�,pr�claris dontsnbsp;/^�tosjin ipfumDeum omnis boni amhoremnbsp;*�undant Nec fieri potcft, vt quis Dcum dilinbsp;qui Dei feruos �eximiaorganagloriasnbsp;odio lacobandreano proCequitur.

1^. ^�bes optime leftor.caufaj prxcipuas bre ^�'*radumbratas,quibus Andreas abreptus,nbsp;J. teinere' K impotenti animo fpicul� lingu�nbsp;*^vscnenatxnonin libidin'em. non inauariznbsp;*�**gt; ( qua clauftra nouorum Vbiquitans moznbsp;^fborum infamiafunOnonin impietatem Si.nbsp;^�Sitia : fed in eos.qui aduerfus huius noiii fiznbsp;' ^rarpofiti fiue Prioris ediftum credunt, donbsp;confiientur, facratifsimam Chrifticar

amp; porconim, fed elelt;fl:orum pionimip �'��m amp; poium eife, contorquet.S; ceiifiilininbsp;.^orutusfulmmafter eintttit. Ha� ver� caiiznbsp;��nonidcoexpofui.vtiacobum Andreamadnbsp;�*''ntcm rcuocarem ( fcio enim Imn; podtc em,nbsp;f'lt;^Utn veteribiis loquar,lotioncm ita luperafnbsp;/�''tnemoampUiis velit caput ein ; uitrolauanbsp;'gt;qu�m littus arare ) fed vt omnibus phs,quinbsp;�'�hort veriratisftudio.qu�m Andreas, duciinnbsp;j^^r.oftcnderem, qua fide,qua cqiifcicnna qvinbsp;quot;s artibus.quo denique Carlo conirnuer-tamnbsp;B i

leng^ grautfsiinam , adquamfopiendame^ mnes pq merit� omne rtjdi� conffrre dcbent,nbsp;traftet Si tomponere ftadear.Peinde vt hominbsp;nis iftiuj miferi amp;i m'ferandi exemplo 8C menbsp;S/. piam iuuentiitem adinoncrctn.ne odio, in-'nbsp;ui�i�^uarniac, aipbitiQiii, otio, obtre ^tandinbsp;ftudionimiiimindulgeant ; fed matur� ante-*nbsp;quS vires acquifierint Si (Rueterauerint.com-'nbsp;primant, Si quantum in fc eft ex anitpis eijei-�nbsp;ant. Nam iftavitia vbipenttus in animo infe'nbsp;derint, radicestjj cgerint,diffifillimc eucllun-'nbsp;tur : nec folum mclancholiam partant, X in fonbsp;litudincs clauftraqjdctrudunr, fed eti� inimanbsp;tartara,niffeximantur,prxtipit3nc. Prius il-'nbsp;ludAndrex triftifsimum exrnplum nos do/nbsp;cet .� poftcrius Saulis,lud�.Hcrodis allot um-/nbsp;que tragici fnneftitp exitus teftautur.

Porrd f� quis fines quos lacc jus propo nens in optim� quenqj graffatur, fpedrt, tresnbsp;potifsimumjmeaquidetnfententia.occurrcnf'nbsp;Primus eft, vtdoif�os piosfjj ho mines, q�'�nbsp;Ecctefijs �i fcliolis ytiliter laboran^popuU'i�nbsp;ndelitcrdocendo,pi3m iuuenrntemafsidue'e''nbsp;rudiendo cxercenlo matx ei'.,3 earner .nf-'nbsp;uos incidunt,fraudes detcg;�uit,errores confu-'nbsp;tant, atep mtferam Vbiquitatem exhomiuuiunbsp;animis itifolitudinem amaiidanttqi a melan-'nbsp;cholict eius fabri quo.Tjdeleflantur, � fuis fa-'nbsp;lutifrris Irudtis a'jftraiiat, ad fecum conuidl�nbsp;certaiidutnjioi; cft.ad otium, tempus, donaDe*nbsp;abuten^

A P O L O 6 � �. 14 ^^JUtenda perdcnda traducat. Hat enim ra-*�one animaducrtitjiomo alioquin ad technasnbsp;^''�ncandas non infelix.cos in pijs fuis, toti^nbsp;^hriftiano orbi vtihbus ftudqs Sfconatibusnbsp;Plurimum impcdiri aut cert� cardari pqffe. At*nbsp;ycl hinc videri poteft.qudm nefarij fint dianbsp;��'^li couatu$,quibus Oei gloria: Ecclefix^ faxnbsp;�^d�:3crtedi'officerefonatur. Cumenimfpilt;*nbsp;Qgaxodoretur Andrcam fibi ipfj � ppblinbsp;exerciiijs Si. mijneribus immunitatcm de^nbsp;�^life.atcp vjtam monafiicam Bibenhupi vouiPnbsp;J'*gt;(ia(ncniin placet ei illud, ab omnibus pru.�nbsp;'1'niibus improbatum; AaS�/S^ao'trot. Itetn il

Ketv^ Itemillud; iunbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;t*nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;) alia ratione e*

Operaabuti tent�t Itatplacobi Andre�nilt; *��*0 oiio (quod puluinar diaboli dicitur) abunnbsp;'*�ntis, SC nimiocibo(qut homines in beftiasnbsp;'onuertit) indulgentis, linguam acuit Siinznbsp;^�nimat, (lingua enimmaledica� geliennaiqnbsp;^��mmatur.Iacobi j verf.tf.) haciprationcfi*nbsp;quot;'les Dei fcruos , qui ftrenuam operam in vilt;nbsp;�'raDomint nauant, eum'qj tanquam imma��nbsp;�'*gt;1 aprum ab ea qu�m longifsimc atcent.re-'nbsp;*�'�rari conatur. Q^iareprudenterpiecpfaci^nbsp;^bqui quantum in I'e eft, Sf quantum glori�nbsp;^cinihil detrahitur, iftius fulminaftri inutixnbsp;��s,fulmina briita Si quouis folio Bibenhul�a^nbsp;leuiora contcranunc, ncque fc hac ratio*�

' MtBBVHLERI ne � fuaftatione, quam Deus afsignauit,�/nbsp;xrmplo Andre�,auocari patiuncur. Satius cftnbsp;cnim in luce verfari cos, acque ijs quiin lucenbsp;fint lucem^ amantjnfcruirc, qua m cum luci^nbsp;fugis et folitarijs criminatiombuscertarc,quonbsp;certe' nihilo plus agerent,qu�m vt cum infanonbsp;infanirent.oleumqr operamperderent. Prsenbsp;fertim cum Deus eorum auditoribuseamgranbsp;tiam largiatur, vt etiam horis fuccif�uisifti ornbsp;dini rel�ftant.eiufqperrores quos in folitudininbsp;parturiunt,(n lucem protrahant.

Alter finis eft vt fua atroci amp; canina maledi centia viros modeftos.SC quibus fuamfamamnbsp;fartam tetflamcp � calumnqs conferuare mefi''nbsp;to cordi eft, etiam � defenfione veritatis publinbsp;cadeterreat; arque is hac ratione trophzuntnbsp;iivvJ)3�gt;Ti �.vcufj.'j)rt (�ne fudorc amp; fanguinbsp;neftatuatjtriumphumtp agat. Nam quemad/nbsp;modum pudica honefta matrona cum infa/nbsp;mi fcorto, quodomnem frontem facicmtppcrnbsp;fricuit,non facil� in arenam defccndit, atq) tufnbsp;gia exercet ; ica quoq: multi boni viri, quibusnbsp;nihil optatius efiec, qu�m placid� de controlnbsp;uerfis articulis conferre, diffictilter fe ed addunbsp;ci paciuntur, vc cum ore iftoimpudent!, quodnbsp;iain pridem pudorem cum pudicicia ami�t�nbsp;quodnihtl aliudqu�mfeipfumfcabere, alioSnbsp;verd criminari poteft,congrcdianrur. MaluBtnbsp;enim dummodo glori�Dei, SC veritati nihilnbsp;dc�edac, imicari illudCatonis, quimalediconbsp;cui-'

APOLOGIA. If ^uidam dicebat : Impar mihi eft tecum certaxnbsp;*xcn.* tibienimmalcdicere �(malc audire innbsp;Pfomptu eft ; mihi ver�mal� audirc infolit�.nbsp;*�)ukdicere autem infuaue. Malunrde conf) lionbsp;Philofophihunc fuum hoftcmnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;vicifci

^lt;3)^0/ nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;honeft� 6d bene* vi

^cnd�. Mahinchocitacundumos vindicate, (vtalibip�lchrc' monet Plutarchu�: cr�^c� �V

^quot;^y^avacrt : � ^iJ^pSin� KVveuJhv, � ^AfltKOF,� iK()2\ff.lt;rovtr �o/^�'�02_o^)iinbsp;^fv��gjv.hoc eft, viros bonosfe prxftando,nbsp;��perantcr, fobnc, pieip viuendo.vcritatemnbsp;^Oquendo,human� Si iuft� ad fc adeuntes traznbsp;^andozqn�m cumper cont�mcliam appciznbsp;*�ndo Cynacdum.eff�minatum, intempcranznbsp;�***�gt;fcurram,fordidum,Sf feruilem., Sciuntcznbsp;�*lt;gt;�primo ilia Andream vrerc, amp; eius crimi�nbsp;^*tiones eonfutare : hxc verd quia iam prixnbsp;orones modefti� fines tranf�uit, atque o�nbsp;��na pudoris repagula perficgit,(ufi^ deqj fernbsp;flocci pcndere. Deinde vcr� ncn igr.Oznbsp;^�nt.ita ffle voJunratemDei, vtbenc agendo,nbsp;S*gt;af� capiftj O frxncnt amentium bominum.iznbsp;8norantiam� Petn2.verf 15 Maluntdcniquenbsp;p�fdem Apoftoli c onfilio morcm gerentesjnnbsp;�qui veftigia Chnfti,amp; conuicijs afielt;�li, non

vicifsim coniliciati,malis affcdi.non m�nar^ iej committere vindi^tam ei qui iult� ludicat�nbsp;tju�m cum Andrea �tio 5C tempore abucentes�nbsp;velut luftrion�s m palxftra puiuere jta conui'nbsp;c�qs fefe oblincntes 8C d�nigrantes certar..nbsp;Qiio ccrt� nihil plus agerent,quant vf cum in'nbsp;fanoinfanircnt,amp;: An�rex folitadinem^quihinbsp;�le lufi'bus pattiuir.leuaret�.

Qiiapropter hoc pr�b� fci�t; fibi^perfii�' dcat Andr�as, ncmmemetinoilris amplius.vlnbsp;lum verbum rcfponfut um ad falfa ems crimi'nbsp;lia amp; conuicia.Qiiippe cumomnes, quitus n�nbsp;gotiam �liquo'J turn �o eft aut fuit, erebro denbsp;lt;to dicerefolcant.quod de Demofthen� A�fcMnbsp;fies Irt ludicio graniter dixit ; trtf�TT�TiKtyt^itlnbsp;avQpcti'Tr�i yonTinbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;�v amV

�Agt;,�� KcP�KeiT�/) Negotium mibi eft cum homine infi'gtiitcr impoftorc, quitu�infeiensnbsp;quidem vert quicquam poisitdicere. Ridicu'nbsp;iusigitiirpian� eflet.qm l�bi crimina, qu�in'nbsp;fert homo, quem dudum omnis f�des apudnbsp;inn�s fanos defecit.diluenda putaret.-fiquideninbsp;fita fponre in fumum abe int Multo igitur pritnbsp;dehtius agunr,qui Andrea: conuiciantt refpoonbsp;flebunt fd.quoJolim Socrates feconuicijs m'nbsp;tpifenti rclpondtfrefenur;

Hoc ante ver� reif��illidicipoflcomnes, credo,raccmnfatebunxur, quihaclenus eiuSnbsp;confi!igt;

^onR'ia ob; erun runt, inftitina n�tarunt amp; fcr� T'a Ifgci-unr. Nam illi cptimc norunt Andrcznbsp;nnllLm vnquam tonfilium eepiflTc, nihil innbsp;� t�iflc, nt'.llum fcriptum edidiffe, quod nonnbsp;l onornm viroruni ignomihiani dirigereznbsp;��^ovodneu rurbas darct.quodnonconuitianbsp;^��Iieirr.c.lr 2cac �uandiu non f�it.quem igndnbsp;^��'P-a aliqua notaret, 0'�cm contuinelia affiznbsp;amp; c�nMictiiinfetflaretitr, tafnditioddnbsp;^��pnu X gen�c iadiilRt Ntc vHi vnqnaiin velnbsp;Pquot;ophe,� vc! Apofiol�, velali] alic�i author�nbsp;�^phcalido vacarc potuit. At qu�rfiim atMgt;nbsp;��tpluradicerc dercnianifefta^Iacobus An*nbsp;quOtics eum deFcu t mate ria certain aligt;nbsp;^**airi p�tfouam exagitandi,amp; ir.ucronemfti�nbsp;�f ^cnndiac exert endiaode� quOuis lapide ma*nbsp;^�sniL'iiis fu t.

Qpoties igitur e�m eius,tuin aliorum ciuP ^mfarifi� hominumfcriptainfpicio.tOtiestrtnbsp;��^emoriarn redeoeins, quod memoriaepro*nbsp;I jditLaitant.lib. �. Defalfareligionecap.��.

Verbis Apud Lind�m, qu�deftoppidutn *^�iodj, i�ercuhs facra fiint. quorum � csetc*nbsp;dslonge diutrfus eft ritus, f�quideronOn�v-{vt Graeci appellant) fed malediftisnbsp;execi atiODc c�lcbrantur : caq; pro violatisnbsp;��bent, fi quando interfolennesritus ve!im*nbsp;P^udenti al icui exciderit bonum verbum Hocnbsp;ficiunt omnesquorquot Vbiquitati no*nbsp;�*��113 fua dedcr�i, quoiquot ei genua fledunt.

quotquoc facra faciunt- Nam alij hxretici qo* fibt nouas doftrinas f�nxerunt, vi plurimuninbsp;argumcntis ea confirmare videri volueriuit:nbsp;atv�r� qui liane Pandoram defendendam a^nbsp;facris colendam fufcep�runt,vr plurimum coonbsp;uictis, criniinacionibuSjCalumnii.Sjinfauftis iWnbsp;preeationibus pugnant,ac fuisbrutisnbsp;nibiisnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cerium territantacinftaf

Ncadum terram,poftes, columnasiprumptf^ conantur Ade� quidcm vt faciliusbalenas*nbsp;a�re volirantes �lt; Delphinum infyliiis eurr^'nbsp;re vid�as,qif�mlt;5�'(pgt;!|Ult;aji aur vllamhumani*nbsp;tatis modcftixCliriftian�f�gnifieatione'��^nbsp;in Vbiquitanor� fci iptis deprelicndasnbsp;agrelteSjadc�eT�ff (prycyenbsp;TO-jTOf TSTii� eezcr�-^SA.ov,Vbiquitas'.

Tertius finis, queni propofitum habet A�'' dreaSjCft , vt apud luos auditores.noftros do'nbsp;�loi es fxofos, atep eorum fcripta fufpcdtanbsp;dat, �iexmanibiis eruditx iuuentutisextof'nbsp;queat. Nam prim� vehementer metuit,nbsp;noftrorum fcripta legat,et diligenter euolu�'�nbsp;fuasfraudesanimaduertat.- craffos erroresdnbsp;prehendatccalumnias videat : atep pofteriof*'nbsp;bus cuns, quae meliores fapientiorescpnbsp;confueuerurit,locum rclinquat. ld quodo�'nbsp;ftra xtate profpieicnte Deo, r�pugnante Annbsp;drea,fxpenumero faftum cflc, amp; adhucnbsp;multorum iiteris,fermoiubus,quxreli?,nbsp;ad߫'

J^BeLe.ihuf�anos ?fferri tni�lum eft dubiiim. ^5igiiiir Inaioi i aftuiia �bi fii�q; fo�nari�Vbinbsp;caueie fo.tft/��.ndteas c,ii.imftcruznbsp;�'ta: iiiiientiiri pft i�uadcat , \i fibi � ftiiptis,nbsp;'i'Jibiis Miiqiiitas cxpiigtiatvr , tancpcius'�inbsp;^igue caucanr. Dcindi veto hat rationefuisnbsp;^'�Oqiieii aterfu�s, quosiaiper, � fcaffli�tisnbsp;perturbatis , Cermanix ?.cadetnns prxfe^nbsp;J'bn.iilris no�tis viriy in exilium eu(ftis,con.'nbsp;**ierejcorumq5 hor.ori ftiiderc conatw � Nam

Nam in eins fcliolis noftri homines ��xima �X parte � fi videlicet coniiiria exci.*nbsp;^'�s)profirentHr K condemnantiirjn enis Ec?nbsp;.'fijs noftri de�torcs fimul concionannir �inbsp;J.f'finitis conuitijs deiormantiir : in einsnbsp;*isnoftri federn domiciliumliabent, ftu^nbsp;f'ofe afteruantiir, chari grariq; hofpitcs finit;nbsp;�fgt;sver�Siin publico vel prchibcntur, velnbsp;'�^ulare iubcntur,vcl ftentoreis clamoribiis innbsp;�^�uni inmdiainqj addiuuntur.

Ex his autem qiixhartenusditfla drmori^ ftrataqj funt,fi inentium noftrarumociilosa^nbsp;tins erigamiis, facile.,intclligfm�s inlacnbonbsp;Andrea cactcrislp eins gregalibus, noiiis non?nbsp;Vbiquitatis monacliis, impleri, quodPaiiluSnbsp;�. Timoth.j. cap, cuenturumpoftremistem''nbsp;poribiis pr�dixit ; videlicet hommes fof�nbsp;lt;p;ActOTE� lui amantes (piAef/s^�poo�nbsp;ros,aAc�lt;^rct� gloriofos,' vTj-iprt^�va�nbsp;maledicos.a^sepi�-a� ingr^nbsp;ios, �voffiH� impurOs, d��pycv� chantatisnbsp;rxpert�s,nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;infcios f�deris^

calumniatoreSiaxg^Tt�� intemp�rant�-�� eiv�fgt;i�p'd� immites gt;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;minim� 3'

mantes bonorum lt;5)^o77-eT�� pr�cipites, TVipa^u^ou� in flato S , lt;p/A�eP�v8� �nbsp;tp(A9'amp;�HC,voluptatiimainantcspotius,qu�thnbsp;amantes D�i, g^orroe uop^pwnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;l��

bentesformam pietatis.T�v e/l'g J\,wua.(ji.iv vim autem eius abnegantes�nbsp;Hlt;tc tire inqiiam funr, lt;m� in fctiptis, confi'nbsp;Iqs.dicfis amp; faiffis ram Andres qu�mciusfonbsp;ciorum luce meridiana clariusetucent; itavtnbsp;ouum ouonontam fim�ei�t,quamijnbsp;iftis hominibus,quosPauIusnbsp;hocl�co defcribit.

. Q�o ca!it}nni�,^uilgt;iis lacolgt;ui �,ndreiK ^�ircum'�eumler�yinpoftrcmis fuKfcrinbsp;ptb aduerpif �. �rynx� in omnium oditinbsp;Vidtcmptim adducerc ftuduit,firmis �jquot;nbsp;fUidenttbui rutionibtn diluuntur.

Lj Afcenus tta�]; Dc� bene muante,qua poz tltuinms modeftia.breiiitaic Siperfpicuitanbsp;J'fxpofutnnis ea.^u� ptjs mentibus merit� donbsp;(Otem affcrur.t.'quia vident Ecclefi'asResi� pitnbsp;i^licasexijs nonexiguum deiriment�capere;nbsp;y^rbi Dei curium mirnm in mod� impediri.-:''ticbriftircgnumaugcri �abiliritanimosnbsp;'^ttiPrincipum qu�mtiibdirorum magismaznbsp;S�Stpexaccrbari-.caufsdifceptarionem; verita'nbsp;inquifirionem omitti; perfonar� ver� eernbsp;^^tum criniinationes cumulari. Nik ver� paunbsp;^�S expon� gaudium qnod ex fcriptis Andrexnbsp;'�pi. Annumcrat tnc magnis illis vins, quoznbsp;futn virtutes tanto ftudio inihi imitandas iudi�nbsp;fP-�quanto ab Andre� vitijs niilii cauend� exi-exprobratmihi ftultitiam,ignoranti�,nbsp;ysnttate.sncptias, quas alijs do�lifsiinis vir isnbsp;�l�ieftat,� quor� eruditiotic is tain l�ge abeft,nbsp;^H�Vbiquitas � maieftate humaniratisCbrifti;nbsp;9nit de nie cpinecia,agit inanem ti iumplium,nbsp;^�tuit troplixa^quod amp; ante multos annos �dnbsp;pi'iuetiamhodiede multis cruditifsirais vins_nbsp;*tcit; cum quibus tarnen f�cert�t/Andreas, reznbsp;ft� dixeris;A�iims contra Lconeni.

H�c funt qua; mihi gaudiiim amp; volupta' tem attuleriint. Qiiid enim qu�fo pr�clarius�nbsp;quidhomini adolefccnti obtingcre pofTctop^nbsp;tatius, qii�m innumerum tot tanto; um� vironbsp;rum reponi� qu� niaior laus efie poffit, qua'mnbsp;ijfdcerie odio,quibusfuncb�niomnes?nbsp;dcnicp honclt;l:ius,qu�m qfdem contumelijs aPnbsp;fici,quibusaff�ciuntur,nonfures,B� latroneS�nbsp;non fcelerati homiaes:fed tottanta�p Rerun�*nbsp;pub.amp;Ecclefiarum lumina.

Scribit alicubi Platarchus Phocionem ini* quis prafiudicqs damnatum , amp;iam iamalt;lnbsp;fupplicium duccndiim,cuidam,qiiod vna mo*nbsp;ricndum effetnbsp;lamcntantiS^ xgrcfcrenti, animo excelfoS^nbsp;jnui�lo dixifle-.ovx. ayaTr��nbsp;7acpoxi�v@'} Annon gaadto 8� voluptati el^nbsp;cumPhocione.viro videlicet optimo,mortcinnbsp;oppeterc lt; QiiodfiEthnici/uturorumpr�''nbsp;miorum ignari, pulchrum.lioneftmn^ dux�'nbsp;runt , candem fiibire fort�,nam cum virisS^nbsp;picrate meritis infignibus ; quid cuxfono^nbsp;bis Chriftianis gratius vfu venire debcat�nbsp;qudm cum Dei feruis , inquos Deus tot tan-*nbsp;taq/dona, certifsima euidcntifsimacpfuxerg^nbsp;ipfos beneuolenn�docum�td.contulit, � mu'�nbsp;dl liuiiis 8i tenebrarum filijs vexari, falfis cri�nbsp;minibus dcformari, atrocibus iniurqsaffi^*�nbsp;dirisipdcuoueri^

Monet denicp idem Plutarchus,lt;c%t lt;5�S�-^24,res fecundas ct animi dolorem,qui ex ^�uritiir,plurimum Icuari porte, fi'in vitam a-�nbsp;Riorum,eoriim� magnorum virorum,intuea-'nbsp;confidcremu^.num quid tale ipfis quonbsp;W acciderit. Hac ipfa medicina vfus dolorc,nbsp;Andreas fuisconuieijs faccrc conatur,nbsp;*gt;011 folum minuOjfed ctiam penitus exhanrio;nbsp;��^troliim cxliauhojfcdetiam in gaudiam connbsp;^frto.Si eniai medaeijs amp; iniquis Andrej prxnbsp;Miciis deformer,video idem cximijs Dei ferxnbsp;��'Sipijs Regibus , Prophetis Apoifolis amp;nbsp;��^nibus fanftis vfiivenirte, att^fummaelaudinbsp;�^glori�fuirte. Si vero homoftultus inexnbsp;P'us ab hoc Theologo delicato appellee, nonnbsp;**deo,curmagnoperc doleam : ac nonpotiusnbsp;�5*fnme' gaude�,miliitpgratuler;vidcns f�tunbsp;*�'n$ Dominum meum lefum Chriftii veile menbsp;fibi 8i dileftis fuis Apoftolis tn/jU5(pplt;poitnbsp;'�gt;iformcm fieri.Nam ipfc quotp � fuis infantnbsp;' d�monium habereproclamabatiir. Apo

�tfi vero,quoad me atcinct, Jacobo Andre? ne verbo quidem refp�ndere ab initio ftatui�nbsp;quippe ciim probe fcircm bonos viros ems cinbsp;�umnijs n� tnoucri amplius '� ac tanc� abc(1c,vtnbsp;itiilii fuis conuicijs apud ipfos inmdiam conH�nbsp;xit,aut eorunj de me cxpe�lationemimminue*nbsp;tk, aut fufpicionc aliqaam maiam illis de nienbsp;mouerit; vtmepotius fumme illis commend�nbsp;lient grstiam corum auxerit. Nam vt bon'^nbsp;virisplacercjfic malisdifplicere, fumma lausnbsp;eft. VndcAntiftbeneSj� malis laudatus.geinei�nbsp;do dixifTe fertur:�iytgt;v/�(j.n-n

M�mo ne quid mali c�miferim. Attaine'1 de confilio 8C fen tentia multorum gfauifsin��nbsp;rum virorum priorem iftam fententi� mutaubnbsp;atq^Andre� calumi�ias,quas non paucas innbsp;confinxit,dilncreconftitui;vtii, qui Andrcan�nbsp;�ter an albiis fit ignorant.eutn ex hifee paiiti^�nbsp;tanqu� leone ex vngiiibus cognofceinbsp;Fcrt aiitem animus criminafalfa,nbsp;ucrfiiin me pugnat vnius fyliogifini fpacio *nbsp;centpo inclndcre ; nam id ad breuitatc aptiuS�nbsp;�d refutationemfacilins.deiflori ad intellig^�nbsp;diim amp; iudicandii proiitdentius crit.Cum ig*''nbsp;tur D. loanncs lacobiis Grynams, pr�ceptO*^nbsp;mens.pietatis, eruditionis amp; modekia: nomi*nbsp;ne toto orbe �larus -, in Synopfforationis qn*nbsp;tiabiiit.cum finis dkpntationiHcidelbcrg�P^*�nbsp;Odidumn liabif� impqncndns cflef, inter

quot; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ter*

*'*iiiHeydelbergaab Andrf�fociis eietflj fucgt;' ne vnius qiiidemhorulxcolloquium e-'nbsp;**^ni fuppliciter petentes impetrare potiiirtc:nbsp;Andreas confutandum fiifcep! fTet, f�c arg�nbsp;��ntatur in iua admonitiouc de Synopfipag.nbsp;3-multis profyllogifinis �Confiitationedifpunbsp;**donis(per antiphrafmfic didlain) pag.nbsp;J�^.afliimptis.

Quicunfp in Academia Tubingenfii magna ^'imdnitate amp;C admirationc per integr�diemnbsp;^�ommem ineprum SI ftultum omnibus locisnbsp;temporibus.de rebus grauifsimis,quas ne-�nbsp;S^�edidicitneque intclligitdifputantcm,3boznbsp;��nibus in fchola T ubingenf� pro ftulto et incznbsp;P'o liabitum, ac fub ementito fuo nomine fcriznbsp;ptum aduerfus Andrea: difpiitationem de Adonbsp;��atione carnis Clirifti edi palTum, magno cumnbsp;auditorum txdio amp; admiratioiie.nonfoliiauznbsp;^�uit.fed etr� publicc confudit : nee folum connbsp;^uditfed etiamc� redegit anguftiarum vt niznbsp;^'ilampiius aduerfus difparationcafferre pof'nbsp;Pee, arqj fc publicc' � fuis Tigurinis dilfeutirenbsp;Profiteretur ,� de eoncutiquSpoteftdici, quodnbsp;Tiieologos Heyde'bcrgehfes, D. Boquiniim,nbsp;2anchium Vrfiuum, ante feptCHnmm i-inyfnbsp;delbcrgxnon audiucrit.

Atcgo lacobus TVndrcas olim dignifsiffl'J* �cademix Tubingcn�'s Cancellaruis, Prxp�nbsp;f)ms venerabiliffiRiuSjTheoIogi� piofeflbrnbsp;Icbcrrimiis.�niincEvemita Bibfnli'jfianus��i�*nbsp;ftiffimus, clauftri eius carnc kvina, deiicadsnbsp;pifcibus,gencro.�s vinis afflucntis Prior �qu*'nbsp;fimii?. Palatinarus Eleftoralis mea opinion�nbsp;ecpotentiaf�tutorilluftrif.funia c�humanif�nbsp;te.vt folco,amp; patientia cum omni�i t�dionbsp;mirationc.fu�cfilentii impof�tio�ie,amp; quidc mnbsp;tegr� dic,omnibus ante amp;' poft meridic lioris�nbsp;in conlefru celeberriino omni� profeirorum��nbsp;rotins ft�diofx luiicntutis j Marcum Beumi�''nbsp;rum Iiominem ftultum amp; ineptum,omnibusnbsp;CIS Sif temporibus derebusgraiiif.,iinis,qu3Snbsp;neep didjcit.nctj intelligicdifputarepr�fum�'�nbsp;tem�vtego ioquor)abomnibus, quotquottn�nbsp;arn.Vlagnific�n�iain,dignitatem,celebritatfni,nbsp;fariiflitarcm amp; fi qiix alia mihi fiimo,reueren'nbsp;tar pro flnlto amp; inepto liabirum,ac fab emcn^nbsp;tito nomine, vt inftarh�dcrc atTurglt;report�t�nbsp;fcripium breueaduerfus meamdifputaiionemnbsp;decarnisChiiftiadorationeedi paliam : nonnbsp;folum audiiii.fed etiam confudi, atep in tantaSnbsp;angiiftias redegi, vt non modd nihil ampliusnbsp;aduerfusdiipiiraf'ont.m afferre pofl'et.atqu�nbsp;ctiain fe ad fiios perfcriprurum publicc teftS''nbsp;remr, neefoiumictlarenir, fedetiamfecuittnbsp;fins Tigiirinis minime fentire profitcremr.

Ergo de me arque meis dici minime poteft, flood ante feptennium Tlicologos Heydelbernbsp;gcnfes fcfe audiri petenres, non audiuerimus.*nbsp;'fl quod mihi Herculeo argumento demon-' -^fandum fumpfi.

Quid quxfocft.optimcLeftor.Oreftis in-� ^�niaminfanire, fi hoc non eft quid eft rotinbsp;�'�undo illuderc,fi hoc non eft �; quid fronicmnbsp;'Ofatnq; faciem perfric3re,fi hoc non cftlt;?Qiiidnbsp;^gfi animi.omni faiio redlorjj iudicio deftitU'nbsp;iracundia tranfuerfum adli ludicium eft,nbsp;�'ohacpropofttione non euidentifsimum eftlt;nbsp;^�mpr�rer fophifma td /Uii iTiV/iiivov,nbsp;*'^fft.fcopas diftblutas, triplex fallacia,ab igxnbsp;��oratione Elenchi,hoceft , tria craip��wianbsp;^^^��exaapertifsima documenta infanix,nbsp;'��pudentix, animi xgriamp; errore vagantisnbsp;nobis offerunt.Aded quidcm.vt de proponbsp;|,��^0e hac qua Andreas D. Grynxi verbis renbsp;P�ndet,re�te dicerc pofsimus.quod olim inznbsp;P'*cuiufdam ineptum amp;: extra chorum falznbsp;refponfum prouerbio loc� d�dit�A/^�nbsp;I �^gt;1T8v,�lt; cP� �.'TrwpvSvTO crxa^a�,Falces pcnbsp;�mdllj vero negabant ligones.

�ni primo noftcr hic Canccllarius vagatur '��acancellos loci,quos fibi circumdarc de.

bebat-Nam doiflor Grynxus ait noftros Hef dclbergac non fuifl'e anditos Hoc veto Cancelnbsp;lariqs , inficere volcns �v�'O^ctf� refpondet:nbsp;Marcum BeumierumTubingx auditiimtfle.nbsp;Ex hoc refponfo,in graciant mucntutis Si launbsp;dem Andrex.inregrum fyilogifin� formabo-vt quilibetaniniaduertat.qui vir f�t Andreas�

Ergo lacobuj Andreas,qua: mea eft in et' �lef�a authoritas.in difputando acumc prnnbsp;dctia.Ycrc aftirmo,Si omnibus fi'mpliciter erenbsp;dcnd'i prxcipio.de eo qui auditur Tubingf,fainbsp;fo dici,quod no etja audiatur (�mulHcydelbcr-Atqui corarn facts mea Auguftifsima com'nbsp;paruit Marcus Beumlerus.homo fi cum met�nbsp;conf�ras.nullius eruditionis, atq; � mea digquot;*nbsp;race auditus fuit.

Ergo ex antecedctibus,eti� iplo Ec!to,qU'�^ Bebenhufli inter fauces tnontium refonai.te�*nbsp;�vctvTipprirM� concludoifaifd de nobis die*�nbsp;quodtheologos Heydelb. non audiuerimu'�nbsp;Id quod milii luculentifsime' et artificiofifsij^^nbsp;f modo logicis probatur, demonftrandii fS*'

Equidem metuo Andre3,ne tui T�bingen'' fes.quos alioquin mctu, atep proptcreao^*��nbsp;(ov Jiic/llaa-hTSTovnbsp;quem cnim metuuntodenint) tibi fubiecifl*�nbsp;tdm longc in hoc tuo Si eicrt/Z�o^^�^nbsp;fyllogifmo � tedif�cnrianr, quandititunSt anbsp;officio tuo abfuifti,�^ yroj^a, zv

KJf�jped� inalienopofuifti. NififortafTehuic ^alo fuccurras, atcp c�municatione quadam'nbsp;^fydelberg� Tubig�,etcontra Tubing� Heynbsp;^tlberg� efre,attjj quicquid ver� de Hcydelbcrnbsp;��cnijntiatux-.idcetiamdcTubinga, amp; c�tr�nbsp;'�unciari pcffe Si deberc.fedinufitata, qu�innbsp;^�aphyfica tua logica tradtiur.prxdicationenbsp;�pfis perfuaferis;aut eii�tua authoritatecre^nbsp;^^ndjum mandaueriSjpropriaip manu fubfcrinbsp;�fndiim cocgeris.'Si liacratione corum rationbsp;in tui obfequium captiuam duxcris.

Neqj hoc tibi faftu aiwgt;i;:^avov difficile erit, ^fiiodo n� cedes malis , fed contra audentiornbsp;'Jis.N� fi lia�tcnus ipfis ita imponere potuiftinbsp;^toculos mentis perftringere,vtte affirmantenbsp;*ota vero S.friptura reclamante,credercnt,5inbsp;�dhiic velint nolint.credant :ccrl� elle in infernbsp;^o,3cinfeinrielfeinc(Elo:c�l� Siinfern�nonnbsp;'fie ioca circumfcripta, fed vbicj diffufa.ita ytnbsp;A^i fit in c�lo,tdc etiu fit in inferno Si contra;nbsp;*�''lt;lto rnincri,crede mihi.negotio eos adducesnbsp;credant Hcydciberg� T ubingx elfe. Si connbsp;^'�a.itc oui fitKeydelbergarcundc cfl�e Tubin

Si contra: itc quicquidfiat Hcydclbcrg� fieri Tubing�.etc�tra.Quandoquidcnonnbsp;'gnoras ex logica tua meraphyfica , qu� antenbsp;�fiquos annos Lipfi�, Philippi Melanch.loginbsp;'�exploGi.inplauftrofopni, quodopportun�nbsp;^des in qiiibus eras.prxtcruehebariir, nnagixnbsp;*Jtaiiter depinxifti, magis pugnare ccrlum Sinbsp;'nfernum, qua m T ubingam Si Heydclberga,

(Qiiod fi igitura fi'mili(quod argument! g**�'*? ti'jiplurimutnarridet att� f�liciterfucceditjnbsp;inhuiic maJum ex fuperionbus argmuentai**nbsp;nSjCofque iimplicifiimamSi ab omni ratio'nbsp;ne retnotiljimam fidem adiungcrc cogef�^�nbsp;Quemadinodum c�lutnfe habet ad inf�f'nbsp;nuni;ficfehabet Heidelberga ad TubingaiO�nbsp;Hanc propof�tionem probabis alio appoߓ�nbsp;Si erudttotimiU,quod fiiperiori hyeme.to^nbsp;Tiibing� dilputares de Adorationc carni*nbsp;Chrifti,affabrefabricafti,Si quam fuauif�*'��nbsp;rifii totiu� Auditorij cxceptumfancitum�yOi�nbsp;minifti.Qiiemadmodri fe habent duo p�li tf^''nbsp;r� inSxi.�lic fe habent duc natur� in Chriftinbsp;fona. Poitea verd vbi videris eos fuaiji�io�^nbsp;6i elTui�fsim� ridere, tibi^annuere fubfiinif^'

Atc�ium cft in inferno,amp; contra; vbi c�' lum ibi infernum.Si contra;qui in c�lo idfO*nbsp;etiam in inferno , amp;contra:quxgeruntuf**Jnbsp;f �lo.eaviem ciiim in inferno. Si contra.nbsp;f�hoc loco excipient facram feripturam c�'nbsp;lum Si infernum longifsimo interuallo diih�nbsp;gnererde vtroqj tanquam de certo definitollnbsp;loco pronunciarcxcclum folis f�deiibus, inf^*^nbsp;num verdreprobis diabolis tribuereitucO^nbsp;P'�trido nricte.quo mcTubtngxproftrauift*�nbsp;fi tefti in propria cama fides habenda eft,ocy'nbsp;ns pi ift.rncs.refponJenjio , Spiritum famft'*nbsp;inijs 1 icis. iobifcum balbutire. Si autem lgt;a^nbsp;non proc.fl.Tit,alta tenxandum cric via,nianbsp;Brent*!

^��enttjautlioritas manifcftx fcriptura: oppo ��quot;'�^a.iiscp.tanquam Gorgonecbie�ia.os obnbsp;'^fandum. Sic omnibus qui � te pendent, tuanbsp;quot;��fitata logica tandem perfuadebis ter.ainnbsp;''�larc,amp;:nilul intra e;Teoleam,nilextrainnunbsp;''duri.

. Wis ita confedis, reliquum cft.vr conclu--jj��; Ergo qu�c�inq?fiunt Tubing�ea reft� j^'^dicunturHcidelbcrg�racper confequens

� Grynxum roagnificc mendacif conuici: omnibus Si l�nguhsprobaui, Sucui-Affricam,fuo more,nouum monf�rumpenbsp;j'*^ilt;re.Ethocefl:pritnum lacobandrice eruznbsp;***onis documenium.

Pr�pofito c�mittitiir, quod non fifci pro--^***1 tempus,de qu� ferroo eft.Scribit D.Gty ^**�5 quidem vere feribit ,anrc feptcnniuninbsp;�^*ncm Theologorum qui Hcydelberga exnbsp;fueruntjcolloquii liberi copiam impetranbsp;J P�tuifpe^qiiam nunc Iliuftrifsimiis princcpJnbsp;Cafimirus lacobi fotqs vluofecit.nbsp;Il i^reas itayt deect Vbiquita�s Pnntificeninbsp;q ''�c� relpondet;Falfum diccre D.Gryn��:nbsp;fji*�3tite biennium eins refpondens auditusnbsp;iN^ Faciam hoc loco quod inHeydelber--(j h difpiitatione fsepe fuit opus Si in gragt;-jjj?�Andre�,cohifcc fcopis integrum fyllo^nbsp;iiti(j'^�'��gt;finiodofieripottft,colligam,adhunc

M. B E y M L E k �

Quicunquc ante biennium audiuit rcfpon

dcntcmGrynd��,eundeni antelepreaniumiK''

tcfle eft audimfle Theologes Heydelbei'^

genfes.

Arqui ego Andreas Pi;vpo(it�s , omnP bus Gennani� Ecciefqs prarponendus,

tc biennium audi�i Tubing� refpondenten*

Grynxi.

Ergo �ecefte eft me ante feptenniiit� Tbf�

logos Hcydeibergenfes audiuiflf. ae per ec��'

feqiiensdemonftraiu D.Gryiiaeum falfafct*''

berc,me contra verum affirmarc, fed crz�ft�� valdc.nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;�

Vxtibituoqjfyllogifmo Andrea iFort�^' I' l�s tm� Tubingenfes qui hadlenus prudentesnbsp;videntes� temifcr�indu(flifuerunt,atlt;pn'3?nbsp;gnam de tua cruditione K difputandi facub� tnbsp;te opinionem coheeperunt, iam te agnofe^*^*nbsp;incipient, fpemquamdetehabuerunt fefr�^ �nbsp;ftratam efle fentient, talemipfeCancellariu��* ' jnbsp;talempr�pofitunijtalem theologi�profei''�''nbsp;fem^talem Priorem B�benh�f�anum fe n3l^i�^nbsp;effe dolcbunt. Jmo qiiod grauifsimuronbsp;non folum in p�dagogium, quo non ita prio^nbsp;l�anncm Sturmium omnium lanornmiiidie*^nbsp;vndiqua(pdodlifsimum,S� D.Ioanncm lat^'� 'nbsp;bum Gryn�um, omnium bonorum fentcni�^ Jnbsp;Thcologum pr�ftannfsimum,magna tui eu*�nbsp;nbsp;'

ignominia,ablcgafti,pucrorumqj fer�l� ' ieafti.ablegandum iudicabunt, fed etiam n�l� j �,nbsp;minores

� p o L o e I 44 ^inorcs tuas eflc in difputando ineptias 5�nbsp;quot;wsiffoZo^ ta4,quam meas efle iudicaruntjVtnbsp;�'�ft' ill hbio poftremo verarum Lticianica�'nbsp;narraticnutii fcribis, iudicabunt.nbsp;htfi verd ba?c tibi impcndere vides An-�nbsp;'^f�a;attameii ammo ne fraugaris. Nam egonbsp;'�bi aliqua ra none fuccurrere pofle videorzdenbsp;quot;*aeiiiiTi maiefiate farta tcfflaijj con�ewiandanbsp;*^P*us fot tafle cogito.qu� tibi maicftas Cliri^nbsp;'��tcrdi eft.Tu n.odoeultursc patientcm acconbsp;��odesaurem.

Perfuafifti iamdudum iis.qui te adoranr, �bquot propria Letta tis, in quo poti�imiiinnbsp;'��tuicras vbiquitat�mCqu�cert c tiiac maieflanbsp;Ctiiils aeerrimus propugnator cs, pluri-*��1 profuit inhumanam Clirifli Domini ndnbsp;J�i naiuram transfufa eflc. Quidfi igitur cif^quot;nbsp;per(uadeas,non di�imili artificio.candcnbsp;��.^'iiram lium�nam tffe infini tam iempore,vtnbsp;'*o�nn�s res tarnfuturjc quam pr�terit�pr�nbsp;'��tesfint� Ncipfortafsts ad id cuincendumnbsp;'��'�nes deernnt:fi modo prius folidis argu^*nbsp;**''�gt;115,id quodhatffenus� tenon vfq; adeob�nbsp;�'faftuin cfl�c plurimi cxifttmant.probaueris

J nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;____ ___________J.-_________

-'^�n , amp; coinniunicatacam nondcftrncre, ornare.

H�c vbicffccfris(ffficiesautemovx oxc-� �ton fine pulucre)f�ne ncgotio probabis

� nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;te.vtante feptenniumTheologos Heydelbff

L nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;gxauJiendos amp; me Tubing�ante bienniu'� j

audnum vno eodemfcp loco.vno eodem^ tf*� h .nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;poreaiidiuiff�.-iiem ftprennium Sibienniui� j

y, nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Tubingam St Heydelbergam vnurn idew^ ,

j; nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;plane cfle credant. Nam poft quam in tempi�

Vbiquitatis federe coepift), tuarum^ ration^ in tni obfequium captiuam duxiftt ,tuisnbsp;pifti vt crederent omncs homines cum fib�nbsp;Dei perfonaliter vniri. Exhoc igitur faIfils�-*nbsp;mofundamento apudipfos vald�apodifftic*^�nbsp;ynbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;hoc eft veritati contrarie,tux autcmmaicft�ti

k nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;conucnicnter argumentaberis.

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Q;ieniadmodiim in perfona Chrifti Denas

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fe habet ad fuam huniaiiitatem ; fic fe habet ad

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;otniies homines.

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Hoc para doxum probabis oraculisBrcntil

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;cuius maieftatem cum tiia cotvunularo haift^

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nus accrrimc'propugnafti.quiRecog'nitioniS � '

j nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;pag.40 fic fcribit.'Difcrimen Chrifti St Pc�'*

1 I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fentia iinpleat Petrum ficut St hominem Cbf*

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ftum,non ramen communicat cmnes fuas pf�

( nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;prietates,fed tantum nonnullas.ltem pag.^J*

j nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Difcrimen inter Chriftum St alios hommes

|. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;non conftatpropric inhabitaticuefilij Dem

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fitiohominis,fed fommunicatione proprieta

E nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;turn,quibus filius hominis ab inhabitaiitcfilio

I' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Dei ornarur.Ne autem teftimonio vnius fidcSnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;J

i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;derogaripofitt, coniungcstuumcumpriorc.'nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;i

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;fit nomi'

H'g 57. li'.ttr irliabiiatict.rni l*ei itJat.�is irClirifiohoc vr.imtfi dikun.tn . cj.adnbsp;difiiil'uit iiiaricra dir.xnfa , Chrif.onbsp;immtnfa.Item f. vidctur ctjsm ilia paznbsp;pna jS.Chriftusbon ol.oc babttfi m cir.niznbsp;^*gt;5 b.pmiiiibits towmunejquGd cum co perfonbsp;*��btcr Deus fuitvnitus.

His ira peraflis fubfumes : Atciii filius Dei ^��bunianitati omnia fua prcpna cfTtniialianbsp;^**liter amp; vercccn-mvnicat KancafTi irprionbsp;��uimanifcfi� falfaro atqj fuosutbori tcntraznbsp;^kcntcm, probabis teflimcnio Ercntij n.odonbsp;'baio. Sinverd fmplici amp;'vbiqiiitariafidenbsp;autboritati acquiefccre r.olint, St facranbsp;^'^��1 liiciarum tcftimoKian tcproftrn flagiznbsp;'�bunt, quibus te plane' deftitiii non igroras,nbsp;^bijcies illis veluti Gorgcnemborribilc choznbsp;minifrrorum EccIefiarum,Lud;magiftronbsp;amp; Aedituorum,qui libro ccncordiac, quenbsp;vocitatis,ncmina fua dederfit.nbsp;proculdubio oiflo millibus miniftrorumnbsp;plus fid�j habendum efTc ccnfebiinr.quam paunbsp;Prophetis , amp; ApoPolis,pi acfcriim cirnnbsp;*'�lgd te.qui iftiKsfiiWcriptorum manipiili conbsp;^ypbrus cs,pro norma do6rinar babeant.

At'vero qux twa eft religio, dicey, hate vi' dentur abfurda.impia amp; in �cekfta Chrifti gt;gt;*nbsp;audita, diiftuaudituquehorrenda. Suntequi*nbsp;demfatcor,mi Andrea, taliaquac �tuiytdo^nbsp;rumque gregalium dogmatibus fcquiintur.^^nbsp;qu� non diunus.vercor.�impune'fereiis.Qj��*�nbsp;quam verd hare ira fin t, attamen tibi etiani a*'nbsp;que enam cogitandum efl�e non negabis.'Gog*nbsp;mulra male' interpi etari, qui vn� reifli' nobn*nbsp;intelligere. Qiiod tibi vfu venmrum eft�anf^nbsp;quindecim annos magnus Pliilofophus prsfdlnbsp;xit, nifimatqri? Vbiquiiatis tnsrpatrccitiiun�nbsp;abqcias.Sed ferd fapiunt I-hryges. Si enim Henbsp;lenam ilia mature reftituiffent repofeentiMe'nbsp;nelao multi$fefecalamitatibiis,qulbus peif^quot;nbsp;(fH funi liberaflcnt.-Sic tu quoque fi ante def�*nbsp;nium SC amplius tuam iftam VbiquitariamHenbsp;lenam,tibi quidem tuisip villisfruifbuofamE^nbsp;clefix verd Dei funeftam reliquifles, non cef'nbsp;tc'necefle haberes nunc tot opinionum mon^nbsp;ftra fingere.

C�tcrumcum fafliim infedium fierinc/ quear, nct^�tupeccata amplius agnofeere po*''nbsp;fis.pr�fta te eum virum.qui nobis � teneris��nbsp;guiculis cognitus es.atqj quotidie,vt videb^e*nbsp;xTcm tuam ficutliaiflenusfacias.vt tuamnbsp;ftatem tuearc, errorcserroribus cumularCjd�nbsp;111 ex dolo neiftcre,at�p ex quouis lapide mO�'nbsp;ftrofum igiicm elicereconare quamuisnbsp;iientfi.quiproculdubio trifiifsimusent, npl'*�nbsp;pra-ftare.nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Ncq��

T^equc can's ert,cur rti nouit�s.inf�l�ntia, 'nipietas taiKoperd commougat, amp; languonbsp;�'rtjcuiuj folttudo cauCa eflcperhibctur, alTe^nbsp;1^*� ! quippe lt;um ante pa�cos annos �rtinl*nbsp;h�niKiibus arqiir iiiaugt;liium,iiirohtum,itnnbsp;l'Uni.ab Omni rauoneet vcritarcalieti� vifuninbsp;'**.�^**gt; figmcnt� tuum dc corporis Clirifti Vbinbsp;2'*gt;tate:jcrcc�lo amp; inferno necj loco definiehznbsp;.o.ncqjrii flt;d�hllgiiendo:cleafrfnf�OncChri(�inbsp;�''fptdtV�m commuianda. Imdqu�m q�itfonbsp;ab eo omnes reftc �nticntes abhorre re,nbsp;^�od til amp; �rentiiis aff�rmaris, omnchomiznbsp;cii filio Dei pcrfonaliter vniri i omnes rcsnbsp;^filio Dei �^��TJit�ii� fenfubffffentialitcr fu^nbsp;^fntari ,� vnionem perfonalem nihil aliud elTc,nbsp;omnium proprietatum Deicans in carznbsp;realem transfuf�onem.fandlos propriet!nbsp;*9 D�iefientiales acciperelt;Aeque, credetni*nbsp;ftcrilcgum �ft dicerc, non folum koftiineJnbsp;�'^d�tiam omnes crcaturas cum Dcopcrfonalinbsp;**rVniri,Deum aliquot cfTcntial�s propriet3gt;nbsp;*'sf�H�:is communicare,id cft,dimidiosDcojnbsp;f�cerc : qii� omnes in eos tr�hsfunderc.id eft,nbsp;*0;os Deosfacerc.

NeCp vcrd, quantum ego iudico.cniquafrti *'*orurn aliqttid iioui fingere videbcris; quanxnbsp;^Ootnnes, qiiotquotte familiarifer n�runr,nbsp;*uis iftis nioribiis atTiiciieriint.

Sedredeo ad (cftiiirn Paralogifmiiin.Gry *'�-�us inqmt Tlicolog�s iHcdelbergenfes nonnbsp;D i

M. I E V � t E R I fuifl�auditos. Tuver�paul� imprudentiuJnbsp;Cquod tarnen tiiapacc ClariGimeD.Do^lofnbsp;dixcrim jregeris:At tuus refpondens � meaiinbsp;dttus eft. Atcp inde per incogitantiamCnam a/nbsp;liquando iracundo quodam zelo Si ardortnbsp;hnguam tuam tnentem prxcurrcre aiunr^ar/nbsp;gumcntaris.

Si lacobus Andreas anditnr Marcum Ceuta leriimaiimcnimuerd feaucriir Grynxumfal*nbsp;fd fcnbcre Theologos Heydelberga cijcicnenbsp;do5,non auditosfuilfe.

Hoe coanexiiin,quia vides non magisco* lixrere.quam lutum en ferro,opus habet pro^nbsp;batioiie.Eam verd defumes ex ccntone.quen�nbsp;auxiho ruorum fociorum adnerfus orthodo'nbsp;xumconrcnfumnonvicpadecifeiicirerccnnbsp;fti Nam ibi inter extera affirmas.Ioiu n ilk mnbsp;Pau'ii t Corinth.i J.Vnnspanis vnum corpusnbsp;multi fumus, nonadinternam fpirirualemnbsp;vnionem,qua f�deles in�hriftocapitc vnumnbsp;cuadunt.S; qud omnes orthodoxi, quocquOtnbsp;in EcclefiaDci florucrunt,refer�t,rcferend�:nbsp;fed de externa quadam p rorfus inaudita v^nbsp;nione, qua fideles cum infidelibus , aduerfuSnbsp;manifeftura Pauh locum 2. Corinth, verfunbsp;14.1$. 8ii�. extra Chriftuna vnumfuntco***nbsp;pusjnterpretaris.

Exhocfacil� conffeies Cnam exabfufd� nilnifiabfurdum^quodin vno homme fiaM'nbsp;dem etiam fieri in exteris omnibus.

.Ergofalfo fcnbit Gryn eus thealo^os He^f gg^Cjj pQd auditos.nbsp;uoio in ills tua maiori propof�tionejnnbsp;S'*'* niliil lanuin.nihil facrum, etiamli ex xdenbsp;*'��3 Bcbenhuffana profefta �t,reperitttr,dii�nbsp;�^imnioran.

- Me igitur ad afliimptum tuum qudm longif fumptnm accingo , in quo mihi paucisnbsp;**fbisniultagrauiaqjconuitia dixiftt, atqucnbsp;'��nes iracundix tux liaftas vibra�i.

. Atitequam ver� omnes p artes eius r�futa� ntanus fumam.ftudiefam iuuentutem tnnbsp;aliquibus capitibus admo*

P^fimo habet hie ftudiofa iuu�tus fordidiSC ^quot;^oilis minimeijtgenerofi animi indicium S�nbsp;**'(Bpluin.N� Andreas inftar ff^rtp^uoAc^ssnbsp;omnia conquirit, �C etiamvanifsimasnbsp;I f*glorixvrabras confeftatur. Ne^fatisnbsp;de alqs magnis viris.cuni quibus ,vciu*nbsp;fapientes.nullo modo conferri Si quo^nbsp;eruditionem neutiquam xquarc poteft,nbsp;. �gnific� Si thrafonic� triumphare.-fcd infuznbsp;ctiam ex. ine,cui tarnen omnia detrahit, X,

quem omnium liom�num , f�fonafsis Ipf�!�� excipias, ineptifsimuni efle proclam�t, tri-*nbsp;u'mphum ajere , viftor currui fuo Saxoni^nbsp;�p impont , inf�gnilaureacprenaiu�, inCa'nbsp;pitoliuip Bibenhuf�anum inuelti gcrtitnbsp;^e� fprdido 8i abicdo �nimo eft hart infa-�nbsp;n� ia�rus,; vt etiam in muRaceo la�reolamnbsp;quxrat.

Tu vert� lacobe Andrea Canccllarie Si Prxpofiie dignifsimc, fatinefanus es quiflt;nbsp;Victoria , quam aya/jUan fine fanguinenbsp;ttv'jJ)ia)'n fine fiidorc, m talis tantustp Can'nbsp;cellarius , tam inf�gnis Theologus, tantvf-'nbsp;�ierand�s Pr�pol�tus, tam Celebris fcholarumnbsp;Si Ecclef�arum reformator, tam fanftiis Et';''nbsp;inita , tot tantisque honorarqs , prscclan*nbsp;tu� virtutispriemiis,ornatus, debominenbsp;tiiodum adolcfcente Si inept�-, tuo ludici*�'nbsp;reportaRi , aliquid ad inf�gnes tuas lauJ^^nbsp;quibus c�lum tangere tibividieri� , acce*!^*nbsp;iepolTe Iperaiieris' lt; Noli quJrfo eK re tai�nbsp;exigua , exadolefcente tam inepfo tamin�' inbsp;gniflc^ triumpliare , fed cogita potius efinnbsp;demam efle verum amp; iuRum triumphuin gt;j :nbsp;benemeritisdcRepublica amp;Ecclella, oini'*'' j ,nbsp;um b�norum confenfu teftimonium tribu*'nbsp;t�renon fi quis �io iudicio triumpliet, inbsp;�iB ea glortx infignia aucup etur, qu� leuibnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;� jni �1'*'

Oeinde cxcmplum nobis (iibminiftrat An* �^��as.hoMiiuis tum arrogantis mg/avTOrnbsp;^gt;fc�^o�fcipfum laudancis, tunKtiani stjb-^*5t�^Ioquacis. Namprimofquodalibi Pfal*nbsp;*'5 imptj gt; tribuiOtemerc garnt, loquitur du*nbsp;*�*ter, laditat fefe infolenter ; vt videlicet eti*nbsp;?�� de fcomnium fermone vfurpetur� �TT��nbsp;��Ta twjtuTcv, �i77np �^Ji�f�CL�, Laudauinbsp;*quot;� vt hiftrio Aftydamas. Atq; hac in parte fenbsp;*'9n tantum u^plt;pt7Jx�r �C o/�i^ya/xorTlienbsp;�Jogiim, fed etiam ��9lt;xoy elTe oftendit. Nan�nbsp;^5'-np tt T�p(po?� �'m^yv'ri�, �inS tSnbsp;*tD/{^T0( (uetyKa^ovreu ^Ixrti tpi-I toDto tS TfAo�

�Vtw� �t �:TeiwvTt� f7m!yuv,ay pci Ty^.^O'iy *fiupov fTrcuyc/yvrav, �uroinbsp;^�p' SuuT�r dpx,��y ��v�i^ttf

I ^Jupetf Jbxo�T�; aTjyt.uowwirt, hec eft: ' Ql^^tnadmodum enira cibo deiliruti ex ipfa*nbsp;� *orpore coguntur fc pr�ter naruram alerc,nbsp;� ��que hic famis finis �ft : ira qui laudes cfu*nbsp;/ *iunt, fl non focios nancifeuntur laudato*nbsp;Z *�e$, ipfi gloriz cupiditatc dult;fli ex fe ipftsnbsp;! ^liquid fuff�eere �i conferre volcntes indeco*nbsp;/ i^fegcrum.inqmtPltttarchus.

Deniqj ,i monachorum 8i Ercmitarum fan* ftitatc art�ftata abhorrer plurimtiin, (uas launbsp;dc;,fnos triumphos.fuaingcntiafafti, fefquinbsp;p�quot;lalibus verbis commemorare.Militum gi�nbsp;rioforum. Si voluptatibus diffluencium funinbsp;ilt;li mores amp; uiepti�.vt pngnas iiarrenc,6fnbsp;catrices fuis ohentent. Nam hiviuunnwicnbsp;mundo:vosautein fanfiuii, incerdum Iniiu*nbsp;mandiperrxi�in gratiam vbiquicans.vcftrc,nbsp;vitam monailicam fouetis. S i ver� f�ac laudi'*nbsp;bus vitam acerbamputas Andrea, cogita te-'nbsp;cam pr�ceptiim illud Soloinonis Proiierb.i?�nbsp;Landet te ali�nas SC uon os tuam : extraneusnbsp;Sc non labia tua.

Deinde Andreashac fua iaiflantia nobis fiippcditat excmplum hominis garrulinbsp;loq iacis. Nam homines ifti, quemadmo^nbsp;dutrt docetPlntarchas in libro de garrulitate.'nbsp;�Tna/t�? cT� xj To'l� J'lKOf iVTU^riS^'nbsp;mv,n mpnyt/UffTinbsp;if'oKiiTiMi �y�i/^p�im3r/Vjnbsp;TT^TTnyrfei 7ro�jtxoAou� tb

'Pitiyei Srof nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;�r�^top e^crii�'

�jv,7r^�!ri!^0^lt;rai',Hyayilt;reugt;r'),lt;/'it�i^Sgt;i^ Ttx�� ijnbsp;pou�,l'yriivf^��Tcuf,hie{t Hoc plan� etiamijs*nbsp;qui in indicijs fnerunt fortiinati.aut apnd jjrirfnbsp;cipes regeic� prxter expeftationem felicitef

APOLOGIA/ 49 *Scre,qiia(�m irb-js q'lidamaccidit 3i coniigt;nbsp;j5fur,vtfxpc coni netnorent.quomodoinccrznbsp;'��inr.addufti rint,certauerint, difputarint,r�nbsp;�^�quot;''�gucnnt aduerfarios quofdam aut accufatonbsp;^�^Sjlaudati fint.

Inierea tarnen cam Andreas Vbiquitatis ^ferdos intcrdum ctiam folcat zt^^o^popeivnbsp;Meramgcftarc , atcK vbiquitatis fu�facn�

im^�ri� ovcT's �npupt e�� Ttai� �aw ��C �TO/./ovi'Twy.Infuauis res amp; molcfta on�nbsp;J*'ba� oratio al�a nulla,tam cxofa SC diff�cinbsp;qtiam eorum qui feipfos laadant, inquitnbsp;^Utarchus.Sed hxc mitto.

Primo lacobus me appellatliomincftultun� �Jineptuinan quocum velitniihi xgreface.'nbsp;��.fuasipfius laudes, quas in me deformandonbsp;ftudiof�? aucupatur.non parum minuit;vilt;ffoznbsp;��iam de me reportatam. qna,quantoperede�nbsp;ledatur, mirum'inmodum extenuat, triumlt;'nbsp;phum,qucm tammagnificc oil:entat,n� trium

Deinde verd dum me alii? deridendant propinare ftudet , non attendit Bibenliufia'nbsp;tiu? fuperintendens, fe fuam impietatem �Cnbsp;leuitatem omnibus infpiciciendam SC deplo'nbsp;randam proponere , atque in Dei offen?nbsp;fam incitato eurfu fefe prxeipitare. Qtiif'nbsp;quis dixerit fratri fuo fatue , reus eritgC''nbsp;licnn� ignis: Matih�i quinto Capitenbsp;fu at.

Prxterea dunt Andreas obuios qnofu�s� qui ineffabilia eius dogma� , qux in folunbsp;tudine cudit , nonapprobant, ftukitizin?nbsp;l�mutat : vcipfe de iiio Bibenhufano n'ipo^nbsp;de folus fapiens proclametur, fuo fe inftafnbsp;ibricis fyiueflris prodit indicio, atquefe �'nbsp;pientem eife , euamf� qmoibus perfuaferit�nbsp;vt habet prouerbium gt; tamen nemini per^nbsp;fuaferit. Verifsimum enim cil illud Solo*'nbsp;anonis Ecclei�aAis lo. verfu p Nam eti^nbsp;am per v��m , qnam ftultus ambulat eo?nbsp;r u: deficit , SC dicit de omnibus ftultuS

At v�rd enm facra feriptura nos iubeatbo? pnm pro maio reddere , en Andrea fapifflnbsp;tifuin� , age pantaebul�x vates tibi faluta'nbsp;re prxeepruin dabo , Sf maxim^ neceffa'nbsp;fium, quod ipetq ctiam gloria; SC maie^*nbsp;ftatis

otrj�p tui aurupium , Vbiquitatemqon �niprobaturum efTe : licet etiam apuJ exo^nbsp;^cricos , � quorum fcriptis Vannianoodionbsp;�iifsidet, reperiatur. Avct7railt;�'d)T0v ^Tin�nbsp;i'SjTeivi TOnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ci ffiavrr�/t^i�

'Tii� � (in �Mgt;�ttvov t'ia�nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;�sTcr eu^iov �gt;\ff.crlt;f)r/J.ta(

�BuXi�J^cLfjt.uati�f iiS't �innipoTip^v. a?�* t�Ui�^TO�� (poi)TO4 t�av.�V)iJ.�i(iVnbsp;Asv sizo;^A^y7ac�T-3fte�; ��s�tfi� tnbsp;�^iyay o�nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;�va.S)i�${Jt.i\:Qi t��

4�gt;gt;t�Tfltc VOT Tri� ei�r,dpia4.Qux vt tu quQ que fine difficultatelegas,latine iic c�nucrto.nbsp;Si aliunvifl�ptiim nominaucris,excita �n te diznbsp;fcendi fiudium amp; laboris�morem : fin ver�nbsp;luxuriofum amp; intemperantem ( quales prohnbsp;dolor noua nouorum monachpruni clauftranbsp;�Htrapaucos annos multos pepererunt) abznbsp;fterg� fi' a'iquod vcftigium amoris voluptaznbsp;tuminanimo tuo latent. Nam niliilturpiujnbsp;cil quam conuitiiim in ipfum auifloreni recurnbsp;Cens nihil etijm moleftius. Sedquemadmoznbsp;dum luminis reperculTus maiori dolore affititnbsp;�nibectllum vifurii; fie criminationes q�� in j-pibs criminaroresretorquentur � veiitatenanbsp;xiniuin inurunt dolorctn.

Q;iapropt�r Andrea cum inpromptu tibl f�tnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;vGi.vnumqucri^ qui � te dilfentit.Si tu�

mai eftatem non intelligic, ftultum, ftolidum, ineptum.fccleratum Siimpiumappeliarexa'nbsp;ue fis ne idem ab alijs optimoiure audtrrpoi^nbsp;fis ; ne� ego.ita Dcus bonus ben� me amet,vbnbsp;fum vnquam doiflum virum,etiam ex Tubin'nbsp;genl�bus.Tubinga: dum vixt,audiui ,qui laconbsp;bi Andrer erudit�onem,do6lrinam, diligcn'nbsp;tiam.modeftiam vel commendarit.vel alii� i'*nbsp;mitandam Si affeiflandam propofuerit. Elo'nbsp;quentiam verbalem.vt Brcntius iunior loquinbsp;tur. Andrer concedebant omne�jT�D��AoT'/''nbsp;8C �/'oAt^ittv pauci detrabcbant.audacif�nbsp;�mmodeftiam, impudentiam.malediccntiamnbsp;multi improbabant.'arrogantiam,fuperbianitnbsp;auarttiam plnrtmi deplorabantzeloquentiamnbsp;real�.vtidc Brctius loquitur ,fapicnti�,modenbsp;ftiamjiiimilitatc qui prjdicarei nemooccurrenbsp;bat JJef�neigitur Andrea tantifprr aliis ftul*nbsp;titiamjneptias.ignorannam.impietatemob'nbsp;iecTare.donec tuam erudirionem, fapientiam,nbsp;pietatem.tins probaueris,amp; harum virtutuwnbsp;non fcrmlfjied 2iberum,non mctuexortum.fednbsp;voluncanum teftimoniumabijfdem confecu'nbsp;tus fiicris.

A d me autem quod attinet, etfi nihil miH a rr ngo,3C quantum milii d�f�t inielligo.Hbe'*nbsp;terq; agnofco, tarnen mihi multum profecif�enbsp;vide or,f�iu4 conuitia perindc fcram, ic

apologia;

^�is bonus nuhi diceret;

^$�1�

ouTt J(^x� o�JT aipp9ii totKfK! ��'Aj ffi ft�ya ^a(pi,Qsoi vv-nto^�ilinbsp;J'Siey

)i fu maliu,in�pienslt;i; videris: ,itbi Cij denrprcjjjcra multa.

**n verd hac quoc^ rationc tc cmollire �lt; mi* non potuero.t�^ tu�cruditionis 8i pfunbsp;��'Ou� documenta �quscfunt conuitiari, ruxnbsp;�*'*ltuari,lues mouerejalfa crimina confin*nbsp;fi�re aduerfus bonos magnog centones farci*nbsp;^*)darenon cxflarc videro .� mequotp roul*nbsp;^*0 profecHTe cxiftimabo, fi nihil durius di*nbsp;'�inquimt'7�W��*lt;'quot;rny ��I eft ro*nbsp;Deum , vt fit mens fana in corpore

, Altera calumniaeft, quod ais me omni* '''�s locis X omnibus temporibus de rebusnbsp;8gt;'3uif�imi$,quas neqp didicerim, ncq; intellianbsp;, difpmare , vttibtloquiplacuit,prx*nbsp;�liniere.

Primo quidc,mi Andrea.facile'parior miH ^�comntm cruditionemdetrahi, atqj co no*nbsp;��line, tuis quorp mulierculis 8C gync cxig lu*nbsp;**cndumpropinari. Interim tarnen, que tua

cftmodeftia, moderat^ feres, fgt; nee ego,t�fi Tubinga iu Jiec, te pro crudito dofto vironbsp;lubeam.ac rnihi vcr� perfuade3m,teme indonbsp;ftum, nulfarumreruminteliigentem appel?nbsp;lando , dc vna f�delia duos paneces dealbare.�nbsp;tua qiioqtie yineta cederc; amp;me tuo inge'nbsp;nio iudicarc : quippe cum tu� erudiHoniSnbsp;non miihd maiora , qudmmex�xtenCte�Ti?nbsp;nionia, ,

In hoe yerd omnes quotquot de ingentj# 8C profeftu eorum iudicarc poHunt, me plufnbsp;qudin teprofeciffeexiftimantiquodego.T'i'Kfnbsp;ttlt;�etyTO!\ intellfgatT� voramil� quotidiefa?nbsp;�ierida eifc Deuni optimum maximum txqnbsp;randum.Vt mibi fuagratia amp; tpiritu ad(�t,me-'nbsp;qiiefuas viasamp;�atucadoceat.Cumtue con*'nbsp;tra c�'um tuaopinionc S(.K^'�oJ'o^�at, ait''nbsp;gens, mini amplius tibi.quantum addodrPnbsp;mm Si enditionem , prorfusdcelTcarbitre/nbsp;ris. Deinde quoquediuino auxilio implorS'*nbsp;ro animaduerranf.nihil mihi tam opus neeePnbsp;firiumque eife , qiiam vt dies noififfqueiiinbsp;Sacraruin literariirti, linguarum , bonariin�nbsp;artium ftudio , omni animi conrenrionein'nbsp;cumbam. Tu vero illaftudia vel conrem''nbsp;nens, vel flocei pendens,vel homine Cliri^nbsp;ftiano indigna iudicans, vel ni ijsnbsp;�mi/ �mpeti�nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;�ti�a ,icj eft.ad tyi'

^ftnos limites amp; Hertu�is co�umnas, vtttfa ^ace Pindari verbis vtar perut-nilfe rarus,�r*nbsp;*'�iitxetxuionunciuiT) mifift�.

Cxteruin dem tibi, qu�d vehrmentrf , te in eninibus e�e omnia oAo:nbsp;�^mcn dicam tibi iHud vetus :

Me verdaisomniloco fiftfBiporedifpu-�Sredc rebits quas neqne didicenm neque ht* *^II)gaiQ. Graue profe�d crimen, 3^ dignuninbsp;^Uod ab otiofo vbiquitatis faterdoKnbsp;Plt;'ehendatur. Primum autem Andrea It*nbsp;mil� ex te quxFcr�, vtrum cerebri fasnbsp;�'s habueris , qmm ifta feriberes , S( annbsp;^Pad te fuchs , quum iftud mihi crimininbsp;'^�ndiim cenferes lt; An alicnum quxfo eft,nbsp;officie ingenui adelefcentis , vbicunquenbsp;ftfe obtulcrit occaHo , de rebus ferijs, gra�nbsp;Jibus , 5i obfeuris lib�r� libenterqtiecon*nbsp;Jffre i Nifi tu malis bona ingenia de rc*nbsp;'Ks Iudicrisamp; leuibus Cqiiodteinterpoen*nbsp;*� farp� facere , amici tui farpe mihi dixe*nbsp;^wnt^ colloqucndo, tempore 5^ otio abuti.nbsp;�go aiitcm pra: me fero , me vbic-ucloco*nbsp;omni tempore , amp; ab omnibus quinbsp;^liquid boni didicerunt , tam audiendo�

quam difputando difrcre prompt�paratum'? lt;ffe. At^ perfuafum habeo.vt tu milu bolt; (f*''nbsp;mini ei�eoportcre opinati�zfic apudomutS l��nbsp;nos laudi Si glori� fore.

Forrd addis mc difputarc, de rebvs netpdidicerim.nccp intclligam. FiaculuniliO^nbsp;quoqucproffd�o magnum eft , amp; non indi'nbsp;gnum quod ab Vbiqmtario Theolcgonbsp;gatur. Scilicet omnium omnino diiputaiio'nbsp;num non finis eft rerum, quas vel ignoram�^nbsp;velnon redcintelligimus, ve! etiamdequ'^nbsp;bus dubitamus.perfcdfacognitio NifiAndrf''nbsp;as hoc quoquenouumamp; infolitrni fiiisf'f*nbsp;fuadcre vclit;pfjus videlicet res perfetffanbsp;tia eomprehendcndas eiTe : ac turn demum aigt;'nbsp;diendo.difputando , excrcendo tra(ffand3S'nbsp;Harcprofedo Andrea tantum abeft, vterudi'nbsp;tis tuam eruditionem probcnt.vt potius teq�^nbsp;que communcm fenfum amififle aperte �e�*'nbsp;Tent; quippe cum non minus a' rei natura v�''nbsp;Titatclt;pabhorreant,quam tua Vbiquitas� vc'nbsp;TOCircumfcriptoipcorporeChrifti.

Vcrumhoc quoque loco miror Andrc�'� fi frontis aliquid 6c confcienttx in te refiditu��Jnbsp;fuit, cum ifta fcriberes. An nefeius es,aufnbsp;Tubing.tiiorumljj decrerorum, poftquatelO'*nbsp;tudini mandafti.tamoblitus, vt r.c mtminff*^nbsp;tePontifieem iftius Academixter Maxime*�nbsp;fedufo' cauifie, et omnibus interdixifie prfuai'Jnbsp;elifputationibuslt; ne fciiicet virus Ca'inni^*��nbsp;(fic enin*

(f'c�enim vobis veriratis doiftrinam appellat �e lubctjtenerisiuuentutis animis itiftiHare-*ur;ade� imbecill� veftr� vbiquitati timetiy.nbsp;Atirogo , ex memoria tuadifcefsit , poftznbsp;^uam �ibenbufium conccGifti, omnes eos,nbsp;SuotquGt contra veftra dogmata difputaruntnbsp;tontinud ad vos delates,fui deli�i rationnbsp;�'em reddere coadlos, grauiier obiurgatos,nbsp;�acere iuflbs cfle^Scis autem Marcum Bcum-'nbsp;lerum ad vos non modo non accerfitumnbsp;Vnquam, fed nc verbo quidem � quoquamnbsp;de liac re compellatum fuiffe. Neque ver�nbsp;�juifquam tam rerum rudis Si ignarus eft,nbsp;Sui fufpicetur Marco Beumlero plus liccn-*nbsp;�'�,qu�mc�teris apud vosfuifie.

Qiiod autem aliquoties domitua: dercgt; 1'gione contult , idfeisnonmea fponte^fednbsp;�einuitantc per alios folicitante faflumnbsp;*fle id.qnod nuncreprehendis, iurene anin^nbsp;�niuria iudicent ij, qui fine affc^fibus iudicarcnbsp;pofl�unt.

In pwblica vertJ difputationc , omnes �luotquot ei interfuerunt,norunt , meinui�nbsp;�urn recufantem tuis obteftationibus difznbsp;ficulteredfuiffepertraeftum, vttecum, quernnbsp;liominemgloriofum eife, f�pc antea tri^nbsp;quot;mphafle vi(floria nondum conftituta , autnbsp;eiiam defperata feiebam,colloqucrer. Sednbsp;tai Andrea , fufeipe ad puniflum temporis.

M, BEVMLERI fi p�tes , hominis fani cogitationem .atq�**nbsp;in teipfum dcfcendc , tuum ingenium i tuo�nbsp;mores, tuamque cruditionemperpende :nbsp;reperies metiio ingenio iudicari, tcqueeo'nbsp;dem crimine,cuius me inf�mulaSjOptimoiu-'nbsp;rec�ndemnan pofTe. Namprim� internbsp;limes coni�at.tef�pennmero amp;(. multisin 10'nbsp;cts inter poculafpumantia n�ftros homines*nbsp;fi videlicet in tuo terri torio fueruiit, Si quoSnbsp;non vfqu� adcd excrcitatosnoiufti.addiipu'nbsp;tandumde p:rfona Clirifti amp; C�na Domini'*nbsp;ta importune Si temer� prouocafle. Dein-*nbsp;de quid libri tui poftremi aliud comple�luHnbsp;tur , qii�m q�omodo nunc in acidulis cuninbsp;Tigurino miniftr� : nuric inaliquo oppiionbsp;cum viro Zimingliano : nunc montis Peli^nbsp;gardi cum Daniele Toflan� : nunc Vuit/nbsp;tenberga� cum multis hoftibus : nunc Tu/nbsp;bingae cum Marco Bcumiero : nunc cum a/nbsp;lijs , alijs in locis difputaueris, viceris, autnbsp;ad abfurda extrema red�geris. Sed neqiienbsp;animus neque otium eft omnia tua conui/nbsp;tia retorqiierc : fans ci�e vidctur demon/nbsp;ftralle.renonamplius turpe ducerc a*nbsp;lijs virio vertere ea, qus tibi

V ^is me fuiflc auditum mm �niriiiim tat^' Afftntior tibi7\ndrea. Sed c�ufahiiiuSnbsp;non certc iii me , fed iiittfuit. Maninbsp;ffim� lu'l� milii non li'cuiffe loto ifta die mu�nbsp;�? tf'qiiijed necefl'e hab�ifTe tuas Icngas con^�nbsp;'*�ne�am(ire,quas intei'dumfeic vitrahcvaminbsp;j^'^oduccbas.Nofti deirid� me farpefuifti�ro, filnbsp;c^cclamitandodefacigatas vtvba falt;cre ctfgt;nbsp;^'*'�s,meum argiimenrum icpeiiifTejarqj rogafnbsp;5*tbreutter amp; rotund� reCponderes, omfllt;isnbsp;l^'Si'efsionibus, tergiucrfaiionibus, anfra�liznbsp;j|^�'gt;ficnt ego mca argumenta bieuiter.fyllog�nbsp;.nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;amp; diluciri� pi oponam Nofti deiiiq; quid

^TOnderis.vidclKet hoc tninimc fieri pofle, ^��Ppe cum non nilei cain'a foii�m adfis.fed ri^nbsp;j'�'Stio habenda fit c�terorumauditorum.quinbsp;^'�S'ore rerum expiicarione erudiendi fi'nt;

�fti tnluper tucirum earn efieprudennam iSi �deftiam , vr factie' inte'ligcre potuerinr,nbsp;!*�* boniini adolcfceuti veniam ciandaninbsp;J� gt; eiainfi aiiqutd pr�tcr d�corum fe-*nbsp;'�quot;�'n.

Quod fi ergo illos audiendi tacdiui� fatietas c�pit, noli quxfo culpam in nJlt;nbsp;confcrrc.fed tuis potius indignarc.-quodnbsp;dignifsimum fuum Cancellahum non ma*�nbsp;ri ftudio vokipcatc audiuerunt, quam v(nbsp;fi'fai t�dium languorem oborin patcreU''nbsp;tur. Idquc ed magis, quod te non fugit,*�]^nbsp;non femel petqrte,tuis intollcrabilibus con�i'nbsp;tiis,quibus nunc dominum Bullingcrum.nun^nbsp;D. Betzam, nunc D. Dan!Ciim,Caluinuni�nbsp;Phtlippum Melanchtonem, Zuuingliumar'nbsp;rodebas commotum.vt mihi omnino tacfte 1*nbsp;ccret, amp; aliiquiconuirijsdeleftarerur,nbsp;difputandi daretur. Ibi tu per Dei glonamnbsp;obteftabaris vt colloquium conrinuarem :nbsp;�us enim; eife dicebas me, qui fim exercitat**^nbsp;argumenta afferre, neminem eflecui reii�^�nbsp;non fit grata futura.

Primd Andrea fi tant� mes fuerunt incp' ti� in difputando, fi omnibus ftultusSinbsp;ptus vifus fui;quid opus erat tanta obteftationbsp;nec� facrofamfto nomine diuinoconium^l^�'nbsp;an non fatis erat mihi illuderc , atq; patient*�nbsp;totius audirorq abuti^quidnecefiumfuitfaef�nbsp;fan�lun� Dei nomen infeenam illamprodu'nbsp;cere vindicabit, noli dubitarc, Deusnbsp;gloriam SC facrofaniftum fu�nom�;pcrquonbsp;iciunt multi boni re in coiniitiris eriam res gt;nbsp;uifsimas confirmaturum,f�nc omni religion'nbsp;peijurare.nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Deind'

Deinde Andrea an non te puduit alijs doz ^is viris difputandi tempus pr�riperc, idipnbsp;*'omini qui omnibus tscdioeflet tribucre.atznbsp;9'gt;e in re tam ardua amp; Dei gloriam concerznbsp;��rnte.inftar hiftrionts,fcurrilitcr, vtquidamnbsp;tuis loquiturjudere'f

Sed fortafsis non fatis vobis fuit ante P�ucos annos , pr�clara Dei organa . Sinbsp;Jnagna Ecclefia: lumina � Philippum Meznbsp;*3nchtonem Si loannem Caluinum, vtrum-Suc in Domino pic placidc'que defunlt;fium,nbsp;'oni Studgardix Bacchanalia celebrarenznbsp;*^t,in fcena introducere, miferc depingcre,nbsp;tandem igni tradere : quod triftc fpe�nbsp;^�culum ab omni humanitate Si Chriftiaznbsp;quot;a charitatc remotum , animi leuis Si cniznbsp;indicium , multi boni viri magno cumnbsp;Colore fpeftarunt. Tu verd Andrea cumnbsp;'�is focqs , qui huiufmodi fabulis delitiaznbsp;'�m veftrarum condimentis pafcimini.pauznbsp;j^poft.nifi feriam p�nitentiam agatis.faznbsp;��la fietis.: neque dubium eft vlli pio, quinnbsp;extremum SC. eraortuale fatum , vosnbsp;ad tantam libidinemexer-

Ais quoque te me ita confudilTejVt nihi! anf jpliiis a Jut rfq? difputationem tuam afferre ponbsp;ucrim Si Dodov Andrea longas oratione�nbsp;texere, ft nihil ad argumentum refpondere.l*nbsp;varie tumultuarijfidilatato giitture clamare�nbsp;figrauia bonis viris conuicia dicere.fi interrOnbsp;ganremriJere, confijndcre amp; vincere eft .'donbsp;tibi larqiorc^. te me atljkiicc confudifte, at^nbsp;tnagiiific� vicif�e. Imd, vt hberaljor in te l�m�nbsp;profl^mo 8i pronuiicio tc yiif^Qrem omni�nbsp;prrliodoxoruip quotquot haiflenus adiierfuSnbsp;tepro veruate pugnarujat: in quo omnes a4nbsp;vnum.quod ego fat fcio,.mihi aftipulabuntur.nbsp;Tu vero pie Leftor, vt viifforiam quam Arfinbsp;flreas an pgapter fibi vendicat.arftimare p�Pnbsp;ffs.tiia tantum argumenta,quae in ilia difputanbsp;tione � me allata fiierunt.lioc loco repctam.etnbsp;*1 lomO'lo Andreas ea coniudcritj bonafidenbsp;lexponam.

Si vnnm proprium effentialc Deitatis rea/ liter non poteft communicari, nec yllo modonbsp;compctcrelmmaiiitati Chrifti; fcquitur nullanbsp;omnino

Rationesdiias afferebam 1. Quiapro-' pria Dei er��ntialia nihil aliud funt,qu�ni ipfanbsp;i^ei efrenfia:ac propterea � fc mutuB tarn noiinbsp;Poffunt fcparari citra fui pernitiem.* qudmnbsp;pfa elfcntia Dei, quxeft iiTT�S� a�f/^p��nbsp;id eft , fimglicifsima,abomnicompofition�nbsp;alienifsima, amp; in nuHas partes dititdua.

t. Quia omnium propriorum efTeptialiuni Vna eademqueeftdcfiriitio, vna eademtpna-'nbsp;*ura, vna cademc^ ratio, quoad communua �nbsp;lt;tonem:Nam omnia eodem modonbsp;Tamp;)� gt; in communicabiliter fe ha^nbsp;bent.

His fubftitucaam : At veto aliquot prox pria eftentialia nec communicantur.ner coin�nbsp;pctunt realiter humanitati Clii liti, vt fuut xrernbsp;tiirasjinfinitas Sic.

Ergo nulla omnino propria elfentiflia Dei ratisrealitcr,liumanitatico.nmiiuicaruuraut lt;�nbsp;rompetunt.

Ad hoc argumentum rum Andrea� nihil baheret quod rufponJcret , vrner ho die baxnbsp;bet quod refpon leat folidc ) foia ucg�t.onenbsp;^onnexi , tam firmis ratio ton.' � m.�voboxnbsp;��ari, fine vHa ratioiie ailata , me . loxnbsp;g'ri- placet �onfudit N�m primo coiicexnbsp;�^cbat, �C adliuc , nifi iioujih monftium,

vt folet pariiiriat.libentcr col cedit,humanj/ tatcm Chnftinon efle abxtenio,ac prop�nbsp;terea non infinitam. Itaque vt modo dixi,nbsp;valdc ml�oientcr cum omnium Dodo/nbsp;rum adtniratione,negare cocpit,non ncccflenbsp;cflcvt, cui vnum proprium eflentiale com/nbsp;municetur , eidem c�tera omnia aut nullanbsp;omnino commumccntur.Atque tandem cumnbsp;fe in omncs partes vertiiTet ni�llumque la/nbsp;pidem pro obtincndo hoc fuo paradoxe nonnbsp;mouiflet , ac me liberius inftare firmasquenbsp;rationes repofeerc animaduertiffet; tandemnbsp;ad M.Georgium Lieblcrum prouocauit,at/ *nbsp;que vt ipfe de axiomatc, quod ego vrge/nbsp;bam , lacobus veto Andreas oppugnabat,nbsp;pronuntiaret, ctiam atque etiam contendit.nbsp;In quo primdjVt verum fatcar,Andrea:let�/nbsp;tatcm, ne quidgrauius dicam,mirabar cquinbsp;cum philofophos amp; Phyficos,d profefsionenbsp;Theologi�amp;� defenfione veritatis valdeinnbsp;folenter,remoueat, iam fut ipfnisoblitus, M.nbsp;Lieblero.hanc fententiam , in fchola Theo/nbsp;logica,dijudicandam proponeret.

Deinde hoc quoqueraihinon minus mi/ rum fuit, quod Andreas M. Licblerifen/nbsp;tentiam , de hoc ipfo axiomatc probe cogni/nbsp;tarn haberet,tamen cam in publico loco rurfusnbsp;expeterer. Nam non multo ante difcipuluSnbsp;quidam eius, Magiftcr bonarum artium creannbsp;dus.

APOLOGIA. 37 ^us, difputationem philofophicam de vnioncnbsp;Perfonali amp; communicationeldiomatum.connbsp;ffripferat,amp; confentiente amp; approbante Lieznbsp;^lero impritnendain curauerat in qua hoc aznbsp;�^lomamultis rationibus abipfoM. Lieblcronbsp;Spprobatis confirmabatur. Ne verdpia luuennbsp;*us rectc in dodirina ilia erudirctur, Andrcatnbsp;fii� Vbiquitaticauercvolens.eamdifputatioznbsp;Hem fuppnmendam curauit : atep ram Lieblcznbsp;fo.quam eius difcipulo multas moleftias cr�anbsp;Uit. Itatp cum tam ego quam /.ndrcasdelcnznbsp;*entia Lieblcri non dubitaremus Si nc et denbsp;Houopericulacrearentur, autnecontraconznbsp;fcientiam pronunctare cogerctur; vtegoeiusnbsp;fententiamnon admodum defiderabam, fic iznbsp;pie earn in tcrponerc tergiuerfabatur. His ego,nbsp;vtgloriatur Andrcas.confufus , iiifTus fumaznbsp;liud argumentum propone re. Et hoc eft priznbsp;Hiumlacob Andricx viftoriatteftimonium.

Qiiemadmodum in perfona Chrifti, in qua dux naturx falux Si incolumes manent,nbsp;habet propria cflentialialiumanitatis ad dinbsp;uinitatem, refpedlu videlicet comnmnicatioznbsp;Hts.�ffc fc habent propria dcitatis eften tialia adnbsp;E 5

M. BEVMLER� fiumanitatem.Hanc propofinonem fulciebaninbsp;�eftimoniis Sacrac fcripturae , inqua propnanbsp;Deicatts n� magis tribuuntur huniariitati�hrjnbsp;fti quam propria liunianitatis tribiiiintur Del�nbsp;tail. Sic Clinftus non magis dicitur fuifle ant�nbsp;Abraharpum Ioan 8.ver j8.Q;i�iTi poft ioan-rnbsp;nemvcnifte Joan.i.ver.27 Slt; jo (icCbriftusnbsp;� loanne Baptizatus non inagis dicirurfiliusnbsp;Dei.Matdi.) ver. vlcimo qu�mglori� Dorninquot;nbsp;BUS crucifixus.r.Cor i.ver.iS. His addebamnbsp;pcrperuum S( conftans primitiuT Ecclefiar te^nbsp;ftimoniiim.quod Damafcenus librOi,deOr^nbsp;thodoxa fide Cap, 4 numero complexuscft�nbsp;Kai 0 ;)^p��-�� , OTi�p to

6��. Keu QTOiy �v�' �^'^/UAp�v tjop�t? diQ� ovo/u(cli^i]'ta/,'^ /�^iTcu �m tnwU'-(p�je�wc io}�)/^m,'^Tin rtic cmpanbsp;KO' , -Sspc wStIto'c

Tti� Jlo^fir. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, K /fas' 9

�^O�j a?�agt;0t� � a��^Tramp;' b �jin��, ^Tava��7gt;'^-�^^^U3(: cu^pwTra ot o-A(S�'�iTae, J ream r�� 3?ixe H^ia� �ieh�

StO� nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;^Wnc^OOtiiJ�,�^X�-

f�t� (pujtw; afTnJilt;^iflt;piQ'^^ i7tpaTisi�cftet, t�^ rZty TriQ \ssv�V�'^�gt;� i^yTOTtjm , i(^nbsp;tluj elt;� a^7lt;.gt;^��, �JJnbsp;fzivm eTujmiiUJtda. i/7rSvnbsp;03�o� �i/ji.�v T�icyfi�nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;T�'ti; e��

Gp� m� en^euii^a^HtiC^ QoiO^TT�'ov^ T� aKTt�'i� )ld^ �-va�ri�, ct�Z^^a.^nbsp;wZ�'Jiqc cil.Etenim Cliriftus, qui eft vtriin-qiie�ina! , 3^ JvtH Homo dicitur, amp; crea^nbsp;tus 5^ tncreatus, amp; paGibilis 8i impafsibiljs.nbsp;Arque nnnex vna pafte films Dei SC Deus nonbsp;ininattir, recipit coafubftanttalis natur�prolt;nbsp;pria.id efi.carni s.�Deus enim pafsibilis nomixnbsp;iiatur Si Dotn nus glonar cnicifixus, nonfexnbsp;cundiim quod Deus,fed fecundum quod homonbsp;�p'c eft .5c eum homo Si filius hominis nomixnbsp;natur, recipit diuinx clfentix idiomata SC gl�nbsp;riam, puer ante f�cutum Si homo principio c*nbsp;tens,nonfecundum quodpuer Si homo, fed fcnbsp;eundum quod Deiis ante f�cula exiftens, faxnbsp;�fus ert.poftremis temporibus puer, Ethiceftnbsp;modus *-*'Pc^a(T?C�)�,id cft alterns attributioxnbsp;nis.cum ytraep nattu a.mutuo tribuit altcri na�nbsp;tur�propria propter perfonxidentitatem. Sinbsp;�pfarum in fe mucuo immeationem-Secundumnbsp;hoc dicere poflurhus de Chrifto, hic Deus no-� �.nbsp;�er in terra confpcdtus eft. Si cumhominibus

JM. BE VM LERI cenuerfatus eft ; Si hic homo increatus eft, SCnbsp;impafsibilis Sfincircumfcriptus*

His ita peraiflis fubfnmebanV Atqui pro� pria humanitans effcntialia, non realiter iri-'nbsp;buuntur Oeitact. Blafphemum enim eiTer.diccnbsp;re Deitatem in fua fubftancia efte nacam, criicinbsp;fixam,p3ftam,raortuam, fepultam, refufcitaznbsp;tarn,ad ccclos elatam.

. Ergo propriaDcitatis eftcntialia non rea-� liter tribuunturnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;competunt humanitati.

Propofttionem mcam facrarum literarum teftimoniis amp; catholicx Ecclef�� confenfu connbsp;f�rmatam oppugnare coepit Andreas, qua connbsp;fcientia amp;pietace, videat ipfe^DiuinitatiStin^*nbsp;qutt,ea eft perfedlio, vt nihil ei potuerit acci-'nbsp;dereabinftrmitatehumanitatis. Namfi quilt;inbsp;accidiflctei,neceflariofequeretur, nonfuiAenbsp;Deitatem. At vero humanitas multa potuit acnbsp;cipere � Deitate. Ethxcfunt prima indicia vinbsp;ftorix lacob Andric�, quam infecundo hocnbsp;confliiftu obtinuit, f� verum eft quodfcribit.nbsp;Ego autcm animaduertens Andream tarn mi-*nbsp;hi, qu�m alqs fucum facere zquiuocationenbsp;vocabuli,c�pi rcponere me necignorarc,necnbsp;negate, humanitatem Chrifti plurima, maxi^^nbsp;ma, amp; nobis incomprehenfibiliadonaacce^nbsp;pirteadiiiinitate; fummam vidcjicetillamdl-'nbsp;gnitatem.vt f�thuman�t�s��rii Dei propria; fonbsp;cictatem offuti mediatoris inter Deum amp;honbsp;minesjCapitisEcclefir, gubernatoris Si iudigt;nbsp;c�to�

APOLOGIA, 39 cis.totius inimdi, focictatetnhonoris �C ado* �,nbsp;ranonis vnius cuiD'^�j-a� Nobis vcrd ccrta^nbsp;Wien efle, non de dpnis, quxChriftus in im-* 'nbsp;�nfnfum loc�pfetius, qu�m omnes homines )nbsp;amp; angeli accepic,fed de efl^ntialibus proprie-^ j'nbsp;tatibus, euiufmodifuntjCfTe�lj�t�rno, cfTc in {�nbsp;finitum loco,temporc,potentia, i� qux funtnbsp;liniilia:dehis inquam quarri, an aliter humaxnbsp;nitaciChrifti, qudm propria humanitatis dixnbsp;Uinitati communicentur-

Quod verd Cancellarius addat diwinam naturamcHe perfeAiorem , quam vtaliquidnbsp;abhumanitate realiter acciperepotuerit : idnbsp;Contra me non efle. Nam humanitatem,quaxnbsp;tenus videlicet humanitas , in fua naturanbsp;clTentia confideratur , non minus perfedamnbsp;elTe, qudm diuinitatem. Vtramque enimitanbsp;perfedlam efle, vt proprietates faluas reiinexnbsp;at,nihil(p fu�perfcdioni contrarium, 6^ imxnbsp;niediat�eumeapugnansrecipiac. Vt Deltasnbsp;in fcn�recipit'�OTro�wTOVJK^�i/ Tnpi^ctTTTOv^nbsp;id eftjVt pati Si loco circumfcribi pofsit.NS �nbsp;i�arc etiam quatcnus humanitatetn in fiia perxnbsp;ionagcftat.realiterinfe recipcrct: Deltas clTcnbsp;de�nerct. Ita quoque humanitas xternitatemnbsp;fii inhnitatem Si omniprxfentiam in fc reaxnbsp;liter non recipit.quia his non minus deftruerenbsp;*ur,qudm diuinitas illis.Itaque in Andrex rexnbsp;iponf�one nihil aliud agi qudm peti principii'i.nbsp;Ac proinde fi ex iftis phrahbus quas Sacra

fer ip tufa 8i Ecclef�a vfurpat Si agnofett, Ho* � moeftOmnipocqis, omniprxfrns, coiligat;nbsp;Ergohumaiiitas Chrifti eft realiter Omnipo^nbsp;� tens Si oinniprxfens : Eodem mo3� me tol-'nbsp;� ligere p�fte ex hi fee. Deus eft narus, paftiis*nbsp;mortuus.Ergo diuinitas eft pafta^rooi tiia.

Ibi turn cum Andreas ntir� fe inftaranguil lxtorqueret,Siproob(inenda viftoria vebeznbsp;mentcr laborarec : nee tarnen quicquam folidinbsp;afferret, acA�^t�neruis Si thorisdeftitutosnbsp;texeret ; nec feil ice c folus veteranus tyronefflinbsp;vinceret, ac fine Thefeot�mopima fpolia deznbsp;portaret: furgit quidam ex difcipulis eius(qu2nbsp;ait Andreas in difputatione Hevdelbergenft,nbsp;aded DodtoremGrynxum confudiftir, vteti�nbsp;Illuft.Principi lohanni Cafimird.admirarioninbsp;fucritjac mifero magiftro fuo opcferens.cocznbsp;pitexclainarc:digniflt;imc D. Cancellarie, eftnbsp;magniim fophifma in opponentis argumenznbsp;to.lbi certc fa teor, me non parum ammo pe r*nbsp;tulfum fuifte N� intelligebamnon folumioti�nbsp;Auditorium, exceptispaucis, qui Vbiquitaznbsp;ii genua non flexerunt, � me alieiium rfte : fednbsp;etiammihi adolefcenti cum tribus robuftifsiznbsp;mis hoftibus, haftasfuasin me vibrancibus,nbsp;eongredi necefTe habere- Primus erat Andreznbsp;as, qui fe omnium hominum doifcifsimumnbsp;putat.* Alter eius refpondcns.qui diuminifteznbsp;rio Ecclcfia: funftus crat , Si lacobuni acuznbsp;minedifputandi, dosflrinaquefuperarc, luznbsp;dkabaz

� P O L O G r At 4a d�caljafur: Tertiuserar his nouusMagifter,nbsp;fl capr�ftitit, qu� triumpliator Andre�nbsp;a? eitri'.vair.non dubium eft, quinmultismolt;nbsp;dis, eruditione Anclream excell�t. Nequenbsp;hune timorem inihi crimini efle oporrerc cx^nbsp;fitimo. Cun� enim ne Hercules quidem contranbsp;djos : quomoda ego adolefcens contra tr�snbsp;iftos Hcrculcs^

Sed tanienaudiamusftilmen il�uc�, quod hic , venu � Cahcellario dignifsimo impcgt;nbsp;Vata, ni me magno clamorc contorfit.nbsp;Suinentatur, inquit, falfda pr�dicato ad ingt;nbsp;I �ffe. Nam milita etiam pr�dicatur in phi�ogt;nbsp;fophia, quTtarnen non inliint. SieCeusdiciznbsp;1 'Urpaffus; non tamen indefequitur,diuinitagt;nbsp;*tni realiter eRe paffam in lua eflentia; quianbsp;diuiniras noncft fubicftumpafsionis.

Hoc bl otum fuln.en, quo nie pr�dicati-' �^us �le M.igiftf r.non fccus ac Do�lorcm Grynbsp;��'.1(11 in d;fpurarioi:c Heideibergenfi,penitusnbsp;Pioitrauifi�e arbitrabatur.ciini ripenic c vefii^nbsp;8'0 in I pfiim autborem, ad hune modum retornbsp;f'Ifem.�odciii modo ego cofitendo, vosfophinbsp;**'cari,lt;um fcnbiiis �i docciis, bumanitatetnnbsp;*fie omnipotentem 5lt;ornniprtcftntcm , quianbsp;^hriftiis homo, cft omnipotens amp;. Omnipr�nbsp;l^ns.�Andreas animaduertens f�um ilium Te-�nbsp;'�iachum non vfq? aded fcrlicitcrpiignaflc,nbsp;*�'que teliiin qiiodiii me mittcretfuperflinim

vidcretjpugnam continuo dirimit, acnos priuatim trani�gere iubet, mcque aliud argu'nbsp;mentum,ff velim.affcrrehortatur. Et Iioc eftnbsp;alterum viclori� lacobAndricx teftimo^nbsp;nium.

Non poiTum hoc loco filentio prarterir� me cum viderem Andrea eiuftp fuccenturiatonbsp;res hoc modo mecum agere, tn hare verba erunbsp;pifle : fl tu lacobc Andrea vel vno Sacr� fcri-pturar teftimonio tuas iftas prardicationes.Hunbsp;manitas Chrifti eft Omnipotens, Omnipr�'nbsp;fens, omnifeiens probare amp;� confi'rmare pogt;'nbsp;tensrtum egopcdibus manibuf� in tuam fen/nbsp;lentiamibo. Ibi Andreas aquamfibi harrerenbsp;fenfi t. Ne tarnen fibi difsimi lis effet, protulftnbsp;locum ex loannis t. Epiftola, fanguis Chriftinbsp;cmundatnos� peccatis. Ergofacra feripturanbsp;aperte dicit humanitatemClirifti efTe Omniponbsp;tentem Si Omniprarfentem. Sed noloomnesnbsp;Andre� nugasperfequi.

T B R T I V M ARGVMBNTVM, aducrfiKgloffam Idcob Andricam innbsp;vef-biS C�nic.

ADuerfus glolTam Adreana qua feriptutn in verbis C�nar.hoc cft corpus meum.innbsp;has formulas loquendi conuertendo, in pane,nbsp;fub pane, cum pane eft corpus Chrifti,r�m acUnbsp;rate retinet Si tuetur : in hune modum argu/

I �teiligend� pr�difationeni depaneinSaeram� p *0 �ina:;e�dfm�planc,eft de vino.nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'�

Huiiispropof�tioni.s ratio afferebatiir ex , ' *O;qijod vnink]^ prscdicatio eflet Sacramentagt; ; *.nbsp;vtiinij? Sacranientalirer fiiretligenJa. \nbsp;Atqui Andreas' rennende Scriptum in ver \ 'nbsp;tiscornsc.pr�pofitiencm iltam, Panis eft corgt; j*nbsp;puiClirifti, adliunc modnm tefbluendam S�nbsp;�nteliigenda effe docet, in pane,fubpan�,lt;umnbsp;pane cit corpus Chrifti,

Ergo lila propofiiio poculiirtteftnouiini Teftamt ncutn, ita reibiueitda 8( intelligendanbsp;�rit,in poculo,fnb poculo.cum poculo cft no*nbsp;Mum reftrametiiunr.

Propof�noncin cum Andreas negare non poftet nee auderei : quippe cum extra omneninbsp;controuerfiain In, eandein eftepr�dicandi ra-�nbsp;tio�em depofuio,qux eftde pane Enchariftigt;'nbsp;to7 carpit,ne fcilicetviftiis tcneri vidererur,nbsp;M.cp omnibit.s luani eruditioncm pro� arer, in-�nbsp;�iidi'um paradoxum, quod ab experientia Vnbsp;gt;iiuerfali,� rerum natura amp; veritate abhorret,nbsp;tommrnifci Slt; propugnarc ; fcilketad vnio�nbsp;hem diplomatis Teilamenti, reilcgatx, adnbsp;Teftamenti veriracem fanciendam, omnino renbsp;t]uiri, vt Teftamentum res Itgata fempi-rnbsp;gt;n vno eodct� ioco ftnt fita, feu vt re.s legata fitnbsp;�n amp; fub Tcftamenio.Secus ciuinfi fiat, Telia

B � 7 ft L t ft � mentum violariS; inane t�ui i. Tandem verdinbsp;rum vidcretme iftis ip�uapieuC Si nugis qualt;nbsp;�ipfepre gcmmishabenda) elfe (cni'ebat, ne�nbsp;tnoueri,iiec pati miht imponi. fed grantfsimfSnbsp;aliquot rationibus, caruni �to?�� demon/nbsp;firare} inii�riftehonie,qiit t�mqnoq{ u ivm/nbsp;f liabat/� lt;iu$ oS.fi frontem , l� iirpud.nn^�mnbsp;fpc�ies,qu3(� furore plt;rcitu$,fe.c ad lurihcrfnbsp;fultos ciarifsimos (or.uerttt, atqnc abils I mI*�nbsp;qux�ionem in Schola Thcologica agirat^nnbsp;dqudicari, fuamlp nouamSi inauduaih cpi/nbsp;nionemconfirmari.ex iuri j prudenua cip u.

In quo rurfus Andreas, fi modo ra vcr^ fii conftanter icntit Si crcd�t,qux nuper in fua Adnbsp;monitione Germanica aducrfus Eo^oremnbsp;Chriftophorum Hcrdcfianum vald� infoieh*nbsp;lerfcrip�t.ijs^ aifcntttur, fui ingenq duo (la/nbsp;rilsima fpecimina edtdit.

Namprimd noluit, ctfi id vebcmenter ft euperclimularet, (larifsimos lurifcontulrosnbsp;fiiain fenrentiam interponere- fed lioc fibi per/nbsp;fiiafgt;c,forc.vtilli, rationein obfequium iacobnbsp;Andreanuin captiua�, f�mplici fide S( �iipidonbsp;aflenfu einsfenrentiam apprcbarrnt, mfifor/nbsp;�arte volnerii ecs repente vtftfgiO non felt; nSnbsp;acVzar Samuel.�.�! Deopiiniri jdquoJeXnbsp;Apoftropbe cius ad lurifconfulios in breiiinbsp;Germanica Admonitionepsgina n. rj.coHi/nbsp;giHtr Namibi inurc�tfraadbnnc modrntnbsp;fcrrbit:Dile/f iCaiuiniani lunfconfuln arbitranbsp;mini

� P � L O G � A, 4* ip�nineDfum vosdiutius toleratungt;mefl�,acnbsp;bon pstius Chri�'uni de dcxti a Dei �liquandpnbsp;probaturuni.Ciiiod eii'i caiifa v�ftTa,quod tarnenbsp;hon eft,bona elfer,earn tarnen fine v�bis, qu�znbsp;fuin tlia v�eatio non ell.tueri p�fsit.ac non nenbsp;teffehabear ciufmodi foci�rfiop�ra vtt, quosnbsp;difeip�ii eiu� amp; Apoftoius Petrus inter fures,nbsp;latrontfSjS; malencos num�rar�t^An �blttinbsp;ftisx Samuel.literisproditumcnc.yzam filii�nbsp;Abihadsib, qui cum boues a via deflefterent,nbsp;iiccurrens.�fcain Dei manu t�h�b�t.ab ira Deinbsp;Sccehfa, continue� occifum fuifTc propter lemenbsp;ht�t�irifu�ni.

Agriof�is proc�ld�bio Andrea veffea tua, *x q�ibus boha fide.hanc fententiani, deduco.nbsp;Jiirlfcdnf�lti �tiariif� b�nam cauf�m in religie�nbsp;hetu�aiit�r, � Deopunienturhofecusac Vza,nbsp;amp; pro fuirtbus latronibus ac tnalef�cis � P�tronbsp;�t Apoftolis habentur.T� ver� Andrea ex bacnbsp;propofit)one,qu� non ratio fed iracundia.nonnbsp;humilitas amp; tn�dedi�,fcd arrogariiia amp; fnpcrnbsp;^�ijf exroil�i,nol�rts volcns fubfumes.

Atqui ante biennium. Andr�a ^�teni� �' iri **iiante,Iunfconfulti Tubtngenfes, fuam f�ngt;'nbsp;**nti�md� Teftament�.in Scbola ThedlOgicanbsp;**plicaruntamp; dijudicariihf.

Hoc ^bi feceris tuo oraeu�o C�ncIudes.Er Roillilu�ifcdiitulti non fec�s ac Viad Dtop�nbsp;�hendi, pro /uHbui', l�ti�iubus Slt; maleficia 'nbsp;fiutt habendt.

�tiplixc te de ipl�s fenfifle amp; n�ne fcntirc ante annum omnibus Tubingenfibus probaznbsp;fti Nam cuin videres Deum lux crudelitatinbsp;non indulgerc, amp; vulnus illud quod Ciarifsiznbsp;mus lurifconfulcus Joannes Hoclimanhustibtnbsp;in Diiputationeinflixit, non modo akamlt;ntcnbsp;repoftum manerct, fed etiam indies recrudez.nbsp;lt;ccret,eum ipfum.cum coram tua magnifietnz'nbsp;tia Mcdicinxlaudes cxtolleret,magna lui cumnbsp;ignoaiinia K omnium admiratione, oranon�nbsp;�lus intcrpellata, Nz-x. videlicet zelo percinis�nbsp;b'iafpliemum amp; impium noroinafti.Aiip in ifonbsp;adbu folenni multa alia admififti, quod tuantnbsp;modeAiam Juimilitatem, charitatem , pacisnbsp;iranquilitatis^ Audium parum commendant.nbsp;Qii�c tarnencum toti mundopateunt^ fZ�mulnbsp;tis bonis deplofentur, nolo in qs recerfcndisnbsp;fiiutius commorari.Sedhabes primum ingentjnbsp;tin candidi indicium.

Deinde ver�tu ipA�is iudicio te caufam inorbidam,putridam,ruinofam, malamgt;inuznbsp;tilem (totenim epithetis tibi in breui Admoznbsp;iiitionc tua vti libuit)fouerc ac defendere , aznbsp;j�ert� demonRraAi, id quod hoc fylogifmo inbsp;tua hypothefiextrudlo eiiincam.

Eos demum Theologos malam caufam lueri ncccAe eA, qui Doctores, iuris amp; mediznbsp;cime, Galenum.^BartlioIum SC Baldum implonbsp;rant,atqt cos ranquam procuratores Si aduoznbsp;catos conducunt.

Hane Propoi�tionem probo t� ftimonio Ia lt;obi Anirexomni cxcepnonei�aiori�.c c�fiftnbsp;Adiuonifioiie pag.'4 def�fnptaeft. Vl�nbsp;h^cciii� verba Icg'.infur. Oportet vcrt�illaihnbsp;�norbidam,putridani,ruinofatn,inalarn,iriutixnbsp;lem er�e caufatn, ad quatn conferuandam conxnbsp;cionatores Zuinglianinonfufficiunt, fedne^nbsp;cclFc habent Dodores medicinxnbsp;nbsp;iuris ciui^

lis, BartliolumBalduminuocare, tanquam procuratores amp; aduocatos tondu*nbsp;cere.

Hl's fubftitues etiam pr�ter uoluntatem tu* am;Atqui lacobus Andreas, in Theoiogica d�nbsp;fputatione T ubingenfi,de T eftamento Cbriftinbsp;Imifconfultos,omnibus aiijs pr�ridijs deftitu*nbsp;tus.in confilium adhibuir, eorumqr opcmnbsp;plorauit,amp; fuffragium emendi'areftuduit.

Ergo voicns nolens ex fupcriori'nis ron* cludet Andreas, fuam caufam effe morbidam.nbsp;putridam.ruinoram.malain et inutilem.quamnbsp;defendendam in gratiam Euthychianx Vbi*nbsp;quitatisfufeepit, Sednon libel plura ingenijnbsp;lacobAndrici in hocfaifbo documenta exponenbsp;re; hoc tantum ideo addidi poftulari ab omni*nbsp;bus, vtabijsfefe abftineantmaxime'vitps,innbsp;quibus alterum reprehenderunt : Atqj non monbsp;dd accufatorem, fedncobiurgatorem quidemnbsp;ferendum effe eum,qui,quod in altero vitiumnbsp;repreliehd�tjin co ipfe deprehenditur.

Ranti^tionem Andreac facramentariam lurif* (onfulnconfijrmarint. inter cxteros furgeb^tnbsp;^d pronunciandum Dot^or loatjiicsHoclimannbsp;piis.luns�^npnici protefTpr^atcp manifeft�^nbsp;lib�re noiiarn inaudicam la�qbi �n^reardenbsp;Teftamento f�nteutiam � Iure C(i|ili abhorre^nbsp;tcpeniiuscjjignorarf qtatis ipciscpmproba*nbsp;Mft; quippecuinTeftam�nii yi^tus non intonbsp;c�nf�liat �l. perfpiciatur,vt in vno amp;: codemlpnbsp;CO cum re iegata collocctur Si c�tungacur; fednbsp;in CO potius,Vt Teftamenti virtutc amp; adiumen

to, tpftimonioq; de re Icgata certi fiamus.at�nbsp;fuo fetpppr� per�ipiamus. Hqi� fententia: ca;*nbsp;t:ri lurif�pnfnUi pfpncs fubfcripftrnnt.ibitun�nbsp;,/Indreas, �um videretf�bt aquamlixrcrr.fc^nbsp;omnibus arnqs e^tprtis c�ftrtdum teneri ; adnbsp;veterem illunafituSifarpius coiftum cocydintinbsp;yltimum^Crcfphygetpn c�fugit, tragic� c^cnbsp;�lamaqdo.Ipfige alia ratip eft, in hoc icframep

tp. -vtdelicctfupernatur31is,ipefrabili$,amp;;p'alt;nbsp;fie diutna. Scilicet Andr�ar fiipcrnaturalis ilianbsp;p�tKip principij multp pluris eft facienda quanbsp;cacrerpruni bominunigfauifsima verifsima'qinbsp;|udici^,amp; Ipngo vfii cpmprpbara.

C�teriim lipc quoqj loco.pptimeLcftorfe (e pftepdjt 4ndreg arrogantia Si leuitas.Namnbsp;quid atfinebat qu�fp prpupc3|re ad lurifconfuinbsp;tos, quid opus �rat eor�fcntent|am cxperer�.l�nbsp;ei reclamare i�ne rafionp li�erftlt; Scilicet hicnbsp;Andr�as fibi perfaafcrat, fe ptnni� raiiopem.nbsp;in fui

A F o L o � r A. 44 �T� 'ftii �bfcquium captiuatn duxiire,atlt;^ Ria f�mnbsp;Fhti jide eaia�uin mentes ita obrtupefecitfe, vtnbsp;*Tiam-�ontraoinnem veniatem.contra rerutnnbsp;tltaram, contra otnni� fapienti�iudtcia.roaxnbsp;tra bont viri ofncium etconfcienri� tn gratiamnbsp;Vbtquitatis JacobAndricx Iuris ctuilis feien'nbsp;tiam ^dulterarent Si corrumperent. Vel etiamnbsp;fi hoc pro fua modcHia fperarc non fiiit aufus,nbsp;voluit cert� non folutn Marei Beutnleh ineptinbsp;as.fed etiam dotflifsimorum lurilconfultorumnbsp;Omnibus planas facere,v� fcilicet folusAndre*nbsp;as Vbiquitacis beneficio fapi�s haberetiir-Nccnbsp;fialum voluit deMarco Beumiero iriumphuntnbsp;agere, fed etiam de lurifconfultis trophruinnbsp;�rigf re;vt fcilice thuic tri�pbo eo maior digninbsp;tasamp; auihofitasccciliaretur. Echoce� terti�nbsp;Ai vltimi'i lacobAndricx vidonar tcrtimcm�.

Expofui lia�ienus bona Rdc qua poiui breuitate 8? perfpicuitate, prxcipua capita,nbsp;quie tn difputatione Tubingeni�, quam vera'nbsp;�u.n narrationumhbrofto foftremoirifarci enbsp;placuit ?n dre�, acfiderunt.Me auteji! n h l �nbsp;Vero alienum feripfuienornntomnes, qui cinbsp;difputationi inttrfticrunt, ad quorum confrixnbsp;entias prouo ;arc niinim� dubito. Std cngt;t�.ilt;nbsp;Om optime nouit Peu snbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, ccrx

lt;lium Si rcnvmkniiatcr , on nismtndsri� 5� amp; fiaudis fcncrifsimus�ufn^imv'tp vindrx:nbsp;qiiem gaudroaiirjUando inter n e amp;� Anrfn rmnbsp;uduentfcfrurumc�c. TeautetnAt drrni crz

JW. B E V M I BR-r tor,vtfi'meiita argiim. nca,qiilt;tlioc locobre*nbsp;uitcr fepetrj ii5 propoim�c, aut te aliter qu�itinbsp;ego commeinorarnn fact�f^ciffe.fcias, idfir*nbsp;mioribusnrgumentu'.qudrufunt it�a quatuor*nbsp;que hoc iolt;o attigiftijConiinonftres.

Riujoaisme itaconfuftunfuine, vtniliil amp'iuiaduerfuj tua� bypothcf�s afftrrenbsp;pjtucrni

Mirarerhoc�oco.An Irea, te iftaferibere: Ijif� latn diiJuni jniiltis ino hs toti mundo pro�nbsp;ba T?.� ,ze tjuliiui rei vaqiiam puduifTe ; vn le,nbsp;f�ue Gregorius de Vaientiafiue alius Papiftinbsp;verilsim� fcnpfiiTe videtur ; inter doua qiiibu�nbsp;Andreas J'eornatumer�e videri vuit.liaud mi'nbsp;nimum cfTc hoc.quod in tota fua vita, etiam innbsp;m mifeftjl�tmafraude deprehenfus.nunquaninbsp;eruSuerit. Idem ver�ctiam hoc loco luce me/nbsp;rtdianac.arius fefeoftendere, ex ijs qua: fub*nbsp;iiingam facile cognofeetur.

Serieus ipfe me integrum diem, omnibus ante 8C poft meridiem horjs � te auditum fui'nbsp;life Quomodo igitur exa(ffodie,cumf�nis di'nbsp;fputat.oni neccnari�imponcnduseftet.aut vnnbsp;de colligis me nihil amplius aduerfus tuas liy 'nbsp;pothefes afferre potmlfeicum teipfo tefte, nonnbsp;inopia argumentorum meorum.aut veritas tunbsp;arumhypothefcon/ed dieihora finemdifpu'nbsp;tationiattulcrit ; nil�fortafsis voiucris tuasnbsp;eonctoncs in mul tam quoque no^em produznbsp;cere;

/ P o L o G r /?. 4y Cere;quod tamcn tc cogitare ncmo fiifpicaba*nbsp;tur Nunc.puto.aniinaduertis tchoclocopraenbsp;Wnnia iracundia, nitniat^ vidlon� cupiditatenbsp;lapfuin �fle Paraiogiftno � non caufa vt caula,nbsp;qiundo non ego , fed dies difputationeninbsp;diremic

Sicuihoc ad fidetn lacobAndricam co-gnolcendain non �ifftcit.hoc qiiotp paucis ac Cipiat. Cum ergo primo die difpiiiarc ceita�nbsp;turn ertet.lacobus Andreas milu copiampotenbsp;ftatemipfccir.feqiienti quoqjdic, fi qiiiddcfidenbsp;rarem.intcrrogandi. Quaproptcr turnde fornbsp;ma Dei 8i forma ferui.ex loco Pauli ad Philipnbsp;penf x. tap cuidain refpondcret, amp; forman�nbsp;bei.formacp ferui dcaccidentalibus.quas ipfenbsp;conf�nxit,formis interpretaretur.hoc argumcnbsp;tuin propofui.

fuit in forma Dei, amp; xqualis Deo, is fele exinaniuit 8�formamferui acccpit.

Ergo fiiius Dei feipfum exinaniuit amp; form� ferui.id eft bumanttatemaccepittquod docentnbsp;Cliryroftomus.�Auguftinus fermone fetundonbsp;de .gt;4arali Domini:! heodoretusDialog.i.Banbsp;filittshb t. contra Eunomium.

Sed aflumptum mc�,in q�io tardodifputa/ tionis vertebatur.iam firmis argumentis do'nbsp;tnonftrabam, qux Andreas inxternum rum-pantur vt ilia Vbiquitati, infirinare non potenbsp;F S

ril. �. A contiexij;quii Paulohac�ofopra f ofituiQ cft ollendere ,qau fuertt kfus �Ij.q^nbsp;ftusat^reincarnanonisniyi^eriu;!! i A �Runbsp;(sonioCyrilli theraun lo.Cap.i. Vbiduhurnbsp;Chriftu in forma Dei Fuiikali xrerno 3 A Nonbsp;tatione vocabult ^op9�(iquoJ i.i� ligni�.'ainbsp;quoi eflenda Dei feu Deitaf 4. A te hmantanbsp;Bafilq Magni lib 4.ron(raE .uioinijCa i/nnbsp;(orma Dei efle,eft KI elTeaina Dciefte None^nbsp;nimalmdfofma,aliuden'cat!a Oei,ne fitroninbsp;pofinis.; Ateftimonio Damafccni. qui hbronbsp;4 0r{lioJoxjrfiJci Rrib�, itiforniaLkietf*nbsp;prxdicaKi^eChriftpgt;ante incarnationem,nbsp;f�gnificarc t� c/uot^^^oif 'o�iiz toi'nbsp;*deft,confubftanrialit3(eni cum p�tre f, A te*nbsp;ftimonio Atnbrofij, qui libro 6. Epiftoia 4�.nbsp;fcribit: Aduerfu� Photinum hate nobis fenten.*nbsp;tin eftraduerfusaurem Apollinarem l�gitimanbsp;circuuifpe^io.vt confiteamur (trut in Deifornbsp;ina.nihil cidefuitdimnxnicur� amp; plenirudianbsp;nisiftc in ilia forma hominis quo imperfetflusnbsp;lioino iudiraremr. y.h vi vocabuli vqnalifnbsp;Deo quodCynllusho; mo Io inrerpretanir:nbsp;quo wq io ergo alien� I'ubftannic eft.cui �quanbsp;Il seiHNamquTnarural iter xqualia funt,cinfnbsp;dem penituj iubftantir (unr.

Ad ho; argumentum turn Andreasne?^^ quidem ref ponderer, qu im N�ftnrianum ef'nbsp;fe, quicunque fenuat �eiMtcm fefe ex muni,nbsp;unie SC

toiffe J^formamferui acccpifle; egover� ralt;r �onem tapti criminis repofccrcmitand� quodnbsp;floriMitompes , mihi fattsfrqt� micquepihtinbsp;Sinpiius adueffus fuas thefes ^fFicrrc ppife�nbsp;bella �J aftuta �gt;�OT7rAs�''gt;�lt;r� demonftrauit;nbsp;Ita fum , mquit� defatigatusCnam affucuiitcnbsp;labori tam videbatiir, quam nuper in difpu*nbsp;Utione Heydelbcrgenf� magnis lacert� di*nbsp;Tcipulus cius qtiipublic� amp; grauitcr, quumnbsp;ei oralis manducatio defendenda ciTeCi conznbsp;querebatur fe publica concionc ita defatilt;nbsp;gacum effe, vt vix fpirarlt; pofsit^vt non pofgt;nbsp;nm tibirefpondercaippliqs : tu ycro fiveriznbsp;tatis ftudium tibi curx cft , veni hifce dielt;*nbsp;bus ad me Sd priuatim confercmus dc ver*nbsp;loci Pauli fentcntiai Exhis candide Lcd^�rnbsp;lib�r� iudica ytrum Marcus Beumisrus adnbsp;Oppugnatiopem Thef�um niljil amplius af.�nbsp;ferre, ytrum yerd Andreas plan� f�conuitianbsp;excipias , nihil refpondereomninopotuerit.nbsp;�tlioc cfi primumfundamentumquonitituKnbsp;Viftoria lacobAndrica.

Alterum Argumentum.quo triumphusia� (obAndricus fancitur , dedudumedexmca�nbsp;lt;]uam confinxit Andr�as confefsione. Naninbsp;in confutationc.mepubiic� dixifTe : Quodnbsp;Ornnial�m perfcripturus adTigurinos. Et innbsp;Admonitione , quo eft ingenio fcraci , ad*nbsp;dntmeprofeflumerte pubiic�, quodminim�nbsp;f�ntiS c� Tigurinis.'f� taoi p roplianf do^rini

prof�teantur qua? inThefibus lacobAjrlri�:!* Si. difputatione publica damnaca fu�rir. Vici*nbsp;ftiprofcfto Andrea �d magnifies vicnti:nbsp;propterea trilimphum � tuis tibi dtcernend�nbsp;clauftrumi^ Bibcnhu�anum donc danduninbsp;cenfeo- Fateor Sd ingenue fa tcor me virumc�nbsp;dixiife: K vt tibi plus largiar.cr. adtiuc eoJeninbsp;fmn animo, quo tum fui,cum tibi ifta dicen tr.nbsp;Nam primo tuas re^ponfiones triumphanifs.nbsp;quas ad obiefta mca argamen a dedifti neunbsp;folumad Tigurinos fcribendas.fed lOti rar.tPnbsp;do hoc publico fcriptoparefacicn.las cenfeo:nbsp;vtomnes intelltgai^quibus a�-tibus,tiiamV/nbsp;biquitatem propugnes, quam audaifter denbsp;rebus vanis Si falfis g'oriari fbieas.

Deinde verd non inScior, fed coram DeO Sc toto mundo fateor, roe non folum � Tigurinbsp;nis fed etiam ab omnibus Hclueticis.Gallicis,nbsp;Anglicis.Germantcis ccclefijs, quas totope/nbsp;H�re vcneror.dilTentirejfi eadoceant, quxiunbsp;affiingis brutisl^nbsp;anatlieinatifmis ferire confueuifti. AbArrijnbsp;nam'q; i npierate,� Neftorq delirio SC alijsblanbsp;(ph-miis, quasiunoftris nunquamnon falfdnbsp;aff�ngis, tam longe abfum abhorreoep : quantnbsp;long� te � veritatis tramite deflc�ferc amp; verenbsp;cundix fines tranfire videoqtioties iftas ca,*nbsp;lumnias aduerfus nofiros euomisiMultum venbsp;r�falleris Andrea , fiexiftimas me , etfi ab ijsnbsp;umdudum cxplofis, quotidiec]; explodendis

I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;.nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, h�refibus

harefiLus toto animo d iTcntiam, ftatirii tiiam qui ta tem, qua: orth�doxosin Eutychiaznbsp;*gt;�scotr.mufat,aut reakniidicmatumtommunbsp;*?icationfm.qusp Arrij furotibus arma fiibmi*nbsp;tfftrat.qu� Neltonum, Martionem, Monoznbsp;tbelitas,Monepl)yfiras,Tlieopafcliitas,abOrnbsp;t� fiuocatiaui ccn'ubftantiationcm.quac elexnbsp;Uati�n�m Papifticam amp; adoranonemfacraxnbsp;l�entild�l�latttram (OifiVmat,probaturumnbsp;�ffe Sdo ctiim Dei gratia ita fugicndum cfTejnbsp;�te trseter cafam Scio efiam fententia fapienznbsp;ignem fe �oniicK.. ,

Cxterum hoe ipfo.locp.tctui (imil^efre, Opcrx prctiiitnmefaftiirum arbitrer , f�pionbsp;Lectori otieiidero.Nam hoc quidemloco ,ncnbsp;Lcio quo calu veto falfutn tnifces.'fcilicetexiznbsp;ftanas , omnetuliiTe pumRum, nonquivtilenbsp;duici.fedqui verofalfummifcuitJralfuinigiznbsp;tur eft,quod niemoria lapfusper fallaci� comnbsp;pofitionis ea coruungis Si. confundis,qHxmenbsp;r-itpdifiitngenda d�; diftinguenda eranc. Namnbsp;�icintnem Tiibingenfiuimqui difputationi inznbsp;�erfucrunt, ex me audiiiifTe fat fcio,quod nonnbsp;fentiam cum Tigurinis, ft vera fintcrimina,nbsp;quorum tu eos iiifimuJas. Itatp omnes.quotznbsp;quotmcntjritarpc ducunt , mirabuntur , tenbsp;�amremcr�inpublicas litcras referre , quic*nbsp;quidinbuccam venerit, amp;viiiofa iraciuidia

diflauertt.prsfertim cum ca tot auritis 8f 0lt;tf lat�s teftibus rcfutari pofsint.Nequc ver� du*nbsp;biummthicft , quin raultorum confcientijSjnbsp;quibus tuterrori es impudentifsim^tnendacqnbsp;�rguaris. Mtrum autem e(t Andrea te di�nnbsp;Tubing� vixi 3; cuni crebritui dem� �p�dnbsp;tnultos fermones efTehr.tamenhuiufce rei nulnbsp;lain apud quenquam mennonemfecifi�. HoCnbsp;ver� tii nofti, Si tua tibi c�nfcientia �g^crit�nbsp;Si multi boni adolefcentes meminerunc^tcfa^nbsp;pc' ijs. Si mihi ipf� coram dixifle.'me � te inte/nbsp;�rum dicinin publica difputatione audit��,nbsp;mea argumcitta difc^TaiMarcum fi�umTeruitinbsp;�l�e deiperatum h�rctic�m,vtpotc qui verita/nbsp;tl nullum locum relinquat. ViSlortx autenfnbsp;A'ullaifii^ecifti ihentibneR�.

C�t�funi quo'd tu publice nie dixiife fii^* ^is ; id priuacim lAtuisxdtbits Anno t $ 91�nbsp;die 7.Septcmb. Tigurum me abiturui� dixif�nbsp;fe.prxfente honcftifsimo Si dodlifsitno ado/nbsp;lefcentc loannc Cafparo Murero' Tigitrin�,nbsp;qui nune mun�re Ecclehaftico apud nos fun/nbsp;gituf, fuipferecordaripoteris ,ft pruts Bi/nbsp;benhuftanani crapulani edormiueris. Neqn�nbsp;autem nobfs tum ferm� eratdetuisTli�fibus,'nbsp;quas paucis ante feptimanas dtfputaucras,nbsp;fed de fchedulis quibufdam qUas aducriiisnbsp;orthodoxum confenftim.non ccrr�, qiiod rc'nbsp;A� memini Si etiam bonts aliquihus viris di-�nbsp;xi, fine mendis Gratnmaticis Cnondum e-�

V F Cf t O � i A� 4gt; rim vt arbitrer alijs forrigcndas �dera|^nbsp;(onknpfvras mihiqur Irgrras.N�m earuiBnbsp;har� erat, Orihodoxum �enfenfunifnbsp;�iquesden omiws.qiJos contra prxcrptuiQnbsp;l'aiikZuuingltanos amp; Caluinianos�re�ijna*nbsp;tcgaiHr* ,nttllainoinnii o prarfentiamisfa#nbsp;tra Cccua corporis fanguinisi}; Chrifti ftatu�nbsp;tc.Ctimvt r�cgo 'Ocis ianrcxOribod�xo�.ennbsp;tenlu,9u�inaliis roftronimfcriptis citaris,i4nbsp;faitum cHc, nobil^ inf�gncm ^niuriam fieri,nbsp;probar(in,tii vt foies voiifcrabaris, Nullainnbsp;Oninino flatiiuni, fi aliquatn^atuuntprx*nbsp;fi'ittiain,Deus me puniat^ac tua impcircuiiigt;nbsp;�aie coRimoinm mcmini inedixifle .�Si ergonbsp;probauens noftros nullam omnino fia*nbsp;*igt;en;, in vin SacrxCcri'X c�rporisChnftinbsp;Frarfentiam , profc�o non fentiatn cum if*nbsp;lis , nequcbafterns fenfi. Hi$ttaqii�per�gt;nbsp;^tis Andreas me demittit : fed panlo po�,vngt;nbsp;�liqiic apud amicos , de me amp; conuifto amp; irinbsp;f�am fcnrsntiatn pertrafto, miferabilis homonbsp;Sgt;oriatiir,ijsinfu�;rrando, Marciis Bei mie*nbsp;cftnofter. Namapert� amp;ronjndrdixit,nbsp;non fencire cumOuhodoxo confenfu 8Cnbsp;fuis Tigurinis. lia quodego nennifi hypo*nbsp;*hefie�iamp; enm con�tionc dixeram, id�n*nbsp;^�c3s,Argiua cahiinnia,amp; fine oir.ni re�gionbsp;he Categoru� 8( f�inplieiter � me diduranbsp;��lulns retulitj�f quidc peierando affirmauit,nbsp;Quaproptcrn�nulh quib. faraihariter notua

�eram amp; quibus men fententia in hoe negori� 'nbn dam erat .* nouitaterei commoci fijemnbsp;Zndre� habere non audebant : fed ad me adixnbsp;bant, quid rei fit audire, quidue inter me dfnbsp;^ndream aftum fuerit cognofetre ex me cii/nbsp;p'iebanr* Ciim verd vt res ada erat expone/nbsp;rem ; animaduerti bonos iHos viroslibidinCnbsp;An.lrec quiduisfingendigraiiiGime'commOnbsp;ueri-Sed vt omne meiidacium eontmud extiiinbsp;guitur ; (�C I1.TCfabula lacobAndncafimulaenbsp;�onn.ffa f�it'.euanuit : necvnquam pofteaabnbsp;aurliorc repetita fuit Fortafsis a.nici, vt eiuSnbsp;lionori liudcrent conf�lftcnt ,� nc tam falfanbsp;long�is fpargcret, monuerunt. Hoe vei d innbsp;Andrea l�'�do.quod hoc ipfo loco, perimpmnbsp;detitiam v�rfaliquid falfo mi(cens,ait,ifta vetnbsp;bad irie'iiBnditionahterpro ata ertc. EthxCnbsp;cft alteVa ratio qua fulcitur viifloria lacob/nbsp;Andri ca.

Tertia ratio ducitur � f�mili exemple ,3t^ htsverbi.sexplicaturpag.4 Admonitionissnbsp;Idem anno oJtuagefimo, Viitttenbergx quo/nbsp;quefaiffum, vbi in qiiartum diem Bifputationbsp;extrada eft, amp; omnium profeGionum Boiflnnbsp;rcs,Magiftri,Srudiofi,Paftores, amp;illiinpri/nbsp;mis proiiocati funt.qiii Caluiniftat um opinionbsp;nem amplexi erant. In qua viri egregic dodi,nbsp;cum vid�rent. opinionem doiffrin� Caluini/nbsp;ftarum.nullo fobdo vernatis fundamento ni/nbsp;�i,in amplilsimo confeflu,5lt; ftudioforum fre/nbsp;quencia

APOLOGIA. 49 ^�cntia fumma , quam Auditorium capcrenbsp;non potcrat, icd ad hneftras aftantes,auditornbsp;�fS qu�m p ur�:ni fc prarbtbant, hat^enus fenbsp;gt;n crrore vcrfatos,f ublicc fatebanmr.Tribucnbsp;re autem laudem verirati manifeftatj.pro quanbsp;Dea Siprxfidi gratia:; cgerunt.

i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ego fomno folutus fum.'non

fecus ac Hercules apud Ariftopliancm , eutn ci Bacebns imbenis,efi�minatus,amp;omnikujnbsp;Voliiptatibus difi1uensDeu$,naiialesfuaspu*nbsp;gnas amp; ingentes viftoriasmagnifi�e,thrafoznbsp;nicc,Gr�caij; fide exponercr. Nam fli Tubin�nbsp;gac amp; Eafilex , amp; nuper admodum Heydcknbsp;bergx meminitnihi, fiepe multa� multisd�nbsp;ifta difputationc narrari.Iacobi vero Aildresenbsp;indufiriatn amp; vicioriamprxter Andream,ncnbsp;mo vnquam narrauit.Hoc feio multos, qui dinbsp;fputationi ifti tnterfuerunt, dicerc, Andreamnbsp;aded feftiuum K lepidutn caput fuifle, vt, itanbsp;vt grauem Thfologum dcect,auditorumftrcznbsp;pitus Si cachinnos effufos, quos Andreas mOnbsp;Uebat fiiauiter Si liberalitcr fubfequutus fueznbsp;ritzvt videlicet omnibus omnia fieret. Gemznbsp;mam verd iftius difputationis in pretiohaznbsp;bent proculdubio omnes , Si jnagnapcc�ni�inbsp;fibi redimendam putanr,Andrea:fimiles.-quanbsp;Sacrofanftum illud Si modis omnibus adznbsp;mirandurn, incarnationis filq Dei Si iu)tabiznbsp;G

t�tiortis plcnitudinis Dfitatis inCbrift�n�n farcimine contuliflc, atlt;^ fcurriliter �ontamigt;nbsp;nafle � muitis dicitur.Magni faciunt etiam aznbsp;miciAndrex comicameiusprudenciam; quanbsp;antequam in arenain defcenderet, fi^pugnxnbsp;fe committeret.do^ifsimos SC clarifsimos rinbsp;TOS partim carccnbus includendos, partim innbsp;trifte exiliumeqciendos curauit.Scilicet faci^nbsp;Ie eft vincerc abfentcs amp; non r�pugnantes.nbsp;Seddebisiudicentalij .* non meum eftfaltemnbsp;in alienammeftem immittere- Et li�c eft ter/nbsp;tia ratio, qua vidoria lacobAndrica ftabtlinbsp;tur.�qux cert� nihil aliud cft,quam carcinomanbsp;perici principq : quo triumpliandirs Andreasnbsp;falfum falfo probarc conatur, at^ arundineonbsp;baculo nititur.

Quarta ratio ducttur � caufts inftrumenta/ libus,quibus aducrfus me pugnauii Andreas�nbsp;atqt tarn iplendtdam viAonam obtinuit. Cannbsp;fx autem illx non funt rationes Sf argumentanbsp;verbo Dei deprompta.fed calumnix obtre-*nbsp;�lationes,quibus viros dotf^os petiuir, meifnbsp;per latera eorum confodcre tcntauit.Arq; hxcnbsp;itaefteteftiseft ipfeAndreas, quipag.jfu�nbsp;adraonitionis in hunc modum fcnbit : In pri^nbsp;mis verd optimi qmque cum ex profeflbribuSnbsp;tumftudiofis quoqiic , in ftuporem conutrftnbsp;funt.cum iIli,Patriarchx erroris huius Zuuinnbsp;glij fubfidium obqcercm, amp; ex hoc ipfius libelnbsp;lo T iguri in quaria forma imprcflb, verba re^nbsp;citarcro

A p o t � (� r Ai f� citaremjn quibiis Ziuiingliusfatetur.fe internbsp;pretation�(tnfuis fcriptis c�prebtnfati) ver^-bor� Teftam�ti Chrifti.in fomnio � fpiritu diznbsp;dicifle.quiatcr an albiisfuci !r,n5irie ninerfi;nbsp;Deo a�t gratias ager� pro reuclatianefa�la.

Vides pie Lebber, quoinodo Andreas mfto Dei iudicio amp; iraciindia abrepnis, inftar fori�nbsp;lt;is fylueftris fuo fe predatindicio : atipapert�nbsp;dicat,fe n� tam argumctiiis noftr� dodrinaranbsp;refutafle.qu�tn c�uitijs amp; criminationibus ir�nbsp;utfam fufpe^tamij reddere tentaflc.De fomnonbsp;Zuuinglii.quodmaligQ�, vt cartera oinnia innbsp;terpretatur Andreas,Cap. j.dif�eretur.

�go autera in ifta difputatione , qua Aiv* dreasmutco plus temporis in crimihationiznbsp;bus � maledrftis, qudm in graui Si feria arznbsp;gumentorum explicatione eSfumpf; t,ld qnodnbsp;noruntomnes , quiomninonihilnoriint,6Cnbsp;quod feit Andreas, fibi obieiflum eile � me punbsp;blicc rprimd ingcmifcens mecum recognouinbsp;illud Pfalmi lio.Quiddabittioi Si quid addetnbsp;tibi liiigua tua fraudulenfa'; Eit veliitifagltisenbsp;robutti hominis acut�t amp; vt carbones luniz'nbsp;peroruiti.

Cum verd viderem, tundem nunc locum sliquem exDo.ZuuingIii,nuiic�xD. Dan�i,nbsp;tiunc ex D. Bez� libris trMncatim,caluinniogt;nbsp;f� amp; innidiof� citare, manifefte corrumpef�,nbsp;audalt;fter in alien�fcnfufndetorquere, tragic#nbsp;�xagitarc; venit �nilu in �nent� quod Plutarch.-'

Jiyi/��ToAfej/WF , d� negotiof�s Si garrulis, eleganter grauiter�nbsp;fcribit,S� butus Andrer mores, ad viiium ex*nbsp;prefsit. Age, inquitPIutarcbus.fi quis vete*nbsp;rum libros inuadens, ex ijs pcfsima qux'q; eXnbsp;cerpac,at(^ librum babeatcoinpolt;4tum, vclutnbsp;�X Homcrids verfibus, qui aW (fctAwdicun*nbsp;tur,aut ex tragicis folcrdfmis, an non dignulnbsp;efletjtragica ifta imprecationc^nbsp;o�oio �vnr�v txAs^wv ja� crvfjKpo�eii�nbsp;lAal� peretfs mortalium cxcerpcnt maU,nbsp;Qnin amp; abfqj tragica imprecatione, inquit,i*nbsp;dent Plutarcbus �TrpiTrit� c�rai�t^^� inbsp;SiiffauQji.a-fX�� ii'K

PlutarchusEtbnicus tanteperc dcte�amr eoS qui'aliorum pcccata Si lapfus tiudiof� obfer*nbsp;uartt,qs(p obietflant : quid quarfo tibi Andreanbsp;Plutarcbum, fi reuiuifceret, tibi didurum 2r^nbsp;bitraris, fi videret te Theologum Cbriftian�,nbsp;vt pra: te fers, tot tanta^ falfa crimina in op*nbsp;�imos viros comminifci, qsip tuain linguam,nbsp;crudele ingenium oble�lare^

Et nuper admodum cuinTubingardedi�^O loannistf.Carononprodeft, �lt;c.difputaresgt;nbsp;tnultorum litens Silcrmonibus ad nos per*nbsp;fertiir, te pro folutione argumentorum, nunCnbsp;D. Grynxum erbis nebuloneni

r�Slhnen appellafle.�nunc dotflt�imum amp;di . w. fertifsimutn virum D. Stephanum Ifaacum, ,1nbsp;quod patrejudxo natus fit, fcurrilitetwadu* inbsp;xifTcAd priorent ilium quodattinet Andrea, {nbsp;hoctibi certdperfuadeas velim, eiustantam 'nbsp;lt;fle apud pleroftp Germania: nobilej gratianinbsp;vt eum exagitando amp; conuitijs infedlando, tenbsp;in eorum odium conqcias. Nam eius modegt;nbsp;ftia, pietas, ftudiofam iuuentutem erudiendinbsp;ftudium Si. diligentia � pluribus laudaturSCnbsp;amp;matur,qu�mtufort3fsi$furpicari$,autetianinbsp;Vis.Quare tux calumnix 8i conuitia non plu�nbsp;cius famxS^ exiftimationi , qaam virtutc Si.nbsp;pietate fibi peperit,non plus nocere pofcrunt,nbsp;qu�imSemeiconuitia Daiiidi nugx Tlier-�nbsp;fitis apud Homerura Vlyfsi 8C Achilli nocueznbsp;runt. Firmum cnim manet illud Ciceronis:nbsp;Vt ignis in aquam conielt;fhus continuo reftinznbsp;guitur amp; refrigeratur.-fic referuens falfum crinbsp;men inpurifsimam caftifsimamvitamcolznbsp;latum ftatim concidit Si extinguitur.

Ad alterumycri^uodattinet,bonaconz feientiaaffinhare po'Sum.ardentiasftudiumnbsp;�Cgrauioremzclum, verbum Dei promoiiennbsp;di in co elucere qu.dm in Andrea.Id quod Annbsp;dreas fuo ipf�us preconio Si teftimonio comz inbsp;probauit:quippc cum nihil ipf� obijccrepoz;'nbsp;tuerit.qu�m quodex ludxisortum fuum duz |nbsp;cat. Bene' eiiam habet,quod in eadem difputaz '

fcrmento vepurgar�, nihil aliud cxprobrarp po�uit, qult;�;n quoJinter c�icros etiamdoznbsp;��lorenj habtat ; qui non tantum fecutidumnbsp;fpiritthnjrd etiam fccundumcarnemfitcx fenbsp;mine Abrahr. Quafi veto Cliriftuj Ecclefia^nbsp;rum paftorum princcps AcAngcius magninbsp;tonfilii non fit ex Judxis fecunlum carnem.nbsp;Rom.8 Cap. quafiProphet� /poftoiio-'nbsp;mnes lud�i, fioriginemeorumfpe�lcs.nonnbsp;fuerintzquafi vcro potior fit Ethtiicorum, eXnbsp;quibus tu qiioquc fatus amp; produclus e?,qu�n�nbsp;credcjitium ludiorum conditio amp; dignitas.nbsp;Oblitus Himirum cs,3lii$ rebus ab his diuerfisnbsp;iivcntusiDeuroovz eif ajt

id eft,non accipere perfonas; fed ex cmni geii te acceptum et efl'e qucmuts, qui eum timeat,nbsp;amp;operetur tuftitiam ; Aif�orum lo.ForwfsiSnbsp;etian, id ex �nimp tuo effluxit.-Non cf�e diftinnbsp;dlionem vel Itidsci.vel Grxci: ft d eundem Opnbsp;rainum omnium ei��diuitem�in omnes� qui^nbsp;bus inuocatur. Et ccrtc hic vir non minori c�nbsp;frinftu amp; dignitate Euangcliurh Chnfti, q��nbsp;tu Andrea docere potrrit.fi in e'o ardore, pie-*nbsp;�te 5t ftiidio,quod hadcnus omnibus quibusnbsp;cutn vixit abunde probauit,perrcxerit:ae quonbsp;nctno nof�rutn eft, qui vel tantillum dubitet.

i Nam primo,proptcr Eiiapgelq confefsippein 1 amp; profefsionem amplifsiino.s iiios reddttiis linbsp;\ bens deferuit, ac Chrifti parpei faftu.s eft aunbsp;�vero Euangelij caufa tantum abeft i vt iadu--ram aut

Win aut damnum aliquod tuorum tone* rum fectris, vt potius ex eo rem tuamfeznbsp;c�ris, magnamque aur� S� argen� viia corranbsp;feri$,q uo iurc qua iniuria iudic�t q,quos tunbsp;fedibus fuis exturbafti, tneum ver� non eftnbsp;prenunciare. Deinde ab illuftribus hominibusnbsp;pluribus pietatis tempcrantiacteftimonqsnbsp;ornatur.qu�miacobus Andreas : qui tarnennbsp;omnibus fe prxfcrre folet. Denique non mixnbsp;nora eloquenti�, cognitionis, linguanim SCnbsp;bonarum 11 terarum Deus in hunc ludarumnbsp;contulit, quam in lacobum Andream terracnbsp;filium. Et hare eft quarta ratio , qua viznbsp;�oria lacobAndrica fancitur. lamreliqunninbsp;�rat vt eti� famofo libelle feu pafquillo, ar*nbsp;gutnento videlicet inartif�ciali, fuas ratioznbsp;ncs comprobaret: quod nupcr in fua confuCinbsp;Confutatione aduerfus Doftorcm Grynacznbsp;urn grauifsim� Si. maxima fui cum laude feznbsp;eit� Sed fortafsis Andream nunc iftarumnbsp;ineptiarum fatietas c�pit Si pudere incipit,nbsp;quippe cum intelligateas indicia efte anirainbsp;parumfaHit

PLacuit tibi quoque Andrea, vtiracundix tux fatisfacercs.tu� iftam fiZtiti� vnftoriSnbsp;tribus profyllogifmis amplificare. Nam pro

M. BEVMLERl tuo acumine facile exiftimare potes, earn Ittnbsp;debilem Siruinofam efTcjVt ad cam ftabiiien-'nbsp;dam vndiqiiaque prsefidia (�nt comparanda.nbsp;Prior igitur ProfyilogifiTiiis tjus , in Confu-*nbsp;tatione tuapaginaj��.Ins verbis concipitur:nbsp;Q�*lt;Beuml�rMs) inftar hederx aflurgerevtnbsp;roflet.fub ipfius ementito nomine pafTus eftnbsp;breue feriptum, aducrl'us meam, de vera Do/nbsp;mini noftri lefu Clirifti inuocationc in Aca/nbsp;demlaTubingenfi habiramdifputacionem innbsp;lucem edi.

Hederx mentionem cum faccrc�,bonis vi' risinmemoriam reuocafti tritum il'udlermonbsp;nj prouerbium aiciaiiii n�^' OFTJ�wexcijdeftnbsp;hedera poft antifteria.Cui confentit illud,AW*nbsp;�m TOV wB��jM�v ��xf/�' poft bellum venirc.Tnnbsp;enim,dum ti� difeipuli Heydelbergj in aciemnbsp;prodirent,vehementer laborarent, tuoqj auxinbsp;lio non parumindigcrent, temporis nimirumnbsp;anguftia locorum interuallo prxpeditus,nbsp;nufquam comparuifti ;nec abeft fufpicio tc in/nbsp;terea tempons, vtEcclefiaiibi magnxeursnbsp;�ft.�/'iTotpcipov id eft , hedcr�geftatorcm innbsp;ceilula Bibenhufjana egific, Nam fatius cfTcnbsp;tibi videbatiir amp; tutius id quod hacbenus o/nbsp;mnibus probafti , cum abfentibus cminuStnbsp;quam cum prxfentibiis comminuspugnare�nbsp;Ego autem Andrea, cuius rei mihi DeuSnbsp;teftls eft Ji�it/ieno}'rftsw�,non certi , vt� mul/nbsp;tis faifbun�

Hs fatfhim eflTc multi queruntur,malis artibus. non furfum atcp deorfum curf�tando, vel aflurnbsp;gert vel eleuari cupio. Virtute ver�, pietate,nbsp;tnodefti3,temperantia,ftudio,diligtntia,�xcrnbsp;citijs Deo meo feruirc.bonis viris placere.manbsp;lis difplieere , eorumlp conatibus quantumnbsp;Dominus dedericref�ftere , cercum apudmenbsp;decrctumlp eft. Toto verd ccclo erras Andreanbsp;fi me ingenio tuo indicans,mihi in ftudijs nihilnbsp;aliud propofitum arbitraris,quam vt prrpoznbsp;fituram,Cancellariatum,Abbatiam,Pra:latu*nbsp;rani, SC ft quaefuntalia veftrarmaieftatii infigt;nbsp;gnia,confequar.Habeantfibi Vbiquitari| fuacnbsp;Pr�pof�turas.fibiCancellariatus, fibi Abbaznbsp;rias, fibi Prxlaturas, fibi alios inanes hutu�nbsp;�nundi titulos, fibi pagos amp; villas, fibi arc�nbsp;amp; caftclla : nobis verd relinquant veritatisnbsp;glorixiyDei drfcnfionem SC propagaiionemnbsp;quoniam fine illis vita beataeflcpoteft , finenbsp;his verd non poteft. Atque idcirco Deo meonbsp;gratias.quas poteft animus meus caperc ma�nbsp;ximas,ago perpecud habebo ,quod eius benbsp;neficio mihi contigit, cum D.DofloreGryznbsp;nxo , in quohumilitatis, modeftix,centcmznbsp;ptus liuius mundi ciuf^ glerix , veritatemnbsp;promoucndi, ftudiofam iuuentutcm ifideliternbsp;erudiendi multd plura luculentiora fpcciznbsp;mina.quam in omnibus noui iftius ordinis honbsp;minibus elucent,amantirsim� SC coniimdtifsiznbsp;me viuere. lacobi verd Andre� ini qua de me

M� B B V H L E RI jBrariudicia, atroces calumnias , trucuictttosnbsp;farcafmos in nomine Domini afpernabor.'cecnbsp;loperfuafus eos milii apuci omnes bonos launbsp;dem 8C beneuolentiam conciliaturos efle. N�nbsp;ts quidemeilquimakdicit, pr�terea nocercnbsp;nsnpotell: Dominus aiuem eft, qui benedicir,nbsp;amp; benefacere pateft-

C�terumfalfd fperauit Andreas fc mihix/ gr� faAurum eflc : � alqsperfuadcatmenonnbsp;erte anthorem �raAbo? wc difpurationis eius*nbsp;5cio nam'c� omnia ea qux cogicamus.med�a^nbsp;n)ur,inftituimus amp;agimus, nonadnoftrumnbsp;honorem K commodum.fedadDeigloriamnbsp;tcnvltimum Kvnicumfinem referenda eiftgt;nbsp;Facile patior me non folumomni laude.quamnbsp;fufpicaius eft ad rae redituram elfe, � confe-'nbsp;6fione iftius fcripti.fi modo meum efle crede/nbsp;retur , fpoliarblcdinluperetiam ignominianbsp;notari , malis malorum hominum iarcafmisnbsp;vcxarizdummodo veritas fana tcfta d piacu'nbsp;lis Vbiqmtatis lacobAndricis conferuenir,nbsp;gloria Deiilluftrcmr , ahh�ds confcicntrisnbsp;confulatur.

Ne tarnen boni viri �niftram de mc opinio nem ex Aiidzex calumnijs imbibant,meqi iu-'nbsp;ucnili impetu.aut cxr o zelo.aut tcincnrate a^nbsp;liquidlncinpartefiifcepiitcfufpicentur ; fednbsp;intelligantme ift� -ti'ctAu jiy confcribendo.donbsp;tffifsiinor.quot;! gramfsimorCijf viror� eonfilia amp;i.nbsp;iudicia fequutum eifetfubqciani duas brcuesnbsp;epi�olag

Epiftolas,quarum altera � reucrcndo viro �. Rodolplio Guualthero ante libri c�fe�lionfynbsp;altera ver� poft eins confeftionem � D Guifnbsp;licimo $tuc�io ad me Bafifcam mifta fuit.

� Ad fcrnas tuas literas mi Bcumlcre,not� 0*rcfpondiha(fl:enus, non quod te minusnbsp;amem,aut ill a s refponfo indignas exiftimetp.nbsp;Ferreus enim S( inhumanus nimis efl'cm, ni^nbsp;�) te mfiainantifsimum SC obferuantifsimumnbsp;redamarcmrfed quod Deo placet mcamvale^nbsp;tudinem fubiiide dolonbus capitis continui^nbsp;fatigare;S;fane� il�sitanunc quoqiie ycxor,nbsp;vt vix iftis fuff�ciam. Non pofTum tarnennbsp;neqiie debeo diutius differrcrefponfum ad p�nbsp;ftremastuasdc Cancellarij Tubingcnfts dixnbsp;fpuratione,De Adoration� carnis Dpmiqinonbsp;ftfilcfnChri�i. Eti�cnim hopio inftlix,quinbsp;perruptis omnibus pietatis Sf modeiliar�annbsp;'cellis , mereretur vt nuUa eius ratio habexnbsp;rerur : tarnen necefTe cft , vt aliquis agxnbsp;ger opponatur hopiini , quem propria co|inbsp;fcientia , SC Principis fui ftd|icia , adcp ingt;nbsp;rbriat , vt neque rationis neque pudoxnbsp;ris alicuius meminerit. Non pofTum igtturnbsp;pon ^robare tuum confilium ihftitutum�

�fui lt;ius hominis fophifmita refatarc deerelt;' uifti.Hoc vnum moneo, vt omnia modeft� aznbsp;gas, dC primo quoque tempore conficias.Qjionbsp;ad Frofchouiierum noftrum fpero me ab eonbsp;cil� impetraturum,vt fuam operam nobis nonnbsp;deneget; ScR qua alia in re mea opera rihinbsp;commodo effe poterit,faxo inteliigas, quantinbsp;cefaciam. Salutabis docliisimitm SfoptiroJnbsp;fratrem Doftorem Grynium.quem ex cordenbsp;diligo.'amp;tumiBeumlerecum illo amp;reliqui$ .nbsp;amicis vale in Chrifto feruatore noftro , quinbsp;tuumpropoi�cumiuuet. Tiguri t^.Ianuarii*nbsp;Anno nati Chrifti 1584.

I lOANMSS aVIblBUMVSnbsp;Stucciuf AUreoEeumlcro difcipulo cfeu�nbsp;ri�i:n3 S.

* fputationis lacobi flndiez, quam diude �deraui,magnj cum voluptate legi. Eft cnimnbsp;tnea fententia clegans,acuta, 8i in fumma brenbsp;uitatcpcrfpicuaNondubium eft, quin ft do^* 'nbsp;ftor illc aliquid refcribac.eodcm modo te tranbsp;ftet Si excipiat, quo D,Bullingcrum,D. Be^nbsp;tzam, D.Sturmium,D. Danxum haiflenus cx^nbsp;cepittVt videlicet raiionibus deftitutus conuinbsp;'tijs f ugnet, ne omnibus armis exutus videa/nbsp;tur.Tu

tur.Tuverdi�ispo�liabitis pergeinp�o tno fiudio.malorum odium afpcrnare : bonorumnbsp;ver� bcnciiolcntiam tibi conciliareftude.Da*nbsp;ixTiguriCalendisMartiis.Anno r $84.

Hsrc vt dixi.pie Le Aor,non ideo hue interfe rerelibuit,vt Andrex K Andreani$ probarc�nbsp;tne authorcm elTe i�ius fcripti, quod aduer*nbsp;fus eius dtfpucatiouem cxtat,f�rmunii}t amp; imxnbsp;tnotum flatifcd vt vid�rent omnes pij, me ni*nbsp;hil temere' amp; abfq; confilio Si confenfu meo*nbsp;rumprxceptorum in Icripto illo tdendofe*nbsp;ciffe. Nam, ita me Deus ben� amet, Andrea�nbsp;milii non tnaioretnCcmachumfecir, cum ne*nbsp;g�uit me authorcm ef�e iliius feripti : qu�m finbsp;ntgaflet me intei-fuiffe ci eolloquio, quo Sel*nbsp;neccerofuoperfuaf�cvaccam c(k, cui nomennbsp;fit Bariho!oinxo;aut cciam ifti conuiuio, quonbsp;ingentigenerofi vinipoculoexhauftoCaluiznbsp;nianorum doiRrinam falfam efle probauitiaucnbsp;lt;iiam eius prxle�iqni Lipfenfi, qua duos il*nbsp;luftrifsimos principes � plauftrofccni Diale*nbsp;^icam ridicule' doccrc voluit,

Sed audiamus rationem , quam Dodo� fitx affirmation! fubiungit ,mc^ authorem il*nbsp;hits fcripti non efl�eprobat:Omnes ais, tepronbsp;fiulto Si inepto habuerunt. Ergo non es au*nbsp;thoriliius fcripti, quod aducri�s raeaoiDi*nbsp;fputatiotiem tuo nomine cxiuit.

Ad antecedens refpondeo per concefsion?* Fateor Si concede tibi omnes quotquot tenbsp;bing� atnplexantur,in manibus habenr,fou�r,nbsp;ofculantur fuatnep voluntatc ad tuam maieftanbsp;tem aggreg3nt,me pro fini to habuiiTe :fed nulnbsp;lam aliam ob caui'ani.qu�m quod tibi cura o*'nbsp;tnnem difsimulationem Si fimulationem, cannbsp;didc Si rotunde', poftifabito metu infamixnbsp;incommodorum veritatc dixitquodaliarqirinnbsp;veceriprouerbioeciamf�mplices homines Sinbsp;ftulti facere dicuncur.En Andrea habes coafi''nbsp;tetem re� .Sed quid vis amplius^ hoc quoq;,Hinbsp;fi me animus fallit, tuos videlicet me idco'prnnbsp;ftulto hominehabuifrr,quod cum tof inifta A''nbsp;cademia,haud equidem obfeuri nominis viri*nbsp;Si qui tarnte quam me dotfirina fuperare di*nbsp;cuntur,ita fibi temperare fuoslp affeftus coefnbsp;cerepofsint : vt quid ftbiintedifpliceat, Sinbsp;quid fc maxim^ offendat (offendunt aut�piu.*nbsp;rima^non apenant, fed metu ruarum calum*nbsp;niarum,infamix,exilrj,difsimulent:egofolusnbsp;Sl ido�efcens.Si peregrinus 8( Hekieiius lib�nbsp;tu�tp Vbiquitati maxime inuifus.tam egregi�nbsp;heroi et inuifto Marti,me oppofuerim. Si qu*nbsp;f� cum Deomp/�on/�) bellare in animum in-duxenm Ef certc hanc eorum de me opinion�nbsp;' nuncplurimum confirmabis, cum intelligentnbsp;m� iamabore tuo petifaliiscriminibusjobruinbsp;Si infinitis conuitijs exagttari : quod ipfifuonbsp;filentio Si obfequio vitarc pofl'unt. En An-*nbsp;dica

Ver�m age.-habes ne amplius quod pro tuS Ifbcralitate in me conferaslt;pro inepto quoznbsp;que inquis rc habuerunt. Profedd tam tunbsp;qu�mipfir�^i*fs'gt;Blt;^de meiud�calhs,amp;rem,nbsp;quoddilt;itur,acHtetigiftis:quo nomine il; veznbsp;ftrarum voluniatum lententiarum^ lummamnbsp;coni�Cnf�onem dexterttatem de ingen�is wznbsp;dicandi vobis gratulor. Nam quia Heluetiusnbsp;funi didici � mets maioribus Si pr^ceptoribusnbsp;non animo abiefto Si feruili, federefto �f Hznbsp;bero efle;melt;� nonfenututi St �bfequio lacobnbsp;Andnto.fed libertati natumcfTe.�ti� idcirconbsp;fatcor.me prxter ingenq msi n�ur8m,prffiernbsp;voluntatem , prsterpatria? mex libert�rem,nbsp;�nea te, fatoor, tuaqj dogmata, qui plumbeanbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;!

�� confidero metp ad te conformare ftudeo: video te interdum fummam fummi Theologinbsp;grauitatcm.'interdum vcrd quod pace tua rf�znbsp;*erim,Bcckui3,necobfcura,funiraxleuitatisnbsp;documenta dare:ita vt quidam ex mis amicssnbsp;�am cxcufarc volent crebris fcrmonibus idnbsp;vfurpet:Fatcri cogimur amp;res ipfa ioquitur.dinbsp;Snifsimum noitrumCanccllarium, interdumnbsp;in r�bus ardiris fcurrili-cr,fed tarnen non ani-nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;tj

itio malo ludere. Et hoc cft primura Lcibit� nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;I

regulxdociuncnturo. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;I

Deinde vcrd luce mcridiana clarius el^� te non folum tibi in Academia Tubingenflnbsp;multis inuitis principamm vendtcare amp; info�nbsp;lenter vfurparezfedctiam exterarum ecclef�a/nbsp;nimSi Rerumpubgt;agt;AoT�zo47ncr)MOTv agenbsp;reJtcnjpr�te ferre, teomnes tuas curas Sinbsp;confilia infolamEccIefis falutem conferre**nbsp;int�rim tarnen aulas Principum inftar Melitrfnbsp;catuli ftudiofc auide^ fe^ari, cibuin lautuntinbsp;palatob} tuo plurimum arridentem,cuni gna-�nbsp;ihonibus � dammapetere pofle : equos alerc:nbsp;pulcina opimatp prxdia animi caufa obequi*nbsp;tars:in cornobiis vino dulci.pifcibus dclicati�nbsp;carneferina afflufntibus,nuncapricationibu$nbsp;caleHeri fuauiter, nunc �Auante flffpumantenbsp;Baccborefrigerarefalubriter, EcclefireqjfJnbsp;penitusabieda. Ethoceftfecundum Lcsbiienbsp;regular documcntum.

Pr�tcrea hoc idem etiam intimi tui, qui fe quotidie ad pedes tuos abijciunt, fuis elogi�^nbsp;amp;tefcimoniisluculcnterconfirmarunf. Antenbsp;noucm ncmpe annos quidam fuis literis quaSnbsp;Baf�l�am mif�t,tc Gr�cis epithetis tibi appri*nbsp;me conuenientibus graphicc' defcripfitae ap*nbsp;peUando^Ay7re5t7�iUovagt;(ptAo7rg|�^|Lt5r»nbsp;�� 5lt;tA�';T^�7iUova.Neq; te oblitum arbitrernbsp;quendam c tuis.hominem n ec indodium, ncenbsp;obfcurum tibi multo vino obruto,3t{p idcirconbsp;vt foies conuitia euoraenti X de rebus niagnisnbsp;glonanti

APOLOGIA* 57 glorianti , �^alios-prx te contemnenti, pernbsp;locum in memoriam reuocafle, manticatn ilianbsp;Sinbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;optimi amp; clarifsimi viri Pliigt;

lippi Melanditonis vocem, quam tnitifsitno alioquiti pe�l�ri.tiia iniolerabilis'amp; effufa ianbsp;ftantia, in conuennt Vormatienfi cxprefsit:nbsp;35c^�r�)ort��5 ��ifcr @c|)tr��bFeinrogFcnnbsp;in �ctttfd) Unb PcFom/fnnf� wnrbc er grognbsp;iamc�-i�ii (Te�tlcl� lanb anrt'e^ten ! hoc eft,nbsp;Deus prohibeat.nehic Sueuus pracf�diumaliznbsp;quod confequaiurmam alioquin magnas turznbsp;bas amp; calamitates in Germania daret. Hocnbsp;quomodo�xitus probarit Si quotidie probetnbsp;fey ipfa loquitur ; fcliolac di�tpata? tcftaniur;nbsp;ftiultorum bonorum virorum exilfa 5; car�nbsp;lt;eres clamant, amp; Principiim animi diftra�:i,nbsp;amp;'�xacerba'rt,fati^fi(pcT�p oft�nduht

Ethup�radmodumiiius hofpes Bibenhugt; Hanus, te Lesbiam regulam cfle, in con��ionbsp;haud obfcnr� probafledicitur; cum tibi multanbsp;defcholxTubingenfi'sref�rmatione, de ftuznbsp;diof�s inordinemredigendis , dehouis fegiznbsp;bus condendis parturienti apert� dicerctfnamnbsp;ai tint eum te non vftp adet� fufpiccre i f�bi e� renbsp;icholarum amp; ccclefiariimforc videri : fi poftnbsp;mortem tumidus venter mus incidatur : quianbsp;animaduerrat temiiliis X'ivc'rcpA(u�^idtH,Ttnbsp;rum innouationibus , quibiisfcilicetfincinznbsp;commodo pofteritas carerenonpofsit, graz

��dumcfTe. Kxcfunt qurtui de te fcntiiifrt� quarte piwitibeain reguiam cfTe docent.

Porrdf�ni3mdo4irtnain,quamlucein miili di c(re,quam normam fidei �i rcligtonis hab�nbsp;ri vts.animo meo luftro SC. pond�ra, ibi ccrt^nbsp;meaminfantiam, amp; ineptias libcnter fateofnbsp;AJagnofco , meddne cogaranimnm meutnnbsp;ad illam Lcsbiam regutani appiicare.Quisnbsp;nim fanus tam apnis ei�e pofsit, qui animun*nbsp;fuum ad ifta adaptet lt; Corpus Chrifti verd Sinbsp;realiter eft corpus f�nituni,circumfcriptum,iitnbsp;certo call loco exiftcns: Et tarnen vnumi^nbsp;demip corpus vne codent^ momento, in in*nbsp;ferno.in terra, in arborum t'oliis.in cantharUnbsp;ceruiftarijs , ingraminibus agri, inludaeia*nbsp;queo, in omnibus iocis obfcccnis , atip adeOnbsp;in ipfo diabolo adujK realiterexiftic. Itmnbsp;Corpus Chrifti realiter, fubftantialiter, cor*nbsp;pora liter efte in,fub,cufn panc.fed non locali*nbsp;ter,non circumfcriptiur,non viCbiiiter.Iteigt;^nbsp;atquipollerc iftas duas propofiiiones ; PaniJnbsp;eft corpus Chriftt;8;,inplt;ine,rubpane,cupa^nbsp;ne eft, ftuelatet corpus Chrifti iiiuifibilitcr,nbsp;fubftantialiter, realiter, fupernaturaliter , SCnbsp;nefcio quot modis aduerhialiter.

Vides ergd te tuorum de meiudiciutn PJ ralogifmo d Dirto fecundiim quid, ad dictumnbsp;fimpliciter.corruttipere amp; in alicnum fenfuinnbsp;detorquere. Nam alioquin qux profefi'oreSnbsp;vcftrt de me mciicp ftudijs iudicia fccerintdi*'nbsp;teri�

� P o t o 6 f A. 5* mis rorum teftan portem;fi non potins taamnbsp;iftam calumniam vel omnino afpernandam,nbsp;vel Audio SC diligentia dilacndam iudi*^nbsp;�aretn.

. St ver�AndreasiuammaieAatem exercns iracttndtxfp mucronem Aringens.cd rem ad*nbsp;ducat, V� oinncs profe�bres Tubingenfct.vc*nbsp;iintnolint.eomodode mciudicent, quo vultnbsp;Andreas.' ego non magnopere laborabo, ncipnbsp;td moicA� aut repugnanter fcram .Int�rim ta*nbsp;Rien me contraniainiqua prxiudicia.calwm*nbsp;nias.S^ conuitiacum ecclef�a Dei con�olabor.nbsp;Pofuifti nos opprobrium vicinis noftris, ludinbsp;brium fubfannationero lus qui circum nosnbsp;funt.Pofui�i nos prouerbium intergentes.'a*nbsp;giiationem capitis inter populos. Quotidienbsp;opprobrium me� coram meeft; amp;opprohri3nbsp;vultus mei ohtegitme. Propter exprobramesnbsp;amp; connitiantes,prc*pter aduerfarios vindictenbsp;auidos.totumhoceuenitnobis: SC tarnen nonnbsp;oblitifumtis rui,nec perfid� egimusinf�dercnbsp;sito.'nondefiexit r�tro cornoftrunt.�necdecli*nbsp;nauitgrciTus nofter � femita tua.

C�tenmn Andrea edico tibi�wvp TtTt� elt;�eq)'ni(gt; luu /.iarcum Brumie*nbsp;turn conuitiis incei�ere, nittciusfamamarronbsp;dere ccfTaueris, Marcuin Bcumlerum ca in pwnbsp;biicas litcras relaturum,qux vos,nil�om�emnbsp;pudorcm rxueritis negarc nonpoterit(S:quonbsp;turn tora Tubinga c�fcia cft Si pcrt^fazquilnM

M. BEVMLBRI veftrumminiftenum non vald� �xornibiw^nbsp;Quare moneo te tues�, vi � malediecndi ynbsp;crimina (onf�ngendi libidine abfrineatis :nbsp;etiam ea audire velitis,quz vobis otnnetn*5nbsp;luptatem, quara maledicendo ecepiftis,pen*^nbsp;tus eripiant.

Cura verri intelligam quanti tuoruin*^ meiudiciumfacias,amp; quantmihiillud prxi**nbsp;dicio elfe veliszreponam tibi paucis non pr^*^nbsp;feflbrumTubingenf�um^qui omnes cruditib^nbsp;ne rc exccllere dicuntnr, fed auditorum tuOf**nbsp;qui te adorant iudieiutn. Nam cttm ante blei�'nbsp;nium Epiftolain Pauli ad Romanes publii^^nbsp;in Academia interpretandam fufcepifTes ,nbsp;IcAienes nec crebras,nec bene' przmcditat^Snbsp;aliquot habuilt;res,memini teiuftiriam�Cb^i'nbsp;ftonobispartam iuifttiz.quam AriftoteicSW**nbsp;Ethicis dcfcripi�toppofiii�e : ac tandem A*^'nbsp;ftoteitcam iuftitiam,cuin iuftitia, quxin Itgfnbsp;MoyGs defcribitur,contuli(re,nihil(p ab eadi'nbsp;fcrepare amp; diflcntire manifeftifsim� dixifie*nbsp;Hoc tuonouo paradoxe difcipulitui inftup�nbsp;rem conuerf�, verba tua formalia exceperuntnbsp;attp multis odenderunt, corum^ iudiciuntdenbsp;bac tuaopintone cxpetiucr�t. Namvidcbaninbsp;fi ftatuaturiuftitiam Ariftotelicamnonaliaiflnbsp;effe qu�m Mofaicam,hoc abfurdum fequi.v*^nbsp;dclicet etiam Arifrotelcm Domino Chrifto�nbsp;teftinioniitm pcrhibuifTe : quippe cum Paulusnbsp;ad Romanos j. Cap.fcribat, iuftitiam Delnbsp;quant

A P o 1. o � I A. f9 quam adipifcimur per f�dem lefu Chriftt comnbsp;probaum tcftimonio Legis ac Prophetarum.nbsp;Itatjf hac tua �itaBOTA�Jc* effecifti, vt non fo-*nbsp;lum pro dodo viro � tuis non habereris, fednbsp;etsamdifcipulis tuis fabula fieres, atep� qui*nbsp;bufdam dodis viri$,ad quorum aures ifta ve*nbsp;nerant, rudifsimus afinus .ab�tinuidia dido,nbsp;notninaris. Vides ergo Andrea tuos non mulnbsp;t� honeftius de te, qu�m de me fentirc.nec tibfnbsp;naiorcm erudttionem. quam mihi tribuere.nbsp;PoiTemcquid�mplura in hanc fententiaminnbsp;medium afferrc.fedhxchuic loco amp; temporinbsp;fufitccre arbitror.Et htc primus eft fyllogifminbsp;tut profyllogifmus.

ACcedo ad alterum. Ais in me non tantam fuii�e erudttionem , vtin difputationcnbsp;Heydelbrrgen(�,opponcntiara dodorum arxnbsp;gumenca alTumcre potuctim Dicis Andreanbsp;quodreseft. Et certe'fateor inter tot calum^nbsp;nias.quas vltimo verarum narrationum libronbsp;cum aduerfus multos prxftantes SC dodosnbsp;*iros,tum aduerfus me effudifti, nullam verinbsp;fimiliorem effe.NamvtD.D Gryn�us, ficutnbsp;lt;uftribis, ad nullum argumentum refpondit:nbsp;fie ego nullum argumentum in ilia difputationbsp;ne aiTuthphire tibi Itbcnter do 8i prx me fero.

At vcr� mi Andrea, noli nobis tant�perc f�e^ ,clt;nferc:fcdatriecuacbilis partcm aliquant innbsp;tuos difcipulos conucrte: idqnodproculdu^nbsp;bio faciendum iudicabis, C vel ad punAuninbsp;temporis hommis modefti cogitationcm tenbsp;fiifcipere melancholia nia pattetur. Nam illinbsp;credc mthijnccrdum non argumenta, fedlb^nbsp;phifmata, interdum non fophifmata verorutnnbsp;fcilicet argumentorum fpeciemimitanttaifednbsp;nxniaspucrii�s , df fcopas diifolutas inme^nbsp;dium artuleruht.citnties^, vt videlicet ad ar/nbsp;tem cauf� afcendere ncceflc non habcrent.msnbsp;gno ciim aiidicorum txdio inculcarunt. Nifinbsp;fortafsistibi, tuxlp Dialedicr inefFabilinbsp;inii(gt;t3t3r,quam non itapridem LipfixnoneXnbsp;natura , non ex vfu Si rcrum veritate, fed eXnbsp;plauftrofocniarefa�li dcdiixiiii, ea qucq;nbsp;gumenta ftnt,qux ad nullam f�gurarum haiflxnbsp;nus reccprarum congruuntcqux fccno Si �ipnnbsp;lts difsipatis.fimiliora funt, qudrn argumcn/nbsp;ris apt� amp;concinn� formatis.

Sed quia tuorum diicipulorum roccyfmi te tintopere obtenant, en pro mco erga te a /nbsp;more aliquos tibi in nvemoriam reuocabo :*lt;nbsp;ex i)s inietligat totus mundus, me nullum tuonbsp;rum difcipulorum argumentum afTumpfilft*nbsp;Quotnodo igitur tibiplacet.illud Marbachijtnbsp;quo fer jptum in verbis c�nx vos accurate te^nbsp;tincre,qualt;t i plauftroconcionatusprobarS

K rcft�diciimur fenurew fun irin Ver* ccenr, qui cum fcn�iM rennent^quc Chrt*nbsp;^us ipfe exprefsit.

Has fcopas An4rca,ctit nunc xiGimpt ; ta* raen rcAe* dices d^vmadconuenicnter, menbsp;argumenium aflumcre non potuiffc. Ratio innbsp;promptu eft, quia hie argumentum nullum eft.nbsp;Nam in maioripropofitione.vtipfequoqj vi*nbsp;des manifefta eft , SC tantodoAorc indignanbsp;contradiAionisimplicatioiqua fententia fcrinbsp;pti ipfum fcriptum, litera externa amp; fenfusnbsp;internus conftinditur amp; pro eodem accipitur.nbsp;In minore vcro.quod eciatn te non latere pu*nbsp;to.pueriliseft Principij petitio Quiscninivonbsp;bis concefsit haAenus quod hie tuus pro con*nbsp;feflb fumit verboru Chnfti, Panis eft corpusnbsp;Ciirifti.hunc verum K genuinum el�� fenfuni*nbsp;inpane.fub pane.cum pane eft corpus Chriftt,nbsp;�tgo in concluftonc,vel te iudice,iiilul fanutnnbsp;nihil facrum eft.

Qtiomodo verd ciufdem, dignifsime Do* mine Canceilarie placetnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;hoci

Igi tur Zuuinglinani non retintnt fenfum� Has quot^ nacnias etf� nunc afTumpfii reftc.ta*nbsp;men dices me non afTumcre potuifle rcueren/nbsp;di Doftoris Marbachq argumentum Rationbsp;prompta paratat^ eft, quia argumentum nul*nbsp;Ium eft, fed tantum ignorantta Grammatica,nbsp;cuius p�erum vel feptennem pudeat. Senfulnbsp;quandoquidcm � Jlarota non differt aliter,nbsp;qu�in quia illudeft vocabulum Latinum, hocnbsp;verdGrxcum. Etcertefivobis VbiquttarqJnbsp;doifloribus lixc argumenta funt, cur non co-'nbsp;dem modo te folitarium noneffe, etff mille annbsp;nos Bibenhufq delitueris,colligamlt;

En egregiam Marba�hianam Eienchi ignora tionem.'quaduo vocabqla,qusrvnum amp; idemnbsp;figtiifi'cant, vnius eiufdemlp noix funt, bis pernbsp;omnia pugnantia facit.

Sed pergamus D.Do(ftor,ft placet, amp; videa mus quomodo tertium Marbachianum fophifnbsp;ma tibtarrideat.

Quinon fueruntfubnubc , quinonfuc.' runt in Mofem baptizati,, qui non tranficruntnbsp;mare, ijnon manducarunteandem efeamnbsp;cundem biberunt potum cum vetcribus pa.'nbsp;tribus,

Etffhas ineptias , ignofce Andrea . berius loquenti , nunc quoquc aflumpfi:nbsp;tarnen rcdb� negabis, me argumentum, 2{^nbsp;fumoce non potuiiTe.Nofti enim vtnbsp;(rx,ti-7TfQ$v eTggpvnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;aliud fceptr�,

aliud plcArum.'f�c aliud elfe verum argumcn.* tum,aliud fophifma putidum amp; ineptum.Ncenbsp;quifqnam vnquam nifi Sophifta deploratusnbsp;omnibus modis impudens.autrerumplan^nbsp;ineptus.omnil^ rarione deftitutus, argumentum nominauit.quod ex puris negaciuispro^nbsp;cedit.

Si iftis fuperioribus nondum expleuifti.aut potius amifiRi omnem valuptate.condimensnbsp;tilocoaddeSf hocmuftaceum .'nonfapidumnbsp;illudquidem, fed tarnen tale vt VbiqUitatis 'nbsp;partum elfe facile' agnofcas.

li tantum eandem efcam manducarunt.qui fub nubefuerunt.qui in Mofem baptizati dint,nbsp;qui mare rubrum tranf�erunt.

Has gerras ct(� n�c alTumpfi reft^.tamc ne gat Andreas mcargumeatum aflumerenonnbsp;potuilfe. Caufa apertaeft. Nam noluit illudnbsp;H �

Kvtiilis impugnare; Caluo turptus cft nihil comato.Ne^ contra ciufdem iententiam pro^nbsp;pugnare aufus cft ; caiuus cum fueris cris co*nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;�

inatus. Viciflctawem vtrum^.f� id argumen-lt;iininoinina(rec,quodiarccunda figura afiir* � matiu� concludit.

Habes Marbaehii coccyfmol : nunc Zint* inermaanircl�gintna (oipolita , ^�irguhanbsp;fylucitru tibifiibftcrnani.vt Marbachi) fruftifnbsp;clcttUatts opplctuitii t fiiauitcr indormirr pofnbsp;fia. Namargnmcnra fyliogifmot tam re*nbsp;dolent, qu�tn fyiueftrta pruna fragrantia au*nbsp;reapoma.

gt; OJitre^giteSproprios generatimdifcUe cuhut Vol LogK�fruHut^ ferot mollite ebenda.

Priraum igitur.quod faltx fauftum^ fi�.re �lerende cu� cap��pponemus hanccrabcmnbsp;Zftamermannicatn, qua fufiuitus, in vtran*nbsp;queauremnon minus fuauiter dormtes.quifflnbsp;C Vbiquitati Bacchice Bibenhuftj litaueris�

Hunc trabalemZimmermanni clauum fiaflumpfi.tamen Andreas verifsim^ affirm�tnbsp;me argumentum afTumcre nonpotuiffe. Ra*nbsp;tto cd.'quia �A/� tfia itttvoi'i b�� per otnnta difnbsp;ferunc. Petitio Princtpij maiiifeda. Si 3rgu'nbsp;tnenrum fanum:Si quai� f Jiametro fibi opponbsp;nuntur.atnbiguitastcnniuorum, amp; conflaninbsp;minimeip

�WMmc� fucatum argumentum, nia�utcm Vitia ita ma�ufefte hocioco pcripkiunturnbsp;Vi nemioem * uiit quen� Vbiquitas ita cxcuranbsp;reddidtt, vt ctiam in luce meridiana caliget,nbsp;fdgiant Nam primo quxritur inter nos, nonnbsp;angt;vlt;rba Chnfti vera fint � an Chriftus prxftanbsp;rc vclii amp; pofsii quod promifit, de his cnintnbsp;dubitare piaculumforct.i�d hoc in controuevnbsp;fiant vocatur,virumcx iftis verbis, Accipite.nbsp;eoenedite. hoc eft corpus meum, re^c fie ve.*nbsp;ritaii cenuenienur coUigatur , �ibfiantialenbsp;corpus Chnfti.inpane.fub pane,cuffl panc,o.*nbsp;te corporis extern� , �am�pijsqu�mimpii�nbsp;manducari. gt;ggt;�gt;ttrabalisZtmmcrman*nbsp;nus quatftioncoi pro argumento fumens innbsp;Itunentodumargumentatur : Re�cdicimusnbsp;in pane corpus Chrifti ore manducari : quianbsp;Chriftus inquit,ac�ipite,comcditc.hoc eft cotnbsp;pus meum. �i Patres dixcnuit,�re corporisnbsp;manducari corpus �hrifti. Qiwd pehndc eft,nbsp;alt; fi in hune modum argumentaretur.'Corpusnbsp;Chrifti nianducatur ore ; quia manducaturnbsp;�re.

Deinde ambiguitas terrninorum eutdentifti ni� qiioqi pcrfpicitur.Nam quod patres,comnbsp;snunem, vfitatamep de Sacramentis loqnendinbsp;confuetudtncmimitati.figurat�dtxerunt.'rriquot;nbsp;buendo nimirum f�gno nomen rei fignatx ; idnbsp;perpendiculum Zimmermanni huius plunigt;nbsp;beum,propri� diAuracftcimaginatur.

Alteram (�ue Tenediam, Hue Ziniermanni' cam fecurim ventri fuo,(� lubet fubfternat Annbsp;dreas. ac non minus in delitili habeat, quantnbsp;olim Alexander Magnus Homeri po�mata.

Hanc plumbeam zdificationis Lesbiam regu Iam,et(� nunc aiTumpli.'tamen Andreas verifsinbsp;m� diccre potent, me argumentum aflumerenbsp;non potuii�e.R.atio efl:, quia inlTpidam Si in^nbsp;fttlfam Elenchi ignorationem aflumplt : quanbsp;ter maximus tile Zimermannus fi'guratuntnbsp;opponit vero.at^ tiac rattone maximam facr(nbsp;fcripturx partem in dubium vocat,fal(itatis9nbsp;inli^ulat. Mamf� primamSf verifsimamil''nbsp;lam Dei promifsionem.inparadifofa�lam,nbsp;Semen mulieris conteret caput ferpentis,nbsp;ferpens conterct ei calcan�um, ad hanc Zimcrnbsp;manicam regulam accomodaueri$,falfirsimanbsp;abfi t blafphemia di�lojcnt: quia tota tropica,nbsp;totafigurata eft.

Verum pergo Sftertium tignuro Zirner� mannicumpropono:Quodfi ita videtur, colnbsp;lo tuo appendesrnam tale te Vbiqui'nbsp;tatis poniiftcem e�e ,omnibus omnino liomunbsp;nibusprobabir.

Etomnei Dialeamp;ici, qnofquotpoft homi* n�s natos vixerunt St florucruntreuiuifce^lt,nbsp;amp; vno ore me banc contradiAionis implica'nbsp;lionem ar��imendo , argumentum afTumpf�tfcnbsp;aflcuerarent.'tametjnon verercrme cum An*nbsp;drea ipi�s opponere. 8t aRitmare, me non ma *nbsp;gisnrgomentum ailumpf�lfc, quam Andrea*nbsp;badcnus ,et(� omni animi corpohsip conten*nbsp;tione in id incumber�, argumento folido eronbsp;bauit corpiu Chrifti cffe in omnibus canthaH*nbsp;ceruii�arijs.

Nunc colophonem Zimertnannicum, vt �q demnugas t�as repetrndi f�nem faciamusjninbsp;ponamus.arip�Andrearftomachoconcoqucn*nbsp;dopropincmus.

Certccum hune colophonem do* difsimus 8i ornatifsimusdo�orZim�rmannbsp;nus.Auracenl�s fuperintendens dignifsim�j,nbsp;tanquam Sy�phi lapidemdiu voluerera�rc*,nbsp;uolueret, ac (tandem fe triumpharc putaret�nbsp;mihi fuccurrcbat f�mile exemplum t quo tunbsp;quoque huius fophifmatis �troTiot animad*nbsp;uerterepoteris.

Si ver� neque hoc ad huiuf fophifmanj �At' ptias intelligendutn ttbi fufficiet, addc criantnbsp;illud: lacobus Andreas eftnouusmonachufnbsp;in clauilro Btben'iul�ano. Ergo clauftrumnbsp;Bibcnhu�anam eft in Andrca.Ex his omnibusnbsp;videt Andreas, fe minim�erraflc, cum fcrip�tnbsp;tne argumenta opponcRtium in difputationenbsp;Meydcibergcnii' aifumere non potuil�r.'fednbsp;inen hocquoque Vider, non meam ignorantnbsp;tiam,fcddi�ipuioruni fuoruni ditputandi inlt;nbsp;f�lcntiam in culpa fuifte.

lam progredior ad tertium tuum profyllo* gifmum.quo te vald� feftiuum fit iocofumnbsp;put ciTe.omnibus probarc voluifti : Gent Vb�enbsp;quitatis monachum decet:

Mirum eft,inquis in ConfuMtionc pagina f� tua qua apud Principcm authoritatenbsp;vales eiedis optimis, dodifsimis S( (yactrifnbsp;do^oribtis SC profciToribuSjdomo Sapientixnbsp;non prrfeccris.

Primum Andrea in hoc quo(p,Gcut in alqs multis opcram perdis,(i multus fis in moncn^nbsp;doDotflorcGrinaro, vtmc promoueat.Noftinbsp;enim prouerbium, Memorem moncs quidfibinbsp;velit. Nam vt ego cum ob fingularcm pi�ta�nbsp;tern, 8; admirabilem modeftiam, SC egregismnbsp;erga me bcncuolentiam iuuandilpftudium manbsp;ximifacio Xobferuo , nonqutdem altcriusnbsp;monitis.fed meo tudicio, mea volunrate , ficnbsp;quo^ �oAori Grinpo no opus eft monirore.

A F O t O � i �; lt;4 ^uippe (um ad me gt;uuanduin,pr�inettcndiifl^nbsp;ci'Udirndum f� promptifljmus.

Deinde ver� praeter tnam grauitatein * niodeftiani agcre videris,cuin fecunduni Plu*nbsp;CMnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Tn6ti�

lt;r� 74Ao�o��rB�a�'��, pedem in alien� (ocofigens te negotiofum ef�e ri*nbsp;dtculum d�claras. Nam Palatinatus Dei gra*nbsp;lia habet fuos (en�liarios nutriiios , ^uinbsp;prMdcntia,graMitate,erudttienc,gt;nduftria,pilt;nbsp;tare cxteris virtutibus te rert^ fiuit nonnbsp;inulto inferiores. Honun opera Palatinanitnbsp;Deofie velcnte Si profpicitntc vtinu-yhisfcnbsp;totumeemmittivius fc tuendum amp; gubernannbsp;dum traditthomm confilijs libenter acquie*nbsp;Ici�iuam verd Vbiquiuriam operamnon re*nbsp;qiiiriiampltusaeomni cura, quant fui fiifcc*nbsp;pifii, liberautc in cernobiis Vbiqnitaiitibi�nbsp;i�cris, qiuere^aautprauageramur curarenbsp;iubet. Hoc verd fi non fcceris,fcd tuo inge*nbsp;nio tuts� tnoribus vti perrexeris, tenon plutnbsp;eficAurumfatetur,quainfiin aquls feribere*nbsp;autfurdofabulatn narrates. De quibusEpi*nbsp;ftola Confolatoria.quanihifccdicbus Palati*nbsp;natumad te mififie aiunt, pleniuste crudircnbsp;potent.

Admeverd quodatnnet,nonmodomag* naSjfedetiam ingentesago granas.progra*nbsp;tu ifia tua cSmcndatione.'ac vt videas officium

M. BeVHlERI mum mihi gratum accicli(re,en l�mtii offi�o,nbsp;temosip deutncire ftudeo. Tu author csDo^nbsp;/lori Grynxo vt me in domum Sapienti�,eilt; )nbsp;Ais dotfiifsimis vins (quorum videlicet ex/nbsp;cellens do Arina, in fophifmatis amp; leptologcnbsp;inatis paul� ante cxpoi�tis elucet^ pne�ciac�nbsp;tgo verd vicifsim tibi author fum, vt tyronemnbsp;ilium,CqueminAdmonitionepag.ts.ais innbsp;Schola tua educatum amp; inftitutum non line adnbsp;m'lratlone duelsloannts Cafitniri, Doi9orinbsp;Grynaro demonftrafTe, quod etiam TyroneSnbsp;eum vniuerfo auditorio ndendum exponefenbsp;potuifrenT)in locum tmim furroges : id quodnbsp;commodiusfacere potes.

Nam primo DoAorem Grynacum (f�tibi fides habend� eft^nuper in difputatione Heygt;nbsp;delbergenfi non foluilt foper3uit,fe'd etiam iPnbsp;luftrifsimo Principi loa'ntii Cafimiro admit*nbsp;fioni fiicrit, C^nam credtbile efteius Celfitudi�nbsp;neVn nbl'Vbiquitatis faccrd�ti,'nJ fatnilfarcmnbsp;eflcjVtenaiheius cogitationes perfpeAash�nbsp;beas�3'Ego vertf vt liber tuus verarimi narra/nbsp;tionum hal)ct,d teannoSz.ita cdtifufus fili, vtnbsp;nihil amplius adutrfus te afierre potuerint-Habesprimam mei cdnfilq raiionem

Dcfnde tyro ille in dil^utatione Tubingen fi.vt antea tibi in mcmoriam reuocauibonamnbsp;tibi operamnaiiauit,acprxclarf'dc temeri'nbsp;ms eft,mm videlicet , iiiueniliterexultans ft Inbsp;tibi antepenefet , ac ad argumentum cui tenbsp;nullu

��Ho modo fansfaccrc vidvbat , rcipondere conarctur.-etf� non vf^ adelt;gt; felici fucceflu, ranbsp;bono confilio;ego vcr�.vt liber tuusnbsp;rariim narrationnm.mcmorix prodidit in di-*nbsp;(putationc Heydelbcrgenfi, Dominum Gry^nbsp;nxum non modo non iuut , fed ne argumentanbsp;quidemaffumere potui. Habes alteram mcinbsp;confili] rationem.

Tertio tibi idfaftufacilHmumerit. Nan� non modo authorirate 8i gratia apud Ducemnbsp;Ludouicum pkirim� potes;fed tu ipfe es prinxnbsp;cepsudquod tenon femel dixificijs qui .� tuanbsp;vioUntia amp; iniqiutatc ad principis tui �qnienbsp;tatein �i cicmcntiam prouocarunt.mul toriimnbsp;reftimoniis.fi bonis virispericulum crcarc vclnbsp;km probate poflem. Quarc impera modo , vtnbsp;is.qucmtantoperc amas,qui fe te doifi ioremnbsp;eiTeprobaiiit.tibi fuccedat, amp; nemo refragarinbsp;audebit.Habes tcrtiam mei confilij rationcwi.

Qiiarto id tibi honefttfsimum iuftitix conuenicntifsimum fuerit.Nam f� ius Canoninbsp;cum vetat ; Ne qiiis duos epifcopatns tenear;nbsp;non certc decet vos Vbiquitatis Prxlatos,Abnbsp;bates .Monacbos,PrapoGtos plus vna prxxnbsp;bcndafruimcipf�sPapiftis auariorcs vidca-'nbsp;ntini. Tibi vcrp quinqncba^nus Vbiquitaxnbsp;��s gratia obtigerimt; fpleTulidifsima eft ault.'inbsp;ca.-huic proxima Bibenbuf�anaihac noninfcxUnbsp;flores tres Tubingenfcs : prima Monachalis^*nbsp;bt ftipeiidio pnncipis;alteraAcadetnica:tertta�

Sccidiaftica.Etccrtc hare prsbendaruthflwl titHdo SC varietas incaufa c(t, quod ha�ienufnbsp;non tanta laude K diligentia,nee tanta adtni^nbsp;�ation� St vtilitatc profefsioni thcologicf pr{nbsp;6icris; quanta autem te dcecbat.fit quanta au^nbsp;di tores tui vellent. V erifsiRium enim eft iHu'^nbsp;Xcnophontis.a�cTu��TOi� tov Trs^ci

^»�,hoc eft impo^ iibilc eft multa fabticanteni,�mnia ben� St rlt;nbsp;ft� facerc.

Porrdnofti quoepboui triturant! noil ob' durandum os.'itein ex alfari viuerc debere,qi*inbsp;alcari feruiuntzex quibus d contrario. velt�anbsp;logica plauftraria duce colligerc poteriSjbo'nbsp;ui non tricuranti fed ocianci obligandutn efffnbsp;�s,8t eos qui altare negliguntex altari vi/lt'nbsp;tari minime debererluxta iHud,Qui non labe*nbsp;fat ne manducei.Cum verd tu inftar bouis C'[nbsp;prq tibi � publicis muneribu$,qux tibi ha�te^nbsp;nusfrucluofa fuerunt,imtnunitatem fumpfe'nbsp;riSjtetp ipfum Otijnimirum vohiptatutnipdulnbsp;cedine inefcatus.defedeCancelIariana, Aca^*nbsp;demica.Eccleftaftica in clauftrum Bibenbufi*nbsp;numpr�cipiia�cris : xquutn omnino fuerit�nbsp;vt tibi OS obligcnir , ac reditus altaris alter!nbsp;deftinetnur. Habes qaartam St quidem omnii*nbsp;maximam mei confiirj rationem.

Hare iiabui Andrea qua: ad calumnias St c5 uitia,qtiibus me deforma re voluifti, refpondenbsp;rem.Si verd inpofterum tut i�milis eftcperre^nbsp;xerif

� J o L o G I A, �� Suris, hoc eft conuitia conuicijs cumulau^ris,nbsp;fcias me, quatenus videlicet Dei gloriacnbsp;hthil dccedat.tua fulminabruta, folo�lentionbsp;Vindicsiturum e�tsatt� non pluris �ftimaturunbsp;2'uani olim Socrates impetus impudehtifsiminbsp;i�ldtr�nis.

� A P V T lil i. (XUoiiu^c4lumnu, ifuilnit Atidreat per,nbsp;tatuf Domini Huldrici Zuuingl� noftrSnbsp;do�rinam p e�t, [u}jgt;e{lam^nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;exofam

Leftor.fi duas infi'gncs calymnias, quas lacobus Andreas in oninibns ferc pagellis,nbsp;fuorum centonum inculca^ K qw*bus per la-tus D.iduldrici 2uuinglii Ecclefias nofttas p�nbsp;tit,earumq; doftrinam fufpe�lam amp; exofan�nbsp;redderc conatur,refutandas fufc�^ero. Naionbsp;cum Andr�as fentiat, feiam omnibus arguxnbsp;mentis dcftitutumfuam^ Vbiquitatem omnt'nbsp;pr�r�dip denudatam.'nunc omne fuum prieli^nbsp;diiun^ confugium in calumntjs Si criminalnbsp;tiomibus.in bene dicforuih calumniofa internbsp;pretatione , Sd fraudulenta depVauatione pOWnbsp;nit.Idqupd pio ledori hoc l�c� ovv �s�T, jdnbsp;�ciilum dcmonftrabo.nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

Prior cal�nia eft,quod in fuis ^oftfentis fcri ptis fex�enties fcribit Zuuinglium infubfidi�'nbsp;fatertjfe itrterpretarionem verborii caen�e Dtt*nbsp;minier ab acrolpiritudidiciiTtf. .nbsp;�

Inhac ver� calumnia tria ingrnij 8� cando' ris fui fpecitnma nobis edit manifeftifsiiha.atnbsp;que omnibus intelligentibus probat fc nonnbsp;tiif� atro fpiritu agitatumhanc calumniam to�nbsp;ties inculcare. Primum eft manifeftum Si im'nbsp;pudens mcndacium; alcerum violenta 8C c3'nbsp;lumniofa deprauatioverborum Zuuinglij,velnbsp;ex malitia lacob Andricavel ignorantia monanbsp;cliali profeift�-.tertium eft depiorata impictaSnbsp;amp; thftis aninii excitas.

t. Mcndaci� amp; faifum teftiinonium,plu$9 quam Argiua calumnia eft quod fchbit Anlt;nbsp;dreas , fateriZuuingliumfcftiamdoftrinamnbsp;�fpiritudidicifle. Nam Zuuinglias infomniinbsp;fui explicatioticnullam omnino fpiritus facitnbsp;mentionem.�lacobus ver� Andreas, � malogcnbsp;nio.qui mendax 8i homicida cft,^i in veritatcnbsp;non perftitir.tranfuerfum adtus har.c dtaboli'nbsp;cam calumniam in gratiamfu� Vbiqitit.attsnbsp;{omniauit, at^ tanquam friiftum crapulx Bi-*nbsp;benhufianac impudenter empmuit. infpiciantnbsp;igitur Ictfforcs �' cuo�uantfubt�dii�m Zuuin-'nbsp;glii.S.' ft ibi mennonem Spiritus,.! quo Zuuinnbsp;gliu� per infomnium aliquid didicerit, inuenenbsp;rint.verax fit Andreas,vera ftnt.qux fuis eennbsp;tot�buK poftremis infarfitomnia, atepomnesnbsp;fiiosacucrfirios vicerit 8C proftrauerit. Cx-terum Andrea vbi os tuum^ vbi frons ? vbi re-'nbsp;l'igio^ vbi confcictJtia ? vbi pietas^vbi timornbsp;Dominik vbi cliaritas Chriftianalt; A te profe-'nbsp;�0,quanlt;

apologia. 67 ^tJ.quantum vel exhacvnica fraude fapien^nbsp;tes iudicanr.quam longifsimc abfunt. Nam finbsp;iftarum virtutum vel aiiqiia fcintilla in animonbsp;tuo ref�dua elTetjnon induxilTes animum in ogt;nbsp;ptimiiftiusviri,8ideEcclefi�a Dei pr�clar�nbsp;meriti cineres tam aporto tam impudenttnbsp;mendacip faruire , tam manifefta fraude 5�nbsp;intolerabililibidinctotiEcclefi�illudcrc, nonbsp;uumqj Decalogi prarceptum.N� dices falfumnbsp;teftimonium contra proximunt tuum, viogt;nbsp;larc.

An ver� ita caligabant oculi tui, an vmbra Bibenhuf�ana ita mentem ruam opacarc potcxnbsp;tat.vt viderc non poiTcs.cui Zuuinglius rcueznbsp;lationem.per foninium faftam acceptam fer^nbsp;ret Edormi fuadeo 8i exhala grauem illamnbsp;crapulam, 8C fobria mente infpicc denuo 10=nbsp;cnm Zuuinglii, SC reveries Zuuinglium hancnbsp;reuelationem non fpiritui atro,fed DeOjfpif i.*nbsp;tui candidifsimo, tribuere: attpproindenonnbsp;Spiritui atro, fed Deo pro ifto benef�cio gra^nbsp;tias ageremon fpiritus.fed Monitoris mentionbsp;nem facere. Hac itacp ratione (� vel ad pun.'nbsp;Aum temporis ad te redieris, facile animadznbsp;uertes teodto,inuidia, ambitionc SC nimioo.'nbsp;tio de mentis poteftate motum ,turpifsimc Ia*nbsp;pfum elfe.Zuuinglioinl�gneminiuriam fecif�nbsp;fejEcclef�xDei impudenter ha�fenus impo.*nbsp;fuilfctanpidcirco merito iftam culpam tibi agnbsp;nofcendam,6lt; cum ccclei�a in gratiam redeunnbsp;dum edie.nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;1 3

Quorum aiitctn hominum 8� ingeniorunf amari ifti cum felle amp; aceto inpieta�s mixtfnbsp;nnt far�afmi,te docere poterie uiftifsimum cXnbsp;�niplum feurrarum illorum Si. fycophantar�j.nbsp;gui.y): eft in biftoria pafsionis Chrifti,illa ycfnbsp;faiu3tgris,Eli Eli lamah fabachthani,Deusnbsp;tpcus �|;us inlt;us,cur me deferuifti, libidinof�?

petuUptcf peruepebant.Chriftmpip Demi num iciololatriar inf�mulab^nt: quafi ip jiccrrinbsp;mo dolore extremo cruciatu.Eli�.non Dennbsp;yeriiro inpoc^ffe):, Illprum tarnen neqnitia SCnbsp;�alumpt� tolerabilipr eOe ifaciliiislp exeufarinbsp;poffe yidetur,quam hsccIacobAndrica. Namnbsp;inter Eli'6; Eli�aliquacftParanomaf�a, quanbsp;illi err^^flf alicuiprob?bil�t6r videripon'cnt.Atnbsp;inter vocabplpm Dgminijs SC fpiritus alter,nbsp;if cm.mpniior 8i Ipiritus.npn maior lin^ilifu*nbsp;do,quam int�r feriptup yerborum C�rns.Panbsp;nis efteorpus Dhrifti,amp;inter gloflam Iacoblt;nbsp;j^ndricam,inpane,rubpane,cumpane eftcornbsp;pusChrifti.Et hoc efl:primumIacpbAndrcalt;nbsp;tji jo|;cnfi fpecimen;noR qpidem � bpno fpiri-'nbsp;tue^itumrquippecumnouum decalogi pt�c-'nbsp;ceptunj defalfpteftimoniomendacip^ yitaiinbsp;dq.ram pefulanter tranfgrediatur.

Akerumfpccimen eft,vel ntalitiadeplqra^ ta, vel ignorantia deplorandjf, noui hunts monbsp;nachi.qua optimi viri difta v�l feiens ^pru'nbsp;dens adult�r�t (Si pcruertit.yel ignorantia re-*nbsp;fiiniq; irnperitia in alienum fenfumjquentha-'nbsp;�7enus �mnes eruditi ignorarunt, detorquet.

A P O Ilt; O � I A. ^8 Id quod K�b;s breuiter 8; liictiUtiter demon*nbsp;ftrarepropoStum eft. Naiq prims Andrea�nbsp;calumqiofc dsprauat dicl� Zuutflgltj.propri�nbsp;nimir� accipicndo,quod hon nt� per prouerxnbsp;bimn S figura�,, tam � ZuuingUo, qu�m �nbsp;veteribus Icriptoribijs vfurpari confueuit.Exnbsp;prouerbioigitqr, feu figurata locutione quanbsp;Zuuing-Vtiiur.fic perper� colligit Andreas.

Zuu�iglio vifum c�in fsmnio adfuifTe M�gt;x nicorc,qui ater an albus fuerit ,n� meminerl,.

Ergo Zuuinglius fatetur fc neftir�, vtruna fptritutn bonum an vero malum videric.

Hoc tuum confequens eti� pueri feptennes ridebunt * eiufi� craiTas fallarisi animaduerxnbsp;tcnt.Na alij exrudimemis Plnlippicis cdoifli,nbsp;mutato genere pra�4i�4�onis, imperitc confenbsp;quentiam colligi reipondebuntjaU, verr� argunbsp;mentaiionemj qua: confier quatuor terminis,nbsp;vitiofam efTe.jures tuas �ir��fpngbunt, alq denbsp;nitp argum�nt� homonymias car�inomate Unbsp;bor�s.animi indofti Sf v�rfipellis certifsim�nbsp;indi�i�efleclamab�t. Ne verd�ostuifimilesnbsp;efle �xiftimes,hoc �fl, crime ignoranti� Si m:^nbsp;litij obieiflare.quod nulla raitonc probarc pofnbsp;fi'nt,ccdo rationefirmifsim�. Nemoi vnquan,nbsp;hoc Prquerbium nif� tropicc amp; f�garatc vfur*nbsp;pauir,de rc vald� 8f plan^igqoca.fiue ilUboxnbsp;na Rue mala fuerit. Id quod Andr�as alto ve*nbsp;terumprouerbio difccre poiuiffet, nifi otio innbsp;erti torpere maluiflevQtud albuna, quid nigr�nbsp;fit nouit: quodmhil aliud fignificat .K veterisnbsp;bus credimus,qu-l nouit c�� id quod veUndo

JM, B E V M L E RI (flifsimopromptum eft.Nam albi 5c n�gri co*nbsp;loris difcrimen eutdemius eft,quam vtaltqu� 'nbsp;albi�jnigri, non propri� amp; figura rc, non denbsp;re fine bona lt;�ucmala,fed de refacili.manife^nbsp;fta,lippis tonforibuslv nota dicitur .-fie contranbsp;albi Si nigriignorantianontamdefpiritibus,nbsp;quam aliis creaturis , non tarnde re mala,nbsp;quam bona.fed de re plane ignora �c abftrufanbsp;de qua nihil tibi conftet,dicitur, Artp hoc mo/nbsp;do Prouerbiiim prarfens.cuin � Cicerone vfurnbsp;patiir,tum� Martialiamp;j Quintiliano repetigt;'nbsp;tur,tum etiam ab Erafmo explicatur. Intelli/'nbsp;gis igitur , opinor, Andrea, tehoc loco nonnbsp;tarn tuam malitiam exagitandam, qu�m ignonbsp;rantiam deplorandam pueris feptennibiisnbsp;propinare.

Hxc verd qua* nunc audij,cum hadenus tc fugerint, non minus prudenter Si dofte' c vernbsp;bis Zuuingli} colligis abfurdum amp; impium:nbsp;quam ohm ludxicx difto Chrifti loannis 3.nbsp;Amen amen dico vobis , fi quis fermonemnbsp;meumferuauerit, mortem non confpicietinnbsp;xternum.petulantcr colligebant.eum drmo-*nbsp;niumhabere : quippe cum Abraham KPro-enbsp;phetx mortui eftenr. Nerp etiam plus veritati#nbsp;amp; pietatis inhactuacolleftioneineft, qu�mnbsp;fuit in teftimonio falforum duorum teftium,nbsp;qui ex difto Chrifti loannis j.Cap. Deftruitcnbsp;templum hoc, SC tribus diebus erigam illud.

A P,O L O -G I A. tff^a�nn�nrC brifium dixifTc, fc umpliim Hienbsp;roiblyniiianiim deinoliturum.tnbufqj diebusnbsp;inliaurattiriim illudeiTe.

Ueindepueniftis fuperioribusnS cStenti, te ita colligcntem, Zuutnglio in iomnioadznbsp;fuit Monitor.de quo non meminn arer an alznbsp;bus fuerit.Ergo Zauingtius didicit ab atro fpinbsp;riiu.effufc ridebunnCum enim ipfe Zuuingliznbsp;usdcexicrnx�Ionitorisilfius fpcciei.fibipernbsp;fomniumobied�.qualitate, hoc eft de exterznbsp;no habitu.de colore line nigro fine albo finenbsp;cscruleo,fiup vjridi.fiuerubro nolueritCarroznbsp;gantiac ntmirnm virandx canfa5pronunciarernbsp;Quis tc ex Dauo ferrario, Ofdipodem fecit,nbsp;vt tanta temcritatc de rebus ignotis rcfponznbsp;deres. Nunc verd Andrea tuis mancipqs maznbsp;gis placebis, omniumfp acclamationibus, etiznbsp;am Danicli Prophetx longtfsimo intcruallonbsp;anteponeris, tdtpiureoptimo tibi continget.nbsp;Nam tu jjt tSnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;hoc eft repente,

^veftigio audadler de fomnio Zuuinglii. �ententiam tuam profers,ncq; animos noftrosnbsp;din fufpenfos tones. Daniel verd,vt de fe,nonnbsp;minus videlicet qudm Zuuinghus arrogan-�nbsp;ti� crimen fugicns,teftatur,non nilt temponsnbsp;aliqiio interuallo interpoftto,dc fomnio Nc'*nbsp;bncadnczerispronunciareaufus fuit. Deindenbsp;tu propria libidine amp;charitate Chriftiana nsnbsp;giffta,defomnio Zuuinglq iudicas, Danielnbsp;verd proprix inhrmitacis (ibi confcius.non ni

K. BEVMLBM g ��aine diiiino imploracq, fomniup Nebu*nbsp;IK^daezeris filx incerpretandum duxit�Scil(clt;tnbsp;Daniel nptv� facerdo� precum, tu ve�nbsp;rd �nona�hijsnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;gt;'�jpy�4dirarum S�

infauftarum imprccationum faiflus es.Tenid i�i}c reuelatione diu�na proprio atroep an�'nbsp;mimotufomni� Zuuinjglt) nobis explicas.04nbsp;nicl verd ante vif�on� nocturna, diuinitus f�b�nbsp;pbiefti/on^ni� Nebucadnezeris indicarenbsp;cxponere.n�c aufus nec potuit. O fqrtun^t^mnbsp;ij^tur Sucui� (� fua bona norit. En tibi ovaponbsp;�jra^nvfomnior� coniclt;fi:orc expeditifsia�;nbsp;�t� adfomnia interpretanda.nec pr^medttationbsp;operofa.qec ffnaqonitni^diuini inuoeatio,nbsp;n.ecdioina reuelatio neccifaria ei�.foU mclanquot;nbsp;cholia/olairacundiaeiadmunus hoc ,qec fanbsp;num nec facr� obe�d� fufncit. Eti� a�t fomnijsnbsp;amp;. reuelationibus interpretandis.magn� lau�nbsp;dem adeptut e$,yi eti� c� �aldps meritp cornnbsp;parari po�Eis.'tamen adeJplnrim'i accedet.itnbsp;adhib�ta tua logiez nobis verba Pauli i. Cor*nbsp;�t.noui hominc inGhriflo, an in corpore, annbsp;extra eprpus nefcio.Deusnouit, raprX in ter�nbsp;eium vfcp cccl�,rocund^ explices.ac f�n� omninbsp;tergiuerfationedicas.vtn'i Paulus in corporenbsp;an ver� extra corpus raptus fuent iq tcftiuninbsp;c�l� N3 eadcfacilitate Si temeritate ex hifeenbsp;Pauli verbis plauftraria tua metaphylicanbsp;dialeftica.ccrtialiquidconcludsrc nobist^o�nbsp;mticm dubitandi occal�on� pr�cidere poterisnbsp;qu�in ex verbis Zuuinglii, quippe cum Zuuin

apologia;� 70 g�ius n� minus de fux reuelationis modo qu3nbsp;Paulus dubitaucrit.Experireigitur quid pof*nbsp;lis,fi rcs fucceflerit ipfum quoep Paul� prudcRnbsp;tiafuperare videberis ; fin vert� prrter animtnbsp;fententiS ceciderit,tua^cxplicatio maiqri honbsp;min� parti ludibrio Si contemptui fuerit^coginbsp;t abistibinihilnoui acciderezquippecumfo'r'nbsp;mula tua concordir.qu� tanto labore tibi cot|nbsp;ftitit, cuius beneficio te tociecclcf�ae Chriznbsp;ftianz imperare pofTe fperafti, nunc � plerifqjnbsp;fuis fubfcfiptoribus vel rideatur, vcl neglig�-lur.vel etiam improbetur.

ver� has tuas tant� ineptias pueri ride bunt,fed etiS cachinnis hic tui argumentationnbsp;pem excipict,Jqua � colore, c�muni videlicetnbsp;accidcce,ftatim c�cludis eifentii ipfa.feu effennbsp;tiaeproprietat�. Nifgt; tibi mctaphyl�co ovftponbsp;vrc�A^.amp;plauftrario dialefticp maxime d^znbsp;rent pueri, Zuuing. vidifl�e mopitorc atro colonbsp;pe przditS;n� tam� inde ��ciud�s,m4l� fniflenbsp;ill� monitor�. Quemadmod� exalbocplprenbsp;fipllacim bon�angel�authominS agnofeerenbsp;PQ�is,quippc c� diabplus,(� Paulo credimus.nbsp;in angel� lucis fefc transformare pofsit,SC di^nbsp;bpli ca fit confuetudo perpetpa vthomines denbsp;c�pere prjtcxtu verbi Dfi Sf veritatis vplcns,nbsp;forma angeli fplend|difsimi aflum^titncntia-*nbsp;tpr SC im;t(^ur.

Nipc ad terti� tuj ingenii fpecimeq cpntem plandumycnio.'quodcft extrema SC d�ploranbsp;taimpietas�dquod rebus addicS nccciUrijs�

Principi� enim quod Zuuingliu� Dominum fibi impertiif�eaffirmat.hoc tu diabolo tribuis;nbsp;quod Zuinglius ad Dei gtoriam commemo^'nbsp;rat,hoc tu diabolo acceptum ferendum �fle 15nbsp;undis.-quod Mofcs Exod.iz.c3p.inftinlt;flu fptnbsp;ritus fan^i literis mcmorisip prodidit,hoc tunbsp;abatrogcniofa^um efle damitas. Similisnbsp;igitur es Andrea, amp; vcftigijs corum infiftis.denbsp;quibus Ifaias Prophetacapitc j. fcribittVa: dinbsp;centibus bonum tnalum SC malupi bonum.'quinbsp;ponunt tencbras lucem Si lucem tenebras,quinbsp;ponuntamarum dulce,Si dulce amarum. Dienbsp;igitur nobis Andrea, vtrum hacc vox, Agn�nbsp;pafchalis celebratio , feuagnus pafchalis e{tnbsp;phafe tranfitus lehou�.� Deo,an verd ab atronbsp;fpiritu prof�cifcatur.Si ab atro fpiritu ei�cdpnbsp;ces, fateberis totam facram feripturam abnbsp;atrofpiritu infpiratam efTe , quandoquidemnbsp;huius didli idem eft author, qui e(t totius ferinbsp;ptur�facra;. Sinver�� Deo profeAam ellenbsp;concedes, fimul quoq; conc�das neceife eft,nbsp;Zuuinglium earn non � diabolo,fed � Deo di-'nbsp;diciife.Nam idem plane' eft qui verbum ab ininbsp;tio d�die, Si qui id adhuc hodie hominibusnbsp;reuclat.

Sedfortaffecontrah�cexcipies, Tenon fendre hoc dic'lum � diabolo efleprofedlum:nbsp;fedZuinglii interpretationem diabolum au*nbsp;thorcm habere vociferaberis. Verumhac tuanbsp;cxceptionc effugere non poteris, quin Si tibinbsp;contradiccre

APOLOGIA. 7� contradicere, Kfalfum impiumi^ dicerc de�nbsp;gt;rchendaris. Namprimoteadhucmeininirfenbsp;�rbitror,quod anno xS.cumTubtngx difpu^/nbsp;tares.Si banc Xuuinglq rcuclationem tragic^nbsp;exagitares^omncs auditoresin ftuporcm connbsp;nertens, tumdicerenonerubefceres: Exodinbsp;12. nonuriptum efTe, agnum pafchalem ciTenbsp;tranf�tum lehoux. ErgoautEitearis necdVenbsp;cO,didiuni tllud in Sacra fcriptura nonrepe-�nbsp;riri,auttuani iiiperiorem fententiam rcuoca�nbsp;rc.Qiiodtamenfaftutibt difficill�mum critsnbsp;quippc cum cam dtfcipuli tui tarn arftc teneznbsp;ant acurate^ defendant, vtnuper pariaudaznbsp;cia in difputatione HcYdelbergenfi affirmarenbsp;non dubitarint,Genef, deCircumcifionenbsp;non prxdicari,quod fit feedus feu padiim inznbsp;tra Dcum Si Abrabamum .-'litem in corna Doznbsp;minica de pane non prxdicari, qiiod fit corznbsp;pus Chrifti.Hxc verd cuius fpiritus cemmertnbsp;ta fint iudicentomnes,qui indicate Spiritus^nbsp;ex verbo Dei probarc poflunt.

� Deinde Andrea impium Si falfum dicis cum Zuuinglij interpretationem � diabolo ornbsp;tarn efl'c clamicas. Nam primo tenon fugitnbsp;diaboli non earn eife naturam Si confuetudiznbsp;nem, vtScripturam cum Scriptura conf�r�t;nbsp;VtScripturamScriptura cxplicet Si il'uftret;nbsp;vt Scripturam cum Scriptura concilict ; quodnbsp;Zuuinglius hoc locoptc, ftudiofc otnniumtpnbsp;fan^orura exemple fecit. Hoc verci diabolus

in more SC vfu perpetuo habet, vt ScripturaiK^ f�bi egrcgic canrenuentem, pugnantemfaci*nbsp;at.*vt fallaeta diuti�onis ( quod hoc loco � tenbsp;quoepherilucemertdiaHa clariuseft) fxrantnbsp;Scripturammutilet corrumpat,aliemnnqtnbsp;�i fenfuth afhngac.Quod te vel vmeus ilte logt;nbsp;eus, quem diabolus Chriftum teikans � Pfai.nbsp;O^.mutilando corrupit,doccr� potent.

. Deinde f� ex eo colligis, � fpiritu atro edo 4lum fuiiTcZuinglium, quodSacramentaleSnbsp;locutiones veteris Teftamenti cumlocutioniinbsp;bus Sacramentalibits noui TeftamcRti contu^nbsp;lit,at$ vtrafq; eodem modointclligendas,exlt;'nbsp;plicandas^ docuit:quid quxfo fupereft, quantnbsp;vt cadem audacia Si impietate Chriftum Do^nbsp;minum damn�s, Paulum SC Chryfoftomunfnbsp;fuam doftrinam abatroipiritu haufiftevoevnbsp;fcrcris� vt fcilicet tibi omnesinEcclefiapaPnbsp;mam tribuant,te folum doftu purent, leChri/nbsp;fto Domino , S.Apoftolis, B. Patribus ante-'nbsp;ponat.

Noftienim Chriftum Dominu rtem minus quam Zuinglium de Sacramenns nqui Teftlt;nbsp;menti,ijfdcm phrahbusSClocutiohibus,qu; in'nbsp;veteri Teftamento pafsim occurruni,vfum ei�nbsp;fe SC retinuiftc.Nam quemadm�dQCircumci'nbsp;(io dicitur fccdus;agnus pafchalis tranfttus.�arnbsp;eaf�derislehoua;facrihciapeccatapopuli.*(�cnbsp;Chriftus Dominus nouiTeftementi facram�ta�nbsp;qrd� plan� locutienibus inftituitiordinauit S�nbsp;fancigt;

A P o L o � I ki 7* ^nt'iult.ltacp panent appcHautt corpus f�Hdk?nbsp;vinuni vet �languiHcm Itium.refpicicns ad Sanbsp;transenta veteris Teftam?ii.Nee ramenquif*nbsp;quam eft.qui ha ^hcntis Chriftum Domin�rc*nbsp;prehenderit autdxmcni� tiabere dixrht.'quipnbsp;pc cum de Sacramentts facramcraltter, verbanbsp;Dei eiusi^ inimotx vehtati conuenienter loc�nbsp;tus fn. Jntolerabdis tgitur eft audacia ncuiht�nbsp;lus Sc imperlti monacht, qua eos �fpiritaa^inbsp;je docerc infolenter afitrn)a[,qui cumChriftanbsp;Domino !oquuOior;quo cerr^ nibilalmdfacttnbsp;qu�m vt Clinftaijqminuin per latus mmiftronbsp;rnmpior� petat. ideircomeritd 8Ccertd,niffnbsp;ferla poenit�tia airteUcrtat.haud mult� pot ninbsp;ftifsitnamillamvo'e� audir� cogeiur, Andreanbsp;Andrea quid me perfcq�cr^s^ Graue tibi erhnbsp;contra ftimulum calcitrare.

Prxtcrca quo fpiritr, du^m jC �d�ft� Pan lum , eximiumilIudSeprxdarumDciorga*nbsp;Sium,3rbitraris Andrea qui nonfolumiocu#nbsp;tioncs facranientales e' veteri Teftamento,inanbsp;gna religione in nouum incr�duxit ; fedetiainnbsp;ipfa Sacramenta inter fe contulit, tiobisnbsp;rum,veteribus uoftra tribuit. NS certe� credo,nbsp;te adro impium Se Impudentem ei�c, vr faterinbsp;audeas,id � fpirltu atrO profctfb� fuifTe. At ve-fnbsp;rd qu�m tibiifta Paulina collatio probetuf,nbsp;quantiue � te fiat, fat is oftendis, cmti in Zuingt;nbsp;glio ta tn grauiter reprehendas ac diabolo tri*nbsp;buas : quod is Pauli exetnplum fequutuSjfe*nbsp;cit. Neceft� igitur eft te aut fateri Paulum

�diaboli inftin�lu Veteris KNoui Tcftamenti .facramenta inter fe conrulifTe, Si nobis vctcrunbsp;vetcribus ver� noftra artribuilTe ; aut faterinbsp;ZuingliutnDei fpiritu atfruin facramenta faznbsp;cramentis explicate facramentales locutionbsp;nes,facramencaiibus locutionibus accommonbsp;dafTe.

Deniep Diuitm quoque Chryfoftomum, ..de cuiusortliodoxafcntentia, indoftrinadenbsp;facramentis nemoorthodoxus vnquamdubi'znbsp;tauit.atrumfpirituni pr�ceptorcm habuiflcafnbsp;fi'rmare necefie Iiabebis.'fi Zuuinglinm ideirednbsp;re�lc colligis ab atro fpiritu impulfum �fle,nbsp;cum eandemrationem iftarum prxdicationunbsp;Panis eft corpus Clirtfti, Si Agnus cfttranf�nbsp;tus lehou�.eflc docuit,vcilramcp Vbiquitart*nbsp;am confub�antiationem , earatione impuznbsp;^gnaiiit. NamD.CIiryfoftomus bomil.8j.innbsp;Matth�um in hune modum fcnbitiOjfcipulosnbsp;�Chrifti ideonon fuiffc turbatos, cum audirentnbsp;fc iuberi carnem Chrifti manducari,quod quenbsp;admodiim Moyfes de agno pafchalijioc xternbsp;num vobis memoriale eft, dicebar.f�c Si ipfenbsp;Pominus.tn mcam commemorattonem facitenbsp;aitjdonec veniam.

Ex bis igitur qu� baflenus difra demon z ftrataip � nobis funt.primd intelligitpius Leznbsp;(flor Zuuiuglium nihil quod � verbo Dei,� donbsp;(flrina Chrifti, � confefsioiic Apoftolorum, �nbsp;fententia primitiux eccicfi� alienum fit.ac n�

p�tius bis per omnia ciim e� confrntiat fcri* P^�He amp; docuiffe -� SI proindc lt;ii;s do6lrinamnbsp;�*o atro Spiriti! prof��lam efTe.netiiinem, niflnbsp;Strum rpiruumfamiltari�imumhabear,peni*nbsp;tiijip ab CO ocfiipctiir amp; i cgatur.dKcre pofte.nbsp;Dei�dc ver� Aiidrex cxemplo, qiiilq; adm�gt;nbsp;tiir�S difcat qurformatar� ir�, odio .iniiidiajjnbsp;ambitiohi, calumniandi ftudio ret�ftcrc, fr�xnbsp;nun.^ inijcere. Nam (� ifta vina in animo ingt;nbsp;federint -, altascp radices egerint.nonmoddnbsp;non euclli amplius pofl'unt, fed eiiam liomm�nbsp;lt;0 infani�adigiint, vtnihil nit� bcriedicla cagt;nbsp;lumniari.fallo interpr�tari.in alicniim fenfurmnbsp;rapcrc , nodumljjiiifcirp� quxrcrc.ccn�inanbsp;amp;cnminafalfacomminifci, litem ex litcne�nbsp;^lere, ccclum terrx inifcece poGiti h�enbsp;ita cfTe, curh alia multa exempla nobis dec!agt;nbsp;rant ; dum verd maxim� in Andrex cxemplolnbsp;funeftifsimo tanqnatn in fpecnlo,nobis iniutrtnbsp;duni proponitur ; Cui vt De�s ocnlos mentisnbsp;tandem aliquando aperiat amp; melaneholiaiiinbsp;quafe amp; aliosmiferc vex�t,eripiat, �urciimnbsp;iuftofuoiudiciocompefcat, nobis fediilo ogt;nbsp;randnin eft, vt tandem aliquando cos,in q�igt;nbsp;busaliquidChriitiineft , c�niiiriis iofed�r�,nbsp;�ccl�f�xpacein,tranqnilliiatemi$perturbarcnbsp;del�iiat.

Alt�ra calomnia qua Zuuinglq doi�rinam fufpeifl� amp; exofamredderecoiiatur,eft,quodnbsp;feribit Zuuinglium , Sclpiooc�a, Herculctn,

Ciccronem � a�iosprarftantes viros in ca� (ollocafTe.PofTem exfcripris Zuuinglij niulfanbsp;amp; illuftn� teftimonia, quxithus viri perpe^nbsp;tuan� amp; conftantemdeiuftif�cationeficlci�n^nbsp;tcntiam explicarcnt lacobum Andream falnbsp;fi' criminis reum agerent,proferre:nifi hxe c�nbsp;lumnia� noftris dudum refutata effet : autigt;nbsp;Quenquam de ea dubiiarehodie exifiimarcra�nbsp;Hoc vnum dico fycophantx Si imptidentisnbsp;fiominis effe, ea qux figura te' 8C metaphoricinbsp;dilt;ffa funt,prcpn�accipiendo adulterate,nbsp;indeabfurdiimaliqiiod deducerc , quodneCnbsp;per fomntum.nec per febnin authori in men-'nbsp;tem venir. Verum Andrea ,etiainfidarerauSnbsp;tibi, quod tarnen nunquam dabimus Si tunbsp;nunquam probabis, Zuuinglium Echcicos e'nbsp;gregijs virtutibus ornaios in �rlo coliccafle;nbsp;tion tarnen grauiter peccaffe videretur.fi ver�nbsp;funtqu�fcripfit Brentzius, f� verafunt. quxnbsp;tu � Brentio accepta mordicus d�fendis.Naninbsp;fi c�lum vtinonftrofe� fcribitis nullo locoi�rnbsp;minatur.fiadtnferna vfcp extenditur.-curnorinbsp;eriam Ethnici in carlo locum habere diccren*nbsp;tur?Pratterea fi diabolus , vt blafphemcfcri.'nbsp;bitis,ihdoir�Patris,in quaCb.riftiis fuiselenbsp;^is manfionem Si locum parauit,fuam quo^nbsp;federn domicilium habet : curquxfononnbsp;necefl'an� fcqtiatur etiam reprobos in codemnbsp;loco collocari : qmppe cum reprobos in ex-*nbsp;trema

� P 0 L O G I �. 74 tudtcio Chriftus iuflurui fit � �� ifce�nbsp;inignem a:r�rnum,qui paratus cftdiabonbsp;lo 3lt; angeliseiu??, ,nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;,

Cum y�.r� exiftimes Zuuinglij doftrinx pr�iudicio (fle dcbere , quodin fuis fcriptis,nbsp;vtfcrcbant (cnipora illa,in qua� inciditZuuinnbsp;gliuamp;,amp; occupationes graui�imsc.durius inxnbsp;terdum minus propri� quod tarnen hodienbsp;lioui Monachi lt; r�brofaci�ntjloquuius fui fienbsp;videtur.'ecce r�pnnatn ubi di^^a aliquot exnbsp;fcriptis Domini Lmheridefumpta.'�^ quid denbsp;q; rentias.aut nobis fentiendum cxifiimesjii^nbsp;benttr audiam. Nam ea talia funt,vc funda�nbsp;tnehtum ncftr� f�liitis pcnitus l�befaiffent.nbsp;Nam inCencfi Capit� quarto pagina 87 f.b.nbsp;denofira f�lutis ca�fa prima in hune moduninbsp;fenbii. Nos fubPapatufortuir�, ytficloznbsp;quar, vehimus admi��ric�idiam. Non cninSnbsp;pr�cifsit c�riapromifsiofuturum , Vthobisnbsp;viuentib�s patefi�t veritas amp; mahifefteturnbsp;Antichriftus. Et pautd ^oft inqiiit; Sic Naliaznbsp;tnan , fie fex Miniuitarutn , fie Nebucadxnbsp;hexar 81 alii �x Gentibus fortuit� mileriznbsp;cordia faktati f�nt. Item ad hune modutnnbsp;propter eledos , qui fortuit� mifericer^nbsp;dia ftl�andi erant, amp; vttx proteAio , pro^nbsp;�hifsidn�s corporales , feu Legales , etO�nbsp;magnx amp; egregi� funt , tarnen funt incerta' amp; fortiiitac. Et ibidem ; Perijt Caiia�nbsp;c�fn flia gen�ratioft� , fine lux , fine cr��tjnbsp;�

K ITue Deus,excrprisiigt;\qHi per fortuitamibi fericordiain ferua�funt.lbid�nv Augeitimo*nbsp;rem Cain,quod Deus telinqutr ei tantum va*nbsp;gam mifencordiam.Pag.�i.f.a.SiciK, inqui�nbsp;Cliriftus niinifler circumcif�onts fuit,propretnbsp;vcritatem amp; ccrtitudincm promifstoi�s l�*nbsp;dxis fa dtx,Gentiu(n autetn minii�er fuit,pr�enbsp;peer mifericordiaai, nam promifsionem nul'nbsp;�am habebant'ita quorp poftentatt Gain ,for'nbsp;tuita ilia mtfericordia contigit.

H�c Andrea cum'animo tuo Iuftra,5{ etii atqt etiamperpendc,nij l�milia/swAC�twv �etvnbsp;vt mollifsim� loquar, reperiantur.nbsp;Quodficrgoex ijs lotis in quibus Zuuingliutnbsp;fuo dicendi genere vfu$,tibi loquutus videturnbsp;durius.ftatim colligendum cenf�, Zuuing Hnbsp;doiffrinam de cana Domini fajfam jrfTezcufnbsp;non eodem modo de Luthero iud�candum cf�nbsp;feRatuis'fSedmalim magnorum ifiprumDcinbsp;feruorum , ad quorum eruditionem �am An'nbsp;dreas.qudmego non peruenit, 0'^aA,clt;5tTrfnbsp;Si lapfus tcgi, duriores locutiones innbsp;meliorempartcm explicari,nbsp;, qu�mita tragic� exa*nbsp;. gitan.

elt;tluinrfi'�,gnt�ntAa^ excoUo^ttio ^^^odatn, ijuod antenbsp;iienniuiu adfontem addum lauartf^cuntnbsp;J'wdatn mini�roZcclefiitagriTigurininbsp;c httbui/p fcribit, in confuMione pag^nbsp;190 .nojirjf doilrin^r ttn^im� ver � in^nbsp;clyt� Rciptt�.Tijurin� inutdMtn conflttnbsp;O re conatur�

VT Andreas, homo durus SC iracundus� non folum priuatas perfonas dentata fuanbsp;charta incefTercGfed etiain Refpublicas Si �cnbsp;c|e(gt;as,optim�eonftttutas,defutsanteceflbnznbsp;bus optime m�ritas, ^tr�cibus iniurqs affice-

grauitacehiftoriam appellat, commcmorar�. In qua narration� duo nobis expendenda fiuitnbsp;capita.'prius cftoarrationishuc fabulx qccaxnbsp;{io;pofterius eft ipfa fabula, feucolloquiuntnbsp;fcenicuin,djgnum quod in laudcm Andrex o*nbsp;mnium gentium Uteris cekbretur.In occa(iolt;*nbsp;tie lacobus hiftoricas leges acurat� obferuansnbsp;fuxipfabulxauthoritate^ Sif�dcm concilia-*nbsp;turus tria exponitn.Tempus,x.Locum )Caunbsp;famimpellentem.Verbaeiush�c funt.Sedlixnbsp;bet all am quoq; hiftoriam breuiter reettare

�um ante biennium in fonte acidolaqar�ti^ vaUtudtni operam darem.tninifter quidan^nbsp;Ecclefi� ex agro Tigunno � me interrogatus,nbsp;qui fimiliter quo(^ valetudinis fus confirmaiinbsp;dx aciduiis vtcbatuP.

� 'Ad leinpqs ig�ur quod attiiiet Andrea, refp�ndep, te Ivftqfi� leges nimis acuratc obnbsp;feruando fummam leqitacis notatn tibi inure^nbsp;rc Ante biennium enim aut ignorafti, quorno.nbsp;do Caen a Dominica in noftns Ecele�is celcgt;nbsp;bretur,automnino cogtiitumh�butili Si iglt;nbsp;noraftijCur qu�fofuperionbus annistotcennbsp;tones contra noftram doftrinam confuiftiinbsp;�uf tot bril ta fiilmina in e�ni emii�fti * fur totnbsp;falf�s praciudiciis earn grauare non d�bitafti?nbsp;eiir tamdir�s indigtiis �nathematifmiseaninbsp;fubiecifti C fcilicet paichriim tibi ;uit, morenbsp;Andabataf�rn , r�m heque vifam neque co/nbsp;gni ta m oppiigna re; fcili cet non infania Si fugt;nbsp;ror eft id Oppugnarc, de quo tibinihil cdh-fiet Si vcr�deea tibi conftitlt, quidopus �/nbsp;rat dcnuo inrirr�gare^ q�iidattinebat�^luninbsp;3gerelt; qux infania te ed adigebat ,vt de re tibinbsp;eognita peregrinum hofpitcm tara odiofcSCnbsp;infidiof� folicitares^

Ad hune locum quod attinethichiftoricus fiium genlum Si ingeniutn nobis contemplannbsp;duin proponif. Qiiod videlicet tutius effe ar�nbsp;bitr�tur, in proprio ftefquilihiq crocitarc acnbsp;fibiloc�cauerc,quam in aciem prodire Naninbsp;alioquin

alioquin , quomodoC�na Dominica in tKgt;z ftns Eccl�fiisaclininiftretur,.vt cognofcerct,nbsp;non �bi expedlandum effe cenfuifllci, donee innbsp;acidnlas antebicnnmm demum fefe conferret,nbsp;ac vbi minidrutn Tigurinum oftenderet, dnbsp;quo de re tanti momenti erudiretur. idep eonbsp;magis quod luperioribus anais, cum fuo Biznbsp;denbacliio,Tigurum furtim ingrefliis Dbmiznbsp;num Rodolphum Guualtheruin concionanznbsp;tem audiuent. Cur nonibi adD.Bullinger�,nbsp;aduerfus quem abfens ftspe pugnauerat, Si denbsp;quo, fuo more, ante vidtoriam conftitutam. punbsp;blicofcriptotriumphauerat,adiuit, 8iex eonbsp;percontaiuseft , quomodoeoenaDomini innbsp;Ecclefi?^ Tiguriqa adminiftretur'�Cur d phraznbsp;fiijus quibus orthodoxi patres vfi fint ,5b^orlt;nbsp;rcant^ Cur Orthodoxu confenfum imprimenznbsp;d urn curauerintlt;�n caufa base fuer ut. Andreasnbsp;etfi Vbiquitarius eft, Tiguri tamep dum fuit,nbsp;non fuit in fuo territoria. Andreas etfi Vbi/nbsp;quitarius eft, tarnen Tiguri fuoi applauforesnbsp;flf afttpulatorcs Honlgt;abuit. Andreas fuar Vbi,nbsp;qattati metuebat,�f c�fubftantiationis fu{ pr�nbsp;(� Jio fe non fatis niuiiitum effc fcicba,t.

Interea tarnen Andreas fuum quaqne inz gratum animnmerga liberamHeluetir genznbsp;temdeclarat,S( quomodo Heliictios (i in eiusnbsp;territorium acc�dant, excipere tra�^ar�ip foanbsp;leat.oftendit. Quo.d videlicicet magnam hult;nbsp;manitacis 3lt; modeftix fpexiem prac fe ferens,

Inffdiof� cos de f�bus percontetur, de r�Hg�� necumipfis conf�rai , vt pottea occafioncn�nbsp;habeat.eeruni didfa Si refp�nfacalumniandi,nbsp;corrumpendi, fiC odiof� tn fuis farraginibqSnbsp;Cxagitandi.Hscc funtxenia,hxc avTiOpfTrfn^nbsp;e^�quxgentiHelueticx de Oiicatu Vuirtc*nbsp;bcrgicociuf^exulibusprxciarcmerjtx , abnbsp;Andrea rcferuncur. An vsrdoblitus eftf^ rSnbsp;amp; noftra memoria,plurimos conctonatot es 4nbsp;Papiftis fedibus fuis pulfos,tquot;�t�ip imperionbsp;nufquam tutos,fefe ad Heluetici gentem, tannbsp;quam extremum afylum contuli�e. Nam vtnbsp;|)rxclare' monet Euripides infupplicibus.

Habet enim confugium Petram quidem f� ra,fcrui ans Deorum, ciui tas verd ad ciuitaxnbsp;tem c8fiigir,rempcftafe exagirata. Nihil enin�nbsp;pcrpetud beatum ei^ in rebusmortalium.

Noftri ergo homines qs non fol� dolore SC eonfilio adfuerunt.fed etiam tuta hofpicia prfnbsp;biieriint,nit!ium hiimanitatis, pictaris amp; libe^nbsp;raijtatisofffcium, quantumiphoneft� potue'nbsp;runt.promoueriint.Tantum abeft vt infidioh^nbsp;�OS iutcrrogarint,aut vexarint, aut corum eanbsp;lamiia*

A P O t O lt;S I k, *77 hm�t�tibus infultarint. At vcr� quam gr?ti3nbsp;feportauennc adliuc hodiereportent Ibpenbsp;rionb�s anms immoderatum Teftamentun�nbsp;I5rentziigt;qui fuperionbus quoi^ annismag*nbsp;nisnoftrorunj hominutn beneficiis vfiis fuif,nbsp;docuit:hodic vei o Andrex ciuftp fociorum dinbsp;(ffa �faftatcftantur. Nam non fatis habensnbsp;inEcclefiasGallicas 8i Bcigicas, qux hodienbsp;erudeiiter � Papiftispremuntur.intolerabili*nbsp;busconuitiis inuehi, fedetiam inhoneftifsianbsp;|nas no�ras Refpublicas.quibus fiia bona menbsp;rito accepta referre deberent , fimodogratinbsp;cHe vellentjni�ntta conuicia amp; maledi�ta connbsp;feruntJta�p haud immerito noftri cum Damde *nbsp;conquer! pql�unr :prQ diledtone me a aducrxnbsp;faneur mihi. Etpofuerunt fuper memalun�nbsp;pro bono,5; odium pro dilcctiont mea Pof*nbsp;funt etiam rei^� contra eofdem vfurpave,ciagt;nbsp;rifs'imi optimt'ip viri Philippi MtlanchtotiiJnbsp;cui pro benefieqs fiivirtutibus egregqs can*nbsp;dem quam noftr js ref�runt gratiam.nbsp;IngrrftHr cucitltiinntricem druorut orenbsp;Ei wiftrr pietM officiofii nocet

�SCU mihi (juifceldf hoc imitantur fepevolucrit Peflora lt;]u^ Cygno eattdtdiora putes.

Poffem hoc loco tibi in mentem reuocare, q�{ maiores noftri illuftrifsimis principibus Vuirnbsp;teberguis.toro impeno Romano profenptisnbsp;p rxftiterint.-nif� omnes prxter re mcmiBiffcninbsp;ac fummc commendarent, tuamep propiercanbsp;K f

Cxcerumprxflat, ytadaUeram fabule haiu? partem venian|js , dtuinum^ collQ^'nbsp;giiium, quod cum niin.lt;l:roE�:le(�x inaglt;'lt;*nbsp;Tigunno tehabuinefcnbis : dignum videli*nbsp;cet,quodaurei$li�eris marmarex ftatux inlt;'nbsp;cidatur.Bibenhufianxcif Vbtqmtati conrecre**nbsp;tur. Sunt autem huius colloquq vel potiusnbsp;t�ntationis lacobAndricx partes quinque,nbsp;quas deinceps examinabimus,

Primum igitur tentator Andreas egreP lt;us in addulas, miniftrum Tigurinqn^ accePnbsp;*fit , hist� verbis adortus eft. Q_iomodQvcr�nbsp;vos Ttgurini Ccc lam Damint in veftris Ec/nbsp;Clefqs celebratis.Et refpondit minifter : Dogt;'nbsp;cetur populus, nos miniftri vobts damns pa^'nbsp;Bern � vinum.'vos autem orate, vt Oominufnbsp;vobis dec corpus Si fanguinem fuum,

Hiftoriim,ideft teftem veritatis tena/-bis fcripturum eife promif�ftt.* fed pro hiftoria fabulam tuafigmenta te nobis darein ipfonbsp;limineo'tendisrquippe cumtua vehementiusnbsp;Qrnando,ali�na nimnim reprchendcndo.affe^nbsp;�flibustuis plus xquo quamconccdityerirasnbsp;largiendo, liiftorix leges n�g�igas , cihitp^o-'nbsp;muera Rdem d�roges. Nam primo Si te SLnbsp;tuQS Tubingenf�sadhiicin recenti memorianbsp;haberearbitror,tentmirum cura apnoSi.innbsp;dilputation� publica Tubingx banc hifto^nbsp;nam

valde ridicule narrarcs fsrpfusq�c re* peteres , hune primum tentationis paroxyPnbsp;tnum mu�t� aliter expofuilTe. Nam ibi aiexnbsp;bas: Ego quxl�ui � miniftro Tigurino , quo-*nbsp;modo i$ fuos auditores de Cccna Dominicanbsp;erudircc^ Ecclefi�arum ver� nc-ftrarum men-*nbsp;tionem nullam faciebas.Nunc ver�, vt noftrisnbsp;EccUfq* Rebufpub. quibus pofc Deum fu|nbsp;focHcitatem 8iotia debet, inuidiatn conflet,funbsp;fpe/tasq�ercddat , hypothefin ad thef�nexnbsp;liitioFico Rhetor ta�lus transfert. Hare varienbsp;tas res cornmemorandi , �i f� ad voluptatemnbsp;tuorum.quorum animi lam ad ifta commentanbsp;obduruerunt, fir apta Sf accomodata , tarnennbsp;hiftorixfiJem imminuit maxim�.hiftoriei le*nbsp;uitaiem K inconftaniiam d�clarai luculen-tnbsp;tif itn� : animos Ledorurofufpenfosamp;du*nbsp;bios tenet,vt nefciant vtrum calidum nc aanbsp;frigidum.quod ex codem folk fpiratur crede�nbsp;Te debeant Quare Andrea cum pofthac velnbsp;in oriq v�uere vel animi caufa hiftonas texe*nbsp;redecreuens ; tibietiamatqueetiam viden*nbsp;dunt eft,vt fermo tuus non folum fplendidiotnbsp;amp; elegantior fiat, fed etiam vtfibi omni tcmgt;nbsp;pore amp; Iqco egregii� cenfonet, nunquam veznbsp;Td fibi repugnet. Nam alioquin poftcritaeinbsp;qux fine amore 8i odiode tuis iiifiorijstuznbsp;dicabit, ndntnagis hifioricuseris quamho*nbsp;die ridicu'us Aefopus, aut inftgniter mendaxnbsp;Lucianus.

Deinde vt hoe quotg moneam in refponfq miniftri c�mitis para�ogifm�diuif�onis :quonbsp;pirnirum ea (�lentio pr�teris SC przcenmttis�nbsp;�|mte hiftqricum fide dignum minime efTe�nbsp;ed vt Icuifsim� dicam fabulaiorem maliggt;nbsp;num agere demonftrai. Nam minifterillcnbsp;mihi ^alii$bonis virisanrequam tchiftori/nbsp;cum fore fufpicaretur , tuam tcncationem in/nbsp;fidioramexpofuit/e� tibi hae refponfumde/nbsp;diiTcaffirmauicDoceq ego roeosauditores mcnbsp;ip�s panem vinum tanquam Cbrifti mini/nbsp;firutn SC. CQoperarium in Cccna Dominicanbsp;eorrigere amp; fubminiftrar�: Chriftum verlt;gt; cfnbsp;fe,qut animas cor um fideles intus corpore 8Cnbsp;fanguine fuo ad vitam �ternam pafcat.*idip vtnbsp;facial feduld SC ardenter inuocandam cife. Adnbsp;debat etiam fe hanc fuam r�fponf�onem ratio/nbsp;re ex ditflo loannisBaptiita; dedudla confir/nbsp;mafTeiBaptizo vos aqua, is autem qui venietnbsp;pqii me baptizabit vos igni amp; fpiritu. Adnbsp;hancrationemdicebac te nihil pr�ter rifumnbsp;amp; cacliinnosrcfpondere pntuiife. Huicvironbsp;vtpon'iis,qu�mtibi nouo.hiiforico iidemha/nbsp;heamduabus ratienibus moueor. Prior eft,nbsp;quod^nonnulli boni viri qui vn� vobifcum Ia/nbsp;inrunt, tuar�pinquilitiontintcrfuerunt,mihinbsp;Tubingaedixerunt miniftrum ilium hscc ver/nbsp;ba 'oanni$,adfuxfcntentiie conf�rmationemnbsp;accomcdaHc. Vndequilibet conijcere poteftnbsp;te cius refponfum maliuof� iruncarc amp; nonnbsp;hiftorica

AP o to su. fciftortfaffd Grsrca ftdc c�rrumperc. Alttranbsp;tatio eft,quod fci� miniftrum ilium pr acier �Cnbsp;contra noftrarumEcclef�arum co fefs�oncn*nbsp;�bi nihil relpondifle^nihilctiaminfua Eccle�nbsp;liadocere. Illaaiitem verba qustuhuic loc�nbsp;inferuifti iq Confefsione noftra non memininbsp;extare.His duabus rationibus.fi placer, tertifnbsp;adde,deploratam videlicet tuam amp; impudennbsp;telm bene diif^a perueftendi,au[ etiam ea, qutenbsp;alijs �n �entem nunquam vcnerunt,affingen^nbsp;eii libidinem liccntiam, nonhiftoricani tllSnbsp;c.iidein,fedpocticamfii Lucianicam. Namnbsp;cuando qusrfo probabis nobis ea,qux in poxnbsp;(�remis tuis comtnetuarqs aduerfusD. Gryznbsp;n�um amp; D.Danielem TofTanum.commenrMSnbsp;CS, qyando nobis probabis ex feriptis Domigt;nbsp;ni Zuuinglij.Zuuinglium fateri fe intetpreta*nbsp;tionem verborum Canx ab atro Spiritu didinbsp;cilfclt; Qtiando probabis ex feriptis D. Petrinbsp;Martyns,MartYre�nDei omnipotentiam ne*nbsp;gafle^non cert� vt etiamamicitm iudirant annbsp;te Calcrtdas Grxcas. Quare cum toties f�dcmnbsp;fefelleris,tories in tnanifcfta fraude deprehennbsp;fus f�s,toties fabulas prohiftortjs venditauc*nbsp;ris, ignofees nobis veniamip dabis, G in po*nbsp;fterumtuxnarrationes , nonplus apudnosnbsp;valeant.nec maiorem f�dem mercantur.qu�n�nbsp;duo libri verarum narrationum Luciant Cutnnbsp;enim qui femel malus amp; perfidus eft, fempernbsp;prxfuppenatur malus,quid nobis de te qui ha

M. SEVMLER� iHxitiis tam multavafr� , perfid^ 5f iippii'nbsp;denter egifti ftatuendum fit,tu ipfcexiftin*^nbsp;re potes.

Secundo inquifitor Andreas rnrfus ac* lt;efsit,nnniftrumqdeTigurinum ad bun,c iro^nbsp;dum adortus efi. Num igitur non di�.lti$*nbsp;Accipite 8C manditcate, bo; eit tOrpns melt;nbsp;tim quod pro v�bis tradirum eft i Hit eftnbsp;fanguis Chrifti qui pro p�ccatis n�ftris ef^nbsp;fufus efti

Si fi'ngulisbienntis memoriam huiusbi* ft-irr� replicabis, plunmum earn, yt video,nbsp;aiigebis ; d^ita quidem, vt � rontinennbuSnbsp;tuis fcriptis.io quibns perpetuam reruni fa^nbsp;b:tlam coniple�leris fecernere banc , qua^nbsp;ft rabulam tu� rentationis amp; inquifinonisnbsp;poi'sis , atque modicum corpus conf�cia.**nbsp;Nam cum ante biepniiim in difpuratione Tugt;nbsp;bingcnfi tiios audiiores buius fabui�recira/nbsp;tioneobled�ares. cius^ crefara repetionemulnbsp;ta argumenta tibi obie5ia Icluenda efte atbi*nbsp;tra; eris.buius fecundi paroxifmi nuliam plagt;nbsp;n�feciftimennonem. OMarce Tulli�ceid,nbsp;quam foclixfuifles,f� pro Luceio,� quo tanto/nbsp;perc flagitaftijVt res was geftas ampiiiicandonbsp;�uftori� leges negligeret.hic iiiftorkusobti-''nbsp;giftet : qui inhiftona fcnbenda non irodo ht^nbsp;ftori� leges fibi violandas efte ducit.fcd etiam�nbsp;quidlibetftiigendi cum piifloribusat^ poctisnbsp;acquamfibi fiimitpoteftatcm. .nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;, ,

, Cactcrum vtut ifta fefe habeant sudiS* ^�s refponf�tn tniniftti quod hie inquif�gt;nbsp;tor ab co (ulit ; ncquaquam refpondit illeinbsp;quia minifter cutn homo tatitnin fit,t)on poteftnbsp;daretorpus amp; iahguinemChrifti .* f�d foin*nbsp;ChriHus dat.

Miteruin te Andrea.fih�c fcripfiftt,etiamgt; (jnonignoiares,netnir.etnfore , quitibif�gt;nbsp;dem cflet habtturus.'miferiorcm verd,f� ita exnbsp;cxcaais es ,vt cibi perfuaferis t� hxc commciinbsp;ta �H tins Tubingeufibus p�rfuafurum cffe.nbsp;Nam multi {untex ijs , q�ilibellum breueirinbsp;b.Ludouici Lauatefi,quem veftris calumniisnbsp;ctimih�tionibus Oppofuit, de Ceremogt;nbsp;hiis ac ntibus noftrarum Ecclefiarum lege#nbsp;t�iit,atque ex e� tognou�r�nt.r.bs in adinini#nbsp;ftratione ecenar Dominicie verba Chrifti ncRnbsp;ihutllatajed int�gra r�ci(are,tommuhi(ann#nbsp;bus {gt;roponeigt;e ineulcare. Net; etiS credibinbsp;le eft vllo modo tniniftr� ill� pr�ter amp; c�ntr�nbsp;inor�in, in noftris ecclefiis vfitat� aliquid re^nbsp;fpondiflTe: prarfertimeuinhoininis modeftiamnbsp;d�dlrin�m ctiamaifeclar tbi,qui vnd tecuthnbsp;Baqs iftijvfifwftt, mihi cOmmchdarihr. Sinnbsp;autem Andrea hoc tibi vis, an in noftris Eccl�nbsp;fijs.vnd cumfymbolorumdifthbuti�ncjfigil#nbsp;latim cuiqj cSraunicanti.dicatur, p�nis eft cornbsp;pus Chrifti ; refpondeo fimpliciter id n� fiert:nbsp;ratioriem quotp exponO;quianull� prscceptif,nbsp;fi Bibenhufianum exetpias , vtidfiat, extat;

M. B E � M I E RI atepid�rco tam omitti.quam vi'urparilineirtnbsp;pieiate poteft; de quo Epiftola Confolatori^nbsp;temonuic.

Rationem autcnri, quamminifter Tiguri* rus lui refponfi dedifle.ab inquil�tore fingirufnbsp;altoqu�f�to euertereconaturinqiiif�ror.�Cufnbsp;ergo Paulus inqutc.* �c��pi � Domino quodnbsp;tradiJi vobis, numpanem vinumtancuntnbsp;a;cepi({

Pulchrc.fafet�, laur� profcd�o diftum 5� fapten'cr.IugularasbOnTincmyfeupotiusiuHnbsp;ignorantiam tuo ipfius gladto. Nam PauIuSnbsp;roloco non difputat de corpore Chrifti in Xnbsp;fub pane larirante non diflernii de eo, an cor/nbsp;pus Chrifti de c�!o dcfccndat in panem itfnbsp;inanus fuas,vt fua manu ebriis Corinihiisid 'nbsp;in ora ingereret : mult� minus locutuseftdenbsp;Vbiquitaria amp; Capernairica manducationc,nbsp;fed ceremoniam X ritum facramC�tiam Donbsp;minicam rcifl� pie� admiiiiftrandi Corinrbi�nbsp;in mcmoriam rcuocauit, Atfp b�c ita cffe du3nbsp;bus ratioaibus addicamncceftariis. Prior eft�nbsp;quod Paulus rinim propbanuni, quo Conn/nbsp;thii C�nam Dominican! m compotationenrnbsp;immodicam conitcrtcrant,grauiterreprehcnnbsp;dit,at(^ cmcndare ftudet. Pofterior eft, quoinbsp;Paulus poft ifta verba, Acccpi � Domino Xnbsp;tradidi vobis.ftatimfubiicitvcramformam�i 1nbsp;ceremoniam C�nam Dominicam admini/ fnbsp;ftrandi.kaqj Andrea intelligis te turpitcr labinbsp;amp;iil

� in error? �iam alios rapere.fallacia figurg 4*ftionis. Namaccipere amp;traderehocloco,nbsp;ytinalijs multisjopn fignificat icaacdpcreS�nbsp;tqadere,Yt ancilla in cunis dominae fux dat innbsp;fantcm : vt multi tibi Vbiquicatis forraulaninbsp;parturienti pccuniasin loculum dederunt.'v�nbsp;pincerna Bibenhufianus in cratere tibi porri^nbsp;git vinuni. S cd fignificat dicerc SC docerc,itanbsp;yt (it fenfus, earn formant SC ritum Cccmtntnbsp;Dominicam �dminiftrandi vobis pr�fcripf�nbsp;�i commcndaui quern in Chrifto Domino di-gt;nbsp;dicUS� quern nunc vobi^in memoria redigo.

Tertio tentator rurfus inuafit miniftrum Tigurinuiri 8C hac qu��ionc propius vrfit.-annbsp;?er� non crederet,Chri(lum quidem dare cornbsp;Susfuum.fed per manum miniftri.Adhoc qugnbsp;turn fibi rcfponfum eiTc fingit hiftoricus. Migt;�nbsp;niftef nihil nifi panem SC vinum dat. Hoc rc;*nbsp;fponfum Andreas his verbis clufit. Numigigt;nbsp;tur, diccbam, alia nunc celebratur Cocna Do^�nbsp;mini, quant qu� femel � Clirifto Domino ceznbsp;lebrata eft lt; vt in ilia prima corpus �C fanguilt;nbsp;nem difiribuerit Chriftus, quia Dominusnbsp;tat, inhacvcro.noftraCccna Dominicacor^-pus SC fanguis Chrifti non diftribuantur.quianbsp;miniftriftni non Dominus , quia cadifpen''nbsp;fant.

Qiiod orationis genus non folum horrid, dumSC incultumfit , fedetiam perplexumSCnbsp;oltfcuf�m; oper�prctium fafturividebim�f,nbsp;Vnbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;t

QuoaChriflus in prima C�na diftribniu' �d quoque inCcrna Domini miniftri hodie fu*nbsp;manu diftribuunt.

Ergo hodie miniftri fua man� in pane, fub pane,cum pane diftribu�t corpus Clirifti.

Afi'umptio grauifsima laborat petition^ principif, 3C varia contradi^ionum implica*nbsp;(ione. Nam primo quxritur,an Chrtfius cor*nbsp;pusfuum quod inmenfa fedit, quod difcipulinbsp;videront;, in cuius Onu loannesrequieuit,nbsp;mut in manu fua habuerii, amp; in pane abfcon*nbsp;d�r�rhocfiiuaffirmaucris contraditfliont in*nbsp;cxplicabili teimplicabis. Deinde quxrtrur,nbsp;anChrifti corpus vifibile,palpabile, locale,nbsp;quale in prima C�na fuit amp; adhuceft, fimulnbsp;quoque fueritintiifibi}e,inpalpabile,inocale,nbsp;quale tota Scriptura Si erudita antiquitas i*nbsp;gnorat;hoc poftremufn d tu affirmaucris,conlt;nbsp;tradufltoncteimplicabis. Tertioqmerittir annbsp;Chridus corpus fuum quod numero vniim 8Snbsp;idem eft fuo corpore tanquam inftrumento dinbsp;ftribueri�� An corpus Chrifti carne amp; ofsibu�nbsp;pcrconfequcns fuis dimenfionibus long!*nbsp;tudinejatirudine SC profunditateconftans, innbsp;manu Chrifti fucrit lt; An vna eademque ma*nbsp;nu? feipf3mdiftribucrir,amp; � difcipultsorem�nbsp;ducataf�crlt^Anmanus quaClinftus corpusnbsp;fuum

A P O L O 6 I At 8* pittm diftribuit.etiam in pane amp; fubpane lati^nbsp;�aueritlt;H�c fi luaffirmaueris contvadidio*nbsp;ne te irretics.aut Chnfto duo corpora neccPnbsp;fan�tribues. Intelligisopinor Andrea, quidnbsp;fyllogifmus tuus monftri alat.

Quand Midreas inqutfitor rurfusaccef* f�t,Si pro fuo imperio, quod fibi in Ecclcfian*nbsp;Tigurinam infolentervfurpat ,inhaec verbanbsp;indignabundus crupit , 8( cur � formulis lo*nbsp;quendi abborrcant,qua:fiui,qMibus ortbodo�*nbsp;xi patres vfi funt, qui manibus miniftrorumnbsp;nonfolum panem.fed etiam corpus Chriftidinbsp;ftribui 8C oreaccipi, fecundum verba Tefta*nbsp;menti Chrifti, fcripferuni�Sicutfalfo di^usnbsp;Ortbodoxuj Confcnfu� teftatur, quiTigurinbsp;impreffus eft, cuius verba illi ad oculumde*nbsp;monftrabam.quod dicant, corpus Cbriftivi*nbsp;deri, manibus palpari,labi)s amp; dentibusattinnbsp;gi.S^ inosingredt.

Primum Andrea non neceffe eft vt de Ec* d�fia Tigurina eiufqtdo�lrina multumlabonbsp;res. Nam habet ilia Dei grati a fuos dodores,nbsp;habet fuos miniftrqs, habet fuos nutricios.V�nbsp;biquitatis facerdotibus baud inferiores.Net;nbsp;verd earn exiftimare debes cuiufquam obfcurinbsp;amp; tnfamis tyrannidem ferre po(fc,autfeGerznbsp;mantci Anticitrifti iugo fubmilfurum effe Suanbsp;libertate illafruitur, quamDei gratia confie*nbsp;quuta eft.fuis fe � Deoordinatis paftoribus 8Cnbsp;nutriciis gubernandam tradit : te ver� plane

refpuitjtibi in fe nihil iuris eiTe teftatur, tra conchas cellul� Bibcnhuf�anx manerc de/nbsp;bere�rbitratur.

' Deinde Andrea quomodoprobabis quaef� vel noftros, velOrthodox� C�nfenfum � phrsnbsp;Cbus orthodoxorum patrum a^horrere, autnbsp;�as improbare Scilicet p�tres cum patribusnbsp;�onferre.phrafes cum phrai�bus explicare,pXnbsp;tres inter fe conciliare.de eorum locutionibuSnbsp;experpetua loquendi confuetudine tudicare.*nbsp;in Vbiquitatis fchela � Patruih phrai�bus ab/nbsp;horrereeft.

Sedaudiamus refpon�im miniftritOrthodo/ Xuni C�nfenfum fe quidem vidiife refpondir�nbsp;fed non legifle affirmabat.Noli Andrea mira/nbsp;ri aliq�em ex n�ftris elfe , qui Orthodoxumnbsp;C�nfenfum, cuinem� noftrtim propria ma*nbsp;tnifubfcriberecoaiflusfuit, legerit, quippenbsp;cum nuper admodum, SC etiam num hodie innbsp;PaTatinatu multi reperiantur qui confitentur,nbsp;fe v�ftram Vbiquitatis formulam , in cui�snbsp;verba itifare contra confeientiam coaAi fiie/nbsp;r�nt, nefp vidiife neqj legifle ,atlt;� idcirco de/nbsp;fenderenon pofle. Netp etiam mirari debes,nbsp;quod miniflerhictibi refpoiidit, �dauthoresnbsp;ortI�odoxiConfcnfus,fe,vttuloqueris,rciicenbsp;re f� quid pecca�erint; quippe cum do�foresnbsp;[nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Si profefl'ores.quorum virtutem Si eruditio*

i nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nem tutantopereextollis, cum ipflsformula

' nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Cacordix defendenda efl�t.llluflrifsimo Priii

dpi Cal�miro, eiuftp conf�liariis SC eondoa�' �oribus.idem refponfuin dederint.Ethxc futitnbsp;quxadtuaconuitia, 8l contumeliasintolcra'nbsp;biles.quibus tamme qu�mecclcf�am SC Remnbsp;publtcam Tigurinam affecifti refpondere yo^nbsp;iutSi veto cui hunc virum durius tra�rai�e vfnbsp;debor.is cogitctlacobum Andream talem ePnbsp;fe virum, talia eius fatfla inftitata^vtnbsp;aliter cum eo agi vix pofslt, Malonbsp;enim nodo malus guxrcnnbsp;dus e^ cuneus.

J I nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;I ��nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;�^-nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;'nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;i'*'�� I

M ti-J,,'�,' ,fiigt;ivlt;rf. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;(

naf miKiim me a�iwm�r^iwamp; er Ctttt^fUdWqWlMtW�pwn^nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;F

lt;wrohUGattftnnp?^trdl�q^��F , tff�ecm m�nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;ofin� WWiptofmvtMS

^wsaana�Wimp�mmnnnmi^ qu�? crfl� weO tuwa�waitttamp;:0w�m6i�ia0|^nbsp;tt�rt�tttm^�^c^ww�am ^eow�nbsp;(�tta�wa^(�tcmr�(h��fitlt;amp;dmttoffenbsp;an^wjjruriwtanir�fi lUflBttOwU'V/v^lUflJLnbsp;cttrqfti�W^uettOwOtMnxmn�w�ctS�nbsp;6|tlkq�*^lt;m�l�mnttHltl�^iW�w�jri�tlt;�nbsp;ttr�o�mfls 9tt�njiinw0 w*w�p'nbsp;WW �mnnm�l�ttriwmwf m�ww��^nbsp;t �mtmlt;�ippttn�VtfKgt;tttq�^�tnlt;md^gt;^�